Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / FTB and CDTFA Settlement Program Best Practices: A View from the FTB & CDTFA
Transcript
- 0:03I'm Philipp Berend, share of the BHBA Taxation
- 0:06Law Section. The tax section is sponsored by
- 0:10Hochmann, Salk and Torscher Press PC. So Hochmann,
- 0:12Salk and Torscher Press PC advantage is experience
- 0:16and eye for innovation and genuine dedication
- 0:18to clients, their families and their business.
- 0:21In addition to their national practice in civil
- 0:24tax and criminal tax controversy and related
- 0:26litigation in federal and state courts, the firm
- 0:29is also active and successful in handling other
- 0:31non -tax. white collar investigation and prosecutions.
- 0:36I am delighted to introduce our speakers today,
- 0:38Gio Immodino and Catherine Lean, and our moderator
- 0:43is Michelle Weiss. Michelle is a principal at
- 0:46Holtz, Slavitt, Drabkin and Warner. She has over
- 0:4920 years of experience in tax controversy and
- 0:52litigation matters. Michelle helps with their
- 0:55civil and criminal tax matters. She represents
- 1:00her clients in all aspects of tax controversy
- 1:03in examination, appeals, and collection matters
- 1:06at the administrative level in litigation with
- 1:10federal, state, and local tax authorities, including
- 1:14the IRS, FTB, the CDTFA, EDD, and the Office
- 1:19of Tax Appeals. Among many achievements, Michelle
- 1:23has been the chair of the BHBA tax sections before
- 1:26me, so I'm very excited to have her here as a
- 1:29moderator. Jiro is an attorney and CPA who serves
- 1:34as the director of the franchise tax board settlement
- 1:37bureau. Before moving to the settlement bureau,
- 1:40Jiro worked in the general tax bureau for a little
- 1:44over nine years, handling like -kind exchanges,
- 1:47abusive tax avoidance transactions, accounting
- 1:50methods, partnership issues, and others. Before
- 1:53joining, Chiu worked at a big four accounting
- 1:57firm in the tax department of one of the nation's
- 2:00largest private commercial construction companies,
- 2:03at an international law firm in Tokyo, Japan,
- 2:06and at a tax law firm based in Sacramento. Chiu
- 2:09has taught accounting and taxation courses at
- 2:12the undergraduate and graduate level. Katie is
- 2:16tax counsel at the CDTFA. the California Department
- 2:20of Tax and Fee Administration. She holds a master's
- 2:23degree in dispute resolution from the Pepperdine
- 2:26-Strauss Institute and practiced commercial litigation
- 2:29and bankruptcy for nine years before joining
- 2:31the CDTFA, formerly known as the Board of Equalization
- 2:35in 2012. After beginning her tenure in the appeals
- 2:39bureau, she transitioned to the settlement bureau
- 2:42in 2013, where she continued her practice outside
- 2:46of work. She is a devoted mother of two, enjoys
- 2:50tax law, snowboarding, watching Netflix and HBO
- 2:53series. And now, Michelle, let's get started.
- 2:57OK. All right. So hi, everybody. Nice to see
- 3:01you here. I want to thank Chiro and Katie for...
- 3:06giving their time to help educate all of us tax
- 3:11practitioners about the settlement bureaus of
- 3:14their agencies and what we're going to discuss
- 3:17today is the scope of what they can do. We'll
- 3:20also mention what they can't do and they'll provide
- 3:23practical tips and insights because as a practitioner
- 3:26you always want to know okay what should I be
- 3:29doing something is My video is very weird, and
- 3:32if it continues, I might have to turn my video
- 3:34off. But anyway, that said, just as a housekeeping
- 3:37matter, if you have any questions, please, let's
- 3:42see, oh, there's no Q &A function here. I guess
- 3:46you have to, is there a Q &A function? No, I
- 3:50guess. Yes, there's a Q &A function. So please
- 3:52put your questions in the Q &A function. We're
- 3:54not really going to use the slides today. They're
- 3:56just materials and some talking points for us.
- 4:00And please ask questions, because this is meant
- 4:03to be a dialogue between three people about the
- 4:08various settlement. So I guess we can kick off.
- 4:13There actually is statutory authority for these.
- 4:18settlement administrations, settlement bureaus.
- 4:20And I guess we could start with Chiro. You can
- 4:22talk a little bit about the scope and the authority
- 4:25of what it is you guys can do with the FTB in
- 4:27settlement. And then we'll, and then maybe, and
- 4:30then Katie can talk about the CDTFA and we'll
- 4:33keep going back and forth. Yeah. Hi. Well, you're
- 4:36welcome everyone. I want to echo Michelle's comments
- 4:39about If you have any questions, please post
- 4:42them. It's a lot more fun when it's interactive
- 4:44and we can respond to your questions as I was
- 4:47to go through this. So the FTB's authority for
- 4:52settlements is in Revenue Taxation Code section,
- 4:5519 -442. And this was initially enacted in 1992
- 5:02and it was made permanent in 1994. Our statute
- 5:08gives us authority is to settle any protest,
- 5:11appeal or claim for refund. And so the big takeaway
- 5:15there is that if you have an audit, it is premature
- 5:18for the settlement process. It has to be in one
- 5:21of those three steps. We have authority to settle.
- 5:29tax disputes based on the cost and risk of litigation,
- 5:32which means we can't consider any other factors
- 5:34except for the cost and the risk. And so things
- 5:37like ability to pay, unfortunately, those are
- 5:40outside of what can be analyzed in the settlement
- 5:44program. And that's kind of a high overview of
- 5:48our authority scope. And Katie, do you want to
- 5:54speak to the CDTFA scope? And my video is being
- 5:57weird again. Yeah, sure Michelle. So we're a
- 6:01lot like the FDB. We also have statutory authority
- 6:04to settle pending appeals cases. So ours is mostly
- 6:09in revenue and taxation code section 7093 .5.
- 6:13That's for sales and use tax. But we also deal
- 6:17with a variety of other special tax and fee cases,
- 6:20so there are similar enabling statutes in those
- 6:23other other. types of tax and fees. For example,
- 6:28you know, we also settle cannabis related issues.
- 6:32And a lot like the FTB, you know, our authority
- 6:36to settle is limited to pending administrative
- 6:40appeals cases. So it's, you know, it's good timely
- 6:42appeal, an administrative protest or a claim
- 6:45for refund. So if you're still in the audit process,
- 6:48and there's no determination issued yet, then
- 6:50it is premature for settlement. Okay, and the
- 6:54question and I apologize my video is off because
- 6:56it's acting weird but For each of you when is
- 7:00there a time and it's too late to approach settlement
- 7:03Okay, so as long as you're you know, we do administrative
- 7:13settlements and so of course once you're at the
- 7:16Superior Court then you're you're beyond the
- 7:19administrative level and so then any some has
- 7:22happened with the AG and we are of course are
- 7:24there to support the process as a client. But
- 7:29during the administrative process, you know,
- 7:32all the way through an appeal with the OTA, you
- 7:35know, up until there's oral arguments, then you
- 7:40can ask to come into the settlement program.
- 7:44You know, once a matter goes final at the administrative
- 7:48level, so whether it's you know, you didn't protest
- 7:51or you got a final decision from the OTA, but
- 7:54once it's final, we lose our authority, our statutory
- 7:58authority to settle, because again, it's based
- 8:00on an act of protest, appeal, or claim for refund.
- 8:05And Katie, what about with the CDTFA? Yeah, same
- 8:08here. It's got to be in the administrative process
- 8:10and not in state court litigation. I think, Cheryl,
- 8:13it sounds to me like you guys take them up to
- 8:16the OTA hearing. For us, we do ask that they
- 8:20request settlement at least five days before
- 8:22the OTA hearing, because then that gives us enough
- 8:24time to notify everybody to stop the hearing.
- 8:27So we do ask that it's at least five days before
- 8:31the OTA hearing. So that means also when you're
- 8:34in front of the OTA, you still can request settlement,
- 8:37and that will pause the OTA process, right? Right.
- 8:43Yeah, mostly, you know, we do. If it's a repeat
- 8:47request, we may not take it in, but it depends.
- 8:51If there's a likelihood of settlement, then yes,
- 8:53we do accept it and that will pause the OTA process.
- 8:57All right, and Katie, can you just explain how
- 9:01do you get into settlement with the CDTFA? Do
- 9:03you write a letter? Is there a form? How does
- 9:06that work and what should a taxpayer include
- 9:11with their? with what they send you. Yeah, that's
- 9:16a really good question. It's really easy to get
- 9:18into some of it. You can. There's a form 393
- 9:22so you can fill that out and email it to us as
- 9:25settlement at cdta .ca .gov or a lot of times
- 9:28the taxpayers will mention it during the appeals
- 9:31conference and then that gets routed over to
- 9:33us as a summer request. They could do it online
- 9:36through their online portals, but pretty much
- 9:39you know any contact. if they indicate their
- 9:42interest in settlement that gets rooted to us
- 9:44will be processed as a settlement request. And
- 9:48I think there's another part to your question,
- 9:50Michelle. Was it what's helpful to include in
- 9:52their request? What should someone include if
- 9:55they were to request settlement? Yeah, you know,
- 9:59I think it's always helpful to include their
- 10:00contentions. You know what their contentions,
- 10:03if they have any additional information or evidence
- 10:06they would like us to consider, that's always
- 10:08helpful to include and to organize their arguments.
- 10:12And what happens if they're including materials
- 10:16that were not previously reviewed by the CD TFA
- 10:22examiner? You know, we consider that too. We
- 10:27review that too, you know. Although I think if
- 10:31it's really good information, it might be helpful
- 10:33to give it to the examiner or the auditor to
- 10:37see if they can provide a complete adjustment
- 10:41as opposed to, you know, a settlement. All right,
- 10:45but is it required? Does it have to go through
- 10:47any kind of process? Is there any requirement
- 10:50that it be looked at by the examiner first? No,
- 10:54there isn't. Yeah. All right, and Chiro, on the
- 10:58FTB side, how does someone get into settlement
- 11:01and what would you like to see included with
- 11:04the package? Yeah, so we have FTB notice 2020
- 11:09-03, and that includes the process for applying
- 11:13for settlement. Nowadays, most people apply via
- 11:17email. There's an email option, a hard mail option,
- 11:20physical mail, and there is a facsimile option.
- 11:26The email, of course, is instantaneous, it's
- 11:29easiest. We've made our system so that once you
- 11:32send your email to our specific request element
- 11:35email address, you'll get a response if it goes
- 11:39through, which acknowledges that it's been received.
- 11:41That way you have peace of mind that you know
- 11:43that your email went through. And so that's the
- 11:48process. We have access to the file, and so,
- 11:54What we like to see in the settlement request
- 11:58is to help us understand the risks and tell us
- 12:02what the party's risks are. And you can tell
- 12:06us both sides. What's FCB's risk? What's the
- 12:08taxpayer's risk? And what we're trying to do
- 12:11is we're trying to tee up a good discussion.
- 12:13And so that's kind of the first step in the process.
- 12:17And I guess to piggyback on what Katie and Michelle
- 12:21are talking about a moment ago, there's a difference
- 12:25between the FTB and the CTFA process where for
- 12:30the FTB, we like to have all the facts in the
- 12:35record before it comes into settlement. And if
- 12:38we're going through the negotiation process and
- 12:40something comes up and there's like a one pager
- 12:43or some simple document which is relevant, it's
- 12:46got some small impact, then of course, we're
- 12:50going to be flexible and have you share it with
- 12:52us. there's two reasons why we like to have it
- 12:56in the record before you apply for Stellman.
- 12:58One is, we're 20 people and we cover all the
- 13:03areas of FTB and so we'd like to understand what
- 13:07the FTB's litigating position is. So have the
- 13:09subject matter experts look at it, have them
- 13:11share what their litigating position is, and
- 13:13have that go back and forth with the taxpayers
- 13:15so we can go right to having real good discussions
- 13:18about the risks. And the other part is something
- 13:21that Katie had touched on which is, You know,
- 13:24if you present facts which show that you're right,
- 13:27we don't want to settle. We want to have a withdrawal.
- 13:29And so if it's going to result in a partial or
- 13:32a full withdrawal, let's have that happen and
- 13:35then let's settle what's left over. So that's
- 13:38really important. So the other question, though,
- 13:41is with the settlement, what if a taxpayer thinks,
- 13:45you know, I'm really correct. I am 100 percent.
- 13:47I am fully correct. But the taxpayer doesn't
- 13:51want to risk, for example, going before the OTA
- 13:54or the cost of going before the OTA will be heavier,
- 14:00for example, than going to settlement because
- 14:01you might have to bring in witnesses and all
- 14:03kinds of other things that you need to do in
- 14:05the hearing process and briefing and so on. And
- 14:09so can a taxpayer come to settlement and just
- 14:13say, look, I think I have 100 percent or do they
- 14:17have to concede something? But I think for us,
- 14:24a settlement is a settlement and 100 % is not
- 14:27really a settlement. I think there's certainly
- 14:30going to be concessions on both sides if it's
- 14:32a settlement. Okay. And before you, so I know
- 14:39with Chiro, I know the answer to this question
- 14:41is sometimes you might put a taxpayer through
- 14:44a certain process in the settlement request to
- 14:49make sure that it's worthy of going through settlement.
- 14:52But do you also do that? In other words, like,
- 14:56Chiro, maybe you want to explain to some degree
- 14:58how you might get involved with settlement requests
- 15:01coming in. Yeah. So I know later in this presentation,
- 15:06we're going to talk about things to look at.
- 15:09But when someone applies to enter the settlement
- 15:11program, the first steps, there's some due diligence
- 15:15administrative steps. But At some point it gets
- 15:18to me to make a decision on whether to accept
- 15:22the case into the program. And one of the things
- 15:24I'm really looking for is are we going to tee
- 15:27up a productive negotiation or is there something
- 15:30which needs to be worked out first so that we
- 15:33can have good discussions. And so what happens
- 15:35sometimes I see a case applies for settlement.
- 15:40And I'll talk to the rep and I'll tell her up,
- 15:43Hey, I see you're making this basis argument,
- 15:45but you haven't. offer any evidence to support
- 15:48your basis? Is there evidence you have that you
- 15:49want to put into the record first? Some clients
- 15:52will say, yes, I do. And so we'll have them not
- 15:55come into settlement. Then they'll go back to
- 15:56the regular part of FTB. They'll admit their
- 15:59evidence. They'll work up their case. Maybe FTB
- 16:01allows part of the basis. And then what's left
- 16:03over, now that comes into settlement. And so
- 16:06that's a lot of what I do is to try and tee up
- 16:10a case for a successful negotiation. And Katie,
- 16:14do you have something similar in the CDA too?
- 16:16And it's informal what Shiro is talking about,
- 16:19but do you guys go through that kind of a process
- 16:21also? Yeah, not really. So a lot of times cases
- 16:27come in to SOMA very early on in the appeals
- 16:29process before they really develop the case during
- 16:32the appeals process. So we do take it in that
- 16:34stage too. So we don't require that they, you
- 16:38know, admit it into record or anything. I you
- 16:42know I if I do see because a lot of times ours
- 16:44are audit cases so they might not have any documentation
- 16:48during the audit but then they later locate a
- 16:50bunch of documentation so if I see that they
- 16:52have very good information now that they didn't
- 16:54have before I might tell them hey I think you'll
- 16:57do better if you present this out in the appeals
- 17:00to the auditor and not you know try to settle
- 17:03it and then leave it up to them. But I've also
- 17:07straight up told them that, hey, I think you
- 17:09might feel better if you present this in the
- 17:10appeals process. All right. So that, I guess,
- 17:14is there anything else that either one of you
- 17:15want to add about just the point of trying to
- 17:19get into the settlement process or kicking off
- 17:22the settlement process? And before we get into
- 17:24what happens during the process? Any other? No.
- 17:30Okay. All right. Great. So the next thing we're
- 17:34going to talk about is the settlement process
- 17:37in each bureau and what to expect. And this is
- 17:40in your materials. But what can you, okay, Katie,
- 17:45let's start with you. Can you just give general
- 17:47timeframes and the levels, you know, the steps
- 17:49that it goes through and how, you know, how someone
- 17:52gets assigned to it and all the different things
- 17:55that happen during the settlement negotiations
- 17:57and process? Yeah, sure. And I think we put in
- 18:02the materials. We do have like a general table,
- 18:05like a time frame on our website, just a very
- 18:08general what to expect when you submit your settlement
- 18:11request. But generally, the request comes in.
- 18:15It'll get assigned to a settlement officer the
- 18:18following month. You know, if it's an audit case,
- 18:21you would try to sign it to an auditor. If it's
- 18:23a legal case, it gets assigned to an attorney.
- 18:26So, you know, you'll expect to hear from your
- 18:29signed settlement officer within roughly two
- 18:32months of you submitting the request. Just a
- 18:35question. So what's the difference between those?
- 18:37You said there's two different cases sometimes.
- 18:40Can you explain a little bit more what you mean
- 18:41about when it goes to an auditor versus when
- 18:43it goes to legal? Yeah, sure. We have a lot of
- 18:47audit cases, so it could be an audit of a liquor
- 18:50store, a car dealership, a restaurant. So if
- 18:53it's a audit issue, peer audit issue. A lot of
- 18:56times those get assigned to an auditor and we
- 18:59have a team of, right now I think we have roughly
- 19:0214 auditors and they're very experienced. A lot
- 19:04of them were audit reviewers from the field offices.
- 19:10So the auditors will review the case for audit
- 19:13risks and they'll work up the case. But if it's
- 19:15a legal issue, for example, if they're arguing
- 19:19nexus or some kind of exemption or partial exemption,
- 19:24then those get assigned to an attorney to work,
- 19:27to research those legal issues. And what about
- 19:31on the FTB side, Jero? Yeah. And so this is a
- 19:35good contrast between our two processes. And
- 19:37just to reflect, we've got different taxes that
- 19:40we administer. And with the FTB, again, we don't
- 19:45have auditors in settlement who audit cases.
- 19:49And we don't have attorneys who are going to
- 19:51be, you know, spend a lot of time researching
- 19:54the issues. Instead, that needs to happen outside
- 19:57of settlement. And so the case gets developed,
- 19:59and then we have attorneys who are such matter
- 20:00experts in the areas that they're going to get
- 20:02up to speed on the issues and start working on
- 20:04the risk. But based on our volume of cases, we
- 20:09just don't have the resources to research issues
- 20:13in our bureau. And so again, we ask that cases
- 20:17come in fully developed. stepping back a little
- 20:21bit, I know for especially a lot of federal practitioners,
- 20:25one of the big differences between how the FTB
- 20:28and the CDTFA administer their settlement programs
- 20:31is I know when you go to the feds, you're generally
- 20:33dealing with a lot of other states too, you're
- 20:36dealing with the same person who's arguing your
- 20:39case and who's also working on the settlement.
- 20:41But the way that we do it is our settlement bureau,
- 20:45it's a separate part of FTB. And so when you
- 20:48want to go, and negotiate a settlement, you leave
- 20:52the part of FTB you're with, you go into the
- 20:54settlement bureau, and all we do is we negotiate
- 20:58cases. We're independent of the issue, we haven't
- 21:01worked on the case previously, and we put a lot
- 21:07of focus in being independent and being skeptical
- 21:09of the FTB's position and the taxpayer's position,
- 21:12trying to really take an objective viewpoint
- 21:14of the risks of both sides. you know, kind of
- 21:19share that difference about how our process works
- 21:22than some other processes that some of your participants
- 21:25may have been through. Right, so for example,
- 21:28if you're in front of the OTA and you're dealing
- 21:33with an FTB attorney, and there goes my video
- 21:36again, one second, and you're dealing with the
- 21:40FTB attorney, that person is just litigating
- 21:42that case in front of the OTA and they They don't
- 21:47even have the authority to settle it. They have
- 21:49to come to you in both ages. Yeah, same with
- 21:54us also. Yeah, we're in a separate bureau. And
- 21:57a lot of times, talk to peers are confused because
- 21:59they don't realize we're separate. And settlement
- 22:02is confidential. So whatever they share with
- 22:04us, we don't share with the appeals conference
- 22:06holder or whatnot. That's a big part is that
- 22:11once you come into settlement, we sign a non
- 22:14-disclosure agreement. effectively, our practices
- 22:18go beyond the terms of non -disclosure agreement,
- 22:20because our goal is that we're going to come
- 22:22into settlement and we're going to be very open
- 22:24about strengths and weaknesses of both sides,
- 22:27positions including FTBs, you know, positions.
- 22:30And so in order to have those real productive
- 22:33conversations, there's got to be a level of comfort
- 22:37in having those open discussions. That's how
- 22:39we kind of bridge the gap and get to a number
- 22:43in the middle, you know, and so That non -disclosure
- 22:46agreement is what kind of protects all that.
- 22:49But again, we go beyond, our actual practices
- 22:52go beyond what is required by the NDA. Which
- 22:56means, and that's a really good point because,
- 23:00for example, in the IRS side, after you go through
- 23:02appeals, if you then go on to deal with an attorney,
- 23:06they get the appeals file. But no one else at
- 23:10the FTB is going to get the file from your settlement
- 23:12discussions, right? So the only thing they'll
- 23:16know is, oh, it wasn't successful. So now they're
- 23:19back in front of the appeals officer or whatever.
- 23:23They're back in their OTA hearing or whatever
- 23:26level they're at. Yeah, we take steps. We don't
- 23:30let settlement staff on our departmental teams
- 23:33for subject matter areas and things. And the
- 23:35way that we actually interact, we really understand
- 23:40that We're all in the same office. And so for
- 23:43taxpayers to be comfortable to have those open
- 23:45discussions, they have to have a belief that
- 23:49when we talk about these cases, that those conversations
- 23:55don't leave the room. We don't leave the Bureau.
- 23:58Yeah. And I think that's a really good point
- 24:01for practitioners to think about, because you
- 24:05can really have a lot of comfort. You might say
- 24:08things that might not help your settlement negotiations,
- 24:11but you don't have to worry that you're going
- 24:13to say something maybe just for purposes of settlement,
- 24:16and then the attorney is going to somehow get
- 24:19it in the case file or something. So that's a
- 24:22very helpful point. And then is there any other
- 24:26points that you want to discuss about what happens
- 24:31during the settlement process, what people can
- 24:33expect, and back and forth, and all that kind
- 24:36of thing? In terms of like what what happens?
- 24:41OK, so you're now in front of settlement and
- 24:44so what's what's happening now? You submitted
- 24:46your package and so now what can the? What can
- 24:52the practitioner expect next? I guess Katie,
- 24:55you can start with that. Yeah, so I I do want
- 24:59to kind of piggyback on to what we're just talking
- 25:01about. I do think it's really helpful when both
- 25:03sides come in. being very frank with each other
- 25:06and very open and honest. Because I think when
- 25:09you do recognize that the other side has good
- 25:11arguments, I think that's when you can really
- 25:13work together to come to a resolution, right?
- 25:17So I think it's helpful to have those open discussions.
- 25:22And for us, in terms of what to expect, it's
- 25:26always nice when the practitioner comes in organized
- 25:29and has their thoughts and contentions in place
- 25:33for us so that we can have that really productive
- 25:37discussion instead of just throwing in the kitchen
- 25:39sink and asking us to figure it out. So it's
- 25:43always nice to come in with your ducks in line
- 25:47and have your case prepared. That way we can
- 25:49really work towards a resolution. But if we are
- 25:53able to reach a settlement, Then we send out
- 25:57our agreements through DocuSign. Once we get
- 26:00the taxpayer signature, then we start the formal
- 26:04settlement approval process. So for us, they
- 26:07do have to be approved by our management. If
- 26:10it's over a certain dollar threshold, it goes
- 26:12to the attorney general's office also, and then
- 26:15gets approved by our director. Okay, and Chiro,
- 26:21what about on your side? Yeah, so. When a case
- 26:25comes into settlement, it gets assigned to a
- 26:28settlement officer. And they're going to go and
- 26:30take an initial view of the case. And they're
- 26:35going to kind of, they'll then meet with me and
- 26:39they'll meet with some colleagues in settlement
- 26:41too maybe, and we'll kind of get an initial calibration
- 26:45of our thoughts of the case. But it's really
- 26:49just an initial, it's made to help tee up. the
- 26:53negotiations. You know, one of the things that
- 26:54we really stress is that we're just trying to
- 26:58get our ducks in a row and that the negotiations
- 27:01have to be open so they can be that whatever
- 27:07way they flow can kind of can take hold. You
- 27:10know, one of my favorite results of a settlement
- 27:13negotiations is when the settlement officer comes
- 27:15back to me says, hey, you know, the taxpayer
- 27:19kind of blew me away. They brought up that we
- 27:20hadn't talked about. And I think the risk is
- 27:25totally different from kind of stuff we initially
- 27:27thought about, because that's our goal is that
- 27:30we want to have a real settlement conference
- 27:34where real discussions take place and they're
- 27:38meaningful discussions and they're merit -based.
- 27:40And so our goal is to really have a collaborative
- 27:44process to reach what everyone feels is a fair
- 27:47deal. And another thing about settlement, I think,
- 27:51which for us is important. I think it's a healing
- 27:54process. I think that with taxis speeds, no one
- 27:57likes them. No one likes going through that process.
- 28:02And settlements, a time when you can be told,
- 28:06hey, I see where you're coming from. There's
- 28:09a lot of merit to what you're saying. You could
- 28:12win based on your arguments. And I think it's
- 28:15got kind of a whole nother layer to that thing's
- 28:19really, really meaningful, too. And yeah, I'm
- 28:23really sorry, Michelle. I'm really glad you said
- 28:25that, Shiro, because I thought that does resonate
- 28:28with me a lot. And a lot of times taxpayers don't
- 28:31like the audit process and it's very stressful
- 28:33for them. So sometimes settlement is the first
- 28:36place they understand what happened during the
- 28:39audit or understand how the audit was done. So,
- 28:42yes, I think it's a healing process for both
- 28:45sides. Right. And what about a payment? Like,
- 28:50how does that work? So when you get into a settlement
- 28:54and there is a proposal of, and obviously this
- 28:58doesn't work with a refund claim. It would only
- 28:59be when there's a deficiency of some sort. Do
- 29:03you have to pay up front? Do you get a payment
- 29:05plan? Like, how does a taxpayer deal with that?
- 29:10Katie, you can start on that one. Yeah, we do
- 29:14offer payment plans. it's a lot of times it's
- 29:18based on need but currently we offer payment
- 29:21plans anywhere between six months to 30 months
- 29:24and that's without financial review. And what
- 29:29if what if a taxpayer really can't afford to
- 29:32pay what happens there? When they can't afford
- 29:37to pay it we have a separate unit that deals
- 29:41with the ability to pay issue it's the offer
- 29:43and compromise unit so I think for us they do
- 29:45need to be able to fund a settlement that we
- 29:48can get approved. Okay so what if someone um
- 29:53just even the amount that if they need to do
- 29:56an offer and compromise would they still be doing
- 29:59it based on the settlement or would they now
- 30:01be out of settlement and now because they can't
- 30:04even afford to pay the settlement are they like
- 30:06how does the offer and compromise come into it
- 30:08are they now out of settlement at this point?
- 30:11Yeah we usually refer them to the offer and compromise
- 30:14unit. So they can just resolve it based on collections
- 30:18anyway, right? And then Chiro, how does the FTB
- 30:23operate in terms of payments? Yeah, so first
- 30:26off, just like the CDTFA, the standards for the
- 30:30offer and compromise unit and settlement unit,
- 30:33they're completely different. And so there's
- 30:36no value in trying to go from one to the other.
- 30:39Just the way the law works, it just wouldn't
- 30:43work that way. If you qualify for offer and compromise,
- 30:48then you can go there. But settlement is based
- 30:52on an amount due based on the risk and cost of
- 30:55litigation. So we don't have payment plans in
- 31:00FTB settlement. Instead, the amount is due at
- 31:05the time we have a tentative settlement. Once
- 31:07we receive payment, then we move the case through
- 31:12the approval process. That being said, we try
- 31:17and work with people. If people need a little
- 31:19bit of extra time, we try and be reasonable.
- 31:22The goal is to be flexible to get the deal done
- 31:26and so we try and work together. If someone is
- 31:30just far away from having the liquidity to pay
- 31:34the settlement amount, sometimes the case leaves
- 31:36settlement and they go back to the place in FTB
- 31:40they were beforehand where they go to the OTA.
- 31:42And once they have the money, then they're welcome
- 31:47to contact me and say, hey, we got the money.
- 31:49We're ready to move forward. And we'll calculate
- 31:51the amount due. We'll confirm that no case law
- 31:54or anything has come out, which changes the analysis.
- 31:57But assuming the risk analysis is about the same,
- 32:00then we'll calculate the amount due and have
- 32:03them pay and bring them right back in. OK, we
- 32:08have a question. Here, I think I understand this
- 32:12one. Also, the person who asked the question
- 32:15about, I'm not sure I understand it, about community
- 32:18property. If you can clarify your question, we
- 32:21can ask it. Okay, so here's one. Does settlement
- 32:24always start with an audit? For example, if a
- 32:27fiduciary paid a tax and a court later determines
- 32:30the fiduciary had no authority to be the fiduciary
- 32:32or pay the tax, Is settlement a place to go to
- 32:36reconcile the difference or does it have to start
- 32:39with filing a claim for refund? I think either
- 32:45of both of you can answer that question. So again,
- 32:48under the statute, we only have authority to
- 32:52settle a protest, appeal, or claim for refund.
- 32:56And so if one of those three isn't in play, then
- 32:59we wouldn't. statutorily be able to bring the
- 33:02case into the settlement program. And Katie,
- 33:07what about on your side? Yeah, I'm not sure if
- 33:11I understand the question. This sounds to me
- 33:12more like an income tax question. But I think
- 33:16there is another part where it doesn't always
- 33:19stem from an audit. No, not necessarily. It could
- 33:22be like an overpayment where they file a claim
- 33:25for refund for CDTFA settlements. Okay, and there's
- 33:31another question. For Chiro, did you say payment
- 33:35is required on reaching tentative settlement
- 33:37but before final approval? What if final approval
- 33:40does not happen? I guess a .k .a. give your money
- 33:44back. Or is it now being applied to the liability
- 33:48or other things like that? That's right, and
- 33:51so a clause in our settlement agreement states
- 33:56that if final approval does not happen, then
- 34:00you'll get the money sent back to you. It doesn't
- 34:03get automatically applied anywhere? No, we don't
- 34:07do that. In fact, what we do is a settlement
- 34:09payment is treated as a deposit. Like any other
- 34:12deposit, you have the right to ask for it back.
- 34:16Actually, that's helpful to know because other
- 34:19taxing authorities don't necessarily have that.
- 34:24By the way, we've had times when the payment
- 34:28was somehow, you know, misplaced by FTB as a
- 34:33payment. And, you know, we unwound it and said,
- 34:36hey, this was a deposit, it was part of a settlement.
- 34:41And so we make sure that, you know, that's the
- 34:45treatment that it gets. So is the taxpayer making
- 34:47an electronic deposit or are they mailing you,
- 34:49I guess if they mail you a check, you can hold
- 34:51it. But I don't know if they can pay by check.
- 34:53I don't know how that works. But we don't hold
- 34:55checks. So almost all payments are electronic
- 34:59and you know anyone who is thinking about making
- 35:02a check payment you have to be very wary because
- 35:05we have an e -pay requirement for many taxpayers
- 35:08and there's e -pay penalty and so those penalties
- 35:13are very hard to obey and so if someone is thinking
- 35:16about making an electronic payment it's better
- 35:19to check first and see if you have an e -pay
- 35:21requirement or if your client has an e -pay requirement
- 35:23and we're happy to help you with that. Okay.
- 35:27And well, Katie, I guess you don't have that
- 35:29issue because you don't have to pay ahead of
- 35:30time. So what happens, Katie, if someone enters
- 35:34into an installment agreement for their settlement
- 35:39and defaults on that installment agreement? Yeah.
- 35:44Yeah, it happens. Are they back to ground zero
- 35:48or what happens? Yes, under under the settlement
- 35:52agreement, there is a provision that allows us
- 35:55to unwind the agreement if there's a substantial
- 35:58noncompliance. So, you know, if there's some
- 36:00kind of bad faith where they. into an agreement
- 36:03and make one payment and the default on the rest
- 36:05of it, then, you know, perhaps there's a substantial
- 36:08noncompliance where we can unwind it and revert
- 36:11their liability to the original amount. But I
- 36:15think, you know, most of the time, you know,
- 36:17as long as they've made a good faith effort to
- 36:19pay, it does, you know, get monitored by a compliance
- 36:23staff. And then, you know, Whatever happens after
- 36:26that, they can work with the compliance staff
- 36:29to adjust the payment or it becomes a collections
- 36:34issue. OK, but they still so they get to try
- 36:39to hang on to their settlement as much as possible.
- 36:42Yeah, they actually get the benefit of it right
- 36:45when it's approved. So for example, if their
- 36:47liability is $100, but we settle for 80. you
- 36:50know, when it's approved, we basically adjust
- 36:52their liability in the system down to 80. And
- 36:55then once they paid off, paid that 80, then the
- 36:58liability is done. So they actually get the benefit
- 37:01of the settlement right when it's approved. Okay.
- 37:06And here's another question. This is for the
- 37:10FTB. Is there a template for FTB settlement that
- 37:12shows the terms of the agreement minus the specific
- 37:15facts of a particular case, is it available for
- 37:19distribution? Oh, I guess somebody is wondering
- 37:21if it's possible to get a a sanitized settlement
- 37:26agreement. You know, unfortunately, we don't
- 37:30have, you know, sanitized settlement agreements.
- 37:35You know, if it's helpful, the terms are, you
- 37:39know, fairly simple regarding the facts is, you
- 37:41know, we agree on a number. That's a big part
- 37:43about settlement is that we don't agree on on
- 37:47different issues or or any kind of weighing of
- 37:51who's wrong or who's right we just agree that
- 37:54a tax liability is being settled in consideration
- 37:58for a certain number either a payment from ftb
- 38:01to taxpayer or pamphlet tax products okay and
- 38:05i think this question was already answered but
- 38:08i'll ask it anyway, just for clarification. Is
- 38:12it necessary or beneficial to go to settlement
- 38:14process even if the taxpayer needs to go to the
- 38:16offer and compromise unit due to the failing
- 38:18financial conditions at the outset? I think you
- 38:22both answered that, but either one of you can
- 38:24answer it. Okay, Shiro, answer it. If in this
- 38:36case, it makes sense just to go straight to the
- 38:38offer and compromise. Right. Yeah. Because you're
- 38:42going to end up with a lesser amount anyway.
- 38:44So you just save a lot of resources on not having
- 38:47to go through the whole process, right? OK. So
- 38:51are there any other things, any tips? Oh, here's
- 38:55a question that I have. Sometimes, and this happens,
- 39:00for example, with the IRS, different appeals
- 39:03officers have different styles. This is the thing
- 39:06I could give the most analogy to for settlement,
- 39:09where I call it the one and done, where you send
- 39:12in all your stuff, they come to a conclusion,
- 39:16you have a meeting, and all they're doing is
- 39:18telling you what they think, and you're not really
- 39:20going to be able to negotiate anything. And other
- 39:22appeals officers, It's the beginning of a conversation.
- 39:27And so the question is, which style is used in
- 39:33your particular agency? So I guess, Katie, why
- 39:36don't you tell us? People do that. Like, is it
- 39:41one and done, where you give everything in, and
- 39:44then they tell you what you think, or are you
- 39:47engaging in a dialogue? Yeah, I like to think
- 39:51we're engaging in a dialogue. Although sometimes
- 39:54I think if it's an audit case, the risks to us
- 39:57are fairly limited and the burdens on the taxpayer
- 39:59to provide evidence to show that they're entitled
- 40:03to adjustment. So, you know, I think we do generally
- 40:07try to hear them out and to see what information
- 40:10they have that we can consider to justify a better
- 40:13offer for them. um you know so it is a bit of
- 40:17a back and forth um but i think we are pretty
- 40:19upfront in terms of what we can offer and get
- 40:22approved based on their case and chiro yeah you
- 40:27know i think you know we you were very similar
- 40:32you know there's there's a number of different
- 40:34styles of negotiations of course and i don't
- 40:38know the last like 30 years or so what's become
- 40:41very popular to read books i can keep getting
- 40:43to yes and all these have modern negotiation
- 40:46books, you hear merit -based negotiation, principle
- 40:51negotiation, interest -based, and what it means
- 40:53is you don't have people going back and forth
- 40:55going, you know, 20, 80, 60, 40, doing that type
- 40:59of thing. Instead, what it is is you talk about
- 41:02the objective facts and you try and have some
- 41:05kind of objective basis, you know, like in our
- 41:07summits we often talk about, hey, What's a court
- 41:10or the office of tax appeals likely to be with
- 41:12this case? Well, let's look at other case. How
- 41:14has it been treated? How are these facts different?
- 41:16We try and have these real productive discussions.
- 41:21And so that's our general kind of approach. But
- 41:24talking about styles, our folks in Selman, all
- 41:28we do is we negotiate. We don't do anything else.
- 41:31And so we spent a lot of training on creating
- 41:35kind of these these environments which lead to
- 41:40productive negotiations. It means that sometimes
- 41:44we have someone who's upset and they've gone
- 41:48through a process and they're reasonably upset.
- 41:50And so our folks are trained to kind of work
- 41:53with them and kind of let the emotions get out
- 41:56and build the bridges and then be able to get
- 42:00to productive discussions and let people be heard
- 42:03and let them know that we see the merit in what
- 42:06they're saying. I would say our folks are really
- 42:10good at accommodating their styles for the situation
- 42:14they are in. Okay. All right. Well, that's great
- 42:20to know. All right. And I think we went over
- 42:24this, but when a taxpayer should choose settlement.
- 42:29Okay. We already discussed that. I'm just going
- 42:31through our list of issues. And so, This is something
- 42:37also important is when what issues may or may
- 42:41not go into settlement. So what can be considered
- 42:46and what can't be considered. So it's sure why
- 42:50don't you kick us off with that one. Okay and
- 42:52again a lot of what we're talking about is in
- 42:56the PowerPoint handout or the materials that
- 43:00we prepared. So first element number one you
- 43:04know when The settlement bureau was created in
- 43:0892. It was created by the legislature to raise
- 43:12revenue. And, you know, one of the things that
- 43:16the direct drive pushed in is that our purpose
- 43:20has changed and our purpose is not to raise revenue.
- 43:24It's to give taxpayers the opportunity to settle
- 43:27their bona fide tax debits. And that's kind of
- 43:29what drives us. And it's important because that
- 43:32changes your... your mentality in the cases you
- 43:36let in, the cases you analyze, in the kind of
- 43:38all parts of the process. And so for us, if there's
- 43:43a bonafide tax dispute, we want to give taxpayers
- 43:46the opportunity to enter into settlement negotiations.
- 43:51Because that's kind of the starting point. But
- 43:54the issues that, you know, generally the issues
- 43:55that come in, you know, when there's an issue
- 43:57of law, the law is not clear. You know, when
- 43:59the facts, there's disagreement on the facts
- 44:01or how they're applied to the law. and those
- 44:03are always really good cases to come into settlement.
- 44:07Some of the cases that are not good candidates
- 44:09for settlement are, you know, does something
- 44:13violate the constitution, whether the U .S. or
- 44:16the California constitution, or is a reg not
- 44:19valid? In those cases, we usually feel that the
- 44:25interests of the tax community in California
- 44:28is better served by getting an answer to whether
- 44:32a statute or regulation violates the constitution
- 44:35or is not valid, then settling these cases. And
- 44:40so usually we will not accept those cases into
- 44:42the settlement bureau so that we can give tax
- 44:45community an answer on them. Again, I mentioned
- 44:50before about undeveloped cases. We want cases
- 44:52that are ready to have discussions. That's important.
- 44:58For a multi -state or, you know, cases We call
- 45:01them multi -state FTB, but for apportioning companies,
- 45:06sometimes there's alternative apportionment requests
- 45:08under 25 -137 of the revenue taxation code. And
- 45:12so we ask that those go to the FTB's 25 -137
- 45:18committee for a determination before someone
- 45:21has to come into the seventh bureau on those.
- 45:24And that way, again, we can understand what's
- 45:26the FTB's position on. this apportionment request
- 45:29and what's the taxpayers position. And finally,
- 45:33the last thing I would bring up is if a case
- 45:36is at the end of the protest process, then the
- 45:42taxpayers need to go to appeal before they ask
- 45:46to come into the settlement bureau. And the reason
- 45:49for this is that the FTB has, we've been instructed
- 45:54to move cases through the administrative process.
- 45:58And so we have to kind of weigh the needs here.
- 46:02And in these instances, it's been determined
- 46:04that moving the case through the process and
- 46:07having them go to appeal first is really important
- 46:10to make sure that cases keep moving. And so if
- 46:13you're in that situation, what a lot of taxpayers
- 46:17do is they contact the Office of Tax Appeals
- 46:19and they tell them they plan to apply to the
- 46:21settlement program and they can file a skeletal.
- 46:25uh open and brief with the right to cure it if
- 46:27the case doesn't settle so that kind of makes
- 46:29it as easy as process as less work you know as
- 46:34necessary for that that case to be able to come
- 46:36into the settlement program. And Katie what about
- 46:41for the CDTFA? Yeah, I think we're very similar
- 46:44to the FTB. There are some minor differences.
- 46:48I think Giro touched upon it. We do consider
- 46:52constitutional arguments. For example, Nexus
- 46:55is one that we do. We have been seeing a lot,
- 46:57but I think for the most part constitutional
- 47:01arguments are so broad that you know we may or
- 47:04may not assign a lot of litigation risk to that.
- 47:09And I think one other minor differences, you
- 47:12know, we do consider administrative cost savings,
- 47:15so we like it when it comes to us early before
- 47:19the appeals bureau has done a lot of work on
- 47:21the case or before an appeals decision has been
- 47:23issued, which then makes it hard for us to take
- 47:26a position that's contradictory to what the appeals
- 47:29conference holder has held. So, you know, we
- 47:32do like to get them in early if possible, because
- 47:35it does, you know. there is a, you know, administrative
- 47:39cost savings for the agency. Can I add something?
- 47:44I'm really happy to hear what she said, because
- 47:47there's sometimes confusion with our discussion
- 47:51about constitutional issues not coming in. So
- 47:54for us, you know, whether something violates
- 47:56the Commerce Clause, those are the type of things
- 47:58that we oftentimes won't bring into settlement.
- 48:00But a lot of the multi -state cases are by their
- 48:03nature, they're constitutional law. And so I
- 48:06don't want to have people think that case, which
- 48:09really is a candidate, might not be a candidate.
- 48:11So if you have any questions, you're always welcome,
- 48:14or any uncertainty, you're welcome to contact
- 48:16me. I'll be happy to talk with you. But when
- 48:19I say constitutional issues, I mean things like
- 48:21violating the Constitution or the Commerce Clause
- 48:23and things like that, not the regular types of
- 48:27issues you see in multi -state cases. OK. All
- 48:32right. And we have a question. Lee, does the
- 48:37California AG approve or not approve a settlement
- 48:40agreed to by the state agency and the taxpayers?
- 48:45So how about Chiro, why don't you start that?
- 48:49So since I've been director, I know my predecessor,
- 48:52I've never heard of it happening. I know. So,
- 48:55you know, we do a very good job of justifying
- 49:00our settlements. And so Yeah, I've never seen
- 49:07happen. Katie. Yeah, I haven't seen it happen
- 49:12either, but I know they are reviewing it carefully
- 49:15and for reasonableness because we have gotten
- 49:17questions here and there from them. So we know
- 49:20they are looking at them carefully. Okay. And
- 49:24is there any sort of hierarchy in the. relevant
- 49:30settlement bureaus. In other words, let's say
- 49:33someone is negotiating with a settlement officer
- 49:37and they feel like the settlement officer is
- 49:41not hearing them and they don't agree with it.
- 49:44Can you appeal your settlement to someone or
- 49:47speak to a manager or is there some process for
- 49:50that, Katie? Yeah. The assigned settlement officer
- 49:57should be the main contact person because if
- 50:00the case settles, they're also the ones that
- 50:02are submitting the approval package and justifying
- 50:06the reduction. So I think it is important to
- 50:08have a good relationship with the the assigned
- 50:12assignment officer. But you know, I understand
- 50:15there's going to be personality differences and
- 50:18maybe. you're just not seeing the same issues,
- 50:21in which case, sometimes they do get elevated.
- 50:23We have review teams. So, you know, if it does
- 50:26get elevated, a lot of times it's the summit
- 50:29officer's reviewer that then comes in and participates
- 50:33in that discussion to make sure there are no
- 50:35issues that we're missing. And Shiro, what about
- 50:38in your bureau? Yeah, you know, we're a very
- 50:42flat bureau, you know, purposefully. And So I
- 50:48agree with you that the first step is to talk
- 50:51to the Selma officer. You know, we put a lot
- 50:54of focus on our objective and just negotiations
- 50:57just in themselves or just a unique kind of subject
- 51:00matter. And so I think our folks are really good
- 51:03about when someone says, Hey, you know, I really
- 51:06don't think you're getting it this one. Can we
- 51:08take a step back and can I explain why I think
- 51:11the risk analysis is off? And I think our team
- 51:13is really good about being open to that. I'm
- 51:17involved in every single settlement. And so,
- 51:20you know, whatever you're talking about with
- 51:21the someone officer, it's always, you know, I'm
- 51:24in the loop in some way. But, you know, if you
- 51:27feel that you're hitting a wall that, you know,
- 51:32that you need to have some recourse, you're always
- 51:34welcome to contact me and I'll be happy to listen
- 51:39to you. And so, you know, we focus really You
- 51:47know kind of strongly on the fact that we don't
- 51:50let our pride get in the way of trying to get
- 51:52the right result That's why we're doing this
- 51:54is you know I know this has a huge impact on
- 51:57people's lives or tax liability and our goal
- 52:00is really to get the right result and so You
- 52:04know, you're always welcome to share a concern
- 52:07Okay, and see Katie do you have any other comments
- 52:12on that issue Yeah, sure do they get a better
- 52:15offer if they go to you You know What what I
- 52:24think Happens is Probably if they would have
- 52:30gone to the cell an officer and had the same
- 52:32discussion they would have gotten The same thing
- 52:35sometimes someone comes to me and I'll I'll happily
- 52:37interject and kind of just be a facilitator You
- 52:41know for that that conversation, but again a
- 52:43lot of what I do in my job Is I try and create
- 52:47that culture where we get rid of the ego. We
- 52:50don't Stick to our guns and get you know, kind
- 52:53of healed in instead my job is to create that
- 52:56culture where we um We're able to say hey, wait
- 52:59a second. Maybe I got it wrong. Yeah. Okay, you
- 53:02know, where you come from? You let me let me
- 53:03step back Let me kind of you know the brain and
- 53:06and yeah be open to it And um If someone has
- 53:12a question about the settlement process, can
- 53:14they reach out directly to either one of you
- 53:18to discuss it? Maybe even before they send in
- 53:21a settlement and how would they go about doing
- 53:23that? Katie, what about that? Yeah, absolutely.
- 53:28I'm happy to provide my email address and I think
- 53:31my contact information might be on the website,
- 53:33but I, you know the. The telephone number listed
- 53:36is my direct extension, so more than welcome
- 53:38to shoot me an email or give me a call and I'll
- 53:41do my best to answer your questions. And Cheryl,
- 53:45yeah, same thing. You know my phone number, my
- 53:47email and I would encourage it to, you know.
- 53:50To have a cell request, go through the process,
- 53:54make its way for me just to figure out there's
- 53:56an issue. You know that's a month or two of time,
- 53:59plus all the preparation time for the representative
- 54:03to get that. you know, filed. And so if you have
- 54:08any questions, any uncertainty, you know, that's
- 54:10why we're here. Reach out, please. All right.
- 54:13And do either one of you have, as we're down
- 54:16to our last few minutes, just like a final, Katie,
- 54:20just maybe like a final wrap up on settlement
- 54:23and how people can proceed and any other tips
- 54:26or insights that we haven't discussed so far.
- 54:31Yeah, I think, you know, we're all looking, we're
- 54:32all working within our our procedures and our
- 54:36constraints. So it's always helpful when the
- 54:39practitioners are professional. I think getting
- 54:42very aggressive is counterproductive to reaching
- 54:46an agreement. So I think it's always helpful
- 54:48to have just a very open and frank discussion
- 54:52of our cases together. And Chiro? Communication
- 55:03is really key. If any part of yourself in the
- 55:07process or any issues, please just be open with
- 55:11us. And we want to help you. We want to get to
- 55:14the right number. We want to get a fair number.
- 55:16If there's issues, tell us about them. And let's
- 55:20see how we can work with you to get a deal that
- 55:24works. OK. All right. see any more questions.
- 55:29This question, I'm going to read it out. I'm
- 55:32not sure if I understand what they're asking,
- 55:34but maybe either one of you would understand
- 55:36it. And I think this is directed at the CDTFA.
- 55:40For a settlement, what information do you need
- 55:44from a California husband held personally responsible
- 55:48by CDTFA? Something is personal liability, personal
- 55:51responsibility sales tax. From his wife referring
- 55:55to community property assets. I'm not sure I
- 55:58understand this question, but if it maybe Katie
- 56:00want to just look at it in the Q &A and see if.
- 56:05Yeah, let me see if I can. What information do
- 56:12you need from the California husband? His wife
- 56:16referring to. Yeah, I'm not sure if I quite understand
- 56:22the question either. But if you don't mind reaching
- 56:25out to me, and I might just have a couple of
- 56:28questions, like what is the case about? What
- 56:32is it? Then maybe I could do a better job of
- 56:34answering your question. All right. So I guess
- 56:40we don't have any more questions, and we're down
- 56:42to our last couple of minutes. So I want to thank
- 56:44you guys again. for doing this webinar, for trying
- 56:48to educate the practitioners who work with the
- 56:51CDTFA and the FTB, and for being so available
- 56:56and such a great resource on the issue of settlement.
- 57:00So thank you very much. Thank you for having
- 57:03us. Thanks for having us. Thanks, everyone. All
- 57:06right. Bye.