Latest / The Great Retirement Debate with Ed Slott & Jeffrey Levine / S3 Ep10: GRD038: Is It Better to Be a Girlfriend, Boyfriend or Spouse?
Transcript
- 0:00Hi, I'm Ed Slott and I'm Jeff Levine.
- 0:02And we're two guys who just love to talk about retirement and taxes.
- 0:06Look, our mission is simple to educate you, the saver, so that you can make
- 0:10better decisions because better decisions on the whole lead to better outcomes.
- 0:14And here's how we're going to do that.
- 0:15Each week, Jeff and I will debate the pros and the cons of a particular
- 0:20retirement strategy or topic.
- 0:22With the goal of helping you keep more of your hard earned money.
- 0:26At the end of each debate, there's going to be one clear winner.
- 0:29You!
- 0:30A more informed saver who can hopefully apply the merits of
- 0:33each side of the debate to your own personal situation to decide
- 0:36what's best for you and your family.
- 0:38So here we go!
- 0:39Welcome to the Great Retirement Debate!
- 0:42So Jeff, here's an interesting story.
- 0:44Actual tax court case, so that should pique your interest.
- 0:47Alright, tell me, what's going on?
- 0:49Well, here's a guy who worked for a company for many years, and he left his
- 0:54multi, well not multi million, one, one point something million, so a million
- 0:58dollar plan, account balance, retirement account balance, to his ex girlfriend.
- 1:04To his ex girlfriend?
- 1:05Yeah, now, you might say, alright, you know, there might
- 1:08have been something there.
- 1:09Yeah.
- 1:09He broke up with her in 1989.
- 1:13It's a long time ago.
- 1:16A very long time ago.
- 1:17And in all those years, he never changed his beneficiary.
- 1:20Never.
- 1:21Even though the company asked him to.
- 1:24As a matter of fact, it was so long ago, in this case, they didn't have
- 1:27really fancy beneficiary forms.
- 1:29Yeah, I was going to ask whether he chisel his beneficiary into stone tablets?
- 1:32Something like that.
- 1:33It was actually written on a card, like an index card, a beneficiary form
- 1:36card the company had at that point.
- 1:38And they went, as they computerized over the years, they sent him
- 1:42notification after notification.
- 1:44He just died.
- 1:44So we're talking about many years ago.
- 1:47Do you want to update your beneficiary form?
- 1:49They said, because we're going to a computerized format.
- 1:52And if you don't.
- 1:53Don't update it, we're going to assume what you had on that handwritten card,
- 1:58that's your selection for beneficiary.
- 2:00And he never changed it, he never changed it, he never changed it, well
- 2:03now he's dead and she gets the money.
- 2:06Now he died unmarried, so he had no spouse and no children.
- 2:11So why is there a court case?
- 2:13Well, with a million dollars in a retirement account, you know people
- 2:16are coming out of the woodwork.
- 2:17Somebody's going to be upset about that.
- 2:18His two brothers.
- 2:19Ah.
- 2:20Ah.
- 2:20Ah.
- 2:21And they said, no, this can't be what he, what he broke up with her in 1989.
- 2:25She can't possibly get the money.
- 2:27The court says, yes, she gets the money.
- 2:30They want, now where it stands, and who knows where it is, by
- 2:33the time you see this, uh, could change a little, I don't think so.
- 2:37They want to appeal it.
- 2:38my position, my feeling, they will lose.
- 2:41They will lose every case.
- 2:42They even said that in this court case.
- 2:44He had every chance to change his beneficiary.
- 2:47He opted not to do it.
- 2:49That's right.
- 2:49It was his money.
- 2:50He can choose to do what he wants.
- 2:51It's like that commercial.
- 2:52It's your money.
- 2:52Do with it what you want.
- 2:54Yeah.
- 2:55And that's what happened.
- 2:56And now, I saw, when I saw the comments to the article, uh, Wall
- 3:01Street Journal ran an article on it.
- 3:02They had tons of comments.
- 3:04And they were in a bunch of camps.
- 3:06Some camps was, she shouldn't get the money.
- 3:08Uh, you know, and she had ended up getting married to somebody else and so forth.
- 3:13That must have been an interesting conversation.
- 3:15Yeah, yeah.
- 3:17Yeah, uh, yeah, I don't even want to go there, right.
- 3:20And so that was part of the camp.
- 3:22People said, uh, well, she shouldn't get the money.
- 3:25She's just not right.
- 3:26And then the brothers should get the money.
- 3:28There is blood relatives more than her.
- 3:31And in every case, uh, she's gonna get the money.
- 3:35Yeah, I mean, it stands to reason that he's able to do what he
- 3:37wants with his money, right?
- 3:39And, and maybe it seems that if he was intentionally passing on these things that
- 3:43his true intent was to leave his money.
- 3:45To his ex girlfriend.
- 3:46Who knows?
- 3:47Maybe they made some sort of crazy pact back then.
- 3:50They said, if you know what, if neither one of us finds love, we'll leave
- 3:53each other our retirement accounts.
- 3:54Well, that's what some people said, and what they said also, and I believe
- 3:58it was in the court case, nobody knows what was, he's dead, nobody knows
- 4:02what was in his mind, why he did that, but he, He purposely did not update
- 4:08that card, that beneficiary card.
- 4:10So now, she will get the money.
- 4:12I don't care how many times they appeal.
- 4:14My feeling is they're going to lose.
- 4:15They'll just end up wasting money on attorneys.
- 4:18Because this goes by operational law.
- 4:20It's a contract.
- 4:21Seems likely.
- 4:22And this is a company plan.
- 4:23They can't just say, you know what, he's right.
- 4:26She shouldn't get the money.
- 4:27They have fiduciary liability.
- 4:28Maybe they should decide what he should do with his money.
- 4:30Right, but by law they can't.
- 4:32That's right.
- 4:33They, you know, there's an ERISA plan and all of that, so speaking of
- 4:36ERISA, this begs another question.
- 4:39What if instead of being the ex girlfriend, She was his ex wife.
- 4:45Well, if she was his ex wife, then as long as they were married for at least
- 4:49a year, that she would have had to have been his beneficiary of the plan.
- 4:53There would have been no choice.
- 4:55Here, with an ex, like a girlfriend, a boyfriend, uh, you
- 4:59know, anyone other than a spouse.
- 5:01It's your choice who you want to make your beneficiary.
- 5:03But with ERISA plans, these are typically 401ks, pension plans, etc.
- 5:08You're, often times, if you're married, your spouse is your beneficiary right
- 5:12away, but there is a rule that ERISA has that says, if you get married, the plan
- 5:16can allow up to a year before that new spouse becomes the automatic beneficiary.
- 5:21But they don't have to.
- 5:23Uh, remember that one case with six weeks?
- 5:26Uh, they don't, right, they don't have to.
- 5:27The plan can wait, but they don't have to allow.
- 5:29That was the, uh, the Kidder case from many years ago.
- 5:32I think it was.
- 5:32Yeah, yeah.
- 5:33New spouse, six weeks.
- 5:34That's right.
- 5:35Six weeks after they were married, she killed, I mean, uh, died.
- 5:37She mysteriously died and she got the money.
- 5:40Exactly.
- 5:41Yes, yes.
- 5:41After only six weeks.
- 5:43So, uh, let's go back.
- 5:45Let's say he was the ex spouse.
- 5:49So let's say he left his ex wife on the beneficiary for okay.
- 5:55Now what would have happened?
- 5:57Well, probably depends upon what state they live in, right?
- 5:59Because many states upon divorce, you are automatically revoked unless
- 6:05and it does happen from time to time unless your ex spouse re-nominates
- 6:09you as the beneficiary afterwards.
- 6:11Yeah, a number of states, more than half of them actually, have revocation upon
- 6:15divorce laws, which means if you left your, you got divorced, and a big mistake,
- 6:20very common mistake, you go through the divorce and everything else, and you
- 6:24forget to update your beneficiary form, and you leave now your ex spouse on there,
- 6:30uh, In those states, she's, she or he is immediately removed as beneficiary.
- 6:37Yeah.
- 6:37Well, you know, those laws come from somewhere, right?
- 6:39Like a bunch of politicians forgot to update their beneficiaries afterwards.
- 6:43And they said, no more, that's it.
- 6:45We're going to make this automatically law.
- 6:46Right.
- 6:47And in the, this was a Supreme Court case, by the way, that, uh, established this,
- 6:52and even the justices, one of them said, and you could, uh, listen to the video,
- 6:57uh, not the video, there's no video of the Supreme Court, but the audio you could
- 7:00listen to, and one of them, uh, Uh, ask the question, but what if, how do we know
- 7:05what exactly what I was talking about?
- 7:06What was in his mind?
- 7:07Maybe there was something there and he purposely wanted to leave it to his
- 7:11ex spouse and they all decided that exactly what you said, that if that
- 7:16was his intention after the divorce to make sure your intentions are carried
- 7:21out, you update the beneficiary form.
- 7:24and name that ex spouse so everybody knows that's what you wanted.
- 7:28All right.
- 7:28So if that's what you want.
- 7:29So now I see what you're getting at in terms of our initial question, is it
- 7:32better to be, uh, you know, a girlfriend or a ex girlfriend or an ex wife had,
- 7:39uh, with, with until you're married, there is no, like, unless you're married,
- 7:44there is no automatic revocation.
- 7:46You can live together.
- 7:47You can be girlfriend, boyfriend, doesn't matter.
- 7:50But unless you're married, Once you break up with that individual,
- 7:54there is no automatic revocation of that beneficiary form, right?
- 7:58So this is an unusual situation because the whole point of we we
- 8:03call this an ERISA plan It's a say a 401k under the federal laws.
- 8:09Spouses have huge protections.
- 8:11Mm hmm.
- 8:12And in almost everything the spouse is protected Except in this scenario the
- 8:18ex girlfriend got the million dollars.
- 8:21Got the whole thing, not even half.
- 8:23Right.
- 8:23The whole thing.
- 8:24Got all of it.
- 8:25So she stood in a better position than being, than being married.
- 8:29Makes me wonder, like, as you think about that, like, what other areas
- 8:33of the law, you know, are, are people better off being married or not married?
- 8:39Uh, and, and just think of a few off top of my head, right, as, as people
- 8:42are thinking about, you know, again, not necessarily directly related to that,
- 8:46but if you're, committed relationship versus being, let's say, married, which
- 8:52also should be a committed relationship.
- 8:55That's a good one.
- 8:56You know what I mean.
- 8:57If you're just, if you're together, yes.
- 9:00Like a lot of people, especially as they get older, they don't want to get married.
- 9:03They've been married once already.
- 9:04They want to keep things separate, but they like to be together.
- 9:08There might be some advantages on the income tax side of the equation because
- 9:10if you're married and file a, a joint return, there can sometimes be a marriage
- 9:14penalty on certain issues versus if you're separate and file single tax
- 9:18returns, there can be a benefit there.
- 9:20Uh, sometimes if an individual was married already, they might be receiving certain
- 9:25social security benefits from an ex spouse, where if they get remarried, those
- 9:30social security benefits might go away, so it might be better off for them to remain,
- 9:34uh, separate as well, but it's interesting to think, are there certain times when
- 9:38you'd be better off being not married, being a, again, a boyfriend or girlfriend
- 9:42and maintaining that as a relationship status versus actually being married.
- 9:45Well, the point of this, uh, what I wanted to get to, is the
- 9:49importance of a beneficiary form.
- 9:51It's an ironclad contract.
- 9:54And this is not the first of these cases.
- 9:56I mean, this is one of the strangest ones I've seen.
- 9:59I mean you know, ex girlfriend from 1989.
- 10:03That's when he broke up with her in 1989, and he just died recently.
- 10:08But checking beneficiary forms is critical.
- 10:11It may be one of the single biggest mistakes people make.
- 10:14You're familiar with other cases like this.
- 10:17A lot of them are in the divorce area.
- 10:18Remember the Kennedy case?
- 10:20Sure.
- 10:20Supreme Court case again.
- 10:21Right.
- 10:22Yep.
- 10:22Yep.
- 10:23Uh, the ex wife got, uh, got the money, even though she said
- 10:27I, she waived her, her rights.
- 10:29She was a liar.
- 10:31Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 10:32And the daughter went to the court.
- 10:33She said, but, but he didn't want to, he didn't want her to get the money, but
- 10:36he didn't change the beneficiary form.
- 10:38And they said the same thing in that case.
- 10:40They said he had every opportunity to change the form, but he chose not to.
- 10:46So and she got, why did she get the money?
- 10:50Well, because she was named on the beneficiary form.
- 10:52Right.
- 10:52And also, you know, this is an ERISA case.
- 10:56Uh, so, you know, you got to look at updates in your life.
- 11:01You got to, uh, you, you have to make sure your beneficiary forms
- 11:05say what you want them to say.
- 11:06Going back to the ex girlfriend case, we don't know what he wanted, but
- 11:09But apparently that's what he was.
- 11:11He had numerous warnings or not warnings, uh, communications over the years from
- 11:17the company over many, many years, over decades, it would seem to me like even in
- 11:21that case, if I was his advisor, right.
- 11:23And he said, yeah, you know, I know this is weird, Jeff, but.
- 11:27I've got this girlfriend from 1989.
- 11:29And she's now married to somebody else.
- 11:31And she's now married, she's now married to someone else.
- 11:33But I really want to leave her this money.
- 11:36My advice still might have been, hey, why don't we fill out a new beneficiary form?
- 11:40Right, make it clear.
- 11:41And just, that's right, make it clear, remove any doubt.
- 11:43You know, the beneficiary form is what controls the disposition of
- 11:46assets most of the time, unless it's overridden by some sort of federal
- 11:49or state law, things like that.
- 11:51But you know, the point is, this is like the last act you have on this earth.
- 11:55Like you're you're gone and this is the last little bit.
- 11:57I can't think of a worse scenario than having your final wishes not fulfilled
- 12:02because it either wasn't clear or because there was ambiguity and you left an
- 12:06opportunity for someone else to interpret what you really wanted to happen.
- 12:11Right, and you should look at, uh, activities in your life.
- 12:13I call them life events when they're birth, a death, a marriage, a
- 12:17divorce, a new grandchild, change of tax laws, whatever it is.
- 12:20These things should be updated.
- 12:22They override the wills.
- 12:23Oh, that was another thing.
- 12:24When I said, uh, there were a lot of comments online on the
- 12:28article, people said he should have said something in his will.
- 12:32Yeah, but where there's a will, there's no way it's gonna work.
- 12:34Right.
- 12:35Yeah.
- 12:35But these were some professionals on there says if he should have said something
- 12:38in the will that she doesn't get it, she still would have got it because the
- 12:43beneficiary form overrides the will.
- 12:46It's a strong document.
- 12:47Now a little difference been if this was an IRA, you don't have to in
- 12:52most cases or then maybe community property leave to a spouse, right?
- 12:57You could leave to anybody.
- 12:58In fact, there's cases there where people have taken their 401ks, move them to
- 13:02an IRA And then name, let's say their kids gotten remarried and said, sorry,
- 13:06new spouse, you don't get the money.
- 13:08It goes to my kids when I'm gone.
- 13:09Because the ERISA laws protecting spouses do not apply in an IRA.
- 13:14That's right.
- 13:14Yep.
- 13:15In fact, there's even cases on file where, uh, people with, uh,
- 13:18non-ERISA plans, things like 403Bs, don't get the same protection.
- 13:23That's right.
- 13:23There's that famous case, I don't know if it was a case, but, uh, I think it was.
- 13:27We used to refer to it, uh, matter of fact, I still use it.
- 13:30It's from January 20, 2005.
- 13:34From the New York Post.
- 13:35Uh, it was called Pension Pickle.
- 13:37We still give it out at our seminars.
- 13:39I still remember the headline, Broke Widower Loses $1 million to in-law.
- 13:42Right.
- 13:43Right.
- 13:43You're a financial advisor, you can't buy headlines that good.
- 13:46I know, I know.
- 13:47It was a great headline and, uh, you just have to see the headline.
- 13:50So this woman worked, uh, you know, 403B for the New York City school
- 13:54system, accumulated a million dollars.
- 13:56She died and, uh, she didn't, the spouse got disinherited.
- 14:02He said, how could this possibly be?
- 14:05Well, when she filled out her beneficiary form, it was before she was married.
- 14:09Years and years ago.
- 14:11So, he wasn't even in the picture.
- 14:12Who did she name?
- 14:13Her brother or mother?
- 14:15Her mother, her uncle, and her sister, I think.
- 14:17Yeah, the brother.
- 14:18The, the sister got the money.
- 14:20The mother and the uncle, I think, uh, pre deceased.
- 14:22Yep.
- 14:23And the sister got the money because she was on the beneficiary form.
- 14:26He said, but I'm the spouse.
- 14:27I've been married to her for years.
- 14:28Well, she didn't update the beneficiary form.
- 14:30Yeah, and, and I'm sure people are, again, you know, this is a confusing area.
- 14:33People are saying, but wait, they were married for more than a year.
- 14:35What's the difference?
- 14:36The difference is state and local 403Bs, like this one,
- 14:40are not covered under ERISA.
- 14:41Right.
- 14:41You know, what, what seems as, you know, As though it's so simple, you
- 14:45know, hey, just write down a name on a piece of paper is actually dictated
- 14:48by , a various number, a significant number of, of laws that all have, uh,
- 14:53you know, strange interactions with one another where, you know, ERISA
- 14:57overrides the beneficiary form, but state, but beneficiary form overrides
- 15:02the will, but state law can override, I mean, it, it's a very complicated mess.
- 15:06And again, the challenge here is not that it seems difficult and is difficult.
- 15:11The challenge is it often seems simple, so people take for granted that what
- 15:15they're doing or what they think they're doing is actually going to happen,
- 15:18when in reality they're not aware of the nuances and intricacies of the law
- 15:23and that's when these mistakes occur.
- 15:24Yeah, make sure to update.
- 15:26forms, make sure you can find them.
- 15:28I've seen problems recently with some mergers and financial planning firms
- 15:32too, uh, where the documents don't carry over to the, uh, next institution
- 15:39or they list the wrong beneficiary.
- 15:40We just saw a case where they listed the estate rather than the
- 15:43name beneficiaries and there were millions of dollars there and nobody
- 15:47noticed it until the guy was dead.
- 15:49Well, you can't change it after that.
- 15:50Yeah, it looks, look anytime there's a question about your beneficiaries,
- 15:54there's a change in institution, a change in life events, etc.
- 15:57Then, you know, I, I, I adhere to one philosophy.
- 16:01When in doubt, fill one out.
- 16:03Oh, that's a good one.
- 16:04Fill out a new beneficiary form.
- 16:05That's it.
- 16:05When in doubt, fill one out.
- 16:07Yeah.
- 16:07It can't hurt.
- 16:08If you're saying the same thing, All that will happen is it'll be even more
- 16:12clear that that was your intention.
- 16:13And keep a copy because there could even be a problem even if you
- 16:17think the institution has a copy.
- 16:19It may be an old copy, who knows, before they went through mergers or
- 16:23transitions and things like that.
- 16:25Yeah.
- 16:25Well, update your beneficiary form.
- 16:28Absolutely critical step as always.
- 16:29Ed, thanks for updating us on that case.
- 16:31That is a weird one for sure, but a great opportunity to learn from.
- 16:35That's right.
- 16:36Check your beneficiary forms.
- 16:38Do it now.
- 16:39That's right.
- 16:39And we'll see you next time on The Great Retirement Debate.
- 16:42Jeffrey Levine is Chief Planning Officer for Buckingham Wealth Partners.
- 16:46This podcast is for informational and educational purposes only and should
- 16:49not be construed as specific investment, accounting, legal, or tax advice.
- 16:52Certain information mentioned may be based on third party information
- 16:55which may become outdated or otherwise superseded without notice.
- 16:58Third party information is deemed to be reliable, but it's accuracy and
- 17:01completeness cannot be guaranteed.
- 17:03The topic discussed in corresponding arguments are those of the speakers
- 17:06and may not accurately reflect those of Buckingham wealth partners.