Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Natalia Grace Documentary Reaction (Chapter 3)
Transcript
- 0:00Hayes, Our listeners, this is part three, the final chapter, if
- 0:04you will, of me publishing the audio version of these videos that I posted
- 0:11on YouTube in which I was watching the documentary called The Curious Case of Natalia
- 0:15Grace. And these episodes are very long because I didn't want to fill up
- 0:21all of the space on the audio feed of the podcast, so I I
- 0:28So if you're into this, then these episodes are going to take a while
- 0:32to get through unless you listen on fast, which I do whenever I listen
- 0:36back to this podcast to review things. I listened at two time speed,
- 0:40sometimes two point two, which sounds absurd but works for me at the releast
- 0:46one point five, you know. And now when I listen to myself back
- 0:50normal, I sound like I'm drunk. Or Bob and Burrow everyone sounds drunk
- 0:55because they're talking at normal speed. Anyway, So let's let's listen to me
- 1:00as I wrap up my discovery and reactions to this extremely fascinating story. Let's
- 1:10watch or listen. And I've been hiding it from you because I don't want
- 1:15it and up. So I asked her, how do you do it?
- 1:19Natania said? She said? She said, when she goes to the bathroom
- 1:23and there's any there. She wipes it up off her leg and she eats
- 1:27it and licks it so nobody will ever find out. My god. So,
- 1:38okay, if I was taking a guess, just a guess, given
- 1:42what we've heard that Christine was forcing Natalia to tell people that she was having
- 1:57her period and was hiding it from others because by this time, Christine really
- 2:05wanted to make sure that everyone thought of her as an adult, so Christine
- 2:07could be let off the hook, because so Christine could get rid of her,
- 2:10and she had not only coached her to tell Rando's, but you got
- 2:15to tell your dad, because that's all part of my plan. I got
- 2:19to convince everyone, including my husband, that she's an adult. And then
- 2:24she, you know, brainwashes the kid, you know, coerces the kid,
- 2:29forces the kid to say, yes, okay, I'll do that.
- 2:31I'll do that, and abuses the kid, says if if you don't do
- 2:34it, I'm gonna I'm gonna get you with the pepper spray or whatever.
- 2:37But either Christine doesn't tell her how to hide it, you know, if
- 2:43she's asked about it, or did tell her something. But Natalia forgot.
- 2:49This is just a guess, because you know, you have a hard time
- 2:51believing that Christine would say, Okay, if someone asks you, you got
- 2:53to admit that you had your period even though you haven't, and you have
- 2:58to if someone asked, like, how do you hide it? You have
- 3:00to tell people that you ate it. Maybe Christine might have said it,
- 3:07but you would imagine that Christine would have a better story that you would want
- 3:15to fabricate. So you can imagine a child who's six years old, seven
- 3:20years old at the time, thinking, I don't even know what we're talking
- 3:23about, but there's supposedly something I'm supposed to be hiding. So what's one
- 3:29way to hide something? I just I guess I'll just say I eat it.
- 3:35And then he hears that, so it's just another thing. Like if
- 3:38you hear that and you're the father, it seems like there would be some
- 3:46major follow up there. And then she made she forced me to put the
- 3:50tamp on it, and then I literally just told it I can't, like
- 3:55I can't do it, it hurts. Christine just kept telling me you need
- 4:00to put it in. She made me do it, but I couldn't,
- 4:03and she was mad. I remember that I remember Christine being mad because I
- 4:08couldn't do it. There's so many things to say. One just yeah,
- 4:16this fits in that category of abuse. You know, there's a lot of
- 4:21there's a lot of behavior. As a clinician, you hear when you hear
- 4:25about abuse to children, and there's this I keep referring to this category of
- 4:30abuse that is callous and I don't know any other word but psychopathic, where
- 4:36the parent exhibits just complete lack of empathy or regard for another human being.
- 4:46Most of the perpetrators that I have treated of child abuse, they're not psychopathic.
- 4:53They do have empathy. That might sound strange, but many parents who
- 5:00are abusive, they absolutely are capable of love and caring. They have major
- 5:05issues, and their empathy might be imparative times, but they're not any different
- 5:12than anyone else regarding empathy, and that that empathy is reflected in there in
- 5:18their abuse because the way that they don't abuse in an empathetic way, but
- 5:23there's a line that they don't cross. And there's a lot of lines,
- 5:28because if you haven't been around this material, there's a lot of lines that
- 5:32you know, you might think, oh my god, that person is so
- 5:34abusive. But if you told that story to me, I'd be like,
- 5:39there's worse than that. And we're hearing, you know, behavior, And
- 5:44if you heard the story, you might even think like, well, you
- 5:46know, is it really abusive? I think I think most people would,
- 5:47But it's not. It's not stereotypical abuse, right, the invasion of everything,
- 5:56not only just her body, but her mind. She has to now
- 6:00believe or tell others not only that she has mistreated, but that she's older,
- 6:06she's not who she is, right, and the damage, and then
- 6:13this feeling you get from someone that's supposed to have your back. I get
- 6:18the impression that the mom was by far the primary parent, and that Michael
- 6:24worked outside the home, worked a lot, It wasn't around nearly as much
- 6:29as the mom was. So it just sounds really, really awful. And
- 6:31then I think is perhaps because I've been wondering if we believe the neighbors regarding
- 6:38the behaviors, even at just a few of the behaviors that they talked about,
- 6:42regarding her trying to have sexual relations with other boys, younger boys,
- 6:48and her propositioning older men. If we believe some of that, then we
- 6:54have to wonder where did that come from? And I was suspecting in terms
- 7:00of the typical story is that she was sexually abused at some point even before
- 7:05she met the Barnetts. Now, she could have been sexually abused by the
- 7:10Barnetts as well, but since I wasn't hearing any data along those lines,
- 7:15it doesn't mean that it's not there. But I was just thinking it could
- 7:18happen. It could have even happened prior to her remembering, you know,
- 7:21when she's like two years old. Who knows. But I was just a
- 7:25huge question mark. There's a possibility that the behavior that was alleged to have
- 7:30happened when she was living in the apartment that the neighbors talked about. That
- 7:33the sexual abuse could literally be only these sorts of things. It doesn't even
- 7:39have to be overtly sexual, but it involves invasion of body, and then
- 7:43you can imagine her you know, there's just a lot of different possibilities thinking
- 7:46like, well, maybe I am old, and what do old people do,
- 7:49Well, they have sex with people. So I'm gonna, you know,
- 7:51like he's just gonna imagine there's a road there, and there's a lot
- 7:56of other roads. But I just I don't know sidt of a mission,
- 7:58but this is Yeah, just think about how callous. And we have to
- 8:03imagine that Christine knew that she was a child at this she's like six years
- 8:09old, seven years old. I mean, it's it is horrific at any
- 8:16age, but to little child. When I was able to take it out,
- 8:24there was blood on it because of the fact that like I'm seven years
- 8:28old, I'm not even supposed to be having now right now, and she
- 8:35would she says, see, you had your period and I couldn't say anything
- 8:39about Yeah, that is h Yeah, that's abuse on the highest order.
- 8:46If I were being victimized, I would rather be hit across the face than
- 8:52having something like that happened to me, for sure. Yeah, I wouldn't
- 8:56want to be hit across the face, but I'd rather be hit across the
- 8:58face than that is. There's so many layers to that. Again, your
- 9:05body, your you know, those parts of your body, your mind is
- 9:13being infiltrated. You're being shown that there is no limit to the invasion and
- 9:18the harm and the brainwashing and the lack of regard. Your whole body inside
- 9:26and out is you know, my playground. I will do what I want,
- 9:31and I don't care. You know that that is That is an awful,
- 9:35awful, awful thing. Have I ever watched anything even close to this
- 9:43on this channel? Now, I'll tell you this is my world. You
- 9:48know, all therapists, this is we hear stuff like this all day long.
- 9:52Potentially I've supervised clinicians who work at a local agency that that's just north
- 10:00of Seattle. It's called Dawson's Place. Kind of reminds you like Dawson.
- 10:03I don't think I think it's Dawson Place. It's Dawson's Creek. But the
- 10:09agency is a really helpful model of helping people in that they specialize in treating
- 10:18children who have been sexually abused, or maybe it's just abuse in general,
- 10:24and they work in the same building as you know, government agencies such as
- 10:31the police or d shs. Because when you have children that you know have
- 10:35been abused, especially if they're currently in the system, there's a trial date
- 10:41or whatever, or there's an ongoing investigation, then it is often helpful if
- 10:45the therapist works very closely with the Department of Health and Social Services and with
- 10:52police. Now, sometimes as therapists, we don't want to have those open
- 10:56lines of communication because we want to have confidentially for our clients. But if
- 11:03we want to truly advocate in a holistic way for victims, sometimes it does
- 11:09require. You know, sometimes the therapists we go to the police and we
- 11:13say, look, you're going too hard after the kid to extract information so
- 11:20that you can put the perpetrator behind bars. And you got to slow down
- 11:24with this kid because I saw this and that, you know, so sometimes
- 11:28it's you're really advocating for the kid, You're not just outing them, you
- 11:31know. Anyway, So I supervised. I've supervised a number of clinicians that
- 11:37worked there, and I didn't work there, but I would work with these
- 11:43therapists over many months years and I saw firsthand just the toll that it takes,
- 11:50you know, the amount of burnout. And they at least back when
- 11:54I was doing this kind of work, they had a lot, they had
- 11:56a good culture of self care at the sage see because of just how stressful
- 12:01it was. Because you know, the typical therapist they might have one or
- 12:05two of these every day, but not wall to wall, and it can
- 12:07be very overwhelming to the therapist. You know, vicarious trauma, secondary trauma
- 12:11and it starts to erode your hope in humanity. It starts to literally traumatize
- 12:20you because you're visualizing the stories that are being told to you. You're witnessing
- 12:24the trauma and it's heartbreaking. You know, it's a lot. But the
- 12:28average therapist will hear this frequently, you know, whether it's kids that are
- 12:33describing this or adults that are describing it that they went through when they were
- 12:35growing up. It's and it's our job sometimes to become extremely intimate with those
- 12:41stories, you know, to talk about them repeatedly and get to know them
- 12:46very well, and to ask for more information within exposure therapy. And so
- 12:52for me and people in my field, this story is you know, it's
- 12:56just it's it's rough, but it's part of our world unfortunately, that we're
- 13:03very aware of on a daily basis. But for the public and for this
- 13:07channel, I don't know if we've ever I can't remember a time where it's
- 13:11been this explicit and this horrific described by a victim, not just speculated or
- 13:20something or reading a report. It's you know, a victim is telling us
- 13:22a story that is so yeah, I can imagine this being absolutely triggering to
- 13:26people so I hope that everyone is monitoring their own traumas if they have them,
- 13:33and taking care of themselves because this stuff would be unbearable for some people.
- 13:37For sure. It's hard anyway, right. The only medical professionals who
- 13:41believe that Natalia was an adult was the family doctor McLaren and a social worker
- 13:48therapist Susan Witten, and they were the basis for the application to re age
- 13:56Natalia. Susan Witten is a license clinical social worker, not a doctor.
- 14:03Yeah. So, boy, if you listen to my audio podcast or you
- 14:07are one of my supervises, then you know that I have a big problem
- 14:15with mental health professionals such as myself, writing reports in areas that we don't
- 14:22have expertise in or not enough information. It's literally in our ethical codes that
- 14:28we shouldn't be doing things like this, and it just makes sense we're often
- 14:33asked to do these kinds of things, right, Like. A more common
- 14:37scenario is you are as a therapist treating a child and you have a relationship
- 14:45with the mother. The mother is the one that brings the kid in,
- 14:48and sometimes you meet with the mother as well, and the mother tells you
- 14:52that the father there's a custody battle, and the mother says, you know,
- 14:58the father was abusive, and you don't have any reason to be skeptical
- 15:03of that, and you just take the mother's word for it, and maybe
- 15:07there's well, let's just go typically there isn't. It's just it's just a
- 15:11lot of people saying things that might be true. It's not like you just
- 15:15discount it. But you weren't there. So you listen to the mother and
- 15:18she's saying that, and then maybe even the kid exhibits signs of having been
- 15:22abused. Maybe even the kid talks about having been abused. But in this
- 15:26scenario, let's say that the father was not actually abusive. Typically that's not
- 15:31the case, but let's just say in this scenario that it is. And
- 15:35over time you just believe the kid and the mom. The kid might be
- 15:41just saying it because either they're being coached severely that's not normal, or the
- 15:46memory has been implanted by the mom. You know, the mom might say
- 15:50something like remember that time, and the kids like huh. And then overtime,
- 15:54the kid just forms a memory around that. That happens even to adults.
- 15:58And then there is a hearing coming up regarding custody, and there's been
- 16:03more talk, and you're as a therapist. Of course, you're concerned about
- 16:07this kid, this child, and you don't want the child to be abused
- 16:11anymore. Of Course, you might call CPS and let's say there's a whole
- 16:15investigation, but there's not enough evidence, or maybe it's ongoing anyway. Then
- 16:18the mother comes to you and says, Okay, we're going to court next
- 16:22week, and I would really like it if you wrote a letter or a
- 16:27report or something to help me, because you know, we can't have this
- 16:33child live with the father. He's abusive, he's horrible. And if you've
- 16:37been believing everything which may or may not be true or not, you know
- 16:41what you're being told. But let's say you're believing everything and you don't understand
- 16:45ethical codes, and you don't understand professional roles, and you don't understand the
- 16:49standard of practice, which happens a lot, which is why it's explicitly written
- 16:53in some ethical codes. And you write this report and you say, positively
- 17:00the child has been abused by the father, and here is the evidence.
- 17:04But sometimes they don't even write the evidence, they just say, you know,
- 17:07take it from me. I know that she has been abused, that
- 17:11the child's been abused, and then the mother says thank you, and you
- 17:14feel good because you're participating in saving this child from the abuse. They go
- 17:18to court and then people start looking at this, at this assessment, and
- 17:23the lawyers just pick it apart because they're just like, so, when did
- 17:27the therapist ever ever witness abuse? Well? Never, Well, then why
- 17:33does the therapist think abuse happen? Well, it's because the mother and the
- 17:37child said so. Well, then why are we even reading this report?
- 17:41It's just a random third person. Now, maybe a therapist can say I
- 17:47have expertise in detecting signs of abuse, but you know, seeing signs of
- 17:52abuse is not an indication of abuse. Plus, you don't know where the
- 17:59abuse came from, even if it was abuse. You know, if actually
- 18:03we understand that a child has been abused, like they have a big bruise
- 18:07across their face, then we don't know unless we were there as a therapist.
- 18:11We can only know what people tell us. And so when we write
- 18:15these kinds of reports, which I recommend people don't do in general, but
- 18:19if you do, you can say, here is because sometimes we're compelled to
- 18:22write these reports. Legally, So we say, this person told me this
- 18:27on this date, and this person told me this on this date, and
- 18:30here are some signs of abuse that I have witnessed, but I can't know
- 18:34if abuse happened because I wasn't there. So there's that So related to this
- 18:38we have. It sounds like a therapist, a social worker saying that she
- 18:45knows that Natalia is an adult. How could a therapist evaluate that? That
- 18:52is not within our realm. No one can just look at someone and determine
- 19:00what and no one can assess someone's psychology even right, especially kids who have
- 19:07been abused and have been bounced around from home to home because they might have
- 19:11had to grow up faster than other kids. We all know that, so
- 19:15there's no way to term it. So if someone asked me, even if
- 19:18I strongly suspected that the child was in fact an adult, if they asked
- 19:22me to write a report, I'd say I can't write that report, one
- 19:26because I'm not impartial because the child is my client. And two, that's
- 19:32not a competency that a therapist has. You know, we don't have any
- 19:37competency in that area, So it'd be like asking a dentist about your plumbing,
- 19:42right, A dentist does not doesn't have any professional expertise in that unless
- 19:47they're also a plumber. You know, so you know that's what you're supposed
- 19:52to say, but so many therapists don't say that because they want to help.
- 19:56And that's great, you want to help and you care, but there's
- 20:00a you know, I hope that it's clear. And I am frequently telling
- 20:07people to keep this in mind because you know, some occasionally I'll have a
- 20:11supervisor that will be asked this. They'll go ahead and write it and set
- 20:15it off, and they don't tell me about it in time for me to
- 20:18say, don't do that, because it can really bite the therapist of the
- 20:22ass because there's potentially an ethical complaint. There, a competency complaint. The
- 20:27you know, in my made up scenario, the husband that you wrote or
- 20:30you know he's abusive, he can sue you because that's defamation or something along
- 20:36those lines. Because you have no basis to say that you weren't there.
- 20:41You just have people's accounts. To just claim that a crime has been committed
- 20:45that you didn't witness, in your professional opinion, is potentially suitable. Ms
- 20:52Witten wrote a couple of letters that alleged that Okay, we're finally seeing something
- 20:59here. Okay, and her adoptive parents, Michael and Christine, were seen
- 21:02in my office December twenty eleventh. The Barnets, I always like these opening
- 21:06statements. By the way, I'm also trying to get supervisors to include this
- 21:11because sometimes they just launch into the thing, figuring that the reader will know
- 21:15the context. The Barnets stated, whether there's apostrophe there. Barnett stated that
- 21:18Natalia is a threat to others. The Barnets stated, Okay, so that's
- 21:22good. So the Barnets stated, the parents stated it should be. The
- 21:26parents stated that Natalia is a threat to others and that she has harmed them
- 21:32to the point of poisoning Christine and creating a clear plan to kill the other
- 21:36members of the home. So it's all. That's all good. It's like
- 21:38the parents told me this, that's all I have. She has been given
- 21:42the diagnosis. So Natalia has been given the diagnosis of reactive attachment disorder,
- 21:48oppositional to fine disorder, and schizophrenia. Schizophrenia. Wow, wow, oposistional
- 21:55define disorder. Yeah, there's a good chance that the criteria were met because
- 22:02it's not a huge threshold across, particularly with kids that come from these kind
- 22:07of backgrounds, and it's not a hugely stigmatizing diagnosis. It can be,
- 22:14but I'm not put off by that reactive attachment disorder. Yeah, absolutely,
- 22:21I talked about that already. Sometimes though, clinicians will just throw that around
- 22:27for clients that clearly have some kind of attachment disruption and some sort of behaviors
- 22:33around that they don't actually fit the criteria of reactive attachment because it's very particular.
- 22:37Of all the kids who have attachment injuries, very few of them actually
- 22:41have reactive attachment story. And then Natalia has been in Saint Vincent's Stress Center
- 22:47three times and has received other treatment through community psychological consultants and Lenin and associates,
- 22:53as well as evaluations from Vala Vista. Okay, per the Barnetts.
- 23:00So again, Barnett's told me several mental health professionals have recommended that Natalia be
- 23:03admitted to a residential treatment center or state hospital. Her background information is and
- 23:07complete disappoint Okay, her background information is incomplete to the point of something.
- 23:15The birth certificate states that she is eight years old. However, she has
- 23:18full adult something of herself to be about to be at least eighteen. Okay,
- 23:25so that's better actually, because this is just saying, look, this
- 23:27is what I've been told. All right, well that is for that episode.
- 23:33Everyone please take care of yourself because you deserve it. You really,
- 23:36really really do. Hey deserve listeners. Natalia Grace documentary. Let's watch.
- 23:40They just dropped me off an apartment and then just left, like they didn't
- 23:45explain that I was getting an apartment or anything like that. I'm over here,
- 23:49eight years old, and I'm like, what do I do? Yeah,
- 23:53I mean, my god. It's interesting because the first season of the
- 24:00documentary certainly didn't paint that picture. Although I do remember thinking, but what
- 24:10if she is a child? And I remember one person saying that she would
- 24:15have been thirteen, not eight or nine. Thirteen would be too young anyway.
- 24:19But still very much looks like there's been a whole bunch more evidence that
- 24:26she was in fact the age that she says she was, which was eight
- 24:30or nine years old. And I again will say that it's a little boring
- 24:37because I felt like I had enough information for season one, but you know,
- 24:41they're just establishing it further, and I suppose those details really put into
- 24:49sharp focus how much manipulation the parents were doing, because it wasn't like they
- 25:00only had one opinion or one medical assessment. They had a number of medical
- 25:07professionals evaluating her, and only one of them, the family friend, identifying
- 25:12her as being twenty two. So that really demonstrates strong evidence that the parents
- 25:21knew or at least strongly suspected. Well, we can't really know. I
- 25:26mean, denial is a weird thing. People will be given all sorts of
- 25:32factual information. I mean, all you have to do is look at the
- 25:34political landscape, not only among politicians but among the voting population to see that
- 25:41you can have just mountains and mountains, mountains and mountains of data and facts
- 25:48from experts, and it only takes one Joe Rogan to just completely dismantle that.
- 25:53So, because when you have a need to believe something, then you'll
- 25:57find a way to believe it. And when you're in a situation like this,
- 26:03it's possible. It's not letting him off the hook, because any parent
- 26:07with half a heart would really make sure if there's any ambiguity, any parent
- 26:12would have a heart would say, well, we can't just put her on
- 26:15even if she were twenty two. She's you know, she has mobility issues,
- 26:21she's small, she doesn't know people. So it really just makes it
- 26:26look the way that she's been talking about it and other people are saying,
- 26:30it's just that they just completely threw her away. And you know, if
- 26:33you had told me this story, I would have said, like, yeah,
- 26:37that sounds like a tabloid writer that would put that together. But it
- 26:41really does look the way that the tabloids would say it that you have this
- 26:47child, this innocent child, who has issues and presents behavioral problems that is
- 26:52normal. I mean, it's not universal, of course, but it's not
- 26:56surprising. And then you have parents that just have no idea what they're doing
- 27:00and have a parenting style that is, at least Christine that is flat out
- 27:07abusive, which makes things worse. And then you have this desperate need from
- 27:12Christine to uphold her image and the parents, I mean, I guess the
- 27:18more fantastical story would be that they would have killed her and disposed of the
- 27:22body and made up a story that she was kidnapped or something or claim self
- 27:26defense. I suppose given the way they're painting Christine. It would have been
- 27:32just that she disappeared or she was abducted, you know, that would be
- 27:36the story that they would put forward, maybe to get more attention or something
- 27:40like that. So that would have been worse, I would say, I
- 27:42would imagine that she would agree with that. But this is close to it.
- 27:47I mean, they put her at risk, she could have died.
- 27:51The chances were pretty high that she absolutely would have been harmed, right,
- 27:55just imagine, So yeah, there's no excuse. And also the more data
- 28:02that comes out, it really does paint a picture that makes a compelling case
- 28:07that Michael absolutely knew what was going on and didn't do much if anything.
- 28:12You know, you just think even if he were abused and gas lit,
- 28:17you just think he would have done something right. So you got to figure
- 28:21that left to his own devices, he has issues as well. He is
- 28:26to blame criminally morally, So it's now. The other thing I'll say is
- 28:33that as a therapist who was referred cases like this the most difficult cases in
- 28:38the county around Seattle, I would observe sometimes that you know, when you're
- 28:45dealing with a lot of issues, a lot of pain, and a lot
- 28:48of trauma and a lot of behavioral problems, a lot of questions, accusations.
- 28:52You know, are the parents abusive? Is the kid a psychopath?
- 28:56As a professional, you don't, you're not there use when those things are
- 29:00happening. So you're hearing all of these accounts, and I'd be working alongside
- 29:03with government officials and police and everything, you know, judges and lawyers,
- 29:07and and what I noticed was that as the fusion and lack of differentiation and
- 29:15conflict and anger and rage increased, the professionals would be emotionally affected as well.
- 29:25And it was sometimes my job to be the one person among the professionals
- 29:30that took a deep breath and tried to remain as calm as I could,
- 29:36because I didn't always see you. In my field, we have a tradition
- 29:41of paying attention account or transference and emotional regulation. It's very important. We're
- 29:47trained and we have supervision around this sort of thing. So I don't expect
- 29:52that the other professionals necessarily have that. And so and some of these other
- 29:56professionals, it might literally be the you know, teachers, for example,
- 30:00it might literally be the only time they will ever interact with a family like
- 30:04that, whereas for me, it was, you know, throughout the week.
- 30:07So I'm saying that because it can be hard, and it makes it
- 30:12harder for the families because a different When our differentiation goes down, then we
- 30:18tend to become black and white thinkers, and we start to identify with one
- 30:22side of the other, and so it's harder to remain neutral, sort to
- 30:25speak, or open to information or recognizing the nuances. Right. The other
- 30:30thing I'll say is that when I would treat families like this, the the
- 30:36the sum was greater than what's the I'm terrible with idioms, but the you
- 30:41know, if you just looked at each individual's issues and added it up,
- 30:47it would equal you know, X, But when you put it all together,
- 30:52it equals ten times X because it all compounds on each other and makes
- 30:56it all worse, which really is unfortunate. And you just imagine that if
- 31:02she were with a different family, one of the families that we saw but
- 31:06we don't know, I mean, those other families who talk glowingly about her,
- 31:10We don't know how they would have fared if they did adopt her.
- 31:12You know, adoptive parents are usually very well meaning and very optimistic and very
- 31:18loving, and they tend to give kids the benefit of the doubt, of
- 31:22course, but you just don't know. But you just got a figure that
- 31:26any family would have been better than what we're hearing alleged about Christine and Michael.
- 31:33It's just so it's just a tragedy, right, it's just horrible.
- 31:36They didn't teach me how to do anything. Yeah, and even if they
- 31:41did believe that she was twenty two, they knew that they I mean,
- 31:47I guess maybe they could have said themselves, well, if we got her
- 31:51when she was eighteen and now she's twenty two, well even then, right,
- 31:55so you would know that she has no life skills. You haven't seen
- 32:01her exhibit life skills. You haven't taught her anything. At the very least,
- 32:07you would watch and observe and see. I mean, it's amazing that
- 32:09she survived as long as she did, honestly, at the age of eight
- 32:14or nine years old, it's crazy. I'm just like I'm lost, Like
- 32:21I feel like I don't know where I am at this place that I have
- 32:23never been to. Yeah, it's so weird seeing these clips in contrast to
- 32:30the first season. On the first season it felt different, but now through
- 32:35the eyes that I have now with the more data that they've given us.
- 32:40It is, I mean awful before and they just expect me to just live
- 32:51by myself. Even though they did what they did. I didn't know what
- 32:57else to do but want to be with my parents like I was just a
- 33:01regular kid. Yeah, it's interesting hearing her side of the story. And
- 33:07it's interesting how unless you hear it, you don't necessarily feel it. Now
- 33:15that I'm hearing it and feeling it. Yeah, this was her family.
- 33:20The Barnetts were the first family that had had her for as long as you
- 33:23know, longer than a couple of years or longer than a year, and
- 33:28regardless of the abuse, regardless of the chaos. Of course, she thought
- 33:34this is my family. She was four years old, five years old.
- 33:37Of course she saw them as her family. They didn't see her as their
- 33:43family, apparently, but she saw them as you're my parents, these are
- 33:49my brothers. Even if there were issues of behavior from her, But the
- 33:52way that they thought about her was that she was a con artist and a
- 33:55psychopath and therefore this alien creature that doesn't have empathy or attachment or anything,
- 34:01which isn't necessarily true. Even if she did have psychopathy. They did all
- 34:06of this just to change my age and get me out of their house.
- 34:13A lot of people did not like me in that apartment complex. I didn't
- 34:17understand why though. I didn't know that people seeing me going in their houses
- 34:24getting food and everything like that. And if we use this as a jumping
- 34:29off point, you know, we've heard about other stories in this category.
- 34:31The K C. Anthony, Kaylee Anthony, the child that died, and
- 34:37the allegations or the speculation that the child was killed by her mother, maybe
- 34:46also the grandfather if I'm remembering the details right. And the motivation this speculation
- 34:53is that the mother saw the child as an inconvenient to her life. She
- 35:00was a young woman and liked to do young people things and considered the child
- 35:07to be in the way, so, you know, and that's just the
- 35:10famous story we've We of course know that this happens unfortunately a lot, right,
- 35:16babies being left literally in the garbage, that sort of thing, and
- 35:22it happens. It's rare, it's extremely rare, but it does happen.
- 35:25But those are just the more extreme stories. There are arguably hundreds times,
- 35:32you know, a hundred times more stories, maybe a thousand ten thousand times
- 35:37more stories in which the parent isn't homicidal or wouldn't just try to get rid
- 35:44of the child entirely into an apartment, but the parents just ignore the children
- 35:49or beat the children whenever the child is any sort of inconvenience. And these
- 35:53stories don't make it into the news because the child is at best there's someone
- 36:00that's alerted at CPS, and then CPS gets involved, and then they might
- 36:05contract with a therapist. I used to do this kind of work back in
- 36:07the day, and I would go into the home and try to figure out
- 36:10what's going on. I would run into hostile, abusive parents and they would
- 36:15consider me like an arm of the law, which I wasn't, or a
- 36:20government employee, which I wasn't. But you know, I was contracted by
- 36:24the government, and I did write a report to the government. But I
- 36:30didn't want to create an environment in which the perpetrator thought that I was going
- 36:35to tattle on them. I wanted to help. I wasn't there to punish,
- 36:37and I can help perpetrators of child abuse. They have to be willing
- 36:42to go along with the program, but they're not doomed to do that.
- 36:45For the rest of their life. Absolutely not, and so some people it
- 36:49was hard, but you know, there were some people that would take me
- 36:51up on it. But I think that's really the depressing part about this is
- 36:54that these kinds of documentaries will focus on the more extreme, more more story
- 37:00worthy incidents, but this is happening all the time around the world. Parents,
- 37:06for whatever reason, their personality problems, their stress, their substance abuse
- 37:13leads to them treating their children as a total inconvenience to their life. And
- 37:20as long as the child is alive and is you know, there's no marks
- 37:25where visibly you can see them, and when they go to the doctor they
- 37:30seem nourished enough, then they just sneak under the radar. You know.
- 37:36In some ways, these kind of parents are much more hidden because they might
- 37:43not even hit the child. They just push the child away, get away
- 37:45from me, ignore the child, don't come home. Parents might not even
- 37:50come home or something. You know. We heard a similar story with Jodyarius
- 37:53her victim. I can't remember his name, but the guy that died,
- 37:59he grew up in family that was like that. His parents just completely abandoned,
- 38:04well not completely, but very much neglected him and his siblings. And
- 38:07he was left in the home to take care of himself and his younger siblings,
- 38:10if I'm remember right, And yeah, situations like that happen all the
- 38:15time. It's terrible. And the solution isn't to watch a documentary and you,
- 38:23Christine, I don't like you. The solution is systems, is tax
- 38:30allocation, is awareness, is giving more funds so that the government can hire
- 38:37more people to work for CPS, for dshs, and those people can actually
- 38:44do proactive work. You know, if as a government employee, all you
- 38:49have time for is reacting to allegations, right, and you have a stack
- 38:52of files and you can only address the five most severe ones in a particular
- 38:59month, even reacting, you can't react, you know. That's what that's
- 39:02the state of affairs for a lot of these folks, because when politicians gut
- 39:08the tax base and allocation of these funds, which completely isn't talked about in
- 39:15the media at all. What gets talked about situations like this. But if
- 39:17we want to solve the problem, then if one you give more money so
- 39:22that you can have more workers so that they can actually get to that entire
- 39:27stack. Then you give more money so that you can have even more workers,
- 39:30you can actually start doing outreach. They can go to the schools and
- 39:35say, hey, is there any are there any kids that have any red
- 39:37flags? Maybe we could just kind of look into it or something that kind
- 39:42of thing, because I'm guessing that she would have had red flags. Someone
- 39:45would have said something the neighbors. That kind of thing, or awareness campaigns
- 39:50of you know, just going to a neighborhood and passing out flyers. Hey
- 39:52have you ever heard of thing? You know, I'm your local CPS worker.
- 39:57I just want to say I'm here to help. I'm not the book,
- 40:00So here's a number, you know, that kind of thing. But
- 40:02there's no way that the government can do that right now because there's like I
- 40:07said, the workers are overloaded as it is. And the other thing is
- 40:13is that when you don't pay them very much, then they don't want to
- 40:15stay at that job very long. And also when you don't pay them very
- 40:19much, they can be burnt out and some of them will become problematic themselves.
- 40:25So that's what we could do to reduce And we have data around this
- 40:32sort of thing. We've done studies, you know, community psychology studies,
- 40:37public health studies. It's all there, and there's a whole there's a lot
- 40:42of other things that could be done as well, like if Christine's parents had
- 40:47greater access to resources and parenting help and therapy. I'm just going to take
- 40:53a guess and say that Christine's parents would have benefited from therapy and parenting support
- 40:59so that Christine wouldn't end up the way that she is, so that this
- 41:01situation never would have happened. It's all solved by these things. Is there's
- 41:06no we don't have as a government. We don't have to fund Amazon,
- 41:10even though there's a lot of tax incentives, right, But capitalism will work
- 41:16to create businesses that will succeed in those industries, because that's how capitalism works.
- 41:23But when it comes to this sort of thing that I'm talking about,
- 41:27there's no profit in doing this because you can't charge the families because at least
- 41:32you couldn't charge them enough, and if you did charge, they wouldn't do
- 41:36it because they can't afford it. So there's no capitalistic gain from it.
- 41:40So you have to have government do it. But you have to have the
- 41:44voting populace actually demand because that's all the politicians want is to stay in office,
- 41:52and if they believe that they're going to be out voted from office because
- 41:57they don't do that one thing or another, then and that's when they get
- 42:00motivated, you know, or a glass half full way of looking at it
- 42:05is they might want to do it, but they don't want to get ousted
- 42:08out of their position, so they hesitate to do things that they want to
- 42:14do to help the people. You know, weed understand these things. There's
- 42:20a lot of thinkers and public policy people that know this stuff, and the
- 42:25workers certainly know these things. And I've been there, so I want to
- 42:32point all this out because I worry that people would watch a documentary like this
- 42:37and say, oh, well, you know, at the very least,
- 42:39Christine and Michael got there just dessert by being outed and being shamed and canceled,
- 42:46and then the people just go on with their lives. But I don't
- 42:52think we should be just going on with our lives. You know, that's
- 42:54not something that normal TONI to or to do, or like they're not supposed
- 42:59to any was you know, but that was the thing. I wasn't twenty
- 43:05two. I was eight years old, right. So she's talking about how
- 43:08she would sneak into other or just walk into her neighbor's places. And the
- 43:15way it was framed in the first season of the documentary, it's that she's
- 43:19this con artist, psychopath, dangerous person, but hearing her side of the
- 43:23story, and she could be lying or spinning things. But at the very
- 43:28least, even if she were a con artist or a psychopath, she's still
- 43:31eight years old. And when you have the attachment history of that, you
- 43:36know that she has and you know I talked about indiscriminate attaching, you know
- 43:40that kind of behavior that children will have, then that's what they do.
- 43:45They don't think of this is my home. These are my people, and
- 43:50those are the neighbors, those are strangers or acquaintances or friends. This is
- 43:52my place, this is my home base, and that's that's other people's homebase.
- 43:58For people that have never had that at home base, they can develop
- 44:00this indiscriminate attaching and you know, to the point where you know, the
- 44:06quintessential example is that you'll be walking through the mall. Say you adopt a
- 44:10kid and they have this indiscriminate attachment and they're four years old, and you're
- 44:15walking through the mall and you're not holding the child's hand the whole time,
- 44:20and you turn around and the child's gone, and the child is you know,
- 44:23you're running around and you find this child just following another person out of
- 44:28the mall, and the other person's like, I don't know why this kid's
- 44:30following me or the other or the kid just walks up to another mom looking
- 44:36sort of person and just hugs and say take me home with you. And
- 44:38you're thinking, what's going on even though you've had the kid for a year.
- 44:43So that's what we see, and then that manifests differently throughout the lifespan,
- 44:50but it's a known thing and she absolutely could have been highly motivated along
- 44:57those lines, just like well will you be my mommy? Or another way
- 45:01to put it is, well you're my mommy because you're an adult and neurologically,
- 45:07I don't understand the concept of an identified mommy. You know, I've
- 45:13been taken care of kind of by a lot of mommies, So everyone's my
- 45:17mommy. That's what the world has shown me, whether it's my biological mom
- 45:22or the Second Family or the Third Family, or the orphanage or the New
- 45:27Hampshire family or those two other families that tried to adopt her or Christine or
- 45:34all y'all everyone, right, Isn't that how it works? So there's that.
- 45:39It's also possible that she, in addition, was, you know,
- 45:45lacking empathy for other people. But you know, when if you're eight years
- 45:47old, the empathy that an eight year old has is is different. We
- 45:52want eight year olds to be different regarding empathy. We don't want them to
- 45:57feel the weight of the pain and the act of everyone around them. We
- 46:00want them to be self centered so that they can take care of themselves.
- 46:04That's why we take care of them. They don't take care of us.
- 46:07So it's weird how the first season was just so manipulative, right, and
- 46:14then I wonder, well as the second season as manipulative as the first.
- 46:17Maybe I'm you know, I don't know. I didn't know that I couldn't
- 46:22just go in people's houses. I didn't know there were boundaries. That's all
- 46:29put on. That's not the way she was at all. She knew what
- 46:32she was doing, and she was twenty two. They proved that she was
- 46:37twenty two, and she wasn't. Well, God bless the woman here.
- 46:40I mean, they probably manipulated her by not showing her all the other data,
- 46:45I'm guessing she would have changed her mind. You know, all this
- 46:51person knows is what she knew. It's also possible that there was something evil
- 46:57seeming about the behavior, so you know, I don't necessarily fault the innocent
- 47:04lay people who are living next to her. You know. The other possibility
- 47:07is that there could be some amount of stigma or prejudiced against the little people
- 47:15or adopted people. You know, there there is stigma, and you know
- 47:20it's like if a black person had moved into the apartment building, we could
- 47:23imagine people being more suspicious, right, so there could have been some of
- 47:28that. That just confirmation bias kicks in and you just start convincing yourself and
- 47:34looking for cherry picking the information, and the neighbors just kind of ran away
- 47:37with that, you know, it is bought and even reworking their memories,
- 47:43like some of the key memories that we heard about her, you know,
- 47:46trying to sexually abuse two boys. Apartment reported inappropriate things she did and they
- 47:53had to get so much on her before they could, you know, like
- 47:58a factor from there, like when she was inappropriate with a little boy.
- 48:06That whole story is misunderesting Okay, so we're about to hear Natalia's side of
- 48:12this story here. Now, even if she did do what was alleged,
- 48:15it doesn't completely throw everything out the window regarding to Talia's account, Right,
- 48:21she could have done what she did and yet also wasn't going into people's apartments
- 48:27because she's this psychopathic evil person and we both can be true. She could
- 48:31have been attachment confused and walked into hall or just desperate, right because she
- 48:37needed attention or food or safety or something. So there was because you know,
- 48:43we heard that that one neighbor was saying that God that throws everything in
- 48:46a different light. You know that one neighbor was saying that they went out
- 48:51of town or they were out for the day, right, a kid was
- 48:52playing soccer and the dad was saying yeah, and Natalie just kept texting and
- 48:58calling, and it's like I just had to say hey, you know,
- 49:00and then we get home and Natalia just comes running across the parking lot to
- 49:07our to our place, and we're just trying to decompress. Like knowing that
- 49:14she was eight years old, that is heartbreaking, right, But in the
- 49:20first season, at least, I feel like at the time they had manipulated
- 49:25me anyway to at least suspect that she was an adult at the time.
- 49:30And yeah, so I don't know, it just it just changes everything.
- 49:36So so in terms of all, you know, the way that the documentary
- 49:38put it forward, it was like this this ball of wax, and the
- 49:45things in the ball of wax that demonstrate her that she's evil is that she
- 49:47would break into places, she didn't respect boundaries, She was sexually abusive to
- 49:52children, and she was hyper sexual and you know, or at least was
- 49:59inappropriate at least sexually you know, propositioning to older men. But a fair
- 50:06amount of these stories were you know, hearsay, being that this this woman
- 50:12was telling a story about how she knew of a guy who told her a
- 50:15story about her about Natalia hitting on him inappropriately in the laundry room, and
- 50:21even also could that have happened. Yeah, but if an eight year old
- 50:24is doing that, we don't go ooh evil, We say, oh my
- 50:27god, let's get her help. That we don't consider eight year olds to
- 50:31be voluntarily hyper sexual. Right. They eight year olds don't go I'm going
- 50:37to be It's like something happened to them, right, they're acting out trauma
- 50:42issues, so or she was thinking, well, maybe I am twenty two,
- 50:45and I guess you have to have a you know, you can imagine
- 50:49a child just months of time where she's alone. It wasn't just a day
- 50:53or just imagine some of you probably have eight year olds. Just imagine if
- 50:58you just left your eight year old in an apartment, Like what kind of
- 51:01roads the child would go down to survive or move forward in life or something?
- 51:07You know. So, so all that is completely different now that we
- 51:15know what we know. Yeah, tickling each other and playing around, Now
- 51:22tell you I was doing more than tickling the little boy. She was getting
- 51:27too familiar in private areas. They said I tried to like sexually touch him,
- 51:36and that was not the case at all. I just started getting killed
- 51:38at I didn't know why. Okay. Is it possible that she's correct and
- 51:46that she was just having an innocent, age appropriate interaction meaning two eight year
- 51:53olds or something, and the neighbors having been primed with a lot of in
- 51:59flo that she's this evil twenty two year old, Might they have seen something
- 52:05that actually didn't happen. Yes, that could have happened. It's also possible
- 52:08that she actually did do these things and she remembers, and it doesn't help
- 52:15to admit that given what case she's trying to make, or she did do
- 52:20those things and she didn't see it that way. She was young, and
- 52:25so you know, she might have completely coded the memory in her mind of
- 52:30Wow, we were just playing tickle fight, but an observer, you know,
- 52:36would actually see, Oh no, no, you're you're going for the
- 52:38genitals. You're trying to get in that person's pants. That's not a tickle
- 52:44fight. So there's a lot of possibilities here, but it don't I don't
- 52:50know if it really changes much for me, because even if she did do
- 52:52those things, like I said, you don't go evil, you say that
- 52:57child needs help. And that's why I ran. I didn't. I was
- 53:01scared. I didn't know why everybody was yelling at me, and I'm Bird
- 53:06always talked about this on the podcast before. If you listen to the audio
- 53:10podcast, he's talked about this a number of times, so I'm not saying
- 53:15something out of turn. But he tells a story about how he was sexually
- 53:20abused when he was five years old by a thirteen year old female babysitter,
- 53:28you know, repeatedly and he bonded with the you know, he was he
- 53:36liked the babysitter. He also will say that it was very icky for him,
- 53:42but he actually, you know, the way the babysitter was with him,
- 53:45it convinced him that he was special. You know, this is a
- 53:49common thing for victims. And so it coded the experience with bonding or with
- 53:57friends, friends being friends, that kind of stuff. And so later,
- 54:01maybe a year later or so, there's this girl his age. He's in
- 54:06a car and he likes her in a child way, and he just reached
- 54:12his hand down her pants, I think the back of her pants. They
- 54:15were sitting in the car, and she reacted, what are you doing?
- 54:19And he pulled his hand out, and he thought, and he remembers this,
- 54:22He remembers thinking, why are you what's happening? You know, he
- 54:25didn't think, ahha, I'm going to get you the way that I was
- 54:29got. He just thought, this is what you do. You know,
- 54:31we're mimicking creatures, perhaps one of the most mimicking of all organisms that's ever
- 54:39mimicked before. We do what we see, and that can be a good
- 54:45thing or a bad thing. And so and this instance is a bad thing.
- 54:47So, and it feels that way to him, right, that urge,
- 54:52it's like I like her, therefore this is what we do. Neurologically,
- 54:58that's where it goes, right, And you could have been something like
- 55:02that for her, that she went through something like that. I think some
- 55:07people would say that was Michael. Some people would say that was someone else.
- 55:12She could have been harmed, even in the apartment a week earlier,
- 55:15because no one was there to protect her. So if I was take a
- 55:21guest, though, I would say that something happened before she was adopted,
- 55:23because it would be rare for an adopt It happens, of course, but
- 55:29it would be rare for an adoptive parent to especially the way that they were
- 55:31talking about that first family in New Hampshire. But who knows what would have
- 55:37happened to her in the orphanage. I don't want to implicate anybody in Ukraine,
- 55:42but that's a big blank spot in our data. We don't know anything
- 55:46really about what happened there. But it really could have happened at any point,
- 55:50or she just saw something on the internet, because that's the other thing.
- 55:57If she's living on her own, presumably she has acts us to the
- 56:00internet. Right, So god knows what she was looking at or who was
- 56:05trying to interact with her online, you know, so it's just sky's limit.
- 56:09And then you know, she just acted on that and it felt to
- 56:13her. So if you would have asked Umbardo when he was six after that
- 56:17incident, what did you just do, and asked him to tell us,
- 56:21because you know, people watching that would say that he sexually abused her,
- 56:24he attacked her, But if he were to describe what he did, he'd
- 56:28be like, we were just having a tickle fight, because maybe that's was
- 56:31even how it was framed to him, right, And the child could remember
- 56:37the incident along those lines. They grow up and they tell a story.
- 56:43It could be true that she's like, that's not what happened, even though
- 56:46it might have actually happened, is my point. But we don't know,
- 56:50and I would have to hear from the other people involved, the boy himself,
- 56:55the father of the boy, who have not been you know, they
- 57:00didn't agree to being the documentary. So we don't know because we heard from
- 57:02another neighbor, not this woman that we're hearing from, that wasn't she won
- 57:07her face and so we just saw, you know, down and she seemed
- 57:14to have a credible account of what had happened. She's like, I saw
- 57:19her do this thing, and I was like, what is happening? And
- 57:21you know, and then the father ran out. You know, it didn't
- 57:22sound ambiguous the way she described it, But it doesn't really matter because she
- 57:28say and even if she did that, you do not blame an eight year
- 57:31old for doing something like that. You'll say that's her fault, No one
- 57:37does. That is something happened to her, It someone else's fault. Let's
- 57:39help her. She's been victimized by something and she's expressing that victimization. The
- 57:46other kid, if victimized as well, is also harmed just being a kid.
- 57:54This is something only incident. There was one gentleman that was in the
- 58:00launder room and he told me that she was a very strange person. And
- 58:05then right, so they're recreating it. And that's another manipulative part of this
- 58:10documentary is they will do these recreations based on hearsay, based on people's stories,
- 58:19which is influence, you know, which would influence the audience. Right,
- 58:22And so I tried when I was watching the first seasons to not adhere
- 58:28to these visuals, right, But maybe it's somehow got under my skin.
- 58:32But so this woman is telling a story that another guy said. So it's
- 58:37you once removed, and who knows what really happened? Again, could it
- 58:42have happened, Yeah, it could have happened. But it doesn't mean she's
- 58:45evil. There was other older gentlemen that lived out there in their apartments by
- 58:50their self, and they would let now tell you come in, and she'd
- 58:53stay for hours and hours. Again, why what she stay for hours and
- 59:00hours? The implication is that she's some sort of sex crazed, abusive rapist
- 59:07or something. But through the lens that we're looking now, she's a child
- 59:10looking for someone to at least be like a parent figure for her. There
- 59:16was a day where I was in the apartment in Westfield. I was just
- 59:23walking around. I was bored. I didn't know stranger danger, not to
- 59:28knock on people's doors, and I was knocking on people's doors. I was
- 59:31just like going around, like seeing if anybody would talk to me. Right,
- 59:35it's interesting that she would say that I didn't know stranger danger. My
- 59:38guess is that the attachment injury is heavily involved in that. There was a
- 59:45guy, he was older, he's a kind of a weird guy. So
- 59:50let me get a little specific about this. And it's hard to exactly know
- 59:54the exact cause because we don't have the technology to measure individual neurons and how
- 1:00:00they all work together. But the idea goes is that if you've had a
- 1:00:05kid, you've seen this where prior to about six months five six months,
- 1:00:10the infant is mainly focused on their own discomfort and satiation. They want food,
- 1:00:20they want maybe some facial interactions. They are uncomfortable, they're too hot,
- 1:00:25they're too cold, they're tired, they want to entertain themselves. They
- 1:00:30haven't really zeroed in on an individual yet about six months, you know,
- 1:00:37around that time, infants universally, unless there's something neurological going on, you
- 1:00:43know, a difference, the child will start to note, oh, you're
- 1:00:47the person who keeps coming here, and there are other people that aren't you,
- 1:00:54And so it could be the primary parent, and then there's the secondary
- 1:00:59parent, and then there's everybody else. Even the secondary parent might not actually
- 1:01:04be preferred, right, It's like I want the primary parent, and that
- 1:01:07can be very hurtful to the secondary parent. You know, they can often
- 1:01:09feel like I love you too. I'm just not with you all the time
- 1:01:15because I'm at work or whatever. And it can be very hurtful because you
- 1:01:19know, the secondary parent might be just as loving and just as fun and
- 1:01:23just as open and warm or even warmer sometimes and it hurts. But if
- 1:01:30you understand it, you're like, ah, they'll come around. There's the
- 1:01:32edible phase of blah blahlah, and so the primary parent will be identified and
- 1:01:40the child will really really prefer that person, right, be very attached.
- 1:01:46Won't let you go to the bathroom, for example, necessarily, and you
- 1:01:52comfort just your face comforts them, your body, your voice. They want
- 1:01:58to see you as they while asleep, and they want to see you as
- 1:02:00they wake up. And aside from some other people that they can tolerate,
- 1:02:06everyone else is stranger danger. Right. We seem to have evolved that mechanism,
- 1:02:12which makes sense that that would serve us in our evolutionary past. So
- 1:02:15if you don't have a primary figure that is there during that shall we say
- 1:02:21an in printing phase, you have a rotating group of people, then the
- 1:02:27child is never given a chance to lock in on someone, and so they
- 1:02:30don't develop this neurological connection between you're my person, and then there's other people,
- 1:02:38and so they are still in that phase when they were five months old
- 1:02:43where anyone can be my parent and no one is my parent. It's sort
- 1:02:47of both. And this is why it is critical that we do what we
- 1:02:52can as a society to support parents when they have young children, that we
- 1:02:59do what we can to help them to have the resources and the availability of
- 1:03:05time and the availability of their energy to actually be there for their infants around
- 1:03:12that time and beyond. But you know, because if that is screwed up
- 1:03:17among other kinds of developments that happened neurologically, it's really hard to redo that.
- 1:03:24You know, you can kind of approximate it. But I would work
- 1:03:29with people who were you know, they missed that critical phase and they were
- 1:03:34given a lot of secure attachment and safety and love by adoptive parents later on,
- 1:03:40and the child never really attached to other people the way that they would
- 1:03:45have if they did have at least somebody. You know, if they have
- 1:03:49at least someone and then they're adopted, that will be different than if they
- 1:03:52have no one than they're adopted. So to really pay attention because when to
- 1:03:58these parents, because there's a lot of problems. Obviously, the individual can
- 1:04:02suffer greatly because of emotional issues and sadness and depression and demoralization, attachment security,
- 1:04:10relationship difficulty, but they also cause ripples away from them that cause a
- 1:04:15lot of issues because they can also become very harmful. So there's not all
- 1:04:18the time, of course, but they can also have their own children that
- 1:04:23they don't attach to because it's hard for them to attach. Not always,
- 1:04:27but it can be more difficult. So we can do a lot for all
- 1:04:30of us selfishly, if that's what we're looking for, by allocating funds and
- 1:04:36tax dollars to helping these young parents if they are If the parents are suffering
- 1:04:43from poverty, they're more likely to be single parents. If they're suffering poverty,
- 1:04:46they're more likely to be working a lot, you know, a lot
- 1:04:49of minimum wage jobs. The jobs are often across town. They don't have
- 1:04:54a car, they have to take a bus. It takes time away from
- 1:04:58the children. They're more likely to suf drug addiction because when your life is
- 1:05:01falling apart, traumatized her in your past, you look for some way to
- 1:05:04soothe yourself or forget and numb the feelings. So when we have safety nets
- 1:05:11at the very least, let alone actual people that can go to the home
- 1:05:15and say, hey, how about we do this or let me help you
- 1:05:17with that. We know because we've done these studies, we'll do a program
- 1:05:24like this in a community that twenty years later, all of those children will
- 1:05:30have far better outcomes than if they didn't do that. And it doesn't cost
- 1:05:33that much money, is the thing, and it's the right fucking thing to
- 1:05:36do. In fighting me in and he wasn't dressed. Okay, So she's
- 1:05:53talking about how some guy invited her in and he wasn't dressed. The way
- 1:05:57she tells a story, it sounds credible, and yeah, of course,
- 1:06:01because on average in any community you're going to have some predators. Unfortunately,
- 1:06:08and she is a walking open invitation for victimization. I hope that things don't
- 1:06:15go badly for her here. I asked him what he was watching, and
- 1:06:18it was a video. It was a very sexual video, but I didn't
- 1:06:25know what it was exactly. He played it and he's like, you can
- 1:06:27watch it, and I just remember, like, can we watch something else?
- 1:06:31And he's like, just watch it. It's okay. I'll send on
- 1:06:34a couch and he moved to the other end of the couch. So when
- 1:06:38people use the word grooming willy nilly, it upsets me sometimes because this is
- 1:06:44grooming that you don't know what you want to know grooming actually is. This
- 1:06:48is grooming, and specifically, it's using a tactic that sexual abusers will learn
- 1:06:56to use, which is to desensitize their victim slowly to the abuse. They
- 1:07:02want to go straight to abusing the child, but they suspect if they go
- 1:07:06straight from A to Z, the child will raise an alarm, run away
- 1:07:12or something, Whereas if you build up to it, then they believe they're
- 1:07:16more likely to get to Z. So they have to start with ab CD
- 1:07:21and B. For this guy is to put in pornography and just say,
- 1:07:29hey, you know, we're just watching a movie. You know, in
- 1:07:30that moment, the victim, the discomfort is only a little bit of discomfort,
- 1:07:34but then you habituate to that, it becomes normalized, and then you
- 1:07:38can take another step. And you know, there's a lot of examples of
- 1:07:41this, even outside of sexual abuse grooming, but that appears to be what's
- 1:07:45happening here, and this is we can blame the perpetrator here, but we
- 1:07:50can also blame the parents. I've seen enough that it is just very uncomfortable,
- 1:07:57Like I'm just like very weird to like I'm very uncomfortable now, like
- 1:08:00I'm not even comfortable with my own seat. Like it's just that man,
- 1:08:09he was a dirty old man. Yeah, okay, so we have confirmation.
- 1:08:15So sounds absolutely credible. The story sounded credible. And then the neighbor
- 1:08:21as saying, yeah, dirty old man. Now this could be a generation
- 1:08:25thing as well. It doesn't let people off the hook, but when it
- 1:08:29comes to the past, that's the way people would frame it. In fact,
- 1:08:33hearing somewhat of her age talking in that way, I'm reminded of that.
- 1:08:40They're like, ah, you know, this is a dirty old man.
- 1:08:43It's just a way to avoid and it's not because she's evil or complicit
- 1:08:48with it. It's just that that's what was in the air, right,
- 1:08:51like men will be men. You know, he's a little dirty, he's
- 1:08:55a little a little perverted. But you know, if you just ignored,
- 1:08:58everything's fine, instead of recognizing, no, this is a perpetrator living amongst
- 1:09:01us and we have to do something about it, which wasn't the way that
- 1:09:04people talked generally back then it was all swept under the rug because some other
- 1:09:10lady was going to get her mail and walk by and he was standing there
- 1:09:14in the nude, and she reported him to the office. But Italia never
- 1:09:19complained about any of them. The neighbor reported to the office. Who knows
- 1:09:25if the office did anything, but she'd call the police, right, And
- 1:09:29I'm guessing the victim didn't know to do that, or didn't know it'd be
- 1:09:32okay to do that or whatever. But yeah, that's absolute at the very
- 1:09:38least, it's worthy of an investigation, right. And this is how perpetrators
- 1:09:44continue to perpetrate, is that everyone's uncomfortable and our sex negativity culture just causes
- 1:09:49everyone to shut down and be like, I just don't want to talk about
- 1:09:53it. And I always give the analogy of if the woman going to the
- 1:09:58mailbox had been stabbed by him, she would immediately call the police and she
- 1:10:02would have no problem just saying, hey, by the way, that guy
- 1:10:05stabbed me. But somehow, when it comes to sexual assault, everyone's hush
- 1:10:10hush about it because we have a sex negative society that shames victims, that
- 1:10:14shames everybody. What were you wearing? What were you doing. You know,
- 1:10:18everyone's just giggly about, Oh he's naked. It's funny, you know,
- 1:10:21and you wouldn't do that if someone stabbed you. It's the same thing.
- 1:10:26It's harm. It's someone who is out to harm. Now, who
- 1:10:29knows. Maybe he was having some kind of cognitive event and he didn't know
- 1:10:31that he was, but you know, hearing what we're hearing, it's likely
- 1:10:33that he purposely was naked to expose himself to someone else because he wants to
- 1:10:42have other people uncomfortable. That's the sadistic nature of sexual Sadism is that they
- 1:10:47get pleasure, sexual pleasure and just general pleasure when other people are made to
- 1:10:54feel uncomfortable by sexuality, and they don't really care in what way that happens,
- 1:11:00and it will you know, rape, of course is one version of
- 1:11:04that, But another version that people rapists might engage in is by doing something
- 1:11:12like this because it is less likely to get the cops called. You might
- 1:11:16have excuses, it's maybe a little easier to get away with it. So
- 1:11:20it all just needs to be seen in that category. The other lady was
- 1:11:25going to get her mail and walk by, and he was standing there in
- 1:11:30the nude and she reported him to the office. But Natalia never complained about
- 1:11:35any of these things. When she was living after the apartment, she was
- 1:11:40always talking about being the guys and sex and Okay, so this notion that,
- 1:11:48well, I don't think it happened because she never complained about it.
- 1:11:51What. Yeah, this woman really does have a black and white perspective.
- 1:11:57There's no nuance. So so is it possible. So she's claiming and I
- 1:12:03think others did too, that she often would talk about Natalia would talk about
- 1:12:08being with guys. I think some people are saying that she was bragging about
- 1:12:12being a sex worker or a cross down or something. Is it possible that
- 1:12:16she Yeah, it's possible. But again, an eight year old that is
- 1:12:21doing something like that, You don't say she's evil or she I don't know,
- 1:12:27she needs to be disciplined. You think what went wrong here? So
- 1:12:31you know, yeah, who knows what Natalia was thinking or resorting to to
- 1:12:39survive or to bond, you know, because you could see her making it.
- 1:12:45You just think about the timeline she is. You know, by the
- 1:12:49time she starts to think for herself, she's either with her third adoptive family
- 1:12:56in Ukraine or she's in the orphanage and she's starting to piece things together and
- 1:13:02learn things. God knows what she learned. Then she is shipped all the
- 1:13:08way across the world, and you know, there's a bunch of handlers probably,
- 1:13:11and she's like, what's how does the world work. Then she moves
- 1:13:15into the student Hampshire family and who knows what happened there. I suspect that
- 1:13:19there were some behavioral problems from Natalia, not her fault, and somewhat typical
- 1:13:26of at the very least the initial phase of adopting a kid like this with
- 1:13:30that kind of history, So that's not super weird. And so and she's
- 1:13:35like, you're my family. This is great, and she bonds right,
- 1:13:39you know, because time goes by much slower for you know, to us
- 1:13:43adults. It's like, ah, what's two years to a kid or what's
- 1:13:45one year for children? That's a lifetime to a child that that's forever.
- 1:13:49It's like, oh my god. And then you're shipped off and then you're
- 1:13:53with Christine and Michael. God knows what lessons you learned there. And then
- 1:13:56all sudden boom, you're eight and you're in an apartment and you're being told
- 1:13:59you're adult and you know that there's this thing called sex, and you're trying
- 1:14:04to get people to pay attention. You know. It just God knows what
- 1:14:08sort of decisions or ideas that she was having about like how I think maybe
- 1:14:14there was another neighbor that was a sex worker that talked that way, or
- 1:14:17I don't know, you know, you just you don't look at an eight
- 1:14:20year old and say that they made this plan to do this. It's it's
- 1:14:26all confusion and discombobulation based on things that they've absorbed. So God knows,
- 1:14:30you know, which is so. Yeah, she could have talked a lot
- 1:14:32about sex. It's possible. But again, I don't blame her necessarily because
- 1:14:38I think she's being manipulated. I wonder what she would say now, having
- 1:14:42watched season two and really seeing the compelling evidence that the child that she was
- 1:14:46a child, that Natolia was in fact eight, I would hope that she
- 1:14:49would change her tune and I would guess that she would this when she got
- 1:14:54that notice. Can you imagine. The Barnettes even had their lawyer of fire
- 1:14:58off a letter to the Department of Children's Services saying, look, she's an
- 1:15:01adult, you don't have any jurisdiction over her. But Barnett's again are notified
- 1:15:06that it doesn't matter what Natalia's age is, she's a dependent because of her
- 1:15:12disability. Okay, that's interesting, and I'm glad the government agency is monitoring
- 1:15:19the situation. That's what our tax dollars are doing for us, protecting US
- 1:15:26humans from people like Christine and Michael. So yeah, this is more evidence
- 1:15:33to make the point that Christine and Michael were absolutely neglectful. Even if Natalia
- 1:15:41is indeed twenty two or twenty three, she has a disability, so you
- 1:15:46have a requirement. Legally, you have a requirement. Of course, morally
- 1:15:49they had a requirement, but they also have a legal requirement. So let's
- 1:15:54see what we hear in terms of how they responded. I'm guessing that we
- 1:16:00did see some of this footage in the first season where we saw at least
- 1:16:03Michael was recording a lot of things, probably in an attempt to demonstrate that
- 1:16:11Natalia is fine on her own, you know, Like there's that film of
- 1:16:15her as she's dragging that garbage can up the ramp, which is just heartbreaking
- 1:16:20to watch, and Michael is like, look, she's fine, It's just
- 1:16:25what do you find what are you talking about, you fucking idiot? So
- 1:16:30I'm guessing that that's what they did. They yeah, And so even if
- 1:16:40they, I guess there are different levels to the lack of empathy and immorality
- 1:16:47of the parents, right, they wouldn't have been as horrifically immoral if at
- 1:16:55least they would have taken care of her. That still would have been immoral
- 1:16:58and horrific, because she's eight years old and she's in an apartment. But
- 1:17:02if they at least just took care of like if you're really looking for as
- 1:17:06a parent, Look, I just don't want to have to deal with what
- 1:17:10I believe to be a highly dangerous, problematic person in buy house because of
- 1:17:15my other kids and myself, And so I got to get rid of the
- 1:17:20kid. But once that's established, then you know, mission accomplished. Might
- 1:17:27as well now take care of her, right at least a little bit?
- 1:17:30It just takes time. Why not? Plus, she's a tiny person,
- 1:17:36even if you think she's twenty two, do you not have any humanity?
- 1:17:40And so to try to get out from under that and not we're not hearing
- 1:17:45any effort to connect her with you know, if they tried to find some
- 1:17:50neighbors to look after her, or connecting her with services or something, you
- 1:17:56know, the way they described it, and maybe they did, but that
- 1:18:00you know, it's not enough. But the way they described it, it's
- 1:18:01like, look, in the first season, they're like, look, that
- 1:18:04apartment building was within half a mile of you know, this service and a
- 1:18:10grocery store and this thing and this thing. What are you talking about?
- 1:18:14Its eight years old. Even if she were twenty two. She can't drive
- 1:18:17a car, She can barely walk. She talks about how even when she
- 1:18:23does walk, her feet are in terrible pain. You know, she was
- 1:18:28talking about that one time when theyre at the creamery and her her feet were
- 1:18:30bleeding. You know, Okay, fine, she can walk, but at
- 1:18:33what costs? So yeah, it's just wow. And then coming out,
- 1:18:43I literally fell. I was so dizzy. I couldn't even walk straight.
- 1:18:55I couldn't even see straight. I felt so I was okay. So the
- 1:19:01implication here is that when the parents were told that Natalia would be a dependent,
- 1:19:09perhaps for the rest of Natalia's life given her disability, that the mom,
- 1:19:14Christine, resorted to killing her because she didn't want to have to take
- 1:19:19care of her. And the evidence that they're putting forward is that there was
- 1:19:25this one recalled incident in which Natalia remembers the mom being very adamant about her
- 1:19:30taking medication and then she had a reaction and she didn't die, of course,
- 1:19:36because she's still with us. But uh, you know, it's possible.
- 1:19:40It's possible, but it'd be hard to demonstrate this to a jury because
- 1:19:47you know, there's a lot of question marks there. It's possible. I
- 1:19:50mean, earlier, I wouldn't have you know, if I give it,
- 1:19:55if I gave it a percentage chance, I would have said, yeah,
- 1:19:58I don't know, one or two percent. You know, it's possible now
- 1:20:00given all the other things that we have heard, you know, because you
- 1:20:04just I often talk about how when you lie or when you know, well,
- 1:20:11not you, but when someone lies or when someone cheats on their partner,
- 1:20:15it's not just one lie. It's perhaps thousands of lies and thousands of
- 1:20:20choices to even cheat just once, right, particularly if it's more than once,
- 1:20:27then there are thousands, if not millions, of little whys in the
- 1:20:30road that you could go either way, and you decide to go further down
- 1:20:33this slippery slope, and then once you do it by not telling your partner.
- 1:20:40Every time. Every second that goes by that you have an opportunity to
- 1:20:43text or tell or write a letter or something is a choice to lie by
- 1:20:47omission. It's lying. And people that say I never lied, I never
- 1:20:53just like, well, you know, you knew that I wanted to know
- 1:20:56that information and you chose not to. That's lying. So with cheating or
- 1:21:00with lying, I think it's important to see it that way because sometimes we
- 1:21:04can frame it as just like, oh, it was just one thing that
- 1:21:06happened. It wasn't one It wasn't just one thing. It was a lot
- 1:21:11of things that were hurtful, and a lot of choices that you made that
- 1:21:15were not in consideration of me and were only selfish choices for yourself in harm
- 1:21:23of me. So when we look at through that lens at the parents,
- 1:21:29I guess not only at the line, because it's possible that they knew she
- 1:21:31was a child, right, it seems highly likely that they knew. But
- 1:21:36even if we don't look at that every second of every day that went by,
- 1:21:42that they didn't take action to help her, even if she's in the
- 1:21:45apartment, to help her along the way, to help her, take the
- 1:21:50garbage out, or drive her somewhere, or entertain her, or protect her
- 1:21:54from the perpetrator. A sexual perpetrator at two doors down. I don't know
- 1:22:00how many doors down he was, but couldn't been that far because that apartment
- 1:22:02building wasn't huge. So every second of every day that goes by, that's
- 1:22:06a choice that is selfish and harmful. And you consider someone because you know
- 1:22:13you could. You've probably been there before, where your remorse or your shame
- 1:22:18or your guilt it gnaws away at you and then eventually ah, okay,
- 1:22:25fine, I'll do this thing. I feel like this happened to me,
- 1:22:27not in a big way, but this happened to me recently. I'm trying
- 1:22:30to remember what it was. I remember having this moment where I just just,
- 1:22:38you know, just swallow your pride and do it or something. I
- 1:22:41can't remember what it was, but I was drawing a boundary of someone that
- 1:22:43I deserved to drive boundary with. But I was perhaps being too boundary,
- 1:22:47that's the way I'll put it anyway. So I remember that moment I just
- 1:22:51felt like, ugh, I can't live with this, even though I feel
- 1:22:56like it's right. That's a situation where I felt like I know I'm right,
- 1:23:00and everyone around me knows I'm right, but you know, the guilt
- 1:23:02nas away for better or for worse, I suppose, And so to not
- 1:23:08have that mechanism, or to have a large enough pushback on that every second
- 1:23:15of every day for both parents, by the way, that says something about
- 1:23:19one's personality. And therefore the percentage chance that this actually did happen where the
- 1:23:26mother legit tried to kill her is a lot higher than what I would imagine.
- 1:23:30Otherwise, what percentage would I put to it, you know, given
- 1:23:33what I'm hearing, maybe there'll be more data here, but I would still
- 1:23:35say it's unlikely. It almost would be against what she would want because if
- 1:23:41she dies, as Michael was saying a while back, I don't know if
- 1:23:44I show this clip, you know, He's like. The worry that Christine
- 1:23:48had was that if Natalia dies, then it might become a news story and
- 1:23:54then they everyone might start looking into it, and her perfect persona as this
- 1:23:58perfect parent would be shattered and she would lose all of her narcissistic supply and
- 1:24:03her money and everything. So I still wouldn't put it over fifty percent The
- 1:24:10other thing is that given what Natalia is saying, it's not uncommon for a
- 1:24:15parent to get real focused on medications, not only because it's good to do
- 1:24:20so for kids that are prescribed meds, but some parents, you know,
- 1:24:24they have behavioral problem kids for good reasons and bad reasons, they can become
- 1:24:29very fixated on meds. I've seen this before. I would work in home
- 1:24:32with some families where I would notice sort of two different categories. One categorygory
- 1:24:38would be the kid would actually if they miss their med even by a couple
- 1:24:42hours, then we would see very very problematic behaviors, whether it was them
- 1:24:48being erratic or rageful, or they might even have many seizures or something.
- 1:24:56You know, so you can so you have parents that can be very adamant
- 1:24:59about you need to take this med and it sometimes is against the will of
- 1:25:03the child, you know. That's one category. Another category is parents will
- 1:25:08be over focused because they just want the child to be subdued, and they
- 1:25:14don't they don't they don't want to take a risk. So that can be
- 1:25:18you know, obviously problematic. Depending but parents can be very adamant about medications,
- 1:25:24especially if you observe a lot of behavior problems, which I think we're
- 1:25:28probably present. So the way Natalia is telling a story, now, should
- 1:25:33you just leave a child by themselves as they are taking a medication that they're
- 1:25:38telling you is causing them to be very drowsy? No, perhaps especially drowsiness.
- 1:25:45I mean, if you hear that from anybody, then you know,
- 1:25:49talk to physicians. So by the way, you know, listen, you
- 1:25:53know, the first action is like, oh, well, don't take them
- 1:25:56mad, Let's talk to the doctor, Let's talk to a nurse or something.
- 1:25:59Cause drowsiness that you know, sometimes not all the time, but as
- 1:26:01a precursor to injury or death. So to you know, to consider that
- 1:26:10if Natalia is telling the truth, which you can't really know, then you
- 1:26:15know, it's hard. It could be a number of things. It could
- 1:26:17be literally trying to kill her, which I guess I would put out about
- 1:26:20twenty percent now given what I've heard. I think it also could be that
- 1:26:25the mom was just unconcerned about the side effects because she doesn't care, and
- 1:26:30it's just like, look, you need to take these meds because it makes
- 1:26:32you easier to deal with or maybe a smaller percentage chance, maybe ten percent
- 1:26:39chance that this was like the way any parent, good or bad, would
- 1:26:45actually act in this situation, like, well, this is the prescribed med
- 1:26:47and remember what happened to you last time? He didn't take the met on
- 1:26:50time, you know, so it's hard to know what happened. But I
- 1:26:54can't believe that I'm considering a twenty percent chance that a mother tried to kill
- 1:27:00her adopted child. It's just that tells you just the amount of atrocious data
- 1:27:09that we've been given already. Dizzy, literally like my eyes were going across
- 1:27:14it was so blurry, and then I fell asleep, like I blacked out
- 1:27:21for like hours until two in the morning. Thinking back on it, like
- 1:27:32it felt like she really did try to overdose me. Yeah, I mean,
- 1:27:35regardless of the intention of Christine, she could have died. That story
- 1:27:43is the story you'll hear about people dying or having oxygen cut off to their
- 1:27:48brain enough that there's injury to the brain. And it's interesting the way she
- 1:27:54just phrased that, She's like, well, thinking back on it, it
- 1:27:56seems possible she could have been trying to kill me. That lends credibility to
- 1:28:00her whole story, because you know, she doesn't know, she doesn't know
- 1:28:03the intention, but given everything, she's like, you know, maybe it's
- 1:28:06possible. So that lends itself to believing the whole story. I really could
- 1:28:15have died that day. I was seven years old, taken an adult drug,
- 1:28:25and yeah, I didn't even think about that, right, So she's
- 1:28:30telling a story about prior to being kicked out of the house, so that
- 1:28:36time then doesn't work out with the dependency, doesn't work out anyway the real
- 1:28:41least. Yeah, I mean, if so, was that what happened that
- 1:28:45because she's identified as an adult, that somehow stronger drugs are but her size.
- 1:28:51I don't know. I don't have enough information. One day, I
- 1:28:56remember I was living in the first apartment. I was taking medical right,
- 1:29:00So I rewound it because I forgot exactly what she said. So she was
- 1:29:04saying I was in the first apartment, so she's saying she was seven at
- 1:29:08the time. I don't really understand. Soon, I don't remember what it
- 1:29:13was. It was like three different pills for the mental stuff that Christine claimed
- 1:29:17I had, and I remember waking up taking And to be clear, it
- 1:29:24was prescribed in all likelihood by a qualified prescriber, and they might have done
- 1:29:31a thorough evaluation and found that she did indeed would be helped by these medications.
- 1:29:36Having said that, I would see children that would seemingly be given meds
- 1:29:42because not because the med actually was legit, and not because the diagnosis was
- 1:29:47legit, but because the med just made the child tired and more docile,
- 1:29:53easier to handle, and so it's sort of like a lobotomy light if you
- 1:29:59will. It's like, okay, great, they're no longer aggressive or defiant,
- 1:30:03but they also are zoned out the entire time. I didn't see that
- 1:30:08very often, because you know, most parents don't want to see that.
- 1:30:12If anything, I would see parents avoid medications too often when medications could have
- 1:30:17helped. But anyway, so we're hearing she's seeing that she was seven when
- 1:30:23she was in And then I fell back to sleep because the medicine made me
- 1:30:29sleepy, and I think it was like literally only an hour later, Christine
- 1:30:33came and she was knocking on the door, like okay, then she takes
- 1:30:38the med in the apartment. Christine came by knocking on the door, pounding
- 1:30:43on the door, and I opened the door and she literally was like,
- 1:30:46why are you still sleeping? Like she was mad that I was sleep and
- 1:30:53I told her I was tired. Christine was very on edge that day,
- 1:31:00and then she was like, did you take your medicine? And I was
- 1:31:03like, yes, I did. Right. So it's interesting going back hearing
- 1:31:09the end of this story and also having the way that she presents it sounds
- 1:31:14credible. Hard to know, but and also it was a long time ago,
- 1:31:18but it could be a very notable story to her because she passed out
- 1:31:23and she would remember like that was, you know, a particularly interesting incident.
- 1:31:27But then she's saying that the mom didn't believe her that she took the
- 1:31:31bed. Yeah, it's hard to know because you know, she was young.
- 1:31:35Yeah, it could be an honest memory, but it could be jumbled
- 1:31:39up. This could be like five different stories crammed into one. At the
- 1:31:43very least, is it possible that Christine tried to kill it? You know?
- 1:31:46The other thing is that if Christine wanted to kill her, it wouldn't
- 1:31:51take much. She had the ability and the fact that if this is all
- 1:31:57we have in terms of any sort of data along the lines, then that
- 1:32:00would point either in the direction that it was an impulsive thing that she said,
- 1:32:05I'm not going to go that far with this, or it doesn't serve
- 1:32:08me to actually kill her because then I might get noticed, So you know,
- 1:32:13I would say that, Yeah, it's funny. As I watched this,
- 1:32:16I'm I'm it's like knowing the truth helps to stand on a foundation of
- 1:32:23something. But we're just not giving enough information. Is the thing? We
- 1:32:27just we just don't know. And I will speculate, I think partially because
- 1:32:31I think what I can provide the internet is a clinical opinion about things.
- 1:32:38Part of that involves recognizing that unless we have factual data, then we can't
- 1:32:43really know much. So she literally got my medicine, gave it to me.
- 1:32:50Yeah, so the rest of it I remember pretty well. But let's
- 1:32:55move on. And that's scary, like the fact that Christine tried to say
- 1:33:03she tried to murder my family, but then she tried to Peru murder me.
- 1:33:11Yeah, that's something I've been thinking about, but I haven't been talking
- 1:33:14about that. It is interesting how for people that are harmful to others that
- 1:33:23they will often accuse others of the thing that they do. And they are
- 1:33:28very different ideas about this, but one is called projection, and in the
- 1:33:33lay public they use projection. In this other way. They tend to use
- 1:33:38projection to mean displacement, which is fine lay people, but and the clinical
- 1:33:43world, projection is to project an unwanted aspect of self, a feeling,
- 1:33:47a trait, a behavior, an urge. So if Christine knew about herself,
- 1:33:54or if Christine either subconsciously or consciously knew that she actually has murderous intent
- 1:34:01or harmful intent on others, then one of the defenses. Because people want
- 1:34:06to believe that they're good people and they don't want to believe that they're moral.
- 1:34:12That might be shocking to hear, because I feel like on the Internet
- 1:34:15that's not usually the way people are characterized. There are evil people, so
- 1:34:18to speak, but even what we might call, you know, like a
- 1:34:21Charlie Manson or a Ted Bundy or something, even they will want often to
- 1:34:28see themselves as good people and will have elaborate justifications like well, that person
- 1:34:32was going to die anyway, or you know, like in Killers of the
- 1:34:36Flower Moon, the character depicted by Robert de Niro, he would say that
- 1:34:43the character I don't know if the actual individual in history said that, but
- 1:34:46the character would say, yeah, well, you know, those Native Americans
- 1:34:50are going to die anyway. So it doesn't justify it, of course,
- 1:34:55but what it does is it helps them to feel better about themselves, as
- 1:35:00if they're not the evil person that they are. And so for Christine,
- 1:35:05it's possible that a lot of the allegations were projections. You know, that
- 1:35:12she actually didn't like these aspects of herself and she would see it in others.
- 1:35:16Another reason for this is that when you're capable of something and you have
- 1:35:23urges or you've done bad things like this, then you're much more likely to
- 1:35:28believe that others are going to do it because you know that you could do
- 1:35:30it and you have done it. It's like with infidelity often that's a projection,
- 1:35:36right. You will be in a relationship and you haven't cheated, but
- 1:35:40you have a partner that is just constantly accusing you of cheating, and then
- 1:35:45later on you find out that they were cheating, like you were obsessed with
- 1:35:51infidelity and how horrible it was and you were doing it. So part of
- 1:35:56it is that projection part, But another part of it is like, well,
- 1:36:00I know people cheat because I'm cheating, and so they must be cheating,
- 1:36:03you know. So it is there's been a number of details given that
- 1:36:10makes me wonder about Christine's personality and how that manifested in the attacking from all
- 1:36:18different angles on Natalia. All right, so they're having another meeting, another
- 1:36:31sit down between Michael and Natalia. And the first thing of note is his
- 1:36:38outfit. You know, obviously people can wear whatever they want to for the
- 1:36:42most part, but given the scenario, why this. I don't know what
- 1:36:46his shirt says exactly, but backwards ball cap because you know, he thought
- 1:36:55about it, he knew he was going to be filmed. Now maybe he'll
- 1:36:58tell us why. The other thing is, you would just think that you
- 1:37:01would. He said earlier that he would like to apologize. Okay, so
- 1:37:10let's see what happens. I already role played from what I imagined to be
- 1:37:15the truth. What he should be saying here, what someone with well,
- 1:37:20what I was going to say, was someone with half a heart would say.
- 1:37:23But as I've also said earlier, public statements by people who probably know
- 1:37:28that they did something wrong are often subpar. In my opinion, Will Smith's
- 1:37:33apology at least one that I saw the initial one. I don't know if
- 1:37:38he's talked about it beyond that, but that very short video I think it
- 1:37:41was like ten minutes or something, did not really address the issue. I
- 1:37:45mean, it was better than others like Bill Clinton. His apology was horrible.
- 1:37:53Donald Trump's apology was horrible. I just and I wonder what that is,
- 1:37:57because apologies are presumably something that we learned very early in life, and
- 1:38:04remorse is very common. You know, it was denial and all these justification
- 1:38:10worries about being canceled or implicated or something. But anyway, so I just
- 1:38:15think he would apologize. I say, you know, because I'm guessing the
- 1:38:16story is, I wanted to adopt you. I loved you. You were
- 1:38:21this cute little child that was in need, and I wanted to help you.
- 1:38:29I wanted to raise you. I wanted to be with you. I
- 1:38:31loved you. And then there was some behaviors from you that were concerning,
- 1:38:38but I didn't know what to do. We took you to some therapist.
- 1:38:41But really Christine, unbeknownst to me, really she just went on this mission,
- 1:38:45I think, to get rid of you. We can get into that,
- 1:38:47but and she was terrifying to me. And I'm kind of a people
- 1:38:53pleaser, so I'm always like, I know now that I defer to a
- 1:38:59thorn and I saw her as my authority, and so that doesn't excuse it.
- 1:39:03I should have been the adult, but I deferred to her and I
- 1:39:09went along with her plan. That doesn't exonerate me, but it does,
- 1:39:14I think, provide a context. And for that, I apologize to you
- 1:39:18a million times for all the mistreatment. I should have done something. I
- 1:39:25should have saved you. I should have called the police. I should have
- 1:39:29just gathered you up and taken you away. I should have done something,
- 1:39:32and I didn't. And then at some point I actually became convinced that you
- 1:39:40actually were twenty two, and I thought maybe you were this evil monster.
- 1:39:45You know. Christine was very good at convincing me of that. And now
- 1:39:48when I look at everything, I think, I don't know. So I
- 1:39:54didn't have any reason to believe she was lying all the time I didn't know.
- 1:39:59It doesn't exonerate I was the adult. You were four, you were
- 1:40:01six. It wasn't your faults, it was my faults. And it keeps
- 1:40:08me awake every night, you know, something like that. Let's see what
- 1:40:09he says. It's difficult to understand. But after fifteen plus years of being
- 1:40:19put down and degraded and controlled and threatened. I didn't have any strength and
- 1:40:28all the stand up to her. I wish I did. Yeah, that
- 1:40:31could be. It still doesn't, in a lot of people's minds, exonerate
- 1:40:36him from not doing something to save her, to save totalia. I've been
- 1:40:45trying to find data and I'm guessing we're not going to get it that will
- 1:40:48help me to land somewhere on the spectrum between full responsibility and no responsibility.
- 1:40:56We know of situations where we would not hold someone accountable for their actions,
- 1:41:01even though they're an adult, because of the abuse and or gaslighting that they've
- 1:41:09been through for a long time and the threat to their life or the ongoing
- 1:41:15threat for thinking for themselves. You know, cult members, victims of partner
- 1:41:18of violence of a severe nature, We wouldn't necessarily hold them accountable, or
- 1:41:24at least I wouldn't maybe a little bit. You know, it depends the
- 1:41:27situation, and I keep trying to figure that out the way that it looks.
- 1:41:31It looks like he is the sort of person that is very people pleasing,
- 1:41:39very dependent, not extremely but enough, and that she was controlling and
- 1:41:45would manipulate. But it didn't look at all the data that we've heard it
- 1:41:53didn't look like the sort of thing where he had no mind of his own
- 1:41:58and he had no sense of agency. It seemed like he did have enough
- 1:42:05agency, enough sense of himself and his own thoughts and his own freedom.
- 1:42:12You know, do we believe that he would have thought reasonably that she was
- 1:42:17Christine would have done something horrible if he had threatened divorce? And you know,
- 1:42:26a common story would be that he just goes to her and says,
- 1:42:28look, what you're doing to Natalia is not right. And I've already tried
- 1:42:32to talk with you about it. I'm guessing it's not going to go well.
- 1:42:34But I'm here to tell you that if things don't change, I will
- 1:42:40leave and I will take Natalia, which I'm guessing you won't mind, because
- 1:42:43I don't think you like her. So let's just start to He could have
- 1:42:47said something like that, or he could have built up to something like that
- 1:42:50right, Or he could have gone to a therapist himself or somebody and just
- 1:42:57said, I don't know what to do. What do we do? Here
- 1:43:00any evidence of that? And so I think that he is culpable, absolutely,
- 1:43:05But I don't want to blame a victim for having taken action under someone
- 1:43:10else's intimidation. So I just I don't have a lot of data to go
- 1:43:15off of. What do you think I wish I did? I didn't you
- 1:43:20ever seen the movie Monster's Income. Yes, you know, the same monster
- 1:43:24goes through bunches of doors, and all these kids around the world have the
- 1:43:27same monster, but they don't know it. We have the same monster and
- 1:43:31we didn't know it for years. So it kind of looks like the way
- 1:43:40the conversation is going, that he's like an older brother or something, the
- 1:43:45way that he's talking, And I think that will rub a lot of people
- 1:43:48wrong, including me. There's a chance that psychologically, given whatever he went
- 1:43:55through, which we have heard nothing about in his early childhood, that he
- 1:43:59actually sees himself that way. It doesn't release him from responsibility, but it
- 1:44:03could even be why he wore this outfit, if you want to call it
- 1:44:08that. So his shirt says slide, So I think it's like a like
- 1:44:10a zoo T shirt or something, and he wants to be seen that way.
- 1:44:15Maybe who knows. It doesn't exonerate him, but it does maybe explain
- 1:44:21the vibe. You know, an older brother wouldn't feel necessarily super well.
- 1:44:27I don't know even an older brother would, and they usually do unfairly.
- 1:44:31Older siblings will often blame themselves for not stepping in right, so that analogy
- 1:44:39doesn't even hold up. So I'm guessing she's crying because the flippant nature of
- 1:44:47his explanation, or she's reminded of what she went through, or she's opening
- 1:44:53her heart to saying like why didn't you take me away? Let's see what
- 1:44:56she says. Everybody that knows me, we don't call her by christy.
- 1:45:05Matter of fact, I hate the word. I don't like the word.
- 1:45:08I don't like hearing the word. Yeah, just stop it to ask her
- 1:45:13a question or talk to her. You're not equals. You weren't like siblings
- 1:45:20being attacked by this monster. You were part of the problem, and you
- 1:45:27were an adult like read the room and this monster's ink thing and yeah,
- 1:45:36yeah, I guess. So this is pointing in the direction of someone that
- 1:45:42doesn't understand responsibly. Well doesn't because we can all feel it, and you
- 1:45:47would think he would feel it because he has hopefully some affection for her that
- 1:45:55still remains. But even just another human being anyways, like, my goodness,
- 1:46:00dude, what are you doing? Her name is evil every now and
- 1:46:04then I'll call it. And the thing is is she knows that Christine is
- 1:46:09abusive or evil, whatever word do you want to put to it, So
- 1:46:15move on. There are other topics of concern, and then this gonna sounds
- 1:46:20silly. I'm afraid of what I don't know, Like I know a little,
- 1:46:34I don't know a lot. What do you know? It's a very
- 1:46:42long answer. Yeah, I think he wants to avoid answering because then he
- 1:46:46will have to answer as to why he didn't do anything or why he stayed
- 1:46:54right, and just claiming that he's an abusive victim, I think only goes
- 1:47:00so far. That could take us a week. And good for Natalia for
- 1:47:13just being calm and asking the questions. It's very poised. Ah. Now
- 1:47:24there's a chance that he well, no, I was going to say,
- 1:47:28it's a chance that he doesn't want to remember because they're difficult. During this
- 1:47:32round of interviewing, he was more than ready to tell other people. So
- 1:47:38yeah, I think I would imagine he feels guilty and he doesn't want to
- 1:47:43admit what he knows, because again, if he really did think of himself
- 1:47:49as an abuse victim that had no power, then he wouldn't have a problem
- 1:47:56say, yeah, I saw sorts of stuff. I saw this, I
- 1:47:58saw that, I saw that, and I did speak up about it.
- 1:48:01But then she beat the living crap out of me, or she threatened to
- 1:48:05kill me and she or whatever. You know. But the fact that he's
- 1:48:09hesitating, I don't know. It's hard to know, but it could point
- 1:48:14toward a part of his conscious mind that understands that he is in trouble,
- 1:48:19and so he's just avoiding as being very careful, whether he's worried about a
- 1:48:25court of law, civil or criminal, or just you know, the court
- 1:48:30of public opinion, to use a cliche, it just seems like he's been
- 1:48:34advised by his an attorney to steer clear or not admit any kind of liability
- 1:48:42or incriminate you in any way. Yeah, I and thought about that,
- 1:48:45and that would be smart to consider, whether he's guilty or not. It
- 1:48:50would be normal for someone to be careful about implicating themselves. But he already
- 1:48:59has said so much on camera, so if he says it in front of
- 1:49:02her or not front of her, it doesn't matter. Plus, there are
- 1:49:06ways of answering this question without getting specific. You'd be like, well,
- 1:49:11I remember, you know that one time with that one thing? Do you
- 1:49:15remember that? Or I don't want to say things that you don't remember,
- 1:49:20so because I don't want you to remember them. So if I allude to
- 1:49:25you know there's ways to say something or hey, Natalia, I don't want
- 1:49:31to say anything along these lines because if I say something, then Christine might
- 1:49:38come after me or I might get blamed or something. But I just want
- 1:49:41to say I saw some really, really horrible things. And because I'm thinking
- 1:49:45that Natalia isn't actually interested in what he remembers, I think she wants to
- 1:49:50establish that he did see things. And then I think she has a follow
- 1:49:55up question, which is, why didn't you help me? I'm so afraid
- 1:49:59of the things I don't know about, and I don't want to know the
- 1:50:01things I don't know about because I know they're all terrible. It's so aggravating.
- 1:50:10Okay, it's possible that he's being genuine right now, but you know
- 1:50:16what she's getting at. I think, I mean, I don't really know
- 1:50:20what she's getting at, really, but I'm guessing I know what she's getting
- 1:50:24at, and I'm guessing he knows what she's getting at. And he's avoiding
- 1:50:30and he's resorting to this woe is me thing right now, like read the
- 1:50:36room, understand that this is a child, your child. You did not
- 1:50:44get abused as much as Natalia did. There's no way by Christine anyway.
- 1:50:50So this idea of just like, oh, we're in the same boat.
- 1:50:55What just not know that there's such horrible things world life doesn't give us those
- 1:51:03opportunities. Well, just seeing this squeamishness, it throws everything and the question
- 1:51:10as to what he said, because we've seen this before, and there are
- 1:51:13times that I've said I think on camera where I'll say, well, you
- 1:51:15know, it's quite possible that this is genuine, but he amps it up
- 1:51:20because of his personality issue of I don't know if it's historyonic. I can't
- 1:51:26evaluate him over the internet, but some sort of need to amplify things.
- 1:51:31And I would think though that underneath it there was genuineness. But now you
- 1:51:38wonder if the whole time, you know, maybe it was true that she
- 1:51:42was abusive to him somewhat, but he doesn't have a lot of current emotion
- 1:51:49about it. But he has to drum that up out of whole cloth,
- 1:51:54just completely fabricated, not exaggerated, but just fabricated. So as he's doing
- 1:52:00this, like, dude, there's a child. And but I could see
- 1:52:05how because his lawyer is a very strong personality, and I could see the
- 1:52:11lawyer having just talked to him fifteen minutes earlier and said, do not say
- 1:52:15X, Y and Z, avoid getting into this. So I could see
- 1:52:17that being a factor. But at the same time, you know, where's
- 1:52:20the humanity. I have an okay future and maybe you've got a little of
- 1:52:27this in there too. If all of us, if every every one just
- 1:52:34stands up and says, this is what happens, what she did, we
- 1:52:39do it all. At the same time, she can't scream, and why
- 1:52:43are way out of it? What is he saying? I don't understand what
- 1:52:46he's even saying. It appears that he's saying, hey, I want you
- 1:52:53to go after her so that she'll be she'll get punished. So I'll support
- 1:53:00that. But this all started with her asking you a question, do you
- 1:53:04remember what she did to me? It's a pretty easy question to answer.
- 1:53:08I absolutely think he suffers from PTSD as a result of his marriage. I
- 1:53:13think he still has a lot of mental trauma as a result of the loss
- 1:53:17of his marriage, and I know he believes that Christine is the reason for
- 1:53:21that. She is screamed and screamed and screamed horrific, horrific, horrific lies.
- 1:53:30It's also narcissistic to focus on you. You can talk with your people,
- 1:53:38your therapist, your friends. This is your child, so what about
- 1:53:43her? Yes, I I think he's just trying to get the criticism of
- 1:53:47the public off of him. Yeah. And as with all personality disorders,
- 1:53:55the defense in the effort of saving the self or you know, getting away
- 1:54:00from danger, will often cause the individual to head directly into danger because his
- 1:54:09effort to save himself and to make himself look better is making him look way
- 1:54:15worse than if he didn't do this. Even if he just if he just
- 1:54:19avoided without the histrionics, it would be a lot less I think bothersome And
- 1:54:27that's how personality sorts work. I don't know if he has one, but
- 1:54:29I'm just using this as a jumping off point. Whether it's borderline or paranoid
- 1:54:34or obsessive, compulsive, personal I disorder or skezoid or schizotypal or you know,
- 1:54:41narcissism, any social these personality sorders are defenses, at least that's the
- 1:54:46way experts will frame them. And the defense is trying to save us,
- 1:54:53you know. Like a classic is that with borderline, the effort of being
- 1:55:00hyper vigilant about abandonment from others and maybe accusatory to others, like hey,
- 1:55:05your abandon me right now is an effort to avoid abandonment that happened in their
- 1:55:11past, but by being hostile or accusatory will push people away and cause the
- 1:55:16individual to get abandoned. With narcissism, the effort is to save the self
- 1:55:24from being ignored, irrelevant, and neglected, because when they were one year
- 1:55:30of age, to be abandoned or neglected or left on your own too much,
- 1:55:35too often was absolutely a terrifying thing for that one year old child.
- 1:55:42And so the defense is, well, I don't need anybody, and I'm
- 1:55:46actually better than everybody, and so I need to avoid attachments and dependence on
- 1:55:55others and vulnerability, and I need to constant beyond the treadmill of telling myself
- 1:56:01and others that I'm superior, because that will save me from that feeling of
- 1:56:06isolation and of being neglected. And of course that is a lifestyle of isolation
- 1:56:15and thus abandonment or just distance. But also to be braggy and annoying is
- 1:56:20to push people away that will cause even more neglect. Right. So with
- 1:56:26Histrionic, it is this effort of running away from trying to save the self
- 1:56:32from not being noticed, from being rejected, not getting attention and love and
- 1:56:38attunement. So I have to be bigger with my expressions. That's in a
- 1:56:42nutshell for the most part, So I'm going to amp it up. But
- 1:56:45as he does that, it causes people to, I guess, pay attention
- 1:56:49to him, but not in a positive way. Right, So it's pretty
- 1:56:54hard to watch. You know. With other reality TV, there's things at
- 1:56:59stake, but not not as much as what's at stake here. I'm trying
- 1:57:02to use a sympathy to be like I was victimized too, Like please don't
- 1:57:06come after me, Like I was a victim too in this, But the
- 1:57:11thing is for me, Yes, you were a victim, but you also
- 1:57:18was the perpetrator. Yeah. And Natalia's coming across as the most mature wise
- 1:57:28good person in among everybody. I mean, Jacob seems like a nice guy
- 1:57:32too, but the fact that she can to have that nuance you know,
- 1:57:38she would have every reason to hate him thoroughly and to throw him under the
- 1:57:42bus, but you know she sees, hey, y, I get it,
- 1:57:45you were abused to you know, she gives him that, and she
- 1:57:48would know because she was there, so that lends credibility to that. But
- 1:57:54she's also like, and it's like close captioning will say the weirdest thing,
- 1:58:02like hey German listeners, or hey demented listener. I don't know, so
- 1:58:08maybe I should start saying, hey, deserving listeners. Did YouTube get it?
- 1:58:14Hey deserving listeners. I'm just trying to add some levity to this very
- 1:58:21dark situation that we're watching. Let's watch you were an accomplice of it all
- 1:58:27too. If Christine was his so called monster, he could have fought her.
- 1:58:35I couldn't. What was the conversation about dropping me off in the apartment?
- 1:58:45What was that conversation? So I think they're editing this, which would
- 1:58:49make sense. I'm guessing he's going to say that it was completely out of
- 1:58:55control. It was something that Christine engineered ray quickly, and then after you
- 1:59:02were dropped off, she said she told me not to help you. But
- 1:59:08that doesn't answer the question as to one, why didn't you come more often
- 1:59:12to help me? Two? Why didn't you seriously escalate things with your wife
- 1:59:19to save me and possibly leading to divorce? Right? Did you do anything?
- 1:59:26Because at the very least he could have been over there more often.
- 1:59:29Now he might say, well, she would have. She was abusive,
- 1:59:31she was horrible, but he hasn't really demonstrated that her abuse resulted in him
- 1:59:38having zero agency and zero ability to do. Plus, I don't know if
- 1:59:43Christine actually would have been upset with him for that, because she might even
- 1:59:47be happier. Yeah, keep her going over there as long as she's gone
- 1:59:50or something, unless she was held bent on trying to get her killed.
- 1:59:54But I don't know if we know that for sure. I don't know.
- 1:59:58But let's see what he says, just what happened? You say? There's
- 2:00:01not a lot of conversation, there's a lot of dictating. Did you know
- 2:00:05that she was getting me an ID? Yes? I did at that point
- 2:00:12in time, legally your age had been altered by the States. Did you,
- 2:00:16like anybody else, need to have an ID? Okay, let's step
- 2:00:20back. Okay, Yeah, he's he's avoiding. I imagine this meeting is
- 2:00:27going to be frustrating, particularly for her, whose idea was it was,
- 2:00:33what, what do you think she's talking about? Work with her? Huh,
- 2:00:43what are you talking about? I did tell all these guys we're not
- 2:00:45getting into that subject. Yeah, it's very possible that his legal counsel told
- 2:00:54him don't get into these things, and him and his lawyer problem even went
- 2:01:00to the production and said, I'm not going to talk about this. I'm
- 2:01:02not going to talk about that. It makes it it's hard for us and
- 2:01:05particularly for her, because we want answers or we want some kind of something
- 2:01:12to see. But I'm it's weird that he even agreed to do this sort
- 2:01:17of thing. It's it's weird that he even agreed to be the documentary to
- 2:01:19begin with, honestly, because Christine didn't end. You know, one calculation
- 2:01:27you can make at the beginning of all this is I don't want to be
- 2:01:30in it. You know, if I'm not in the documentary and Christine isn't
- 2:01:32in the documentary, then maybe they won't make a documentary because they because you
- 2:01:36know, arguably seventy five percent of the footage is of him talking, you
- 2:01:42know, anyway, but he could have said I'm going to exonerate myself.
- 2:01:45Who knows, but this is you know, it's just frustrating to watch.
- 2:01:48Oh, why can't you say, did you guys not over these parameters?
- 2:01:55Now there are other things that he could just generate from himself. Does he
- 2:02:01not have anything he wants to say? Now, I'm guessing that my role
- 2:02:05played apology would not be on the table regarding his lawyer. And you know,
- 2:02:15if you apologize, then you are admitting something. So there's that.
- 2:02:18So I guess the only thing that the lawyer and Michael are saying is okay
- 2:02:25to talk about is that we were both victims. But I can't talk about
- 2:02:29how you were victimized. I can only talk about So the only thing I
- 2:02:31can talk about in this interview is about how I was victimized. That's the
- 2:02:36only thing we can talk about. Why are you there? You know me?
- 2:02:45And I just want to say that I have been in situations that are
- 2:02:47analogous to this where the law and or lawyers, judges, police officers are
- 2:02:55telling a parent one thing, but because the parent has an overwhelming desire or
- 2:03:00urge or drive to love on their child, they go counter to all of
- 2:03:08the advice and they love their child, there's some affection, there's or yeah,
- 2:03:14so that's not happy. Just you would think in this moment he would
- 2:03:16say I know I'm not supposed to say this, but you know, or
- 2:03:20or figure some way around. Like I'm trying to imagine what he's been told
- 2:03:26that he can't say. And I don't know the lead of Landscape. I
- 2:03:29do know that he was already acquitted, right He's found out guilty whatever the
- 2:03:33language is, so he can't be tried again for that, but he could
- 2:03:36be tried for other things. So there's that, but he is and he's
- 2:03:43probably facing that that I could imagine that happening after this season, So that
- 2:03:49is a concervative his which is fine. That's normal. It's not great that
- 2:03:55criminals get away with that or they concern themselves or save themselves, but pretty
- 2:04:00normal. But I'm just trying to think, Okay, given what I imagine
- 2:04:02is what he's what are the barriers? What else could he say in this
- 2:04:06moment that could generate from him. You know, she's asking questions, but
- 2:04:09he could just say, Okay, it's hard for me to answer that question
- 2:04:13because of some legal things, but I do want to say. I'm trying
- 2:04:17to think what he could say that would well, he could say, I
- 2:04:24I I loved you. I don't know if I love you anymore because of
- 2:04:29the way that I think about love. But I did in the beginning,
- 2:04:33and we had some great times together. And I worked a lot, but
- 2:04:38I did see you and we had fun and we laughed, you know,
- 2:04:42you and the boys, and we had even Christine, you know, we
- 2:04:45had We had some good times and I think fondly on those times. And
- 2:04:50I think I was influenced to believe that you were worse than you were and
- 2:04:56like a lot worse, and I pulled away from you emotionally, and that
- 2:05:01hurts because as your father, that hurts me, and I'm so sorry for
- 2:05:06you. Know. That's not admitting any kind of crime, right, that's
- 2:05:10something that would be you couldn't you know, you can't charge someone for that,
- 2:05:15right, So you would just think that the overwhelming desire and the drive
- 2:05:23of a parent or human being to reach out would be there. And the
- 2:05:29fact that it's not, I think it does say something. You know,
- 2:05:32what does it say well for people? If we go with the hypothesis of
- 2:05:38histrionic personality, then individuals with this personal I sort of will have impaired empathy.
- 2:05:44They have empathy, but it's impaired and it's also primorial because it hasn't
- 2:05:48developed and aged normally. So their empathy is very childlike, but it's there,
- 2:05:56but it's unrefined. It's not very wise. They don't feel responsible for
- 2:06:00others because that is the develop You know, there's empathy when you're five,
- 2:06:04but eventually you start actually feeling like you're your brother's keeper, so to speak.
- 2:06:09You are there, you know, you can do something to help others,
- 2:06:13and especially if you hurt others, you know, then there's a there's
- 2:06:16a greater sense of responsibility and empathy. And with Historyonic and I don't know
- 2:06:21if he has it, but for the people that go through the precursors to
- 2:06:26that, the traumas, the relational traumas, which is often neglectful, sometimes
- 2:06:30abusive, then they often are on a constant treadmill of trying to get attention
- 2:06:35for safety, and they they generally feel this ongoing sense of danger and that
- 2:06:41they have been treated wrongly by originally their family, their parents, and then
- 2:06:45by everyone past that, whether they were actually treated wrongly or not as an
- 2:06:50adult, they are just in that in that state, right, they're they're
- 2:06:56they're sad, they're threatened. You know, if someone has just came out
- 2:07:00of a robbery or something where they had a gun to their head, you
- 2:07:04don't expect them to have a lot of empathy for people, well, for
- 2:07:08people with borderline and histrionic and you know, to some extent narcissistic people.
- 2:07:12They're in that kind of constant state. It's a normal state for them to
- 2:07:15be in, and so their empathy is impaired in that way because they're in
- 2:07:20a constant state of relational danger. They also tend to not have a lot
- 2:07:26of self awareness about this and also their emotions and their reactivity. They also
- 2:07:33tend to have a childlike understanding of responsibility, especially when it comes to situations
- 2:07:39like this. If I just told you this whole scenario, and I didn't
- 2:07:44say that he was the dad, and I didn't say that he was his
- 2:07:47age, I didn't describe him visually, if you just heard the story,
- 2:07:50I think most people would assume he's not the dad. He must be like
- 2:07:55an older brother or just or a younger brother or something. You know,
- 2:07:58the way he's coming across, it's just like, hey, why if he
- 2:08:03were ten years old in this seat. We wouldn't hold him accountable, We
- 2:08:07wouldn't yell at him like he's ten. You know, he doesn't have that
- 2:08:11sense of empathy or responsibility. So people with histeronic personality sort, especially when
- 2:08:16they're pushed into a corner, will exhibit that kind of what from the outside
- 2:08:22would look like as cruelty and callousness, or at the very least, lack
- 2:08:26of concern for other people's feelings. It's not because at the foundation they're psychopathic
- 2:08:31and have no empathy. It's because of the impairment and the childlike nature of
- 2:08:37the empathy to begin with. Doesn't let him off the hook. It just
- 2:08:41might explain why. Because the other thing is if he truly is trying to
- 2:08:46preserve his image, which of course anyone in his shoes would be concerned with,
- 2:08:52not just criminals, then there's a much more logical presentation. You know,
- 2:09:00you think he would have thought about that. You know, I'm gonna
- 2:09:03The other thing is is why did you agree to do this? If if
- 2:09:05this is all that you were willing to do, which also points to not
- 2:09:09only histrionic but and maybe a desire to be in front of the camera,
- 2:09:13But because it is narcissistic. You know, people with historyanic are narcissistic,
- 2:09:18they have a Narsixtis treat it's not narcissistic person. But anyway, so he
- 2:09:24also, as I've been hypothesizing, might and I can't know, it's total
- 2:09:28speculation that he learned as a child to defer to other people because that's what
- 2:09:33was safe, and so when people ask him to do things, he's like,
- 2:09:35okay, especially if you have producers who are kind of breathing down your
- 2:09:39neck, you know, and especially if they're giving you a lot of approval,
- 2:09:41like I just really, I think your story's really great. Or whatever
- 2:09:45they do to him, who knows, I don't know, but it's just
- 2:09:48kind of it's interesting to see this case because there's a lot of shooting himself
- 2:09:52in the foot, and I'm just wondering what blind spots and what defenses and
- 2:09:56needs that he has that's driving this whole thing. That's pretty fascinating. Actually,
- 2:10:01just admit it. A lot of things would have been different if they
- 2:10:05would have maybe just sent me back. There were some ground rules going into
- 2:10:11this, and one of them was that the reaging is off topic, that
- 2:10:18is off the table, not to be discussed. I just I want to
- 2:10:20sta away from things that might be too almost so now I was just lying.
- 2:10:24I think, who knows. I don't know if he's lying, but
- 2:10:24he could be. The other thing to think about in terms of the timeline
- 2:10:30is this is just my layperson's point of view because I'm not a lawyer.
- 2:10:35But he was not found guilty in his criminal hearing because the whole premise was
- 2:10:43that Natalia was twenty two at the time of the crimes and not eight or
- 2:10:48nine years old. So at this point he hasn't seen the second season of
- 2:10:54the documentary, right, so at their timeline, you know, the whole
- 2:11:00a foundation of him not being in prison right now is staying in the world
- 2:11:05that she's older, and if we get into the nitty gritty there, that
- 2:11:09could be overturned. Right. I think if he knew how much data they
- 2:11:15have the documentarians and how much data she has, that they knew that she
- 2:11:22wasn't twenty two then at the time of the crimes, then I'm guessing you
- 2:11:26might, but maybe not. Maybe it would still be advisable. It's like,
- 2:11:30don't get into that because if you get into it, you're gonna reveal
- 2:11:33things you know that would actually that would be I think sound legal advice of
- 2:11:39you know, you can get into that topic of the twenty to eight years
- 2:11:43old thing, but because you're speaking off the cuff, you might reveal something
- 2:11:48like you knew that she wasn't twenty two, or you suspected she wasn't twenty
- 2:11:52two, or you'll be backed into a corner where any answer other than at
- 2:11:58least you suspected she wasn't two is ridiculous. And if that happens, then
- 2:12:03you could absolutely be implicated and thrown in jail because of previous statements that you've
- 2:12:09made or whatever. You know, and you know that I could see that,
- 2:12:13but again there's other topics that he could generate. He's a grown man.
- 2:12:18He can say, Look, I can't talk about that. I'm really
- 2:12:20sorry. It's a legal thing. I don't know. I want to get
- 2:12:24into it with you, but I don't understand everything and I can't get into
- 2:12:30it. But I do want to say these things. I do want to
- 2:12:33ask how was it for you? Some kind of yeah, I why not
- 2:12:37ask that question? But you know what though, touchy, that's all okay,
- 2:12:41Well, can you step away from because I got a lot of questions.
- 2:12:43Okay, and again, she is just showing so much poise and maturity
- 2:12:52and differentiation. And that's a weird that's a weird dynamic. Why not just
- 2:13:03put me up for an option? Again? Unfortunately, the real answer for
- 2:13:09that lies in Abel's head. I can make a couple of assumptions that are
- 2:13:13pretty good ones. Yeah, so I'm guessing he's actually telling the truth here,
- 2:13:18And that's a great question. My wife asked that question too. She
- 2:13:22has been watching this upstairs while I've been watching this here, and then after
- 2:13:28at night we're just like, so this, oh I got And by the
- 2:13:33way, I will say that she has helped me to see and understand things,
- 2:13:37because you know, two heads are better than one. So part of
- 2:13:41what I'm saying is actually absolutely influenced by her. But so anything weird,
- 2:13:45I said, it's because she's a joke. I don't want to be like
- 2:13:46him. So he is saying that, well, I can make some guesses.
- 2:13:56Yeah, and now, well he could have tried. He's a grown
- 2:14:01man. He could have also said, well, let's move for adoption.
- 2:14:05So he's not completely under the thumb of Christine. But yeah, I think
- 2:14:11at the time he was completely deferring to her. So I guess another angle
- 2:14:18here is that he's if we go with the hypothesis that he is a people
- 2:14:22pleaser, and especially when someone is tagging him along, you know, like
- 2:14:26manipulating she would only give him love or maybe sex when he was a good
- 2:14:33boy, which we could imagine, right, And then he's he's more and
- 2:14:39more in this state of just like, whatever she wants, I need to
- 2:14:43just pay attention to it. And then horrible abuse is happening to Tatalia,
- 2:14:48which was giving him some inkling of wait, maybe I shouldn't be pleasing Christine
- 2:14:54all the time, maybe I should actually be stepping away and looking at the
- 2:14:58situation. But because of his issue, whether it's histrionic or some other related
- 2:15:05thing that as a result of whatever went on in his childhood, that urge
- 2:15:13that motivation to say, well, wait, maybe I should figure out a
- 2:15:18big picture issue here and maybe look towards pushing back in Christine, like actually,
- 2:15:22let's not put on apartment list, or let's not try to get her
- 2:15:26to be twenty two. Maybe let's think about having her adopted by another family,
- 2:15:30because that'll solve the problem. Right. And I'm guessing that he would
- 2:15:33speculate that Christine would think that that would go against her image. It's kind
- 2:15:39of weird though, right, because what's better for your image if it gets
- 2:15:43out that you had a kid in your house that was like the kid from
- 2:15:50orphan, you know, like any you would think actually having her in another
- 2:15:54home would actually almost be the best case scenario for her, because you know,
- 2:16:01she could spin the story, Christine. She could say, look,
- 2:16:03things didn't work out because she, you know, exhibited some medical and behavioral
- 2:16:09issues that we just weren't equipped to deal with. But that would go against
- 2:16:16what I believe to be her, her persona that she was trying to push,
- 2:16:20that she's this magical mother that can with her magic wand can turn a
- 2:16:26special needs kid into a genius that's going to college. So I guess that
- 2:16:31would be against but putting her in an apartment, I guess I'm guessing she
- 2:16:35had this fantasy that somehow if she put her in this white trash you know
- 2:16:39her words town, then everyone would just forget her. She would just fall
- 2:16:45into this whole of poverty and working class or white trash neighborhood and she would
- 2:16:52just like drift away, Like doesn't make any sense, right, the human
- 2:16:58being is still or that maybe she would ruin her life, or she would
- 2:17:03do things like become addicted to something or get involved sexually with someone, and
- 2:17:09then she could say, well you look at her, you know, yeah,
- 2:17:13I could see her. Who knows, all as specuative, but anyway,
- 2:17:18let's see what he says here during that time after Florida and before the
- 2:17:24Chacon's released you, that six month period. Wait, what is he saying?
- 2:17:28What period of time? What's he saying during that time after Florida and
- 2:17:35before the Chacon's released you, that six month period after Florida and before the
- 2:17:41Chacones released you. I don't know if I knew about this time. And
- 2:17:45so they went to Florida and I think had met her Natalia. Natalia claims
- 2:17:52that all the parents met each other, but Michael claims he never actually met
- 2:17:56the Chaconi's in person. Who knows, But it sounds like there was a
- 2:18:01six month period in waiting to actually get all the adoption situation worked out.
- 2:18:09Is that what am I missing? Something? Something was wrong, something was
- 2:18:13off during that time. I had a conversation with the monster about look,
- 2:18:24things aren't working right. Maybe this is no harm, no foul. We
- 2:18:28don't have to do anything because you legally were still theirs. Maybe maybe we
- 2:18:33just walk away from this, Okay. So he's saying that something was off.
- 2:18:37What was off? And he says that they were he was suggesting to
- 2:18:43Christine that they back out of the adoption. Okay. I could see that.
- 2:18:48I could see him thinking, now, you know, we don't know
- 2:18:50enough information, or we're hearing a couple of things that are concerning okay,
- 2:18:56cooler jets. And that was that with a very very very very very very
- 2:19:01very very very stern though, why the deeper? Why? Okay, So
- 2:19:09he's hearing he's saying that Christine was adamant about getting Natalia, and the speculation
- 2:19:18that I think, you know, it's coherent. It's hard to know because
- 2:19:24it would be hard to demonstrate this with any sort of facts, but that
- 2:19:28she Christine was determined to find the most disadvantaged child to adopt so that she
- 2:19:35could waiver her magic wand and I haven't said this out loud, but I
- 2:19:41think that that if that all that is true, which is you know,
- 2:19:43just speculation upon speculation, then that does point towards narcissism potentially, because the
- 2:19:50narcissistic individual will believe their own bullshit. They'll believe they can do anything they
- 2:19:56need to believe that they can do any you know, not anything, but
- 2:20:00whatever their wherever their narcissistic supply is coming from, they will lean into because
- 2:20:05it's finally getting them the validation or at least pseudo validation that they desperately wanted
- 2:20:11since they were born and never really got. So it's possible that because randomly
- 2:20:16one of her sons, and you know, she might have had a hand,
- 2:20:20she probably did in at least being a good enough parent so that Jacob
- 2:20:24could succeed in academics. You know, she probably was instrumental, and since
- 2:20:31peerc is the primary parent, she probably was fairly instrumental. But there wasn't
- 2:20:35anything magical about her parenting. It was it was his own work, Jacob
- 2:20:41and maybe his neurodivergence that helped him in some way so that he achieved that
- 2:20:46and it was independent of her, and a lot of parents would have had
- 2:20:52a similar result, if not better. You know, but she because you
- 2:20:56know, this is all speculative, but she needs it to be true because
- 2:21:00it's like, oh, I'm worth something now and I need to lean into
- 2:21:03that I write this book. It's not about my son, it's about me,
- 2:21:07you know, the spark that I did, you know, And then
- 2:21:09all the interviews I'm going to go there. I'm going to be in the
- 2:21:11interviews. I you know, I'm this wonderful person, I'm the best.
- 2:21:18Well, what better way for me to demonstrate that than to do it again?
- 2:21:20But to do it with someone that is so disadvantaged in my head that
- 2:21:26it would be undoubtable that I have this magical power, and then believing that
- 2:21:31right, believing that it will work because I'm awesome. That's just a fact.
- 2:21:39Now. Meanwhile, underneath all of that, with narcissistic people is a
- 2:21:43much louder voice, just the whole ocean of low self esteem or even no
- 2:21:50self esteem, just like no sense of who they are as a human being
- 2:21:52because they were denied that sort of attunement reaction from their caregivers growing up.
- 2:22:00It's not like their entire person is believing any of these things. It's it
- 2:22:05could be argue that a tiny portion of them is desperately holding on to this
- 2:22:09idea that they're at least worth it, if not perfect. So I guess
- 2:22:15you know that is it's interesting. It's a fascinating case. She saw the
- 2:22:20adoption, especially the adoption of somebody with special needs, as a societal thing.
- 2:22:30The one thing we can always count on is evil sure does love her
- 2:22:35some attention and some cameras and some eyes on her. Yeah, you know.
- 2:22:41And this is in line with a similar problem with individuals called Munchausen or
- 2:22:48Munchausen by proxy, and it's also called fectitious disorder and posts on another which
- 2:22:54I haven't been using that term because I don't know. I'm old, so
- 2:22:58I still use the old term. But if you want a full deep dive,
- 2:23:01I did a whole deep dive when I watched the Gypsy Rose documentary when
- 2:23:07it first came out years ago. And it's similar to that, where you
- 2:23:13have an individual that is so desperate for attention, usually because a trauma doesn't
- 2:23:18justify it, but they need it so badly because you know, as a
- 2:23:22parent, a healthy parent with you know, a low amount of relational traumas
- 2:23:28in their life. They want to be recognized as a good parent, that's
- 2:23:31normal, that's okay. They want to be appreciated by at least their partner,
- 2:23:37maybe even the occasional teacher says yeah, I got a great kid on
- 2:23:41your hands. You know, it feels good. There's nothing wrong with that.
- 2:23:43Being a parent isn't one hundred percent selfless. It'd be weird if it
- 2:23:48was. So, you know, there's some hope there and maybe even a
- 2:23:52little bit of fishing for that at times, and that's okay. But if
- 2:23:58you have no self esteem and you're in a constant treadmill running away from the
- 2:24:03traumas, you need a lot of it. And one of the ways to
- 2:24:07do that is through Bunchausen by proxy, by poisoning your child and creating all
- 2:24:13these problems so that you can be held up as this wonderful parent who is
- 2:24:18taking care and nursing a child, you know, where other parents would have
- 2:24:24just rejected this kid or whatever. And that seems to be the motivation for
- 2:24:28many with Munchausen by proxy. And then I guess we don't have a word
- 2:24:33for it. I guess you could call it Munchausen adjacent or something where an
- 2:24:39individual would want to adopt a child that had a lot of disadvantages and they
- 2:24:46wanted to instagram it and write books about it and have people say what a
- 2:24:52wonderful human being you are. You know, it wouldn't be hard to speculate
- 2:24:56about some people on YouTube or Instagram around this. You know, I talked
- 2:25:00about Mikus Staffer, and I don't know the full story on that, of
- 2:25:03course, but at least that was the allegation, and so that is interesting.
- 2:25:09I think that's what he's getting at and people worshiping her. She wrote
- 2:25:13out a full one page piece of paper once explaining to me why she qualifies
- 2:25:18for sainthood based on the two miracles she's performed. That's what we're dealing with.
- 2:25:24Wait, so he could be lying. Everyone could be lying, but
- 2:25:31if we at least entertain this he's saying that she had written, let's ruin.
- 2:25:37She wrote out a full one page piece of paper once explaining to me
- 2:25:43why she qualifies for sainthood based on the two miracles she's performed. So who
- 2:25:48knows what that piece of paper was because he could be spinning it right now.
- 2:25:54It could have been a piece of paper that she wrote. You know,
- 2:25:58they were going back and forth, arguing with each other, and she's
- 2:26:01like, look, you got to recognize that I am a good person because
- 2:26:03da da da dah. You know it's not it's a different spin. But
- 2:26:07but it is possible. I guess at the very least, there's the allegation
- 2:26:13or the claim that she considered herself to be this wonderful person because of Jacob
- 2:26:22and because of Natalia. So now some people can have that that need,
- 2:26:31that selfish need, and still be a good parent and still not be abusive.
- 2:26:35They might be a little into themselves and a little cold, a little
- 2:26:39not really paying attention to the child child, you know, instead paying too
- 2:26:43much attention to how things are coming across. So it's you know, there's
- 2:26:46a spectrum there. But given everything we've heard, you know we could because
- 2:26:52it is weird, right, Like I think I've entertained this question before.
- 2:26:56If the allegations about Christine are true, to confirmed a lot of it and
- 2:27:01added a lot. So if that's true, why would that person adopt someone?
- 2:27:07Right, there's an easy way to avoid having to deal with a child
- 2:27:13that has issues or traumas. The first option on the list is just don't
- 2:27:18adopt the child, and adopting a child there is so much hassle. The
- 2:27:22way they framed it in the first season, it was like, lu could
- 2:27:26he split? You have twenty four hours to decide, But now we're hearing
- 2:27:28that there's been six months, which is much more common. You know,
- 2:27:33the bureaucracy and all the things that have to be worked out, it strangely
- 2:27:37takes a long ass time. So there's some other reason. There's to be
- 2:27:41some reason as to why she would even be into it. And it sounds
- 2:27:46like she was the primary engineer of the whole thing, and so there must
- 2:27:50be some screwed up ulterior motive, which I think we could speculate us to
- 2:27:56what that is. That's what we're dealing with. So when you're dealing with
- 2:27:58that level of narcissists, it's vaguely possible. It's funny ninety nine point nine
- 2:28:05to nine percent of the time whenever I'm reacting to something on this channel and
- 2:28:11someone says narcissist or narcissism, they're not using the term in the same way
- 2:28:16that at least I and other experts would use. But in this instance,
- 2:28:22I think he is. I don't know if that's just a clock, a
- 2:28:24broken clock being right twice a day, or if he actually understands what the
- 2:28:30term means. I don't know that she saw the adoption as a Aren't I
- 2:28:35a great person? Everyone look at me. Hey, neighbors, Look,
- 2:28:41I'm so wonderful. I'm so wonderful. I'm so charitable. She compared herself
- 2:28:46to Oprah regularly. She was going to be the Oprah for a artistic kid.
- 2:28:50That's a sha and that's believable. We don't know, but it's believable.
- 2:28:54And he has a reason to fabricate. But we could see that,
- 2:28:58and that is an interesting detail. We could imagine that, and that does
- 2:29:05point in the narcissism direction. This, you know, this overblown sense of
- 2:29:11who you are and your importance and this need. You know, like Oprah
- 2:29:16herself probably never said I'm going to be the next you know whatever, because
- 2:29:22successful people, you know, they have a goal, but they're not grandiose.
- 2:29:28Typically some are. But I don't know what, I don't know Oprah,
- 2:29:33maybe you know, but I get. My point is is that when
- 2:29:35I meet someone and they have that kind of talk, I usually am thinking,
- 2:29:41well, maybe, but really, this says something about you as a
- 2:29:45person. What do I say. There's nothing wrong with someone saying I want
- 2:29:48to do something fantastic with my life, you know, like I would talk
- 2:29:52to a teenager and they would say, I want to be the next Lebron
- 2:29:56James, and I wouldn't say that they were narcissistic. So what am I
- 2:29:58sa I'm saying When you add that in to all the other data, if
- 2:30:05we believe half or more of it, it does completely fit within the hypothesis
- 2:30:11that narcissistic person I is short is a viable hypothesis for diagnosis, because that
- 2:30:18is something that narcissistic people will will do, is they'll they're fixated on those
- 2:30:24kinds of comparisons and on those kinds of achievements and having other people see those
- 2:30:28achievements, right, Because the thing that you would hope someone in that position
- 2:30:33would say is, well, I don't know how the world's going to see
- 2:30:37me. You know, maybe I'll be the next Oprah for special needs kids,
- 2:30:39whatever, it doesn't matter. But why I'm doing this is for the
- 2:30:43kids because I want to give back to the community. So what does it
- 2:30:50matter how I'm seen? You know what I mean. I've heard this so
- 2:30:52many times. So my assumption is the reason that she wouldn't undo where we
- 2:30:58were all those people that were, Hey, look at me, look at
- 2:31:03me, look at me. Aren't I great? Aren't I great? Aren't
- 2:31:03I great? Wait? What do you mean, where's my newly adopted daughter?
- 2:31:07Oh? Hell, I gotta explain this. Oh interesting, Okay,
- 2:31:13So he's saying that before they even got her, she had already been bragging
- 2:31:20again, which is his word. Who knows, but given other things we've
- 2:31:24heard, we can't imagine that, and she didn't want to be seen.
- 2:31:30So maybe even she knew by that point that like, oh, you know,
- 2:31:35there might be some red flags here, but I would rather go ahead
- 2:31:41with it in the short term because I don't want to have any sort of
- 2:31:43humiliation. Did she tell you why she took me out of school? I
- 2:31:48was told that you were a danger to the other students, that you were
- 2:31:52ramming your wheelchair into them on purpose, that you had taken your parking break
- 2:31:56off the wheelchair and hit it. Blah blah. We don't need to get
- 2:31:58into this. This is what I remember, is Christine telling me that she
- 2:32:03was getting a phone call at nine o'clock every single day. Yeah. I
- 2:32:05think a lot of things can be true here. You know. It could
- 2:32:09be that she was homeschooled by Christine because Christine wanted to manage image by isolating
- 2:32:20Natalia from the world. Because of Natalia's out there in the world people can
- 2:32:24talk about Natalia, So there's that motivation. There's also the It also could
- 2:32:30be true that the family was getting called by the school frequently about Natalia's behavior.
- 2:32:37I mean, it's rough for any kid, but if you're from another
- 2:32:45country, you are in a wheelchair, you have trauma issues that lead to
- 2:32:52some behaviors, maybe aggressive behaviors when someone is bothering you, you don't use
- 2:32:58your words to work it out. You know, it's pretty normal. And
- 2:33:01given one's history, you can imagine, given her history, you can imagine
- 2:33:05that being extra you know, we could. It would be weird if it
- 2:33:07wasn't present. Honestly, So during his parent teacher conference, where there are
- 2:33:13any compoints made that of steel chair incidents, yes, the teacher stated that
- 2:33:18Italian had hit children with the chair. She never never once said that is
- 2:33:24a thousand and ten percent. Oh so we are going to talk to the
- 2:33:28teacher. That's amazing, So that is ony ten percent false. Wow,
- 2:33:35what her behavior was nothing but extraordinary? Did she ever cause you any problems?
- 2:33:43Oh my gosh, no, she was like yeah. And then I'm
- 2:33:45thinking, well maybe one of the teachers, but what about others? And
- 2:33:48then you're talking to the principle. Wow, I'm getting chills because if that's
- 2:33:52not true, then maybe the entire fucking thing is made up. Wow.
- 2:34:03That is shocking. That is shocking. I mean, there's a chance that
- 2:34:11the teachers don't remember it was a while ago, but they sound pretty sure
- 2:34:15of themselves, and maybe they would worry that they're going to get canceled if
- 2:34:18they're on the wrong side of this documentary. I'm just trying to fink this
- 2:34:22out, but it's absolutely possible that Natalia was an exceptionally good kid in school,
- 2:34:31which would really throw everything into question because when you have kids with conduct
- 2:34:39disorder or burgeoning, antisocial or defiance, one of the things that we would
- 2:34:46look at very closely is does that child do those behaviors in all contexts,
- 2:34:54because if there's something wrong with the child, that wrongness follows them ever where
- 2:35:00they go, Whereas if you only see the concerning behavior in one context,
- 2:35:05it could be something about that context that's exacerbating something or even creating it.
- 2:35:11So, for example, if you have a kid who is you know,
- 2:35:16you have teachers that are claiming that the kid has ADHD and very distractable.
- 2:35:20But then when I evaluate the child in my office, and they're not distractable,
- 2:35:26then what does that say? It's what it says is that the child
- 2:35:31doesn't have a condition that's causing their distractableness. There's something about school, there's
- 2:35:37something about the environment, and so we want to look at that, right,
- 2:35:41similar to differences in behavior between school and home. So if at school
- 2:35:48for but it's also hard to know how long she was there because other adoptive
- 2:35:54parents would say that she was wonderful too. But it's possible that Natalia's first
- 2:35:58few months with the Barnett's was also wonderful, that's not and then her issue
- 2:36:05started to emerge. That's almost universally the case in these situations because for the
- 2:36:11I don't know about, I tell you, But for people that have those
- 2:36:15kind of traumas that result in them acting out and being aggressive or even machiavellian
- 2:36:20and harmful, they they know enough to exert a lot of control over their
- 2:36:28behavior at first so that they don't get in trouble or they don't get rejected
- 2:36:31right, and then once they feel it more safe, they start to relax
- 2:36:35those controls because it's impossible to keep that up forever. And then those behaviors
- 2:36:41start to come out. So you know, I guess I would really want
- 2:36:45to know how long. If it was only a few weeks, that's one
- 2:36:48thing, but if it was a full year, that's a different thing.
- 2:36:50I mean, it is data. My teacher said that she never had to
- 2:36:54call Christine. Oh but right at the very least, we're hearing that the
- 2:37:00teacher never told Christine that information. And wow, just that we have an
- 2:37:09example of just flat out big time lying, right, Wow, that I
- 2:37:16didn't do what Christine was claiming that I didn't nothing, And then why would
- 2:37:22she pull her out of school? Right? Then you have to think,
- 2:37:24well, it can't be for any good reason. It must be because of
- 2:37:28something nefarious, right, because if she's doing well in school, why,
- 2:37:33you know, take it from any parent that had kids in grade school during
- 2:37:39the pandemic, Homeschooling a kid is not fun. Now, maybe some parents
- 2:37:45enjoyed it, but you know, as soon as the school's opened up,
- 2:37:48there weren't a lot of parents that said, no, I want my kid
- 2:37:50to stay home with me all day. You know, not that kids aren't
- 2:37:54wonderful, they are, but you know, trying to teach a kid at
- 2:38:00home while they're you know, they have all their distractions and there's no kind
- 2:38:07of group think. You know, there's something beneficial to having a bunch of
- 2:38:11kids together that are all doing the same thing, right, there's a there's
- 2:38:13a pressure to go along with the program. So why why the homeschool is
- 2:38:18the thing? Nobody did any of the things she accused everyone of doing.
- 2:38:24Did you cant Talia while getting people with a wheelchair? Yes, Natalia stated,
- 2:38:31I want to hurt the other kids. Oh and then the coaching by
- 2:38:37Christine to make her Natalia say yes I did those things, the pepper spray
- 2:38:43and all that horribleness. I mean, when we hear this scenario, which
- 2:38:48we could believe, it sort of moves the needle a little bit for me
- 2:38:50with Michael and how responsible he was, right, because if he's hearing a
- 2:38:54lot of this stuff and then hears it from Natalia, then you know,
- 2:38:58you could imagine that being very concerning to you, and drastic action might be
- 2:39:05justified. It doesn't exonerate him by any means. You know, at this
- 2:39:09point, I'm more like he's sixty percent responsible. When Natalia lived with she
- 2:39:16was homeschool so at every stop and that Natalia has been. There are all
- 2:39:20these reports about her averrate behavior. Now there's another possibility that Michael was completely
- 2:39:26on board with the whole thing. He might have that need for that narcissistic
- 2:39:31supply as well of being seen as a saint, and he might have been
- 2:39:37completely on board with Yeah, yeah, let's let's get her out of the
- 2:39:39schools. Okay? Would we say if you don't tell her when I was
- 2:39:50a baby? But I think she didn't know any of that. Again,
- 2:39:54the producers of this documentary or whatever we want to call it, are non
- 2:40:01consensually sharing information. I mean, you have a child that just said I'll
- 2:40:05tell you if you don't tell Natalia. Because you know, children, they
- 2:40:09don't necessarily understand the broader context here, and you would think they would include
- 2:40:13this now, maybe after they asked her, so you know that Natalia's going
- 2:40:18to see this potentially, is it okay if we publish it? And the
- 2:40:20kids said okay? But I doubt it, right, So it's pretty gross.
- 2:40:26They just shouldn't have included this. You're using a child, I yeah.
- 2:40:33So moving on, we hear that she is saying, oh, you
- 2:40:39know, she bit me, and you know one siblings do that sometimes two.
- 2:40:48Given her history with the Barnetts alone, right, this is the man's
- 2:40:54family, this is one of the kids, and the Natalia would have went
- 2:41:00to live with the Mans in my notes, do I have exactly when that
- 2:41:03happened. Twenty fourteen was when she connected with Cynthia Mans and then she moved
- 2:41:09in three days later, so and that was I think soon after. You
- 2:41:16know, she was in an apartment and Talia was in an apartment for maybe
- 2:41:20one or two years, and then in Lafayette met Cynthia Mans and then moved
- 2:41:26in there. Anyway, so it would be also normal for Italia to have
- 2:41:33some behavioral problems given what she's been through, also what she went through with
- 2:41:39the Barnetts alone, Right, So I think that's all that we're hearing.
- 2:41:43It's not great, but it's it's not an indication that Italia is some sort
- 2:41:48of psychopathic, con artist monster. He did but she said it was like
- 2:41:52when she was ten and she did it okay, according to the sibling.
- 2:42:03I think this is a sibling. It happened when Natalia was ten. It
- 2:42:09sounds like Natalia told her that she did it and felt bad about it.
- 2:42:13I think that's what we're hearing. And so ten. Yeah, that would
- 2:42:16have been at the very beginning of her moving in with the man's family.
- 2:42:22So you know, you could imagine an adjustment period there, a jealousy of
- 2:42:26a younger child that's getting attention. It's normal, it's not great, but
- 2:42:30it's it's again, not an indication that she's a psychopathic monster. Perfect.
- 2:42:45The man's took her to the hospital Saint Franciscan, and you know, the
- 2:42:48report was she'd harmed one of their children and that she had been disruptive in
- 2:42:54the house, she had been violent. Okay, so wait, I wish
- 2:42:58we could just read that report. Let's let's see if I can get a
- 2:43:01screenshot of it. Okay, so I just read through the report. I
- 2:43:05got a little screenshot of it, and long story short, it appears that
- 2:43:11Cynthia Man's or Antoine Man's, one of them brought her into the er in
- 2:43:16twenty thirteen because she was being violent with the other kid, the kid that
- 2:43:22was interviewed earlier. So there seemed to be that and you know the fact
- 2:43:26that they brought her to the er says something, right, because if it
- 2:43:31was just a bite and then it's like, hey, don't do that,
- 2:43:33that's one thing. It typically what happens if you're bringing a kid to the
- 2:43:37er. They're out of control ongoing, right, and so there's as possibility.
- 2:43:43Now in the report, it didn't didn't say anything about that, so
- 2:43:46it could have been just they just didn't know what to do and they bring
- 2:43:50her to the er and the incident was minor, but it doesn't seem likely
- 2:43:54now. It would be expected. It would be unfortunate that they younger daughter
- 2:44:00was being harmed in that way, but given everything that's happening, you know,
- 2:44:05it's understandable that Natalia would have some acting out. And then the report
- 2:44:09went on to talk about what Natalia's reasoning for being upset, and according to
- 2:44:16the report, Natalia said that she doesn't like it when people talk about her
- 2:44:20past, which we could imagine, so she's saying that's what that's what triggered
- 2:44:24her. So maybe the mans were asking about her past and then that's I
- 2:44:28guess if that happened, which is speculative, we can imagine that Natalia would
- 2:44:33be worried that if she brings up the past, that will cause her to
- 2:44:37be rejected by the man's who she has this burgeoning attachment with the report was
- 2:44:43she'd harmed one of their children and that she had been disruptive in the house,
- 2:44:48she had been violent and they wanted to leave her there and she wasn't
- 2:44:52welcome back in their home. And there was also additional parts of that report
- 2:44:56where Natalia wanted to take a taxi to go back to the mans allegedly when
- 2:45:00the hospital reached them. Okay, so there's another report again twenty thirteen.
- 2:45:05I think this is at the hospital spoke with patient about following up with the
- 2:45:09resources given to her by social work. Explained to patient the people that brought
- 2:45:13her in do not want to be contacted by her, after she stated she
- 2:45:18had tried to call them fourteen times that they didn't answer. That's interesting.
- 2:45:20So it sounds like the man's family were saying, look, she's just someone
- 2:45:26that we befriended who lives nearby. We felt bad for a situation. We
- 2:45:31opened up our home to her at times, and she went after our So
- 2:45:37that says something about the severity of the attack, right, because or I
- 2:45:41don't know, maybe it could have been minor. And the man's family just
- 2:45:43like, look, we don't just don't want to. So they said we're
- 2:45:46done with her. And she called them fourteen times and they didn't answer,
- 2:45:52which is consistent with other things that we'd heard. You know, when she
- 2:45:56was in the apartment by herself, she was really desperate, which makes sense.
- 2:46:00And then going on, she said that they were going to give her
- 2:46:03a ride home and told her we would give her a taxi voucher to get
- 2:46:07home. Patient didn't seem to understand why they wouldn't want to have her around
- 2:46:11the house because she states they are such good friends. She said she would
- 2:46:13try to get hold of them again tomorrow. I encourage her to try to
- 2:46:16call one time and if they didn't answer, she should leave them alone.
- 2:46:18Asked Patient if it was okay to call her adoptive parents and talk with them
- 2:46:22about what is going on, and she agreed. I called the adoptive dad.
- 2:46:26So this is just a little side note. This is a very typical
- 2:46:31progress note or medical note, and in my field we have similar notes and
- 2:46:37are required to keep those records in our sessions or contact with our clients.
- 2:46:41And one of the things that I have a pet peeve with my supervises is
- 2:46:46that they won't use complete senses. You know, there's all these phrases and
- 2:46:52often they will leave out the subject of the sentence. So because I'm inserting
- 2:46:56it as I'm reading it, the sentence actually is it just starts it's with
- 2:47:00asked patient if it was okay? So there's no subject who asked patient if
- 2:47:05it was okay? Well, the implication is it's I asked because the author
- 2:47:11is a registered nurse. You can see that at the top, So the
- 2:47:15nurse is writing it, and it's like, why not just say I.
- 2:47:18It doesn't take long to type I I asked patient. And when I ask
- 2:47:22people, including medical professionals, why they leave that out, they provide no
- 2:47:28viable answer. The answers I'll get are well, it's what we've always done,
- 2:47:33or it's what I was taught to do, or I thought that this
- 2:47:37was more of a professional looking sort of note, because I think somehow it
- 2:47:43got into people's heads when they were learning how to write academically in high school
- 2:47:48or something that if you can't say I, but it's much more clear,
- 2:47:52you know. Progress notes are supposed to be understandable and and understandable not only
- 2:47:58to other clinicians, of course, but also to the patient because patients have
- 2:48:01access to these and they have to some extent a legal right to these notes,
- 2:48:07and therefore it should be written so that they can understand them. You
- 2:48:11know, I was taught that your notes should be understandable at like an eighth
- 2:48:15grade reading level, not at a doctoral reading level like US clinicians. So
- 2:48:20you have to not use jargon. You have to be understandable, has to
- 2:48:24be clear to the point. And so you know, someone reading this would
- 2:48:28say, asked patient and plus they use the abbreviation PT for patient, and
- 2:48:33I get that because you know you're typing patient so often. But at the
- 2:48:37same time, it doesn't it doesn't take a long time, and you don't
- 2:48:41print these outs. You're not wasting ink. Just type out patient. It's
- 2:48:43not hard. But that's okay because you know you could tell someone but asked
- 2:48:50patient and then the next sent and called the adoptive dat just say I called
- 2:48:54who called? Because the other thing is sometimes you have a team of people
- 2:48:58that are doing things and someone else called, and if you don't include the
- 2:49:03subject of the action, then it can be ambiguous and you need to be
- 2:49:09very clear. So yeah, all my supervisors have heard me get on them
- 2:49:13about this. It's plus, like, what would be the bad consequence to
- 2:49:18having a full sentence, I called, like, what would be the viable
- 2:49:22criticism against that? Anyway, if you have any ideas about this, tell
- 2:49:28me, because you know, just seeing actual medical professionals do this stuff too,
- 2:49:31it just I don't understand. Now, this note is fine because you
- 2:49:37can basically tell, but they're much more egregious situ Like if you're a family
- 2:49:43therapist and you're seeing the parents and like three kids, and you start sentences
- 2:49:46that don't have subjects in it, then you don't. It is ambiguous.
- 2:49:52You know, if say, you know, talked to child about their trauma
- 2:49:56history, well who was it the therapist or the parent? You know anyway
- 2:50:01called the adoptive dad, adopted and the advocate. So I think the Barnett's
- 2:50:05who said a lot of our history and attempted to murder two times adoptive mother,
- 2:50:11one time by poisoning and the other time by electric fence. The electric
- 2:50:13fence thing. So that's interesting because most of the time we're hearing about the
- 2:50:18poisoning, but at this point at least Christine is still focusing on the electric
- 2:50:24fence. And that's not super plausible, right that you would you know,
- 2:50:33and I've already been over that. So it's another detail that adds because if
- 2:50:37there was something else in there, like she tried to stab me once or
- 2:50:39something, then it would be harder to refute. But the notion that this
- 2:50:48very tiny person who has a hard time even walking would have even the remote
- 2:50:54ability, let alone the notion themselves that they could actually push someone into electric
- 2:51:00Plus I don't think electric fences would be strong enough to kill someone anyway.
- 2:51:05He also states that she has been in and out of psych facilities and as
- 2:51:07danger to society. She manipulates people in a caring about her and then plans
- 2:51:11ways to physically harm them. He also, oh, so this is Michael
- 2:51:13talking. He also states that she is not from the uk from the Ukraine,
- 2:51:20so that's their word. He also states that she is not from form
- 2:51:24the Ukraine and as fake documents to make it appear that she is from there.
- 2:51:28That's interesting. So was that in season one that they were thinking that
- 2:51:33that she wasn't from right, They thought that she was an impostor. She
- 2:51:37wasn't even Natalia, she was this impostor. So they were still thinking that
- 2:51:43or believing that, or trying to make other people believe that. So huh
- 2:51:48out to the Mans. They're told she can't come back, she's not welcome.
- 2:51:52We don't want her calling us anymore. When you look at all the
- 2:51:56families that she's been connected to that we are aware of, from the Chacons
- 2:52:01to the Barnets to the Mans, all of these families are reporting similar instances
- 2:52:05where Natalia has inflicted harm on a family MEMBERY Yeah, And I've been saying
- 2:52:11from the beginning that it is quite possible that the Barnett's claims, not necessarily
- 2:52:18the poisoning or the electric fence, but the you know, at the foot
- 2:52:22of the bed with the knife, or the smearing of the feces on the
- 2:52:26siblings, or other kinds of harmful, abusive behavior from Natalia to others.
- 2:52:35It's possible that it absolutely did happen, but it doesn't mean that she's this
- 2:52:39you know, irredeemable monster, or that all the other allegations are true as
- 2:52:45well, you know what I mean. So that is interesting though, because
- 2:52:48to get that report that was given by the Mans, you know, it's
- 2:52:54not the Barnetts, it's the Man's who are are so at some point Natalia
- 2:52:58must have made up with them, and presumably those kinds of things didn't happen
- 2:53:03at least to nearly that degree because they've been with her for so many years.
- 2:53:07Are we all saying that all of these folks are wrong and or liars
- 2:53:11and that Natalia is simply this innocent bystander. She's this innocent wallflower who's just
- 2:53:16well, the lawyer's doing a good job at trying to paint a picture.
- 2:53:20But the amount of people, at least we've seen a documentary is to the
- 2:53:24actual first hand accounts. It's mainly Christine and now we have an account from
- 2:53:30the man's and Michael, but mainly Christine because we don't have well, you
- 2:53:35might be referring to accounts from the Chickcnes, but I feel like we would
- 2:53:39have seen that if they had access to that, So it's not like it's
- 2:53:43this mountain of evidence. Oh and then from the hospital there was there were
- 2:53:48accounts, but not as severe as what Christine was saying. Anyway, I
- 2:53:52never even spoke with the hospital people because she was an adult, so they
- 2:53:58would not let me in with her. I feel like Christine definitely must have
- 2:54:05called the hospital and told them that this is what happened in all these things,
- 2:54:11because those are not my words I don't know who drew that up.
- 2:54:15Who wrote, Wait, what patient brought to er by friend tonight? I'm
- 2:54:20guessing that's Cynthia for a psychiatric evaluation after becoming very angry earlier today and attacking
- 2:54:26her friend's daughter, so that today while patient was at school, advocate that
- 2:54:37I don't know, this sounds fishy because the nurse is saying, you've called
- 2:54:41the man's fourteen times, they're not answering, and the man's told us they
- 2:54:46don't want you to be with them anymore. So I don't know. I
- 2:54:48have a hard time believing that the nurse would call Christine. And it's also
- 2:54:56it looks like, you know, they called Michael. Not that that wouldn't
- 2:55:00necessarily change the allegation here, but I have our time believing that the nurse
- 2:55:03would call the family, the Barnetts, and then Christine would influence, and
- 2:55:07then the nurse would actually because you know, the language is pretty precise,
- 2:55:11so the nurse would be much more likely to say, I called the advocate
- 2:55:16previous, you know, adoptive parents, and here's what they told me,
- 2:55:20you know. So yeah, and the report doesn't really say anything about what
- 2:55:30Cynthia might have said today. Patient was at school her advocate Da da da
- 2:55:33da. She states patient friends spoke to her advocate today on the phone.
- 2:55:37Oh I think I missed that. So what triggered her, according to Natalia,
- 2:55:41which is in this report, is that I think Cynthia spoke to Christine
- 2:55:48or Michael today on the phone about past the past, and then that's what
- 2:55:54triggered her. So that's what she's saying anyway. Yeah, so we can
- 2:55:58imagine that even being more threatening, right because if Atalia is like desperate for
- 2:56:03any kind of person to pay attention to remember, like at this point she's
- 2:56:05like nine or ten years old, so she finally found some people that would
- 2:56:11take her in and give her at least some attention. And then Cynthia calls
- 2:56:18the adoptive mom, which you know would make sense that this concerned adults would
- 2:56:24say like, oh, maybe I should talk to you. Yeah, So
- 2:56:26that happens, and then that triggers in Talia to be like, oh no,
- 2:56:31I'm gonna you're going to be influenced by them, you know, And
- 2:56:33because she doesn't have a way of expressing, you know, like a maybe
- 2:56:37her today would go to Cynthia, say I got to tell you something about
- 2:56:41Cynthia, like if you or Christine, I got it. I got to
- 2:56:43tell you something about Christine. If then you know. But at that age,
- 2:56:48with those traumas, the behavior is is violence and anger that but that
- 2:56:54was not was said. Can we go back a little bit wherever you want?
- 2:57:01So now I'm wondering because you know, they've been interviewing the man's and
- 2:57:03they've been speaking very glowingly about Natalia this whole time, so that kind of
- 2:57:09throws it into the question. You know, maybe they have a bone to
- 2:57:11pick with Christine and they're downplaying things. I don't know. I don't have
- 2:57:16much to go off of, but there's something fishy. You're over there and
- 2:57:20she gets you to hear, stay out of my way or you'll never see
- 2:57:26your sons again, and she launches you on the ground and the usual who
- 2:57:33are you? Where have you been? And she's wailing. I don't know
- 2:57:37if I've talked about this yet, but as I often will talk about PTSD,
- 2:57:43complex PTSD trauma reactivity is difficult, obviously, and when triggered, the
- 2:57:50symptoms can become much worse, and a common trigger for people's PTSD symptoms is
- 2:57:56to recall the event that traumatize them to either themselves to remember it or to
- 2:58:05talk about it, or to have other people talk about it or see images
- 2:58:09of it, or have smells that remind them of it, or other kinds
- 2:58:11of triggers to the memory. So it's important clinically for me and others like
- 2:58:18me in my field to take care when clients are about to talk about the
- 2:58:26traumas that they've been through. We need to do a lot of upfront work.
- 2:58:28I think I did talk about this in an early video about you know,
- 2:58:31emotional regulation. There's just a lot of prep that I go through with
- 2:58:35clients before we even begin to talk about before I even encourage them to think
- 2:58:39about the traumas that they've been through. And so as I'm watching this documentary,
- 2:58:46I'm seeing Natalia, you know, talk about the traumas that she's been
- 2:58:50through and the way she talks about and I think she even said as much
- 2:58:52that she doesn't like to think about it, which is normal for people with
- 2:58:56me and I don't know if she has PTSD. You can have trauma,
- 2:58:58major trauma and not develop PTSD. You can develop a lot of other trauma
- 2:59:03reactions, you know. PTSD is just one of the effects possible effects of
- 2:59:09that kind of trauma. So I don't know if she has PTSD, and
- 2:59:13if she doesn't have PTSD then it's less of a concern. But you know,
- 2:59:18so I've been wondering how she's doing as the documentary is asking her to
- 2:59:24recall and in this moment he Michael is describing in full detail. He's also
- 2:59:31being really demonstrative, and he's role playing as if he's Christine, and he's
- 2:59:35pointing at her and saying like, you know, I'm just thinking, like
- 2:59:41tone it down a little bit and so, and he could be traumatized by
- 2:59:45it too. He could be triggering himself in this moment too. So as
- 2:59:50she has this reaction right now where she seems overwhelmed or sad or you know,
- 2:59:54something's coming up for her, I don't know which one it is.
- 2:59:58If it's if it's a spike that's high in distress, then that's indicative of
- 3:00:03PTSD, which would tell us that we shouldn't have her exposed to these stories
- 3:00:11by asking her questions or by telling her a story until she has recovered from
- 3:00:16PTSD sufficiently. However, if her reaction is just the kind of feelings you
- 3:00:24get of sadness and pain, emotional pain that you feel when you recall something
- 3:00:33that was bad that happened to you. Then that isn't it's not likely to
- 3:00:39be damaging to one hear about the story and two to have emotions in this
- 3:00:45moment. But I don't know which one it is, and maybe we'll see
- 3:00:48some indications here. So I when I watch these shows, you know,
- 3:00:54I think there's this. You know, of course the documentarians are they're just
- 3:01:01champion at the bit to get these kinds of scenes, you know, recalling
- 3:01:03the trauma and the emotions. And I don't blame them for not knowing these
- 3:01:09kinds of things. I mean, maybe they should look into it if they're
- 3:01:11professionals, but you know, I don't know. I just wish that Natalia
- 3:01:20had a therapist that would sign off on these things like okay, because if
- 3:01:24she were my client, I would assess this obviously, and then if PTSD
- 3:01:28was present, I would say, you can't go into that material until we
- 3:01:33get to that point in our therapy. You could actually make your PTSD worse
- 3:01:37if you go into those stories and those narratives. It can actually cause us
- 3:01:41huge spike and distress and fear and terror That can make the original traumas even
- 3:01:50more avoided, because there's yet another reason to avoid those those emotions. And
- 3:01:58therefore, as the next time you're triggered, you'll have an even bigger distress
- 3:02:03reaction and perhaps more dissociation or more acting out or whatever. So I'm stunned
- 3:02:07from what's going on. I'm just I'm shocked. I'm frozen in fear.
- 3:02:13And I know for a fact, if I do anything, I never see
- 3:02:18Wesley Ethan or Jacob ever again. And I hate to put it to you
- 3:02:22in that fashion, but I just wanted to have my family altogether, so
- 3:02:28I start recording it. It's notable just how little compassion he has. It's
- 3:02:33just like he's telling a story. The way it comes across is he's trying
- 3:02:37to make a case that he's a victim. He's still in that kind of
- 3:02:41mode instead of looking at his daughter and seeing and having some care. Some
- 3:02:48But you know, he could continue the story, but there's an attunement of
- 3:02:52some level that he just is not exhibiting. And the only thing I can
- 3:02:56think is if I could just show her look at this, this is abhorrent.
- 3:03:05I'm just thinking maybe I could just show it to her, and she'll
- 3:03:07see how bad she is and she'll stop. She'll realize she's going too far
- 3:03:11and she'll stop. I still can't tell what is happening for her or there's
- 3:03:16not a lot of indication she turned away, which makes me worry that it
- 3:03:24is a PTSD reaction, but it very well could be a grief reaction,
- 3:03:28a sadness reaction. It's still not great, but it actually could be quote
- 3:03:35unquote cathartic for her to hear him tell the story and to feel the feelings
- 3:03:41and to get it out there. You know, it actually could be healing
- 3:03:45to have this moment. It looks painful, but sometimes healing is painful.
- 3:03:52So I can't really tell. I'm worried though it would be weird if she
- 3:03:56didn't have PTSD, right, But it's also possible that the amount of physical
- 3:04:03abuse terror that she went through was you know, minimal compared to the amount
- 3:04:09of gas lighting and brainwashing and you know, the sort of harm that she
- 3:04:16went through with Christine and others, you know, because the bait, the
- 3:04:22foundation of PTSD is terror, is that spike and adrenaline and fight or flight
- 3:04:28that is extreme and often chronic and there's a there's a feeling that your life
- 3:04:35is at risk, and so it's possible that those major spikes in the moment
- 3:04:43didn't happen. It was very distressful, it was very painful, it was
- 3:04:46very hurtful emotionally, but it didn't have that terror chronic terror element. I
- 3:04:52don't know. I kind of hope that she doesn't. I mean, for
- 3:04:56obvious reasons, but also so that she didn't develop PTA and thus in this
- 3:05:01moment, she's not being further harmed. While she's up there, I get
- 3:05:05my phone and I hit play on it so I could look at it,
- 3:05:07and it's shot disgusting. Unfortunately, while I'm looking at it, she showed
- 3:05:15up right behind me, and if I ever want to see my kids again,
- 3:05:20I have to reset my phone right now in front of her and delete
- 3:05:22everything. So he told the story before, it's slightly different. I think
- 3:05:26there's just more detail, and it's possible that this happened. But if he
- 3:05:31really wanted to document by video or audio or something the abuse that was happening,
- 3:05:41he could have tried again. And even if she did manage to get
- 3:05:45this erased, it's not like that was the end of the road. For
- 3:05:48him. So it says something, but I think to him it says,
- 3:05:54well, then it was over. Now he could make a case of I
- 3:05:58was very concer learned about our marriage if I even attempted to do that again.
- 3:06:03But he still had the free will to act differently. Christine told me
- 3:06:11in a series of messages, Natalia ruined her wife in so many ways.
- 3:06:16Christine basically said that Natalia started her husband. She had either caught Natalia having
- 3:06:26sex with her husband. Okay, so we're finally getting to the video interview
- 3:06:31with Freddie that we were teased a while back, and what Freddie is saying
- 3:06:39is that Christine told Freddie that Natalia had sex with Michael. Which is an
- 3:06:46interesting way of phrasing it, right, because Natalia was a child, or
- 3:06:50the very least an adopted adult. Even if you go with the thought that
- 3:06:56she's twenty two or older around that age, you wouldn't say that a twenty
- 3:07:03two year old child seduced an older, you know, her adoptive father.
- 3:07:07You know, you would say that the adoptive father assaulted or raped or coerced
- 3:07:13or you know, it's just like anyway. So it sounds to me like
- 3:07:18the way Freddy is, and we'll hear from Natalia here. Her facial expression
- 3:07:24gives me some relief that this never happened. I mean, Michael, I
- 3:07:28don't really. I mean I say relief for her sake, for Natalia's sake,
- 3:07:33and really for mine. This is my brain is already filled with too
- 3:07:39many horrible things. But I think what Freddy is saying is that Christine was
- 3:07:46making a case that Natalia was such a bad person she even had sex with
- 3:07:50my husband. Like, what makes me wonder how sophisticated she is, Christine
- 3:07:58because some of these, you know, these actions, if we speculate as
- 3:08:05to the motivation, you know, there are other ways to make your daughter
- 3:08:09out to be a bad person. Right, So let's see what happens.
- 3:08:15Messages Natalia ruined her wife in so many ways. Because he basically said that
- 3:08:20Natalia sorted her husband. She had either caught Natalia having sex with her husband,
- 3:08:30became aware of it, and then apparently and Freddie doesn't have a huge
- 3:08:35reason to lie about this, I don't think so. I am appreciative of
- 3:08:43these kinds of figures in the documentary because Michael could be lying, that Natalia
- 3:08:48could be lying or misremembering. Other people could be lying, but Freddie doesn't
- 3:08:52have a huge reason to lie about this, and he has a lot of
- 3:08:56specifics around it. So that's interesting one of the neighbors husbands or one of
- 3:09:01the neighbors. So also that Natalia was having sex with one of the neighbors.
- 3:09:07So it makes me wonder if the neighbors you know, in the apartment
- 3:09:11were heavily influenced by Christine as well around this whole sex crazed aspect of her,
- 3:09:18and then primed with that information. Everything they saw was through that lens.
- 3:09:24I mean, it could be simply remember Christine just telling me the heartbroken
- 3:09:28she was over the situation with Natalia sleeping with her husband. No, are
- 3:09:33you crazy? That is a total lie? Okay, So all right,
- 3:09:41all right, yeah, wow, wow, absolutely not. I have never
- 3:09:46at all touched in Italian in appropriate way. I have never had any kind
- 3:09:50of sexual relations with Natalia, unequivocally. Absolutely hell no. At the same
- 3:09:58time, that's Christine, she will make up whatever crazy loudlish he says.
- 3:10:07At the same time. Pause, I'm like, no, not because that
- 3:10:11phrase is typically used like if I were to say, you know, Seattle
- 3:10:16has pretty good weather you know, contrary to what everyone says, it's it's
- 3:10:20pretty good, pretty good weather. You know, it doesn't it doesn't get
- 3:10:22super cold in the winter, Like right now, we're in the middle of
- 3:10:26winter and it's like fifty five fahrenheit maybe more than that. So, you
- 3:10:31know, super cold can be annoying in a lot of ways. And the
- 3:10:35summers are great. At the same time, it rains here a lot or
- 3:10:39it's cloudy a lot. So he's like, no, I did not have
- 3:10:43sex with my adoptive daughter. At the same time, I think there's a
- 3:10:48different transition phrase there, putting that aside. I don't know. I'm just
- 3:10:56she's never came at us with the knife or put thumbtacks up on our stairs
- 3:11:00or tried to hurt our children. I was lying all the time, stealing
- 3:11:05all the time, I cussed. I probably did say some sexual stuff that
- 3:11:11I should not have. They probably remember more than I do. I'm sorry,
- 3:11:18Mom and dad, I'm sorry. So she's talking about the man's parents
- 3:11:22as mom and dad, by the way, and yeah, so she's admitting
- 3:11:26to the behaviors that we might imagine we're also present with the Barnetts, and
- 3:11:33that's consistent with the other kids that I would work with who were adopted later
- 3:11:37and had been abused, the lying, the stealing, the sexual inappropriateness,
- 3:11:43not necessarily because they've been abused, but because they just like to shock people.
- 3:11:50They like to annoy people. They like to get under people's skin.
- 3:11:54They're testing boundaries, they're growing up really fast. They don't respond to authority
- 3:12:00very well. They don't respond to people getting annoyed by them very well.
- 3:12:05So she's admitting to it, which is which is which is great? I'm
- 3:12:09not surprised. Sounds like the man's parents were able to manage, right,
- 3:12:13And that's what I was wondering, Right, if she was adopted by one
- 3:12:18of those other lovely parents, you know, those other families that wanted her,
- 3:12:22it's likely, especially that one woman who was a teacher. I believe
- 3:12:28she likely would have been able to handle it and wouldn't go down a road
- 3:12:33that Christine did. My goodness, right, and then this would would have
- 3:12:37been a completely different situation. So there's that they had a long back and
- 3:12:43forth about the knives thing that Michael brought that up. He said that he
- 3:12:48was told about the knives thing a lot by by Christine, but he did
- 3:12:54say I do remember seeing you at the foot of our bed with a knife,
- 3:13:00and Natalia was like, no, that never happened. That's ridiculous,
- 3:13:05And I'm thinking, well, she might believe that, but it could have
- 3:13:09happened, and it doesn't necessarily mean. You know, I've had clients that
- 3:13:15have done I've talked about this, that would do stuff like that and I
- 3:13:18could never know. But it wasn't a precursor to murder. It can be
- 3:13:22a way of shocking, it can be a way of expressing anger or something.
- 3:13:26It could be murderous intent, but that's not typical. I mean,
- 3:13:30how often do you hear of a child that stabs their parents to death while
- 3:13:35they're sleeping. It's very rare. However, there are unfortunately a lot of
- 3:13:39stories about kids with knives waking up their parents. So what does that say.
- 3:13:46I don't know about every case, but to me, that says that
- 3:13:50it's not an expression of murder. Plus, like, if you were really
- 3:13:52trying to murder someone, you're not going to wait there for them to wake
- 3:13:54up, right, You're just going to go for it. So it's not
- 3:14:00necessarily some crazed horror movie situation. So Michael was adamant that, and he
- 3:14:05was I think there's a more careful, compassionate way of saying what he was
- 3:14:11saying, but he was holding it to it. He's like, well,
- 3:14:15it happened, and Natalia was continuing to deny it. She brought up you
- 3:14:22know, at some point, Natalie's like, I know that the knives were
- 3:14:24like out of the kept up really high. I couldn't reach them. And
- 3:14:28I'm thinking, well, if you knew that, I mean, how many
- 3:14:33kids know that the knives are kept out of their reach? Right? I
- 3:14:37don't know, but it sounded to me like she was saying, the knives
- 3:14:41were eventually kept out of my reach, and maybe that's what she remembers.
- 3:14:45She doesn't remember doing that. You know, there's also dissociation. But she
- 3:14:48was really young. She was four. How many people remember the various details
- 3:14:52of when they were four years old. So there's that, And it could
- 3:14:56have been an expression of her valid anger against and the behavior, but it
- 3:15:01also could have just been her behavior that is unfortunate, something that you see
- 3:15:07and what else. The legal expert said that Michael seemed credible. You know,
- 3:15:13there was a bit of body language talk, which I'm not a fan
- 3:15:16of. Because there's extremely limited science about body language and telling the truth.
- 3:15:22I've heard people touching body parts. You ever have anything like that happened?
- 3:15:28Tell me about that. It was actually when I was star in Ukraine,
- 3:15:33when I was which guy the one? That's the thing. It's interesting.
- 3:15:41Wow, that's interesting. So they're interviewing her when she was still pretty young,
- 3:15:46and she is remembering a recent event for her that sounds like she was
- 3:15:54sexually abused while in Ukraine. That's what we're hearing, which you know,
- 3:16:00I've been speculating about, and it's just so unfortunate. All get together and
- 3:16:05we would pray together to show her that she is a good person and she
- 3:16:11is able to be loved. Your therapist believed that reactive attachment kids needed to
- 3:16:20be bootcamped, that you needed to be treated like you're in the military.
- 3:16:26Okay, So he's referring to her therapist, and Michael is phrasing it as
- 3:16:33if he heard that from the therapist himself. Now it's possible that he's just
- 3:16:37parroting what Christine says, but I'm guessing he wouldn't do that here. He
- 3:16:41would. I think he would phrase that. Well, Christine told me that
- 3:16:43your therapist. So it sounds like he's saying that a therapist said that to
- 3:16:50him. I mean, even bad therapists wouldn't say such a stupid ass thing.
- 3:16:56So it makes me wonder what sort of quote unquote therapist this person was,
- 3:17:01because some families will go to unlicensed, uncertified, unqualified people like a
- 3:17:09church leader and call that person a therapist. So I don't know, now,
- 3:17:13could a therapist do this? Yeah? Unfortunately. So we're hearing is
- 3:17:18that when you have reactive attachment disorder, the solution is harsh discipline at a
- 3:17:24facility like a boot camp. Yeah, it's so dumb. It's like,
- 3:17:28no, show me the evidence of that. Show me the evidence that a
- 3:17:31boot camp situation works for anything other than satisfying sadistic urges on half of the
- 3:17:39parent or society or something, you know, getting like with doctor Phil that
- 3:17:43kind of stuff. You have a teenager that is very defiant and then you
- 3:17:46have a drill stargent yelling at her on stage. It apparently appeals to a
- 3:17:52certain group of people looking for that sort of thing. I mean, hope
- 3:17:56all of us see when we have a teenager that is act that way,
- 3:18:00someone that's struggling I will say that there are there's a small percentage of people
- 3:18:03that are, regardless of what's happening to them, very cruel and sadistic.
- 3:18:11But that's not typical anyway. So we're hearing that the therapist said that,
- 3:18:15because you know, we heard that other but Michael was saying that Christine was
- 3:18:20saying that the therapist was justifying the action. So I really wish we knew
- 3:18:24more about the so called therapist. He shared a couple of words with Christine
- 3:18:31and she took them and ran with them. Okay, so I was referring
- 3:18:35to the therapist. He was telling Christine something and Christine ran with it.
- 3:18:39So did he hear the therapist either way? Same result, Christine ran with
- 3:18:45it. So terrified of what she'll do next? Are you sorry? Are
- 3:18:54you sorry about what she did to me? Okay, great question. I'm
- 3:19:00guessing he's going to dance around it. But let's see what he says.
- 3:19:05I'm overly sorry about what she did to you. I am horrified by what
- 3:19:09she has done to you. I am sorry. I wasn't stronger and didn't
- 3:19:13stop her. I wasn't. I just wasn't. Okay, that's less dancing
- 3:19:22than I thought he was going to do. Obviously, there's a lot more
- 3:19:28apologizing potential here. I'm sorry I didn't leave her and bring you with me.
- 3:19:33I'm sorry I didn't get help so I could be stronger, so I
- 3:19:35could stand up to her. You know, just being in a situation and
- 3:19:41you're overwhelmed you don't know what to do, doesn't mean that's the end of
- 3:19:45the road regarding responsibility, Like, did you put effort into being stronger,
- 3:19:50did you put effort into trying to get perspective? Did you talk with anyone
- 3:19:54about it? You know, victims rarely do that, but it's possible,
- 3:20:00well that he had a bit of the same condition that we might speculate that
- 3:20:03Christine did, and he didn't want this situation to tarnish his image as well.
- 3:20:09I don't think I'm strong enough now to do it, but I'm doing
- 3:20:13it anyway. I'm so sorry, Michael. I forgive you. Well now
- 3:20:31I'm gonna cry jam Wow. Wow. Yeah. The amount of maturity and
- 3:20:46wisdom and goodness in her that's been exhibited throughout this series this season, it
- 3:20:54really puts a lot of it in a different light. Wow, you don't
- 3:21:00have to I don't forget me, he said, I just could it just
- 3:21:09good Michael. It is interesting though that he was if we believe he was
- 3:21:20victimized, he was far less victimized, so that, you know, if
- 3:21:30he had spent the past nine hours consoling her and being directed towards trying to
- 3:21:35make her feel better, then okay. But when you look at the whole
- 3:21:43shebang, it's like, and it's interesting. You know, I've been in
- 3:21:46situations like this, obviously clinically but also personally where there's this weird irony that
- 3:21:52kicks in that wait, so because she is taking care of him right now,
- 3:21:58he can have his feeling. This isn't maybe the time, but we're
- 3:22:03now in a situation where she is consoling him, she is helping him,
- 3:22:09she is helping him to heal. Again, if he had spent a hundred
- 3:22:15times more effort in the opposite direction, then okay. But he didn't do
- 3:22:20that. The whole time, he's basically been referring to her as this temporary
- 3:22:28thing that happened. And they also he was talking about how he doesn't have
- 3:22:33contact with his two sons and how devastated he is by that. Meanwhile,
- 3:22:39you know, and the phrases he's doing it like I didn't get to see
- 3:22:41those kids grow up. I'm completely cut off from them. And I'm thinking,
- 3:22:46you have an adopted daughter sitting right next to you that you chose to
- 3:22:52be distant from. So how do you think that makes her feel? So
- 3:22:56it's upsetting to watch Michael. I should have stopped. Michael, look at
- 3:23:05me. I forgive you, Hm. Can I pray for you? Please?
- 3:23:20Well? Yeah, and I've been saying that he might legit have a
- 3:23:33side to him due to trauma that is that of a of a child,
- 3:23:37a hurt, abused, dependent, incompetent child. And the outfit, the
- 3:23:46body language, the emotional vibe is in line with that name. Jesus,
- 3:24:00Thank you for protecting Thank you for giving them a second chance. Thank you
- 3:24:05for saving you from the pills that he took. Thank you, Lord Jesus.
- 3:24:11Well would you've done? Wow? It's just it's incredible. I didn't
- 3:24:16think I would see that, this scene, this this documentary. That's it's
- 3:24:22pretty incredible. This this documentary. If you just had ten of the things
- 3:24:31in this documentary and a documentary, I would say, Wow, what a
- 3:24:33documentary? But wow, what a documentary? I already know. Okay,
- 3:24:52So I thought it was going to end on a happy note, and maybe
- 3:24:56it will. But at the very end of the second season, there's two
- 3:25:00weeks ago and six months after Natalia's adoption. Two weeks ago and six months
- 3:25:05after Natalia's adoption by the Man's the producer's got a shocking phone call away right,
- 3:25:16Okay, So Antoine is calling the producers of the show something ain't right
- 3:25:20with Natalia. This girl is tweaking. Okay, who knows what that means?
- 3:25:24And why would he be calling the producers if us her hosty? So
- 3:25:37he says, she's the enemy in the house and she had said to us
- 3:25:41that we have held her hostage. Okay. I My first hypothesis is that
- 3:25:48the man's parents were downplaying some of the behavior, not to a severe degree,
- 3:25:54but in an attempt to help Natalia safe face. I was thinking if
- 3:26:01the man's parents, I didn't want to think this, but you know,
- 3:26:07you have to wonder if they have a similar motivation as Christine did, that
- 3:26:13they want to be seen as the sort of people that can save the life
- 3:26:18of someone in need, and therefore would put forward a story that And you
- 3:26:24know, CYNTHI even said, like, we have a way, and so
- 3:26:28we helped her and helped her heal and that sort of thing. I can't
- 3:26:31remember the words, but and that could be true. It seems likely,
- 3:26:35honestly, But I was wondering if there were still some behaviors and they weren't
- 3:26:41telling the producers, because it seems unlikely that after years and years that all
- 3:26:46of a sudden there's something anomalous about her behavior. It's six months after the
- 3:26:52adoption, so I could wonder if for Natalia, once she felt more or
- 3:27:00secure in the relationship with the man's family, that she started to exhibit some
- 3:27:05of her anger, which would often be directed at people that you trust the
- 3:27:11most because you don't think that they're going to leave you. So you know,
- 3:27:16it's possible something like that could happen. It's also possible that given her
- 3:27:22development, you know, psychologically, she wasn't allowed to be a kid,
- 3:27:26she wasn't allowed to be a teenager, and she's re entering that phase because
- 3:27:31there's still some psychological development to do, and meaning, you know, the
- 3:27:37phase of life where you start to say, leave me alone and I got
- 3:27:41things figured out, and a differentiation phase, individuation phase, and there's some
- 3:27:46complications there and they got into you know, so it's just me just speculating.
- 3:27:52But the way that dad is, I could see him not having a
- 3:27:58lot of flexibility, and if she were to try to individuate and he were
- 3:28:03to clamp down and escalate things, I could see how she could escalate things
- 3:28:07too potentially. And then at some point she says, you know, let
- 3:28:11me go, or you you you held me hostage, not that you've always
- 3:28:16helped me held me hostage, but you're holding me hostage now like he grounded.
- 3:28:20I don't know. I'm just trying to take a guess as to what
- 3:28:22the most likely story is. Are the arena of the story? Make us
- 3:28:24look wordy en, I mean that how your dad and her family in the
- 3:28:30back over? Okay, so now we're hearing that stabbing. So was it
- 3:28:35a public statement that Natalia said or something she's done? But this was a
- 3:28:41new load that how it does not have equotions but does to put ours down.
- 3:28:46We're done, we're done, We're done. She only has emotions for
- 3:28:50herself. Know. The dad seems like a volatile sort of fella, and
- 3:28:58I could see how he and Natalia could end up butting heads and then he
- 3:29:03would just ride her off. You know, I don't know his personality obviously,
- 3:29:07but he seemed to be in that direction, so it could be exaggerated
- 3:29:13out of them. It also could be that Natalia is some sort of monster,
- 3:29:16But if she were, why would it only show up at this point?
- 3:29:22I don't know. So now we have to wait for season three,
- 3:29:28Okay, I guess they'll milk this for all it's worth. I'm hoping there
- 3:29:35isn't much more to this story, honestly, because if there's more story,
- 3:29:37then there's more horribleness. So hopefully there's just a follow up episode. So
- 3:29:43I actually just took a break right there and googled around of any news stories
- 3:29:50that have come out as the time of this recording. It's early February twenty
- 3:29:54twenty four for me, and I didn't find anything that provides anything new.
- 3:30:00It was just a lot of speculation and reporting about what was in the documentary,
- 3:30:05So it's hard to say what happened. I mean, there's a good
- 3:30:07possibility that Antoine Mann's it's all his fault. I mean, who knows,
- 3:30:13but it's possible that, you know, because as a family therapist, I've
- 3:30:16seen some parents who will get hell bent over nothing and have a similar narrative.
- 3:30:24It's all about her, you know, she just thinks about herself.
- 3:30:28She doesn't think about anybody else. She's tweaking, you know, those kinds
- 3:30:31of things, and then when you look into it, you're like, what
- 3:30:35happened exactly? And one stark example of that was a parent was saying all
- 3:30:43this stuff, and when I investigate, I wasn't investigating. I was assessing
- 3:30:46as a therapist, and I asked a lot of people, including the dad
- 3:30:50who was the one saying all this stuff. And long story short, the
- 3:30:54only thing that the teenage boy had done wrong was that he got instead of
- 3:31:01a's in his classes. That was it. It all stemmed from there,
- 3:31:05and you know, I was astonished, what's going on here? So,
- 3:31:11yeah, who knows. It could be all over the place in terms of
- 3:31:13options here. But it's unfortunate, right because I had it seemed like Natalia
- 3:31:20was in a really good place with them and they and she probably was.
- 3:31:24It's just unfortunate that this happened. It could also be a matter of Natalia
- 3:31:31wanting to start to move away from them a little bit, but because you
- 3:31:37know, meaning that she was ready to start spreading her wings a little bit
- 3:31:41more and the parents were pushing back on that, or Natalia has difficulty with
- 3:31:48saying goodbye or difficulty with transition or guilt about moving away emotionally, and you
- 3:31:58know, the whole family blew up or one side blew up or something you
- 3:32:01know that wouldn't be unheard of. So I don't know it's too bad.
- 3:32:05But from the Instagram story, sounds like Totalia's doing okay. But given Talia's
- 3:32:11life, I mean, she seemed really well put together when she was talking
- 3:32:15with Michael. But I would not doubt that Natalia is suffering very frequently,
- 3:32:20and that gives me a lot of sadness. I hope she finds more people
- 3:32:26to be there forever with her, you know what I mean, forever relationships.
- 3:32:31And yeah, so I thought I would have more videos or articles to
- 3:32:37react to, but I didn't really find anything. Maybe when season three comes
- 3:32:41out there'll be more stuff by then. I don't know what a journey.
- 3:32:48When I started watching this, I thought, you know, this shouldn't take
- 3:32:54too long. It doesn't look like that long of a documentary and there's probably
- 3:32:58not that much to react to. What was I wrong? And you know,
- 3:33:03to be honest with you. At this time, as I'm recording this,
- 3:33:07I was planning on working a lot less. That was my big thing,
- 3:33:11you know, if you saw my announcement video in early January, I
- 3:33:16was planning on really scaling back on work and trying to get all these other
- 3:33:22things done, which I still haven't been able to get done. But I
- 3:33:24don't want to bore you with that. So I thought, well, a
- 3:33:28lot of people are asking me to watch this, and it does seem interesting,
- 3:33:31and I do want to watch it, and I wonder if it'll just
- 3:33:37take a little bit of time, you know, I'll just I'll just take
- 3:33:39this a little bit of time. And then as I'm watching it, and
- 3:33:41it's just there's just so much to get into, and so I ended up.
- 3:33:45But you know, it's my fault. I want I did it too.
- 3:33:46I yamored a lot. So what are you going to do? I
- 3:33:48guess, well, there's that. So what do I say overall? I
- 3:33:56don't know. I hope that if you didn't already, you have a more
- 3:34:05nuanced view of these kinds of stories. The horror music that was playing in
- 3:34:11the first season, the beginning of season that makes her out to be this
- 3:34:13devil monster is tugging at a stereotype about children, maybe disabled children, maybe
- 3:34:22adopted children, or just children who exhibit violence or talk about knives. I
- 3:34:28hope that you have a more nuanced view, if you didn't already, that
- 3:34:33yes, those situations can and do happen. They're extremely rare. It's much
- 3:34:37more common that you'll see behavior like that, and it's concerning and scary,
- 3:34:41but it's workable and changeable, and it's just the symptom of something. It's
- 3:34:46not evidence of possession by the devil or something. So there's that. I
- 3:34:52hope that my soapboxing about raising taxes an allocation of taxes to services for families,
- 3:35:00I hope that it. I hope you heard it, because I do
- 3:35:03hope that I can do my part to influence the tiny corner of the Internet
- 3:35:09that we're in right now. You and me and I can push the needle
- 3:35:15a little bit towards justice for people. And if we think selfishly, when
- 3:35:20those people get those services, they're less likely to cause problems away from them,
- 3:35:26like crime or other kinds of harm, and they're much less likely to
- 3:35:31have parenting problems themselves. And continuing the multi generational problems. How's that affecting
- 3:35:39me? I'm reminded of the clients that I worked with back in the day.
- 3:35:45It's been a while since I've been reminded of it, you know.
- 3:35:48It was. I became a therapist in ninety six, and probably until two
- 3:35:56thousand and five ish, I was working in this program of being contracted by
- 3:36:03the government to go into homes. So I had a portion of my practice
- 3:36:07that was adults, portion of my practice that was couples, and a portion
- 3:36:13of my practice that was families with teenagers. And among those families with teenagers,
- 3:36:18there was a portion of them that were adopted from another country, and
- 3:36:24the common story was that it was similar to this where they had been shuffled
- 3:36:28around orphanage, DA, DA DA, and then they come to the States,
- 3:36:30and then they exhibited a lot of these behaviors. Another thing I want
- 3:36:35to say is that you know, they referred to reactive attachment disorder a lot,
- 3:36:39which bugs me because, as I've been saying that, that is something
- 3:36:45that she probably did suffer from legitimately, but it doesn't encapsulate what I often
- 3:36:50would see as the behavior and the condition of someone who would go through something
- 3:36:56like what she went through. I'll also amend something I said along time ago,
- 3:37:00which was that she might not ever have the capacity for empathy, and
- 3:37:05she didn't exhibit that with Michael, So she might be one of the a
- 3:37:09good example of someone that might have had some impaired empathy or some delayed development
- 3:37:15of empathy, but she wasn't doomed to a life of not having as much
- 3:37:20empathy or attachment attunement as other people do. But I have seen that from
- 3:37:26kids that were adopted later, So there's that. Yeah, So this adherence
- 3:37:31to the DSM, whenever we're looking to explain something is wrongheaded, the DSM
- 3:37:37is there for us and it's a good tool, but it's just one of
- 3:37:41many tools. Like when I talk about attachment injury, attachment reactivity, trauma
- 3:37:46reactivity, I'm usually those as broader statements or broader categories than the limited categories
- 3:37:52we have available to us in the DSM. So I hope that that you
- 3:37:56know, just because we don't have a label for it, don't mean it
- 3:38:00doesn't exist. It is the thing. What else, How did it affect
- 3:38:03me? It was hard. I'm also frustrated and ticked off at the documentary
- 3:38:18because in the first season, particularly at the beginning, it was so manipulative.
- 3:38:24Just looking back, it was just so manipulative. I mean, I
- 3:38:28guess that's what makes it interesting, but I feel manipulated. I'm reminded of
- 3:38:35the fact that there are kids going through this right now. This isn't the
- 3:38:39only time this has happened. It's happening all the time, and just how
- 3:38:45much sadness that makes me feel. You know, it's depressing to think about
- 3:38:50how we learn. We know this is not the first time this has happened.
- 3:38:56It's not the first time that there's been a famous story in this category,
- 3:39:01or at least famous enough. We've had studies for decades around this,
- 3:39:07you know, various different issues in this documentary, and yet as a society
- 3:39:11we're barely doing anything. We're reactive when as a story becomes known or bad
- 3:39:20enough so that the police are called, but even then we barely do anything
- 3:39:24as a society. And I find that people say, like, well,
- 3:39:30how comes she just doesn't go to a mental health hospital, or how comes
- 3:39:33she just not have a psychiatrist, or how comes shes noa a therapist?
- 3:39:35She did all she did, she had all those things, and it's like
- 3:39:39we can't imagine things that don't exist, right, But just because something doesn't
- 3:39:46existing we can't imagine, it doesn't mean that there isn't an option available to
- 3:39:50us that we've never tried before, or an option that is you know,
- 3:39:54very unknown. And you know, I've been ranting about this this whole time,
- 3:39:58that there there are institutions that can be developed or bolstered by tax dollars
- 3:40:05that would absolutely reduce the risk of all this stuff happening. So, you
- 3:40:09know, people think, well, therapists will help. Well, you know,
- 3:40:13as therapists, there's only so much we can do. Could we can
- 3:40:16help. But if they only see us once a week for an hour or
- 3:40:22two, we can't be there when all this stuff is happening at home and
- 3:40:26it can escalate. Why can't she go to mental health hospital? Well,
- 3:40:28it costs money. Mental health hospitals can be abusive themselves, often because they're
- 3:40:35underfunded as well. Because if you don't have a lot of money and you
- 3:40:37need an you know, X amount of staff, you got to pay everyone
- 3:40:41pretty poorly. So there's a lot of burnout in situations like that, you
- 3:40:45know, over capacity of patients, that sort of thing. I am uplifted
- 3:40:52by seeing Italia rise above it and forgive Michael and take care of him,
- 3:41:03because she is just a good person. So let's end on that note,
- 3:41:09all right. So I'm just chiming in here at the end of the final
- 3:41:13episode that I'm going to be posting on Natalia Grace because I want to present
- 3:41:20the results of the survey that I sent out to y'all. I posted the
- 3:41:24survey on YouTube and on Patreon and other places, and I wanted to go
- 3:41:30over the results. So the background on the survey was that I watched all
- 3:41:35the two seasons of Talia Grace. I hadn't posted any of the episodes yet.
- 3:41:41I watched everything, and then I hadn't seen any comments or anything yet,
- 3:41:46you know, and I'd looked online a little bit. But I was
- 3:41:48curious what y'all would think about the details of this story. Did you think
- 3:41:54she did it? Did you think you know? What did you think about
- 3:41:58Michael? What did you think about Christine? Kind of thing? And so
- 3:42:01I was curious. So I sent out a survey and then I got the
- 3:42:05results, and I thought I would record a little addendum to the final episode
- 3:42:11here and I would share what y'all think about this. So the first details
- 3:42:16that one hundred and ninety nine people responded to this question and the first question,
- 3:42:22so I had a number of items and people could check a box if
- 3:42:26they agreed with the statement, and the first one here. When I hover
- 3:42:31over it, you can see the full statement. It says Natalia did threaten
- 3:42:35others, for example, using knives to intimidate. So I'm asking, do
- 3:42:41you think that Natalia actually was intimidating maybe using knives or other kinds of threats,
- 3:42:48that kind of thing. And thirty six percent of y'all agreed with that
- 3:42:54statement, which indicates that it's a minority opinion, which is interesting to me
- 3:43:01but makes sense now for me. If I were to be in Vegas betting
- 3:43:09on this, which would be weird, I would put my money down that
- 3:43:13she did the way that Michael talked about. And of course Michael could be
- 3:43:18lying. I mean, he's not the most believable person, but the way
- 3:43:22he described the incident, you know, one incident he just you know,
- 3:43:26one time she showed up at the foot of the bed with a knife and
- 3:43:28he saw it wasn't something that Christine told him. And he was recalling this
- 3:43:35toward the end of the documentary, and I think he had had enough time
- 3:43:41either to extract his mind from the brainwashing of Christine, or he had enough
- 3:43:48time to reckon with the truth and the falsehoods that he either went along with,
- 3:43:56or he might have even drummed up in himself to defend himself with the
- 3:43:58pack. So I think that it's possible. Is it possible he's lying?
- 3:44:05Yeah? And the only other person in the documentary who could speak to this
- 3:44:09would be Natalia, and she said she didn't do it. And there's just
- 3:44:16a lot of question marks there. One would she remember. You know,
- 3:44:18there's association trauma, reactivity. You know there's sleepwalking as well. I wouldn't
- 3:44:24imagine that it would be some version of sleepwalking, but I had a condition
- 3:44:28like that when I was a kid. I didn't show up to my parents'
- 3:44:33bedroom with a knife, but I would show up to my parents' bedroom basically
- 3:44:37hallucinating and delusional. I would basically wake up in the middle of a dream
- 3:44:45and I would superimpose the dream on the real world. And I've read the
- 3:44:52research on this. It's kind of rare, but it was very unpleasant.
- 3:44:56It was never like a happy dream. It was always extremely disturbing. I
- 3:44:58can still visualize what I saw, and it was when I was around,
- 3:45:05you know, five to ten years old, maybe younger as well, and
- 3:45:09it would happen, I don't know, maybe once every six months, and
- 3:45:11it was very unpleasant, and I would go up to my parents' room to
- 3:45:16ask for help and my mom would just soothe me, and then I'd go
- 3:45:20to bed and I'd wake up fine. So anyway, it could it be
- 3:45:24something like that. It's possible, but I think more likely is that Natalia
- 3:45:30was motivated by trying to get attention. You know, she's four or five
- 3:45:33years old. God knows what she saw, where she came from, God
- 3:45:37knows at what point she showed up in the bedroom with the knife, right
- 3:45:41after being terribly mistreated by the family, particularly Christine. You know, it's
- 3:45:48just it's hard to say, just you know, just imagine the amount of
- 3:45:52suffering that the fact that there weren't more things that were factual or presented to
- 3:45:58us is actually pretty bizarre, given my experience with kids that go through stuff
- 3:46:03like this. So I would say that would I would put my money down
- 3:46:07that she did do it? Was it, you know, adequately demonstrated that
- 3:46:15she did beyond a reasonable doubt. No, but fifty to fifty chance,
- 3:46:18you know, beyond a fifty percent chance that it did happen, like in
- 3:46:22a civil case. I would say yes. Now, if I were in
- 3:46:26Vegas, how much money would I put down? I say, you know,
- 3:46:28at the low end, like a dollar, that's little, that's not
- 3:46:30very confident. The high end I got, like ten dollars, I would
- 3:46:35put like three dollars down on that. You know, I'm not very confident,
- 3:46:39of course, but I would. I would say that it probably did.
- 3:46:45And I'm curious as to where people were coming from when they well,
- 3:46:48well, I totally imagine for people, because at some point you just have
- 3:46:54to say, well, who is the more truthful, believable person. By
- 3:46:58the end, it was absolutely Talia, and she says she didn't do it,
- 3:47:01and there was a lot of other fabrications, so you know, it
- 3:47:07seems absolutely possible. Okay. So the next question here is Natalia is innocent
- 3:47:13of the vast majority of allegations. So this is interesting. Fifty five percent
- 3:47:20of y'all agreed with that statement, which I would have thought that would be
- 3:47:24more, especially given the thirty six percent that agree that she did indeed threaten
- 3:47:31others. Maybe people interpreted that as the knife incident only or something, but
- 3:47:37I guess the vast majority of allegations include a lot of other things, which
- 3:47:41I actually ask about later. But fifty five percent, only fifty five percent,
- 3:47:46but most believe that Natalia is innocent. And of course none of us
- 3:47:50know because we just saw a documentary that was heavily edited and manipulative. I
- 3:47:56don't know if I've ever seen a documentary that was more borderlining on ninety day
- 3:48:01Fiance territory, the way it was edited, the music, the sort of
- 3:48:07storylines that they would go down anyway. In fact, after the first season
- 3:48:13I mentioned, a lot of people walked away thinking that Natalia was guilty of
- 3:48:16a lot of things, which is a terrible injustice anyway. So the question
- 3:48:24here is Atalia is innocent? Of the fifty five percent said yes, I
- 3:48:28would say I would give that myself a definite Yes, I would put my
- 3:48:33money down on that, and I would put ten dollars. I mean,
- 3:48:37it depends on what we mean by vast majority of allegations, you know,
- 3:48:43do we think Well, let's get into the specifics here. The third question
- 3:48:48here is Natalia did attempt to sexually abuse others. Only twenty one percent of
- 3:48:54y'all agreed with that statement, and that makes sense to me. I would
- 3:48:56put my money. Well, the more I watched, the more I started
- 3:49:05because at first I thought the neighbors would be the most credible because they were
- 3:49:09not in the family and they were a third party witnesses, right, And
- 3:49:16there were a number of them. There were at least three very strong,
- 3:49:22you know witnesses, people that gave a lot of testimony, maybe four,
- 3:49:26and I thought, well, all four of them would lie or something,
- 3:49:33and their allegations are so specific. One person, you know, the person
- 3:49:37that was only filmed from the waist down, was saying that she actually observed
- 3:49:41Natalia trying to get into the pants of another boy. Now do I think
- 3:49:46that Natalia was this monster? There's no evidence of that. Was she acting
- 3:49:52out something that seems possible if these allegations, you know. And the other
- 3:49:58other allegation we had was that the grandma, who seemed less and less credible
- 3:50:01as time went on, she said that her grandson was playing Xbox in her
- 3:50:09place. She wasn't home. Natalia came in, was get sitting closer and
- 3:50:15closer to the boy, which given the fact that Natalia was eight years old
- 3:50:20and just looking for a friend or someone to bond with, we would understand
- 3:50:22that. And then according to the grandma, the grandson told the grandma and
- 3:50:30she could be listening through bias tears, that Natalia tried to touch him somehow
- 3:50:37and it didn't go any further than that, and the boy said that he
- 3:50:41had to yell at her and then she walked off. So it sounds like
- 3:50:46a pretty believable you know, if a boy told me that, if I
- 3:50:50heard the kid tell me that directly afterwards, it would be very believable.
- 3:50:56It's hard to know what Natalia was trying to do even with that story,
- 3:51:01right, given that she's eight years old. If if you now the neighbors
- 3:51:05thought she was twenty two, so it changes everything. Right, you hear
- 3:51:09about an eight year old doing something, especially with her background, you just
- 3:51:13think, well, maybe she just doesn't know. So there's that could it
- 3:51:20be Could it have actually happened? Yeah, So with those two incidents,
- 3:51:24agreeing with the statement, did Natalia attempt to sexually abuse others? Twenty you
- 3:51:28know, very few people twenty one percent said yes. I would put my
- 3:51:33money down that'd be a hard pet to make. But if we're going,
- 3:51:39you know, more likely than not, like in a civil case. You
- 3:51:45know that one story that that one you know, the one neighbor that was
- 3:51:50shot from the waist down. She the way she described it, it sounded
- 3:51:54very believable. Now, I wouldn't go off of what she said to indict
- 3:52:01someone, or you know, it's such a you know, there's so many
- 3:52:05other oppor possibilities given what we know now that Christine poisoned the well by telling
- 3:52:09everyone that she was this murderous killer, and then she was brainwashed herself Natalia
- 3:52:15to tell everyone that, So you know, there's a there's a high likelihood
- 3:52:20of bias and a misunderstanding. So did it? And I guess maybe people
- 3:52:28wouldn't even characterize it as sexual abuse anyway, But I would put my money
- 3:52:35down that the incident that that one neighbor witnessed did happen along those lines.
- 3:52:46But was Natalia trying to get into his pants? I guess is the question
- 3:52:50that people are asking. I guess it's interesting even for me to like nail
- 3:52:54my self down regarding my opinion. Is there a fifty one percent chance that
- 3:53:01that happened. I it's funny because you know, as a clinician, I
- 3:53:07think, well, it's better safe than sorry, right, and let's look
- 3:53:11into it. So I'm usually of the mind of, well, the risks
- 3:53:16are much higher if it actually happened, so let's be careful and not discounted.
- 3:53:20Let's keep it on the table. This is a tough one. Let's
- 3:53:26say I would put one dollar that, yes, it did happen, and
- 3:53:31that Natalia, you know, and it maybe was just that one time that
- 3:53:37for whatever reason, maybe it wasn't even motivated by perpetration or trying to harm.
- 3:53:43But she was Plaine Tickle, you know, she said, we're Planetickle
- 3:53:48and the boy and the girl Paintackle and they're about the same age. Maybe
- 3:53:52she's a little younger the boy, I'm not sure. And she just got
- 3:53:56this weird idea to start unbuckling his pain. I mean, if you hang
- 3:54:01around enough kids, weird stuff happens. You know, what do they know,
- 3:54:05they just do stuff. Whether or not that was some sort of attack,
- 3:54:11we wouldn't know. So yeah, I'd put a dollar on that.
- 3:54:15So I guess I'm a counter to what a lot of people would say there,
- 3:54:18which you know, what are you going to do? This? Fourth
- 3:54:22one is Natalia was a young child when adopted by the Barnett's, contrary to
- 3:54:28the claim that she was much older. So of course ninety three percent,
- 3:54:31but only ninety three percent. I would have thought that'd be ninety nine or
- 3:54:35on hundred percent. So apparently seven percent of y'all think that Natalia was indeed
- 3:54:43older. Now maybe those people only saw the first season. I don't know,
- 3:54:46but that that is interesting. I wonder if that's because people have because
- 3:54:52it's hard to walk, or maybe they know more information I tried to look.
- 3:54:56Strangely, there isn't much reporting on this case. A lot of the
- 3:55:00articles are just summarizing what happened in the documentary, which is really annoying because
- 3:55:05it's not a real article. You're you're just a cliff notes for a TV
- 3:55:09show. And I wonder if people are, you know, they've been traumatized
- 3:55:15by someone that is like Natalia, Which does happen? I mean, I'm
- 3:55:18guessing some of you might have had siblings who were like this, or cousins
- 3:55:24or even kids. You might have even had kids of your own that were
- 3:55:28like this, So maybe that's what would lock people in but that's a real
- 3:55:33hard question to not agree with. Anyway, if you agreed with that,
- 3:55:39if you disagreed with that statement, let me know what your thoughts are,
- 3:55:41because now I'm worried. I haven't posted any the episodes yet, so I'm
- 3:55:46like, oh god, you know my off base. Okay, this next
- 3:55:52one. Natalia's neighbors interviewed in the documentary are at least mostly telling the truth
- 3:55:56about Natalia's concerning behavior. About fifty five percent agreed with that statement that that's
- 3:56:05interesting too. I would have thought that people most people wouldn't agree with that.
- 3:56:09I mean the way I worded it, You know, at least mostly
- 3:56:13telling the truth about Natalia's concerning behavior. So, you know, we heard
- 3:56:18the story about leaping out at the construction workers or the landscapers. We heard
- 3:56:22the story about the boy on the lawn. We heard about the grandson.
- 3:56:26We heard about her propositioning an older man in the laundry room. We heard
- 3:56:33about her saying that she tried to poison her parents or her mom. We
- 3:56:39heard her saying that she said that she was twenty two. We heard allegations
- 3:56:46that she would wander into their house while they weren't home. You know,
- 3:56:50people would come home and she would be in their kitchen. Again, we
- 3:56:54understand why an eight year old with attachment issues would do that, or even
- 3:56:58just an eight year old without attachment and issues like you know, I would
- 3:57:03hope, you know that an eight year old would actually try to reach out
- 3:57:05to someone instead of just staying in an apartment by themselves. So I don't
- 3:57:11know. I guess it depends on what we mean by you know, if
- 3:57:15we put all the allegations, including walking into people's houses, then then yeah,
- 3:57:20I guess I would agree with that as well. How much money would
- 3:57:24I put down, again, depends on what we're meaning, you know,
- 3:57:26what sort of demarcation line we're having here, But yeah, I would put
- 3:57:33if we include the breaking into people's houses or sneaking into people's houses or whatever,
- 3:57:39then but of the biggies, I would say, that's a hard Well,
- 3:57:43I don't know. Did she proposition or seem to proposition a guy in
- 3:57:48the linery room? You know, I could see that, and that was
- 3:57:52a different neighbor than the neighbor who was seemingly trying to groom her, and
- 3:57:56thank God that she got out, but you know, God knows. Actually,
- 3:57:58now they think about it. Maybe she didn't and she just doesn't want
- 3:58:01to remember. Anyway, it's horrible. It's all the parent's fault for putting
- 3:58:05her in that position to begin with, even if she were twenty two,
- 3:58:09right anyway, So do I agree with most of most of the allegationious the
- 3:58:16neighbors said, I'd say yes, hard to know that much money. I
- 3:58:20put down the next question, Natalia is currently a risk to others and probably
- 3:58:28should be monitored. Natalia is currently a risk at the age of I think
- 3:58:33she's in her late twenties, I think, and probably should be monitored.
- 3:58:39Eleven or twelve percent of y'all agreed with that. That's interesting too, that
- 3:58:45I love. Did people not see the second season? Maybe they weren't convinced
- 3:58:48or something, But that's interesting because I don't agree with that statement. I
- 3:58:54don't, Well, it's hard to know. Of course, we saw at
- 3:58:56the very end that she had some kind of blowout with the man's which I
- 3:59:03think just points to her attachment issues and her conflict issues. But you know
- 3:59:09that Dad, the adoptive dad Antoine Mans seemed like not someone who would back
- 3:59:18away from some kind of confrontation. But I don't know, you also seemed
- 3:59:22like a really nice person. So it's just it's a total blank spot in
- 3:59:26terms of our data, so we can't really I mean, I guess you
- 3:59:30could use that as circumstantial evidence that she still has issues, and maybe those
- 3:59:33issues are still around regarding the possibility of being at risk, but you know,
- 3:59:39risk to others. Maybe people don't interpret risk to others in the same
- 3:59:43way that the way that I meant it was that she's like a physical risk
- 3:59:50or or a sexual abuse risk, you know, some kind of serious risk.
- 3:59:54Maybe people interpreted that differently. I guess I should have been more clear
- 3:59:58in the question. The next statement is Natalia often lied as a child,
- 4:00:05and fifty percent of you agreed with that Natalia often lied as a child.
- 4:00:11Yeah. Again, hard to know where the debarcation because every kid lies,
- 4:00:16but fifty seven percent, you know, I think what we're we're getting at
- 4:00:20here is are the lies about her behavior even currently right, that she would
- 4:00:28remember having done things and not be super enthusiastic about wanting to admit that she
- 4:00:35did do some things when she was a kid. But we're not talking about
- 4:00:39that. We're talking about that she lie as a child. I mean,
- 4:00:45you got a figure. But what were the lies? Because you know,
- 4:00:48the big lies were that she was not a child, which she wasn't lying
- 4:00:52about. Well, I guess she had to lie because she was forced to
- 4:00:54lie, So maybe people interpreted it that way. I guess this this survey
- 4:01:00a little you know, I whipped it together pretty quickly. Natalia is a
- 4:01:05con artist. Okay, only two percent believe that. That's that's great,
- 4:01:07but still two percent. I'm just worry maybe they only saw the first few
- 4:01:13episodes or something of the first season. Natalia is a psychopath. Three percent
- 4:01:18agree with that. That's interesting. I don't agree with that. I mean,
- 4:01:24she might have issues regarding conduct or empathy, and it might be legit
- 4:01:30on the psychopathic spectrum. There's no evidence of that, of course. In
- 4:01:33fact, if we really just zoom out and look at the credible allegations,
- 4:01:41she actually exhibits a fair amount of resilience regarding her personality given her first you
- 4:01:48know, ten years of life or twelve thirteen years of life. The next
- 4:01:54thing, the parents neglected Natalia who agree with that? Ninety six percent agree
- 4:01:58with that. Yeah, that's a pretty easy thing to agree with, and
- 4:02:03I'd put ten dollars on that the next question here, Christine was at least
- 4:02:15moderately abusive to Natalia, and ninety percent agreed with that, but only ninety
- 4:02:20percent. It's you know, as a researcher, and I did market research
- 4:02:26before I was a therapist. When I graduated from college at the age of
- 4:02:31twenty to twenty three, I one of my first kind of real jobs was
- 4:02:35doing market research. And when you survey a lot of people, you're you're
- 4:02:41always going to there's a bell curve, and you're always going to get some
- 4:02:45It's really hard to find any statement that everyone will agree with, even if
- 4:02:50it's like is the Earth a sphere? And instead of flat, you know,
- 4:02:58is it round? Some people don't really understand the question. Some people
- 4:03:01are pissed off that they're being asked. You know, there's a lot of
- 4:03:03when you survey a lot of people, you realize, oh, there's a
- 4:03:07lot of fringe ways of thinking or confusion or something. But according to some
- 4:03:13people, they and again maybe they didn't watch the whole thing. But Christine
- 4:03:18was at least moderately abusive to Natalia. Ten percent said no, she wasn't
- 4:03:26even maybe she was minimally or less abusive. Is what they're saying to Natalia,
- 4:03:33which is which is you know, it's shocking. What does that say?
- 4:03:37Yeah, I'd put that at a ten dollars right there. It's a
- 4:03:41very confident one. Next one, Christine should be convicted of childhood of child
- 4:03:48mistreatment. Christine should be convicted of child mistreatment. We got we have seventy
- 4:03:56nine percent of people agreed with that statement. Christine should be convicted. Yeah,
- 4:04:05that's not hard for me to say yes to. Now the threshold for
- 4:04:11that kind of abuse and also the threshold for conviction because a lot of the
- 4:04:18families that I worked with were not being charged criminally, but they had been
- 4:04:24found to be abusive to their kids, and thus they sent in therapists and
- 4:04:30other workers to try to fix the situation instead of putting one of the parents
- 4:04:35in prison or something or taking the children away completely. So you know,
- 4:04:41there's a gray zone there, so to speak, or a zone or a
- 4:04:46degree of child abuse that you wouldn't necessarily convict. So maybe a lot of
- 4:04:50people are like, well, look, you know, someone should have done
- 4:04:54something, but I don't think she should be convicted or spend time in prison
- 4:04:56or something. But but given I just feel like when it comes to stuff
- 4:05:03like this, it's so easy not to be this way. You know,
- 4:05:07Christine made so many choices, Like there are situations where you go through a
- 4:05:13really bad point in your life. You lose your job, someone dies close
- 4:05:20to you, you lose your home, you lose your car, you're trying
- 4:05:26to get help, no one's helping you, and then one night you get
- 4:05:30drunk and you're just like, fuck it, I'm gonna I'm desperate, and
- 4:05:37I know there's a rich neighborhood with rich white people and I don't. And
- 4:05:39you know, those people can go to hell. They've ruined our whole world.
- 4:05:43I'm gonna go over there. I'm not saying this is right. That's
- 4:05:46not right, but you know, you can imagine that they go over there
- 4:05:50and they get a knife where they just act like they have a gun,
- 4:05:54and they mug someone, and that person is traumatized. You know, they're
- 4:05:58affected by that, the victim. Do I believe that that person, you
- 4:06:05know, in terms of the grand scheme of their life and their risk and
- 4:06:09their goodness versus their evilness. That's horrible what they did, of course,
- 4:06:16and not very few people would ever do something like that, but that to
- 4:06:20me emotionally or in terms of the circumstances. It exhibits to me that the
- 4:06:26amount of decisions someone said yes to to go down that road is limited compared
- 4:06:33to what Christine did. She for years went down so many roads of yeses
- 4:06:39that it was just like every day she was continued for years she was going
- 4:06:45down this road and determined in a way that she didn't have to be All
- 4:06:50she had to do was at the very least just like be kind of a
- 4:06:56bad parent to Natalia. That would have been horrible. But she went way
- 4:07:01beyond. You know, there's tons of bad parents in the world. Christine
- 4:07:05went way beyond that. And so to me, I feel like, look,
- 4:07:09there are lines, there are thresholds, and if you cross them and
- 4:07:15go way beyond that threshold, then you have forfeited your rights as an American
- 4:07:22citizen. And I have no problem with sanctioning your rights, including you being
- 4:07:28detained in prison. Yeah, you knew what you were doing. You had
- 4:07:33several decision trees that you could have veered away from that path, and you
- 4:07:39just kept going down that path. And so I don't have a lot of
- 4:07:43sympathy the guy that you know goes across town while he's drunk because and mugs
- 4:07:48somebody. You know, let's say, in this story, at the very
- 4:07:52least the next day he's like, ah, that wasn't very good. I
- 4:07:56don't want to do that again. That was kind of scary and whatever.
- 4:08:00He doesn't even ever morse, but he just rethinks it and say I'm not
- 4:08:03going to do it again. Not good. But he is more getting back
- 4:08:09into the stream of at least not antisocial behavior. You know, it's a
- 4:08:15different situation, and I don't think many people would say that that person shouldn't
- 4:08:20be tried or convicted of something, you know what I mean? And so
- 4:08:24and plus like, it's an innocent child mugging someone across town another adult.
- 4:08:31Not good. But Atalia was an innocent child and you chose to adopt her.
- 4:08:39It's just it's one of the worst crimes I think you could ever commit.
- 4:08:43So do I think she should be convicted? Yes? And eight seventy
- 4:08:46nine percent of you agree with me. The next statement here is Christine is
- 4:08:50a horrible person. I just kind of threw this in and sixty four percent
- 4:08:56of you said, yes, that's interesting. I would have thought it'd be
- 4:08:58more are what do I think is Christine a horrible person? You know?
- 4:09:05I don't know. I tend to not use that language even in my personal
- 4:09:11life, well most of the time. And I would say, that's a
- 4:09:18hard question to answer. I don't know what the criteria are. What do
- 4:09:24I say horrible person? I think according to most thresholds, yes she is
- 4:09:31a horrible person. But we don't know because we just got this manipulative documententary
- 4:09:39that laid out the data as it was. But yeah, so sixty four
- 4:09:43percent of you agree with me Christine attempted to sex traffic Ittalia. So I
- 4:09:50was really curious about this one because the documentary was really trying to make this
- 4:09:56case, and six percent of you agreed with that, which is interesting.
- 4:10:03Certainly there's questions, But the only example or the only data point we have
- 4:10:13that was really in that direction was, I mean, Natalia remembers getting gussied
- 4:10:20up or something like with makeup. But that's really hard to know what that
- 4:10:26was about. The only real strong data point is Freddie said, and I
- 4:10:31guess maybe handed over or when they subpoenaed her phone records and got the text
- 4:10:37they showed it on the documentary where in the course of Christine having a sexual
- 4:10:46or online sexual affair with Freddie and flirting heavily with them, you know,
- 4:10:52just all that stuff, and also apparently reaching out to Freddy for advice or
- 4:10:58community or something, and the course of that she sends a text. I
- 4:11:03wish they would have shown the context of that text, but we just have
- 4:11:09this text where she says, I can set up a time where you could
- 4:11:13meet her or something like that. And it absolutely could be what it looks
- 4:11:18like in that she was trying to sex traffic her, but it doesn't really
- 4:11:22fit within what we would hypothesize as the narrative of the motivation that Christine had,
- 4:11:33and she was trying to get rid of Natalia and have Natalia just disappear.
- 4:11:39She wanted Natalia to disappear. She wanted Natalia out of the house.
- 4:11:43She didn't want any association with Natalia. She didn't want Natalia to do anything
- 4:11:50that would be newsworthy that would cause people to connect the dots and to sex
- 4:11:56traffic Natalia. Now, maybe you could argue that Chris seems just a horrible
- 4:12:01person and just wanted to harmor but I don't think that's the pattern. Certainly,
- 4:12:05there's a lack of remorse exhibited in the data. But uh, and
- 4:12:11maybe you could make a case that she was trying to get Freddie and Natalia
- 4:12:16to get together so that but that doesn't make any sense because if if Christine
- 4:12:22was trying to get them to get together so that she could say, see,
- 4:12:28Natalia is a horrible person, it wouldn't that would I mean, Christine
- 4:12:33did. She didn't seem like the sharpest tack of the box. But you
- 4:12:37know that that's a stretch. Plus, it's so fantastical. It happens,
- 4:12:41for sure, but in terms of the commonality of that kind of behavior,
- 4:12:48it's it's pretty rare. So whenever we have something like that, we need
- 4:12:54we need more data. You know, if if my wife tells me later
- 4:12:58today that she had cereal for breakfast, I wouldn't need a ton of data
- 4:13:07to believe her, because it's not a fantastical claim. If she told me
- 4:13:11that she was abducted by aliens last night, I would need data to believe
- 4:13:18firmly that that actually happened, right, because it's not typical. It's not
- 4:13:24something now, you know, sex trafficking is more common, obviously being actually
- 4:13:28abducted, but meaning that just I feel like that I have to say.
- 4:13:35I know a lot of people have claimed to have been abducted by aliens,
- 4:13:39but we in our field have a lot of science to demonstrate how people would
- 4:13:46actually believe that firmly when it never actually happened. There's a lot of sleep
- 4:13:52disorders in which, like I was saying earlier, actually that can result in
- 4:13:56seeing things or believing things, sensing things. You know, there's a phenomenon
- 4:14:05in which you can wake up but your body is still paralyzed because you know,
- 4:14:07when you fall asleep, at some point your brain decides to paralyze yourself
- 4:14:13so that you don't act out your dreams and wake yourself up. So the
- 4:14:20idea is is that you're supposed to be unparalyzed and then wake up, so
- 4:14:24you wake up and you can move, but sometimes because of a sleep disorder,
- 4:14:28or because of serotonin issues or sleep deprivation issues or alcohol or something,
- 4:14:37you can actually wake up before you're no longer paralyzed. And for a lot
- 4:14:43of people that's very terrifying. It's one of my phobias to some extent because
- 4:14:46it sounds very unpleasant because it's not just for a couple of seconds. For
- 4:14:50some people, can you know last like fifteen seconds, thirty seconds, and
- 4:14:54that can be a lifetime, right, It's like, oh my god.
- 4:14:58So I keep trying to remind myself like, if that ever happens, just
- 4:15:01wait everything, I'll be fun. Don't panic. Also, when people have
- 4:15:09that experience, often they will have a sensation of something pressing on their chests,
- 4:15:16and they sometimes will have this sense that there's this evil presence in the
- 4:15:20room with them. They might even hallucinate it. In the old days,
- 4:15:24five hundred years ago, there were all these accounts of demons sitting on people's
- 4:15:28chests, because that's in Europe anyway, how people saw the world, it
- 4:15:33was a religious god, angels, demons world, and so that's how their
- 4:15:37brain interpreted it. And if you ask them what happened the next day,
- 4:15:39they would say, there was a demon on my chest. I saw it.
- 4:15:41It had the wings and the horns, and you know whatever they said.
- 4:15:46Because our hallucinations are cultural. So for today, it could be anything
- 4:15:52from believing there's a serial killer in the room or a ghost, or being
- 4:15:56abducted by aliens. And it's not just this, it's not just this experience.
- 4:16:02There could be other kinds of experience, you know, you wake up
- 4:16:04the middle of the night and you're paralyzed, and you just have this sense
- 4:16:10that like something is happening to you, and you feel like something's happening to
- 4:16:15your body, and there's this doom, there's a presence, but you don't
- 4:16:18necessarily see it, and it's dark in your room, and you might even
- 4:16:23manifest. Instead of seeing the demon, you see actual aliens, you know,
- 4:16:29or sort of blurry images of aliens or something, and you know it's
- 4:16:34real. But anyway, Plus a lot of people just makes it up because
- 4:16:40they're they're trying to get attention, or they they have mild schizophrenia or something.
- 4:16:45Away, So this this next, So where were we Christine attempt to
- 4:16:53sex traffic yet? So thirty six percent of you agreed with that, which
- 4:16:57I totally get, But if I were to put my money down, I
- 4:17:03would say no because we would just need more information. Plus, if Christine
- 4:17:07was doing that, similar to the allegation that Christine was trying to kill Natalia
- 4:17:12with medication, it doesn't fit with what she was trying to do. I
- 4:17:19think she wanted Natalia to just and I think Christine had this delusion that even
- 4:17:26though I'm pretty sure she's eight years old. If she is told that she's
- 4:17:32twenty two, she'll figure it out eventually, and she'll just become one of
- 4:17:37those white trash people, you know, because she said, I'm gonna put
- 4:17:41her in Lafayette with the white trash people and she'll just, you know,
- 4:17:45disappear into the statistics of the world and I'll never have to I think that
- 4:17:49was her plan, because if she was really murderous or trying a sex trafficker,
- 4:17:53I just think we would have seen a lot more data. We have
- 4:17:57mountains and mountains of data demons that Christine wanted to get rid of Natalia,
- 4:18:04and there's a lot of data also that she probably knew that Natalia was a
- 4:18:10child. We don't have to look far for data. But if we just
- 4:18:12look at one text that this manipulative crew of documentarians are just showing us,
- 4:18:19I would need a lot more data along those lines. And frankly, I
- 4:18:23guess I just don't trust the documentarians to be honest with us, because they
- 4:18:29weren't. There were so many deceiving aspects of this next statement is Michael is
- 4:18:37mostly lying? Okay. The next number of questions are all about Michael and
- 4:18:41sixty two percent of you agree with that Michael is mostly lying, and that's
- 4:18:47interesting. What do I think of that? Again, it's hard to know
- 4:18:51what the threshold here is. You know, we also have to define lying
- 4:18:56because there's a chance that he was still well well, yeah, I guess
- 4:19:00I would agree with that on a number of levels, especially when you consider
- 4:19:06what he was saying in the first set of interviews in twenty nineteen, because
- 4:19:11he was really leaning heavily into Natalia was indeed an adult when they adopted her,
- 4:19:18And of course we know that is very, very very unlikely, and
- 4:19:25at twenty nineteen, he had had enough time to think about it. He
- 4:19:27was no longer with Christine, so all that he said about that. Could
- 4:19:37a factor in the line be that he was still kind of brainwashed maybe or
- 4:19:45scared of Christine. That's hard. That's a harder one to believe. Or
- 4:19:49I guess brainwashing and still being under the thumb is are both hard to believe
- 4:19:56given what we saw. I don't doubt that he was intimidated and scared of
- 4:20:02her, felt controlled by her during the relationship. I think there's you know
- 4:20:07that one thing I didn't actually talk about was their phone conversation you know,
- 4:20:11they had actual recorded phone calls between her you know it bet your Christine and
- 4:20:17Michael, and I will say that the style of her talking. The thing
- 4:20:23is is, I'm pretty sure Michael recorded those and during those times he was
- 4:20:29he knew that it was recording, so he would watch his p's and q's.
- 4:20:32Right. Also, we did hear about this car incident where he is
- 4:20:37saying I'm going to kill you. Shut up, I'm going to kill you
- 4:20:40to Christine. You know, that's a pretty severe thing to say. That's
- 4:20:45not a common thing to say when you're in conflict, right, There's a
- 4:20:49lot of things that are more common that are horrible, like you're an asshole,
- 4:20:53or I hate you or I never loved you or whatever. But I'm
- 4:20:59going to kill you in front the kids. So it's hard to know exactly
- 4:21:03what their conflict was, like, it's very likely, you know that if
- 4:21:08we actually had an objective account, that we would hear that Michael was verbally
- 4:21:15abusive frequently. Maybe not I'm going to kill you. It sounded like he
- 4:21:19said it like ten times or something, so maybe it wasn't to that degree,
- 4:21:26but you know, the chances are is he probably said other things in
- 4:21:30that direction. Now, might he have been a victim who was just trying
- 4:21:33to defend himself or you know, going beyond his breaking point. It could
- 4:21:37be absolutely So it's hard to know, but I will say that the recordings
- 4:21:42we had of Christine, the style of her communication was evidence of an overall
- 4:21:51abusive relationship, because the way that she in her text actually kind of exhibited
- 4:21:56this as well. But there's a tone like when I watched the videos of
- 4:22:03Amorant I believe her name was. If you watch that series on YouTube,
- 4:22:08it you know, she gets she's live streaming and she gets on the phone
- 4:22:12with her husband and he doesn't know that she's recording it, and it's on
- 4:22:18speakerphone, and he the way he talks to her. A similar thing when
- 4:22:23we were watching the documentary about that one woman who was a chef in New
- 4:22:33York of a vegan restaurant and her you know, they recorded her husband the
- 4:22:37way he talked. There's just a way that abusive people talk. They're on
- 4:22:41a mission, and they'll they kind of they're all over the place. You
- 4:22:45know, the victim usually in those conversations are more kind of like just letting
- 4:22:51the abusive person yammer and rant, and the victim is more just trying to
- 4:22:57survive and not very emotional often, and the abusive person might even be saying,
- 4:23:07you're so abusive to me, You're so mean to me, And that's
- 4:23:10what she was doing. You know, we kind of heard evidence of this
- 4:23:12during the Johnny depp ember Heard trial as well, And I don't know how
- 4:23:17to characterize who was the abused and who was the abusive person in that,
- 4:23:21but you know, there's a similar kind of tone both ways in the recordings
- 4:23:26anyway, So I will say that she did have that. So regarding you
- 4:23:33know, was Michael mostly lying then, yeah, I'd agree with that.
- 4:23:41The next question here is Michael is lying occasionally but mostly telling the truth.
- 4:23:51Only twenty one percent agreed with that. I wish I was more specific in
- 4:23:56these questions because I would say that by the end, I think he was
- 4:24:00mostly telling the truth and he was avoiding situations in which he had to lie.
- 4:24:06But throughout the whole documentary, Yeah, next question, Michael was at
- 4:24:11least moderately abusive to Natalia. Seventy eight percent agree with that Michael was at
- 4:24:17least moderately abusive. Yeah, again, I wish I was more specific about
- 4:24:22the what abuse means, what the word abuse means, because I would say
- 4:24:26that he definitely neglected her. At the very least, he neglected to look
- 4:24:33into whether or not she actually was an adult. You know, before you
- 4:24:38kick out a kid that could be eight, you would just think that parents
- 4:24:44would be absolutely positive. And so they had a lot of reports saying that
- 4:24:48she was an eight, and then they cherry picked one from a family friend
- 4:24:51that said that she was twelve. And I also should say that I imagine
- 4:24:55that Christine actually abusive. People can be persuaded and gas lighting and intimidating and
- 4:25:03coursive with people that they're not really involved with. They can be that way
- 4:25:07with a cashier or a family physician, or a therapist. I've had clients
- 4:25:12like this, and even though I'm a professional, I understand how to uphold
- 4:25:18my professionality, there are times when I will be dealing with someone like that
- 4:25:25and I'll hear myself going along with them, because they give off a sense
- 4:25:30of danger and threat without being threatening. It's weird. So it's possible that
- 4:25:37that doctor, being closer to the family, actually was just giving in.
- 4:25:42There was actually some evidence of that when they were interviewing him later, if
- 4:25:45I remember right, anyway, so Michael was at least moderately abusive to Natalia.
- 4:25:52Yeah, so that's abusive. And it's also looking like he probably did
- 4:26:00know right, at least anyone in their right mind would know that she's eight,
- 4:26:07or at least there's little evidence that she's twelve. And yeah, right
- 4:26:12from there, now, I wish I would have asked, do you think
- 4:26:15Michael had been physically harmful to her? Because I'm trying to remember for those
- 4:26:22data along those lines, I don't think, Well, did Jacob say something?
- 4:26:29Yeah, at the very least we know that the vast majority of abuse
- 4:26:33seemingly came from Christine. The next question, Michael should be convicted of childhood
- 4:26:37of his treatment. Sixty three percent agreed with that. I would agree with
- 4:26:42that. I'm pretty careful to say stuff like that about parents because parenting would
- 4:26:48be hard, and to just throw everyone in jail, I think is not
- 4:26:55wise. But like I said earlier, there's a threshold and it went on
- 4:27:00for so long, and yeah, you were a victim, but I don't
- 4:27:03know if you demonstrate I don't know if Michael demonstrated that he was a sort
- 4:27:07he was the sort of victim that lacked any sort of agency and power,
- 4:27:14and after the separation, he didn't do anything to try to help her.
- 4:27:19He just you know, left her where she was. So now I'm guessing
- 4:27:27that Natalia wouldn't have wanted to be with him because she had a new family
- 4:27:33at that point. But he didn't even seem to care at all, And
- 4:27:37so that just points to the you know, the strong possibility that when Natalia
- 4:27:42was living with them, that he seemed like the sort of adoptive parent that
- 4:27:48never actually bonded with her. And there's no reason why he should that.
- 4:27:55I heard that he should have refrained from bonding with her. I could see
- 4:27:59how Christine could have thrown a wrench in that. But yeah, I think
- 4:28:03Christine should be convicted before let's see what's the comparison here. Christine should be
- 4:28:11convicted. Seventy nine percent of you agree, Michael should be convicted sixty three
- 4:28:17percent. Yeah, yeah, Michael sexually abused nat in Natalia, sorry,
- 4:28:22it only says nat Michael sexually abused Natalia. Four percent of you agree with
- 4:28:27that, And that's interesting. I think those are just anomaloust's responses because the
- 4:28:33vast majority of you think the way I do, which is, at least
- 4:28:37there's not evidence of that it could have happened, but there's extremely circumstantial evidence.
- 4:28:44Christine is the main evidence. She told Freddy. So another Questionner,
- 4:28:51Michael is a horrible person. Forty percent of you agree with that, with
- 4:28:56Christine being sixty four, forty percent of you believe that Michael is a horrible
- 4:29:02person. Yeah, I guess I would say that I don't think Michael is
- 4:29:06a horrible person in terms of the common definition of a horrible person. Do
- 4:29:11I think he has major problems? Yeah, But at the same time,
- 4:29:15let's say that Christine wasn't Christine. Let's see Christine was more like one of
- 4:29:19the other mothers that was being presented in the documentary. You know that that
- 4:29:22other adoptive mother that wanted Natalia the teacher. I believe imagine if that was
- 4:29:29his wife, I would imagine that that Michael would have been fine with Natalia.
- 4:29:37Now imagine if Christine was married to anyone else. Do we think that
- 4:29:41Christine would have been fine and that Natalia would have been fine? No?
- 4:29:45I think no matter who Natalia was, who Christine was married to, the
- 4:29:51situation would have been the same, if not worse. So in terms of
- 4:29:56who's a horrible person, you know, Christine and Michael as problems and issues
- 4:30:02and seeming a lack of understanding or seemingly a lack of remor seemingly lack of
- 4:30:14empathy, at least when it comes to him being responsible for things. I
- 4:30:19don't think he's a psychopath, but you know, I've already been over that.
- 4:30:23But next question, Jacob the oldest son is telling the truth and the
- 4:30:29documentary only fifty seven percent of you agreed with that. Huh. I would
- 4:30:33put a very confident ten dollars that it's a yes. Jacob seemed very credible
- 4:30:40to me, so I mean, he's not telling you the whole truth.
- 4:30:44Of course he even said that. But even beyond that is, are there
- 4:30:48things that he could have said that would have been interesting, like things about
- 4:30:51Michael that he's refraining from saying. It's probable there too, but it's interesting.
- 4:30:56Only fifty seven percent thought that Jacob is telling the truth. I mean,
- 4:31:03maybe people interpret it like the whole truth, but I might even say
- 4:31:07that I don't have I wonder what people's reason reasons were for thinking that Jacob
- 4:31:11was lying. I mean about about about what was he let me know another
- 4:31:19statement, The first adoptive parents, the New Hampshire parents in the US,
- 4:31:26they were abusive. So I worded this way, So the first adoptive parents
- 4:31:30in the US was abusive. I had originally had a different subject of that
- 4:31:37type of that sentence, and then I changed the subject, but I didn't
- 4:31:40change the verb. That bugs me. And once I send out the survey,
- 4:31:44you can't edit the survey because you have to. You have to.
- 4:31:48It's you know, you understand. So the first adoptive parents they were abusive.
- 4:31:53Only nineteen percent agree with that. Yeah, that makes sense to me.
- 4:31:56There was no evidence of that, and Natalia didn't even really say that,
- 4:32:03So I would say a confident know there as well. The mental health
- 4:32:07system failed the family. Seventy one percent of you agree with that, And
- 4:32:11that makes sense to me because I think that, on one hand, the
- 4:32:15mental health system did fail the family. You know, there are questions about
- 4:32:19the mental health hospital and the staff and their attention to detail. I think
- 4:32:29that we could say that the system failed because you know, the people that
- 4:32:33they interviewed were probably tech what we call techs or what I would call a
- 4:32:37tech meaning that they're not clinicians, they're not psychiatrists or therapists, because those
- 4:32:42people probably hopefully wouldn't just randomly talk to the documentary people. But you have
- 4:32:49workers who work in the facility who assist the overall treatment. They might also
- 4:32:57clean or help people get into bed and do activities that kind of thing.
- 4:33:03And so for those people, they're not paid a lot, and they don't
- 4:33:08have necessarily any sort of specialized education or training, and for those folks,
- 4:33:17it's harder for them sometimes to really understand what's happening and to have any power
- 4:33:23of this situation. So in a mental health hospital, because of the system
- 4:33:30being poor and bad and tax is not being allocated for that because as a
- 4:33:33society apparently we don't care and the politicians will care, then it really puts
- 4:33:40a strain on these hospitals to hire people that might be kind of a revolving
- 4:33:45door of employees and to have not enough staff. And hear about this all
- 4:33:51the time that it can be a very very stressful job because if you had
- 4:33:56more staff, you know, for the one or two patients that present like
- 4:34:00a physical risk, then with more staff you can create more safety for everybody.
- 4:34:06But if you have limited staff, then it's harder to monitor the situation
- 4:34:11and you're kind of thrown to the wolves as an employee. So the menial
- 4:34:15health system, and I'm not saying Natalia was dangerous, but I think that
- 4:34:19things might have been different for Natalia if there was a more funded program around
- 4:34:26her in the mental health hospital, such that the texts probably would have seen
- 4:34:33something different or understood it to be different, because you know, the way
- 4:34:34they were framing it was that Natalia was doing things that Christine was saying.
- 4:34:41Now, do I think that Natalia was doing things as the employees were saying,
- 4:34:45Yeah, I could see it, you know, in line with the
- 4:34:49sexualized behavior allegations from the apartment complex and the you know, mental health hospital.
- 4:34:56There was at least one where she seem was at least suggesting being suggestive
- 4:35:03or was seemingly Now again, she's at this point, like six seven years
- 4:35:08old, eight. No child is like voluntarily doing something at that point,
- 4:35:17you know, they're they're acting a part or so it's not like the way
- 4:35:22that we would see it as adults. But but so, how did the
- 4:35:26menial system fail? Well, I guess if indeed they never went into that
- 4:35:32other therapist if the you know, the therapist that supposedly was on board,
- 4:35:37if not encouraging very harsh treatment abuse of natalia, which a couple of years
- 4:35:42ago I would have said would be absurd. But after the whole Jody Hildebrant
- 4:35:45thing, I think is absolutely possible. It might even be way more prevalent
- 4:35:49than I can even imagine, so that, you know, is it possible
- 4:35:56that we could say that the menial system failed because of that if we believe
- 4:35:59it. Yeah, absolutely, there were two other therapists. But I worry
- 4:36:06that people would think that the mental health system failed the family because they didn't
- 4:36:11really provide any solutions. And you know, I've been over I've been down
- 4:36:15that rabbit hole on my videos. But sometimes there just is no solution,
- 4:36:22and the solution isn't necessarily therapy. Therapy might be a part of it,
- 4:36:26but what needs to happen is a lot of support. People paid to coordinate
- 4:36:34help and respite, you know, taking the kid out for the day or
- 4:36:40training for the parents, or you know, various different coordination with psychiatry.
- 4:36:45You know, when you're a family in this situation, often you're begging providers
- 4:36:52to pay attention to you and they're barely involved, and they have very limited
- 4:36:57time because there's they have too much on their on their you know, docket,
- 4:37:03and so they, like a psychiatrist will only have fifteen minutes every few
- 4:37:10months to have a check in. And as a parent, you're just like,
- 4:37:14I got to tell you all these things are happening, Like what's going
- 4:37:17on here? Is it true that she actually asked schizophrenia and the psychiatrist,
- 4:37:21you know, just very quickly because they're under the gun. And that's that's
- 4:37:26a problem with funding or systems or something, you know. So, I
- 4:37:33mean, the psychiatrist often is making a lot of money. So, but
- 4:37:37if you had other professionals, like a psychiatric nurse that was paid less,
- 4:37:42that had more availability of space and time, then you had a therapist that
- 4:37:47was paid to coordinate with the psychiatry, uh you know staff and get in
- 4:37:52an interpret that sort of run with that, and so you know, just
- 4:37:55the parents feeling like they're being taken care of and and so in that way,
- 4:38:00yeah, the metal health system failed, But I don't think that the
- 4:38:04system was being utilized in good faith by the family. I don't think that
- 4:38:12any amount of support from the outside would have fixed anything aside from catching the
- 4:38:18abuse earlier. So I guess you could say the system failed in that way.
- 4:38:26But that's a hard one, you know, because the kid comes in,
- 4:38:30the therapist has limited time. If the kid doesn't say anything, then
- 4:38:34it's hard to know, you know, what you're supposed to do anyway.
- 4:38:37And the last question is the parents saw the statement the parents saw the movie
- 4:38:44Orphan in two thousand and nine and attempted to copy it by adopting Italia.
- 4:38:48Only twenty eight percent agree with that, but still, it's a lot of
- 4:38:51people, and it's possible, and you know it's not fantastical. Well,
- 4:38:57it is fantastical. You know what do we think that Christine? Is it
- 4:39:06possible? Yeah? But I think the narrative that they put forth in second
- 4:39:10season is cogent or coherent in that Christine had, you know, some motherly
- 4:39:19love to give, but she mostly was running from the issues that she's been
- 4:39:29through and trying to gather narcissistic supply and had been doing well along those lines
- 4:39:36through Jacob and with the book and CNN and the movie deal and book deal,
- 4:39:41and and she might have been worried that well, it's starting to that,
- 4:39:48you know, this amount of narcissistic supply starting to dry up because he's
- 4:39:52he'll be an adult and that he'll be on his own. And that storyline
- 4:39:56has kind of run its course, and so how do I recreate it.
- 4:40:00I'm going to take a guess and say that she went to her other two
- 4:40:03boys. It didn't work out because why would you adopt? And then she
- 4:40:07thought, or maybe she just went straight to I'm a god. I'm a
- 4:40:10golden god. I can do anything, and I'll pick someone that's very disadvantage.
- 4:40:15Maybe she even heard a story where that might have happened, you know,
- 4:40:17like The blind Side, which apparently had the real story had nothing to
- 4:40:22do with the movie and the book, and so you know, she adopts,
- 4:40:30and she is hopeful that things will work out, whereas and then you
- 4:40:37know, the issues go from there and it's mostly generated from her personality.
- 4:40:41So the alternative hypothesis is that she watches Orphan, the movie I guess both
- 4:40:47parents and then they say, you know, and I don't know the movie,
- 4:40:51but from my understanding from the trailer, there's a child that's adopted from
- 4:40:56Ukraine or Russia and into the States and the parents are getting some creepy vibes
- 4:41:03from the kid, and then they learn the kid as actually an adult.
- 4:41:07And I'm assuming people are killed by this monster of a child or adult that's
- 4:41:12acting like a kid. So what do we believe that the parents saw that
- 4:41:18movie and said, yeah, I want so let's adopt a kid from that
- 4:41:22part of the world, and then let's claim that she's older, let's make
- 4:41:29up all the details that she actually is threatening and we both don't care about
- 4:41:37her at all, and then we'll tell everyone about it and get sympathy.
- 4:41:45I mean, when I say it out loud, it's less fantastical than it
- 4:41:48was at first. But still, I mean, that's like I said earlier,
- 4:41:52there's a lot easier ways to get attention, you know, like saying
- 4:41:56that you're a golden god of a mother. It's still pretty hard, but
- 4:42:02it's a lot easier than just even going through the adoption process. And anyway,
- 4:42:07So but maybe people mean it differently, like they saw the movie and
- 4:42:11decided to narrativize the situation as that, you know, retrospectively. But you
- 4:42:18know, the way I worded it is they saw the movie and attempted to
- 4:42:21copy it by adopting the Talia. Yeah, so that because do you believe
- 4:42:26that? Let me know what do you think of that? So I also
- 4:42:30asked a question if anyone had any hot takes, and about half of you
- 4:42:37responded there, and Stephanie said something that I think is basically in line with
- 4:42:44the way I saw. It was good to read those kinds of comments.
- 4:42:48Stephanie says both Christine and Michael should have been convicted of child abuse and of
- 4:42:56disabled person abuse. Michael to a lesser degree than Christine. Michael was also
- 4:43:03a victim, but he was an adult. Natalia definitely has issues from all
- 4:43:07her trauma as a baby and as a child and as a disabled person.
- 4:43:11She may have done some of the things. Natalia may have done the things
- 4:43:15that they said she did, you know, the parents and the neighbors,
- 4:43:19but she was a child, an abused child, and should have been treated
- 4:43:22with kindness, love and correctly treated medically. Yeah. And there were a
- 4:43:29number of different comments along these lines which helped me because watching the documentary,
- 4:43:34it's so I can see why people would like this or want me to do
- 4:43:40a reaction to it, because you can't just watch this and walk away.
- 4:43:44You have to watch it and go because Stacey and I that's all you've been
- 4:43:48talking about for the past couple of weeks. I remember that one thing,
- 4:43:52you know, And also it's just so enraging and you just want to let
- 4:43:59it out. And so it was good to read a lot of these hot
- 4:44:02takes because I was like, Okay, yeah, that's basically what I was
- 4:44:04thinking. So anyway, let's adjourn there. I already gave my sort of
- 4:44:15final remarks. I won't do that again, and I did like doing this
- 4:44:19survey. I'll try to do that more. I was thinking, you know,
- 4:44:22this was kind of an elaborate one because I watched this very in depth
- 4:44:26documentary and had a lot of questions. But you know, like if I'm
- 4:44:30watching Love is Blind or Nine Day Fiance or something else, I think it'd
- 4:44:34be fun to send a survey. So watch for those on various you know,
- 4:44:40on Patreon or on YouTube, maybe on Facebook. And I think you
- 4:44:47have to go to the the community tab or the posts tab, but you
- 4:44:49don't necessarily see it come up on your feed. So yeah, but does
- 4:44:57that what do you think? And everyone out there, please take care of
- 4:45:00yourself because you deserve it, You really really do.