Latest / Five Games for Doomsday / Advent Calendar-Dec 12th-Through the Ages
Transcript
- 0:00M from the kitchen of the cabin. We look the best games of all
- 0:16time according to board game Geek in Ben and Steve's advent calendar. I want
- 0:29an next fucking planation. I thought this one that we were gonna start,
- 0:33Like, is that called smesis? What when you stick a swear word in
- 0:38the middle of the worldsis? Is that what it's called? Are you thinking
- 0:42of timysis? Is it timysisimysis or tmesis? Yeah? So fucking lutely,
- 0:47Yeah, I want an explor fucking le nation for what? Why? Yeah?
- 0:54Yes, Ben, So they did a they did a scientific experiment.
- 0:57Yes, some scientists. Yep. Uh it was Bob Johnson etal. Doctor
- 1:02Bob Johnson. Yeah, well of course, Yeah, just to clarify on
- 1:06what's the best ever board game ever fucking made? Plus one? Yeah,
- 1:08you know, like replication crisis and that I don't know what that means.
- 1:12That means like, you know, if you repeat the study, you might
- 1:15not find the same. Well, they repeats it, so it can't prove
- 1:18it in time. We can't prove it. It repeats it infinity times.
- 1:22Yeah, yeah, and they can image. You know what conclusion was?
- 1:25I believe the conclusion was that the best mobile app game of all time is
- 1:30Through the Ages. I'm the fucking I'm gonna throw is fucking hot in your
- 1:37face. So I love it. I can fucking play as many games as
- 1:41I want, over and over again. In my life. I don't have
- 1:42to fucking move cubes around. I don't have to deal with cards. Why
- 1:46you don't even have to I don't even have to people, And most of
- 1:51all, best of all, I don't have to deal with you. Why
- 1:53aren't you here? Why aren't you on a podcast called five Mobile Games for
- 1:56Dooms? I could? I could fucking play it. I can do it
- 2:02right now. Fucking fain. Board game designer Isaac shaalb is reading new game
- 2:07Don't You Fucking Dead? So for the listeners, Steve's got his crap app
- 2:12act. So explain to me why what is objectively the best board game ever
- 2:16made is only fourteenth in the top one hundred on Board game Geek. Well,
- 2:23it's a very competitive list. I'm not gonna give you any spoilers ast
- 2:25but people can just go and look for themselves. June Imperium's higher, Twilight
- 2:30Imperium fucking four aren't Nova's higher? Explain this to me Okay. I mean
- 2:36I think some of these are like cult of the new, So newer games
- 2:38just get more attention, and as the hobby expands, people forget about the
- 2:43classics they do, they don't remember, they don't know, and uh and
- 2:46you know, they're fucking tasteless right right there, They're tasteless, cretiness,
- 2:51fucking troglodie. We are the greatest taste makers in all the world of taste.
- 2:54What exactly is this hobby gonna do when we're finally gone? Exactly?
- 3:00It's a good thing of recording this content for posterity. Yeah, Like,
- 3:02listen, if you're listening from like fifty years in the future, Wow,
- 3:07these is the greatest couple of guys ever. Do you think people fifty years
- 3:12in the future are gonna have to be able to take time out from their
- 3:14fucking subsistence lifestyles to listen to board games? Are you seem they're gonna Bill
- 3:17and ted this shit? Yeah? Exactly, like we're gonna be gulds.
- 3:22It makes sense. So yeah, carry on. So I don't think I
- 3:28like Through the Ages as much as you do. I mean, I have
- 3:30a lot of respect for it. It's really interesting to me. That you
- 3:34like it so much. Like so, I think the most formative game of
- 3:38my childhood was a computer game called Civilization, Yeah, which is allergically based
- 3:45on the Avalon Hill game Civilization, although it's very different. I think I've
- 3:50probably played I've sunk more hours of my life into playing Civilization than any other
- 3:53activity, right, because like my entire childhood and like a big chug of
- 3:58my adolescents because you know, not getting late in that exactly, and Civilization
- 4:00two and Civilization three, it's up to five. Even I skipped four.
- 4:03I've played five, I haven't played six. There's a sex six through the
- 4:09ages. It's like a a brilliant like abstraction or distillation of what you were
- 4:14actually doing in Civilization that doesn't involve like fucking giving this shit about what's happening
- 4:18on a map. So do you know why captures the essence of the SIEV
- 4:24game so well? But but it does it with very tight mechanics, a
- 4:29very tight economy, and it's and it's so card driven. The car I
- 4:33think that the tableau of cars is what makes it infinitely replayable. Yeah.
- 4:36Absolutely, it is just like a strategic gem and it's so fucking frustrating too.
- 4:43That's such a frustrating game. So I think I think part of the
- 4:46reason when I got into games that they so bewitched me is because I couldn't
- 4:49see how it was done. Yeah, that famous Arthur C. Clark quote
- 4:56magic any technology so far out of our understand is considered magic. And never
- 5:00thought about board games as the technology, but I guess they are, and
- 5:03I would play these games. I don't think, how do people come up
- 5:05with these ideas? And as I got it's cleverer than we are. As
- 5:10I got more into the hobby, as I've become a renound designer myself,
- 5:14as I've you know, critiqued them and started to unpick them, it's amazing.
- 5:21And so I've realized that that I can sort of see the construction of
- 5:28many games, which disabuses them of their magic somewhat. And I don't I
- 5:32think. I think there are some game designers they look at a game and
- 5:35they can like see the matrix, and it kind of ruins it for them,
- 5:38right, I don't see that through the ages, it is still magical
- 5:42to me how you come up with a game with so many different moving parts,
- 5:46so many leavers, and yet it is so tight and he's so functional,
- 5:51and it is just so I bet if you could ask, if you
- 5:55could speak check and ask a lot of Kavati how he did it, it
- 5:59probably like wouldn't be that magical, Like he just play tested the fuck out
- 6:02of it. Sure, but the thing is that he worked, like he
- 6:04put the effort in. It's that's the thing. If you speak like so
- 6:08many designers don't put the effort in these days, like so many designers like
- 6:13Janie Stegmeier don't put the effort in these days, great great artists, I'm
- 6:18sure it is something al chemical. I'm sure great artists can't explain to you
- 6:24how it happens. Great. I think it's hard work. I don't think
- 6:28no, it is like Joseph Heller and Catch twenty two, he fucking diagrammed
- 6:30out the whole thing before he wrote it. Sure, but it's not just
- 6:33hard work, is I think that's the biggest part of It's not just hard
- 6:38work. It can't be just hard work, otherwise people would be preproducing.
- 6:42You want to believe that there's some kind of like football genius every day,
- 6:44there's some kind of like mystical surplus, like some kind of something unidentifiable.
- 6:49I don't know. I have read that a lot of it is really just
- 6:53hard work. But you know, it looks like you have to you have
- 6:55to make it look like it isn't. But that's so reductive. Why it's
- 6:58a reductive argument, what it's all just hard work? Because it can't be
- 7:01just hard work. But I mean, at the end of the day,
- 7:03what you're doing is like it is work. You know, there there and
- 7:09there's manual labor, and like you're doing activities, like what is the magical
- 7:14part? But if you couple hard work with un ineffable talent, and I'm
- 7:18not saying it's mystical or supernatural, it's just the brain is a very very
- 7:24complex organ and so it is impossible to map those paths to genius. And
- 7:30if you mix those two things, you end up with something like Through the
- 7:33Ages. As a cultural artifact, it emerged at the nexus of a lot
- 7:38of Chivato's own experiences in games, what he was exposed to, who he
- 7:42was working with, right, what what happened to him on like the Sunday
- 7:46when he came up with the fucking colonies mechanism. But the thing he's with
- 7:49you can never really know there's something with Lauchabathel. I always said this about
- 7:56him. I think he speaks gains. His language is games, like your
- 8:01first language is cunt. Yeah, exactly. There are many There are many
- 8:05game designers that are really good game designers that have honed their craft. Whereas
- 8:09now I might be talking out of my ass here, but it seems like
- 8:11Valachi battle is just instinctive. I mean with respect to the fact that all
- 8:16you do is stuck out of your ass. Yeah. Does he have a
- 8:18kind of like juvenilia? What's that mean? Like early works that you wouldn't
- 8:22judge his later works by, like sort of like you don't consider them part
- 8:26of the cannon. No, I can't think of any eye. I mean,
- 8:28I haven't played Bunny Bunny Moose Moos, so I can tell you.
- 8:31But you know, is that a real game? It is Bunny Bunny Moose
- 8:37Bunny Bunny Moose Moos. It seems like a game you would play, though,
- 8:39But if you look at if you look at his two towering achievements in
- 8:43game through the Ages and Galaxy Trucker Code Names, Oh yeah, I mean
- 8:48sure, Party game code Names is an astonishing world. It's like the party
- 8:54it is a crystalline piece of perfection. And these are two games that are
- 8:58on opposite signs of the spectrum when it comes to complexity. But you really
- 9:03fucking lean into the purple pros. And yet they're both incredibly audacious, incredibly
- 9:09invented, incredibly impactful. I remember the year. I think Code Names is
- 9:13more impactful, though, right, it depends what you mean. More people
- 9:18play it, it's it's sells better, much much more of an empire.
- 9:22I don't think. Yeah, I don't think it's a better game. But
- 9:24at the same time, I still think it's a brilliant design. I mean,
- 9:26you're definitely like the biggest through the ages stand in the hobby. I
- 9:31still think it should be it should be on this list if I if I
- 9:35had a choice. Ah, good question. Are there any party games on
- 9:37this list? No? I kind of mentioned there is not a list for
- 9:41like party games, small card games. I think the lightest game is probably
- 9:45Seven Wonders. You. Yeah, so we see, like which way the
- 9:48deckheads in this hobby tends tend to lean right. And I will give you
- 9:52some like rare credit here. You actually like you You are willing to compare
- 9:58game games of all categories and and wait against one another, of course,
- 10:05as they should be done much much much more than I would like. I
- 10:07wouldn't compare through the Ages to code names. I think that you would.
- 10:11And you and you want to grant all types of games the same amount of
- 10:16dignity. Yes, I I don't agree with it, but I think it
- 10:18is like a respectable position to agree with it. I just I well,
- 10:20I just don't got I think I'm one of these dickheads. The thing is,
- 10:24some of these games belong on this list, like where's Skulking? You
- 10:28could legitimately ask where's code? Where's code names? Absolutely? Where is?
- 10:33Well? My goods and savage but cypical, fucking ben reaction to the greatest
- 10:39boarding game designer of the tummy That's right, yeah so. And the thing
- 10:43is what people fail to talk about when they talk about through the Ages is
- 10:46how much of a sort of work of aut are to day, How to
- 10:54through the mechanisms you get a you get a picture into the brain of the
- 10:58designer, how anti communisty is, how much he leans towards having a having
- 11:03a positive view on religion, how funny he is, How when you get
- 11:11sid Meyer as a leader your art goes up, but your productivity goes down
- 11:16because everyone's sat in their office playing Civilization and it's all mechanical and it's brilliant.
- 11:22I don't. I don't, and it's wonderfully full times. I don't
- 11:24actually give a shit about any of that stuff. But it is, as
- 11:28your philistine Yeah, I just don't care, but I'm like, I'm it
- 11:31is a completely addictive game, unlike most board games that we play, like,
- 11:33I don't have this feeling after I play most board games that I want
- 11:37to play them again. And as as much as you you you you belittle
- 11:41the app players, there's a reason that this game became an app, and
- 11:45that the app is so popular and that I can't stop playing it, and
- 11:48it is. It is the design. It is as Civilization was when I
- 11:54was a child. Yeah, I want to play it over and over.
- 11:56I want to master this game. Yeah, so I can finally beat you.
- 12:00So can we agree then that I'm right? I mean, this is
- 12:05basically the premise upon which this podcast has based. Ben can't ever be wrong,
- 12:11because if you've ever suggested he is, he fucking whins and cries like
- 12:15a little baby child. Damn scipping thank you for listening. You can support
- 12:22the show at Patreon dot com, forward slash five GFID, and join the
- 12:24discord by going to five gfid dot com. Have a very merry Christmas.