Latest / Legally Speaking with Michael Mulligan / Provocation, Defamation, and Disclosure in Canadian Law
Transcript
- 0:00Adam Stirling: It's time for a regular segment with Barrister and Solicitor with Mulligan Defense Lawyers.
- 0:03Adam Stirling: It's Legally Speaking on CFAX 1070.
- 0:06Adam Stirling: Morning, Michael Mulligan.
- 0:07Adam Stirling: How are you?
- 0:08Michael Mulligan: Hey, good morning.
- 0:09Michael Mulligan: I'm doing great.
- 0:10Michael Mulligan: Always good to be here.
- 0:11Adam Stirling: Some interesting files on the agenda for us this week.
- 0:13Adam Stirling: In the latest legal affairs Provocation, I'm reading here what it is and how it may relate to an appeal from a murder conviction.
- 0:23Michael Mulligan: Indeed, and I should say this, I think, is an important general topic for people to know about, because it's one of the sort of principles in criminal law that is often very much misunderstood.
- 0:35Michael Mulligan: People have generally heard of this concept of provocation and it is common in my experience that people think that somehow provocation amounts to a defense to all kinds of criminal conduct.
- 0:49Michael Mulligan: Right, the idea that you know well he provoked me before I hit him, or you know he provoked me so I kicked over his flowerpot, or whatever it might be right, provocation this is the important point is not a general defense to criminal conduct, right?
- 1:07Michael Mulligan: Somebody calling you names or saying something to you doesn't authorize you to go over and hit them or do something to get back at them.
- 1:13Michael Mulligan: So that's the first thing.
- 1:15Michael Mulligan: That's important is people have heard of this idea of provocation.
- 1:17Michael Mulligan: Now, we do have in Canada this legal concept of provocation, but it's really narrow in terms of where it applies.
- 1:25Michael Mulligan: That concept of provocation applies to potentially reduce a charge of murder to the offense of manslaughter, and the idea there is that if you have somebody who is subject to some sort of provocative conduct which would be sufficient to deprive an ordinary person of the power of self-control and the person acts on the sudden, before he has time for passions to cool and kill somebody, it can have that effect.
- 2:01Michael Mulligan: Now there was an interesting change to that requirement brought in in 2015.
- 2:07Michael Mulligan: Back in 2015, we had this thing called the Zero Tolerance for Barbaric Cultural Practices Act.
- 2:13Michael Mulligan: Yes, we have to be against that.
- 2:15Michael Mulligan: Who wants to be in favor of a barbaric cultural practice?
- 2:17Michael Mulligan: Indeed, yes, we should have zero tolerance for barbarism.
- 2:21Michael Mulligan: Yes, but the idea there, or the concern there, was that somehow these provisions would provide a partial defense for people engaged in honour killings.
- 2:33Michael Mulligan: That was the concept there, right, the idea that if somebody's honour was so damaged by their spouse cheating on them or something like that, it would somehow be acceptable to go and kill the person over it.
- 2:44Michael Mulligan: Right Now, I should say about that general concern, bear in mind, you've got to persuade a jury that this is something which would be sufficient to deprive an ordinary person of the power of self-control, and you act on the sudden and there's no time for passion to cool, and ultimately, at the end of the day, there are 12 ordinary people, so good luck with that pitch.
- 3:03Michael Mulligan: They're 12 ordinary people, so good luck with that pitch.
- 3:05Michael Mulligan: But anyways, that was at least the political justification for a change to the provocation provisions that added a requirement that the act, the alleged provocation, also would have to constitute an offense punishable theoretically by five years or more in prison punishable theoretically by five years or more in prison.
- 3:25Michael Mulligan: And so the idea there, I guess, was to eliminate the possibility of, say, infidelity on its own or something like that being the provocation.
- 3:33Michael Mulligan: Now you can imagine the challenges.
- 3:36Michael Mulligan: I mean you can think you appreciate what I just described.
- 3:39Michael Mulligan: Yes, okay, fair enough.
- 3:40Michael Mulligan: We don't want honor killing somehow being justified in some you know theoretical world where a jury was doing that.
- 3:46Michael Mulligan: But you can imagine how there could be circumstances where there would be something which would be extremely provocative, that may not also be a crime, right?
- 3:57Michael Mulligan: So let's say, you know, a woman comes into her bedroom after you know chopping wood and catches her husband in bed with her sister, right, and responds by throwing the wood at the husband or something and he dies.
- 4:13Michael Mulligan: Well, is that what we intended to not have covered?
- 4:17Michael Mulligan: Probably not right Now.
- 4:20Michael Mulligan: On the other hand, in that same fact pattern, if the woman came in and caught her husband in bed with her sister and the husband, you know, threw something at her the TV, remote control or something, oh, that could be an assault with a weapon.
- 4:32Michael Mulligan: Now, provocation could apply.
- 4:33Michael Mulligan: Is that really what we were?
- 4:34Michael Mulligan: Is that the line we were trying to parse?
- 4:36Michael Mulligan: Probably not.
- 4:46Michael Mulligan: And there's been some issue, like in BC.
- 4:46Michael Mulligan: There's at least one case in BC, bc where a judge found those changes to themselves be unconstitutional, but there's been uneven treatment of that.
- 4:50Michael Mulligan: So there is some uncertainty in the law I'll put it that way in terms of whether those provisions in the Zero Tolerance for Barbaric Cultural Practices Act are constitutionally permissible to restrict that concept of provocation to just where the Provocative Act was also a crime.
- 5:09Michael Mulligan: Right Now, this brings us to the case in BC, the decision that just came out I think it was just yesterday, yeah, yesterday by the BC Court of Appeal and this was a case where there was a husband who was charged with murdering his spouse.
- 5:24Michael Mulligan: And this was a case where there was a husband who was charged with murdering his spouse.
- 5:31Michael Mulligan: And in that case the husband testified and at trial he alleged that he'd been the subject of abuse by the wife for a number of years, including physical abuse, verbal abuse, trust issues, alleged some incident in the past, biting his hand and injuring his leg with a flower pot.
- 5:47Michael Mulligan: That was the background of it.
- 5:49Michael Mulligan: And he claimed that on the occasion of the killing and there's no doubt that he killed his wife.
- 5:55Michael Mulligan: He admitted to doing that.
- 5:56Michael Mulligan: He alleged that he had come home and there'd been a dispute and eventually she wound up.
- 6:03Michael Mulligan: He alleged that she charged at him with a machete and that he picked up a dispute and eventually she wound up.
- 6:05Michael Mulligan: He alleged that she charged Adam with a machete and that he picked up a baseball bat and hit her and killed her.
- 6:10Michael Mulligan: That was his version of events and so at trial and I should say the Crown's version of events was quite different their version of events was that he had killed her and then placed the machete there, left the house and phoned the police some 50 minutes later, after talking to a friend.
- 6:26Michael Mulligan: So there's just a factual dispute.
- 6:28Michael Mulligan: But for the jury one of the issues was and I should say it was a jury case, as virtually all murder trials are, unless both sides agree to have just a judge hear it.
- 6:37Michael Mulligan: Here, one of the issues was whether the judge should have clearly specified that the things that can be considerations for self-defense are not considerations for that concept of provocation, and here's why that matters.
- 6:55Michael Mulligan: You can have a case like this one I'm describing where both potential defenses would apply.
- 7:00Michael Mulligan: Right On his version of events he was just defending himself, right?
- 7:03Michael Mulligan: Hey, she was attacking me with a machete.
- 7:04Michael Mulligan: I was just protecting myself with a baseball bat.
- 7:05Michael Mulligan: Right On his version of events he was just defending himself, right.
- 7:06Michael Mulligan: Hey, she was attacking me with a machete, I was just protecting myself with a baseball bat, right.
- 7:08Michael Mulligan: But you can have a circumstance, like in this one, where the amount of force used was very significant, like there was forensic evidence that made it appear that the woman who died was hit multiple times with a baseball bat, very badly injured right and died.
- 7:22Michael Mulligan: And so you could have a circumstance where a jury would say, well, maybe you were defending yourself, but you used too much force.
- 7:29Michael Mulligan: Right, because force used has to be reasonable.
- 7:32Michael Mulligan: Right in order to constitute, given all the circumstances, in order to constitute a potential defense, a defense of self-defense.
- 7:39Michael Mulligan: But this idea of provocation does not have an element of like weighing up or reasonableness.
- 7:44Michael Mulligan: The idea is the person just sort of snapped because there were some, you know, tremendously insulting things that just occurred, and they just snapped and they acted on the sudden.
- 7:53Michael Mulligan: Now I should also say this the only reason we have this concept of provocation really is because murder in Canada has a mandatory minimum life sentence, and so this is one of those examples where this was designed to kind of temper that right, the idea that you know somebody just kind of on the quick explodes in rage at some terribly insulting thing that's happened to them.
- 8:14Michael Mulligan: We don't want to necessarily put them in prison for life, which is why we have this.
- 8:18Michael Mulligan: An alternative approach would be to allow judges greater flexibility in terms of sentencing, so they could take into account the woman who catches her husband in bed with her sister and how she responds and what sentence should be imposed.
- 8:30Michael Mulligan: But we don't.
- 8:31Michael Mulligan: So we have this division between murder and life in prison, or it doesn't amount to provocation, one of the ways to kind of reduce the harshness of the mandatory minimum penalty in that kind of case, bearing in mind human frailties, right, that's really what is at the root of all this, right?
- 8:50Michael Mulligan: Yes, now, in this particular case the Court of Appeal dealt with, the judge did not expressly tell the jury that when they're considering provocation, if they determine it wasn't self-defense, they are not required to consider things like whether the force used was reasonable or proportionate to the risk of a machete-wielding person running at you, right?
- 9:12Michael Mulligan: But the Court of Appeal ultimately found that they didn't have to parse out and decide that issue about whether the insulting activity has to also constitute defense, because his version of events was she attacked me with a machete, right?
- 9:25Michael Mulligan: So that would be potentially quite provocative but also a crime right which could get you more than five years in prison.
- 9:31Michael Mulligan: So the Court of Appeal didn't have to sort out that little interesting legal issue.
- 9:35Michael Mulligan: But the Court of Appeal here pointed out that even though the judge didn't expressly tell the jury, hey, you don't need to take into account the things you just thought about if you determined this was self-defense or not, like the amount of force used, whether it was reasonable, proportional, that kind of thing that the person is not entitled to describe it as a perfect jury instruction.
- 9:57Michael Mulligan: It just has to be a proper instruction.
- 10:00Michael Mulligan: And they found that the way the judge did it here.
- 10:02Michael Mulligan: Telling the jury you need to consider self-defense and all the elements of that, and only if you find self-defense didn't apply would you then go on to consider this issue of provocation.
- 10:12Michael Mulligan: Telling the jury they had to determine whether the Crown had proven that the woman hadn't committed an offense punishable by more than five years in prison.
- 10:21Michael Mulligan: Again, didn't have to sort out that issue Whether it was sufficient to deprive an ordinary person of the power of self-control, whether the person lost the power of self-control as a result of the deceased's conduct, whether it was on the sudden and whether this act occurred before there was time for passions to cool.
- 10:37Michael Mulligan: The judge had set it out as a five-part framework for the jury and ultimately the Court of Appeal found that the way the judge did it was fine.
- 10:47Michael Mulligan: It may not have been the perfect way to describe it.
- 10:49Michael Mulligan: Maybe you could have also said well, you don't have to consider the proportional nature of the force and reasonableness of it when deciding on provocation.
- 10:58Michael Mulligan: But in the context of all of this, the way it was done and the way it was laid out for the judge, the Court of Appeal found that that was acceptable, and so the jury ultimately did convict the man of second degree murder, and the Court of Appeal yesterday upheld that.
- 11:13Michael Mulligan: But I thought it was an interesting case because it does deal with this concept of provocation, which is both some legal controversy in terms of how that should be interpreted and whether those changes were permissible, but also because it is just so broadly misunderstood and it's important for people to know.
- 11:29Michael Mulligan: Provocation in the sense of you know, he said something that was terribly rude to me so I went up and slapped him is not in any way a defense.
- 11:36Michael Mulligan: So don't think that because somebody does something provocative that's somehow going to amount to a defense to, you know, hitting somebody or slapping them or damaging their property or threatening them or all the various things that are more common than somebody being killed.
- 11:51Michael Mulligan: So that's provocation.
- 11:52Michael Mulligan: That's for the lawyers in Canada and that's the latest from the BC Court of Appeal.
- 11:56Adam Stirling: All right, Legally speaking, we'll continue in just a moment on CFAX 1070.
- 12:00Adam Stirling: Legally speaking, on CFAX 1070 continues with Michael Mulligan from Mulligan Defense Lawyers.
- 12:05Adam Stirling: Michael up next, I'm reading it says no trial when there is no possible defense to a defamation claim for calling a city employee.
- 12:14Adam Stirling: Does that say pedophile?
- 12:16Adam Stirling: That's right.
- 12:18Michael Mulligan: Oh dear.
- 12:18Michael Mulligan: So here's the background.
- 12:21Michael Mulligan: This is the case out of Nanaimo and it's a case it's a defamation claim that was brought by the city of Nanaimo and a fellow there who is a communications manager, suing an individual.
- 12:35Michael Mulligan: Described to somebody, an individual, that this is a description by the judge that frequencies the municipal hall.
- 12:41Michael Mulligan: So, in the best description of you, somebody who frequents the municipal, that this is a description by the judge that frequencies the municipal hall.
- 12:45Michael Mulligan: So, in the best description of you as somebody who frequents the municipal hall, it may be a cause for further inquiry.
- 12:49Michael Mulligan: Anyways, the alleged conduct that was being sued over was this person who frequents the municipal hall For some reason took a disliking to the communications manager as a result of that person doing things like raising a pride flag and issuing a statement in support of the school board's gender-inclusive learning environment, and so, in response to that, this frequenter of the municipal hall was doing things like showing up at public meetings and in front of other people, calling this person a pedophile, alleging that he was sexualizing children, and doing things like posting on Facebook a video where he voiced over it, saying there's the pedo sitting with his plaid jacket on.
- 13:41Michael Mulligan: So doing it publicly in front of others and online and, as the judge pointed out, doing that without a scintilla of evidence that this person was anything like that.
- 13:52Michael Mulligan: He's just a municipal employee doing things directed by, no doubt, the city, none of which were anything like what was being alleged.
- 14:00Michael Mulligan: Now, the way it works, here's how a civil claim works If you want to sue somebody, you set out what you're suing them for and, I think, called a notice of civil claim.
- 14:08Michael Mulligan: So you set out, like here's what I'm claiming you did and here's why I'm saying there's a cause of action.
- 14:13Michael Mulligan: Here's what I'm saying, how that impacted me and here's what I say happened.
- 14:17Michael Mulligan: And then you give that or serve that to the person you're suing, and the person you're suing has to file the document responding to that.
- 14:24Michael Mulligan: If they don't, you win automatically.
- 14:26Michael Mulligan: So it's an obligation to respond.
- 14:28Michael Mulligan: And in the thing replying to the notice of civil claim, you set out like what do you dispute here, right?
- 14:34Michael Mulligan: Sometimes a dispute might be like well, I didn't do that, a factual dispute, or you know, the law doesn't allow you to do this, whatever it might be right.
- 14:42Michael Mulligan: So the idea with those two documents is they kind of frame what is this claim?
- 14:46Michael Mulligan: What's going on here, right?
- 14:52Michael Mulligan: So a judge has a basis, or the lawyers have a basis, to sort of what's this all about?
- 14:55Michael Mulligan: Right?
- 14:55Michael Mulligan: And in this particular case those things happened, right, the city and the communications person served the frequenter of the municipal hall with the claim.
- 15:04Michael Mulligan: The lawyers for the city and the employee, after looking at the response that was filed, came to court and said, look, even if you accept everything this person said in the response, right, like he said things, like he believed the statements were true, right, but that doesn't do it.
- 15:24Michael Mulligan: And he said various other things claiming like, well, he had the right, this was somehow a matter of public interest that he was commenting on.
- 15:31Michael Mulligan: Again, that just doesn't apply here, right, it's just some person, you know, some municipal employee, and so the way it works.
- 15:38Michael Mulligan: So this was an application for what's called a summary judgment and the idea there is look, judge, please read everything that I'm claiming happened, read the defense that the person has filed, right?
- 15:52Michael Mulligan: And then ask yourself if you accept all these things that the person is saying in their defense, it's still made out or there's just no possible defense to it, right?
- 15:58Michael Mulligan: And in that case you don't need to have a trial.
- 16:01Michael Mulligan: Why are we having a trial right?
- 16:03Michael Mulligan: It's like if I sue you claiming that you I don't know came over and knocked over a flower pot on my front deck, damaging it, and I'm suing you for a new field the cost of the flower pot and your defense is it was a sunny day and I had white shoes on, and so you're like, okay, well, that's fascinating, but you don't disagree that you knocked over the flower pot, right, or how much the flower pot cost.
- 16:24Michael Mulligan: So why are we having a trial here, right?
- 16:26Michael Mulligan: And so the point is that when you have that kind of a circumstance, a claim, and then a response to it that doesn't amount to a defense to it at all and there really isn't a factual disagreement.
- 16:36Michael Mulligan: It's like well, there's what you said, it's right there, it's recorded, right, and there's no evidence that it's true.
- 16:41Michael Mulligan: The point is you don't need to have a trial.
- 16:44Michael Mulligan: And so the judge of this case did what was being requested and without having a trial, trial just found look, there's just no possible defense to what's being claimed here.
- 16:53Michael Mulligan: And so I gave judgment for the plaintiffs, and what was being asked here for was an injunction to order the person to like stop doing this and take those things down from Facebook and other places.
- 17:07Michael Mulligan: You've posted them right.
- 17:08Michael Mulligan: It doesn't look like they were going after money, because, let's be honest, somebody whose primary description is a frequenter of the municipal hall probably doesn't scream out a great deal of resources ready to pay a financial claim.
- 17:22Michael Mulligan: It looks like what they were really concerned with here is get this stuff offline and stop doing this, because the person was doing it repeatedly, and the judge granted exactly that and so issued a permanent injunction ordering this person to stop doing this.
- 17:36Michael Mulligan: No more comments like that.
- 17:38Michael Mulligan: And you've got seven days to get these things removed from the Internet, off of Facebook and so on, and if you don't do it, the result would be he could then be held in contempt of court.
- 17:47Michael Mulligan: So quit.
- 17:47Michael Mulligan: It is really what the order amounts to, and so I thought that was worth commenting on, just so people appreciate how it works.
- 17:53Michael Mulligan: How those uh, like the civil claim and response to it frame the uh, what's going on and what happens when the display and the response to it really isn't a meaningful response to it.
- 18:03Michael Mulligan: They're just a bunch of things that would not amount to a defense.
- 18:05Michael Mulligan: You don't need to have a trial about nothing, so that's the latest out of the city of nanaimo.
- 18:10Michael Mulligan: On the definition claim.
- 18:12Adam Stirling: Four minutes remaining in the hour.
- 18:14Adam Stirling: Up next crown disclosure obligations in criminal cases, a matter we've discussed before, of great importance.
- 18:21Michael Mulligan: It is of great importance, right, and that is there's a requirement in criminal cases, and it comes from the idea that you need to have a fair trial and a person has to be able to properly defend themselves, and the general principle in terms of disclosure is that Crown and the police have to turn over to the defense evidence that they've collected that would be relevant to the case.
- 18:42Michael Mulligan: Kind of makes sense, right, you know, please turn over the videotape and the witness statements and so on.
- 18:49Michael Mulligan: Things can get a little murkier, though, when you're dealing with things that either the police or Crown don't have or that were collected in other investigations, right?
- 18:59Michael Mulligan: The law is pretty clear that if the police collect evidence, like in the case that they, you know is being prosecuted, the evidence has to be turned over, right?
- 19:08Michael Mulligan: You can't hide the evidence that shows the person might be innocent.
- 19:11Michael Mulligan: Why would you want that, right?
- 19:12Michael Mulligan: But what about things like and in this case, it was an allegation of uttering threats, and it was an allegation made by an ex-wife, claiming that her ex-husband had threatened her?
- 19:26Michael Mulligan: The background, though, was that the husband said look, she's made similar allegations, which were determined to be untrue, on multiple other occasions in a very similar circumstance when he was trying to exercise access to their common child right, and so he was saying I want the disclosure from the previous false claims that she made on other occasions, right, multiple ones.
- 19:48Michael Mulligan: And the Crown didn't provide that and they took the position that those are things called third-party records and the idea there is that if it's something that the police gathered in the case, turn it over.
- 19:59Michael Mulligan: If it's something which is like somebody else has and the police didn't collect like, let's say, the person wants to get a copy of the I don't know doorbell video from the next-door neighbor and, whatever reason, the police just didn't go get that.
- 20:12Michael Mulligan: They don't have it Well, the police and Crown don't have to give you what they don't have.
- 20:16Michael Mulligan: Nor can you force the police to go out and gather other evidence, right, and so if you want to get like the doorbell cam, for example, you have to make an application to get that as a third party record.
- 20:26Michael Mulligan: Somebody else has it Might be relevant, there's a process for it, else has it?
- 20:32Michael Mulligan: It might be relevant, there's a process for it.
- 20:34Michael Mulligan: But what about the police files from other cases?
- 20:35Michael Mulligan: And the idea is that generally, police files from other cases are going to generally be third-party records, with the idea that not everything the Crown has has to be disclosed, because the Crown's a pretty broad concept.
- 20:47Michael Mulligan: You know, if somebody's being prosecuted for uttering threats and they want some record the federal government has, you know that might have some bearing on it you say, well, go get it from them.
- 20:55Michael Mulligan: It's not all disclosure material in the ordinary way, but there's a recent case that emphasizes a BC case.
- 21:10Michael Mulligan: The defense made clear the defense says that she's making a false claim and she's made previous false claims that the police investigated and they have files on it.
- 21:18Michael Mulligan: And I like those other examples of false claims this person made right and the idea there is that even though it's not the investigation it'd be a different file number on it right Happened on a different time.
- 21:29Michael Mulligan: The court pointed out that there is an obligation that comes from a supreme court, a candidate place for the crown, to make proactive inquiries.
- 21:35Michael Mulligan: They can't just sit passively back and look at the stuff and if that other stuff, even though it's, yes, it's from a different investigation, that some complaint she made three weeks ago or three months ago or last year that the police determined to be untrue, that amounts to stuff which would be obviously relevant given what they know about the case, and so this BC case that came out recently points out that the Crown has an obligation to provide that obviously relevant stuff, even if it's from a different case.
- 22:02Michael Mulligan: That's not a third party record, and the Crown can't just passively back.
- 22:07Michael Mulligan: When there are things like that that look like they clearly exist, they should be making queries and looking at it and, if it's obviously relevant, turn it over.
- 22:14Michael Mulligan: They can't hide behind yeah, that is a different file number on it, all right, so that's why I thought that was interesting.
- 22:19Michael Mulligan: That's the concept and latest on disclosure.
- 22:22Adam Stirling: Michael Mulligan, with Mulligan Defense Lawyers, legally speaking during the second half of our second hour every Thursday.
- 22:26Adam Stirling: Thank you so much as always.