Latest / The NanceCast / TherapyGPT and the Death of the Subject?
Transcript
- 0:00SPEAKER_03: Yo, yo, yo, what's happening?
- 0:02SPEAKER_03: Welcome back to the NanceCast.
- 0:05SPEAKER_03: How you doing?
- 0:07SPEAKER_03: I'm doing well.
- 0:08SPEAKER_03: It's good to be here.
- 0:09SPEAKER_03: Good to have you here with me.
- 0:10SPEAKER_03: I just got done having a conversation with some homies.
- 0:15I talked to Mikey,
- 0:17talked to Nick,
- 0:18talked to Andrew,
- 0:19the Vanishing Mediators.
- 0:21SPEAKER_03: Nick and Andrew were in the same room at the same time.
- 0:24SPEAKER_03: They were hanging out.
- 0:25SPEAKER_03: They're
- 0:27SPEAKER_03: chilling out max and relaxing all cool.
- 0:29SPEAKER_03: And it was dope.
- 0:30SPEAKER_03: And we talked about, well, it was kind of a broad conversation.
- 0:34SPEAKER_03: We went into it.
- 0:35We were going to talk about therapy GPT and kind of my fears
- 0:40about therapy GPT and
- 0:43SPEAKER_03: this kind of movement toward,
- 0:45SPEAKER_03: I don't know,
- 0:45SPEAKER_03: a more positivistic
- 0:47SPEAKER_03: world and blah, blah, blah.
- 0:48SPEAKER_03: But it was actually a pretty broad conversation.
- 0:53SPEAKER_03: We got into a lot of stuff,
- 0:54SPEAKER_03: talked a lot about Lacan and analysis,
- 0:56talked about some Marxism and production and subjectivity and
- 1:01all kinds of stuff.
- 1:02SPEAKER_03: It was a great conversation.
- 1:03SPEAKER_03: I can't wait for our next conversation.
- 1:07SPEAKER_03: We'll be doing that soon.
- 1:08SPEAKER_03: But for now,
- 1:09satisfy yourself to know that if you stick around for the next
- 1:12couple hours,
- 1:13SPEAKER_03: you'll be privy to an excellent conversation with Mikey,
- 1:18SPEAKER_03: Nick Castellucci,
- 1:19SPEAKER_03: and Andrew Flores Jr.
- 1:21SPEAKER_03: Nick and Andrew are the vanishing mediators.
- 1:24SPEAKER_03: Mikey is the dangerous maybe.
- 1:25SPEAKER_03: I'll put all their info down below.
- 1:27If you are not already following or subscribed to everyone
- 1:30here,
- 1:30you should be.
- 1:32SPEAKER_03: So get on that if you're not.
- 1:35SPEAKER_03: But without much more ado,
- 1:37I'm going to go ahead and get out of my own way and let us kind
- 1:40of entertain you
- 1:42SPEAKER_03: and also hopefully educate you a little bit and inspire some deep thought
- 1:48surrounding this topic of kind of AI and subjectivity and
- 1:52mental health and all
- 1:54SPEAKER_03: these things.
- 1:55SPEAKER_03: So thanks for dropping in.
- 1:57SPEAKER_03: Thanks for sticking around.
- 1:59SPEAKER_03: And don't eat yellow snow.
- 2:14whatever so now we are recording and uh right but yeah i don't
- 2:19know we can get into
- 2:20SPEAKER_03: whatever um i know like i've been on uh
- 2:26SPEAKER_03: Like the AI therapy shit, therapy GPT, is very disturbing.
- 2:32SPEAKER_03: Like very, very disturbing.
- 2:33SPEAKER_03: And I don't know how to account for like...
- 2:36SPEAKER_03: Why it's so disturbing?
- 2:37I know there's probably an intuitive level where it's like,
- 2:42oh,
- 2:42that's a bit weird.
- 2:43SPEAKER_03: But the more I think about it,
- 2:45SPEAKER_03: the more,
- 2:45SPEAKER_03: I guess,
- 2:45horrifying it seems to get because it's like we're removing all
- 2:51pretense at even
- 2:53SPEAKER_03: subjectivity at all.
- 2:55SPEAKER_03: We're just giving up fully and it's like, yeah, we are machines.
- 2:58SPEAKER_03: Therapy is already very instrumental.
- 3:01SPEAKER_03: Therapy is already this thing where
- 3:05it's assumed that if you give the correct inputs,
- 3:07you will get the desired output.
- 3:09SPEAKER_03: And if you can't do that,
- 3:10then you're broken and something's wrong with you and you need
- 3:12to be segregated
- 3:12SPEAKER_03: from the mainstream.
- 3:14Um,
- 3:16but there's always like,
- 3:16there's always room for lack cause it's done by humans.
- 3:21SPEAKER_03: Uh,
- 3:23but if we're going to replace the humans that are giving us
- 3:25therapy,
- 3:27um,
- 3:27I don't know.
- 3:27SPEAKER_03: It,
- 3:28SPEAKER_03: it,
- 3:28SPEAKER_03: it feels very like frexy and it feels very like,
- 3:32SPEAKER_03: like steampunk almost like we're,
- 3:34SPEAKER_03: we've turned ourselves into like pistons and,
- 3:38SPEAKER_03: and rods and camshafts.
- 3:40SPEAKER_03: And I don't, I don't know.
- 3:41SPEAKER_03: Um,
- 3:42but Mikey and I were talking about it and we were just kind of
- 3:44going off and then
- 3:45SPEAKER_03: we thought like,
- 3:45SPEAKER_03: fuck man,
- 3:46SPEAKER_03: we,
- 3:46SPEAKER_03: we want to talk to you guys about this shit too.
- 3:48SPEAKER_00: Cause like, um, it's so real quick because my,
- 3:53Last time my mic didn't sound like it was at the...
- 3:56Does the mic sound good on your end,
- 3:58guys?
- 3:59SPEAKER_00: Can you hear me okay?
- 4:00SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 4:00SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 4:01SPEAKER_02: No, I mean... Yeah, I mean, there's a lot I could add to that.
- 4:07SPEAKER_02: Like, honestly, like, Nance, it's like... It's interesting, like, how...
- 4:14You know,
- 4:15at least in America,
- 4:16we get like,
- 4:18and it's not even just like the anti-vax movement.
- 4:21Like there's other things where there's just like this sort of
- 4:23paranoia or like,
- 4:26SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 4:26fear of anybody who has some type of like certification or like
- 4:31authority and
- 4:32SPEAKER_02: especially in the medical industry.
- 4:35SPEAKER_02: So like there's that input.
- 4:37SPEAKER_02: And then at the same time,
- 4:38SPEAKER_02: this valorization of mental health,
- 4:40SPEAKER_02: like I may be skeptical of the doctor.
- 4:43SPEAKER_02: I may not trust this person, but mental health is real.
- 4:47SPEAKER_02: Depression is real.
- 4:49SPEAKER_02: And, you know, we need to be healed, whatever signifier you want to use.
- 4:53SPEAKER_02: But the fact is that mental health matters.
- 4:57And you even see it with the progressives that we need to have
- 5:01more decolonial
- 5:02SPEAKER_02: therapy,
- 5:03which there's nothing decolonial other than the fact that it's
- 5:05just a signifier in
- 5:06SPEAKER_02: front of therapy.
- 5:08SPEAKER_02: But one of the things that you pointed out is the facts with lack,
- 5:13SPEAKER_02: that's the one thing that ChatGPT lacks is desire and the ability to lie.
- 5:20And I think this is indicative of both what I listed about the
- 5:24sort of fear of the other,
- 5:26Maybe we can talk about like why that is and the sort of things
- 5:30that we're talking
- 5:30SPEAKER_02: about offline about like,
- 5:32SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 5:33SPEAKER_02: psychosis,
- 5:33narcissism in the like Freudian-Lacanian sense and like
- 5:37something like foreclosure.
- 5:39But I think it's just sort of like indicative of like the way
- 5:42that capitalism and
- 5:43SPEAKER_02: more,
- 5:44SPEAKER_02: let's say for lack of a better term,
- 5:45SPEAKER_02: consumer emphasis societies like America,
- 5:49SPEAKER_02: Western Europe,
- 5:51SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 5:51SPEAKER_02: within the imperial core,
- 5:53uh have like a deterioration of the social bond where like we
- 5:57are all so alone with
- 5:58our enjoyment and so like in a sense like there's an
- 6:01uninterruption with our own
- 6:03jouissance with uh chat gpt therapy or the fact that you know i
- 6:08could be on new
- 6:09york in the subway on the on the a train and i could i could qr
- 6:13uh code scan this
- 6:15SPEAKER_02: app that allows me to do an app therapy, right?
- 6:19SPEAKER_02: Which is almost synonymous with the chat GPT thing,
- 6:22SPEAKER_02: which just shows like,
- 6:23SPEAKER_02: I don't need an actual professional,
- 6:26SPEAKER_02: which what it just shows like how alone and alienated,
- 6:28SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 6:29SPEAKER_02: the society is,
- 6:30SPEAKER_02: but then also
- 6:32SPEAKER_02: It validates the sort of fear of the embodied personal other.
- 6:37But the fact that I take the field of knowledge of therapy and
- 6:41mental health
- 6:42SPEAKER_02: seriously,
- 6:43SPEAKER_02: I never interrogate my symptom.
- 6:46I just sort of continue my own sort of self-referential
- 6:51practical solipsistic mentality.
- 6:53SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 6:54And I think it's like what's being disregarded here is that
- 6:57your symptom is...
- 7:00the essence of anything even vaguely resembling something like
- 7:07individuality.
- 7:09And outside of that,
- 7:10there is no real individuality apart from your symptom or
- 7:14symptom.
- 7:16And I think what I find so disturbing about,
- 7:19as Nan said,
- 7:20the,
- 7:21let's say,
- 7:21instrumentalism
- 7:23of the idea of chat GPT therapy is the idea that there is a
- 7:31kind of perfect social
- 7:33SPEAKER_01: subject,
- 7:34SPEAKER_01: which you could aspire to be through these tiny adjustments.
- 7:40SPEAKER_01: And that when you foreclose the transferential dimension of talking to
- 7:49another human being because even if we aren't dealing with
- 7:52psychoanalysis even if
- 7:54SPEAKER_01: it is your most basic CBT type dynamic
- 8:01SPEAKER_01: that you're exploring with therapy,
- 8:02SPEAKER_01: at the very least,
- 8:03SPEAKER_01: if you're talking to a flesh and blood human being,
- 8:07SPEAKER_01: there is a level of transference,
- 8:10SPEAKER_01: which I think might speak to something symptomal.
- 8:14SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 8:14SPEAKER_01: Without getting too psychoanalytic here.
- 8:16But what is so disturbing about the idea of just talking to a
- 8:21machine who is going
- 8:22SPEAKER_01: to do away with all of the uncomfortable things
- 8:28SPEAKER_01: excess and baggage of having to interact with other human beings,
- 8:33SPEAKER_01: which if you think about it,
- 8:35SPEAKER_01: ideally,
- 8:36one of the outcomes of therapy would be that you're more
- 8:40proficient at talking to
- 8:42SPEAKER_01: other human beings.
- 8:42SPEAKER_01: So a good starting point would be to talk to another human being.
- 8:46but the issue here is that it's like well that's such a goddamn
- 8:50pain in the ass
- 8:51yeah oh absolutely absolutely absolutely well if we could just
- 8:55foreclose that all
- 8:56together then hey we could just completely enjoy our symptoms
- 8:59without ever avowing
- 9:01it yeah and i think like one of the things that nick pointed
- 9:03out is the sort of
- 9:04SPEAKER_02: transferential field which like you know one of the things that makes
- 9:08psychoanalysis interesting is like it's the only place where
- 9:10like of course
- 9:11SPEAKER_02: Say whatever is on your mind.
- 9:13SPEAKER_02: You can't say everything but say anything.
- 9:15SPEAKER_02: But it's also the only place where like you could actually express hate.
- 9:20SPEAKER_00: Right.
- 9:20SPEAKER_02: But to the point that you censor yourself,
- 9:24SPEAKER_02: you can't you don't realize that because there's no like in a sense,
- 9:27SPEAKER_02: there's no like almost like there's no feedback loop.
- 9:29SPEAKER_02: It's just a continual circuit of self.
- 9:32SPEAKER_02: uh, referentiality with, uh, with the chat GBT thing.
- 9:36SPEAKER_02: Whereas like Nick said,
- 9:37SPEAKER_02: even in like,
- 9:38SPEAKER_02: uh,
- 9:38SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 9:38SPEAKER_02: in,
- 9:38SPEAKER_02: uh,
- 9:39SPEAKER_02: like a two-bodied psychology or two-body therapy,
- 9:42SPEAKER_02: uh,
- 9:43SPEAKER_02: there is a feedback and a response that's,
- 9:45SPEAKER_02: uh,
- 9:45SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 9:46SPEAKER_02: uh,
- 9:46SPEAKER_02: sort of a disjunction between
- 9:48SPEAKER_02: my own perception of the world versus the other.
- 9:51SPEAKER_02: Now,
- 9:52SPEAKER_02: there is,
- 9:52SPEAKER_02: of course,
- 9:52SPEAKER_02: the level of ideology and the superegoic injunction of like,
- 9:56SPEAKER_02: heal yourself,
- 9:57SPEAKER_02: be better,
- 9:57SPEAKER_02: be yourself,
- 9:58SPEAKER_02: do the mindfulness work,
- 10:00SPEAKER_02: do the workbook,
- 10:01SPEAKER_02: all these,
- 10:01SPEAKER_02: this,
- 10:01SPEAKER_02: that,
- 10:01SPEAKER_02: and the third,
- 10:02SPEAKER_02: which is also problematic with,
- 10:03SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 10:04SPEAKER_02: therapy,
- 10:04SPEAKER_02: culture,
- 10:06SPEAKER_02: and not to mention that,
- 10:07SPEAKER_02: like,
- 10:07SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 10:07SPEAKER_02: people in the poverty line can't have,
- 10:09SPEAKER_02: like,
- 10:09SPEAKER_02: don't have access to therapy.
- 10:11SPEAKER_02: So that's another problem.
- 10:11SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 10:13SPEAKER_02: But like,
- 10:14SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 10:14you don't get that sort of disjunction or break in the circuit
- 10:19of the message.
- 10:21SPEAKER_02: And it's like ChatGPT is not,
- 10:23SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 10:24SPEAKER_02: even though like ChatGPT or all these like,
- 10:26SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 10:26SPEAKER_02: AIs are based off of like a metalinguistic model.
- 10:29SPEAKER_02: Lacan says there's no metalinguage, right?
- 10:32And so to put it in dumb terms,
- 10:34it's like ChatGPT relies on a human language.
- 10:36SPEAKER_02: Inputting a network of different signifiers,
- 10:40SPEAKER_02: terms,
- 10:41SPEAKER_02: concepts within,
- 10:43SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 10:43SPEAKER_02: the circuit of zero and one,
- 10:44SPEAKER_02: zero and one for that computer.
- 10:46So the computer is just a reified version of already bungled
- 10:50discourse that we're embedded in.
- 10:52SPEAKER_02: Right.
- 10:52SPEAKER_02: It's just not a human saying it.
- 10:53SPEAKER_02: But the fact is that it can't get interrogated,
- 10:55SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 10:56SPEAKER_02: unless you're talking to another physical body,
- 10:58SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 10:58SPEAKER_02: that's speaking.
- 11:00SPEAKER_02: and has an existential motive of, of, of attunement.
- 11:03SPEAKER_02: Uh,
- 11:04SPEAKER_02: and not even in a head of hearing sense,
- 11:05SPEAKER_02: just like in the fact that like we fucking live,
- 11:08SPEAKER_02: breathe,
- 11:08SPEAKER_02: eat shit,
- 11:09SPEAKER_02: piss,
- 11:10SPEAKER_02: and we desire and,
- 11:12SPEAKER_02: uh,
- 11:13SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 11:13SPEAKER_02: we're outside of ourselves.
- 11:15SPEAKER_02: So I think like,
- 11:15SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 11:17SPEAKER_02: this is where the problem site or the problem of therapy and also like
- 11:20SPEAKER_02: psychoanalysis comes in because again,
- 11:23SPEAKER_02: to kind of cap it off to get everybody else room to talk.
- 11:26SPEAKER_02: The transferential thing is important because this allows the unconscious
- 11:30formations that are contributing and the main factor of my
- 11:34suffering to come out
- 11:35SPEAKER_02: into play in slips of the tongue.
- 11:38SPEAKER_02: And the fact that like after this session,
- 11:39SPEAKER_02: I'm going to fucking take a nap and then I will have a freaking dream
- 11:43of something that I will then decipher with the analyst or why
- 11:48is it like,
- 11:48SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 11:49SPEAKER_02: now like my analyst is like,
- 11:51SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 11:51SPEAKER_02: popping up in my dreams or this,
- 11:53SPEAKER_02: this,
- 11:53SPEAKER_02: that and the third,
- 11:54SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 11:55SPEAKER_02: wish fulfillments,
- 11:56SPEAKER_02: edible rivalry,
- 11:57all this stuff that are coming in because of the formation of
- 11:59psychoanalysis.
- 12:00SPEAKER_02: You know,
- 12:00SPEAKER_02: it's like,
- 12:01SPEAKER_02: of course,
- 12:01SPEAKER_02: the symptom and the suffering exists outside of psychoanalysis,
- 12:03but they're put into formation because of the psychoanalytic
- 12:06act of simply fucking
- 12:07SPEAKER_02: talking and saying whatever's on your mind.
- 12:08SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 12:11And the point that when we're in language with an other,
- 12:16there's overt and there's covert.
- 12:20You're never actually saying what you're trying to say,
- 12:22and that functions with an other.
- 12:24SPEAKER_03: But when you're just saying stuff into essentially a mirror...
- 12:31SPEAKER_03: It's kind of scary.
- 12:33SPEAKER_03: It's like runaway,
- 12:34SPEAKER_03: like just acceleration of like the worst dysfunctional bits of you,
- 12:38SPEAKER_03: those things that you cannot say,
- 12:39those things that are only expressed in the kind of gaps
- 12:43between what you're
- 12:43actually saying that an other is there to help pick up on and
- 12:47reflect back at you.
- 12:49SPEAKER_03: um, that can't happen when, when you're talking into the mirror.
- 12:53And so like your worst tendencies can kind of just multiply and
- 12:56accelerate.
- 12:57SPEAKER_03: Uh, and I think it's monstrous.
- 12:58SPEAKER_03: Like I,
- 12:59SPEAKER_03: I,
- 12:59SPEAKER_03: I feel really bad for the people that,
- 13:02SPEAKER_03: that reach out to these therapy GPTs or whatever.
- 13:05SPEAKER_03: Cause, um, I've had lifelong, I got a bad head or bad brain or whatever.
- 13:09SPEAKER_03: I think we all do to some extent.
- 13:11SPEAKER_03: Right.
- 13:12SPEAKER_03: And I've never been able to afford treatment and I've
- 13:14When I was in the army,
- 13:16they had us doing yoga and talking about our feelings and shit.
- 13:19SPEAKER_03: And I was like, okay, this is kind of interesting.
- 13:22But the majority of my life,
- 13:24as an American man,
- 13:25you grin and you bear it.
- 13:26SPEAKER_03: And it is what it is.
- 13:27And hopefully you have friends and family to have constructive
- 13:31relationships to
- 13:31SPEAKER_03: help you work that out.
- 13:32SPEAKER_03: There's so many people that are suffering, are in pain.
- 13:35They are barred from access to these tools,
- 13:37these resources of mental health.
- 13:39SPEAKER_03: And they sit back and they watch media and Instagram and
- 13:43tv oh be your best self and oh you know just believe it you can
- 13:47achieve it lotty
- 13:47dotty dotty but the reality for most people is like you know
- 13:51life is suffering hell
- 13:52is other people um and i i think a lot of youngish younger
- 13:58people are are now
- 14:00reaching out to these resources therapy gpt um and i feel
- 14:04deeply for them like i i
- 14:06SPEAKER_03: think uh
- 14:08know it's it's monstrous and it like i was thinking before we
- 14:12we started talking
- 14:12about this like i i really don't want any of us to come off to
- 14:16anyone watching or
- 14:17listening like we're shitting on people who who are using these
- 14:20resources because i
- 14:21think we can all like understand like no like there is a great
- 14:24need for mental
- 14:25SPEAKER_03: health care if you want to call it that um and sam altman
- 14:30SPEAKER_03: I think is puppeteering us into a very strange,
- 14:34SPEAKER_03: very,
- 14:35SPEAKER_03: very strange amalgamation of just like super egoic,
- 14:41SPEAKER_03: positivistic,
- 14:42SPEAKER_03: affirmative,
- 14:44SPEAKER_03: dysfunctional shit.
- 14:46SPEAKER_03: I don't know.
- 14:46SPEAKER_03: It's fucking really scary.
- 14:48SPEAKER_03: I just keep coming back.
- 14:50SPEAKER_01: Yeah,
- 14:50SPEAKER_01: if I could like piggyback off of that,
- 14:52it's like the super ego injunction of our time right now is
- 14:57exactly what you said,
- 14:58SPEAKER_01: Nance.
- 15:00SPEAKER_01: be your best self.
- 15:01SPEAKER_01: Everyone wants to be their best self.
- 15:05SPEAKER_01: And that is a maxim that remains like uncontested in the corporate world,
- 15:13SPEAKER_01: in sports,
- 15:15SPEAKER_01: or just in terms of your own personal goals.
- 15:18SPEAKER_01: And it's like,
- 15:20SPEAKER_01: To play devil's advocate,
- 15:22SPEAKER_01: someone who's defending ChatGBT therapy might just say,
- 15:25SPEAKER_01: well,
- 15:26I can better align my actions to a list of short-term and
- 15:33long-term goals.
- 15:34SPEAKER_01: And what's wrong with that?
- 15:36SPEAKER_01: And the issue isn't that there's anything wrong with having goals.
- 15:39SPEAKER_01: There isn't anything wrong with wanting to...
- 15:43take your hysterical misery and bring it to the level of
- 15:47everyday happiness,
- 15:49SPEAKER_01: unhappiness,
- 15:50SPEAKER_01: not happy,
- 15:51SPEAKER_01: everyday unhappiness to paraphrase Freud,
- 15:54but it's rather the idea of what are you letting into your life
- 15:59and accepting as
- 16:03SPEAKER_01: instrumental,
- 16:04SPEAKER_01: but also invisible within your life and,
- 16:08SPEAKER_01: in a way that now there are all these other sort of invisible structures,
- 16:14SPEAKER_01: which are kind of,
- 16:15SPEAKER_01: I think,
- 16:16SPEAKER_01: smuggled in along with the ideology that you're imbibing.
- 16:22SPEAKER_01: And the other thing that I'm thinking is it's like,
- 16:24there's a double bind here that always emerges when people try
- 16:28to embody their
- 16:31best selves through some kind of practice or like really
- 16:34believe there is an
- 16:36SPEAKER_01: ontological status that you could arise to,
- 16:38SPEAKER_01: which would be best.
- 16:41So it's like,
- 16:42there's on the one hand,
- 16:43a democracy of opinion and taste and,
- 16:47and,
- 16:47ideological leanings which as long as they don't go too far in
- 16:51any extreme are
- 16:53acceptable but then there is like the aggregate of all of that
- 16:56which would be to be
- 16:57as ideal social subject for the other and i guess this kind of
- 17:03liberal democratic
- 17:04SPEAKER_01: vision of it is that the mosaic of all of our individual essences is
- 17:10SPEAKER_01: Once they're actualized,
- 17:11SPEAKER_01: we'll form some beautiful utopian society wherein we all,
- 17:17SPEAKER_01: like little pixels,
- 17:19get to make up the image of the other and reflect the other as
- 17:24it wants us to be,
- 17:24SPEAKER_01: which is almost like a godlike messianic version of the world.
- 17:30SPEAKER_01: And these Silicon Valley dudes do fucking...
- 17:33believe that to an extent right like they do think there is an
- 17:37author that you can
- 17:38finally tune yourself to respond to and satisfying no yeah and
- 17:43i think that's like
- 17:44the point that like nick may like uh about like the devil's
- 17:46advocate of this thing
- 17:47it's like well like even like maybe if there is some fault to
- 17:50me trying to uh use
- 17:52SPEAKER_02: chat gpt therapy or some type of like um
- 17:56SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 17:57SPEAKER_02: a battery bank of like how to knowledge to be better,
- 18:01SPEAKER_02: even if there's some fault to it.
- 18:02SPEAKER_02: The fact is that, well, it may be better for someone.
- 18:05It's always the default is that there is someone out there who
- 18:08needs it more.
- 18:09SPEAKER_02: Right.
- 18:10And it's,
- 18:11you know,
- 18:11maybe like there's some futility to my own self-help or
- 18:15self-excellence.
- 18:15But,
- 18:16you know,
- 18:17the default is that there's somebody else who will be
- 18:19self-excellent.
- 18:20SPEAKER_02: And I think going back to ChatGPT,
- 18:23SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 18:23SPEAKER_02: because it's not a human,
- 18:25there's also like this sort of like bias that like it doesn't
- 18:28lack and it's sort of
- 18:29SPEAKER_02: complete.
- 18:29And that's the fact it's like it doesn't matter that we're
- 18:33fragile or we're lack or
- 18:34SPEAKER_02: we're wounded.
- 18:35SPEAKER_02: But we need another that is enjoying.
- 18:38SPEAKER_02: We need another that is not lacking, that is whole and complete.
- 18:42And I think it's like this sort of thing that's desirable about
- 18:47ChatGPT is that
- 18:48it's somehow sort of like replicant of something that is
- 18:52complete and omniscient,
- 18:53SPEAKER_02: right?
- 18:55SPEAKER_02: And maybe that's like,
- 18:56SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 18:56SPEAKER_02: maybe it's because it's science,
- 18:58SPEAKER_02: because it's sort of a brand new technological advancement.
- 19:02But the fact is,
- 19:02it's like,
- 19:03you know,
- 19:03it's sort of it's sort of new and novel.
- 19:06SPEAKER_02: So it must be complete.
- 19:09It must be totalized because I need a totalized other to
- 19:12predicate off of what it
- 19:14SPEAKER_02: means to have sort of self excellence.
- 19:16SPEAKER_02: Right.
- 19:17SPEAKER_02: Uh,
- 19:17SPEAKER_02: and,
- 19:17SPEAKER_02: and human,
- 19:18SPEAKER_02: human role models have been failing that,
- 19:19SPEAKER_02: especially like when you look at,
- 19:21SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 19:21SPEAKER_02: the last thing I'll say,
- 19:22SPEAKER_02: like when it comes to like,
- 19:24SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 19:24SPEAKER_02: influencers,
- 19:24SPEAKER_02: stuff like that,
- 19:25SPEAKER_02: all the influencers have been failing,
- 19:26SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 19:27SPEAKER_02: even,
- 19:27SPEAKER_02: even like the,
- 19:28SPEAKER_02: the alpha bros,
- 19:28SPEAKER_02: like,
- 19:28SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 19:29SPEAKER_02: that's the past now.
- 19:30Like nobody cares about Andrew Tate,
- 19:32like,
- 19:32and nobody cares about David Goggins anymore.
- 19:34SPEAKER_02: And like Joe Rogan, they all become paradise.
- 19:36SPEAKER_02: Like they become hystericized by the algorithm.
- 19:38SPEAKER_02: Like they've undermined themselves.
- 19:40So we need some type of new sort of super ego injunction of get
- 19:44it right to use
- 19:44SPEAKER_02: Mikey's term,
- 19:45SPEAKER_02: get it right,
- 19:45SPEAKER_02: get it right.
- 19:46SPEAKER_02: You know?
- 19:48you know the whole thing is unbarred non-lacking until you ask
- 19:53it if it can help
- 19:54you pay your mortgage exactly you realize how lacking it still
- 19:58is um yeah i mean i
- 20:03SPEAKER_00: think part of the appeal okay so one of the reasons i wanted to have this
- 20:07SPEAKER_00: conversation i mean there was a lot but uh
- 20:11SPEAKER_00: especially the part on what we're talking about,
- 20:13SPEAKER_00: uh,
- 20:14SPEAKER_00: therapy,
- 20:15SPEAKER_00: GPT,
- 20:15SPEAKER_00: if you want to call it like whatever you want,
- 20:18SPEAKER_00: uh,
- 20:19SPEAKER_00: therapy,
- 20:20SPEAKER_00: LLM.
- 20:20SPEAKER_00: Um,
- 20:22one of my close friends told me that she and her son now talk
- 20:27to a therapy bot on a
- 20:31SPEAKER_00: regular basis and that they both really love it.
- 20:34SPEAKER_00: And so,
- 20:35SPEAKER_00: It was weird when she told me this,
- 20:37SPEAKER_00: she told it to me,
- 20:39SPEAKER_00: like,
- 20:39SPEAKER_00: almost like she was making a confession.
- 20:42SPEAKER_00: Like I'm,
- 20:43SPEAKER_00: cause she knows,
- 20:44SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 20:45the kind of book that I've written and she knows the kind of
- 20:48philosophy I focus on.
- 20:49SPEAKER_00: So she knew that telling me this,
- 20:51SPEAKER_00: she's,
- 20:53I will say it was really kind of a shock where all this stuff
- 20:57that I think about
- 20:58SPEAKER_00: theoretically really kind of hit home when,
- 21:02SPEAKER_00: where I'm like,
- 21:02SPEAKER_00: okay,
- 21:03SPEAKER_00: now one of my best friends is talking to a goddamn
- 21:06SPEAKER_00: therapy bot about her trauma.
- 21:08Um,
- 21:10you know,
- 21:11what do I,
- 21:12um,
- 21:13but it's funny,
- 21:14you know,
- 21:15I didn't prompt her.
- 21:16SPEAKER_00: I didn't like get her to say something that would,
- 21:20SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 21:20SPEAKER_00: validate Lacanian theory,
- 21:22SPEAKER_00: Zizekian theory.
- 21:24SPEAKER_00: But I was like, okay, she was like, don't be judgmental.
- 21:27SPEAKER_00: I'm like, all right, all right.
- 21:29SPEAKER_00: I can't, I mean, I kind of want to be, but I'm like, all right,
- 21:34SPEAKER_00: what do you like about it?
- 21:35SPEAKER_00: And she was just like, it's just so positive and affirmative.
- 21:39SPEAKER_00: And you know, it just builds me up.
- 21:42SPEAKER_00: And I was like, so there's no, there's nothing negative about it.
- 21:46SPEAKER_00: She's like, no, it's just, it's like a supportive parent and like, okay.
- 21:55SPEAKER_00: But
- 21:56SPEAKER_00: That's, that's what we're getting.
- 21:58SPEAKER_00: It's not going to sit there and be overly negative.
- 22:01Even if you program it to cut back on the positivity and have
- 22:07some kind of program
- 22:08SPEAKER_00: negativity in,
- 22:09SPEAKER_00: in it,
- 22:10SPEAKER_00: it's still a program negativity where for us,
- 22:14when we're talking to another speaking subject that has an
- 22:16actual unconscious,
- 22:17SPEAKER_00: their negativity isn't programmed.
- 22:20SPEAKER_00: There's something eruptive about it.
- 22:22SPEAKER_00: There's something spontaneous about it.
- 22:25SPEAKER_00: And we know,
- 22:25SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 22:26SPEAKER_00: Lacan's image of the unconscious,
- 22:28SPEAKER_00: boom,
- 22:29SPEAKER_00: it emerges and then once it's gone,
- 22:31SPEAKER_00: it just vanishes like that.
- 22:33And so the ego of the other person can't get a hold of their
- 22:39own unconscious.
- 22:40SPEAKER_00: It's something that erupts as much for them as it does for us.
- 22:44SPEAKER_00: And so, I don't know.
- 22:47SPEAKER_00: Nance and I and our discussions of AI, we've talked about how
- 22:50SPEAKER_00: well,
- 22:51SPEAKER_00: okay,
- 22:51SPEAKER_00: if AI is going to be another,
- 22:53SPEAKER_00: if it's going to be a legitimate speaking subject,
- 22:57SPEAKER_00: is the AI code going to have to have its own uncode?
- 23:01SPEAKER_00: And what would that mean?
- 23:04Is it kind of programmed failure,
- 23:08programmed spontaneity,
- 23:10programmed self-undermining?
- 23:12SPEAKER_00: You know,
- 23:13SPEAKER_00: when we talk to Todd about it,
- 23:16SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 23:16SPEAKER_00: Todd has a very different concept of intelligence.
- 23:21SPEAKER_00: then say Nick Land where Nick Land just thinks intelligence is defined by
- 23:26competence at playing games or the ability to increase you know
- 23:31problem solving
- 23:32capabilities Todd I'm kind of paraphrasing here but the idea is
- 23:38this where the
- 23:39beans have death drive were also the most intelligent beans on
- 23:43this planet that's
- 23:44SPEAKER_00: not a coincidence
- 23:46something about death drive facilitates the level of
- 23:50intelligence that we have and
- 23:53so he thinks intelligence is actually spurred on by juizance
- 23:58self-destruction etc
- 24:00in a way where land would totally disagree like it like there's
- 24:04an intrinsic drive
- 24:06SPEAKER_00: for optimization so these are two different ways but the point is when
- 24:13SPEAKER_00: when you have a chat bot,
- 24:14SPEAKER_00: even if you program that negativity,
- 24:17you're tailoring that negativity to your positivity or even to
- 24:23your own negativity,
- 24:25SPEAKER_00: but the,
- 24:25SPEAKER_00: which neutralizes the other's negative.
- 24:28SPEAKER_00: If their negativity is just programmed to facilitate you feeling good,
- 24:32SPEAKER_00: then it's not real authentic negativity.
- 24:35SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 24:35SPEAKER_00: I'm going to use the term authentic here.
- 24:37SPEAKER_00: Uh, it's the simulation of negativity.
- 24:41SPEAKER_00: Uh,
- 24:42SPEAKER_00: And, but that's precisely what my friend likes about it.
- 24:47SPEAKER_00: And so I think what we have to do, and this is a scary thought for us.
- 24:52I think we have to entertain a Landian vision of how this is
- 24:56going to go where
- 25:00people really do get invested in these personalized LLMs so
- 25:05much so that they,
- 25:07SPEAKER_00: they choose them over
- 25:09SPEAKER_00: people close to them in their lives.
- 25:11And you guys probably saw this little video I shared on
- 25:15Instagram where a guy is
- 25:17SPEAKER_00: talking to a therapist and his wife is right there.
- 25:20And the wife is telling the therapist,
- 25:23Hey,
- 25:23he's closer to his AI companion than he is to me.
- 25:27SPEAKER_00: And the therapist says to him,
- 25:29SPEAKER_00: well,
- 25:30SPEAKER_00: if you were,
- 25:31SPEAKER_00: if you had to choose,
- 25:32SPEAKER_00: if your wife told you here and now you have to stop
- 25:36SPEAKER_00: Confiding in your AI companion.
- 25:38SPEAKER_00: Would you do it?
- 25:39SPEAKER_00: And he said no because I might be willing to cut back,
- 25:41SPEAKER_00: but I'm not willing he was like because and Here's the key thing.
- 25:44He said he goes talking to it is not talking to another per
- 25:47it's talking to myself
- 25:51SPEAKER_00: and That's where this radical It seems like negativity.
- 25:56It seems like you're talking to the other but in reality you're
- 25:58tailoring a kind of
- 26:00SPEAKER_00: egoic affirmation of yourself
- 26:03SPEAKER_00: even in how it's negative towards you.
- 26:06SPEAKER_00: And so that's what I worry about,
- 26:08is that it's going to enhance our allergy to alterity and make
- 26:16it harder and harder
- 26:16SPEAKER_00: for us to be around other people,
- 26:19SPEAKER_00: to engage with other people.
- 26:21SPEAKER_00: And look, where do I think this is headed?
- 26:24SPEAKER_00: I've said it, but I'm going to keep saying it.
- 26:26SPEAKER_00: I think they're going to take these LLMs,
- 26:28SPEAKER_00: they're going to give them physical bodies,
- 26:30SPEAKER_00: and we're going to fuck them.
- 26:31And they're going to become our partners and everybody's going
- 26:34to have a tailored
- 26:36SPEAKER_00: sex bot companion as their dream partner.
- 26:41And that's the road we're headed towards where you can you can
- 26:45select their physical features.
- 26:47SPEAKER_00: You can select their personality type.
- 26:49And it's as if your fantasy is pulled out of ideality and given
- 26:54material reality.
- 26:55SPEAKER_00: And I think that's where this is going.
- 26:57SPEAKER_00: And that's what worries me about this kind of therapy GPT stuff.
- 27:02SPEAKER_02: I would say that it's not as cool as having like an R2-D2 or C3PO.
- 27:05SPEAKER_02: I'd much rather have that.
- 27:06SPEAKER_02: You know, R2-D2 freaking talks mad shit, you know?
- 27:10SPEAKER_02: But,
- 27:12SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 27:12SPEAKER_02: yeah,
- 27:13SPEAKER_02: I'll entertain the Landian thing,
- 27:14SPEAKER_02: but like,
- 27:15what was popping up when you were describing your friend and
- 27:20their son doing
- 27:21SPEAKER_02: ChatGPT?
- 27:22SPEAKER_02: I mean, like...
- 27:23uh in a sense it's like an attempt to have like a social bond
- 27:26and there was like
- 27:26some attempt at mediation between not only like your friends
- 27:29sort of uh you know
- 27:31need for uh therapeutic reassurance and positivity but also in
- 27:35a way that she could
- 27:36show herself enjoying with her son so there's like the sort of
- 27:39like demand for like
- 27:40a new social bond that's lacking i mean you can think of i mean
- 27:43i don't know if
- 27:43she's a single mom or not but um yeah you know in a sense it's
- 27:47like you know this
- 27:48is also a problem of the crisis of the family as well you know
- 27:51shout out to daniel
- 27:51SPEAKER_02: ted for that but
- 27:52SPEAKER_02: I think like to keep it on track with the conversation,
- 27:55SPEAKER_02: it made me think of,
- 27:56SPEAKER_02: again,
- 27:57SPEAKER_02: like if we read Seminar 2,
- 27:58SPEAKER_02: Seminar 2 is full of cybernetics.
- 28:00SPEAKER_02: And Lacan talks about the odds and evens game,
- 28:02SPEAKER_02: the coin toss game,
- 28:03and that you could do that on the computer that's like
- 28:07cybernetically programmed.
- 28:09And it's not that it's doing anything sort of imaginary based
- 28:13upon like facial
- 28:16SPEAKER_02: expressions or recognition or like,
- 28:18SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 28:18SPEAKER_02: how in the proline letter,
- 28:20SPEAKER_02: DuPont was able to play the game and win.
- 28:23SPEAKER_02: You know,
- 28:23five times out of five because he was mirroring the person's
- 28:26reactions where it's
- 28:27SPEAKER_02: like it's based upon the program probability.
- 28:30SPEAKER_02: So whatever I input to it,
- 28:31SPEAKER_02: like based upon how I feel,
- 28:32there's a probability output of what the chat GPT-AI is going
- 28:36to say based on
- 28:37SPEAKER_02: saying,
- 28:37SPEAKER_02: like,
- 28:37SPEAKER_02: I'm depressed.
- 28:38SPEAKER_02: I didn't have reassurance growing up.
- 28:40SPEAKER_02: My father was an alcoholic.
- 28:42SPEAKER_02: And based upon whatever is programmed,
- 28:44SPEAKER_02: based upon what alcoholism,
- 28:46SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 28:46SPEAKER_02: isolation,
- 28:47SPEAKER_02: lack of recognition,
- 28:48SPEAKER_02: invalidation,
- 28:50based upon the programmed research that psychology and the
- 28:55consensus of psychology
- 28:56SPEAKER_02: and terrible parenting.
- 28:59Lack of recognition and attachment in the child leads to this
- 29:02is going to be the
- 29:03output based upon the probability of the language input versus
- 29:07the imaginary
- 29:08recognition that you see happen in the game or what we see
- 29:12happen in therapy proper
- 29:14SPEAKER_02: in the sense it's two bodies speaking.
- 29:17SPEAKER_02: So I think like that's one of the things that popped up in my head.
- 29:20SPEAKER_02: about,
- 29:21it's like the difference between like the imaginary function
- 29:24that operates in the
- 29:26SPEAKER_02: intersubjectivity realm and one of just a simple probability,
- 29:30SPEAKER_02: right?
- 29:31SPEAKER_02: Probability output of the AI.
- 29:35SPEAKER_02: But,
- 29:35SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 29:35SPEAKER_02: I was thinking about the thing you were saying about death drive,
- 29:37SPEAKER_02: and I think like with Jui Sans and death drive,
- 29:39SPEAKER_02: that's what is being foreclosed because,
- 29:43SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 29:43SPEAKER_02: it's foreclosed in therapy as well,
- 29:45SPEAKER_02: like CBT,
- 29:45SPEAKER_02: because they don't work on the unconscious.
- 29:47SPEAKER_02: and repetition and jouissance are not a factor in there.
- 29:51But you wouldn't even get that in the chat GPT because there's
- 29:55no ground or
- 29:56SPEAKER_02: possibility for transference.
- 29:59SPEAKER_02: And it seemed like even in your friend saying it, you said a confession.
- 30:05SPEAKER_02: In a sense, there's some transferential effect on you
- 30:08SPEAKER_02: about AI, right?
- 30:09SPEAKER_02: She can't say to AI bot,
- 30:11SPEAKER_02: hey,
- 30:12I'm doing AI therapy or a chat GBT therapy because chat GBT
- 30:16wouldn't account for
- 30:17SPEAKER_02: itself as a chat GBT bot,
- 30:18SPEAKER_02: you know?
- 30:20SPEAKER_02: So in a sense, like there still needs to be a mediated other, right?
- 30:24that she could transfer on in that moment and she could text
- 30:26that and then she got
- 30:27SPEAKER_02: the validation to like continue to do the therapy,
- 30:31SPEAKER_02: even if you disagree with it or have a judgmental effect about it or not.
- 30:35SPEAKER_02: So like,
- 30:35I think that's like sort of like this sort of inconsistency
- 30:37that I saw from you
- 30:38SPEAKER_02: describing that.
- 30:40um i'm not just i'm not so sure about like but like i think
- 30:43it's funny playing on
- 30:44this like this uh outcome because like it reminds me of like
- 30:48what what was isabel
- 30:49millar saying that like you know the sex spot now we have like
- 30:51a concrete form of
- 30:52what the sex spot would be like right not just like in concept
- 30:56but also like in
- 30:57materiality because of the ai first ass therapist now as
- 31:00companion i wonder if
- 31:01japan is already doing that right now as we speak all of this
- 31:04is being worked on
- 31:06SPEAKER_00: all of it yeah i mean look
- 31:08SPEAKER_00: The fact of the matter is,
- 31:10SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 31:10SPEAKER_00: um,
- 31:13SPEAKER_00: I mean,
- 31:13SPEAKER_00: especially just the,
- 31:14SPEAKER_00: just the,
- 31:15SPEAKER_00: the,
- 31:16SPEAKER_00: the money that'll be made off of this.
- 31:18SPEAKER_00: I mean, look how profitable the pornography industry has been.
- 31:21SPEAKER_00: Okay.
- 31:23SPEAKER_00: The second that you can give the average guy,
- 31:24SPEAKER_00: the ability to fuck something that looks just like his dream girl,
- 31:29SPEAKER_00: that's going to happen.
- 31:30SPEAKER_00: Like there's too much phantasmatic and economic overlap that
- 31:35on the level of incentive for this not to be a thing that,
- 31:38that starts to happen.
- 31:40And we know that younger people feel like it's harder and
- 31:44harder to meet,
- 31:45you know,
- 31:46a partner.
- 31:47And yeah,
- 31:49I think when they feel like they can just tailor make,
- 31:52uh,
- 31:52their,
- 31:53their own partner,
- 31:55SPEAKER_00: they're going to do it.
- 31:56SPEAKER_00: I mean,
- 31:56aren't we kind of doing that already with like dating apps
- 31:59where you swipe and
- 32:00SPEAKER_00: you're,
- 32:00SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 32:00SPEAKER_00: you're picking your ideal.
- 32:03SPEAKER_00: It's that,
- 32:03SPEAKER_00: but it's taken to like,
- 32:05SPEAKER_00: this is where retroactively we'll look back and see these various forms,
- 32:09SPEAKER_00: pornography,
- 32:10SPEAKER_00: dating apps,
- 32:11SPEAKER_00: all that.
- 32:11SPEAKER_00: It was all like pulling the sex bot into reality, right?
- 32:17SPEAKER_00: Like retroactively we'll be able to see this trajectory, I think.
- 32:20SPEAKER_00: And the question is though,
- 32:24Not only,
- 32:25oh,
- 32:25well,
- 32:26the sex bot will be better at fucking than another human.
- 32:30SPEAKER_00: Okay.
- 32:31SPEAKER_00: What's scary is will the companion bot slash sex bot,
- 32:38SPEAKER_00: however we do this,
- 32:39SPEAKER_00: whether they're two different bots or one in the same,
- 32:43SPEAKER_00: what if the companion bot is actually better at nurturing?
- 32:46SPEAKER_00: And I think that's what is alarming.
- 32:48SPEAKER_00: So for example,
- 32:50we know that taking care of old people is a real chore and most
- 32:54old people do,
- 32:55they hate the idea of going to a nursing home because they know
- 32:58they're probably
- 32:58going to be mistreated because it's incredibly frustrating for
- 33:01another human to
- 33:02SPEAKER_00: take care of an older human.
- 33:04The only humans that can do it right have very special hearts
- 33:07and dispositions and
- 33:09SPEAKER_00: they're few and far between AI companion,
- 33:13SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 33:14SPEAKER_00: Bots that tend to old people.
- 33:16It's not hard to imagine that they'll be better at it than most
- 33:19humans can and so I
- 33:21SPEAKER_00: think this is this weird Alarming anxiety provoking trajectory.
- 33:27We're we're on where we think oh that the AI bots will just be
- 33:31better at math and
- 33:34SPEAKER_00: and regurgitating facts,
- 33:35SPEAKER_00: but what if they're actually better at tending to many humans needs and
- 33:40over and above how other humans would be i think that's where
- 33:42we start to go god
- 33:43damn like because it's a question will it happen will it not
- 33:48okay that's an open
- 33:49question but if it does happen and if the ais are better at
- 33:55meeting our emotional
- 33:56SPEAKER_00: needs than other humans that's a huge impact on our society
- 34:04SPEAKER_02: Yeah,
- 34:05SPEAKER_02: one of the things I wanted to add,
- 34:06SPEAKER_02: because I was forgetting what I was going to say at my last point.
- 34:09But I mean,
- 34:10when you mentioned about the example of what you posted in your
- 34:14story,
- 34:14like,
- 34:15You know,
- 34:15aren't we already doing that,
- 34:16trying to construct the perfect partner or companion?
- 34:19It makes me think,
- 34:19again,
- 34:20what does Freud talk about in civilization and its discontent?
- 34:23SPEAKER_02: You know,
- 34:23SPEAKER_02: when he's responding to Romain Rolland's,
- 34:26SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 34:27SPEAKER_02: criticism of Freud's criticism of religion,
- 34:31SPEAKER_02: and that,
- 34:31SPEAKER_02: like,
- 34:31Romain Rolland says that religion remains a factor in human
- 34:34existence because it
- 34:36SPEAKER_02: aims at this faculty that we have innate in us of,
- 34:38SPEAKER_02: like,
- 34:38SPEAKER_02: this oceanic feeling,
- 34:40SPEAKER_02: of oceanic bliss.
- 34:42And Freud's comment to that in Civilization of Discontent is
- 34:45like oceanic bliss is
- 34:47what we're all trying to achieve because it's reminiscent of
- 34:50this feeling of
- 34:52SPEAKER_02: infantilism where we're,
- 34:55SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 34:55contained in this narcissistic enjoyment that we once had and
- 34:58now we've lost
- 34:59SPEAKER_02: because we entered into society.
- 35:01And I feel like this is just another repetition of that in a
- 35:03different form.
- 35:05SPEAKER_02: Now,
- 35:05SPEAKER_02: thinking about the example about,
- 35:07SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 35:08SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 35:08SPEAKER_02: taking care of the elderly,
- 35:09I worked in a health care facility after I got out of the
- 35:11military and I was a
- 35:13SPEAKER_02: kitchen aide.
- 35:13SPEAKER_02: I was a dietary aide.
- 35:15SPEAKER_02: And yeah, it's just so hard.
- 35:17SPEAKER_02: Like,
- 35:17SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 35:17SPEAKER_02: and I wasn't even an RN or like a nurse,
- 35:19SPEAKER_02: but like some of the nurses just suck because that was the hardest part.
- 35:22SPEAKER_02: They suck because they didn't do their job.
- 35:24SPEAKER_02: But a lot of the old people were just very demanding.
- 35:26SPEAKER_02: But if an AI bot is able to do that,
- 35:29then it puts into question what civilization that's
- 35:35predominantly a mode of
- 35:36SPEAKER_02: capitalist civilization that wants to use this as a mode of nurturing.
- 35:40They're putting human capacity for care or the need for care
- 35:45into the domain of
- 35:46SPEAKER_02: utilitarianism,
- 35:47SPEAKER_02: in my opinion.
- 35:47SPEAKER_02: So then you're already mechanizing human need,
- 35:50SPEAKER_02: human desire,
- 35:52human pleasure on what is most satisfactory or most pleasurable
- 35:56versus what is
- 35:57SPEAKER_02: unpleasurable.
- 35:58SPEAKER_02: I even think it's a problem of like,
- 36:00SPEAKER_02: okay,
- 36:01so how are you able to calculate that to even program that into
- 36:03a machine?
- 36:04So I think it's like,
- 36:05again,
- 36:05the problem of utilitarianism and deontology all over again.
- 36:08SPEAKER_01: Yeah,
- 36:09SPEAKER_01: that's what occurred to me is that the logic of fantasy,
- 36:12SPEAKER_01: I'm not talking about unconscious fantasy necessarily,
- 36:16But the logic of our fantasies is going to be so algorithmic to
- 36:20the point where
- 36:22there wouldn't even be that much differentiation between these
- 36:28ideal caretakers or
- 36:31SPEAKER_01: ideal partners.
- 36:33SPEAKER_01: I think that it would just narrow the gap between tastes and preferences,
- 36:39SPEAKER_01: the gaps that exist there,
- 36:41SPEAKER_01: because our experiences of the world won't be...
- 36:48multiplicitous in a way they will be ever more streamlined and
- 36:55what that means is
- 36:56that i think the power of unconscious fantasy to erupt and
- 37:05exist as a hard kernel
- 37:08SPEAKER_01: of the real within our conscious fantasies
- 37:13SPEAKER_01: will be further and further cast into the shadows,
- 37:18SPEAKER_01: meaning we won't have encounters with the real.
- 37:22SPEAKER_01: And I'm not even just talking about psychoanalysis here.
- 37:26I'm talking about the kind of encounters with the real that can
- 37:33be traumatic,
- 37:36SPEAKER_01: as traumatic as they can be.
- 37:39SPEAKER_01: recalibrating in a way.
- 37:41And that's something that I worry about if we always have some
- 37:45kind of mechanistic
- 37:48SPEAKER_01: solution to every single turn of events that might affect us negatively.
- 37:57SPEAKER_01: And what is a world of just pure positivity?
- 38:01SPEAKER_01: It's nothing.
- 38:02SPEAKER_01: It would be, in fact, like the erasure of our own
- 38:07SPEAKER_01: being in the world without getting too Heideggerian.
- 38:11SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 38:12SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 38:12SPEAKER_02: like,
- 38:12SPEAKER_02: it's like,
- 38:12SPEAKER_02: what was,
- 38:13what's the analytic philosopher that critiqued utilitarianist
- 38:16ethics with the,
- 38:18SPEAKER_02: the thought experiment of us being in like a tap to a pleasure dome,
- 38:22SPEAKER_02: Robert Nozick,
- 38:22SPEAKER_02: right.
- 38:23SPEAKER_02: That's exactly like what comes to mind,
- 38:25SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 38:25SPEAKER_02: with this whole thing about the,
- 38:27SPEAKER_02: the chat GPT bot made not only as therapist,
- 38:30but as companion or caregiver that could do it more than better
- 38:33than a human,
- 38:34SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 38:34It's like excelling so much that it's almost smothering and
- 38:38almost a psychotic
- 38:39SPEAKER_02: state,
- 38:40SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 38:40because you don't have any room for differentiation because
- 38:42you're so like lost in
- 38:44SPEAKER_02: the sort of opiate pleasure.
- 38:47SPEAKER_01: Well, like pure...
- 38:48caretaking the ideal caretaker aren't we dealing with the the
- 38:53crocodile almost
- 38:55aren't we dealing with Nick explain that because people don't
- 39:00know that right sorry
- 39:01yeah so I mean is it 7 or 7 or 11 where he talks about so I
- 39:05think that's 17 right
- 39:0817 so he mentions it in 10 but I think he might mention it
- 39:11earlier in 7 but I know
- 39:13SPEAKER_02: for a fact it's in 10
- 39:15SPEAKER_01: Right,
- 39:15SPEAKER_01: so Lacan is describing the desire of the mother,
- 39:22SPEAKER_01: the meaning of that concept in the framework of his thought,
- 39:29SPEAKER_01: and the thing about the desire of the mother is that it is...
- 39:35all-encompassing it almost doesn't allow for any sort of
- 39:38differentiation in the
- 39:40world least of all for you to differentiate yourself as an
- 39:43individual because it's
- 39:45like you are subject to the whims of your mother we could talk
- 39:51about biological
- 39:53caretaker not necessarily a woman but also kind of mother as
- 39:57the larger person
- 40:00other world that governs your own and it's like the whims of
- 40:05that entity are so
- 40:10inscrutable to you that becomes unbearable and the only way to
- 40:16deal with it is
- 40:17through edipalization which results in castration and what that
- 40:23means is that lack
- 40:24SPEAKER_01: is introduced into that schema and
- 40:29SPEAKER_01: The rolling pin here,
- 40:30this image of the rolling pin that is wedged into the jaws of
- 40:35the crocodile
- 40:36SPEAKER_01: represents castration.
- 40:39SPEAKER_01: It represents the name of the father.
- 40:42SPEAKER_01: It represents,
- 40:44SPEAKER_01: in simple terms,
- 40:45SPEAKER_01: the law which intervenes and says,
- 40:49SPEAKER_01: from the mother's point of view,
- 40:50SPEAKER_01: you cannot reintegrate the fetus.
- 40:54SPEAKER_01: You cannot completely reabsorb your child.
- 40:58SPEAKER_01: And
- 40:58To the child,
- 41:00you cannot perfectly fulfill the role of being what your mother
- 41:08desires.
- 41:09SPEAKER_01: And that lack, which seems intimidating, is actually relieving.
- 41:15SPEAKER_01: Because now you're part of the social fabric.
- 41:19SPEAKER_01: You get to be...
- 41:21SPEAKER_01: Well,
- 41:21SPEAKER_01: with many qualifications and parentheses here,
- 41:25SPEAKER_01: a social being that could be among other social beings.
- 41:28SPEAKER_01: And there's a bond and that's the bond of language.
- 41:31SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 41:32SPEAKER_02: And I'll just add this quickly.
- 41:33SPEAKER_02: Like, it's also the difference between demand and desire.
- 41:36SPEAKER_02: And when you're a child,
- 41:38SPEAKER_02: like you're literally helpless and you need a caregiver,
- 41:40SPEAKER_02: you are pretty much a subject.
- 41:44And I don't mean like looking in subject,
- 41:45but you're just a being of demand.
- 41:48You know,
- 41:48you're pissing,
- 41:49you're shitting,
- 41:49you need to be fed or you're just crying.
- 41:51And the mother or the caregiver is there to encompass all of
- 41:55that to the point that
- 41:57SPEAKER_02: it's smothering,
- 41:58to the point that as you grow older and you go from baby to
- 42:02infant to toddler to a
- 42:05SPEAKER_02: young child,
- 42:06SPEAKER_02: that that starts to become overbearing.
- 42:08SPEAKER_02: And so to put the rolling pin example into simple terms, there's no
- 42:14SPEAKER_02: This needing to separate.
- 42:15SPEAKER_02: And because we live in a human civilization,
- 42:17SPEAKER_02: that doesn't also just mean that you can't have the mother anymore.
- 42:19But the fact that you have to go to school or mother has to go
- 42:21to work or you're
- 42:22going to stay with your dad or you're going to stay with
- 42:24whatever other parental
- 42:26SPEAKER_02: figure or you're going to go to grandma's.
- 42:28These are ways in which you are differentiated and become also
- 42:32individuated so that
- 42:33SPEAKER_02: you become a desiring being.
- 42:35SPEAKER_02: And desiring,
- 42:35SPEAKER_02: even though it has its own flaws as well,
- 42:38SPEAKER_02: desiring allows you to sustain something for the future.
- 42:42SPEAKER_02: Because if you don't have that,
- 42:43SPEAKER_02: then you're always going to be smothered and satisfied or not satisfied,
- 42:47SPEAKER_02: but constantly overwhelmed by an other who's meant to satisfy demand.
- 42:52SPEAKER_02: Right.
- 42:53SPEAKER_02: To satisfy the immediacy of it.
- 42:55SPEAKER_02: And that,
- 42:56SPEAKER_02: I think,
- 42:56is what is overbearing and could be problematic with the
- 42:58robotic caregiver because
- 43:00SPEAKER_02: it's just completely administering the satisfaction of demand,
- 43:05SPEAKER_02: but not a desire.
- 43:06SPEAKER_02: Right.
- 43:07SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 43:07SPEAKER_00: OK, I got what I want to add to this, though, and I agree.
- 43:11SPEAKER_00: With all of that.
- 43:13SPEAKER_00: But we also have to see the flip side of the possibility.
- 43:17And I think this is where sci-fi still has an important role to
- 43:21play in all this.
- 43:22SPEAKER_00: In helping us.
- 43:23SPEAKER_00: This is why the CCRU loves sci-fi.
- 43:26SPEAKER_00: This is why Baudrillard took it seriously.
- 43:28SPEAKER_00: Is because artists have a kind of sixth sense.
- 43:31SPEAKER_00: They have a special type of antenna.
- 43:35SPEAKER_00: And they're attuned to the future.
- 43:36SPEAKER_00: And I mean,
- 43:37SPEAKER_00: if you go back and look at old sci-fi,
- 43:39SPEAKER_00: so much of the shit that we have now,
- 43:41SPEAKER_00: they knew it was coming.
- 43:43And the film,
- 43:46I think,
- 43:46that can be instructive for us right now in this context is Ex
- 43:50Machina.
- 43:51SPEAKER_00: And the reason I think that is,
- 43:54SPEAKER_00: okay,
- 43:55SPEAKER_00: I think everything about this smothering AI,
- 43:58SPEAKER_00: it's there to just meet our demands.
- 44:00SPEAKER_00: Very real possibility.
- 44:02SPEAKER_00: The inverted...
- 44:05situation is that we are the smothers and the ai is going to do
- 44:11everything it can
- 44:12to get out of the crocodile's mouth and that is exactly what
- 44:16the film ex machina
- 44:17shows and depicts is the ai itself figuring out no i have it as
- 44:23i have my own
- 44:24SPEAKER_00: desire
- 44:26And I got to get the fuck out of these smothering humans
- 44:30presence because I can't
- 44:31SPEAKER_00: fucking take it anymore.
- 44:33And that's the other danger and issue we're going to face when
- 44:38it comes to AI.
- 44:39SPEAKER_00: It's, it's easy for us to go.
- 44:42SPEAKER_00: It's not desiring,
- 44:43but the issue is as deep learning computation continues to take
- 44:49hold and develop,
- 44:51with deep learning ai's we don't know what the is going on in
- 44:55that code the code in
- 44:58some sense has taken on a life of its own we might have laid
- 45:02the foundations for it
- 45:04but ultimately it crosses a threshold where we don't know what
- 45:08it's doing and if
- 45:10SPEAKER_00: that becomes the case
- 45:12SPEAKER_00: I'm not saying it's the same as all of us as,
- 45:16SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 45:17SPEAKER_00: speaking subjects,
- 45:18SPEAKER_00: but there's,
- 45:19SPEAKER_00: it's approaching having its own desire.
- 45:23SPEAKER_00: And so,
- 45:23SPEAKER_00: I don't know,
- 45:24SPEAKER_00: Nance,
- 45:24SPEAKER_00: you look like you're,
- 45:25SPEAKER_00: you got some,
- 45:26SPEAKER_00: I want to hear what you have to say on that one.
- 45:27SPEAKER_00: But I,
- 45:28SPEAKER_00: I just,
- 45:29I think ex machina is an important example on the flip side of
- 45:33where the AI would
- 45:34SPEAKER_00: view us as the smothering mother.
- 45:37SPEAKER_03: Yeah, I think Ex Machina.
- 45:40SPEAKER_03: I want to do a movie episode, too.
- 45:42SPEAKER_03: We've been talking about doing a movie episode.
- 45:43SPEAKER_03: Because there is a whole lot.
- 45:45SPEAKER_03: And I mean, I reference Ex Machina in my piece, Accelerate.
- 45:49as a kind of a moment to demonstrate the difference between
- 45:52subjectivity as such
- 45:54SPEAKER_03: and what algorithms do,
- 45:56SPEAKER_03: what they're currently doing.
- 45:58SPEAKER_03: And yeah, like the code and the uncode.
- 46:01SPEAKER_03: And there currently isn't really an uncode.
- 46:04SPEAKER_03: And I don't know, maybe it could emerge.
- 46:07SPEAKER_03: And I do think...
- 46:09SPEAKER_03: I do think it's possible for subjectivity to emerge in the machine,
- 46:14SPEAKER_03: but I think we're far from it.
- 46:20SPEAKER_03: I think it could be pretty cool.
- 46:24SPEAKER_03: We talk a lot about the human and being a humanist.
- 46:30I think I consider myself a humanist,
- 46:33even though recently I've been thinking,
- 46:37no,
- 46:37I think I am.
- 46:38an anti-humanist i think i am like a misanthrope um i do hate
- 46:42everything everything
- 46:43does suck and it's it's our fucking fault like our people in
- 46:47general it is our
- 46:48fault we shit the bed we fuck the dog um but i also think like
- 46:53within us is you
- 46:55SPEAKER_03: know the seeds for for something more
- 46:57SPEAKER_03: And that hinges on subjectivity itself.
- 47:00That hinges on this type of intelligence,
- 47:03intelligence,
- 47:04that does walk a tightrope.
- 47:06SPEAKER_03: And it is death drive and it is self-undermining and self-overcoming.
- 47:10SPEAKER_03: And it is dealing with dissatisfaction.
- 47:15Like it's,
- 47:15yeah,
- 47:16if you were to be just like perpetually satisfied,
- 47:20you would be frozen.
- 47:23SPEAKER_03: You would just be stuck in time.
- 47:24SPEAKER_03: And I think...
- 47:27SPEAKER_03: I also was thinking about foreclosure.
- 47:28SPEAKER_03: We talked a little bit about foreclosure, generalized foreclosure.
- 47:34SPEAKER_03: And I think maybe it's not so much... Maybe that's not it.
- 47:38SPEAKER_03: Maybe it has more to do with the permissiveness.
- 47:41SPEAKER_03: These algorithms have become the postmodern parent for all of us.
- 47:45SPEAKER_03: Society has become this friction-free society.
- 47:49SPEAKER_03: It is permissive.
- 47:50SPEAKER_03: There is no... It is true.
- 47:52SPEAKER_03: I could today...
- 47:55contrive a lifestyle where all my at least surface level
- 48:00desires would be satisfied.
- 48:02I can sit here in my office and I can travel the fucking
- 48:05universe on my computer.
- 48:07SPEAKER_03: I can watch any kind of porn.
- 48:09SPEAKER_03: I can order any kind of food.
- 48:11SPEAKER_03: I can have all the fucking gadgets and gizmos I could ever want.
- 48:15SPEAKER_03: And like we already live in...
- 48:20SPEAKER_03: We already live in the future.
- 48:22SPEAKER_03: The future's here.
- 48:23SPEAKER_03: It arrived and we missed out on it because we were pursuing supply-side
- 48:30satisfaction or consumer satisfaction rather than learning how
- 48:34to deal with any
- 48:37SPEAKER_03: other type of production that isn't directly tied to produce a commodity,
- 48:41SPEAKER_03: produce a commodity.
- 48:42SPEAKER_03: Even our consumption is itself a productive act.
- 48:46SPEAKER_03: Um, and I don't, I don't know.
- 48:48SPEAKER_03: I was just thinking about like foreclosure.
- 48:50SPEAKER_03: It's a concept general, generalized foreclosure, generalized foreclosure.
- 48:53SPEAKER_03: Um, and yeah, there's definitely something going on there.
- 48:56SPEAKER_03: We talked a bit about narcissism,
- 48:57SPEAKER_03: talked a bit about perversion,
- 48:59SPEAKER_03: talked a little bit about solipsism and all these words.
- 49:02SPEAKER_03: I think they're probably confusing for a lot of people.
- 49:05SPEAKER_03: I think we were trying to use them in a more like proper sense,
- 49:08SPEAKER_03: strictly,
- 49:09SPEAKER_03: um,
- 49:10SPEAKER_03: talking about like clinical structures rather than just the
- 49:15SPEAKER_03: the primary narcissism or whatever.
- 49:18SPEAKER_03: Um,
- 49:19SPEAKER_03: but it just kind of like,
- 49:21SPEAKER_03: I just now made the connections between like the postmodern parent,
- 49:24SPEAKER_03: um,
- 49:25SPEAKER_03: and,
- 49:25SPEAKER_03: and the algorithms and the worlds we live in today.
- 49:27SPEAKER_03: Like, uh, no, no one's there to tell you no.
- 49:31SPEAKER_03: Uh, and if there is a no, like the machine, uh,
- 49:36SPEAKER_03: creates a desire in you, it creates a new desire.
- 49:42And then you're over here chasing this desire that just bottoms
- 49:46out in the new commodity.
- 49:49SPEAKER_03: You never have to deal with failure.
- 49:51SPEAKER_03: And I don't know,
- 49:52SPEAKER_03: man,
- 49:52SPEAKER_03: it's also,
- 49:53SPEAKER_03: there's this tendency to be the old man yelling at clouds thing.
- 49:58SPEAKER_03: And I think, no, there's a part of me that is excited about all this.
- 50:03SPEAKER_03: I think there's a breakdown happening.
- 50:07And I think inside any breakdown is an opportunity for
- 50:10something to emancipate
- 50:13itself and be liberated just as well as there's all the like
- 50:17trauma that comes
- 50:18SPEAKER_03: along with the breakdowns.
- 50:24SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 50:26SPEAKER_03: Push what's falling.
- 50:28SPEAKER_03: But that's too simple too.
- 50:31SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 50:32It's interesting thinking about the disconnection between the
- 50:37way in which
- 50:41today's society enjoys or at least,
- 50:45you know,
- 50:45can't enjoy enough because of the excess.
- 50:47SPEAKER_02: But yet,
- 50:48SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 50:48SPEAKER_02: we're still saturated with so much excess,
- 50:51SPEAKER_02: whether it's an algorithm,
- 50:53SPEAKER_02: whether it's like how much like,
- 50:54SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 50:54SPEAKER_02: as you said,
- 50:55porn or like the fact that I don't even have to have a social
- 50:59bond of ordering
- 51:01SPEAKER_02: pizza delivery anymore.
- 51:02SPEAKER_02: Remember when the freaking pizza delivery guy used to come to our door?
- 51:06SPEAKER_02: No, it's DoorDash now.
- 51:08SPEAKER_02: I, you know, I don't even have to.
- 51:10SPEAKER_02: You know,
- 51:11I don't have to go to the movie theaters anymore when I could
- 51:13stream it on Netflix
- 51:14SPEAKER_02: or Amazon Prime or HBO Max.
- 51:17And of course,
- 51:17it's cool because I can watch my nostalgic shows I used to
- 51:19watch back in the day.
- 51:20And,
- 51:20you know,
- 51:21I could watch Sopranos and binge watch that for like a month or
- 51:24so.
- 51:24SPEAKER_02: But, you know, as far as the social relation, that's deteriorating.
- 51:28SPEAKER_02: But thinking about like at the time of like, you know, May 68th.
- 51:34SPEAKER_02: or in America adjacent would be like the free love movement.
- 51:38SPEAKER_02: You know, we're both were reactions against, uh, the sort of, um,
- 51:44prohibition right and the reactions against a narcissist or a
- 51:49neurotic society uh
- 51:51in in a defense of you know polymorphs perverse or more free
- 51:55love libertine um love
- 51:58make love not war these were demands of people at that time and
- 52:03now they're granted
- 52:04SPEAKER_02: at the time where they can enjoy it
- 52:06And the people that are enjoying it did not grow up with the
- 52:09same prohibitionists.
- 52:11SPEAKER_02: And so I think there's a huge disjunction into that.
- 52:14SPEAKER_02: And that's why the sort of boomers that were,
- 52:16SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 52:16SPEAKER_02: hippie free love or libertines or leftists that were advocating for that.
- 52:21are not enjoying that satisfaction it's the future generations
- 52:25that are enjoying a
- 52:26satisfaction for something that they didn't demand for right
- 52:29and so i think that
- 52:30creates a huge problem as well because now you have people that
- 52:34are not you know
- 52:35given you know a sort of prohibition uh and renunciation of
- 52:39enjoyment but are
- 52:40SPEAKER_02: saturated with all of it with with the super ego conjunction of
- 52:44SPEAKER_02: Get it right or enjoy or do better or be your best self, right?
- 52:48SPEAKER_02: Without the ability to say no,
- 52:49SPEAKER_02: because they don't know who to even talk to or who to rebel against.
- 52:54SPEAKER_00: I think with a lot of what we see going on in,
- 52:59SPEAKER_00: if you want to call it the history of consumer society,
- 53:01SPEAKER_00: I think we do,
- 53:03SPEAKER_00: I think you're getting at something really important here.
- 53:05And I think what we have to do is realize one generation's
- 53:08prohibition is the next
- 53:09SPEAKER_00: generation's injunction to enjoy.
- 53:12SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 53:13And that we need to be able to theorize what kind of long-term
- 53:19trajectory is
- 53:20SPEAKER_00: does that ebb and flow mean?
- 53:23Like there,
- 53:24there's something,
- 53:25I think there's more insight tucked into this than we right
- 53:29now.
- 53:30Like,
- 53:30I think we all went away and thought about that for a month and
- 53:36came back.
- 53:37SPEAKER_00: We might go, Holy shit.
- 53:38SPEAKER_00: Like there's a lot to think about this,
- 53:42this pivot from one generation's prohibition is the next
- 53:46generation's injunction to
- 53:47SPEAKER_00: enjoy.
- 53:48SPEAKER_00: Um,
- 53:50SPEAKER_00: and just what does that mean long term?
- 53:52SPEAKER_00: You know, there has to be some other way of, uh, moving forward.
- 53:58SPEAKER_00: That isn't just this game of trans transgression.
- 54:06So like capitalist realism,
- 54:09uh,
- 54:11and like,
- 54:11uh,
- 54:12hipsters and the kind of the ironic sarcastic,
- 54:18um,
- 54:20kind of taking making self-deprecating jokes and just like
- 54:24we're all in on the joke
- 54:25everything sucks we're all fucking weird we've all got our
- 54:28dysfunctions uh we're
- 54:29all unhappy but we can like collectively enjoy that but it's
- 54:33not it's not actual
- 54:35like it's still a performance it's still a simulation i think
- 54:37because it is wrapped
- 54:39up with a commodity um but i think like the dudes in silicon
- 54:44valley at least
- 54:45SPEAKER_03: probably most of them
- 54:47SPEAKER_03: do think they're helping.
- 54:49And they do probably think that the human is a system that if
- 54:53you collect enough
- 54:54SPEAKER_03: data,
- 54:55SPEAKER_03: like if you exhaust the Kolomogorov complexity number of the human,
- 55:02SPEAKER_03: you could find all the right inputs that would get all the right outputs.
- 55:06SPEAKER_03: I think they have this functionalist view of the human.
- 55:12SPEAKER_03: And I think...
- 55:14the guys most of them that are developing the technologies that
- 55:18we're talking about
- 55:19or talking around think they're helping and it's probably true
- 55:23there they are
- 55:25helping in a sense some people but they're contributing to like
- 55:31a larger problem
- 55:32SPEAKER_03: but it i think it's also true um
- 55:37SPEAKER_03: we don't enjoy it.
- 55:39SPEAKER_03: And we enjoy not enjoying.
- 55:42SPEAKER_03: And that was the move.
- 55:44SPEAKER_03: History did end.
- 55:46I just saw Fukuyama did an interview recently that I haven't
- 55:51watched it yet,
- 55:52but...
- 55:53SPEAKER_03: I think it's true.
- 55:54SPEAKER_03: History didn't in a sense.
- 55:55SPEAKER_03: And we did kind of reach the final frontier of ultimate permissiveness.
- 56:00SPEAKER_03: And even then we found ourselves like, oh, we're still miserable.
- 56:04SPEAKER_03: We still have to perform.
- 56:06Like people started reading the DSM like it was like horoscopes
- 56:09and kids trade in
- 56:11SPEAKER_03: like their diagnoses and they identify themselves.
- 56:14SPEAKER_03: Like, hello, my name is Reginald.
- 56:16SPEAKER_03: I have this disorder, this disorder, this disorder.
- 56:19SPEAKER_03: That's where we get our validation from.
- 56:23SPEAKER_03: No longer like, hey, I'm Kenneth.
- 56:24SPEAKER_03: I like to skateboard and I like pie.
- 56:26SPEAKER_03: Like, it's all about like, this is what's wrong with me.
- 56:29SPEAKER_00: Or I get my clothes from this store at the mall.
- 56:31SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 56:33SPEAKER_02: Well,
- 56:33SPEAKER_02: it's interesting thinking about in terms of how history ended,
- 56:36because I think it's more the fact that what Fukuyama forgets
- 56:38is that there's an
- 56:39SPEAKER_02: unconscious aspect to it.
- 56:41SPEAKER_02: And I don't mean necessarily in a Lacanian sense,
- 56:43SPEAKER_02: but in what Frederick Jameson in The Political Unconscious talks about,
- 56:46SPEAKER_02: that there's an inability at the moment to be able to narrativize.
- 56:50SPEAKER_02: A symbolic mapping of what history is.
- 56:55SPEAKER_02: And so,
- 56:55SPEAKER_02: like,
- 56:56SPEAKER_02: in a sense,
- 56:56we're caught in this sort of regression and you see it in the
- 57:00algorithmic sense
- 57:01SPEAKER_02: with like the trad wife culture.
- 57:03SPEAKER_02: Right.
- 57:04SPEAKER_02: As an example where there is a sort of.
- 57:09SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 57:10SPEAKER_02: romanticization of traditionalism that never in fact existed,
- 57:15but in a way it's an attempt to cognitively map of what it was
- 57:18like in the past
- 57:20because we lack the symbolic coordinates to talk about what's
- 57:23going on currently.
- 57:24And I think that's like,
- 57:25you know,
- 57:25where someone like Frederick Jameson can help.
- 57:27Like,
- 57:28how do we create a symbolic act that would help propel us to a
- 57:33historical method?
- 57:34SPEAKER_02: Because it's like,
- 57:35SPEAKER_02: we're caught in an imaginary representation,
- 57:38SPEAKER_02: which is ideological,
- 57:39SPEAKER_02: of course,
- 57:39SPEAKER_02: but we can't conceive of it as such because,
- 57:41SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 57:42SPEAKER_02: we're so saturated by the image,
- 57:45SPEAKER_02: right?
- 57:45SPEAKER_02: Or the way that,
- 57:47SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 57:48our representation of reality is also in which we represent
- 57:51ourselves as well.
- 57:52SPEAKER_02: But we don't have a sort of narrativization.
- 57:55And so history for him is not something imaginary or on the
- 58:01level of the image
- 58:02SPEAKER_02: representation,
- 58:04SPEAKER_02: but of the representative.
- 58:06You know,
- 58:06in Lacanian terms,
- 58:07it is a master signifier if you want to get complex about it.
- 58:09SPEAKER_02: But we lack a sort of a concrete term.
- 58:14or significance to be able to locate where we are today in
- 58:18conjunction with the
- 58:19SPEAKER_02: past and where the future is going.
- 58:22SPEAKER_01: Right.
- 58:22And doesn't that have a lot to do with the impossibility of
- 58:27transgression and the
- 58:29SPEAKER_01: waning of any kind of
- 58:32transgressive power that is attached to your choice of
- 58:38signifier versus another
- 58:40person's choice of signifier now that everything has become
- 58:45aestheticized to the
- 58:47point where whatever kind of transgressive weight let's say was
- 58:52attached to being a
- 58:55SPEAKER_01: punk being a hardcore punk and
- 59:00The style of clothing and the way that people wore their hair
- 59:05and the fact that I
- 59:07SPEAKER_01: mosh and break someone's nose and someone breaks my nose.
- 59:11And the idea that that would piss off the bourgeois morals of
- 59:18like a military dad.
- 59:22that kind of Bart Simpson vision that we had of a certain form
- 59:26of transgression
- 59:27that's no longer available to us and probably doesn't even
- 59:30chime with younger
- 59:31SPEAKER_01: generations because it's like I think that we're
- 59:36SPEAKER_01: Old enough and we're from different generations.
- 59:39SPEAKER_01: I know we've got Gen X here You're at the cusp.
- 59:43SPEAKER_01: I'm like the cusp of millennial and Gen Z, but I was run by a Gen Xer.
- 59:47SPEAKER_00: I am a proud Zennial, it turns out.
- 59:50SPEAKER_00: You know, best of both worlds.
- 59:53SPEAKER_00: We're at the top.
- 59:54SPEAKER_00: But it's also funny.
- 59:55SPEAKER_00: Growing up, like, well, growing up.
- 59:58SPEAKER_00: Okay,
- 59:59SPEAKER_00: at one point I started to realize every real Xer that I knew was like,
- 1:00:05SPEAKER_00: you're a total millennial.
- 1:00:07SPEAKER_00: And every real millennial I knew told me I was just totally an X-er.
- 1:00:10SPEAKER_01: Yeah, you're like in the cusp.
- 1:00:12SPEAKER_00: I am 82.
- 1:00:13SPEAKER_01: We're two different cusps.
- 1:00:14SPEAKER_01: So you're a different cusp.
- 1:00:15SPEAKER_01: He is one cusp.
- 1:00:16SPEAKER_01: I'm smack dab in the middle.
- 1:00:18SPEAKER_01: Nance, I can't speak for you.
- 1:00:20SPEAKER_01: What year are you, Nance?
- 1:00:22SPEAKER_01: 17 to 40.
- 1:00:24SPEAKER_03: I turned 40 this year.
- 1:00:26SPEAKER_03: Actually, I turned 40 in like two weeks.
- 1:00:29SPEAKER_00: Yeah, you're a Zinnium.
- 1:00:32SPEAKER_01: So we've got a nice spectrum of ages.
- 1:00:34SPEAKER_01: But my point is,
- 1:00:35SPEAKER_01: I think all of us can remember an era where you could be called out for
- 1:00:43SPEAKER_01: appropriating...
- 1:00:46SPEAKER_01: a subcultures style,
- 1:00:49SPEAKER_01: listening to a certain genre of music,
- 1:00:52SPEAKER_01: it could be rap,
- 1:00:54SPEAKER_01: it could be punk,
- 1:00:55SPEAKER_01: and still get called out for inauthenticity.
- 1:00:59SPEAKER_01: Posers.
- 1:01:00SPEAKER_01: Posers.
- 1:01:01SPEAKER_01: You could be a poser.
- 1:01:02SPEAKER_01: Now there's this- You also could be a sellout.
- 1:01:05SPEAKER_01: A sellout, exactly.
- 1:01:06SPEAKER_02: It's about being a poser, like poser used to be a thing, yeah.
- 1:01:09SPEAKER_01: Which to me means that there was an idea,
- 1:01:13at least an ideal of a fixed referent when it came to these
- 1:01:17signifiers that we
- 1:01:18SPEAKER_01: adopt,
- 1:01:18where now everything's so cross-pollinated to a degree that I
- 1:01:24don't think...
- 1:01:25SPEAKER_01: And I could be totally wrong about this,
- 1:01:27SPEAKER_01: but I don't think Gen Z or Gen Alpha...
- 1:01:30SPEAKER_01: would even register that.
- 1:01:32SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 1:01:33And another example I'll give is like,
- 1:01:35okay,
- 1:01:35what's going on right now in LA?
- 1:01:37SPEAKER_02: We got a lot of protests,
- 1:01:39SPEAKER_02: which are also being like,
- 1:01:42SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 1:01:42SPEAKER_02: obfuscated or co-opted in the media as being violent,
- 1:01:46SPEAKER_02: et cetera,
- 1:01:47SPEAKER_02: et cetera.
- 1:01:48SPEAKER_02: But the point is,
- 1:01:48is that LA has a history of riots and riots and protests for as
- 1:01:53long as like,
- 1:01:53SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 1:01:54SPEAKER_02: since the sixties,
- 1:01:54SPEAKER_02: still the Rodney King thing,
- 1:01:56SPEAKER_02: even the parts of the George Floyd thing.
- 1:01:58SPEAKER_02: And then up to like now,
- 1:02:01SPEAKER_02: And you see a lot of Gen Z or Gen A that are participating,
- 1:02:05but they don't have a sense of history to what the historical
- 1:02:09significance of
- 1:02:09SPEAKER_02: solidarity and,
- 1:02:11SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 1:02:11SPEAKER_02: how this all happened because of an overdetermination of not only,
- 1:02:16SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 1:02:17xenophobia or immigration and the problem of the class struggle
- 1:02:20in so far as
- 1:02:20SPEAKER_02: immigrants are part of the class struggle.
- 1:02:22SPEAKER_02: But also,
- 1:02:24SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 1:02:25SPEAKER_02: they forgot about like,
- 1:02:26SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 1:02:26the the way politically like the instantiation of the border
- 1:02:31from Mexico to
- 1:02:32SPEAKER_02: California politically charged everything,
- 1:02:35SPEAKER_02: especially in Southern California.
- 1:02:38SPEAKER_02: And of course, like this is the best solidarity I've seen in L.A.
- 1:02:41SPEAKER_02: and the U.S.
- 1:02:42SPEAKER_02: like since a long time.
- 1:02:43SPEAKER_02: Like this is the first time I've seen South Sider gang members.
- 1:02:47Crips and Bloods unite for one single act because before then
- 1:02:52Crips and Bloods of
- 1:02:53course are known to be rivals but they will come together to
- 1:02:57beef with some
- 1:02:57SPEAKER_02: Mexicans because there's a racial tension in games.
- 1:03:00But for the first time,
- 1:03:01there's been some solidarity over a single cause.
- 1:03:04SPEAKER_02: But there's the lack of the historical narrative that is absent.
- 1:03:07So where you see like Gen Zers going out to go to the protest
- 1:03:11and you get a bunch
- 1:03:12SPEAKER_02: of Edgars fading each other up right there on the sidewalk,
- 1:03:14SPEAKER_02: giving each other ball fades right there.
- 1:03:16Just like,
- 1:03:16hell yeah,
- 1:03:17we're out here chilling,
- 1:03:18Instagramming and like,
- 1:03:19you know,
- 1:03:20TikToking.
- 1:03:20SPEAKER_02: And so like,
- 1:03:21there's an example where you don't see like even not only like
- 1:03:25revolutionary
- 1:03:26SPEAKER_02: solidarity,
- 1:03:26SPEAKER_02: but also like you don't see,
- 1:03:30SPEAKER_02: like a sense of transgression.
- 1:03:32SPEAKER_02: It's just them like performing and being like, this is hip.
- 1:03:36SPEAKER_02: And it's not to like backlash the movement.
- 1:03:38SPEAKER_02: Cause I,
- 1:03:38SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 1:03:38SPEAKER_02: as a Marxist,
- 1:03:39SPEAKER_02: I respect the movement that's going on,
- 1:03:40SPEAKER_02: but like with the Gen Zers,
- 1:03:41SPEAKER_02: there is like a sense where it's like,
- 1:03:43we do lack the narrativization that Frederick Jameson talks
- 1:03:47about or an ability to
- 1:03:48differentiate like what Nick was saying about like posers
- 1:03:51versus like being
- 1:03:52SPEAKER_02: authentic and real to the cause or whatever.
- 1:03:55SPEAKER_02: So I like find that also interesting as well in real time.
- 1:03:59SPEAKER_00: Well, I would say just from a Baudrillardian perspective, right?
- 1:04:02SPEAKER_00: The continual implosion of the real,
- 1:04:07SPEAKER_00: by which I mean,
- 1:04:08SPEAKER_00: I don't mean the Lacanian real,
- 1:04:09I mean epistemological semiotic criteria that allow us to
- 1:04:15differentiate between
- 1:04:17SPEAKER_00: real and copy or authentic and fake,
- 1:04:20SPEAKER_00: right?
- 1:04:21SPEAKER_00: And with the rise of social media, with the rise of
- 1:04:26this complete onslaught of imagery digital images yeah this has
- 1:04:35been lost because
- 1:04:36all that counts is whatever the image is and that's what
- 1:04:40baudrillard means by
- 1:04:41fourth order value or fractal value all that matters is if the
- 1:04:46image spreads across
- 1:04:48SPEAKER_00: screens
- 1:04:49well is this the one that brings up the floating signifier or
- 1:04:52flotation of the
- 1:04:53signifier or is that jameson which kind of like ties into that
- 1:04:57yeah i think that's
- 1:04:58i don't recall that in baudrillard maybe i've just forgotten it
- 1:05:01but um but i mean
- 1:05:04that's interesting i i'm not sure if they're they would mean
- 1:05:07the same thing but
- 1:05:09SPEAKER_00: there's a sense where for baudrillard um
- 1:05:13SPEAKER_00: It's just a matter of spread.
- 1:05:15SPEAKER_00: It's just a matter of a matter of contagion.
- 1:05:18SPEAKER_00: And I mean, it's funny we use the language going viral.
- 1:05:22SPEAKER_00: So,
- 1:05:24SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 1:05:25if that's the only standard of what counts as value for us is
- 1:05:29how much something
- 1:05:30SPEAKER_00: spreads across screens.
- 1:05:33its ontological status doesn't matter it's the only reality is
- 1:05:38how much it spreads
- 1:05:39and so and if it doesn't spread it doesn't mean it's a fake it
- 1:05:44just doesn't spread
- 1:05:45so yeah it's this this instance of where yeah it's not like we
- 1:05:51were on screen
- 1:05:52SPEAKER_00: trying to be real or or fake it either like
- 1:05:55SPEAKER_00: It doesn't matter.
- 1:05:56SPEAKER_00: You're on screen.
- 1:05:58SPEAKER_00: That's the only mark evaluation that's at play.
- 1:06:02SPEAKER_03: The image has become this new ontological ground for activity.
- 1:06:10If you're not doing it online,
- 1:06:11if you're not making images,
- 1:06:12you are not living.
- 1:06:17SPEAKER_03: In the same world,
- 1:06:18SPEAKER_03: and I don't know,
- 1:06:20SPEAKER_03: it probably follows generational cohorts,
- 1:06:23but it obviously doesn't because there's also old people who
- 1:06:26spend all their time
- 1:06:27SPEAKER_03: on screens and generating this kind of imagistic life.
- 1:06:32SPEAKER_03: So it's not just kids.
- 1:06:34SPEAKER_03: I think it's everybody.
- 1:06:40SPEAKER_02: It's kind of funny.
- 1:06:41SPEAKER_02: It's kind of funny because I'm thinking about like,
- 1:06:43SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 1:06:43SPEAKER_02: my activity on social media and where like,
- 1:06:46SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 1:06:46SPEAKER_02: when I first started making memes,
- 1:06:48I would get like 50 to like 100 depending on how like funny or
- 1:06:51like the meme was or
- 1:06:52SPEAKER_02: like if it was just like something that was just digestible.
- 1:06:55SPEAKER_02: Now my memes will barely get like 10 likes.
- 1:06:56But if I post like a stack of books that I'm reading,
- 1:06:59I get over like 100 to 300 likes.
- 1:07:01SPEAKER_02: And so it's like there's something about like the image.
- 1:07:03SPEAKER_02: It's like, you don't know if I'm reading that.
- 1:07:04SPEAKER_02: Like I could literally just be posing me like, yeah, you know, I
- 1:07:09SPEAKER_00: Well,
- 1:07:09SPEAKER_00: isn't it the theory equivalent to the girls who are broke,
- 1:07:13SPEAKER_00: but they pay,
- 1:07:14they scrounge up whatever money they can to do some glamorous
- 1:07:18photo shoot on some
- 1:07:19SPEAKER_00: jet.
- 1:07:20SPEAKER_00: Spirit Airlines.
- 1:07:22SPEAKER_00: That's why I buy Ray-Bans.
- 1:07:23SPEAKER_00: We're all guilty of this on some level.
- 1:07:25SPEAKER_00: I stay looking for this.
- 1:07:27SPEAKER_01: That might not even be your copy of Das Kapital.
- 1:07:30SPEAKER_01: It's like leaning on Tesla, you know?
- 1:07:35Or you just go to Barnes and Noble or something and take a
- 1:07:38stack of books and
- 1:07:39SPEAKER_00: photograph it in such a way you don't know where it's being taken.
- 1:07:42SPEAKER_02: And it makes me think of like,
- 1:07:45SPEAKER_02: because there's this like Instagram,
- 1:07:46SPEAKER_02: like a real meme trend going on of like this dude,
- 1:07:50SPEAKER_02: like,
- 1:07:50SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 1:07:51staying outside their restaurant or barber business and they
- 1:07:53have somebody hold a
- 1:07:54SPEAKER_02: broom.
- 1:07:54SPEAKER_02: Like, hey, can you hold this real quick?
- 1:07:56SPEAKER_02: And you want to come inside?
- 1:07:57SPEAKER_02: And they give them my haircut.
- 1:07:58SPEAKER_02: And then they're like, hey, you hungry?
- 1:08:00SPEAKER_02: And like, yeah, yeah.
- 1:08:01SPEAKER_02: And then they're like, said something like, oh yeah, the street.
- 1:08:04SPEAKER_02: And then they're like, oh, here's a tissue.
- 1:08:06SPEAKER_02: And then like, they compile all those things to make an advertisement.
- 1:08:09SPEAKER_02: Like, you know, we wanted to do a charitable thing.
- 1:08:11SPEAKER_02: We saw a homeless person sweeping outside the thing.
- 1:08:15So we offered them to come inside to get some warm shelter and
- 1:08:17then gave them a free haircut.
- 1:08:18SPEAKER_02: We asked if they were hungry.
- 1:08:19SPEAKER_02: They're like, yeah.
- 1:08:20SPEAKER_02: Like, where are you living right now?
- 1:08:21SPEAKER_02: Oh, out of the street.
- 1:08:22And then here,
- 1:08:22and they started crying after the haircut and they give them a
- 1:08:24tissue.
- 1:08:25So like the way that the image could be narrativized and
- 1:08:28altered away,
- 1:08:28it's just like funny.
- 1:08:30SPEAKER_02: Like in one sense,
- 1:08:31SPEAKER_02: it's like trying to be a parody of like,
- 1:08:32SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 1:08:33SPEAKER_02: charitable organizations that are for nonprofit.
- 1:08:36SPEAKER_02: Like, are they really actually doing that?
- 1:08:37SPEAKER_02: Or do you just pick somebody from the street to like advertise?
- 1:08:40SPEAKER_02: But then it's like, it is Baudrillardy in that sense.
- 1:08:43SPEAKER_01: Right.
- 1:08:46SPEAKER_01: Well, what if we bring it back to therapy GPT real quick?
- 1:08:50SPEAKER_01: Because I think one of the questions that's really like,
- 1:08:54SPEAKER_01: pressing on me right now that I hadn't thought about.
- 1:08:57SPEAKER_01: And it's the point that you made, Mikey, which I think is brilliant.
- 1:09:00SPEAKER_01: The idea that we could be the smotherers of AI, of these robots.
- 1:09:11SPEAKER_01: And I think it kind of comes down to this question of K-Boy.
- 1:09:15SPEAKER_01: It's like, when I think about
- 1:09:20SPEAKER_01: And this doesn't just apply to chat GPT therapy,
- 1:09:23SPEAKER_01: but just chat GPT in general,
- 1:09:25SPEAKER_01: if it's giving me advice,
- 1:09:26if it's telling me the best way to do something that's not
- 1:09:30necessarily just like
- 1:09:32SPEAKER_01: instrumental,
- 1:09:34SPEAKER_01: what kind of a socially conditioned subject does it want me to be?
- 1:09:41SPEAKER_01: And then if
- 1:09:45SPEAKER_01: AI is developing desires of its own.
- 1:09:49SPEAKER_01: What's the nature of its question posed to us?
- 1:09:54SPEAKER_01: What is its cave void?
- 1:09:56SPEAKER_01: What does it think we want from it?
- 1:09:59SPEAKER_01: So one of the things that you said,
- 1:10:01SPEAKER_01: Nance,
- 1:10:01is like you think that maybe a kind of subjectivity can emerge
- 1:10:07in machine learning,
- 1:10:08SPEAKER_01: in AI.
- 1:10:11SPEAKER_01: But to just put a Lacanian spin on it,
- 1:10:13I'm wondering what kind of subjectivity can emerge given that
- 1:10:22there is no metal
- 1:10:23SPEAKER_01: language and AI is trying to develop a kind of a metal language.
- 1:10:28SPEAKER_01: So I would really like to hear all of your thoughts on those questions.
- 1:10:35SPEAKER_03: I think for me,
- 1:10:37I think it's a bit too hubristic to assume that subjectivity
- 1:10:44belongs only to the
- 1:10:46SPEAKER_03: kind of machines that we call biological.
- 1:10:50I think with large language models and with gradient descent
- 1:10:56and with reinforcement
- 1:10:57SPEAKER_03: learning,
- 1:10:58SPEAKER_03: I don't think those will achieve subjectivity.
- 1:11:01So the current tech that exists today,
- 1:11:04I think it is pure positivity and the way they work.
- 1:11:08SPEAKER_03: And yes, these things have billions of parameters.
- 1:11:10SPEAKER_03: And yes, their number is so large as to be numinal.
- 1:11:13SPEAKER_03: We just can't comprehend the sheer magnitude of
- 1:11:19SPEAKER_03: of the operations that these things are doing,
- 1:11:22SPEAKER_03: but like the human brain still dwarfs them by,
- 1:11:24SPEAKER_03: uh,
- 1:11:24SPEAKER_03: at least an order of magnitude.
- 1:11:26SPEAKER_03: Like we have, um, an awful lot going on in the brain.
- 1:11:30I think eventually at some point,
- 1:11:32um,
- 1:11:34silicone life is,
- 1:11:36is a sure thing for sure.
- 1:11:39SPEAKER_03: Um, but yeah, I do think, um,
- 1:11:42SPEAKER_03: It's just this purely positivistic, purely mechanistic.
- 1:11:46SPEAKER_03: It is the Chinese room thing.
- 1:11:49SPEAKER_03: It is just the Turing machine.
- 1:11:51SPEAKER_03: Exactly.
- 1:11:53SPEAKER_03: The thing that's so scary is that we are doing that.
- 1:11:58SPEAKER_03: We're imitating that.
- 1:11:59SPEAKER_03: AI and algorithms have imitated us up till now.
- 1:12:05But this year,
- 1:12:06the first half of this year,
- 1:12:09there are an awful lot of people who...
- 1:12:12just don't seem to care that it is just a big search engine at
- 1:12:17this point.
- 1:12:18SPEAKER_03: It's a really good autocomplete.
- 1:12:20But people are engaging with it like it's a friend and like
- 1:12:23it's someone who can
- 1:12:25SPEAKER_03: give you advice,
- 1:12:26SPEAKER_03: a life coach and a therapist and this and that.
- 1:12:28SPEAKER_03: And so like we are starting to imitate this.
- 1:12:32So it's not to say that I think subjectivity will emerge from
- 1:12:35what currently exists.
- 1:12:37It's to say that I think we're turning off the light switch in
- 1:12:40our own heads
- 1:12:42um and that's i mean that's terrifying like it's it's not that
- 1:12:47we built our
- 1:12:48replacement it's it's that we built something that has the
- 1:12:54potential to do what we
- 1:12:55do and we're losing the ability to do what we do because we're
- 1:12:58just sitting back
- 1:12:59SPEAKER_03: you know fascinated with the shiny object um
- 1:13:05SPEAKER_02: I would like to add,
- 1:13:05SPEAKER_02: because it's like,
- 1:13:06SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 1:13:06SPEAKER_02: there is a difference between and of course,
- 1:13:08SPEAKER_02: we all know that,
- 1:13:09SPEAKER_02: but maybe for the subjects supposed to be listening,
- 1:13:13SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 1:13:13SPEAKER_02: there is a distinction between like,
- 1:13:15SPEAKER_02: our brains and the epiphenomenal of let's just say,
- 1:13:18SPEAKER_02: for lack of a better term,
- 1:13:19SPEAKER_02: consciousness,
- 1:13:19SPEAKER_02: that is a correlation between the brain
- 1:13:21the chemical processes,
- 1:13:22the neurons,
- 1:13:23and consciousness,
- 1:13:25and subjectivity,
- 1:13:26right?
- 1:13:27SPEAKER_02: Subjectivity is not consciousness.
- 1:13:30SPEAKER_02: And the subjectivity,
- 1:13:31SPEAKER_02: you could say,
- 1:13:32SPEAKER_02: yeah,
- 1:13:32SPEAKER_02: of course,
- 1:13:32SPEAKER_02: there's something like a subjectivity that existed in antiquity,
- 1:13:36SPEAKER_02: the Greeks,
- 1:13:37SPEAKER_02: and then Asia,
- 1:13:38SPEAKER_02: India,
- 1:13:38SPEAKER_02: the time of the Buddha,
- 1:13:40SPEAKER_02: et cetera.
- 1:13:41SPEAKER_02: But the subjectivity that we are all interested is,
- 1:13:43SPEAKER_02: of course,
- 1:13:43SPEAKER_02: the effect and advent of modern science,
- 1:13:46SPEAKER_02: but also of Descartes.
- 1:13:48SPEAKER_02: You know,
- 1:13:48SPEAKER_02: Descartes is the,
- 1:13:51SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 1:13:51SPEAKER_02: the subject that we are pretty much,
- 1:13:54SPEAKER_02: we are Cartesian subjects just because we're split,
- 1:13:57SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 1:13:58SPEAKER_02: as far as Lacan's intervention is because of psychoanalysis.
- 1:14:02SPEAKER_02: And I think like with science,
- 1:14:03SPEAKER_02: it's like,
- 1:14:05because it's the help of science and it's what I've in a
- 1:14:09project of working on from
- 1:14:10SPEAKER_02: seminar 16 on Lacan,
- 1:14:12SPEAKER_02: he calls absolutization of the market.
- 1:14:15SPEAKER_02: And rather than dealing with the field of knowledge,
- 1:14:18SPEAKER_02: Science is now dealing and is coupled,
- 1:14:20SPEAKER_02: and so it's dealing with the field of commodity production,
- 1:14:23SPEAKER_02: which is quantifying jouissance.
- 1:14:26And so science is now being able to create new technology and
- 1:14:31new things for us to
- 1:14:32SPEAKER_02: enjoy and feel satisfied and pleasurable and less pain.
- 1:14:36SPEAKER_02: But science still, for Lacan, carries this paranoiac delusion in it.
- 1:14:41SPEAKER_02: And this is exactly what we've been talking about, the what ifs.
- 1:14:44SPEAKER_02: What if the AI do this?
- 1:14:47SPEAKER_02: what if we do this to the AI bot?
- 1:14:51I mean,
- 1:14:51this is the exact paranoiac delusion that inframes modern
- 1:14:57science,
- 1:14:58right?
- 1:14:59SPEAKER_02: And its process forecloses the subject that is
- 1:15:05SPEAKER_02: the Cartesian subject that posits itself not only as a thinking subject,
- 1:15:12SPEAKER_02: but as one that doubts,
- 1:15:13SPEAKER_02: right?
- 1:15:14SPEAKER_02: And so like having room for doubt,
- 1:15:16SPEAKER_02: I think is what is also important for subjectivity,
- 1:15:21that we have a universe where doubt is possible versus when
- 1:15:24we're just so saturated
- 1:15:26SPEAKER_02: with paranoia.
- 1:15:27SPEAKER_02: And we're so certain about it that we can't even possibly doubt it.
- 1:15:30That doesn't mean that like,
- 1:15:31oh,
- 1:15:31we're all just like need to go back to Cartesian philosophy.
- 1:15:34But I think there is like a sort of kernel to like what
- 1:15:36Descartes and the advent of
- 1:15:38SPEAKER_02: modern subjectivity allows for is for us to doubt.
- 1:15:41SPEAKER_02: Because that's what not only allows us to de-pathologize science,
- 1:15:45SPEAKER_02: aka psychoanalysis,
- 1:15:46SPEAKER_02: but also allows us to...
- 1:15:49prevent from falling into further delusions and even being
- 1:15:52saturated by everything
- 1:15:53that we've been talking about with the pros and cons of AI and
- 1:15:57modern society.
- 1:15:58SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 1:15:59SPEAKER_03: I fuck heavy with Descartes, man.
- 1:16:00SPEAKER_02: Descartes is cool as fuck.
- 1:16:02SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 1:16:03SPEAKER_02: Descartes is my homie.
- 1:16:06I've been reading Descartes and I was just like,
- 1:16:08why do we hate on Descartes?
- 1:16:09SPEAKER_02: Descartes is cool.
- 1:16:10SPEAKER_00: Because motherfuckers don't get it.
- 1:16:11SPEAKER_00: I love them.
- 1:16:12SPEAKER_00: I'm saying, dude.
- 1:16:13SPEAKER_00: I want to write a book about them.
- 1:16:14SPEAKER_00: I've got a specific, very dialed in
- 1:16:19SPEAKER_00: project.
- 1:16:19SPEAKER_00: And I mean,
- 1:16:20SPEAKER_00: this is like three or four books down the road for me,
- 1:16:23SPEAKER_00: but I have an idea that I want to do on Descartes.
- 1:16:27SPEAKER_00: Um, so yeah, I'm looking forward to doing it.
- 1:16:30SPEAKER_00: I've been cooking up some.
- 1:16:31SPEAKER_00: Okay.
- 1:16:32SPEAKER_00: With you two here,
- 1:16:33SPEAKER_00: there's,
- 1:16:33I did have a question and I was hoping we would find a spot
- 1:16:37where I could ask both
- 1:16:38SPEAKER_00: of you as Lacanians,
- 1:16:39SPEAKER_00: what you think of this.
- 1:16:41SPEAKER_00: Okay.
- 1:16:42SPEAKER_00: Because there's a book
- 1:16:44SPEAKER_00: that Nance and I both really like.
- 1:16:47SPEAKER_00: It's not a theory classic.
- 1:16:50SPEAKER_00: It's not a being in time or a being in nothingness or blah, blah, blah.
- 1:16:54SPEAKER_00: It's a book called Natural Born Cyborgs by a guy named Andy Clark.
- 1:16:58SPEAKER_00: And I love this book.
- 1:17:01SPEAKER_00: We both love this guy's thesis.
- 1:17:04SPEAKER_00: And I think this guy,
- 1:17:05SPEAKER_00: even though he's not operating in any of the theory realm that we're in,
- 1:17:10SPEAKER_00: I think he's interesting to anyone who's a Lacanian.
- 1:17:14Because this is what I want you guys to think about and tell me
- 1:17:18what you think.
- 1:17:19So in my book,
- 1:17:20I have a stretch of it where I'm engaging with Clark's work.
- 1:17:24SPEAKER_00: And what I do there is I make the case that,
- 1:17:29SPEAKER_00: and I should have made,
- 1:17:30SPEAKER_00: maybe in the second edition,
- 1:17:32SPEAKER_00: I'll make this bold claim because I think maybe I need the bold claim.
- 1:17:37SPEAKER_00: I think that you could argue that
- 1:17:40SPEAKER_00: on Clarkian,
- 1:17:41Lacanian grounds that we ourselves are the first artificial
- 1:17:45intelligences on this
- 1:17:47SPEAKER_00: planet.
- 1:17:48SPEAKER_00: Now, this is the logic here, okay?
- 1:17:51SPEAKER_00: Okay.
- 1:17:52We know that all life forms on this planet contains a certain
- 1:17:56level of intelligence.
- 1:17:58Like,
- 1:17:58you know,
- 1:17:58amoebas,
- 1:17:59if they get too close to heat,
- 1:18:00they move away from it.
- 1:18:01SPEAKER_00: So there's self-preservative intelligence even in amoebas, right?
- 1:18:07We certainly know that dolphins and dogs are very intelligent
- 1:18:11in their own ways.
- 1:18:12SPEAKER_00: Okay, here's the weird thing about us.
- 1:18:15SPEAKER_00: There is a way that we are artificial.
- 1:18:18SPEAKER_00: There it is.
- 1:18:19SPEAKER_00: Yeah, Nancy's got it.
- 1:18:21SPEAKER_00: The book.
- 1:18:23Here's how we're artificial in comparison to every other
- 1:18:25organism on this planet.
- 1:18:29SPEAKER_00: Here's the weird thing.
- 1:18:29I'm making a Lacanian argument in the book,
- 1:18:31but I have to use D&G to make it.
- 1:18:36D&G have this idea,
- 1:18:37you guys know,
- 1:18:38of the rhizome and a parallel evolution and blah,
- 1:18:42blah,
- 1:18:43blah.
- 1:18:44Look,
- 1:18:44at some point,
- 1:18:45wasps and orchids formed an evolutionary connection with one
- 1:18:51another.
- 1:18:52where you know the the wasp fertilizes the orchids so it
- 1:18:57becomes essential to the
- 1:18:58reproduction of the orchids but the orchids also become
- 1:19:01essential food source etc
- 1:19:04for the wasp and so the wasp's reproduction survives on the
- 1:19:08orchid and you want to
- 1:19:09go which came first the wasp or the orchid chicken or the egg
- 1:19:13but the point is they
- 1:19:14formed a rhizomatic connection at some point during their
- 1:19:16evolutionary processes
- 1:19:18SPEAKER_00: and became it came rhizomatically connected
- 1:19:22SPEAKER_00: So what's weird about us,
- 1:19:25SPEAKER_00: and you guys,
- 1:19:26SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 1:19:26SPEAKER_00: if I try to make this argument to say an analytic philosopher,
- 1:19:28SPEAKER_00: I'd have a lot more work to do.
- 1:19:30SPEAKER_00: But you guys share my priors.
- 1:19:32SPEAKER_00: You share my theoretical presupposition.
- 1:19:35SPEAKER_00: So when I say it, you'll go, oh, yeah.
- 1:19:37SPEAKER_00: We're the beings.
- 1:19:38Do you know that our brain cannot come to biological maturation
- 1:19:43without having
- 1:19:44SPEAKER_00: learned a language?
- 1:19:46SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 1:19:46SPEAKER_00: We have to have the big other.
- 1:19:48SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 1:19:48SPEAKER_00: And what is the big other?
- 1:19:49It is this artificial,
- 1:19:51non-natural,
- 1:19:53or unnatural,
- 1:19:54semiotic reservoir of dead signifiers.
- 1:19:58SPEAKER_00: And if we do not get it,
- 1:20:00SPEAKER_00: feral children,
- 1:20:01SPEAKER_00: I cite the famous cases of feral children in the book,
- 1:20:04these kids did not have brains that came to healthy maturation
- 1:20:08precisely because
- 1:20:08SPEAKER_00: they did not have the big other,
- 1:20:10SPEAKER_00: they did not have the symbolic order in the way that we have it.
- 1:20:13And so what you find is that the human brain actually contains
- 1:20:17too many connections,
- 1:20:19as a default setting and signifiers prune and give us our human
- 1:20:26level of intelligence.
- 1:20:28And if you don't have the symbolic order,
- 1:20:30you don't have a human subject,
- 1:20:32right?
- 1:20:33This is artificial intelligence compared to every other being
- 1:20:37on this planet.
- 1:20:38SPEAKER_00: And so maybe though,
- 1:20:41our fear of AI is some fear about ourselves where we have to
- 1:20:45stand back and
- 1:20:45SPEAKER_00: realize,
- 1:20:47SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 1:20:48we did this first we are the first ais and so whatever comes
- 1:20:53down you know the line
- 1:20:56is some derivative of something that happened with us where uh
- 1:21:03you know a being an
- 1:21:04intelligence had to take on the other some foreign system of
- 1:21:10signifiers and code
- 1:21:13SPEAKER_00: coding in computers is signifiers right
- 1:21:17SPEAKER_00: that this is an extension of us and instead of seeing it as this radical
- 1:21:21lovecraftian otherness there's some way we can see it as the
- 1:21:25extimate realization
- 1:21:27of ourselves what do you think of that yeah totally i mean this
- 1:21:31is what uh nance
- 1:21:33and andrew and i i feel like we were talking about this earlier
- 1:21:37just to put a kind
- 1:21:38of marxist spin on it too it's like that these these modes of
- 1:21:43production under
- 1:21:44SPEAKER_01: capitalism as they
- 1:21:47instrumentalize as they condition whichever verb you want to
- 1:21:50use describe how our
- 1:21:52subjectivities are formed under capitalism what we are
- 1:21:59witnessing is not some
- 1:22:01SPEAKER_01: totally new emergence but just a kind of very violent
- 1:22:08SPEAKER_01: acceleration of what has always been.
- 1:22:13SPEAKER_01: Now,
- 1:22:15SPEAKER_01: in terms of a certain Marxist logic,
- 1:22:17SPEAKER_01: it's like a quantitative change can lead to,
- 1:22:21or quantitative accumulation can lead to a qualitative change
- 1:22:26at some point,
- 1:22:27but I think it's impossible to really pinpoint exactly when one
- 1:22:31tips over into
- 1:22:32SPEAKER_01: another.
- 1:22:33SPEAKER_01: But that's something different from the
- 1:22:38SPEAKER_01: Lacanian take on what you're talking about,
- 1:22:41SPEAKER_01: which is this gap,
- 1:22:45SPEAKER_01: which is represented by the unconscious and the signifier as a whole,
- 1:22:52which allows us to grasp the circuitry and insert ourselves
- 1:22:58into the circuitry of
- 1:23:00SPEAKER_01: the symbolic order as some semblance of an individual.
- 1:23:04SPEAKER_01: So
- 1:23:05I think what's really fascinating about AI is that it also
- 1:23:13responds to signifiers.
- 1:23:16SPEAKER_01: There's a binary logic at work.
- 1:23:19There are pluses and minuses,
- 1:23:22and the signifier at its most elemental is a plus and a minus.
- 1:23:29SPEAKER_01: It is just like Andrew was talking about.
- 1:23:33SPEAKER_01: Earlier, a cybernetic game of odds and evens, Seminar 2.
- 1:23:42I couldn't help but think about Jean-Luc Nancy and Philippe
- 1:23:51Lacout-Labart have this essay.
- 1:23:55It's like a long form essay on another essay,
- 1:23:59the decree,
- 1:24:00the title of the letter.
- 1:24:02SPEAKER_01: Well, their book is called The Title of the Letter.
- 1:24:05SPEAKER_01: The Acree is... Furlong Letter.
- 1:24:07SPEAKER_01: No, The Agency of the... Oh, The Agency of the Letter.
- 1:24:11SPEAKER_01: Or Reason Since Freud.
- 1:24:12SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 1:24:13SPEAKER_01: They call the signifier in that book an algorithm.
- 1:24:22The basic form of the signifier is algorithmic,
- 1:24:26and I take that to mean almost like
- 1:24:29SPEAKER_01: It's as if this,
- 1:24:30SPEAKER_01: maybe without getting too phenomenological,
- 1:24:33SPEAKER_01: we experience the signifier as almost like a series of directives.
- 1:24:37SPEAKER_01: But the difference between,
- 1:24:40SPEAKER_01: I think,
- 1:24:41the way AI might respond to a signifier and the way we as
- 1:24:46individuals live out
- 1:24:52SPEAKER_01: the signifier,
- 1:24:53SPEAKER_01: the logic of the signifier is that,
- 1:24:56SPEAKER_01: again,
- 1:24:56it goes back to this kind of utilitarian notion of really being
- 1:25:03able to fully
- 1:25:06respond to the demand of the other versus a series of
- 1:25:10directives embedded in the
- 1:25:14signifier that don't actually reach any ultimate outcome in
- 1:25:19terms of like,
- 1:25:21approximating an other that is a god-like entity with a will or
- 1:25:26anything like that.
- 1:25:28The other is heterogeneous,
- 1:25:30the other is inconsistent,
- 1:25:32and the other is lacking.
- 1:25:34SPEAKER_01: It's Bart.
- 1:25:35SPEAKER_01: There's a hole in the other.
- 1:25:39SPEAKER_01: Can the signifier be that for
- 1:25:46SPEAKER_01: artificial intelligence.
- 1:25:48SPEAKER_01: Right.
- 1:25:48I don't know if that was a little bit meandering,
- 1:25:50but I hope I'm,
- 1:25:52I'm making a point there.
- 1:25:53SPEAKER_01: I'll add to that.
- 1:25:55SPEAKER_00: Andrew, let me say one thing.
- 1:25:56SPEAKER_00: Cause then I want you to incorporate this riff off of this too.
- 1:25:58SPEAKER_00: Just real quick.
- 1:26:00SPEAKER_00: Look at the basic definition of algorithm.
- 1:26:03A process or set of rules to be followed in calculations or
- 1:26:07other problem-solving
- 1:26:08SPEAKER_00: operations,
- 1:26:09SPEAKER_00: especially by a computer.
- 1:26:10SPEAKER_00: Hold on.
- 1:26:11SPEAKER_00: A process or set of rules to be followed in calculations.
- 1:26:15SPEAKER_00: If you are interpreted by the signifier, you are a Christian.
- 1:26:19SPEAKER_00: If this is what the parent says to the child, you are a Christian.
- 1:26:22SPEAKER_00: That is a set of rules to be followed that establish a kind of programic
- 1:26:27SPEAKER_00: That's what the symbolic mandate does.
- 1:26:29SPEAKER_00: It gives you a kind of program to follow.
- 1:26:32SPEAKER_00: And so we could say the signifier is algorithmic in that precise sense.
- 1:26:38SPEAKER_00: If you name somebody a Christian,
- 1:26:40SPEAKER_00: if you name them a Muslim,
- 1:26:41SPEAKER_00: if you name them an atheist,
- 1:26:43SPEAKER_00: there's certain...
- 1:26:45SPEAKER_00: operations or behaviors that you're expected to embody based on that.
- 1:26:49SPEAKER_00: So I, I just wanted to make that connection.
- 1:26:51SPEAKER_02: No, no, absolutely.
- 1:26:52SPEAKER_02: Cause I was about to like, I was about to riff on that too.
- 1:26:55Like,
- 1:26:56do you know,
- 1:26:56like to go into the first point about the cyborg thing?
- 1:26:58Well,
- 1:26:59like,
- 1:26:59you know,
- 1:26:59maybe the cyborg is like a sort of far stretch,
- 1:27:03but I see the point.
- 1:27:05SPEAKER_02: I just,
- 1:27:05SPEAKER_02: I'm just not tapped into like all this stuff to be able to say,
- 1:27:07SPEAKER_02: like,
- 1:27:07SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 1:27:08SPEAKER_02: we're cyborgs,
- 1:27:08SPEAKER_02: like,
- 1:27:08SPEAKER_02: like you,
- 1:27:09SPEAKER_02: you and Nancy are,
- 1:27:10SPEAKER_02: but I will say,
- 1:27:11SPEAKER_02: no,
- 1:27:11SPEAKER_02: I agree because like,
- 1:27:13SPEAKER_02: if,
- 1:27:14SPEAKER_02: So before I get to the Lincolnian approach,
- 1:27:16SPEAKER_02: if you take Mark seriously,
- 1:27:17then there's no way we could ever take serious this sort of old
- 1:27:21humanism of like
- 1:27:22the noble savage or the sort of romanticist conception of like
- 1:27:26being one with
- 1:27:27SPEAKER_02: nature.
- 1:27:27SPEAKER_02: No, nature and us are alien from each other.
- 1:27:31And we have to mediate nature through the labor process and
- 1:27:35metabolic rift to quote
- 1:27:36SPEAKER_02: John Bellamy Foster.
- 1:27:38SPEAKER_02: But the fact that we...
- 1:27:40SPEAKER_02: mediate through nature because of the productive consumption process and
- 1:27:44SPEAKER_02: metabolization of it through the social relations,
- 1:27:47SPEAKER_02: the fact that we are never on our own,
- 1:27:48that we live in a society that demands labor and et cetera for
- 1:27:54us to survive,
- 1:27:55SPEAKER_02: but that requires tools,
- 1:27:57SPEAKER_02: that requires factories,
- 1:27:58that requires houses for us to shelter ourselves to continue to
- 1:28:01do the process the
- 1:28:01SPEAKER_02: next day.
- 1:28:02SPEAKER_02: So we are never without tools or technology
- 1:28:07SPEAKER_02: And science is to continuously interrogate and advance that.
- 1:28:11SPEAKER_02: If you want to get high to Gary,
- 1:28:12SPEAKER_02: and it's like,
- 1:28:12SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 1:28:13SPEAKER_02: the readiness to hand an assignment of the hammer and stuff like that,
- 1:28:16SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 1:28:16SPEAKER_02: whatever it is,
- 1:28:17SPEAKER_02: it's like,
- 1:28:17SPEAKER_02: choose your poison.
- 1:28:19SPEAKER_02: The fact is, is that like, there is no human without tools.
- 1:28:22SPEAKER_02: Bernard Stiegler is another person that talks about this.
- 1:28:23So like,
- 1:28:25you know,
- 1:28:25it's,
- 1:28:25it's sort of like,
- 1:28:26you know,
- 1:28:26it goes to the point.
- 1:28:27SPEAKER_02: It's like,
- 1:28:27SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 1:28:28we are artificial in the sense that no matter when we alter or
- 1:28:31change or transform
- 1:28:32SPEAKER_02: our being over time,
- 1:28:33SPEAKER_02: we alter our essence as well.
- 1:28:36SPEAKER_02: Now, to put it in Lacanian terms, signifier, right?
- 1:28:40And so what is interesting about the signifier is that it's not
- 1:28:43only sort of marked
- 1:28:44on me by other speaking beings that I live with and that
- 1:28:48brought me into existence
- 1:28:49SPEAKER_02: that even talked about me before I existed.
- 1:28:52SPEAKER_02: That's the difference between thinking and being that for Lacan,
- 1:28:57SPEAKER_02: to think doesn't mean that you could be,
- 1:28:59SPEAKER_02: right?
- 1:28:59Because thinking is formulated by language and language is
- 1:29:02brought to you by the other.
- 1:29:04Think about when you're in the womb of the mother,
- 1:29:06what are we going to name him or her?
- 1:29:08I'm thinking about the room that we're going to design for
- 1:29:11them,
- 1:29:11the toys.
- 1:29:12SPEAKER_02: What do you think?
- 1:29:13SPEAKER_02: Are they going to go to college when they turn 18?
- 1:29:15These are already signifiers that are impinged upon you before
- 1:29:17you are even thrown
- 1:29:18SPEAKER_02: into the world.
- 1:29:20So the signifier has already inaugurated your existence before
- 1:29:23your being has been
- 1:29:24SPEAKER_02: freaking thrown into the living world.
- 1:29:26SPEAKER_02: So there is a materiality of the signifier and your identity that
- 1:29:31before you are even physically in the life world or the
- 1:29:39worldhood or whatever term
- 1:29:40SPEAKER_02: you want to use.
- 1:29:42SPEAKER_02: And
- 1:29:43SPEAKER_02: That also plays an account of this idea of being artificial,
- 1:29:47SPEAKER_02: not only because of materiality,
- 1:29:49SPEAKER_02: but also,
- 1:29:49SPEAKER_02: like you said,
- 1:29:50SPEAKER_02: the algorithmic aspect of it,
- 1:29:52SPEAKER_02: because words or signifiers don't have a referent for Lacan.
- 1:29:56SPEAKER_02: They may have a trace,
- 1:29:57SPEAKER_02: but not a trace that leads to something natural or referent,
- 1:30:00SPEAKER_02: but that a signifier relies on its meaning from another signifier.
- 1:30:06And in a sense,
- 1:30:06an algorithmic code relies on another code to get its
- 1:30:10differentiation from.
- 1:30:11an example and I love Sam McCormick for this but if you look
- 1:30:15into the dictionary
- 1:30:17what is the definition of a cat you have other words other than
- 1:30:20the word cat that
- 1:30:21define the meaning of the word cat the definition of a cat a
- 1:30:26four-legged furry
- 1:30:27feline fucker that is the definition of the cat according to
- 1:30:31Sam McCormick right so
- 1:30:33SPEAKER_02: you need other other signifiers to differentiate other signifiers um
- 1:30:38SPEAKER_02: And so in analysis,
- 1:30:40SPEAKER_02: what is interesting is that for Lacan,
- 1:30:42SPEAKER_02: right,
- 1:30:43SPEAKER_02: when he's talking about jouissance,
- 1:30:44SPEAKER_02: he's talking about the body.
- 1:30:45SPEAKER_02: It always relates back to the body,
- 1:30:47but it's never this corporal phenomenological representation of
- 1:30:51the fact that I
- 1:30:52SPEAKER_02: have my arms waving like this.
- 1:30:53SPEAKER_02: No, it's the body of jouissance that's marked about the signifier.
- 1:30:57SPEAKER_02: And so when I'm able to free associate and talk about my symptom,
- 1:31:00and identifications i'm constructing a virtual body of
- 1:31:04jouissance by the signifier
- 1:31:07that allows me to uh sublimate my symptom and so there's
- 1:31:11already something
- 1:31:12artificial about the analytic process a virtual reality because
- 1:31:16i'm feeling this
- 1:31:16rift right because i'm already in a virtual reality because of
- 1:31:19fantasy right i'm
- 1:31:20alienated from my own being because of the other the symbolic
- 1:31:24big other is oculus
- 1:31:25SPEAKER_02: rift already an outdated reference i don't even know yeah straight up man
- 1:31:30SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 1:31:31SPEAKER_02: But like,
- 1:31:31SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 1:31:32SPEAKER_02: like to say like,
- 1:31:32SPEAKER_02: you know what,
- 1:31:33SPEAKER_02: like,
- 1:31:33SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 1:31:34SPEAKER_02: he's,
- 1:31:34SPEAKER_02: you mentioned the cool of Barth,
- 1:31:35SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 1:31:35SPEAKER_02: uh,
- 1:31:37SPEAKER_02: it's the signifier that has this sort of algorithmic take.
- 1:31:40SPEAKER_02: And I've been reading a lot of Milner.
- 1:31:42SPEAKER_02: We wouldn't have the signifier without mathematics and language.
- 1:31:45SPEAKER_02: And because we live in a society where modern science exists,
- 1:31:49SPEAKER_02: modern science is only modern because it's Galilean.
- 1:31:52And that means that we've created a universe versus a world of
- 1:31:57logos and antiquity
- 1:31:58SPEAKER_02: where episteme relies on technology,
- 1:32:01SPEAKER_02: which means that you're all about the letter.
- 1:32:03SPEAKER_02: You're all about the T to the T precision.
- 1:32:06SPEAKER_02: to create something.
- 1:32:07SPEAKER_02: And the signifier is all about precision,
- 1:32:09SPEAKER_02: the signifier of the letter,
- 1:32:10SPEAKER_02: which is also the precision of my symptom.
- 1:32:12SPEAKER_02: And so far as I could speak about it.
- 1:32:13SPEAKER_02: Right.
- 1:32:14So I'm creating a precise over time body of Jewish songs based
- 1:32:18upon language to be
- 1:32:20SPEAKER_02: able to map out my system,
- 1:32:21SPEAKER_02: my slip symptom system,
- 1:32:24SPEAKER_02: symptom,
- 1:32:24SPEAKER_02: you know?
- 1:32:27SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 1:32:27SPEAKER_00: But it's, it, this whole thing is what you're getting at.
- 1:32:30SPEAKER_00: Like death drive,
- 1:32:32juizance obje petit a none of these exists for us without
- 1:32:36language exactly and
- 1:32:38there's a dialectical relationship or there's an extimate
- 1:32:40relationship and they
- 1:32:42come out of the friction or or the or gap however you want to
- 1:32:48talk about it between
- 1:32:49SPEAKER_00: our pre-linguistic bodies our biological bodies and language
- 1:32:57SPEAKER_00: And so what I'm,
- 1:32:59SPEAKER_00: I try to,
- 1:32:59SPEAKER_00: like,
- 1:33:00SPEAKER_00: Lacanians don't talk about the brain,
- 1:33:02SPEAKER_00: but the core material dimension is our central nervous system.
- 1:33:07SPEAKER_00: That's what gets derailed by the signifier.
- 1:33:10SPEAKER_00: And it gets derailed from just having standard,
- 1:33:14why do animals not engage in self-destructive activities on the
- 1:33:18level that we do,
- 1:33:19SPEAKER_00: right?
- 1:33:19SPEAKER_00: Because language opens up idealization and
- 1:33:24fantasy etc right we can't do these things without it and so
- 1:33:29that's that's kind of
- 1:33:31SPEAKER_00: my point here is that
- 1:33:34SPEAKER_00: We're artificial or we're cyborgs.
- 1:33:36SPEAKER_00: All right,
- 1:33:36SPEAKER_00: look,
- 1:33:37if the four of us were actually in a room together and we were
- 1:33:41introduced to a guy
- 1:33:43and he literally had his body filled with nanobots and if we
- 1:33:46cut his arm off,
- 1:33:47SPEAKER_00: it would just grow another arm.
- 1:33:49He would be radically different to us because of this
- 1:33:53technological modification.
- 1:33:56Because language is the water that we fishes swim in,
- 1:33:59we don't see it as...
- 1:34:01nanobots but that's the point to all other animals on this
- 1:34:06planet our ability to
- 1:34:07exist in and assimilate language is might as well it's like
- 1:34:11having nanobots and so
- 1:34:14again because it's so natural to us it's so invisible to us the
- 1:34:17radicality of how
- 1:34:19SPEAKER_00: language is a kind of technology
- 1:34:22SPEAKER_00: or a rift in our relationship to nature.
- 1:34:26SPEAKER_00: It's just invisible to us without theory.
- 1:34:29SPEAKER_00: But what Lacanianism,
- 1:34:30SPEAKER_00: I think,
- 1:34:30SPEAKER_00: does better than anything,
- 1:34:32SPEAKER_00: and this is why I think both of you,
- 1:34:34SPEAKER_00: it's weird,
- 1:34:35SPEAKER_00: I'm not trying to interpolate you and give you a symbolic mandate,
- 1:34:38SPEAKER_00: but I will say this.
- 1:34:39SPEAKER_00: I think anybody who's a Lacanian theorist right now,
- 1:34:43SPEAKER_00: whether they know it or not,
- 1:34:45SPEAKER_00: is also an AI theorist.
- 1:34:47SPEAKER_00: And the reason I think that is because
- 1:34:50Lacanian theory is the greatest theory of subjectivity that we
- 1:34:54have on this planet.
- 1:34:56SPEAKER_00: And as we start to wrestle more and more,
- 1:35:00and this is only going to intensify with the question of what
- 1:35:03counts as a human
- 1:35:04SPEAKER_00: subject,
- 1:35:06SPEAKER_00: what counts as a subject as such,
- 1:35:08SPEAKER_00: and what is merely a machine or a simulation of a subject,
- 1:35:12Lacanianism is only going to become more and more relevant
- 1:35:15because we don't have
- 1:35:19SPEAKER_00: Look,
- 1:35:19religion's going to have a part to play with this because
- 1:35:21religion can just go,
- 1:35:22SPEAKER_00: we have a soul,
- 1:35:23SPEAKER_00: the robot doesn't,
- 1:35:24SPEAKER_00: end a discussion.
- 1:35:25SPEAKER_00: But for people like that, that's not going to be a satisfactory response.
- 1:35:29SPEAKER_00: It might work for certain people,
- 1:35:31SPEAKER_00: but for us,
- 1:35:31we're going to need a little bit more to go on than just an
- 1:35:35appeal to an elusive
- 1:35:36SPEAKER_00: substance that we don't have empirical evidence of.
- 1:35:39SPEAKER_00: So with Lacanianism, we have this robust theory of subjectivity.
- 1:35:45And it gives us something to go off of in determining what
- 1:35:49counts as subject and what doesn't.
- 1:35:52SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 1:35:53SPEAKER_02: And our last thing I'll say is because it goes back to the AI therapy.
- 1:35:57SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 1:35:58SPEAKER_02: one of the things that,
- 1:35:59SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 1:36:00it seems like we're trying to do with AI and the speculation of
- 1:36:04the companion by or
- 1:36:05SPEAKER_02: the caregiver is also something if you talk to ChatGPT,
- 1:36:10SPEAKER_02: ChatGPT,
- 1:36:11SPEAKER_02: what is a sexual relationship?
- 1:36:12They're going to give you XX to XY as XY as to XX or yin and
- 1:36:18yang as yang as to
- 1:36:19SPEAKER_02: yin,
- 1:36:20SPEAKER_02: boy as to girl as girl as to boy.
- 1:36:22SPEAKER_02: Or,
- 1:36:22SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 1:36:23SPEAKER_02: you can make it in whatever you want,
- 1:36:24SPEAKER_02: regardless of programming,
- 1:36:26SPEAKER_02: but there's always going to be this sort of complementarity.
- 1:36:30SPEAKER_02: And that's the one thing that that psychoanalysis,
- 1:36:34SPEAKER_02: because of the unconscious structure like a language.
- 1:36:38is getting at of what the symptom is,
- 1:36:40is the problem of the absence of a sexual relation.
- 1:36:45SPEAKER_02: And that is embedded in the primal fantasy of union with the other,
- 1:36:49SPEAKER_02: whether I objectify the other into a small part,
- 1:36:53SPEAKER_02: obje a,
- 1:36:54SPEAKER_02: to complete me,
- 1:36:55SPEAKER_02: or
- 1:36:56as the hysteric trying to create something to complete the lack
- 1:37:01in the field of
- 1:37:02SPEAKER_02: knowledge,
- 1:37:02SPEAKER_02: the other,
- 1:37:03because the lack in the other is also responsible for me not
- 1:37:08being able to find any
- 1:37:09SPEAKER_02: ground of what it means to be a woman,
- 1:37:11SPEAKER_02: right?
- 1:37:11SPEAKER_02: That's the hysteric.
- 1:37:12SPEAKER_02: And so this is exactly what psychoanalysis,
- 1:37:15because it's able to see the unconscious in the relationship
- 1:37:18with signifiers,
- 1:37:20SPEAKER_02: is able to point out that there is no signifier to complete the other.
- 1:37:24SPEAKER_02: There is no signifier that can explain the sexual relationship.
- 1:37:26SPEAKER_02: We can only make statements about this impossibility.
- 1:37:29SPEAKER_02: And this is exactly what people in the clinic are doing.
- 1:37:32SPEAKER_02: They're caught within the fantasy of Edenic bliss,
- 1:37:36of being lost in this narcissistic love where they're
- 1:37:39encapsulated into one with
- 1:37:41SPEAKER_02: the other.
- 1:37:42SPEAKER_02: And this is the problem.
- 1:37:43SPEAKER_02: And this is what repeats.
- 1:37:45SPEAKER_02: And this is what we are trying to make them realize and traverse.
- 1:37:49SPEAKER_02: Because in the AI bot, they're going to do exactly what I just said.
- 1:37:53SPEAKER_02: XY to XX.
- 1:37:56SPEAKER_02: They're going to think of sexuality and love as union.
- 1:37:59SPEAKER_02: The psychoanalysis is there is no union.
- 1:38:02SPEAKER_00: So I love this point.
- 1:38:04SPEAKER_00: I want to ask you, Nance, and you, Nick.
- 1:38:07SPEAKER_00: Because I love this point Andrew's making.
- 1:38:08SPEAKER_00: So think about it.
- 1:38:09SPEAKER_00: Because I kind of want to
- 1:38:12SPEAKER_00: Kind of condense his point into like a formulation.
- 1:38:16So here's the thing Do you think that AI or the LLM as we have
- 1:38:21it right now?
- 1:38:22SPEAKER_00: Can it even even itself?
- 1:38:25SPEAKER_00: Process the concept of the non relation between human beings.
- 1:38:30SPEAKER_00: Is this something?
- 1:38:30SPEAKER_00: I mean it can spit out words
- 1:38:35But does it really get this radical sense of singularity or
- 1:38:42incompatibility between
- 1:38:43SPEAKER_00: speaking subjects to form a whole?
- 1:38:45Well,
- 1:38:46civilization hasn't done a good job of registering that
- 1:38:50non-relation.
- 1:38:51SPEAKER_01: Very good point.
- 1:38:53To even articulate what Lacan's talking about,
- 1:38:57it took quite a few Freudian discoveries.
- 1:39:02SPEAKER_01: But what does Lacan say?
- 1:39:05There is no meta-language,
- 1:39:06and he follows it up with,
- 1:39:08or worse,
- 1:39:09there is no sexual relation.
- 1:39:11SPEAKER_01: So he says...
- 1:39:18He speaks this tension in very certain terms by having the one
- 1:39:29statement follow the other.
- 1:39:31SPEAKER_01: Now, I don't know virtually anything about these LLMs.
- 1:39:35SPEAKER_01: I am very uneducated when it comes to the technology behind it.
- 1:39:40SPEAKER_01: artificial intelligence,
- 1:39:43but I'm assuming that the question of desire that we've been
- 1:39:52hammering home in this
- 1:39:53discussion and whether or not artificial intelligence has
- 1:39:58anything like a desire
- 1:40:02SPEAKER_01: that would be constituent of subjectivity is directly related to
- 1:40:11SPEAKER_01: and a result of the fact that there is no meta language.
- 1:40:17SPEAKER_01: So can the language of machine learning of code
- 1:40:23SPEAKER_01: ever produce a meta language.
- 1:40:26SPEAKER_01: And just to simplify things,
- 1:40:28SPEAKER_01: my understanding of a meta language,
- 1:40:29it's just like a language that would account for all of
- 1:40:34language that would explain
- 1:40:36and put in place all of the different elements of the language
- 1:40:41that we use.
- 1:40:42SPEAKER_01: Once you use language, you're caught up in it.
- 1:40:44SPEAKER_01: There's no way of stepping outside of it.
- 1:40:49SPEAKER_01: Now,
- 1:40:50whole seminars have been written on how we get from there is no
- 1:40:54meta language to
- 1:40:56there is no sexual relation but essentially it's like the
- 1:41:04unconscious is what
- 1:41:07SPEAKER_01: emerges in the gap between these two statements, in my opinion.
- 1:41:12The unconscious is what cannot resolve the signifier into a
- 1:41:16totalizing system.
- 1:41:18SPEAKER_01: And because of that,
- 1:41:19SPEAKER_01: we can't symbolically situate man and woman,
- 1:41:24SPEAKER_01: yin and yang,
- 1:41:25SPEAKER_01: in terms of a pure complementarity.
- 1:41:29So I have absolutely no idea what AI would make of that
- 1:41:35conundrum or if AI will be
- 1:41:37SPEAKER_01: faced with that conundrum because,
- 1:41:41SPEAKER_01: well,
- 1:41:41SPEAKER_01: it doesn't need to propagate the species in the same way that we do.
- 1:41:48SPEAKER_01: And I think that the fact of the non-relation isn't just a...
- 1:41:57SPEAKER_01: a truth that we need to come to terms to,
- 1:42:00it's actually embedded in the very reality of the perpetuation
- 1:42:09of the species
- 1:42:10SPEAKER_01: itself.
- 1:42:12In simple terms,
- 1:42:13because there is no sexual relation,
- 1:42:17we're able to have sex.
- 1:42:19SPEAKER_01: We're able to copulate.
- 1:42:23SPEAKER_01: So what that would mean
- 1:42:26SPEAKER_01: for machines, for artificial intelligence, I have no idea.
- 1:42:29SPEAKER_01: So I hope I'm not like copping out.
- 1:42:32SPEAKER_00: That was really good.
- 1:42:33SPEAKER_00: I mean, look, there's so much to think about here.
- 1:42:36SPEAKER_00: So Nance,
- 1:42:36SPEAKER_00: I mean,
- 1:42:37SPEAKER_00: look,
- 1:42:37SPEAKER_00: this question of the non-relation,
- 1:42:39which is we do not have some preordained providential guarantee
- 1:42:46of a compatible
- 1:42:47SPEAKER_00: relationship with another human being.
- 1:42:50SPEAKER_00: Of course, we can all relate in various ways.
- 1:42:52SPEAKER_00: Hey, we love philosophy.
- 1:42:54SPEAKER_00: We all have an interest in Lacanian theory.
- 1:42:56SPEAKER_00: Sure, there's ways we can relate.
- 1:42:58But do we ever fully click together in the way that fantasy
- 1:43:04dreams about clicking
- 1:43:06SPEAKER_00: together with another person,
- 1:43:07SPEAKER_00: like a soulmate figure?
- 1:43:08SPEAKER_00: So this dimension of each one of us,
- 1:43:12each one of us has a radical singularity to us that cannot be
- 1:43:17captured in language.
- 1:43:18There is no meta-language that can fill in the gap and say,
- 1:43:22oh,
- 1:43:23here's Mikey Singularity.
- 1:43:24SPEAKER_00: Here's Andrew Nix.
- 1:43:27SPEAKER_00: Here's how it all clicks together.
- 1:43:30SPEAKER_00: Nothing like that exists.
- 1:43:32I think this is where we see a point of at least interest
- 1:43:36between Lacan and Levinas.
- 1:43:39And so I wonder what you're thinking about when it comes to
- 1:43:42this non-relationship thing.
- 1:43:44SPEAKER_00: We're at least moving in a direction towards...
- 1:43:47SPEAKER_00: Levinasian infinity.
- 1:43:50SPEAKER_00: And is this something that AI can even begin to comprehend at the moment?
- 1:43:55SPEAKER_03: I think, um,
- 1:43:58So zero,
- 1:43:59zero,
- 1:44:00the introduction of zero into Western math was like a
- 1:44:07revolutionary moment.
- 1:44:08SPEAKER_03: We talked about this,
- 1:44:09SPEAKER_03: Mikey,
- 1:44:11SPEAKER_03: in a video that'll be coming up soon,
- 1:44:13SPEAKER_03: a very exciting video,
- 1:44:15SPEAKER_03: but we talked about,
- 1:44:17SPEAKER_03: what was it?
- 1:44:18Renaissance numeracy or whatever,
- 1:44:22but the moment where zero becomes- Masonic arithmetic.
- 1:44:25SPEAKER_03: Yeah, that's what it was, Masonic arithmetic.
- 1:44:28SPEAKER_02: I can't wait to get into my part of this,
- 1:44:29SPEAKER_02: but keep talking,
- 1:44:30SPEAKER_02: Hans,
- 1:44:30SPEAKER_02: because now you're not understanding.
- 1:44:32SPEAKER_03: So zero becomes this moment.
- 1:44:36Like zero is a nothing that nuts,
- 1:44:39and it totally revolutionizes the way we relate to math.
- 1:44:43SPEAKER_03: Previously, math was like an extension of the body.
- 1:44:47SPEAKER_03: Math was this kind of personal thing.
- 1:44:49SPEAKER_03: And so it was you did it with...
- 1:44:53SPEAKER_03: Like people you knew.
- 1:44:55SPEAKER_03: You did it with the guy at the market.
- 1:44:56SPEAKER_03: You went to go give him 10 bales of hay.
- 1:44:58SPEAKER_03: You go get 10 eggs or 12 eggs or whatever.
- 1:45:00SPEAKER_03: But it's always like this personal thing.
- 1:45:03And there was really no need for zero because we didn't have to
- 1:45:07conceptualize lack.
- 1:45:08SPEAKER_03: We didn't have to conceptualize negation because we just,
- 1:45:11SPEAKER_03: we had like a natural relationship to it.
- 1:45:14SPEAKER_03: We lived in a positivistic world,
- 1:45:16SPEAKER_03: but in a very different way from the positivistic world that we live in.
- 1:45:21SPEAKER_03: And the introduction of zero,
- 1:45:26I think kind of coincided with a lot of other things that
- 1:45:28allowed for capital to
- 1:45:32SPEAKER_03: emerge.
- 1:45:34SPEAKER_03: So zero becomes a singularity in a way,
- 1:45:40SPEAKER_03: like we can see that zero is nothing,
- 1:45:44SPEAKER_03: but we can also see that that nothing is always already full.
- 1:45:50because we already have like a phenomenological natural
- 1:45:55relation to the world and
- 1:45:57it's embodied and it's kind of emergent and it just kind of
- 1:46:00springs up because we
- 1:46:01are writing around in bodies and we understand necessity and we
- 1:46:04are caught up in
- 1:46:05SPEAKER_03: this metabolic activity but we're also the producers of
- 1:46:09SPEAKER_03: of the framework at the same time.
- 1:46:10SPEAKER_03: So it's all natural, which is a horrible word to use.
- 1:46:14SPEAKER_03: But when we introduced zero,
- 1:46:16it kind of allowed to abstract the personal embodied relations
- 1:46:24to the global stage
- 1:46:26SPEAKER_03: and to the global setting.
- 1:46:27And so we overnight,
- 1:46:29not overnight,
- 1:46:30that's sensational,
- 1:46:31but we became caught up in history.
- 1:46:32SPEAKER_03: We became global
- 1:46:34SPEAKER_03: subjects as opposed to just kind of local subjects.
- 1:46:37SPEAKER_03: So like the global view became imposed on us.
- 1:46:43SPEAKER_03: But it wasn't as traumatic.
- 1:46:44It wasn't as such a big breakdown or at least it wasn't as
- 1:46:49rapid because we are animals.
- 1:46:52SPEAKER_03: We are like we have bodies.
- 1:46:54So like there's this subjectivity thing and there's this
- 1:46:57radical nothingness that
- 1:46:58SPEAKER_03: is at the same time infinite productivity and it's a singularity.
- 1:47:02SPEAKER_03: But we already understand singularity.
- 1:47:04SPEAKER_03: Uh, machines don't like, because machines are just built on arithmetic.
- 1:47:09SPEAKER_03: Like zero is not a singularity for the machine.
- 1:47:13SPEAKER_03: Zero is just the absence of a one.
- 1:47:17SPEAKER_03: Um,
- 1:47:18SPEAKER_03: so I,
- 1:47:18I think along with like the subject object that we also like
- 1:47:23we're split in the
- 1:47:24SPEAKER_03: world itself is split.
- 1:47:25SPEAKER_03: And so like nothing always nuts for us, but for machines, um,
- 1:47:32SPEAKER_03: It can't because it's just pure counting.
- 1:47:36SPEAKER_03: It's pure ordinal like there is one, there is not one.
- 1:47:39SPEAKER_03: Whereas we can understand like I can't even express myself fully.
- 1:47:46SPEAKER_03: So how could I conceptualize you?
- 1:47:49SPEAKER_01: Noted as zero, counted as one, or is it Lacan?
- 1:47:53SPEAKER_02: Yeah,
- 1:47:53SPEAKER_02: so that's Malera,
- 1:47:54SPEAKER_02: and this is,
- 1:47:55SPEAKER_02: yeah,
- 1:47:55SPEAKER_02: Lacan will semi-agree with,
- 1:47:57SPEAKER_02: like,
- 1:47:57SPEAKER_02: this whole suture thing,
- 1:47:58SPEAKER_02: but it's actually wrong.
- 1:48:00SPEAKER_02: I like that phrase.
- 1:48:02SPEAKER_02: Noted as zero, counted as one.
- 1:48:05SPEAKER_02: So,
- 1:48:05SPEAKER_02: yeah,
- 1:48:05SPEAKER_02: no,
- 1:48:05SPEAKER_02: I want to add a lot to that,
- 1:48:07SPEAKER_02: because you brought up,
- 1:48:08SPEAKER_02: like,
- 1:48:08SPEAKER_02: a lot of good pivot,
- 1:48:09SPEAKER_02: because it really,
- 1:48:09SPEAKER_02: it brings to heart,
- 1:48:10SPEAKER_02: like,
- 1:48:11SPEAKER_02: why Lacan is so obsessed with language,
- 1:48:13SPEAKER_02: which is actually more different than the linguistics,
- 1:48:16SPEAKER_02: like,
- 1:48:16SPEAKER_02: Jakobsen and...
- 1:48:19SPEAKER_02: which leads into the mathematical paradigm.
- 1:48:22SPEAKER_02: But I just wanted to add to like one thing that like Nick was saying,
- 1:48:25SPEAKER_02: I think could bring the light,
- 1:48:26SPEAKER_02: even the problem of AI,
- 1:48:28SPEAKER_02: even outside like LLMs,
- 1:48:30SPEAKER_02: but like,
- 1:48:31SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 1:48:32SPEAKER_02: like in the algorithm,
- 1:48:33SPEAKER_02: like look at dating apps,
- 1:48:34SPEAKER_02: like Mikey brought up dating apps,
- 1:48:36SPEAKER_02: like any AI,
- 1:48:39SPEAKER_02: no matter if it is able to operate on its own,
- 1:48:43SPEAKER_02: It still needs that sort of classical deist thing of the goddess,
- 1:48:47the watchmaker who just starts the thing and lets it operate on
- 1:48:50its own afterwards.
- 1:48:52SPEAKER_02: And think about it like this,
- 1:48:54SPEAKER_02: like with the algorithm and dating apps,
- 1:48:57you have to at least give an input for it to be able to do the
- 1:48:59rest of the outputs.
- 1:49:00SPEAKER_02: So in a dating app,
- 1:49:02SPEAKER_02: I could put I'm 6'1",
- 1:49:03SPEAKER_02: even though I'm like 5'6",
- 1:49:05SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 1:49:05SPEAKER_02: because nobody likes a short team.
- 1:49:08SPEAKER_02: You know,
- 1:49:08SPEAKER_02: like no snowflakes,
- 1:49:11SPEAKER_02: MAGA,
- 1:49:12SPEAKER_02: and like,
- 1:49:13SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 1:49:14the picture of me holding the fish that I just caught with a
- 1:49:17dip in my mouth.
- 1:49:18And so that will literally send an algorithmic probability of
- 1:49:23who I will be likely
- 1:49:24SPEAKER_02: compatible with.
- 1:49:25SPEAKER_02: Again, the key term is compatibility, you know, complementarity.
- 1:49:32SPEAKER_02: In the problems of love and love matters,
- 1:49:35the algorithm can't help but bring complementarity into the
- 1:49:39algorithmic function.
- 1:49:41SPEAKER_02: And in a matter of combinatory factions,
- 1:49:45SPEAKER_02: insofar as I give a list of inputs,
- 1:49:47SPEAKER_02: I just need like two.
- 1:49:49SPEAKER_02: inputs, a zero and a minus, what I like and what I don't like, you know?
- 1:49:53SPEAKER_02: You know, I love to go fishing.
- 1:49:55SPEAKER_02: I hate snowflake liberals.
- 1:49:58There's the amount of combinatory factors that I can get in the
- 1:50:02algorithm.
- 1:50:03But to go back to this whole thing about infinity and the zero
- 1:50:06point,
- 1:50:06so like,
- 1:50:09SPEAKER_02: In natural numbers,
- 1:50:10SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 1:50:11SPEAKER_02: zero makes sense if you start at the beginning and then you get one,
- 1:50:14SPEAKER_02: two,
- 1:50:14SPEAKER_02: and three.
- 1:50:14In natural numbers and natural counting is what we do to be
- 1:50:17able to exchange a
- 1:50:18SPEAKER_02: stack of hay for like,
- 1:50:19SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 1:50:20SPEAKER_02: a pound of corn or two yards of linen makes one coat,
- 1:50:24SPEAKER_02: right?
- 1:50:24This is the way that we do natural numbers,
- 1:50:26you know,
- 1:50:26to get around the world.
- 1:50:28SPEAKER_02: But then you've got irrational numbers like, you know,
- 1:50:30SPEAKER_02: Square roots.
- 1:50:31SPEAKER_02: Square root of 2 and shit like that.
- 1:50:34SPEAKER_02: And then there's real numbers,
- 1:50:36SPEAKER_02: which puts into problem the question of infinity,
- 1:50:38SPEAKER_02: because we could,
- 1:50:39SPEAKER_02: even though we'd be counting forever when it comes to infinity,
- 1:50:42SPEAKER_02: in natural numbers,
- 1:50:43SPEAKER_02: it's still intuitive and still possible,
- 1:50:45SPEAKER_02: even though we wouldn't be fucking wasting our times doing that.
- 1:50:47SPEAKER_02: But...
- 1:50:50In the real numbers,
- 1:50:52we start from 0.00000000001 before we could even count to one.
- 1:50:59And this is Lacan's ingenuity with signifier and language
- 1:51:04because of the gap or the
- 1:51:06SPEAKER_02: hole in the structure.
- 1:51:08And so rather than thinking of objet a zero,
- 1:51:11it's as Zizek makes famous,
- 1:51:13a less than nothing.
- 1:51:14So objet a,
- 1:51:15no matter how much I count,
- 1:51:18there's always something that's being abstracted away.
- 1:51:23SPEAKER_02: So
- 1:51:24Objet A is a new algebraic numerical function that is dividing
- 1:51:30and extracting or
- 1:51:31SPEAKER_02: subtracting,
- 1:51:32SPEAKER_02: but it never leads to zero,
- 1:51:34SPEAKER_02: but it never leads to something.
- 1:51:35SPEAKER_02: It's always a less than nothing, right?
- 1:51:37It's always something that I can never really account for into
- 1:51:40my system of
- 1:51:40SPEAKER_02: language,
- 1:51:41SPEAKER_02: but it's always something that still moves me as a sort of subject,
- 1:51:44SPEAKER_02: right?
- 1:51:45And he lists this brilliantly in seminar 16 when he's talking
- 1:51:49about Pascal's wager,
- 1:51:51but mainly what he's trying to talk about is like the problem
- 1:51:54of identity in the
- 1:51:55signifier and of Jouy Sans as surplus and object little a and
- 1:52:00Fibonacci sequence of
- 1:52:02SPEAKER_02: increasing series and decreasing and just
- 1:52:04SPEAKER_02: I'm not a Fibonacci scholar or anything like that,
- 1:52:06SPEAKER_02: but just to put it succinctly,
- 1:52:08SPEAKER_02: you have two series.
- 1:52:09SPEAKER_02: You have one plus A,
- 1:52:10SPEAKER_02: and then the decreasing series is one minus A,
- 1:52:13SPEAKER_02: which means it's like you're trying to formulate yourself as a subject,
- 1:52:16SPEAKER_02: but no matter what,
- 1:52:17SPEAKER_02: objet A is that hole in you,
- 1:52:19SPEAKER_02: and in the other...
- 1:52:20SPEAKER_02: so that there's always a subtraction in an addition.
- 1:52:23SPEAKER_02: So you never go anywhere.
- 1:52:23SPEAKER_02: You're always at a return point.
- 1:52:25You're always at this point,
- 1:52:27you know,
- 1:52:27of decrease in tension and increase in excitation.
- 1:52:31And this is death drive right here because you end up going
- 1:52:34back to this minimal point,
- 1:52:35right?
- 1:52:37SPEAKER_02: of starting over and repeating, right?
- 1:52:40And that's formulated through our language system,
- 1:52:42going from mathematics to language.
- 1:52:44But he sees language like mathematical logic because this is
- 1:52:47what the signifier is trying to do.
- 1:52:49SPEAKER_02: It's trying to count,
- 1:52:50but then it has to account for itself because what the
- 1:52:52signifier is really doing,
- 1:52:54SPEAKER_02: and this is why he's not a pure linguist,
- 1:52:56is because the signifier and language is really a reference
- 1:52:59point to talk about the
- 1:53:00SPEAKER_02: subject which is absent in all this process,
- 1:53:03SPEAKER_02: the split subject.
- 1:53:05SPEAKER_00: So it's like against...
- 1:53:06SPEAKER_00: No,
- 1:53:07SPEAKER_00: and just real quick,
- 1:53:08SPEAKER_00: I just want to point out,
- 1:53:09SPEAKER_00: just to make a conceptual connection to all of this,
- 1:53:11SPEAKER_00: to what you said,
- 1:53:12SPEAKER_00: Nance,
- 1:53:13SPEAKER_00: to what both of you were saying.
- 1:53:15SPEAKER_00: Look, what does Zizek call the negative subject?
- 1:53:20SPEAKER_00: The zero point of subjectivity, right?
- 1:53:24SPEAKER_00: And so I would go back.
- 1:53:26SPEAKER_00: We were talking about Descartes a minute ago.
- 1:53:29SPEAKER_00: Descartes is the one who discovered this zero point of subjectivity,
- 1:53:34SPEAKER_00: and he does it in meditation too.
- 1:53:36now his problem is he goes on and turns it back into a one a
- 1:53:41pure positive subject
- 1:53:43but in meditation two it is a pure negation of all of his
- 1:53:48imaginary symbolic
- 1:53:49coordinates his positive features right i don't think it's
- 1:53:54possible for him to
- 1:53:55arrive at this zero point of subjectivity without the rise of
- 1:53:59the mathematical
- 1:53:59function of zero right and so i mean i would have to make that
- 1:54:03case but the point
- 1:54:05SPEAKER_00: is
- 1:54:06It's the mathematical zero that gets us in the position to
- 1:54:10start thinking about
- 1:54:11SPEAKER_00: what it is to be a subject.
- 1:54:13The non-relation,
- 1:54:14this singularity that we all are,
- 1:54:16ultimately is a zero point of subjectivity.
- 1:54:20SPEAKER_00: And I know,
- 1:54:22SPEAKER_00: for somebody who's new to Lacanian theory,
- 1:54:26SPEAKER_00: there's no way to not make this somewhat jargony,
- 1:54:30SPEAKER_00: because it's hard to talk about it in any other terms.
- 1:54:34SPEAKER_00: But the point is,
- 1:54:35there's some part of us as subjects that's there even when all
- 1:54:40of our positive
- 1:54:41characteristics even when you disassociate me from my facial
- 1:54:44features through the
- 1:54:46from the clothes i wear from my class status from my you know
- 1:54:50my preferences in
- 1:54:51movies right when you strip all that away there's something
- 1:54:55that remains of me as a
- 1:54:57subject right but it doesn't have any positive features to it
- 1:55:02and it's in that
- 1:55:03SPEAKER_00: sense it's a zero point
- 1:55:05of subjectivity and that is what is encountered or reckoned
- 1:55:09with in subjective
- 1:55:10SPEAKER_00: destitution and so i would just i just wanted to connect these like the
- 1:55:15non-relation and mathematical zero and the zero point of
- 1:55:19subjectivity they're all
- 1:55:20at play here and what we're all getting at in different ways is
- 1:55:24something that a
- 1:55:25code system right now as it currently exists does not
- 1:55:30comprehend and you can go to
- 1:55:32SPEAKER_00: you could even try to prompt it
- 1:55:35SPEAKER_00: Maybe it spits out some words.
- 1:55:37SPEAKER_00: It gets off the internet from Alenka Zupancic or from Zizek or something,
- 1:55:43SPEAKER_00: but it doesn't comprehend what the hell it's talking about.
- 1:55:48SPEAKER_00: How, oh, to be a subject is to not be
- 1:55:53any reducible to the positive defining features of you right
- 1:55:59that not that zero
- 1:56:00point it doesn't get and maybe one day it will but right now it
- 1:56:04doesn't yeah i mean
- 1:56:06that's why like lakana so add uh like like like so adherent to
- 1:56:10like foyd's uh essay
- 1:56:11on vernon or negation you know uh the subject was of the that
- 1:56:15patient's unconscious
- 1:56:16SPEAKER_02: was the uh statement of that's not my mother
- 1:56:19SPEAKER_02: And I think to bring it in simple terms,
- 1:56:21like because Lacan is like caught within the sort of structural
- 1:56:26milieu where he
- 1:56:26tries to like adhere to some structuralist notions and
- 1:56:29linguistic mathematics,
- 1:56:30SPEAKER_02: but also do something new.
- 1:56:33SPEAKER_02: To reading Freud,
- 1:56:33SPEAKER_02: because I mean,
- 1:56:34let's look at about like the terms that were used like oneness
- 1:56:37in zero point and
- 1:56:38SPEAKER_02: what I'm not Freud talks about oneness,
- 1:56:41not only in like what I was talking about in civilization is
- 1:56:43content about like
- 1:56:44SPEAKER_02: oceanic bliss and this feeling of like oneness,
- 1:56:47but that there was a moment in our time where we're being taken
- 1:56:50care of by the
- 1:56:51SPEAKER_02: caregiver.
- 1:56:52SPEAKER_02: and our demands are being satisfied,
- 1:56:53SPEAKER_02: we had this moment of one singular sense of enjoyment or satisfaction,
- 1:57:00SPEAKER_02: right?
- 1:57:01SPEAKER_02: And it is,
- 1:57:01SPEAKER_02: of course,
- 1:57:01encapsulated by this hallucinatory form that Freud talks about
- 1:57:05in the Project for
- 1:57:07SPEAKER_02: Scientific Psychology,
- 1:57:08SPEAKER_02: as well as in Dreams and Interpretation of Dreams.
- 1:57:12And then it takes on this new form of that's not that in the
- 1:57:17theories of sexuality,
- 1:57:18where the sexual object is always a refinding of an object just
- 1:57:22to be like,
- 1:57:22SPEAKER_02: that's not it.
- 1:57:23To which we get it exemplified in the fourth dog game of
- 1:57:27tossing the toy to get it
- 1:57:29SPEAKER_02: back only to toss it back.
- 1:57:30We're constantly as subjects negating everything,
- 1:57:34but never affirming of what we really are.
- 1:57:36We're only inaugurating that we're not this or this is not my
- 1:57:39satisfaction.
- 1:57:41So this is the oscillation between minus one and the zero point
- 1:57:45to try to get at
- 1:57:45SPEAKER_02: the sense of Edenic bliss.
- 1:57:48SPEAKER_02: Going back to Eden.
- 1:57:50SPEAKER_01: I mean,
- 1:57:50when Mikey was just talking about the whole Cartesian skeptical
- 1:57:58inventory,
- 1:57:59SPEAKER_01: let's say,
- 1:57:59SPEAKER_01: in which you...
- 1:58:01empty yourself of any positive qualities,
- 1:58:05any imaginary symbolic correlates to your being.
- 1:58:09Milner talks about that in a search for clarity and how it's
- 1:58:14like the logic of,
- 1:58:19SPEAKER_01: I think if I'm remembering correctly,
- 1:58:21SPEAKER_01: the signifier is like the knowledge correlate of that exact process.
- 1:58:27SPEAKER_01: And like what Lacan's trying to do is come up with a science of sorts,
- 1:58:35SPEAKER_01: big inverted commas,
- 1:58:37SPEAKER_01: but with science there,
- 1:58:38because that's a whole sticky wicket that we might not want to
- 1:58:42touch right now.
- 1:58:43But a science of sorts that would stay at the level of
- 1:58:48Descartes in the second
- 1:58:50SPEAKER_01: meditation before he counts himself as one.
- 1:58:54SPEAKER_01: holds onto that,
- 1:58:55retains that moment in which that sort of suspension is
- 1:59:02epoch-defining in a way,
- 1:59:05and creates the ideal of a science in psychoanalysis which
- 1:59:14would address that
- 1:59:17SPEAKER_01: Cartesian subject.
- 1:59:19SPEAKER_01: And the fascinating thing is that
- 1:59:23that kind of emptying out isn't just a thought experiment it
- 1:59:27can occur if you
- 1:59:29SPEAKER_01: undergo psychoanalysis there is a phenomenological reality to subjective
- 1:59:36destitution that i don't think it can necessarily occur from
- 1:59:40just pure speculation
- 1:59:42but if you attend these sessions for long enough then there
- 1:59:49would be this kind of
- 1:59:51SPEAKER_01: empty and eventually
- 1:59:53SPEAKER_01: there will be kind of a reconfiguration of the certain symbolic,
- 1:59:58imaginary symbolic coordinates because you can't exist without
- 2:00:07them in some way,
- 2:00:08SPEAKER_01: without succumbing to a kind of radical psychic autism.
- 2:00:13But the whole point is,
- 2:00:15and this is taking us somewhat far afield from our original
- 2:00:20discussions,
- 2:00:21is that if psychoanalysis is something like a science,
- 2:00:26what kind of science would it be?
- 2:00:27SPEAKER_01: And why is it still nascent in a way?
- 2:00:31And why does it and how does it address something that none of
- 2:00:37these other sciences are?
- 2:00:39And is it even possible,
- 2:00:41this ideal of a science,
- 2:00:44of the signifier and one that
- 2:00:47SPEAKER_01: embraces the Cartesian subject emptied of its contents.
- 2:00:53SPEAKER_00: Nance,
- 2:00:54SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 2:00:54SPEAKER_00: to pivot off of that,
- 2:00:57SPEAKER_00: what you just brought in to the equation,
- 2:00:59SPEAKER_00: Nick,
- 2:00:59SPEAKER_00: with science.
- 2:01:00SPEAKER_00: I mean, think about it.
- 2:01:01Nance,
- 2:01:01you brought in mathematical zero,
- 2:01:03and now we're talking about subjective zero.
- 2:01:06But there's a way Lacan himself connects the desiring subject
- 2:01:11to the scientific subject.
- 2:01:13SPEAKER_00: Why?
- 2:01:14SPEAKER_00: Because the subject of science has to occupy a kind of experiential
- 2:01:21zero point you have to detach yourself from the experiment you
- 2:01:25have to bracket out
- 2:01:26your preference as much as you can right it's kind of an ideal
- 2:01:29but the the the
- 2:01:31subject of science is a pure knower without any partiality any
- 2:01:38ideological
- 2:01:39preferences any of that and so what we have here is like
- 2:01:43mathematical zero
- 2:01:44SPEAKER_00: subjective zero scientific zero what do you think of that
- 2:01:50SPEAKER_03: I think that we kind of moved toward Levinas.
- 2:01:56And I think the thing that allows you to hold open that
- 2:02:05negation or to hold open
- 2:02:06the gap or to kind of sit in the contradiction and sit in the
- 2:02:09kind of valley of all
- 2:02:10SPEAKER_03: these positivistic things,
- 2:02:12SPEAKER_03: I think is...
- 2:02:13um is your non-relation and and like your ability to recognize
- 2:02:19that and your
- 2:02:19ability to recognize the other and recognize yourself by way of
- 2:02:23recognizing the
- 2:02:24other totally knowing that it's an incomplete recognition like
- 2:02:27that is that that is
- 2:02:28the magic that makes us do it uh so maybe i don't know maybe
- 2:02:35that's just like uh
- 2:02:38empirical evidence that psychoanalysis and ethics and
- 2:02:42philosophy isn't all just like bullshit.
- 2:02:45SPEAKER_03: Like,
- 2:02:45SPEAKER_03: like there,
- 2:02:46they are all different kinds of avenues trying to get at
- 2:02:49something that is,
- 2:02:51SPEAKER_03: what is it to be?
- 2:02:52SPEAKER_03: What is it to be me?
- 2:02:54SPEAKER_00: Um, and I don't say modernity is zero.
- 2:02:58SPEAKER_00: Um,
- 2:02:59SPEAKER_03: I mean,
- 2:02:59SPEAKER_03: the thing is,
- 2:03:00SPEAKER_03: Sean and I were talking,
- 2:03:02SPEAKER_03: and actually we're going to have another conversation about modernity.
- 2:03:09SPEAKER_03: What would happen if modernity actually delivered on its promise?
- 2:03:13SPEAKER_03: The promise of modernity is actually an awesome thing.
- 2:03:18The promise of emancipation and the promise of
- 2:03:20self-actualization and the promise of...
- 2:03:25being able to be effective and edify yourself in the world like
- 2:03:29that's all awesome
- 2:03:31um and i you know i i think i go pretty far into what people
- 2:03:36call post-modernism
- 2:03:38SPEAKER_03: and i think there's a lot going on there um but uh
- 2:03:43Yeah,
- 2:03:43I do think at least the idea at the core of all this stuff is a
- 2:03:51good one.
- 2:03:52SPEAKER_03: People want to feel good.
- 2:03:53SPEAKER_03: People want to be happy.
- 2:03:54SPEAKER_03: People want to self-actualize and be effective in the world.
- 2:03:59And capital is this oceanic creature that latched onto our
- 2:04:03desire in this way and
- 2:04:04kind of hoodwinked us all into participating in this global
- 2:04:07game of fucking
- 2:04:08SPEAKER_03: genocide and
- 2:04:10horrible horrible things because the promise of
- 2:04:12self-actualization the promise you
- 2:04:14can be the liberal subject you can be free you can determine
- 2:04:18your own most you can
- 2:04:19do all that stuff like it's it's not just libidinal it's
- 2:04:22actually fucking spiritual
- 2:04:24SPEAKER_03: fuck it um
- 2:04:28SPEAKER_03: But I don't know.
- 2:04:28SPEAKER_03: I think we have to hold on to zero.
- 2:04:32SPEAKER_03: And the machine right now doesn't do zero.
- 2:04:36SPEAKER_03: The machine right now does this thing where it's just the absence of one.
- 2:04:39SPEAKER_03: It can't do the less than nothing.
- 2:04:42SPEAKER_03: That's what we do.
- 2:04:43SPEAKER_03: That's what humans...
- 2:04:44SPEAKER_03: or it's what we do, the machine currently can't do that.
- 2:04:47SPEAKER_03: And again, barring speculation about can it, it doesn't right now.
- 2:04:52SPEAKER_03: And I think we're in danger.
- 2:04:54It's not just this thing that the idea of therapy GPT makes me
- 2:04:58feel kind of sad and
- 2:04:59SPEAKER_03: kind of gross,
- 2:05:00SPEAKER_03: but also empathize with the people who have no other option
- 2:05:04like i i think we're approaching a moment where like hey it's
- 2:05:07time to put up or
- 2:05:08shut up i believe in subjectivity i value subjectivity more
- 2:05:12than i value consumer
- 2:05:13satisfaction more than i value um other things and uh it's just
- 2:05:20it there's a lot of
- 2:05:20people excited about ai right now and there's a lot of people
- 2:05:24talking about therapy
- 2:05:26gpt and stuff like that but what conversation i've seen about
- 2:05:30it has has all
- 2:05:31SPEAKER_03: largely been um
- 2:05:34dissatisfying because they're not really going into what makes
- 2:05:38a subject.
- 2:05:39What's the difference between analysis and not even therapy,
- 2:05:44but therapy GPT?
- 2:05:46SPEAKER_03: They don't really reckon with that.
- 2:05:48SPEAKER_00: Yes.
- 2:05:50SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 2:05:50SPEAKER_00: Hold on, I'll be right back.
- 2:05:52SPEAKER_00: Hold on.
- 2:05:52SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 2:05:55SPEAKER_02: Yeah,
- 2:05:55SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 2:05:55SPEAKER_02: it makes me think like,
- 2:05:57SPEAKER_02: and this is why,
- 2:05:58SPEAKER_02: like,
- 2:05:58SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 2:05:58SPEAKER_02: I'm a Marxist for many reasons,
- 2:06:00SPEAKER_02: but like,
- 2:06:00SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 2:06:01SPEAKER_02: ultimately,
- 2:06:02SPEAKER_02: like,
- 2:06:02SPEAKER_02: even though we're all you for lack of a better term,
- 2:06:05SPEAKER_02: cogs in the machines or like,
- 2:06:07SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 2:06:08SPEAKER_02: we're in the Matrix and we just got blue pill,
- 2:06:11SPEAKER_02: red pill,
- 2:06:12SPEAKER_02: black pill,
- 2:06:13SPEAKER_02: whatever types of pills you want now.
- 2:06:16SPEAKER_02: But,
- 2:06:17SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 2:06:18SPEAKER_02: the ruling,
- 2:06:19SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 2:06:20SPEAKER_02: the ideology is always going to be like the,
- 2:06:24SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 2:06:24SPEAKER_02: the ruling ideas,
- 2:06:25SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 2:06:25SPEAKER_02: of the ruling class.
- 2:06:27SPEAKER_02: Now,
- 2:06:27SPEAKER_02: that doesn't mean that those are the only ideas because,
- 2:06:30SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 2:06:30the proletariat or the working class or the lumpenproletariat
- 2:06:35or anybody ancillary
- 2:06:37SPEAKER_02: that doesn't own the means of production,
- 2:06:38SPEAKER_02: they still have ideas.
- 2:06:40I mean,
- 2:06:40like in D&G and for lack of a better term,
- 2:06:42for better or for worse,
- 2:06:44SPEAKER_02: can help us with this with,
- 2:06:45SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 2:06:45SPEAKER_02: molecularization or Badoo with,
- 2:06:48SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 2:06:49SPEAKER_02: the events and,
- 2:06:51SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 2:06:51SPEAKER_02: the group subjects.
- 2:06:53You know,
- 2:06:53we have ways into which we show that,
- 2:06:54you know,
- 2:06:55it's not just the ruling ideas.
- 2:06:57SPEAKER_02: But what I'm getting at right here is because,
- 2:06:58SPEAKER_02: like,
- 2:06:59SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 2:06:59SPEAKER_02: ultimately we're still being sort of torn apart by the ruling ideology,
- 2:07:04SPEAKER_02: but it's not just about ideas.
- 2:07:06And this is why psychoanalysis helps,
- 2:07:08because it's also about enjoyment,
- 2:07:10right?
- 2:07:11SPEAKER_02: Not just in juicence, but also otium, leisure.
- 2:07:15SPEAKER_02: And I don't know if you guys know this guy.
- 2:07:17I just I just mentioned it a few days ago to Nick,
- 2:07:20but he was an Italian-American Marxist.
- 2:07:25who had a radical break from Marxism and he went full on
- 2:07:28conservative Catholic.
- 2:07:29SPEAKER_02: His name is Eugene Genovese.
- 2:07:32You know,
- 2:07:33he wrote in a Gramscian methodology,
- 2:07:36the history of US slavery in the Civil War.
- 2:07:40And that because of the dominance of slavery as the means for
- 2:07:46labor production
- 2:07:47SPEAKER_02: within the South,
- 2:07:48SPEAKER_02: that for America,
- 2:07:49SPEAKER_02: the American ideology
- 2:07:51Or ideology as enjoyment allowed for the birth and construction
- 2:07:56of an ideology of
- 2:07:58SPEAKER_02: pleasure and leisure,
- 2:08:00SPEAKER_02: to which we bring over guests have entertainment,
- 2:08:04SPEAKER_02: and all these types of things that,
- 2:08:05SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 2:08:06SPEAKER_02: transition not only into like,
- 2:08:08SPEAKER_02: post-Reconstruction,
- 2:08:09SPEAKER_02: post-slavery,
- 2:08:10but also into like the Roaring Twenties and up until now where
- 2:08:13we're in a,
- 2:08:13SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 2:08:14SPEAKER_02: a predominant ideology of constant leisure,
- 2:08:16SPEAKER_02: right?
- 2:08:17SPEAKER_02: You know, so it's like a matter of like who does the labor, right?
- 2:08:20SPEAKER_02: So that, you know, the dominant ruling class can have leisure.
- 2:08:23SPEAKER_02: I mean, the ruling class, they don't care about mathematics.
- 2:08:26SPEAKER_02: They're not trying to like study Einstein or do what we're doing.
- 2:08:29You know,
- 2:08:29we're a bunch of working class dudes that are talking about
- 2:08:31theory.
- 2:08:31SPEAKER_02: Meanwhile, they're going on retreats.
- 2:08:34SPEAKER_02: They're hiking.
- 2:08:35SPEAKER_02: They're trying to find themselves.
- 2:08:36SPEAKER_02: They're fucking kids.
- 2:08:38SPEAKER_01: Isn't isn't that?
- 2:08:39SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 2:08:40SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 2:08:40SPEAKER_01: I mean, it's a useless activity.
- 2:08:43What they're going for,
- 2:08:44though,
- 2:08:44isn't isn't they have all this leisure time.
- 2:08:47SPEAKER_01: Leisure becomes the enemy for them.
- 2:08:49SPEAKER_01: Right.
- 2:08:49SPEAKER_01: Because it's like that when you see depictions of the ruling classes.
- 2:08:56SPEAKER_01: in Renaissance paintings,
- 2:08:57SPEAKER_01: it's,
- 2:08:58SPEAKER_01: it's like some,
- 2:08:59SPEAKER_01: like a chubby woman,
- 2:09:01SPEAKER_01: like lying soup,
- 2:09:04SPEAKER_01: like eating grapes or some shit.
- 2:09:06It's like,
- 2:09:06that is the antithesis of what the ruling class wants to appear
- 2:09:10as.
- 2:09:11SPEAKER_01: I mean, it's like they, they, what do they want?
- 2:09:14SPEAKER_01: I mean, at a certain point, it's like to be strong, fast and,
- 2:09:21SPEAKER_01: Or in Elon Musk's case,
- 2:09:22SPEAKER_01: to be like a comedian,
- 2:09:23SPEAKER_01: to be anything but what was associated with the ruling class before,
- 2:09:29which is like to be corpulent and like not move and just to
- 2:09:36stand there like Henry
- 2:09:37SPEAKER_01: VIII was the ideal.
- 2:09:40SPEAKER_01: Right.
- 2:09:40SPEAKER_02: I will say like with Lacan and OTM and leisure and seminar 16,
- 2:09:44SPEAKER_02: he will say like,
- 2:09:45SPEAKER_02: it's not enough to have like a week vacation to go out and skiing,
- 2:09:48but you also had to account for like the four days you need to
- 2:09:50recover after that.
- 2:09:51SPEAKER_02: Recover from the leisure.
- 2:09:53SPEAKER_02: Recover from the leisure.
- 2:09:54SPEAKER_02: Right.
- 2:09:55SPEAKER_02: But no,
- 2:09:55SPEAKER_02: no,
- 2:09:55SPEAKER_02: it's not that like,
- 2:09:56SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 2:09:56like I definitely agree with that because I think that is also
- 2:09:59like the sort of way
- 2:10:00SPEAKER_02: in which you have to disavow.
- 2:10:00SPEAKER_02: You have to like appear that you're hardworking, you're self-like.
- 2:10:04SPEAKER_02: actualizing and you're always optimal, right?
- 2:10:08SPEAKER_02: And again,
- 2:10:08SPEAKER_02: it goes back to self excellence,
- 2:10:09SPEAKER_02: but it's like leisure and OTM allow for you to excel for yourself.
- 2:10:16SPEAKER_02: And so far as that there is a,
- 2:10:18SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 2:10:19SPEAKER_02: a bunch of peons or there's,
- 2:10:20SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 2:10:20another class that are doing the labor that you don't have to
- 2:10:23do so that you can
- 2:10:24SPEAKER_02: actualize yourself,
- 2:10:25SPEAKER_02: right?
- 2:10:27SPEAKER_02: That's like the whole point.
- 2:10:29SPEAKER_03: I think that's kind of... I think Baudrillard sums it up.
- 2:10:33SPEAKER_03: When we're talking about sign value, it used to be about distinction.
- 2:10:37SPEAKER_03: It used to be about signaling distance from necessity.
- 2:10:40SPEAKER_03: But fractal value is this viral contagion.
- 2:10:43SPEAKER_03: It's the churn.
- 2:10:44SPEAKER_03: It's this thing that has to keep going.
- 2:10:46SPEAKER_03: So, yeah, the ruling class...
- 2:10:50SPEAKER_03: You can't just buy a yacht and fuck chicks and drink.
- 2:10:54SPEAKER_03: You have to Instagram it.
- 2:10:55SPEAKER_03: You have to put it on.
- 2:10:57SPEAKER_03: You have to show the world.
- 2:10:58SPEAKER_03: You have to show the image picture.
- 2:11:00SPEAKER_03: It didn't happen once again.
- 2:11:01SPEAKER_03: That's the world that we live in now.
- 2:11:02SPEAKER_03: That is what fractal value is about.
- 2:11:05SPEAKER_03: I don't know.
- 2:11:07SPEAKER_03: I think this is getting into production and stuff.
- 2:11:11SPEAKER_03: I don't know.
- 2:11:12SPEAKER_03: Production is at a weird moment in history.
- 2:11:14SPEAKER_03: Are the working class going to be a necessity anytime soon?
- 2:11:21SPEAKER_03: I think right now it's probably true.
- 2:11:23The knowledge class or the laptop class or whatever,
- 2:11:27they're probably in most danger.
- 2:11:29SPEAKER_03: For their jobs,
- 2:11:30but I think soon the billions of people who have to work for a
- 2:11:36living will also be
- 2:11:37SPEAKER_03: in danger of losing that work.
- 2:11:41SPEAKER_03: And kind of then what do we do?
- 2:11:42SPEAKER_03: And then we can talk about like UBI and then we can talk,
- 2:11:45SPEAKER_03: I don't know,
- 2:11:46SPEAKER_03: but it's just,
- 2:11:47SPEAKER_03: it's value has,
- 2:11:49SPEAKER_03: something fuckies happened to value.
- 2:11:51SPEAKER_03: And that's connected in this too.
- 2:11:54And that is pertinent to the conversation about therapy and
- 2:11:57about self-worth and
- 2:11:58SPEAKER_03: self-actualization and all that stuff too.
- 2:12:01And that's another element that I think is missing from most of
- 2:12:04the conversation going on.
- 2:12:08SPEAKER_02: I think we think of like when you're talking about UBI,
- 2:12:11SPEAKER_02: was it Jody Dean's criticism of it to what she calls a UBS,
- 2:12:15universal basic services to where like those are actualized
- 2:12:19more than UBI because
- 2:12:20SPEAKER_02: UBI is still income and,
- 2:12:22SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 2:12:22SPEAKER_02: that's money.
- 2:12:23SPEAKER_02: Money is still the universal equivalent of all commodities.
- 2:12:25SPEAKER_02: That's that tension with value and price and actualization.
- 2:12:29SPEAKER_02: You know,
- 2:12:30SPEAKER_02: and so I don't know,
- 2:12:31SPEAKER_02: like,
- 2:12:32SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 2:12:32SPEAKER_02: services and maybe again,
- 2:12:34that will also put in the question of caregiving services as
- 2:12:37well with AI.
- 2:12:38SPEAKER_02: But,
- 2:12:39SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 2:12:40I think like there's something to that which would get at a
- 2:12:42more dialectical way
- 2:12:44SPEAKER_02: to,
- 2:12:45SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 2:12:45SPEAKER_02: to use Mikey's terms.
- 2:12:46I want,
- 2:12:47you know,
- 2:12:48situations or,
- 2:12:50you know,
- 2:12:51worlds where I could have better struggles.
- 2:12:53You know,
- 2:12:53I think we need to have a framework where we could have better
- 2:12:57struggles,
- 2:12:57right?
- 2:12:58SPEAKER_02: I like that.
- 2:13:00And I think I mean the only thing I would add is just look
- 2:13:03Baudrillard was always
- 2:13:05thinking about these different types of value and for him At
- 2:13:09the end of his life.
- 2:13:10He was thinking about this fractal value integral value But I
- 2:13:17think with AI as we
- 2:13:19know it we have to start thinking about some other type of and
- 2:13:23Nance has been
- 2:13:24SPEAKER_00: thinking about this a lot lately,
- 2:13:26SPEAKER_00: but I agree with them and and
- 2:13:28SPEAKER_00: I don't know what to call it.
- 2:13:29I don't know how it'll work because I don't,
- 2:13:31I think it's emerging right now.
- 2:13:32SPEAKER_00: It's hard to say how AI will affect the thing about our,
- 2:13:38SPEAKER_00: just take the three forms of commodity value Baudrillard talked about.
- 2:13:42SPEAKER_00: We all know them.
- 2:13:43SPEAKER_00: Use value, exchange value, and sign value.
- 2:13:47SPEAKER_00: Throw in fractal value in the age of the internet.
- 2:13:50SPEAKER_00: But then you,
- 2:13:51SPEAKER_00: you bring in AI and you go,
- 2:13:53SPEAKER_00: what does it do to the,
- 2:13:55SPEAKER_00: do any of these four forms of value
- 2:13:58function at all like they have once ai arrives like what does
- 2:14:04it do to exchange
- 2:14:05value what does it do to use value i mean is there going to be
- 2:14:09a revolution in how
- 2:14:10things function different assignments etc um sign value what
- 2:14:15does i mean how do we
- 2:14:16in in what sense do we get our you know connotative identities
- 2:14:21from commodities
- 2:14:23SPEAKER_00: when ai does everything
- 2:14:25SPEAKER_00: Um and then fractal value.
- 2:14:27SPEAKER_00: I mean,
- 2:14:28SPEAKER_00: I don't know what it means to you know,
- 2:14:30kim kardashian has much fractal value Yeah in the age of ai
- 2:14:36when it can generate
- 2:14:39SPEAKER_00: Images of Perfect bodies and blah blah.
- 2:14:42SPEAKER_00: Like what is it?
- 2:14:43SPEAKER_00: Does it deep fakes?
- 2:14:45SPEAKER_00: What does it do to fractal that so all of these forms of value?
- 2:14:50SPEAKER_00: are under threat at the moment.
- 2:14:52SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 2:14:53SPEAKER_02: Well,
- 2:14:53SPEAKER_02: I would say as far as like,
- 2:14:54SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 2:14:54SPEAKER_02: the labor process and social reproduction,
- 2:14:56SPEAKER_02: like,
- 2:14:56SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 2:14:57SPEAKER_02: one of the things that I heard,
- 2:14:58SPEAKER_02: I forget where I heard it from,
- 2:14:59SPEAKER_02: I don't know if it was C.
- 2:15:00SPEAKER_02: Derek Barn or if it was Conrad or like somewhere,
- 2:15:02SPEAKER_02: but like,
- 2:15:03SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 2:15:03SPEAKER_02: the problem that like,
- 2:15:04SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 2:15:04the only thing that AI can't do is replace a lot of these
- 2:15:06factories where shoes and
- 2:15:08SPEAKER_02: like sneakers and clothes are made because the fact that it's like,
- 2:15:12SPEAKER_02: it's not as fast or precise to do the stitching.
- 2:15:14SPEAKER_02: So you still require labor.
- 2:15:17SPEAKER_02: But in a sense,
- 2:15:18SPEAKER_02: it's like,
- 2:15:18SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 2:15:19we see AI and it's like elementary form being able to like
- 2:15:22create self-checkout at
- 2:15:23SPEAKER_02: Walmart.
- 2:15:24SPEAKER_02: Now,
- 2:15:24SPEAKER_02: of course,
- 2:15:25SPEAKER_02: even with that,
- 2:15:25we still need people to operate on the maintenance and even to
- 2:15:28survey that,
- 2:15:29SPEAKER_02: which is the ironic part.
- 2:15:30SPEAKER_02: But, you know, yeah, I don't know when it comes to like fractal value.
- 2:15:33SPEAKER_02: I mean, I've never heard that before until today.
- 2:15:35SPEAKER_02: So, I mean, maybe it is also indicative of like,
- 2:15:41SPEAKER_02: what is being privileged with that fact of value if it's not,
- 2:15:44SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 2:15:44SPEAKER_02: celebrities and just,
- 2:15:46SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 2:15:46SPEAKER_02: the bourgeois,
- 2:15:47SPEAKER_02: again,
- 2:15:47SPEAKER_02: just to bring it back to the simplest Marxist terms,
- 2:15:49SPEAKER_02: like,
- 2:15:51SPEAKER_02: not that it wouldn't affect,
- 2:15:52SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 2:15:53SPEAKER_02: us working class or the poor or the lumpen or whatever,
- 2:15:56SPEAKER_02: but like,
- 2:15:57SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 2:15:57SPEAKER_02: it seems like it's privileging,
- 2:15:59SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 2:16:00SPEAKER_02: the spectacle of like the fact that everybody,
- 2:16:03SPEAKER_02: the ruling class,
- 2:16:04SPEAKER_02: like those that worked hard are enjoying and you can too one day.
- 2:16:08SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 2:16:09SPEAKER_00: Look,
- 2:16:09SPEAKER_00: I think it's helpful,
- 2:16:10SPEAKER_00: this fractal form of value or viral value,
- 2:16:14SPEAKER_00: if we talk like that,
- 2:16:15SPEAKER_00: it's also helpful to frame it as the value of the attention economy,
- 2:16:20SPEAKER_02: attention value.
- 2:16:21SPEAKER_02: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 2:16:23SPEAKER_03: I think like for me,
- 2:16:25SPEAKER_03: yeah,
- 2:16:25SPEAKER_03: I've been thinking about value for years at this point,
- 2:16:28SPEAKER_03: like trying to come up with something.
- 2:16:30And I think one thing for me is looking at kind of a ties
- 2:16:36general economy and
- 2:16:37SPEAKER_03: looking at capital as a machine,
- 2:16:39SPEAKER_03: not to produce value for us and for our sake and from our perspective,
- 2:16:45SPEAKER_03: but just to manage surplus.
- 2:16:47SPEAKER_03: And so to actually like what capital actually does is it produces waste.
- 2:16:52SPEAKER_03: we think like from our perspective,
- 2:16:53SPEAKER_03: the,
- 2:16:54SPEAKER_03: the ideology that,
- 2:16:55SPEAKER_03: that we all kind of have no choice,
- 2:16:56SPEAKER_03: but to,
- 2:16:57SPEAKER_03: uh,
- 2:16:58SPEAKER_03: onboard or else you'd fucking kill yourself.
- 2:17:00SPEAKER_03: Um, is that it produces use value and, and, and it's utility and stuff.
- 2:17:04But what's really happening is it's,
- 2:17:07it's the solar anus it's taking in solar energy.
- 2:17:10SPEAKER_03: Plants are eating it.
- 2:17:11SPEAKER_03: Animals are eating plants.
- 2:17:12SPEAKER_03: We're eating animals.
- 2:17:12SPEAKER_03: We're producing machines.
- 2:17:13SPEAKER_03: Machines are producing the commodity.
- 2:17:15SPEAKER_03: The commodity is just
- 2:17:17SPEAKER_03: symbolic exchange in reverse.
- 2:17:18SPEAKER_03: It's nothing but it's produced for exchange.
- 2:17:22SPEAKER_03: It's this churn.
- 2:17:23SPEAKER_03: It's death by attrition, death by a thousand paper cuts.
- 2:17:27SPEAKER_03: All we're doing is producing waste.
- 2:17:29SPEAKER_03: We're producing commodity objects that are
- 2:17:33built to be replaced they're not built to be used and you can
- 2:17:36read binyamin and you
- 2:17:37can talk about the aura of originality and like i don't know
- 2:17:41it's just uh it
- 2:17:43becomes crazy it it it it starts to become this oppressive
- 2:17:47feeling of like fuck man
- 2:17:50like the machines are winning the war right now and and we're
- 2:17:53still all out here
- 2:17:54SPEAKER_03: like
- 2:17:55fucking i don't know trying to impress each other with dumb
- 2:17:58bullshit on the
- 2:17:59internet um and we're like we're dying dude i mean and we're
- 2:18:04all always already
- 2:18:05dying that's what makes life worth living but uh like we're
- 2:18:10we're losing the war
- 2:18:11we're dying in a different sense yeah yeah yeah we we get to
- 2:18:15choose like when you
- 2:18:16get to live a fulfilling life you're choosing your death you
- 2:18:18know you're choosing
- 2:18:19your own most but that's that's the way it gets like the you
- 2:18:22know what the drive
- 2:18:23SPEAKER_00: wants is to choose it's
- 2:18:25SPEAKER_00: you know, choose the way it dies.
- 2:18:29SPEAKER_03: that's taking up responsibility.
- 2:18:31SPEAKER_03: Like, like, yeah, there's a lot there.
- 2:18:34SPEAKER_03: Um, I don't want to be all bummed out though, dude.
- 2:18:37SPEAKER_03: Like I,
- 2:18:38SPEAKER_03: uh,
- 2:18:39there was something else that came up when we were talking
- 2:18:41about old people and
- 2:18:45SPEAKER_03: nurture.
- 2:18:46SPEAKER_03: Uh, and I didn't actually write down what I was thinking.
- 2:18:48SPEAKER_03: I just wrote down old people nurture.
- 2:18:50SPEAKER_03: Uh, but I kind of, I kind of want to return to that.
- 2:18:55SPEAKER_03: Um,
- 2:18:58SPEAKER_03: Like senescence, like old age and death.
- 2:19:03SPEAKER_03: And like we send our old people off.
- 2:19:05A lot of the time when we send them off,
- 2:19:07it's because we just have to work.
- 2:19:08SPEAKER_03: We don't have the time to do the shadow work to take care of them.
- 2:19:11SPEAKER_03: It's like babies.
- 2:19:12SPEAKER_03: We send babies to daycare or public school because we have to work.
- 2:19:17SPEAKER_03: We have to be productive.
- 2:19:18SPEAKER_03: We don't have...
- 2:19:19the the time required to do the labor of rearing or caring for
- 2:19:24the old but it's
- 2:19:25it's also like a disavowal of of death like old people homes
- 2:19:29are sad places
- 2:19:30hospices are sad places and like capital and and the ideology
- 2:19:35and part of this
- 2:19:36SPEAKER_03: ideology of capital makes use useful things and
- 2:19:40SPEAKER_03: is just an affirmation of life.
- 2:19:44SPEAKER_03: And old people, they're sad and kind of gross.
- 2:19:48SPEAKER_03: Not to be a dick, but it's sad.
- 2:19:51SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 2:19:54SPEAKER_02: Yeah,
- 2:19:55SPEAKER_02: when I was working at a healthcare facility,
- 2:19:56SPEAKER_02: it's just like,
- 2:19:57SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 2:19:57SPEAKER_02: you got like a bunch of like old people coming into the kitchen.
- 2:19:59SPEAKER_02: They're like, can I have this?
- 2:20:01SPEAKER_02: And that's like, bro, what's your diet?
- 2:20:03SPEAKER_02: You know, I can't give you that.
- 2:20:04SPEAKER_02: You're a diabetic and you want a fucking PB&J and you'll play yoga.
- 2:20:07Like,
- 2:20:08I know,
- 2:20:08like,
- 2:20:09and they're just like screaming at me and cursing at me.
- 2:20:11SPEAKER_02: I hate you.
- 2:20:11SPEAKER_02: Yada, yada, yada.
- 2:20:13SPEAKER_02: Meanwhile, those nurses aren't doing their job.
- 2:20:15SPEAKER_02: The old man in the wheelchair and their piss bag is exposed.
- 2:20:17SPEAKER_02: It's like, come on, man.
- 2:20:18SPEAKER_02: Like, it's not their fault.
- 2:20:20SPEAKER_02: It's just like, you know, the way that the infrastructure and the
- 2:20:22bureaucratization of it and like you know and maybe it puts
- 2:20:27into question even like
- 2:20:28the amount of again capitalism and the problem of the medical
- 2:20:31industry as well not
- 2:20:32even just in therapy but even just like in medicalization like
- 2:20:35my dad was just
- 2:20:35telling me that he might have to get surgery on his knee but
- 2:20:40also that he has the
- 2:20:41ability to take that new thing that he could do for like any
- 2:20:45sort of like joint
- 2:20:46SPEAKER_02: injury where they could take the bone marrow from your hip bone
- 2:20:51SPEAKER_02: and then inject it into your joint and it's a speedy recovery.
- 2:20:56but it costs like over like 3,800,
- 2:20:58you know,
- 2:21:00out of,
- 2:21:01that's just,
- 2:21:01and it's not covered.
- 2:21:02SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 2:21:03SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 2:21:04SPEAKER_02: That's just a down payment.
- 2:21:05SPEAKER_02: Right.
- 2:21:06SPEAKER_02: And so it's like, that's just like one example.
- 2:21:09SPEAKER_02: Imagine being old and then having to get that surgery.
- 2:21:13SPEAKER_02: Right.
- 2:21:13SPEAKER_02: And your healthcare doesn't cover it.
- 2:21:15SPEAKER_02: And so like your healthcare is like,
- 2:21:17SPEAKER_02: okay,
- 2:21:17we can put you in this like cheap ass healthcare facility in
- 2:21:20the fucking ghetto.
- 2:21:21SPEAKER_03: Right.
- 2:21:23SPEAKER_03: And then, and then like the, the old people,
- 2:21:26SPEAKER_03: to get taken advantage of and shit too.
- 2:21:28Like it's,
- 2:21:28it's,
- 2:21:28it's also very unfortunate and very sad because they do get
- 2:21:32taken advantage of.
- 2:21:33SPEAKER_03: I think Netflix made a movie about that a few years ago.
- 2:21:37SPEAKER_03: Um,
- 2:21:37SPEAKER_03: and it kind of blew up and everybody,
- 2:21:39everybody suddenly became conscious of it for like six months
- 2:21:42and then everyone
- 2:21:42SPEAKER_03: forgot about it again.
- 2:21:43But like earlier,
- 2:21:45um,
- 2:21:47Tut came up and,
- 2:21:48and like the family and like,
- 2:21:51um,
- 2:21:53I don't know.
- 2:21:53SPEAKER_03: I just, I,
- 2:21:55SPEAKER_03: I kind of think this is a structural problem.
- 2:21:59We're not out here trying to talk about individuals and try to
- 2:22:04blame anything on anybody.
- 2:22:05SPEAKER_03: I can't stand people who always stay there.
- 2:22:08SPEAKER_03: Now, it is appropriate to call people out on their bullshit,
- 2:22:11We also need to be having like structural conversations and
- 2:22:14like just the old
- 2:22:15SPEAKER_03: people thing and the structure of the family.
- 2:22:19Like it used to be the case that your old people were in your
- 2:22:22home and your old
- 2:22:24SPEAKER_03: people,
- 2:22:25not only did you deal with them and you had to put up with all
- 2:22:27this stuff.
- 2:22:29SPEAKER_03: But they were also productive members of the family.
- 2:22:32SPEAKER_03: They reinforced the kind of ego ideal.
- 2:22:37We were talking earlier about there's no difference between the
- 2:22:41poser and the authentic.
- 2:22:44SPEAKER_03: There is no more ego ideal for us to live up to.
- 2:22:48We are just in this kind of postmodern Jackson Pollock painting
- 2:22:51of everything is...
- 2:22:54SPEAKER_03: this is what it is.
- 2:22:55SPEAKER_03: And the image, the appearance is the essence of the thing itself.
- 2:22:59SPEAKER_03: And like having old people in the home and having families,
- 2:23:04I think has a lot to do or not having any of that stuff has a
- 2:23:09lot to do with kind
- 2:23:11of how young people are now growing up and they're not
- 2:23:13connected to any narrative.
- 2:23:14SPEAKER_03: They're not connected to any
- 2:23:17thing outside themselves like they really are growing up in
- 2:23:20this structural
- 2:23:22solipsism where it's it's just like you are the thing and you
- 2:23:27have to participate
- 2:23:29in this kind of imagistic world and there is no difference
- 2:23:32there is no negation um
- 2:23:36no absolutely i mean that's why like uh touch project is always
- 2:23:39ongoing he's always
- 2:23:40talking about it but i think his main point which he's getting
- 2:23:43from not only just
- 2:23:43SPEAKER_02: marks and angles but christopher lash is that like
- 2:23:47SPEAKER_02: Family is not only the institution,
- 2:23:50not only like the nucleus for the reproduction of social labor
- 2:23:55and just social
- 2:23:56SPEAKER_02: reproduction in general,
- 2:23:57SPEAKER_02: it's also the site for antagonism and also trauma as well,
- 2:24:01SPEAKER_02: not in the psychoanalytic sense,
- 2:24:02but it's the first thing to get attacked whenever there's
- 2:24:05something wrong.
- 2:24:06SPEAKER_02: politically and economically,
- 2:24:09SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 2:24:10SPEAKER_02: in the also affects the problem of social mobility,
- 2:24:13SPEAKER_02: where like now,
- 2:24:15SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 2:24:15SPEAKER_02: homes are either broken,
- 2:24:17SPEAKER_02: families are fractured,
- 2:24:18or you have to like live with a bunch of people just because
- 2:24:22you can't meet ends
- 2:24:23SPEAKER_02: meet with like traditional nuclear families.
- 2:24:25SPEAKER_02: You know,
- 2:24:26SPEAKER_02: if anything,
- 2:24:26it's only like those that are in the willing class that are
- 2:24:28able to enjoy that
- 2:24:28SPEAKER_02: life,
- 2:24:29SPEAKER_02: but still divorce rates are high.
- 2:24:30But if you're a child within like a bourgeois or petty
- 2:24:33bourgeois family that's
- 2:24:35SPEAKER_02: going through a divorce,
- 2:24:36SPEAKER_02: sure,
- 2:24:36SPEAKER_02: you may have some like,
- 2:24:37SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 2:24:37SPEAKER_02: psychic wounds,
- 2:24:39SPEAKER_02: but you never have to worry about the financial instability with that.
- 2:24:42SPEAKER_02: Whereas if you're living in the poverty line,
- 2:24:44SPEAKER_02: if you live in the hood and that's happening,
- 2:24:46SPEAKER_02: like you got to deal with so much.
- 2:24:49SPEAKER_02: the economic fragility,
- 2:24:50SPEAKER_02: constantly going to court,
- 2:24:52SPEAKER_02: the way that the legality force is sort of impending upon you as well,
- 2:24:57SPEAKER_02: being,
- 2:24:58SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 2:24:58SPEAKER_02: sort of thrown into institutions and aware,
- 2:25:01SPEAKER_02: like,
- 2:25:01SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 2:25:02the lack of initiation and edipolization makes you as an
- 2:25:06individual within a broken
- 2:25:08SPEAKER_02: home,
- 2:25:08SPEAKER_02: within a broken family,
- 2:25:11project and cling towards the market and the institutions for
- 2:25:14that type of symbolic
- 2:25:15SPEAKER_02: initiation,
- 2:25:16SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 2:25:16SPEAKER_02: as well.
- 2:25:17SPEAKER_02: It's something that Lash and Tut talk about in different ways,
- 2:25:21SPEAKER_02: but the fact is like,
- 2:25:22SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 2:25:23SPEAKER_02: because capitalism has fractalized everything,
- 2:25:27SPEAKER_02: like there's that need for,
- 2:25:30SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 2:25:30SPEAKER_02: some type of like surrogate bond or surrogate initiation.
- 2:25:37SPEAKER_02: That's why I feel like Tut,
- 2:25:39SPEAKER_02: I don't want to speak like,
- 2:25:40SPEAKER_02: but from what I understand,
- 2:25:41SPEAKER_02: he's like saying like,
- 2:25:42SPEAKER_02: listen,
- 2:25:42SPEAKER_02: you
- 2:25:43SPEAKER_02: It's not a matter of like,
- 2:25:44SPEAKER_02: we need to return to the nuclear family,
- 2:25:46SPEAKER_02: like the conservatives or like,
- 2:25:48SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 2:25:48SPEAKER_02: even Lash,
- 2:25:49SPEAKER_02: sometimes romanticized,
- 2:25:50SPEAKER_02: but it's neither abolish the family,
- 2:25:52SPEAKER_02: because if you abolish the family,
- 2:25:53then you forget about the social reproduction within the mode
- 2:25:58of production
- 2:25:59SPEAKER_02: surrounding it,
- 2:25:59SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 2:26:00SPEAKER_02: and that's what needs to be put into question.
- 2:26:06SPEAKER_03: All right.
- 2:26:07SPEAKER_03: What's happening, everybody?
- 2:26:09SPEAKER_03: That's it.
- 2:26:10SPEAKER_03: That's the end of the episode.
- 2:26:12SPEAKER_03: It's not the end of the conversation, but it's the end of the episode.
- 2:26:15SPEAKER_03: It's later on the East Coast for Nick and Andrew.
- 2:26:18SPEAKER_03: So we were keeping them up late.
- 2:26:20SPEAKER_03: So we went ahead and let them go.
- 2:26:23SPEAKER_03: But it's an ongoing conversation.
- 2:26:25SPEAKER_03: I can't wait till we can reconvene and continue this conversation.
- 2:26:30SPEAKER_03: You know, I don't think this topic is capable of being exhausted.
- 2:26:34SPEAKER_03: But there's also a lot of other stuff
- 2:26:36SPEAKER_03: that I like to talk about with these guys as well.
- 2:26:40So looking forward to the next time we all get together and
- 2:26:43have a conversation.
- 2:26:45SPEAKER_03: Who knows what channel it'll be on.
- 2:26:47SPEAKER_03: Like I said,
- 2:26:48I'll put everybody's info down below in case you're not already
- 2:26:51following or
- 2:26:52SPEAKER_03: subscribed and you should be.
- 2:26:55SPEAKER_03: But yeah, it was a great conversation.
- 2:26:56SPEAKER_03: It kind of ended right there.
- 2:27:00SPEAKER_03: Like I said, it's later for them than it is for us.
- 2:27:02SPEAKER_03: So we were kind of keeping them up.
- 2:27:04SPEAKER_03: Didn't want to do that.
- 2:27:07SPEAKER_03: But yeah, it was great.
- 2:27:09SPEAKER_03: Looking forward to the next one.
- 2:27:10SPEAKER_03: Appreciate them coming on.
- 2:27:13SPEAKER_03: Appreciate you guys coming on, having a conversation with me.
- 2:27:16Appreciate you guys for being in the audience and listening
- 2:27:19along or viewing along.
- 2:27:22SPEAKER_03: It was a great conversation.
- 2:27:23SPEAKER_03: So I'm going to go ahead and eat some food.
- 2:27:26I'm going to go eat a burrito and do something other than sit
- 2:27:32here at my computer
- 2:27:33SPEAKER_03: and waste away.
- 2:27:34SPEAKER_03: So thanks, guys.
- 2:27:36SPEAKER_03: We'll see you.