Latest / Science Behind the Glass: illuminating the human side / Taking ownership of your data and privacy with Dr Jaya Brekke
Transcript
- 0:01Who are the characters behind science? This is
- 0:04Science Behind the Glass, illuminating the human
- 0:06side. In this podcast, we unveil the human side
- 0:11of laboratories and science. Scientists share
- 0:14personal experiences and we discuss their meanings
- 0:17from different perspectives and fields of research.
- 0:22Welcome to Science Behind the Glass, illuminating
- 0:24the human side. The podcast where we go behind
- 0:27the labs. data, and headlines to uncover the
- 0:30personal stories shaping the future of science
- 0:33and technology. My name is Linda Hernandez. I'm
- 0:37your host. And today, this episode is going to
- 0:39take us on a fascinating journey into the heart
- 0:42of decentralized technologies. Hello, my name
- 0:45is Rafael Giordano, and our guest today is someone
- 0:48who truly lives at the crossroads of technology,
- 0:51society, and human values. Dr. Jaya Clara Brekke
- 0:55is a chief strategy officer at NIM Technologies,
- 0:59a groundbreaking decentralized privacy network.
- 1:02She's from Durham University and an interdisciplinary
- 1:05background. She's one of the leading thinkers
- 1:08on how emerging technology like blockchain can
- 1:11reshape power dynamics in our world. Dr. Brekke
- 1:14works. doesn't stop at academia. She's an advisor
- 1:18to the European Commission on Blockchain Technologies
- 1:22and a recognized expert in the field of political
- 1:26economies, governance, and the ethics of decentralization.
- 1:30But what really makes her work stand out is her
- 1:33focus on the human stories and the societal impacts
- 1:36behind these technologies, how they challenge
- 1:39authority, redefine autonomy, and create new
- 1:43possibilities for communities worldwide. Clara,
- 1:46thank you very much for accepting this invitation.
- 1:48It's a pleasure having you here. Thank you for
- 1:51the invitation. I'm very happy to be here. So
- 1:54to start, what is the specific moment or the
- 1:57passion that drew you to your attention to decentralized
- 2:00technologies? So decentralization has been something
- 2:06that I've been interested in since like probably
- 2:09my teenage years, to be honest. I became active
- 2:13in political activism. This was around the time
- 2:17of there was a global movement back in the late
- 2:2090s, early 2000s called the Alter Globalization
- 2:22Movement. It was a movement that was coming together
- 2:24around environmental action, labor action, feminism
- 2:29and indigenous rights, and kind of pooling everybody's
- 2:34ideas, resources, time, action together in order
- 2:39to present a united front against the spread
- 2:41of neoliberal economics. So at the time, I started
- 2:45studying political economy, and I was also looking
- 2:49into how more decentralized structures could
- 2:52actually be part of the solution. During that
- 2:56time, I also came across a media network called
- 3:00Indymedia, and this was a network of media producers
- 3:03that was organized in a decentralized way, non
- 3:07-hierarchical, people making videos and reporting
- 3:10from large -scale demonstrations. from political
- 3:14actions and really telling the story from the
- 3:16ground up. And this was, in fact, what we didn't
- 3:19know at the time was that this was actually the
- 3:20beginning of social media. So this was the invention
- 3:23of blogging. This was the invention of Twitter,
- 3:26in fact, as well came out of this movement. So
- 3:30a lot of the kind of technologies that we're
- 3:32used to today from social media. came out of
- 3:35this idea that people themselves can tell their
- 3:37stories. What we didn't know, though, was that
- 3:40the social media that was to emerge was going
- 3:44to go hand in hand with large -scale surveillance
- 3:47as well. So that was a kind of twist to the story
- 3:49that came later on. And that's kind of what I've
- 3:52ended up working on very much today, so looking
- 3:55at how decentralized... networks can actually
- 3:58solve the problem of mass surveillance that came
- 4:00after the rise of social media. In short, I'm
- 4:03interested in decentralization because I still
- 4:05believe that in many ways it can present an alternative
- 4:08to hierarchical power structures. But what I've
- 4:11also found in my work, especially with blockchain
- 4:14and also what happened with the story of indie
- 4:17media developing into a vehicle for mass surveillance.
- 4:21is that sometimes if you focus just on the technical
- 4:24layer, a decentralized technical architecture
- 4:26can actually result in centralized power at a
- 4:30different level. So when you decentralize technology,
- 4:33you create a vast open field for someone to actually
- 4:37harness a lot of information and data and so
- 4:39on. and value and economic value from people.
- 4:42So that's what I've been focusing on ever since
- 4:44then, is to look at all the different layers,
- 4:46not just the technical layer, but also the social
- 4:48layer, political layer, economic layer, governance
- 4:50layer, and so on, to see how these interact and
- 4:53understand that when we say decentralization,
- 4:56sometimes the actual effects can become centralized.
- 5:00Really interesting. Yeah, maybe we can break
- 5:03that down a little bit for listeners, our decentralization
- 5:05is, and can you briefly explain? what that term
- 5:09really is in technology is in the social aspect
- 5:12of it. And how does it differ from centralized
- 5:15systems? And possibly what are the pros and cons?
- 5:19I know they interweave in some ways. Some can
- 5:22camouflage as decentralized systems, but they're
- 5:26quite some authoritarian as per se. But yeah,
- 5:30it would be interesting to unpack that for maybe
- 5:33new listeners that are not unaware of what that
- 5:35really means. Absolutely. So on the technical
- 5:39level, when we're saying decentralization, we're
- 5:42usually talking about networks here, right? Let's
- 5:44say the kind of like extreme version of decentralization,
- 5:47what some people like to call distributed, is
- 5:49when you get rid of servers effectively. So you
- 5:53have lots of devices and things out there that
- 5:57are networked and they speak directly to each
- 5:58other. This is what we like to call peer -to
- 6:00-peer networks. So that is when you have... Yeah,
- 6:04digital devices that somehow speak directly to
- 6:07each other without going via a kind of server.
- 6:09Then a normal architecture, usually you'll have
- 6:12devices speaking to a server. The server then
- 6:14passes on your information or your communication
- 6:16to wherever the final destination is. You can
- 6:19have forms of decentralized architectures that
- 6:23include servers as well. Ours is a kind of hybrid
- 6:25model like that at NIM for a lot of different
- 6:27reasons. And they're usually easier to scale
- 6:31in a sense, but that's a deeper conversation.
- 6:34So in effect, when we're talking about decentralized
- 6:36technologies, we're talking about ways for communication
- 6:40to pass between digital devices that does not
- 6:43require the coordination of some sort of centralized
- 6:46entity, a server or otherwise, that the theory
- 6:51goes that that server would then be able to potentially
- 6:54manipulate that information or throttle that
- 6:57information or decide who gets to speak to who
- 6:59or whatever. There's a certain understanding
- 7:01of what power comes along with these types of
- 7:03architectures, where peer -to -peer architectures,
- 7:06you have, you know, people pinging each other
- 7:07directly without that intermediation, so to speak.
- 7:10So that's kind of on the technical layer. But
- 7:12I wanted to contrast that with, you know, the
- 7:14thinking in the social and political economy
- 7:16layer. And, you know, there we have this kind
- 7:20of interesting history of the concept of decentralization
- 7:23coming from, you know, on the one hand, political
- 7:26thinking. where the idea is you have what most
- 7:30of us are used to is like some sort of parliamentary
- 7:32democracy. We vote for people that then represent
- 7:35us in kind of decision making. And we take kind
- 7:38of a way of decentralizing parliamentary democracy
- 7:41further than you have these ideas of direct democracy,
- 7:45where people represent themselves in various
- 7:47decision making forms. And there's been a lot
- 7:49of thinking there of how to scale. direct democracy
- 7:53and how to introduce ideas. There was an idea
- 7:57floating around in the early 2000s also around
- 7:59liquid democracy. And this was an idea of taking
- 8:02advantage again of technologies where instead
- 8:05of voting every four or five years, we can, on
- 8:09every single issue, delegate our decision making
- 8:11to various experts. So instead of having professional
- 8:14politicians, it's a much more kind of fluid delegation
- 8:18process. That kind of gets rid of that politician
- 8:21class in a sense, and it becomes more, you know,
- 8:23the idea was it would be more kind of meritocratic
- 8:26and you kind of, okay, you know, on a certain
- 8:28environmental question, you defer to a scientist,
- 8:30on a certain economic question, you defer to
- 8:32economists or political economists you respect
- 8:34or so on. So having this much more kind of fluid
- 8:37version that sits somewhere between. direct democracy,
- 8:40where you have to be involved in every single
- 8:42decision making through to parliamentary democracy.
- 8:44But let's contrast that kind of political idea
- 8:46of decentralization that's very intertwined with
- 8:49democracy with the idea of economic decentralization.
- 8:53And this is a kind of market thinking that comes
- 8:56very much out of neoliberal economics, where
- 9:00the thinking is that, how about we get rid of
- 9:03human decision making in terms of politics entirely,
- 9:07and we let the market decide, right? Here, you
- 9:09know, communication around various issues. The
- 9:12idea was it was going to happen through like
- 9:15price mechanisms instead. Here I'm referring
- 9:18specifically to kind of Hayekian ideas. Friedrich
- 9:21von Hayek, an Austrian economist, kind of contrasted
- 9:24very much with Karl Marx in terms of political
- 9:27affiliations. So tends to have kind of more of
- 9:29a right wing flavor, let's say, and is a bit
- 9:32of a kind of market extremist. So the idea is
- 9:34like. You know, you have people out there in
- 9:36the world, everybody is kind of buying and selling
- 9:38things. And when you buy and sell things, that
- 9:41sends a signal across the market. So the more
- 9:44people that want to buy a certain thing, the
- 9:46more the price rises for that thing, which means
- 9:49that it incentivizes producers to actually produce
- 9:51and supply that more. So it's this idea of price
- 9:55as a communication mechanism. You know, people
- 9:59that take kind of Hayek. to the extreme, they
- 10:01kind of want to see everything in the world translated
- 10:04into price and market dynamics, right? And they
- 10:07kind of see, you know, that as the route to decentralization
- 10:10and that as an alternative to centralized decision
- 10:13making. At this point, this was contrasted very
- 10:16much with the rise of communism and authoritarian
- 10:18communism specifically. That is a kind of like
- 10:21market -based decentralization. And the reason
- 10:24why I'm telling this long drawn out story about
- 10:27these two different imaginations of decentralization
- 10:30on the one hand related to democracy, direct
- 10:32democracy, perhaps, let's say, a more kind of
- 10:35like left wing understanding. And then this kind
- 10:37of market price based version of decentralization
- 10:40is because the field that I'm working in today
- 10:43in blockchain, you have this wild mix of both
- 10:46of them. And you have people that are reading
- 10:48across the board and drawing in crazy ideas from
- 10:51both of these like long traditions without necessarily
- 10:55really understanding this history and this political
- 10:58economy. Wow, that's very interesting. It's like
- 11:01everything goes together. So you can unpack one
- 11:04together with, for example, the economics and
- 11:07the political part and everything is just stick
- 11:10together. As you mentioned, the blockchain and
- 11:13privacy networks. Can you explain a little bit
- 11:18more in baby words? Yeah, so blockchain. It's
- 11:26a technology that's been through a similar hype
- 11:28as we're currently going through with AI, right?
- 11:32Everybody was crazy about blockchain for a few
- 11:34years there. And it's a particular form of decentralized
- 11:38technologies that actually builds in markets
- 11:41effectively. So the idea is, and this is what
- 11:44I'm saying, it was drawing a lot from kind of
- 11:46Hayekian thinking, but with a little bit more
- 11:49engineering that's gone into it, more kind of
- 11:52bespoke engineering. So the beginning of... Blockchain
- 11:55technology per se was in Bitcoin. That was the
- 11:58invention of this technology. And in very simple
- 12:03terms, it's a ledger, right? It's a kind of list
- 12:06of things that you can add to. But it's a list
- 12:09of things where the agreement on what you add
- 12:12to that list of things happens in a decentralized
- 12:15way and happens via different kind of computer
- 12:20mechanics. So in Bitcoin, it's a competition.
- 12:23The people kind of run, you know, they engage
- 12:25in this competition on their computers in order
- 12:27to find a number that then allows them to add
- 12:29to the list. And the list in terms of Bitcoin
- 12:32is a list of transactions. It's a very kind of
- 12:34peculiar type of technology that came out of
- 12:37the idea that governments and central banks and
- 12:42the way that money operates has a little bit
- 12:44too much power involved, too much human decision
- 12:48making. And the idea was to... distribute this
- 12:51decision making and this power into computational
- 12:54mechanics instead. So that instead of having
- 12:57a government or a central banker deciding how
- 12:59much money to print at any given moment, it happens
- 13:02via an algorithm. And that algorithm is designed
- 13:05in such a way that it is economically disadvantageous
- 13:10to alter the way that it works. So in a sense,
- 13:14like blockchain is this kind of very strange
- 13:17new form of decentralization. So you know how
- 13:20I was talking about the political decentralization
- 13:22on the one hand, talking about market decentralization
- 13:24on the one hand. Blockchain tries to work with
- 13:27a little bit of ideas from both of those, but
- 13:29in effect is the idea of decentralization via
- 13:33harnessing the material world, harnessing, you
- 13:37know, let's say mechanics and engineering and
- 13:40computation and actually distributing human decision
- 13:44making. into a kind of computational process
- 13:47instead. This was something that I got very interested
- 13:50in because I was like, I don't even know, I don't
- 13:53even know where to place this on the political
- 13:55spectrum. And you had, you know, the early kind
- 13:57of, I went to some of the first Ethereum conferences,
- 14:02Ethereum being the second largest cryptocurrency
- 14:04after Bitcoin. And their very first developer
- 14:08conference took place in the city of London.
- 14:11and uh the city of london is a financial district
- 14:14of london and it was in uh i forget the name
- 14:17of the hall now but the hall was like a gold
- 14:20you know decorated hall super elaborate um and
- 14:24i walk into the room and i don't know there's
- 14:27maybe like 50 to 100 people there it's not not
- 14:29very big the meeting but it is this strange strange
- 14:32mix of bankers anarchists uh developers you know
- 14:38like a mix that i just haven't really seen before
- 14:41And I couldn't place people politically. People
- 14:44had all kinds of wild ideas. And that's what
- 14:47made me interested really in the field was that
- 14:49there was not a kind of easy recipe to what was
- 14:51going on here. It was neither really left wing
- 14:53nor right wing, which might turn out to be far
- 14:57more sinister. It got me interested. So here
- 15:03I am today. The way that that intersects with
- 15:05privacy and the way that it intersects with the
- 15:07project that I'm working on today. Is so if you
- 15:11remember, I was talking about this network called
- 15:13Indymedia and the invention of blogging and social
- 15:15media. You know, the next part of that story
- 15:18is, you know, after social media, I think most
- 15:21of your listeners are probably also aware of
- 15:22just how much, you know, companies are surveilling
- 15:26their users now. Right. So you have, you know,
- 15:28the big scandals that came out, Edward Snowden
- 15:30revealing that the NSA is spying on everybody.
- 15:32And then, you know, subsequently, all the information
- 15:35coming out about how much Facebook gathers about
- 15:37people. And that was the outcome of a set of
- 15:41design flaws effectively at the core of the Internet.
- 15:44And these design flaws are basically like, you
- 15:46know, when the Internet was invented, it was
- 15:50invented in kind of a bit of an academic context.
- 15:53So it's, you know, people that are like, oh,
- 15:55my God, look, we can share information with each
- 15:57other. How cool is that? You know, and then this
- 15:59thing kind of just blows up. And it was, you
- 16:03know, that that kind of design context where
- 16:05it's like there is a certain, let's say. trust
- 16:08involved. There's a certain kind of goodwill
- 16:11involved. All of a sudden, we have this network
- 16:14that is, you know, that crisscrosses geopolitics
- 16:17and crisscrosses economic, commercial interests
- 16:20as well. So people start looking at the technical
- 16:22architecture and they're like, how can we take
- 16:23advantage of this technical architecture? Well,
- 16:26it's an architecture that's not designed with
- 16:28strong privacy protections. In fact, someone
- 16:31that's keeping an eye on the network can see
- 16:32traffic flowing and can monitor who's talking
- 16:35to who, when, how often, and all that information
- 16:38is readily available. And even more information
- 16:41if you're a social media company. And social
- 16:44media companies obviously had a whole other interest.
- 16:46They wanted to become the biggest social media
- 16:49company. And so they needed to find ways for
- 16:51people to actually stay on their platforms. So
- 16:54they get some of the best designers in the world
- 16:56to figure out how can we design infinite scroll?
- 16:58How can we make buttons the best color that make
- 17:01people want to press those buttons? How can we
- 17:03get the best content producers involved? every
- 17:06trick possible to make sure that people stay
- 17:08on their platforms, using their platforms, posting
- 17:11to their platforms as much as possible. And I
- 17:14mean, we've seen, you know, designers come, you
- 17:17know, out of, you know, Facebook, Meta, Instagram,
- 17:20so on, talking about like the work that they
- 17:23were doing and actually like sincerely regretting
- 17:26it and really seeing the negative effects and
- 17:29the negative impact in terms of people's mental
- 17:31health, in terms of phone addiction, all these
- 17:33sorts of things. In short, we've ended up with
- 17:36this kind of like technical environment that
- 17:39is, first of all, ubiquitous, which means it's
- 17:42everywhere. You know, we've got our devices with
- 17:44us all the time. We're carrying it with us all
- 17:46the time. It's become integrated with every single
- 17:48service that we use. So whether it's, you know,
- 17:51public services, commercial services, everything,
- 17:53you know, you use your phone to speak to the
- 17:56bank. You use your phone to send emails. You
- 17:58use your phone to interact with the public sector.
- 18:00You use your phone to buy things. These devices
- 18:03have become part of like pretty much every single,
- 18:07you know, activity that we need to do in society
- 18:10in our relation to other people, including payments
- 18:13now too, right? So cash is being eroded. And
- 18:17so we're using, you know, our devices for that
- 18:19as well. And all that comes at, brings in all
- 18:22these vulnerabilities that I was talking about
- 18:24around lack of privacy at a very core level that
- 18:28opens people and their lives up to manipulation
- 18:30and fraud and so on. That was a big backstory
- 18:33to say what I'm working on now is privacy. I
- 18:35think it's one of the most important topics today,
- 18:38especially as we're moving into an age of not
- 18:42just having devices with us everywhere, but artificial
- 18:44intelligence as well, which is the outcome effectively
- 18:47of all this data that these companies have been
- 18:49gathering about us. You know, then they train
- 18:51that data and all of a sudden you can automate
- 18:54all sorts of behavior and interactions. So, yeah,
- 18:58so I believe. Privacy is one of the most important
- 19:01things to be working on today, both for people's
- 19:05security and sanity, but also as a form of kind
- 19:09of almost like activist blockade, you know, on
- 19:12the data pipeline, let's say. So this whole kind
- 19:17of production industry that's happening. For
- 19:19our listeners and for us to unpack a little bit
- 19:22about the structure of this decentralized mixed
- 19:25net architecture. We've gone a little bit into
- 19:29the details of privacy, the importance of it,
- 19:31but we'd like to understand a little bit of the
- 19:33project that you're currently working on and
- 19:36what's you guys' goals pretty much. Yeah, absolutely.
- 19:41We're building something that hasn't existed
- 19:44before, and it's something called a mixnet. Effectively,
- 19:47what a mixnet does is vaguely similar to a VPN.
- 19:53even more similar to Tor for those who are familiar
- 19:56with Tor, but it does something that none of
- 19:58those networks can actually do, which is it mixes
- 20:02your internet traffic. So the way to imagine
- 20:05it is, if you think about the internet as this
- 20:08vast network that spans the world, you've got
- 20:11people all over the world that are sending messages
- 20:14to each other, browsing the internet, making
- 20:17phone calls, making payments, this and that.
- 20:20And all of this, it takes the form of data packets.
- 20:24So these packets that are moving across the network.
- 20:26And we have got to a point where luckily a lot
- 20:30of people have been working on privacy. And we've
- 20:32got to a point where what's called end -to -end
- 20:34encryption has become the norm. So what that
- 20:37means is the content of your messages and the
- 20:39content of what you're doing is encrypted. And
- 20:42that's pretty much the default for most things
- 20:46these days. It's kind of become the gold standard,
- 20:48which is great, which is fantastic. But there's
- 20:50still a major problem, which is that someone
- 20:53can still watch the network and see the patterns
- 20:56of communication. And now the patterns of communication
- 20:58is things like how often you're sending a message
- 21:01to a certain person, what time of the day, how
- 21:03big are the data packets that are transferring
- 21:06across, where are you sending it from? And all
- 21:09of that can be analyzed to actually learn possibly
- 21:13even more than the content of your message. Now,
- 21:16that sounds a bit kind of strange because it
- 21:17feels counterintuitive to the human brain. But
- 21:20if you think about how a machine operates. A
- 21:22machine can read patterns very well, especially
- 21:25if it's structured. So what I'm talking about
- 21:27here is the metadata of your communications.
- 21:30So, you know, and the metadata will usually be
- 21:32quite structured data. So like I said, the kind
- 21:34of time that a packet is transferred, size of
- 21:36the packet, etc. That can be analyzed with machine
- 21:40learning algorithms or otherwise, you know, doing
- 21:42kind of traffic analysis to understand things
- 21:45like what is your relationship to this person?
- 21:47You know, even what is your state of mind? Even
- 21:50like... For kind of voice calls, for example,
- 21:52it can be analyzed to such a fine -grained manner
- 21:54that you can actually sometimes detect what's
- 21:57actually being said in a phone conversation.
- 22:00So and if you think about the content of a communication,
- 22:04it might be like, I don't know, you might be
- 22:06you have a specific kind of like way of speaking
- 22:09to your best friend where you use a certain slang
- 22:11or whatever. All that kind of stuff is not very
- 22:14easy for a machine to understand, actually, because
- 22:16it's like quite a kind of unique personal language
- 22:18between you and this person. And making sense
- 22:21of that and making meaning out of that is not
- 22:22that straightforward. So in a weird way, when
- 22:25we're talking about surveillance that's powered
- 22:28by. machine learning algorithms, the content
- 22:31is less important than the metadata, than the
- 22:34patterns of communication in the network. So
- 22:36that's something that we're working on. We're
- 22:38working on, the way we like to put it is we're
- 22:42adding noise into the internet. And that noise
- 22:45disrupts that pattern, right? And it makes it
- 22:48impossible for machine learning driven surveillance
- 22:52to actually read. what's going on in the network.
- 22:55So what does noise actually mean? Noise is just
- 22:58a kind of word that we use to describe this kind
- 23:01of mixing techniques that we're doing. And what
- 23:03happens in real terms is on your device, before
- 23:07you send anything out, it encrypts all your data
- 23:10packets in several layers of encryption that
- 23:12make all data packets look exactly the same as
- 23:15they come out of your device. And then we add
- 23:18what's called timing obfuscation. So that disrupts
- 23:21the kind of pattern in terms of timing as you're
- 23:23communicating. And then we send your data packets
- 23:26across several, like three to five operators
- 23:30that are running servers all over the world.
- 23:32We send it through their servers and mix it with
- 23:34other people's communication. So that mixing
- 23:38and timing obfuscation and encryption make it
- 23:41very hard, nearly impossible to trace. what I'm
- 23:45sending to the destination that I'm trying to
- 23:47send it to. So that's what a mix net does. It
- 23:49basically just adds, you know, it kind of disrupts
- 23:52the traffic patterns, let's say, and make your
- 23:55communications untraceable. That also applies
- 23:58for like a different applications. For example,
- 24:00when they're banking on social media, in the
- 24:04way that, for example, you're talking and then
- 24:07five seconds afterwards, you see apps about what
- 24:11you're talking like, oh gosh, this is... Yeah,
- 24:13exactly. Exactly. So it works for any application.
- 24:20Effectively now we've... We've tried to make
- 24:24it as easy to use as possible. So it's basically,
- 24:26it looks like a VPN app. You can just download
- 24:28the app and then you can just send all your traffic
- 24:30through, you know, either the MixNet or a kind
- 24:33of lighter version of the MixNet because the
- 24:34MixNet is obviously, it's still in an experimental
- 24:37phase, which means it slows your traffic down
- 24:40a lot because you have all this mixing happening.
- 24:42You're sending it through different, you know,
- 24:44routes across the network and so on. So we have
- 24:46a lighter version that's just like. two hops
- 24:48without the mixing, but it's still, you know,
- 24:51it still adds a lot of protection. Yeah, so everybody
- 24:53can use the app already now. But ideally, our
- 24:57ambition, you know, to be honest, is that this
- 24:59just becomes integrated into the everyday apps
- 25:02that you're using and you don't even need to
- 25:03think about it. We really want this to become
- 25:05basically the routing protocol for any secure
- 25:08communications across the whole internet. I have
- 25:10a question that you're explaining. But for example,
- 25:13how do you contract like a legal action? Like,
- 25:18you know, like, or I don't know, people watching
- 25:21what they... Bad people using the network. Well,
- 25:26I mean, the very simple answer is you can't.
- 25:29Our understanding of society is there are certain
- 25:31things that should be available to people no
- 25:34matter what. And here I'm talking about clean
- 25:37water, for example, right? So you're not going
- 25:39to poison the water of a village just because,
- 25:41you know, potential criminals are drinking from
- 25:43that water. So there are certain kind of like,
- 25:45let's say, essential infrastructures. that we
- 25:48need as a society and that we need collectively
- 25:51in order to function as a society and in order
- 25:54to make sure that we can maintain our health,
- 25:56our basic rights and so on. So clean water, good
- 25:59housing, you know, sanitation, and from our perspective,
- 26:04secure communications. If you, you know, if you
- 26:07have insecure communications because you want
- 26:09to catch the criminals, well, then you're having
- 26:11insecure communications for everybody. That's
- 26:13the problem. The question of crime and how to
- 26:15kind of deal with crime from our perspective
- 26:18should really happen through other means rather
- 26:20than through mass surveillance. That's very interesting.
- 26:23I have no idea about it. And in science, scientists
- 26:27managing the data is very important. Could decentralized
- 26:32systems make scientific research more open, secure
- 26:35and collaborative? And how this can change the
- 26:39way we publish and validate discoveries. Because
- 26:41you know that when we publish a paper, it's always
- 26:45like an editorial that manages like 50 % of all
- 26:50of them. For me, it's like a centralized. Yeah.
- 26:54Not sure, but it's like a monopoly. Yeah, yeah.
- 27:00But how the centralized technology can help with
- 27:04science and the managing of the data. There was
- 27:08actually in the early days of blockchain, there
- 27:10was a number of experiments exactly with this,
- 27:12with academic and scientific publishing. I think
- 27:16any of us who've been in academia knows that
- 27:19the publishing, the journals are, you know, it's
- 27:23a deeply fucked up economy, right? Poor academics
- 27:27working for free doing I don't know how many
- 27:28peer reviews. And then you have the journals
- 27:30selling all that material back to the universities.
- 27:34It's a deeply corrupt publishing industry. So,
- 27:37yeah, there was there was experiments early on
- 27:40in the blockchain space to actually develop a
- 27:42new economic model for for scientific and academic
- 27:45publishing. But I haven't actually followed it
- 27:47so closely. So I'm not sure, you know, given
- 27:50that I haven't I can kind of think of it off
- 27:52the top of my head. I don't think any of them
- 27:53were like. super successful, at least not quite
- 27:56yet. But I'd be surprised if they're not still
- 27:59around trying to kind of solve this. Decentralized
- 28:02technologies, like first of all, you know, there's
- 28:05like peer to peer knowledge sharing that, you
- 28:07know, absolutely at that layer, you know, that
- 28:09I think there's a number of different experiments
- 28:12that are happening there. And then with how to
- 28:14structure the economics of academic publishing
- 28:18and scientific publishing, that's where blockchain
- 28:19is potentially interesting. But yeah, I don't
- 28:22have the latest info on how successful those
- 28:26projects were. That would be great. Because yeah,
- 28:28as you said, it's just suck. We have a special
- 28:31guest that is Dr. Ani Maria Cheto. And she was
- 28:34explaining to us all the business behind the
- 28:37publications and the editorials and how they
- 28:41get the money to like everything. And it's just
- 28:43millionaire. It was like a good idea to try to
- 28:48figure out how to. reach out the more people
- 28:52and accessing to this information absolutely
- 28:55we can still stay on this scientific topic and
- 28:59like uh so scientific collaborators often rely
- 29:02on trust and transparency if we take these two
- 29:06concepts like how can decentralized systems ensure
- 29:10that the data integrity and the open net access
- 29:13uh is in research so how can scientific research
- 29:18take advantage or leverage decentralized or perhaps
- 29:21blockchain to their advantage? Well, in theory,
- 29:24that's exactly what blockchain should be able
- 29:26to do, right? Both the transparency and the trust
- 29:29bit. So, you know, the transparency being, you
- 29:32know, that you have, you're effectively running
- 29:33a public ledger of information. You know, it's
- 29:37a database effectively. You know, a blockchain
- 29:40is a public database of information that has
- 29:42been verified by actors. that are part of that
- 29:47network. So on an abstract level, that sounds
- 29:50wonderful. And that sounds like something that
- 29:52is absolutely useful to maintain, store and validate
- 29:56scientific information. What complicates it a
- 30:00little bit, I think, has been the kind of wild
- 30:03economics that usually goes hand in hand with
- 30:06the whole kind of crypto space. But it doesn't
- 30:09need to involve that, especially if you have
- 30:12kind of collaborating institutions and you make
- 30:14sure that whatever token is involved in the architecture
- 30:18is not out there in the open markets, but is
- 30:20rather just used as a coordinating token amongst
- 30:23kind of collaborating institutions, then absolutely
- 30:25it should be fine. Crypto and like blockchain,
- 30:29it's in everybody's mouth. I mean, it's unfortunately
- 30:31the upcoming US president. You have Bitcoin going
- 30:36left, right and center. And there's a buzz around
- 30:40it. So it would be interesting to unpack, you
- 30:44know, like the monetary aspect of it as well,
- 30:46because it's very financialized. And it seems
- 30:49like even the far right is leveraging this whole
- 30:53movement as well. Even though I find it interesting
- 30:57because blockchain has got like the Ethereum.
- 31:00I was reading a fair bit about it, about decentralized
- 31:03DAOs. decentralized autonomy organization you
- 31:09know at a grassroots level very left leaning
- 31:13so it's like this mix of these two sides of course
- 31:18is very financially driven for personal gain
- 31:22and stuff like is it just a trend that's happening
- 31:26now because technology for me is really fascinating
- 31:29and I'm trying to see how scientists perhaps
- 31:33can leverage it i mean academics in one form
- 31:35or another and been been using it to one degree
- 31:39or another but it's very very financialized right
- 31:43now and speculative i find yeah so it i mean
- 31:47first of all i think it's important to say it
- 31:49doesn't have to be but it's just that you know
- 31:52so one of the benefits of blockchain has is in
- 31:55fact the kind of financial financialized aspect
- 31:58what i mean by that is that what happened early
- 32:01days was people that have been working on open
- 32:03source software for quite some time realize that,
- 32:06oh, if we put a blockchain on this, then we can
- 32:10raise money very easily and very quickly to actually
- 32:13create a project that would be almost unimaginable
- 32:16otherwise, or would get peanuts in public funding,
- 32:20or we'd need to beg grants on a regular basis
- 32:25or whatever. So the kind of financialized aspect
- 32:27of blockchain was kind of part of its early selling
- 32:29point. quite a bit like industry and scientific
- 32:34uptake that has taken the kind of database architecture
- 32:38and this idea that you can have different actors
- 32:43come together to arrive at a consensus around
- 32:46what should be in that database. And you can
- 32:49do that in a kind of algorithmic manner. That's
- 32:54possible without the financialized element. The
- 32:56financialized element comes in if you... effectively
- 32:59put the token on the open markets then you're
- 33:02tied to the markets right um and that's when
- 33:04you need to start like maintaining the token
- 33:06price getting involved in like dodgy you know
- 33:10exchange listings and this and that and that's
- 33:13where the whole kind of financialized aspect
- 33:15comes in and things get a little bit complicated
- 33:18you know all that to say that i think like you're
- 33:20the potential application for for scientists
- 33:23um especially also for I think data engineers
- 33:26that are interested in a kind of more equitable
- 33:29direction for AI, blockchain is quite a powerful
- 33:35tool. And I believe it has a really important
- 33:38place in the kind of like future technical stack,
- 33:41let's say, as we move into artificial intelligence.
- 33:44Artificial intelligence is effectively, you know,
- 33:47machine learning algorithms that are trained
- 33:48on data sets, right? And then the question is,
- 33:51what are those data sets? Where do they come
- 33:53from? Whose knowledge do those data sets actually
- 33:56represent? Whose perspective on the world do
- 33:58those data sets represent? What is the narratives
- 34:01that are going to be repeated and automated through
- 34:03AI? Are those narratives that we actually want
- 34:06to automate and perpetuate? Is there counter
- 34:10-knowledges that are not being represented here?
- 34:12What's missing from this knowledge base? All
- 34:14those questions are really deep and important
- 34:17societal questions. The way to understand it
- 34:20is almost like... ai is going to supercharge
- 34:23any given kind of person or group's understanding
- 34:27of the world or perspective on the world so you
- 34:30know it's super super important that we have
- 34:33people involved in shaping ai so we don't it
- 34:37doesn't just represent you know i don't know
- 34:39the perspective of elon musk or whatever do you
- 34:41know what i mean it's like we need to actually
- 34:43have this is like this is about the the it's
- 34:46effectively kind of the future knowledge repositories.
- 34:50So it's a kind of like a modern day version of
- 34:52the library. So if the library only has books
- 34:56in it that like some, you know, random rich dude
- 34:59has picked out, well, guess what? It's going
- 35:01to like, it's going to have serious consequences
- 35:03for science and society. We'll end up in, you
- 35:07know, the dark ages basically, which seems to
- 35:10be where we're headed. So when it comes to this
- 35:13question of governing the data that informs artificial
- 35:16intelligence, which is the knowledge repository
- 35:19of our modern day world, that's where I think
- 35:22blockchain can potentially have a lot to say
- 35:25as a database that has some sort of consensus
- 35:29mechanisms and governance built in. That's what
- 35:33I'm hoping to see more of and what I'm looking
- 35:36forward to seeing in that space. I think it's
- 35:38something that's potentially absolutely wonderful
- 35:40and marvelous and groundbreaking in a very, very
- 35:42positive way. But to speak a little bit to the
- 35:45negatives, which are much more evident right
- 35:47now. Yes, crypto has played a huge role in the
- 35:50US elections. Unfortunately, you know, as someone
- 35:54who's involved in the crypto industry, you know,
- 35:56I saw lots of people and... investors, you know,
- 36:00really rally around Trump when it became clear
- 36:03to them that Trump was supportive of blockchain
- 36:07and supportive of deregulation in the crypto
- 36:09space. But I'm also baffled by how ridiculously
- 36:13naive these people are to think that there's
- 36:16any goodwill from the side of Trump on that front.
- 36:19My perspective is both Trump and Elon Musk see
- 36:23crypto as markets that are small and incredibly
- 36:26easy to manipulate. And that's exactly what they
- 36:28do. So guess what? They're making money out of
- 36:31it. It's that simple. There's nothing more deep
- 36:34there. They're not in favor of any sort of political
- 36:36decentralization. They're not in favor of any
- 36:39sort of equitable distribution of wealth in any
- 36:43way whatsoever. These are markets that can be
- 36:45easily manipulated. And they're also markets
- 36:47that tie easily into their whole like more like
- 36:52vibes based politics. Your listeners might be
- 36:55familiar with Dogecoin as well. And this. Funny
- 36:58trick that Elon Musk and Trump pulled off of
- 37:01establishing the, what was it, Department of
- 37:04Organizational Efficiency? Department of Organizational
- 37:08Efficiency, I think is what it was. Yeah, that
- 37:11sounds right. Yeah, and DOGE was the acronym,
- 37:14right? And Musk was going to oversee that new
- 37:18department, which is effectively slashing 70
- 37:20% of budget for federal institutions. So, you
- 37:24know, you see this. this like destruction of
- 37:27any mechanisms of accountability for those holding
- 37:30power. But it's spun in a way that makes it look
- 37:33like they're anti -authoritarian, like they're
- 37:36all about freedom. They're all about funny memes
- 37:39and cryptocurrencies, but they're really just
- 37:41consolidating power and wealth at an insane level,
- 37:45you know, unprecedented, really. So that's the
- 37:48kind of negative side to that story. We go through
- 37:51ups and downs. There's going to be some dark
- 37:54years ahead. But honestly, I see so much wonderful
- 37:58and important stuff that's happening beneath
- 38:00the surface of these pretty horrific headlines.
- 38:04Wow, that's scary. It's quite volatile. Yeah.
- 38:09I might just quickly chip in because there's
- 38:11something quite positive that I've seen out of
- 38:13blockchain has given the rise and empowered a
- 38:18lot of digital artists. creators and created
- 38:21an economy for them so like i curated a few generative
- 38:26artists uh exhibitions and a lot of these people
- 38:30weren't able to either uh exhibit their work
- 38:33in any other form besides blockchain so and has
- 38:36given an economic incentive to their work and
- 38:40has also brought their yeah this whole genre
- 38:44that was kind of some obscure in some ways uh
- 38:47to the limelight um so that was quite interesting
- 38:50like i've chatted to different artists uh from
- 38:54coming from all over the world some even have
- 38:57been doing this practice for many many many years
- 39:00like uh from decades and uh got recognition so
- 39:04it was quite exciting to see that and botching
- 39:06was able to to incentivize that for them So,
- 39:09yeah, there's been some really cool things. So
- 39:12every now and then I dabble into some form of
- 39:14positivity that has come from the industry, which
- 39:17is really cool. And of course, the work that
- 39:19you guys are doing is pretty amazing. I think
- 39:22the Ethereum ecosystem is far more healthy in
- 39:24that sense. And it's one of the biggest kind
- 39:27of success stories of crypto really is, you know,
- 39:31NFTs and, you know, digital art, the digital
- 39:34art world that's kind of emerged around. And
- 39:36in the Ethereum ecosystem, I completely agree.
- 39:39I think there's some really amazing stuff happening
- 39:40there. It's kind of like the golden age for digital
- 39:44art, really. There wasn't really a space for
- 39:46it before. You had a couple of awkward galleries
- 39:49here and there trying to display a few things
- 39:51back in the 90s, but it was never really working.
- 39:54But yeah, I agree. I think it's really, it's
- 39:57quite, it's very cool. A lot of really good stuff
- 39:59has been made over the past few years. And with
- 40:01this buzz about blockchain and cryptocurrencies,
- 40:05how we can make these technologies more accessible
- 40:07to people for the average person, how we can
- 40:11someone begin to use or benefit from these technologies
- 40:14in their daily life, because sometimes it's just
- 40:18so compacted that it's like, oh, what is that?
- 40:20Well, I mean, I'm on the fence about that. It's
- 40:23kind of like on my good days, I'm really proud
- 40:26of everything that we're doing. On my bad days,
- 40:28I'm thinking, are we just a gateway to what is
- 40:30effectively a corrupt, financialized technology
- 40:33that's causing, I don't know, unprecedented levels
- 40:36of fraud and speculation and this and that. Technology
- 40:40is important as a potential leverage of empowerment.
- 40:46So accessibility is an important thing. But I'm
- 40:51also very much in favor of people taking it slow,
- 40:56actually, like being careful of how and when
- 40:59and for what we're actually using these technologies.
- 41:02It feels like right now in history, we've got
- 41:07to a point where there's been really rapid development
- 41:11of digital technologies. And as I mentioned earlier,
- 41:13integration of digital technologies into every
- 41:16single aspect of our lives. And I'm not sure
- 41:19it's been for the better always. You know, I
- 41:21think there are certain things that really don't
- 41:23need that digital intermediation and that our
- 41:26quality of lives would be better without it.
- 41:29So, you know, here I'm also thinking about like,
- 41:31I don't know, automated checkouts and cashless
- 41:34payments and this and that, that like effectively
- 41:36hollow out a city where you have less and less
- 41:39of this kind of more casual engagement with other
- 41:42people, you know, in a shop or at a bank or whatever
- 41:46else. We've kind of stripped society of these
- 41:49more everyday interactions between people and
- 41:52instead put screens, devices, and apps in front
- 41:55of us for every single activity that we need
- 41:57to do. So I guess what I mean is, to me right
- 42:00now, it feels like a time to take stock of who's
- 42:04pushing these developments and dynamics in that
- 42:07direction. Is there a direction that we want
- 42:10to go in? Where and when does it make sense to
- 42:13have an app? you know, doing something for us
- 42:16and where and when does it make sense to use
- 42:17AI and where and when does it make sense to use
- 42:19blockchain and start making some considered decisions
- 42:23around like what are the types of societies that
- 42:26we're really trying to develop here. And it feels
- 42:28like that scale of conversation, that level of
- 42:30conversation hasn't really quite found a home
- 42:33yet. I hear policymakers having these sorts of
- 42:36conversations all the time, but they end up just
- 42:38creating very, at least in Europe, very ambitious
- 42:41regulation that with, not very great effects
- 42:45on the ground. So, you know, I don't know, in
- 42:48the EU, it's like, let's have these serious conversations
- 42:51at the European Parliament or whatever, and then
- 42:53it'll end up in a PDF. And the actual real effect
- 42:56on the ground is just annoying cookie banners
- 42:58or, you know, other shit like this. It needs
- 43:01to happen. I don't know, there needs to be some
- 43:03sort of forum for that type of conversation to
- 43:06happen. Policymakers are part of it, but I think
- 43:09it also needs to involve artists is really...
- 43:14My sense, actually, and I think artists should
- 43:16be at the forefront of these conversations, really,
- 43:19because that's where ordinary people can start
- 43:21to understand the potential impact of the technologies
- 43:24that we're seeing and that we're using. A good
- 43:27advice to get a guidance before starting just
- 43:30crazy, jumping on it. Crazy searches. Well, the
- 43:35main guidance is if you're going to touch crypto
- 43:37at all, just be careful, you know. There's so
- 43:42much scams out there. Find a community is the
- 43:45first thing before you start throwing your money
- 43:47at it. Find a community that you trust, meet
- 43:50with people, have chats and make sure that you've
- 43:54got kind of sound advice. Otherwise, I think
- 43:57it's also important for people to know that you
- 43:59don't need to be an expert. So what I've also
- 44:02found is. some of the most expert people that
- 44:06are like the engineers actually building these
- 44:08protocols and coming up with these protocols,
- 44:10they are also some of the people who have the
- 44:11least clue about how these technologies are actually
- 44:15impacting people's ordinary lives. So you as
- 44:18a user of, you know, whatever app, whatever blockchain
- 44:23system, whatever crypto wallet, whatever DAO
- 44:27you might be involved in, you are actually as
- 44:29much an expert as these engineers or, you know,
- 44:33people like me or whatever, because, you know,
- 44:36many times we're so deep in building stuff out
- 44:39that we don't actually have much awareness of
- 44:41the experience of using it. And that experience
- 44:43is the real stuff. Don't be shy to get your hands
- 44:47messy. Don't be shy to kind of ask questions.
- 44:50Don't be shy to push back. The experts have no
- 44:53clue what the scale potential impact of what
- 44:57they're doing, to be honest. So, yeah, I do invite
- 45:00everybody to get involved in the conversation
- 45:02and get their hands messy. I know it's a really
- 45:05big topic, decentralized finance. We don't have
- 45:09a lot of time to go into it. I just maybe we
- 45:12can touch base a little bit of what DeFi is.
- 45:16And if a user wants to get an understanding of
- 45:20it. Is it a way for somebody to take ownership
- 45:23of their assets? Because that's my understanding
- 45:26of it. Or what's your view of it? It's a big
- 45:28question. Yeah, it is a big question. I mean,
- 45:31DeFi is a fascinating space. Yeah, decentralized
- 45:34finance, it sits in a legal gray zone is a good
- 45:38thing to kind of like mention. It's kind of one
- 45:40of these places where it's not really sure. depending
- 45:44on what jurisdiction you're in, this and that,
- 45:47because effectively decentralized finance does
- 45:50not have a lot of the kind of controls that banks
- 45:53usually have to kind of be under, right? So especially
- 45:56things like anti -money laundering regulation,
- 45:59know your customer, this sort of thing. DeFi
- 46:02is a little bit more of a kind of like open wild
- 46:05space of experimentation still. It's becoming
- 46:08more formalized, but... effectively, the core
- 46:12of DeFi is decentralized exchanges, right, which
- 46:16is where instead of having an exchange where
- 46:19you might buy Bitcoin, you know, you come with
- 46:21your whatever your euros or your dollars or whatever,
- 46:24and you buy some Bitcoin from a centralized exchange
- 46:26that's, you know, regulated, decentralized exchanges
- 46:30are kind of user driven, right? So it's like
- 46:33someone will put up a pool. of, you know, some
- 46:36tokens and be like, I'm up for exchanging Ethereum
- 46:39for Solana or something like this. And then,
- 46:42you know, you can do those exchanges at that
- 46:45kind of like peer to peer direct level. It's
- 46:47a rabbit hole to go down, but it's also very
- 46:50fascinating because there's often a lot of very
- 46:52interesting experiments with governance also,
- 46:55because you've got these funds that happen or
- 46:58that people put up. And sometimes these funds
- 47:00are community governed. So people kind of have.
- 47:03decision -making processes around like, do we
- 47:06want to add liquidity to this pool over here?
- 47:09And if we do that, then the proceeds from that,
- 47:12from those exchanges will go into this fund that's
- 47:15going to fund this community development project
- 47:17where we're going to build out new tooling, a
- 47:20new kind of platform to, I don't know, monitor
- 47:23XYZ networks. So it's kind of, there's a lot
- 47:26of community to be found there, but anyone that
- 47:29gets involved, you have to have a kind of interest
- 47:32also in like, finance, basically, and financial
- 47:35techniques and whatever. But it's a pretty wild
- 47:37and creative space. So I do, I mean, I do invite
- 47:40people to get involved and get curious. There'll
- 47:43be a lot of kind of jargon to get through and
- 47:44stuff. But it's quite fascinating what's happening
- 47:47there. And I have to say, I was initially like
- 47:50quite reluctant to look at DeFi. I mean, personally,
- 47:53I come from kind of more of a left wing background
- 47:55that's been, you know, traditionally hugely critical
- 47:57of finance more generally. DeFi has something
- 48:03kind of like quite different. I mean, this community
- 48:06element to it is actually quite powerful. And
- 48:10especially when you see people that might not
- 48:13have access to lending and banking otherwise
- 48:16get involved and actually like become empowered
- 48:19by that space. It's like it's fairly interesting,
- 48:22but it does go very much against like the European
- 48:24left wing sensibilities of state regulation and
- 48:28taxation and everything being quite kind of ordered.
- 48:30And grounded in a real economy. I mean, this
- 48:33space is like, it's pretty wild in comparison.
- 48:36So NIM has a crypto token. I'll explain why.
- 48:41Because it gives some insight into how tokens
- 48:44are different from money. So, you know, Bitcoin
- 48:48was invented with the idea that it was going
- 48:50to be some sort of digital gold or digital cash.
- 48:53And people had a lot of monetary theories in
- 48:56their head. But actually... What it unleashed
- 48:58was the designs of tokens more generally, which
- 49:01can be engineered to do all sorts of things.
- 49:03And what's fascinating, this is something I've
- 49:05written quite a bit about actually, is that when
- 49:08you have computer engineers creating tokens,
- 49:11they are creating tokens to solve engineering
- 49:14problems. So you have this like unique new kind
- 49:17of persona that's like playing around with economics,
- 49:21but not really like. for the sake of economics
- 49:24per se, but more for the sake of trying to design
- 49:26certain types of systems. So it's more of this
- 49:29engineer's mentality where economics is just
- 49:32one ingredient in the same way that encryption
- 49:34or whatever is. So in the case of NIM, what we're
- 49:39trying to do is we're creating a decentralized
- 49:41network of servers that can route user traffic
- 49:45and mix user traffic, right? So the question
- 49:47is, how do you establish a decentralized network?
- 49:50Now, in the case of Tor and the case of many
- 49:53other decentralized networks, you will have a
- 49:55decentralized network in the sense of people
- 49:57operating servers, but a centralized list that
- 50:00says these are the servers that are part of the
- 50:03network. So the question is, who gets to decide
- 50:05about that list? You know, if we think of potential
- 50:08kind of attacks here, you have someone deciding
- 50:12over that list that is a malicious person. you
- 50:16can effectively create a network of malicious
- 50:18nodes that are monitoring and tracking user traffic.
- 50:22So we needed to solve this problem. And this
- 50:24is where the blockchain comes in, and this is
- 50:26where the token comes in. So we have a blockchain
- 50:29where anybody who gets hold of NIM tokens, and
- 50:34that can be they can buy an exchange, they can
- 50:36win it in a competition, they're kind of out
- 50:38there in the world. We don't control them. They
- 50:40get hold of NIM tokens. they can use those tokens
- 50:44to what's called bond a node to the network.
- 50:49And that happens via a smart contract that lives
- 50:51on the blockchain. So it's effectively entirely
- 50:54out of our control. So what that means is we
- 50:57don't control the list of nodes that are in the
- 50:59NIM network. It is something that happens purely
- 51:02via economics, purely via people getting NIM
- 51:05tokens out there in the market. bonding those
- 51:08NIM tokens, which basically means locking them.
- 51:10I'm trying to use kind of simplified words here,
- 51:12locking them on the blockchain, which is a signal
- 51:15to say, I want to be part of this network and
- 51:18start routing user traffic. In return, they also
- 51:21get rewarded and paid via NIM tokens. So when
- 51:24they successfully route user traffic, they get
- 51:27paid in NIM tokens that they can then sell in
- 51:29the market and redeem their operating costs.
- 51:32But there's even more to the logic here. The
- 51:37next question is, how can we make sure that these
- 51:40operators are actually doing a good job of routing
- 51:42user traffic? And that's where we invite a broader
- 51:45community. So anybody who holds NIM tokens that
- 51:48might not, you know, feel like they're experts
- 51:50in running servers, but they want to kind of
- 51:53somehow be involved, they can do what's called
- 51:55staking on NIM nodes. So they can look at the
- 51:58list of nodes, they can see who's doing a good
- 52:01job, who's like, you know, providing quality
- 52:03service. And then they lock their tokens onto
- 52:06that node, which performs, it becomes a kind
- 52:09of reputation for that node. So the node gains
- 52:12kind of community reputation by getting a lot
- 52:14of stake from the community. And the better the
- 52:17community reputation, the more work is invited
- 52:20to perform in the network. And the more rewards
- 52:23it starts earning. And then it distributes those
- 52:26rewards to everybody that's staking on that node.
- 52:29So it becomes this whole community involvement
- 52:31around. reputation for providing a good quality
- 52:34of service and a kind of distribution mechanism
- 52:37also for distributing the value of the network
- 52:40out to both operators and stakers. So that's
- 52:44the use of the token. You know, here it's both
- 52:46economic, but it's also technical. And it solves
- 52:49a very important question of how can we actually
- 52:52make sure we have a properly decentralized network
- 52:55so that we can secure people's privacy in a good
- 52:59way. And the idea is that that work is what represents
- 53:04the value. Yaya, thank you very much for this
- 53:08time, for all your knowledge, for simplifying
- 53:12the concepts and for bringing this topic in a
- 53:17really simple way. Thank you. This episode was
- 53:21inspired by the chorus to rethink the digital
- 53:23systems that shape our lives and to ask who they
- 53:27truly serve. Yaya's path. shows that building
- 53:30technology is also about building values. She
- 53:33challenges to create systems that empower rather
- 53:36than control, where privacy, equity, and transparency
- 53:39are not optional, but foundational. Science Behind
- 53:44the Glass is an independent produced and edited
- 53:47podcast hosted by Linda Hernandez and Daniel
- 53:50Esguerra. With the invaluable support of our
- 53:52technical director, Rafael Giordano, and the
- 53:54original music by our colleague and friend, Bernardo
- 53:57Aguila. Follow us on Instagram, X, Facebook,
- 54:00TikTok, and LinkedIn. And visit our website for
- 54:03more stories, resources, and updates. Don't forget
- 54:06to subscribe and share this podcast with your
- 54:08friends, colleagues, and community to amplify
- 54:10these essential conversations. If you enjoyed
- 54:13this episode, we invite you to support us with
- 54:15a contribution via PayPal. Just click the Support
- 54:18Us button on our website. Your support is vital
- 54:21for this project to keep growing. Thank you for
- 54:24listening. Keep questioning, sharing, and celebrating
- 54:27science made from every corner of the world.
- 54:29Until next time.