Latest / Common Practice Show / From 5 Jobs in 5 Years to 30-Year CEO: Tiffany Crenshaw's Journey
Transcript
- 0:08podcast.
- 0:09I am excited to be here today.
- 0:11My guest today is Tiffany Crenshaw.
- 0:13She is the CEO of Intellect Resources for the last 20 plus years and just really excited.
- 0:19Go ahead and Tiffany, before I steal too much more of your thunder, go ahead and explain some more of your background and what you've done and what you're doing now.
- 0:27Okay.
- 0:28So almost 30 year professional in the talent acquisition space, everywhere from executive search to direct hire to staffing to advisory services.
- 0:40Really with a niche in health care, spent much of our career in technology.
- 0:45But over time, we're adding operations into that, doing a lot of executive search right now with health care operators.
- 0:52So we've got a North Carolina based company and we do work all over the country with health systems, practices, professional services companies, as well as software vendors.
- 1:04Awesome.
- 1:04So let me ask you this.
- 1:05What made you decide to make this your career?
- 1:08What kind of led you down the path of talent acquisition, let alone into the health care field?
- 1:15Justin, nobody wakes up one day and says, I want to be a recruiter.
- 1:19Right.
- 1:19Right.
- 1:21But in college, I was a college recruiter.
- 1:23I did all the campus tours for a small women's college that I attended before going to Chapel Hill.
- 1:30So I guess my history was set way back when.
- 1:33But no, quite honestly, I was a journalism major.
- 1:35I went to UNC's journalism school, one of the top 10 in the country.
- 1:39And so I just had my heart set going up to New York.
- 1:42I wanted to work in a
- 1:43publishing house or an advertising agency.
- 1:46And, you know, tales all the time followed my heart to Greensboro, North Carolina with my college sweetheart and worked in a couple of small agencies.
- 1:57And ultimately, I think that's where my recruiting background set.
- 2:02I changed jobs once a year for every five years.
- 2:05I was looking for something and it's something you're not supposed to do, right?
- 2:10And in those, it looks like you had some stints in your career where you've moved around a lot, right?
- 2:16And it really set the stage for me to help me really appreciate the interview process and what it was like to be a candidate.
- 2:29And that is really has been core to my background is we are very candidate focused and spend a lot of time with our candidates, prepping them for interviews.
- 2:39debriefing with them, coaching them through the process.
- 2:42It's something I really enjoy doing.
- 2:44And it's because I remember what those five years felt like in that job market.
- 2:49That job market also, every time I made a move, I was moving because of the leader.
- 2:55I either was leaving a leader or I was really impressed with a leader, right?
- 3:02And many of them were entrepreneurial, very successful, but really crappy bosses, right?
- 3:09So I learned a lot about my own leadership and the way that I wanted to lead.
- 3:15So that five-year period that landed me into recruiting, it taught me a lot.
- 3:19At the end of that five-year period, I was...
- 3:25basically selling into hospitals everything that is now digitized.
- 3:31So if you think about the old, you go into, you know, a hospital and all the forms, like your registration forms, your encounter forms, you know, they used to do their lab request on a form, right?
- 3:45They get the lab results back on a form.
- 3:48You know, the stickers that would go on to pharmacy bags, the
- 3:52prescriptions, like secure prescriptions.
- 3:55I sold all of that.
- 3:58And that was the last of those five years of jumping around.
- 4:01I was in every hospital and every department side of a hospital selling what was now digitized.
- 4:07And I landed in a place where there was a small startup healthcare IT consulting company.
- 4:13And they were looking for a recruiter who knew healthcare.
- 4:18And my mom was doing all his financial planning.
- 4:21And she said, hey, my daughter's a recruiter, but she's got healthcare experience.
- 4:27I went to go join this company and start up their recruiting team.
- 4:31And that's really where my healthcare started.
- 4:34Went into this small 20-something company and helped them grow to 100 employees in the recruiting.
- 4:42You've got that recruiting experience, too.
- 4:44So imagine you get someplace.
- 4:45There is no database.
- 4:47There is no.
- 4:48ATS, there is no recruiting process.
- 4:51I got to go in and build it all for this company.
- 4:54Ultimately, the company merged and sold to IBM.
- 4:58And in that acquisition process, the owner came to me and he's like, okay, you made me a hell of a lot of money and you get bored.
- 5:05What are we going to do?
- 5:06And I think he did me the best favor of my life.
- 5:09And I said, let's start a recruiting company.
- 5:12We've got all these resumes.
- 5:14You've got all these customers.
- 5:15They're not going to all want consultants.
- 5:17Some of them are going to want perm hires.
- 5:20And we started Intellect Resources together.
- 5:23As he was getting his final check from IBM, he let me buy him out for basically the investment he put in.
- 5:30And it's been mine ever since.
- 5:32Awesome.
- 5:33All that job changing led me to
- 5:37Healthcare sales, it led me to recruiting.
- 5:40It led me to this company called HealthLink.
- 5:42And then that became the recruiting function that we developed there became intellect resources.
- 5:49So that's the journey.
- 5:50Awesome.
- 5:52But I think ours are, it's very similar, right?
- 5:54Where you've went year to year thinking maybe this was the new role that I'm going to thrive in.
- 6:02But then you realize you were sold the wrong item.
- 6:05So now take that and bring it into present day.
- 6:09So when you approach someone like yourself,
- 6:12Hey, you've been with five different jobs in five years.
- 6:14When you talk to people that you're representing to find them hires or consultants, how are you, what are you doing to be able to bridge that gap?
- 6:23Are you talking to the candidate first to get a good explanation on those five years?
- 6:28Or do you understand where that comes from?
- 6:31Walk me through when you get that resume and it's like, in five jobs in five years, I don't think I want to touch this person.
- 6:37What advice do you have for that?
- 6:39Well, I will tell you because I have been there.
- 6:43I do get those resumes a second look.
- 6:45But let me tell you, Justin, the other things I look at those resumes is I go back and look.
- 6:50Have they finished anything?
- 6:52What certifications, college degrees, anything that shows that they can start and finish something?
- 6:58So that's one thing that I do.
- 7:01And then the next thing I do is, was there anywhere where there was staying power?
- 7:05Give me something that was over two to four years, right?
- 7:10Like, okay, this one.
- 7:12So again, it shows that you can stick with something.
- 7:15Yeah.
- 7:15Also, our industry is pretty small enough.
- 7:18Sometimes I can look at those resumes and go, that was HealthLink, you know, or IMG, which became HealthLink, which became IBM, which became, and that I can follow it, that it might look like they've got five stops, but I know that all five of those companies are all the same.
- 7:37So I really give one that study because I think it's fine to give somebody a second chance or, you know, a second look to unpack it.
- 7:45And then the next advice that I give or the next thing I do is I don't like hone in and immediately ask, why have you only been someplace, you know, for one year?
- 7:57I ask them to kind of walk me through the background.
- 8:00and trying to find some common themes on what they're saying on why they made a move or what have you.
- 8:06And then after they've kind of shared their story, if something doesn't smell right, I just dig right in and ask the hard question.
- 8:13You know, my client is not going to like that you've had five job changes in five years.
- 8:19What would you tell them?
- 8:20You know, in there, and sometimes it's the person, sometimes it's a, it's a,
- 8:26It's a bad look, right?
- 8:28Or, you know, it can easily be explained.
- 8:30And then I coach them in the interview process on how they need to better address it.
- 8:36And then I try to, you know, I have got to come in strong with the story because clients many times ago, yeah, I'm not going to touch that resume.
- 8:43You know, so I've got to have built that story to say, OK, let me explain to you, you know, it was, you know, her boss left this company and they went someplace else and she was recruited to join that company.
- 8:58That company was then acquired.
- 9:01So, you know, when you look at that, I would like you to have an open minded.
- 9:05Isn't it a great sign that her boss recruited her away, you know, in there?
- 9:10So it's all circumstantial.
- 9:13Now, what about the other side where someone's maybe been in a job for 15, 20 years and spontaneously pop back up into the market?
- 9:21Or maybe you reach out to them through LinkedIn and be like, hey, I think it'd be a great opportunity for this, but they've been with their company for 15 years.
- 9:29How do you approach that for someone who has the longevity but is so solidified in their current role?
- 9:37I think that's less of an issue because sometimes you just catch somebody at the right time.
- 9:43Yeah, they've been there for 15 to 20 years.
- 9:45They're stuck.
- 9:46They don't want to go anywhere to do that.
- 9:48And I don't really have any problems with them on the client side.
- 9:51I've never had a client say, hey, I don't like this person's been at one company for 20 years.
- 9:57I can tell you that you will see it on resumes a lot of times that when someone's been someplace for 20 years and they make a move,
- 10:05They're usually only at that next place for one or two, right?
- 10:08Because clearly whatever they had here was really special, right?
- 10:13And then they get someplace and they're constantly comparing, right?
- 10:19But it's a different world than it was 15 to 20 years ago.
- 10:23Most people do only stay in companies for two to three to five years.
- 10:26So a lot of times that's not as big of a deal.
- 10:30The clients aren't worried.
- 10:32This person's been there forever.
- 10:33They're going to be a short timer here, right?
- 10:35But that's the reality of what happens is it's not a problem on the candidate side, but they don't typically stick a long time.
- 10:44And then the clients don't, they don't look at it that way.
- 10:47They're all excited someone showed loyalty and longevity.
- 10:50Okay, gotcha.
- 10:51Yeah.
- 10:51And then when you get a resume, right?
- 10:54I know right now I get solicited all the time.
- 10:57It's like, hey, upload your resume and we'll curtail this to fit this job with these certain keywords.
- 11:04How are you combating that?
- 11:06What advice do you have to the person out there who we know this market right now?
- 11:10It might take you 300 applications to even get one interview.
- 11:20How can someone put themselves in a better light to be able to be recognized by someone like you?
- 11:26Right.
- 11:26Well, applications really, you know, there is so much noise and clutter in the applications with AI that I would just say, you know, you can do that because it's part of the game.
- 11:39And, you know, make sure your resume is, you know, honest and true and it's got the keywords in there of the jobs you want.
- 11:49But that's not how you're going to get a job.
- 11:51Your job is that the way that you get a job is getting yourself out there in LinkedIn.
- 11:56having a nice, crisp, clean, accurate, true resume with all the keywords that you need, professional pictures, references, endorsements, you know, a full, clean profile.
- 12:09Because those are where recruiters go to find you.
- 12:13Right.
- 12:14So put yourself out there and then networking.
- 12:17That's what it's all about.
- 12:18You know, network with former bosses, former employees, former colleagues.
- 12:24And, you know, just let people know that you're out there in the job market.
- 12:28That's how you get those jobs.
- 12:30And as much as the online application process is a pain for candidates,
- 12:38It's just as bad for hiring managers, right, to get in there.
- 12:42There are so many fake and phony resumes that,
- 12:45We might, they're all working off the same template or what have you.
- 12:49You might have six people with resumes that look almost identical.
- 12:54It's noisy.
- 12:55It's crowded.
- 12:56It's, you know.
- 12:58So typically what we do when people come in to apply, you know, we'll take a look if they fit something that we're working on right now.
- 13:05We pick up the phone because we just want to learn more about that person.
- 13:08Yeah.
- 13:09Otherwise, it goes into our database and that's the first place we go when we are looking for somebody.
- 13:18So I always tell candidates just because it's gone into an application black hole and it feels like a black hole.
- 13:26That doesn't mean you're not going to get a call three months from now, six months from now, a year from now, three years from now.
- 13:33Because if you think about it as recruiters,
- 13:36First place you go is your database.
- 13:38Those are the warmest candidates.
- 13:39There's somebody that at some point talk to somebody in your company or voluntarily put it in there.
- 13:45So you go there, then you go out to LinkedIn when you need to expand past your network.
- 13:51And then you do the heavy recruiting and the heavy sourcing.
- 13:54But most of the time, you don't have to go that much further.
- 13:58And the fact of the matter is, let's just say I have 100 applicants for one role.
- 14:07If you go through those hundred applicants, there are probably only three that are qualified.
- 14:12So the whole application process is cluttered and noisy.
- 14:15Yeah, and in those hundred applicants, is that a hundred that you have sourced out that you're individually looking at or through your ATS and it's looking through those hundred applicants?
- 14:26Those are where we post a job out there.
- 14:29Applicants apply and we manually go through them.
- 14:34Because AI does a great job kind of pulling some up at the top to say, hey, you should look at these.
- 14:41But we go through them manually because who's to say that...
- 14:48You know, the ATS may not know something we've not had time to put into our applicant tracking system.
- 14:53Or they may not know what companies we're calling on or what companies that may have said, hey, in six months, I'm going to need a XYZ engineer.
- 15:03I'm going to need a CFO or keep your eyes open for a CEO.
- 15:07The ATS and AI doesn't know that.
- 15:10So we manually look at our applications.
- 15:12Yeah, it was interesting.
- 15:14Go ahead.
- 15:14I was going to say the only time that we don't stop and look at every application is when we have a go live going on.
- 15:20And if you're familiar with, you know, our industry, you know, those are when we've got these projects where we're recruiting, you know.
- 15:29from 10 to 400 people to go out on these temporary assignments and word gets out.
- 15:34We'll have 3,000 applicants in two days.
- 15:38And then the applicants are not only applying, but they're blowing up our cell phones and our texts and our, you know, our work lines, our emails, our LinkedIn.
- 15:49We just, you know, there was a time we looked at every single one of them, but, you know, I cannot hire enough people to do it.
- 15:58Does that make sense?
- 15:59Yeah, 100%.
- 16:00And I was reading an article on, I think it was LinkedIn the other day, and it was talking about the automated ATS.
- 16:07And the leader was going, why are we not getting any candidates?
- 16:10And they said, listen, out of 200 applicants, we haven't had a single one.
- 16:14you know, qualified and they started going, it was through something through tech and they started going through the applications.
- 16:20Well, the AI was trained to look, I'll use Python for example, right?
- 16:26P-Y-T-H-O-N, but people were putting on their, and again, this is just an example.
- 16:33It was like P-Y-T-H-O-N, but the AI wasn't trained to look for the dash.
- 16:39It was only trained to look for the word.
- 16:42So they went back through all these resumes and they said out of the 200 resumes you guys have declined, almost 150 of them met all the minimum requirements.
- 16:50But the AI threw them out because the way that they formatted their resume, AI couldn't pick up the difference.
- 16:57So I thought that was an interesting piece, too, where some some I bet some people are just.
- 17:03really qualified, but if it doesn't hit the way that AI was trained to read it, they can just be getting left in the wayside.
- 17:10And it's not a reflection on them.
- 17:12It was a reflection on the process that that company had to help filter through all the applications.
- 17:18So I thought that was an interesting topic that I heard earlier this week.
- 17:22Well, it's not only that, but if you also think about hospital recruiters, we do a lot of work with hospital recruiters.
- 17:31A lot of them have many different jobs that they're recruiting on, right?
- 17:36And then let's say a specialty IT role comes in, they don't understand the roles.
- 17:42So even if they are looking at, sometimes some of them really do understand that, but and I'm using IT as an example, it could be something else.
- 17:51you've got the AI that misses it and you have the people that miss it because they don't.
- 17:56And so I think therein lies the value of while so many recruiters are specialized, that they can take apart a resume and they can look at it.
- 18:07And even if it doesn't have the key of the keyword that AI is searching for or the recruiter that's trying to do this job and, you know, they just don't have the
- 18:17They're trying to do 100 other jobs and this isn't their specialty.
- 18:21Does that make sense?
- 18:22Yeah.
- 18:22I say that all the time to clients is we'd love to take a look at your database because there's chances are you've got a goldmine sitting in there that a candidate's already expressed an interest in the organization, you know, and they just don't know how to go back and retrieve those.
- 18:37So we do have some clients that let us into their ATSs that were actually working in their ATSs.
- 18:42Oh, nice.
- 18:44Yep.
- 18:44Gotcha.
- 18:45All right, so we're going to backtrack a little bit.
- 18:47Okay.
- 18:47So you had the five different jobs in five years.
- 18:50You've learned a lot about management.
- 18:52You got into management.
- 18:53Now you run your own company.
- 18:55What were some of the major takeaways that you learned in those initial five years to be...
- 19:03to be the best leader that you are today, where would you say, and what would you say those, some of those qualities that you hated versus liked?
- 19:11Cause we know recruiters and BDers, we're all kind of a different breed of people.
- 19:16So it's, it's trying to figure out how are you the best leader to run a business for 30 plus years and be as successful as you have been.
- 19:24Okay.
- 19:25So there are two things.
- 19:28Yep.
- 19:28Well, there are a lot, but I'll start with the best manager, boss, leader ever was the one who founded the original HealthLink that sold to IBM, and he and I started and elect resources together.
- 19:42And I remember going to one of his leadership retreats.
- 19:45I'm pretty sure it was a leadership retreat, not the company retreat.
- 19:50And he stood up in front of the company.
- 19:52And I'm not going to get this exactly right because I guess I could pull up pen and paper.
- 19:58But he pretty much drew a pyramid.
- 20:01When he gets up there and he's standing at the bar.
- 20:04the board, the flip chart, and he draws this pyramid.
- 20:08And at the top, he puts a dollar sign.
- 20:11Then at the middle of the pyramid, he writes clients.
- 20:14And the bottom of the pyramid, he put employees.
- 20:20And he said, most companies are focused on this, right?
- 20:27Is the number, the money, the revenue.
- 20:30And if you look down, the clients are bigger than that area and the employees are the biggest base.
- 20:36And we as leaders within the organization, we're going to turn this upside down.
- 20:42Our focus needs to be the employees, 100% focus on the employees, because if you take care of your employees, they take care of your clients and then the money will come.
- 20:54And that was his philosophy.
- 20:56Yeah.
- 20:56And if I compare him to the other individuals that I worked with, money was everything.
- 21:02Money, money, money, money, money.
- 21:04Right.
- 21:05And as a result, the turnover in these companies, when it was the first recruiting company I worked with, I was there in the first nine months.
- 21:17I was almost one of the senior recruiters on the team.
- 21:20Wow.
- 21:20In nine months, right?
- 21:22Like this churn because of the way he treated his employees.
- 21:27Now, I've also learned my lesson is that I went above and beyond overboard for a period of time where employees started to take advantage of it.
- 21:40So I think that there is a really nice happy medium.
- 21:44If you wake up every day with the idea that you're feeding these families differently,
- 21:49Right.
- 21:50And how do you make sure that they're happy in their roles?
- 21:53You're going to be a better leader than if you're focused on on the revenue because your employees are going to help you make that happen.
- 22:00You know?
- 22:00Yeah, absolutely.
- 22:02And, you know, we know, especially on the recruiting, health care recruiting, very first in that there is there tends to be quite a bit of turnover in what we do.
- 22:12So when with your group and what you've done in the past, how do you measure KPIs, output, placement, success?
- 22:21Walk me through the parameters of the KPIs that you kind of held your team together, your leaders to with the team underneath them, if you could explore that a little bit.
- 22:30Hands down, there's just one number, the number of candidates you have in the interview process.
- 22:35Because if you don't have candidates in the interview process, something's broken.
- 22:40So I really, and then you back into what kind of sales do you need to have the jobs so that you have that number of candidates in the interview process, right?
- 22:52Then what do the recruiters need to be doing that when we've got the jobs, they've got the candidates in the interview?
- 22:58the interview process and or what are the account managers falling down in the job that you've put candidates over the wall and they've not been scheduled or they've gotten stalled in the interview process.
- 23:12So that has always been my KPI.
- 23:15Now, where I have failed miserably as a leader is in the sales.
- 23:21And I think we've had that thing that, you know, many founder led companies have
- 23:29A lot of times it's the founder that brings in the sales.
- 23:31And so I've struggled on that one.
- 23:33But we've had some really successful sales folks come through our doors, so we've had some not.
- 23:38But at the end of the day, I do not have the magic bullet on those sales KPIs.
- 23:42Gotcha.
- 23:43So on the recruitment, that's the far right one.
- 23:45Are interviews scheduled?
- 23:48What are some of the left ones, right?
- 23:50Because a lot of, I'm a believer and I always read right to left.
- 23:54Like, I don't care what the left side of it looks like as long as your right side is kosher.
- 23:58If the right side is broken or not where we need to be, where are some of the other levels that you look at as you build away from the interview process?
- 24:07Is it calls, text, emails, LinkedIn messages?
- 24:11What helps derive that number?
- 24:14I am still old school.
- 24:17It's the number of conversations you have, you know?
- 24:20And let's say for, you know, one of my recruiters, she's got one at the top LinkedIn, like whenever we do our annual reviews with LinkedIn, she gets more responses than anybody else on our team in LinkedIn, right?
- 24:36That's great.
- 24:36You're getting all these responses, but how many people are you getting on the phone and talking to, right?
- 24:42And her hit rate is great.
- 24:50I mean, her hit rate, she'll get back at least 25 to them if it's unless it's one of those purple unicorns.
- 24:58Right.
- 24:58Yeah.
- 24:58And then she drills down and then she has the phone calls.
- 25:02And, you know, by the time she gets into the phone calls, they're pretty well screened.
- 25:06She gets in.
- 25:08But that other benchmark is if you're not getting on the phone with candidates.
- 25:13You're not going to meet your KPIs.
- 25:15You're never going to get those candidates into the interview process.
- 25:18And whatever it takes you, you know, this one doesn't have to, you know, she cast a big net, but it's really successful.
- 25:26But some of my other recruiters have to cast lots more nets to get those coming in.
- 25:31So this person's KPI for text and emails and phone calls going out may be way higher than,
- 25:38than this recruiters because she's so successful at that.
- 25:41But at the end of the day, they need to be talking to at least four candidates a day, period.
- 25:45Hands down on the phone with four candidates a day.
- 25:49But whenever they're doing upstream, it just depends on them and it depends on the role.
- 25:55Does that make sense?
- 25:56It does.
- 25:56And does that vary based on...
- 25:59The kinds of roles we're working on.
- 26:01Yeah.
- 26:01Yeah.
- 26:02Yeah.
- 26:03Okay.
- 26:04I was going to say, because I know in healthcare, that can be a little tricky, especially if you do the physician recruitment side where you might be taking a call at 10 o'clock at night when that doctor got off shift.
- 26:17So that's why I was curious if there is a certain different parameters per different specialty of job.
- 26:23Yeah.
- 26:24But think again, each of my recruiters could be working on multiple things, right?
- 26:28So four has always been a magic number for us as a company, right?
- 26:33And it levels out on some of those others.
- 26:35But to me, that's a bare minimum.
- 26:36And when I started this company, you know, as kind of like, you know, the founder working in, you know, like an attic office, I would just sit there and smile and dial until I could finish the word new profiles a day.
- 26:48You know, that was just the way that I did it.
- 26:51But
- 26:52Every candidate you talk to is another relationship, whether you're going to place them now or you're going to place them five years down the road or they're going to land in a role and they're going to become your next customer.
- 27:02You've got to be on the phone with people.
- 27:05Yeah.
- 27:06Awesome.
- 27:07And then what are you so for the for the person out there struggling to get a job?
- 27:13struggling to get recognized, what advice do you have for them?
- 27:16Is it get on LinkedIn and start building more relationships?
- 27:20Is it, well, back in my day, it was go in and shake the hand of the person of the hiring manager, right?
- 27:26Like I remember my grandma's like, no, when I was trying to be a busboy of all jobs, a busboy, she's like, you need to go in and ask for the general manager and introduce yourself if you want your application looked at.
- 27:37I'm like, okay, well, we can't do that now.
- 27:39Right.
- 27:40Like those days have been gone.
- 27:41So what advice do you have for the person who maybe just went through a layoff and it's just really cranking to try to get food back on the table for their family?
- 27:50Where, where, where would you advise them to go and how would they attack the attack it?
- 27:56Well, applications are fine.
- 27:58You can do that.
- 27:59That's not where you're going to get it.
- 28:01But I would like start picking up the phone, calling old managers, old bosses, former colleagues, previous colleagues, digging into your network and then.
- 28:13working your network on LinkedIn, right?
- 28:15Like go through and look at the updates of what has happened with people.
- 28:20You know, have they made a job change?
- 28:22You know, what have they posted?
- 28:23Engage with what they're doing so that you are fresh in their minds, right?
- 28:29And do that.
- 28:31It never hurts to be ballsy and pick up the phone.
- 28:35You know, is there, you know, an implementation leader somewhere, a project manager there, a director or a leader?
- 28:41you know, pick up the phone and just call them.
- 28:44Or if you know somebody who knows somebody that you want to meet, ask them for that referral.
- 28:49I mean, you can't sit back and be passive in this job market and you've got to get creative.
- 28:57The other thing that I would say it's easier to get a job.
- 29:01When you have a job, so maybe think outside of the box for a little bit.
- 29:07Was there something out there that you haven't done?
- 29:10Is there a local role?
- 29:11Is there a fractional role?
- 29:13Is there a volunteer or something that you could be doing that could open up some new paths or new opportunities for you?
- 29:20So I think you cannot just sit back and post and pray, right?
- 29:24You can't just post your resume somewhere and pray that something's going to come up.
- 29:28You've got to work it.
- 29:30by engaging in your network, thinking outside of the box.
- 29:33Now's also a great time to, you know, take some online certifications and post about what you're learning and the things that you are doing to start getting attention.
- 29:43And again, maybe that opens up some additional avenues for you in there.
- 29:48Are there any online certifications that you would recommend people to try to get to get on their background?
- 29:56Like some of the hot ones that you've seen in your experience?
- 30:00Yeah.
- 30:01You know, any AI certification right now, but, you know, I do understand some of those AI certifications, you know, are like, here's Python and here's how to go do that.
- 30:11I can't tell you if I can point to any particular one, but I would say that's not what you need.
- 30:18What you need, and you can go to Coursera, you can go to Johns Hopkins, and I'm sure there are a gajillion other ones online.
- 30:25but where you're learning the basics of AI governance or AI prompt writing.
- 30:30You can never go wrong with advanced Excel skills, right?
- 30:34You just cannot.
- 30:35You can't go wrong with any kind of Microsoft certifications.
- 30:39You can't go wrong with trying to find like a Google marketing or doing a, you know, Canva certifications or any of those type things.
- 30:49Again, think outside of the box, right?
- 30:51Right.
- 30:52What are some things that that are either in your wheelhouse and the world that you work in or what's something that just looks interesting to you?
- 31:02You know, I think one that's kind of coming up on my my radar that I want to learn a little bit about is.
- 31:10All right.
- 31:11And you think about recruiting and sales.
- 31:14You do a lot in those areas.
- 31:16Marketing kind of falls within there.
- 31:18You've got SEO for websites.
- 31:20Well, there's this whole new thing about what is AEO, right?
- 31:25Like how do you try to build your digital front door so that the AI engines are catching stuff about your company or about your resume and they're putting them in there?
- 31:38That's a new thing that could be really interesting and exploring in that maybe it's going to be helpful for someone in a job search too.
- 31:46putting a website up there and how do you make that crawlable for the AI engines.
- 31:53So that's something I'm trying to learn a little bit about.
- 31:56Project management professional, PMP.
- 31:59I think that's a great one to go look into and see if there's something that you can do with that.
- 32:06So I think the list can go on and on.
- 32:09LinkedIn Learning's got all kinds of courses.
- 32:12So ways to stay fresh and look at, but PMP, Excel, AI, those are some things, AEO, those are some things that are popping up high on the list.
- 32:23And the other thing I do tell a lot of folks that have been in healthcare or healthcare technology, it never hurts to get a clinical certification at all.
- 32:33You know, we do not have enough rad techs, med techs, lab techs, pharmacy techs, any of those techs.
- 32:39And usually those are a couple of year certification programs.
- 32:42Okay, maybe you don't ever want to go and do bedside or work in the pharmacy or do the lab.
- 32:48But that education may open up doors for you for selling a widget from those areas or a device from those areas or selling those services.
- 32:58Or maybe there is something they're looking for an IT person that knows lab really well.
- 33:04So I don't think you could ever go wrong with a clinical certification ever, period.
- 33:09And hospitals are desperate for many of these techs right now.
- 33:15And what advice would you have for someone who wants to start getting into healthcare recruiting?
- 33:22Where obviously there's entry-level jobs all over the place right now.
- 33:26So what would you give them as a tool bag to be able to go in and excel in their first or mentality to be able to excel in their first role?
- 33:37In their first role in recruiting or trying to land the job?
- 33:41In the job already.
- 33:42Okay.
- 33:43In the job, I say this all the time.
- 33:45A really successful recruiter has got to have an amazing work ethic because it is not.
- 33:51That is why the turnover in our field is so high.
- 33:55It takes a really long time to establish yourself, start getting a name, creating your pool of your candidates that you're going to have around you for the next decade or two.
- 34:06And it's a lot of work to get there.
- 34:08Again, you know, don't leave the office every night till you've met four new people every day.
- 34:14That's 20 a week times da-da-da-da-da-da-da.
- 34:16And it adds up in there because that network is so important.
- 34:20And if recruiters aren't willing to go in and do that work,
- 34:24And you've got to be willing to get on the phone.
- 34:26A lot of people all want to do their recruiting by digital right now.
- 34:32But it's a competitive market.
- 34:34You've got to be willing to get on the phone.
- 34:37And then if a recruiter cannot be able to start a conversation and draw somebody into a conversation in the first 30 seconds, you're going to just fail.
- 34:46I call that the gift of gab.
- 34:48Right.
- 34:49So you just have to.
- 34:51The other thing is, and I don't know how to describe this, except for to say you see it when somebody has it and you see it when somebody doesn't.
- 35:03OK, so let's say I'm interviewing you right now, Justin.
- 35:07Right.
- 35:08And we're going through this interview and you don't fit anything I have open right now.
- 35:16If that recruiter can't think ahead and go, hey, the client had a need for somebody like this a year ago.
- 35:25I'm going to go call them and see if they filled it or they have additional needs.
- 35:29Or I call it connecting the dots, right?
- 35:33If they can't like start thinking about and too many recruiters are focused on this opening and these five job specifications right here.
- 35:44And if Justin doesn't fit these five, they don't know what to do with it.
- 35:49Does that make sense?
- 35:50You've got to be able to connect the dots and go, okay, you've got four of the five, but what other skills do you have that maybe could add up or could show that you could do this skill?
- 36:02Or, hey, with four of these five, you may fit this job that my colleague over here is working on.
- 36:09And there are a lot of recruiters that can't connect those dots.
- 36:12They're so focused on that skill.
- 36:15one, that, that one list of requirements on that one job.
- 36:20Does that make sense?
- 36:21It does.
- 36:21Yeah.
- 36:23Awesome.
- 36:23So you, I think you nailed the biggest thing is the gift to gab.
- 36:28So you called me, right.
- 36:30And you have 30 seconds to figure out, you have 30 seconds to get me right.
- 36:37Walk me through what that script for you sounds like.
- 36:40OK, well, most of the time, you know, I have, you know, noticed your resume or noticed somebody online.
- 36:48And I'd love to just quickly call and just cut to the chase.
- 36:51You know, hey, Justin, you know, Tiffany Crenshaw, I'm a 20 plus year old, you know, 20, a history of 20 years in recruiting.
- 37:00Your background caught my interest.
- 37:02Yes, I do have a role right now I want to talk to you about, but I really just want to meet you.
- 37:07Because even if timing isn't right for you to make a job change or you're not interested in my job, I'd love to know a little bit more about you so I can keep eyes and ears open for future opportunities.
- 37:17I get very few people that say no.
- 37:19And I think I have been hung up on less than five times in my career.
- 37:24Right.
- 37:25But you got to get that word out really fast, set the stage and then know it's not like I'm not trying to sell you something today.
- 37:34Right.
- 37:34Now, it's very rare.
- 37:37that people actually pick up the phone.
- 37:40So that outreach that you, so, you know, I kind of have my voicemail pitch that I will do, but a lot of times I'm doing that outreach in LinkedIn, email, text.
- 37:50So when you get them on the phone, you again, reiterate, you know, I've got two decades of recruiting in healthcare.
- 37:57You caught my eye.
- 37:58Yeah, I've got something I wanna talk to you about, but I really wanna start with an open-ended conversation.
- 38:02I want to hear about you, Justin, what you've done, where you want to go.
- 38:06Maybe we have a fit here.
- 38:07Maybe we identify something completely different, either now or in the future.
- 38:12You know?
- 38:12Yeah.
- 38:13Let's dive in.
- 38:14A hack I've been using recently is I will message you on your cell phone first.
- 38:21Mm-hmm.
- 38:22And be like, hey, Tiffany, this is Dr. Voskis, blah, blah, blah, blah.
- 38:26Well, then I will call maybe five minutes after I send you that text.
- 38:31Because then it pops up, maybe Dr. Justin Voskis.
- 38:35And it's like, oh, maybe I do know this person.
- 38:38And then they pick up, right?
- 38:39So there's little hacks that I've figured out through my time where if they just see a blank number with how much are spam calls, I don't know.
- 38:47I get probably 50 spam calls a day.
- 38:51Right.
- 38:52So now you get someone who's calling you from an actual number.
- 38:55It doesn't say potential spam, but it's like, well, did you skip the spam filter?
- 38:59So that's been one hack I've been using is I'll text first and then I'll call that way.
- 39:05My name shows up on your screen to where maybe I can get a higher pickup rate because it's somebody who you actually think you might know.
- 39:13That's a good hack.
- 39:14I'll have to track that.
- 39:15I like it.
- 39:16Feel free to steal that one.
- 39:18I probably just mentioned my secret sauce out loud so it won't be as effective, but I'm going to continue doing it.
- 39:25But that's the piece, right?
- 39:28It is, I tell people this isn't for the faint of heart because people don't want to talk, air quotes, don't want to talk to you.
- 39:38Right.
- 39:38Or you have to be scared of the no.
- 39:40No, I'm not interested.
- 39:42Is that going to?
- 39:43Yeah.
- 39:44Right.
- 39:44That's where we're at now.
- 39:45It's like, all right, click next on moving on to the next one.
- 39:48But it's like you have to have a thick skin, not because people are rude to you.
- 39:52I don't think I've ever met someone rude to me, but it's more you have to be okay with the rejection.
- 39:59And that's where we have to be ready to go.
- 40:02And the rejections are nice.
- 40:04They're like, no, thank you.
- 40:05I'm not.
- 40:05I'm not interested right now.
- 40:06I'm happy where I'm at.
- 40:08And I think that's the biggest piece.
- 40:09And I think that's why we've seen cold calling dissipate so much in our, in our lifetime, because the only way you really, it's easy to say no through text and it's like, oh, okay, cool.
- 40:20Right.
- 40:21Versus having, having the courage to have that conversation with you.
- 40:27No, I don't know what your response is going to be.
- 40:30It's like back in the day where you actually had to approach girls to ask them out on a date.
- 40:34Yeah.
- 40:35Right.
- 40:35And it's like, oh, I don't think I can.
- 40:36What if she rejects me?
- 40:37Well, then she does.
- 40:39Right.
- 40:39But you still have to do it.
- 40:41So that's where I think a lot of people struggle.
- 40:44now on the recruiting and kind of even the BD sales side is it, what do you do the first time you get the no?
- 40:51And I listened to a lot of Grant Cardone, level Merheadle, but he has some good things in it.
- 40:57He kind of talks about, you know, wait till the leave me the F alone comment.
- 41:03He goes, you keep calling him until you hear that.
- 41:06And obviously I don't do that because you'll ruin relationships really quick.
- 41:09Yeah.
- 41:09Yeah.
- 41:10But yeah, it's always interesting.
- 41:11And that kind of segues me to my next piece of relationships.
- 41:16In your eyes, your opinion, how crucial is the recruiter client relationship for honesty, transparency and feedback?
- 41:30I want to answer this, but I just want to say one more thing about rejection, if you don't mind, is I always thought about myself in the early days.
- 41:38Well, I'm the job fairy.
- 41:40And if you don't want to talk to the job fairy, then shame on you.
- 41:43Right.
- 41:43That was like my attitude, like your loss.
- 41:47So that just made it easier.
- 41:48Right.
- 41:49But in my head, I'm like, well, you know, two fairies moving on.
- 41:52The job fairies moving on.
- 41:54So, yeah, that's kind of how I handle that with a little sense of humor.
- 41:59Yeah.
- 42:00And I would say that the client relationship is all the difference.
- 42:06Let's say we've got, you know, all of a sudden we are, you know, slams.
- 42:11And, you know, this happens.
- 42:12We go through these peaks and valleys.
- 42:14Right.
- 42:14And let's say every client calls at that time.
- 42:17Who's going to get our attention?
- 42:19Right.
- 42:19First, you know, it's the one that has like the most respectful, communicative, thoughtful relationship.
- 42:28Those are the ones that we roll the red carpet out for.
- 42:33And I think, too, a lot of clients don't really understand, particularly in the contingency world, how much work we.
- 42:41really do behind the scenes for them.
- 42:45And it's those clients that really understand that, that are more appreciative.
- 42:50They just get the best out of us.
- 42:52You know what I mean?
- 42:54And you waste a lot of time if a client doesn't give you a full understanding of the role up front, right?
- 43:04And I mean, you've had this, clients call and they give you a, you know, two-sentence, right?
- 43:10you know, job description and they want you to go recruit after that.
- 43:14Okay, well, maybe you've been working with that client for several months or several years and you just know exactly what those two sentences mean.
- 43:22But in the beginning, we can do a much better job and we have a thorough understanding of,
- 43:29You know, what's the company?
- 43:30What's the mission?
- 43:31What's the culture of the company?
- 43:33Right.
- 43:34OK, where does this role fit within the company?
- 43:37What impact are they expected to make?
- 43:39You know, what are going to be their signs of success?
- 43:43What are the big knockout factors if they come in and they behave this or perform like this?
- 43:47They're going to they're going to lose it.
- 43:50We can do such a better job if clients spend this time with us up front.
- 43:56And I got to tell you, when a client spends that much time up front and we're on the phone with them like that, I've made one call placements that literally the client is describing.
- 44:08And in the back of my head, I'm going,
- 44:10God, Justin is going to fit this job.
- 44:12Again, connecting the dots.
- 44:14Justin is going to fix that job.
- 44:16And I can say to the client right now, let me tell you about a candidate.
- 44:19I know I'm not going to name him because I don't know if he's interested, but I've got this candidate and this is his background.
- 44:25This is what I know he's looking for.
- 44:26And the client's going, yes, yes, yes.
- 44:29Yes.
- 44:29I called Justin.
- 44:31Justin, I found the thing you told me when we spoke six months ago.
- 44:34You were looking for it's here.
- 44:35What do you think?
- 44:36Here are the details.
- 44:38You send it over and our job is done, right?
- 44:42Versus a client gives you a little bit because they are too busy.
- 44:47We spend all this time finding candidates.
- 44:49We send them over there and they're like, well, I don't know.
- 44:52I'll talk to them.
- 44:54But it's not what we really need, you know?
- 44:57Yeah, exactly.
- 44:59Yeah.
- 45:00I'm getting a lot.
- 45:03Good.
- 45:04I'm just getting a lot of feedback all of a sudden.
- 45:07Oh, yeah.
- 45:07It's so good on my side.
- 45:08Okay, good.
- 45:10But yeah, that was a great piece.
- 45:11And I guess I would say a struggle that we've seen a lot, and maybe you have, and maybe you have a different way of kind of handling it, where the salary expectations aren't where they should be, but they're not willing to take...
- 45:28the responses that we're giving them.
- 45:31It's like maybe, and they come back and say, well, I just don't think you're pitching it to the right people.
- 45:36So when you get that right, we know salaries end all be all for most people, but when the salary is drastically lower than what the market is saying, how do you handle that in the relationship model with your clients specifically because you're on the contingency side?
- 45:54Well,
- 45:55Sometimes the best thing to do is say, here's somebody that fits your salary.
- 46:01Here's what you've asked for.
- 46:04Where do you want to go?
- 46:06Yeah.
- 46:06Right?
- 46:06This is what I can get for your money.
- 46:10Right?
- 46:10This is what it is.
- 46:12This person doesn't have an EPIC certification, but they got five years of EPIC.
- 46:16And, or, you know, this person, you know, has been a CFO, but they're not a CPA and they've not done it in a private equity group, but their salary.
- 46:29So we kind of show them what they can get.
- 46:32And then we bait them with what they want.
- 46:35But then, you know, as a leader and a business owner, I also understand where they're coming from and maybe they're dealing with rate bans inside.
- 46:45And this is a bigger internal issue.
- 46:48of where they need to be.
- 46:49Right.
- 46:50So then it is pushing on your client to say, listen, this is going to be below market, right?
- 46:58I got to know how to sell this with candidates, right?
- 47:02What are you offering instead of that money that may be of interest to them?
- 47:07Are there equity?
- 47:08Is there bonus?
- 47:09Is there a sign in bonus?
- 47:10Is there,
- 47:12you know, a title.
- 47:13Maybe someone's always wanting a C-level title.
- 47:15This might be what they need to get there.
- 47:18So I think that there are different ways to do it.
- 47:22And then sometimes, honestly, Justin, and just speaking with the candidates, if you explain to them
- 47:30Right.
- 47:30OK, the salary is going to be lower, but look at the match on the 401k or OK, here's where the bonus is going to come in or here's what your equity is going to look like.
- 47:41Right.
- 47:42And I think you owe it to your candidates to really talk about the big picture and to sell that opportunity, because, you know, sometimes people take one step back to take two leaps forward in there.
- 47:56And 100 percent.
- 47:57Yeah.
- 47:58So I just think that just comes into the negotiations, the conversations, asking the right questions, you know, giving people things to think about.
- 48:07You can't make the decisions for any of them, but you can push them to think about it.
- 48:12Yeah.
- 48:13And I will tell you, I think some people don't, you know, there are a lot of folks that really don't understand the value of a 401k or a profit sharing or those things because they're so focused on that base salary.
- 48:27And maybe they need to be because that's what's going to, you know, pay the bills, you know, every month and those type things.
- 48:33But sometimes if you think about, wow, did you see they pay 100% of a family's health care?
- 48:40That's worth $15,000, right?
- 48:42I was going to say that's... Yeah.
- 48:45Or you get at some pay scale and you're right at the cusp of what your tax withholdings are going to be.
- 48:53Right.
- 48:54All right.
- 48:54So, you know, you know, go back and explore and encourage them to kind of go talk with their accountant.
- 49:01If I'm at this salary and I'm at this tax break and this tax bracket and I'm at this salary at this tax bracket, where am I taking home more of?
- 49:11Yeah.
- 49:12Right.
- 49:13So I just think is you can give everybody on both sides some things to think about and not laser focus on that one number.
- 49:22Yeah.
- 49:23And what advice do you have?
- 49:25Because sometimes that's what not the applicants focused on, but I know on our side, hospitals run.
- 49:35It doesn't matter what hospital you go to.
- 49:36They all pay different.
- 49:37They all have different thresholds and ways to compute salary.
- 49:43So how do you...
- 49:45How are you able to go back to the client and just say, even in your region, this is too low?
- 49:51Or I guess that's really the biggest piece is data numbers.
- 49:58You know, here's what XYZ hospitals paying.
- 50:02You know, here's what XYZ.
- 50:04Okay.
- 50:04I've talked to.
- 50:06You know, we've reached out to 7,000 candidates and we've gotten bites from, you know, 1,000 candidates.
- 50:12We've gotten to talk to 200 candidates.
- 50:15And of those 200, two are willing to take your salary.
- 50:19Like numbers talk.
- 50:20Yeah.
- 50:21You know.
- 50:22Data is what they want to see.
- 50:23That's what they can go back to the board with.
- 50:25Be like, hey, we got to at least raise it a little bit.
- 50:28Yeah.
- 50:28Yeah.
- 50:30And for...
- 50:32On the recruiting side, how many people are total in Intellect right now?
- 50:39Well, I've got a couple internal fractionals, but there are about six of us that are FTEs.
- 50:44And then I've got some, like my controller's fractional.
- 50:47My vice president of marketing is fractional.
- 50:50I've got a fractional sourcer.
- 50:52Yeah.
- 50:52Gotcha.
- 50:53In there.
- 50:53Yep.
- 50:54So that's actually, I wasn't expecting this.
- 50:58So on the fractional side, we see that starting to get more and more popular.
- 51:02Yeah.
- 51:03What's kind of your advice to the expert or the corporate person who is looking for fractional work?
- 51:11How did you come across the fractionals that you have with you?
- 51:14And what made you bring on a fractional versus trying another route?
- 51:19Oh, I'm a big fan of fractionals.
- 51:21Always have been.
- 51:23And I will tell you, as a hiring manager and a business owner, you know, being in our business, you know, our needs, we might have a big project.
- 51:35And, you know, all of a sudden, you know, we've got 400 people on staff or we might be doing just a ton of executive recruiting and direct hire work.
- 51:43work, we have less, right?
- 51:46So when you have a company that has so project to project swings, you can't afford to keep a CFO, a full-time marketing person.
- 51:56So we adopted this model very, very early on, right?
- 52:00And, you know, we've got folks that, you know, contract and swell with what our needs are.
- 52:05So we've been doing this even before the word fractional was even.
- 52:1325 years, right?
- 52:15So it's been great for us.
- 52:17Now, out in the market, I have been placing fractionals a lot, a lot, a lot.
- 52:23And so if you think about the difference between a fractional and a consultant, the fractional really is the idea is this person is their opportunity, right?
- 52:34It's not like, hey, it's a consultant that's coming in for six months, right?
- 52:38This is a person that
- 52:40I think I need five hours a week, 10 hours a week, 20 hours a week, 100 hours a month or whatever that might be.
- 52:48And we do a lot of this work and, and I find my candidates in the same way we find all of our others, right?
- 52:56Is, you know, we find them on LinkedIn, we find them through our network.
- 53:00You know, I never thought I was going to be here at this age, but you know, I'm now at that, what I used to call my seasoned candidates, right?
- 53:08So I'm now one of those seasoned candidates.
- 53:11And a lot of my contemporaries were at the twilight of our careers, right?
- 53:15There are a lot of folks that I can take a look.
- 53:17You talked about, hey, that person that's been in a role for 20 to 25 years.
- 53:22I can call and say, hey, I've got some fractional work.
- 53:25What are you thinking about doing over the next couple of years?
- 53:28Right.
- 53:28And catching people there.
- 53:30And I'm filling a lot of those folks with folks that are ready to retire, but not ready to stop working.
- 53:37And my clients are getting the best of everything because at this point, many of them, they're not working because they need the money.
- 53:43They're working because they enjoy doing the work, but they don't want to be tied to something 40 hours a week.
- 53:50So it's a win-win.
- 53:52And I love being the matchmaker in those situations because everybody's happy.
- 53:57Awesome.
- 53:58Particularly the spouse that doesn't want the person to come home and be fully retired yet.
- 54:02Fully retired yet, right?
- 54:04Yeah.
- 54:05Awesome.
- 54:07But yeah, before we wrap up, I do have one question that I surprise everybody with.
- 54:12Okay.
- 54:12It is, what is the one thing that everybody in our business does that you think is flat wrong and how would you do it better?
- 54:20Okay.
- 54:25Okay.
- 54:25Our business being recruiting.
- 54:28Yep.
- 54:29And what does, not everybody does it wrong.
- 54:32No.
- 54:33One thing, what's the one thing everybody in our business does that you think is flat wrong?
- 54:44He's saying yes to contingency work.
- 54:47There we go.
- 54:48Okay.
- 54:49And what would you do better?
- 54:51But we do it because sometimes that's a foot in the door or, you know, our clients start working with us and it's become a habit and it's been successful.
- 55:02So why change?
- 55:03But I don't think contingency work is great all around.
- 55:09You know, I think clients have less of a vested interest of, you know, staying engaged or working with a sense of urgency.
- 55:18And then I think firms like mine, when we do contingency work, we give away just a lot of work where we do not get compensated for it.
- 55:26Now, in the search, we meet a lot of people.
- 55:29We build a lot of relationships.
- 55:31We're networking.
- 55:31We're selling as we're going.
- 55:33But yeah, I think everybody should stop contingency.
- 55:36I just don't think, I think it's a practice that started years ago.
- 55:39And I think it's going to be really hard to get rid of this practice, but it's not good for anybody, but it's the, what is it?
- 55:45It's just what you have to do.
- 55:47Yeah.
- 55:49Also, well, that's the pun.