Latest / Dr. Heather Evans with The BioBeautiful Effect / GLP1 & The Muscle Problem
Transcript
- 0:01(Transcribed by TurboScribe. Go Unlimited to remove this message.) Suppressing your appetite isn't the ultimate goal.
- 0:04Improving your health is the goal.
- 0:06This is the science of living better, feeling good, and looking great.
- 0:13Welcome to Dr. Heather Evans with The BioBeautiful Effect.
- 0:17Board certified in Family and Neuromuscular Medicine
- 0:19and specializing in Holistic Wellness and Medical Aesthetics at Temsegrity Health & Aesthetics.
- 0:24Here's Dr. Heather Evans.
- 0:26Welcome back to The BioBeautiful Effect
- 0:29where we talk about the science behind looking better, feeling better, and aging better.
- 0:34And today we're talking about something that I think is becoming
- 0:36one of the most important conversations around GLP-1 medications.
- 0:41For the last few years, everyone has been asking how much weight can I lose?
- 0:45But now I think we're finally asking a better question.
- 0:48What exactly am I losing?
- 0:51Meaning fat versus muscle?
- 0:53Exactly.
- 0:53Because if you tell me you lost 30 pounds, that's great.
- 0:57But I want to know what those 30 pounds were.
- 1:00Did you lose mostly body fat?
- 1:02Did you lose visceral fat?
- 1:04How much lean mass did you lose?
- 1:06Are you stronger?
- 1:07Are you weaker?
- 1:09What's happening to your body composition?
- 1:11Because losing 30 pounds isn't necessarily the same thing as losing 30 pounds well.
- 1:17And I feel like that's completely different from how most of us have been taught to think about weight loss.
- 1:23You get on the scale, the number is lower, I'm happy.
- 1:27Right, especially women.
- 1:29We've basically been conditioned our entire lives to think smaller number equals success.
- 1:35But what if you're 25 pounds lighter and significantly weaker?
- 1:39That's not necessarily the outcome I want for you.
- 1:41And this becomes even more important for women in their 40s, 50s, 60s.
- 1:45So today we're talking about the GLP-1 muscle problem.
- 1:50We're going to talk about protein, strength training, creatine, visceral fat, body composition, bone health, sarcopenia,
- 2:01and why sometimes the bathroom scale is the least interesting thing happening to your body.
- 2:06This is going to be good.
- 2:08Do GLP-1s actually cause muscle loss?
- 2:13Okay, let's start with the scary question because you see this all over social media.
- 2:18GLP-1s make you lose all your muscle, true or false?
- 2:22Well, that's just overly simplistic.
- 2:24GLP-1 medications don't somehow selectively attack your muscles.
- 2:28The bigger issue is that weight loss itself can involve loss of both your fat and your lean tissue.
- 2:34That happens with traditional calorie restriction.
- 2:36It happens after bariatric surgery.
- 2:39It happens with rapid weight loss.
- 2:40And it can happen during GLP-1 assisted weight loss.
- 2:43So some muscle loss can happen whenever you're losing a significant amount of weight?
- 2:49Correct.
- 2:49Your body doesn't have a little manager sitting there saying,
- 2:52Heather wants to lose 30 pounds.
- 2:54Please remove exactly 30 pounds of abdominal fat and don't touch anything else.
- 2:58Right? I wish.
- 3:00Right.
- 3:00But when you're on a calorie deficit, your body can lose fat, glycogen, water, and lean tissue.
- 3:05And I want to make an important distinction here.
- 3:08When studies talk about lean mass, that isn't exactly synonymous with skeletal muscle.
- 3:14Lean mass includes water and other nonfat tissues.
- 3:17But skeletal muscle loss is absolutely something we need to think about.
- 3:21So the medication isn't necessarily the villain?
- 3:24No.
- 3:25The bigger issue can be what happens because the medication works so well.
- 3:30You're less hungry.
- 3:32You get full faster.
- 3:33Food noise decreases.
- 3:35You're eating significantly fewer calories.
- 3:37And sometimes people are eating significantly less protein.
- 3:42Which initially sounds like exactly what you want.
- 3:45Until someone tells me, I haven't been hungry at all.
- 3:49Yesterday I had coffee, half a yogurt, and four crackers.
- 3:52And they're excited about it.
- 3:53Because they're thinking, I'm crushing this.
- 3:56Exactly.
- 3:57And I'm thinking, oh, we need to feed you.
- 4:00But suppressing your appetite isn't the ultimate goal.
- 4:04Improving your health is the goal.
- 4:06The scale can lie to you.
- 4:08Let's say we have two women who both start at, say, 190 pounds.
- 4:13They both get down to 160.
- 4:15Wouldn't we normally say they had basically the same result?
- 4:18No, not necessarily.
- 4:19So let's say woman A loses primarily fat while maintaining most of her skeletal muscle.
- 4:26Woman B loses the same 30 pounds, but a much greater proportion comes from the lean tissue.
- 4:31So now they both weigh 160.
- 4:34But metabolically and physically, those outcomes can be very different.
- 4:38So this is where body composition comes in.
- 4:41Yes.
- 4:41This is why I don't want patients only thinking 190 pounds to 160 pounds equals success.
- 4:48I want to know what happened to your fat mass?
- 4:51What happened to your lean mass?
- 4:53What happened to your waist circumference?
- 4:55Are you stronger?
- 4:56Are you lifting more?
- 4:58How are your clothes fitting?
- 4:59How do you feel?
- 5:01And what happened to your metabolic markers?
- 5:04So somebody could technically lose less weight but have a better result.
- 5:09Absolutely.
- 5:10Someone who loses 20 pounds primarily from fat and maintains muscle may have a better body composition outcome
- 5:17than someone who loses 30 pounds but sacrifices substantially more lean tissue.
- 5:23Visceral fat.
- 5:24The fat we really want to target.
- 5:26You mentioned visceral fat.
- 5:28Explain the difference because I think people hear body fat and assume all fat is basically the same.
- 5:35I know I do.
- 5:36Right.
- 5:36Well, it's not.
- 5:38Subcutaneous fat is the fat underneath the skin.
- 5:41The fat you can pinch, right?
- 5:43Pinch an inch, that's subcutaneous fat.
- 5:45Visceral fat is deeper in the abdomen and surrounds your internal organs.
- 5:50And excess visceral adipose tissue is strongly associated with things like insulin resistance,
- 5:55metabolic dysfunction, cardiovascular disease, and chronic inflammation.
- 6:01I don't think I've ever had that explained to me before.
- 6:03Yeah.
- 6:04And I completely understood that.
- 6:05I'm so happy.
- 6:06Thank you so much.
- 6:07So if I'm losing inches around my waist but the scale isn't dropping dramatically.
- 6:12I may be thrilled.
- 6:13That's why waist circumference can actually tell us something important.
- 6:17If you're losing visceral fat, maintaining muscle, getting stronger, and improving your metabolic health,
- 6:22I don't care that someone on TikTok lost twice as much weight as you last month.
- 6:28Thank God, because TikTok has convinced everyone they're supposed to lose 17 pounds by Thursday.
- 6:33Exactly.
- 6:34And that's one of the things I'd love to change about this conversation.
- 6:38Faster isn't automatically better.
- 6:41Why midlife women need to pay attention.
- 6:43Why is this especially important for women in perimenopause and menopause?
- 6:47Because we're already fighting an age-related battle with muscle and bone.
- 6:51As we age, we naturally begin losing muscle fat and strength.
- 6:55Then women enter perimenopause and menopause, and estrogen declines.
- 7:00Sleep may deteriorate.
- 7:01Activity levels may change.
- 7:03Insulin sensitivity can change.
- 7:05Bone loss accelerates around menopause.
- 7:08And a lot of women aren't resistance training consistently to begin with.
- 7:11Now, add a medication that significantly decreases your appetite, and suddenly she's eating much less.
- 7:18She's barely eating protein.
- 7:20She's doing a lot of cardio because she wants to lose weight faster, and the scale looks fantastic.
- 7:26But underneath that number, she may be losing tissue she really needs.
- 7:31And that's where I think medicine needs to get smarter about weight loss.
- 7:35I don't want to take a 52-year-old woman and simply turn her into a smaller, weaker 52-year-old version of herself.
- 7:43I want to improve her metabolic health while protecting the muscle and the bone she's going to need for the next 30 or 40 years.
- 7:49Let's talk about, and I'm going to try to say this word, okay?
- 7:52Okay.
- 7:53Because I've heard it.
- 7:54Let's talk about sarcopenia.
- 7:57Yes, sarcopenia.
- 7:58Sarcopenia, because that's one of the words people hear but may not really understand, and I'm one.
- 8:04Okay.
- 8:04Well, sarcopenia refers to age-related loss of muscle mass, strength, and physical function.
- 8:10And I want people to understand that this isn't a vanity issue.
- 8:14Muscle determines whether you can get yourself off the floor, carry groceries, climb stairs, lift a suitcase, maintain your balance, catch yourself if you trip, and remain independent as you get older.
- 8:28Which you don't necessarily think about when you're 45.
- 8:30No, but the groundwork for how you're going to function at 75 or 80 is being laid much earlier.
- 8:37I like to think of muscle as a retirement account for your physical independence.
- 8:40You're depositing it into it now.
- 8:43Because eventually, life is going to make withdrawals, illness, injury, surgery, periods of inactivity, aging itself.
- 8:53The more reserve you have going into those situations, the better off you are.
- 8:56That's a very different reason to lift weights than trying to look good in a tank top.
- 9:00Although, we can have both, right?
- 9:03Yes.
- 9:04So this is the biobeautiful effect, and we're allowed to care about both.
- 9:09Right.
- 9:10Women are not going to accidentally get bulky.
- 9:12Okay, let's address the thing women have been saying forever.
- 9:15I don't want to lift heavy because I don't want to get bulky.
- 9:19I would like to officially retire that statement.
- 9:22Oh, wow.
- 9:23And you've been a personal trainer.
- 9:25Yes, absolutely.
- 9:26That's your background, right?
- 9:27Totally.
- 9:27How often did you see women accidentally getting bulky?
- 9:32Never.
- 9:33Never.
- 9:33Right.
- 9:33Women have spent decades being told, eat less, weigh less, do cardio, use tiny weights, don't get too muscular,
- 9:42and now we're realizing how incredibly important muscle is for healthy aging.
- 9:47Building significant muscle is actually difficult, right?
- 9:50You've seen it.
- 9:51Yes, it is.
- 9:52I live it.
- 9:53Yeah.
- 9:54Especially as we age.
- 9:56You're not going to do squats twice a week and suddenly wake up looking like a competitive bodybuilder.
- 10:01Unfortunately.
- 10:02Right?
- 10:02Well, I know.
- 10:03If only building muscle were that easy.
- 10:05So, yes, pick up the weights.
- 10:08How much protein do we actually need?
- 10:11This may be the number one question.
- 10:13How much protein?
- 10:14Because online, I see everything from just eat normally to you need 200 grams a day.
- 10:20And like most things, the answer is individualized.
- 10:23The standard RDA or recommended daily allowance for protein is about 0.8 grams per kilogram of body weight per day.
- 10:31But that recommendation is primarily designed around preventing deficiency in healthy adults.
- 10:36That's different from asking what's optimal for preserving muscle during weight loss.
- 10:42For many adults who are intentionally losing weight, particularly as we get older,
- 10:46a reasonable range may be around 1.2 to 1.6 grams of protein per kilogram per day.
- 10:52But that needs to be individualized based on your body size, goal weight, activity level, age,
- 10:58medical conditions, and your kidney function.
- 11:01Don't forget about your kidneys.
- 11:03Can we make that easier for someone who doesn't want to do the math every time she eats?
- 11:08I'm not going to name any names.
- 11:09Okay.
- 11:11So a really practical strategy is aiming for roughly 25 to 40 grams of high quality protein at each major meal.
- 11:18And ideally distribute it throughout the day.
- 11:20A lot of times for your average height woman, I'll say,
- 11:24if you could really just get 30 grams of protein in the morning, midday, and evening, that would be amazing.
- 11:31Let's start there.
- 11:32So when they meet with you, you don't give them these high, unrealistic,
- 11:37you need to start eating 80 grams.
- 11:38You start them slow so that they don't feel like the reality or what they have to do is like so far fetched.
- 11:44Well, 80 grams is actually fair.
- 11:46You know, when they go to a personal trainer, no offense,
- 11:49but some of these personal trainers are really having them go high, high on protein.
- 11:54And that's not always realistic.
- 11:56I always tell my clients, it's actually hard to get that protein in.
- 12:01And we've had this discussion multiple times around the office.
- 12:04It's hard.
- 12:04You have to work at it.
- 12:05And if you're not working at it, you're not getting enough.
- 12:08I mean, that's just the fact of the matter, truly.
- 12:11But it becomes easier as you do it more.
- 12:14I think so.
- 12:15I've had the conversation with you several times, and I keep getting the same answer.
- 12:21And finally, it sinks in, you know, with me after a few times.
- 12:24Protein distribution matters because we want repeated stimulation of muscle protein synthesis throughout the day.
- 12:29Think eggs, Greek yogurt, cottage cheese, chicken, fish, lean beef, turkey, tofu or tempeh,
- 12:36and protein shakes can be extremely useful for GLP patients because appetite and food volume can be limited.
- 12:42But my stipulation is that you only get one protein meal replacement a day
- 12:48because I really want you focusing on real food, real food that contains real protein.
- 12:53But if a protein shake is what you can do in the morning, it's actually what I do in the morning, to be honest.
- 12:59You do?
- 12:59Yeah, I absolutely do.
- 13:01Then so be it.
- 13:02If that's how you get your 30 grams of protein in for that morning.
- 13:05Yeah.
- 13:05Great.
- 13:06Okay.
- 13:07But I'm not hungry.
- 13:08So what do you tell the patient who says, but I'm just not hungry?
- 13:12I say that's wonderful that we're controlling appetite,
- 13:15but your nutritional requirements didn't disappear just because your hunger did.
- 13:19Your body still needs protein.
- 13:21Your body still needs essential fatty acids, vitamins, minerals, fiber, fluids, and adequate overall energy.
- 13:28So when appetite is limited, I tell people first, we need to reevaluate your dose of the GLP-1.
- 13:35Too much is not a good thing.
- 13:37So let's take a step back.
- 13:39Second, protein is first, right?
- 13:42Yes.
- 13:43If you're going to get full after eight bites, let's not make the first seven bites bread.
- 13:48That is devastating.
- 13:51I'm sorry.
- 13:52You can have some bread.
- 13:53Oh, I'm gonna.
- 13:53But eat the chicken first.
- 13:55Okay.
- 13:55That's fair.
- 13:57Walking is wonderful, but it's not strength training.
- 14:00What about someone who says, I'm getting my 10,000 steps every day.
- 14:04Isn't that enough?
- 14:05Well, for muscle preservation, no, unfortunately.
- 14:09And I love walking.
- 14:10Walking is fantastic for cardiovascular health, glucose regulation, mental health, mobility, and overall activity.
- 14:17Keep walking.
- 14:19But walking doesn't provide the same stimulus as resistance training.
- 14:23Muscle needs a reason to stay.
- 14:25Meaning if the body doesn't think it needs all that muscle.
- 14:29And you're in a significant calorie deficit, it's expensive tissue.
- 14:33The body can reduce it.
- 14:35Resistance training sends a very different signal.
- 14:38Hey, I need this muscle.
- 14:40How often?
- 14:41Well, for most adults, some form of resistance training, at least two to three days per week, is a great goal.
- 14:46Assuming they're medically able.
- 14:48And I always tell people, too, you don't have to get expensive membership to a gym.
- 14:53If that's your thing, go for it.
- 14:56I love gyms.
- 14:57They're great.
- 14:58Great for like-minded people.
- 14:59But if gyms make you uncomfortable, you can either work out from the comfort of your home.
- 15:04There's tons of free online sources now.
- 15:08Or if you're just not comfortable in a gym and you need a little bit of assistance becoming comfortable in a gym or even learning how to lift weights.
- 15:15I mean, I'll say it again.
- 15:17I was never really trained in weights at all.
- 15:21So I still go to a personal trainer once a week.
- 15:24And I mean, it's fantastic.
- 15:27And it helps me know my way around the gym.
- 15:31It helps me figure out different muscle groups to target while he helps me.
- 15:35And it's just fantastic.
- 15:37But you can do a lot from the comfort of your home as well.
- 15:40So don't make that a reason that you aren't going to weight lift.
- 15:44What does progressive overload actually mean?
- 15:47You hear the phrase progressive overload constantly now.
- 15:50So basically your muscles need to be progressively challenged.
- 15:53If you've been doing the same exercise for the same five-pound dumbbells for three years and you can easily do 30 repetitions while discussing what you're having for dinner, we probably need to make it harder.
- 16:04So I don't necessarily have to lift enormous weights.
- 16:07No, progress can mean increasing weight, more repetitions, more sets, better range of motion, more difficult variations, or improved control.
- 16:16There's a lot of ways to progress.
- 16:17But your body adapts to what you repeatedly ask it to do.
- 16:20So if you want to maintain or build muscle, eventually you will need to ask it to do more.
- 16:26Creatine.
- 16:27Because I feel like suddenly every woman over 40 is hearing you need creatine.
- 16:31And for years I thought creatine was something 22-year-old guys took at the gym.
- 16:36But I have been hearing that a lot lately.
- 16:39Yeah.
- 16:40Creatine.
- 16:40Absolutely.
- 16:41And creatine has somehow become branded as a gym bro supplement when it's actually one of the most extensively studied sports supplements we have.
- 16:49And there's growing interest in creatine for women and healthy aging.
- 16:53Creatine helps replenish phosphocreatine, which helps rapidly regenerate ATP, which you know I love.
- 17:01English, please.
- 17:02Okay.
- 17:03As we recall, ATP is basically cellular energy currency.
- 17:08Creatine helps your muscles rapidly regenerate energy during short, intense activity.
- 17:12And when creatine is combined with resistance training, it can help support strength and lean mass.
- 17:17So how much?
- 17:18Okay.
- 17:19So a common maintenance dose is about three to five grams of creatine monohydrate daily.
- 17:25You don't necessarily need a loading phase.
- 17:28You don't need some fancy $80 proprietary creatine.
- 17:31Plain old creatine monohydrate has an enormous amount of evidence behind it.
- 17:35But here's the question every woman is going to ask.
- 17:38Will creatine make me gain weight?
- 17:40And that answer is possibly a little.
- 17:42And this is where we have to stop being terrified of the scale.
- 17:45Creatine can increase water within the muscle cells.
- 17:48So you might see an increase in body weight.
- 17:51But that's not fat.
- 17:52No, exactly.
- 17:53Let's say you're losing body fat, maintaining or gaining muscle, and your muscles are holding more water because of the creatine.
- 18:00And the scale goes up one pound.
- 18:01Did you get worse?
- 18:03No.
- 18:03Your body composition may have actually improved.
- 18:06And that's why I keep saying the scale is data.
- 18:09It is not a daily performance review.
- 18:12Creatine isn't appropriate for every person.
- 18:14So supplementation should still be discussed with your health care professional, especially if you have kidney disease or other relevant medical issues.
- 18:20You've called muscle a longevity organ.
- 18:23But muscle also affects blood sugar, right?
- 18:26Yes.
- 18:26Skeletal muscle is a major site of glucose disposal.
- 18:30After you eat carbohydrates and glucose enters the bloodstream, muscle tissue can take up glucose and store it.
- 18:36And that's one reason maintaining muscle and exercising can actually improve your insulin sensitivity.
- 18:40So when we're treating obesity or metabolic dysfunction, we don't just want to remove excess fat.
- 18:46We also want to protect the tissue that helps manage your glucose.
- 18:50So I think about it like this.
- 18:51Fat loss improves the metabolic environment.
- 18:54Muscle preservation improves the metabolic machinery.
- 18:57And ideally, we're doing both.
- 18:59Exactly.
- 19:00And that's what I want from a medical weight loss program.
- 19:03We've talked a lot about muscle.
- 19:05So what about bones?
- 19:07Right.
- 19:07Bones are very important.
- 19:09I will just say it simplistically.
- 19:12Weight loss can be associated with reductions in bone mineral density in some circumstances, especially with significant weight loss in older adults.
- 19:19And again, this becomes particularly relevant in perimenopausal and postmenopausal women.
- 19:25Estrogen plays an important role in maintaining bone.
- 19:28As estrogen declines around menopause, bone turnover increases and bone loss can accelerate.
- 19:33Imagine combining hormonal changes, rapid weight loss, low protein, inadequate calcium or vitamin D, or both.
- 19:41I mean, vitamin D, you've seen the labs that we get from our clients.
- 19:45Oh, yes.
- 19:46And vitamin D, I'm just going off on a tirade here.
- 19:49It's low.
- 19:50Yeah, it's low.
- 19:51I've never seen such low.
- 19:52No.
- 19:53Okay, so you have inadequate calcium or vitamin D, no resistance training, and already low muscle mass.
- 20:00And that's not the combination of things that I want.
- 20:02So when someone is starting a GLP-1 at 50, we shouldn't only be discussing her goal weight.
- 20:08Absolutely not.
- 20:09We should be thinking about the whole person.
- 20:12I like to ask a goal weight.
- 20:13It gives me an idea of what they're kind of aiming for.
- 20:16But we're also talking about nutrition, exercise, muscle, bone, hormones when appropriate, metabolic health, and long-term function because we're not treating a number on a scale.
- 20:27We're treating someone we hope is going to be strong and independent decades from now.
- 20:32This might be difficult for people to hear.
- 20:34If I'm losing two pounds a week and my friend is losing four pounds a week, I want to lose four.
- 20:40Of course you do because we're competitive.
- 20:43Very.
- 20:44But faster isn't automatically better.
- 20:47There may be situations where substantial early weight loss is clinically appropriate, but if someone is barely eating, losing muscle, exhausted, becoming nutritionally deficient, and dropping weight incredibly quickly, I'm not necessarily celebrating.
- 21:00So what about increasing the GLP-1 dose because you want her to lose faster?
- 21:06No, that's another misconception.
- 21:07The goal isn't to get to the highest dose possible.
- 21:10The goal is to use an effective, tolerable dose that helps you achieve the clinical outcome we're looking for while still allowing adequate nutrition.
- 21:19And that is huge.
- 21:21We need to allow for your adequate nutrition.
- 21:24More isn't always better.
- 21:26And no appetite, it's never better.
- 21:28Faster isn't necessarily better.
- 21:31Better is better.
- 21:33Yes.
- 21:34Body composition.
- 21:35So let's say we're throwing away the scale.
- 21:38Well, we're not throwing it away.
- 21:40Well, I tried.
- 21:41We're just taking away some of its power.
- 21:44Fine.
- 21:45So what else should we measure?
- 21:46So this is where body composition testing can be really helpful.
- 21:50DEXA can provide valuable information about fat loss and lean mass.
- 21:55And of course, it's also the clinical standard we use for evaluating bone mineral density.
- 21:59But for ongoing weight loss monitoring, we also use the STIQ, which is a 3D body scanner.
- 22:05And what I really like about STIQ is that it gives us another way to look at progress beyond just pounds.
- 22:11So explain how that actually works.
- 22:12Because when people do a STIQ scan, they stand on this little rotating platform, and suddenly we have this entire 3D image of their body.
- 22:19Yes.
- 22:20So STIQ uses an infrared camera to capture the external shape of your body and creates a three-dimensional model.
- 22:27And from that scan, the software can measure circumference and body shape very consistently
- 22:31and then use validated predictive algorithms to estimate things like body fat, lean mass, and visceral fat.
- 22:38And that's an important distinction.
- 22:40It isn't taking an X-ray of your body like a DEXA.
- 22:43It's using 3D anthropometric measurements, your actual body shape and dimensions,
- 22:49and mathematical models developed by comparing those measurements with reference methods such as DEXA.
- 22:55And now STIQ gives people these two scores, the health score and the shape score.
- 23:01Yes.
- 23:01What exactly do those mean?
- 23:03They're actually looking at two slightly different things.
- 23:07So we'll start with the health score.
- 23:08The STIQ calculates the health score using three equally weighted pieces of information.
- 23:14Your BMI, which I know nobody loves a BMI.
- 23:18Your waist circumference and something called TLVR, which is STIQ's three-dimensional body shape risk metric.
- 23:26The idea is to combine your traditional health risk markers with information about where you're carrying the weight and the actual shape of the torso.
- 23:34So it's not just saying, okay, here's your BMI.
- 23:37Right.
- 23:37And that's useful because BMI itself has obvious limitations.
- 23:41It only knows your height and your weight.
- 23:43It doesn't know whether that weight is primarily muscle or fat, and it doesn't know where your fat is distributed.
- 23:50Waist circumference gives us another piece of that metabolic risk picture because abdominal adiposity,
- 23:55particularly excess visceral fat, is much more strongly associated with metabolic disease than simply knowing someone's weight.
- 24:03So the STIQ takes those components and essentially creates a one summary number that can be followed over time.
- 24:09But I would never tell someone your health score is 72, therefore you're healthy or unhealthy.
- 24:14It's not a diagnosis.
- 24:16It's a tracking tool.
- 24:18STIQ itself recommends interpreting it as a starting point and using repeat scans to monitor your change over time.
- 24:25Okay.
- 24:25Then what's the shape score?
- 24:28Because the shape score sounds a little like we're grading somebody's body.
- 24:31And that's exactly how I don't want people to interpret it.
- 24:35It's not congratulations, your body gets an A.
- 24:38The shape score is really designed around more body composition and recomposition.
- 24:43It also combines three components weighted equally.
- 24:46The first is body fat percentage.
- 24:49Second is muscle fat index.
- 24:51And the third is your waist to height ratio.
- 24:54Okay, let's break this down.
- 24:56Body fat percentage is obvious.
- 24:59What's muscle fat index?
- 25:02It's essentially looking at the relationship between the muscle in your limbs and the amount of fat you're carrying.
- 25:06And this is exactly why I think it's so relevant to this GLP-1 conversation.
- 25:11Because we're not simply asking, did Heather get lighter?
- 25:14We're asking, what's happening to the relationship between her muscle and her fat?
- 25:19Because someone who could lose 25 pounds and end up with a very different muscle to fat profile,
- 25:24depending on how they ate and trained while losing the weight.
- 25:27And then waist to height ratio?
- 25:30That's your waist circumference relative to your height.
- 25:32It gives us additional information about central adiposity.
- 25:35Again, we're getting away from just, what do you weigh?
- 25:38And moving toward, where is the weight?
- 25:40What is it made of?
- 25:42And how is your body composition changing?
- 25:44And that's a much more meaningful conversation.
- 25:47So practically, what are you looking for when someone comes back for a repeat DICU scan?
- 25:54That's where it becomes really useful.
- 25:56So let's say somebody comes in and says, I'm frustrated.
- 25:59I only lost four pounds.
- 26:01So then we pull up her DICU scan side by side.
- 26:04Maybe her waist is smaller.
- 26:06Her abdominal circumference is down.
- 26:08Her estimated body fat percentage has decreased.
- 26:11Her visceral fat estimate has improved.
- 26:14And she's maintained her lean mass.
- 26:16And suddenly, those only four pounds look very different.
- 26:20Because she may actually be having a fantastic month.
- 26:23Exactly.
- 26:24Or we may see the opposite.
- 26:26Someone says, I lost 18 pounds.
- 26:28This is amazing.
- 26:30And then I look at the body composition and think, okay, we're losing weight quickly.
- 26:34But I'm not thrilled with what's happening to your lean tissue.
- 26:37And that's when we have a different conversation.
- 26:40Are you getting enough protein?
- 26:42Are you resistance training?
- 26:43Are you eating enough overall?
- 26:45Have we suppressed your appetite too much?
- 26:48Do we really need to increase your medication dose?
- 26:50So STIQ can almost function as a quality-controlled check-in on the weight loss.
- 26:56That's a great way to describe it.
- 26:57The scale tells us how much mass left on the body.
- 27:00Body composition testing helps us ask what is the mass we want to see.
- 27:05And STIQ also gives us something incredibly valuable psychologically, a visual.
- 27:10You can overlay your first 3D scan with your current scan and physically see where your body has changed.
- 27:17Sometimes that's much more motivating than seeing the scale go from 174 to 171.
- 27:23Do you think STIQ is as accurate as a DEXA?
- 27:26There are different technologies, and I don't want people treating them as interchangeable.
- 27:31DEXA uses low-dose X-ray technology to estimate tissue composition
- 27:35and is the clinical tool we use for bone mineral density.
- 27:38STIQ uses external 3D body measurements and predictive algorithms to estimate the body composition.
- 27:44What STIQ is particularly valuable for is repeatability and trend monitoring.
- 27:49So if we can see you under similar conditions every few months,
- 27:52we can watch the direction your measurements are moving.
- 27:55And that's often what matters most in a weight loss program.
- 27:58We're looking for trends.
- 28:00Less fat, less abdominal adiposity, preserved muscle, improved waist-to-height ratio,
- 28:06better body composition, and ideally, more strength in real life.
- 28:09Because at the end of the day,
- 28:11I don't care how beautiful your STIQ report looks if you can't pick up the groceries.
- 28:16So we're still making people do the squats.
- 28:18Always.
- 28:19The computer does not get you out of the squats.
- 28:21Can you lose a lot of weight and still have poor body composition?
- 28:26Absolutely.
- 28:28That's even a phenotype called normal weight obesity,
- 28:32where someone can actually have a normal BMI but relative high body fat and low muscle mass.
- 28:36That's why skinny isn't necessarily synonymous with healthy.
- 28:40You can diet yourself into a smaller body without building a stronger body.
- 28:44So what's the goal instead?
- 28:46I want strong, lean, metabolically healthy, capable.
- 28:50And aesthetically, muscle matters too.
- 28:53It gives shape to the body.
- 28:54It improves your posture.
- 28:56It supports your tissue.
- 28:57And it creates that strong, healthy appearance that most people are actually trying to achieve.
- 29:03Okay.
- 29:03Let's make this really practical.
- 29:05I'm listening to this podcast.
- 29:07I'm taking semaglutide or terzepatide.
- 29:10I don't want to lose my muscle.
- 29:12Give me the checklist.
- 29:14Okay.
- 29:14First, stop tracking only weight.
- 29:17Track waist circumference, body composition when it's available, strength, how your clothes fit, and how you feel.
- 29:24Second, prioritize protein.
- 29:26For many people, somewhere between 1.2 to 1.6 grams per kilogram of ideal body weight per day may be appropriate during intentional weight loss, although that does need to be individualized.
- 29:39The third is strength train, ideally two to three times a week, and progressively challenge your muscles.
- 29:45Four is keep walking.
- 29:47Strength training and walking aren't competitors.
- 29:49Do both.
- 29:51Number five, consider creatine if it's appropriate for you.
- 29:54Usually around three to five grams of creatine monohydrate daily.