Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / [Deep] Li Lu: Value Investing and Civilization 3.0
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Deep Dive. Today we're tackling a a really
- 0:04comprehensive view of value investing, one that goes, you
- 0:07know, far beyond just spreadsheets and quarterly
- 0:10reports. We are diving deep into the mind
- 0:13of Lee Liu, the founder of Himalaya Capital.
- 0:16He's an investor who's, well, he celebrated for these spectacular
- 0:20returns and of course, his very close association with Charlie
- 0:23Munger. And that association is key.
- 0:26Lilu's success is not some accident, and it's definitely
- 0:29not just because he's a brilliant accountant.
- 0:31He is a philosopher, investor. I mean, his entire approach is
- 0:35rooted in this expansive, almost proprietary system.
- 0:38A system that does what exactly? Synthesizes everything.
- 0:42It takes the deep value principles of, you know,
- 0:45Benjamin Graham, and it merges them with a compounding growth
- 0:48philosophy of Munger. OK, but there's a unique anchor
- 0:50to it. There is, and it's all anchored
- 0:52in this unique, almost physics based theory of history and
- 0:55civilization. We're here to unpack what he
- 0:58calls his Unified Field Theory of Capital.
- 1:00Wow. OK, that that immediately raises
- 1:03the stakes. We're not just looking at a few
- 1:04investment tips here. Not at all.
- 1:05We're looking at an entire epistemological framework, a
- 1:09complete way of knowing the world, before you even think
- 1:12about picking a single stock. Exactly.
- 1:14So our mission today is to really get the why behind the
- 1:18how. Why does he believe that just
- 1:20owning stocks is justified by the arc of human history itself?
- 1:24And then what are the the really rigorous steps he takes to find
- 1:28those mispriced assets when the market is just pure chaos?
- 1:31Precisely. And to do that, we've
- 1:33synthesized his foundational lectures, the ones he gave
- 1:36across, you know, almost 2 decades, specifically at
- 1:40Columbia University, impeaching university.
- 1:42And these talks are the key. They're the blueprint, yeah.
- 1:45They reveal this internal conviction mechanism that lets
- 1:48him stay rational when it feels like markets are just collapsing
- 1:51around him. And that conviction, it has to
- 1:53be tested against real world volatility, which brings us to a
- 1:56really crucial point about mindset.
- 1:59As we're discussing tracking these huge market forces, you
- 2:01know, trying to understand the overall market temperature.
- 2:04It's so important to have the right tools for anyone trying to
- 2:08develop Lilu's preservation first mindset.
- 2:12You can actually search and download the iOS app Buffett
- 2:16Indicator from the Apple App Store.
- 2:19It helps you track the total market cap relative to GDP.
- 2:23Which is a vital gauge of market temperature.
- 2:25It's a great companion piece really for anyone trying to
- 2:29apply this kind of deep value discipline.
- 2:31That awareness is absolutely key now, before we really dive in a
- 2:35mandatory clarification. Always.
- 2:38Everything we discussed today is based on publicly available
- 2:41sources. It's purely for educational
- 2:43purposes. This is not, and I'll say it
- 2:45again, this does not constitute investment advice.
- 2:49You absolutely must conduct your own due diligence before making
- 2:52any investment decisions. OK, so let's unpack this.
- 2:54Lelu's starting point is, well, he sees it as mandatory.
- 2:58He argues that if you don't understand the fundamental
- 3:01economic game, you are playing. You're just gambling.
- 3:03Exactly. You're gambling and you don't
- 3:04even know the house rules, he insists.
- 3:06We have to move beyond the typical economic models.
- 3:09Right, forget Econ one O 1 for a minute.
- 3:11And instead analyze human history through the lens of
- 3:14energy capture and social organization.
- 3:16He calls this the physics of civilization.
- 3:19And this historical taxonomy, this framework, it provides the
- 3:22fundamental justification for why you as an investor should
- 3:26even be in the equity market in the first place.
- 3:28It's the core conviction. It's the core conviction that
- 3:31you need to endure the volatility because what you're
- 3:33really betting on is the, well, the inevitable continuation of
- 3:36human technological progress. And he breaks this down into
- 3:39three very distinct eras. The journey begins, he says,
- 3:43with civilization. One point O the hunter gatherer
- 3:46paradigm. This is humanity's baseline.
- 3:48It lasted for for what, 200,000 years after Homo sapiens first
- 3:51emerged? And almost unimaginable amount
- 3:54of time. And the core reality of that
- 3:56time was total reliant on immediate energy acquisition.
- 3:59Muscle power, muscle power. You haunted, you gathered, you
- 4:02consumed. That was it.
- 4:03And because resources were perishable, you know, energy
- 4:06storage was either primitive or just impossible.
- 4:08The whole system was a 0 sum game.
- 4:10Or even negative sum. You know, during a famine or a
- 4:13drought, if your tribe secured a good hunting ground, that meant
- 4:18another tribe lost it. It's a finite pie.
- 4:20And the implication here is just structurally critical.
- 4:23There was no mechanism for compounding wealth.
- 4:25None. Accumulating wealth beyond your
- 4:28immediate needs was physically impossible.
- 4:30You lived completely in the present.
- 4:32Which creates a survival mindset, right?
- 4:34Yeah, a very, very short term focus.
- 4:36Which changes with Civilization 2.0, the agrarian limit.
- 4:41This starts with the agricultural Revolution, and it
- 4:44lasts all the way until about 1700 AD.
- 4:47And this was the first huge technological leap
- 4:50domestication. This allows for, for the first
- 4:53time, reliable energy storage, grain and the division of Labor.
- 4:57Which creates civilization as we know it.
- 4:59States, cities, hierarchies, all of it.
- 5:01But, and this is a huge but, this introduces the famous
- 5:05Malthusian trap. Right growth was strictly
- 5:08linear. It was directly tied to the
- 5:09photosynthetic limit of your air.
- 5:11You can. Only grow so much food per acre.
- 5:14That's it. So when you had an innovation,
- 5:16let's say a better plow, sure, productivity improved for a bit.
- 5:19But then what happens? Population inevitably grows to
- 5:22consume that surplus, and pretty soon per capita resources are
- 5:26right back at subsistence levels.
- 5:28It's a. Trap this cyclical reality, this
- 5:30constant ceiling on growth, is what forged what Lelu calls the
- 5:34static mindset. And he finds this so pernicious.
- 5:38This is a crucial psychological take away for him because
- 5:41humanity spent what, 99% of its economic existence in a world
- 5:45where wealth was a 0 sum game tied to land?
- 5:48Our cultural and psychological default is that static view.
- 5:51It's in our DNA, the idea that if I gain, someone else must
- 5:55lose. And that mindset, he says,
- 5:57translates directly into how most people behave in the stock
- 6:00market. That makes Civilization 3 point
- 6:02O the era of compounding just a radical, fundamental break from
- 6:05all of human history. It's a complete paradigm shift.
- 6:08This era is defined by the industrial Revolution.
- 6:10It's where our energy constraints are just shattered
- 6:13by coupling massive external energy sources, first fossil
- 6:16fuels, later nuclear power, with modern science and crucially,
- 6:20free market institutions. For the first time, energy is
- 6:23basically unlimited compared to that Malthusian constraint.
- 6:26Exactly. And the combination of that
- 6:28energy with intellectual capital, ideas, processes,
- 6:33technology, software, it moves the economy from linear growth
- 6:36to exponential compounding growth.
- 6:40This is what he calls the unbounded economy.
- 6:42And this is it. This is the vital insight that
- 6:44underpins every bit of Lilu's investment conviction.
- 6:48This is the foundation. The economy is no longer a
- 6:50static a 0 sum game, it's a positive sum machine.
- 6:54Right. And therefore the stock market
- 6:56is not a casino where you're just betting on price changes.
- 6:59It is a legal mechanism for owning a piece of that
- 7:02continuous, unbounded creation of new value.
- 7:04So if you hold a quality piece of equity.
- 7:07Then mathematics, history, and physics are all working in your
- 7:09favor. Time is your ally, not your
- 7:11enemy. So if Civilization 3 point O is
- 7:13the new environment we're playing in, he then introduces
- 7:16the Iron Law of Modernization. Right.
- 7:18And this is the engine, this is what drive the acceleration and
- 7:21the distribution of that compounded wealth across the
- 7:23entire globe. He uses this really great
- 7:25analogy to explain the velocity of it.
- 7:29In civilization 2 point O, you know traditional trade, it
- 7:32required value A to be less than the price which was less than
- 7:36value B. So 1 + 1 is greater than two.
- 7:39Exactly. It creates A surplus.
- 7:41It's a net positive, but it's incremental.
- 7:43You trade your extra grain for someone else's extra iron.
- 7:46But in Civilization 3 point O, the trade is totally different.
- 7:50It often involves intellectual capital and technology.
- 7:53And when a piece of code or some advanced manufacturing process
- 7:57is shared, it breeds innovation. Everywhere else.
- 8:00The value created is exponentially greater than the
- 8:03sum of its parts. This is the multiplier effect. 1
- 8:05+ 1 is greater than 4. Can you give an example of that?
- 8:08Sure. Think about an open source
- 8:10software library. A team of developers creates it
- 8:12right, but then thousands of companies use that knowledge to
- 8:15build their own products. The value created far, far
- 8:18exceeds the initial cost of developing that software.
- 8:21So the Iron Law statement just formalizes this idea.
- 8:23It does. It says that the system with the
- 8:25greater trade volume, the biggest economies of scale and
- 8:27the highest division of Labor will have the greater velocity
- 8:30of compounding growth. And what's the end result?
- 8:33It will eventually create a single, unified global market.
- 8:36This has a huge strategic implication, especially today.
- 8:40Lulu argues that despite all the intense geopolitical tension,
- 8:44the tariffs, the nationalist rhetoric.
- 8:47The gravitational force of mathematical superiority.
- 8:50I mean the fact that participating in a global market
- 8:53is just exponentially more beneficial than isolation.
- 8:56It makes globalization inevitable in the long.
- 8:58Run The benefits of specialization and global scale,
- 9:01he believes, will always, always overcome the temporary barriers
- 9:05we put up. I have to push back a little
- 9:07here though. Isn't that analysis, you know,
- 9:10potentially of a bit politically naive or at least maybe it's too
- 9:13long term? That's a fair question.
- 9:14If a major country decides to impose massive, sustained
- 9:18tariffs, doesn't that mathematical superiority grind
- 9:22to a halt, at least temporarily? It could, and that could
- 9:25threaten the investment timeline for even the most patient,
- 9:28disciplined investor. It's an essential question, and
- 9:30Lila's answer is really rooted in a kind of historical
- 9:33determinism. He sees these political actions
- 9:36as noise, not signal. So a temporary distraction.
- 9:40Exactly. He believes that tariffs and
- 9:43isolationist policies hurt the countries that enact them far
- 9:47more severely than the system as a whole.
- 9:49Because they're voluntarily cutting themselves off from that
- 9:521 + 14 multiplier effect. You got it.
- 9:55The speed of global growth might slow down for a bit, but the
- 9:58difference in growth between the open and the closed systems
- 10:02becomes so vast. That the isolated country
- 10:04eventually suffers. It suffers severe internal
- 10:07pressure to reengage with the world.
- 10:09His conviction is that the fundamental physics of
- 10:11compounding growth will eventually force political
- 10:14reality to align with economic reality.
- 10:17So the investor's job is just to endure the political noise and
- 10:21hold on to the compounding asset.
- 10:23That's the core of the conviction.
- 10:24So this macroeconomic conviction is critical.
- 10:27It explains who you're competing against, or maybe more
- 10:29accurately, who is providing your opportunities, right?
- 10:32Lulu applies his whole taxonomy directly to the stock market
- 10:36participants. He explains market volatility
- 10:39not as some economic phenomenon, but as a psychological 1.
- 10:42He says 95% of market participants behave as
- 10:45speculators. And their mindset is rooted in
- 10:48civilization. One point O the hunter gatherer
- 10:51paradigm. They operate under a 0 sum
- 10:53focus. They're hunting for that
- 10:55immediate price jump. Yep.
- 10:56They're hoping to sell to a greater fool.
- 10:59They see the market as this finite pool of capital that they
- 11:01have to exploit and exploit quickly.
- 11:03And the outcome for the vast majority of that 95% is, well,
- 11:08it's pretty predictable. They underperform the broad
- 11:10market after you factor in fees, taxes, and their own inherent
- 11:14emotional and cognitive biases. All of which are amplified by
- 11:17the pressure of short term quarterly performance reviews.
- 11:21Then you have the investor, the other 5% and they operate with a
- 11:24civilization 3 point O mindset. They see themselves as part
- 11:27owners of productive assets. Of a compounding machine.
- 11:31Their focus is strictly on the fundamentals of the business and
- 11:33the long term flow of cash back to the owners.
- 11:36They're not trading, they're allocating capital based on the
- 11:39mathematical inevitability of that iron law.
- 11:42And here's where the synthesis gets really dynamic.
- 11:45The 95% aren't your enemies. Not at all.
- 11:48They're essential. They're collective
- 11:49irrationality. They're frantic 0 sum trading.
- 11:53That's what creates the liquidity, and critically, it's
- 11:56what periodically creates massive mispricing.
- 11:59This volatility is the opportunity, the 5% wait for the
- 12:03speculators. Noise is the investor's signal.
- 12:06So the value investor becomes the liquidity provider of last
- 12:09resort. That's the role you step in
- 12:12during periods of total panic or, you know, irrational
- 12:15euphoria, when the 95% of retail and emotional institutional
- 12:20players are capitulating. Often because they're driven by
- 12:22that old static mindset of civilization 2.0.
- 12:26Right, that's when the 5% are executing their civilization 3.0
- 12:30conviction, buying quality assets at extreme discounts.
- 12:33OK, so the macro foundation gives you the conviction to be
- 12:36an owner in the 1st place. Now we have to shift to
- 12:38execution. The how?
- 12:40How does that 5% investor practically find these mispriced
- 12:43assets when the 95% are generating so much distracting
- 12:46noise? Lulu describes describes this as
- 12:48well rigorous investigative due diligence.
- 12:51Work of a forensic detective or Sherlock Holmes.
- 12:54Let's start with a classic example of his early style, the
- 12:57Timberland case study. Yes, from around 1998.
- 13:01This perfectly illustrates information arbitrage,
- 13:05exploiting the gap between a toxic market narrative and the
- 13:08factual reality. And, of course, the crucial
- 13:11concept of margin of safety. To set the scene, the late 90s.
- 13:14You've got massive tech euphoria, the.com bubble is
- 13:19inflating and at the same time there's just panic in non tech
- 13:22stocks. Anything that's not a.com is
- 13:24getting thrown out. Exactly.
- 13:26And Timberland's narrative was incredibly bleak.
- 13:29There were headlines about lawsuits, management disputes
- 13:31and fears that the brand was fading.
- 13:33The classic yellow boot was out of style.
- 13:36All of which drove the stock price down dramatically.
- 13:38So Lulu just disregards the headlines.
- 13:41He focuses on the quantitative disconnect.
- 13:42He calculates Timberland's total market capitalization at around
- 13:45300 million. Dollars.
- 13:46But then he looks at the balance sheet.
- 13:48And the tangible assets alone, the working capital, the
- 13:51inventory, the real estate gave a conservative book value of
- 13:54roughly 240 million. OK.
- 13:56So that initial finding, that's the margin of safety right
- 13:59there. That's it.
- 14:00Your downside was heavily protected by hard assets.
- 14:03You could touch and sell the profitable iconic Timberland
- 14:07brand and its entire ongoing operation.
- 14:09We're essentially being acquired for $60 million or less, which
- 14:12is. Absurd.
- 14:14But here is the critical Sherlock Holmes step.
- 14:17This is what separated Li Liu from every other analyst on Wall
- 14:20Street. He didn't just accept the
- 14:22narrative about the lawsuits and bad management.
- 14:25No, he knew the market was obsessed with short term
- 14:28guidance, so he physically retrieved and read the
- 14:31voluminous court legal filings. And in 1998, that meant tedious
- 14:36manual labor. Oh.
- 14:37Absolutely. This wasn't a quick database
- 14:39search. This was going to a courthouse,
- 14:41getting boxes of documents and just reading for weeks.
- 14:45Wait, so you're saying the difficulty of getting that
- 14:47information was itself part of the arbitrage?
- 14:49That's a huge part of. It the sheer laziness of the
- 14:52rest of Wall Street created the opportunity.
- 14:54Absolutely. The arbitrage wasn't just in the
- 14:56numbers, it was in the effort. Wall Street analysts are
- 14:59incentivized to move fast, provide rapid coverage and rely
- 15:03on management conference calls and headlines.
- 15:05They don't have time for weeks of reading legal documents.
- 15:08And what did he find? He found that the lawsuits were
- 15:11mostly trivial disputes and many were actually driven by
- 15:15frustrated analysts who were angry that Timberlands
- 15:18management refused to provide short term quarterly earnings
- 15:22guidance. So management was actually
- 15:24acting with integrity. They were protecting long term
- 15:27value against short term noise. But the market mistook this
- 15:31defiance for incompetence. They saw it as bad management.
- 15:35So the market was punishing good behavior.
- 15:36It was mistaking non cooperation with that 95% speculator mindset
- 15:41for a failing business. You got it, and the final
- 15:43outcome speaks for itself. The stock rose nearly 700% as
- 15:48the market was eventually forced to correct its perception of the
- 15:50true value. The lesson is profound then
- 15:53volatility is not risk. It's the source of profit for
- 15:56those willing to do the boring forensic work of actually
- 15:59verifying the facts. OK.
- 16:00Another deep value example, this one focusing on a pure asset
- 16:03play, the Hyundai department store.
- 16:06Right. And this one illustrates a
- 16:07similar principle, but in a structurally different context.
- 16:11It's about finding value in global markets that have, you
- 16:14know, a lot more opacity. What was the structural anomaly
- 16:17there that he found? It was corporate complexity.
- 16:21This is really common in some Asian corporate structures, like
- 16:23the Korean table. Lilu was able to identify shares
- 16:27where the market cap of the holding company was incredibly
- 16:30low. Hello.
- 16:31Around $60 million, the market was essentially ignoring the
- 16:35underlying assets because they were just obscured by layers and
- 16:39layers of cross holdings between different companies in the
- 16:42group. So his forensic investigation
- 16:44showed what? That the underlying real estate
- 16:46and the subsidiary stakes were conservatively valued at $320
- 16:50million. So that's an extreme arbitrage.
- 16:53You're buying $1.00 verifiable value for about $0.19.
- 16:56Exactly. And this investment really
- 16:58highlights that market inefficiencies are often
- 17:00structural or informational. The hard work here wasn't just
- 17:04verifying the assets were real, it was successfully untangling
- 17:07that corporate web to confirm they were legally accessible to
- 17:11shareholders. So in these cases the book value
- 17:13gives you the margin of safety. And the company's operating
- 17:16earnings were truly, as he put it, just the icing on the cake.
- 17:21So those examples focus heavily on assets, but long term
- 17:26compounding that requires something more.
- 17:29It requires identifying a competitive advantage, a Moat
- 17:33and exceptional management quality.
- 17:35The intangibles. How does Lia Lou measure those?
- 17:38He uses a story, the tale of two gas stations.
- 17:41It's a simple, elegant parable to define a Moat even in what
- 17:44looks like a commodity business. OK, what's the setup?
- 17:47You have two identical gas stations, same intersection,
- 17:50selling the exact same product, gasoline at the exact same
- 17:52price, yet station A generates 400% more traffic and profit.
- 17:57So what's the differentiating factor?
- 17:59It can't be the product or the price.
- 18:01It's the owner's mindset that which translates directly into
- 18:04operational excellence. Station B is managed by an
- 18:07indifferent Salard employee. He gets paid whether the station
- 18:10does well or not. He's just punching a clock.
- 18:12Right, but Station A is run by an owner operator.
- 18:16He often describes this as an immigrant family living nearby
- 18:20who has skin in the game. Their entire livelihood is tied
- 18:24up in that station. So they rush out.
- 18:25They wash the windshields. They offer prompt service.
- 18:27They remember their customers. They treat the business as their
- 18:31lifeblood. This is a perfect metaphor for
- 18:33the C-Suite of a public company. It.
- 18:35Is Lilu searches for that stationary dynamic in public
- 18:39companies? He's looking for managers who
- 18:41possess what he calls the fiduciary gene, people who treat
- 18:45shareholders capital as their own, or even better, as if it's
- 18:49their own family's entire net worth.
- 18:51And that owner operator characteristic is an intangible
- 18:54quality that often determines success far more than basic
- 18:57financial metrics. It's the human element that
- 19:00sustains the compounding machine over decades.
- 19:02Now we have to highlight a crucial strategic pivot in his
- 19:06career, which was heavily influenced by Charlie Munger.
- 19:08This is a really important evolution.
- 19:10His early success came from Graham's cigar butts.
- 19:13You know, the Timberlands and Hyundai's of the world.
- 19:16But he evolved to focus almost exclusively on compounders.
- 19:20And the problem with those classic cigar butts, which
- 19:22Munger famously made fun of, is that while they're safe.
- 19:26Because they're protected by the balance.
- 19:28Sheet You have to sell them when they reach fair value, and that
- 19:30triggers capital gains taxes and forces you to face continuous
- 19:34reinvestment risk. You're always on the hunt for
- 19:37the next mispriced asset. It's a lot of work, and the
- 19:41turning point for Lee Lou was what he calls the cable company
- 19:44lesson. This was a mistake he made.
- 19:46OK, what happened? He bought an early cable company
- 19:49for the statistical value of its telecom licenses, a classic
- 19:53asset play. He sold it when it doubled.
- 19:56Which sounds like a great statistical win in the short
- 19:58term. It was, but he realized he had
- 20:00fundamentally missed the dynamic growth potential.
- 20:04Because what happened next? The stock went up another 10
- 20:06times. He had valued the licenses as
- 20:08static assets. He failed to grasp that those
- 20:11same licenses were becoming critical infrastructure for the
- 20:14entire civilization. 3 point O mobile Internet boom.
- 20:18So he was looking at the balance sheet value, the Civilization 2
- 20:21point O value. And not the dynamic compounding
- 20:23power the civilization 3 point O value.
- 20:26The lesson? Was painful then a great asset
- 20:29sold too early is a profound mistake.
- 20:31A. Huge mistake of omission, and
- 20:34this shifted his modern focus entirely to finding great
- 20:38companies at fair prices. The compounders?
- 20:41These are businesses that can reinvest their capital at very
- 20:44high rates of return for decades.
- 20:46And they can be held, ideally indefinitely.
- 20:49This is the ultimate expression of his macro thesis.
- 20:53By investing in compounders, he is letting the iron law of
- 20:56modernization, that unstoppable force of exponential growth, do
- 21:00all the heavy lifting for him. The strategy moves from just
- 21:03asset protection to maximizing your participation in the
- 21:07compounding upside of the modern era.
- 21:09OK, so this brings us to what he believes is the most important
- 21:12part. Leila Lu famously states that
- 21:14successful investing is 99% temperament.
- 21:17Right, you can have the macro conviction, you got the micro
- 21:19analysis, but if you lack the emotional discipline you will
- 21:22fail to the point of maximum stress.
- 21:24Every time. So this section explores the
- 21:27philosophical underpinning that's required to build that
- 21:29discipline. To structure that discipline, he
- 21:31relies heavily on this neo Confucian concept of zixing hay.
- 21:34The unity of knowledge and action is to the philosopher
- 21:37Wang Yang Ming, and it's absolutely fundamental to his
- 21:40internal operating system. OK, what's the core principle?
- 21:44The principle asserts that true knowledge isn't academic or
- 21:47theoretical, it is the simultaneous occurrence of
- 21:50knowing and acting. So knowledge without action.
- 21:53Is mere delusion, and action without knowledge is just
- 21:57recklessness. How does that apply to an
- 21:59investor? I mean, we often hear people
- 22:01say, oh, I understand that company just because they built
- 22:04a perfect Excel model. And Lelu would argue you don't
- 22:07truly understand the company at all, not until you have put
- 22:10significant capital on the line. Because that's the action part.
- 22:13That's the action. True knowledge is forged when
- 22:16the psychological pressure of potential loss test the math and
- 22:19the assumptions in your model. It's that moment when your Excel
- 22:22model says bye, but your gut is screaming wait.
- 22:25It's the execution under pressure.
- 22:27Exactly the act of executing the trade, especially when the 95%
- 22:31are panicking. That's what exposes every hidden
- 22:34flaw in your logic that a spreadsheet could never show
- 22:36you. This must explain his skepticism
- 22:39towards sell side research. It does.
- 22:41Analysts may have the knowledge, the data, but they lack the
- 22:45action. There's no risk for them.
- 22:47Their theoretical knowledge is often just performative.
- 22:50It is the high stakes of Personal Capital allocation,
- 22:53that gut wrenching fear of permanent loss, that's the only
- 22:56Crucible that develops the necessary psychological clarity.
- 23:00He strongly advises aspiring investors.
- 23:03You have to manage your own money first.
- 23:06That's how you develop the fiduciary gene and internalize
- 23:09Zixing Hay. So to make sure the knowledge
- 23:13part of Zixing Hay is rock solid before you act, he implements
- 23:17this very strict test for intellectual honesty.
- 23:19A standard borrowed directly from Charlie Munger.
- 23:22It's all about combating our natural human tendency for
- 23:25confirmation bias. It demands A profound level of
- 23:28preparation. It really does.
- 23:30An investor is not entitled to a Billish opinion, Lelu argues,
- 23:33unless they can articulate the bearish case better than the
- 23:35smartest, most dedicated short seller on the planet.
- 23:38It's a methodology of refutation, then broken into
- 23:41three steps. The first step is you have to
- 23:43find the smartest person who fundamentally disagrees with
- 23:47your thesis. Step 2.
- 23:49You must master their argument perfectly.
- 23:51You have to understand their facts, their premises, their
- 23:53conclusion so well that you could effectively debate your
- 23:57own position on their behalf. You can't just dismiss them as
- 24:00being wrong. And only then, third, after
- 24:03truly mastering that counter argument, can you attempt to
- 24:06refute their best argument with objective facts and superior
- 24:10data. And if you can't complete that
- 24:12third step, the investment is outside your circle of
- 24:14competence. Period.
- 24:16So it transforms the entire process.
- 24:17It's not about seeking validation anymore.
- 24:19It's about seeking refutation. Most people look for reasons to
- 24:24buy. Lilu forces his team to spend
- 24:27the majority of their time looking for reasons not to buy.
- 24:29This preservation first mindset it's encapsulated in a very
- 24:33specific heuristic he uses for his analysts the worst case
- 24:36scenario stress test. And it focuses entirely on
- 24:39minimizing permanent capital loss.
- 24:40He doesn't ask how much money can we?
- 24:42Make he asks what? He asks, can you tell me exactly
- 24:46what the business will look like in the worst case scenario 10
- 24:49years from now? That seems like an almost
- 24:51impossible question in a world that's changing so fast.
- 24:54Why 10 years? The time horizon is critical
- 24:58because it forces you to think about systemic destruction, not
- 25:01just a short term cyclical downturn.
- 25:03The reasoning is very clear. The upside is usually handled by
- 25:07those Civilization 3 point O tailwinds.
- 25:09If the business is high quality, compounding will take care of
- 25:12itself, right? But permanent loss occurs on the
- 25:15downside. If you cannot predict potential
- 25:18technological disruptions, regulatory obsolescence, or
- 25:21competitive failures A decade out, you simply don't understand
- 25:24the dynamics of the business well enough to risk capital.
- 25:27It's a complete reversal of focus.
- 25:29Then you spend 80% of your energy on that 20% downside
- 25:33risk. Because the 80% upside is
- 25:34already taken care of by the iron law if you chose the
- 25:37business correctly in the first place.
- 25:38This leads to the ultimate behavioral requirement, the
- 25:41temperament needed to survive those inevitable 50% drops that
- 25:45even great companies experience. The fiduciary gene, a term he
- 25:49coined. What is the precise definition
- 25:51of this psychological makeup? He defines it as an innate,
- 25:55almost biological revulsion to losing money, especially money
- 25:59that belongs to other people. It's a profound, overriding
- 26:03sense of responsibility that has to suppress those primal human
- 26:07urges for excitement or gambling.
- 26:09It's the difference between the salaried manager and the owner
- 26:12operator from the gas station story.
- 26:14Exactly. The CEO must feel the loss of
- 26:16shareholder capital in their bones.
- 26:18But how do you test for that gene in ACEO who has only ever
- 26:22known success? Success can mask a lot of flaws.
- 26:25That is the challenge and Leilu looks intensely at Capital
- 26:28education history. Is the manager willing to return
- 26:31excess cash to shareholders rather than engage in reckless
- 26:34empire building acquisitions? Does the CEO obsess over the
- 26:37quarterly stock price or are they willing to endure years of
- 26:41criticism from Wall Street to build long term value?
- 26:44A true fiduciary will tolerate public shaming if it means
- 26:47protecting the future of the enterprise.
- 26:49A lack of the fiduciary gene often shows up as a desire for
- 26:52applause, which is just incompatible with the lonely
- 26:55long term work of value investing.
- 26:57He also has a stern warning for you, the listener.
- 27:00He says most people lack this gene.
- 27:03He's very clear on that. If you are the kind of person
- 27:06who panics when your portfolio inevitably drops 50%, which is
- 27:10standard volatility for highly concentrated, high quality
- 27:13investments, you should simply invest passively in index funds.
- 27:17Trying to be an active manager without the fiduciary gene is
- 27:19just financial self destruction. And his own history is the
- 27:23ultimate test case here. The Crucible for sure.
- 27:25In the first year of Himalaya Capital, 1997 to 1998, the Asian
- 27:30financial crisis hits and the fund drops 19%.
- 27:33That's the moment when most new managers would panic.
- 27:36They'd chase momentum or abandoned their principles just
- 27:39to stop the bleeding. But Lelu did the opposite.
- 27:41He didn't sell anything. He viewed the drop as the
- 27:44practical application of Zixing Hay.
- 27:47The psychological pressure clarified his thinking.
- 27:49He did. He deepened his research, He
- 27:51reverified his original Timberland and Hyundai theses,
- 27:55and he bought more. This demonstrates the discipline
- 27:58required remaining perfectly rational when the 95% of
- 28:02speculators are acting like hunters whose entire world is
- 28:04burning down. So Lilu is perhaps most unique
- 28:07because he took these, you know, universally Western derived
- 28:10value principles from Graham and Munger and he applied them
- 28:14successfully to the structurally complex and often very volatile
- 28:19Asian markets, especially China. And he argues directly against
- 28:22the idea that value investing only works in developed,
- 28:25institutionally efficient markets like the US.
- 28:27How does he characterize the Chinese market?
- 28:29He says it structurally resembles the US market of the
- 28:321950s, which was the golden era for Benjamin Graham and Warren
- 28:35Buffett to find all that statistical arbitrage.
- 28:38And the main factor creating that arbitrage is the structure
- 28:41of the market itself, retail dominance.
- 28:44Absolutely. The Chinese market is heavily
- 28:46dominated by individual retail investors.
- 28:49They're prone to extreme emotional swings, high turnover
- 28:52and short term gambling. It's a 95% speculator mindset,
- 28:56but amplified. And I've heard the regulatory
- 28:59environment is different too. It is.
- 29:01It often lacks the deep short selling infrastructure that's
- 29:03common in Western markets, which means there are fewer discipline
- 29:07players available to police valuations when prices get way
- 29:10too high. So the inefficiency isn't just
- 29:12behavioral, it's also structural.
- 29:14It's both the high turnover and the lack of those efficient
- 29:18counter forces create massive price to value divergences on a
- 29:21scale you just rarely see in the US today, where algorithms often
- 29:25close those gaps in a nanosecond.
- 29:27So for the disciplined 5% investor, this presents a long
- 29:31runway of opportunity. A very long runway.
- 29:34While the US market is highly efficient, the Chinese market is
- 29:37inefficient and volatile. It offers active value investors
- 29:41the chance to exploit the noise created by millions of retail
- 29:44speculators who are still operating with a Civilization
- 29:462.0 static mindset even though they're living in a Civilization
- 29:503.0 economy. And this feeds directly back
- 29:53into his big macro thesis. Lilu sees China as being in an
- 29:56interim phase. He calls it civilization 2.5 to
- 29:593.0. It's making that rapid
- 30:01transition from an industrial society to a fully modernized
- 30:04consumption and technology driven economy.
- 30:07The implication of that is massive.
- 30:08It is because China is still catching up in areas like
- 30:11urbanization, domestic consumption and service sector
- 30:14development. The potential underlying
- 30:16economic growth rate is structurally higher than in the
- 30:19mature U.S. economy. It's a built in tailwind.
- 30:22It's a. Huge tailwind that acts as an
- 30:24accelerant to your returns, provided you choose the right
- 30:27companies. And the Iron Law is paramount
- 30:29here. Absolutely.
- 30:31As China continues to integrate globally and adopt the best
- 30:34practices of free market social technology, the domestic
- 30:38companies that dominate this transition, the great
- 30:40compounders like a BYD or a $0.10, will inevitably become
- 30:45global giants. Driven by economies of scale and
- 30:47that intellectual multiplication effect.
- 30:49So investing in these compounders during this volatile
- 30:52transitional phase is the highest form of his
- 30:55modernization thesis. You're betting that the
- 30:57mathematical superiority of compounding growth and
- 31:00civilization 3 point O will ultimately overcome the short
- 31:03term political and regulatory volatility.
- 31:05The risk is high. But the potential reward writing
- 31:08that structural growth and the IR law at the same time is
- 31:11commensurate. It's also worth noting his
- 31:13caution here, though active selection is mandatory.
- 31:17Oh, absolutely. Unlike the S&P 500, which is a
- 31:20pretty clean proxy for US innovation, the major Chinese
- 31:24indices are often heavily weighted towards state owned
- 31:26enterprises or older, less dynamic industry.
- 31:29So just buying the index there often fails to capture the
- 31:32dynamism of the private sector modernization wave that Lilu is
- 31:36actually focused on. You really have to do your
- 31:39homework. So, given the enormous effort
- 31:40required for the Sherlock Holmes analysis and the temperamental
- 31:44rigor of the fiduciary gene, it's logical that Lilu rejects
- 31:48the modern dogma of broad diversification.
- 31:51Which leads to his punch card philosophy.
- 31:53This is a behavioral mechanism. It asks you, the investor, to
- 31:57operate as if you only have 20 investment slots, a punch card
- 32:01for your entire lifetime. And this constraint is a
- 32:03brilliant cognitive filter. If you know you only have 20
- 32:07chances, you will never buy a stock on a whim or because of
- 32:10peer pressure. It instantly combats so many
- 32:12critical cognitive biases, the action bias, that feeling you
- 32:15have to be doing something. The illusion of over
- 32:18diversification where you just dilute your best ideas.
- 32:21And just plain intellectual laziness.
- 32:23It demands overwhelming high conviction.
- 32:26It necessitates that extreme margin of safety and that deep
- 32:30owner level understanding of the business we talked about.
- 32:34You are forced to ensure you're truly buying a station, a
- 32:36business at a significant discount.
- 32:39The results, naturally, is a highly concentrated portfolio.
- 32:43He sees himself not as a manager of a basket of stock tickers,
- 32:47but as a partial owner of a small collection of exceptional
- 32:50businesses. But this concentration, it
- 32:53requires strict adherence to defining and respecting your
- 32:56circle of competence. And Li Liu stresses that the
- 32:58circle is defined not just by what you know, but by what you
- 33:01admit you don't know. That's maybe the most important
- 33:04part because the market is hyper competitive.
- 33:06You have to specialize, you have to fish where the fish are to
- 33:09achieve that deep 10,000 hour understanding that's required to
- 33:13justify placing one of those precious 20 punches.
- 33:15And that specialization is the final piece of the puzzle.
- 33:18The entire framework, history analysis, temperament and
- 33:21concentration, it all works together.
- 33:23It allows the investor to maximize their returns by riding
- 33:27that inevitable wave of civilization 3.0 while
- 33:30minimizing the risk of permanent loss.
- 33:32So this deep dive really reveals Li Liu's investment philosophy
- 33:36as this truly layered and integrated system.
- 33:39It's not just a collection of tips.
- 33:41It's a total worldview. We've seen the three pillars
- 33:44that provide the ultimate structure for his conviction.
- 33:46First you have the macro layer. Right, Civilization 3.0 and the
- 33:50Iron law. That's what justifies advise
- 33:52long term equity holding in the 1st place because the economy is
- 33:55a positive sum compounding machine driven by physics and
- 34:00history. Then second, you have the micro
- 34:02layer, the Sherlock Holmes due diligence.
- 34:04That's the execution. Finding the mispricing through
- 34:07forensic analysis of balance sheets and management intent.
- 34:11Creating that overwhelming margin of safety by exploiting
- 34:14the informational and structural inefficiencies created by the
- 34:1795% of speculators. And 3rd, the behavioral layer.
- 34:21Zixing, Haye and the fiduciary gene.
- 34:24This provides the discipline. This is what ensures the
- 34:27investor acts rationally, buying more when the market is
- 34:30panicking, because their conviction is rooted in
- 34:33historical inevitability, not in fleeting sentiment.
- 34:36Ultimately, Lulu presents the value investors role as one
- 34:40that's both, well, moral and highly functional.
- 34:43It is by rigorously allocating capital to the most honest and
- 34:47efficient stationary owner operators, the value investor is
- 34:51actually accelerating the modernization process, and the
- 34:54iron law rewards them for this contribution with compounded
- 34:58wealth. As a final provocative thought,
- 35:00let's go back to that evolution he had from buying cigar butts
- 35:03to holding compounders indefinitely.
- 35:06Consider the psychological difference between those two
- 35:08approaches. This is huge.
- 35:09If you had followed his Timberland analysis in 1998, you
- 35:12would have profited 700%, a great value play a home run.
- 35:16But if you had instead held an equivalent compounder, say like
- 35:19Amazon from that same era, you would have had to endure far
- 35:22greater volatility. We're talking 50 to 70% drops
- 35:25over several years. But the potential reward would
- 35:28have been vastly superior truly exponential results.
- 35:32So the question is this. Which strategy demands greater
- 35:36temperament? And does your own fiduciary gene
- 35:39truly allow you to capture those civilization 3 point O
- 35:42exponential returns? Or are you secretly still
- 35:45looking for the quick safe profit of a civilization?
- 35:482 point O static mindset. A profound question that really
- 35:52tests the foundation of your conviction.
- 35:54It does. And remember, this entire
- 35:56analysis is based solely on the sources provided and is for
- 35:59educational insight, not investment advice.
- 36:02You must conduct your own due diligence.
- 36:04And for those of you seeking to incorporate that essential
- 36:06preservation first mindset that Lelu demands, remember the
- 36:10importance of knowing the market temperature.
- 36:12You can search and download the iOS App Buffett Indicator from
- 36:15the Apple App Store to track total market capitalization
- 36:18relative to GDP daily. That awareness is the first step
- 36:21toward developing the required discipline.
- 36:23Thank you for joining us on The Deep Dive.
- 36:25We'll see you next time.