Latest / Consumerpedia / 90 - Buy Now, Pay Later
Transcript
- 0:02Buy now, pay later has become a mainstream financial product
- 0:05that continues to grow in popularity with 10s of millions
- 0:08of users, especially young and lower income Americans who want
- 0:12flexible payments and no credit card debt.
- 0:14But personal finance experts warn there can be serious
- 0:18downsides to paying this way. I'm Herb Weisbaum, the consumer
- 0:21Man, a contributing editor at checkbook.org.
- 0:24Welcome to consumerpedia@checkbook.org.
- 0:28We're the nonprofit that helps consumers select services, avoid
- 0:31trouble, and save money. Because we don't accept any
- 0:34advertising or take money from any business, we recommend you
- 0:37can rely on checkbook.org to be completely independent and
- 0:41objective. Now here's the host of Consumer
- 0:44Pedia America's consumer expert, the Consumer Man Herb Weispom.
- 0:49Once limited to online shopping, Buy Now Pay Later is rapidly
- 0:52expanding into brick and mortar stores, and it's now being used
- 0:56for everyday purchases such as groceries and gasoline.
- 0:59The companies providing Pay Later financing say they're
- 1:02offering a low cost payment option that enables consumers to
- 1:06make small dollar purchases without incurring high fees or
- 1:09interest. Consumer advocates worry Buy
- 1:11now, Pay Later makes it too easy for people to buy things they
- 1:14can't afford, resulting in late fees and costly bank charges.
- 1:18There's a lot to talk about with our guests
- 1:20tedrossmanseniorindustryanalyst@bankrate.com. Hi, good to be here.
- 1:25And Lawrence Saunders is associate director at the
- 1:27National Consumer Law Center, a nonprofit that for economic
- 1:30justice for low income and other vulnerable people have been
- 1:33abused, deceived, discriminate against or left behind in our
- 1:36economy. Hi, Lauren.
- 1:37Hi, thanks for having me. So Ted, let's start with you.
- 1:39Let's make sure all of our listeners know how a buy now,
- 1:42pay later loan works. The typical short term loan.
- 1:44We're talking about companies like a firm, Afterpay and
- 1:47Klarna. A typical flavor is for interest
- 1:51free payments over six weeks. You've probably seen these on
- 1:54various e-commerce platforms. It's important to note though
- 1:58that buy now, pay later is evolved and it's not just for
- 2:01interest free payments over six weeks anymore.
- 2:04Some of these plans are lasting longer, three months, six
- 2:07months, 12 months, sometimes even a few years.
- 2:10Many of those longer plans do charge interest and ironically
- 2:14it's actually similar to what a credit card would charge, maybe
- 2:1615 or 20%, sometimes more. This industry has positioned
- 2:20itself as the anti credit card or the kinder, gentler form of
- 2:25financing. Interestingly, it is behaving
- 2:27more credit card like over time, which we can get into.
- 2:30But basically we're talking instalment financing.
- 2:33You're committing to a specific length of time for a specific
- 2:37purchase. That's what makes it different
- 2:39from a credit card where you might get a $5000 limit and they
- 2:42just turn you loose. Buy now, pay later is really a
- 2:45one to one relationship. Usually it's it's 1 certain
- 2:48purchase and you're committing to a certain number of payments
- 2:52with a certain interest rate. Sometimes zero, sometimes not.
- 2:55And while they never say the word loan, it's a loan just like
- 2:58any other loan. Yeah, it's debt.
- 3:00I mean, that's an important point.
- 3:01People say that credit cards can be like power tools.
- 3:03They can be really useful or dangerous, depending on how you
- 3:07use them. I would extend that analogy to
- 3:10buy now, pay later. Sometimes this works for people.
- 3:12They like the ability to spread out their cash flow and afford
- 3:16things in installments. Other times it's a ticket to
- 3:19impulse buying and overspending. It really does depend how you
- 3:22use it. And we're going to talk more
- 3:23about that later in the episode. Lauren, I often hear buy now,
- 3:26pay later described as a modern version of layaway.
- 3:29You know, remember when a store would put an item aside for you
- 3:31until you paid off the purchase? But buy now, pay later is
- 3:34nothing like layaway. That's right, Layaway is save
- 3:37first and buy when you have the money.
- 3:39Buy now, Pay later is buy now when maybe you don't have the
- 3:43money and split up into more payments.
- 3:46But it can make things look more affordable than they really are.
- 3:50So let's talk about who's using these loans.
- 3:52A survey by the Federal Reserve released in May found that most
- 3:56of these are being used by low and middle income adults.
- 3:59Nearly 3 quarters, 72% of those with an income of less than
- 4:02$50,000. So they use buy now, pay later
- 4:05because it was the only way they could afford to make a purchase.
- 4:08Lauren, what does this tell you? Well, if you can't afford to
- 4:11make a purchase in full today, not clear to me whether
- 4:14splitting it up into four payments over the next six weeks
- 4:17is going to make it a lot more affordable.
- 4:19And we're seeing that some people are finding buy now, pay
- 4:23later makes things look cheaper than they are, and then they end
- 4:25up in trouble. And because it makes it look
- 4:27cheaper than it is, you may buy more than you were expecting.
- 4:30That's right. That's one of the reasons that
- 4:32that stores and websites like Buy Now pay Later, because they
- 4:34find that people buy more, but it's not necessarily good for
- 4:38the consumer if they're ending up with purchases that they
- 4:41really can't afford. Ted, this same study found that
- 4:43nearly 24% of those who use Buy Now pay Later.
- 4:46Nearly 1/4 of the Buy Now, Pay Later customers made a late
- 4:50payment, and that's a sharp uptick from 18% who made late
- 4:53payments in 2023. What happens if you don't pay on
- 4:56time? Some of these providers don't
- 4:58even charge late fees. The firm has famously not
- 5:01charged late fees typically doesn't affect your credit.
- 5:05This is what's so interesting about this is that you talk
- 5:08about the carrot or the stick approach.
- 5:10There's not much of a stick with buy now, pay later.
- 5:13There's sometimes no late fees. There's often no credit score
- 5:16damage. Really the only way this is
- 5:18going to appear on your credit report right now is if you're so
- 5:21late that you go to collections. So then you might ask, well, why
- 5:24does anybody pay them back? The biggest appeal has been the
- 5:27carrot of continuing to use these services.
- 5:31I know in the aggregate, that sounds alarming that one in four
- 5:34users have paid late. However, the delinquency rates
- 5:37that these companies report is actually lower than what we see
- 5:41on credit cards. Klarna's delinquency rate is
- 5:43about half of 1%. A firm also has a lower
- 5:47delinquency rate than credit cards.
- 5:49The delinquency rate for credit cards is about 3%.
- 5:51So it sort of depends which lens you're viewing this through.
- 5:55I mean, yes, maybe one in four have paid late at some point
- 5:58over the next year, but overall, this industry has held up better
- 6:02from a delinquency standpoint than expected.
- 6:04And really one of the biggest reasons for that is a lot of
- 6:07people like it and they want to keep using it.
- 6:09Lauren, do you have any thoughts on this?
- 6:10Yeah, there's another problem, though.
- 6:12The late payments show that these loans are unaffordable.
- 6:16And even if you don't go delinquent, the company is going
- 6:19to keep hitting your account to try to get that money.
- 6:22And that debit can trigger overdraft fees, so they may get
- 6:26repaid if the bank eventually pays it.
- 6:28But if it overdrafts your account, you could have a $35
- 6:32fee on top of the late fee, which can really add to the
- 6:34unaffordability of these loans. Good point.
- 6:37You know people are now using buy now pay later to buy
- 6:40gasoline and groceries. It's become a common way to pay
- 6:43for takeout or food delivery services.
- 6:45You can now use Klarna to pay for DoorDash purchases of $35 or
- 6:48more. I don't know about you guys, but
- 6:50I find this troubling. I think by now, pay later makes
- 6:53most sense for large purchases, occasional purchases, but for
- 6:58everyday things like gas and food, you're going to have to
- 7:01buy gas and food next week. So why put off some of the
- 7:04payment of this week's food into next week or the week after
- 7:08that? It just can lead to a lot of
- 7:10complicated payment dates and debt that sort of piling up.
- 7:14Ted. I agree.
- 7:15I would say that the best use case is something like a couch
- 7:18or refrigerator or a new set of tires.
- 7:20I mean something that you hopefully really need some
- 7:23people like the ability to spread out the cash flow whether
- 7:25they have the money or don't. I mean, there's even some of the
- 7:29so-called Henry, the higher earners, not rich yet that are
- 7:31using buy now, pay later to buy a Peloton bike, let's say.
- 7:35And there's a certain kind of person who's buying a $2500
- 7:38exercise bike. But for some, if they're able to
- 7:40split it up over time, it's interest free.
- 7:42You pay 50 bucks a month. That's the appeal.
- 7:45But I agree about the downside of some of the short term plans,
- 7:48gas, groceries, other consumables, Lauren's right.
- 7:52I mean, you're going to need more before that six week
- 7:54payment plan is even up and you are at the risk of stacking
- 7:58payments, $20 here and $50 there can still add up.
- 8:02So I I would see this better used for some of the longer term
- 8:06bigger ticket items. But you have to watch that
- 8:08interest rate because like I said, a lot of the longer plans
- 8:11are not interest free anymore. It has a 15 or 20 or sometimes
- 8:15higher interest rate. That's the fine print to be
- 8:17aware of. Another problem with using buy
- 8:19now, pay later for routine things like food.
- 8:22Unlike with a credit card, you have one bill at the end of the
- 8:25month. You know how much it is.
- 8:26You pay it. Buy now, pay later.
- 8:28You're sweating every purchase up into four payments.
- 8:31Well, if you're doing that all the time, you're having all
- 8:34sorts of payments coming out of your account every other day
- 8:37perhaps. And it's a lot more complicated
- 8:40and harder to manage your finances and make sure you
- 8:42actually have the money when the payments come in and.
- 8:45People are having that problem. We're going to talk in the next
- 8:47section to a credit counselor all about that, you know, buy
- 8:50now, pay later Lenders claim they offer a smarter way to pay
- 8:53with no surprises. But is that really true?
- 8:56We'll look at ways buy now, pay later can cause serious finance
- 8:59actual problems. I'm Herb Weisbaum, the consumer
- 9:01man, and this is Consumerpedia, powered by checkbook.org.
- 9:06At checkbook.org, we have the answers to your consumer
- 9:09questions 24/7. That's checkbook.org.
- 9:12We're a unique nonprofit that can help you with select local
- 9:15service providers, avoid trouble, and save money.
- 9:18Because we don't accept any advertising or take money from
- 9:21any business, we recommend you can rely on Checkbook to be
- 9:24completely independent and objective.
- 9:27Our advice is always free. Medians of local services are
- 9:30available with a subscription. If you live in one of these
- 9:33seven metro areas and haven't joined checkbook yet, check us
- 9:36out. Boston, Chicago, Philadelphia,
- 9:39Seattle, San Francisco, Minneapolis, Saint Paul and
- 9:43Washington DC Get your free 30 day subscription by going to
- 9:46checkbook.org/consumerpedia. Buy now, pay later lenders
- 9:52promote their service as a smarter way to pay than with
- 9:55credit cards, one that offers flexibility and no surprises.
- 9:58Approval is instant, and there's no hard credit check.
- 10:01The Financial Technology Association, that's the group
- 10:03that represents buy now, pay later lenders, told Checkbook
- 10:06its members have safeguards in place to make sure customers
- 10:09don't take on too much debt. For example, as Ted pointed out,
- 10:12those who miss payments cannot make new purchases.
- 10:14A firm in Klarna, 2 of the largest buy now, pay later
- 10:17companies, insists they only extend credit to those who can
- 10:20pay. So let's dig deeper into all
- 10:22this. First, I would question that buy
- 10:24now, pay later lenders are not encouraging people to borrow as
- 10:27much as possible. Thoughts on this?
- 10:29We'll start with you, Ted. One thing that's really unique
- 10:31here is that they're underwriting each individual
- 10:33purchase. So it's different from a credit
- 10:36card lender that might give you a big credit card limit and then
- 10:39you just sort of have at it. That's what they mean when they
- 10:41say they're not approving you for more than they believe you
- 10:44can afford. Now, there are different ways to
- 10:46look at this, of course. You know, there's what's a wise
- 10:49financial decision and what's not.
- 10:50I mean, a lot of times a lender will approve you for more than
- 10:54maybe you should borrow because they're only looking at, let's
- 10:57say, your credit score or your income or some combination of
- 11:00the two. And they're not doing the most
- 11:02detailed examination. And I've heard of college
- 11:04students who, you know, they thought it was $20 here and $50
- 11:07there and, and they ended up being over their heads with
- 11:09BNPL. But it's also true that there's
- 11:12a school of thought that says, well, how much trouble could you
- 11:14get into with a relatively small dollar loan over a relatively
- 11:18short period of time? You can get into trouble double,
- 11:21but you know, that's one of the things that has helped the BNPL
- 11:24industry that the typical ticket size is a few $100.
- 11:29A lot of these plans are paid back in six weeks, but these are
- 11:32some of the reasons why the delinquency rate has been lower
- 11:35than many feared. The other thing is that the job
- 11:37market's been good. So what if that changes?
- 11:39I mean, a lot of people say that BNP LS never really been
- 11:42recession tested because a lot of these companies were formed
- 11:46after the financial crisis. And yes, we had that brief COVID
- 11:50recession, but that was is very different when you think about
- 11:52all the stimulus money and the fact that so many businesses
- 11:56were closed. I mean, that was not a normal
- 11:58recession by any means. It's an open question for the
- 12:01industry. So far better than expected.
- 12:04But there are fears that the other shoe could drop.
- 12:06And in fact, recently when we had all that tariff turmoil on
- 12:10Wall Street, BNPL company stocks dropped more than traditional
- 12:14credit card providers like American Express because the
- 12:16feeling is a firm and Afterpay in Klarna might have a riskier
- 12:20audience. A lot of this is still untested.
- 12:23Lauren, your thoughts? Well, by now pay later
- 12:25companies, they certainly care about whether they get repaid,
- 12:28but that's not the same thing as ensuring that the consumer can
- 12:31afford the purchase because they're going to take out that
- 12:34money automatically from your bank account every two weeks.
- 12:37So they've got a pretty good chance of getting their loan
- 12:39repaid. But it could overdraft and then
- 12:42you're stuck with a $35 overdraft fee or could make it
- 12:45more difficult for you to pay for your rent or your auto loan.
- 12:48So I'm not confident that the kind of underwriting they're
- 12:52doing is really enough to ensure that these loans are affordable
- 12:55for people. Which leads us to my next point.
- 12:57Credit counselors who are on the frontline dealing with people
- 13:00who have financial problems tell me they are seeing an increasing
- 13:03number of clients struggling to pay multiple buy now, pay later
- 13:06loans. Here's what Laura Ciccarelli, an
- 13:09NFCC certified credit counselor at American Financial Solutions,
- 13:13a nonprofit counseling agency based in Seattle, told me.
- 13:16We're seeing people really struggle with these types of
- 13:18accounts. The main problem that we're
- 13:20seeing is that most people, people who have buy now, pay
- 13:22later accounts don't have just one.
- 13:24They have multiple and the payments tend to stack up really
- 13:26quickly. It can be really hard to keep
- 13:28track of them. People aren't familiar with
- 13:30where they can go to track these payments online in the way that
- 13:33they're familiar with how to log in to like their credit cards or
- 13:35their bank accounts. So it can be really easy to lose
- 13:37track of these payments and have them stack up and leave you
- 13:40overextended in your budget. The other problem that we're
- 13:42seeing is that consumers are using these products to cover
- 13:47purchases that they don't have the cash on hand for, and their
- 13:50budgets are already tight, which is why they're having to turn to
- 13:52these products. And the recurring payments that
- 13:55then stack up are making those budgets even tighter.
- 13:57So it's this kind of compounding problem.
- 13:59You know, there's no interest on the loans, which is fantastic,
- 14:02but it doesn't mean that the payments aren't creating a
- 14:04hardship. So you get a monthly statement
- 14:05with a credit card, as one of you pointed out, but you don't
- 14:08get statements from the buy now pay later lenders.
- 14:10And as Laura said, if you get 5678, she's seen people with ten
- 14:14of these going on at the same time.
- 14:15You may have no clue as to when the money's coming out of the
- 14:17bank and the money might not be there.
- 14:19That's isn't that the problem, Laura?
- 14:21Exactly, It could be a lot more complicated to manage than just
- 14:24having a credit card with one statement and one payment every.
- 14:26Month. Something else to consider.
- 14:28If something does go wrong with the transaction, who's going to
- 14:31help you? Do you go to the buy now, pay
- 14:33later lender or the retailer? From the complaints I've seen,
- 14:36you may get the runaround. The one points to the other and
- 14:38you're left in the middle again. You might not have that problem
- 14:41if you made the purchase with a credit card that's.
- 14:42Actually, one of the biggest problems that BNPL users
- 14:45identified in our recent survey, 14% said they've had
- 14:48difficulties with returns and refunds.
- 14:51You're right, sometimes there is this middleman kind of thing
- 14:54where you sent the merchandise back, but how do you get your
- 14:57money back? That can sometimes be a pain
- 14:59point. And Lauren, if you're disputing
- 15:01this thing, I've heard from people who say, but they're
- 15:03still digging me for the money while I'm arguing that I got a
- 15:05defective product or whatever. That's right.
- 15:07With a credit card, you have really clear dispute rights.
- 15:10And if you didn't get what you paid for, you returned an item.
- 15:13You have a right not to pay the credit card until that's
- 15:16resolved, and the bank has a duty to investigate it.
- 15:19Now, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau says that buy
- 15:21now, pay later companies have those same duties to help people
- 15:25when there are disputes or mistakes or unauthorized
- 15:27charges. At least they said it last year.
- 15:30This year, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau has
- 15:33backtracked. And so there may be a dispute
- 15:35about what the law is. But I think it's essential for
- 15:38this industry to help people with their problems and not just
- 15:41leave them hanging if they return something and are still
- 15:43stuck paying that loan. Looking at the Better Business
- 15:46Bureau website, on June the 1st in the last three years, the BBB
- 15:49received 6000 490 customer complaints about a firm, 3405
- 15:56complaints about Afterpay and 2713 complaints about Klarna,
- 16:01which they give AC minus rating. Each company has a rating of one
- 16:05star out of five. I think that indicates that
- 16:07there is a little bit of a problem with this industry.
- 16:10There are a lot of people who love buy now, pay later, and
- 16:12they really like the ability to afford things now and pay for
- 16:16them in installments. But it's also true that it can
- 16:19get you into trouble. To me, by buy now, pay later is
- 16:21something that most people should aspire to graduate from.
- 16:25You know, not to cast aspersions, but I honestly think
- 16:28this is more of a starter financial product.
- 16:31I would love for people to get to the point that they can pay a
- 16:34credit card in full and get the rewards, get the buyer
- 16:36protections, get some of those advantages that buy now, pay
- 16:40later doesn't necessarily have. Then again, there are some loyal
- 16:43fans who just really like this whole installment thing.
- 16:47You just have to be careful that you're actually paying it back
- 16:50and that you're not overdoing it because sometimes there can be
- 16:53an impulse buying angle. A firm even talked about that.
- 16:55Their CFO said once that their delinquency rate spikes at 2:00
- 16:59in the morning. I mean, that definitely speaks
- 17:01to people browsing their phones late at night.
- 17:04Maybe they're bored, maybe they've been drinking.
- 17:06Maybe they click buy and then they later regret it.
- 17:08That is a definite pain point. I don't think this is a starter
- 17:11product. I think the research is clear
- 17:13that, you know, most people who have buy it now, pay later loans
- 17:16also have credit cards, other forms of credit.
- 17:19So the question is, are they turning to buy now pay later
- 17:22when they've maxed out on their credit and they really are
- 17:24struggling and shouldn't be taking on more credit?
- 17:27I also don't think we can say buyer beware on the issue of
- 17:31disputes and mistakes. It's the duty of these companies
- 17:33to take care of problems and make sure that people aren't
- 17:36being caught between the store and the buy now, pay later.
- 17:39So it's their duty. That's not something that
- 17:41consumers should have to figure out.
- 17:43All right, up next, how buy now, pay later compares to paying
- 17:46with a credit card? Plus tips on the right way to
- 17:48use these pay later loans should you decide to go that route.
- 17:51I'm Herb Weisbaum, the consumer man, and this is Consumerpedia,
- 17:55powered by checkbook.org. Consumerpedia Fast Facts
- 18:01According to a recent Motley Fool Money survey of people who
- 18:04use Buy now, pay later, slightly more than half, 53%, use this
- 18:08payment option more often than their credit cards.
- 18:11While available in many stores, buy now, pay later is most often
- 18:15used for online shopping, the survey found.
- 18:17The key purchases made this way are electronics, followed by
- 18:21clothing and fashion accessories.
- 18:23More than 1/4 of Pay later users said they buy groceries,
- 18:26furniture or appliances this way, and 31% of buy now, pay
- 18:29later users said they lost track of the payments they owe at one
- 18:33time or another. Buy Now Pay Later started with
- 18:38online purchases and has quickly moved into the brick and mortar
- 18:41space. It's an option at the checkout
- 18:43counter at many major retailers. That's because pay in 4 is good
- 18:46for business, according to a market analysis by RBC Capital,
- 18:50offering Buy now pay later financing increases conversion
- 18:53rates by 20 to 30% and boost average sales transactions by 30
- 18:58to 50%. The company says that's why
- 19:00retailers pay these companies a steep Commission for helping
- 19:03complete the sale. Between 3 and 6% in most cases.
- 19:07That's more than they pay the credit card companies.
- 19:09They're doing it, Lauren, because it works, right?
- 19:11That's right. It gets people to spend more and
- 19:13then that's not necessarily good for individual families.
- 19:16Is there a psychological aspect here that if you're only paying
- 19:19$25 for $100 item, somehow you think oh I got $75.00 free money
- 19:23here to play, I can buy some accessories to go with this or
- 19:26whatever? I think that's right.
- 19:27It also just looks cheaper, right?
- 19:28Paying $25 seems a lot cheaper than $100, and people aren't
- 19:32necessarily fully paying attention to how quickly the
- 19:35rest of that $75 is going to come due. 10 In a recent article
- 19:39on bankrate.com, you noted how the industry has been pushing
- 19:42deeper into more daily and in person transactions, and I like
- 19:45what you wrote, so I'm going to read it here.
- 19:46It's an ingenious business model that helps some people afford
- 19:49things they couldn't otherwise afford.
- 19:51The problem though, is that sometimes it allows you to
- 19:53purchase stuff you didn't necessarily need and that you
- 19:56can't really afford. That's right.
- 19:58I think that the business case here is very compelling.
- 20:01These companies are trying to be the next super app, they're
- 20:03trying to be the next PayPal. Basically.
- 20:06There's a lot of different ways. To pay for things and they want
- 20:08to be in on all of them. So it fits in with this shift
- 20:11towards technology. But it's also pay now with their
- 20:14debit card, a firm and Klarna and Afterpay.
- 20:16They all have debit cards now. So you could pay right away or
- 20:19you could pay in weeks with this four payments over six weeks
- 20:22model or you could pay in months with the six month or 12 month
- 20:26or two year kind of plan. It's a very smart business
- 20:29model. Now, whether or not it's good
- 20:31for the consumer depends on how you use it.
- 20:34They are pushing more into physical transactions.
- 20:36It's not just e-commerce anymore.
- 20:38You can use those debit cards to either pay right away or turn it
- 20:42into an installment plan that you pay back over time.
- 20:45They're pushing more into services, travel, dining,
- 20:48veterinary bills, dental bills, things like that.
- 20:51Again, it depends on how you use it.
- 20:53You know, you think about some of the point of sale financing
- 20:55for dental and veterinary things like the Care Credit credit card
- 20:59that have very high interest rates.
- 21:02Some people are paying upwards of 30% on products like that.
- 21:05So that's the appeal of buy now, pay later is, oh, you're telling
- 21:08me I can split this dental work into a bunch of installments
- 21:12that maybe fit into my budget a little bit better?
- 21:15The key is you have to look at the fine print.
- 21:17It's not one-size-fits-all anymore.
- 21:19There's a lot of different options here.
- 21:21And in your survey, your recent survey, you found that 24% of
- 21:24those responding said they had overspent using buy now, pay
- 21:28later. So it's clearly a problem for a
- 21:29bunch of folks. That's because people look at
- 21:31the installments, not the total cost.
- 21:34And that's a big pitfall. And we see it with infomercials
- 21:37too. I mean, you talked about how
- 21:39this is sometimes viewed as reverse layaway.
- 21:42It's also A twist on the old infomercial model.
- 21:44I mean, it's kind of like 04 easy payments of 4999 and it
- 21:47could be yours today. Sometimes there is this false
- 21:50sense of urgency. Sometimes you only look at the
- 21:53installments and you don't think about the total cost.
- 21:55You need to consider all this, how much you're paying in total,
- 21:59what's the term, what's the interest rate.
- 22:01Lauren made a good point earlier about the confusion of having a
- 22:05lot of these plans running at the same time because, yeah,
- 22:07they can set you up with auto payments, but that could maybe
- 22:10lead to overspending or overdrafting.
- 22:13And also, right now, a firm doesn't really know what you're
- 22:16doing with Klarna or Afterpay or vice versa.
- 22:19There's a push to get more credit reporting underway here,
- 22:23but it's been slow going. There's a lot of blind spots
- 22:25here for lenders and some for consumers.
- 22:27As well. So which means if you're not
- 22:29paying your firm bill and they shut you down, you could open up
- 22:32a loan with Klarna or Afterpay or anybody else and just keep
- 22:35right on going and. That's the biggest reason that I
- 22:37would give to providers to say why we need more credit
- 22:40reporting. There's other ones, too.
- 22:42It would be good for consumers, but it would be good for lenders
- 22:45to know, like, yeah, if someone's behind with two of
- 22:48your rivals, do you really want to lend to them as well?
- 22:51I think credit reporting would be useful, for better or for
- 22:54worse. I mean, it should help your
- 22:56credit if you're using it responsibly, and it should hurt.
- 22:58And if you're falling behind traditionally credit reporting
- 23:02has been kind of a square peg, round hole thing with buy now,
- 23:04pay later. It doesn't fit neatly with our
- 23:07understanding of credit. For example, you're penalized on
- 23:10the credit reporting system if you open and close a lot of
- 23:14credit card accounts frequently or if you Max out cards.
- 23:18Buy now, pay later by nature is basically a series of often
- 23:21short term small dollar loans that are opened and hopefully
- 23:25paid off relatively quickly. I would like to see this come
- 23:28more into the light. There are some pilot programs
- 23:31underway between a firm and Experience and Klarna and
- 23:35TransUnion. I'd like to see more of it.
- 23:37I was asked this question the other day, so Lauren, I'd like
- 23:39to ask you, is buy now, pay later better than taking out a
- 23:42payday loan? Yes, I think it is.
- 23:45I mean, you know, payday loans are pretty terrible, so it's not
- 23:48hard to be better than them. I mean, they've got, you know,
- 23:50short repayment periods and steep fees, but you know,
- 23:53whether they're better than a credit card, you know, credit
- 23:55cards, you know, have their own downsides for sure.
- 23:58It's very easy to get deep into credit card debt.
- 24:01It takes forever to pay it off and you can end up paying
- 24:04interest for years and years. So while you have a lot of
- 24:07strong protections on credit cards, especially if you have a
- 24:10dispute around something, it's not great for managing your
- 24:13finances either. And certainly any credit
- 24:15product, if you can't afford things today and you're buying
- 24:18everything on credit, whether you're using a credit card, buy
- 24:20now, pay later, or something else, that's to be a problem
- 24:24because you're just taking on debt you really can't afford.
- 24:26In some ways, I think the sweet spot product, which still needs
- 24:30some improvement is the longer term installment loans that do
- 24:34have interest, but they've got more affordable payments over a
- 24:38longer period of time, you know, six months or a year now, you
- 24:41don't want to stack those up either.
- 24:43And they don't have the same clear dispute rates that credit
- 24:46cards have. So we don't quite have the
- 24:48Goldilocks product out there today, but I worry that buy now,
- 24:51pay later is too too short and too deceptively affordable.
- 24:56Credit cards are too long and too much interest in too much
- 25:00period of time, and people really in general need to be
- 25:04careful with credit no matter what they're using.
- 25:06Well, I'm a big believer in credit cards if use wisely.
- 25:09Use wisely means you make the purchase and you pay it off when
- 25:12the bill comes. You get all the fraud
- 25:14protection, you get chargeback rights.
- 25:16There's a lot of other perks that you get with credit card
- 25:18companies. And it also builds a credit
- 25:20history which by now pay later doesn't do.
- 25:22So I'm a believer that if you use a credit card wisely, and
- 25:26there are many millions of Americans who use credit cards
- 25:29wisely, that is a very smart way to go.
- 25:31Either you disagree with that. Well, again, my, my point was,
- 25:34you know, putting credit on your credit card and then carrying it
- 25:39for a long period of time. I mean, sure, I do.
- 25:40I buy everything on my credit card because I know I can afford
- 25:43to pay it off at the end of the month.
- 25:45But a lot of people can't do that.
- 25:46And so just paying the minimum payment for, you know, month
- 25:50after month where you're really just paying interest and not
- 25:52paying off the credit card, it's, you know, very easy to
- 25:55amass a lot of debt that is hard for people to handle.
- 25:59So if you can afford it, for sure, but it's not necessarily
- 26:02great for managing your finances if you're operating a little
- 26:05more paycheck to paycheck. Credit cards are great if you
- 26:08pay them off right away, and that's the key.
- 26:10It's roughly half and half when we talk about cardholders who
- 26:12pay it off right away and cardholders who carry
- 26:15potentially very expensive debt for a long period of time.
- 26:18I would note that credit cards are the gold standard in terms
- 26:21of buyer protections, everything from disputes to purchase
- 26:25protection, extended warranties, travel insurance.
- 26:28There are a lot of nice benefits there used properly and rewards
- 26:32are great too. So credit cards work to your
- 26:34advantage for about half of Americans.
- 26:37The other half, if you have pricey credit card debt, that's
- 26:40where I would say don't dig the hole any deeper.
- 26:42And for some of these people, buy now, pay later is a viable
- 26:45alternative. Sometimes it can get them into
- 26:48trouble. So you need to be careful about
- 26:50that. But like Lauren said too, you
- 26:52can use selectively. It's possible to have both.
- 26:55I mean, I could envision someone using buy now, pay later some of
- 26:58the time and credit card some of the time.
- 27:00It just depends on what you're being offered.
- 27:03If buy now, pay later is a good long term, low or no interest
- 27:07plan, that could make sense for your couch or refrigerator or
- 27:10something like that. But just be careful that you can
- 27:13swing the payments and think about that total cost of
- 27:15ownership, not just what's due every two weeks or every month.
- 27:19So let's bring it all home. If you are going to use buy now,
- 27:23Pay, pay later and some people are going to use it for certain
- 27:25purchases, I guess the rule would be try to have only one
- 27:28going at a time and pay that off and then move along to the next
- 27:31if you need to and make notes somewhere in a calendar as to
- 27:35when those payments are going to come out of your checking
- 27:37account so you make sure there's money in there.
- 27:39Anything else I missed? I think by now, pay later is
- 27:42really best for occasional purchases, not for routine
- 27:45everyday expenses. Occasional things where you've
- 27:48planned for the payments, you know you could afford them, you
- 27:51just need a little extra time. For a lot of people, I don't
- 27:54know what six weeks is really going to be enough extra time,
- 27:57but you know, for occasional purchases, sure it might be.
- 27:59Yeah, I would agree with that. One little anecdote that I
- 28:02thought was actually a very clever use of buy now pay later
- 28:05is I have a Co worker who used buy now pay later this winter to
- 28:08buy a season long ski pass. It was a $900 purchase.
- 28:12She split it into three interest free monthly installments of
- 28:15$300 a piece that worked for her.
- 28:18That was a nice way to spread out some cash flow and she had
- 28:21the money to pay for it, but it was kind of this, if they're
- 28:24going to give me 3 months interest free, I might as well
- 28:27take it. Used responsibly, that can make
- 28:29some sense and provide some breathing room in the household
- 28:32budget. But if you're spending $900 that
- 28:35you don't have on a ski pass or something else, what's to say
- 28:39it's going to be better in a month or two or three?
- 28:41So that again comes back to the know thyself.
- 28:45Know how you're going to use it. Go in with a plan.
- 28:47I mean, if you opt into something like that, make sure
- 28:50your budget allows for those three monthly payments of
- 28:53$300.00 so that you're not just kicking the can down the road
- 28:56and running into financial trouble later.
- 28:58Amen. Want to thank our guests
- 29:00tedrosmanseniorindustryanalyst@bankrate.com. My pleasure, good to be here.
- 29:05And Lawrence Saunders, associate director at the National
- 29:07Consumer Law Center. You'll find them on the web at
- 29:09nclc.org. Thanks so much.
- 29:11Great to be here. Let me jump in here with an
- 29:13update since we recorded this podcast.
- 29:16FICO, the company that provides credit scores to 90% of all
- 29:19lenders in the US, announced that it will soon include buy
- 29:23now, pay later, loan history and some of its new scoring models.
- 29:26The new credit scoring models will be introduced in the fall
- 29:29and individual lenders will decide whether to use them.
- 29:31You'll find a complete report about this in the Consumer News
- 29:34section of checkbook.org. Before we go a few related
- 29:38Consumerpedia episodes, you might want to check out episode
- 29:4180, Debt Busters Real Life Success Stories, and episode 50,
- 29:45Finding a Credit Card that's right for you.
- 29:48And with that, we come to the end of another episode.
- 29:51Thank you for listening. We hope you'll rate this episode
- 29:53episode and follow us on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever
- 29:56you listen to your podcasts. Remember, we release new
- 29:59episodes every other Thursday. Another way you can support this
- 30:03show is to follow us at Consumerpedia on Facebook and
- 30:06Instagram, at consumerpedia.org on Blue Sky, and at my
- 30:10Consumerpedia on X. You can find me at
- 30:14consumerman.com. I'm Herb Weisbaum, the consumer
- 30:17man always looking out for you. Until next time, be smart and
- 30:21shop wisely. Consumerpedia is a public
- 30:24service of checkbook.org. We're a unique nonprofit that
- 30:28helps you save money and make smarter choices.
- 30:30You can count on Checkbook to help you find the best services
- 30:33and avoid the worst with local ratings that are accurate and
- 30:36unbiased. If you live in or around these
- 30:39seven cities and haven't joined Checkbook yet, check us out
- 30:43Boston, Chicago, Philadelphia, Minneapolis, Saint Paul,
- 30:47Seattle, San Francisco and Washington DC.
- 30:50To get your free 30 day subscription, go to
- 30:52checkbook.org/consumer Pedia Consumer Pedia.
- 30:56Empowering consumers to save money and make smarter choices.