Latest / Educate Me Well / Parent Perspectives
Transcript
- 0:04Tonya: Welcome to Educate Me Well, the podcast that brings faith and education together.
- 0:10Tonya: Hi, I'm Tanya, and I'm so glad you're here.
- 0:22Tonya: Welcome back, everyone.
- 0:25Tonya: In today's topic, I want to talk about parent perspectives on education.
- 0:31Tonya: And I am basing my viewpoint, this is my personal viewpoint, on past experience that I've had in public education, private education, observing private homeschools and private homeschool co-ops, I guess you would say.
- 0:54Tonya: And I just wanted to say that sometimes, starting out, that each section or each environment, the people in those environments can have a myopic vision.
- 1:10Tonya: Sometimes when you're, I see that in public education, I've kind of seen it in private, and then I've seen it with homeschooling families sometimes.
- 1:20Tonya: It's easy to be in the environment that you're in, whichever it might be, and see what is going on in the school and want certain things to happen.
- 1:35Tonya: Because children or students are with educators all day, sometimes they begin to see them as their responsibility or our responsibility, especially education-wise, because most educators really care about the students that they have and they want the best for them.
- 1:58Tonya: And some teachers see parents as not knowing enough to make the education decisions.
- 2:04Tonya: However, educators forget that the child belongs to the parent, not the school, regardless of how you feel about it.
- 2:15Tonya: Education also forgets that parents know their children best sometimes.
- 2:21Tonya: Now I'm not trying to paint everyone with the same stroke, but I have seen this over and over, and that's what I'm talking about by my optic vision for child.
- 2:33Tonya: They knew that I was the expert.
- 2:35Tonya: They appreciated the time and effort that I put in.
- 2:39Tonya: And I think it's that case, you know, that is the case for most parents in public and private education.
- 2:47Tonya: They really do trust the educators to know what is best.
- 2:52Tonya: They don't want you to take over their decision making, though.
- 2:58Tonya: Parents want to be included in that decision making, and then they also want to be the ultimate decision makers.
- 3:08Tonya: And then I know particularly in the United States, we have political viewpoints of the candidates that are running for whatever office that might impact education, whether it be public education or private education.
- 3:25Tonya: A lot of times those candidates, one side will be for one choice.
- 3:32Tonya: Only public education is allowable, you know, for tax dollars.
- 3:37Tonya: And then the other side might support multiple choices.
- 3:41Tonya: They may support giving tax dollars to public educators, private education, and even homeschoolers.
- 3:50Tonya: So whose decision is this to make?
- 3:54Tonya: We really need to ask ourselves that.
- 3:56Tonya: A lot of times I hear, and I'm gonna have to say it because I've heard it over and over, and I'm seeing it a lot right now because there are a lot of political races going on in Texas where I live.
- 4:07Tonya: But a lot of times they think public educators think they are the ones to decide.
- 4:14Tonya: And that's not the case.
- 4:15Tonya: The children don't belong to public educators, the children belong to the parents.
- 4:21Tonya: So the decisions should be made by the parents.
- 4:25Tonya: And I think politicians or whoever is in control of the money needs to listen to the parents.
- 4:34Tonya: What do the parents want?
- 4:36Tonya: They are the parents of those children, which become students.
- 4:42Tonya: There are a lot of questions there to ask.
- 4:45Tonya: How do we determine who gets the money from public tax dollars?
- 4:49Tonya: And I think the word public is key.
- 4:52Tonya: A lot of people think because it is public that it should go to public schools, but it is given by all taxpayers.
- 5:03Tonya: Why should one segment, public, private, or homeschool parents decide for everyone?
- 5:12Tonya: And then we're gonna talk about today what is the reason many parents are wanting more than one choice now.
- 5:20Tonya: Used to, it was only one choice that you had, it was public education.
- 5:25Tonya: It all started with the one-room schoolhouse, right?
- 5:28Tonya: That was public local education, but it has become public education has become more than local.
- 5:37Tonya: And so it's taken some of the autonomy of the parents out and given it to more government.
- 5:45Tonya: Parent perspectives on education are currently reflecting a period of significant transition and polarization.
- 5:55Tonya: Parents are weighing fit, trust, safety, academics, flexibility, and cost.
- 6:06Tonya: And many explore alternatives without ultimately switching from where they're at.
- 6:13Tonya: In public education, many parents express deep appreciation for the accessibility, diversity, and specialized services such as IEPs, individual education plans, and 504 plans that public schools provide.
- 6:31Tonya: However, there is a growing trend of frustration regarding standardized testing, large class sizes, and perceived bureaucratic rigidity.
- 6:44Tonya: A significant point of tension in recent years involves the culture war, with some parents feeling that public school curricula have become too politically progressive, while others worry that local political interference is eroding academic freedom and inclusivity.
- 7:06Tonya: So who decides?
- 7:08Tonya: It's a parent's choice.
- 7:10Tonya: Many families remain in public schools, and public options are still common among families who do switch.
- 7:18Tonya: In a 2025 survey of 2,873 parents, 60% said they had considered a different school in 2024, but 28% actually changed.
- 7:34Tonya: Of those who switched, nearly 60% chose a district, charter, or magnet public school.
- 7:43Tonya: This points to strong interest in alternatives, but also to the role of access and practicality in the final decision.
- 7:53Tonya: Private school perspectives often center on the desire for a more curated environment.
- 8:02Tonya: Parents typically move toward private education to find smaller class sizes, more rigorous academic standards, or a specific religious or philosophical alignment that isn't possible in a state-run system.
- 8:20Tonya: While the higher cost is a primary barrier, parents who choose this route often view it as an investment in a social network and a more tailored mentorship experience for their children.
- 8:35Tonya: Parents may be drawn to a particular school's environment, values, or perceived fit, but cost can be a major barrier.
- 8:45Tonya: In the same survey I was talking to you about before, interest in private schools rose, yet relatively few families who considered them ultimately enrolled in one.
- 8:59Tonya: And I know that cost is a significant barrier a lot of times.
- 9:04Tonya: And so that is why, in my opinion, that I think tax dollars should go to all parents, not just public school parents.
- 9:15Tonya: Homeschooling has seen a massive surge in popularity evolving from a niche choice, often tied to religious beliefs, to a mainstream option for a wide variety of families.
- 9:32Tonya: Many modern homeschooling parents are driven by educational autonomy, the ability to move at the child's own pace, and avoid the social pressures or safety concerns associated with traditional schooling.
- 9:49Tonya: The rise of homeschool collectives and pods shows that parents are now seeking a hybrid approach, combining the customization of home education with the social interaction of a peer group.
- 10:04Tonya: And I have seen this in my own city where I live.
- 10:34Tonya: Parents' reasons can include concerns about the school environment, a desire for moral or religious instruction, maybe wanting more family time, and dissatisfaction with the academic instruction, as we've said.
- 10:48Tonya: And those are findings from a federal survey about homeschooling in 2019.
- 10:54Tonya: So they're useful context rather than a current snapshot.
- 10:59Tonya: Across all three paths, the overarching theme is a shift toward personalization.
- 11:06Tonya: Parents are increasingly viewing themselves as the primary architects of their children's education rather than passive consumers of a provided system.
- 11:17Tonya: And that's the way it should be.
- 11:19Tonya: But satisfaction and preference aren't the same.
- 11:23Tonya: A 2024 survey reported higher satisfaction among private school and homeschool parents than among district school parents.
- 11:34Tonya: But stated preferences don't necessarily predict what families can access or choose in practice.
- 11:43Tonya: A few questions I would ask as educators and as parents, especially as parents, what would make you feel your child is safe, known, and learning well?
- 11:57Tonya: Did you choose this setting or did cost, location, admissions, or scheduling narrow your choices?
- 12:07Tonya: Is that the only option you have?
- 12:09Tonya: Because that's all you can afford.
- 12:12Tonya: What do you wish the other kinds of families understood about your decision?
- 12:18Tonya: If you're unable to afford anything but public education, but you really, because of religious values, you would like to pull your child from a public school and put them in private or homeschool?
- 12:33Tonya: What do you wish that educators, politicians, and other families understood about that decision?
- 12:41Tonya: It's really important.
- 12:43Tonya: What would you reconsider under your current arrangement?
- 12:47Tonya: Would you do something different if you're in a private school and it's not performing well?
- 12:52Tonya: You're not seeing that your children are receiving a good education?
- 12:55Tonya: Or if you're struggling in homeschool and you just feel like you just can't do it yourself?
- 13:02Tonya: What would make you reconsider that and put your child in another arrangement, such as public school or homeschool to private school?
- 13:11Tonya: And even public school to one of these other options, private school or homeschool?
- 13:15Tonya: What would make you reconsider that arrangement?
- 13:18Tonya: And what support do parents need from schools, communities, or policymakers?
- 13:26Tonya: What do you wish they knew about your family and what you need and what you desire?
- 13:33Tonya: And what are your thoughts?
- 13:35Tonya: What is your voice?
- 13:36Tonya: It's so important.
- 13:37Tonya: I wish more parents would let their voice be known to the people who make the decisions because it makes all the difference in the world.
- 13:46Tonya: No matter which environment you choose to educate your child in, remember, you, the parents, are the first and final determiner of that place.
- 13:58Tonya: You are the one that is going to be held accountable to God for the outcome of your child.
- 14:04Tonya: Have you done all you can do to make sure that they are getting a good education and that they are going to be good Christian adults?
- 14:14Tonya: That is so important.
- 14:15Tonya: And that's what this podcast is about.
- 14:17Tonya: It's not about will they be good secular adults?
- 14:21Tonya: I'm not as concerned about that as I am about are they going to serve the Lord well.
- 14:26Tonya: Make sure it fits your family's needs and desires.
- 14:30Tonya: All of these options have a lot to care about.
- 14:34Tonya: And we all want to support each other, not fight each other.
- 14:39Tonya: I hope this has been helpful for you today.
- 14:42Tonya: Thank you for joining me today on Educate Me Well.
- 14:46Tonya: I'm grateful you spent this time with me, and I hope the conversation encouraged and equipped you.
- 14:53Tonya: If you have ideas for future episodes or questions you'd like me to explore, you can reach me anytime at admin at educatemewell.com.
- 15:05Tonya: And be sure to check out our social media pages for great resources.
- 15:10Tonya: You can find those on each podcast episode page.
- 15:15Tonya: Until next time, keep making a difference in the lives of children.