Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Alibaba Q2 2025 Business Deep Value Analysis: Valuation, Growth, and Risks
Transcript
- 0:00All right, welcome to The Explainer.
- 0:02Today, we're diving into a real head scratcher at the heart of
- 0:05the global market, the incredible story of Alibaba.
- 0:09This was a tech giant that seemed absolutely unstoppable.
- 0:12And then almost overnight, it took a spectacular fall from
- 0:16grace. So what on earth happened?
- 0:19And is this company now a historic bargain, or is it a
- 0:22giant that's just broken? Let's dig in.
- 0:26Yeah, that's really the core of it, isn't it?
- 0:29How does a company at the absolute peak of its power, one
- 0:33of the biggest tech Titans in the world, lose more than half a
- 0:36trillion dollars in value? I mean, we're talking about a
- 0:40loss bigger than the entire GDP of some countries.
- 0:43It's just wild. So how did it happen?
- 0:47And maybe more importantly for investors, what comes next?
- 0:51And look, the numbers here really paint a stark picture.
- 0:55At its peak back in October 2020, the stock was flying high
- 0:59at around $310 a share. Just two years later, it had
- 1:03plummeted to about 63 bucks. That's over $600 billion in
- 1:09market value. Poof, gone.
- 1:11To even begin to understand how that's possible, we have to
- 1:14unpack the story piece by piece. OK, so first up, let's get to
- 1:19know the company at the center of this whole drama, a true
- 1:23Titan of technology that soared to incredible heights before
- 1:27this massive fall. Before we can get into why it
- 1:31all came crashing down, we've got to understand what Alibaba
- 1:35actually is. Because, you know, most people
- 1:38hear Alibaba and think of online shopping, But the reality is so
- 1:42much bigger, so much more complicated than that.
- 1:46It's a sprawling digital empire that touches almost every part
- 1:50of China's modern economy. All right, let's pull back the
- 1:53curtain and see what's really going on inside this digital
- 1:56empire. Understanding all the moving
- 1:58parts here is absolutely critical if we're going to
- 2:01figure out what this company is really worth.
- 2:03OK, so this chart tells a really interesting story.
- 2:06Sure, it's main e-commerce business in China, you know
- 2:09Taobao and Tmall makes up almost half its money.
- 2:13But look at the rest. You've got cloud computing,
- 2:16international business and its own massive logistics network
- 2:20can IO, each kicking in over 10%.
- 2:22So you see, this isn't just some big online mall, it's a whole
- 2:26ecosystem, a giant octopus with tentacles and cloud computing,
- 2:30global shipping, you name it. And the sheer scale, I mean,
- 2:34it's just mind blowing. Every year Alibaba serves over
- 2:381.3 billion active customers around the world.
- 2:42To put that into perspective, that's like every single person
- 2:45in North America and Europe combined, all using Alibaba
- 2:49stuff. That's the kind of reach we're
- 2:51talking about. And then there's the money.
- 2:54The cash flowing through this thing is just, wow, in just one
- 2:58year, it's platforms handle over $1.3 trillion with AT.
- 3:04That's a firehose of cash so big it makes the economies of a lot
- 3:07of countries look tiny in comparison.
- 3:09But you know, it's not just about the raw numbers, it's
- 3:12about how sticky the platform is.
- 3:15They have this special membership program, ED-8 VIP,
- 3:18that gives you perks across the whole system.
- 3:20And over 50 million people are paying for it.
- 3:24These are the Super loyal, high value customers.
- 3:26So you've got this massive, dominant, deeply entrenched
- 3:29business. What in the world could possibly
- 3:32go wrong? Well, this is where the plot
- 3:34thickens. It turns out a perfect storm of
- 3:37really powerful headwinds slammed right into the company,
- 3:41and it caused this seemingly invincible giant to just
- 3:45stumble. And this is super important.
- 3:47We have to separate the short term bumps in the road from the
- 3:51really deep, scary long term risks.
- 3:55Sure, things like a slowing Chinese economy hurt, but what
- 3:58really had investors spooked were the long term problems.
- 4:01Brutal new competition from companies like Pindu Duo and
- 4:04Byte Dances doughy in fears about US, China, politics and
- 4:08the real boogeyman. The thing that sent a shiver
- 4:11down everyone's spines was this massive regulatory storm.
- 4:15Yeah, this was the big one, the earthquake.
- 4:18Starting in late 2020, the Chinese government suddenly
- 4:22decided to rein in its tech giants and boom, Alibaba found
- 4:26itself right in the center of the bullseye.
- 4:29The government wanted to curb the immense power of these
- 4:32companies and crack down on what they saw as monopolistic
- 4:35behavior. And to show they weren't messing
- 4:37around, they slapped Alibaba with a fine of, wait for it,
- 4:41$2.8 billion, a record breaker that sent a crystal clear
- 4:47message from Beijing. The wild freewheeling days for
- 4:50Big TAC were over. And that uncertainty is what
- 4:54absolutely terrified the market. So what do we have?
- 4:58A dominant cash gushing business that's suddenly facing some
- 5:01existential threats? This is the classic investor's
- 5:05dilemma, right? Is this a falling knife you
- 5:07should never try to catch or a once in a lifetime bargain?
- 5:11To figure that out, let's try looking at it through the eyes
- 5:14of a value investor. If we run it through a quick
- 5:17Buffett style checklist, we get a really interesting mixed bag.
- 5:21First U financial strength check.
- 5:24Easy pass. The company is sitting on a
- 5:26mountain of cash with very little debt.
- 5:28It's a fortress. How about cash generation?
- 5:31Another big check mark. It's a cash machine literally
- 5:34spitting out billions in free cash flow year after year.
- 5:38But, and this is a big but, when you look at other metrics,
- 5:42things get messy. Are profits consistent?
- 5:45Nope, they're all over the place.
- 5:46Is it highly profitable? Well, it's profit margin has
- 5:49dropped way below that 20% level that value investors love to
- 5:53see, so it fails there too. And here's something that really
- 5:58makes you go At the same time the market was panicking, the
- 6:02company's own leaders, the top brass like Co founders Jack Ma
- 6:07and Josiah, were reportedly snapping up shares.
- 6:11That's a huge vote of confidence, right?
- 6:13They're basically putting their money where their mouth is and
- 6:16saying we think the market is dead wrong about our company.
- 6:19OK, so this all leads to the big question, with all its strengths
- 6:24and all its very real problems, what is this giant company
- 6:29actually worth? Let's try and put a number on
- 6:32it. Now, the way finance pros try to
- 6:35do this is with a tool called a discounted Cash Flow analysis,
- 6:39or DCF. Sounds complicated, but the idea
- 6:42is actually pretty simple. You're just trying to figure out
- 6:45what all the cash a company will make in the future is worth to
- 6:48you today. Step 1, You basically guess how
- 6:52much cash the company is going to make in the future.
- 6:54Step 2. You take all that future money
- 6:57and discount it because a dollar tomorrow isn't worth as much as
- 7:00a dollar in your hand today, right?
- 7:02And boom. Step three, you add it all up
- 7:04and get a rough estimate of the company's intrinsic value.
- 7:07So when you run the numbers, you get a few different
- 7:09possibilities. Let's start with the Super
- 7:12pessimistic worst case scenario. If you assume Alibaba's cash
- 7:15flow never grows again, like flat lines forever, its value
- 7:19comes out to about 121 bucks a share.
- 7:21If you assume just modest growth, it jumps to 169, and if
- 7:25you're an optimist, it could be worth 225.
- 7:28And here is the absolute kicker. The stock has been trading right
- 7:32around that zero growth number. Let me just say that again,
- 7:36because it's really the whole point.
- 7:38The stock market right now is essentially betting that this
- 7:42massive, innovative global tech company will have literally 0
- 7:46growth ever again. For a business of this scale
- 7:50that is well, that's an incredibly pessimistic view.
- 7:54So when you put it all together, the fear, the deep pessimism
- 7:58from the market and the huge potential upside if that fear is
- 8:02just a little bit wrong, it all boils down to one single massive
- 8:06question. And that right there is the half
- 8:09trillion dollar question. Is the market right to be this
- 8:13scared, making Alibaba a classic value trap that will just keep
- 8:16burning investors? Or just maybe is this the kind
- 8:20of rare opportunity where you get to buy a world class tech
- 8:23empire at a price that has all the bad news and then some
- 8:26already baked in? The answer to that question is
- 8:29going to be one of the biggest stories in investing for years
- 8:32to come. Thanks for joining me on The
- 8:34Explainer. And hey, just a quick reminder,
- 8:36everything we've talked about today is for educational
- 8:39purposes. It's all based on public info
- 8:41and it's definitely not investment advice.
- 8:43You've got to do your own homework before making any
- 8:45financial moves. OK, great.