Latest / Ahead At The Apex / Niche Sports are Better: Why F1 is Worse in 2026
Transcript
- 0:00We still we need to bring in when, where, at that time, when
- 0:04or whenever you called it, what we're going to do about Karoon
- 0:06Chandok. Oh, Karoon Chandok, wait.
- 0:09When Karoon Chandok was in F1. When Karoon Chandok was in
- 0:12Kizri, Yeah. And that's the end of our Karoon
- 0:15Chandok session. It's his favorite part of the
- 0:19week. Oh, I applied for the sky thing,
- 0:21you know that. But yeah, yeah, it's.
- 0:22Let's see. Let's see what they say.
- 0:24Haven't heard back yet. Are the races more entertaining
- 0:57for you now than they were? Yeah, because of, because.
- 1:01Because the midfield's more. Two, if you're if you plan it,
- 1:05but you have you have properly 1 go.
- 1:09To go quicker than the other. To go quicker than everyone else
- 1:11there, and that doesn't mean anything anymore.
- 1:53We've had the new regulations for all of two Grand Prixs, 3 if
- 1:58you're listening to this, but by the time of recording, we've
- 2:02only had two and there has been quite a controversy.
- 2:07Welcome back to Ahead of the Apex and this week we are
- 2:10talking about the new regulations.
- 2:12I think I've made that very clear.
- 2:13And once again, I'm joined by Tim and Katie.
- 2:15So hi, Tim and Katie. Hi, Tim and Katie.
- 2:23And Tim and Katie have found a soundboard this week.
- 2:25So Tim, the new regulations, quite a big outcry on social
- 2:32media, quite a big outcry from the drivers.
- 2:35But the thing I want to start with, which I think is perhaps
- 2:39the worst that has come from this, is Formula One censoring
- 2:45people online, guys, Josh here in the edit.
- 2:53So the video you're about to see has some language in it and some
- 3:01text that was written by people online.
- 3:04And we felt it important to portray that in an honest and
- 3:11open way because this is a major company, major media outlet,
- 3:19censoring fans of that media outlet.
- 3:24And so, yeah, we apologize for the language that was used in in
- 3:31the video by people, not us. If anybody is upset by that, we
- 3:38apologize. The, the kind of comments that
- 3:45people have been putting on a, on the F1 posts that F1 have
- 3:50been censoring and it's a little bit unusual because you might
- 3:53think, oh, OK, they're hiding stuff that's got, I mean, there
- 3:57are death threats in there, sure.
- 3:59Or they're hiding stuff that's got language on sure.
- 4:02I completely get that they're trying to brand themselves as a
- 4:05sort of clean, family friendly sport.
- 4:07I can, I can understand that. But some of the stuff that's
- 4:10been on there is, is confusing because there's some posts that
- 4:15have been allowed through and some that haven't.
- 4:17So it's not random. It seems more like a when did
- 4:20you post type thing. So to put it into perspective,
- 4:24F1 published on the 8th of March a graphic that featured George
- 4:27and Charles going through Turn 2 at Australia and in front of
- 4:32Charles's carcass just because he was behind it said 45
- 4:34overtakes in the 2025 Australian Grand Prix.
- 4:37And next to George's Carr, it's at 120.
- 4:39You see this? Yeah, you see my post.
- 4:41OK, so first of all, this parts huge outcry, mainly because more
- 4:46overtakes does not mean better racing, that that is not the
- 4:51case. Also, they're comparing the end
- 4:54of a regulation cycle to the start of a new regulation cycle.
- 4:57So obviously the racing is going to be more erratic and therefore
- 5:01there's going to be more overtaking in a new set of
- 5:03regulations. Think 2022 compared to 2025,
- 5:06right? Like Charles and Max batting out
- 5:09the start of every Grand Prix to maybe Lando gets passed at the
- 5:14start, right? That that's what we're talking
- 5:17about. So they don't they don't mean
- 5:18the same thing. But some of the comments that
- 5:23were allowed through and again, I'll put this video up.
- 5:30So one of them was stop the RIPF 12026 all caps.
- 5:36Who cares about overtakes it's so fake.
- 5:38This is by far the worst F1 I have ever witnessed in maybe 25
- 5:41years. Artificial overtakes and fake
- 5:44racing were not falling for that.
- 5:45Sorry. These were allowed through.
- 5:49The ones that weren't allowed through.
- 5:50Swapping for positions for one corner and swapping back because
- 5:54battery power isn't an overtake, it's a game.
- 5:57Artificial overtakes? Bullshit.
- 5:59You killed the spirit of the sport Delusion in every word you
- 6:02speak, which is what's wrong with that.
- 6:06And artificially increasing these numbers with a stupid Reg
- 6:09doesn't make it entertaining at F1, you idiots.
- 6:15Well, how do we feel about that? I mean, they're the same photo,
- 6:19do you know what I mean? Yes, I yeah, corporate wants you
- 6:23to find the difference. Those comments are not too
- 6:27dissimilar to the ones that were allowed through.
- 6:30I think let's take a take a second.
- 6:33So when you think of and you know that we we're trying to
- 6:38answer the question, what were the regulations successful?
- 6:43Yeah. Now, if you take a very
- 6:45objective view, the regulations were completely successful
- 6:51because the intention of them was to boost overtakes.
- 6:55It was to inflate the number of overtakes per race.
- 6:58This was the goal going into. They said OK, how do we change
- 7:03it so there's more over text? That was the metric that they
- 7:06selected to focus on. Well, mainly because all the
- 7:09fans said the race is over by the end of turn 1, lap one.
- 7:13Yeah. So was it right for the for the
- 7:19FIA to respond and dictate the regulations to be as such?
- 7:23That's a separate question, But in listening to what people were
- 7:29saying, they then said, right, we're going to change the
- 7:33regulations to do this, and they've done that.
- 7:35So yes, they have been successful in that objective.
- 7:38Now is I think the bigger question is, is that objective
- 7:42the right objective? And I think what's becoming
- 7:45clear is the answer to that question is no, right?
- 7:48Because as you say, as a lot of people and a lot of these
- 7:51comments have said, it's if you just overtake someone because
- 7:55you've mushroomed through the off road.
- 7:58Yeah. Is that racing?
- 8:02No, it's a video game. And I think that's a good a
- 8:05good, a good point and a good comment.
- 8:08What? But then I think you can.
- 8:10You can. I think what they should say is.
- 8:13OK, well, what would you like? Sure.
- 8:16Because you will forever get this problem and you will
- 8:20forever get this criticism at the start of any regulation
- 8:23period. And you have had that and that's
- 8:25fine. I think.
- 8:25Is it fair for the for the FIA to censor any F1, to censor any
- 8:31criticism? Absolutely not.
- 8:33No, they shouldn't be doing that.
- 8:34No, and and there's more censorship going on.
- 8:36So there's a we're we're going to get through, you know, what's
- 8:41working about the regulations, what's not working, you know, is
- 8:43it real racing? All of that stuff very shortly.
- 8:45But I think firstly we need to address the censorship.
- 8:49Is it right? I agree full heart
- 8:52wholeheartedly. It is not right for F1 censor,
- 8:55right? Social media platforms have an
- 8:57age restriction for a reason. This is that reason amongst
- 9:00other things. But the people who should be
- 9:05reading this post are considered either adults or mature teens,
- 9:08right? So a little bit of bad language,
- 9:11maybe a death threat or two. None of us want to see the
- 9:15social media admin threatened this way, but we're all supposed
- 9:19to be adults here so we can see that and realise, oh this person
- 9:23is just angry. He thinks hiding behind a
- 9:24keyboard is fine. Censoring opinions is not OK.
- 9:29Yeah, I, I think there's there's a comment to be made about and I
- 9:34would implore everyone to think about this.
- 9:38Why would you bother commenting anything?
- 9:41If you have an opinion and you want to make a make at that
- 9:45point, go to your buddies and say I think this is really
- 9:49stupid. Start your own podcast.
- 9:50Yeah, and like I, I've, I've always thought Instagram comment
- 9:54sections are a bit pointless if you don't know the person or you
- 9:58don't know the images. People in our Instagram comment
- 10:00sections think that you're well. But but generally I think this
- 10:06is more a social media conversation rather than an F1
- 10:10conversation, so. To bring it to F1, have you seen
- 10:14the theory that they are actually censoring the footage?
- 10:18That's what we're about to get onto.
- 10:19So the next part of this is dishonesty, right?
- 10:21So as Katie so accurately puts, there's, there's a couple of
- 10:26things about footage here that don't make sense.
- 10:28So firstly, they're only showing 1 decimal place on the timing
- 10:33tower, right? That's weird.
- 10:34It's awful. I hate it because because 8
- 10:38point .801 is completely different to .8. 99.
- 10:43Yeah, I mean, it's rounded differently, but.
- 10:45Oh do how do we know that though?
- 10:47That's true? How do how do we know that
- 10:48they're rounding correctly and not just showing us the 1st
- 10:50decimal place right? Exactly.
- 10:54Also the graphics. Yeah, I've heard allegedly
- 10:58they're keeping the top speed up on the graphics.
- 11:00Right. So that's the next one.
- 11:01So there's a video of Antonelli in China where if you listen to
- 11:06the clip, you can hear the Super clipping taking place and the
- 11:08engine Revs dying. If you watch the graphics on the
- 11:11Halo, the speed stays the same, right?
- 11:16That's an interesting choice. Now, OK, you might say
- 11:20Antonelli's going over because there's a tunnel there.
- 11:23It's under this. The Chinese Grand Prix is built
- 11:25on marshland and, and at that particular corner where the
- 11:28hairpin is, there's a tunnel that runs underneath.
- 11:30And we've always had trouble with tunnels in Formula One
- 11:33telemetry, right? There's the reason that the
- 11:35Singapore Grand Prix, the very first Singapore Grand Prix,
- 11:37there were the underground train tunnels underneath and when the
- 11:41train passed through it cut and a lot of engines retired.
- 11:44We've had issues with the Bahrain tunnels that run under
- 11:47the track for for many years. All all of that stuff, right?
- 11:50But why? Why lie about it?
- 11:54It's funny you should say you saw it about Kimi Antonini Cos I
- 11:57heard about George Russell. OK.
- 12:00So if it's multiple drivers. But then it's multiple drivers
- 12:04from the same team. Is it an issue with the Mercedes
- 12:06communications? We know that various teams have
- 12:10had communication issues with the cars and that's why some of
- 12:13them haven't started. But the one that gets me and I,
- 12:17I saw this recently is that we're all aware of the AWS
- 12:21graphics, right? So the striking distance and
- 12:24tire life and we used to see the battery level predictions and
- 12:28whatever else, right? But it always said powered by
- 12:30AWS and not real, right? So like you'd see back in 21, we
- 12:36used to see the Lewis tire life versus Max tire life.
- 12:39And yeah, Max is catching Lewis even though he's got 10% like
- 12:42tire life left and whatever. And usually you just look at it
- 12:45and you go, OK, well, you. Know yeah, and you take it with
- 12:47a pinch of. Salt.
- 12:48What? We're talking about an overtake.
- 12:49Striking distance was the five lap difficulty was the is the
- 12:53funniest one. It's like the striking distance
- 12:56I think is OK because it just take the number to extrapolate,
- 12:59but then when they go overtake difficulty.
- 13:02And it's like it's. Lewis Seeing AWS overtake
- 13:05difficulty 8. See, I like the ones where it's
- 13:10like, oh, expected battle in five laps.
- 13:13That's. Fine, Yeah, Yeah, that's what I
- 13:14mean. The striking distance I think is
- 13:15cool, but in. This new era of battery powered
- 13:21F1, if that's what we're calling it, we've seen the the F1
- 13:28graphics at the bottom where it's like Charles and George and
- 13:31it's live speed. Whether that's live or not is
- 13:35another debate and battery percentage and whether they're
- 13:38deploying or harvesting right. We've seen those batteries move
- 13:40up and down. That graphic should not exist
- 13:45because the battery level is not transmitted to the FIA.
- 13:50Interesting. So that graphic is completely
- 13:53made-up, and yet it appears in the F1 broadcast like it's
- 13:57gospel. So the battery level isn't
- 13:59transmitted to who it surely it's transmitted to the the
- 14:03garage 'cause there's the words of wisdom where?
- 14:07Well, yeah. So it's transmitted to the
- 14:08garage, but it's not broadcast. Yeah.
- 14:12Like. I think we should call it
- 14:13Formula One point E. So so that is completely.
- 14:16And again, this is just, it's just dishonesty.
- 14:19It's, it's smoke and mirrors to hide what the potential problems
- 14:22are, right? Because people are watching
- 14:25going, oh, wow. You know, George has got 70% and
- 14:28Charles has got 80, which means Charles can boost for longer.
- 14:30And that's completely made-up. It's completely in fiction,
- 14:34completely fiction. So, yeah, I just wanted to get
- 14:36that off. Clearly, Katie, you did the same
- 14:38thing. So great.
- 14:41Should we talk about what's, should we sprinkle some
- 14:44positivity on these regulations and talk about what is working?
- 14:47So when we were talking about overtakes, I honestly thought at
- 14:50the Chinese Grand Prix, the battle between Hamilton and
- 14:54Leclaire, which had many overtakes, that was that was
- 14:58exciting to. Me.
- 14:59That was good. Yeah, it was great.
- 15:00I loved it. I was see, I was expecting them
- 15:03to crash at one point. I think they did hit each other
- 15:06a little bit, yeah. But honestly, that's one of the
- 15:11most exciting races I or a part of a race that I've seen in a.
- 15:15Yeah, it was great. Yeah.
- 15:15Yeah, it was great. And I don't think that would
- 15:17have been possible without the new rags.
- 15:19Maybe. Oh, it wasn't possible last
- 15:22year, No. Yeah.
- 15:24Not for as long, not, not, not that prolonged.
- 15:27I'm trying to think. I mean, Tim will remember the
- 15:30Red Bull days in 2010 to 2013 side by side, so that that was.
- 15:35Possible. That was all pretty aggressive,
- 15:37but that's that was more because it was small and there was there
- 15:40was less arrow, Yeah. So you weren't as disruptive?
- 15:43I remember the Mercedes Battles 141516 sort of time when they
- 15:48were very, very fairly equal. Last year, I just don't feel
- 15:52like the battles were really there to be.
- 15:54Honest, the last time I can remember a side by side battle
- 15:56that long was 2022 and it was Max and Verstappen, Max and
- 16:02Verstappen, Max and Charles. I think it was because the, and
- 16:05again, we've spoken about this before, I think album was
- 16:10talking about it by the end of the regulations, the arrow, the
- 16:18arrow became so aggressive. By aggressive, I mean you
- 16:22designed your arrow to be as disruptive to the car behind you
- 16:25as possible. This whole idea that you can
- 16:28follow really closely, which was the intention of the regulation
- 16:31change in 22 was eliminated. And I think the fact that we
- 16:39have a lower reliance on aero means that you will get this a
- 16:45bit longer into the regulation period than we had last time.
- 16:49Like you said, 22 was fine. It wasn't so hostile with in
- 16:53terms of the aero designs. But even then, I'm thinking the
- 16:56regs that started in 2009 were basically the same aero regs
- 17:02that made it to 2016. Yeah.
- 17:05The cars didn't change much right yes we had the hybrid
- 17:08switchover we had the introduction of KERS and DRS,
- 17:10but realistically the car's shapes didn't change too much
- 17:15yeah yeah the the, the front wing dimensions, the rear wing
- 17:18height, all of that stuff was fairly consistent and those
- 17:20error rates were good by 2016 was a great season I, I yeah,
- 17:27it's good but yes you're right the.
- 17:29So I think it has, I think it has provided a platform in which
- 17:33you can race. Yep.
- 17:36Each other more more closely for longer.
- 17:40So I think that's a positive. We've got good side by side
- 17:42racing. Have they provided a clear path
- 17:46for somebody to make it to the top of the field?
- 17:48Is there is there a a package that works that has allowed
- 17:54somebody to win the first two races?
- 17:56And the answer is yes, right? So Mercedes have a good chassis
- 18:00integrated well with a power unit era that works.
- 18:02They're able to look after their tyres, they're able to manage
- 18:05their battery. So yes, there there is, there is
- 18:09one clear way currently of winning races, right?
- 18:14Like other teams may have got it wrong, but there is a.
- 18:19There is a method. There is a current clear right
- 18:21method to get there, it's just that other teams have got it
- 18:23wrong. Katie, have we got new
- 18:27manufacturers? Yeah.
- 18:30So that works, that worked because that was the goal, right
- 18:33was was we redesigned these regs to make it attractive to car
- 18:38manufacturers to come back to the sport.
- 18:40And I think, I think looking at Audi's performance, it hasn't
- 18:44been that difficult for them to integrate like they're doing
- 18:48quite well. I mean, Cadillac is another
- 18:50story. But they're they're more
- 18:52starting from scratch than ALDI. Whether ALDI had kick already,
- 18:55but they I'm actually excited for ALDI this year.
- 18:59I think by the end they they will have a competitive car.
- 19:02So that's worked. Have the new regs pushed the
- 19:08envelope on car development? No, we're slower.
- 19:12No, no. But car development not not
- 19:14speed. Have we pushed car technology
- 19:19forward a step? I mean, you look at the the
- 19:21state of the front wings, they're a lot different than
- 19:24last year. The actual arrow looks quite a
- 19:28bit different. The side pods you've, I mean,
- 19:31you've got Red Bull with, well, not Red Bull Racing Bulls with
- 19:34that huge, I can't remember what it's called.
- 19:39But we've pushed battery tech forward, right?
- 19:41Yes, I think we've done more in this this regulation change than
- 19:45Formula EE have ever done. Interesting.
- 19:49Because Formula EE is a spec series, so sure, it killed that,
- 19:53Yeah. But I think the fact that we are
- 19:56slower than we were last year is bad from a sport point of view.
- 20:03Yeah, maybe a little. As a relatively new Formula One
- 20:12watcher, I love the crashes. When someone crashes, I love it.
- 20:16It's so much drama. But I think we're going to have
- 20:19less crashes this year because we're not going as fast into the
- 20:22corners. Because everyone's not starting
- 20:24the race, there's no one to crash into.
- 20:28I was. I was sort of likening this to
- 20:31sort of go karting because we went go karting the other week.
- 20:35The hardest bit that I found was the corners, being able to go
- 20:39into the corners fast and not get loads of oversteer right.
- 20:45With this super clipping, they're going into the corners
- 20:48slower to charge their batteries.
- 20:50Well, the chef can drive the car, right?
- 20:51So it's. Easier, you know.
- 20:53Yeah. So, as a new, relatively new F1
- 20:59follower, are the races more entertaining for you now than
- 21:02they were? Yeah, because of, because,
- 21:06because the midfield's more. I don't know if it's just
- 21:09because we have what, like 6 retirees each race it seems so
- 21:14far, but the midfield seems a lot more varied.
- 21:18But last year you knew who you knew, like who was going to be
- 21:22at the back of the pack. Yeah.
- 21:23This year you've got Alpine who are actually doing quite well.
- 21:26You've got Hearts who are doing quite well.
- 21:29They're sort of underdogs from last year.
- 21:31I mean it looking at Mercedes and Ferrari at the start last
- 21:35year, we had different people at the start more often.
- 21:39I mean, it's only been two races, but I can see we'll have,
- 21:42I don't think we'll have many, many different pole people, but
- 21:45we didn't really have that last year so.
- 21:47True, I don't. Have we lost any element of
- 21:51sport with the new regulations? Has it become too much in
- 21:55entertainment or do we still? Have I think, one of the things
- 21:58I am upset about? Oh.
- 22:02Is that there is? I don't feel qualifying is
- 22:09anywhere near as important. Right.
- 22:13We're going to get on to that in a SEC.
- 22:14And I think when you talk about sport, I think that takes a lot
- 22:20out of it because that is the that is the most difficult part
- 22:27of the weekend. Yeah.
- 22:29Is can you you have one try two if you're if you plan it, but
- 22:34you have you have properly 1 go. To go quicker than the other to.
- 22:39Go quicker than everyone else there and that doesn't mean
- 22:43anything anymore because George will poll and then Leclerc will
- 22:47just marry at the beginning. So it sort of kills the kills
- 22:52that, and I think that's a shame And my favorite part, and you
- 22:56know, there's a lot said about Monaco, but my favorite part of
- 22:59the whole F1 season is qualifying in Monaco.
- 23:02I think that is epic. That is the most raw and
- 23:07technical and challenging part of the entire year.
- 23:13And I think it still will be the most exciting part of the year,
- 23:17but it sort of made it feel less important.
- 23:22And I think that's a shame. And I think you've lost some of
- 23:24the core spirit of that sport, of the sport.
- 23:26I can agree more because actually I think even if you
- 23:30look at this and go, OK, so the battery management, the tire
- 23:33management, the fuel management, that is all part of racing that
- 23:36happens in WAC, happens in touring cars and happens in, you
- 23:42know, in in other GT series and other racing series.
- 23:45That is a thing OK but WEC cars still get hyper polled and they
- 23:50still really fast. Yeah.
- 23:54In in in qualifying sessions, they're still able to go 3
- 23:59seconds a lap faster in qualifying than they are in the
- 24:02race. But here now I don't think so
- 24:06and it's really punishing some of the drivers.
- 24:10I think the race has become more exciting.
- 24:14So for example, we are sure, do you watch the race and you said,
- 24:20oh, I've watched the first few laps, that's all that exciting
- 24:23or something? Well, I fell asleep.
- 24:24It was 4:00 AM. But it's.
- 24:26Brutal to have Australia and China back-to-back.
- 24:29It's absolutely killed me. I was hungover in China.
- 24:31I was like I could do it with some sleep.
- 24:34You have you. Before last year you would watch
- 24:36the the first corner and then pretty much the rest of the race
- 24:39unless there was the same. Time.
- 24:40Yeah, there's a bit more to kind of get your teeth in there.
- 24:42There wasn't, really. Sort of, I don't know, some of
- 24:45the tracks, it was pretty much decided the finishing after the
- 24:49first corner, whereas I don't know if this is going to
- 24:52continue, but I think it's exciting to watch the whole race
- 24:56now. It's not just going to be OK.
- 24:58So Kimmy's first after the first corner, he's going to win the
- 25:01race, sure. Yeah, I agree exactly what
- 25:04happened. No, no, he dropped places, I
- 25:07swear. Oh, he only fell behind Hamilton
- 25:11and you got Hamilton on lap 3 or 4 or whatever.
- 25:13But at least in the at least in the midfield, we watch more of
- 25:17the midfield now. Yes, I love the battle for 11th
- 25:21to be fair. That's what keeps me up at
- 25:23night. Last year I was sick of just
- 25:26watching Lando try and overtake it's.
- 25:28Funny, because actually one of my biggest criticisms about Moto
- 25:31GP is that you only ever see the fight for the lead, right?
- 25:36Like you're only ever watching the leader and maybe the podium
- 25:39places. You never see what happens
- 25:41further down the field. And yet my criticism for F1 so
- 25:44far is that there's nothing going on at the front, so we
- 25:47don't see the front. I think we're just impossible to
- 25:51play. Right.
- 25:55So qualifying you and I agree on Tim.
- 25:58I think that's the only thing I think that's that to me feels
- 26:01like the big loss. I think there's always a big
- 26:03loss and a big win from a regulation change.
- 26:06I think the big loss is this qualifying, though, the lack of
- 26:10importance in qualifying, and I think the big win is, yeah,
- 26:12we're getting more overtakes. Well, I wonder as well if these
- 26:15new regulations are going to force a lot of teams to break
- 26:18the cost cap and therefore have they made the cost cap
- 26:22irrelevant? Oh, interesting.
- 26:24So. What happens if they do?
- 26:26Well, they just have. They're not allowed to have
- 26:28lunch next year. Yeah, there is a list of
- 26:29penalties that they're allowed to hand out, right.
- 26:32So it's anything from losing a bit of wind tunnel time to
- 26:36disqualification. A bit boring, but if you ask
- 26:40Christian Horner, just put it down as chips.
- 26:43Yeah, pies. Red.
- 26:45Bull are the only teams who have broken the cost cap ever and
- 26:49they went on to win the title the next year and again and
- 26:53again. Yeah, but I can see that.
- 26:58I particularly Honda, I can see Honda just going well.
- 27:02We are a huge corporation, so we'll just spend more money.
- 27:06Well, they need to fix it, don't they?
- 27:07Yeah, but there's needing to fix it and there's then breaking the
- 27:10rules. Yeah, but I feel like for their
- 27:13business as a whole, the the. Yeah, yeah.
- 27:16But that's what I mean. Like Williams can't do this.
- 27:19Williams don't have the budget to break the cost cap.
- 27:23Neither do Haas. But Honda, Yeah.
- 27:26Red Bull? Yeah.
- 27:28Ferrari. Heck yeah.
- 27:35I'm still on my qualifying point, I think.
- 27:38Qualifying exhibits. That was so 15 minutes ago.
- 27:41Exhibits a different challenge than in a race stuff and I think
- 27:46that's interesting because it means that you have to make a
- 27:50choice. You have to compromise one to
- 27:53benefit the other in some ways. And the fact that, and then the
- 27:56Sprint weekends came in and then suddenly Brundle was like,
- 28:01fantastic, don't have to watch practice anymore, we can watch
- 28:05racing. Which of course then means it
- 28:08actually, it makes that choice much more obvious to to bias the
- 28:12race because there's more racing and therefore having a race trim
- 28:16is better than having a qualifying trim.
- 28:18And Ferrari made this mistake at 22 because they had a phenomenal
- 28:23qualifying car, but then didn't have the race pace because they
- 28:26set the car up and the way that they set the car up.
- 28:28And I think the fact that you then have this what feels like
- 28:32convergence in how it how sensible it is to set the car up
- 28:42for a race, it then just, and also the things like they when
- 28:47they got rid of the rule about whatever you qualified out of
- 28:51Q2, you have to start on that tyre.
- 28:53Those kind of rules, you had to make choices.
- 28:55There had to be some conscious thought about it.
- 28:57Now it's just there's no choice there and and this is making it
- 29:02to me feel very, very repetitive.
- 29:03So I actually like that rule. I loved that rule and I was
- 29:07gutted on the goal. The.
- 29:07Thing that gets me about that is that it goes against the
- 29:10qualifying is about outright pace, right?
- 29:13Because you're you are making a choice as to whether or not you
- 29:18are better in the race or not. Yeah.
- 29:20So in qualifying. Yeah, and how?
- 29:23About we bring in a few little points for qualifying, so less
- 29:28points than the obviously Grand Prix.
- 29:29But if you say had from like like with the Sprint race, yeah,
- 29:34I don't know top 10 get if you if you go poll you get 10 points
- 29:38blah, blah blah. Well.
- 29:39The Sprint used to decide the Grand Prix grid when it was
- 29:42first introduced and that was, you know.
- 29:45Or just pointless it. Well, yeah.
- 29:47Because you then just ended up running, then everyone's
- 29:50criticisms about Monaco being a train, then they then made a
- 29:55Sprint race which meant anything that was slightly out of place
- 29:57would get sorted out and then you just drive around like that.
- 30:00Yeah, that was ridiculous. And actually the one that gets
- 30:02me is the one that people throw around are like, is Lewis in
- 30:04Brazil, where it's like, Oh my God, he came from last to win
- 30:07the race? No, he didn't.
- 30:08He came from last to finish 10th and then went from 10th to
- 30:11finish first, and he did that in 1 1/2 grand prixs.
- 30:15Yeah. With an absolute rocket ship
- 30:17engine anyway. The other one, what I, what I
- 30:19was going to say was I think having some, having something
- 30:24that forces you to compromise or forces A-Team to compromise is a
- 30:30good thing. And we've slowly been losing any
- 30:33sense of compromise throughout the weekend.
- 30:36And therefore it just ends up feeling very, very
- 30:39one-dimensional, which I personally don't like.
- 30:45And and this, this to me or this regulation period feels to me a
- 30:49continuation of that. Yeah, but also, how many times
- 30:52do we hear now? Oh well, Max has got an extra
- 30:54set of hearts. Yeah, they all do like, but it
- 30:57back in the past you'd you'd choose whether you were bringing
- 31:00extra hards or extra softs or extra mediums and even super
- 31:05softs, hyper softs, ultra softs. I miss hyper.
- 31:07Soft you. You choose your tyres for a
- 31:10Grand Prix weekend. So Red Bull might think to
- 31:12themselves, well I've got better tyre life than Mercedes, So what
- 31:15I'll do is I'll bring more softs.
- 31:16I'll be exactly on average. And this is what I mean about
- 31:19it. It then that adds so much depth
- 31:22to the sport, so much depth. And now it's like everyone can
- 31:26have every single tie that they want all of the time.
- 31:29And actually the ties are not so good that they basically degrade
- 31:33at the same rate of. Do you?
- 31:34Think that the team should be given the whole catalog of ties
- 31:38and then they choose OK they want the C4, they want the C2 to
- 31:42for the race instead of Pirelli deciding that yes I also.
- 31:46But you choose that at the start of the season.
- 31:49No, I think you choose that buffet.
- 31:50No, no, no, no. No.
- 31:52Yeah, but you you choose that per race, but you make that
- 31:54choice at the start of the. Season Yeah, yeah, yeah, so you.
- 31:56Can't adapt to the car. You can't.
- 31:58You can't turn up in Australia, realise that actually your tyre
- 32:01wear is monstrous. You've selected a bunch of softs
- 32:05for every single race in the first half of the season and now
- 32:08you're screwed. That's your choice.
- 32:09You made that choice. You have to now live with that
- 32:12choice. I also think you've said it in
- 32:15the past, I love your idea of bringing back points for fastest
- 32:20lap so you get the PAC 10, putting on the the softs and
- 32:23having a full on race. But again, that's the decision,
- 32:26right? Like and it became strategical
- 32:28like in 2021, you would have Perez and Bottas 50 seconds off
- 32:33the lead in 3rd and but 30 seconds ahead of 5th place and
- 32:38then they would pit to try and take the fastest lap.
- 32:40So that Mercedes or Red Bull scored the fastest lap.
- 32:43I always, I always thought it was so rubbish that if you got
- 32:47fastest lap that didn't finish in the top ten, you didn't get
- 32:49any points. Yeah, that was ridiculous
- 32:51because I feel like it also made.
- 32:53Let's say you are in. 19th. 19th, 20th, 20th to 12th.
- 33:01You then just end up having this really aggressive qualifying
- 33:04scramble at the end of the race. That would be awesome.
- 33:06Yeah, that would be awesome. Why would why would we prefer to
- 33:10just watch the battle for 16th over absolutely nothing for no
- 33:13reason? Who cares?
- 33:15Literally. You've taken so many points and
- 33:19so many goals out of the sport. To.
- 33:23Simplify it or. So simple if you go back and
- 33:26watch like I think it was, correct me if I'm wrong, Tim
- 33:302018 where they had the the full rainbow of tyres.
- 33:37They also had, they hadn't yet got the fastest lap point, but
- 33:40they still had the Q2 rule. And also on the timing tower
- 33:44they had the badges, the colours, the tyre colours, the
- 33:48gaps in three decimal places and on the little mini, the timing
- 33:53window. In qualifying they had the mini
- 33:55sectors. Oh the mini sectors were
- 33:56fantastic. Right, which they've now brought
- 33:58back on the Halo graphic a little, but the mini sectors and
- 34:02and you watch it and yes, there is a lot going on, but that is
- 34:08what I watch the sport for. That's interesting.
- 34:10I'm a nerd. I am a nerd, I am an F1 nerd and
- 34:14I want all that information. And you can get all that
- 34:17information if you pay US 2599 a month for F on TV and you don't
- 34:21live in the UK. So that information exists.
- 34:24Give me it back. I think it's took.
- 34:26It away from us. I have recently started getting
- 34:30an appreciation for American football, right?
- 34:33And I think American football does.
- 34:35They don't have any apexes. We're not talking.
- 34:36About no, I know, but but the point I want to make is I think
- 34:40you look at it or you just watch it and you sort of go, it's a
- 34:43bit weird. You know, it's quite stop
- 34:45starting, it's quite slow, but it's one of those sports that
- 34:50the more you watch it, the more complicated it becomes and
- 34:55therefore the more interesting it becomes.
- 34:57It becomes very quickly. This ridiculously tactical game
- 35:02and understanding the roles of each of the players is very
- 35:04interesting and how this fits into one cohesive unit.
- 35:08And then, I mean, don't even get started about special teams.
- 35:10And you know, it gets quite complicated, but I think that's
- 35:14a good thing. I think the having complexity
- 35:17and having layers is a good thing.
- 35:19Yes. I I think football is probably
- 35:23where they've started leaning towards because they go,
- 35:25football is the simplest game in the world and therefore it has
- 35:27the biggest viewership. And it's like no football is the
- 35:31has the biggest viewership because culturally it's more
- 35:33important because back in the day when it really started
- 35:37cementing itself, everyone was a little.
- 35:40Bit thicker. And we didn't have the resource
- 35:44and the in order to learn about things.
- 35:47Soccer football is is perhaps one of the simplest games.
- 35:52Yeah, there are 11 people on the team, and the goal is put that
- 35:57ball between those in the goal. 2 posts. 3 posts.
- 36:01And like the most complicated rule is is off side.
- 36:05Yeah. But again, that's not very
- 36:06difficult. And but that's a sport that
- 36:08benefits from simplicity because it's more about the players and
- 36:13the team and how it connects. F1 is not that kind of sport
- 36:17because it is technical, because you've got to build a bloody.
- 36:20Car. Anybody can go out to that car
- 36:22park right now and go and play a game of football, but you can't
- 36:25go out there and play a game of F1.
- 36:27And and then I think as a viewer, understanding what it is
- 36:31they're doing and why they've done things in that way adds to
- 36:35the interest. It adds to this thing.
- 36:37And then also making it so that they have to make decisions and
- 36:42compromise and be adaptable. Race to race also throws things
- 36:47up in the air more often. And taking away things like
- 36:50fastest lap, taking away things like the Q2 rule meant that they
- 36:53do. The teams have to do that less
- 36:55and less and less, and therefore it becomes more simple.
- 36:58But because it's a technical sport, I don't think that
- 37:00advantages things. Well, last night, well, I was it
- 37:02becomes boring. Formula One released Schumacher
- 37:05versus Haneken Hakkanen. Schumacher versus Hakkanen
- 37:10highlights Imola, and they were like, oh, well, Michael's got,
- 37:14you know, hard attires. So he stayed out for longer, but
- 37:17now he's going to catch back. He's been able to extend that
- 37:20with his fuel strategy and now Hakkinen's got to chase him
- 37:23down. And this is absolutely epic.
- 37:25And they called it Schumacher and Hakkinen's epic battle.
- 37:28Not once was Schumacher and Hakkinen sharing the same space
- 37:31for tarmac, but they were in a battle over time in the Grand
- 37:36Prix because they were 30 seconds or so apart.
- 37:39Hakkinen was bearing down on Schumacher, who had to pit
- 37:42again. So it was like, well, Will
- 37:45Schumacher could come out in front of Hackerman or behind
- 37:47Hackerman, they're on different parts of the track.
- 37:49And it was still more exciting than than Australia.
- 37:52And the first one, the first change I think that really
- 37:56kicked us all off was the no refuelling.
- 37:59Obviously sucks. Obviously a good safety
- 38:03decision. I mean the number of videos of
- 38:06mechanics on fire. Yeah, but how many times since
- 38:09we've got rid of refuelling and we now have 3 second pit stops
- 38:12if we run over a mechanic's leg? Fair.
- 38:16But again, that was another that took away another decision you
- 38:22had to make. Yeah, which is how much fuel are
- 38:23you going to put in the car? Yeah.
- 38:28Yeah. And the more decisions you for
- 38:31or or you remove, the more optimized it gets because it's
- 38:36more predictable. And then from a racing
- 38:38perspective, because it's more predictable, it becomes more
- 38:42boring I think. I think when you go back to
- 38:44saying what has it been entertaining, I think and it's
- 38:50very difficult to define entertaining.
- 38:52Yeah, because your idea of entertainment and my idea are
- 38:54very. Different.
- 38:55It's different. But the bigger question is,
- 39:03should we be patching these regulations so quickly?
- 39:06And, and the thing we talked about when we first came in,
- 39:08Kate, if you remember, was Fred, Big Fred.
- 39:11Oh yeah. Kicking off at the FAA last
- 39:13night. That enough's enough and Ferrari
- 39:17will not stand for this anymore. Is the start right, the start
- 39:20procedure. So I was surprised at anybody
- 39:24else to see in Australia that the blue light flashed this
- 39:27start procedure because I didn't realise they'd pass that.
- 39:29What's I don't really get the the point.
- 39:32So last literally last year, literally 3 races ago in Abu
- 39:37Dhabi, the start procedure was red light counts down to when
- 39:42the picture has to go off and then the lights come on and the
- 39:44two inner, the 2, so there's a out outer and a middle one.
- 39:49They're all off and the two lights in the middle flash
- 39:53formation lap begins, right? The formation lap procedure is
- 39:57safety car procedures. So no more than 10 car lengths
- 39:59behind the car in front. No erratic changes of speed,
- 40:04warm tyres, brakes, get the cars warm ready, get back into your
- 40:08pick box, fill from the front when the last cars in the lights
- 40:13go green and then off and then a guy walks past with the green
- 40:17flag at the back to make sure everybody's in that position and
- 40:20then the lights come on 12345. Out go.
- 40:23So why have they added this blue?
- 40:25Because I saw it but I don't get why they've added it.
- 40:28So this is one that spin the spin the turbo.
- 40:30This is because everybody and their mums, apart from Ferrari
- 40:34said, well, the problem with these big turbos is that we're
- 40:38going to have cars that really start off the line.
- 40:39So we need time, we need 12 seconds of time to want to spool
- 40:44the turbos up so that we have full battery deployment off the
- 40:48line and we'd not all stationary.
- 40:50And Ferrari warned the FAA of this last year and said you need
- 40:53to make changes to these regulations.
- 40:55And the FAA said no, design your car within the regulations.
- 40:59Come Bahrain testing, the other teams say we're going to have
- 41:03problems at the start. And Ferrari say, well, design
- 41:05your cars within the regulations.
- 41:08And and, and the compromise was this five second delay, that
- 41:11which is the blue light, it says start procedure.
- 41:14Well, now they're talking about changing it to 10 seconds and
- 41:17Fred has had enough. I'm quite right too.
- 41:21I agree with him. It's, I think it's, it comes
- 41:24down to what you're, you were previously talking about, like
- 41:26we're changing the regs to be more simpler, We're taking away
- 41:31this chaos, we're taking away choices.
- 41:34A Ferrari have obviously chosen to have a really good start,
- 41:38which we see that mega, you know.
- 41:41But that punishes them. But that punishes them with the
- 41:43overall pace, right? Yeah, because they don't have
- 41:45straight line speed. Mercedes have decided to have a
- 41:48terrible start so but they've got the pace.
- 41:52We know at the moment that the pace outweighs the start.
- 41:54But like I've I've keep on saying is a late safety car.
- 41:59Ferrari are going to do really well.
- 42:01And we've all said Hungary and Monaco, Ferrari will do really
- 42:03well, right? So let them play, let them play,
- 42:06Let. Them have let them have this
- 42:07chaos, let them make choices. I don't want to go back.
- 42:10Have some accountability, Jesus I.
- 42:12Don't want to go back to the mad conversation that you had, but
- 42:15it's like, it's like you were comparing it to football.
- 42:18Football being really simple, right?
- 42:20Rugby is a sport of chaos, you know, and you don't have the
- 42:26overall viewership as you do with sort of football, but
- 42:31rugby's more exciting to watch them football because of that
- 42:33chaos. You don't know what's gonna
- 42:34happen. I'd I played rugby for I don't
- 42:37know how long, I don't know all the rules, right?
- 42:39But I still like to watch it. It's like with F.
- 42:41One I should know some of the rules.
- 42:42I know some of the rules I don't know all of but.
- 42:44That's a great point. You said the viewership is less,
- 42:47but it's more exciting and that's what F1 was, right?
- 42:49F1 used to be a relatively small sport in terms of viewership.
- 42:54Keep all the, the, you know, complex rules.
- 42:57Not everyone's going to know the rules but, and that's fine, like
- 43:00with me with rugby, but I still find it entertaining.
- 43:03Dare, dare I say it's the job of Martin Brundle and David Croft
- 43:07to explain the rules. They're terrible, Yeah.
- 43:10The the fact they didn't even realise that Kimi had taken his
- 43:1410 second time penalty or fight whatever in the spread.
- 43:17Oh, not even that. Colapinto was on a lap in Q2 and
- 43:20they were reeling off who'd been eliminated.
- 43:21Yeah, that's bad. I remember that.
- 43:23I don't know if it's just because they see the footage,
- 43:25but even I know that like. His time was at the bottom in
- 43:29anyway. It's I, I've been on the Martin
- 43:33Bodran used to leave train for about 10 years.
- 43:39But yes, I agree. I have to say though, I do love
- 43:44Bernie's technical knowledge. She's fantastic.
- 43:48Yeah, absolutely. I'm very conscious of time.
- 43:51There was a lot more that I had written down.
- 43:53What I will do with this is I will take this sheet and I will
- 43:57put it in the Patreon Patreon Patreon, but I will I'll take
- 44:02I'll take these notes, I'll flesh them out and I'll put them
- 44:05in the comments and notes of the podcast when I upload it.
- 44:08I'll also stick it on the website head@theapex.com.
- 44:12The final thing I just wanted to mention, I just want to mention
- 44:14it really quickly because we are not a geopolitical podcast is
- 44:18the council races in April. Look, it's, it is, it's, we're
- 44:25not, we're not going to go into why this is all happening, but
- 44:29we've lost the Bahrain, the Saudi Arabian Grand Prix, we've
- 44:31lost the opening round of the World Endurance Championship and
- 44:34we've postponed the Qatar Moto GP Grand Prix and all of that.
- 44:38Just want this all to be finished so that we can all get
- 44:41along and so we can all have our racing tracks back.
- 44:43Please, amongst everything else that's going on, we're not going
- 44:48to comment on, but I hope everybody's staying safe where
- 44:51they can, right? That's the end of the podcast,
- 44:54so. Last thing I want to say, yeah,
- 44:57I think based on this conclusion, which I think we've
- 45:01all sort of said is about a lack of choice.
- 45:06Let's go and do a comparison on an estimated.
- 45:09Let's say, let's put ourselves in the shoes of a team and say
- 45:13if you were in doing a race in 2010 and let's say won 1990,
- 45:192010 and now and then estimate, right, how many decisions per
- 45:24weekend are we going to have to make?
- 45:27And I think that'll be quite an interesting thought experiment.
- 45:30Should we pick the same racetrack?
- 45:31Yeah. Yeah, yeah.
- 45:32Same race in three different. So we pick the same, let's say
- 45:34Australia or let's say Suzuka. Suzuka, something like that.
- 45:38Yeah, OK. That might be quite interesting
- 45:40to just put some numbers to it. I'm.
- 45:42Highly under qualified for this. That's alright, me and Tim will
- 45:45just do it. Yeah, Josh will just do it.
- 45:49Yeah, OK, cool. So head over to the Patreon AT
- 45:52Apex. You'll see this episode early.
- 45:54You'll also get all the notes from from this episode and
- 45:58you'll also get our from our perspective, right Kay?
- 46:02Yeah. I like from our perspective.
- 46:04I think it's a good series. It's good.
- 46:06I find it interesting seeing other people's perspectives.
- 46:09Yeah, yeah. And we also take submissions for
- 46:12from our perspective as well. So it's more reason to get
- 46:15involved, more reason to become a member and it's free.
- 46:19What? What more can I say?
- 46:22I always have to say is thank you Katie for joining us and we
- 46:26will see you next time for a wack.
- 46:28Wack are we are so back baby episode peace.
- 46:34Peace.