Latest / Politics with Paul / What Political Civility Really is and Combatting Toxicity w/ Michael Lee | Politics with Paul #86
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Politics with Paul podcast, your home for nonpartisan discussion of
- 0:04political science and civics.
- 0:06I am your host, Paul Rader, and we have another great guest today.
- 0:10And for such episodes, always add a disclaimer that I do not take a stance for or against any
- 0:14particular party, ideology, or group, but that's really never a problem here.
- 0:19And episodes are for anybody of any political persuasion.
- 0:21So political discussions are often filled with toxic rhetoric and behavior.
- 0:26People are too often attacked verbally or even physically for their opinions, and such
- 0:31toxicity has led to some high profile instances of political violence, especially in recent
- 0:38years.
- 0:38And we can combat all this with more civil discussions.
- 0:42But what exactly is civility?
- 0:45Toxicity is easy to spot, but what actually constitutes civil and effective dialogue is
- 0:51sometimes misunderstood.
- 0:52And it's critical to truly understand civility to counteract polarization.
- 0:57So how do we become more civil?
- 0:59Well, that's what today's guest, Doctor.
- 1:01Michael Lee is here to discuss.
- 1:03Doctor.
- 1:04Lee is the executive director of the Civility Initiative at the College of Charleston, which
- 1:08promotes dialogue across differences as well as hosts panels and workshops about communal
- 1:13engagement and healthy discussion.
- 1:15He is also a professor at the college, the host of the When We Disagree podcast, and an author
- 1:20of multiple books.
- 1:21Doctor.
- 1:22Lee also earned a PhD in speech communication and rhetoric from the University of Minnesota.
- 1:27So let's get his insights on the meaning of civility and how to effectively push back
- 1:32against toxicity.
- 1:33Please welcome Doctor.
- 1:34Michael Lee to the show.
- 1:35Doctor.
- 1:35Lee, thanks for coming on.
- 1:36How are you?
- 1:37It's a real honor, Paul.
- 1:38Thanks for having me.
- 1:39Oh, well, honor's all mine.
- 1:41So, always like to go back to the beginning for my guests.
- 1:45Before all this work with the Civility Initiative, what got you involved in work on
- 1:50promoting civility and combating toxicity in general?
- 1:53You know, I was practicing it honestly because I come from a debate background, and so I was
- 1:58not a very good high school student, and I was looking for an easy a.
- 2:03And a friend of mine said that this debate class at east shout out to East Mecklenburg
- 2:08High School in Charlotte, North Carolina, that this debate class was pretty easy.
- 2:12I should take that as maybe a junior in high school.
- 2:16I got into it.
- 2:17I really loved it.
- 2:18I went to a debate camp for super nerds, and then was lucky enough to get a scholarship and
- 2:25keep debating in college.
- 2:26And then I coached debate for few years after college.
- 2:28And then so I wasn't really thinking about it as promoting civility.
- 2:31I was just thinking about it as a fun activity that was obviously highly argumentative, very
- 2:36research based.
- 2:38And then as when I left the activity and got a PhD and was researching political theory and
- 2:44writing books on conservatism or succession or whatever was floating my boat at the moment, I
- 2:50kept coming back to debate.
- 2:51I kept coming back to the importance of people debating ideas in a democracy, skills it takes
- 2:57to debate, not just expecting good debates, but structuring good debates.
- 3:01And so I realized that debate itself was an act of civility, which I just mean as an act of
- 3:08engagement.
- 3:09You know, to really debate you, I have to some extent take your argument and your point of
- 3:13view very seriously.
- 3:15I have to give you some charity about the idea that you researched that argument.
- 3:19I have to share a space with you.
- 3:21I have to engage in turn taking, letting you speak, listening to what you say.
- 3:26And so I think debate, it can be very connective.
- 3:28Debate can be very dialogic.
- 3:30Debate can be very civil.
- 3:32My favorite definition of it, which I'll steal, Theresa Bajon, mere civility talks about
- 3:36civility as not trying to land all your punches at the same time, but also not necessarily
- 3:42pulling your punches either.
- 3:44And mere civility just means it's it's, in some cases, beneath politeness.
- 3:48You know?
- 3:48Let's just try to be civil to one another.
- 3:51And so the question is how are we engaging?
- 3:52And I think that debate done really well can actually be a really great act of giving
- 3:57respect to one another, sharing space with one another in a democracy and civility.
- 4:02I like that definition.
- 4:03I ought to I ought to keep that in mind.
- 4:07Yeah.
- 4:07It is funny how, you know, when you take a certain path, you don't you sometimes never
- 4:12know what it's gonna lead to.
- 4:13Right?
- 4:13You talked about just how much you didn't actually mean to get on this whole debate path.
- 4:18It was just something fun for you, and then it you know, look how how well it turned out.
- 4:22Definitely oh, shit.
- 4:23Go ahead.
- 4:23With that point, I'm I'm reminded of the the long debate about Robert Frost's two roads
- 4:29diverged in a yellow wood, and we like to think that that poem is about looking back and
- 4:34saying, you know, I made I made the right choice, and look how my life has turned out.
- 4:39But in fact, at least his intention was to write a book about how we delude ourselves,
- 4:44that many of our choices are completely accidental.
- 4:47And we would look back at our lives and say, oh, no.
- 4:49I really made the right call in all these different ways.
- 4:51And look how good I am and how my life has gone so well because I really made myself suffer,
- 4:56took took the the road less traveled.
- 4:59When in fact, when you read the the text of it, both roads are the same, and it's just kind of
- 5:03an accident.
- 5:04It is just I was a lazy high school student.
- 5:07I got into a class that I that I thought would be an easy class, and that has made all the
- 5:12difference, as Frost would say.
- 5:14Yeah.
- 5:15That that's I think that's a good call.
- 5:18Well, now let's talk about the civility initiative.
- 5:20So how did this initiative at the College of Charleston start?
- 5:24How did you become involved with it?
- 5:25And what talk about more about what it does?
- 5:28I know I gave a little bit of an idea of what it is, but I wanna hear it more in your own
- 5:31words.
- 5:32Yeah.
- 5:32The civility initiative by my direction is interested in dialogue and debate.
- 5:38So we promote healthy dialogue across our differences, and we promote debate skills
- 5:43amongst the students, faculty, staff, and then the wider public here around Charleston.
- 5:49And to that end, to both of those ends at least, debate and dialogue, we do movie
- 5:54screenings, book talks, panels, debates, workshops, communication skills trainings, you
- 6:01name it around those two goals.
- 6:03And so in addition to our event programming, we have obviously the media arm.
- 6:07I host a podcast when we disagree, which is about powerful disagreements that have shaped
- 6:12people's lives one story at a time in over a 115 or so episodes now.
- 6:18In two and a half seasons, we have had every kind of disagreement you can imagine, which is
- 6:23from mom to MAGA and dad to the Denver Airport and conspiracies about that.
- 6:29So it's been amazing to cover so many different ordinary people's memories of and relationships
- 6:35to conflict in their lives.
- 6:38And then on campus, we do skills training because it's one thing for you and I to to
- 6:43create one episode about the importance of listening or the importance of depolarization.
- 6:47It's one thing for me to get a writer or a speaker to come talk about their book on the
- 6:52subject, but those are ephemeral.
- 6:55They can be inspirational, but they're also ephemeral ephemeral in the sense that if you
- 6:59miss this episode, you miss it.
- 7:01And then even if you heard it, did you maybe you got more interested in the subject, but did
- 7:06you get any better at the practice of it?
- 7:08So so many of the things that we're talking about today are skills.
- 7:10They're dispositions, but they're also skills.
- 7:13And you and I could have a hour long conversation about dribbling a basketball, and
- 7:18maybe people would be more interested in dribbling a basketball, but would they be any
- 7:21better at it?
- 7:23Probably not.
- 7:24And so we need to structure what we've been structuring at Civility Initiative is year long
- 7:29trainings for select students.
- 7:31Our free expression fellows do debate dialogue training, and then they do debate and dialogue
- 7:36peer to peer programming, tabling events, and bigger events with speakers and invited guests
- 7:42and so forth with staff to integrate debate and dialogue into the co curriculum.
- 7:48And so we do a training for a year on that, then and we do a training for a year with
- 7:51faculty on how to construct assignments based on debate and dialogue.
- 7:55In other words, to increase the skill, the disposition, and then our bandwidth for
- 7:58conflict to tamp down our fight and flight responses.
- 8:02That's such a such an important point you make about the development of skills.
- 8:06And that's why I try to not just have I mean, yes, I like talking about this stuff and
- 8:11teaching people these things and all that.
- 8:13But, you know, if they don't have any actual practical application of it, then, you know,
- 8:19how how impactful is it really?
- 8:21That's why I always try to have as much practical information that people can act upon
- 8:26as well.
- 8:26So I I can definitely appreciate that.
- 8:29And, you know, I I think also with people listening to politics in general, they just see
- 8:34they it that people just have a if they're not in it, I it feels like they don't necessarily
- 8:40feel like there's a practical way they can get involved.
- 8:43They feel like it's too inaccessible, I guess.
- 8:45And I think this is stuff like this is a really great way to show people how it's, it does not
- 8:50have to be inaccessible.
- 8:51There is a way that you can actually practice this.
- 8:54And it doesn't have to be anything super like, oh, you have to get ingrained in politics to do
- 8:58this.
- 8:59No.
- 8:59There's That's right.
- 9:00There's other ways that you can go about it as well without completely dedicating your life to
- 9:04it like like we do.
- 9:06And Yeah.
- 9:07And and and speaking of which, when I was looking at the website, I saw this really
- 9:12interesting point that you guys for the civility initiative make about how the
- 9:16initiative works in two different areas to promote civility, and it's fight and flight.
- 9:21And fight includes aspects like polarization and bigotry.
- 9:24Flight includes aspects like withdrawal and echo chambers.
- 9:28So can you tell us more about what this fight versus flight dichotomy is about, why the
- 9:33initiative makes those distinctions, and why those differences are so important?
- 9:37Yeah.
- 9:37Thank you for that, and that distinction is really meaningful for me.
- 9:41You know, I know this is the Politics with Paul podcast, and I love the alliteration there.
- 9:46But I also when I talk about our work in the civility initiative and my work in general, I
- 9:51try to say that it's not just political.
- 9:53In fact, most people think when I talk about civility that I am talking about red states and
- 9:58blue states or arguments about the presidency or arguments about foreign policy and so forth.
- 10:03And I think it's just as much an organizational issue, a relational issue, a media issue, a
- 10:10theological issue, and you name it as it is a political issue.
- 10:15So most of the time, I'm actually just trying to say, we need to think about this beyond
- 10:19politics because we need to think about our personal relationships to conflict, to conflict
- 10:24within ourselves.
- 10:25You know, to what extent can I sit with a messy idea and a debate with myself about how I feel
- 10:31about something or what's true, or do I need to make a a final decision as quickly as possible
- 10:35because that brings up so much cognitive dissonance or just feelings of distress that I
- 10:39can't handle it?
- 10:40And then how do I feel about about conflict with you or anybody else?
- 10:44Can I find any curiosity in it?
- 10:46Can I find any joy in it?
- 10:48Can I find any relational connection in sometimes really necessary conflicts or even
- 10:54joyful conflicts?
- 10:55And so to that end, I say, you know, we're not doing political work.
- 10:59We're not doing media ecosystem work.
- 11:01We're not doing free expression First Amendment work.
- 11:04We are doing nervous system work.
- 11:06And we are doing nervous system work in the way that I relate to conflict within myself and the
- 11:10way that I relate to conflict with you.
- 11:12And my pet theory is that, of course, we all have nervous systems, but I think relationships
- 11:16have systems.
- 11:17And I think organizations have nervous systems and maybe even nations have nervous systems,
- 11:22which is the extent to which they can tolerate stress before they become dysregulated.
- 11:27So what is the extent to which I can tolerate it, you can tolerate it, but also our
- 11:30relationship can tolerate my campus can tolerate it, my stay, and then on out from
- 11:35there.
- 11:35And so if we're doing nervous system work, then we are improving our responses to the
- 11:41potentially dysregulating functions of fight and flight.
- 11:44So can I acknowledge fight instincts that come up with me as it relates to conflict and then
- 11:50move past those, acknowledge them, move past them, move through them, and then still engage?
- 11:54Or flight issues.
- 11:56So most of the time, I think when we think about problems with incivility in The United
- 12:00States, we we have a negativity bias that makes sense.
- 12:03You mentioned violence at the top.
- 12:06And so those are fight issues to me, cancellation, bigotry, violence, and so forth.
- 12:11And more often than not, in my experience, the real enemy to connection, the real barrier to
- 12:17connection is silence, is not violence.
- 12:20And it's our fear of of violence, our fear of getting canceled, our fear of, as one student
- 12:25said to me, becoming known as that kid who said that thing, which is to say a fear of stigma or
- 12:31a fear of excommunication.
- 12:33But most of the time, the chilling effect caused by that negativity bias and our fear of
- 12:38fight creates flight instincts.
- 12:40And those to me work in a kind of infinite mutually reinforcing loop cycle where the more
- 12:46we fight, the easier it is to flee from one another.
- 12:49And the more we flee, the easier it is to demonize each other and therefore fight.
- 12:53Yeah.
- 12:54I think you see that so often in politics where people just issue it just because they just
- 12:59don't wanna deal with other people.
- 13:00And then when you don't interact with other people, you don't really actually get to see
- 13:04what they think.
- 13:05And then, of course, some people just want to sit out of politics completely because they
- 13:09don't want to get involved in it.
- 13:10And then that helps.
- 13:11Unfortunately, this incivility fester.
- 13:14But the point you made about this not just being a political issue is is so important to
- 13:19you.
- 13:19Obviously, yes, like you said, this is a politics based podcast, but this really is
- 13:23something that can be applied to all facets of life.
- 13:26And when you when I think when you put it that way, people who are naturally averse to
- 13:31politics, they'll at least be a lot more open to it when you're saying, oh, no.
- 13:36This is for all your relationships or if you're into religion or anything else.
- 13:41It it's it's it's information that can help anybody in whatever strife they're having with
- 13:48another person.
- 13:49So I I can I can definitely appreciate that?
- 13:51I know I know I look at it through the lens of it being politics based just because of, you
- 13:55know, my work, but it is definitely something to think about in all aspects of life.
- 13:59And something else I've I've talked about before is that I think a lot of people
- 14:04misunderstand what civility actually is.
- 14:07They might think it's you know, we just talked about it now.
- 14:10It might simply not be pushing back on people or never getting upset.
- 14:13So do you see a lot of this misunderstanding about what civility actually is?
- 14:18And what do you think are two to three of the most common misconceptions about the meaning of
- 14:22civility or how to employ it ourselves?
- 14:25It's a good question.
- 14:26I would say the most common that I face are that it's politeness, that civility is
- 14:33etiquette, that civility is exclusively political.
- 14:38So it's only relevant when we talk about politics and especially relevant when we only
- 14:42talk about politics with Paul.
- 14:44And then that civility is, in some sense, people telling each other to be more civilized
- 14:50is an argument I run into.
- 14:52But I would say most of the time, of course, I direct the civility initiative, and I'm
- 14:55interested in the broader cause.
- 14:57But the the two words that I use the most often are debate and dialogue.
- 15:02And I've and I like to filter those down into better decision making.
- 15:05So how can we improve our dialogue skills, meaning listening, meaning letting go of
- 15:10winning, meaning humanizing connection and humanizing disagreement, meaning perspective
- 15:16taking and seeing the world through your eyes as best I can.
- 15:20And then debate, which is also perspective taking, but also comparisons of evidence and
- 15:24crystallizing arguments and making conclusions about complicated issues.
- 15:29And so and how those filter down into better decision making for people, for organizations,
- 15:34for political parties, you name it.
- 15:36So that is where the rubber really hits the road is, of course, we can talk at a high level
- 15:40about stability.
- 15:41What is it?
- 15:41But when we start talking about skill building, I think we're really talking about skill
- 15:45building around those two things, debate and dialogue, and then making situational judgments
- 15:49about where one or the other is necessary and how that can improve our decision making.
- 15:54So do we want the most people involved in the decision?
- 15:58Do we want the most relevant information?
- 16:00Do we want most buy in from key stakeholders who stay loyal to the decision making process
- 16:06of the group even if they don't get their way?
- 16:08And can we make the decisions that we think best reflects what the evidence tells us?
- 16:12That to me is what the best decision making looks like.
- 16:16Sometimes that requires us to figure out what's true and what's false or what's probably true
- 16:20given our limited evidence and what's probably not true.
- 16:23That's a debate skill.
- 16:25Sometimes we need to just humanize disagreement and say, I understand where you're coming from.
- 16:29Don't agree with it, but I completely get how you got from point a to point b.
- 16:33And and that's a full stop.
- 16:35So that's a that's a complete sentence.
- 16:37And that's a dialogue skill.
- 16:38So civility is one thing, but then when we talk about the work of skill building, we start
- 16:43talking about debate and dialogue.
- 16:45Yeah.
- 16:45And I I think, unfortunately, some people that on that last point, they still they still see
- 16:50that as, like, a tacit endorsement of, like so you're not gonna fight them.
- 16:54You're just gonna say, oh.
- 16:55Right.
- 16:55I just I disagree with it.
- 16:57Or or I see your point, but I disagree then, you know, some people think, oh, you're still
- 17:01giving them too much ground.
- 17:02Something I've
- 17:03That's right.
- 17:04Looked into a lot is this, you know, those moralized attitudes and how I'm trying to
- 17:09myself, I'm trying to figure out how to break through those moralized attitudes because
- 17:12people think it's it's a moral imperative to not budge an inch because you figured
- 17:17everything out.
- 17:18And it's you know, for some of those people, I imagine it's a bit harder to teach those debate
- 17:22skills.
- 17:23And I I think another thing of civility that I see a lot of times is people think it means you
- 17:28can't ever be angry, which Mhmm.
- 17:31I mean, I I think is just it's not reasonable to expect human beings to never be angry.
- 17:37It's more about how you've channeled that anger properly.
- 17:40You can still be, you know, be angry about something you think is is wrong, but you can
- 17:46still try to talk to people and try to be at least see where they're coming from.
- 17:51It doesn't have to preclude you from doing that.
- 17:52Now, if you're gonna tear their head off, then of course, then nothing's gonna, you know,
- 17:55nothing's good is gonna come out of it.
- 17:57But I think some people try to also, you know, that kind of think that's kind of why people,
- 18:03you know, escape from it.
- 18:05That flight response you talked about is just because they think I can't ever be angry about
- 18:09something.
- 18:10So I'm just gonna be angry over here.
- 18:11That's not what it means.
- 18:13But you have to channel that anger properly, which I think a lot of people don't do and
- 18:16myself included.
- 18:17I'm not gonna pretend like I've done it correctly all the time either.
- 18:21But another big thing I try to emphasize is that everybody is capable of contributing to
- 18:26polarization, including myself.
- 18:28But a lot of times for it's it's unintentional in a lot of people's cases.
- 18:33But what do you think are two to three things people think are civil, but in reality actually
- 18:38contribute to toxicity and political discourse?
- 18:41I know we kinda touched on it earlier, but let's dive into it a little bit more.
- 18:45That's a really good question.
- 18:46To what I've said, are people mistaken about the things that they do that they think are
- 18:51simple, but in fact are not?
- 18:53Yeah.
- 18:53The two that come up for me are, I think, that sometime that lots of time I mean, because most
- 19:01of the time, as I mentioned earlier, I'm focused on the extent to which people are not
- 19:05engaging as opposed to people are over engaging.
- 19:08In other words, I'm worried about avoidance rather than antagonism most of the time.
- 19:13And I think that a lot of times, people tell themselves that avoidance is the way to stay
- 19:18civil.
- 19:19And avoidance preserves a thin connection at the expense of a thicker connection.
- 19:25But if we just avoid the hard topics, then we can live to fight another day.
- 19:28And sometimes that is true.
- 19:29Absolutely.
- 19:30And sometimes we have to look at what our relationships what we want out of this
- 19:34relationship.
- 19:34Like, do I want a deeper political relationship with my uncle at the stereotypical Thanksgiving
- 19:40dinner, and so I have to talk about the most sensitive issue.
- 19:43No.
- 19:44But a lot of times, even in our closest personal relationships and our marriages and on
- 19:48our campuses and in our organizations, we avoid the issue.
- 19:52We don't talk about the issue at hand because we're worried about giving offense.
- 19:56We're worried about the consequences of giving offense and so forth.
- 19:59So I do think avoidance is something that we do to do that.
- 20:03And the second thing I do I think that we do is we talk a lot about authenticity.
- 20:07I think it's really important for people to show up to discussions and not be provocateurs
- 20:13who are deluding themselves into thinking that they're gonna have a million followers and
- 20:18because they've owned somebody in a kind of, like, online stream or something.
- 20:22So I do think it's important to speak your heart and approach things as you really feel as
- 20:27opposed to playing some character for an imagined audience.
- 20:31But I also think it's important to not just reinforce who you and I are as stable forever
- 20:37entities as we've entered this conversation and really open ourselves up to the vulnerability
- 20:41that it takes to encounter another person and the vulnerability that takes to say, I don't
- 20:46know everything and perhaps you know information that could shift my perspective.
- 20:50And so the extent to which we need to really do perspective taking is limited by a kind of cult
- 20:56of authenticity in which I am always and forever my one true self.
- 21:01And I think that sometimes we think about that as a civil move.
- 21:04And I do think there's like I said, with with anger and others, there's a a real role for
- 21:08that.
- 21:09There's real power in that.
- 21:10But we can also overdo it and limit the extent to which we can do perspective taking because
- 21:15we don't want to, as you said earlier, give attention as opposed to affirmation.
- 21:21We don't wanna have a conversation that makes us complicit.
- 21:24And then those two that I talked about, the attention and conversational avoidance, kinda
- 21:28kinda work hand in hand.
- 21:30Yeah.
- 21:30You know, that's a that's a that is a good point to make about the avoidance is that
- 21:34sometimes you you don't actually have to get into something.
- 21:36That that that is true.
- 21:38Some people think, you know, as soon as something political comes up, they have to get
- 21:42involved in it, and they have to have some sort of debate usually get taken a little, little
- 21:47too far.
- 21:48But, you know, I think every one of us has those situations where, know, you we have a
- 21:53family member or whatever that gets a little too wound up about something and we just kind
- 21:57of say, you know what?
- 21:58I'm just not gonna deal with that.
- 21:59And that that sometimes is fine.
- 22:01But when he when he carried into every single potential conversation where you just don't
- 22:07wanna deal with it, that becomes a problem.
- 22:10And I I I appreciate that point about authenticity because it is good to be
- 22:14authentic.
- 22:14You don't wanna be lying about the kind of person that you actually are.
- 22:18But at the same time, some people take that to a point where they just really like play up who
- 22:24they are.
- 22:25And then sometimes it's okay to temper things a little bit.
- 22:28You can you you you just because you're, you know, talking something out doesn't mean you're
- 22:33not being authentic.
- 22:35And I do think there is a little bit of an overemphasis, like you said, on being
- 22:41authentic, or at least the way that they think they're being authentic is I think not
- 22:47ironically, I think some people thinking the way that they're being authentic is not
- 22:51necessarily actually as authentic as as they as they think.
- 22:55I don't know if that makes sense, but it's it's kind of something that I'm just thinking about
- 22:59now because of that point that you made.
- 23:00But, of course, we've all encountered toxicity in our lives, whether it's from somebody else
- 23:06or maybe we contributed to ourselves.
- 23:09But for from your personal experience, what are two to three personal examples from your life
- 23:14where you use civility to push back against toxicity?
- 23:17And what were the results of that?
- 23:18So people, in case they have similar situations to you, they might be able to say, oh, okay.
- 23:23Maybe Doctor.
- 23:23Lee handled it this way.
- 23:25What were some examples of that?
- 23:26Gosh.
- 23:27Again, I'll go back to kind of my hobby horse, which is that I think that when we think about
- 23:34how we engage one another and when we talked about the possibilities of relating to one
- 23:39another as people and as citizens, we kinda have three choices in how we deal with
- 23:45difference.
- 23:45And one is silence, One is violence on the other end of the scale or some sort of
- 23:51elimination or separation.
- 23:53And in the middle, we have all sorts of kinds of engagement that can look lots of different
- 23:57ways.
- 23:57And antagonism, negativity bias, the fight issues get a lot of publicity, and I don't need
- 24:04to relitigate those.
- 24:06But the silence issues, the more insidious issues of flight are the ones that I also see
- 24:12as toxic.
- 24:13Those are the ones that I also see as uncivil or incivil.
- 24:17Those are also the hardest ones to measure.
- 24:19It's easy to measure when people are screaming at each other, but it's hard to measure when
- 24:24people don't talk because they fear getting screamed at.
- 24:28And so the numbers of times because we do trainings for the community at libraries and so
- 24:34forth.
- 24:34We do trainings for county local government and corporations.
- 24:39We do trainings for faculty, staff, and students around how to engage one another in
- 24:44terms of creating fun, easy on ramps to get our conversations flowing in terms of having
- 24:51accessible topics that people have a personal stake in so they're interesting and fun to talk
- 24:56about.
- 24:56And three, to make it fun, it has to be enjoyable.
- 24:59So what are the structures and turn takings that we can do to make it fun, to make it seem
- 25:04like there's some cash value to it?
- 25:05Like, I'm gonna get something out of this, like better decision making or being better today or
- 25:09better at dialogue or better listener.
- 25:11There's some sort of cash value, some sort of action item.
- 25:15Though we've done so many of those, and those would all be examples that I would point to to
- 25:20say, this is a place where the work of civility can really help people's lives get better in
- 25:25the moment.
- 25:26But all of those examples are about getting people to talk, not people getting people to
- 25:31stop screaming.
- 25:32I like that point about making it fun and engaging because I think a lot of times people
- 25:38find debates and that kind of thing.
- 25:41And especially in the realm of politics, think a lot of people find it boring or just not not
- 25:48not not any sort of interesting to to them.
- 25:51And I I think that's unfortunate because I I it really is a can be very fascinating experience
- 25:57for you to actually engage in that and have some sort of I personally think it's fun to
- 26:02find new ways of how people think about something.
- 26:05I'm I'm not necessarily, you know, supporting what they think or not, but at least getting I
- 26:10find it more fascinating and engaging to try to at least figure out why somebody thinks the way
- 26:16they do, whether it's for me to think about, okay, well, if I'm gonna debate this later, how
- 26:20how do people think about this?
- 26:22How can I counteract it?
- 26:23Or maybe they'll say something that I find convincing, and I'll be like, oh, you know
- 26:27what?
- 26:27Never thought about it like that.
- 26:28Maybe there is something to that.
- 26:29But I personally find it interesting in that angle.
- 26:33May maybe it's maybe partly there are some people that just don't have a natural curiosity
- 26:39in finding why people think the way they do.
- 26:42And that that's probably a whole other topic to get into.
- 26:46But I think that's also a really good point to make about, you know, this has people aren't
- 26:52gonna get involved if they don't find it engaging in some way.
- 26:55And it's not necessarily because they don't wanna get involved in in arguments or anything
- 26:59like that.
- 27:00They just don't think it's interesting in any sort of way for them, which I think is a shame.
- 27:04And I think that's I really appreciate that this civilian initiative takes that into
- 27:11account.
- 27:12And so going more back on the actual toxicity and division that we have right now, there's a
- 27:17lot of things that are contributing to our toxicity and polarization and division of
- 27:22today.
- 27:23For you, what are two the two to three factors in particular that heavily influence toxicity
- 27:29and political discourse and thus make civility more challenging?
- 27:33Inattention to one another is a big one.
- 27:36I think that, as I mentioned, the more we fight, the easier it is for us to flee and the
- 27:40further away we are from one another.
- 27:42I'm far from the first person to say that, the easier it is for us to develop misconceptions
- 27:46around one another.
- 27:47I do think that that plays into I'm one of these people who thinks that we as humans, and
- 27:52this is a a big claim, so go with me for a second.
- 27:55I think we have kind of a dual nature in a way.
- 27:59I think that we can be deeply connective, and I think we can be deeply combative.
- 28:04And that's a really confusing thing to say.
- 28:07But the minimum thresholds under which we can create group identity by which we can
- 28:13tribalize, by which we can have form in groups and out groups and clicks is nearly infinite,
- 28:19and it doesn't really take a big deal for us to tribalize over.
- 28:23And, of course, if it is a big deal, if there's a lot of identity or money or life or treasure
- 28:28on the line, then it can be very tribalizing.
- 28:32But also, we can be deeply connective and empathetic, both within our groups and beyond
- 28:38our groups, hopefully, as the circle of morality and who matters really expands for
- 28:44many of us.
- 28:45And so places where the the political scientist or political psychologist Liliana Mason talks
- 28:51about cross cutting cleavages, these places where our identities just don't quite line up,
- 28:58you know, Democrats who are in guns, for instance, or something along those lines.
- 29:01These places where we we think we live in these perfectly siloed spaces where my TV shows, my
- 29:11consumer choices, the car I drive, the ZIP code I live in, the neighborhood I live in, the
- 29:16place I work, and, of course, my politics and my political identity, all those things are
- 29:22perfectly in unison with one another.
- 29:24Finding cross cutting cleavages within people, places where my identity is just contradictory
- 29:31or screwy, and then places between us where we're connecting across those kinds of lines of
- 29:37assumed vision, I think, is a real antidote.
- 29:40Because it promotes not just that kind of connection of humanization, but hopefully, in
- 29:44the end, what I'm really working on is the ability to do perspective taking.
- 29:48So anything that we're not doing that is encouraging perspective taking, encouraging
- 29:52exposure, encouraging connection across difference to me is a place where we can be at
- 29:58real risk.
- 30:00I very much agree with the point about human beings being very contradictory.
- 30:06In fact, I think that's one of the most human things about us is how contradictory we can be.
- 30:10I mean, no, I don't think anybody is ever a 100% in line with what they believe.
- 30:16And put another way, human beings can be incredibly creative and incredibly destructive.
- 30:21And sometimes it's the same person.
- 30:23Or you look back at, you know, US history, and I this can sometimes be a very touchy subject.
- 30:30But, you know, you look at the founding fathers, and there's so many amazing things
- 30:34they did and what what they built and what and how long it's sustained.
- 30:39But also a lot of them were slave owners, and that also has to be acknowledged.
- 30:44There's a creative side to them.
- 30:46There's a destructive side to them.
- 30:47And, yes, you can say, oh, well, it's it's the time frame they came from.
- 30:50Doesn't mean that it's justified.
- 30:52You understand that it's a different time frame, but, you know, like George Washington,
- 30:58for example, you know, talking about or Thomas Jefferson saying all men are created equal, but
- 31:03they still had slaves.
- 31:04But doesn't doesn't discount that they a lot of the great things they did, but you also have to
- 31:09acknowledge a lot of the more destructive aspects of them even though they you know,
- 31:14there was that little bit of that cognitive dissonance.
- 31:17And, you know, the point about you you made about the the cleavages, think, is so important
- 31:22because we we do have a tendency to mistake groups for individuals and, you know, groups
- 31:29being we'll when we see a group, we obviously have a specific idea of what they are.
- 31:35And a lot of times that's, you know, it's it makes sense.
- 31:38But then you'll you'll find somebody in that group that just happens to step out of that
- 31:43line.
- 31:43And I've sometimes really wanna know more why they do.
- 31:46What what exactly makes them do that?
- 31:48But you'll, you know, you'll like you said, you'll find Democrats that are pro life.
- 31:52You'll find Republicans that are pro gun control.
- 31:55It's, you know, we have to be careful that we don't make this assumption that, oh, just
- 31:59because they have this one label that that means that they're obviously this way because
- 32:04you're mistaking the groups for the individuals.
- 32:07And now some people, you know, get into that group think mindset where, like or, you know,
- 32:12the really hardcore partisans talk about rhinos and dinos.
- 32:15Republicans in name only, democrats in name only because they get upset that they're
- 32:18stepping out of that line.
- 32:19But the parties are, by definition, a coalition, so there's going to be some tug and
- 32:25pull.
- 32:25There's there's there's gonna be some conflicting identities in in there.
- 32:30So really appreciate you highlighting those points as well.
- 32:35And so we're coming up a little bit towards the end of here, but I want to give you a chance to
- 32:44real quick promote your own podcast since obviously it's it's very relevant to the
- 32:48discussion we're talking about.
- 32:50So you have your own podcast called when we disagree.
- 32:53So can you tell us more about the podcast?
- 32:55I know you talked about it a little bit earlier, but tell us a little bit more about
- 32:58the podcast, why you started making it, and is it a component of the civility initiative, or
- 33:02is it your own thing?
- 33:04Yeah.
- 33:05The civilian initiative, I think about having three audiences.
- 33:08One is how are we influencing our national conversation about collective, peaceful,
- 33:13democratic coexistence?
- 33:15How are we influencing our state and our region in promoting effective decision making at all
- 33:21levels?
- 33:21And, of course, the college campus at the College of Charleston where I where I love to
- 33:25work.
- 33:26And so those are three audiences.
- 33:28And so to what extent we can talk about and reach a nation or find an audience that is not
- 33:33in my ZIP code or in my state, that is through appearances like this, media media work, but
- 33:38also the podcast.
- 33:39And so the podcast is very much a part of the civility initiative.
- 33:42Podcast is when we disagree is the shower idea that has taken over my life, and I adore it.
- 33:48And we are I started almost two years ago.
- 33:50We're about at a two year anniversary this March 2024, and we've had, like I mentioned,
- 33:56over a 100 episodes.
- 33:58And the the premise of the show is simple, which is what's a disagreement you can't get
- 34:02out of your head?
- 34:02And I try to get people who are thoughtful about conflicts or thoughtful at least about
- 34:07one conflict, if not lots of conflicts in their lives.
- 34:10So sometimes we'll have authors talk about a conflict related to a book they wrote, but
- 34:14sometimes we have people who have nothing to to promote, and they just wanna talk about a
- 34:19conflict they had with their mom or a conflict they had with about how to restore a piece of
- 34:24land near their house or a conflict they had with their mechanic about repairs to their car.
- 34:30But these are meaningful conflicts in people's lives that they can recall very, very well.
- 34:35And most of the time, it's about our internal emotional connection to conflict and trying to
- 34:39get a little bit better at that.
- 34:41And sometimes it is relational.
- 34:42You know?
- 34:43So the the story I told in the first episode and the reason I created the show in part was
- 34:48that I have this really powerful memory of being in an airport fifteen years ago, and I
- 34:53needed to change my flight.
- 34:54And the agent who was working at the desk that day made a mistake and canceled my flight as he
- 35:01was trying to change it.
- 35:02And it was early in the morning, and I didn't have my coffee and all the other excuses.
- 35:06And he said that he had accidentally canceled the flight relatively flippantly, or at least I
- 35:10heard him say it flippantly.
- 35:13And I didn't do anything horrific, but I really came at him verbally.
- 35:17And after the the interaction, and he was quickly able to save the issue, he ended up
- 35:22actually being able to recover my ticket and change my flight, and I got everything I wanted
- 35:27out of the engagement.
- 35:28And as I was walking to my new gate, I felt just tremendous shame.
- 35:34I felt shame about the way that I had talked to him.
- 35:37I felt shame that this little monster, it felt like lived within me.
- 35:40And who is that little monster that lurks in there?
- 35:43And what how did that come out?
- 35:45You know?
- 35:46And I also felt embarrassed.
- 35:47I mean, it wasn't super public, but there were people around.
- 35:49And I remember him looking at me straight in my face and saying, sir, I work at the airport.
- 35:54Your words mean nothing to me.
- 35:56And I felt felt very low at that moment because he had kind of won the exchange.
- 36:01And the other thing that really came up for me in that moment too is that I really wanted to
- 36:05tell him I was sorry.
- 36:07I really wanted to tell him and not even just making excuses.
- 36:10You're like, look.
- 36:10When that one got away from me, man, and I'm really sorry.
- 36:13And that's really important to me to be able to acknowledge when I've been wrong about
- 36:17something and to make a repair.
- 36:19And because I was catching a flight and I was in a hurry, I couldn't make the repair.
- 36:23I can I never I don't know his name?
- 36:26I it was a fifteen minutes of my life at best, but I can still see his face, and I can still
- 36:31feel how I felt in that moment.
- 36:33And that was in the grand scheme of your life, fifteen minutes, so relatively meaning meaning
- 36:38less.
- 36:39But it's meaningful for me in the way that I relate to conflict and how I think about myself
- 36:43and how I treat other people, especially strangers.
- 36:46And so, obviously, I've had way more meaningful conflicts relationally than that one, but that
- 36:50one keeps coming up for me.
- 36:51And so sometimes on the show, people tell stories like I just did where they're kind of
- 36:55the villain, and they had to learn something from being on the wrong end of of dispute.
- 37:00Sometimes we have people who tell stories where they are the victor, and maybe they were in a
- 37:05one-sided relationship where somebody had been taking advantage of them or bullying them.
- 37:09And they finally told them what time it was and stood up for themselves or set a boundary, and
- 37:14that's the meaningful conflict.
- 37:15And they learned something powerful about themselves and their ability to be brave in a
- 37:18moment and advocate for what they need.
- 37:20And then sometimes we have stories where you and I have both been in arguments where you
- 37:24will kinda look back after fifteen minutes or fifteen years and think, how did we even get
- 37:29here?
- 37:29And how did this even start in the first place?
- 37:31And it's just kind of the fog of argumentative war.
- 37:34And so we tell stories of confusion and people try to make their way in relationships amid
- 37:39confusion clashes as well.
- 37:41So in the end, it's a story about important conflicts in all of our lives and how we all
- 37:45relate to conflict.
- 37:47Yeah.
- 37:47I I can't I can't tell you the number of times I've had a you know, whether as I even if it's
- 37:53not like a really heated discussion about something, I I look back not even like ten
- 37:58minutes later.
- 37:59I'm like, that was so stupid.
- 38:00Why did I do that?
- 38:01Or or I you know what?
- 38:03I might I might have been right, but I still handled it poorly in a way where it's like, no,
- 38:07see, I could have said this in a much better way even if I really thought I was right.
- 38:11And sometimes I might have been.
- 38:12Sometimes I still just didn't wanna admit that I was wrong.
- 38:16But, you know, there are so many instances where I could have said y instead of And and
- 38:23the point you made about it being, you know, only fifteen minutes of your life.
- 38:28I I have a you know, and I think it's a lot of it's just anxiety where I think about something
- 38:32that happened that was relatively just not meaningful in the grand scheme of things, but,
- 38:37like, it still nags at me.
- 38:39And I think there's I think you showed a a a much better balance there.
- 38:43It's you shouldn't just, you know, outright dismiss all these experiences, but that at the
- 38:48same time, you they shouldn't be crippling to you where they're just, you know, you just as
- 38:52you start to think, oh, that's who I am.
- 38:54I'm not a terrible person.
- 38:55I think some people can get caught up in that too.
- 38:58It's no.
- 38:59These these these things, if as long as you they can seem small in the grand scheme of
- 39:06things, but if you actually do take a lesson out of it and become better, then even though
- 39:11it really didn't take up that much time in your life, you could still use it as a positive
- 39:16change for going forward.
- 39:17And I think you're what you talked about what the, for the guy at the airport was a really
- 39:22good example of that.
- 39:24And so let's I think that's a good segue into this this point about, you know, we talked
- 39:29about earlier how we like to give practical experience to people so that's not just very
- 39:34abstract or philosophical.
- 39:36It's things that they could do now.
- 39:37So I always like to make sure that at least one question I have towards the end of interviews
- 39:42is specifically dedicated to how people can practically apply information given by the
- 39:47guests.
- 39:47So what are two to three practical pieces of advice that anybody listening right now can use
- 39:53to promote civility?
- 39:55So first one is be a bridge builder.
- 39:59So how are you creating connection and conversations that are otherwise conflicting?
- 40:05And so what questions are you asking to inspire curiosity in the other person?
- 40:11What kinds of common ground are you trying to find in terms of values, in terms of beliefs
- 40:17about the world, or just in terms of your shared love of pickleball or whatever the thing
- 40:21is.
- 40:22And the second one is I think we should talk to more strangers.
- 40:25So let's build bridges where we're having conversations with one another, and let's talk
- 40:30to more strangers.
- 40:31Let's expand our social circle.
- 40:33Let's try to find some new, interesting, curious, unlikely connections and alliances.
- 40:38I will definitely vouch for the expanding social circles.
- 40:41You never know who you're gonna meet, and you'll you'll find I mean, there's gonna be
- 40:44something something you agree with.
- 40:46Might not be politics, might not be religion or anything like that, but you'll probably find
- 40:49some sort of interest that you two can agree on.
- 40:52Any final thoughts you'd like to share on civility and toxicity or the initiative?
- 40:57Any anything relevant to that?
- 40:59Any final thoughts?
- 41:00I appreciate the work you do, Paul.
- 41:02I mean, there's lots of good bedfellows in this space and who are promoting healthy conflict
- 41:07writ large, whatever that means, promoting healthy conflict, promoting bridge building,
- 41:12promoting talking to more strangers.
- 41:14And so my final thought would just be thank you for the work that you do, and I appreciate the
- 41:18chance to be on your show.
- 41:20Oh, well, I appreciate it.
- 41:21And thank and thank you for being on here, and thank you for the work that you are doing in
- 41:25this regard.
- 41:26It is nice to see it does feel like there's at least more and more people that are getting
- 41:31involved in this space, or at least I have been involved in this space much longer than I have.
- 41:34So it's always great to find other people that are in that space, especially because there are
- 41:39a pretty eclectic mix of us.
- 41:41There's some Republicans.
- 41:42There's some Democrats.
- 41:42There's some independents.
- 41:43There's some third parties.
- 41:44There's some people that don't even, you know, wanna specify what their politics are.
- 41:48Try to do that as little as possible myself.
- 41:51So really appreciate the work you do as well, and thank you for the kind words.
- 41:55And speaking of the Civilian Initiative, before we get to the final final question, how can
- 41:58people contribute to the work of the Civilian Initiative?
- 42:01Check out our media sources, which is you can find us at When We Disagree in any podcast.
- 42:07You can find PBS story that Judy Woodruff did about our work, and you can find me at a
- 42:13civility initiative at the College of Charleston.
- 42:15I'll come right up if you Google it.
- 42:17And then we are supported by viewers like you and by donors like you as well.
- 42:22And so we we always appreciate people's support, whether it's with their attention or
- 42:26their resources.
- 42:27Absolutely.
- 42:27I'll give you a chance to also share some links at the end, so I'll definitely put those as
- 42:31well.
- 42:32But before we get to that, gonna go to the final final question of the podcast.
- 42:38So for all my guests, I like to have random questions.
- 42:41You I mean, rarely ever related to politics.
- 42:44And even if it is related to politics, it's it's usually something silly.
- 42:48But I just like to use it just to round out the podcast, give people a different side to the
- 42:54guests.
- 42:55So for you, doctor Lee, random question of the day is, is a GIF file pronounced GIF or JIF?
- 43:04It's definitely GIF, and anybody who says it's GIF
- 43:07is Yes.
- 43:08Is fundamentally wrong.
- 43:10My my my deeply broken.
- 43:14Yeah.
- 43:14That's a great question.
- 43:15Yeah.
- 43:16I I I know we talk about civility here, but, boy, whenever I hear somebody say, Jiff, I it
- 43:21makes me irrationally annoyed.
- 43:23That's right.
- 43:23That is how can you think that?
- 43:25It's a graphics interface.
- 43:27Only appropriate response to that is
- 43:29But apparently, the guy apparently, the guy who created the type of file, I think he calls it a
- 43:34GIF.
- 43:35I was like, why would you do that?
- 43:37Like, I don't care what yeah.
- 43:39I don't care what he says.
- 43:41He's wrong.
- 43:41It's it's a GIF.
- 43:42It's a GIF.
- 43:43I'm gonna share a GIF.
- 43:44Come on now.
- 43:45Really?
- 43:45What are
- 43:46we talking about?
- 43:47But Great question.
- 43:48Yes.
- 43:48Okay.
- 43:49I I'm I'm I'm so thankful you said that.
- 43:52More thankful than I probably should be.
- 43:53Just drives me crazy when people say shit.
- 43:56You a lot invested in this one, but I get it.
- 43:59I have I've had other questions like that too that I've had with other people just that I get
- 44:05way too.
- 44:06So in in in a way, I kind of I kind of get, like, to be a little it's a little bit more
- 44:10cathartic for me there, so I don't get, like it helps me not to get angry about something
- 44:16political.
- 44:16You know, we're obviously talking about here with civility.
- 44:19So I kind of like to channel it at something that really actually doesn't matter in the
- 44:24grand scheme of things, like whether it's pronounced GIF or JIF.
- 44:26In a way, I think that actually kinda helps with the the catharsis.
- 44:29But, doctor Lee, thank you so much for being on here.
- 44:32And like I said, other things you wanna promote if you if you wanna promote your books that you
- 44:37have real quick, I you can do so right now.
- 44:41Thanks, Paul.
- 44:41Yeah.
- 44:42If anybody's curious to to go to sleep to either book I've read written called Creating
- 44:47Conservatism Post World War that Made an American Movement and We Are Not People,
- 44:53secession, and separatism in American politics since 1776.
- 44:58Alright.
- 44:58There you go.
- 44:59So I will definitely have those links there as well as to the civility initiative and the one
- 45:03we disagree podcast.
- 45:05My links, my Facebook, LinkedIn profile, medium.com profile, my five day educational
- 45:11email course, very relevant to this about how to more effectively combat toxicity in politics
- 45:17and my email and my website.
- 45:20So we are going to wrap things up here.
- 45:22So thank you all so much for listening.
- 45:24Please like, comment, share, and subscribe on YouTube, Spotify, and Apple Podcasts, and we
- 45:29will see you next time.