Latest / The Checkout Point / Week 43 - Holiday Forecasts Are In: Adobe's $275.1B Online Number, Shopify's New Canvas Tool, and Google Discover Turning Into an AI Concierge
Transcript
- 0:05[Max] Welcome to the Checkout Point, your quick dive into this week's ecommerce
- 0:08[Max] buzz with me, Alex, powered by Blicket.
- 0:12[Max] These 20 minutes pack the latest trends, news, and insights.
- 0:15[Max] Let's navigate the digital marketplace together.
- 0:18[Max] Ready?
- 0:19[Max] Let's go.
- 0:27[Rachel] Okay, confession.
- 0:29[Rachel] I bought an air fryer at 11:58 on the last night of
- 0:31[Rachel] the sale.
- 0:32[Rachel] Did I need it?
- 0:33[Rachel] No.
- 0:34[Rachel] Do I own three already?
- 0:35[Rachel] Also no.
- 0:36[Rachel] Wait, yes.
- 0:36[Speaker 3] Try, Max, what's the actual ROI on a fourth air fryer?
- 0:41[Rachel] Zero.
- 0:42[Rachel] Joy, maybe.
- 0:43[Speaker 3] Amazon's own page says Prime Big Deal Days ran October sixth to
- 0:47[Speaker 3] seventh, 48 hours of member deals.
- 0:50[Rachel] So Fall Prime Day is done.
- 0:53[Speaker 3] Which means the holiday season has officially started, ready or not.
- 0:57[Rachel] Ready?
- 0:58[Rachel] Rachel, I haven't even finished my Halloween candy shopping, and now it's
- 1:01[Rachel] holiday season.
- 1:03[Speaker 3] Of course you haven't.
- 1:04[Rachel] Anyway, I'm Max.
- 1:05[Rachel] This is the Checkout Point, and that's my co-host, Rachel, who will
- 1:08[Rachel] now judge my purchases.
- 1:10[Speaker 3] Gladly.
- 1:11[Speaker 3] The forecasts are rolling in, and honestly, two big ones don't line
- 1:15[Speaker 3] up the way people think.
- 1:16[Rachel] Plus, there's an AI question hanging over all of it.
- 1:19[Speaker 3] Mm-hmm.
- 1:20[Speaker 3] Let's get into it.
- 1:21[Rachel] All right, here we go.
- 1:22[Rachel] So anyway, the sale is over.
- 1:24[Rachel] Let's talk about what the forecasters say comes next.
- 1:31[Rachel] Okay, numbers.
- 1:33[Rachel] Adobe says US shoppers will spend two hundred seventy-five point one billion
- 1:38[Rachel] dollars online between November first and December thirty-first.
- 1:42[Speaker 3] Billion with a B.
- 1:44[Rachel] Billion with a B.
- 1:45[Rachel] Adobe's release says that's up six point seven percent from last year.
- 1:49[Speaker 3] Hmm, and that's a record, I assume, because every forecast is a
- 1:53[Speaker 3] record?
- 1:54[Rachel] Every forecast is a record.
- 1:56[Rachel] Nobody ever releases a press conference titled Pretty Average Year Ahead.
- 2:00[Speaker 3] Fair.
- 2:01[Speaker 3] Give me the sub numbers, though.
- 2:02[Speaker 3] Where's the money piling up?
- 2:04[Rachel] Adobe projects Cyber Week at forty-seven point five billion.
- 2:08[Speaker 3] Okay.
- 2:09[Rachel] And Cyber Monday, November thirtieth, at fifteen point one billion on its
- 2:13[Rachel] own.
- 2:13[Speaker 3] One day, fifteen billion.
- 2:16[Speaker 3] That's a supply chain bottleneck with a bow on it.
- 2:19[Rachel] Your warehouse manager just felt a chill.
- 2:21[Speaker 3] Mine did, honestly.
- 2:23[Speaker 3] I've lived through those Mondays.
- 2:25[Rachel] Okay, story time.
- 2:26[Rachel] What does a Monday like that actually look like from the inside?
- 2:29[Speaker 3] Controlled panic.
- 2:31[Speaker 3] In my retail operations days, the weeks before a peak were all
- 2:34[Speaker 3] about one question: Can the building physically ship what the website is
- 2:39[Speaker 3] about to sell?
- 2:40[Speaker 3] A forecast tells you the demand.
- 2:42[Speaker 3] It doesn't pick, pack, or drive anything.
- 2:45[Rachel] So a big forecast number is really a staffing and inventory question
- 2:49[Rachel] wearing a marketing hat.
- 2:50[Speaker 3] Exactly.
- 2:51[Speaker 3] And a small merchant has a tiny version of the same problem.
- 2:55[Speaker 3] Fewer boxes, same cliff.
- 2:57[Rachel] What's the cliff?
- 2:59[Speaker 3] Selling something you can't ship.
- 3:01[Speaker 3] Cyber Monday is November thirtieth, which is under two months away.
- 3:05[Speaker 3] So plan your stock around the products that actually move, not the
- 3:09[Speaker 3] whole catalog.
- 3:10[Rachel] And plan people.
- 3:12[Rachel] Who's answering the where's my order emails that land the next morning?
- 3:15[Speaker 3] Right.
- 3:16[Speaker 3] The day after is where the pain hides.
- 3:18[Speaker 3] Sales are fun.
- 3:19[Speaker 3] Support tickets are the bill.
- 3:21[Rachel] The bill always arrives.
- 3:23[Speaker 3] Always.
- 3:25[Speaker 3] Anyway, keep going.
- 3:26[Speaker 3] What else is in the Adobe coverage?
- 3:28[Rachel] Digital Commerce 360 covered the Adobe forecast too, and their coverage puts
- 3:32[Rachel] Black Friday at twelve point nine billion.
- 3:35[Speaker 3] Wait, so Black Friday is smaller than Cyber Monday in this forecast?
- 3:39[Rachel] Smaller dollars, yeah, but the coverage says Black Friday is growing faster,
- 3:44[Rachel] up nine point two percent.
- 3:46[Speaker 3] Huh.
- 3:46[Speaker 3] So the Monday's bigger, the Friday's hotter.
- 3:50[Rachel] Right.
- 3:50[Rachel] Cyber Monday keeps the crown.
- 3:52[Rachel] Black Friday keeps the momentum.
- 3:53[Speaker 3] Quick caution on that one, though.
- 3:55[Speaker 3] That Black Friday figure comes from trade coverage of Adobe's forecast, not
- 3:59[Speaker 3] from me reading Adobe's own release.
- 4:01[Rachel] I'd treat it as secondhand.
- 4:03[Speaker 3] Good flag.
- 4:03[Speaker 3] So the headline is one level up, and the Black Friday detail
- 4:07[Speaker 3] is relayed.
- 4:08[Rachel] Right.
- 4:08[Rachel] And does faster growth mean better for you?
- 4:10[Rachel] Not automatically.
- 4:12[Rachel] A day that grows faster just means more people crowd into it.
- 4:15[Speaker 3] Which could mean more competitors going after the same shoppers.
- 4:19[Rachel] Could.
- 4:19[Rachel] The forecast doesn't say.
- 4:21[Rachel] I'm only saying don't assume a hotter day is a cheaper day.
- 4:25[Speaker 3] Hotter isn't cheaper.
- 4:26[Speaker 3] Got it.
- 4:27[Speaker 3] And that goes for Cyber Week too.
- 4:29[Speaker 3] Forty-seven point five billion is the whole stretch.
- 4:32[Speaker 3] So a good week for the market could still be a rough
- 4:35[Speaker 3] week for a single store with thin margins.
- 4:37[Rachel] A rising tide, but a leaky boat.
- 4:39[Rachel] Okay, I like that, and it's a better metaphor than my gym
- 4:42[Rachel] one.
- 4:42[Speaker 3] Okay, now the other forecast, Deloitte.
- 4:45[Rachel] Oh, this is where it gets fun.
- 4:47[Speaker 3] Deloitte's September tenth release projects holiday e-commerce at three hundred and sixteen
- 4:52[Speaker 3] billion to three hundred and nineteen billion.
- 4:55[Rachel] Wait, really?
- 4:56[Rachel] That's forty billion more than Adobe.
- 4:58[Speaker 3] Forty-ish, yes, and their growth is higher too, seven and a half
- 5:02[Speaker 3] to eight point four percent.
- 5:04[Rachel] So Deloitte is just more bullish.
- 5:06[Rachel] Somebody's lying.
- 5:08[Speaker 3] Nobody's lying.
- 5:09[Speaker 3] Look at the calendar.
- 5:10[Rachel] Ah, I hate calendars.
- 5:12[Speaker 3] Deloitte's release says itself that the window is three months, so it
- 5:15[Speaker 3] isn't directly comparable to Adobe's.
- 5:18[Rachel] That's like comparing my gym attendance in a two-month stretch to someone
- 5:21[Rachel] else's three months and calling it a rivalry.
- 5:23[Speaker 3] Your gym attendance is a flat line, Max.
- 5:26[Rachel] Ha, a very stable flat line, low variance.
- 5:29[Speaker 3] But seriously, this is how bad decisions get made.
- 5:32[Speaker 3] Somebody grabs the bigger number for a board deck and sets a
- 5:35[Speaker 3] revenue goal off it.
- 5:36[Rachel] And the bigger number's got an extra month baked in.
- 5:39[Speaker 3] Right.
- 5:39[Speaker 3] So before anybody quotes either figure, ask what dates it covers.
- 5:44[Rachel] Totally.
- 5:45[Rachel] Okay, Rachel, you've got a look.
- 5:46[Speaker 3] I do, because these are top-line numbers, and top line is not
- 5:50[Speaker 3] profit.
- 5:51[Rachel] Hmm.
- 5:52[Speaker 3] Go on.
- 5:52[Rachel] Say the whole market grows nearly seven percent.
- 5:55[Rachel] Great.
- 5:55[Rachel] But what's my ad cost doing in the same stretch?
- 5:58[Rachel] What's happening to my margin?
- 6:00[Rachel] Hmm.
- 6:00[Rachel] You mean if everybody's spending, auction prices go up?
- 6:03[Speaker 3] I mean, a growing pie doesn't mean your slice is bigger.
- 6:07[Speaker 3] Market growth tells me nothing about my cost to acquire a customer.
- 6:11[Rachel] Fair.
- 6:11[Rachel] These forecasts can't tell you that.
- 6:13[Speaker 3] No.
- 6:14[Speaker 3] They tell you demand is probably there.
- 6:16[Speaker 3] They don't tell you what it costs to catch it.
- 6:18[Rachel] Walk me through it with numbers, Rachel.
- 6:20[Rachel] Pretend I'm a small store, totally made up for illustration only.
- 6:24[Speaker 3] Fine.
- 6:24[Speaker 3] Say you sell a product for a hundred dollars, and after product
- 6:28[Speaker 3] cost and shipping, you keep forty.
- 6:31[Speaker 3] That forty is what's left to pay for everything else, including ads.
- 6:35[Rachel] So if it costs me thirty to get that customer through ads,
- 6:38[Rachel] I keep ten.
- 6:40[Speaker 3] Right.
- 6:40[Speaker 3] Now say the auction gets more crowded and that same customer costs
- 6:44[Speaker 3] forty.
- 6:45[Speaker 3] You made the sale, the dashboard says revenue, and your profit on
- 6:49[Speaker 3] that order is zero.
- 6:51[Rachel] Revenue up, profit gone.
- 6:52[Rachel] That's the movie you keep warning about.
- 6:54[Speaker 3] And the forecast would still say record year, both things true at
- 6:59[Speaker 3] once.
- 7:00[Speaker 3] These are invented numbers, to be clear.
- 7:02[Speaker 3] Plug in your own.
- 7:03[Rachel] Which means the homework is knowing your real per order margin before
- 7:07[Rachel] the season starts.
- 7:08[Speaker 3] Before.
- 7:09[Speaker 3] Then you know the most you can pay to win a customer
- 7:12[Speaker 3] without losing money on the first order.
- 7:14[Rachel] So the number is more like a weather report than a budget.
- 7:17[Speaker 3] A weather report with a six-figure ad bill attached.
- 7:22[Rachel] Ouch.
- 7:22[Rachel] And honestly, most small merchants don't have a Deloitte or an Adobe
- 7:26[Rachel] sitting in their dashboard anyway.
- 7:27[Speaker 3] Right.
- 7:28[Speaker 3] They've got their own last year numbers and a nervous feeling.
- 7:31[Rachel] Nervous feeling, which, to be fair, is also a forecasting model.
- 7:35[Speaker 3] A low confidence one.
- 7:38[Rachel] Very low.
- 7:39[Rachel] Okay, so the take is use the forecasts for direction, pick one
- 7:43[Rachel] source and check its dates.
- 7:45[Speaker 3] And then look at your own margins before you celebrate anything.
- 7:48[Rachel] Can we make that concrete?
- 7:50[Rachel] What's a starting point for someone listening?
- 7:52[Speaker 3] Write down your own numbers: last year's holiday sales by week, your
- 7:56[Speaker 3] ad spend by week, and what you kept per order.
- 7:59[Speaker 3] It's boring.
- 8:00[Speaker 3] It beats a forecast you can't act on.
- 8:03[Rachel] And then compare the direction of the forecasts to your own history
- 8:06[Rachel] instead of copying their totals.
- 8:08[Speaker 3] Yes.
- 8:08[Speaker 3] Borrow the direction, keep your numbers.
- 8:11[Rachel] Speaking of which, there's one number in that Adobe coverage that changes
- 8:15[Rachel] who shows up at your store.
- 8:16[Speaker 3] Oh, you're gonna make me ask, aren't you?
- 8:19[Rachel] Little bit.
- 8:20[Rachel] It's not a dollar figure at all.
- 8:26[Rachel] Okay, so the number I teased.
- 8:28[Rachel] Digital Commerce 360's coverage of Adobe's forecast says AI traffic to US
- 8:33[Rachel] retail sites is projected to rise a hundred and thirty percent year
- 8:37[Rachel] over year.
- 8:38[Speaker 3] Wait, really?
- 8:39[Speaker 3] Say that again.
- 8:40[Rachel] One hundred and thirty.
- 8:41[Rachel] More than double.
- 8:43[Rachel] And it's a projection, so nobody's counted it yet.
- 8:45[Speaker 3] Right.
- 8:46[Speaker 3] Forecasts are forecasts.
- 8:48[Speaker 3] When does it land?
- 8:49[Rachel] The coverage says the biggest increases hit on Thanksgiving, Black Friday, and
- 8:53[Rachel] Cyber Monday.
- 8:54[Rachel] So the peak days.
- 8:55[Speaker 3] Of course, exactly when your ad costs are already screaming.
- 9:00[Rachel] You can't just let me enjoy a number, can you?
- 9:03[Speaker 3] I mean, come on.
- 9:04[Speaker 3] More visitors sounds great, but what's the actual conversion on a visitor
- 9:08[Speaker 3] an assistant sent you?
- 9:09[Speaker 3] Nobody in that coverage says.
- 9:11[Rachel] Fair.
- 9:11[Rachel] The source gives traffic, not conversion.
- 9:14[Rachel] So we know the door's getting busier, not who walks through it.
- 9:17[Speaker 3] And for a small store, that distinction is everything.
- 9:21[Speaker 3] More than double the assistant traffic sounds like a windfall, but you
- 9:24[Speaker 3] could end up with more sessions in your analytics and the same
- 9:27[Speaker 3] number of orders.
- 9:29[Speaker 3] Visits are not revenue.
- 9:31[Rachel] So what would you actually watch?
- 9:32[Rachel] If I'm a small store, where do I even see AI traffic?
- 9:36[Speaker 3] I can't tell you how any given analytics tool labels it.
- 9:39[Speaker 3] The coverage doesn't say.
- 9:41[Speaker 3] What I'd do is check whether your reports separate referral sources at
- 9:44[Speaker 3] all before the peak days, so you're not guessing in the middle
- 9:48[Speaker 3] of Cyber Monday.
- 9:49[Rachel] That's a good boring task.
- 9:51[Rachel] Check the dashboard before the dashboard matters.
- 9:54[Speaker 3] Okay.
- 9:54[Speaker 3] Hold that thought because there's a second piece.
- 9:57[Rachel] Search Engine Journal, October twelfth.
- 9:59[Rachel] Roger Montti reported that Google is planning to turn Discover into an
- 10:03[Rachel] AI concierge.
- 10:05[Speaker 3] Concierge, like a guy in a vest who recommends the restaurant?
- 10:09[Rachel] Kind of, yeah.
- 10:10[Rachel] The stated goal is making Discover more useful.
- 10:14[Speaker 3] Useful to whom?
- 10:16[Rachel] That's the catch.
- 10:17[Rachel] The same report flags the risk, which is less traffic for publishers.
- 10:21[Speaker 3] Hmm.
- 10:22[Speaker 3] So the helpful thing and the traffic-killing thing are the same thing?
- 10:27[Rachel] Pretty much.
- 10:28[Rachel] Though the report is about publishers, I won't pretend it says anything
- 10:31[Rachel] about your product pages.
- 10:33[Speaker 3] Right, but merchants live next door.
- 10:35[Speaker 3] A lot of us lean on content to pull people in.
- 10:38[Rachel] Totally.
- 10:39[Rachel] So here's where my brain went.
- 10:41[Rachel] AI sends you a flood of visitors.
- 10:43[Rachel] Great.
- 10:44[Rachel] Reach goes up.
- 10:45[Speaker 3] And the same kind of system decides what gets shown at all.
- 10:48[Rachel] Yes.
- 10:49[Rachel] Whoever sits between you and the shopper picks the shelf.
- 10:52[Speaker 3] Which is my supply chain brain screaming.
- 10:55[Speaker 3] You've got a distributor who can reroute you whenever they want.
- 10:58[Rachel] Okay, but is that worse than before?
- 11:00[Rachel] Google and Amazon already sorted the shelf.
- 11:02[Speaker 3] Sure, but a ranked list of ten links is different from one
- 11:05[Speaker 3] answer.
- 11:06[Speaker 3] If the assistant names one or two stores, the rest of us
- 11:08[Speaker 3] are invisible.
- 11:09[Rachel] Huh.
- 11:09[Rachel] That's a fair difference.
- 11:11[Rachel] Ten shots versus two.
- 11:12[Speaker 3] And to be fair to the other side, nobody has shown that's
- 11:15[Speaker 3] how it plays out.
- 11:16[Speaker 3] The Discover report describes a plan, not a finished product.
- 11:19[Speaker 3] Plans change, and the stated goal is to be more useful to
- 11:22[Speaker 3] the people using it.
- 11:23[Rachel] So the honest version is it's a direction, and you get to
- 11:26[Rachel] decide how much to hedge against it.
- 11:28[Speaker 3] Right.
- 11:29[Speaker 3] Hedge is the word.
- 11:30[Speaker 3] I'm not saying panic and rip out your content.
- 11:32[Speaker 3] I'm saying don't let one door be the only way anyone finds
- 11:36[Speaker 3] you.
- 11:36[Rachel] Which is a very nice way of saying diversify without using the
- 11:39[Rachel] word diversify.
- 11:40[Speaker 3] So what does that do to unit economics?
- 11:42[Speaker 3] If you're one of the two, maybe your cost per sale looks
- 11:45[Speaker 3] great.
- 11:45[Rachel] And if you're not?
- 11:46[Speaker 3] Then you pay more elsewhere to make up for it, or you
- 11:49[Speaker 3] pay the platform to be seen.
- 11:51[Speaker 3] Either way, the margin shrinks.
- 11:53[Rachel] I can't prove that from these sources, to be clear.
- 11:55[Rachel] It's the risk, not a reported result.
- 11:57[Speaker 3] Agreed.
- 11:58[Speaker 3] It's the question to ask before the forecast makes you hire three
- 12:01[Speaker 3] people.
- 12:01[Rachel] Walk me through the unit economics version with the caveat that it's
- 12:04[Rachel] an illustration and not a finding.
- 12:06[Speaker 3] Sure, and it's illustration only, not from any source.
- 12:10[Speaker 3] Take your margin per order, then ask what happens if you have
- 12:13[Speaker 3] to spend more to get that same order, either because a channel
- 12:16[Speaker 3] got more crowded or because you're paying to be shown.
- 12:19[Speaker 3] If your margin can't absorb that, the traffic isn't growth, it's a
- 12:23[Speaker 3] bill.
- 12:23[Speaker 3] And the real test is how many of your orders come from
- 12:26[Speaker 3] places you can't turn off or negotiate with.
- 12:29[Rachel] The forecast hired three people.
- 12:31[Rachel] Classic.
- 12:32[Speaker 3] Because if the gatekeepers keep shifting, who actually owns the customer?
- 12:36[Rachel] Yeah, because right now the answer might not be you.
- 12:44[Rachel] Okay, so who owns the customer?
- 12:47[Rachel] I found a piece that tackles exactly that.
- 12:49[Rachel] Mexico Business News ran it on October 12th, titled Who Actually Owns
- 12:54[Rachel] Your Customer in Mexican E-Commerce.
- 12:56[Rachel] Oh, I like that title.
- 12:58[Rachel] Straight to the point.
- 12:59[Speaker 3] Right?
- 13:00[Speaker 3] The writer is Juan Martn Vignart, and he argues that direct-to-consumer E-Commerce
- 13:05[Speaker 3] in Mexico builds long-term customer relationships, retention, and value beyond a marketplace
- 13:11[Speaker 3] transaction.
- 13:12[Rachel] Beyond the transaction, meaning a marketplace sale is a one-and-done?
- 13:16[Speaker 3] Careful.
- 13:17[Speaker 3] The summary I have says what he argues, not a data set.
- 13:21[Speaker 3] It's a case for D2C, and I'd treat it as an argument,
- 13:24[Speaker 3] not proof.
- 13:25[Rachel] Fair.
- 13:25[Rachel] Still, it's a clean idea.
- 13:27[Speaker 3] It is, and it's my lens on everything.
- 13:30[Speaker 3] A marketplace sale gets you revenue today, but what's the actual lifetime
- 13:34[Speaker 3] value of a shopper who bought from you through someone else's storefront?
- 13:39[Rachel] You didn't even wait a beat on that one.
- 13:41[Speaker 3] Because if the marketplace holds the email, the reviews, the whole relationship,
- 13:45[Speaker 3] you can't bring that shopper back.
- 13:47[Speaker 3] You're renting them.
- 13:48[Speaker 3] Retention is a supply chain problem, Max.
- 13:51[Speaker 3] If you don't control the inventory of customers, you can't restock.
- 13:55[Rachel] Ah, okay.
- 13:56[Rachel] I'll give you that one.
- 13:57[Speaker 3] Thank you.
- 13:58[Rachel] So how do you actually own the relationship?
- 14:01[Rachel] Because build a brand is a nice slogan.
- 14:03[Rachel] What's the plumbing?
- 14:05[Speaker 3] First party data.
- 14:06[Speaker 3] Who's on your list, what they bought, what they do on your
- 14:09[Speaker 3] site.
- 14:09[Rachel] And that's where tracking comes in, which is unglamorous but matters.
- 14:13[Rachel] A GlobeNewswire release says Elevar published a Captain Compliance setup for
- 14:17[Rachel] Google Consent Mode and server-side tracking on Shopify.
- 14:21[Speaker 3] Okay, translate for the people who just heard four nouns in a
- 14:24[Speaker 3] row.
- 14:26[Rachel] Fair.
- 14:27[Rachel] Consent Mode is how your tracking respects what shoppers agreed to.
- 14:31[Rachel] Server-side tracking means the data flows through your own setup instead of
- 14:34[Rachel] only the browser.
- 14:35[Rachel] And Captain Compliance is the consent layer Elevar says it documented for
- 14:39[Rachel] Shopify stores.
- 14:41[Speaker 3] And it's a press release, so that's the company's own description of
- 14:44[Speaker 3] its own work.
- 14:45[Rachel] Totally.
- 14:46[Rachel] I'm not telling anyone it fixes their attribution.
- 14:49[Rachel] I'm saying it shows where the plumbing conversation is going.
- 14:52[Speaker 3] Which is the right conversation.
- 14:54[Speaker 3] If shoppers arrive through AI surfaces you don't control, your own data
- 14:59[Speaker 3] is what's left.
- 15:00[Rachel] Wait, really?
- 15:00[Rachel] That's the whole connection?
- 15:02[Rachel] Consent plus tracking equals owning the customer?
- 15:05[Speaker 3] No, it's a piece of it.
- 15:06[Speaker 3] Consent gets you permission.
- 15:07[Speaker 3] Tracking gets you signal.
- 15:09[Speaker 3] Retention is what you do with them afterward.
- 15:12[Rachel] Right.
- 15:12[Rachel] And honestly, as a CRO nerd, I've seen a lot of first-party
- 15:16[Rachel] data plans.
- 15:17[Rachel] Most of them are a spreadsheet named Final V Seven that nobody
- 15:20[Rachel] has opened since March.
- 15:21[Speaker 3] I have personally been in that spreadsheet.
- 15:24[Rachel] Everybody has.
- 15:25[Rachel] It's the haunted house of marketing.
- 15:27[Speaker 3] But seriously, tie it back.
- 15:28[Speaker 3] If you're a merchant, ask one question.
- 15:31[Speaker 3] When this shopper buys again, do I get to be the one
- 15:34[Speaker 3] who remembers them?
- 15:35[Rachel] Ooh, that's a good test.
- 15:36[Rachel] Can you email them?
- 15:37[Rachel] Can you recognize them?
- 15:38[Rachel] Can you tell if they came back?
- 15:40[Speaker 3] And can you do it legally, which is the consent part.
- 15:42[Speaker 3] Skip that, and your clean data becomes a liability.
- 15:45[Rachel] Mm, yeah.
- 15:47[Speaker 3] Cheap reminder, though.
- 15:48[Speaker 3] One source here is an argument, and the other is a company's
- 15:51[Speaker 3] own description.
- 15:52[Speaker 3] I'm using them as prompts, not proof.
- 15:54[Rachel] Good reminder.
- 15:54[Rachel] They're conversation starters, and the real work is on your side of
- 15:57[Rachel] the screen.
- 15:58[Speaker 3] So no, it's not glamorous, but it's cheaper than buying the same
- 16:02[Speaker 3] customer back through ads every single time.
- 16:05[Rachel] Okay.
- 16:05[Rachel] Give people a checklist, something they can start without a developer.
- 16:09[Speaker 3] Fine.
- 16:10[Speaker 3] One, know where your customer list actually lives.
- 16:13[Speaker 3] Is it in your store, in an email tool, or in a
- 16:15[Speaker 3] marketplace account you can't export from?
- 16:18[Rachel] Two, make sure people can clearly say yes to hearing from you
- 16:21[Rachel] right at checkout.
- 16:22[Speaker 3] Three, check that your orders connect to a person so you can
- 16:25[Speaker 3] tell a repeat buyer from a first-timer.
- 16:28[Rachel] Four, find out what your tracking does when a shopper says no
- 16:31[Rachel] to being tracked.
- 16:32[Rachel] That's the consent piece, and it's worth a conversation with whoever set
- 16:35[Rachel] it up.
- 16:35[Speaker 3] Five, pick one retention number and watch it on a schedule.
- 16:39[Speaker 3] Repeat purchase rate or how many people come back.
- 16:42[Speaker 3] Just one.
- 16:43[Rachel] Not 12 dashboards.
- 16:45[Speaker 3] 12 dashboards means nobody looks at any of them.
- 16:49[Rachel] Painfully true.
- 16:50[Speaker 3] None of this needs a vendor to start.
- 16:52[Speaker 3] It needs someone to own the list.
- 16:54[Rachel] Speaking of cheaper ways to get things done, before I forget, there's
- 16:57[Rachel] new tooling news that might help with all of this.
- 17:00[Speaker 3] Oh, the Shopify thing?
- 17:01[Rachel] That's the one.
- 17:07[Rachel] Okay, tooling news.
- 17:09[Rachel] Practical Ecommerce put out its weekly merchant tools roundup dated October seventh,
- 17:13[Rachel] and three items jumped out.
- 17:15[Speaker 3] Only three?
- 17:16[Speaker 3] That's restraint.
- 17:18[Rachel] I'm learning.
- 17:19[Rachel] First one, Shopify launched Canvas.
- 17:21[Rachel] It's a design surface where you build layouts with Sidekick, which is
- 17:25[Rachel] Shopify's AI agent.
- 17:27[Speaker 3] So you talk to the robot, and the robot lays out your
- 17:29[Speaker 3] homepage.
- 17:30[Rachel] Roughly, yeah.
- 17:31[Rachel] The roundup says merchants build layouts with Sidekick on Canvas.
- 17:35[Rachel] That's all I'm gonna claim about how it works.
- 17:37[Speaker 3] Mm, because I have no idea if it's fast or good.
- 17:41[Rachel] Right.
- 17:41[Rachel] No results in the roundup.
- 17:43[Rachel] Nothing on conversion, nothing on time saved.
- 17:46[Speaker 3] Which is my whole problem with launch news.
- 17:48[Speaker 3] A new design tool is a new thing to learn, and learning
- 17:51[Speaker 3] has a cost.
- 17:52[Rachel] Wait, you're gonna tell me this is a supply chain thing?
- 17:54[Speaker 3] Everything is a supply chain thing.
- 17:57[Speaker 3] If your team spends the two weeks before the rush redoing layouts,
- 18:00[Speaker 3] you've moved the bottleneck, not removed it.
- 18:03[Rachel] Okay, fair.
- 18:04[Rachel] Though if a layout is stale, you probably wanna fix it before
- 18:06[Rachel] traffic shows up.
- 18:08[Speaker 3] Sure.
- 18:08[Speaker 3] Before, not during.
- 18:11[Rachel] And if your layout is fine, nobody's forcing a redesign just because
- 18:14[Rachel] something shiny launched.
- 18:16[Speaker 3] Right.
- 18:16[Speaker 3] A launch date on their calendar isn't a deadline on yours, especially
- 18:20[Speaker 3] in the middle of peak season.
- 18:22[Rachel] Totally.
- 18:23[Rachel] Second item: Swap acquired Vizby, and Vizby is an AI-visibility tool.
- 18:28[Speaker 3] Hold on.
- 18:29[Speaker 3] Visibility into what?
- 18:31[Rachel] The name says AI visibility and the roundup stops there.
- 18:34[Rachel] I'm not gonna make up what the dashboard shows.
- 18:36[Speaker 3] Fine, but it's interesting that it exists.
- 18:39[Speaker 3] Earlier, we were talking about AI as a gatekeeper.
- 18:42[Speaker 3] Somebody's selling a way to see how you show up there.
- 18:44[Rachel] Somebody bought one even.
- 18:46[Speaker 3] Right.
- 18:47[Speaker 3] Acquisitions are a signal that people think the problem is real.
- 18:50[Speaker 3] They're not proof that the tool works.
- 18:52[Rachel] Mm-hmm.
- 18:53[Rachel] Big difference.
- 18:54[Speaker 3] Huge.
- 18:55[Speaker 3] I'd wanna know what it costs and what I'd do differently on
- 18:58[Speaker 3] a Tuesday because of it.
- 18:59[Rachel] That's your question for everything.
- 19:02[Speaker 3] But what's the actual ROI?
- 19:04[Speaker 3] Yes, it is.
- 19:05[Rachel] I knew it was coming.
- 19:07[Rachel] Third one: MoEngage launched a native Shopify integration.
- 19:11[Speaker 3] Native as in built to plug in, not duct taped together.
- 19:15[Rachel] That's the idea behind the word, but the roundup just says native
- 19:18[Rachel] integration.
- 19:18[Rachel] Whether it's smooth for your store, I can't tell you.
- 19:21[Speaker 3] I'll say this: anything that connects messaging to your Shopify data without
- 19:26[Speaker 3] a pile of custom work is at least pointed at the right
- 19:29[Speaker 3] spot because that's where repeat purchases come from.
- 19:32[Rachel] Okay, that tracks with the retention stuff we just did.
- 19:34[Speaker 3] It does.
- 19:35[Speaker 3] Still a pointer, not a promise.
- 19:38[Rachel] So three launches, zero performance numbers.
- 19:40[Rachel] If you had to rank them for a store that's about to
- 19:42[Rachel] get slammed.
- 19:44[Speaker 3] Hmm.
- 19:44[Speaker 3] Honestly, none of them before the rush, unless one fixes something already
- 19:49[Speaker 3] broken for you.
- 19:50[Rachel] Ooh, even Canvas?
- 19:52[Speaker 3] If your layout is fine, leave it alone.
- 19:54[Speaker 3] If your email tool is the thing that's limping, the MoEngage piece
- 19:58[Speaker 3] might be worth a look.
- 19:59[Speaker 3] If you've got no clue how AI sees your catalog, Vizby's category
- 20:03[Speaker 3] is at least worth knowing about.
- 20:05[Rachel] Let me push on that.
- 20:06[Rachel] How would somebody test a tool without wrecking their week?
- 20:09[Speaker 3] Four questions: What specific problem is it for?
- 20:13[Speaker 3] What will it cost in money and in your team's hours?
- 20:16[Speaker 3] How will you know it worked?
- 20:18[Speaker 3] And how do you undo it if it doesn't?
- 20:20[Rachel] The undo one is underrated.
- 20:22[Speaker 3] Because holiday traffic is a bad time to find out something can't
- 20:26[Speaker 3] be rolled back.
- 20:27[Speaker 3] If you can't picture reversing it, wait until January.
- 20:30[Rachel] And how will you know it worked needs a metric before you
- 20:33[Rachel] start, not after.
- 20:35[Speaker 3] Exactly.
- 20:36[Speaker 3] Decide the metric first.
- 20:38[Speaker 3] Otherwise, you look at whatever went up and call it a win.
- 20:41[Rachel] Everybody's done that.
- 20:43[Speaker 3] Turns guilty.
- 20:44[Speaker 3] And one more: Who owns it?
- 20:46[Speaker 3] A new tool without an owner is a subscription nobody opens.
- 20:50[Rachel] So you try it small, one page or one email flow before
- 20:54[Rachel] trusting it with everything?
- 20:55[Speaker 3] If at all.
- 20:56[Speaker 3] The roundup gave us no results, so the burden of proof sits
- 20:59[Speaker 3] on you.
- 21:00[Rachel] So the filter is what's broken right now.
- 21:03[Speaker 3] Yep.
- 21:04[Speaker 3] Shiny is not a diagnosis.
- 21:06[Rachel] Put that on a mug.
- 21:08[Rachel] All right, let's wrap this up quickly with one thing to do
- 21:10[Rachel] this week.
- 21:11[Speaker 3] Just one.
- 21:12[Speaker 3] I like it.
- 21:18[Rachel] Okay, so the wrap.
- 21:19[Rachel] Quick scoreboard before we let everyone go.
- 21:22[Speaker 3] Quick being the keyword.
- 21:23[Speaker 3] Two forecasts that can't be lined up side by side, a projection
- 21:27[Speaker 3] of AI sending more shoppers, and a lot of talk about who
- 21:30[Speaker 3] owns the customer.
- 21:32[Rachel] That's the whole episode in one breath.
- 21:34[Rachel] Impressive.
- 21:35[Speaker 3] I've had practice.
- 21:36[Speaker 3] Budget meetings at Amazon will do that to you.
- 21:40[Rachel] So what's the homework, Rachel?
- 21:42[Speaker 3] One action.
- 21:43[Speaker 3] Pull up your holiday plan and mark every piece that depends on
- 21:46[Speaker 3] a channel you don't control: ads, marketplaces, search, and AI assistant you
- 21:51[Speaker 3] can't see inside.
- 21:53[Rachel] Mark it how?
- 21:54[Speaker 3] Highlighter.
- 21:55[Speaker 3] Literal or digital, I don't care.
- 21:57[Speaker 3] Then look at how much of your plan is highlighted.
- 22:00[Rachel] Oh, that's gonna be a lot of yellow.
- 22:02[Speaker 3] For most people, yes.
- 22:03[Speaker 3] And then ask the ROI question.
- 22:06[Speaker 3] If one of those channels changes its rules in November, what happens
- 22:09[Speaker 3] to your margin?
- 22:11[Rachel] Nobody wants to answer that in November.
- 22:13[Speaker 3] Which is why you answer it now while it's still a spreadsheet
- 22:16[Speaker 3] and not a panic.
- 22:18[Rachel] Give me a concrete first step.
- 22:19[Rachel] What does someone do Monday morning?
- 22:21[Speaker 3] Open the plan, list the channels, and write one sentence next to
- 22:25[Speaker 3] each.
- 22:26[Speaker 3] If this changed tomorrow, what would I do?
- 22:29[Speaker 3] One sentence.
- 22:30[Speaker 3] If you can't write it, that's your risk, and now you know
- 22:33[Speaker 3] where it is.
- 22:34[Rachel] Totally.
- 22:35[Rachel] And hey, if your plan comes out looking like a yellow school
- 22:37[Rachel] bus, that's fine.
- 22:38[Rachel] Just know who's driving it.
- 22:40[Speaker 3] Max, that's almost wise.
- 22:43[Rachel] I have my moments, maybe two a year.
- 22:46[Speaker 3] If you want more of this, head to blicket.co and subscribe so
- 22:49[Speaker 3] the next episode just shows up.
- 22:52[Rachel] Do it.
- 22:52[Rachel] Future you will thank you.
- 22:53[Rachel] Thanks for hanging out with us at the Checkout Point.
- 22:56[Speaker 3] Go check your highlighter supply.
- 22:58[Rachel] And be kind to yourselves out there.
- 23:00[Rachel] Happy holiday prep, everyone.