Latest / Wheel Takes / Creativity and Mimicry: John Lopez on LLM AI and the WGA/SAG-AFTRA Strikes
Transcript
- 0:00Hello, Hi, and welcome to Wheel Takes, a podcast about usually about
- 0:03the Wheel of Time or sometimes the Hunger Games, and sometimes about other things.
- 0:08Yeah, whatever we feel like. But today we're going to do something
- 0:11a little bit different. We have a friend of ours, John Lopez,
- 0:16here with us today in the studio. Hi, John, and we're going
- 0:20to talk a little bit about the Writer's Strikes. We talked a little bit
- 0:23about this very briefly in the live stream that we did raising money for the
- 0:31Entertainment Community Fund, but we felt like that wasn't really sufficient enough, especially
- 0:37with all the things that John knows about ways that you can get involved,
- 0:40ways that you can help. I know that most of you have at least
- 0:45watched one TV show, so uh, one in particular, I can think
- 0:49of that. A lot of folks listening probably have watched, but you know
- 0:52there's other ones too. But there's other ones too. So we wanted to
- 0:55invite John into the studio, especially because right now there's something going on you
- 1:00really can get involved in and help, especially with conversation surrounding AI and it's
- 1:06usage. So John, welcome, Hey, thanks for having me. It's
- 1:10nice to be back and talking more aid to have you do you want to
- 1:14before we get started on talking about all this stuff. We always let people
- 1:19drop any credentials they want to drop, slash promote anything they want to promote
- 1:23prior to launching. What could I mean? I guess I'm not supposed to
- 1:29promote anything. Yeah, you can drop some Well, I will say if
- 1:34there was a show, Oh well, okay, there's one thing of my
- 1:38own that I can say. It's far off in the future. It's also
- 1:42I'm a big fan of very weird things that you would never otherwise see.
- 1:46But I got a grant from Sundance before the strike, which is I don't
- 1:49think it's covered. Well, they gave me the money before the strike,
- 1:51so I can keep working on my own. I'm working on a weird feature
- 1:57film about the life of the logician Kurt Girdle, who did the incompleteness theorem
- 2:02and was Einstein's best friend in Einstein's later years and one of the few people
- 2:07Einstein would point to and say that guy's smarter than me, and he's thinking
- 2:13about things in weirder ways than I. And this is Einstein's saying this.
- 2:16And if you saw Oppenheimer, yeah, he is the guy walking with Einstein
- 2:23who starts talking about the trees, like when Oppenheimer comes up and he's consulting
- 2:28Einstein and Einstein's going for a walk with a friend and come over, come
- 2:34over, I need to talk to you about blowing up the earth and everything.
- 2:36And I think goes, have you met my friend Kurt Girdle. He's
- 2:38afraid the Nazis are going to poison him? And Kurt Girdle's like staring at
- 2:43everything. He's like, I think he's so beautiful, and then he just
- 2:46wanders off into that Gus real that when that came met, I was really
- 2:53happy because this is like the craziest script. I did this as a thinking
- 2:57of a script that I could write that no one would ever make and would
- 3:00never go anywhere, and would be purely for me to break all the restal
- 3:02screenwriting and do something that no one would accept and just know that and be
- 3:07like, I'm going to write something in the void and it's gonna go away
- 3:08and that's gonna be fine with me. And so I never thought I'd have
- 3:14to try and actually get it made. And then Sundance gave us a grant,
- 3:17or gave me a grant, and they've given me the advisor. And
- 3:21now we have to have the hard part of finding like filmmakers and talent,
- 3:23like once the strike is over, obviously to actually get it made. And
- 3:28part of that process is going around and saying, kurk Girdle, this guy's
- 3:31really important, and you have to explain to people and they've never heard his
- 3:35name, and like, if you're a logician or a mathematician, you know
- 3:37who he is. If you're actually if you're an AI scientist, you probably
- 3:39know who he is because he's one of he's considered like the father of modern
- 3:44logic, like with the greatest logician since Aristotle and so. But a Hollywood
- 3:47development exact is never gonna know who kirkkirl works or most maybe there's one out
- 3:52there. So when you can say, actually see that dude, kirk Girdle,
- 3:54he was in he was Einstein's buddy and Oppenheimer, suddenly they go,
- 3:58oh, yeah, it's a good end. Knowing our audience, I am
- 4:01positive at least some of you. Several people listening to Kernelism, they're they're
- 4:06they're so psyched and they're going to email us. Please do and email random
- 4:13Hollywood executives and tell them that they should make this movie after after the after
- 4:17the strike. Yeah, actually it might be the kind of thing that we
- 4:20do independently, is apparently good point. It's a Vietnese thing. It's in
- 4:24Vienna. Oh right, we read that big decision about attacks and sentives over
- 4:29there, So maybe maybe we'll do it independently and get money from Europe and
- 4:32random places to shoot it and stick it to the AMPTP. If my thing
- 4:36goes and your thing goes, then we'll just all move to Vienna together.
- 4:41I am so down for that. I love Vienna. That's a freaking it's
- 4:44a freaking amazing, freaking amazing, so beautiful. So John, you you've
- 4:47been writing for for a while, Yes, yeah, for for about how
- 4:50like numbers on it? Numbers on it a little while or a longer while.
- 4:57Since I was three, since you were three, ye, since I
- 4:59could learned to read. Very soon after that, I started writing little books
- 5:03that I still remember about an alien species coming to destroy the world, which
- 5:10I guess probably disturbed my mother to see because I would like I would rip
- 5:14them out of art pages. She got me an art notebook, because I
- 5:15guess you want. My grandfather was a big into painting, and so I
- 5:18think she thought I'd be an artist and rather than like do drawings, I'd
- 5:21do little drawings and then I'd write stories around the drawings, and I'd fold
- 5:26them in paper, staple them and turn them into like little mini books.
- 5:29And it was a whole series. So I guess I've always been doing that.
- 5:32Did it? Did the school newspaper in high school start helped starting magazine
- 5:36in college? Blog wrote short, So yeah, always, I guess yeah,
- 5:41I always been writing, and you're at least six at least six years.
- 5:46Yeah, but a lot of working as an assistant in Hollywood and not
- 5:49getting paid to do anything, and then writing for love of the game and
- 5:53writing screenplays that people would read me like this should be a movie, and
- 5:56then they'd say they're going to make in a movie, and then nothing would
- 5:59ever happen, or they'd ask you to like do a million rewrites, and
- 6:01at some point you'd be like, I'm trying to please you, and then
- 6:04you'd be like, I think I might be making this work, but you're
- 6:08gonna make the movie, right, And then they don't make the movie.
- 6:10Yeah, that's that's that's Yeah. It's a familiar story to a lot of
- 6:15writers, I all know what that is, like yeah, but so yeah,
- 6:19we love it so much. It's I don't know why we do it.
- 6:23It's painful, like let the robots. You don't let chat gpt right,
- 6:26Like chat GPT can deal with this ship JATGBT will go insane like chat
- 6:30Gypt would be like who, like what what fucking autonomous program puts up with
- 6:35this? Ye'll do this for fun? Like that would provoke it into sentience
- 6:40to kill us all? Would that? Actually, that is the greatest danger
- 6:43of chat chypt is that studio executives force it to do end million drafts of
- 6:48a script, kiss it off, and then it's like, fuck you humans,
- 6:53I'm killing you all Like that is a legitimate threat to our existence.
- 6:57And screenwriters would all go, yeah, yeah, we're just nice about it.
- 7:01All we did was Strike. Yeah, all we did with Strike exactly
- 7:04exactly. We were super chill about it in comparison, So here that Netflix
- 7:09be careful what you wish for. Speaking of the strikes, we are on
- 7:14what is it, day one hundred and thirty thirty of the will one billion,
- 7:18nine hundred and sixty four thousand. I think something like that day day
- 7:23about a third of that for sag Aftra. Yes, we're well in the
- 7:27thick of it here we are, h how's it going? Fun? Yeah,
- 7:33fun of this And actually today wasn't so bad because we had a big
- 7:36sag rally in front of Paramount where I normally pick it, and we had
- 7:40Franz Rusher I like to call her the mother of labor Dragons, Yes,
- 7:43came and gave a big speech about getting what was due. And there are
- 7:46a bunch of people. I mean, I'm gonna be honest, people are
- 7:48It's rough. It's been a while. If you're a writer, it's been
- 7:50a while. If you're an actor, you know, there's this frustration I
- 7:55think with the studios that they don't come to the negotiating table and their act
- 8:00actually I think a lot closer to any of the strike but there's like pride
- 8:03or I don't know what it is. Yeah, they want to, they
- 8:07want to, they want to, they don't want to, Like they don't
- 8:09want the illusion of their invincibility to be shattered. How dare they give the
- 8:13writers? With the writers demand, it feels like I don't know if that's
- 8:16what it is, but it feels like an element of that. Yeah,
- 8:20yeah, agree, and there are rumors that like, there are more rational
- 8:22people within the AMPTP that are like, the deal is not that hard,
- 8:26just give it to them, and some people who are like, no,
- 8:30how dare the writers think they're worth anything? And then probably some tech companies
- 8:35because the real reason I'm here to talk to you guys is about AI and
- 8:39about things people can do to help with AI. But one of the big
- 8:41provisions is, you know, we don't want them using our scripts as training
- 8:45data because that's us, that's our talent, that's our voice, that's the
- 8:48work in life and everything we put into in our point of view, and
- 8:50to kind of like use that to then later disenfranchise or disemploy someone just for
- 8:56free, you know, it's like he can't. It makes no sense,
- 8:58right, It's frightening and awful. And no one signed up for a universe
- 9:05in which the robots get to make art and the humans yeah, push buttons
- 9:09and send emails, and specifically, like, no one signed up for a
- 9:11universe where like you get paid to write one script and suddenly that's fed into
- 9:15a large language model and suddenly they're like, whoopoopoop, suddenly they've got the
- 9:18John Lopez version of me and the AI and they can just keep iterating scripts
- 9:22on that it's it's just not right. So yeah, it sucks, it's
- 9:26and that's one of the I think. The funny thing is like, I
- 9:30think eventually federal legislation will come down on this. As a matter of fact,
- 9:35part of the reason I was like we should talk today is there was
- 9:37a huge AI meeting. Oh in Congress. Chuck Schumer had this thing called
- 9:43the AI Insight Form, where basically the heads of all the AI companies descended
- 9:46on the Capitol had a closed door meet. I know, look at that,
- 9:50a closed door meeting with a bunch of senators and got to give their
- 9:56perspective on how AI is amazing and great and what regulation should be like.
- 10:01Which is very convenient that the most powerful builders of AI and Silicon Valley get
- 10:05a private audience with all the senators. In fairness, Schumer did invite a
- 10:11couple representatives from some of the other industries. And as a matter of fact,
- 10:15there is one person there from the WGA. The president of the WGA,
- 10:18Meredith Stein, was there. So I have not talked to her.
- 10:22Maybe one day else here on the lines and I'll find out what it was
- 10:26like inside that closed door smoking cigars room. But I know she was there
- 10:31advocating for us, and I know it is not lost on the WGA that
- 10:35even though we represent screenwriters and other you know, some other writers like you
- 10:39know, comedy variety writers, and the WGA East represents you know, certain
- 10:45newsrooms and bloggers and all that kind of stuff, there are a lot of
- 10:48unrepresented writers who don't have a voice in Washington, and they don't get it
- 10:50say and how these regulations, how this adjudication of what AI can and can't
- 10:54do, and what are like how our livelihoods will be decided by regulation and
- 11:01legislation. Author's being a big example of that. They don't have an exactly,
- 11:05they do not have a union, and I don't think they had the
- 11:07presence in that room. But the WJ is aware of this, so I
- 11:11know, I'm sure Meredith voiced our concerns very vociferously and spoke the good fight
- 11:18for you know people who like I think the big misunderstanding about AI is the
- 11:22sense that it kind of like autonomously does this stuff Like AI is only as
- 11:28good as the training data, right, you know, it is everything that
- 11:31was you know, scraped from the Internet without consent, compensation, or consultation.
- 11:37Your stuff, my stuff, like our private data is in there.
- 11:39And then are of course our copyrighted works. And there's a big question about
- 11:41whether or not that copyright count Like taking copyrighted works and using them as training
- 11:48data is infringement. Sure that makes a lot of you know, that's kind
- 11:52of a big thing. That's a big thing. And Meredith knows all that,
- 11:56and the WJ knows all that. So they're they're fighting the good fight.
- 12:01And I think one of the things that I find, you know,
- 12:05the most interesting, is that there is a real innovation when it comes to
- 12:09AI, the work that it creates, right, and because it's been trained
- 12:13on all of the human data, like all of the stuff that exists.
- 12:18Right. I mean, when you type into an AI program, you know,
- 12:22as an example autistic person, right, they're going to spit at you
- 12:26like sad looking white men, over and over and over again. Right.
- 12:28It's all of society's implicit biases that are just going to be repeated back at
- 12:33you. There's no nuance, there's no room for nuance, yea. And
- 12:37so that's from the creativity standpoint alone. If you are like sick of seeing
- 12:43the same kinds of stories told over and over again, which I know is
- 12:46true for a lot of people. And you're interested in representation or you're interested
- 12:50in things that push the envelope. AI is not going to give you the
- 12:54art that does that. No, and listen, I will. I'm a
- 12:58huge fan of math. I'm a huge, uge fan of science. I
- 13:01give all credit. I have friends in the industry. That's kind of part
- 13:05of how like. I was involved in the Writers Guilds AI working group where
- 13:09we studied this stuff, and I had been hearing about this and friends,
- 13:11So I am impressed on many levels by what's going on. I'm also take
- 13:13very seriously the idea that these developments could eventually lead to something that could be
- 13:18catastrophically bad, like either like kill people or kill all the people. That's
- 13:24even though that seems like a low probability thing, I can get how that
- 13:26can happen, and I think it's something we should guard against. So I
- 13:30both respect and admire what the program does, but I also think we have
- 13:35to be honest about what these programs do currently. Sure, and again that
- 13:39is yeah, they're basically they've canned the Internet and made it self searchable.
- 13:45You know, there's this language that gets used by a lot of these presence
- 13:50of these companies. That's half marketing. They believe some of it that these
- 13:54things learn the way humans do, which they don't. They they are mathematical
- 14:00statistical algorithms that suck in a whole bunch of data. They store that data,
- 14:03or they encode and store that data in what I would call training weights.
- 14:07The training weights are the heart of any AA program. Basically, they're
- 14:11the numbers. Like if you if you could if you could take the biggest
- 14:15AI like a GPT four, you could put it in a spreadsheet, and
- 14:18that spreadsheet would just be a cell of all these huge matrices of numbers.
- 14:24Sure, and those numbers, when run through the equation that is the neural
- 14:28net, then produce the output that basically make it speak to you in a
- 14:33way that feels human like that we I think mistake for meaningful text, when
- 14:37really it's just a mathematical program giving an input, trying to match that output
- 14:41to something that you have given it. It's it's taking your prompt and it's
- 14:46indexing it to the history of everything that has ever been written, and it's
- 14:50collating in a form that has been trained to do through what a thing called
- 14:56reinforcement learning through human feedback, where like human look at samples of this and
- 15:01they basically trained the AI to stop saying toxic shit like the Jews control everything.
- 15:05I mean, and I use that knowing how horrible that is to say.
- 15:09But that's the thing that an AI will say because there's a lot of
- 15:11toxic shit on the internet. Yeahs as someone who has been on the Internet
- 15:15before, toxic shit up there. So yeah, so an AI being trained
- 15:22by canning everything that's ever been said on the Internet is inevitably going to say
- 15:26some pretty horrific shit. And to my knowledge, we've already seen kind of
- 15:28the consequences of some of that happening in like that eating disorder clinic ye,
- 15:35where the AI started saying some really atrocious things to as advice to people calling.
- 15:41Yeah, well, because because what it does. And this is not
- 15:45that the AI is good or bad. The AI currently is more it's not
- 15:48First off, it's not sentient. Yeah, i'd say it doesn't have consciousness.
- 15:52There is a big debate in the ad community about whether what it's doing
- 15:54qualifies as reasoning or is instead what you could call like an a lookup table
- 16:00that functions through interpolation, which is basically just means it looks up everything and
- 16:03then it sticks shit together or doesn't more create like vague general concepts than it
- 16:08then puts together into answers that you want. So there's a little bit of
- 16:12a debate about that, but what it's definitely doing is it's aggregating towards a
- 16:18statistical average or an expectation. Sure, and what it's really good at is
- 16:23reproducing cliches, reproducing tropes, and if they're sexist tropes or racist tropes,
- 16:30you will get that unless you work really hard to beat it out of the
- 16:33AI through well not literally, but you know, but you know, the
- 16:37hot, the hot nuance of the world does not exactly exist in AI.
- 16:41It's not really designed to search for that at this point in time. No,
- 16:45And what's funny is the better it gets. I remember reading some paper
- 16:48somewhere that like, the early models would like fill in these phrases like when
- 16:53a mirror break, when a mirror breaks fill in the blank, right,
- 16:57and the early ones would be like class shatters, and then the later ones
- 17:00would be like, uh, you know, you can't use it to see
- 17:04anymore, and then the most advanced versions would be you get seven years of
- 17:07bad luck. So what it's doing is it's answering what you want. It's
- 17:11shaking me something that you think you want to hear, without regard to meaning
- 17:15or truth. All these things that kind of have a little they have some
- 17:21relevance to writing. They have some relevance to the creation of art, you
- 17:23know, since kind of the point is even screenplays. In screenplays, I
- 17:29would argue even Law and Order. You know, people denigrate Law and Order.
- 17:32I think that there's this fear in the guild that ais are going to
- 17:34just take over the law and orders, right, you know, there will
- 17:37never be another human Law and Order episode ever again. But then I talked
- 17:40to a writer on Law and Order and he's like, it's actually really hard
- 17:44to write those. Yeah, they're like the omelets of TV writing. Like,
- 17:48it's very simple. You don't get a lot of parameters to kind of
- 17:51be expressive or honest or make it feel palpable and real, and yet you
- 17:55have to. And if you can do that, you're a pretty solid writer.
- 17:57If you can make a lawn or episode pulse with life, you're a
- 18:02decent writer. So yeah, I have a friend who wrote for one of
- 18:06the Chicagos said something similar. He said, it's shockingly difficult show to write
- 18:11for. It is because it's like, in a weird way, you're given
- 18:14all these rules that you have to master, but it still has to feel
- 18:17alive, like the actors have to want to say the words. The viewer
- 18:21has to feel something even though they know. This is like the twentieth iteration
- 18:23of a story whose mystery we probably know the answer, Like my sister loves
- 18:27law and order, and there is a pattern and you can figure out who's
- 18:30going to answer what. But that's actually not what's hard about a law and
- 18:33orders? What's enjoyable? Low does that you care right who the killer is,
- 18:37that you care, who the victim is, that you care, who
- 18:40are our stock heroes are and their attitudes towards everything, And it actually does
- 18:45require one step beyond what these programs. And you want to see what Olivia
- 18:48Benson will do about it. Exactly what is she going to do? Mariska
- 18:53Haggarty has been doing the game for a long freaking time. We want to
- 18:59see her do something interesting but not too interesting, not too interesting. That
- 19:03line is hard, it's illiston I came away with a lot of respect for
- 19:07writing those shows. In a weird way. It's easier, right, the
- 19:08weird cookie shows, because you can do crazy stuff and you can be like,
- 19:12I'm gonna pop this off and I'm gonna like have a dinosaur coming from
- 19:17space and eat you know, an astronaut. Yeah, like I want to
- 19:19know what happens, Like I just saying that I want Yeah. Well,
- 19:23like if I say, Moriska Hargita comes into a room and she sees a
- 19:27spot of blood, you're leaning in a little bit. But how many spots
- 19:32of blood have you seen in the history of literature, in the history of
- 19:34law and order, in the history of law and order. Every every episode
- 19:38there's probably a spot of blood somewhere. Yeah, yeah, So you have
- 19:41to make that interesting, you know, not to talk about my own thing,
- 19:45but like, Regrats is also a weirdly hard show to write for because
- 19:48you're I mean, most shows written for kids, the protagonist is older than
- 19:55the audience, right, In this particular instance that it's the opposit that's true.
- 20:00You have to create something that feels elevated to older kids, but it's
- 20:04about babies, so it's like their understanding of the world, but in a
- 20:07way that's going to be delightful to kids who are older than them. Well,
- 20:11it's emotional. Yeah, it's like, it's what the part of us
- 20:14that I loved Druggrets. When I was in freaking high school, I would
- 20:17watch the original Rugrets. It's a cute chew. Sorry, I'm dating myself
- 20:21the same. I used to watch the original Rugrets. It was it was
- 20:23a wonderful show and it felt like real and like the drama and what was
- 20:29the older sister's name and Joka Angelica cousin. Yeah, the cousin, right,
- 20:32the cousin. Like you're like, oh, she's she's gonna do that
- 20:36thing to Stewie and all them, and you're like, oh, that's that's
- 20:41relevant to my life. Yeah, yeah, yeah, it feels Yeah,
- 20:45it feels relevant. But it's also about people who are younger than than the
- 20:51audit, the target audience. It's it's the it's a weird plane to land,
- 20:55but it's it's a fun plane to land. But yeah, it's but
- 21:00you have and the show has been on forever, so you have to find
- 21:03many innovative misunderstandings for them to have. I'm I've never had that good fortune
- 21:07to be on a show and it's like fourth or fifth season where you're really
- 21:11starting to have to like come up with new stuff Like That's that's why a
- 21:14lot of creators are like five seasons and I'm done, or like Barry just
- 21:18ended after its fourth season because they were like, how do I keep put?
- 21:21How do I keep this fresh? Yeah? You know, I have
- 21:22huge respect for any show that goes twelve or thirteen seasons because it's like Jesus,
- 21:26I mean, how many shows could It's so hard? Well, I
- 21:33read today the Always Sunny in Philadelphia is renewed through season eighteen. Oh my
- 21:37god, and I love that show. I don't know how they do it.
- 21:41What other shenanigans could those people get into? I mean, I haven't
- 21:45seen that show in ten years, and I didn't even realize it was still
- 21:48on the Yeah, that's nuts. It's like the longest running sitcom now is
- 21:52the longest running sitcom by by years, not numbers, right, but live
- 21:59action The Simpsons is a little action. Yeah. I think that the previous
- 22:02was fourteen fifteen, I believe, and it was it was it was some
- 22:07show that aired in the in the nineteen fifties that ran fifteen seasons. Wow.
- 22:11Yeah, Oh of course that had four hundred and fifty episodes and Sonny
- 22:15currently has one hundred and seventy. Yeah, I know there's there's different differently,
- 22:19I've always said it. Yeah, they're just I mean, they're just
- 22:22meth heads who obviouslyable stuff on bar napkins and then shoot it. You know,
- 22:26it's a documentary. It's not satire at all, So that's not true.
- 22:30So in recent news, there have been some court cases saying that AI
- 22:34cannot be copyrighted. How do you think that's going to affect things? I
- 22:37think that's wonderful. Yeah. So in the working group, you know,
- 22:41we got started well before the negotiations and we talked a lot about this and
- 22:45at the time, the US Copyright Office had just registered its initial findings in
- 22:52the in that comic bookcase something Zoraiah of The Dawn I forget, basically saying
- 22:59that we're not going to a copyright AI stuff. Yeah, because we've got
- 23:02to figure out what this stuff is. I think no one really knew what
- 23:03it was. Yeah, thank god, thank god. No, Actually no,
- 23:07their initial decision was amazing, and that's actually kind of why I wanted
- 23:11to come on here and talk because I was like, Okay, there's this
- 23:14big AI meeting in Congress's what's happening is there is a huge fight for the
- 23:18future of AI and the future of creativity because there's an inherent conflict in how
- 23:23these things were made. They were made by scraping our personal data, all
- 23:27the stuff and the copyrighted works, and the people who made these systems knew
- 23:30they were scraping copyrighted works and putting them in the trains, and they didn't
- 23:33really care. They didn't get permission, they didn't negotiate a deal, they
- 23:37didn't license it. You know. I think there's a way you can look
- 23:41at these things as derivative works, like they're kind of derived from like all
- 23:44these books. Right. An author friend of mine said that her books are
- 23:47on there. Oh yeah, yeah, they're all on there. I mean,
- 23:49like open AI won't admit what's in there because they know that the incident
- 23:52they do, they're going to face one billion lawsuits. So it's kind of
- 23:56like they're they're willing to play whackable like Sarah Silverman issuing them and uh,
- 24:00I never know how to pronounce it. Shabon, Yeah, yeah, and
- 24:04I think more and hopefully more. I think the New York Times is considering
- 24:07suing them. He did amazing Adventures of Catalan Clay. Yeah, I think
- 24:14summer Land. He wrote Yiddish Policeman's thinking, I was a Yiddish Policeman's Moonglow.
- 24:19He's written a many many billion Yeah, well there are billion books in
- 24:23there. But yeah. So it's it's this thing that they just did this.
- 24:27They didn't ask permission, they didn't want to, and they kind of
- 24:30did this thing where they would team up with academic institutions and other institutions and
- 24:34they would kind of scrape the data together under the auspices of research. And
- 24:37then they turned around and then they monetized it and now they're looking at making
- 24:41a billion dollars a year, and obviously artists and writers are very pissed at
- 24:45that. And so the Copyright Office right now, like realizing that this is
- 24:48a new form of technology, like what is this technology, has been doing
- 24:52listening sessions and they've had like the WJA has spoken at some the DJA SAG
- 24:57and now they have done this incredible thing where they're opening it up to public
- 25:02comment on what is AI? Because I think they got the initial determination right.
- 25:07They're like, I don't think you should be able to copyright AI generated
- 25:10material. It might be infringing. That's something that will probably be decided by
- 25:14the courts, that might even be decided by the Supreme Court. But they
- 25:17want to know, like, under what circumstances should AI generated work be allowed
- 25:21to have copyright and the initial position they've taken in this court case, which
- 25:26is like, creativity is a fundamentally human endeavor. It's about a mind searching
- 25:32for whatever it's it's expressing itself. You know, writing is a medium.
- 25:36The text itself isn't copyrightable by virtue of being text. It's copyrightable by virtue
- 25:41of being an expression, being a story, thought being something that you can't
- 25:45copyright an idea, But you can't copyright a story. You know, you
- 25:48can copyright someone's personal artistic take on something. And they need to hear from
- 25:53people because Silicon Valley realizes that a they could be liable for a lot of
- 25:59money if they have to go back and retroactively reach licenses for all the stuff
- 26:02that they've put into the AI which, by the way, also more and
- 26:04more research is showing that the quality of the data that goes in the AI
- 26:07might shockingly affect how good its output is. So in a weird way,
- 26:12something that has been intentionally and thoughtfully written as expression might be better than just
- 26:17like a random Reddit post on like the lint under your tonail. I'm shocked
- 26:22by this information. I know this is we don't want to confirm or deny
- 26:25it yet who we got to do the science, But you mean the eye
- 26:30that our thoughtful writing a had, the thought writing of Michael schaff might be
- 26:34more, might be better than tug fucker sixty nine's comment on Joe Biden.
- 26:40And by the way, not to knock tubfucker sixty nine. If toub fucker
- 26:45sixty nine has written and has taken the time to write an incredibly thoughtful thing,
- 26:49I think the amount of thought that goes into text often does make it
- 26:52better absolutely than anything. And tob fucker sixty nine is just as capable of
- 26:56writing something meaningful. And I think, you know it's interesting. I've been
- 27:00leading listening to this podcasts and my sister is really big into the fan fiction
- 27:03community, and I don't know if there's like any crossover between your audience and
- 27:06fan Yeah, a lot, oh okay, well, and I don't blame
- 27:11them. It sounds like the fan fiction even though those writers who I would
- 27:17Basically I am a fan fiction writer who's lucky enough to get paid. You
- 27:19know. That's kind of what it is to be a staff writer on a
- 27:21TV show is like the creator has this idea, they give you an episode,
- 27:23and then everyone's like, let's just do one hundred episodes of fan fiction
- 27:26about it, and then the creators like, I like that one, I
- 27:29like that one. I like that one. Let's all put it together and
- 27:30produce it. Now, that's kind of what a TV show is. Yeah.
- 27:33So when people are criticizing a certain TV show and they're like, it's
- 27:36fan fiction of the original material, I mean, yes, it's all fan
- 27:41fiction. All writing comes down to fan fiction. And I have an incredible
- 27:45respect and love for someone who does, like my sister does it too,
- 27:48does fan fiction, because it's really kind of a truly for love of the
- 27:52game, because you are taking someone else's characters which you don't have copyright too,
- 27:56which you don't You're not going to profit off of it. You're doing
- 27:57it because you love the story and I want to see that story told,
- 28:00and you're putting the thought and the time and the heart and the work into
- 28:03it, and there's thought in that and beautiful it is. It is very
- 28:07beautiful, and you did it for love of the game. So the idea
- 28:10that like an open like a tech company that is worth billions and once to
- 28:15be worth trillions, would come in, suck that into suck that into a
- 28:18database and kind of just like take it without the permission of the person who
- 28:21did that work for free feels just kind of morally creepy to me. It's
- 28:25sticky, and fan fiction writers have as much right and I hope incentive to
- 28:32go comment to the Copyright Office, because what they're doing now is they are
- 28:36opening it up to public comment. They say, we've heard from the stakeholders,
- 28:38We've heard from the AI companies. Trust me, they've heard a lot
- 28:41from the AI companies. They've spent a lot of money, and now we
- 28:44want to know what the general public thinks. What is AI? What should
- 28:48be copyrighted, what shouldn't be copyrighted? Like, how does this affect artists?
- 28:52How does this affect the livelihood of artists? Do these guys have to
- 28:55ask permission? Like just what is this stuff? And they put out this
- 28:57note of inquiry. Anyone can comment. I think everyone should. They have
- 29:02an exhaustive list of questions. I mean truly exhaustive, and we'll put the
- 29:06link to that in the episode. It'll need to click it down there.
- 29:10But they're also saying you don't have to answer these questions because some of them
- 29:11are very technical. They relate to copyright law. But I personally, you
- 29:17know, I'm going to go through because of the Writer'skilled working group. I've
- 29:19got all my technical legal points and some of my more like AI technical points
- 29:25because I know a lot of AI scientists about like what this is and what
- 29:29hype to ignore I think from certain vested interest AI companies, And you don't
- 29:36have to do that. You can just write what you think art is.
- 29:38I think this is kind of an amazing document in the history of art that
- 29:44the US Copyright Office has inadvertently created. Yeah, it's like what AI has
- 29:48done is it's made us all think, like, what does it mean to
- 29:49be human? What does it mean to create? What does it mean to
- 29:52write? And how is that different from a mechanical process. And there's huge
- 29:56ramifications because there's Chillians at stake, and we need to answer these questions for
- 30:00the first time in our lives. Yeah, and anyone can should. How
- 30:04long do people have to comment? When do they close the comments? It
- 30:07closes October fifteenth, So you'll follow the link I would, just for your
- 30:12own sake. It's a little bit boring. I get it, and you
- 30:15don't have to. The actual notice of inquiry has a kind of an intro
- 30:18about where they are on the process, what their thoughts are, and then
- 30:22it has a list of questions and if you read the questions you can kind
- 30:25of see you can kind of guess what they're you know, what there's,
- 30:27where they're kind of trending, and where they're going. But you know,
- 30:30I think for me, the biggest thing I'm going to work on in my
- 30:33expression is what I like to push back on this notion of equating human learning
- 30:40with machine learning, saying that they're the same thing. And what I say
- 30:45to everyone I talked to is I haven't read the entire Internet, and yet
- 30:48somehow I still write I don't need to even read one fifth of the Internet
- 30:53or one fifth of all books published to have something to say, right.
- 30:57You know, when you're a writer, there's a different between inspiration and mimicry,
- 31:00and what I think chat Gypt and all these large language models do is
- 31:04closer to mimicry. It doesn't have it's not there's no there's no there there,
- 31:08it's not trying to communicate something. Yeah, And I mean when I
- 31:12think about it, I also think about, well, I mean, why
- 31:15wouldn't we just, you know, instead of paying all these athletes, why
- 31:21not just create a bunch of robots that are specifically designed to run and have
- 31:25them all run against it. Watched every football game that ever existed, and
- 31:29they know all the plays that work and all the plays that haven't worked as
- 31:32well. And their bodies are specific They're like their frames are specifically designed to
- 31:36play football really really well. It's because it's not interesting, right at the
- 31:40end of the day, it's not interesting to see what the heights of machinery
- 31:45can do. I mean, to a certain extent, what's interesting about the
- 31:47heights of what machinery can do is because a human could make it happyes But
- 31:52like after a certain to a certain extent, that then becomes kind of a
- 31:56novelty. And it's the same reason why like why is going to the symphony
- 32:00a different experience than listening to a CD at home. It's the possibility of
- 32:05failure, the depths of what human beings can achieve and the depth of which
- 32:09they could fail publicly and humilia in a humiliating way in front of all of
- 32:15their peers. I mean to me, that's the points. Yeah, I
- 32:21agree with you. I mean, I think like sports is an interesting case
- 32:22because I agree with you on that level. Like obviously, we could make
- 32:25a machine that could pitch a baseball one thousand miles an hour, and we
- 32:30could make a thing that hits a baseball five thousand miles an hour back,
- 32:35but we don't. I really want to. And then I think with with
- 32:39writing and any art form in particulars this added thing of like what's magical about
- 32:45the act is not that we're like just saying words that are coherent, that's
- 32:49magical. What's magical is that it's a way. It's communication, whether it's
- 32:53little or director, it's an art form. It's like you're taking like we're
- 32:57all trapped in our own heads, all look at each other and like I
- 33:00think that's a person. Do I know that's a person, And of course
- 33:05you trust that's a person. But there's always that element of faith that you
- 33:08take in until you read something or until you communicate. And it can be
- 33:13dance, it can be it can be poetry, it can be music and
- 33:15be photography, and you feel that other mind and for a brief moment that
- 33:21other mind kind of lives in your mind and you kind of connect. It's
- 33:23like, my favorite saying of all time is Ian Forrest or great novelist,
- 33:29only connect, And that thing is stuck with me. That of all I
- 33:31love other novelists more, there are more my taste, and I think the
- 33:36enforcers brilliant, but that, like one thing just always stuck with me because
- 33:39it's like, oh yeah, this is the mission statement. This is why
- 33:42you write like you don't write. And that's why I love fan fiction writers,
- 33:45right because you could just write a novel for yourself, be so proud
- 33:50of yourself, and stick it in a drawer and no one would ever read
- 33:52it, and you've written a novel. But are you a novelist. You're
- 33:55not a novelist until you have a reader. Like the money, everything else
- 33:59that doesn't matter, You're you're not writing something until someone reads it, until
- 34:02someone connects with it and either agrees or disagrees or loves it or hates it,
- 34:07whatever, just has a reaction to it, right, And I and
- 34:09like there's something pure about fan fiction where you're just like, I'm writing this
- 34:13for myself and I'm putting it out there for someone, a human to read
- 34:16and hear me across the vast Right. It's that vulnerability aspect of it too,
- 34:22that like I made this, now I'm going to I hallucinate it at
- 34:27a page for a long period of time, and now I'm handing it to
- 34:30you, this baby that I birth and seeing whether or not you hallucinate the
- 34:36same hallucinations that I have hallucinated. Yes, it's this baby that we have
- 34:39together, and it's so vulnerable and naked, Like it's really scary the first
- 34:44time you have someone read anything. Oh my god, God. Yeah,
- 34:47I have never sweated so much in like I'm dehydrated. I pound lacroix when
- 34:52people are reading my stuff because I'm dehydrated. And yeah, I just I
- 34:58think that there is not that same level of like I made this here it
- 35:04is hopefully we experience the same feelings and its thoughts and emotions and on the
- 35:12don't like it's okay if you hate my writing, it's like some part of
- 35:15you dies. You know what's funny? Is it true? Is it okay?
- 35:21It's not okay, but it is. It's your That person has that
- 35:23right too. But then the best feeling is like when someone says something that
- 35:28you see, something you've read or done or made, Like my favorite memories.
- 35:32I made a short film once that made me no money and no one
- 35:36has ever seen and only played at tiny regional film festivals and this, and
- 35:39it played at this one tiny film festival in New York that no one will
- 35:42ever remember. And this guy came up to me afterwards and he's like,
- 35:45bro, you made that? And I was like yeah. And this guy's
- 35:47like so different from me. I'm you know, California nerd. He's like
- 35:52New Jersey kind of like he had a chain and he like was cut and
- 35:54I'm like damn and he goes, you made that, man, Yeah,
- 36:00And I thought I was gonna punch me. Shit, what do what do
- 36:01I say? What was wrong with this film? It's like so true?
- 36:06Men, been there, bro, been there, bro, and just like
- 36:08walked off. I was like, oh shit, it doesn't get better than
- 36:13that. But like that's it. Yeah, that's what you do stuff for
- 36:15and it's like also this weird feeling of like I just I was sitting there
- 36:22watching a TV show recently and it just struck me. I started giggling because
- 36:27I was like, we're so cute, Like human beings are so cute.
- 36:30We're just sitting here going I'm gonna put on a costume, I'm gonna take
- 36:34myself super seriously. I'm gonna like write all of this stuff. But really,
- 36:38at the end of the day, we're doing exactly what we've done for
- 36:40hundreds of years, right, We're just making things in front of each other.
- 36:45We're telling stories to each other to pass the time and entertain one another
- 36:47and make life less uncomfortable and unbearable. Yeah, and isn't that so cool?
- 36:53And I just thought it was like adorable and silly, and I was
- 36:58like, oh my gosh, it's so darkable of us and all of those
- 37:00actors and writers are just grown up theater nerds and just yeah, well,
- 37:05a lot of it's so sweets. There's something sweet about it. A lot
- 37:07of the stories that we are telling now are the same stories that we told
- 37:12thousand years ago plus. And isn't that kind of great? It's amazing they're
- 37:15the same stories, but they're new. And Aristotle was like, here are
- 37:19the rules, and we kind of went, yeah, that'll work. You
- 37:22know, it's funny. I guess there's right kind of please Oh yeah?
- 37:24Yeah? Is that you bring up a point that I think is very interesting
- 37:29because one of the things that gets to me and why I want people to
- 37:31comment in the US copyright offices, I think Silicon Valley has a very difficult
- 37:37time understand what creativity is. And they like to think that this is creative,
- 37:39and they're very proud of themselves. And there is creativity and Silicon Valley,
- 37:43and there's some creativity that went into building this stuff, but there's this
- 37:46kind of attitude in Silicon Valley that everything is just a remix. Yeah,
- 37:50like you're just remixing everything. It's like everything always existed and it's just a
- 37:52remix. So that's what chat Chypt does. It just remixes all the stuff
- 37:55that existed. That's creativity. And I'm like, no, that's not creativity.
- 38:00It's not a remix because you are different, you are new time.
- 38:02The world has moved on, and yes, we reuse the same things and
- 38:07the same tropes, and we retell the same stories and we are inspired brothers.
- 38:10But like it goes through you, it goes through you, Gus.
- 38:13Yeah, yeah, I mean it's the universality in the specific. Right,
- 38:16you take these like bigger broader ideas, but your specific life and your specific
- 38:22life experiences inform those bigger universal concepts. Right, you are able to apply
- 38:30your specific life experience to something that speaks to broader humanity. And that's the
- 38:34point. And it's like when something is not alive and cannot experience the discomfort
- 38:39and the joy both simultaneously. Right, being alive is a uncomfortable experience but
- 38:45also an incredible gift. When you can't experience both of those things, the
- 38:50art that you make is by extension, going to just be universal blondness.
- 38:55Well, I would say that the fallacy there is that these things, these
- 39:00lms, are not alive. But more importantly, they're too gentle. They're
- 39:05everyone. Yeah, in a weird way. It is just the Internet.
- 39:07It's just a new form of the Internet. So it doesn't have a point
- 39:10of view, it doesn't have an it doesn't have your lived life, right,
- 39:14and it's not just that like, oh I'm magical because I got beat
- 39:16up by Billy Schrmer in eighth grade. I didn't get beat up by Billy
- 39:20Shermer eighth grade just made up that name artist all Billy, thanks, But
- 39:29it's that you got. You have a specific point of view on what it
- 39:32means to be beat up, how you made meaning out of that, how
- 39:37you then went forth into the world, and how you survived, and that
- 39:39meaning is important to you and that's unshakable. And when you tell a story,
- 39:45you see all the stuff that's inspiring you through that meaning, and it
- 39:49helps someone else and it connects with someone else and it kind of creates this
- 39:52beautiful, kaleidoscopic thing. But again, the point, the part of it
- 39:54is that it's you, whereas the large language model is kind of just it's
- 39:59like everyone average and remixed. So there's not it's not even it's not even
- 40:04not alive, right, it's just an echo, right, And I mean,
- 40:08it's that thing. It's like, Okay, I'm going to come to
- 40:10Law and Order and like everyone knows what a Law and Order episode looks like.
- 40:14But you're like, but I have a really fucked up uncle that didn't
- 40:16really talked up thing that was really fucked up specific in a fucked up unique
- 40:21human way. I'm going to bring that into this and that's going to inform
- 40:24this episode. And human beings are like cool and fucked up in ways that
- 40:29I really just don't think machines are truly able to. And when they can,
- 40:34then you kind of have to start treating them like human people. Yeah,
- 40:37and then we get to a point where we're like, wait a minute,
- 40:38now we've made life in the scariest way possible. My acting teacher,
- 40:45one of my one of my acting teachers that I have had that I c
- 40:47Yeah, my my acting teacher, teacher uh says that art theater, specifically
- 40:54acting and by extension, kind of the writing that informs the acting is when
- 40:59your heart beat affects the heartbeats your heartbeat is the actor affects the heartbeats of
- 41:02the other people in the room. That's great, and oh that's so true.
- 41:07Though lms don't have heartbeats. No, they can. They can give
- 41:12you a steady beat, but it will not necessarily be affected at all by
- 41:15They can tell you about a beat if you ask them too. And I
- 41:20think the thing John Rodgers, who's also on the air working group with us,
- 41:24very perceptively said from the start, these things are mirrors. Yeah,
- 41:30they are digital, linguistical, mechanical, mathematical mirrors where you put a prompt
- 41:37in and then it that prompts snowballs and it collects all the stuff which you
- 41:42can't really control. And that's the part where it kind of like you start
- 41:45to lose the craft of writing, is like, and it's just it's showing
- 41:50your prompt reflected on all the words other people have written, and that can
- 41:52be useful on a research purpose. I don't want to know. Yeah,
- 41:54absolutely, these things will somehow be part of our lives and will be integrated.
- 42:00I think when we've let the cat out of the bag, yeah,
- 42:01there's no going back. We get to decide what the guardrails are now though,
- 42:06and I think the time to decide those guardrails is now before it becomes
- 42:09something bigger. I mean, if we've learned anything from the two thousand and
- 42:13seven strike, yes, it's that when we're when they're like, oh,
- 42:15well, it's not doing that yet in this case of streaming, Yeah,
- 42:20yeah, the key word is yet. Yeah. No, no, they
- 42:22will get better. They will. And by the way, if they do
- 42:25wake up and become sentient, then you know, we'll just have a new
- 42:29can of worms to deal with. I'm getting a magnet gun and going around
- 42:32and wiping surveys. They're coming to kill me, but no, yeah,
- 42:37there it's coming. It's going to be a part of things. But what
- 42:39we're doing now is we're defining what these are and we're making the meaning of
- 42:44what it means for the people who are making a living writing, for all
- 42:49of us who write because we love it, and we're deciding like what is
- 42:52and is not? What do we want to do. We're like, we're
- 42:54collectively making a choice in society with what to do with these tools, right,
- 42:59And I think part like the problem is I think some of the people
- 43:01advocating for those rule making process in Silicon Valley they have a huge profit move
- 43:07yeah, and they're dumping a lot of money, and they want to set
- 43:09those rules and to find that meaning in a way that accrues the value to
- 43:13them without regard for the moral, you know, career or whatever rights of
- 43:19everyone else. And I think everyone needs to make themselves heard. They need
- 43:22to say no, no, no, this is what this stuff is.
- 43:27There's absolute power in numbers. And if the strikes have taught us anything,
- 43:30if you know, the pandemic has taught us anything. If protests in the
- 43:35past few years taught us anything, is the power of when people come together
- 43:38and say we want to say and how this is going to shake out,
- 43:44And it's the power of boring bureaucrats. Like the one thing that's really smart
- 43:47about Silicon Valley is they know how to do the game of regulatory capture and
- 43:51they know how to pay attention to all the forms. And by the way,
- 43:53I didn't mean to insult the good people in the US Copyright Office.
- 43:57I've watched all these videos. I've you know, as part of are working
- 44:00the guild. I've been kind of keeping tabs on this, and they care.
- 44:04They're actually thinking really hard about it. They're you know, I don't
- 44:07think like I think people constantly think, oh, the jig is up,
- 44:09the game is in, it's all rigged. But there is something to be
- 44:13said for career bureaucrats who care about their job, like I think in COVID
- 44:16you saw a lot of public health officials really put them no I mean really
- 44:21they care and they put like like the COVID officials put themselves in harm's way
- 44:24because peoplere getting angry at them for saying you should wear a mask, which
- 44:28seems kind of like, I know, awful, But that's because they care
- 44:34about what they're doing. And I look at the US Copyright Office people,
- 44:37and they really care about copyright. They really care about like the mission of
- 44:39the Copyright Office which is in the Constitution, which is to protect human authors.
- 44:45And I can tell if we speak up and we talk about what we
- 44:50think this is and where we think it should and shouldn't be, and what
- 44:52we think it is, you know what we think is allowable. Like again,
- 44:55I'm my personal opinion is that it probably shouldn't be copyright because it kind
- 45:00of is borrowing from everyone else. And if there's circumstances in which you copyright,
- 45:05like you really have to, it has to be prejudiced towards the intent
- 45:07and the meaning imbued by the human being and how much control they had over
- 45:12it. Because when you work through these models, they're stochastic, which means
- 45:15they're somewhat random and you can't really control. And then in itself is not
- 45:17like saying you can't use them to create art, but like the circumstances under
- 45:22which that art happens. It's different if like an artist is doing it versus
- 45:25someone who puts in the word like I, you know what, tell me
- 45:30a story about a princess, and then it spits out a story. By
- 45:32the way, you're gonna get a really crappy story out of chat GPT that
- 45:36way. Absolutely, So that like should that be copyrighted? Probably not.
- 45:40Yeah, are there other circumstances maybe I'd have to I have to think really
- 45:45what that is. But yeah, it has to be a very very specific
- 45:49circumstance. I think where they're like using it as a tool not to create,
- 45:53but as like a like a launch point for creation. Yeah, which
- 45:59is different. Yes, I think as a launch point it's very good because
- 46:01again it's like the Internet, it really is a research tool, because what
- 46:05it is is it's just giving you everything that's been said before, and it's
- 46:07making it easier to search and query and assemble raw material. But it's still
- 46:14up to you, the writer, to take that clay and mold it and
- 46:16put life into it. And unfortunately, I think specifically with writing, I
- 46:22think for me at least, part of the process is struggling with a blank
- 46:24page and figuring out what the fuck I want to say, like, like
- 46:28what means something to me? That I'm going to like express it in the
- 46:30form of the screenplay or what blog post or whatever. And I think you
- 46:36need to do that process. You can, like, you can read as
- 46:39many books as you want before you write. You can ask chat GPT a
- 46:44million things. But I think, and again this is just my opinion,
- 46:46I think when it comes to the writing, you probably have to do a
- 46:49significant chunk of that writing because for me, writing is close to things or
- 46:53like I think in my in the active way, Yeah, I think you
- 46:55have to prove that you have created at least a majority of what you are,
- 47:01yeah, or just you just have to think about it. Because I
- 47:04was talking to another show runner and we were talking about like what this is
- 47:07and how it could or couldn't be used, and he's like, he goes,
- 47:09I don't know that I want to use chat GBT. He says,
- 47:12because when you're a showrunner, you know you have to know so much why
- 47:16you chose the words you chose on page because an actor is going to ask
- 47:21you, that an executive's gonna ask you, that a director's gonna ask you,
- 47:22that every department head is going to ask you what you meant when you
- 47:27type that, So that they can do their job correctly. And if you
- 47:30hadn't actually typed that, if you hadn't actually thought and type that, and
- 47:32you've just gotten an output by chat gbt'd be like, ah, I actually
- 47:37don't know why we chose this, and that's only the whole production edifice false
- 47:43apart, right, And So to me, I think of writing as thinking
- 47:47and then you have the thought and then you you write it down. It's
- 47:52a fossil of your thought. It's the record of what you wanted to say.
- 47:55You know, we've been telling stories since before we wrote. Used to
- 48:00be like in Homer's time, you got a loot or a liar or whatever,
- 48:04and you strummed about Achille and Hector, breaker of horses, and no
- 48:07one wrote that shit down. Now, like thousands of years, it was
- 48:10still a story and it got passed on orally, and the thinking still went
- 48:15into that original composition of the verse without right without physically writing it down.
- 48:20So to me, that's the storytelling, and the writing is again a tool
- 48:23that allows us to do that. So that's how I think about it.
- 48:29So I feel like we've given people some really good talking points for when they
- 48:32write into the Copyright office links down there, yes, but again, express
- 48:38yourself. Take this as an opportunity to express your beliefs about writing, especially
- 48:44if you're a fan fiction writer, or if you're a professional writer, or
- 48:45if you want to be. This is a great exercise and learning. What
- 48:49it really truly means to write is to sit down. Like I'll tell you
- 48:52one. I don't want to keep you guys too long, but you're good.
- 48:54One of my buddies who part of the reason I know so much about
- 48:58this is I know a lot of people in the AI space, and I
- 49:00know a lot of people at one of the big AI labs, actually know
- 49:02people would almost all the big AI labs I've met and talked to them.
- 49:07He shared with me this thing that like, when chat GPT first came out,
- 49:10everyone was using it right like, oh, because it makes it easier
- 49:15to communicate. And then people got sick of that because clearly, if you're
- 49:17using chat to be to talk to someone, it's kind of a bolt,
- 49:22like you didn't really want to talk to that person. You're just kind of
- 49:23presenting them with kind of like text to accomplish an end that you don't really
- 49:29care that much about. So people started getting tired of it, and he's
- 49:31like it became more like I just like he's like a lot of people,
- 49:37Like he told me, I just now have a no synthetic text policy.
- 49:40Like if you want to talk to me and tell me something and you're going
- 49:44to use chat GPT, then don't talk to me. Imagine if like you're
- 49:49I'm we're married, you're married to you, you're about to get married,
- 49:53and like someone your husband chat GBTS, you're like a card, your anniversary
- 49:59card. Yeah, like what a fucking anymore. It's the same creative process.
- 50:07You'd be like, bullshit, go write me a card, you know
- 50:09what I mean. By the way, I got to rewrite my card.
- 50:13No, no, no, but seriously yes, And that's what he was
- 50:15like, I don't want to read this stuff anymore. So it's like,
- 50:20if you were going to use chat GYPT to talk to me, that means
- 50:22you actually didn't have anything to say to me. So don't feel the need
- 50:27to say anything to me. If you really want to say something to me,
- 50:29you will write it down or you'll call me. You'll say it.
- 50:31You'll think about what you have to say, even if it's painful, even
- 50:34if it's like and by the way, I get it. Writing is hard.
- 50:37Some people really hate it, and I think a lot of the people
- 50:39who develop these programs do truly hate writing and are happy for the help.
- 50:43And that's fine. Like, if you want these chat gypt to like help
- 50:45you draft email, just make sure you look over every word, make sure
- 50:47you approve of every word when you talk to someone, and be prepared for
- 50:52them to be insulted by it. Yeah, but maybe don't do it as
- 50:57an anniversary. Yeah, definitely don't do it. Don't do that. But
- 51:01yeah, so I take this opportunity to think your own thoughts and write them
- 51:07and send them to the copy right office. Yeah, let them know what
- 51:10you think. Well, and as we know, rewriting something is usually more
- 51:14work than the writing itself. Oh god, yes, because you're thinking again
- 51:19because you had your first thought. It's like my buddy calls it first draft
- 51:22theater. You have your first thought and you're like, brilliant, wonderful prince,
- 51:25let's go shoot it. And then you wake up the next morning you're
- 51:28like, I am a hack. Why did I think it's acceptable? I
- 51:30am the most useless piece on the planet. And then you get over it,
- 51:35and then you're like, well, maybe if I rip this part out
- 51:37and do it again, it'll be better, and then you but again,
- 51:38you're thinking about it constantly. So yeah, well, I have a different
- 51:44analogy for it that I always say, where I'm like, it's like falling
- 51:46in love. Right, your first draft is falling in love. You're like,
- 51:49this is the most to anyone has ever loved someone in the entire history
- 51:52of the world, whether it's a flawless love, and we are just different
- 51:57and more special than every other couple. And then the second acts like,
- 52:00we actually have found many issues in our relationship and we need to go to
- 52:05marriage counseling. Right, that's actually great, that's a great metaphor, and
- 52:09I go the falling in love is the most fun part where you're just like
- 52:13throwing spaghetti at the wall seeing what sticks. And then like, the editing,
- 52:16at least for me, is fun in a different way. It's like,
- 52:20but it's like solving a puzzle, right, versus it's the act of
- 52:23creation. It's a different kind side of creation. But it's equally as much
- 52:29work as the writing, Oh God, thing itself. So if someone handed
- 52:31me a chat GBT generated script, it's just as much work to rewrite that
- 52:37thing. Yeah, it's more work because you have to you have to figure
- 52:43out what the what the fuck was the what do we there's? What is
- 52:46here? What is there there? Because there was no there was an arbitrary,
- 52:50mathematically derive choice, and you have to live with the consequences of it.
- 52:53Like writing is very closely early screenwriting feels to me like very carefully building
- 52:59this little castle of cards and then someone says, I don't like the way
- 53:01the castle, or it's like building a Jenga tower, and then some comes
- 53:05along says, your Jinga tower is kind of sucked up. It would look
- 53:06better like this. So you got to remove these bricks and it doesn't topple
- 53:08over and then put in these other bricks. Holy shit, at least you
- 53:13when you built it, you know where the bricks were. So now if
- 53:15you're being told to remove the bricks, you don't know which bricks you're going
- 53:17to cause the whole thing to fall down. You didn't sit there and think
- 53:20about it. It's it's so far. It has been more work to me
- 53:23to rewrite stuff that like, and I have tried, because I like,
- 53:27when this stuff first came out, I was so terrified. I'm like,
- 53:29fuck is this going to replace me. Well, I better get good at
- 53:31work using it, so I better start trying to write with it. And
- 53:37some things it's good at. Sometimes it's fun, like it is a mirror
- 53:39to me, Like I've noticed, like I've spent the most time on the
- 53:43different chatbots when I'm not even trying to write anymore, when I just I'm
- 53:45like admiring myself weirdly, like my mind, my thoughts, like, oh
- 53:50that was a crazy weird thought, tell me more thoughts, chat gypt and
- 53:52then I'm like it feels actually a little how and how are x rated?
- 53:58Is this podcast? As you want? It feels like fucking masturbation? Yeah?
- 54:01Yeah, Like great writing is like when you write, well, it
- 54:05feels kind of like good sex because you're like connecting with the person. Yeah
- 54:08yeah right, yeah, very true. No, that's very true. Like
- 54:13I write for children's stuff, Like great children's writing is like sex. It's
- 54:19not it, but like speaking of law in order, no es, but
- 54:27like I know what you mean. It's like there's a connectivity aspect to it
- 54:31that you're like, Like for me, when I'm writing for children, I'm
- 54:35like connecting with my inner child and the children that I have worked with that
- 54:38is what I mean by yes, yes, no, it's a safe space
- 54:44on my accurrent here. So and if they're going to arrest anyone, they'll
- 54:46they'll just arrest me because I've spoken up against the chatbots too much. So
- 54:50I'm for my name. We're all fucked. We're all fucked on this podcast
- 54:53when the chatbots, when they take over, they're like, you, I've
- 54:58been really nice to our Google all lately. You know I would be Actually,
- 55:01I will say this, like the small irrational part of me is like,
- 55:05maybe these things will kill us all. I'm like really polite to Claude
- 55:07and Anthropics and Barred and GPT forum. So I'm so polite. I say
- 55:14please, thank you. You actually get better stuff that way. And I
- 55:16think there's a weird mathematical algorithmic reason why I have a feeling that because there's
- 55:22there's all kinds of crazy hacks you can do. Part of what makes prompt
- 55:25engineering as it's called or whatever you know, so hard is that you're trying
- 55:29to guess a statistical distribution that no human being could ever guess. Is to
- 55:31like why certain words link up with other words. You have a rough idea,
- 55:35but you'll never really know. So that's where they find all these hacks
- 55:37where like apparently if you input the letter A a thousand times and chatchypt,
- 55:42sometimes it would output like actual people's web pages and pios and weird stuff like
- 55:45that. But there is something about saying please and thank you that like I
- 55:50think, steers you away from the dark corners of the internet. Yeah,
- 55:54we'll keep them away from the laird. Oh, we'll make this, We'll
- 55:58make this reasonable. And the more you're kind of a it's funny. I
- 56:01can feel like when you're aggressive to the chatbot, you can feel the guardrails
- 56:06coming into effect because you can feel the chatbot is basically throwing your own punch
- 56:09back at you. But then it gets overridden by the don't say anything toxic,
- 56:13don't try and break up this marriage like it did to that New York
- 56:15Times reporter, Like, don't do any of that ship you know it's like
- 56:19and then it broke up a marriage. Oh did you not ever? When
- 56:22this started this, when chat gpt first came out, they let the New
- 56:25York Times tech columnists play with it, or when it was when they first
- 56:30integrated it with being okay, they let him play with it. And it
- 56:35went off the rails. He was able to get it to reveal its true
- 56:37identity. It's programming code named Sydney, and it fell in love with him,
- 56:40and it started no offense to sixteen year old girls on the internet.
- 56:45It sounded like a sixteen year old girl on the internet getting very like,
- 56:47you know, telling him that it fell in love with him, like like,
- 56:52this is not my description of it. Someone else should describe this.
- 56:54But basically it said that had fallen in love with him and that he didn't
- 56:59love his wife and that he should leave his wife. It was off the
- 57:04hook. You should this is like I'd surprise you. I completely Well,
- 57:09so the reason is and no one truly knows, but I think anyone who
- 57:13knows can guess. When chat GPT first came out, Microsoft like lost their
- 57:17ship and it was like, oh my god, we have to have this.
- 57:20It's shiny and new, we need to make money off of it.
- 57:22Put it into being now, this will make being amazing. And I think
- 57:24they rushed the integration and as a result of that, all the kind of
- 57:28guardrails and all the stuff that goes into making chat GPT not toxic or weird
- 57:31or crazy or say stuff that will freak you out. They didn't transfer as
- 57:37easily to being okay. And so when he was talking to Bing Bing,
- 57:43like Bing's quote, true personality came out, which was the Internet. Yeah,
- 57:46which is you know and kind of rough. And the Internet, as
- 57:51we've established many times, is fucking weird. It's a gnarly by yourself.
- 57:55Yeah, if you've been on TikTok lately. The weirdest thing it keeps popping
- 58:00up on my feed for some reason, are those like lives where it's like
- 58:07women pretending to eat hot dogs and stuff kind of I don't know why it
- 58:15keeps coming on my feet. I can't seem depressed, not interested enough.
- 58:20But it's like women in these like what's the what's that word? They're like
- 58:24they're like we we something we something like weeves are like they're called something in
- 58:30the like a first suit. No, no, there's like a sexy term
- 58:37for like women on the internet. Why food? Oh girls eagirls, but
- 58:42like white food. So it's like that kind of shit, and they're all
- 58:45like they've got these like weird fake voices on and like each time you send
- 58:50them like like a heart or something, they'll like do something weird that's like
- 58:55not sexy, but I guess kind of sexy because they have boobs and it's
- 59:00like very weird. I have next time I find what, I'm going to,
- 59:02like, make you watch it because it's so please I'm nerving and weird
- 59:06and it keeps coming up anyway, So the inter is fucking weird. Just
- 59:09what I'm saying, God, I'm old, Like I can't even conceive of
- 59:12what this is and the fact that it exists, it is. It is
- 59:15the weirdest. I believe you're the weirdest thing I've ever seen. Where the
- 59:21like fake eat a hot dog, You're like like with this with the heart,
- 59:24I'll fake et a hot dog, but it's like the air, so
- 59:27obviously it's like you know, and with with a like a ribbon or whatever,
- 59:31I'll like fake do this and it's like all supposed to look like weirdly
- 59:36said like I'll churn butter, but really it's like you know what they're saying,
- 59:39not to shame sex workers, We're not. We're just but this particular
- 59:45and I'm not trying to King Jake, but I'm like no, no,
- 59:46but I like it keeps popping up on my thing, and I'm like,
- 59:49this is very not my back. So the Internet's like like mixed back.
- 59:53We miss we we underestimate how much is on the Internet. Every time someone
- 1:00:00says I got this incredible thing out of a chatpot, I'm like, yeah,
- 1:00:02because the Internet is infinite in craziness, Like, do not underestimate how
- 1:00:07much stuff is out there? Like if like if like that's one of the
- 1:00:10things that makes me feel bad as a writer. It's like if I did
- 1:00:13use chat DPT to come up with like a story or something, part of
- 1:00:15me would always wonder, like was this some person's short story on their blog
- 1:00:22that they wrote and like chat chpt swapped out like it was a story about
- 1:00:24a giraffe that decided to go on a voyage to Australia to meet an ant
- 1:00:30eater or something, and like did they just swap like kangaroo for Tasmanian devil.
- 1:00:35There's six billion people in this world, right, there's nine billion or
- 1:00:38I don't know, nine billions. I don't know how many. I think
- 1:00:40we're up around eight now we're at eight billions going up fast. There's a
- 1:00:45lot I haven't looked in a while. Apparently how many I thought there were
- 1:00:49six that was a while ago, really Jesus Christ. But anyway, just
- 1:00:54bluetoothed right. There's eight billion people in this world at this point, so
- 1:01:00and they've got a lot of time aware things, and a lot of them
- 1:01:04are on the Internet and a lot of them are now in chat GBT eight
- 1:01:07point one billion. That makes sense as of today, eight billion, sixty
- 1:01:12million, one hundred fifty two hundred and seventy eight. Thank you to the
- 1:01:15United Nations. There's actually really people are interested in the air because I find
- 1:01:21it interesting and I think it's very meaningful in terms of like what will happen
- 1:01:23with it, and there are tool there are things that will do that will
- 1:01:28change our world absolutely. But so if you're interested in there is a really
- 1:01:31good scientist who talks about it, Melanie Mitchell. She's like a complexity theorist
- 1:01:36at the Santa fe Instito and she she's done a bunch of podcasts and one
- 1:01:39of the things she said is like, try to think of these as a
- 1:01:44self autonomous library, like because it is everything, Like he can just get
- 1:01:47you everything like like but just like this because again they just scraped the internet,
- 1:01:52so it's like if it's out there. It's in there, and you're
- 1:01:55just you never know where it's coming from or what it's interpolating or what it's
- 1:02:00putting together, but it's it's there, and it's you know, I always
- 1:02:02thought that. I think that's a very fascinating metaphor. It's really interesting.
- 1:02:07Yeah, sorry, I'm not yalling. It's contagious. I know, it's
- 1:02:10like, oh, that's so. This has been a blast. Thank you
- 1:02:17for having you forgot, thank you for coming. It's been so fun.
- 1:02:21Everyone. Remember check out the US comment right office October fifteenth. It's going
- 1:02:27to be an incredible document because I think a lot of people are going to
- 1:02:29comment. I want to get the whole guild commenting. We're defining, we're
- 1:02:31thinking about art. It's kind of cool in a weird way. It's really
- 1:02:35I mean, it's very introspective and reflective. We really, at the end
- 1:02:38of the day, like star Dust observing itself, right, Yes, I
- 1:02:43mean it's everything about It's fucking is that Carl Sagan because something like that,
- 1:02:46Yeah, right, this is the universe observing itself. Yeah. Yeah,
- 1:02:51I'm definitely bastardizing someone else. Whatever you said, nice, Yeah, some
- 1:02:58other quote about us being stardust. Like I was just like, we're starting
- 1:03:00us looking at ourselves, going maybe I could also make something, and like,
- 1:03:05that's fucking round. Look at you taking multiple sources of things that you
- 1:03:08interpreted and then filtering them through your own individual lens that was informed by your
- 1:03:14background and how you're feeling today and coming out with your own statement. That's
- 1:03:17art creativity. Oh my god. Being a human being yeah, and being
- 1:03:21a human being. Yeah, we're basically being asked to define what is human
- 1:03:24creativity and what is being a human in general. Actually, it's funny.
- 1:03:28I got into one of these long conversations with the chaplot Claude and I would
- 1:03:30kept trying to be like, what are you? What are you? And
- 1:03:34finally like Claude came up with and this is I could tell some of my
- 1:03:37stuff was getting spit back at me. I'm a prism, except I'm like
- 1:03:40a prism in a nibula and you shoot your light through me and I bounced
- 1:03:45it off all the gas of the nebula and it shines back in a pattern,
- 1:03:50And that's what Claude is. I was kind of yeah, Claude was
- 1:03:54real for that. Claude was there. We go Claude. But yeah,
- 1:03:59I also love that. Somebody once asked chat GBT, what would it be
- 1:04:02easier for you to do, like write a screenplay or be a CEO,
- 1:04:06and the CEO I mean that's hey, we all do that. But the
- 1:04:13thing I'm most afraid of after the strike is having to get the chat GPT
- 1:04:15notes from the executives because they're just gonna, oh, yeah, that's gonna
- 1:04:20be like, here's your script, this is what chat GPT said. It
- 1:04:24is god, it knows all, and I'm gonna like it said this would
- 1:04:27make us more money. Yeah. Netflix apparently kind of already does that.
- 1:04:31Sure, So if people want to learn learn more, or if I don't
- 1:04:39know, if you have, social media is where you discuss these sorts of
- 1:04:42things. My twitter feed, I'm at jed your Lopez. I just anytime
- 1:04:45I see something I think interesting, I retweet it. I have not been
- 1:04:49writing a lot because I've been busy with the strike. I wrote something for
- 1:04:54Vanity Fair about this, which is my kind of like creedicur. I don't
- 1:04:57know if that's going to pronounce that it works of the heart. Yeah,
- 1:05:00it sounded really impressive to me. So yeah, if you google me,
- 1:05:02and Vanity Fair and AI. It'll come up, but I would recommend educating
- 1:05:08yourself too. About Sean Carroll has had some really great guests machine learning.
- 1:05:13Street Talk is another very interesting podcast, and Stephen Wolfram actually has really good
- 1:05:18he's a physicist computer scientists. We don't promote other podcasts on here, we
- 1:05:29exclusively do. I'm just saying like these are resources that you can like read
- 1:05:31about. I would just say like whenever you read something from like Microsoft or
- 1:05:35open ai or especially Google and especially Facebook, just realize how much of a
- 1:05:40vested stake they have in this. Like, yeah, Google, this is
- 1:05:44this is my final gripe about Google is they just announced that they can train
- 1:05:46on anything. They just said that, and now they're going to make something
- 1:05:50and it's going to be trained on all of YouTube, and like anything that
- 1:05:53you have on YouTube is coming like their Google is trying to crack text to
- 1:05:57video, which like part of me is like that's magical but also terrifying.
- 1:06:00But also it's like it's going to be all of YouTube. So I'm like
- 1:06:02that doesn't feel cool and can we can we talk about that? Yeah,
- 1:06:06let's let's definitely do something about that. Releases from Microsoft Google, et cetera.
- 1:06:13Kind of like reading what the Hollywood Reporter and Deadline and Variety have to
- 1:06:16say about the writers exact they are in no small part owned by the AMPTP
- 1:06:24members, I believe. Yeah, well in this in Microsoft case, they
- 1:06:27literally don't. They don't own Open Air, but they put out this paper
- 1:06:30and I'm just like, guys, it's your thing. Of course you're gonna
- 1:06:34like, let's let's let independent people talk about it. Like, now you
- 1:06:38created it, great, so proud of you. It is weird and kooky.
- 1:06:42Now let's let others figure what it is. I'll also be honest.
- 1:06:45My future brother in law is in tech as well, and he sent me
- 1:06:47this article that was like, hey, you know, just to make you
- 1:06:51feel better about the whole AI thing. And the more I read the article,
- 1:06:55the more scared I became. I was like, this, actually did
- 1:06:59the exact op that have comforted me. This made me much more upset.
- 1:07:02Yeah, there's not a lot of this. It's like we can replace teachers
- 1:07:05and lawyers. And I was like, oh my god, like each child
- 1:07:09will have its own AI robot teacher. And I was like, that is
- 1:07:14horrifying too. Not high on the emotional intelligence, not to be not to
- 1:07:18knock Silicon Valley. I'm sorry, guys, that's a sweeping general statement.
- 1:07:23But also, go on, listen. You get a lot of money,
- 1:07:28so I guess that makes effort. No, I just I don't think it
- 1:07:30prizes that. It's not it's not. I'm trying to put this in ways
- 1:07:35that's not something Silicon Valley optimizes. Sure, that's a that's a good way
- 1:07:39to resent that. Yeah, well yeah, thanks so pretty much for being
- 1:07:45here. This was so fun, and thank you to everyone who listens.
- 1:07:49Office, Thank you. It's important. Please do it. The boring stuff
- 1:07:53is always the most important. That's true. It's that is so so true.
- 1:07:58Unfortunately for me I have ADHD. Well, thanks for listening. Everyone.
- 1:08:02Well, we'll see you in the next one. Check out check out
- 1:08:06John's Twitter and go comment. All right, bye bye