Latest / I Love You Keep Going with George Haas / Purification of Mind Part 1
Transcript
- 0:00You're listening to the deepening, your practice podcast
- 0:03with George Haas, deepening. Your practice is recorded at the
- 0:07against this dream, Buddhist Meditation Society in Los
- 0:10Angeles. California for more information,
- 0:12visit our website at www.medicare.gov dot-org.
- 0:17That's www.a me. TT a gr, oup dot-org.
- 0:26So, welcome everybody. This is deepening your practice,
- 0:30deepening. Your practice is intended as an
- 0:33intermediate or advanced class. And what that really means is
- 0:35that I don't offer basic meditation, instruction, I
- 0:38expect you all ready to know that.
- 0:42That being said, if you find that, I am talking about
- 0:44something and you don't understand what I'm talking
- 0:46about. I'm happy to answer any
- 0:47questions. I'm just not going to include
- 0:49basic instruction. We've been talking about the man
- 0:56Manual of insight, the new translation of the Maha see
- 1:00Manual of insight and we're talking about purification of
- 1:05mind. Purification of mind or mental
- 1:21purification are translation of the Pali word, Citta vasudha.
- 1:27Sativas sooty. The preeminent element of City
- 1:30velocity is Citta or mind. And one cultivate strong
- 1:35concentration by means of Tranquility or Insight
- 1:38Meditation. The mind is no longer distracted
- 1:40by thoughts and other hindrances.
- 1:44Such pure concentration, continuously focused on an
- 1:47object, of either Tranquility or Insight is considered mental
- 1:51purification. A mind associated.
- 1:54With such concentration is also purified of hindrances, do ^,
- 1:58the concentration, There are three types of mental
- 2:02purification. There are three types of
- 2:06concentration, that entail purification of Mind, accents,
- 2:09access or neighborhood concentration, absorption
- 2:13concentration, and momentary concentration.
- 2:18Access concentration, one develops access concentration,
- 2:22by contemplating a conceptual object of meditation.
- 2:26In order to block hindering thoughts.
- 2:29It is called access or neighborhood concentration
- 2:31because it nears absorption concentration.
- 2:35True access concentration can be aroused by contemplating a
- 2:39visual object, such as a colored disk piscina the impurities of
- 2:44the body, mindfulness of the body, the in and out breaths, Of
- 2:48the four Divine, abodes, or immaterial out in materiality.
- 2:54Contemplating the eight kinds of recollection.
- 2:57The perception of impurity, or the analysis of the four
- 3:00elements. Cannot arouse true
- 3:02concentration. Concentration aroused using
- 3:08three objects. Cannot be considered true excess
- 3:10concentration because it does not have the potential to lead
- 3:14to absorption concentration. It is nevertheless typically
- 3:19referred to as access concentration because it
- 3:21produces similar results in terms of suppressing hindrances.
- 3:27So access concentration is the, in some sense.
- 3:33The minimum level of concentration that you need in
- 3:36order to do either meta practice, or to do inside,
- 3:41practice inside or loving, kindness practice, I like to
- 3:47talk about these things in terms of specific goals that you can
- 3:51evaluate. So that you have a sense of
- 3:54whether or not you've achieved it or And so I would describe
- 3:59access concentration as being able to count up and down to 10
- 4:03on the out, breath only for a period of ten minutes without
- 4:08losing count even months. Anybody think that they can do
- 4:12that here? so, It is a question of
- 4:20developing this and it isn't a big hurdle.
- 4:22Really, I would say that if you did a breath counting practice
- 4:27for 10 minutes a day, it would take about two or three months
- 4:32to develop that level of concentration doing in teaching
- 4:36for these years that I've been teaching, I've only had one
- 4:39student to couldn't do that. Access concentration is able to
- 4:47still the mind. And then absorption
- 4:49concentration is more of a jhana practice.
- 4:52Any thoughts or questions about the access concentration?
- 4:56Does that make sense? These different things that they
- 5:03described here a visual object, to casino or impurities of the
- 5:06body, mindfulness of the body in and out of the breadth of for
- 5:09divine, abodes and materiality are all different objects that
- 5:13you could focus on the in and out of the breath is one of the
- 5:18objects that I'm describing as the means of developing access
- 5:22concentration. And it's, I don't think it's any
- 5:26better or worse than any of the other ones.
- 5:28It's just the one that I was trained on when Was this
- 5:32originally trying to do this and it's the one that is stuck with
- 5:36me. I like working with the breath
- 5:39because as an object, it's always available and simple.
- 5:47Okay. Objects here.
- 6:09Used to access to get that access from situation like the
- 6:12Divine go. Go to Michael's the body, some
- 6:16more insight. So, just kind of cancer.
- 6:35Well, it would depend on how you're doing the technique?
- 6:38Are you doing it as an Insight practice or in doing it solely
- 6:42to develop concentration? I think that would be the
- 6:45distinction. Well, the concentration inside
- 7:02practice. So, Maja seems describing here
- 7:06but we would call a wet inside practice where you develop the
- 7:09concentration first. And I think that this is
- 7:13actually the difference between Retreat teacher and somebody who
- 7:17teaches. In a meditation center where
- 7:21people are not often going on Retreat.
- 7:24Who goes on, at least one Retreat, a year here. so, what's
- 7:28that about half of the people and then who goes on to Retreats
- 7:32a year, So then we're down to a quarter of the people and who
- 7:37goes on three Retreats a year. And so we're still in that
- 7:42twenty percent. If you go on Retreat and you
- 7:48said a week-long retreat, and you do the 8 hours of practice a
- 7:52day, you're likely to generate the access level concentration.
- 7:56Enough to do your Technique without needing anything else.
- 8:00But if you don't do that, it's unlikely.
- 8:04That I think just doing an Insight practice as a
- 8:07householder who doesn't go on a lot of Retreats, you will
- 8:10develop enough concentration to be able to do your Insight
- 8:14practice, but I This one, I started teaching here.
- 8:18The just the most basic Insight practices that were dead.
- 8:24Simple for me to do, nobody could do because they didn't
- 8:27have access level concentration. And so that's when I began to
- 8:32teach the breath counting here because I'm if you can't hold
- 8:39your attention long enough on the object of meditation, the
- 8:42insides don't arise. And if your Sitting for short
- 8:46periods of time. You know, how long do you sit
- 8:53who sits for an hour? so, a small number who sits for
- 9:0145 minutes, So a bigger number who sits for half an hour.
- 9:08Booth. So, who sits for 20 minutes.
- 9:14If you sit for an hour, you're also sitting for 20 minutes, I'm
- 9:17trying to reach the point where everybody is raising their
- 9:21hands. I know, at the lowest common
- 9:24denominator and who sits for 10 minutes, is that getting
- 9:28everybody up? So, so in the 10 or 15-minute
- 9:32range of trying to do Insight practice it, Likely that you're
- 9:38going to be able to develop enough concentration, actually
- 9:41to get much inside out of the practice.
- 9:43So you may find a sense of frustration, or you may come to
- 9:49believe that actually, inside practice doesn't do that much,
- 9:52doesn't really produce that much, because you're not
- 9:54actually able to hold the object of meditation.
- 9:58Well, enough for the insight to arrive.
- 10:02Even doing something basic like 10 minutes of concentration,
- 10:06practice three times a week over a period of two or three months,
- 10:10you'll develop a sufficient level of concentration.
- 10:13That then you can move into the inside practice and that will
- 10:17actually begin to Bear the fruit of inside practice that.
- 10:20You wouldn't have been able to get it too.
- 10:33Practices. Both in trying to do those
- 10:38techniques. I don't understand.
- 10:40I know meta. I know my voice.
- 10:43I don't know what I'm doing concentration.
- 10:48Again, it's how you do the technique whether whether or not
- 10:52your focus is on Insight or on developing mental or on
- 10:55developing concentration? I teach here a concentration
- 11:00based meta practice And the purpose of that is to develop a
- 11:06strong enough ability to concentrate in meta that you can
- 11:10use it as a refuge. One of the things about the
- 11:15Insight practice is it can be dis regulating.
- 11:17You can be disturbing depending on how defended you are against
- 11:23your own conditioning. Some of us don't really like to
- 11:28have an experience, an authentic experience of ourselves and So
- 11:33we masks that and we present them in authentic way of being
- 11:37in the world. Then mindfulness or Insight
- 11:40Meditation is very good at cutting through that.
- 11:43But then you have to have the experience of actually how you
- 11:46are and if that is troubling to you, it can be quite disturbing
- 11:52but that's making sense. So you get bent out of shape
- 11:57doing the inside practice. And if you don't have a place to
- 12:00come to, to a draw from that to recollect and come back into
- 12:04balance, it can make you very timid about going and doing much
- 12:08Insight practice. But if you have a place that you
- 12:11can withdraw to That you can actually feel safe and secure
- 12:16and, and allow the body-mind to rebalance in that place of
- 12:22safety. It actually makes you pretty
- 12:23Fearless in terms of being willing to do your Insight
- 12:27practice. So that this is integrating
- 12:31meant of a positive. For me, has been incredibly
- 12:33useful in that a highly concentrated met to state, where
- 12:37you're in a place, a conscious experience of kindness and
- 12:42peace. Even though the the body-mind is
- 12:46is in the state of disruption allows time for the body-mind to
- 12:51come back into balance and then you can come out of the meta and
- 12:55go back into the Insight practice.
- 13:00So what if you do a mentor and you're constantly repeating,
- 13:06really important quality that you would have?
- 13:08If you would like to have for yourself for yourself, is that
- 13:12concentration or so inside? There's something inside.
- 13:22Is my like mindfulness. Just free for me watching your
- 13:26thoughts, not getting a text or correct, okay?
- 13:30And concentration is like, counting, your breaths.
- 13:33Like you suggested for correct? Say three or four words over and
- 13:40over again, right? As meant to that concentration.
- 13:44It Is So Meta. Do can be done as a wet or dry
- 13:48practice, as well as for positive can be done.
- 13:50A wet or dry practice. It's just for referring to a
- 13:53different wetness in this traditionally concentration, is
- 14:04the Tranquility technique was the offset to insult heating up,
- 14:09right? So he had a balance between a
- 14:13concentration technique, let's get right down here breath, I'm
- 14:17not decomposing the brass but really just focusing.
- 14:20Under breath as route. That's the Tranquility offset to
- 14:25inside practices, getting over here.
- 14:27That's right. So when you combine what you're
- 14:31doing is taking the matter and focusing on mind State as an
- 14:37object of concentration is sort of like a double whammy you're
- 14:41getting the Tranquility, correct concentration along with the
- 14:44time. Call mr.
- 14:47Thompson Medford of the various options.
- 14:53You could get because it wouldn't happen.
- 15:02Which is, which is what Maja see is saying in this, in terms of
- 15:06developing access code, is that making sense everybody?
- 15:09What what's being said, in some sense, it's if you'll forgive
- 15:15the meta phrase of killing two birds with one stone, You're
- 15:23developing concentration and meta as an offset to the heating
- 15:27up of the past and of which makes you a totally Fearless
- 15:31Insight practitioner because you know whatever trouble you get
- 15:35into. You can withdraw safely and ride
- 15:38it out and then emerge again and go right back into the Insight
- 15:44practice I find it. How much of a daredevil you are?
- 15:54Could you maybe Define what you mean by wet?
- 15:58Like I know what meta or well. I know in metal, practice like
- 16:04dry matter practices, you're saying the phrases.
- 16:07When you don't necessarily mean them, sort of in the hopes that
- 16:11you get there and then you are feeling it.
- 16:16So in wet matter, the purpose of the meditation is to generate
- 16:20the feeling of loving kindness in the body.
- 16:22So it's an embodied approach to the practice, the danger with
- 16:26wet meant to is that you're not in true metal, but you're in
- 16:30sentimentality. So you're generating a
- 16:35repetition of the phrase or repetition of story that is
- 16:39intended to generate a feeling of loving kindness.
- 16:42In the body true met is the Variants of the present moment
- 16:48in that feeling and sentiment tally would be caught up in the
- 16:51thought. That's generating, the feeling
- 16:54in the body is that distinction? Clear No, could you?
- 17:08Describe a little more. At least in your own words, the
- 17:12difference between sentimentality and
- 17:18loving-kindness. So Meta.
- 17:22True meta is in the present moment and sentimentality is in
- 17:28the thought that generates the feeling.
- 17:31So, rather than you lose awareness of the present moment
- 17:35and get caught up in thinking, and then you're in the storyline
- 17:39that's generating the Metro that would be sentimentality the near
- 17:42enemy like a Nostalgia, right? Yeah.
- 17:46So you're in a tearjerker rather than in the present moment.
- 17:51Wet Meadow is designed for the feeling in the body dry meta is
- 17:56a concentration oriented meditation.
- 17:59So the focus is not in the body, but it's in the mind state.
- 18:04So, dry meta. The object of meditation is the
- 18:07Mind state of meta the filter. The, that part of it and wet
- 18:12meta is focused in the body. Looking at the emotional
- 18:16experience of The felt sense of loving kindness in the body.
- 18:24The problem with wet meta is that it's almost always based on
- 18:29the generation of a thought. So, in some sense, it's a
- 18:31self-generated emotional experience, which would take you
- 18:36out of the present moment into the thought itself.
- 18:38And then you would not be in true metal.
- 18:41You would be in thinking, is that making sense?
- 18:44Now, in a concentration oriented method, where the dry matter,
- 18:48where your focus is on the Mind, state of matter, you're
- 18:51absolutely in the experience of the present moment.
- 18:55And the experience of the present moment is filtered
- 18:59through the Mind state of loving-kindness.
- 19:01So you're in the present moment in the experience of
- 19:05loving-kindness rather than the potential of being caught up in
- 19:09the thought that generates a facsimile of that experience.
- 19:18So we also do, we all sort of start out dry?
- 19:23And then you kind of move into wet or it's not even know.
- 19:27I would say that most of the instruction you're going to
- 19:29receive in meta in our culture is going to be wet meta.
- 19:33You're going to be intentionally generating a thought that
- 19:37produces a feeling of loving kindness.
- 19:40And if you could be in the present moment in the experience
- 19:44of that, then you would be untrue met to.
- 19:46But what often happens is, it's so easy to drift into the
- 19:50thought. That's generating that your
- 19:52know. Longer in the present moment in
- 19:55the experience of metal, your caught up in the sentimental
- 19:58thinking process. With the dry met to practice.
- 20:02Since there's the body is not included as the object of
- 20:06meditation. It's much harder to get pulled
- 20:08into sentimentality. And then you can go into meta
- 20:14John on these deeply concentrated states that are
- 20:19incredibly Blissful. So that the the experience of
- 20:24bliss and the body is not generated by thinking, it's
- 20:27generated by being concentrated. And and it's a much it's a much
- 20:34more intense experience. If you can get in to say that
- 20:38the third method Jonna is incredibly Blissful and almost
- 20:43unceasingly Blissful. Whereas the the the the
- 20:48experience of loving-kindness that's generated by the
- 20:52repetition of phrases and thought is is only Blissful to
- 20:57the extent that you can generate it.
- 21:01And now isn't drying at the also the reputation of the same
- 21:04phrases the in TriMet. The object of meditation is the
- 21:09Mind state of meta and the phrases are secondary.
- 21:12The intention of the Met is secondary.
- 21:16You're really narrowly focused just on the Mind state.
- 21:21So, you know, first off you have to be able to distinguish the
- 21:24Mind state of meta from all of the other mines states that you
- 21:27might notice once your have an awareness of what a mind state
- 21:30of mint is like, it's is perfectly obvious as the mindset
- 21:34of anger is, and you know, whether it's there or not, and
- 21:38then you can develop strategies for bringing it to mind in
- 21:45developing dry Mentor. For instance, it's useful to do
- 21:47an inventory of people that you know, because Do you need to do
- 21:52the practice for one person intentionally but some people
- 21:56when you bring them to mind, they bring with them, the Mind
- 21:58state of meta and some people when you bring them to mind,
- 22:02they bring a complex relationship that has kindness
- 22:05and anger or lust or longing, or all sorts of different
- 22:09experiences disappointment. And so, you look for these very
- 22:15simple relationships or just the thought of the person, brings
- 22:19the mind in. Into kindness and then you
- 22:23perpetuate that that mind state of kindness and narrowly focus
- 22:29on it. So it's a tiny object so it's
- 22:31easy to become highly concentrated on it.
- 22:35So you go into absorption in the mindset of meta the same way
- 22:40that you would in on the breath or some other way of going in to
- 22:48John or absorption. But because you've chosen the
- 22:52object of meta, it also has the capacity of enhancing your.
- 22:56Your capacity for metal, which is the two in one piece.
- 23:03And so we talked about drying over only talking on Medevac
- 23:05Place. Well, dry and wet.
- 23:07Also applies to the past and practice, but it's, but it's the
- 23:11wetness is different. That's what I was saying.
- 23:13So, in wet and dry the Pasadena you're talking about, whether
- 23:20there's a separate concentration practice or there isn't a
- 23:24separate concentration practice. So, in Drive opossum NE, there's
- 23:29no way. Central focus on developing
- 23:31excess concentration. You simply do the Insight
- 23:35practice with no attendant effort at developing
- 23:39concentration, in a wet of a positive practice.
- 23:43There is a period of intentional generation of concentration
- 23:47before you go into the inside part.
- 23:52So if you're if you for instance, if you call in to
- 23:54morning meditation on the concentration and insight,
- 23:57there's a period of ten minutes of concentrated.
- 24:00Rating the mind and then you go into the Insight practice.
- 24:03So that's a wet for pasta. So Drive.
- 24:07Awesome. Concentration right before you
- 24:18just go straight into the Insight technique.
- 24:23How is everybody doing what this is?
- 24:24Is it too technical or you staying with us?
- 24:32Loosely termed faking it until you make it stick it, till you
- 24:35make it. No, the wet meta.
- 24:38It can be useful. It's the near enemy of of meta.
- 24:43When you practice that way is sentimentality, the near enemy
- 24:47is called the near enemy because it's easy to confuse the two
- 24:51states. So you could do wet meta and be
- 24:56in true meta and that would be a fine way to practice.
- 25:01But what I notice in my teaching practice, is that most of the
- 25:08people that I encounter that are doing that, practice are
- 25:10actually not in met to their in sentimentality, and they can't
- 25:14distinguish the difference between it so that the mind is
- 25:18generating a feeling of loving kindness, but they're not in the
- 25:21experience of that. They're in the story that's
- 25:23generating it. With, with the dry meta.
- 25:29It's much harder to get caught into the sentimentality because
- 25:34they're there isn't that intentional generation of an
- 25:36emotion, the emotion arises in the body, it's not an object of
- 25:40meditation, so you just let it go on in the background.
- 25:43So it has less gripping, power to pull you into it.
- 25:48And then if you can get into Jonna while you're doing dry
- 25:52meta you end up in Suka, which is bliss, which is much more
- 25:57intense than almost any self-generated emotion that you
- 26:01can do so that you have the, you don't miss out on that that
- 26:06emotional component that comes from what meta?
- 26:09And actually experience is much more intense if in terms of that
- 26:15and that case Bliss is also felt in the body.
- 26:20Yeah. The whole body.
- 26:21Really, you know, John a, is five aspects, the first jhana is
- 26:29the Toca which is sip attacker. Vicara can't remember at the
- 26:35moment the taka is where you place your attention.
- 26:41The Pali word for placing your attention.
- 26:43These are the five qualities that are make up the experience
- 26:46of the first jhana. This Would be absorption
- 26:49concentration. You place your attention on the
- 26:52object of meditation so you would place your attention.
- 26:56If you were doing meted practice on the Mind state of meta youth
- 27:01sustained at that speed Cara. So you place and sustain your
- 27:05attention then you wait for PT to arise.
- 27:09PT is often translated as Rapture but mostly I noticed it
- 27:14as an energy in the body of vibrating energy in the body.
- 27:19The there's a kind of emotional response to the vibrating energy
- 27:23in the body which is called Suka Suka is kind of the opposite of
- 27:27dukkha and that's often translated as Bliss.
- 27:30So it's an intensely pleasant experience that arises in
- 27:35reaction to the PT in the body. And then you come into eka
- 27:39gotta, which is one pointedness and that would be absorption
- 27:43concentration. The first jhana.
- 27:46Uh-huh. Suka, Suka, Suka do guys like
- 27:55you have to get up and take a shower, right?
- 27:58Dukkha sugars. I mean, okay.
- 28:13No, that would be equanimity. Which is peka different.
- 28:19Here's the trick between the paws and Jonna and meta Jonna
- 28:24meta. John is limited to the third
- 28:27jhana, we're talking about the commentary level, not that
- 28:30canonical level. Because in meta there's always
- 28:34an intention for something and in Equanimity there's no
- 28:39intention it's perfect balance. So Meta is always intending the
- 28:44kindness, always radiating out the kindness towards somebody in
- 28:49particular, or to all beings. And so there's always an
- 28:52inclining and it so it can't be perfectly Economist.
- 28:56So when you talk about focusing, John and practice on met You
- 29:02know that there's a limit to it, but it's a perfect way to go.
- 29:07You go into the third jhana and meta and then when you want to
- 29:11go into the 4th jhana, you switch into the positive
- 29:14practice and go into the fourth job.
- 29:20How do you switch? So, you go from meta to you
- 29:25switch techniques and go into an Insight technique from a meta
- 29:30technique. So let's say that you want to
- 29:34explore the First Foundation of mindfulness.
- 29:38You go into a say a technique of noticing sensation in the body.
- 29:42So you look for sensory Clarity around sensation in the body
- 29:46might say use a shins and young technique, see her feel so you
- 29:51go from Mayo, may may be peaceful now, you'll be
- 29:56peaceful, maybe peaceful focused on the Mind state of meta and
- 30:01then Drop into the body and start tracking which sense gate
- 30:06the sensory experiences that you're drawn to and then if you
- 30:11wanted to add to that an exploration of the second
- 30:14Foundation of mindfulness, fading are feeling tones.
- 30:17You'd note for sensory Clarity and then you'd note for feeling
- 30:21tones and then if you wanted to really make it intense, you
- 30:25could add the third foundation and be looking at weather.
- 30:31You're craving aversive unconscious or actually in
- 30:36Equanimity with it which I would.
- 30:39I like to do as a triple noting practice?
- 30:47You don't come out, you could maintain the John in that.
- 30:52Where are you could also lose it and continue with the positive.
- 30:58Well I noticed I noticed for instance, doing pool work, pool
- 31:10is working with some meta sized emotion.
- 31:13That actually one of the objects of the meditation is PT because
- 31:17that's the energy that holds the emotion and watching the
- 31:20releases that it was easy to stay and say third jhana and be
- 31:25with that releasing process. But let's go through the John.
- 31:33It's because we are talking about purification of mine and
- 31:36we are talking about absorption. So the topic you place, your
- 31:42attention vaccari sustain your attention, PT arises Rapture
- 31:46arises smoke, arises Bliss, arises and then one point of
- 31:51this arises after got the first John is kind of unstable so you
- 31:56bounce in and out of it, but as it coalesces, as it stabilizes,
- 32:01you drop into the second jhana and you no longer need to apply
- 32:05or sustain your attention because it's stabilized.
- 32:08So then you have Rapture Bliss and and one-pointedness.
- 32:14But the the PT is, of course, energetic feeling in the body, a
- 32:19lot of energy in it. And so when you go into the
- 32:23third jhana, the PT goes and you're just in Bliss.
- 32:29And one pointedness, shinzen is always called this the most
- 32:34pernicious trap in meditation that you get into the third
- 32:38jhana. It's so pleasant.
- 32:40And so Blissful that you're just Bliss out and stay there, and
- 32:45you abandon any further Insight practice,
- 32:59figure out how to get there efficiently in their practice
- 33:01and they just come in and then they Bliss out for an hour and
- 33:05then they come out and they and that's their their practice.
- 33:10Yeah, certainly well. Let me see, I can tell you that
- 33:23for two and a half years of my practice.
- 33:25That's what I did. And I would I could drop in.
- 33:31I would drop into full rest and I would go into Jonna and would
- 33:34be very Blissful. And I would just hang out there.
- 33:37And after two and a half years shins and said to me, you're not
- 33:41making any progress, you should stop doing it.
- 33:45But and I was simply talking to him about the nature of my
- 33:48practice and from the the reporting that I was doing to
- 33:53him, he was noticing that my forward Insight practice had
- 33:58arrested itself and so I just stopped doing it.
- 34:03So now I don't really have a facility just to drop in there
- 34:07like I did before because I haven't been focused on it but I
- 34:11thought it was an interesting remark because I didn't have the
- 34:14Option that I wasn't making any progress.
- 34:17I thought it seemed totally fine to me.
- 34:23Third, jhana. If you're talking about a meta
- 34:26Jonna, then the third John is as far as you can go.
- 34:31So Bliss and one pointedness with the intention to radiate
- 34:37that out to someone else is as far as you can go and met
- 34:40dijanna in order to proceed further, you would have to
- 34:44abandon meta and go into vipassana John.
- 34:46Oh, so you would let go of the Bliss.
- 34:49You would renounce the Bliss and come into Equanimity and one
- 34:53pointedness. And those are the four embodied.
- 34:58Material, John has. There are also then four more
- 35:03genres, which are the non material or non embodied.
- 35:08John has, the fifth one is called the sphere of Infinite
- 35:12Space. Or sometimes a big mind, they
- 35:17call it, but the sense of the Consciousness, the sense of
- 35:24awareness becomes massively, expands at all as big as the
- 35:28sky. And you have the sense of being
- 35:31in this concentrated State. That's huge.
- 35:36And then the six, China is called the sphere of infinite
- 35:40Consciousness. And it's characterized by the
- 35:43formation of Seen it for most people which is a bright white
- 35:47light that seems to be right here.
- 35:49I was on a retreat up in Santa Barbara the first time I had
- 35:53that experience and I thought that somebody had parked the car
- 35:57in front of me and the headlights were off shining in
- 36:00my eyes and I thought, how could they possibly get a car there?
- 36:04That I opened my eyes. Of course, there was no car and
- 36:08then I close my eyes again. It was this bright white light.
- 36:14And then the 7th jhana is called the the sphere of no thinness.
- 36:24and, When I was talking to shinzen about the experience, it
- 36:28was like a, in some sense, a Halo of Crystal and blue light
- 36:33that was surrounding, and there was nothing else.
- 36:36Just that awareness in this sort of crystalline blue light and
- 36:43that one tended to be quite stable.
- 36:45And then the 8th jhana is the sphere of neither perception,
- 36:50nor non-perception, which is my experience of, it was total
- 36:55blackness. And just awareness, but nothing
- 36:59too sense. and often times, this is Miss perceived as the same
- 37:06thing as the cessation experience, but there's no
- 37:10awareness in cessation, whereas, in the 8th jhana, there is this
- 37:16awareness without anything to be aware of If that makes sense, I
- 37:24have never been able to do these more esoteric, or arrive at
- 37:30these more esoteric States except in long retreat practice
- 37:35and then it then it seems to be pretty ordinary there if that's
- 37:40the focus of the practice. But again this is not an Insight
- 37:44practice. This is concentration practice.
- 37:48And so the then the question is, what is the purpose of your
- 37:52practice? Are you here to have psychedelic
- 37:56experiences or you here to get free?
- 38:00I guess that would be one way to put it.
- 38:13They're not. You want to have enough
- 38:16concentration so that you can do the Insight techniques.
- 38:23So, excess concentration actually would be enough, but if
- 38:27you could come into the first jhana and then go into the
- 38:29Pasadena, you might have an easier time with Insight
- 38:34technique, go to the second or the third one of the reasons
- 38:38that I like them. The concentrated met Jonna
- 38:41practices that you come into this very kind and peaceful
- 38:45place so that you can then go into the Insight practice from
- 38:49this place of extraordinary kindness and if it's a kindness
- 38:53You hold for yourself then in actually being able to see your
- 38:59conditioning, which often we hold with very harsh judgment
- 39:04without having brought the Mind into a place of kindness.
- 39:07First, that can be a very Jagged experience.
- 39:11But if you bring the Mind into this deeply kind place in regard
- 39:15to yourself, This lack of judgment, then when you go into
- 39:19the deposit of practice and see these these Conditioned
- 39:24experiences this condition way that you respond to the world.
- 39:28It's much easier to be in there with it, I don't know.
- 39:35Are you suggesting that in the same city?
- 39:39To practice dry Mecca before going inside.
- 39:44Yeah, absolutely. It would be an efficient way to
- 39:48do it. Ten minutes of dry meta and then
- 39:51go into your repository, Practice What word, what I'm
- 39:55doing now on my, my Retreats is I'm doing five days of pure meta
- 40:02first. And then going into the pasta in
- 40:06this concentrated, deeply concentrated, but
- 40:09extraordinarily kind place. And I can tell you that in doing
- 40:13this, that the result is Ben Really different in terms of the
- 40:19reporting from students. The students that were sitting
- 40:23just a straight repository tree would be reporting real hardship
- 40:28and holding onto the experience of a lot of their conditioning,
- 40:33but doing the five days of met beforehand.
- 40:36I had on the last two Retreats, I had zero reports of that was
- 40:41really startling how different it was to settle into this
- 40:46place. Of really deep kindness for
- 40:49yourself and then go to look at the conditioning and what a
- 40:54contrast that was to the very harsh judgment.
- 40:57That a lot of people experience when I really attempt to look
- 41:00deeply at their conditioning Are they actually still is?
- 41:47Value is. Right.
- 42:43Hopefully, what I've been. Saying.
- 42:45At least, as far as I know the higher levels, you're talking
- 42:52about the ones that just have like Morgan experience, is that
- 42:55something that you use for insight when you're there?
- 43:00What I noticed in my own practices that when I got very
- 43:04deeply into the inside practice, they would arise as a result of
- 43:08doing the inside practice and it would be a CO commitment
- 43:12experience. I would be in that that level of
- 43:16John, and but I would also be pursuing some insight actus
- 43:25Levels of job. And other ones you can see like,
- 43:30I guess. It's got a phrase attached to
- 43:45describe, what some of the experience?
- 43:49Well, I don't know if I have a good answer for that.
- 43:56I think that it's useful to know what they are because that that
- 44:00depending on how you practice it, you may have those
- 44:03experiences and it's useful to know that they are not the same
- 44:07thing as enlightenment. I guess that would be the main
- 44:11value that I would find in it. It's a, it's a, such a different
- 44:16experience of being in that mind that mind than it is to be in an
- 44:21ordinary mind. And in the beginning before
- 44:24you've had say, stream entry or one of those experiences, you
- 44:30may think that you've gotten there.
- 44:32And so to understand that actually that isn't there, it's
- 44:36the 7th jhana. Worthy 8th jhana is used.
- 44:40You saying that the on those jobs, there's an Enlightenment
- 44:44later on enlightenment is different than that.
- 44:48So I think of you, if you or at least the stories of the Buddha
- 44:54that we're told that in the beginning of his practice, he
- 44:58studied with the teacher and I forget the name and that they
- 45:01were doing John and practice and he got to the eighth level of
- 45:04John Andrews. Very skilled at getting at the
- 45:05eighth level of China and the that's what they were saying was
- 45:09enlightened. It.
- 45:09And that the Buddhist Discovery. Was that actually that isn't it,
- 45:13but Enlightenment is something different than that. so the way
- 45:21that you just described it, that's kind of housing that a to
- 45:24like, People who are highly concentrated or having these
- 45:28experiences and then reporting back and people are having to
- 45:33sort of like these common experiences.
- 45:35And then we're like, just sort of labeling them, five, six,
- 45:39seven, eight. Like, oh, that happened to me,
- 45:41too. That is that kind of you talking
- 45:44about? I'm not understanding that like
- 45:51that the genres are like, they're like common experiences
- 45:54that people are having rights. Like, yeah, I got really
- 45:57concentrated and I I saw the bright light.
- 46:01I said that too. So we're going to call that.
- 46:03Right, exactly. Okay gotcha.
- 46:10You don't have to do any of that and you can still pursue Insight
- 46:14practice, you just have to have access level concentration in
- 46:17order to do that be concentrated enough, that you can do the
- 46:21technique, well, enough to get the Insight from it and, and
- 46:25that's different. But we do come back to this
- 46:29question of, do you have access level concentration?
- 46:32So that you can do the inside techniques or not?
- 46:36And how do you do then develop them?
- 46:38But if you're In the process of developing concentration, you
- 46:42may notice that these other John experience happen.
- 46:47But you know, it's also depending on the, this school of
- 46:51thought rotation is a very popular teacher does not believe
- 46:56in meta, does not believe in concentration.
- 46:58Practice is object of meditation is a mind State and just paying
- 47:04attention to the Mind State. Because the thing that he thinks
- 47:07will take you to To Liberation and that may be true.
- 47:13But it's only true if you can focus on the Mind State.
- 47:16Well enough to know whether it's there or not.
- 47:17And if you don't have a basic level of concentration, you
- 47:21won't be able to do that. So we're then back again, to the
- 47:25question of how many Retreats are you going on each year, to
- 47:29be able to develop a drive appositive practice, where you
- 47:33don't need to do any additional concentration work?
- 47:37And if you're not going on two or three, For Retreats a year
- 47:40it's unlikely that you're going to be able to develop sufficient
- 47:44concentration and then I would be advocating that you do a wet
- 47:48for pus in a practice. And I teach that pretty much
- 47:51exclusively because in our community here, people are not
- 47:55going on multiple Retreats a year.
- 47:58If people are going on, say one Retreat, a year that isn't going
- 48:02to do it. It's not going to be enough.
- 48:27The game having straight at self-inquiry called is Pretty
- 48:31Tough call. Yeah, unless you have a
- 48:33naturally concentrated mind, or you've done some kind of
- 48:37Athletics, where you've developed it, or you've done
- 48:39some kind of dance where you've developed it or you've developed
- 48:42it somewhere. Alright, with accounting,
- 48:47practice, for instance, I every now and then somebody who
- 48:50competitively swam came in and they can do it immediately, I
- 48:55can do the highest most Complex levels of counting immediately
- 48:59because they've trained to do it.
- 49:01So you have to really look at where you're at, but I want to
- 49:04talk momentarily about the last kind of concentration, which is
- 49:10momentary concentration when an Insight Meditation practitioners
- 49:15Faith effort. Mindfulness, concentration, and
- 49:18wisdom. Did you get that?
- 49:19They, at first, the fullness and wisdom have become strong, and
- 49:25balanced the process of meditation continues.
- 49:27With uninterrupted Purity, thoughts or other hindrances.
- 49:31Do not interfere with the process at such times each and
- 49:34every noting produces a strong and clear concentration on the
- 49:38physical or mental phenomena. That is the object of
- 49:41meditation. This is momentary concentration
- 49:44aroused by moment-to-moment observation.
- 49:49So this may not seem particularly controversial But
- 50:00Maha sees advocation for the momentary.
- 50:04Concentration was at one time extremely controversial because
- 50:09the one-pointedness the absorption was the standard and
- 50:14the idea that you could allow the mind to be drawn from one
- 50:17object to one object to one object, one one object and
- 50:21momentarily concentrate on each of those experiences and that
- 50:25that would lead to a deeply concentrated mind.
- 50:30Hi hotly, debated by everybody. What's interesting about this, I
- 50:37think to understand is the reason that this came about was
- 50:41because Maja see understood in this lineage?
- 50:47At the time that if they did, not provide a way for
- 50:50householders to practice that Buddhism itself, was in Jeopardy
- 50:54of being lost the British invaded Burma and they declared
- 50:59Buddhism non-religion. They tried to make Get a kind of
- 51:05hobby experience through States, the suppression of it, they were
- 51:12going to completely close down and eradicate.
- 51:15The monasteries that had been there for Millennia and insert
- 51:21Christianity and the monastics of the time realized that if
- 51:27they didn't engage, the whole populace in the protection of
- 51:31this, that they would lose it. Then so they developed this
- 51:36momentary concentration practice as a way of allowing
- 51:40householders to develop a deep deep practice, so they didn't
- 51:45have to come and to retreat and do the, do the traditional
- 51:48monastic way of being practiced. So they began to teach,
- 51:53householders how to do deep practice and it was built
- 51:56around, Carnival samadhi or momentary concentration and the
- 52:02original descriptions of the Maha.
- 52:03See But teaching list of note, everything constantly noting
- 52:08everything. So moving and moving and moving,
- 52:11lips thinking, all of those things, every little thing
- 52:14you're constantly noting. So that the you have this
- 52:17continuous experience of being present in the moment.
- 52:26So if you like this noting practice that, I teach that it's
- 52:31a very straight up Maha c-type practice.
- 52:34I tend to teach it with shins ends techniques because his
- 52:40techniques are actually pretty easy to learn.
- 52:43And then to do In some sense, when you begin, as Maha see
- 52:53technique, you're noting where your attention is.
- 52:56And then you're noting the inclination of your attention to
- 52:59move to the next object, which you can detect pretty easily.
- 53:03When you, when you practice it stands at the moment to moment
- 53:08to cultivate a Wandering mind. Well, you're in, you're not
- 53:14attempting to control where your awareness goes.
- 53:17Your The monitoring. So in some sense, it takes you
- 53:20out of consciousness of the sensing experience into
- 53:23awareness of Consciousness. That's the shift that will
- 53:26happen and that's actually very useful another way to describe
- 53:30it as you come out of self into, no self and back and forth.
- 53:34So you have the object that can be sensed you have the capacity
- 53:37to sense it when they meet a consciousness of that sensing
- 53:41experience arises, which awareness knows And when the
- 53:45object of meditation is no longer, they object of sensing
- 53:49is no longer in contact with the capacity to sense.
- 53:52The consciousness of that sensing experience ends and
- 53:56awareness knows that. So rather than being caught up
- 53:59in Consciousness, you move into awareness, which is constantly
- 54:05watching where your attention goes.
- 54:08So, a Wandering mind would mean that you're actually caught up
- 54:11in Consciousness and you lose awareness of what's Is that
- 54:16making sense? So it's these momentary
- 54:20experiences where you're highly concentrated on what the
- 54:23experience is watching from awareness that were that this
- 54:28technique of momentary concentration is meant to be and
- 54:32it's highly useful for inside practice.
- 54:38Had enough everybody. Shall we just practice.
- 54:42Now, we have gabbed a long time so that the period of practice
- 54:50today is going to be on the short side.
- 54:56And why don't we just do some straight-up concentration,
- 54:59practice? What do you think we've been
- 55:02talking about it? Okay.
- 55:40So this is keeping your practice.
- 55:44So I'm always advocating ways to deepen your practice.
- 55:48I've just started as an intensive yesterday, but if you
- 55:54wanted to still come to it and you were willing to start next
- 55:58into Sunday's that would be okay.
- 56:00Wouldn't have missed too much. It's called the meaningful life.
- 56:05And it's a relational mindfulness class where we
- 56:08really examine ways to practice meditation to improve or
- 56:12relationships. It's focused on John bowlby's,
- 56:16attachment Theory. So determining what your
- 56:20conditioning has wrought in terms of your attachment
- 56:23strategy and then looking at ways that it might be useful to
- 56:26shift it. If your conditioning has put you
- 56:29at a disadvantage in terms of relationship, It's an intensive.
- 56:34So two classes, a month on the second and fourth Sunday, you
- 56:39have to mentoring sessions a month.
- 56:41So 30-minute one-on-one, Skype sessions with the meditation
- 56:46Mentor. Six morning's a week of guided
- 56:49meditation and that runs for nine months, so it'll end in
- 56:54June. No, it's a conference call.
- 57:00Live conference call. Anyway, it's still up on the 80s
- 57:06website for a little bit longer and then it'll come down.
- 57:09And if, if you don't engage it pretty quickly, then it'll be
- 57:12too late. It's a closed class so you can't
- 57:14just drop into it. There's a retreat coming up a
- 57:19full Retreat. There's a flyer up there for
- 57:21that. You can see a bunch of different
- 57:23flowers up there for different events coming up to take a look
- 57:26at those. I think that it's useful to go
- 57:30on retreat, at least one Retreat a year.
- 57:33The next one that I'm doing is in December.
- 57:35So, December 26th to January 8th, at La Casa.
- 57:39De Maria up in Montecito, will be doing a method of apostle
- 57:43Retreat, which means the first five days of the retreat will be
- 57:47exclusively focused on meant to practice and then we'll go into
- 57:51of apassionata. It's a really good way to
- 57:53practice. I am an Ardent supporter of
- 57:58meditation centers. One of the things about the
- 58:01meditation path, is it can sometimes be difficult and it's
- 58:04important to have people support you on the path and what better
- 58:08place to meet them. That in a meditation center.
- 58:13I'd work with people all over the country and the biggest
- 58:16complaint for most people who don't live near a big city is
- 58:19that there are no meditation centers.
- 58:22And so their Dharma orphans out there in the Hinterlands.
- 58:29You know, you get into trouble with meditation or something
- 58:31comes up in meditation and you want to describe this process to
- 58:35somebody and if they don't meditate, they really are not
- 58:38going to have much of a way to help you relate to you in it.
- 58:42So having a place to come to his really useful and speeds the
- 58:47practice along. I can assure you that even
- 58:50though we've been here for a long time, that the finances of
- 58:53a meditation center are quite precarious, and so each of these
- 58:58Each time you come this practice of Donna, this practice of
- 59:02generosity that you engage in is vitally important to keep the
- 59:05lights on and the doors. Open the suggested data here is
- 59:09$15, but really the practice of done is done for yourself and
- 59:13you need to be giving it a meaningful level if $15 is a
- 59:18meaningful level of giving them do that.
- 59:20If it's not enough, give more if it's too much, give less.
- 59:24If you if you're not resource and you can't do it, then we, as
- 59:28a community, I will happily afford the space for you but
- 59:32really be engaged in your own practice of generosity.
- 59:37We take cash and checks and credit cards, if you would also
- 59:43be so kind as to put the chairs back in the Christians away.
- 59:45That's appreciated and we'll see you next time.
- 59:47Thank you.