Latest / Stage Talks with Bellingcat / "Mapping Hate Networks Across Borders" with Bellingcat
Transcript
- 0:03You're listening to a stage talk titled Mapping
- 0:06Hate Networks Across Borders. This week we were
- 0:09discussing techniques for estimating the scale
- 0:11of hate groups. What can their online presence
- 0:14tell us about their fundraising and recruiting
- 0:16efforts? Joined by my colleagues, Bellingcat's
- 0:19Michael Colborne and Pooja Chaudhuri, We broke
- 0:22down how we approach these types of investigations
- 0:24and what helps us identify key organisations
- 0:27slash figures and connections within these networks.
- 0:30You can find links to all the resources mentioned
- 0:32in the talk in the podcast description. This
- 0:34talk was hosted by me, Charlotte Maher on Thursday
- 0:37the 3rd of September 2026 in the Bellingcat
- 0:40Discord server. Thanks for coming to another
- 0:53stage talk. Today's talk is titled Mapping Hate
- 0:57Networks Across Borders. We're joined by Bellingcat
- 1:00researchers Michael Colborne and Pooja Chaudhuri.
- 1:03Both of these fantastic researchers have traced
- 1:06hate groups online and across the globe, from
- 1:08Finland to the States, Hungary and India to only
- 1:11name a few. Hate groups can use the internet
- 1:14to turn local movements into transnational networks
- 1:17without needing a formal international organization.
- 1:20Social media is a powerful tool for propaganda
- 1:23and recruitment, and digital anonymity allows
- 1:27for easier financial cash flows. But what happens
- 1:30when hatred stops being confined by borders?
- 1:33A movement that begins in one country can now
- 1:35reach people thousands of miles away in seconds.
- 1:38A video goes viral, a private online community
- 1:41forms, and suddenly people who have never met
- 1:43and may never meet can feel like they're part
- 1:46of the same cause. finding out who is connected
- 1:48to who is vital in order to really understand
- 1:51the scale of the network you're looking into.
- 1:54Today, we're hoping to share knowledge of how
- 1:56to track this scale with you. Michael and Pooja
- 1:58will break down their methods for investigating
- 2:01the span of these connections. As always, we
- 2:05will have plenty of time to answer your questions.
- 2:07You can place your questions in the chat accessible
- 2:10on your right -hand corner of your screen. It's
- 2:13a little message bubble, but please remember
- 2:15that this is being audio recorded for the podcast.
- 2:20So if you don't want me to mention your username,
- 2:23please add that as a note in your question. Okay.
- 2:27Michael and Pooja, over to you. All right. Thanks,
- 2:33Charlie. And thanks everybody for coming into
- 2:38the virtual room here. Always good, I haven't
- 2:41done a stage talk in a while, so good to be virtually
- 2:44back. So what I want to talk about first for
- 2:48a few minutes are kind of some, about four or
- 2:53five general tips that I have for anybody who
- 2:57is, like if you're researching whether, in whatever
- 3:02capacity, if you come across an individual, a
- 3:07group, network or movement, that you want to
- 3:11research, understand more about, particularly
- 3:14like obviously in the context of what we're talking
- 3:17about, a hate group network, individual movement,
- 3:21what have you, really just going through some
- 3:25of what I follow, what I do, even quite informally
- 3:28to do what I have always argued is to... your
- 3:34best bet to try to get the sense of the ecosystem
- 3:38that you are starting to research or just starting
- 3:43to dunk your head into, even if you're just doing
- 3:45it for a few minutes, if you're just doing it
- 3:47for a bit of preliminary research and you want
- 3:49to build on it in the future. You can see me
- 3:54glancing down on my notes. I have five points
- 3:58that I generally... follow and that I'd recommend.
- 4:03The first one or two might be a bit obvious and
- 4:05this first one probably might be a little bit.
- 4:08It is ask yourself or find out where are they
- 4:13communicating with the outside world on social
- 4:15media through open sources? Where are they communicating
- 4:18with each other? Basically on what platforms?
- 4:22Is it X? Is it Telegram? Is it Instagram? For
- 4:28a lot of the work that I've done recently, it
- 4:30has been mostly telegram and actually increasingly
- 4:33on Instagram. And if you basically, you want
- 4:39to start researching a group, you come across
- 4:41individuals or groups or what have you, you come
- 4:44across posts, you want to find out more about
- 4:46the network or the broader ecosystem that they're
- 4:51operating in. Obviously you find out and you
- 4:54see where they're. Where they're online, but
- 4:57you also see who's you know, who exactly is posting
- 5:01and communicating? Who who are you really starting
- 5:03to look at? Are you just looking at one or two
- 5:06individuals that you came across? Are you starting
- 5:09to look at a specific? Formal or informal movement
- 5:13and you've got 10 15 20 accounts more or less
- 5:16that you might want to look at That's really
- 5:20the first thing to ask yourself is What exactly
- 5:24am I interested as a starting point to look at?
- 5:27And where can I start researching? Like I said,
- 5:31sometimes it's obvious because you might be on
- 5:33one of these platforms and or, you know, discover
- 5:36something and you want to find out more about
- 5:38it. So that sort of simple first point moves
- 5:42on to what I would say is usually the second
- 5:45step that I follow. And I'm trying to reduce
- 5:48these to key words because I have it underlined
- 5:51in my notes here. Number two is to kind of ask
- 5:54yourself who, but more importantly, who else?
- 6:00If you're following, you're starting to research
- 6:02an individual group, network on social media
- 6:07particularly, who are they resharing or reposting
- 6:12or retweeting, rewhatever? That's always one
- 6:18place to look. But particularly what I'm interested
- 6:22in, especially using Instagram, which I've done
- 6:25for some recent investigations, particularly
- 6:28the recent Columbia -related investigation, one
- 6:33of the key places to go is to see who these accounts
- 6:37follow, who follows them back. In other words,
- 6:41where the mutual follows. Particularly, are they
- 6:44following or are they followed by... what in
- 6:48your estimation might be quote unquote unusual
- 6:51accounts. If you're looking through the follows
- 6:53of some say somebody who's an open neo -nazi
- 6:58or and you discover that or say you because of
- 7:06some of these links you you stumble upon a sort
- 7:08of low level Colombian politicians Instagram
- 7:11and you notice that eight members of an active
- 7:14club follow this Follow this particular account.
- 7:18Well, why is that? So and then you can go and
- 7:20look like the article that that Early is just
- 7:23linked to you follow and you find out that there's
- 7:26there's a heck of a connection there So really
- 7:29going and looking at who they might reshare that
- 7:33can often be one point But particularly who they
- 7:36repost maybe how often they might repost particular
- 7:40accounts particularly like I said with Instagram
- 7:43if that's because unfortunately, there is a lot
- 7:47more hate content on Instagram than there used
- 7:51to be. I have seen some of it taken down recently,
- 7:54but especially in languages other than English,
- 7:57there's still quite a lot. So seeing follows,
- 8:00mutual follows, starting from there, even just
- 8:03something, yeah, something is relatively simple
- 8:05as seeing an account, seeing who they follow,
- 8:09seeing who follows them back can really... lead
- 8:12you in some pretty interesting directions and
- 8:15that leads me to What I have is sort of a point
- 8:20number three that I follow kind of following
- 8:22on from this when When you're researching one
- 8:26of these individuals groups networks you kind
- 8:28of start getting even a small a Small group of
- 8:33accounts or maybe not so small group of accounts
- 8:36that you're looking at Ask yourself. Where do
- 8:40they? cluster, are there, not even in the sense
- 8:44of using some sort of data analysis tool, like
- 8:48actual sort of cluster graphs or anything like
- 8:50that, yet you can informally look and see, oh,
- 8:55are there particular, if you're looking at a
- 8:58dozen specific accounts and you notice that they
- 9:01all follow like very, some very specific accounts
- 9:06among them. In other words, they all follow a
- 9:09particular a particular account or set of accounts
- 9:11that can tell you something. Sometimes if in
- 9:14one of these far -right hate ecosystems, if a
- 9:19lot of people follow one account, well, maybe
- 9:22it actually is just a relatively prominent influencer
- 9:26account in their sphere. Maybe it is an indicative
- 9:29of some sort of deeper connection. But if you
- 9:31notice, for example, and I've had this actually
- 9:33in ongoing research that I'm doing now, when
- 9:37you look and you see, oh, there's partly making
- 9:40up this example. Oh, I notice that 10 of these
- 9:43accounts follow this relatively obscure private
- 9:47individual account that only has 200 followers.
- 9:51That should tell you something. That should tell
- 9:53you that whoever that account is, is somebody
- 9:55probably quite important and you should look
- 9:58into it. So when you start to get a sense of
- 10:02what I call these clusters, in other words, a
- 10:05cluster of Follows and followings and yes, of
- 10:08course, there are tools that you can use to do
- 10:10this But even just at these sorts of preliminary
- 10:12stages, I do it quite informally where I'm just
- 10:15looking Oh a lot of people follow the all of
- 10:19you know This particular account or these sets
- 10:21of accounts, but these other people don't well,
- 10:24that's interesting it can lead you to some interesting
- 10:27places and that leads on to What I want to impart
- 10:32today is sort of the more important points that
- 10:36I have to talk about based on the work that I've
- 10:40done over a lot of years now and that I'm literally
- 10:45doing before and after this stage talk. Fourth
- 10:50point, I think you should ask yourself when you're
- 10:53starting to investigate some of these groups,
- 10:55especially if it's something quite new to you
- 10:58or you haven't really dug quite that far in yet.
- 11:01One of them... It's really key to ask yourself,
- 11:05and I phrase this as asking yourself this sort
- 11:08of hypothetical question. How connected are they?
- 11:13In other words, how connected are some of these
- 11:16different accounts? Try to assess as best as
- 11:20you can almost the level of the interaction or
- 11:24the apparent connection. Are they just reposting
- 11:29or liking an account's posts? Sometimes that
- 11:32could mean something, sometimes it necessarily
- 11:34doesn't. But are they leaving comments on each
- 11:39other's posts? What kinds of comments are they
- 11:42leaving? Are they sort of effusive comments?
- 11:46Are they betraying some kind of familiarity or
- 11:50friendship even from what they're saying? Is
- 11:54there evidence of deeper interactions, as I would
- 11:58say, deeper interactions than just you know,
- 12:01reposting or sharing, positively resharing content.
- 12:06Are they talking about, for example, the place
- 12:10where they get their far -right clothes manufactured?
- 12:13Or are they at least giving you enough information
- 12:16that you can do some digital footprint tracing
- 12:18and find out through Instagram that they're getting
- 12:23their clothes manufactured in or... They're getting
- 12:26their clothes made in Bulgaria. That was an investigation
- 12:29I did. Time runs together. I think it was about
- 12:31two years ago. But you can also see other things.
- 12:33You can see, oh, are they appearing even on like
- 12:36each other's podcasts? Are they doing things
- 12:40like selling, you know, selling their designs
- 12:44or promoting their designs through some brand
- 12:47on some other side of the world? One particularly
- 12:50important thing I would argue in Weave managed
- 12:53to do this with several Bellingcat investigations
- 12:55related to these so -called fight nights, whether
- 12:58more recently or several years in the past, is
- 13:03looking at what they post and seeing who or at
- 13:06least what groups appear at each other's events.
- 13:09Sometimes they'll blur faces and sometimes you
- 13:14might not be able to immediately identify them.
- 13:16But when it comes to groups, especially in the
- 13:19European context, which I mostly write about,
- 13:21but also Around the world as as it goes You can
- 13:26see oh these At this Hungarian far -right fight
- 13:31night they there's flags from this group in the
- 13:34Czech Republic or there's there's a lot of these
- 13:36This group from Bulgaria there or what have you?
- 13:41That if if there's evidence from their social
- 13:44media posts from their media from their photos
- 13:46and videos of them like in person attending each
- 13:50other's events like even traveling, thanking
- 13:53each other, participating in things like concerts
- 13:57and fight nights. That can be quite indicative,
- 14:01obviously, of a strong connection. I live here
- 14:04in the Netherlands and for their active club
- 14:08here, for their fight nights when they have fighters
- 14:11from Sweden come or people from Sweden come every
- 14:16coming like two or two years in a row, that suggest
- 14:21to me some level of more than just casual connection,
- 14:25or at least I can have that as a hypothesis.
- 14:28So that leads me to my sort of final point is,
- 14:36say you've started to dunk your head in here,
- 14:38you've started to piece together some accounts,
- 14:41looking at mutual follows, posts, reposts, clusters,
- 14:46trying to hypothesize about the nature of the
- 14:50connections or at least draw inferences on the
- 14:53nature of some of the connections or relationships.
- 14:56One of the things that I think is really important
- 14:58to do is to be a bit counterfactual. Ask yourself
- 15:02what some of the differences are between some
- 15:06of the accounts or individuals or group that
- 15:10you're looking at. In other words, if you're
- 15:13looking at a particular network or even a smaller
- 15:16network, is only a part of that network really
- 15:24reposting or seem to have a relationship with
- 15:27a specific group? Why is it only this small cluster
- 15:31or some of these groups that have this relationship?
- 15:39evidence or at least something to help you hypothesize
- 15:41about within some of these movements where the
- 15:46individuals or subgroups that they might gather
- 15:48around and also With a lot of these kinds of
- 15:52movements this may be a shock to some of you
- 15:54It may not be a shock to others but within these
- 15:57sorts of hate groups or movements a lot of the
- 16:00people involved especially on Leadership or senior
- 16:03levels. They do not always like each other. They
- 16:06don't always get along And what I found with
- 16:11research years ago was just very informally following
- 16:15these steps, I was able to get a sense of within
- 16:20a much larger scale movement. It was as of particularly
- 16:25in Ukraine, but before the 2022 post scale invasion,
- 16:29because suffice to say, things have changed.
- 16:32By following this, I was able to get a sense
- 16:34of within the quote unquote movement where individuals
- 16:39or groups tended to gather around or maybe seeming
- 16:42to have some relationships with some subgroups
- 16:44or senior people. Well, maybe not seeming to
- 16:47get along with others. It can give you a sense
- 16:49of even rivalries or camps within maybe a larger
- 16:54network or group. So, and also this can involve
- 16:59more work, of course, but ask yourself has in
- 17:04terms of differences, has it changed over time?
- 17:06Are you seeing a group or something reposted
- 17:11a ton now by an individual or a group of accounts
- 17:16that was never being reposted before or vice
- 17:19versa, which I've seen come up where somebody
- 17:23or a group whose content kept getting reposted
- 17:27or posted about or reshared or being at events,
- 17:31well, all of a sudden they're not anymore. that
- 17:34can be a clue to help you infer something that
- 17:37might be going on, lead you down a path of more
- 17:41investigation. With researching these kinds of
- 17:45groups, in a lot of ways, asking yourself a counterfactual,
- 17:54that can oftentimes be your best bet. And with
- 17:57these methods, the very general approach that
- 18:02we're general approach that I've laid out here.
- 18:05You can start to get a sense, at least with some
- 18:08of the groups that I do, not as robust a sense
- 18:11as I might like, but you can get some sense also
- 18:15of finances, some sense. If you're looking at
- 18:20events that bring in money, concerts, fight nights
- 18:25where they're selling merch and whatever, you
- 18:27can see who's connected and they maybe are connected
- 18:30business -wise. You can get a sense of some groups
- 18:35based on what they post and their resources,
- 18:37the kinds of events they host. You can get at
- 18:40least some sense that some groups seem to have
- 18:43more resources than others. Oh, well, and maybe
- 18:46you'll notice that one of these much smaller
- 18:48groups or individuals really seems to be butting
- 18:50up with a more established group that seems to
- 18:54have a lot more resources. That can lead you
- 18:56somewhere. in that you can touch on the financial
- 19:01side of things, but I know Pooja is going to
- 19:04get more into that. And that is the end of my
- 19:09spiel for now. Thanks, Michael. That was great
- 19:18and a good segue into what I will also be talking
- 19:22about. I like researching what helps a group
- 19:28or a network to function, like sort of like their
- 19:32backbone, like who supports them, who's behind
- 19:34them, and specifically who gives them money.
- 19:39I did a story a couple of years ago on how these
- 19:43really popular Hindu nationalist media organizations
- 19:47were making money. I looked at four of them.
- 19:52I found that One, these four were quite popular,
- 19:56and I also saw that they made a lot of money
- 19:59through donations. And they were making money
- 20:02through donations at a time when the Indian government
- 20:05was cracking down on donations to media outlets,
- 20:09especially foreign donations. And all these four
- 20:12media outlets that I looked at were receiving
- 20:15foreign donations. So one way, I think, to start
- 20:22researching or start an investigation into, if
- 20:27you're interested in looking at the far right
- 20:29and what is the machinery that helps it exist
- 20:34is to look at, of course, money is a good way
- 20:37to start looking at it. A lot of them receive
- 20:40donations. If you are looking at organizations
- 20:43that exist in jurisdictions where you have to
- 20:46make them public, that's a good place to start.
- 20:48India is not one of those jurisdictions. They
- 20:51don't have to make their tax filings public,
- 20:54but in a lot of places you can receive donations
- 20:56if you're a non -profit and then you have to
- 20:59file annual tax reports and you have to make
- 21:02them public. So that's a good place to start
- 21:05depending on which country you're researching
- 21:08in. So I was trying to see how can I report this
- 21:13in India where data is not publicly accessible
- 21:19in a lot of other places. I started looking at
- 21:22it from a different way because I was seeing
- 21:25that the Indian government is cracking down on
- 21:27non -profits and media outlets, whereas there
- 21:31are these four really popular Hindu nationalist
- 21:34organizations that are able to receive donations,
- 21:39including foreign donations, which are very,
- 21:40very regulated. It's not that this was new in
- 21:44the sense that people knew of these far right
- 21:47media outlets, at least the ones who follow the
- 21:50Indian far right would be aware of them. But
- 21:52I was still curious to see if they were breaking
- 21:55any potential laws while making the money. And
- 21:58it's very difficult to say because, you know,
- 22:01laws are a lot of laws are just, it's the way
- 22:04they are interpreted. So you can't exactly pinpoint,
- 22:09at least in my case, I couldn't pinpoint or just
- 22:13say that, yes, they were breaking laws, but the
- 22:15lawyers that I spoke to were of the opinion that
- 22:19there could be potential violations. And if there
- 22:22are potential violations and no action has been
- 22:24taken, it's a suggestion that, okay, they do
- 22:28receive some sort of impunity from the government.
- 22:32And in my previous story, there was this one
- 22:35organization that was quite interesting because
- 22:38it was directly making money. It was publishing
- 22:42hate and propaganda in India, but it was, I saw
- 22:45that it was able to directly make money in the
- 22:48U .S. When I say directly making money, I don't
- 22:52mean like a dollar in the U .S., say, transferring
- 22:56donation to the Indian organization. But this
- 23:00organization had a nonprofit set up in the U
- 23:03.S. and they were receiving money through this
- 23:07nonprofit. Again, very difficult to say exactly
- 23:10if this nonprofit was transferring money or how
- 23:14they were transferring money, but they were both
- 23:16mentioned in each other's books, so to speak.
- 23:20So I saw that there was this nonprofit which
- 23:23was affiliated to this media outlet in India,
- 23:27and this nonprofit in the US was raising funds.
- 23:30It wasn't a lot of money. It was a few thousand
- 23:33dollars. But it did make me think that if there
- 23:37is a small nonprofit making a little money in
- 23:40the US, are there more? And there are a lot more.
- 23:45And I'm going to talk about that in a minute
- 23:49and how this network functions. But before I
- 23:53get into that, let me talk a bit about the RSS,
- 23:56which is the Hindu nationalist organization in
- 24:00India. In case you haven't heard about them,
- 24:04they are, I'd wager, the largest and the most
- 24:08successful far -right movement in the world.
- 24:12So yeah, just a brief introduction about the
- 24:14RSS, which is short for Rashtriya Swayamsevak
- 24:18Sangh in Hindi, which in English translates to
- 24:22National Volunteer Organization. The word volunteer
- 24:25is key here because the RSS is a Hindu registered
- 24:29entity in India and that's by design. They have
- 24:33been criticized a lot for not making their financials
- 24:36public for any scrutiny. It functions in India
- 24:39with an almost an absolute impunity with no accountability.
- 24:44It's very powerful. It's a super powerful Hindu
- 24:47nationalist organization. And like I said, by
- 24:49far the most successful far right group in the
- 24:52world. The current ruling government in India
- 24:54under the Bharatiya Janata Party or the BJP is
- 24:58reported to be the political wing of the RSS.
- 25:01Prime Minister Narendra Modi himself has said
- 25:03that he was a member or a volunteer since RSS
- 25:08again is not registered, so it doesn't have an
- 25:11official list of volunteers. The Prime Minister
- 25:17has said that he was a member since he was a
- 25:19teenager and now He has filled his cabinet with
- 25:23ministers who reportedly have an RSS background.
- 25:27So India is pretty much ruled, governed, shaped
- 25:30by the RSS. The RSS sort of has an omnipresence
- 25:34in the country. And it's important to understand
- 25:37that it's not just the main body, which is the
- 25:40RSS, but everything and all of the initiatives
- 25:42and organizations, some registered, some not
- 25:46registered, that come under it and are a part
- 25:48of its family. And these organizations don't
- 25:51just exist in India, they exist across the world.
- 25:56And they are linked to the RSS through historical
- 25:59references, like when they were set up, they
- 26:03explained how they were set up. And you can go
- 26:05back and look at archived copies of their websites
- 26:08or some statements that their members may have
- 26:12made that suggested that they were started by
- 26:16the RSS, or they were started by people who were
- 26:18in the RSS. I'm going to read out just to give
- 26:24a better understanding of how the Indian Far
- 26:27-right functions and how it's different from
- 26:30European Far -right. I'll read out this short
- 26:33excerpt from this professor from Australia. His
- 26:36name is Professor Felix Ball and he has researched
- 26:41the RSS extensively. Super short paragraph that
- 26:44I'm going to read out from one of his papers.
- 26:48He writes, I propose one explanation for far
- 26:52-right success in India, a far -right organizational
- 26:55network strategy that I refer to as organizational
- 26:59diffusion. I define organizational diffusion
- 27:02as the strategic creation of a large number of
- 27:06proxy civil society organizations through which
- 27:09the central network executives can covertly organize
- 27:12sophisticated divisions of labor. These elaborate
- 27:16but covert divisions of labor ensure far -right
- 27:19presence in many sectors simultaneously, reaching
- 27:23more diverse audiences, opening opportunities
- 27:25for constituency expansion, and creating the
- 27:29false public image of ostensibly independent
- 27:31organizations organically seeking the same goals
- 27:34in coalition. What this means is that when it
- 27:37comes to the Indian far -right, it is important
- 27:39to understand how it functions in a sort of a
- 27:43diffused model. It's a normalization technique
- 27:47often focused on tradition and culture and way
- 27:50of life instead of just pure hate. There is a
- 27:53lot of hate, don't get me wrong, but there is
- 27:57a lot more so that it has become a way of life.
- 28:02It doesn't just rely on societal divisions. but
- 28:06aims to infect every part of a nation's structure.
- 28:10And a lot of it could be through programs that
- 28:13look good from a very superficial look, for instance,
- 28:20like educational initiatives or relief work or
- 28:23food programs. And they sort of do this so that
- 28:28they are able to infiltrate society in a very
- 28:32normalized fashion. You can't be a part of Indian
- 28:35society and not live in this structure or be
- 28:40among those who follow this ideology. And a lot
- 28:43of times it's unintentional. It could be your
- 28:46friends, it could be your parents. The RSS has
- 28:50a non -traditional support base. It has regular
- 28:53people. It is not as defined as... you know,
- 28:56like the Nazis. It's not like a National Socialist
- 28:59German Workers Party or the Nazi Party. It is
- 29:01the school you go to, but you know, you're not
- 29:03aware, or it is the judge who may be presiding
- 29:06over your case. It is the policies that the government
- 29:09is making for you. It is the food that you eat
- 29:12at restaurants. It isn't people marching on the
- 29:15roads. Sometimes, well, sometimes they are, but
- 29:18it's not as obvious as, you know, they're wearing
- 29:20uniforms, marching on the roads. taking you out
- 29:23of your homes or just beating you up. It is a
- 29:29group of young men in motorcycles brandishing
- 29:33swords or flags and dancing outside a mosque
- 29:37out of their own will when a Hindu festival is
- 29:40going on and they are just outside a mosque trying
- 29:43to make a point. Which is why reporting on it
- 29:47is complex, but India has a good case study.
- 29:50to acknowledge that a lot of research on the
- 29:53far right, current research is sort of Eurocentric.
- 29:57It focuses on the idea of ideological commitment
- 30:00for the members of the far right, a lot of times
- 30:03for electoral politics. And the research is a
- 30:08little inattentive to far right movements that
- 30:10have been successful in other parts of the world
- 30:13where people join for non -ideological reasons.
- 30:18It's not fringe. It's regular people. And a lot
- 30:22of times you can't tell that, okay, you know,
- 30:25I could be a cog in the far right machine, but
- 30:27you just are. And a lot of these organizations
- 30:32that function in the network of the RSS help
- 30:36it flourish from the grassroots level. And they
- 30:41are not just in India, but they are across the
- 30:44world. There was a recent... project I'll share
- 30:49in the chat here. Again, this map has, oh, thanks.
- 30:54Sorry for sharing that. This map, one of the
- 30:57people who worked on this is the professor, Professor
- 31:00Felix Paul, and I read his, the excerpt from
- 31:03one of his papers. So if you open that map, you
- 31:05can see these are all the RSS affiliated organizations.
- 31:10They have their methodology. You can read it.
- 31:13They mapped out where organizations affiliated
- 31:17to RSS exist in the world and you can see that
- 31:19it's like throughout the world. Right now I've
- 31:24been looking at how RSS has its network in the
- 31:29US and how it uses a lot of these organizations
- 31:35that are set up in the US to fundraise and I
- 31:41am able to get partially an idea of how much
- 31:46money they are able to make by, because like
- 31:49I said before, in the US, which is not the case
- 31:53in India, but in the US, you have to make, if
- 31:55you're a nonprofit, you have to make your tax
- 31:57filings public. So I'm able to see how much money
- 32:00that they are able to raise. You also have to
- 32:03show how much, what their expenses are so you
- 32:07can sort of track where the money is going. you
- 32:10won't be able to exactly tell, okay, if it was
- 32:13used for an X or Y purpose, but you can tell
- 32:16that, okay, this much money was transferred into
- 32:20a certain region or to a certain country. And
- 32:23this is possible not just with the RSS, but if
- 32:27you are looking at other far -right groups and
- 32:30you see that, okay, they have networks in other
- 32:34parts of the world. You can check if they're
- 32:36registered or not registered and then try to
- 32:38see their tax filings or other reports and try
- 32:42to see if you're able to track the money in some
- 32:47way. Even if it's not a complete picture, it
- 32:50can give an idea. Yeah. I think I should end
- 32:52there and continue if anyone has questions. Amazing.
- 32:59Thank you so much, both of you for sharing your
- 33:02insights. First, Michael, going through kind
- 33:05of mapping out how you make digital network connections
- 33:09and then future going into the financial status
- 33:12and giving a background to the RSS as well, which
- 33:16is really, really useful and possibly surprising
- 33:20for a few people in the audience here. I definitely
- 33:23wasn't aware of the scale having looked at that
- 33:27map. And please do get your questions into the
- 33:29chat. We have about half an hour. for questions.
- 33:33I wanted to ask questions related to those two
- 33:36points, digital network mapping and then the
- 33:38financial networking mapping. I was wondering,
- 33:42first and foremost, maybe Michael, your best
- 33:45to answer this. What does rigorous attribution
- 33:48look like when you're dealing with pseudonyms
- 33:51and anonymous online identities? How do you kind
- 33:54of take it from this is a an Instagram account
- 33:59that's particularly prominent in this network
- 34:01and then starting to connect that to actual people
- 34:04in photographs that you might find. For example,
- 34:08is it just look of the draw finding kind of tags
- 34:10or is there like a technique to kind of build
- 34:14that digital footprint into real life connections?
- 34:18I think I would say there is a technique or techniques
- 34:24at least with a lot of the networks, your groups,
- 34:30individuals that I focused my work on, depending
- 34:34on the platform that they use, when you're trying
- 34:38to research, like identify individuals as in
- 34:41like, oh, who's behind this Instagram account
- 34:43or, oh, what is this person's real name? Who
- 34:49are they? I find with a lot of these networks,
- 34:56using some pretty rigorous digital footprint
- 35:01tracing, as we would call it, in terms of seeing
- 35:05where else they're tagged, trying to find, and
- 35:08usually successfully finding some sort of other
- 35:11photos of them, other social media accounts,
- 35:15screen names that they've used or reused across
- 35:18other platforms that they'd have shared, maybe
- 35:21often without knowing biographical information
- 35:23about themselves. It can often be once you get
- 35:27enough of the right clues lining up, the problem
- 35:32of attribution actually usually gets solved pretty
- 35:37quickly because fortunately for us, unfortunately
- 35:40for them, a lot of, at least most of the kinds
- 35:45of networks and movements that I've looked at,
- 35:50they... even if they think at times they're being
- 35:53careful with their digital safety and security,
- 35:57they've still left plenty of digital clues out
- 36:00there. In work that maybe I've done over the
- 36:02last year or two, or even stuff that I'm doing
- 36:05now, there's not that many of these accounts.
- 36:14There haven't been many cases when I've wanted
- 36:17to... identify or at least know whether I publish
- 36:19it or not, identify a person behind an account.
- 36:23And a lot of times, I'm sorry, there haven't
- 36:26been that many times and a lot of those times
- 36:28it's not somebody who is particularly prominent
- 36:32and probably wouldn't publish about anyways.
- 36:35So that can change if you start looking at different
- 36:41sorts of networks, it can become a bit complicated.
- 36:45But yeah, just to loop back to my main point,
- 36:47in general, these guys often leave far too many
- 36:52digital clues in a way that makes attribution
- 36:57not a problem. Yeah, and there's been cases,
- 37:03right, where there has been an attempt to possibly
- 37:07obscure data that Yes. That has led to identifying.
- 37:14Yeah, where they've blurred their faces, which
- 37:17believe it or not, guys, does not always work.
- 37:19Or in the Columbia investigation, extensively
- 37:22blurring tattoos, but forgetting that colors
- 37:27show through blurring and placement of tattoos
- 37:31shows through blurring. Even if you've blurred
- 37:35every frame of somebody that you're trying to
- 37:38identify who's covered in tattoos. If I know
- 37:41what the original person looks like or the person
- 37:43who I suspect it is, and like I did for that
- 37:45article match up in three or four places, draw
- 37:47a conclusion. It's like, okay, it is, you know,
- 37:50not scientifically, but journalist eating like,
- 37:53it's extremely unlikely that this person is anybody
- 37:57other than this guy. Blurring does not always
- 38:01help. Tip for anyone listening there. We've had
- 38:05a question. Thanks for this talk. My data scientist
- 38:08mind makes me wonder if quantitative methods
- 38:10involving graphs and network science have their
- 38:14place in these investigations. Short answer is
- 38:17yes. I would defer more to Pooja on that. I will
- 38:20admit that a lot of the data journalism, data
- 38:26science that maybe could be done with work that
- 38:29I'm doing now or in the past is just personally
- 38:31not something I've made use of a lot. Probably
- 38:37should make use of it more. But I know Pooja
- 38:39has definitely a lot more. Yeah, it's definitely
- 38:45possible. I think Bellingcat also had that QAnon
- 38:48map where we made a network graph. It was before
- 38:53I joined. But it's definitely possible. And this
- 38:59RSS map that I shared as well. they have a map,
- 39:03but they also have a network app where they have
- 39:06made a network map. And you can see which nodes
- 39:11are more popular than the others. So it's definitely
- 39:16possible. And even for the current research that
- 39:20I'm working on, if you look at the map, there
- 39:22are 113 organizations in the US. Some of them
- 39:28are non -profits and because in the US you can
- 39:31download tax filings, you could possibly automate
- 39:35this process and look at how much money they
- 39:39are making, what are their expenses, and try
- 39:42to do it through some data journalism instead
- 39:48of doing everything manually. I couldn't find
- 39:51the correct QAnon link, but there's an interesting
- 39:55article that I linked to from 2021 in the chat.
- 39:58Nick asks two questions for Fujia. How useful
- 40:01is the RSS to the ruling BJP party? Like how
- 40:04much of BJP's volunteers and fundraising come
- 40:06from these diffused elements of the RSS? And
- 40:09also for tracking the financing of hate groups.
- 40:12What is the role of cryptocurrency in hiding
- 40:14donor networks? For the first question, how useful
- 40:21the RSS to the BJP? BJP is reportedly the political
- 40:27arm of the RSS, so super important. And they
- 40:32don't acknowledge it. None of these affiliates,
- 40:35none of these organizations would acknowledge
- 40:37that they are a part of the RSS family, but there
- 40:43is evidence from, you know, ground reporting
- 40:46or their early literature that suggests that
- 40:48there are links. The BJP also says that it functions
- 40:53independently. And there would be no acknowledgement.
- 40:57That's why it's like RSS is particularly difficult
- 40:59to report on, just because of its quote unquote
- 41:02unofficial status. But yeah, it's super important.
- 41:08And how much of BJP's volunteers and fundraising
- 41:10come from these diffuse elements of the RSS?
- 41:14I think I can link a report. If you just Google
- 41:18Modi ministers, RSS or something like that, I
- 41:22think a majority of the current cabinet in the
- 41:25Modi government, they have an RSS background,
- 41:29which means that a majority of the ministers
- 41:34in the Modi government, they were at least directly
- 41:39linked to the RSS. They've been volunteers or
- 41:42members of the RSS. or have been volunteers or
- 41:45members of its affiliate groups. So a lot of
- 41:50BJP people are historically RSS. And how much
- 41:55of the fundraising comes from these diffuse elements,
- 41:59it's very, very difficult to say. If these elements
- 42:02are in India, then it's almost impossible to
- 42:07say. Just because in India, it's not mandated
- 42:12by law to make your filings public. But if you
- 42:18look at their foreign affiliates, I'm not sure
- 42:22where you're from, but if you look at that map,
- 42:25you can click on. RSS affiliates in the UK and
- 42:30see if they are registered or not registered
- 42:32and check if what kind of laws exist in the UK
- 42:35and if it allows you to look at their filings
- 42:37and you can then see that, okay, in UK there
- 42:40are 20 RSS organizations according to this map
- 42:43and this is the amount of money that they are
- 42:45making. So I have looked at the US and it's a
- 42:51lot of money. It's like I just looked at For
- 42:59my current research, I'm looking at three organizations
- 43:01and it's millions and millions of dollars. So
- 43:05it's a lot of money that goes from pure potentially
- 43:09to RSS causes, although they are all going to
- 43:12deny that it is used for anything except good
- 43:17work because they pose themselves as relief organizations.
- 43:21And I'm sure like a lot of work that they do
- 43:23could be relief as well, could be... programs,
- 43:26like education programs or things like that,
- 43:28because like I said, RSS wants to establish itself
- 43:32not just as a hate group, even though their ideology
- 43:38is to establish India as a Hindu nation, but
- 43:42a lot of the work that they do is to insert themselves
- 43:47in every part of your life, which means that
- 43:49some of the work that they do would come across
- 43:52as good work. For the cryptocurrency, I'm not
- 43:57sure. I haven't looked at that at all. So I wouldn't
- 44:02be able to comment on that. When investigating
- 44:06Andrew Tate's network several years ago, I did
- 44:12speak to some journalists and did try to do some
- 44:16analysis or tracing of some cryptocurrency accounts.
- 44:25But it was also, it's not my expertise, it was
- 44:31not immediately fruitful because there were so
- 44:36many, there were so many, some of them were small
- 44:42amounts, couldn't figure out what money was going
- 44:46where. So I do think for networks like that,
- 44:50particularly as time goes on, trying to see what
- 44:56cryptocurrency accounts they might be using or
- 45:00possible connections or payments. That needs
- 45:03to be an avenue explored more to the extent that
- 45:06these kinds of networks or groups use it. Absolutely.
- 45:12It does seem to be popping up quite a bit. In
- 45:16regards to questions from the audience, we also
- 45:18have another one. Thank you so much for the talk.
- 45:20How do the different groups do diplomacy with
- 45:23each other? Do they have certain people that
- 45:27are more responsible for inter -fascist outreach
- 45:30or is it more like they happen to like the same
- 45:33content? How do these groups get along basically
- 45:37and coordinate? I would say for the most part,
- 45:43especially in a European context, it is a lot
- 45:48based on individuals and personalities. For the
- 45:54people from these groups who are meeting up with
- 45:59other people, who are going to each other's events,
- 46:03promoting each other, often it'll be somebody
- 46:05who's a leader, a de facto leader, or somebody
- 46:08senior. And in some cases, kind of depending
- 46:12on the group where it might be. in Europe and
- 46:17beyond. Excuse me. It can come down to, in terms
- 46:25of these international connections, it can come
- 46:27down to one individual's preferences or even
- 46:33skills with foreign languages. Trying to do this,
- 46:37as the questioner phrased it, inter -fascist
- 46:40outreach. There's not much of a common language
- 46:46then or if somebody say doesn't some of the some
- 46:51of these individuals like some groups might not
- 46:53be hugely interested or some members of groups
- 46:57or networks might not be hugely interested in
- 47:01too much international connections, but some
- 47:04individuals might because me like I'm actually
- 47:08Thinking of an individual that I'm aware of from
- 47:11I'll just say a Balkan country And I know this
- 47:14individual is a fringe figure on this country's
- 47:18far right, to say the least. He is well -educated,
- 47:23speaks quite good English, and also has, I think,
- 47:27spent time maybe at university being educated
- 47:30in Italy. So he's got Italian connections and
- 47:36really pushes those kinds of even Italian fascist
- 47:41influences on on his own group or in particular
- 47:45the outreach there. You really can see sometimes
- 47:46the outreach, if we can call it that, is dependent
- 47:50on personal relationships. Like really sometimes
- 47:55between specific people internationally and if
- 47:58or when those friendships or those individuals
- 48:02are no longer around, sometimes it will just
- 48:05fade off. Interesting that it's built on those
- 48:07personal connections rather than kind of matching
- 48:13matching beliefs or matching rhetoric. Yeah.
- 48:19I mean, obviously a lot of that certainly drives
- 48:23a lot of it. But one thing that I would say based
- 48:27on the work that I've done over what seems like
- 48:32a lot of years now is a lot more of the activity
- 48:35that I've spend all this time monitoring, paying
- 48:40attention to researching, investigating, what
- 48:43have you. So much of it is driven by individuals
- 48:49within these groups or networks. At a point in
- 48:56time, there was a network that I assumed or movement
- 49:00that I assumed had across the board, incredible
- 49:05interest in international networking and attention
- 49:10and whatnot but as I did more and more research
- 49:13it really became apparent to me that a lot of
- 49:16that was led by one person who was responsible
- 49:21for the outreach who had very good foreign language
- 49:25skills and was not necessarily a priority for
- 49:29for the rest of the rest of the their movement
- 49:32or whatever we want to call it. So I mean, yes,
- 49:35a lot of it is still is going to be driven by
- 49:39at least some shared beliefs, they're not going
- 49:41to, they don't necessarily have to align in all
- 49:45of the various ridiculous permutations of hateful
- 49:51far right thought, but they're, you know, you're
- 49:54not going to see rabidly pro -Russian or and,
- 49:58you know, at least normally quote unquote pro
- 50:01-Ukraine far -right groups hanging out like that
- 50:05or like that's that that kind of thing is less
- 50:09is less going to happen. Adrien in the chat is
- 50:12asking whether these groups, these connections
- 50:16just stay online or whether there is a physical
- 50:20presence. They've asked, do hate groups sometimes
- 50:24travel to other countries to actively commit
- 50:26hate crime with other local groups or is it quite
- 50:29rare and mostly just online alliances? You've
- 50:32mentioned some of the fight night events, Michael,
- 50:34but is there cases of actual action? The short
- 50:40answer, I think, is yes. It does depend on the
- 50:44country and where some of whatever meetup they're
- 50:49doing or wherever the networking is. It can depend
- 50:53on whether they're traveling to a place where
- 50:57maybe they feel they can get away with more or
- 50:59just sometimes something happens, there's some
- 51:04bite or they're... maybe in some cases, though
- 51:09in kind of randomly committed attack. But what
- 51:12I will say is they're both the online and the
- 51:16offline work together. And what makes, you know,
- 51:22do members of hate groups, will they, I wouldn't
- 51:25say they would necessarily travel to other countries
- 51:28just to engage in acts of violence. I mean, there
- 51:35might be some that do, but I think that's more
- 51:37straight -up football hooliganism, for example,
- 51:40which people probably are aware of that. That's
- 51:44where I would see that more. For this kind of
- 51:47networking, they're not, say, traveling to a
- 51:51particular... When the Dutch Active Club has
- 51:54had their quote -unquote fight nights, those
- 51:57groups are not traveling here to go roam the
- 51:59streets committing hate crimes. At least that's
- 52:02not their intent. I don't know if they do. I
- 52:04don't really think they do. Their intent is to
- 52:06network, to have their little fight night, to
- 52:09film their propaganda, to beat each other up,
- 52:11to build up their fighting skills, et cetera,
- 52:13et cetera. It's more about that. And if there
- 52:16is violence that happens, it is maybe secondary.
- 52:24I'll just add to that, that yeah, like whatever
- 52:29Michael said, I've noticed a similar pattern
- 52:33in the Hindu far -right as well. There is a lot
- 52:36of networking and they do travel across countries.
- 52:41But I don't think the primary objective is to
- 52:44commit hate crimes. At least for the Hindu far
- 52:48-right, it seems to be to fundraise because your
- 52:53foreign supporters could have a lot of money.
- 52:56And if your supporters are based in rich countries
- 52:59like the US, they potentially have a lot more
- 53:02money than you can raise from individual donors
- 53:05in India. To that point, just this weekend, the
- 53:10supreme leader of the RSS, he's doing a tour
- 53:14of the US, Canada, and the UK. So this last weekend,
- 53:19he was in New York at Madison Square Garden,
- 53:23which is I've heard very difficult to get into.
- 53:28And so you know that, you know, it is, they care.
- 53:31They do want to talk to their audiences outside
- 53:36of, you know, the borders of the country where
- 53:38they mainly function. And it's not, nothing happened.
- 53:41It's not like, you know, because of this supreme
- 53:45leader, you know, visiting New York, it's not
- 53:47like any incidents happened, but The point is
- 53:52that he was visiting probably because he thinks
- 53:55there is a lot of support here and he needs to
- 53:59maintain that. And there is already some reporting
- 54:03about the money that the RSS is able to raise
- 54:06in the US. It's interesting that he's currently
- 54:11in the US. I did not know that. Lots of reports
- 54:14to read there. And some people in the chat are
- 54:17responding to that. saying that in the US context,
- 54:21you do frequently have people traveling a thousand
- 54:24miles to attend multiple rallies. For example,
- 54:27some of the Proud Boy meetups and somebody in
- 54:32Belfast Island also mentioned that there was
- 54:35a few events in Ireland that saw far right from
- 54:39the USA, France and Austria arrive. That's related
- 54:44also to larger scale protest movements. Nick
- 54:48has asked, one of the things the US 2025 national
- 54:51security strategy focused on was European civilizational
- 54:54erasure and called for US support for European
- 54:57far -right parties. What kind of impact could
- 54:59slash does that have on European hate groups
- 55:02slash far -right politics? What does the influence
- 55:05from abroad have on localized movements? I will
- 55:11give a quick answer and say two things as far
- 55:13as the could or maybe Already is one. I think
- 55:19is that it's this US support Has or at least
- 55:25will make some of these far -right parties You
- 55:31give them a bit of wind in their sails and make
- 55:34them feel feel more confident in Pushing the
- 55:39envelope in term in terms of their rhetoric.
- 55:41I think in in a lot of countries compared to
- 55:47five years ago, there are things that these kinds
- 55:51of actors are saying in the public space that
- 55:53was extremely unacceptable five years ago, but
- 55:57at least to some extent is being tolerated now.
- 56:00So on the one hand, I do think there's a bit
- 56:02of wind in the sails effect, if I can use that
- 56:04metaphor. But secondly, I think we might see
- 56:10over time US, because I know some of the funding
- 56:16has started or at least is being planned. Some
- 56:22funding for far -right organizations, probably
- 56:27not the explicitly say neo -Nazi ones that I
- 56:29focus on. I mean, I don't think, at least I hope
- 56:32we don't see that, but the more funding for some
- 56:36of these quote unquote NGOs or again, quote unquote
- 56:40think tanks. who are allied with the far right
- 56:43pushing some of these kinds of policies. I think
- 56:45there's a good chance that some of, in particular
- 56:48countries, some of these kinds of almost relating
- 56:52to what Pooja was saying with the RSS, some of
- 56:54these almost kind of wannabe civil society organizations
- 56:58linked to the far right, they might have at least
- 57:02a bit more funding to work with thanks to the
- 57:05U .S., but I think we'll see down the road. protests
- 57:11last year or where Elon Musk made an appearance
- 57:15and his statement about the dissolution of the
- 57:18UK parliament and a change of government kind
- 57:21of echoed in our newspapers for days after the
- 57:25event really gave it much more. I mean, Steven
- 57:29Yatso -Lennon froze quite a few protests, but
- 57:33that one really stuck in the media sphere because
- 57:35of the involvement of Elon Musk and a few other
- 57:38American figures. Yeah, that's definitely changing
- 57:42on the UK sphere anyway. We are almost at time
- 57:46and I'm really sorry to say that, but I wanted
- 57:48to just quickly recap on some of the discussion
- 57:51that we've had and quickly ask you, what are
- 57:55you, if you are starting an investigation into
- 57:58a larger network or ecosystem. What are usually
- 58:04your first signals that something is worth investigating
- 58:06further? If we could just end with that question
- 58:10and then I'll wrap up. Michael, do you want to
- 58:14take it first? Yeah. Sorry, in terms of like
- 58:17when you see something, what's assigned for two
- 58:19and that you maybe want to investigate? Exactly.
- 58:25especially when you're looking at social media,
- 58:28when or if you're looking at again, depending
- 58:31on what you're looking at, if it might be a very
- 58:33small context, maybe you're a or your specific
- 58:35country context or, or part of a country is looking
- 58:41for, like I said, and when I was speaking, the
- 58:44things that you might consider, quote unquote,
- 58:47unusual, depending on the context, like, oh,
- 58:50why is this? I'm making up examples here. Why
- 58:54is this very small group from this country in
- 58:56the Balkans, why are they following all these
- 58:59French groups? Or maybe there's something there.
- 59:03Why are they following this or being followed
- 59:06by a local politician? Like I said, with the
- 59:09Columbia investigation, that right away it was
- 59:10like, something's up here. This is weird. And
- 59:13there was. When it's something that based on,
- 59:18even over a short period of time, what you've
- 59:20managed to learn about a network. It's when something
- 59:26stands out as unusual. It doesn't mean that every
- 59:30single one of those things is going to be some
- 59:31lead that leads somewhere. But in for some of
- 59:36the what I think the most impactful investigations
- 59:39that I've done, it's seeing something that I
- 59:42knew was in the context, not normal or unusual.
- 59:47And I latched onto it right away. And it was
- 59:51able to lead somewhere. I think I would give
- 59:57a similar answer. It doesn't have to be too big.
- 1:00:04Anything that looks unusual raises some eyebrows
- 1:00:07and you could always expand and see if there
- 1:00:10is a pattern. But anything that looks off, and
- 1:00:15I would also say that some things may already
- 1:00:19be reported on. which is okay, it doesn't mean
- 1:00:23that there can't be further reporting on it.
- 1:00:26It's always good to read what has already been
- 1:00:29reported and see how things have changed since
- 1:00:34that past reporting or if there are new angles
- 1:00:37to a story. So especially for starting out, I
- 1:00:40think reading other people's reporting, academic
- 1:00:44papers as well, is a good place to start. Thank
- 1:00:50you both for coming in and sharing your insights
- 1:00:52into research on this topic. This podcast episode
- 1:00:57will be available by next week on all podcast
- 1:01:01providers. And we'll be back in two weeks' time
- 1:01:03talking about cold cases and reporting on cold
- 1:01:06cases with open source research. But for now,
- 1:01:09please do read Michael and Pooja's work on the
- 1:01:11Bell and Cat website. Check out the links that
- 1:01:14will be included in the description of this podcast.
- 1:01:16And thank you so much for joining. Thanks everyone.
- 1:01:20Thank you. Thank you for listening to the Stage
- 1:01:23Talk. If you'd like to catch a Stage Talk live
- 1:01:27where you can ask the guest questions, join the
- 1:01:30Bellingcat Discord server by visiting www .discord
- 1:01:35.gg slash Bellingcat. The music you've heard
- 1:01:39is titled Dawn by Newer Self and is courtesy
- 1:01:43of Artlist.