Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Final Settlement E007: Value 4 Value (Part II) with Sam Means of Wavlake
Transcript
- 0:02It all comes down to computers. Communicating the information
- 0:07superhighway can be a confusing mix of on ramps and off ramps.
- 0:11Bitcoin is worthless artificial gold.
- 0:16Is it still rat poison? Probably rat poison squared.
- 0:19We need to get into the world of, OK, this is actually
- 0:22foundational technology. What the Internet of Money does
- 0:26is it creates a single network which can do a microtransaction
- 0:32to a giga transaction. The Internet is going to be one
- 0:38of the major forces for reducing the role of God.
- 0:42The one thing that's missing, but that will soon be developed
- 0:46is a reliable E cash. Thank you for joining us for
- 0:52this week's episode of Final Settlement, a podcast from On
- 0:55RAMP Media. On today's show, we speak with
- 0:57Sam Means, the founder of Wave Lake, a music streaming app that
- 1:00seamlessly aligns incentives between creators and listeners
- 1:03through the power of open protocols.
- 1:05We explore the value for value model of content monetization,
- 1:08value driven social graphs and discovery mechanisms, and the
- 1:11issues with existing centralized creator platforms as well as
- 1:14ticketing systems. Sam and Wave Lake are innovators
- 1:17at the forefront of leveraging open protocols like Bitcoin,
- 1:20Lightning and Noster. To disrupt incumbent models by
- 1:23empowering both the user and the creator.
- 1:26Now time for the show. Welcome back to final
- 1:29settlement. Today we have on a guest Sam
- 1:33Means from Wave Lake. Very excited for this
- 1:35conversation. As as mentioned in previous pods
- 1:40on funnel settlement, we try to take a take a look at Bitcoin
- 1:42really more from a technological perspective as a piece of
- 1:46software and open protocol that people are building on.
- 1:49And one great example of of this sort of element of the Bitcoin
- 1:53thesis if you if you will is what the guys at at Wave Lake
- 1:57are building. And so really excited to have
- 1:58Sam on here and and talk through everything that they've done
- 2:01both on you know the music and streaming side but also more
- 2:04recently a few announcements about disagree meeting the the
- 2:08ticketing space as well. So excited to get into that, but
- 2:11welcome Sam. Thanks for coming on.
- 2:14Thanks for having me. I'm excited to be here.
- 2:16Glad we could finally make it work after few weeks moving
- 2:19stuff around, here we are. Yeah, I love it.
- 2:22I'm like, Brian said, very pumped for this conversation.
- 2:25You know, we've been talking for a few years.
- 2:27I think back my days when I was at 10:31 and some of the stuff
- 2:30you guys were doing and always found a passion for personal
- 2:33passion and and music and caring.
- 2:36You know it's something that's very visceral and when you get
- 2:39to that point you kind of you, you look at it differently than
- 2:45our any other experience and then because of that that
- 2:48experience matters from like the money side you start to think
- 2:51about it. One of the conversations we had
- 2:52early was back in the the COVID days when people used to play
- 2:57online and you would like tip them over like cash app.
- 3:01And I think now even if you go to like a local restaurant or
- 3:03wherever, you can tip them if they they put up the QR code,
- 3:06it's like there has to be better experience because people are
- 3:08really willing to actually put up dollars, hard earned capital
- 3:12for this feeling. And it just felt right for like
- 3:14this new wave of open protocols and value transfer to be able to
- 3:18figure out a better structure that has historically been kind
- 3:21of I think we'll talk about this for decades, if not longer,
- 3:24maybe it's over 100 years where creators have kind of just been
- 3:28cut out from middle men from their end value that they
- 3:31produce. Yeah, yeah, it's a it's a it's a
- 3:37cycle that keeps happening. It's been happening.
- 3:39We we say on calls. You know the just in the music
- 3:43industry alone, it's been essentially 100 years that
- 3:47artists have somehow gotten the low, the low end of the deal on
- 3:52on everything you've been dating back to, to how sheet music used
- 3:56to be sold. You know it just there's this
- 4:00thing that comes out that's a really cool connection from
- 4:02artist to fan and then people just get in the way and you know
- 4:07I think you you need people to create those those pathways.
- 4:10But hopefully with what we're working on here, we can we can
- 4:16act as a middleman, as the, as the on ramp.
- 4:18No pun intended. But we can build as we build
- 4:22these things, people, other people can adapt those in many
- 4:26different ways and many different clients and completely
- 4:28separate from us completely, you know.
- 4:29So yeah, it's exciting. It's exciting to actually be
- 4:34working on something that could potentially at least be the
- 4:37start of a new era for creators and artists.
- 4:42At ON RAMP, we believe that Bitcoin will be the most
- 4:44important asset to own in the 21st century.
- 4:47Our multi institution custody solution is the safest and most
- 4:50secure way to ensure that your Bitcoin remains in your in your
- 4:53family's possession for decades to come.
- 4:55Multi institution custody maximizes security and minimizes
- 4:58counterparty risk. Leveraging Bitcoin's native
- 5:01properties to eliminate single points of failure that have
- 5:03historically complicated Bitcoin ownership on RAMP provides Peace
- 5:07of Mind for your Bitcoin journey.
- 5:09For more information, check us out.
- 5:10At on rampbitcoin.com yeah, maybe it would be helpful just
- 5:14to sort of take a step back and and learn a little bit about,
- 5:18you know, your background, how you got into the music business.
- 5:20But then also you know how you found Bitcoin and then sort of
- 5:24you know secondarily to that, like you know what, what were
- 5:27the problems that you identified in the existing sort of music
- 5:31industry and and how did Bitcoin ultimately help sort of map how
- 5:35you would attack those inefficiencies or or issues that
- 5:38you that you had identified? Yeah, it's a lot.
- 5:43I'll try not to be super long winded here.
- 5:45I'll try to give the the Cliff notes version.
- 5:47So yeah, I mean I've been, I've been in music ever since I I
- 5:51could. I mean, I started playing guitar
- 5:52when I was like 9 or 10 or something and got into The
- 5:56Beatles and and as soon as I found out you could be in a
- 6:00band, I started one with my friends.
- 6:03And that turned into, you know, going to a ton of concerts.
- 6:08And that turned into working for the venue and that turned into
- 6:12being a concert promoter and and all the while still making music
- 6:15and figuring out ways to you know utilize those business
- 6:22elements and to to to benefit the band and how kind of sort of
- 6:25how that structure works. I mean I even at one point in
- 6:27time was making websites and and posters and all kinds of you
- 6:32know just doing graphic design for artists and talking to the
- 6:34managers and just figuring out how the the behind the scenes of
- 6:37all that stuff. How everything worked and then
- 6:41ultimately got into a a a more successful band got signed to a
- 6:46major label. It was something I knew from my
- 6:52my DIY background probably wasn't a great idea but it
- 6:58seemed like a a good way to get some money that we would never
- 7:02have to pay back and we could maybe use it to to kick start
- 7:05something. But what I didn't fully
- 7:09understand is the I guess the implications that truly come
- 7:14with that which is you're you are stuck.
- 7:16Like you are truly stuck at a certain point.
- 7:18So what ended up happening is that was not really a a timely
- 7:22deal. The record industry started
- 7:24falling apart. That was in 2003, The beginning
- 7:28of 2004 a bunch of the major labels collapsed.
- 7:31I was on Electra that completely folded after you know 40
- 7:36something years and and we got moved to Atlantic Records and
- 7:41then we were stuck there in just this weird limbo period for a
- 7:43couple of years until we ultimately got dropped.
- 7:46This all connects at some point I promise.
- 7:49So we you know from that point forward it it just I I just sort
- 7:55of made a decision never to or at least to try to never do
- 7:58anything like that again. I mean certainly never do
- 8:00anything just for money. It was you know it didn't feel
- 8:03great going into it but it you know when you're in your early
- 8:0520s and you're broke and you're just trying to live your dream
- 8:10you just you sometimes you make mistakes.
- 8:12So went on to be pretty DIY from that point.
- 8:17We started putting out our own records, started doing our own
- 8:20merchandise, tried out a lot of interesting experiments from,
- 8:27you know that point, like 2005 into 2008 or 2009 or 2008.
- 8:32I guess a few years of just trying stuff out like giving out
- 8:36our music for free just doing interesting things around
- 8:40touring and you know Fast forward from there.
- 8:45I I the van broke up I started merch company.
- 8:48I just sort of on the IT. It rolled over into doing merch
- 8:53for my band to just doing merch for a bunch of bands and then I
- 8:58so then I got really heavily into e-commerce and then you
- 9:01know 2014 I think after a couple years of a friend of mine some
- 9:07people may may know him. Mike Jarmus, someone I knew from
- 9:12back in Arizona in middle school.
- 9:14He had been telling me about Bitcoin for a couple years and
- 9:18and I just saw an opportunity through.
- 9:20I think at the time it was BitPay connected to Shopify and
- 9:23I was like, I'll just turn it on and see if anybody uses it.
- 9:27And that was my first interaction with Bitcoin was
- 9:29just, can this be used in commerce?
- 9:33Will people use it? And it's more of an experiment
- 9:35like I'll just turn this on and see if people use it, see what
- 9:38happens. Cause I mean it's really easy to
- 9:41set up an e-commerce store. Now the credit card networks
- 9:45have changed so much in the last 16 years since I started this,
- 9:49the merch business that I have. But it's always been tough.
- 9:54I mean you can you know I've I've, I've, I've I've stopped
- 9:58using PayPal now completely because they froze one time.
- 10:01They froze up just a large amount of money for no reason
- 10:03with no explanation. And you know, you just, you
- 10:06really see like how you know at the mercy you are.
- 10:12I have a lot of these credit card companies and payment
- 10:15channels. So the idea of of Bitcoin and
- 10:18being able to interact around the world essentially for free
- 10:22really was interesting to me. So I did that for a number of
- 10:26years and then I heard about the Lightning Network, you know a
- 10:28few years later skip ahead 2017 I think or 2018 somewhere around
- 10:34there. Whenever that started picking
- 10:36up, same thing I just I was it was more so just seemed like a
- 10:43an improvement on this, on the utility of spending it.
- 10:46So I got into it, but I really had no idea how to participate.
- 10:51But I definitely started getting more interested in getting
- 10:54involved somehow. So I started going to some
- 10:56conferences and paying attention and spun up a couple nodes and
- 11:00did that whole thing, but wasn't until 20/21 when I discovered
- 11:08you know, through I think Marty's podcast listening to
- 11:11Paul from Sphinx talk about how they were streaming money
- 11:16through this application and that that really connected all
- 11:19the dots for me. So then I not only was I
- 11:23thinking about the, there's the e-commerce aspect of it, but
- 11:27then I started thinking, well, if you can stream this money,
- 11:30what can you do with music and how can I, you know, how can I
- 11:35help this. This is now going to help with
- 11:36physical merchandise and physical exchange of goods.
- 11:40But also this could work digitally for for streaming and
- 11:45start to solve potentially solve that problem.
- 11:48That was really starting to ramp up at that point.
- 11:51So I spent the next couple years really just like going out on
- 11:57Twitter and trying to find people who might be interested
- 12:00in building something on Bitcoin and Lightning that would, you
- 12:08know, be be heavily focused on music.
- 12:11So yeah, I mean 2000, end of 2022 or something.
- 12:16I met Michael Rhee, who's a Co founder of Wave Lake.
- 12:20He started an early version of Wave Lake before we officially
- 12:23teamed up and I was his first beta tester.
- 12:29And we just kept in touch and he tried it for a year and it
- 12:33didn't really work. And so we put our heads together
- 12:37and sort of read change a bunch of things around you know that
- 12:42that the point at that at that point it was it was kind of a
- 12:47paywall thing and we decided to to change it into a distribution
- 12:51channel and that really opened the door for a lot of stuff and
- 12:55got us essentially to where we are today which is you know it's
- 13:01it kind of encapsulates all of those all that stuff I just
- 13:03talked about it like brings it into a place where now we're
- 13:09building something that could potentially be the starting
- 13:14point. The portal for everything is my
- 13:16current catch phrase I'm working on.
- 13:19It really is kind of the portal for everything for an artist.
- 13:23You know, in the future you, you come here, you distribute your
- 13:26digital music, you come here, you, you, you're live streaming,
- 13:30you're you're doing something that feels similar to Patreon,
- 13:33you know, but without the pressure of the the monthly
- 13:36subscription. You're releasing your music to
- 13:38multiple clients and social media and platforms and and
- 13:44maybe booking, you know, selling tickets and events and all kinds
- 13:48of things. So building that social layer is
- 13:52what we're working on now and starting to think about some of
- 13:55these bigger picture things. But that's that's how I got
- 13:58here. It's amazing.
- 14:01It's it's cool. Like we mentioned in the top,
- 14:04you know, we haven't chatted in a while and here in the
- 14:06progress, you know, portal for everything and what that means.
- 14:09And we'll dig into it because it sounds exciting and like again,
- 14:13loving music, just knowing that these tools need to exist that
- 14:16are more kind of like rooted in what's needed from a participant
- 14:20side with an also creator. But you said something early
- 14:23that I know you're very passionate about and knows the
- 14:26creator. I'm sorry.
- 14:27Being stuck with the record label, I think it's really
- 14:30helpful to like understand where people get stuck and how that
- 14:33that model's broken because I think that'll help And just our
- 14:37side understanding and anybody listening and like how
- 14:39foundation because I think most people inherently know a lot of
- 14:42the music industry has been kind of crazy or even maybe
- 14:45entertainment in general. But like the intermediate
- 14:47intermediaries that like rent, seek and all of that process I
- 14:50think is helpful to to understand better.
- 14:52Yeah, I mean it's it's so complicated.
- 14:56But I guess to simplify it as much as I can, it's just things
- 15:01are always when when you're starting out or even just in the
- 15:04process, you know, maybe you're a few years in, everything is
- 15:08just out of reach for the most part.
- 15:10You know, it's like when I was a kid and I was growing up, it
- 15:14was, it was touring. It was like get in a van and
- 15:16tour, you know, So that seems easy.
- 15:19But you need a booking agent or you're just going around and
- 15:24booking crappy shows that you know aren't going to get paid or
- 15:27have people have people there. So you need a booking agent, but
- 15:31you can't get a booking agent until you have a record deal.
- 15:33And you can't get a record deal until this happens.
- 15:36And so everything is just like kind of one step ahead of you
- 15:40unless you somehow do something and stumble into something that
- 15:46that makes you just shiny enough that that record label or that
- 15:51booking agent that you know, that person sees you and
- 15:54discovers you and gives you something and now it just opens
- 15:57up all the other doors for you. But when that happens, you don't
- 16:01just you have to give up a lot, you know, you have to give up in
- 16:04that how what that looks like today is totally different from
- 16:07when I was a kid. But now it's like you have to
- 16:10battle through TikTok and build up a massive following on social
- 16:16media so that the because the label doesn't know how to
- 16:19develop record labeled, the music industry doesn't really
- 16:22know how to develop artists anymore because everything's
- 16:25changed so much in the last 10 to 15 years and they just
- 16:28haven't kept up. You know, the way they used to
- 16:29develop artists is very different.
- 16:31We don't have radio anymore, barely.
- 16:33There's no college radio. There's or at least none that,
- 16:36you know, it's making any kind of like significant impact
- 16:39around the world or the country. And so they don't, they don't
- 16:43know what to do. So now they just kind of put all
- 16:45that pressure on on the artists and that pulls them away from
- 16:51their what what they should just be doing is just making music.
- 16:55But now they're now they're content creators and and they
- 16:58build up this following and they do all the heavy lifting and
- 17:00then a record label will come and you know, like, hey, thanks
- 17:06for doing that. Now you're ours.
- 17:07You know, if if you want to here's a little bit of money and
- 17:10some promise of success, but it it doesn't usually work out like
- 17:15that, you know. So it's just it's it's like most
- 17:19of you you you have to do something that you don't really
- 17:21want to do so that you can keep doing the thing you want to do.
- 17:26That's kind of the the deal that's like the handshake and it
- 17:29always feels kind of gross, you know.
- 17:30So I I think we're just trying to step in and help with this
- 17:39idea of you still need a little bit of help.
- 17:43You do need someone to have this bridge you you might need a
- 17:45platform, you might need a service, you know.
- 17:48But, but if you want to just make have that connection
- 17:53straight with your fans and and that can be something that can
- 17:56now be monetized in a way that brings way more value to you and
- 18:02allows you to to just be a regular musician or artist or do
- 18:06the thing that you that you truly love doing at your pace.
- 18:10That's going to be really important for people and they
- 18:13won't be as desperate to connect with these other avenues that
- 18:20typically you would have to do because they're able to just
- 18:24live as artists now because their fans are able to to help
- 18:28them in a way that they've really never been able to do
- 18:30before. Because right now it's you know
- 18:32it's touring is still great but it's becoming very hard,
- 18:35difficult to tour just because it's expensive.
- 18:39It's way too expensive. And a lot of the venues have
- 18:41been bought up by Live Nation and bigger companies.
- 18:44And so touring just doesn't exist the same way it did 20
- 18:47years ago. And yeah, it's tough.
- 18:52It's tough. It's it's really it.
- 18:54We're sort of in this weird area between between cycles of, you
- 19:00know, the the peak of digital streaming and sort of the peak
- 19:06of social media and what is about to come next is the
- 19:11exciting part. Yeah, I'm, I'm curious if you
- 19:14can sort of pull on that thread a bit of you know being able to
- 19:20monetize your content or whatever you're creating in a
- 19:25way that was previously not possible without without
- 19:27Bitcoin. Like the this concept of value
- 19:30for value for folks that aren't necessarily familiar with what
- 19:33that means. And it would be helpful to sort
- 19:35of breakdown, you know, the actual logistics of of what what
- 19:40this model for monetization looks like for creators and why
- 19:44it's a, you know, arguably a step function improvement on
- 19:47what we just outlined in terms of you know, whether in in sort
- 19:52of previous eras you had to get a record deal.
- 19:56Now there's social media, but you know that's not necessarily,
- 19:59you know a great way to monetize unless you have you know
- 20:02millions of followers and maybe it's a creative to some sense
- 20:05but what what is Bitcoin and in this value for value model
- 20:09unlock that was was really not previously possible.
- 20:14Yeah. So I guess the main, the main
- 20:18difference now is you know you're building up a following
- 20:21in a very specific place. This is why we like Noster and
- 20:26why we integrated it so quickly even though it's still so new
- 20:30and people are very skeptical of it.
- 20:35We we don't really want everybody coming to Wave Lake,
- 20:38you know, we we want Wave Lake to be just the the, the place
- 20:41where the music gets pushed off and now it's everywhere.
- 20:44We started building, we started building things to to highlight
- 20:50how that stuff works, but not not to get people to come there
- 20:54necessarily, but just to as a showcase to show like hey, this
- 20:57is what this is what's possible here.
- 20:59You know, here's a music player, here's a mobile app, here's a
- 21:02here's a Nostra client. Now take all the stuff and you
- 21:06guys go do this and implement it in your stuff.
- 21:10So you know this is still somewhat conceptual, but it's
- 21:14like if you build up a big following right now on let's say
- 21:18you'd you know on Wave Lake and Wave Lake starts to suck.
- 21:21But whether you realize it or not your social profile, you
- 21:26know soon we're sort of unifying this across the the desktop and
- 21:30the mobile version. But ultimately you're you're
- 21:33just building up a following on Noster which is an open protocol
- 21:37where your identity can really live anywhere.
- 21:39And so whereas in the past you build that up on Instagram or
- 21:44TikTok or YouTube or whatever it is and they start to roll out
- 21:50advertising. You know after a a couple years
- 21:52they get you hooked in and you've built built up your
- 21:54following and now you have to start interacting the way they
- 21:59want you to interact so that you're feeding those algorithms
- 22:01and and they're able to you know manipulate that that content
- 22:10however they however they want to.
- 22:11So next thing you know you're essentially just creating stuff
- 22:15for a computer algorithm in hopes that it's going to feed it
- 22:19to the people that actually are following you here.
- 22:23I mean I'm sure with Noster and some other things and there will
- 22:26be algorithms, but I guess the main difference is if they start
- 22:31to, they start to suck. You can just take your following
- 22:34wherever you want, you know. So if Wavely starts to become a
- 22:39bad social client, maybe it's still a great place to to
- 22:44distribute your music. But maybe, you know, we're doing
- 22:46something that you don't like and so you can just go to go to
- 22:50Fountain or go to maybe even like a social media client, like
- 22:55not like a primal or or Dom is one of those things.
- 22:58And then maybe they've now figured out a way that they have
- 23:05and a good way for them to implement music as a service.
- 23:08You know, much like Fountain has, like Fountain only did
- 23:11podcast, but now the Wave Lake catalog's on Fountain and
- 23:13they've started adding features for music and playlists and and
- 23:17they've they're experiment experimenting with some other
- 23:20things like the jukebox they did a couple months ago.
- 23:24So yeah, I mean, I think it's it.
- 23:27It's still such a a fund, developmental, early stage.
- 23:31But I guess the idea is just you should own your Internet
- 23:37identity and you should be able to take that with you wherever
- 23:41you want. You know, maybe it's not even
- 23:43that one client's doing a bad job.
- 23:45Maybe it's just you, you make music and now you want to start
- 23:47making videos. It's really cool to just think
- 23:50that you just pop over to that video client and everyone's
- 23:53there with you. You know, whoever's using that
- 23:55video client, if they're following you on wavelength,
- 23:58they're following you there too. So I think as it grows that's
- 24:04that's going to be one of the main catalyst that drives people
- 24:07to it is once they realize they can hop around the Internet with
- 24:11this identity and everyone's there with them, you know, so
- 24:14you're not having to start over when a client, when a product,
- 24:17when a platform starts to change the rules on you or you get you
- 24:24do something wrong and you get kicked off of it or whatever.
- 24:26You know, it's like that kind of stuff won't necessarily happen
- 24:30with this, with this new idea. So yeah, we're very optimistic
- 24:35about it, but it is, it's new, you know, so a lot of people are
- 24:39very unsure we are as well. But it's it's the best thing out
- 24:44there right now for us to utilize for the the social
- 24:47elements and the engagement. And if we want to, if we want
- 24:51people, if we want this to work cross-platform, then it's the
- 24:54way to go right now. I think, I think one of the
- 25:00interesting dynamics is like on the artist side, right, Because
- 25:03generally things like this are two sided.
- 25:05You need to have the listeners, but then to get the listeners,
- 25:08you know you need the the artists and they kind of come
- 25:10back. If you want to get paid, you
- 25:11need listeners or people that are going to use the app.
- 25:14Yeah, I've always thought like the the artist side, this is
- 25:17like the one unique experience where the artists, it's natural
- 25:20because they want the relationship, they have a
- 25:22relationship with the end user and they can help move them.
- 25:24I think we saw this like Kanye in title, right?
- 25:26And there's different flavors of artists have followings that can
- 25:29really move in mass as individuals.
- 25:33That dynamic that exists today with the aggregators like
- 25:35Spotify and and Apple like understanding the, you know for
- 25:39that 1% or 3% that actually get paid anything there or the rest
- 25:44of that long tail gets basically peanuts if if even peanuts and
- 25:48why they would opt for a better experience or value transfer I
- 25:52think is important to like why the structure starts to like
- 25:55move over where we could see growth.
- 25:58Yeah. And it's, you know, people talk
- 26:00about these things not having enough users yet, which is true.
- 26:05They don't. You know, I think Nostra has
- 26:06like 13,000 daily users or something.
- 26:08But you know, you get if if the clients are there, if the if the
- 26:17clients are there and they can easily onboard fans and and
- 26:22create that connection and it's seamless.
- 26:24You know, like Primal's really good for social and you can buy
- 26:28Bitcoin there and it just makes it really easy.
- 26:32We're doing that with our mobile app, like working on just making
- 26:34sure like when we roll that out to the public.
- 26:36You can beta test it now on wavelake.com, but if you know
- 26:40eventually when it's in the app stores and stuff, it's going to
- 26:43have to be a seamless experience so that someone discovers it and
- 26:47they have maybe they have a 500,000 fans or something and
- 26:51they get on and the current community on there starts doing
- 26:54their thing and being generous and discovering this music and
- 26:58they're like wow, this is really refreshing, this is cool and
- 27:01they go out and they tell their their actual fans, hey, this is
- 27:05a really great place to support me.
- 27:07I've been here for a week and I've already made X amount and
- 27:10that's that feels really good and I'm like communicating with
- 27:13people then if they bring over their people you know that that
- 27:18could move the needle overnight if you get the right person to
- 27:23do that and if you're set up to scale quickly like that.
- 27:27So you know it could it could be something like Wave Lake.
- 27:33I I I certainly think social media is a great start.
- 27:37But I think it's it it's sort of peaking you know, at this point
- 27:40because we have everyone over from Twitter that's probably
- 27:43going to come here at least at least the big boom for now.
- 27:46You know until there's until there's a significant thing.
- 27:48I mean a lot. So many people are talking about
- 27:51what needs to happen next in order to to really move the
- 27:54needle there. And I think it could be it's
- 27:56going to be something or need to be something like music or
- 27:59gaming or someplace that just where you have these these
- 28:02people that can really change things overnight.
- 28:05You know, you get a small handful of artists talking about
- 28:08the value of of this new exchange that they're finding.
- 28:11And that could spark something huge that just starts
- 28:16compounding, you know, snowballing down.
- 28:18And next thing you know, you could have, within a week, you
- 28:20could have multiples of what you have.
- 28:23And much like what happened when Jack first started talking about
- 28:27it in December, you know, like that that type of thing can
- 28:30happen over and over and over again, but with much larger
- 28:33audiences. Yeah, it's almost like the, you
- 28:37know, the earliest adopters of these protocols of these
- 28:41networks, whether it's Noster or you know, just using lightning
- 28:44for for value, for value streaming.
- 28:46It's like, you know, the the the first people who adopt that are
- 28:49going to be, you know, largely bitcoiners, people on Twitter
- 28:52who are just interested in the tech.
- 28:53And I think it's, it's interesting in the sense that,
- 28:58you know, I'm curious how we cross that chasm of whether it's
- 29:03an artist or, you know, someone creating any form of content,
- 29:07getting them to recognize that this isn't just about Bitcoin.
- 29:11This is just a a better, a better product or a better
- 29:13experience, a better way for you to monetize what you're
- 29:15creating, right. Like if we can get them to that
- 29:19point of understanding, then it starts to, you know, inflect
- 29:24this flywheel of they're not just adopting it because it's
- 29:28Bitcoin and it's and they think Bitcoin is interesting, they're
- 29:30adopting it because it's a better product or service or
- 29:32experience, right. And they might not even know
- 29:34that Bitcoin is on the back end, but they're.
- 29:36They shouldn't know. They shouldn't have to exactly.
- 29:39Yeah. And that's that's our main goal.
- 29:41Like we, we tried to barely even use the word Bitcoin, 'cause
- 29:45it's, it's a turn off, if anything, for most people, you
- 29:48know, Yeah, I mean I have 10 years of education on this.
- 29:52And luckily the education part is getting easier, like things
- 29:56are definitely getting easier. It's there's it's so much more
- 29:59in the mainstream now than it was 10 years ago, obviously.
- 30:02So you know, you don't need as much time to learn, but you
- 30:06really shouldn't have to learn anything at all.
- 30:09You don't have to learn how to use TikTok, really, You know,
- 30:12it's pretty seamless. You don't have to learn how to
- 30:13use Twitter. It's just the idea is simple.
- 30:15You just get on. You don't have to know how you
- 30:19know. So many people use this all the
- 30:22time, but it's like you don't have to know how HTTPS and
- 30:24e-mail work. You know, they just work.
- 30:26You just have to. The barrier for entry is really
- 30:29low. And so that's what I think most
- 30:32of us are trying to do, especially with Noster and and
- 30:35these new Bitcoin apps is, you know it it has to be easy.
- 30:39The the, the education piece. Our Roy from Breeze had a really
- 30:45cool article. I think it was called an orange.
- 30:47Orange Pilling is no longer working or something like that.
- 30:50You know, and it's I mean it's smart.
- 30:53He's right. It it's there's only so far you
- 30:56can keep having this orange pill conversation with people.
- 31:00You know it's like all of my friends and everybody knows that
- 31:03I like Bitcoin and I'm a dork and I'm doing all.
- 31:06I've tried all these things and you know eventually they'll
- 31:10figure out and some of come over and whatever.
- 31:12But until there's something that like really they can just use
- 31:15that actually has a better a better function for them and
- 31:19Wave lake's not even there. I mean I have a ton of friends
- 31:21in that are in bands I have. I work with a ton of musicians
- 31:25and I I haven't even brought this up yet.
- 31:28You know, like they've caught wind of Wave Lake, but it's just
- 31:30not ready yet and I want it. I don't want to miss that
- 31:33opportunity to say like hey, go check this out and not have it
- 31:38be right, you know, and not have it work.
- 31:39So yeah, it's just it's just going to take some time and it's
- 31:45hard because it's, you know, when you're working on stuff
- 31:47like this, it's it's hard to get funding.
- 31:49It's hard to get things going. Your resources are limited.
- 31:52You can only move so fast and it's we have a million ideas and
- 31:57a ton of stuff we want to do and we have to just really be
- 32:00patient and try to think through this outing.
- 32:04There's there's there's three of us that we've like and I don't
- 32:07code anything so I'm not much help there.
- 32:09I'm just sort of being obnoxious and hoping things can get done
- 32:15and and somehow magically they do between Michael and Josh.
- 32:17So yeah, it's you know it's if people, it's our job on this
- 32:24side of things to just really support the people that are
- 32:28building these projects and and do the best that we can and and
- 32:32try to get things to work for us.
- 32:34If they're not working for us, they're definitely not going to
- 32:36work for anybody else. That's the that's the main thing
- 32:38right now. It's like we have to get like
- 32:40100% of the Bitcoin people have to be into Wave Lake or else no
- 32:44one's no one's going to use it. Can't expect the mainstream to
- 32:47use it if if if you know someone on this podcast, can't figure it
- 32:53out. Yeah I think that's where like
- 32:55it gets a bad rap but why price is the ultimate function forcing
- 32:59function because I when I think about you know one of the
- 33:03forcing functions for a wavelength and and the growth of
- 33:05that is like the artist moving over and taking over like you
- 33:08referenced really making a size of change even on the Noster
- 33:11side of things. But what what takes an artist to
- 33:15move over and they have to really go down the the rabbit
- 33:17hole and like you know one of the easiest ways to start get
- 33:20them started on that is that price appreciation and the the
- 33:22market sentiment and the awareness and then the natural
- 33:25progression happens like that. We've seen it happen time and
- 33:28time again every time we like go up and so but then the other
- 33:34part is like in the growth and we we see it's like you have the
- 33:36price appreciation but it's starting to come to like the
- 33:40vision of the utility maps to the price in parallel.
- 33:43So like price goes up and people like number go up but then
- 33:45utility goes up in parallel and generally it comes down to like
- 33:49oh which happens 1st that I think it like happens together,
- 33:51right. We're like price goes up and
- 33:53then these services or platforms exist.
- 33:56And the one that it seems like incredible when I was listening
- 34:00to today you and Marty on the the the pod discussing the
- 34:04ticketing side of things. Because again like on the
- 34:09there's just, it's so perfect for music because there's a
- 34:11natural relationship that we keep anchoring to with the
- 34:14individual artist and and the individual that transcends like
- 34:18the platform or anything related to like lock in.
- 34:21So if they say hey, do this or try this, they will just go
- 34:24naturally there because they have a tie to that artist and
- 34:27they think about what's happening with the events and
- 34:29the the ticket set up and and would love for you to kind of
- 34:32like tie tie that in like how broken that is.
- 34:35But everybody knows when you go buy a ticket you see all these
- 34:37crazy surcharges and all the craziness with like, you know
- 34:40Taylor Swift and all these fees. And there's this indie guy
- 34:43that's kind of blown up and you might know of him, Sam.
- 34:45Just because being a music of Zac Bryant and Zac Bryant and
- 34:48following him for years and he was like putting.
- 34:49He was in the Navy and put YouTube videos and you know
- 34:53that's where he. I think he got actually got big
- 34:54and got honorably discharged from the Navy to go pursue his
- 34:57passion and blew up the past two years.
- 34:59And he loves his fans. He came from like small town
- 35:01Oklahoma and would love for his fans be able to see him at
- 35:04$15.20. He literally can't because every
- 35:07time he does it, they just completely crush it.
- 35:09And like when you guys were talking about this idea of like
- 35:12the social graph on Noster and him and being able to map to the
- 35:15followers and knowing that these people have actually exchanged
- 35:17value for listening and then opening that these tickets only
- 35:20up for these people. If he knew of that he would 100%
- 35:23move over. I know without question like we
- 35:25were able to get in touch with him because that's all he's
- 35:27looking for is like that experience.
- 35:29And especially as counterculture like grows and that's like what
- 35:33music is, right. It's kind of like counterculture
- 35:34when it starts. It's like the opposite of what
- 35:36people are popular with. That's like this is where that I
- 35:39could see it tying into is just having a better relationship
- 35:42with your end user and then artists start to learn that and
- 35:44if you can monetize it just all like works out downstream.
- 35:48So anyway, long way to way of saying like you could see the
- 35:50path, it's just obviously takes time with appreciation.
- 35:53The tools have to be pulled out. Yeah, I mean the ticket thing is
- 35:56so, so early. I mean if if if the if wavelike
- 36:00with music and all these and noster and all these things are
- 36:02early. I mean this is like a you know
- 36:05the idea of that being even remotely ready for someone like
- 36:08that is it's gonna take a lot of work you know.
- 36:12But the the cool thing about it is that it all those things are
- 36:16possible like it is it is completely possible and it might
- 36:19you know maybe he does catch wind of this some point in time
- 36:22and just fund somebody to build that that platform and that's
- 36:25the cool thing. That's the other cool thing
- 36:27about it. It's like it's there, somebody
- 36:29go build it. Like we don't have to do it in
- 36:31Wave Lake. That was literally just like we
- 36:33had a show in Nashville, a show in Nashville coming up and
- 36:36around the conference on the 25th.
- 36:38And we're just like, hey, wouldn't be cool if we could
- 36:41just this this idea that we've had of artists being able to to
- 36:46go live on Wave Lake eventually and do an RSVP.
- 36:50You know, it would be nice to know how many people are going
- 36:53to show up or like you're you're booking a small tour somewhere
- 36:57or whatever, you know, you can just be able to throw up a
- 36:59ticket. It's just going to be very
- 37:01helpful for for an artist. So we just did it as part of our
- 37:05annual, our our new annual hackathon thing.
- 37:09Last year we did it, it was the mobile app, we did a proof of
- 37:12concept called Wave Man, which was essentially turned into our
- 37:14mobile app. And this year it was the ticket.
- 37:18Let's just let's our little hackathon will be like can you
- 37:20guys get this done in a couple weeks.
- 37:24And they did and it works and it's really cool.
- 37:26And it it actually, yeah. I mean there's if if you go back
- 37:29and listen to this the TFTC episode that we did this week,
- 37:34we go into much more detail. But there's everything you need
- 37:39we need to be able to do for ticketing.
- 37:40We can do it. You know we can totally do it.
- 37:43We can limit and control the resale market.
- 37:47We can he said identify your number one fans.
- 37:50I mean, I'm I'm in a band. I put some shows up on sale a
- 37:55few years ago before COVID, and they didn't end up happening
- 37:58because it killed the whole thing.
- 38:00But you know we wanted we you try to do the thing.
- 38:03You try to like get a promo code that's just for your mailing
- 38:07list and just for the the people that are really paying the most
- 38:11close attention to you and you just can't.
- 38:13It just ends it ends up getting manipulated somehow.
- 38:17And I mentioned on a couple shows, I feel like this last
- 38:21couple weeks, you know, someone like Maggie Rogers is a great
- 38:24artist who's doing physical outlets to try to combat that a
- 38:29little bit like you have to actually show up and buy a paper
- 38:32ticket at a retail. You know it's old school but it
- 38:36helped back in the day. You know you'd have to go to the
- 38:37department store or record store or something and get your ticket
- 38:40for the show which scalping was still a problem then but it
- 38:43definitely helped like there weren't bots you know and that
- 38:46that type of thing that we see now.
- 38:48So yeah I mean we're really excited.
- 38:51I don't I don't know where. You know it's that's the fun
- 38:56part of building on Bitcoin and Lightning and Noster and living
- 39:01in this world right now is it's it's really open.
- 39:04You know how the how this stuff ends up integrating with Wave
- 39:07Lake and through other projects and events.
- 39:10I don't I don't know we'll see how it shakes out but we're
- 39:11definitely very excited to be able to be working on ticketing
- 39:16right now because we didn't think we would be when we when
- 39:18we first launched in January of last year.
- 39:22You know the Noster was very barely on our radar just kind of
- 39:27coming into focus and had no idea what we could do with it.
- 39:31And now you know fast forwarding just barely a year later.
- 39:35It's cool to be able to start now we have a mobile app and now
- 39:39we're working on ticketing and our next integration of this is
- 39:42coming out in a couple weeks will be like way more of a
- 39:45social layer And all these things we just didn't think we'd
- 39:47be able to do for years. We're suddenly able to do
- 39:51relatively quickly. Whether you're a seasoned
- 39:54bitcoiner or brand new to the asset class, On RAMP provides a
- 39:57best in class private client experience.
- 39:59To ensure that your Bitcoin remains accessible, secure, and
- 40:02in your control, I'll have a dedicated advisor to guide you
- 40:05every step of the way. If you want to meet in person,
- 40:07we now have on ramp branches in New York, New Jersey,
- 40:10Philadelphia, Nashville, Dallas, Austin, Houston, Los Angeles and
- 40:15Denver with more on the way. Check out on
- 40:18rampbitcoin.com/branches to learn more and get connected
- 40:22with our team. Yeah, the the ticketing stuff is
- 40:25is really fascinating to me because you know if you think of
- 40:28if you well one, it's just complementary to what you're
- 40:31already doing and sort of the music space in terms of
- 40:33streaming. But to me it's it's even more
- 40:38tangible is the wrong word, but it's like, you know people who
- 40:41stream music on Apple or Spotify, like most of the normie
- 40:44crowd is like pretty pleased with that experience I would
- 40:47presume, right. Whereas like with ticketing, I
- 40:49think everyone can agree like the ticketing experience is is
- 40:53pretty bad and it's gotten worse over the years.
- 40:55Yeah, it's just the the fees that that feel prohibitive or
- 41:01it's just that you know the various platforms, the lock in
- 41:04the the you know whatever it may be.
- 41:07I think it's something that people will appreciate.
- 41:10You know the normal person who doesn't understand Bitcoin will
- 41:12appreciate a different method of ticketing where you know they're
- 41:16actually getting the ticket directly from the artist.
- 41:18It is is like a very interesting concept.
- 41:20So I I'd be curious if you could walk through a little, maybe a
- 41:23little bit more detail like how logistically the ticket bot in
- 41:26particular works and then like what you envision can be built
- 41:29on top of it because obviously it's very early stage and sort
- 41:32of a prototype MVP type release. But just you know, where do you
- 41:36envision this going and? That would be interesting.
- 41:40Yeah, I mean, I'm, I'm not the, the dev at Wave Lake, so I can't
- 41:45get too too nerdy here. But I'll try to just, you know,
- 41:49walk through the the Normy explanation of this.
- 41:53Yeah. I mean at its simplest form.
- 41:54I mean you are, you're on, you're on the Wave Lake app, go
- 41:59download the Wave Wave Link app and you're on Noster.
- 42:02You may not realize it. We're going to make it even more
- 42:04so so that you don't really have to think about that right now.
- 42:08You know there's language in there that's pretty technical
- 42:11and and dorky so and most people are using that our app at that
- 42:15app are familiar with NOSTER. But you know what's happening is
- 42:19you are, you know, cryptographically signing into a
- 42:23a Noster client. There's a listing that is a,
- 42:30there's an event Nip I guess that is universal for all
- 42:35clients that read this calendar, this calendar event type that's
- 42:40happening. It was really cool because we we
- 42:44listed this and then I think it was coracle or one of the other
- 42:46things at one point in time implemented a calendar for
- 42:49Noster events and it just automatically populated there,
- 42:51which was really cool. That was just a very early peek
- 42:54at how this could work across client.
- 42:58But today the way it works is you just, you know you go into
- 43:00Wave Lake, you see an event listing you you click on it.
- 43:06We made this a total value for value thing.
- 43:08So there's a one sat minimum just to just to state that there
- 43:12is some purchase price you can pay one sat you can pay a
- 43:17million Sats, you can do whatever you want.
- 43:19That money's getting distributed to the artists that are
- 43:23performing on the 25th of July in Nashville.
- 43:27But then what happens is you're you're signing, you're
- 43:30essentially signing it with your Noster identity within the app
- 43:34on your social client. It's let's say you're using
- 43:37Primal or Domus, you're going to get Adm from the ticket bot that
- 43:41gives you your information. Your ticket will also live
- 43:43within Wave Lake, but you'll get in your DMS, you'll get all your
- 43:47ticket information and you know when you get to the door there's
- 43:51AQR code. It's very similar to how most
- 43:53well call ticketing works today. Scan AQR code and verify that
- 43:57you're there. Where we see it going, I mean
- 44:00just like a couple cool features you you want to sell that
- 44:04ticket, someone else has to essentially sign it and so it's,
- 44:10you know you can kind of do that now with with Ticketmaster.
- 44:12I think they have a thing where it can only go from Ticketmaster
- 44:16app to Ticketmaster app if you want to, if you want to sell it.
- 44:19Unless of course you're selling it on the secondary market,
- 44:23which I think Ticketmaster owns and they they get to double dip
- 44:26on on or one of the secondary markets.
- 44:30But you know in the future, let's say this is my event and
- 44:35it's very popular and I know the show's going to sell out and I
- 44:38know that there's going to be a secondary market.
- 44:40I could say hey that's cool. You know you can you can sell
- 44:45this ticket to your to your friend or you can give it to
- 44:48your brother or something and they can sign off on the other
- 44:51side. But if you resell it, you can
- 44:54only resell it for 5% above the face value of the ticket.
- 44:59You can't exceed that. You could put a limit on it or
- 45:02you could say, you know you could sell it for whatever you
- 45:06want. But when that exchange happens,
- 45:09I become part of the split. So you have to give me 50% of
- 45:12whatever you sell, the overage or even the like.
- 45:15Future, future, you buy a ticket and everybody gets paid the 2nd
- 45:19that ticket is purchased. So you buy a ticket for my show
- 45:23and I get paid and my drummer gets paid and the promoter gets
- 45:25paid and the everybody who's involved is, is, is part of some
- 45:29sort of instant settled split that's set up when the tickets
- 45:32created. There's a lot of ways it could
- 45:37go, but it just solves, sorry, that's something's beeping here.
- 45:44Good old New York, you know, there's a lot of things that can
- 45:48happen. That's just really the start.
- 45:52That's that's the the the first version of this and what we're
- 45:56focused on is just we want people to be able to create
- 46:01tickets from within Wave Lake for for small independent
- 46:04events. Sorry.
- 46:07All good. Brian's in a New York as well
- 46:12and and we have work calls and and is it goes off and every
- 46:15time I hear it it's just so foreign to me.
- 46:16I'm thinking that he still has like a a landline that's call
- 46:20like and then I'm I'm expecting like 1/2.
- 46:23People won't even know what I'm about to say is like I'm
- 46:25expecting like the audio recording to pick up.
- 46:27It's like this is Brian, you please leave a message at.
- 46:31Yeah, it's there's no way to mute this thing.
- 46:34If you've ever been in an apartment with a a door buzzer,
- 46:38luckily, it's it's somewhat It's not totally obnoxious, but.
- 46:43Sam, you just made me think like how amazing one of the ideas
- 46:47with this is like, so there's the angle of the resell and the
- 46:50programmatic nature of you get the ticket and the downstream
- 46:54effects, which is I think important.
- 46:56But thinking about like even ahead of it, imagine that graph
- 46:59and I'm not technical, but I would imagine just in the same
- 47:03perspective like somebody buys a ticket, they sell it.
- 47:06You can figure out the split in in the relationship with the
- 47:09buyers of the relationship with the followers and zaps, with an
- 47:14artist where you can actually incentivize the amount of value
- 47:18for value pre any merch or ticketing coming out.
- 47:23Because you can basically say if you have X whether it's sats or
- 47:26number of that's then you can actually maybe get ahead of it
- 47:29or a discount on the tickets or even have the ability.
- 47:32So then you actually keep the bots from ever being able to buy
- 47:35and you influence or incentivize your artists or your fans to
- 47:39like participate when it historically it's like that, you
- 47:41know you like create a better experience for everyone.
- 47:44Yeah, you have a way better super fan group or fan club or
- 47:48whatever you want to call it. You know, it's like, right now,
- 47:52the way people do that are through, you know, something
- 47:55like Patreon where it's like, hey, if you are like extra and
- 47:59you spend 8 bucks a month, I'll give you all this extra stuff,
- 48:03and then you'll have early access to tours and music and
- 48:06stuff. But it's just so hard to keep up
- 48:08with that 'cause you, you know, you have to keep up with this
- 48:10subscriber base and you have to keep pushing out the content
- 48:13that whatever it was you promised to give them.
- 48:17In order for that to come in, you have to maintain that.
- 48:19It's really difficult or like a Kickstarter thing.
- 48:22That was a big thing for a while with artists where you know, if
- 48:25they wanted to make a record, they may put it up on
- 48:29Kickstarter and then they have to come up with a bunch of all
- 48:32these different rewards and things in order to get someone
- 48:34to pledge for the the campaign. And if that's just so hard to do
- 48:38and keep up with. So yeah, that that concept,
- 48:43that's really that's what we're working on next which will be
- 48:45great for ticketing. It'll be great for merchandise,
- 48:47it'll be great just for really anything is yeah, you can see
- 48:51you'll be able to see your top fans and identify them in your
- 48:58in in Wave Lake or you know other other places and just see
- 49:01like hey, this is my, these are my top 100 supporters.
- 49:05They get first access to to everything or they only get
- 49:08access to these things. So it kind of creates the, the
- 49:14OR allows you to like move off something like like Patreon
- 49:17because now you you just have them like the the supporters,
- 49:20they just are your supporters naturally because they've
- 49:22supported you. They've they've now fallen into
- 49:24a certain category and maybe they did that through streaming
- 49:30your music. Maybe they did that while you
- 49:31were on a live stream. Maybe they did that by buying
- 49:34one of your tickets. Maybe they purchased, merged,
- 49:37merged through this which we also want to get into at some
- 49:40point in time soon You could really set those boundaries and
- 49:44it's really just about implementing it into the back
- 49:46end of of of Wave Lake. Just being able to activate
- 49:50those things and and organize these events in a way that show
- 49:54who did what when and and you can reward them however you'd
- 49:59like, you know? In your mind, would that be?
- 50:02Would that would those sort of functions be like artist view
- 50:07only if you will? Or would that be like, you know,
- 50:09if I'm a fan or a listener, I can go see those leaderboards
- 50:12and see, like, you know, I'm #5. I've zapped the five, you know,
- 50:16fifth most zaps to this song. I've bought 2 shirts.
- 50:19I've gone to five events. Because that's an interesting
- 50:21dynamic too, where it's like you could almost gamify fandom to an
- 50:25extent. Yeah, I mean it could go either
- 50:28way. And I think that's that's a
- 50:29choice that the artist could make and that's the choice that
- 50:32the fan could make. Maybe I'm super privacy focused
- 50:34and I don't want to be on the leaderboard.
- 50:36That's cool. You don't have to be.
- 50:37You can opt out, but maybe you do want to be.
- 50:39That's a big, that's a big thing that can really, you know like
- 50:44think about like back in the day with Myspace and stuff, the top
- 50:47eight, that was a big deal. When you were a fan of a band
- 50:51you wanted to be in their in their top eight and that was
- 50:53just a manual process that they maybe they just arbitrarily
- 50:57identified or through some through whatever decided you
- 51:01were going to you were going to be there, you know.
- 51:02But there's yeah, there's so many ways to gamify this and
- 51:07ways for fans to interact. I mean even just the simple act
- 51:10of of commenting or boosting. I mean we see that with like the
- 51:13Boostogram or Boost. I forget the name forget the
- 51:18name on Noster where it's like the the boost the ZAP
- 51:20advertising. Zapper, Zapper Tising was like
- 51:23an early experiment which was like, I'm going to be the
- 51:27highest ZAP and I'm going to put a link to my thing in this app
- 51:32comment so that when it shows up, if it's sorted by tops apps,
- 51:36then my my advertisement. You know, you're kind of
- 51:39spamming a comment but through support.
- 51:44So it's sort of warranted, you know.
- 51:46And that's that's really what this could be too for.
- 51:49You know, it's like if I'm a fan and I want, I want recognition
- 51:52from the artist that I'm a supporter, then I'm going to ZAP
- 51:55a lot and with frequency or depth or whatever, you know,
- 52:00there's just, that's the cool thing is there's just going to
- 52:03be so many different ways to interact with support
- 52:07financially or even just interacting through communicate,
- 52:11communicating and participating in things, you know, because
- 52:16this is all, it's all connected. So if you if you've connected
- 52:20through Wave Lake or Fountain or one of these other things you
- 52:22know, and you want to see a live show it, it'll be there if you
- 52:26want to by merch. It'll be there if you want to.
- 52:29If you want to just listen to a new track or watch a song get
- 52:33written, you can do all of that there.
- 52:36Very cool. You mentioned earlier that
- 52:40you're sort of you know you obviously are well networked in
- 52:43the music industry and and at current you're sort of like
- 52:45hesitant to like push this on folks and say hey go use this
- 52:50two-part question. Like I'm curious at one point
- 52:52will you be comfortable doing so being like OK what do you need
- 52:55to see for it to be like ready state for you to say to get a
- 52:59little bit more aggressive about being like this is a better way
- 53:02to monetize your content. And then also sort of second
- 53:07part to that is like from the from the artist side, it's like
- 53:11you know how do you incentivize them to see that vision, you
- 53:14know when when that conversation does happen like what is the
- 53:17carrot to say this is actually a better way to go about things?
- 53:23It's getting really close. So I mean on the artist side,
- 53:25it's on the artist side, it's pretty much there.
- 53:28I mean that was the thing we built first was just making sure
- 53:30the upload process felt incredibly similar to to band
- 53:34camp or something like that. You know that's that's
- 53:36essentially what we've done there and it's it's working.
- 53:40You know we have about 700 artists on there.
- 53:42We get we have very few customer service issues.
- 53:45Most people can get track set up pretty pretty simply So that
- 53:48part's done. The part that is was tough was
- 53:53in, you know, like July when Aidsley Costello, who didn't
- 53:57know anything about Bitcoin, her dad heard us, heard me talking
- 54:03at at Bitcoin Park in Nashville and, you know, a few days later
- 54:09uploaded his daughter's music and she was like, cool, where do
- 54:12I send my fans, you know? And there just really wasn't a
- 54:17great place for that. Like we, I could say like
- 54:19wavelake.com, but can't buy Bitcoin there.
- 54:21It's like you have do you have to know what a lightning?
- 54:23Well, I mean, there's just so many complications there from
- 54:25the fan side. So that's why we expedited the
- 54:29mobile app and the things we're finishing up within the mobile
- 54:33app are really the final, well, not the final stage, but what's
- 54:39going to start getting me there where I'm, I'll start pushing
- 54:43it, you know, to certain levels of of friends and artists that
- 54:46I'm, I work with and just see how they react and how their
- 54:50fans react to like I wanted to be.
- 54:52I wanted to be real incremental with it.
- 54:53But you know, you have the artist has to.
- 54:56They'll get on and they'll see it because we're we've seen that
- 54:59already. Artists get on.
- 55:00They find out very quickly. This is really cool.
- 55:02I'm getting ZAP. I'm getting, you know, people
- 55:04are talking to me, people are discovering my music.
- 55:07This has never happened before. Spotify is an abyss.
- 55:09All these other places are just so hard for me to get noticed at
- 55:12this level. But the mobile app is is still
- 55:17in beta. So like it's going to take that.
- 55:19We have to get it into the app stores.
- 55:22The mobile app needs to have a wallet in it, which we're about
- 55:25to finish that. And I really want there to be
- 55:29some sort of listen to earn implementation so you don't have
- 55:34to buy any Bitcoin. You know, you could just get in
- 55:36there and we have some really cool ideas that will probably be
- 55:39the next, The next big thing that people find out about is a
- 55:44version of that, a concept of that that will ultimately roll
- 55:49into the app as well. Once that happens, once it's
- 55:52like truly frictionless for the artist and the fan, then we'll
- 55:56start pushing more to the mainstream.
- 55:59I love that you you said something on Marty's Pod that
- 56:03really resonated and I think resonates.
- 56:05A lot of people building this space is that the rules have
- 56:07changed. And I think that's important
- 56:10because a lot of these concepts, while they're foreign and they
- 56:13seem so far fetched, the reality is like once you've really get
- 56:16them and you, you get the the background and you know your
- 56:20background and having asymmetric information in the music
- 56:23industry and knowing how broken it is and then knowing Bitcoin,
- 56:25right? Those are two disparate themes.
- 56:27And once you combine them together, it's like, oh, I can
- 56:30see, like how the game has changed and it it doesn't go
- 56:32back in and it's just fascinating to think about what
- 56:36you're describing. And it's like when an artist
- 56:39goes in there and they have their existing relationship with
- 56:42whatever provider and all the things that they've been told is
- 56:44all the tools you have. And then you see another one.
- 56:47It's just like, oh, you don't put that back in the box.
- 56:50It's just the game has changed and now it's just a matter of
- 56:52time until everybody else wakes up and realizes it.
- 56:56Yeah, because it, I mean, it's so easy.
- 56:57It's just for the artist. It's just another place to
- 56:59upload your music. There's so much already.
- 57:01It's like it's not it's not that big of an ask.
- 57:04Just be like, I don't know dude, go throw up a track here, you
- 57:06know, and and try it out. So it's actually pretty easy to
- 57:10get them that's that's sort of the easy part because they're
- 57:13just used to uploading music everywhere just because that's
- 57:16what it is. It's like just spray everywhere
- 57:18and hope that something happens. You know, it's yeah, but it's
- 57:23that fan side. They're going to need them,
- 57:28their music to be there. They're going to need to be the
- 57:30the music that they want to listen to is going to have to
- 57:32get there. And that's a big ask.
- 57:34You know it's like no one's going to leave Spotify for for
- 57:38Wave Lake. No one's going to leave Apple
- 57:39Music right now for Wave Lake. They may supplement their, I
- 57:43mean we've been asking people or something we've seen out there,
- 57:45it's like, hey, what what are your, what are you listening to?
- 57:48And it's like 90% other platforms, 10% Wave Lake.
- 57:52And it's like that's awesome. I'll take that.
- 57:53You know it's like it's kind of cool to just be a part of
- 57:56someone's. And I I still use traditional
- 57:57platforms too. You know I I can't listen to The
- 57:59Beatles on Wave Lake. So yeah it's going to take some
- 58:04time. But you know, there's even if it
- 58:10takes a long time to get like legacy artists onto an idea like
- 58:14this, which I think it'll ramp up a lot faster than we saw
- 58:18before because the idea isn't really that foreign.
- 58:21It's really pretty similar to what we have going on now, which
- 58:23is better for the artist financially.
- 58:25So it'll be a lot easier to sell.
- 58:27But even just to build a robust independent music library like
- 58:33SoundCloud did or like Band Camp did, those are both very highly
- 58:37successful companies that had very strong communities and and
- 58:41started careers of a lot of artists and are still existing
- 58:45and as far as I know profitable today, you know, So there I I
- 58:52mean I have a lot of hope just for getting to that point and
- 58:55then implementing, you know, seeing how these other things
- 58:59that those things don't have can really change, change the
- 59:05trajectory of where we go from there.
- 59:06Because you can't buy tickets, you can't do live streams, you
- 59:09can't do all these things with these other music platforms, and
- 59:13you certainly can't do them in a way where it's all sort of
- 59:16unified in one place. You know, it's like you can buy
- 59:18merch on Spotify, but it has to be through this other thing.
- 59:21You can see ticket listings on somewhere else, but it's fed in
- 59:27through some other company, you know?
- 59:28So yeah, I think it's going to be really great.
- 59:35Yeah, your your music portal for everything.
- 59:37I I liked that early in the call and is that in like it actually
- 59:40works, right? Like you have this ubiquitous
- 59:42form of of money that that settles instantly and for a low
- 59:46cost and you can do all these different things all in the same
- 59:49place and can sort of sort of create this this music centric
- 59:53hub with just a much better model where.
- 59:57You know there aren't middle men extracting rent from from.
- 59:59Various elements of it. Yeah, for sure.
- 1:00:05What I mean I'm curious on the music side the the lock in
- 1:00:09because you referenced you still go into Spotify like everyone
- 1:00:12does and is there like are you able, is there any lock in that
- 1:00:16it occurs on a larger scale or is it pretty like anybody that's
- 1:00:20on Spotify can go they just have to opt it opt in to like
- 1:00:25uploading their their music to wave like?
- 1:00:28Yeah, I mean, there could be. There could be.
- 1:00:33I mean, I could see a world in the not too distant future where
- 1:00:36you're uploading through a different service like Distrokit
- 1:00:41or The Orchard or one of the OR Tune Core, one of these
- 1:00:44distribution platforms where you're selecting all the things
- 1:00:47that you're you're uploading to. It's like, hey, I I upload my
- 1:00:50music through Tune Core and it tells me I'm distributing to 65
- 1:00:54different things. You know, it's it.
- 1:00:58This is all open. So we could partner up with with
- 1:01:01a with an existing distribution on ramp and say hey you know
- 1:01:09connect this here and and this could be one of your options and
- 1:01:15that could that could be a a way that we on board a bunch of
- 1:01:18people without anyone even realizing what it is whatsoever.
- 1:01:21You know, it could just, it's just another box that gets
- 1:01:23checked and funds start coming in in in a very different way
- 1:01:28and we would have to interact with something like that
- 1:01:32differently than you would if it was a one to one transaction.
- 1:01:36But yeah, I mean, there's so many ways to bring bring people
- 1:01:40into this. Yeah, that.
- 1:01:43That's a fascinating concept because you E reference how do
- 1:01:46the artists get on or the the fans asking for it.
- 1:01:49And we talk about price and and adoption grow and as adoption
- 1:01:52grows the overlap becomes greater with the list, the fan
- 1:01:56and the holder. Bitcoin or or you know whatever
- 1:02:00Bitcoin or whatever we refer to folks, I think we start to
- 1:02:03change as every money just becomes ubiquitous.
- 1:02:05But point being is when we launched this podcast a year
- 1:02:08ago, the only reason we got on true truly is got on Fountain
- 1:02:14was because everybody in Twitter D and comments were saying like
- 1:02:17are you on Fountain, Are you in Fountain?
- 1:02:18And they kept tagging. And then Fountain reached out
- 1:02:20and like, OK, well, it's just another app.
- 1:02:22And then it's just like, oh, these SAT's keep like growing.
- 1:02:24And there's like hundreds of dollars sitting in this thing
- 1:02:26that we don't like, you know, and it eventually gets to a
- 1:02:29certain point, you get enough zaps, enough incentive baked
- 1:02:34into that, then you're like, wait, this is actually real
- 1:02:36money. So you could see like that
- 1:02:38distribution channel like opening based on either
- 1:02:40partnerships or partnerships coupled with just like the fans
- 1:02:43asking for it at a fewer pace. Yeah, it's it's it's just going
- 1:02:48to take experimenting from artists.
- 1:02:51You know it's going to take, it's going to take some time.
- 1:02:55You know it's even right now on Fountain.
- 1:02:57I mean there's a pretty robust amount of listeners and podcasts
- 1:03:02on on Fountain, but it's still that's still very small.
- 1:03:05You know you it's, I mean it's evident now you could look at
- 1:03:08the supporters on Fountain and you can see like a lot of times
- 1:03:11it's even a small group of people that are sort of propping
- 1:03:14that show up and that's the thing works the same.
- 1:03:18You could say the same thing for Wave, like you know, it's very
- 1:03:22comparatively, it's an incredibly small market right
- 1:03:25now, you know, so but that's The thing is we just we have a
- 1:03:29better, we do have a better solution here, us and Fountain
- 1:03:33and all these other clients in Austere like it is actually a
- 1:03:36better system and that's typically that kind of thing
- 1:03:40typically tends to cut through, you know, it it may not be this
- 1:03:43exact version. I think Jesse from Amboss
- 1:03:45tweeted or maybe it was on Noster a couple months ago.
- 1:03:49But I liked it and it was like lightning may not, may not be
- 1:03:53the thing, but it's definitely going to be the thing to the
- 1:03:56thing that gets us to the thing. And that might be Noster, it
- 1:03:59might be lightning, it might be, you know, this E Cash and these
- 1:04:02fediments and all these other things are sort of becoming very
- 1:04:06interesting. You know, there's a lot of stuff
- 1:04:08popping up like this technology is moving very quickly and it's
- 1:04:14so exciting to be able to participate in it.
- 1:04:18But it's also nerve wracking because it's it's like happening
- 1:04:21so fast and you have all these options and it's it's tough to
- 1:04:24have the patience to pick the right one and not like get too
- 1:04:26deep, you know, before the user base is there.
- 1:04:30Not to get too in the weeds in the business model, but like you
- 1:04:32just made me think of this whole notion of people are going to
- 1:04:38need support navigating this, right.
- 1:04:40Like you referenced the different ways artists can adopt
- 1:04:42these things And it's just like, well, you can do XY and Z to
- 1:04:44optimize for revenue growth. And it's like are they going to
- 1:04:48have to do it or somebody's going to need to be able to
- 1:04:49provide them with the different, you know, like segments or tiers
- 1:04:54or be able to like shepherd them through until it's just I don't
- 1:04:57know what the end state looks like.
- 1:04:58But you can imagine the experience that we're describing
- 1:05:01is from anybody that has a relationship from produces some
- 1:05:04kind of like, you know whether it's a fitness instructor that
- 1:05:08has a following or artist where they want to do something that
- 1:05:13requires digital value like scarce value to provably show
- 1:05:19that it's not bots trying to extract rent.
- 1:05:22And you can imagine that like whole experience needs
- 1:05:25cultivating and like create creation around it to be able to
- 1:05:30like create like the the ticketing thing is a good
- 1:05:33example of imagine you're an artist or somebody that does
- 1:05:37something online and you want to open an event up to your
- 1:05:40community. But you don't want people to
- 1:05:41like go and you know basically corner the market on whatever
- 1:05:45that opportunity is. And so you can imagine going to
- 1:05:47something like a wave lake or somebody that creates something
- 1:05:49like this and to open up this is how you can effectively do it.
- 1:05:53So you can monetize it while also giving your fans the best
- 1:05:56experience. And that seems like a very like
- 1:05:58interesting opportunity. Have you guys thought about like
- 1:06:00whether it's on the music side or that in general or or not
- 1:06:03really? Yeah, I mean that's ultimately
- 1:06:06the goal. I mean we want, we want people
- 1:06:08to be able to essentially activate the, the, the top
- 1:06:15percentage of their audience in in every way, in every way
- 1:06:18possible. And we want to support that idea
- 1:06:21whether that's music or a fitness instructor or a recipe
- 1:06:26website or whatever. You know, it's anytime I explain
- 1:06:30this, this concept of just like giving your value to somebody as
- 1:06:37you consume the thing that's giving giving value to you this
- 1:06:41value for value idea. It's everyone's like, Oh yeah,
- 1:06:45that makes so much sense. How do I do that?
- 1:06:47You know, it's like you don't want it.
- 1:06:49I don't want a New York Times subscription because somebody's
- 1:06:53because my friend sent me one link, you know, to read an
- 1:06:57article. It's so dumb.
- 1:06:58Like it's just so dumb. And you explain to someone like,
- 1:07:01hey, wouldn't be cool if, like I sent you this link and you could
- 1:07:03just read it and pay $0.13 and then never pay New York Times
- 1:07:09anything ever again. Like, wouldn't that be great?
- 1:07:11Or like if you read it every single day, you could give them
- 1:07:14that $14.00 over the course of a month.
- 1:07:16Or, you know, whatever it is, this, this.
- 1:07:20There's no doubt in my mind that this is going to be the thing,
- 1:07:25the next thing, everywhere. You know, it just it's that's
- 1:07:28how we do everything. You have a you have you have a
- 1:07:32water bill. You don't just pay for, like a
- 1:07:33water subscription. You don't pay like $2000 a
- 1:07:36month, just have access to as much water as you want.
- 1:07:39You'd pay for the water that you consume.
- 1:07:40You pay for the gas that you consume and the electricity you
- 1:07:42consume. And that's how most things work.
- 1:07:46It's really strange, this idea of of paying like a monthly fee
- 1:07:51for unlimited access to stuff. You would could never in a
- 1:07:55million years conceivably listen to.
- 1:07:57I mean, I have my like main playlist on Spotify has like 8
- 1:08:01days of music on it. I'm never going to listen to
- 1:08:03that like in one in one sitting, you know, it's like half the
- 1:08:06time I hit shuffle, it just plays the same 14 songs anyway.
- 1:08:10So yeah, I think I think people are going to be incredibly
- 1:08:13receptive to this as it starts moving more into the mainstream.
- 1:08:16It's just about building these things and pushing through and
- 1:08:20and like I said, supporting all of these things is the best that
- 1:08:23you can. I would someone, someone had a
- 1:08:27thread. I think it was.
- 1:08:28I can't remember who it was. Someone had a thread yesterday
- 1:08:30on Twitter about just like the early days generosity of Bitcoin
- 1:08:36and how you know like the pizza story or whatever, like any
- 1:08:41story from that era or like the first in 2014, someone buying 5T
- 1:08:45shirts on my merch company. It's, you know I'm paying
- 1:08:48looking back and laughing at that transaction, how much it is
- 1:08:50now. But you know that's what needs
- 1:08:55to happen. Like we all have to some people
- 1:08:57have to be building things. People have to be supporting
- 1:08:59those builders even if it's not perfect yet.
- 1:09:02And that's how we're going to get to the next step.
- 1:09:05That's how this thing has gotten us from A to B&B to C&C to D it
- 1:09:08just keep supporting. That's what I love most about
- 1:09:11the the bear markets is that's when everyone's is building the
- 1:09:14coolest stuff and you get in this new cycle and you get to
- 1:09:17see that get put to use. And every single time that
- 1:09:22happens, the stuff that gets built becomes more interesting
- 1:09:24and more more mainstream focus. And it's not just about wallets
- 1:09:28or exchanges or you know, infrastructure and mining and
- 1:09:32all these things. Now it's starting to be fun
- 1:09:33stuff like music and blogging and video and social media and
- 1:09:39these things that people want to, that actually use, people
- 1:09:42use daily. I feel like I got way off track
- 1:09:46there on no. No, that's that's exactly right.
- 1:09:49Because it go, it furthers that idea of like the convergence
- 1:09:52between utility and value because as the utility becomes
- 1:09:56more relevant and built out the the value increases to the point
- 1:10:02where people want to accept Bitcoin.
- 1:10:04Because right now, right, it's like you mentioned, you can't
- 1:10:05really bring it up or it doesn't come up.
- 1:10:07But imagine a state where the tools are built out to a point
- 1:10:10at the same time somebody's saying, hey, I actually want to
- 1:10:13receive Bitcoin and those two meet in parallel.
- 1:10:16Like if this in this convergence were like that everything just
- 1:10:18kind of like, you know, runs even faster because now people
- 1:10:21have the tools coupled what they want a better form of money to
- 1:10:24to receive, which both don't exist today.
- 1:10:26Yeah. And people are coming around to
- 1:10:27that. And the the cycles prove that
- 1:10:30because you see these things come and go, you know, but then
- 1:10:33Bitcoin sticks around and stays stable actually comparatively to
- 1:10:38all these other things. And I think people are starting
- 1:10:40to actually notice that you know it's like oh this everyone said
- 1:10:44this thing was the thing but then it just where to go.
- 1:10:48Like my my cousin told me to buy this shit coin and I lost 1500
- 1:10:52bucks. My friend told me to buy
- 1:10:54Bitcoin. And like I would have made you
- 1:10:56know it's if you're thinking about it from that mindset and
- 1:10:58then you get and then once you realize that happens you start
- 1:11:01seeing the utility and you Start learning about that and that's
- 1:11:05that's how we all got here. You know, it's like it
- 1:11:07ultimately comes, starts with the price and ends with the the
- 1:11:10utility and and what this can do to really fix our just
- 1:11:14infrastructure of how we live. But I yeah, I mean, I think
- 1:11:18we're really close, 'cause I I think it is a lot of that, a lot
- 1:11:22of the nonsense that's attached to it that makes those
- 1:11:24conversations difficult to have. And just regular mainstream
- 1:11:27life, I think are starting to get easier, 'cause people are
- 1:11:30starting to realize like, oh, this isn't a scam, you know,
- 1:11:33this isn't the oceans haven't boiled yet.
- 1:11:38I don't know something's some somebody said this was going to
- 1:11:42happen and it didn't happen. So maybe it was just maybe that
- 1:11:44wasn't true. Maybe I should actually look
- 1:11:46into it. So yeah, I don't know.
- 1:11:48I think, you know, I I think I, I was sort of hopeful for this
- 1:11:53cycle that we might get some more, we might get more
- 1:11:56mainstream adoption that I'm starting to suspect it might
- 1:11:59take you know one more before we really go into like hyperdrive
- 1:12:02with that. But the more time the better,
- 1:12:04because it just allows for more of this stuff to get built and
- 1:12:06more things more of the kinks to get worked out.
- 1:12:09Yeah, I think that's fair. I think we're still very nascent
- 1:12:13and early in terms of sort of this more utility focused
- 1:12:15adoption, maybe this, this cycle is the the digital gold thesis,
- 1:12:19institutional adoption that's occurring more and more near
- 1:12:23term. But no, that's all really great
- 1:12:28thoughts in there in terms of you know this one, it's better
- 1:12:33money, it's better tools, it's open systems, interoperable
- 1:12:36system so people can continue to iterate and build on these
- 1:12:38things. It's it's been really cool to
- 1:12:41see what what you guys have built and excited for the future
- 1:12:44as well. Michael, did you have anything
- 1:12:47else or you? Want to maybe wrap it up?
- 1:12:50No, this has been great, Sam. Appreciate you coming on.
- 1:12:52I'm sure you're excited to think about like the incumbents they
- 1:12:56they'll more than likely miss all of this.
- 1:12:58It's not in their best interest to to, you know, adopt any of
- 1:13:01the things talking and there's some poetic justice and and kind
- 1:13:04of all of it. That's what I'm hoping for.
- 1:13:07The comeuppance for the artists. Yeah, that's that'll be really
- 1:13:11cool to see. Awesome and.
- 1:13:14Then Nashville. Maybe if he wants to just plug
- 1:13:16Nashville. Cause, Yeah, yeah.
- 1:13:17Yeah, if you're gonna be in Nashville July 25th, we're doing
- 1:13:20a show, sort of a celebration that the Bitcoin conference is
- 1:13:24really like a milestone place for us.
- 1:13:26It's where I met Michael in person, and sort of a lot of
- 1:13:30this stuff came to be. So in celebration of that, it's
- 1:13:34a music town, so it makes perfect sense.
- 1:13:36We're throwing a concert with Joe Martin and Ainsley Costello
- 1:13:39and Jess Loud and the Higher Low and the Satoshi Rockamoto sort
- 1:13:44of live karaoke type thing, which has been at a few of these
- 1:13:47conferences. If you ever seen that, Yeah.
- 1:13:50July 25th at the Vinyl Lounge in Nashville, go download the Wave
- 1:13:55Lake app. You go to app.wavelake.com.
- 1:13:58Or you can just look for the little app logos on on
- 1:14:01wavelake.com and try it out. The mobile app's pretty cool,
- 1:14:06we're we're doing some updates in the next couple weeks that
- 1:14:08are going to make it even cooler and you can RSVP for the event
- 1:14:11there and try out this tick a bot thing and let us know what
- 1:14:14you think. And share with an artist.
- 1:14:17If you have an artist in your network, definitely show it.
- 1:14:20Yeah, yeah, absolutely. Yeah.
- 1:14:22Let's I It's funny because a lot of people don't.
- 1:14:25I mean, the app is like, like I said, it's in beta, so it's
- 1:14:27pretty under the radar. But even a lot of people that
- 1:14:29are familiar with Wave, like, don't realize we have an app.
- 1:14:31So if you're one of those people, go download it and show
- 1:14:33your friends. Because it is actually like I,
- 1:14:36you know, I showed my sister and she's like, oh, this is cool.
- 1:14:38I didn't know this was like that.
- 1:14:41I thought it was, you know, Dorkier.
- 1:14:43So it's we're we're getting there.
- 1:14:45It's starting to get more familiar for the listener too.
- 1:14:47I love it. Well, go download the app, share
- 1:14:51it with friends, family, creators.
- 1:14:54Sam, thanks again. Really appreciate you coming on.
- 1:14:56It was a great convo and hopefully we can have you have
- 1:14:59you again. Yeah, down the line.
- 1:15:01Thanks guys. Appreciate it.
- 1:15:03All right, see you guys. Thanks.
- 1:15:04In a few weeks later, thanks for listening to this week's episode
- 1:15:08of the show. If you found the information
- 1:15:10valuable, please share the episode with a friend or leave a
- 1:15:12rating on your favorite podcast app.
- 1:15:14All the links we discussed in today's show will be in the show
- 1:15:16notes inside your podcast app. Before we finish, a quick
- 1:15:19reminder that On RAMP Media is for informational and
- 1:15:22entertainment purposes only and nothing should be construed as
- 1:15:25investment or legal advice. Regardless of where you are on
- 1:15:28your Bitcoin journey, we'd love to hear from you.
- 1:15:30Visit onrampbitcoin.com/contact. Schedule a consultation with one
- 1:15:34of our private client advisors.