Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / How Cultural Awareness Can Help Reduce Bias
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to How Cultural Awareness Can Help Reduce
- 0:06Bias. I'm Belinda McCauley, Executive Director
- 0:09and CEO of the Beverly Hills Bar Association.
- 0:12I am delighted to be here today to introduce
- 0:15our speaker, the Honorable Angel Bermudez. Judge
- 0:19Bermudez is a mediator, arbitrator and neutral
- 0:21at Jams. He retired from the bench after more
- 0:24than 18 years of judicial service on the Riverside
- 0:26County Superior Court, where he primarily presided
- 0:30over complex, unlimited civil matters and also
- 0:33served in the Family Law Division. Prior to the
- 0:35bench, Judge Bermudez spent 16 years as a senior
- 0:38deputy district attorney, including working as
- 0:41a white collar crime specialist, shaping his
- 0:43disciplined and analytical approach to dispute
- 0:45resolution. A native Spanish speaker, he's widely
- 0:48recognized for his fairness, preparation, and
- 0:51ability to resolve high conflict matters with
- 0:53civility and efficiency. And he handles disputes
- 0:55spanning personal injury, product liability,
- 0:58business and commercial, real estate, professional
- 1:00liability, and family law. And just based on
- 1:03my brief, chat with him in the prep room. I think
- 1:07this is going to be a wonderful program and we're
- 1:09going to learn a lot. So thanks all for being
- 1:12here and let's get started. Absolutely. All right
- 1:16if we can get the face slide please. All right
- 1:22perfect. So welcome aboard with respect to the
- 1:26presentation. A lot of times when this category
- 1:30comes up for purposes of instruction This is
- 1:33how most people feel. Can we get on the next
- 1:36slide then? Back the bags, we're going on a guilt
- 1:40trip. Yeah, so that's Charlie Sheen in Terminal
- 1:43Velocity. I think a lot of times when we talk
- 1:45about subjects like this, also I think subjects
- 1:48like straight ethics and applied bias, we are
- 1:53kind of feel like an emotional bag is going to
- 1:56be brought upon us and that we're going to have
- 1:58to carry it. That's not my intention in any way.
- 2:02What we're doing today is recognizing that all
- 2:07human beings have biases. Let's just get that
- 2:09out of the way. What we're really trying to do
- 2:12is figure out how to address those biases, all
- 2:15right? And so in that regard, next slide. In
- 2:21that regard, I've got some video to share with
- 2:23you. Now I'm gonna give you the heads up. Some
- 2:27people might find this a little distressing,
- 2:28because this video involves children. And it's
- 2:32a manifestation of how quickly biases start to
- 2:36affect us. The videos that you have here today,
- 2:39though, that I have found to share are not videos
- 2:42of American kids, because it seems like we here
- 2:47in our country, we get a lot of attack for our
- 2:51bias issues and the way we interact with each
- 2:53other, etc. But this isn't an American issue.
- 2:57This is a human issue. And so this first video
- 3:00that you're going to see is actually one that
- 3:05involves Italian children. So let's take a look
- 3:08at how quickly these bias issues come up. Go
- 3:11ahead and push play. Which doll is white? Which
- 3:38doll is black? Which one is pretty? This one
- 3:49Which one is pretty? Which one is ugly? And which
- 4:01one is good? Which one is bad? Which one is good?
- 4:27Why is she good? Because she has blue eyes. Which
- 4:34one is bad? Why is she bad? Because everything
- 4:51is black. And which doll looks more like you?
- 5:28All right, thank you. Next slide. It's a tough
- 5:32video. For some of you, you're probably a little
- 5:34bit upset right now. And if you are, my heart's
- 5:37with you. It's really tough to see children at
- 5:41that early of a stage in their lives already
- 5:44starting to show bias issues. But without having
- 5:48that hard example of how we probably received
- 5:53programming, and not probably, but we received
- 5:56programming, in terms of the way that we view
- 5:58the world, maybe the lesson is not taken well
- 6:02or is not taken to heart. And at the end of the
- 6:05day, I really want you to take what we talk about
- 6:07to heart and maybe make a difference in your
- 6:10lives and the lives of other people that you
- 6:11interact with. And I think by using that example,
- 6:17the tone is set. This is a serious topic, and
- 6:20it's not just something to appear to be nice.
- 6:24It's the goal is To actually be a kind person
- 6:28right and treat everybody the same. So at the
- 6:31end of the day being Treating people the same
- 6:33should not be a mandate which is of course what
- 6:37happens Through the law it should just be the
- 6:40way that we are but we're here because we're
- 6:43legal professionals and next slide and because
- 6:45of that there have to be There have to be mandates
- 6:49that direct us in terms of behavior And of course,
- 6:54we have to talk about those with a level of frequency
- 6:57that we satisfy our state bar obligation. But
- 7:00really, at the end of the day, I think this is
- 7:01a topic that should be talked about, not just
- 7:04to satisfy a particular hour of credits that
- 7:07are necessary, but something to talk about to
- 7:11make us better people. And at the end of the
- 7:12day, by the end of this presentation, you'll
- 7:14understand it actually makes you a better lawyer
- 7:16or a better advocate. By the way, down at the
- 7:19bottom, you'll see the 19th Amendment. I don't
- 7:23really give short shrift to women's issues in
- 7:26this presentation. It's just that I focused more
- 7:28on racial issues. But I will talk a little bit
- 7:30about women's issues when I get a little bit
- 7:33further on the presentation. So if you listen
- 7:35in, you'll hear me touch base on that. For the
- 7:39most part, yes, I honestly do focus mostly on
- 7:42racial issues in this presentation and cultural
- 7:45issues. Next slide. So there's the mandates,
- 7:49right? Everything's telling us to treat everybody
- 7:51the same. And yet, the genesis of the country,
- 7:55which I once heard Condoleezza Rice at the College
- 7:57of William & Mary describe our history as having
- 8:03one with a birth defect, which I thought was
- 8:05interesting. You know, our Declaration of Independence
- 8:09itself says that we hold these truths to be self
- 8:12-evident that all men are created equal. Of course,
- 8:14a document was only signed by 56. white men.
- 8:18It doesn't mean that it's not an important document.
- 8:20It just means that that was the genesis of what
- 8:23started it. But even as we have these mandates,
- 8:26we'll see that in some of these rules, there's
- 8:28still some issues as we discuss them. Okay, so
- 8:31let's go through the mandates. Next slide. Of
- 8:36course, if you're a legal professional lawyer,
- 8:39you go by the California rules of professional
- 8:41conduct. If you are not aware, the bench goes
- 8:46by the Judicial Conduct Handbook. It actually
- 8:50follows the canons, the judicial canons, but
- 8:54those judicial canons are actually discussed
- 8:56with a lot of detail in Judge Rothman's book.
- 9:03And if you ever want to know how a judge has
- 9:06to live, how they have to abide by ethical standards,
- 9:10you might want to get an old copy of that book
- 9:12so you can understand why your judge might behave
- 9:15the way that they do. Okay, let's look at the
- 9:17oath that attorneys take. Next slide. So, for
- 9:22my iteration of the practice of law in my generation,
- 9:26it was a little bit different. You took the oath
- 9:30to faithfully execute the laws, or not to faithfully
- 9:34execute, faithfully support the Constitution
- 9:36of the United States and the state of California,
- 9:38etc. And then a few years ago, I started to notice
- 9:44when I swore in new attorneys, that there was
- 9:46some new language added. And that new language
- 9:50comes in Rule 9 .7, and you'll notice that when
- 9:53you renew your bar now, you'll see that there's
- 9:58an oath or affirmation that you take with that.
- 10:00And what I find interesting about it is that
- 10:05the change tells us that we're to behave at all
- 10:09times with dignity, courtesy, and integrity.
- 10:11And at all times has not yet been defined. I
- 10:14haven't seen that case yet, or that situation
- 10:17yet. But I think when the bar or the rules of
- 10:22court are telling us that our behavior at all
- 10:26times matters, I think that that's really what
- 10:28we're targeting. Not to be one person in the
- 10:31professional arena and yet a completely different
- 10:33person in the non -professional arena. Next slide.
- 10:40You'll see some of the inconsistencies here because
- 10:45here's the probably the single closest rule that
- 10:47touches on the issue that I'm addressing today,
- 10:51which is Eight rule eight point four point one,
- 10:56but you'll notice in sub paragraph subsection
- 10:59a it says in representing a client and then it
- 11:01goes on To give another situate or give the factual
- 11:06situation. So it's in representing a client Well,
- 11:09this is where it gets interesting, right? Because
- 11:10here you have a rule of professional conduct,
- 11:12but yet we just took a note that says it all
- 11:14times. So, do these line items, if you will,
- 11:21that you see on the right hand of the slide,
- 11:24are they just in the setting of rule 8 .41, that
- 11:28is in representing the client, or are they things
- 11:30that we should, as legal professionals, kind
- 11:33of treat with respect? at all times, right? So
- 11:40that's food for thought for you. I don't have
- 11:43an answer because there really is no guidelines
- 11:45yet on what they mean when there's a conflict
- 11:48between this is the way you behave when you're
- 11:50practicing versus this is the way you behave
- 11:52as a human being that has a license to practice
- 11:55law. Next slide. All right, so with respect to
- 12:01the judges, how do they have to comport themselves?
- 12:04They have to comport themselves under Canon 3B5,
- 12:08without bias or prejudice, and that means, again,
- 12:17that they have to perform their judicial duties.
- 12:20I think, and I would submit to you, that a judge
- 12:22should be acting in this way at all times, because
- 12:27if a judge acts against these rules in a social
- 12:31setting, and you happen to see that, then certainly
- 12:34you could question the integrity of the entire
- 12:36judicial system when that person is officiating
- 12:40over proceedings, right? So I think most certainly
- 12:43a judge has to behave at all times following
- 12:47these rules of treating everyone the same and
- 12:49without bias. The next rule is the one that we're
- 12:52going to talk about with respect to legal professionals
- 12:55and their behavior and why maybe judges say something.
- 12:58So a judge shall require under rule 3b6, shall
- 13:02require lawyers and their proceedings to refrain
- 13:05from certain behavior. So let's look at when
- 13:08this type of discussion might come up. Next slide.
- 13:13All right. So here's something that I would hope
- 13:17would be something that never, ever, ever hear
- 13:19again. But oddly, just last week, in a private
- 13:25professional setting, during the course of doing
- 13:31my job, Now somebody actually used this terminology
- 13:35and although I'm no longer a judge I Still didn't
- 13:40think it was the right thing to do and so I still
- 13:43made comment on it and I corrected conduct So
- 13:47if somebody says judge my client was jipped out
- 13:49of his money. It is a pejorative statement it
- 13:53is pejorative to people that are Romani or As
- 13:57people used to say in old days days gone by gypsies
- 14:02It is a pejorative attack on them, and it's improper.
- 14:08So under Rule 3B6, should the judge say something?
- 14:12Yes, the judge should say something. So if this
- 14:15ever happens to you, you use a word and you don't
- 14:19know its origins, you just happen to use it.
- 14:21And there's a few of these. I think we'll cover
- 14:22a couple more. One's patently obvious, but if
- 14:26I haven't covered one of the ones that's less
- 14:28obvious, I'll tell you about it. the judge has
- 14:32to say something. Because if they fail to say
- 14:34something, then they themselves are violating
- 14:37their own ethical canons. So if that ever happens
- 14:40to you, just realize that that's why, why it
- 14:44happened. And maybe you just, you might want
- 14:46to just have a private chat later. You know,
- 14:47Judge Wedges scold me on that, if they don't
- 14:49tell you upfront. Or maybe you just have to do
- 14:52a little bit of homework. Okay, next slide. So
- 14:57of course, there's exceptions, right? I can't
- 14:59think of a root or word. really to be used in
- 15:03a courtroom or in any other discussion really
- 15:05But you know there you are in a professional
- 15:08setting and the attorney uses the word Says in
- 15:11the courtroom. So you heard mr. X say Quote get
- 15:16out of here and quote or get out of here n -word
- 15:20end quote Right, so now this horrible words used
- 15:25in the courtroom but it's being used because
- 15:28it's relaying a factual statement that's necessary
- 15:32for the trial or effect. Should the judge take
- 15:34corrective action? No, probably not in this situation
- 15:39because it would divest one side of being able
- 15:43to make its point so long as that point is relevant.
- 15:47Now, where would the judge chime in on this type
- 15:50of situation if that attorney uses that as a
- 15:54sword and then just starts repeating the word
- 15:56to try to create animosity or hostility towards
- 16:00the declarant or getting to the passions of the
- 16:05jury by using that word repeatedly to create
- 16:08offense against the declarant. If that type of
- 16:12tactic takes place, then yes, the judge should
- 16:15probably take corrective measure against the
- 16:17attorney. Um, so just be mindful of that. You
- 16:20don't necessarily have to sanitize things always
- 16:23in the courtroom, so long as you're trying to
- 16:25relay facts, but don't play games. Um, because
- 16:29you might get chewed out, uh, because that judge
- 16:31is just doing their job and doing what's right.
- 16:35Right. Next slide. Right. So here it gets a little
- 16:40bit more subtle. So the attorney might say, well,
- 16:42the opposing party is hot blooded. And you might
- 16:45just say, well, what does that So what? You know,
- 16:47there are people that are quicker on the fuse
- 16:51or shorter on the fuse. So what's wrong with
- 16:53that? Why do we care, right? Well, if the person
- 16:57on the other side happens to be Hispanic or Latino,
- 17:02then that might be a cultural attack and a statement
- 17:09that's viewed as offensive. I certainly would
- 17:12view it as offensive. Would the judge be obligated
- 17:16in this situation to say anything? I Yeah, if
- 17:19the judge but here's where it gets interesting
- 17:21if the judge picks up the subtlety of What is
- 17:24offensive not everybody's in tune with what's
- 17:28going on? In the courtroom, so I might get my
- 17:32eyebrow furled because I'm offended by it But
- 17:35somebody else doing the same gig in the courtroom
- 17:39would not necessarily have any problems with
- 17:42it because they don't they're not aware of it.
- 17:44But now you are. Be sensitive to that declaration
- 17:48because it could be offensive to those of us
- 17:51that are Latino. Now, do people actually say
- 17:53things like this? Well, take a look at the next
- 17:55slide. So, kind of says it all. I don't really
- 18:05need to say much. And this is 2006. Ironically,
- 18:11Governor Schwarzenegger was the one that appointed
- 18:13me. So, interesting subcategory or substatement,
- 18:19but yeah, people do say this. And we have to
- 18:23be cognizant or aware of things that might be
- 18:26viewed as offensive to people, might be hurtful,
- 18:29which requires a little bit of study. All right.
- 18:32Now that I've taken you on that kind of guilt
- 18:34trip that Charlie Sheen's been talking about,
- 18:35and we've been talking about the rules, and you're
- 18:38kind of feeling, man, this isn't going well.
- 18:42I'm going to show you another video about kids.
- 18:45This video, though, is not set in Italy. So these
- 18:48aren't Italian kids. These are Singaporean kids.
- 18:51And so when you look at their responses, they're,
- 18:55of course, going to be influenced by where they
- 18:58are geographically. And you'll now see that the
- 19:02discussion isn't just which is the good kid,
- 19:05which is the bad kid, based on color and things
- 19:07of that sort. You're going to see a little bit
- 19:08more complexity in the discussion. The purpose
- 19:11of this video again is not to upset you but to
- 19:14be patient and wait till the end because in the
- 19:16end you're going to see that there's some hope.
- 19:18There's some hope for all of us. So can we go
- 19:19ahead and get to the next slide and play that
- 19:21video? The skin is shiny. This one. This one.
- 19:48This one. Because this is bad baby. Because the
- 19:58brown is so dark. He is no cute. I think this
- 20:03one. Chinese Adam really like. One plays me and
- 20:09all the others never play me. Because I like
- 20:18the peach colour. This one. This one. This is
- 20:25the third one. Because I just know brown is smart.
- 20:30Because my father is smart. This one. Because
- 20:38the skin is almost the same. Because it's that
- 20:46brown. This one. And these dolls. I want to be
- 20:59born peach color. What do you think about her?
- 21:17She has brown skin. She does have brown skin.
- 21:21She has a name. Her name is Shanti. I'm going
- 21:26to go on to the next one. Well, who's this? Okay,
- 21:37but her name is Sha. Okay. His name is Raj. Raj.
- 21:54Joel. Joel. What's her name, do you remember?
- 21:57Sha. Sha, that's right. Okay, let's see who can
- 22:00remember. Who's this? Rita. Rita. She's smiling.
- 22:09And how about this one? She likes to dance? Why
- 22:15do you think she likes to dance? Because she
- 22:17has a skirt. Because she has a skirt, she likes
- 22:20to dance? OK, what about this guy? They made
- 22:27stuff up, but to my mind, that was a striking
- 22:29thing. Put a name there and suddenly these become
- 22:32people, they have imaginary lives. There's a
- 22:35story there that the children want to know about.
- 22:37By encouraging kids to categorise each face even
- 22:40further... as individuals with their own names,
- 22:44instead of the broader marker of race, it can
- 22:47reduce their implicit racial bias. So as you
- 22:53can see from that video, the children are immediately
- 22:59gravitating towards identifying physical features
- 23:01and what the doctor is able to do is once he
- 23:08is making that little person, a human being,
- 23:13the children are adapting, and they are enveloping
- 23:17their empathy, if you will, towards that little
- 23:21person. And so they start giving it characteristics
- 23:23like they like to brush their teeth and things
- 23:25that are they like to dance, etc. And so they
- 23:28are showing us that we can learn and we can adapt.
- 23:32So let's figure out how we can do that from within.
- 23:36So the next series of slides that you're going
- 23:38to see are my attempt to try to help you help
- 23:44yourself, right? Because I can't really do anything
- 23:47for you other than kind of give you the rubric
- 23:49to help you out. But it's going to be up to you
- 23:52if you really care about improving yourself to
- 23:55do these exercises and to give them a go. All
- 23:58right, so let's talk about how do we figure out
- 24:01if we have biases? Well, look at your first reaction
- 24:05or what we call the gut reaction. Because bias
- 24:08appears automatically. So, when we get into this
- 24:16discussion, certainly one of the things that
- 24:18people talk about is, Well, are you just trying
- 24:20to, to preach to me to be a better person? Because
- 24:25really, I'm a lawyer, and I'm busy, and I got
- 24:27stuff to do. But here's the thing, if you follow
- 24:30what comes between now and the ending of this
- 24:34presentation, it's actually going to help you
- 24:36be a better practitioner. So just bear with.
- 24:39until that message gets across. And then hopefully,
- 24:42you'll appreciate it. So look at your gut reaction.
- 24:46You know, so there you are. What's your first
- 24:48assumption about this person? Of course, we were
- 24:50all taught, don't judge a book by its cover.
- 24:52But what do we do? We judge books by people by
- 24:56their cover, right? Just like those little kids,
- 24:58we have that tendency, we cast judgment. And
- 25:03so one of the first things that you need to break
- 25:05is from that assumption, right? So what you can
- 25:12do in that regard is look at how you are with
- 25:15that person. Are you more or less patient with
- 25:18that person? So they come in, they sit down in
- 25:22your conference room, they're there for your
- 25:23interview, a client interview, you're trying
- 25:26to decide whether to take the case, they sit
- 25:28down and you immediately are judging them. You
- 25:31know, their clothes tells me this or this clothes
- 25:34tells me that, right? And then the way they cut
- 25:37the hair or the way that they apply their makeup,
- 25:39whatever it is, you start to cast judgments.
- 25:41If you start to see that, that might be bias
- 25:44that's creeping in and it might affect the way
- 25:46that you accept this person and accept what they
- 25:49have to say. The next thing that you would have
- 25:52is your patience tested with this person. In
- 25:55other words, the way that they interact now starts
- 25:59to affect you. You're like, I don't have time
- 26:02for this. This person takes too long. Could it
- 26:04be that your mind has already started to create
- 26:07a solve a paradigm that pre -existed in there
- 26:10and so as a result of that you're not giving
- 26:13this person a real chance and so this person
- 26:16that could actually be an outstanding client
- 26:18or maybe even outstanding witness for your client
- 26:20is dismissed by you because of the barriers that
- 26:23your mind puts up. That's all we're talking about.
- 26:26Your mind will actually affect your skepticism.
- 26:30You might be less likely to accept what they
- 26:32have to say. because of the way that they come
- 26:35across. And remember bias works both ways. You
- 26:38could actually be more enveloped in what they
- 26:40have to say because you are programmed to be
- 26:44favorable to whatever paradigm is in front of
- 26:45you. So you gotta be careful of that as well.
- 26:52When you do this, so the next time you start
- 26:55interviewing somebody, whenever it is, it could
- 26:57be at a grocery store, it could be anywhere,
- 27:00and you start talking to them, and you're all
- 27:03done. Maybe just log your observations. Not necessarily,
- 27:07I'm not saying keep a written journal. I'm saying,
- 27:09you know, just kind of mentally go through the
- 27:11discussion with yourself. Many of us do that.
- 27:14We rehash something that's just happened in order
- 27:16to process it. But be honest with yourself. Were
- 27:20you open? Did you start to draw conclusions before
- 27:23their statements were completed? Did you have
- 27:27an impression of them, even without them having
- 27:29said anything? But here's the thing, though.
- 27:33Don't judge yourself. Don't be harsh on yourself,
- 27:35right? What you're trying to do is learn, and
- 27:38learn who you are and how you process people.
- 27:42I think we'd all agree that those little kids
- 27:45that we just watched, whether they were in Italy
- 27:47or whether they're in Singapore, they're just
- 27:49human beings, right? They're not evil people.
- 27:53They're just human beings exhibiting the biases
- 27:55that human beings do. So if you find yourself
- 27:58doing that, don't be hard on yourself, but don't
- 28:02avoid the discussion because it's going to be
- 28:04an uncomfortable realization with yourself. And
- 28:07I don't mean literally talking to yourself out
- 28:09loud. Although, you know, maybe if that works
- 28:11for you, so be it. But I'm saying, when you have
- 28:14that challenge to yourself, where you're trying
- 28:16to make yourself better, and you're asking yourself
- 28:18these pointed questions, just realize that you're
- 28:22not a bad person. Okay, next slide. Again, our
- 28:28biases manifest themselves in emotion. So they're
- 28:31not reason. They're not logical. They are a feeling
- 28:37that comes out when you're talking to somebody.
- 28:39So you might be in an interview with a potential
- 28:42client and you find yourself getting more irritated
- 28:44with them. Like, like you don't have a fuse.
- 28:46Like five minutes into the interview, you're
- 28:48already like, I'm done with this. This is a waste
- 28:49of time. I got stuff to do. I need to move on.
- 28:52Why is that irritation coming up? that irritation
- 28:55may be manifesting itself because your own cultural
- 29:00programming may be inhibiting your receptors
- 29:03towards this person and what they have to say.
- 29:06That's all we're getting at, or all I'm getting
- 29:07at. Maybe when you're talking to somebody, you
- 29:12start getting defensive. So if you see that,
- 29:17why are you getting your guard up? Why is that
- 29:20happening? Is it something empirically based?
- 29:23or is something emotionally based? If it's emotionally
- 29:25based, then we would say it's likely a bias,
- 29:28right? So we have to be in tune with that. We've
- 29:33already talked about skepticism. Dismissiveness
- 29:36is an important one. We're going to talk about
- 29:38dismissiveness within cultural aspects, just
- 29:41in a little bit. But dismissiveness is what I
- 29:45was just talking about. You start to then listen
- 29:48to the witness or the potential client, and every
- 29:52time they say something, you devalue it. You
- 29:55devalue it with your own contra -argument so
- 29:57that you're not really fairly accepting what
- 29:59they have to say. You're already creating the
- 30:03against argument for every statement that they
- 30:06make to you. If you're doing that, you have to
- 30:08ask yourself, why am I advocating against this
- 30:11person? Am I being truly clinical or is there
- 30:14something else going on? It doesn't mean that
- 30:17that skepticism or that structure that you have
- 30:21that's causing you to believe that is always
- 30:23going to be a bias, by the way. Your paradigm
- 30:26could be actually accurate. And maybe this person
- 30:28is not a credible person. But what I'm saying
- 30:32is, when it comes to this arena, this is something
- 30:34that you actually actively have to work on. At
- 30:38the end of the day, when you're done talking
- 30:40with this person, think about how you viewed
- 30:44your discussion with them. What's the story that
- 30:47you would paint as you or relate, if you will,
- 30:51to somebody else about the interview that you
- 30:52just had. I like this person. I didn't like this
- 30:55person. I thought that what they had to say was
- 30:58poignant. I thought what they had to say was
- 31:01ridiculous. And then just kind of think of the
- 31:03story that you paint about that human being and
- 31:07kind of think of those kids in Singapore. Think
- 31:09about how they're painting a story about those
- 31:11characters and yet they don't really know if
- 31:13that little character brushes their teeth or
- 31:15whatever. So you may be contriving, if you will,
- 31:19your own story in your mind because of the way
- 31:22that programming is affecting you. Okay, next
- 31:28slide. So in the hopes of basically showing a
- 31:34couple things. Number one, that this issue is
- 31:37not an American issue, but it's a human issue.
- 31:40The other thing that I wanted to bring up is
- 31:42that we as legal professionals you know, it's
- 31:45not just us, right? Here is what I think is a
- 31:49vaulted career, you know, do no harm. Medical
- 31:52doctors, they take that Hippocratic oath. They
- 31:58do the best that they can, right? That's the
- 32:00goal. They're there to help people. And yet,
- 32:05here's the reality. In the medical profession,
- 32:09there's a dirty little secret that female patients
- 32:12do not get the same treatment as male patients.
- 32:18Now, I don't have the benefit of a room where
- 32:20we're all together, but I've done presentations
- 32:23similar to this in the past, and one of the things
- 32:25that I've done is by a show of hands so it's
- 32:27manifest. I've asked women, if they would, how
- 32:32many of you have felt that you have been with
- 32:35a physician and that your feelings, the things
- 32:38that you were going through were dismissed? right,
- 32:41or ignored. And it's, it's, it's amazing because
- 32:45almost every woman's hand in the room goes up.
- 32:48And then I ask the same question of the men.
- 32:51And it's just a scattering of hands that go up.
- 32:54And I've done it a few times over the years.
- 32:58Well, here's a study that actually talks about
- 33:01this being a real thing. And you may be thinking,
- 33:05Well, yeah, but that's just that one area. No,
- 33:08it's not. If you're a woman, Did you know that
- 33:14if CPR was administered for you in an emergency
- 33:19situation, that you would be 27 % less likely
- 33:23to have a successful administration of CPR than
- 33:27a man? And the reason is people that train on
- 33:32CPR dummies train on CPR dummies without breasts.
- 33:39Simple enough. So the mannequins that are used
- 33:45for purposes of instruction Don't have breasts
- 33:47and so all of a sudden people that are trained
- 33:49in CPR don't know how to deal with that That's
- 33:54a bias and I can't think of a simpler scientific
- 33:58way of showing that Look that one up after I'm
- 34:01all done. Is that true and see for yourselves?
- 34:04There's actually an organization in the UK that
- 34:06raises money to provide mannequins for instruction
- 34:13that have breasts, because they've identified
- 34:17that as an issue. All right, next slide. All
- 34:24right, when you're talking to people, what else
- 34:26can you do? You can look at your own way of speech,
- 34:31what you're saying about the situation. So remember
- 34:34when you were creating that narrative or that
- 34:36story, does your story come up with some red
- 34:39flag things like people like that always or they're
- 34:43probably just or at the end of it when you've
- 34:47come up with a story and you've drawn up your
- 34:49conclusions about whether to take that client
- 34:51or not take that client or believe the witness
- 34:54or not to believe the witness, you start to say
- 34:56something like, I knew it. That's typically the
- 34:59way that they are, or something like that. If
- 35:03you see anything like that in your language pattern
- 35:05of describing that event, that's a red flag.
- 35:10Okay? Then what you have to do is ask yourself,
- 35:15why did I categorize that person that way? What
- 35:19is it about me and the way that I took in what
- 35:22they had to say that could be affecting me, or
- 35:26that did affect me? Why did I lump them into
- 35:29a group? What am I doing? What is it about me
- 35:33that makes me do that to them, to that person?
- 35:38Because here's the bad news. What if that client
- 35:40that you completely dismissed was actually somebody
- 35:44that had a really legitimate concern, a really
- 35:48righteous grievance, and at the end of the day,
- 35:51a really good lawsuit that you could have helped
- 35:53them with? And whether out of honor or whether
- 35:57out of desire to make a living and a vocation,
- 36:02you really passed up a good opportunity just
- 36:05because of your own programming. Is it worth
- 36:07it to stay with that programming? Is it worth
- 36:09it to kind of maybe test it and see if you're
- 36:13doing the right thing and thinking along the
- 36:15lines that you're treating everyone the same?
- 36:17That's all we're talking about. All right, next
- 36:19slide. Some questions that you could ask yourself
- 36:25as you try to improve. are these. And I'm not
- 36:30going to go through them because I want to get
- 36:31to the end of the presentation. So you'll have
- 36:33a copy of this presentation with you. All of
- 36:36these are original. You're not going to find
- 36:38them anywhere. I just sat down and tried to come
- 36:41up with as many things as I could to try to help
- 36:43you. OK. Next slide. You know, one of the things
- 36:51that you can do is in assessing your own standards
- 36:54is ask Go to the last one that I put on here,
- 36:59which is, ask the person who are your true friends,
- 37:02and we'll be honest with you, what they think.
- 37:06And when I say true friends, we all have friends
- 37:10that we love dearly, and we think they're the
- 37:13greatest thing in the world. However, when you
- 37:15ask them a question, like, what do you think
- 37:17of this shirt? You always get that like really
- 37:20nice response. I really like the color, right?
- 37:23This is the moment to ask that friend. Sometimes
- 37:26I describe them as your East Coast friend, right?
- 37:28People on the East Coast are a little bit different
- 37:29on the West Coast. Ask the East Coast person,
- 37:32what do they think about the shirt? And your
- 37:33East Coast friend is more likely to say, Why'd
- 37:36you buy that shirt? You look ridiculous, right?
- 37:38So, so in that regard, ask that person, the brutally
- 37:43honest person in your life, or brutally honest
- 37:45persons in your life, Hey, what do you think?
- 37:49Do you think I've got some blind spots? Let me
- 37:51tell you about the situation. to the extent that
- 37:54you can share it and see what their input they
- 37:56give you. And if they're a good friend, they'll
- 37:59tell you, yeah, I've noticed that, right? Think
- 38:04about social settings. So now we're here in electronic
- 38:08media, but next time you're in an event and you
- 38:10gather in a room and you're there with a whole
- 38:13bunch of other people that you don't really know,
- 38:16whether it's a mixer or a training or whatever
- 38:19it is, look at how you gravitate towards people.
- 38:23Are you always gravitating towards people that
- 38:25fit a particular look? Or are you somebody that
- 38:30truly works the room, so to speak? You just go
- 38:32around and you talk to everybody. You find them
- 38:34all equally interesting. If you're gravitating
- 38:36towards a select group, identifiable group, that
- 38:39might tell you something. Next slide. But at
- 38:43the end of the day, whatever is being told to
- 38:44you is not that you're a moral failure, right?
- 38:49When you talk to your best friend, who's going
- 38:52to be honest with you, don't get defensive, don't
- 38:55get angry. Just try to learn from it, right?
- 38:59This isn't your good or bad type of discussion.
- 39:04Next slide. I mean, keep in mind these kids.
- 39:08Remember their faces. Remember what you just
- 39:10watched. You wouldn't cast judgment on them,
- 39:13right? So you shouldn't cast judgment on yourself.
- 39:16Next slide. The thing to understand is that bias
- 39:22is a cognitive habit. It's something that's been
- 39:26formed, and you see it in those children, right?
- 39:30I mean, it's not like they're going to meetings
- 39:33and learning to hate, right? That's not what's
- 39:36going on. They're just processing and picking
- 39:38up information. Interestingly enough, we're in
- 39:41the era of AI. And I don't know if you're aware
- 39:43of this, but AI has shown some bias issues in
- 39:47its own responses. So bias is something that
- 39:51is learned. It's cognitive. But there's good
- 39:53news. And here's the good news. The good news
- 39:56is that neuroplasticity allows you to reprogram
- 40:00your brain. And you see that in terms of an example
- 40:04in the tail end of the Singaporean children's
- 40:08discussion with the doctor, where he is creating
- 40:11different neuro paths for those kids in their
- 40:15brains. and they're starting to alter the way
- 40:18that they perceive Raj or any of the other little
- 40:22people in the photos that they got. So what we're
- 40:26talking about here in today's presentation is
- 40:28the very same thing. If you really care and you
- 40:32really want to become open -minded, you can reprogram
- 40:36your brain. You're not locked and tied to the
- 40:39way things have always been in terms of doing
- 40:42that. Next slide. All right a few weeks back
- 40:48I had The benefit of having one of my articles
- 40:52published by the Daily Journal I think you're
- 40:54gonna get a copy of it after this presentation
- 40:57and it was something that's Near and dear to
- 41:00my heart and I wanted to talk about it. You may
- 41:02wonder why right, you know Why is cultural awareness
- 41:05and bias something that you're interested in?
- 41:08Well number one, I'm not speaking to you in my
- 41:11first language it is my adopted language because
- 41:18I am the product of immigration. So with that
- 41:22being said, having come from or being from another
- 41:26world and yet growing up in the U .S., which
- 41:31probably many of you in the audience or in today's
- 41:34meeting are from somewhere else or maybe you're
- 41:37first -gen American, the reality is you're kind
- 41:41of in two different worlds. You're not really
- 41:44from the old country anymore, and you're not
- 41:46really from this country. You just kind of feel
- 41:47like you're lost. But because of that, it makes
- 41:51you much more aware of cultural issues, and it
- 41:56affected me. So there's my bias, right? Because
- 41:58of my background, I'm interested in the subject
- 42:01matter. Okay. All right, next slide. So here
- 42:08in the US, of course, we have called ourselves
- 42:12a melting pot. That was the term that I remember
- 42:16when I was young. But then eventually, the discussion
- 42:19said that the United States was a mosaic. And
- 42:22then, of course, over the last many years, we
- 42:25talk about things like diversity. But at the
- 42:28end of the day, we're just talking about a nation
- 42:30that is not culturally singular in background,
- 42:34but rather an amalgam of different cultures coming
- 42:38together into a single ideal, right? An ideal
- 42:45of the American dream, of opportunity, etc. That's
- 42:48the ideal. Economic freedom, that's the origins
- 42:51of the country, right? So, because of that, we
- 42:54don't have a singular cultural identity. What
- 42:56do I mean by that? Well, you can travel to other
- 42:59countries in the world. Japan's a great example.
- 43:01Japan is still 95 % culturally Japanese. because
- 43:06there's only a 5 % non -Japanese population in
- 43:10the country. So it is a singular culture, still
- 43:14a monoculture nation. If you travel to Europe
- 43:1840 years ago, you would notice that when you
- 43:21were in France, it was very different than being
- 43:24right next door in Spain, and that being in France
- 43:27was very different from being right next door
- 43:29even in Belgium, which is... has its ties to
- 43:32France as well. Everybody was very culturally
- 43:35different. Well, the United States, because of
- 43:38that, because of our origins, has always been
- 43:41ahead of the curve when it comes to these issues.
- 43:44So, because of that immigration, we have ethnic
- 43:47and racial diversities, we have enclaves, right,
- 43:52we call them neighborhoods, we get linguistic
- 43:54variety, cultural blending. All of these things
- 43:57kind of affect the way we are as people. All
- 44:02right, next slide. So getting back to you being
- 44:07a great legal professional, making yourself better.
- 44:10What has cultural awareness got to do with me?
- 44:13Well, let's just think, think about a few of
- 44:15these things. Americans are really good at the
- 44:19small talk, right? So you walk into a store,
- 44:22and you say, Oh, hey, how you doing? How's your
- 44:25day? Right? Well, in America, when we say, Hey,
- 44:29how's your day? we don't really mean, tell me
- 44:32about your day. It's just a pleasantry. Or we
- 44:36would say, you're just making small talk. It's
- 44:39inconsequential talk. You're not really going
- 44:41to extract anything from it. In other countries,
- 44:44like for example, in Denmark, if you were to
- 44:46go into a store and you say to somebody, how's
- 44:49your day? They might actually tell you that they've
- 44:51had a beef with the boss, that they don't understand
- 44:54why their workday is so long, which is not likely
- 44:57in Denmark. They have pretty good work hours.
- 44:59But they might tell you everything that's going
- 45:01on, the troubles or ills with their dog or their
- 45:04pets, because they're taking that as a sign of
- 45:08discussion. So that's how I'm talking about cultural
- 45:13awareness. You have to be aware of little things.
- 45:19Another one, direct communication. So, you might
- 45:23just want to get to the facts, right? You just
- 45:26want to get to the heart of the matter. But yet,
- 45:29if the person that you're interviewing, that
- 45:31potential witness or that potential client, is
- 45:34culturally from Asia or from the Middle East,
- 45:38that direct confrontation, if you will, about
- 45:41just give me the facts because, you know, I got
- 45:43to get out of here, I got another client, I got
- 45:45to go to court, I got to file a document, whatever
- 45:47it is, That direct confrontation is not approved
- 45:54by that cultural segment. So what does that mean
- 45:59to you as the interviewer? Well, you may just
- 46:02want the facts, but yet this person is not relaying
- 46:04the facts directly to you because they don't
- 46:06want to have that discussion with you in the
- 46:09fashion that you want. And what do you do? You
- 46:12immediately start to draw the conclusion, oh
- 46:16my gosh, they're being evasive. So I don't think
- 46:19I should believe them. That's how a cultural
- 46:22bias could affect us in an interview Other little
- 46:29things so there you are everything's gone kind
- 46:31of great with the interview and The person that
- 46:35interview and says oh, would you like a candy
- 46:37or would you like this or would you like that?
- 46:38And you say no, thank you. You just know I'm
- 46:41good. I don't want any water. I don't want anything
- 46:43from you Well in some cultures that's actually
- 46:45viewed as rude. So all of a sudden now You were
- 46:48in an interview. You thought everything was going
- 46:49great. But now in this interview, what you pick
- 46:52up is that this potential client or this witness
- 46:55no longer wants to interact with you. They're
- 46:57somehow offended. Well, it could have just been
- 47:00that simple thing of saying, no, thank you. You
- 47:02don't turn away hospitality in some cultures.
- 47:06In some places, like South Korea calling people
- 47:10by their first name, that's not commonplace.
- 47:16Right? But what do we do? We immediately, as
- 47:19Americans, we go, Oh, can I call you this? Or
- 47:21can I call you that? Right? We immediately jump
- 47:24to the first name. But yet, if your client is
- 47:27culturally from one of these other segments of
- 47:30the world, that might be viewed as offensive.
- 47:32So there's that turn again in the interview.
- 47:34And you're trying to figure out, well, where
- 47:35did I lose this interview? Why is this client
- 47:39not working out? Next slide. Here's a few more,
- 47:46you know, there you are interviewing somebody
- 47:48and you're thinking everything's going great
- 47:49and you give them that gesture with the thumb
- 47:52Because you think that's a you know, hey, this
- 47:54is this interview is going fantastic Well, you
- 47:57know what culturally you might have just offended
- 47:59that person and again, you're you're now trying
- 48:02to figure out Why is this person completely turned
- 48:04on me? I had this third party witness not my
- 48:08client I'm not my clients bestie. Not the other
- 48:11side's bestie this neutral person the interview
- 48:14is going great i didn't think i'd need to subpoena
- 48:16them they were just going to show up on their
- 48:18own uh because uh they're just a good person
- 48:21and now all of a sudden they're acting kind of
- 48:22hostile i don't get it what did i do could have
- 48:25just been a simple cultural miscue something
- 48:28that you just completely missed you gave them
- 48:30the thumbs up thumbs up and it and it offended
- 48:34them Other things, the OK sign, of course, the
- 48:39use of the index finger in some cultures is something
- 48:42that can be offensive. So if the point of all
- 48:45this is in terms of cultural awareness, if you're
- 48:48in an interview and all of a sudden somebody
- 48:49turns off on you, and you're feeling the heat
- 48:52in the room, look to see what it is that you
- 48:54might have done. That's all. Right? So this is
- 48:59not just, what is your paradigm? And how do you
- 49:03expect the world? This is What is their paradigm
- 49:06and what do they expect from the world? And when
- 49:09you interact with them, it could just be that
- 49:12you are doing something that's affecting the
- 49:16way that they trust you, or the way they interact
- 49:19with you. And then you just got to figure out,
- 49:21what is it that I did? And of course, remember,
- 49:25direct questions might be viewed as offensive.
- 49:27So in that situation, the most obvious thing
- 49:30you do is you would say, well, tell me what I
- 49:32did that offended you. Because I notice that
- 49:34you've changed. Well, now you got to be careful.
- 49:37So you just got to be in tune a little bit with
- 49:40the fact that the entire world is not Anglo -American.
- 49:44Even in the United States, it's not Anglo -American.
- 49:48Direct eye contact. So I grew up culturally with
- 49:51direct eye contact is not something that is highly
- 49:56favored. It's kind of something that you do to
- 50:01intimidate. But it's not something that you do
- 50:03in a normal arena. So here I am staring at the
- 50:06camera to make eye contact with you. But if we
- 50:10went back in time and you asked the little person
- 50:13in me, do you stare at people? I would have been
- 50:16told by my parents, don't stare at people. It's
- 50:18not polite. Right? So in that regard, you got
- 50:23to be in tune with that. Why? Because what do
- 50:25we do in trial advocacy school or trial advocacy
- 50:28in law school? What do you do when you take a
- 50:30trial advocacy class or program to enhance your
- 50:33trial skills, right? Or you take a deposition
- 50:37class and you try to improve your deposition
- 50:40skills. And what do they say? Oh, if the person
- 50:42avoids eye contact with you, they might be skittish
- 50:45on reality, right? They might not be telling
- 50:47you the truth. Yeah, maybe. Or maybe they're
- 50:52from a culture where they do not engage in making
- 50:54direct eye contact. And it is up to you as the
- 50:57skilled professional to try to pick up on that
- 51:00situation and not just to shut them down and
- 51:03dismiss what they have to say because of those
- 51:06cultural differences. Another one that you should
- 51:10know is the effect of crossing your legs in front
- 51:14of people. Right? Crossing your legs, not keeping
- 51:18them down, planted on the floor, might be viewed
- 51:21as offensive. Showing your shoe or the bottom
- 51:23of your shoe in many cultures is not well regarded
- 51:27and it could create a situation where now that
- 51:31third party neutral witness that was going to
- 51:33be great for you and became hostile became hostile
- 51:36just because you elected to cross your legs and
- 51:40you can't even pick that up, right? Because you're
- 51:43not aware of it. Well, you know you are. There
- 51:45might be something that I did. What is that I
- 51:47did? Okay, everything was going great in this
- 51:49interview until this point. What did I do? And
- 51:52in your analytical skills, you'll pick up, that's
- 51:55what I did. That's, that was the moment I lost
- 51:58them. Okay. Sorry, I crossed my legs. I didn't
- 52:01realize that would be offensive. Simple enough.
- 52:05Okay, next slide. All right, next slide. Yeah,
- 52:12this is what we were just talking about, right?
- 52:14So, your trial ad class, what we would do with
- 52:16these slides, we would say, Oh, well, the person
- 52:19that's not making eye contact, they must be evasive,
- 52:22right? It could just be that they're being pensive,
- 52:24right? It could just be that there's emotion
- 52:27that they don't really want to make eye contact
- 52:29with somebody because those emotions will be
- 52:32brought out at that moment that they generate
- 52:34eye contact with another person because of the
- 52:37concern for empathy. And so they avoid it. It's
- 52:40not that they're always lying. And so you have
- 52:43to be aware of about why, what's going on, and
- 52:48what's going on with that person, and not just
- 52:51relied on our Anglo -American paradigm that non
- 52:54-eye contact means evasiveness. Okay, next slide.
- 53:00I think we've really talked about this one enough
- 53:02that we can move on to the next slide because
- 53:05we now know enough about eye contact and its
- 53:09importance. All right, so When we apply our paradigm
- 53:17without considering the other person's paradigm,
- 53:19we cast judgment. Okay, so what are we saying
- 53:21there? When you take or when we take our personal
- 53:27programming, whatever it was, yours may have
- 53:30been like mine, yours may have been different
- 53:31than mine, everybody hears may have been different,
- 53:34who knows, right? But we have our own sense of
- 53:37programming. For some people, for example, if
- 53:41I hold up this mug, they get all warm and fuzzy
- 53:44because they have good memories or ties to husky
- 53:49land. And then other people, you know, if they're
- 53:52from Washington state that they started to get
- 53:55kind of an ill feeling because they saw that
- 53:57everybody's different. But the key thing is you
- 54:00have to understand your paradigm. how you're
- 54:03programmed, and then you have to work on trying
- 54:05to understand other people's paradigm. How were
- 54:07they programmed? And when you can do that, that's
- 54:10going to help you extract the information that
- 54:12you need as a legal professional, right? Because
- 54:16when you eliminate bias from the equation, your
- 54:21analysis becomes more data -driven. And by taking
- 54:26in data -driven information, what is it that
- 54:28you're doing? You are improving the facts understanding
- 54:33of the facts in your case, in your matter, and
- 54:37what drives results in the law, either having
- 54:41the law completely in your support or having
- 54:44the facts completely in your support in conjunction
- 54:46with the law, right? That's what we always say.
- 54:49So if you can gather the facts more completely
- 54:52than the other side and those facts actually
- 54:55support your position, guess what? You're in
- 54:57a far stronger position than the other side.
- 55:04Right next slide All right, so coming into any
- 55:10type of presentation similar to this You know,
- 55:14you always have to set goals and my goals today
- 55:18are hopefully goals that you believe in to teach
- 55:23humility just because we have our own paradigm
- 55:27of The way that we see the world which we call
- 55:30our biases doesn't mean that our paradigm is
- 55:34the only one or the right one. And to say that
- 55:39requires humility. It also requires today that
- 55:46you are willing to self -reflect. I mean, I'm
- 55:51going to be hanging up with you, or they're going
- 55:53to cut me off in three minutes, whatever the
- 55:55music will come on. And that will be the end.
- 55:59I won't be with you again. You're not. We're
- 56:01not going to be talking again. Whether you take
- 56:04this message to heart or not depends on you and
- 56:07whether you're willing to engage in self -reflection.
- 56:11If you don't have humility, then you probably
- 56:14won't self -reflect. And what I mean by that
- 56:17is if there's a pride that kicks in in your personality,
- 56:22I've got it. I treat everybody great. I'm the
- 56:25best. This guy, whatever, he's just preaching
- 56:28to me or whatever it is that you want to say
- 56:30to dismiss me. If you're coming into it with
- 56:34that mindset, then I'm not going to be able to
- 56:38help you. And more importantly, you won't be
- 56:40able to help yourself. And I can't think of a
- 56:44more culturally diverse place than Southern California.
- 56:49I can't. And I've traveled every continent on
- 56:52earth. You know, there's something unique about
- 56:57Southern California in that regard. So this area
- 57:02of discussion is really important geographically.
- 57:06You are going to interact with people from every
- 57:09place on earth. So you have to be aware of where
- 57:12they're coming from. You may want them all to
- 57:15be paradigm like you, but they're not going to
- 57:17be. And what a boring world it would be anyways
- 57:20if everybody was programmed the same way. The
- 57:23next thing is my goal is to create curiosity.
- 57:27You know, there's a reason I've traveled every
- 57:28continent, right? I love learning about different
- 57:32cultures. Tell me about living in. What is it
- 57:37that you like? To the extent that you can have
- 57:39those in -depth discussions. In some countries,
- 57:41you frankly can't. But in many places, people
- 57:46want to share and they want you to understand.
- 57:49So I want to create that curiosity. And at the
- 57:52end of the day, really, to create an emotional
- 57:55honesty, for you to actually be honest with yourself
- 57:59over how you feel. And once you eliminate the
- 58:04negative variables, it's going to make you a
- 58:07better analyst for purposes of the practice of
- 58:10law. And at the end of the day, you're here for
- 58:13continuing legal education. It's not just about
- 58:15making you a better person at all times, it's
- 58:18about making you a better professional. Next
- 58:21slide. I have failed. When you're all done with
- 58:25this, any of these things come into your mind.
- 58:29I totally got it. Oh, I needed this one hour.
- 58:32I've checked the box. I got it. I know all about...
- 58:38I'm not a stereotyper. I know how to analyze
- 58:41people. Or you just take the process of mental
- 58:45correctness, right? Next slide. At the end of
- 58:50the day, what I'm doing today is hoping that
- 58:52this makes you a better attorney and a better
- 58:54person. I can tell you that having prepared this
- 58:56program, I felt like it made me better. The information
- 59:00that you gained today helps you become better.
- 59:03Next slide. This is me. This is how you get a
- 59:07hold of me. You'll have this. If you ever have
- 59:09any questions, you want to brainstorm, you want
- 59:12to shoot me an email, good or bad, it's cool.
- 59:15I get it. Everybody's entitled to their opinion.
- 59:18I just want to talk so you can get a hold of
- 59:21me. I wish you the very best. We're right at
- 59:24your one hour, and I know you've got a busy day.
- 59:27Thank you very much. Have a good day.