Latest / The Sperrins: Mining, Power & Community in Northern Ireland / #🎙️113 |Public Inquiry Week Begin 12th Oct Methodology and Restoration Day 4 |
Transcript
- 0:10Unknown: Welcome back. I'm Marella, your host, and I'm part of the Save Our Sperrins campaign. And this podcast is following the Coronalt public inquiry and the proposal for a gold mine in The Sperrins. If you're new to the podcast and wondering how we got here, I'd suggest going back to podcast
- 0:28number 43, the first in this public inquiry series, that will give you some of the background before joining us here. As the inquiry continues, I'll be following the evidence and the arguments and trying to make sense of what they could ultimately mean for the people, the water, and the landscapes of
- 0:50The Sperrins. Well, that's it. Day 49 of the public inquiry into Dalradians' proposed gold mine in The Sperrins. Today we finally reached the end of air quality, worked our way through monitoring and enforcement, and packed up for a three-week break. I imagine there will be some relieved barristers and
- 1:17consultants this evening, temporarily liberated from their enormous bundles of documents and computer models, and the increasingly awkward business of explaining how this mine is supposed to operate without causing unacceptable environmental damage. For those of us on the other side of the
- 1:37room, the break will be welcome too. I know I have a garden to rescue, a family to reacquaint myself with, and neglected jobs to tackle, and a life that has been on hold for weeks. And I'll be taking a few long walks in The Sperrins to remind myself what all this effort is about. But before we close the door on
- 2:03day 49, there are a few things worth recording about the day today. We reach the arrangements intended to keep this proposed industrial operation under control, safe and environmentally responsible by meeting industry standards, yet the more I listened, the clearer it became that much of the
- 2:28promised environmental protection still exists on paper, in plans yet to be written, and decisions still to be made. Today was another day in the world of fantasy predictions, this time in relation to air quality. We began with diesel emissions, nitrogen oxides, sulphur
- 2:49dioxide, ammonia, dust deposition, and blasting residues-a veritable chemical cocktail to accompany the fresh mountain air. There were further exchanges about the figures for heavy goods vehicle movements, and the modelling methods used to predict diesel pollution. Fedelma challenged the use of an
- 3:14older emissions model, which she argued was known to underestimate certain vehicle emissions. A fairly significant point, when the entire assessment depends upon the reliability of predicted concentrations. If the starting figures are too low, the reassuring conclusions that
- 3:34follow aren't worth very much. You know, I'm growing very weary of models that produce comforting predictions, while the assumptions holding them together escape the same level of scrutiny. We also return to emissions from blasting and the assumption that the pro that the proposed controls will perform
- 3:56as intended. Meanwhile, the possibility of toxic fugitive dust travelling beyond the mine site continues to trouble me enormously, particularly when I know people with compromised health living within a couple of 100 metres of potential emission sources. Yet here we are on day 49, still arguing about what
- 4:22will be monitored, where equipment will be placed, which pollutants will be measured, and what happens when limits are exceeded. And while we are struggling to establish exactly how air quality will be monitored in the future, a local woman has already been out doing some of that exact groundwork,
- 4:43gathering evidence of existing conditions. Unfortunately, when Quiva Warnock's air quality survey was brought before the inquiry today, the evidence fell foul of the procedural rules. During the summer, Quiva monitored particulate level. At several locations around Green Castle, gathering evidence of
- 5:04existing conditions before any proposed industrial development, Fedelma attempted to introduce the findings, but the commissioners declined to admit them because of the late submission and concerns about procedural fairness to the other parties. The decision was made without even the briefest glance
- 5:24at the results. Now I recognise that an inquiry needs deadlines and procedures; otherwise, we'd probably still be sitting there in 2046, listening to someone explain the difference between a planning condition and an informative. But there's something just a little crazy about real, locally gathered
- 5:44baseline evidence being excluded on procedural grounds. I've watched ordinary people spend months examining technical reports, attending meetings, raising money, and carrying out their own investigations, all while managing jobs, families, and their lives.
- 6:04In contrast, Delridin has extensive network of professional advisers and consultants and resources, all focusing on just getting the application over the line. The procedural rules may be the same, but the resources available to navigate them certainly aren't. So having to
- 6:23watch a piece of community-generated citizen science fall at that hurdle was deeply frustrating. Quiva's efforts deserve better, and I hope she knows how much her work is appreciated. By the afternoon, we had reached monitoring and enforcement, leaving behind the glossy
- 6:42predictions and moving into the less glamorous business of what happens when things go wrong. The questions came hard and fast, mostly directed towards the Department of Infrastructure. Independent monitoring, the reliability of information supplied by the operator, departmental
- 7:03responsibilities, enforcement delays, and the long-term obligations associated with the mine waste facility were all examined. DFI has indicated that it would take the lead in planning enforcement, and we heard about the available legal powers. Enforcement. notices, stop notices, legal
- 7:25remedies-really, an impressive collection of instruments to bludgeon lawbreakers into shape. Unfortunately, I've lived long enough in Northern Ireland to know that possessing statutory powers and actually using them are two very different things. Those familiar with the environmental condition of Loch
- 7:44Ne will understand my scepticism, and as we already have development at the proposed mine site, which, as we've heard during this inquiry, has taken place without plan permission, the absence of effective enforcement, therefore, hardly inspires confidence in what might happen with a fully
- 8:07operational mine, and that gap between having the power to act and actually acting could be devastating in The Sperrins. Polluted waters won't wait for an enforcement notice. Toxic dust won't respect departmental boundaries, and damage peatland won't recover simply because the authorities eventually get
- 8:28around to doing their job. We also heard concerns about emergency arrangements and warning communities downstream of the mine waste facility. Years spent designing the mine waste facility, millions of tonnes of toxic waste to be stored, endless assurances about safety, and no emergency plan
- 8:51for the people living downstream. That tells you something deeply disturbing about where the priorities lie, and the responsibilities don't end when the mining finishes. Water treatment, monitoring, maintenance, and the stability of engineered structures will demand attention for
- 9:11generations. The financial arrangements intended to fund that work deserve serious scrutiny. The people of The Sperrins should never inherit an expensive, potentially dangerous industrial legacy, while those who profited from from it have disappeared into the distance. Another point that was raised
- 9:33today was from Carol Glass, who asked about the monitoring of community health, including children's health. I was glad she did. Over and over again, the people who will live with the consequences of this development seem also almost incidental to the technical discussions. Those living near
- 9:51the proposed mine and who will almost certainly suffer the impacts of it deserve effective protection of their health, not just another collective. Of reassuring figures, and it was by the end of the afternoon, we'd accumulated plenty of enforcement powers, departmental responsibilities, and procedural
- 10:12explanations. What we haven't accumulated was much confidence that any of them would protect The Sperrins or the people who live there, when it matters, and then towards the very end of the day, we return to Mary Brawley. You may remember from yesterday's podcast that Mary had been issued with a formal
- 10:32warning following an exchange with the commissioners. Mary asked for it to be withdrawn, explained that her intention had been Misunderstood. She hadn't been attempted to reopen a discussion that had already concluded she was trying to draw attention to an entirely different matter. When Mary
- 10:52waited throughout the day's proceedings to hear whether her explanation had been accepted, and finally, at the very end of the day, she got her answer: no, the warning would stand, and there we have it. If anyone needs reminding where the power lies in that hearing room, leaving the solicitor for Save
- 11:11Our Sperrins waiting for over a day to learn her fate was fairly effective demonstration. All that waiting, all that procedural solemnity and the final verdict amounted to one word: no. Parados occasionally have a wonderfully economic vocabulary, particularly when it's somebody else's time being
- 11:32spent, and with that little master class in the exercise of authority and the management of public participation, we adjourned for three weeks. After the inquiry ended, I read some of the messages circulating amongst the campaigners.
- 11:48First, there was anger and exhaustion. People described feeling disempowered, discouraged, and humiliated, and believe me, I got every word of that. This inquiry has been an unasked for education in mining, hydrology, peat, ecology, air pollution, waste management, and the bewildering architecture of
- 12:06planning, law, and procedures, and many, many other side shoot subjects. And we've also learned how easily the voices of ordinary people can be diminished when money, legal muscle, and procedural power dominate the room. And that truly is an ugly experience. There have been moments when I
- 12:25have looked around the hearing room in almost physical disbelief at what we are being asked to accept: the removal and attempted restoration of peat that has taken 1000s of years to form, the destruction and disturbance of habitats occupied by creatures with no voice in these proceedings, the certainty
- 12:46of toxic substances entering crystal clean mountain waters, the presence of a huge mine waste facility in a landscape that has never needed one, and the horrible thought of future generations left with the financial nightmare of managing the consequences of decisions taken today, and of course, all
- 13:07of this is accompanied by carefully worded assurances and a procession of conditions, all designed to make the systematic destruction of a living landscape look like an exercise in good environmental management. I know some people still see this project as an economic opportunity, but after
- 13:2449 days of evidence, I am more convinced than ever that its true costs extend far beyond any bespoke financial model. Many of those costs will fall upon people, wildlife, and ecosystems who will receive none of the prophets, then to return to the messages received today, Fedelma wrote something which prompted a
- 13:47smile. I am emboldened. Well, thank goodness for that. It is the refusal of ordinary people to be worn down that has kept this campaign alive through years of applications, consultations, legal arguments, and now day 49 of the public inquiry. We are sometimes angry, sometimes exhausted,
- 14:08occasionally bewildered by the latest procedural contortion. But we're still here, and that is worth celebrating. The inquiry resumes on the ninth of November when climate change comes under examination, in the meantime, I intend to spend some time out in The Sperrins, away from the fluorescent lights and
- 14:28predicted impacts. I want to hear the water running through the burns, watch the birds flying over the hills, and remember that the peep beneath our feet has been quietly doing its work for 1000s of years, to remember the badgers are still carrying on with their nocturnal business, the hares still out on
- 14:48the open ground, the rivers will carry the swollen autumnal rains down through the valleys. Three weeks away from the hearing will do us all a power of good. Because come ninth of November, there is still a great deal to be said, and we have absolutely no intention of going quietly. As Frederick Douglass said in
- 15:121857, power concedes nothing without a demand. Never did, and it never will. You've been listening to the Save Our Sperrins podcast, Voices from the Frontline. Thank you for joining us today. All the links you'll need, from campaign updates to our social media pages, as well as links shared
- 15:32by today's guests and resources mentioned in the conversation, are available in the show notes. Please take a moment to share this podcast with friends, neighbours, or anyone who cares about protecting our land and communities, and don't forget to hit the follow button on your podcast platform. It really
- 15:50helps the algorithm spread these voices further. Together, our voices are stronger. Thanks for listening, and until next time, keep standing with the land, the water, the air, and the people who protect them.