Latest / Newcomer Pod / Imploding Fast (w/Kate Clark)
Transcript
- 0:06Welcome back on Sally. Hey, welcome to dead cat.
- 0:15Hisses are newcomer. We've got Tom and Katie here and
- 0:19we have Kate Clark. Startup reporter VC reporter
- 0:23from the information who's been writing tirelessly about one,
- 0:28Klick payment disaster. World with fast imploding and
- 0:32the bolt CEO being a lunatic or export CEO.
- 0:36Anyway, so we should have a fun. Startup World conversation.
- 0:41Katie has undiagnosed covid at the moment and Kate has lost her
- 0:47voice. So we've got a bunch of sick of
- 0:49straddling this so sickos. This yeah, cait was probably
- 0:54screaming at PR people all of yesterday.
- 0:57Well, thanks for having me, despite despite my Lost voice.
- 1:00Yeah, of course. I mean we feel like this story
- 1:03is taken and it's been mostly you and your colleagues
- 1:06reporting, you know, as taken Silicon Valley by storm
- 1:09partially because it's one of the first real I think startup
- 1:13implosions when, when everybody sort of thinks they're coming or
- 1:17I don't know, like, I just want you to sort of lay out this
- 1:20story a little bit because a lots happened.
- 1:22Like where does it begin to you like when did we all start
- 1:26caring about one-click, checkout companies went Did they really
- 1:31get on your radar as like startups that mattered in like
- 1:34the Zeitgeist of Silicon Valley? Yeah, I mean it's a good
- 1:36question. I think they really started to
- 1:39matter when all of this VC funding flew into them.
- 1:42Like these companies were raising, you know, over a
- 1:44hundred million dollars and in fasts case it really, really got
- 1:49my attention when stripe invested which, you know, is now
- 1:51been a couple of years ago. And then not only the stripe
- 1:55invest, but this company, you know, free product launch really
- 1:58early stage was Out in the market looking for a
- 2:01billion-dollar valuation, you know, as long ago as like late
- 2:052020. So when you start seeing that
- 2:07and you know, at the same time you're seeing them, sort of
- 2:09pedal, these $1 hoodies on Twitter that didn't make a lot
- 2:14of sense for a fin tech company. So, I think those early signs
- 2:16really got people paying attention and then you had the
- 2:19competition with bolt and you had this really bombastic public
- 2:23figure CEO you know in Brian. Breslow sealed bolt and I think
- 2:28he really he really Got people's attention to.
- 2:31So then you have this war, these two companies, so Amazon lost
- 2:34its patent in 2017 and then I think it in a couple, in the, a
- 2:38couple years later, you really start to see two companies rise
- 2:42with the help of hundreds of millions in VC funding together
- 2:46and that's fast and bolt. Yeah.
- 2:49Both companies had CEOs who were all over Twitter all over the
- 2:52tech press like really Making a Splash and really really trying
- 2:56to capture and bring a lot of attention to what they were
- 2:58building, which was when I got software so fast in particular,
- 3:02you know, really gets on my radar when stripe invests and
- 3:06then invest again that the series B and puts a hundred
- 3:10million dollars. You know, with the help of leaf
- 3:12Exel. There's a former tiger Global
- 3:14partner. His forearm addition puts total
- 3:16of a hundred million dollars in this company and then again,
- 3:19pre-launch nothing to show for it self.
- 3:21So, of course, we're all watching.
- 3:22Paying attention wondering what's going on this company?
- 3:25Luncheon, even realize, yes, and they had a lot of delays and
- 3:29it's a After bolt, right? Bolt is a little bit ahead of
- 3:33fast. Yeah, so Ben and bolts run by
- 3:35this guy, Ryan Breslow, or at least he he co-found sir the
- 3:39dead and he's the CEO for a long time until this year, which is a
- 3:42whole other story. Doesn't probably talked about
- 3:44yes, a bowl. Get started many years before
- 3:47actually, I think Bowl was founded in 2014, you know, it
- 3:49took a long time to build the technology took a long time
- 3:51before launch. So already had it, had a head
- 3:54start, also had a different strategy, they were targeting
- 3:56larger businesses which, you know, larger businesses Equals
- 4:00more transaction. Volume equals more Revenue.
- 4:03Fast was targeting smaller businesses and you need a lot
- 4:05more customers in order to make any Dent there and that ends up
- 4:08being a big problem for them. And so, then to skip it, skip
- 4:11ahead a little bit. I mean Ryan Breslow is basically
- 4:13the guy who does the Tweet storm right before leaving the CEO job
- 4:17at bolt where he says you know there's this Grand conspiracy
- 4:20where YC and stripe or basically running Silicon Valley and it's
- 4:24made it hard for him to fun with the Irish mafia, right?
- 4:27Exactly. So you know that, Now it's The
- 4:30Road to Perdition drama. And honestly it made me think
- 4:34sort of not following these companies closely like, oh, fast
- 4:38the Rival must be doing super well because this tweet storm
- 4:41seems really like defensive. It's like, oh, you know, we've
- 4:45had such a hard time because all the stars have aligned with our
- 4:48rival fast. Yeah.
- 4:50And then all of a sudden so then then what happens with fast
- 4:54like. So all of a sudden I had heard
- 4:55of fast because you know the co-founder is what Allison.
- 4:59Our Allen Bar Allen. Yeah, who is XU Burr?
- 5:02And was sort of Buzzy Twitter presence.
- 5:05So I knew I was more aware of her then Dom.
- 5:09But so yeah, we're pick us up from.
- 5:11We've got the Tweet storm and then where's the, what's the
- 5:14first sign of something going on at fast?
- 5:16Yeah. So what would was tweet?
- 5:18Starting January January, February, let's say, okay, so a
- 5:21few months ago, I remember reading that tweet storm and
- 5:24thinking what is, you know, what is Dom?
- 5:26The CEO fast going to say, you know, he had been, he'd gone
- 5:29quite quiet on Twitter, I noticed then and again this is
- 5:32someone who was very loud on Twitter for several years and he
- 5:35made some statement on Twitter like supporting Ryan Breslow,
- 5:39which I thought was interesting. But at the time, you know, I was
- 5:43not aware of any issues at fast. I like I didn't think that they
- 5:46were booming necessarily, but I wasn't aware of what was to
- 5:49come. What's really unique to me about
- 5:52this about fast. And what's really crazy is how
- 5:54fast how fast it all happened, like the collapse.
- 5:58I don't think I've ever seen. Suppling have a collapse so
- 6:02accelerated. So you know, we first heard of
- 6:06issues there. I want to say less than three
- 6:08weeks ago. Yeah, maybe about three weeks
- 6:11ago and, you know, the companies already shut down.
- 6:15So, and that is because I mean at the end of the day, it's
- 6:18because they expected. They could raise more money and
- 6:20it was saying, oh good, Venture capitalists are not as readily
- 6:23investing in companies right now as you know, so they just it
- 6:27just happened. Like what was interesting about
- 6:29it to me? Is it it shut the fuck down like
- 6:33you don't see that that often in Tech, you know, companies will
- 6:35have soft Landings, they'll manage to place, you know, half
- 6:39of the P'nay elsewhere. They'll be just some sort of
- 6:41selling in parts that happens but a full-on like everything
- 6:44must go. This shit is over with.
- 6:46Shut it all down. Just doesn't happen that often
- 6:49and certainly not one that is. When's the last time you saw
- 6:51that? Was it just Arrow?
- 6:52I mean this is like eight years ago, seven years ago.
- 6:55This is like very personal to me because I wrote about one
- 6:58company. This was like 7 years ago, there
- 7:00was like a laundry company called washio.
- 7:03That had some high end VCS in a laundry space.
- 7:06So, you did a new laundry strike.
- 7:08I'll never stop. Keep it.
- 7:09Your laundry stories. I will I will I will take you
- 7:12seriously. It was like a ten million dollar
- 7:14round or something. They didn't I say.
- 7:15Yeah Taro and it's hot. Tom actually just he just needs
- 7:20a new washer dryer. That's the actual no, actually I
- 7:23got a new one that's will do a spin-off podcast about my my
- 7:25back and forth with my home warranty.
- 7:28But, but yeah, they they shut down like sold the desk sold the
- 7:32Macbook. So that was one that I remember,
- 7:34but, you know, not this is more professional than that.
- 7:37This was 100 million race. This is different.
- 7:39There have been many like, dis Arrow type startup implosions,
- 7:43but I don't know how many there have been when they're, you
- 7:46know, over 500 or roughly 500 employees and I think that's why
- 7:49it happened so quickly. It's like there were the, the
- 7:53other option, I guess would have been laying off 400 workers and
- 7:55trying to keep on 100. But I think, you know, when you
- 7:57actually have zero dollars and no VC is willing to invest.
- 8:00Like they just they put themselves up against a wall by
- 8:05growing so fast in 2021 they hired then went from 92 like
- 8:09nearly 400 workers in 2021 and they were bragging about the
- 8:12pace of employee growth as if that was sort of a sign of
- 8:15underlying success which you all reported and then the revenue
- 8:21figure is astounding. How did you get the sort of
- 8:24financials who it was six hundred thousand dollars in
- 8:27Revenue in a year s offer? Yeah, from their checkout
- 8:30software. So and I note that because they
- 8:32also have emerged business. So they sell t-shirts and
- 8:34hoodies, and they've got they've sold 60,000 hoodies according to
- 8:38the website. Oh, my God, it's like Evernote
- 8:40back for maybe a dollar. Yes.
- 8:42So there's there's perhaps other Revenue that we didn't account
- 8:44for. I don't know how much I'm there,
- 8:46merge business. But yes, I think we were we were
- 8:49quite shocked by that number as well.
- 8:52It's so much to ask about with the, I mean, I don't want to
- 8:54jump too far ahead because the actual details of how Dom ran
- 8:57the company or hysterical and, you know, to use an overused
- 9:01term like a cautionary tale with in Tech.
- 9:04But my takeaway from there being just no outcome for the company,
- 9:08is that there was Nothing there in the end.
- 9:10Like there was no Tech of substance to acquire.
- 9:13I mean, it's a quasi fairness situation where like when you
- 9:16really get down to like what it invented or what it really
- 9:20produced over the course of its lifetime.
- 9:22There's just nothing of value. No one wanted to a choir shit
- 9:25other than some Engineers. Right there was some problems in
- 9:27years. Yeah.
- 9:28And we'll see, I'll, I'm very curious myself, how many of them
- 9:31like what that deal actually entailed and how many Engineers
- 9:34firms actually going to take on yeah as in a choir or just
- 9:37hiring people? Well, it was Some kind of
- 9:39agreement where they're going to take on.
- 9:41Like, I don't know the specific. So we basically, we just said,
- 9:44in our story like a firm agreed to take on, I'm in, probably
- 9:47like a couple dozen of them. I think they have like a pretty
- 9:50pretty large engineering team. So, I mean, there's a certain
- 9:53responsibility when a company dies you're supposed to.
- 9:58Like, I mean, I think they're even laws about it like you're
- 10:01supposed to. If you think your company is
- 10:03about to run out of money, you're supposed to say save
- 10:06enough to give some sort of reasonable To the people that
- 10:11work there. Like, did they, they gave like,
- 10:12two days of severance or what did they do when this whole
- 10:15thing shuts down to, like, look out for the employees.
- 10:18Yeah, I don't know what the severance packages were, but
- 10:22you're right there, I mean, not only is there may be rules or
- 10:24laws but they also as a CEO he should have been thinking
- 10:28further ahead and that's why I like the only way I can
- 10:31understand what happened is by believing that he was 100%
- 10:36certain that he would be able to get that rescue financing at the
- 10:38end. I think that he really thought
- 10:40the VCS like stripe or addition or index Ventures who are all
- 10:45you know, big investors in this company.
- 10:46I think he really believes that one of them would would provide
- 10:50that last-minute round look like what good is being tied in with
- 10:53the mob. Yeah, exactly.
- 10:58Like it, right? And what is your thinking on
- 11:00like why they didn't think we've seen Venture Capital firms
- 11:04bailout? So many companies.
- 11:06Yeah, was it simply the insanity of the CEO.
- 11:09What, why was it? They chose to let this one go
- 11:11and not just let it go. But like in a really public and
- 11:15Incredibly dramatic way, right? I mean, because it's, it hurts
- 11:18their reputations, right? Like, I mean, particularly
- 11:20stripe who is like a absolutely balli darling, that's kind of
- 11:24developed this big reputation as an investor to But I mean, I
- 11:27think the real reason is likely because of how large the company
- 11:30was and how much money it would have required.
- 11:32Because it's not like one round would have, would have been the
- 11:36Silver Bullet. It's going to need to continued
- 11:38investment and how, I mean, how much hundreds of millions like
- 11:41like to support a 500-person company that is made six hundred
- 11:46thousand dollars in Revenue like yeah, ten million dollars a
- 11:49month and burn so just, you know, you can do that math.
- 11:52So I think that's the answer. I think another, you know, I
- 11:54mean, I don't want to Be late too much, but I think that
- 11:58there's perhaps I think some of these investors might have
- 12:01realized what they had on our hands with dom and Lady realized
- 12:05that what he had promised. You know, he was not delivering
- 12:07on his promises. So I think there was some of
- 12:09that as well. And maybe just the markets
- 12:12themselves, sort of everyone seems like they're taking a step
- 12:15back, a little bit to assess. Absolutely bad timing for them
- 12:18with that, right? This was 20 21.
- 12:20Yeah, I gotta say can like, can Massa no longer be tricked into
- 12:24taking these shitty companies, what happened?
- 12:26Wow. He wasn't crazy enough, soft
- 12:28pink ball pulled back? Yeah, iger's kind of pulled back
- 12:32and if it was a different, I mean, yes that's what's also
- 12:35really interesting about this as it really tells a story of the
- 12:38moment and I think we're going to see we're definitely going to
- 12:42see more of this. This is certainly an outlier for
- 12:45certain reasons like the behavior of the CEO.
- 12:47He already had a spotty past Etc, but I think we'll see many
- 12:51more startup implosions because they're just not gonna be able
- 12:54to raise the money. They need to keep Going, can we
- 12:57dig into that for a second here? I'm and I want to definitely go
- 13:00into the larger implications and what, you know, what it all
- 13:03means going forward. But he's I mean, there's so much
- 13:05funny stuff in your story on the way he ran the company and like
- 13:09the big kind of company-wide meetings.
- 13:12I'm still watching the we work show.
- 13:14So I just saw the episode where they have like the, we work, you
- 13:16know, cult Camp. You know, we were chanting.
- 13:20So what like give us some anecdotes from, how how Dom was
- 13:26Hanging out in Florida with jet skis.
- 13:28Oh yeah. So that I actually, I highly
- 13:31recommend anyone listening. You can go on Facebook and
- 13:33search this and you can watch the video and it is surreal.
- 13:37So, Dom last year decided to open an East Coast Hub or east
- 13:40coast headquarters in Tampa Florida where he had moved.
- 13:42So yeah I bought a house there and you had a yes, Tampa
- 13:46Florida. So I'm not even my Tampa
- 13:49strawberry Choice. He bought a very nice home in
- 13:53Tampa open up, open up a headquarters.
- 13:55Anyhow Hosted this big really lavish exciting event to
- 14:00announce this. He has the mayor of Tampa there
- 14:02with him. He has several local sports
- 14:04stars who I can't name, you know, sports teams that are
- 14:07based there. And then he makes a grand
- 14:10entrance in a NASCAR with a, a NASCAR race driver in the driver
- 14:15seat, and they do a bunch of doughnuts spinning around in the
- 14:19vehicle. And then, in a revving, the
- 14:21engine like crazy. And then they'll and you right
- 14:24next to kind of where the mayor's speak again.
- 14:26Dom gets out. He has somebody in the audience,
- 14:28put his jacket on him, kind of like you know like a celebrity
- 14:32Pink Blazer walks up on stage and then just gives this speech
- 14:35about how, you know, how the phenomenal growth that they've
- 14:39had what's ahead for them, how they, you know, Tampa's the next
- 14:42big Hub. And they, you know, he's got all
- 14:44these local supporters because of course, the mayor was there,
- 14:47right? Yeah.
- 14:48Yeah. Yeah.
- 14:48Mary Jane Kelly, Eric everyone who buys a house in Tampa gets
- 14:52this treatment. So just know that if you buy a
- 14:54house in Tampa, Summer in Kansas is one of the things that happen
- 14:58nice city. You know?
- 14:59It is. It's a real, it's a big.
- 15:01I think it's a biggest, major blow down there in Florida.
- 15:04It is. Yeah, I think Florida mayor is
- 15:07one of those jobs that like, at some point in your career, you
- 15:09may not you may not put on your LinkedIn like Florida town,
- 15:13mayor is a chance. You're just like yeah, that did
- 15:16that did happen but let's not go after the events you went to
- 15:19were with some sort of like huckster Florida man type you
- 15:22know you look the yeah I'm like yeah look at some point.
- 15:25Mary. You converted your entire income
- 15:28into Shiba Inu. You realize that this was all a
- 15:32huge mistake and your third wife is leaving you.
- 15:34And yeah, you didn't realize you gave Dom from Fast, a pink
- 15:38jacket like it's all a blur anyway.
- 15:41Well yeah that was going down. He's got all their support
- 15:43because this is like a, what there may be a third tier Tech
- 15:46Hub, whatever you want to call it.
- 15:47That's trying to invite more Tech workers.
- 15:51So there are so excited that you know, they say this is one of
- 15:54the fastest growing companies in Silicon Valley.
- 15:56Lee which, you know, he just told them and they repeated and
- 16:00it's exciting to watch. I mean it to see what else we
- 16:10can get you a video with a bearer of the mayor of
- 16:13Pensacola. Yeah, so anyways, it's eight
- 16:17months later there are sent down so it's quite a sight to see.
- 16:19Any didn't hire anyone in Tampa, right?
- 16:22Nobody. Yeah, that one colleague.
- 16:24Who moved out there with him. An engineering manager.
- 16:28Yeah, but that it was. Yeah.
- 16:30I mean, he was again, false promises.
- 16:33I don't know what his intentions are.
- 16:35This guy is not, he'd like changed his name because his
- 16:38past was good. That's you right?
- 16:40He used to be got he used to go by Dominic, he changed it to
- 16:43Dom. Long story short, he had a
- 16:45towing tow truck startup in Australia that not only like was
- 16:49liquidated but there was like some really bad things that
- 16:52happened to some of the like it just kind of screwed over all
- 16:54the employees and you can read about that.
- 16:56I think NPR has done some good reporting on that.
- 16:59And I mean I personally think that some of the early investors
- 17:02did not know about that and that is completely on them.
- 17:05It just takes a Google search but I think we were it's not
- 17:08like he changed his name from Dominic to Richard.
- 17:10He changes him. Nominated are incredibly easy to
- 17:13find and I think it just really telling of the moment you know
- 17:15that was 2019 when he raised all that early funding and certainly
- 17:19that was at 2021 but honestly 2019 was pretty like euphoric
- 17:23and Venture Capital to it was just before the pain that Boom.
- 17:27So it was during a period that lasted years where diligence was
- 17:31sometimes don't exist. I mean, I literally just just a
- 17:34pause there, like there was the 2012.
- 17:36Boom, the 2014, Boom, the 26 teams of the Trump, Boom, the
- 17:40recession. Boom, the penalty was abuzz the
- 17:42valley. Not booming.
- 17:43They will Bloom for anything bill, right?
- 17:45Boom. Is not even Sims.
- 17:46I don't know. It's sort of no.
- 17:50But sometimes, there are like three weeks for three-week-long
- 17:52drawbacks and, you know, the batten down the hatches winter.
- 17:55Winter comes. Yeah, like winter comes for a
- 17:59long weekend this, I just think that's not what you know, but
- 18:04that's just crazy to me. That it would have been easy to
- 18:06find out more about his past. Yeah, I mean, literally you
- 18:09probably when you Google like Dominic or Dom they're just, you
- 18:12know, Google's like did you mean Dominic?
- 18:15I mean y'all Hammers and index. I mean, he's sort of the lead
- 18:19early investor here, right? Or I feel like he's big in Robin
- 18:24Hood, which is his own company that people have liked.
- 18:26Big big moral like objections to.
- 18:28I don't know, like, what's your sense of his role here?
- 18:32Yeah. So he's the First Institutional
- 18:33Investor. So he plays a huge role in
- 18:36providing credibility to this early stage company.
- 18:39He is at the time already big and Robin Hood transferwise and
- 18:43add Yen, which are three of, you know, the largest fintech
- 18:45companies. So he is kind of the consumer
- 18:48fintech investor. Like, there's no denying that
- 18:50again, that he provided that credibility, I don't know what
- 18:53he knew. I mean, you can I cited some of
- 18:55the blog? That he wrote about fast and
- 18:572020, he really believed in Dom and he thought that Dom was an
- 19:01incredible leader and said many nice things about him.
- 19:06You know, he wouldn't, they would not comment for the
- 19:08article. So I couldn't really find out
- 19:11more about what actually happened in more recent times.
- 19:14I mean, one broader, one Trend in Silicon Valley that I'm sure
- 19:17you've seen, is just like these boards are becoming more and
- 19:20more like founder inventions, they like bring on whoever they
- 19:26And so that they don't get bothered by like their investors
- 19:29and I went in the Wayback machine and it's like in January
- 19:322021, they say their board is Dom, lucky groom and Brian sugar
- 19:39from group 9. Like what, what is that for?
- 19:44Like I mean I think of you know, lucky as you know, he was at
- 19:47stripe, he deployed a lot of capital.
- 19:50Like what what's the, what's the deal there?
- 19:54And then I guess like towards the end, And I forget you
- 19:57probably know the board at the end better than I do.
- 20:00Yeah. Yeah.
- 20:01I think it's it's a small board. I think it's maybe someone an
- 20:08executive might, right? Yeah, Brian Dom.
- 20:11And and Ian. Yeah.
- 20:12So it's interesting. Lucky lucky groom was a surly
- 20:15stripe employee as we know now is like a big-time solo VC.
- 20:20He is not investor in fast but he has a close relationship with
- 20:23stripe and was sort of like there he represented straight.
- 20:26The board basically, like he is kind of like a call a favor.
- 20:30He knew stripe. Well, I thought he'd be good.
- 20:32So he's on the board for a bit. I don't know much about Brian
- 20:35sugar. I know I know.
- 20:36Brian quit. Yeah, welcome down.
- 20:38Would ya? I mean, Brian.
- 20:39Brian is the president of group 9.
- 20:41I imagine he may be on his way out.
- 20:43Post the merger with Vox and then he has a side Venture fund
- 20:48that I think he invested his personal capital.
- 20:51I think called like sugar fund or something and they're an
- 20:53investor in fast. Yeah, and they do a lot.
- 20:56He's done a lot of e-commerce like oh yeah, see stuff.
- 20:59Yeah he does a lot of data, see stuff, he knows e-commerce but
- 21:01not necessarily the fan Tech side.
- 21:03Apparently I don't know, I don't want to speak for Brian.
- 21:07We should ask him to come on some time because he's a chatty
- 21:09guy but you know, he's plugged into that space but seems like
- 21:13something something. There's it seems like there's a
- 21:16bit of a gap between that expertise.
- 21:18And what would have been good oversight for this company?
- 21:22Would be my assumption that I was, you know, in the reporting
- 21:24process, we were told Some former employees that Brian was
- 21:28often cited kind of like in sales pitches as like in a lucky
- 21:32investor and some of the sales people were like why are we even
- 21:34talking about this guy like this is it going to be relevant to
- 21:36any of these customers so there was a lot of confusion about
- 21:39like your dry why they promoted certain investors in the in the
- 21:43pitching to two clients. He has a great Instagram, I
- 21:47follow him there because it's all solid stories, a lot of home
- 21:50cooking, you're all over the startup World stuff.
- 21:53What's your view on like, I don't know.
- 21:55Board composition. Isshin right now sort of
- 21:57generally because, you know, we saw, you know, the Tigers of the
- 22:00world basically being like we don't want aboard see we don't
- 22:03want to meddle, it gave the founders a lot more like control
- 22:07over who they appointed. I'm sure you've heard the same
- 22:09things as I have where there there early investors who
- 22:13bristle you know, the Sequoias the world.
- 22:15I mean they're obviously all over but when they invest early
- 22:18it's sort of like oh we have to keep being the responsible
- 22:20person. Even though these sort of hedge
- 22:22funds crossovers come in, I don't know.
- 22:25What do you think? There's Have any optimism that
- 22:27there's a move back to like, okay, investors need to take a
- 22:31board so you can have some, like, culpability for their the
- 22:33companies they invest in. I mean, I think, I think it'll
- 22:37be interesting to have this conversation and like six to
- 22:39nine months when there's been more of a Fallout because right
- 22:41now, a lot of, the more traditional Silicon Valley
- 22:44investors who do take board seats are really trying to
- 22:47convince me of like how messed up.
- 22:49It is the strategy, the tiger took, which is, you know, not
- 22:52not to take board seats and to be passive investor.
- 22:54Because now a lot of those companies, Knees are struggling
- 22:57more and they don't have like the expertise.
- 22:59And this is this is only if you believe that some of these
- 23:01people are actually helpful on the board.
- 23:03If you believe that then some of these companies feel a little
- 23:07bit abandoned because they don't have that support and more
- 23:09difficult times. So I mean, I think it will be
- 23:12interesting to see like if a lot of tiger Global backed companies
- 23:16which and negatively, a lot of them are going to fail because
- 23:18there's hundreds and hundreds of them if they if they do feel
- 23:21abandoned and there's a more of a public dialogue about that, I
- 23:24do think that we will see a shift But it kind of depends on.
- 23:27Again, it's really about, if you believe that these people are
- 23:29really helpful members of the board, which you can only find
- 23:34out and more difficult times. It does seem Reckless to me,
- 23:37just like, you know, like you're saying these companies rate get
- 23:42customers based on the firms to invest.
- 23:44It's not like they're Anonymous. It's not like we just have
- 23:47Anonymous money. It's like we have named money
- 23:50and so the firm's reputations are being attached to these
- 23:55companies. And just like, I don't know, I
- 23:57run a business. I wouldn't want my brand to just
- 23:59be attached to things. I had no influence over what
- 24:02what came of it it's like people are ruining your brand and you
- 24:05don't care like to me like if there's more of a correction
- 24:08like just there will be business pressure to worry about it
- 24:11because you're trashing your brand by attaching it to
- 24:15companies. That's probably why the plug was
- 24:16pulled at this point rather than you know investors, I mean yeah
- 24:21like there's a different way of an investor nothing more
- 24:22embarrassing than a company with six hundred thousand dollars in
- 24:25Revenue. I mean it's just like that's a
- 24:28makes you look like an idiot. Yeah.
- 24:29Right. They should address it.
- 24:30I think that it's frustrating as a reporter that all of these
- 24:33investors are being so silent about it.
- 24:35I think, you know, I mean I know it's we all say this but it's
- 24:38like the hive table so much and they beg us to write about them
- 24:41and that it's like the times that there are these these
- 24:44implosions. I just wish there was more
- 24:45honest about it. I think like that's frustrating.
- 24:48Agreed, you know, every startup forwarder would agree with you,
- 24:51right? Like, we all it's a broken
- 24:53record, but, but as far as the like the what you're Thing about
- 24:56the board and the brand, I think, like the hedge fund
- 24:59crossover funds. I actually don't think that
- 25:00that's something they're concerned about.
- 25:01I think that perspective is a very like, Silicon Valley
- 25:04venture capital firm, Sand, Hill Road, Our Brands, important,
- 25:06like tigers, as you know, we've all reported as like operating
- 25:09like a public market investor and just like, treating
- 25:12everybody like stocks. So different strategy.
- 25:15What I mean, what's the situation now with with bolt?
- 25:19Obviously their CEO, got shit-canned is the chair he got
- 25:23elevated, he ascends he was from Right?
- 25:26He got a pyramid chairman of the board now.
- 25:29So he's still revolved. You reach, Enlightenment?
- 25:32Even rest and top. Yeah, he decided he wanted to
- 25:35spend more time with his Twitter posts.
- 25:38That is what a chairman allows you to do.
- 25:40He's got a lot of side projects. I mean, didn't he say in his
- 25:42Twitter that initially that he was thinking about building some
- 25:45kind of Y, combinator competitor, he said something
- 25:47about like yay. Yeah he's working with the
- 25:50founder of Mind Med which is so psychedelics companies like love
- 25:54medicine or what's it called It's called love our love.com,
- 25:58okay? They've really gotten to the
- 26:00essence of what what people want, you know, we're selling
- 26:02blockchain psychedelic or not. It's actually, it's not
- 26:05psychedelics. It's right, is the intersection
- 26:06of psychedelics and blockchain. It's yeah, it's it.
- 26:10Anyways, he's doing that. He's involved.
- 26:13Decal and bolts doing much better than fast.
- 26:16We, I think we reported the revenue.
- 26:18I'm doing much better than fast that's well.
- 26:20Well, obviously. Yeah, they're still, there still
- 26:22a business, like, souvenirs also doing better than your right But
- 26:26they had 40 million. I think 40 million Revenue last
- 26:28year, so a better business but they do have like a 12 13
- 26:33billion dollar valuation. So the correction is probably
- 26:36overdo there. But like I said doing a lot
- 26:38better than fast. Right.
- 26:40Okay so so so is there still a belief?
- 26:42I mean because I imagine what happened with both.
- 26:44These companies is that there was this thesis on the part of
- 26:48investors saying, like well the patent is expiring there's going
- 26:51to be a bun or at least like a couple of winners of people in
- 26:54like the one-click checkout. Space.
- 26:56And so that's how you get, you know, quick Investments and high
- 26:59valuations early on. With these two companies fast is
- 27:02dead bolt is, you know, I guess doing better, but is there like
- 27:06still a strong belief among investors that?
- 27:08There's a real opportunity here or is this just something that
- 27:12what little business exists is just going to be owned by
- 27:15whatever Amazon one-click checkout or Apple pay or what I
- 27:18mean. Like is there anything here?
- 27:20Or is this just a mistake? I think people are gonna like
- 27:23put that on ice for a little bit and maybe it keep their
- 27:25distance. I don't think we're going to see
- 27:27a lot of funding there. I mean, I think it's also like a
- 27:29product that I'll other fan text can build, right?
- 27:31A firm was sort of, didn't you say this in the story sort of
- 27:34competing with them? I mean, obviously a firm offers
- 27:36a different product, but I mean, people are building in this type
- 27:40of I think a bit more complex businesses are incorporating
- 27:43this into their business. Like, I don't think that we're
- 27:45going to see a lot of funding and Standalone one-click
- 27:48checkout companies. Here's my big question.
- 27:51Do you think if the Tweet storm never gets dropped?
- 27:54You know, I Ryan told What the three cartoon avatars but I
- 27:58guess he was like oh I'd been sitting on it for two or three
- 28:01years, waiting for the right moment.
- 28:02Like you think of you never drops up fast and still in
- 28:05business today? Like do you think like that
- 28:08really drew the attention in or you think this was like this was
- 28:11coming, whether there was the Absurd, I think this was coming.
- 28:14I just didn't care about these companies until it was like he
- 28:17was talking about but you reported them so you know your
- 28:20own interest in it and I don't if I wasn't doing it I do them
- 28:23well I think so I guess I'm biased.
- 28:25It's hard for Like have an objective opinion on that
- 28:27because I already knew them already knew.
- 28:29Ryan, are you Dom? But I could know.
- 28:31I really think it was inevitable.
- 28:32You just can't you can't burn ten million dollars a month.
- 28:36What the only thing that could have saved them is, you know,
- 28:40going back, six months and like us, like not allowing the stock
- 28:44market to the behavior that as, you know, right?
- 28:46It's because of the environment change what also, it seems like
- 28:49the mistake that they made here is that there were only burning
- 28:5210 million a month, you know. Like that's an unfortunate.
- 28:56Ozone to be in if you're burning two million.
- 28:58Oh yeah, you've got some Runway if you're burning 100 million or
- 29:01like 70 million. Oh, then you've got investors
- 29:03really feeling that they need to get this thing going because
- 29:06because you're in the too-big-to-fail zone, but like
- 29:0810 million is like, you didn't go big enough right?
- 29:10Actually, it's funny because a lot of people after the article
- 29:13came out, we're like, well, you know, like that's pretty normal
- 29:15for a start-up like burning 10 million and like not making any
- 29:18revenue and like, okay, well, like a semi the list of
- 29:22examples, I would like to have is like, you know, others that
- 29:26Okay, but again, yeah, if you run out of the funding, then
- 29:29you're screwed. So it doesn't really seem like
- 29:30what was, what was Uber doing, Eric at like, edits craziest and
- 29:34I mean, who burn like two billion dollars in China and
- 29:37like a lot of the revenue was like yeah if you want to be
- 29:40late, so many accounting games. Yeah.
- 29:41I was going to actually joke on your point about yeah, not
- 29:44pretty enough money. There is like, well, we're a
- 29:47company that burns through a lot of money.
- 29:48So we need to raise a lot of capital, which means you'll be
- 29:51able to deploy a lot of capital. Take a lot of owners are, you
- 29:53know, you can sell any of these things is like, Upside in boom
- 29:57times where it's like, oh yeah, we want to deploy.
- 29:59And this is a company that really, really has appetite for
- 30:02Capital, right? I mean if you're good at
- 30:04fundraising, then you can fund raise a lot of money and that's
- 30:06the thing. It's like, there are these
- 30:07people in Silicon Valley who like they've started.
- 30:10A lot of companies, we know them.
- 30:11They're really good there. They have a lot of charm, big
- 30:15personalities, and they're really good at selling a vision
- 30:17and like all, sometimes, obviously, sometimes terrible at
- 30:20building, but that ability to fundraise really well can take
- 30:24you really far. I would not be As if Tom is back
- 30:27in a year with a new company, raising my, I really won't be
- 30:30Insider. We ran a story.
- 30:31I had nothing to do with it, but we ran a story.
- 30:34Interviewing, some of the angel investors who were like hundred
- 30:36percent back him again. Do it tomorrow?
- 30:38Pitch Me Pitch. Me.
- 30:39Dom pitch, me hard like yeah, I love it.
- 30:43They love this shit. What, what are some companies
- 30:46that have burned that much money, or more that did turn
- 30:51around. And we're successful, like,
- 30:53obviously Uber, but they had to shut down.
- 30:56Down some of its money losing. They had to shut down like a lot
- 30:59of projects. I'm order to like look, here's
- 31:01this is like Javi. I'm interested, but like, should
- 31:03be very high. Right, I'm margin, right?
- 31:06It's like, yeah, it's like, what's a pure software company
- 31:10that has had that kind of burn rate will palantir burn.
- 31:13A lot of, I mean, palantir had the whole Consulting thing
- 31:15forever, where it was like, yeah, that's they were never a
- 31:18pure software company because their software us too hard to
- 31:21use needed. Like so many people.
- 31:23All right at it first to make it go.
- 31:26So but yeah, it's like so weird. I just like the math is so
- 31:29bizarre doesn't make anything. But on the angel investment
- 31:32point, I just wanted to say, I mean, you know, we had Parker
- 31:35Conrad on is our first guest. He's sort of the case in point
- 31:38on Fantastical blow-ups, or a strong sign that this is a CEO,
- 31:43who knows where the action is, you know, knows how to build a
- 31:46company with Buzz Right Place Wrong.
- 31:49You know, I mean obviously I mean some people would say what
- 31:53Parker it is and if it's is worse, I mean I think Parker I
- 31:56know Parker better. He's such a product Visionary
- 31:59that it feels like. There's so much substance there
- 32:02that it was believable. But yeah, I mean there's a
- 32:06reason to back Founders who have crazy blow-ups, I mean, because
- 32:10they did some things really well and learned things from the
- 32:13rest, right? I mean, it's frustrating for
- 32:14people, especially like female Founders watching someone like
- 32:17that continue to raise money, but you're right and I do think
- 32:21that he was a talented brand marketer.
- 32:24Like, I don't counted. Yes, Don.
- 32:26Talented fundraiser, maybe, I mean, maybe a good salesman
- 32:29clearly, not good enough good considering that, you know,
- 32:31their business. But in a different role could be
- 32:33successful thing. It's the not good enough that
- 32:36makes it that clearly was. The flaw here.
- 32:39It's like he was a good fundraiser, but not a good
- 32:40enough fundraiser. He was good at promoting himself
- 32:43and making a big, but he wasn't that big because not that many
- 32:45people knew who they were. You know, like didn't reach Adam
- 32:49Newman like levels, you know? He was big in Florida but not in
- 32:51Miami. It was fucking Tampa, couldn't
- 32:54cook couldn't reach Adam Newman level.
- 32:56As though if the market had to change these last few months and
- 32:58he continued to raise like that's the question because he
- 33:01did raise 125 million dollars. That's a lot of money.
- 33:03It makes way more sense. We were I don't think this guy
- 33:06this guy didn't go big enough. He's not, maybe you're right if
- 33:09he'd gotten there but he's not, he's not Parker he's not out of
- 33:13he's not I don't think he's getting the ice Australian but
- 33:16he's always really it's not there.
- 33:18He just seems like some of these other people at least they were
- 33:21like really in it. You know, you want to come off
- 33:23like you were a lunatic but on a huge impression, To scale battle
- 33:27commence, the lunacy big enough. You know, this seems sort of.
- 33:31So what does stripe look like after this.
- 33:33Obviously, I don't think there's a reckoning that's going to
- 33:35happen in stripe, put out a report on its super high level
- 33:39financials and said that in 2021, the total payment value
- 33:44over his platform was six hundred, forty billion dollars
- 33:47up, 60 percent year over year by comparison, add Yen, had five
- 33:54hundred sixty 1 billion, In up 70%, add un's, valuation is
- 33:58about fifty seven billion and down 25% year over year and
- 34:03Stripes valuation is 95 billion and flat since basically March
- 34:09of twenty Twenty-One. This is she'll Mo not an
- 34:13investor seed investor. I hope I'm saying his name,
- 34:15right, but credit to him for pulling the information
- 34:18together, but yeah, so and stripe also said that document
- 34:22that they didn't think 2022. Be necessarily as good as 2021
- 34:27be. Some of what they saw was thanks
- 34:30to the pandemic anyway. So those are just some fast
- 34:32facts from their report, but yeah, Kate.
- 34:34I don't know. We have what is to follow up on
- 34:36times. But, yeah, I mean, Kate, you've
- 34:37done a really good job for a number of years.
- 34:39I even back when I was at the information talking about
- 34:42Stripes VC effort and their kind of path towards disrupting, a
- 34:46lot of, a lot of early stage investors and their their stripe
- 34:51is like when it comes to fintech, they're basically like
- 34:53the NSA, right? They they know everything.
- 34:55That's going on. Which is another reason why it's
- 34:57kind of incredible that fast went on as long as it did
- 35:00because they should have had very good Intel as to whether or
- 35:03not this was being picked up. But anyway, I mean, like, what
- 35:05what's, you know, what's your take on them at this point?
- 35:08Well, on the DC side of things, I don't know, but I think that
- 35:13they are going to probably slow down a little bit.
- 35:15Well, for, of course, because of the market, but I also think
- 35:17like I get this, this probably, this took a huge hit to the
- 35:22reputation. I think that they're probably
- 35:24quite embarrassed about it because they're Involved.
- 35:26I mean every headline it's like I mean from us like Strike Back
- 35:29fast like they're just they're a huge part of this story and also
- 35:34the two people who are really leading VC.
- 35:37There have left they left a year ago hey that was Jordan Angeles
- 35:42who went to Ribbit and Justin overdorf who went to light speed
- 35:47right and both now Partners at these firms, Jordan was the one
- 35:50on this steel was involved guess who was on the deal had been
- 35:53there in that emanate apartment are Corp tempted, Parchment a
- 35:56long time, our while longer than Justin.
- 35:59So they're gone. So Maya, I can't, I don't know
- 36:01her last name, but she's now kind of filling that role in
- 36:03Cork Dev. I think she's interim.
- 36:05They haven't really seem to build up that team.
- 36:07And I think in their absence, like they're just is in.
- 36:10It's not as much of a priority, although I do think the
- 36:12Collison's and will Gabe Rick, who's like their Chief product
- 36:15officer? Do care a lot about investing in
- 36:17are very interested in it, so I will be watching, I don't know
- 36:20how they're going to act, I don't know if they're going to
- 36:22make a splash or just kind of chill.
- 36:23I think given everything happening in the market.
- 36:25They Probably are going to take a step back and maybe they'll
- 36:28focus more on Acquisitions because things are going to be
- 36:30real cheap. And we're going to be seeing at.
- 36:32So it's probably what I would expect for them and what about
- 36:35stripe the business? Or what's your view?
- 36:38Yeah that's a big question. I mean like it doesn't seem like
- 36:41this is going to be the year for them to go public.
- 36:42I'm curious what you guys think but I still going to do it this
- 36:45year. It's got to be under the year.
- 36:46I probably looking more like 2023 to me but like of course,
- 36:49employees are wanted to go public so bad.
- 36:52How old is this company now? Like 12 12 years, 13, Ten.
- 36:56It's like a decade plus and it's time but now they kind of missed
- 37:00their Winter Camp was founded in 2010 toys.
- 37:03Answer told ya. I mean do you guys what do you
- 37:05think about their valuation? Like people ask me all the time
- 37:07and for the longest time I felt like they were like I was
- 37:10expecting made raised at you know, a hundred fifty billion,
- 37:12two hundred billion and they took me there were definitely
- 37:14private Market transactions in the mid, you know, hundred we
- 37:19got 1450 range and you know, I had an interview with Chris
- 37:22sacca who's bought up a lot of stripe and he said that he'd
- 37:26gotten offers at 200 billion. It's not clear if that actually
- 37:29transact it or not but, you know, yeah, they got out.
- 37:32There is definitely a ton of appetite.
- 37:33Yes. I mean, we don't really know,
- 37:36you know, the numbers, so it's hard.
- 37:38The public comps are hard. I mean, I think that's sort of
- 37:40didn point is just. There are companies that have
- 37:42gone public, that seem to be trading at worst multiples than
- 37:47stripe. And the other point this
- 37:49investor made is that stripe has more than 7,000 employees,
- 37:53whereas a d and has like Thousand employees.
- 37:56So just on a sort of payment volume to employee basis, stripe
- 38:01is clearly racking up the expenses.
- 38:05I think that there's a theme here to about over hiring like a
- 38:08lot of the companies I've been covering that's been a key
- 38:10issue. And like we saw with hopin that
- 38:12was like a that was like the company for the last couple of
- 38:14years and they cut I think 20% of staff and I I've heard like
- 38:19interest in Reading other reports that there are more
- 38:21layoffs likely to come. And I just think last year
- 38:23people made a really big mistake.
- 38:25And beefing up their staffs just way too much and hearing that.
- 38:28Maybe that's the case was right. Maybe they need to also take a
- 38:30haircut to the to that massive number and that's that's huge.
- 38:33Well did they I mean was part of that with stripe because they
- 38:37were Staffing up for pandemic. Level transaction, volume
- 38:40increasing. I think you saw that being a big
- 38:42driver of head. Count increases for businesses
- 38:45that had a tail one because like I mean again sorry to bring up
- 38:48go puff again but like, you know they hired a shitload of people
- 38:52because ordering to your home was a big deal.
- 38:55During the pandemic. And you know, they had layoffs
- 38:57at you guys reported and that is a result of needing to
- 39:01restructure both because, you know, we're not living in the
- 39:04same environment. Now, where you need, you know,
- 39:06the maybe the number of people to do that and there was maybe a
- 39:09mistaken bet on, you know, the continuation of the business.
- 39:12Yeah, those are very different types of business.
- 39:15Yeah. It's really great.
- 39:16It's not a great comp. Unfortunately, the one I've been
- 39:18spending time talking to people about right?
- 39:20But you're right. I see what you mean.
- 39:21It's like people did make that bet.
- 39:22But like, in Hopkins case, I don't know if I understand fully
- 39:26why they thought that the demand for their service would would be
- 39:30sustainable after people are no longer at home of the growth
- 39:34metrics are all predicated on pandemic Behavior, continuing
- 39:38right? As if even after the pandemic,
- 39:41then you have to sort of commit to that in strategy, even if it
- 39:45doesn't really make sense and it's a huge issue for cops.
- 39:48Right. I mean like that really was what
- 39:49Screwed instacart when they really had their hearts set on
- 39:52going public. Was that right there, massive.
- 39:55Honey. And, you know, 2021 was going to
- 39:58look awful and you're going to go, you know, to Market with an
- 40:01S one. That was like, yeah.
- 40:03So we're flat but were, you know, at best but we're going to
- 40:07command, you know, growth multiple on.
- 40:09What's basically, you know, a not great Merchant delivery
- 40:12business and so, yeah, I think for any company that had a huge
- 40:16tail, when going public at this environment is just such a bad
- 40:19idea. Macro macro factors,
- 40:21notwithstanding, you know what, it reminds me also Kate like the
- 40:24stripe. Raishin and I actually, I defer
- 40:27to Eric and Katie on this because you guys actually cover
- 40:29the company, but reminds me of Airbnb near like the final
- 40:32stages of being a private company where they really wanted
- 40:34to hold out for as long as they could.
- 40:36But employees were so antsy, I do think it's similar.
- 40:39Yeah, I think that's the biggest easy to compare to that moment.
- 40:42There was like a lot of reporting in the lead-up to are
- 40:45babies IPO. And I like there hasn't really
- 40:48been actually that much reporting on how stripe
- 40:50employees are failing. It's something I've liked on my
- 40:52to-do list, I haven't gotten to but I know it.
- 40:54Well, it's always I always I'm sure you feel the same way.
- 40:56It's like I should write more about stripe but it's like is it
- 41:01that interesting of a story like everybody else?
- 41:03Typical cautious. It's harder right?
- 41:07Right. And they're just, has it been
- 41:09that narrative that has been that interesting?
- 41:11I mean, like the colosseum's are just like picture-perfect, like
- 41:13again like Silicon Valley's darling.
- 41:15So it's like, I don't know, hasn't been as compelling
- 41:17diving. I mean, like, the Airbnb
- 41:19Founders. They seem a little, like,
- 41:20Precious about their brand. I don't, but they're good at it.
- 41:25I mean, they're really good guy and he's more reporting, though.
- 41:27It does. I think like, given the given
- 41:29its size, I mean, it's 7,000 people.
- 41:31It's a hundred billion dollar company.
- 41:32Definitely is a Silicon Valley story.
- 41:34It's it just I wish I wish there were people who could smell more
- 41:36time on it. What has striped done to relieve
- 41:38some of that pressure because I feel like, you know, palantir
- 41:41Airbnb. Different companies have done
- 41:44more or less to give employees secondary.
- 41:47So yeah, exactly. It's like has stripe done.
- 41:51Secondary is how they found ways to obtain.
- 41:53I'm sure that they have. Yeah, I'm sure.
- 41:55Done many. They've I'm sure they've done
- 41:58many trenches of secondary sales to they've had to have re like,
- 42:01I named both die. I think.
- 42:03Important. All these companies are doing
- 42:04secondary. Yeah, I mean, it's a big again,
- 42:07another topic always, worth more reporting.
- 42:10You know, I using their these firms that pursue secondary
- 42:13strategies, where they have a big information advantage over
- 42:16employees. Employees are often the ones
- 42:18getting the worst deal on these secondary sales.
- 42:22But then they have the least control over when the company
- 42:24actually goes public. Alec so they need they need the
- 42:27money. So I do think.
- 42:29Yeah, the push back on some of these companies when you forever
- 42:33to go public, is that they're hurting their own employees.
- 42:37And I feel like they don't get that much criticism for.
- 42:39Yeah. But I said go like I've strived
- 42:41goes now, you know, it's a bad outcome for everyone.
- 42:43Yeah, that might be an interesting way to look at a
- 42:45company like stripe because it's not consumer-facing but to look
- 42:47at it through the employees, this a long time ago, I did a
- 42:50story on a company that had basically failed and So you
- 42:56know, looking what happened the employees there was really a
- 42:58dramatic, but I think I would love to read a story about a
- 43:01company like stripe where the company is not failing, but the
- 43:04employees are still not having good outcomes.
- 43:06Yeah. And like the flip side of it is
- 43:08also actually just had a story this morning about doordash
- 43:12which, you know their stock has been pretty bad over the last
- 43:16six months if they had a pretty good, you know, first half of
- 43:192021 and they really they they're down like more than half
- 43:22from their Peak and they hired a lot during the pandemic and
- 43:25They're not having to offer, like, refresher Equity, grants
- 43:28to employees, because so many of them were compensated, you know,
- 43:31their compensation comes through stock and that stock is now not
- 43:35valuable as much as it was. And so it, you know, it's a I
- 43:40almost feel somewhat for the companies here.
- 43:42That's like, yeah, sure. We can go public, but that's not
- 43:44going to solve the problems. I mean, give some liquidity to
- 43:46early shareholders so you'll get returns there.
- 43:48But if you staffed up a ton during, you know like stripe
- 43:51maybe did. And if they were to go public
- 43:53and their valuation is down, you could suddenly Have you?
- 43:56No, not particularly valuable, you know, Equity.
- 43:59So craziest thing about startup employees, is also always been
- 44:03that there's a set that seems to pick companies based on High
- 44:06valuations when they should pick them based on low valuable.
- 44:09They don't, well, they don't know.
- 44:11And that's like the big issues. Like, nobody knows how Equity
- 44:14works, really, and companies do such a terrible job of educating
- 44:18employees about exercising and options and what Equity is and,
- 44:21like, valuations and it's frustrating.
- 44:24I think like, for those As employees and like their taxes
- 44:27and all these things that like these companies often times even
- 44:30like the executives are for a start-up, like a sort of
- 44:33executive might not even be that educated on and then gets a big
- 44:35problem that I'm surprised hasn't that's what like Carta is
- 44:38doing it. Like they're trying to like sell
- 44:41that education to these companies.
- 44:43So I think that's a good thing because it, it seems like a
- 44:46problem that there's not more knowledge in the ecosystem about
- 44:49that, but they're happy to Hype it up when times are good.
- 44:51Right. I remember years ago, read
- 44:54Albert Gotti at the Sandro I think fuck I'm pretty sure he
- 44:57wrote the story. I remember talking to him about
- 44:59it. How palantir used to have like a
- 45:01fun interactive expel, Excel spreadsheet for palantir
- 45:05employees to sort of show like how much their Equity be worth
- 45:08if they joined at certain times, you can kind of, like, put a
- 45:10little slider on to see how much your, your net worth would be.
- 45:13So they're totally happy to gamify it when times are good
- 45:17and uses an attraction. But yeah.
- 45:18Like the nitty-gritty of flat or a Down Round or like you're
- 45:22saying the taxes. It's like, I don't know you guys
- 45:25for you. Get into that and even like, in
- 45:27fast case, I saw an offer letter, you know, that went
- 45:30through total comp and the trajectory that they like the
- 45:34projections that they provided were.
- 45:35So were somewhat silly. Like I said, in the story the
- 45:38highest was a 12 billion dollar valuation and this is like a 500
- 45:42million dollar startup. That was that was struggling
- 45:44than this is a September offer letter.
- 45:45Like you know it was a different period, maybe they didn't know
- 45:47what was coming but like they knew their revenue.
- 45:50So it's just those are the kind of numbers that employees are
- 45:52given and they're like oh shit like my equity.
- 45:55Going to be worth that much like when you guys had to 12 billion
- 45:57dollar valuation, like that's awesome.
- 45:59Yeah, let's think for the car last question here.
- 46:02Like last segment here. Like we really in a downturn.
- 46:05Okay, like is this actually something that you think is
- 46:09going to persist for any I mean, I was just talking to people
- 46:12about a company the other day and they were sort of saying
- 46:15like, I looks like the text out you NASDAQ is back.
- 46:18You know what maybe seem like a completely postponed IPO for the
- 46:21rest of the year can now be like a cue for thing and and that
- 46:24sort of stuff, you know. It starts early in the private
- 46:26market. So like what's your sense
- 46:28actually as this, you know record this on April 8 22, like
- 46:33where are we? Yeah, I mean it's six months now
- 46:35of me just being like it's an uncertain period I don't know
- 46:38right but I think what I'm realizing is like regardless of
- 46:41how the stock market's behaving regardless of other
- 46:44macroeconomic conditions. I think investors Venture
- 46:46capitalists have decided collectively that like, they
- 46:49don't want to do those high-priced valuation Deals.
- 46:51They don't want to work at that pace that they've been working
- 46:53at and they are all kind of taking a Back.
- 46:55And if they're all taking a setback like startups, have a
- 46:57harder time raising you know, so domino effect on the startup
- 47:00Market in particular. So yeah, I think we're entering
- 47:04I don't know how. I don't want to be the person to
- 47:05say it's a downturn, I don't know, but I think we're
- 47:07certainly entering into a much slower period.
- 47:10I think on the macro economic side, it supports you because as
- 47:13interest rates are rising, I'm not going to say that it will
- 47:16cause a downturn, but if interest rates go up, it just
- 47:18makes other Investments that have been really low return, for
- 47:21basically, since 2009 makes them more attractive because I'll
- 47:25yield more as interest rates go up.
- 47:27So part of the reason why so much money was going into
- 47:30venture capital and into private equity, in general, was because
- 47:33the yields of the Investments were generally so much higher
- 47:36it. Seems silly not to put the money
- 47:38there but if you can get more on a more traditional investment.
- 47:41Now, you'll just start allocating big, you know, big
- 47:46endowments will start allocating money differently.
- 47:50So, I mean, is that a downturn or is that just people saying we
- 47:53can make more money with less bullshit?
- 47:57Are we gonna make reasonable money?
- 47:59You've got somebody who agrees with you.
- 48:01You may watch Peter teal, talk at a, the Bitcoin conference, I
- 48:05watched the you to know but I'm going to say that I'm surprised
- 48:10like I've listened to Peter tail Taco.
- 48:12Like a lot of his speeches especially like his Rene Girard
- 48:14speeches and stuff. The number of times that I'm an
- 48:17agreement with Peter teal is not zero.
- 48:19I'll put it that way, but just make me think.
- 48:21Like I mean he was an amazingly Tie company argument for
- 48:28somebody who makes a bunch of his money from a VC first, but
- 48:31it sounds like a contrarian Tay. I know, I mean, I thought I was
- 48:35dumb, I thought I was dumb, but he was basically arguing, you
- 48:38know, that gold and equities used to be sort of similarly
- 48:42valued in, you know, Collective Collective equities and gold in
- 48:46the 70s. And that now, we've seen just
- 48:48like an explosion of equity values.
- 48:51And is it that crazy to think that the value of Bitcoin should
- 48:54be more? Equivalent to the total value of
- 48:58equity is. I don't know that.
- 48:59It seems like it and then then he got all the headlines by
- 49:02saying that, you know, the enemies of Bitcoin are, you
- 49:05know, Warren Buffett, Jamie dimon and Larry Fink at
- 49:11BlackRock. And then he then teal was like,
- 49:13you know, ESG equals CCP, you know, it was a very sort of
- 49:19trumpian sort of argument as Other the smartest point of his
- 49:31thing was that he was arguing that, you know, Bitcoin, we had
- 49:35basically been a canary for, you know, inflation and that if
- 49:40inflation continues, that that will be a strike against
- 49:43equities, and we'll people moved to sort of more old-school
- 49:46stores a value like old or as he would sort of prefer Bitcoin.
- 49:50Yeah, I was being sort of cute that you were totally agreeing
- 49:54with. And I think I have to say it's a
- 49:56correction, right? How NVC, that's probably like.
- 49:59Is that safe for them saying, it's a full downturn.
- 50:01I think it's a correction to like what happened last year and
- 50:04just like the insanity and yeah, you're right.
- 50:05Like the it is going to be much more difficult for second tier
- 50:10or credit like the crappier VC funds to fund raise and that's
- 50:13going to, you know, of course, that a plays a huge role.
- 50:15So I think we'll start to see more evidence of that.
- 50:17Like so far this year, we've just seen like, record
- 50:19fundraising because it's all a steer, kind of right tumbling
- 50:22over into early this year, but soon, we'll get into Like the
- 50:25meat of this actual year and we'll start to see the struggles
- 50:28a little bit, but that's, you know, that's the funny thing
- 50:30here though. Is that you do you still see
- 50:32these crazy rounds that will come up from time to time and
- 50:34everyone's like? Yeah.
- 50:35But that was a deal that really is more of a 2021 deal, you
- 50:38know? It's really just trickling over
- 50:40carrying over from 2022. It's like all right you know we
- 50:42are four months into this year don't announce that stuff for a
- 50:45long time. Yeah fair enough.
- 50:48So that's why I mean you know you have a lot of deals where
- 50:50it's like the hands were they shook hands and October or like
- 50:53Java and they They wait to announce it so you don't need to
- 50:58ask when it was done as you and your colleague Berber reported,
- 51:02you know, you've seen companies like tiger clawing back and
- 51:05really in elegant ways on some of the deals that they had
- 51:08strong. Honestly, that was a great
- 51:10story, but I think less and some of the VCS would fear Monger
- 51:13over. It doesn't feel like there's
- 51:15been this like, wholesale claw back, or do you.
- 51:19You think they're just like a ton of unreported cases?
- 51:22I mean, that is what like a free pricing.
- 51:24Yeah. Maybe he's ever maximum points
- 51:27that same one. The Forbes reported, I feel like
- 51:30that company comes up all the time.
- 51:31Oh, DBT. Yeah.
- 51:33Yes, I think the repricing was like, a, six-week season, not
- 51:37occurred, like, in January February, after like those 21,
- 51:41you know, really close to 20 21, so like the deals kind of were
- 51:44negotiated around when the markets really changed.
- 51:46So I don't think it's happening now and I agree with you.
- 51:48I don't I mean I was like I just went like weeks trying to find
- 51:51as many examples as I could and kind of continued for a while.
- 51:53And I don't think there's a ton that we Know about because like
- 51:56those are often the ones that get to us because people want to
- 51:59like shit on those investors that people want to show tiger
- 52:02is like bad. Like this is why you shouldn't
- 52:04take their money. There's so much of a source
- 52:06interest in. Showing that the fact that more
- 52:08has emerged to me, is I like agree.
- 52:11I think that probably shows because I mean most investors
- 52:13know that that is like suicide because if you're if you start
- 52:17doing that like that gets around so quick and then people don't
- 52:19want to work with you. So I don't think that that a
- 52:21still in a founder market. Even if like even if things are
- 52:24changing, the Dynamics are changing Changing like there are
- 52:27still you know, a finite number of like these great companies.
- 52:29And there are so many investors and there's like what like three
- 52:32hundred and fifty billion dollars or thing raised in 2021,
- 52:35just like insane amount of money.
- 52:37So I don't think this is much too, that sometimes I feel like
- 52:40they're more exciting investors than companies.
- 52:43It's like it's more fun to talk about some of the investors.
- 52:46I'm like, what are the companies that are like, so exciting to
- 52:49talk about? There's so much politics in the
- 52:51ventures and I think that is interesting to.
- 52:53So, like, yeah, I think it can be more compelling.
- 52:56To dive into like their Dynamics, then the founders.
- 52:59I agree. Sounds to me, like, we're all
- 53:01getting ourselves ready for a Dom Holland.
- 53:03Come back, maybe maybe in the next week or two.
- 53:07So when that happens I'll be very excited to have you back on
- 53:10here. Kate definitely hopefully
- 53:12feeling better. And look at least we're all
- 53:14doing better than fast. Can we?
- 53:15At least say that. Thanks so much for coming.
- 53:19Yeah, thanks so much for joining.
- 53:20This was fun. Thank you.
- 53:21Yeah, thanks for having me. Goodbye.
- 53:36Goodbye. Goodbye, goodbye, goodbye.
- 53:39Goodbye. Goodbye.
- 53:36Goodbye. Goodbye, goodbye, goodbye.
- 53:39Goodbye.