Latest / SHULCHAN ARUCH YOMI: Own the Halacha in 25 minutes a day! / Yoreh De’ah 267:14-20. Slaves: When Slavery Applies, Forcing Deviants Into Forced Labor, Government Decree/War, Female Owner, No Support

Transcript

Yoreh De’ah 267:14-20. Slaves: When Slavery Applies, Forcing Deviants Into Forced Labor, Government Decree/War, Female Owner, No Support · SHULCHAN ARUCH YOMI: Own the Halacha in 25 minutes a day!

• 0:00
  Good morning, we are in Herzegovina Zion up to sif you
• 0:05
  dollar. This is a bit of a interesting
• 0:08
  then you dollar ain't every knowing every knows every is
• 0:15
  only knowing when you're is knowing the Hani Mili, the
• 0:21
  Migni, a goofy. This then only apply is is
• 0:25
  talking about for Kenyan ha goof that you would need to get
• 0:29
  Shikhar for that would allow him to marry a Shifka things like
• 0:33
  that marry whatever it is the Shard DNA Evidevi Avaheka de
• 0:38
  Kanye Shavai, the Maisi Yadav. If a Jew was was captured and
• 0:46
  and they forced him into the office.
• 0:50
  Maisi Yadav, Dina da Mahusa according to the laws of the
• 0:54
  country Kagan Shinish Bahama, he was captured in Mahama Shimahu
• 1:02
  or it should be Oh, Shimahu Gulbe Hamas or like it mentioned
• 1:07
  this case yesterday. There was a case in the Gamora
• 1:10
  where the Melok said, OK, anyone can't pay taxes and get sold as
• 1:13
  a slave. And so the the you know, the tax
• 1:16
  collector sold him sold him as a slave.
• 1:18
  How the multi Luzuna Israel and I say, oh, though you can you
• 1:22
  sell can be sold for his might see a dime.
• 1:24
  There is such a thing as an every livery, the multi high
• 1:27
  evidence mayor of the rabbit Israel, the baby not sorry and
• 1:31
  this evidence every can give pay the pay the pay off the you know
• 1:36
  if he has something in the bank and pay off his master, the
• 1:40
  Israel to go free ultimate Shavyev or even if the how much
• 1:45
  you pay by however much they they would estimate how much
• 1:48
  he's worth and Norfolk and he would go free.
• 1:51
  We had a Alden Altarina Lika Apocos and the other one you
• 1:56
  have to take the puffles, which is interesting.
• 1:58
  I don't just say, well, how could you go ahead and buy the
• 2:00
  year then whatever, you know, you lost your money.
• 2:05
  He has to he would have this this Jew would have to pay the
• 2:09
  pay off the guy in order to go for free.
• 2:12
  Otherwise he can he can use he can, you know, he can be his,
• 2:15
  you know, a free accountant for for the next number of years or
• 2:20
  whatever. Yeah, the office doesn't only
• 2:22
  mean you will see, doesn't what does only mean cleaning floors.
• 2:24
  It can mean, you know, being an accountant like Joseph Asadek
• 2:27
  was the first Jewish accountant and or it can mean any all types
• 2:32
  of all types of work. It doesn't specifically mean.
• 2:37
  It just means he works for free. So that's not up with that part,
• 2:41
  right, Right. Well, if every Yeah, so every,
• 2:44
  every so someone. So then the truth is it is
• 2:46
  interesting again, when you do get to there is a discussion
• 2:51
  about the the the foreign discussed this in to have an
• 2:55
  understanding about how how long someone can put make a contract
• 3:02
  for. And there is a din and you
• 3:03
  shouldn't make a contract for more than three years because
• 3:08
  then it might look like he's inevitably some say some
• 3:11
  understand him because he really would have a dinner but never
• 3:13
  there. But he shouldn't make him if he
• 3:15
  makes a contract. Yeah, OK.
• 3:18
  All the details are over there. But Uncle Panim the Apollo you
• 3:22
  smell might even there are different.
• 3:24
  There are different stuff in the if he's working for a long a
• 3:27
  long time might have a different some denim of an of of every
• 3:31
  livery and certain for certain things.
• 3:36
  Uncle Panim not for like ISR or anything like that on Tess Valve
• 3:42
  Anashim Shan, Nogam Kishura Motorola Daison Barholska who
• 3:49
  stopped Ibrahim people who are not who who are not acting
• 3:54
  appropriately that you know they're you know, the criminal,
• 3:59
  criminal activity, whatever it is, it's criminal Dafka Then
• 4:03
  then it's motor to to hop them to take them and force them into
• 4:08
  some sort of forced work to try to rehabilitate them.
• 4:11
  This is it's a Gemara that's a brother, brother's brother used
• 4:15
  to do that and used to force into into working, you know, so
• 4:19
  to do something. So you know, I guess, you know,
• 4:23
  prison labor and all these things.
• 4:25
  I don't know prison labor, but but people sit around doing
• 4:28
  nothing and, you know, doing something like give them, you
• 4:31
  know, a push. I don't know that's Zion Melek.
• 4:34
  She Gazar, she called Michelite Hamas.
• 4:37
  I call Ishvi Ish. He stopped being the session
• 4:41
  also. I'm also.
• 4:41
  Yeah, although Melek was gazer that anyone who does not give
• 4:46
  taxes pay the taxes. Then he he comes to Mushubud to
• 4:52
  to the one who paid, who paid the tax for him.
• 4:54
  I raised a mutually established boy.
• 4:57
  This guy, you know his you know his neighbor, he didn't pay his
• 5:00
  taxes. His name was like, you know,
• 5:01
  great. So he he paid the guys, you
• 5:04
  know, this guy's taxes in this case, he's allowed to go ahead
• 5:08
  and force him to work for him. He used to me die.
• 5:10
  He's allowed to you know, we said before he's a different
• 5:13
  evidence, right, And he's allowed to go ahead and even
• 5:16
  make him work hard. You know, it's he has a
• 5:20
  different evidence of a low of a low Evan, but not my machine.
• 5:24
  He can make him work harder, but not hard Arcade cough like an
• 5:28
  evidence that who like you know, he could be controlling his
• 5:31
  brakes. This whatever he's allowed to
• 5:34
  work him a little more than a little more than normal.
• 5:36
  Ain't annoying Kashura. And if, like the second case,
• 5:39
  the last say, if he's not annoying Kashura multiple
• 5:41
  establishment Evan, then he's allowed to even make him work
• 5:45
  like an Evan. So the first case, the first
• 5:48
  date of this of now, what will be a nowadays we called, you
• 5:51
  know, NF and every is, you know, so if you dial that, if he gets
• 5:55
  sold because he because of the some law or something in the
• 5:59
  country that he has to go ahead and do you know that?
• 6:02
  So then so then in that case, he can, he can, he can, he can use
• 6:07
  it, he can push him a bit more, a loss of a coffee break, you
• 6:12
  know, a little less siesta. You can make them work harder.
• 6:14
  There's no issue. But if you and if, but if you
• 6:17
  take people off the street or in jail, I don't know, whatever,
• 6:22
  and you and you force them into into some sort of service.
• 6:25
  So then you can even make them work like an Evan.
• 6:28
  You're dying a kind of Evan Or if you could have him is well,
• 6:31
  someone who buys an Evan of you could have him or from another
• 6:40
  or from another for a non Jew. Or if there would be a non Jew
• 6:48
  who would sell himself to a Jew or he sold his kids.
• 7:00
  They all have a dinner with Ella.
• 7:08
  The difference is is that someone who buys an avid from
• 7:12
  another from another from from a different from another from from
• 7:16
  a guy is not ankle for Konoi Ella Baisa Yadav his he's only
• 7:22
  calling me from my my so you're dying Naf Kamina.
• 7:25
  The traps is Naf Kamina is for this is more is mostly only that
• 7:30
  he can be called on the tovol. He can, you know, jump in and
• 7:32
  say, you know, I'm being to evil as a Ben Hurin.
• 7:37
  That's the only enough Camino. That may be other enough.
• 7:39
  Camino is obviously, if he doesn't hurry, just need to get
• 7:41
  Chikur and Chikur is only for Kenya Naguf.
• 7:46
  I don't know if there are other. No, no, get I get Chikur.
• 7:50
  You need a star get Ellen and Kane Kano with Dina de Marcusa
• 7:56
  unless they bought him and he was Dina de Marcusa.
• 7:59
  Again, Dina de Marcusa is a discussion.
• 8:02
  Was it? What does that What does that
• 8:04
  mean? You know, it means that the law
• 8:06
  was so it means that it is in Dafka.
• 8:09
  I mentioned this. Does it mean Dafka if through
• 8:14
  Mahama or a law, you see from here that even a law from the
• 8:18
  denial of the moths can go ahead and push it and force a person
• 8:21
  into into into Abdus? Yeah, I mentioned I mentioned in
• 8:26
  the in the beginning that you know, the the question, the
• 8:29
  question brought up. If someone nowadays someone
• 8:32
  wants to retire and Amser and they want to go ahead and they
• 8:36
  and they will be clean it. And so they want to make a they
• 8:38
  want to, you know, be the guy or a woman as a as a shift of
• 8:43
  Canaanis instead of a full instead of a full, you know, a
• 8:48
  full guy artist. And they're they're by Mary and
• 8:50
  Amser Shyla's is that would that be Hal.
• 8:54
  So I did see a few different cheetahs there.
• 8:58
  It's not how we don't have slavery.
• 9:03
  It's not how the Kenyan Avdas wouldn't be how that's what he
• 9:11
  says Pasha. Kenyan Avdas wouldn't be how I
• 9:13
  saw a story or I don't know, a snippet that they asked the
• 9:18
  solovatrix. I don't know all these, you know
• 9:19
  the story books about him or whatever, like you know things
• 9:22
  of that. So they asked him once after
• 9:25
  Rasheer and he's about it and he's about Dina.
• 9:29
  There's no there there, there's you can't be coined in avid
• 9:33
  slavery. Slavery is forbidden.
• 9:35
  You can't be you can't be coined in avid.
• 9:39
  The slavery is forbidden the United States all international
• 9:46
  by law. By law it's forbidden.
• 9:48
  Yeah, I think you know, and eventually it was accepted.
• 9:51
  There's for confidence around the world.
• 9:52
  Now, first of all, there's no international dental sadina.
• 9:56
  There's no malach of the world. Every country is yes, I'm saying
• 10:00
  yes, except one. Yeah, except one.
• 10:03
  So the so each country is according to their laws.
• 10:06
  So there was a the Nicholas Yitzhak suggested that I've
• 10:11
  heard the suggestion that I don't remember so that you can
• 10:15
  go to a country where the is not so strong.
• 10:20
  There's a couple different things A country where a
• 10:25
  dictatorship is Kobe is the passion is if it's not, if it's
• 10:32
  not a it's not a it's not a place where the where the laws
• 10:35
  are enforced, well accepted by all the, all the, all the
• 10:39
  inhabitants, things like that. Then the then the mouthful.
• 10:42
  So there is not the, you know, if one, if one, if 11 week, it's
• 10:45
  one militia next week it's another warlord or I don't know,
• 10:48
  depends where you are, depends on different things.
• 10:52
  Where they're not, they're not really going to go ahead and you
• 10:55
  know, going to enforce the laws. So there are they gonna, you
• 11:00
  know, listen, you know, you go to someone's private islands.
• 11:04
  I don't know, private compound. I don't compound.
• 11:06
  I don't know in America country that is OK with slavery.
• 11:10
  No, I don't know there's any country which is OK with
• 11:12
  slavery. I don't think officially, I
• 11:14
  don't think there's any country which is OK with slavery.
• 11:18
  I have no idea. Yeah, I don't know the country,
• 11:20
  but they may not just be, they may not have the power.
• 11:22
  The government does not have the power to enforce anything.
• 11:27
  Yeah. So are you saying that it's not
• 11:29
  so then so that's over there could be would be Hal because
• 11:33
  the point is, is that if if the government has a right has a way
• 11:36
  to mafia the Kenyan or lots of Kenya not be Hal.
• 11:39
  So it could be it's a Hal Sternberg and Mashma.
• 11:44
  Also, they say that it could be also even say in America or even
• 11:48
  whatever that the definition of a Schiffer Klanes wouldn't fit
• 11:53
  into the definition of of of of slavery, because celebrations is
• 11:59
  even a case is even if you if you buy if you buy them I'll
• 12:03
  I'll I'll deny that you and them Chakra them that wouldn't fall
• 12:06
  under the the definition of of of slavery because yeah, and
• 12:14
  that would sidestep the deal in the mouth.
• 12:15
  So which would stop. But because yeah, that would be
• 12:18
  permitted by the horror because Kenya, Madam, it would sides
• 12:23
  that because because that's not the point of slavery.
• 12:25
  Slavery is you being shot at someone.
• 12:26
  You have possession, you pass whatever.
• 12:29
  There's a lot of guidelines. It's a little bit unclear in the
• 12:31
  constitution. I looked up the lushness of
• 12:34
  slavery. OK, it's a little bit unclear,
• 12:36
  but you know, but the idea of slavery is is you're is you're
• 12:40
  forcing someone to do things. The one point is, is that
• 12:44
  technically, even in the case where you would go ahead and to
• 12:47
  it could be result tonight that you're Misha, you'll be Misha
• 12:50
  her then could be that would be better.
• 12:51
  Because if it's just that you're going to be we'll see in a
• 12:53
  second. You're going to be nice to them.
• 12:55
  You're not going to she's going to be your wife and you're going
• 12:57
  to be, you know, whatever. There's still bets of outside
• 13:00
  that. Technically he could he could
• 13:02
  sell. He could sell her just OK, you
• 13:05
  know, sell to the next person. Like there is a technical sound
• 13:07
  like that. So it depends how deep in the
• 13:09
  social measurement that gets. Yeah, well, it does right.
• 13:14
  Right. If it's not outside, then the
• 13:16
  whole thing rebuttal, whatever. But but it's so Uncle Pan and
• 13:20
  there are there are patenting. There are different solutions.
• 13:24
  Diane White said that even if you have a country which is not
• 13:27
  so strong in the in the mouth, so you can even just go to their
• 13:30
  embassy. I go on to the property of the
• 13:33
  embassy and do it there. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
• 13:37
  He says that and this is here and it's as well.
• 13:40
  I don't know if you go to the Stachim here.
• 13:43
  You think I'm joking. You go to you go to like Niger
• 13:46
  Rico over there. I don't know how Stark is Dino
• 13:48
  Malkinson there. I don't know how much control.
• 13:50
  I'm not getting into whether if if the country Bidafa doesn't
• 13:53
  apply Malkinson or not. I don't know all these things
• 13:56
  and it's military rule, I don't know.
• 13:57
  But if you're in a place of you know, of you know that the that
• 14:01
  the that the the that it's more Hefker, whatever could be this.
• 14:06
  It's also less of an issue. I don't know, but cool close
• 14:11
  manually. It's real the shame Abdul's
• 14:13
  Dinoco Avikovi, the whole dova. And if they weren't titled the
• 14:16
  shame Abdul, then they were like an Avikovi for you know, they're
• 14:20
  not Jewish at all. Well, after she actually little
• 14:22
  the shame Abdul to evid after you title them.
• 14:25
  There are there are, there are the mitzvahs Shahisha Hayeves,
• 14:29
  Bahem and the hive in mitzvahs that the woman is is hiving of
• 14:35
  association as van grammar, whatever zemmuter Lavo, the
• 14:39
  pera, the pera this every kleini you are allowed to work to work
• 14:44
  in the pera. Even though this is true.
• 14:52
  Hey, all the Rachman the person should have Rachmanos, though
• 14:56
  you shouldn't be, you know, forced into the heavy, you know,
• 15:01
  heavy load don't to mitzar him Yokiluviyushku me call Michael
• 15:08
  Mashke and it should feed him and you know, feed him well for
• 15:13
  any of everything below you Vasuhu and nor and he should not
• 15:17
  vasa him embarrass him a little bit Yab a little bit very him
• 15:20
  not with like it was slapping him or words or whatever below.
• 15:26
  Yeah, I would say say call the homing your children also call
• 15:29
  the homing someone who you know is an employer to his employees
• 15:33
  and they're also may have been a volume as well.
• 15:36
  Below you are bell of Taco E the cast Ellie Dabber e-mail Binaka
• 15:41
  Suishma time and if you speak Binakas, people will listen to
• 15:45
  you. So volume also will listen to
• 15:47
  you. It's whatever.
• 15:51
  And this is one of the assaults of treats.
• 15:54
  He treats his workers as his voting.
• 15:58
  You know nicely that's what it should be.
• 16:00
  You have there was a non Jewish king who made a war behavi
• 16:07
  Shuwim and he brought Shuwim A mukram and he sold them and he
• 16:14
  told me he gave his sister. Anyone wants to go ahead and and
• 16:18
  steal people, kidnap people from this nation.
• 16:21
  Shyama Mahama, you can go ahead and and and and kidnap app and
• 16:27
  sell the captives for the you know for themselves.
• 16:32
  They came higher Dinov or any case there was a law she called
• 16:37
  me shaloite Hamas I maker sometimes them pay tax will be
• 16:40
  sold as a slave or Mishiyasa Khakhakh or if he broke this
• 16:44
  law, the Oyasa you maker Harry Dinovdin the dinner who said
• 16:50
  that would apply? I've been on Duke with him
• 16:54
  either way UK evic 90 little Dovar and he's in evic 90.
• 16:57
  He would need to get sure for all these things.
• 17:00
  I was just wondering was this now you know what to see about
• 17:03
  Shukurim. But when it came to those in the
• 17:06
  South and that you know the emancipation during the civil
• 17:08
  War Lahore that that time even I don't know about whether you
• 17:13
  need to get you know, get Shukur or not.
• 17:14
  I don't know. But Lahore they were all the
• 17:16
  slaves could be would have. I was thinking maybe have a
• 17:19
  dinner of Shuyin because, you know, it was during Bahamas.
• 17:23
  The North said, okay, we're taking all your slaves away now
• 17:26
  we're freeing them. But that I don't know.
• 17:28
  I don't know if freeing the slaves was tantamount to to, you
• 17:32
  know, was the same thing as capturing them.
• 17:33
  I don't know. It's just interesting to think
• 17:35
  about. I don't know you test Aisha.
• 17:40
  Aisha is allowed to be to to buy maidservants about Aina coin of
• 17:46
  volume. She's not allowed to buy men.
• 17:49
  You know men. A few look, Tani, because you
• 17:55
  know, it could come to you could come to it could come to
• 17:58
  problems and anytime and especially if they're said the
• 18:01
  task points out that this is not this this supplies Dafka the
• 18:05
  case where she's like the the master and then the evident that
• 18:08
  there's an extra reshuffs on top that that could that you know,
• 18:15
  you know that. First of all, he said that by
• 18:18
  Evan Ivory, like Mara says that the Evan Ivory's workshop
• 18:22
  because he would cover something if something unseemly happened,
• 18:25
  they would cover it up. Say that this is only in the
• 18:30
  case where she's mamish, like the boss, like you know, the
• 18:33
  like the other ones of the avid, but a stomp case of Co workers.
• 18:36
  This doesn't this doesn't apply because people keep you know,
• 18:40
  people keep, you know, keep a certain distance just in a case
• 18:43
  where there's she would so certain.
• 18:45
  I guess boundaries can get can get more easily erased.
• 18:49
  Huff, the master can say to his avid you know, you work for me.
• 18:58
  I am not going to support you and you'll you know, and what
• 19:05
  does this mean? One second.
• 19:08
  Yeah, that's he means and you go collect stucco.
• 19:11
  Go take stucco. He's allowed to say you're going
• 19:13
  to do my work and you'll and then you'll have to go out of
• 19:16
  collecting for yourself to buy food of Abde Nixa mulug by value
• 19:21
  of Nixa mulug Pierish Nixa mulug.
• 19:29
  That's a it's it's taking it. I'm feathering the head of a of
• 19:34
  an animal Satoshi and say are the Oasis in a rush.
• 19:37
  You, you pluck the hair and you leave the head Kahabao Uncle
• 19:40
  Paris, the husband eats pears. The next same a little years
• 19:47
  when a wife has, let's say she gets a yerusha, a simple case.
• 19:51
  And so that, so that money is invested in something.
• 19:56
  Let's say they buy, they buy an apartment, they buy a house,
• 19:58
  whatever and they rent it. So he gets the rent from it.
• 20:02
  So if she had a look, let's say she had in her possession from
• 20:06
  her family of Adim, then Hive Luzunam because that he's tried
• 20:11
  to manage properly manage the look and he's in that case he's
• 20:16
  Hive to support them. Gabi is showing him.
• 20:24
  How do you hold on but in a in a drought year or famine year
• 20:31
  shame or Akima love no one's going to give him any money low
• 20:35
  right then then then he can't do that of all Yahoo.
• 20:37
  That's that's beyond of all Yahoo lawyer load same.
• 20:40
  I say your diaphragm is on the side not speaking.
• 20:47
  He's allowed to say OK, work for yourself.
• 20:49
  I can't support you. You should go out and work for
• 20:51
  yourself and support yourself. Even if this guy is not so
• 20:55
  talented and he can't get a, you know, job is a, you know, in a
• 20:59
  law firm or whatever, he's he can't, he's going to be, you
• 21:03
  know, janitor or something of a Peking.
• 21:06
  He's allowed to say he is allowed to say that.
• 21:08
  He's not allowed to say, you know you're working for me and
• 21:11
  you have to go try to find your bread wherever you can.