Latest / Energy Voice – Out Loud / Energy Voice Out Loud x Scottish Enterprise
Transcript
- 0:05Hello and welcome to a very special edition of Energy Voice
- 0:09Out Loud brought to you in partnership with Scottish
- 0:12Enterprise. Now I'm Aberdeen Features lead,
- 0:15Ryan Duff, and joining me today is Terry Hogg, Innovation
- 0:19Systems Team Leader at Scottish Enterprise.
- 0:23He started with the organization all the way back in 2002, left
- 0:27in 2010 and then returned in 2016.
- 0:30You've been around the block, Terry.
- 0:32How you doing today? Right, thanks.
- 0:34It seems like that long ago as well.
- 0:36But yeah, thanks for sharing that.
- 0:37Yeah, but you know what, it's it's important.
- 0:40We're speaking about offshore wind today.
- 0:41And offshore wind, people keep referring to it as an emerging
- 0:45technology, but it's been around for a good wee while.
- 0:48And I feel like your time at Scottish Enterprise, you've
- 0:50really seen that technology grow.
- 0:52Joining us today as well is Nissima Brown, strategy director
- 0:56from FedEx. Now she's also a director at the
- 0:59Aberdeen Renewal Renewable Energy Group with decades of
- 1:02experience and what having worked in places all over the
- 1:05world, including Ghana, Texas, and of course, my native Granite
- 1:09City. How are you doing, NASA?
- 1:12You feel like it feels like you're well suited to tackle the
- 1:16questions that we're going to pose to you today.
- 1:18Well, we'll see about that. Thank you, Ryan, and thank you,
- 1:21Terry, for inviting me to join you on this conversation.
- 1:24Yeah. And I'm here to share our
- 1:27experience working with Cost Enterprise and our work, great
- 1:33work to support the emerging, like you said and the fast
- 1:37growing offshore wind sector. Definitely, definitely.
- 1:41And you know what, we, we obviously spoke a little bit
- 1:43before this, this podcast and we, we discussed something
- 1:47that's maybe maybe a term that for the folks that haven't
- 1:50worked with Scottish Enterprise before or maybe haven't or maybe
- 1:54aren't within your organization, Terry might, might not be too
- 1:58familiar with. So I'm going to ask you straight
- 2:01down the line, demand driven innovation.
- 2:05What the heck is that? Yeah, it's a good, good
- 2:07question, right. We use it all the time.
- 2:09And yeah, and I suppose don't think about it, but pretty
- 2:13simply it's about focusing in on on where the industry demand
- 2:18we're customer demands, customer demands are for for innovation.
- 2:23We have a wealth of innovation support products, funding
- 2:29expertise that's fantastically set up to support companies who
- 2:34approach us with technology and supporting them to develop
- 2:38technology through various concepts, prototypes and and and
- 2:42whatnot. And that that's that's great.
- 2:44Whereas demand driven innovation and we're supporting is to
- 2:48complement that by using our knowledge networks to really get
- 2:54under the skin of what the industry looks like and what the
- 2:57industry wants. What is the industry industry
- 3:00demanding in terms of improvements to products and
- 3:06services? You know, where are their pain
- 3:07points? Where are the existing products
- 3:10on the marketplace not quite giving them what they need?
- 3:14And it's really about fully understanding that and using
- 3:18that as a, as a, as a signal to encourage companies within the
- 3:24supply chain to respond to that and a clear opportunity, a clear
- 3:29industry demand that says you, if you can solve this, again,
- 3:33I'm disappearing into a buzz free as an innovation challenge.
- 3:35If you can solve this particular demand that the industry has for
- 3:39a, an improved product or service, then potentially
- 3:42there's a specific market opportunity there for you.
- 3:44So that's that's what we term demand driven innovation.
- 3:48So it in a nutshell, it's sort of breaking down silos between
- 3:52tech firms that are working to sort of solve the issues they
- 3:55think developers have and, and you know, the developer issues
- 4:00and bringing them together to make sure that efforts are best
- 4:03placed. Yeah, I know I'll probably go a
- 4:05stage further and yeah, there will be folks who are we're able
- 4:08to better bring that together. But what we're also looking to
- 4:12do is to stimulate others who haven't even thought about it
- 4:15yet. It may be in other sectors who
- 4:18think, you know what, I've got something here.
- 4:20If I if I can understand and the opportunity, I can understand
- 4:26that that market customer demand, I can apply my
- 4:29technology that may be pointed somewhere else a completely
- 4:32different market to that. So, so as well as bringing the
- 4:35two things together. Yeah, you're absolutely right.
- 4:37And that's, that's part of it, but it's about really making
- 4:40sure that we are identifying and flushing out the the innovators
- 4:45throughout the Scottish supply chain that can respond to to the
- 4:48the industry challenges that may not even be aware of.
- 4:51And you know, we, we touched on the, the idea of when offshore
- 4:55winds specifically being a bit of an emerging market now,
- 4:58we've, we've had turbines in the North Sea for, for over a decade
- 5:03now. But it's important to sort of
- 5:06make sure that this demand driven innovations or connects.
- 5:10But how, how important is it for areas such as offshore wind?
- 5:14I mean, offshore wind, such a massive space.
- 5:17And then we've got floating, I'm hearing deep water, which is
- 5:19somewhere between fixed bottom and floating.
- 5:21Then we've obviously got the traditional stuff too.
- 5:24How important is this demand driven innovation?
- 5:27Yeah. Well, we, we fundamentally
- 5:29believe that the, the demand driven approach is, is important
- 5:32to all sectors. But I, I, I think there's
- 5:34particular attributes of offshore renewable was an
- 5:39offshore wind that, that sort of heating the importance of it.
- 5:43And a couple of areas there that you, you mentioned that, you
- 5:48know, there's, we've had offshore winds for over a decade
- 5:51in, in Scottish waters the, the little period.
- 5:54But I wasn't in Scottish Enterprise.
- 5:56I was actually at the offshore renewable energy Catapult.
- 6:00And at the time, I think people were laughing at the the
- 6:06ambition that we had to to reduce the cost of offshore wind
- 6:10energy from 100 and 4000 and 50 lbs per MW hour down to a target
- 6:15of 100 because it was so ambitious.
- 6:18And that was smashed. And a lot of the reason for that
- 6:21was the industry. And this is continuing.
- 6:24So you look at a cost reduction curve.
- 6:26So it's important that within these developing industries that
- 6:31the industry gets together and actually collaborates and shares
- 6:36information on what the common challenges are.
- 6:38Yes, it's a highly competitive area, but there are some
- 6:41fundamentally common challenges that if we can work with
- 6:46industry to uncover them and find solutions to them that can
- 6:50be shared and that will help the industry become more cost
- 6:54competitive. And now you've got offshore
- 6:56energy cheaper and and all that Folks don't realize this
- 7:00actually, you know, it's it's it's vastly undercut fossil fuel
- 7:04energy generation standard fixed.
- 7:06Yes, we know we are pushing you into deeper and floating which
- 7:10has those same challenges, but also has that same potential to
- 7:13reduce in that cost curve through sharing information
- 7:18about their challenges and and really stimulate more demand
- 7:21driven innovation to to address that.
- 7:23Also, what I would say as well is that from a an innovator's
- 7:26perspective, part of the demand driven innovation is about
- 7:29finding the market signals, Yes, but if we get this right, it's
- 7:33finding a first customer, you know who wants to be a first
- 7:36customer, right, Not not many folks really.
- 7:38So and actually if you think about it, all offshore wind
- 7:42innovations need to be tested at some point offshore with a first
- 7:46customer. So it's really important that we
- 7:49do that and the risks and the costs offshore are are very
- 7:55significant. So it's really important that we
- 7:57find ways to share the innovation challenges, but also
- 8:01find viable ways to that that first customer and that
- 8:04demonstrator that can de risk technologies and show the
- 8:07industry and and encourage the industry to adopt.
- 8:09Them yeah it's that older oil and gas North Sea turn of phrase
- 8:14isn't it that race to be second no one wants to be the first
- 8:18person to test that new technology it's.
- 8:20Human nature, isn't it, you know, Why would you if someone
- 8:22else? Well, but there are fortunately
- 8:25there are organisations with support and that's where
- 8:29governments come in. You're with, you know,
- 8:31recognizing that there's a degree of risk that commercial
- 8:35industry players will take and there's a degree of risk they
- 8:37want. And when we understand that we
- 8:39could find ways to to to address that collectively, then we've
- 8:42got a chance of of really demonstrating and rolling out
- 8:46innovations that can benefit everyone.
- 8:48Do you know, I want to throw a slight spanner in the works and
- 8:50cycle back to to price, if that's all right, the the cost
- 8:53of fixed bottom because you know, the price of renewables
- 8:56was a big headline earlier in the year.
- 8:59Wasn't that you know, with the the allocation round seven
- 9:02winners announcement the opposition were, you know, very
- 9:06much, very much saying that we were paying too much for
- 9:10renewables in your in your sort of capacity as a former ORE
- 9:14catapult, you know, staff member.
- 9:18Did you does it is it difficult not to feel a bit smug going
- 9:21well, look at how low it is compared to what it was.
- 9:24People laughed at us at 100 and now we're we're smashing that
- 9:28and people are still saying it's too.
- 9:29I don't. You know, no, no, not from my
- 9:31perspective and spugness. I think what what what is clear
- 9:34is that there's a lot of and I I'm no expert of, you know,
- 9:38cards on the table, my things innovation, innovation support.
- 9:41That's what I was doing the offshore near to catapult.
- 9:43But in terms of the the energy economics and the comparative
- 9:47price points of various technologies of as much, you
- 9:50know, knowledge as as as can most folks in the industry, but
- 9:53no experts. But I think that there's a lot
- 9:56of misinformation out there at times and a lot of confusing
- 10:00information out there as well. But where, where I was going
- 10:03with the, the comment was to say, look, you know, I think
- 10:05it's easy to look at a snapshot in time and not the that again,
- 10:10I mentioned that that cost reduction curve, which is really
- 10:13important. And you see it with another, you
- 10:15know, photovoltaics is a classic example that went from, you
- 10:17know, in terms of the, the speed that cost curve came down was
- 10:22incredible. And you know, offshore winds
- 10:25there in terms of the, the fixed and the monopolies at a certain
- 10:28depth somewhere to go otherwise. But I think it's just a
- 10:32recognition that, you know, there's, there's, there's,
- 10:34there's a price point agenda definitely, but there's a,
- 10:37there's a cost curve to be thinking about as well and
- 10:40actually showing progress down that.
- 10:42And that was one of the things that we we did at the Catapult
- 10:45was to show the predictions and the curve and to show progress
- 10:49and to keep governments and industry on board.
- 10:52Actually, this is a this is a believable path because I think
- 10:55you had your floating at the last option was about 200.
- 10:59And some people would balk out your why are we paying £200, you
- 11:02know, for when we can pay, you know, 90 lbs for, for standard
- 11:06offshore? Well, yeah, we can.
- 11:08But actually, you know, if, if, if the trajectory is the same,
- 11:11then that will come down, come down below the fossil fuel price
- 11:15and actually open up much more indigenous market.
- 11:18More importantly, export markets where they have topography such
- 11:23that, you know, the the standard fixed doesn't work like Japan,
- 11:25for instance, shelves off pretty rapidly and is really looking
- 11:29for non hydrocarbon solutions to their energy needs.
- 11:33So, so I think it's about you know, just communicating the
- 11:38fact that that the initial price when you're at an R&D and a
- 11:42demonstrator is one thing. And if you can get industry to
- 11:48collaborate on sharing innovation challenges and get
- 11:52really good demand driven programmes going and find ways
- 11:55to for customer and demonstrations, you can really
- 11:57accelerate down that down that curve.
- 12:01And I'm aware that we're a good chunk into this conversation and
- 12:04there's many things we haven't addressed, one of which is
- 12:07Nassima, I've, I've not actually asked you a question yet.
- 12:11I'm really sorry. But we were speaking about that
- 12:13race. The second the, the mentality
- 12:17of, you know, that sort of maybe being slightly scared, maybe
- 12:20slightly hesitant to pick up new technology now in your capacity
- 12:23of FedEx. Is that is that an attitude
- 12:27that's changing, or is that something that's still here to
- 12:29stay? Being the 1st to try something
- 12:33that is new and innovative still quite a challenge for a lot of
- 12:37companies out there and believe it or not, we always think that
- 12:43the bigger the company, the bigger risk they can take.
- 12:46The reality is from our perspective, and I'm sure a lot
- 12:49of companies relate to that, the hardest part is for, you know,
- 12:56corporate big companies to really open up too disruptive or
- 13:01an effective way to do things. So I think racing to be #2
- 13:07perhaps it's quite unfair from my perspective, if I'd like to,
- 13:11if I put it out there, it's quite easy.
- 13:13It is very challenging to, to try out a new way of doing
- 13:18things. And I think the fear of
- 13:22disruption, the fear of not knowing, you know, what are,
- 13:25what's the result, what the impact, it's always there for
- 13:29any company to kind of assess and evaluate.
- 13:32However, I think it's also fair to to admit and to highlight
- 13:39that Scottish based companies and companies out of Aberdeen
- 13:43really deeply rooted in the engineering decades of
- 13:47engineering supporting cutting edge or maybe, you know,
- 13:51disruptive engineering technologies that have been
- 13:55supporting the offshore energy industry across the world for
- 13:58the last few decades have been quite successful in developing,
- 14:04commercializing new tech right from here.
- 14:09So I think the know how is there, the credibility is, is
- 14:14there? Is it easy?
- 14:17No, it's never easy, but that's, you know, that's the fun part of
- 14:21it, I think. Do you know what we're we're
- 14:23skirting around the, the, the major talking point of the, of
- 14:26this conversation. We're, we're speaking about
- 14:29innovation, but we're not speaking about the offshore wind
- 14:32innovation program from Scottish Enterprise.
- 14:35Terry, do you mind telling me a little bit about that?
- 14:37And then I'm going to throw straight to Nasima because
- 14:39you've taken part in that and I'd really like to hear about
- 14:44your involvement in the program. So Terry, if you could explain
- 14:47first the Nasima give us the the example.
- 14:50Yeah, I'll just you'll give a brief description and all of it
- 14:53and really keen to to to make sure NASA's got time to to
- 14:56describe her response to it. So, yeah, the the demand driven
- 15:01innovation programme as was was we've developed it with four key
- 15:06elements. It's actually part of a series
- 15:08of projects and programmes that we're developing and it's First
- 15:12off the blocks if you like. So we just had this and it is it
- 15:15is fairly new Ryan as well. So we had the SE board Scotch at
- 15:18the price board approved this at the end of of December there.
- 15:22So it's a five year programme that was set up specifically
- 15:25with the resource dedicated to that demand driven approach for
- 15:29innovation support. So the first element and key
- 15:32element is that that demand identification.
- 15:35So really understanding the international market for
- 15:39offshore wind, particular focus on floating and, and deeper when
- 15:43really understanding where those clusters are, really
- 15:46understanding the the the key developers, the key OEMs, the
- 15:50key tier ones, the organisations that are willing to share
- 15:55information on a challenge and be those those first customers.
- 15:58So we can use that information to, to stimulate and support
- 16:03innovation, but also then to, to provide a better understanding
- 16:08of the routes to market. You know, what do you need to
- 16:10look like very well, You know, solving the innovation challenge
- 16:12is one thing. What does a company need to look
- 16:15like to do business with that, that, you know, OEM or tier one
- 16:19and, and, and being able to communicate that as well.
- 16:22So that's the core part of it. We have innovation funding, as
- 16:25you'd expect from Scottish Enterprise.
- 16:27NASAM has secured support through our initial feasibility
- 16:32calls, which is a, a, a this was an approach that we've developed
- 16:36a competitive approach where we're providing, you know,
- 16:40competitive short funding, 3 month funding up to 50,000 lbs,
- 16:44really flushing out the best innovators in Scotland that can
- 16:47respond to those challenges. And, you know, giving them a
- 16:50chance to, to work through the process and build a pipeline of
- 16:54projects we can support to, to develop larger R&D and, and, and
- 16:58commercialize them. And and unashamedly Ryan, we're
- 17:01looking to leave at another other folks monies that we're
- 17:04working very closely with other agencies like Innovate UK, GP
- 17:08Energy and trying to bring that system together.
- 17:11We've also got an element, third element.
- 17:13We were looking at the test and demonstration pathway for
- 17:16technologies all that way from that first customer and offshore
- 17:19demo and walking back the way and understanding what testing
- 17:23is required. Where are the assets?
- 17:25Can we connect innovators to the assets?
- 17:28Are their assets missing other gaps in that that that
- 17:31validation infrastructure we can address?
- 17:33And finally, we've got advice and support.
- 17:36We've got wealth of really sharp commercialisation, innovation
- 17:41support, business growth advice and Scottish Enterprise.
- 17:44And we're bringing in additional offshore wind expertise into
- 17:49that, working with partners such as the Offshore Wind Group
- 17:52Partnership, Blairy, Cat, what I mentioned in, in the Northeast,
- 17:57we're working very closely with the Net 0 Technology Centre an
- 18:02ETZ. So there's a collective body of
- 18:04knowledge out there. So we're bringing that together
- 18:06just to try and make it as easy to access the knowledge, the
- 18:10funding and expertise for innovators coming forward.
- 18:12So that's the the four key elements of the program.
- 18:15NASMA, respond to your. Point, Yeah.
- 18:18So, NASMA, you took part in this programme.
- 18:20We've just heard all about what it offers.
- 18:23Can you tell me a little bit about your involvement?
- 18:25Yeah. So first of all, if you can
- 18:28allow me to kind of describe who's Phoenix, what we do, how
- 18:31we came about to to work and collaborate with the Scottish
- 18:36Enterprise innovation team and the wider ecosystem like Terry
- 18:40has mentioned, some of them, they are a forefront, some of
- 18:44them really behind the scene. The ecosystem it is in my view
- 18:49is always the cornerstone behind the success of programs like
- 18:54that. So FedEx had been founded back
- 18:57in 2016 by ex oil and gas professionals with more than 25
- 19:02years experience on the operational offshore industry.
- 19:06And you can see there, there is a lots of alignment with the
- 19:09offshore energy sector as a whole.
- 19:13You know, bringing that expertise from the operational
- 19:18side, we have identified a gap in the lack of connected
- 19:24data-driven digital solutions to really connect and streamline
- 19:29very critical safety critical processes when it comes to
- 19:32safety assurance and risk reporting and management.
- 19:37And our desire to really contribute and be part of the
- 19:42energy transition has been from the get go by.
- 19:46But a lot of companies like ourselves, we're not really
- 19:49unique in that, you know, the word transition is quite scary
- 19:54transition, which means going into an industry that you don't
- 19:57know, you need to understand what Terry has described,
- 20:01understand their challenges, understand if we can contribute
- 20:05and bring value. To this to, to the to that
- 20:08industry. So the word transition is really
- 20:11actually literal. They're wanting to move or not
- 20:15move, but really transfer a significant amount of know how
- 20:20and, and expertise and, and identify a new market and a new
- 20:26and the sector that perhaps is aligned with the challenges we
- 20:30are describing. But we really wanted to see to
- 20:33understand exactly what are the, the challenges and the gaps that
- 20:37has started about 3 years ago. And it really started from
- 20:41working with Scottish Enterprise as we described today is
- 20:45research, you know, research, we really, it's underrated.
- 20:49Research is quite resource demanding, but also really just
- 20:55understanding what it is this industry about.
- 20:58Scottish Enterprise has helped us in small funding and I, you
- 21:03know, putting us in front of the ecosystem to go and I'd, you
- 21:08know, understand what are the challenges?
- 21:11What is it they out there that is not solved that perhaps we
- 21:15can come and and help with? And that's exactly what has
- 21:19happened. And to the discussion of
- 21:22today's, you know, conversation is demand innovation driven
- 21:28innovation. It's exactly that understanding
- 21:32where the gaps are, our understanding where the
- 21:34challenges are and really bring either existing know how or
- 21:40expertise to really go and drive innovation in that particular
- 21:45market is exactly what demands innovation is.
- 21:49We don't innovate in a silo. We don't assume that we
- 21:53understand the problems. We don't assume we understand
- 21:56the the customers or the you know or the companies pin pain
- 22:01point. We go and really and identify
- 22:07and talk to the industry and really understand and validate
- 22:12all these all these gaps. The work with Terry's team has
- 22:18actually helped us to go and advance an area which we have
- 22:25identified through networking or you know being part or taking
- 22:32part in master classes for for example delivered by ETZ team a
- 22:40Reg the OR Catapult and other programs that we participated
- 22:45in. And again, at the heart of it is
- 22:47Scottish Enterprise like Launch Academy has really helped us to
- 22:51identify a very critical point whereby lots of systems in the
- 22:57offshore wind industry as a sector is scaling and
- 23:01accelerating its its growth. A lot of tools and softwares to
- 23:07help connect and really drive a clear and full visible safety
- 23:14and risk management was lacking and we understood the pain and
- 23:21the challenges. We absolutely thought that it
- 23:24would be less challenging than the oil and gas industry because
- 23:29you know, 25 years experience in industry that is mature.
- 23:33We've worked in the most challenging project.
- 23:36We worked in deep water projects around the world, HPHC, you can
- 23:41name it right. But moving and really go in and
- 23:44understand the offshore wind sector, we really have
- 23:49discovered far more challenges that we never expected.
- 23:53The complexity of the the sector really makes a lot of processes
- 24:00more difficult to connect. I think the cycle of the
- 24:04project, life cycle of projects throughout the years was
- 24:08significant amount of supply chain in a number of companies.
- 24:12It just taking part of in these projects really makes it very
- 24:17hard. But most importantly, I think
- 24:20the risks associated with the engineering part, you know, the
- 24:23offshore wind, you said it yourself, exists since decades,
- 24:26but the future of the offshore wind is not the one that has
- 24:29happened the last decades. It will be further afield from
- 24:33the from the shores, it will be floating, it will be in deep
- 24:37water, it will be in harsher environment.
- 24:40All these elements are amazing opportunities to grow and
- 24:45advance and scale the industry, but it really brings, you know,
- 24:51a huge amount of, of amount of risks and issues associated with
- 24:56the complexity of the project, the number of people, the number
- 25:00of workers and the, the sheer complexity of the of the, the
- 25:05different companies. We need to work together.
- 25:08So that's what we have identified.
- 25:10We put, you know, a project together as a feasibility study
- 25:16that has been presented to a couple of companies through the
- 25:21network or through the, you know, introduction through
- 25:24Scottish Enterprise Innovation team.
- 25:26We validated our, our project and before we know it, we're
- 25:33really, you know, advancing the development of our technology
- 25:37and our products called Winsafe. 2 weeks ago, you know, maybe a
- 25:43week and a half ago, we were, we had the opportunity to take part
- 25:50in meeting suppliers or an event where 20 other companies besides
- 25:58Fennex were invited into a room where 12 industry leading wind
- 26:05developers and Tier 1 and Tier 2 contractors were in A room.
- 26:12All these companies, they, they share the same challenge that we
- 26:16are solving. And it was absolutely impressive
- 26:22the amount of the, you know, the, the quality of engagement
- 26:25we had only in one day to clearly talk about the solutions
- 26:30that we have at hand, how this is aligned with our goals and
- 26:34objectives. And more importantly, showing
- 26:38the the level of innovative, you know, innovative work and
- 26:42innovation that has been taking part into that.
- 26:46If we had to do, you know, if I would like, for example, to look
- 26:50at the process to say I would like to raise the awareness and
- 26:54present the innovative work that Phoenix is doing to contribute
- 26:59and address and really solve a big challenge in the industry to
- 27:0312 leading industry players. It would have taken years and a
- 27:12significant investment and a lot of resources just to be with
- 27:18them in the same room to let them know and raise awareness of
- 27:22what we're doing. This has happened in exactly 1
- 27:26day, so you can connect the dots for yourself to understand how
- 27:33to accelerate and really bring initiative solutions in front of
- 27:38people who own the challenge or own the problem and let them see
- 27:43for themselves how can that impact their operations or their
- 27:47business. Do you know on on this was done
- 27:50a very good job of explaining the the innovation challenges
- 27:55that are that are identified by Scottish Enterprise.
- 27:59But how does Scottish Enterprise set about finding these
- 28:03challenges and how does it communicate them to the supply
- 28:06chain? Terry Yeah.
- 28:07Ryan, it's a good question. I suppose the key element that
- 28:12touched on previously in the programme is that, you know,
- 28:14Scottish Enterprise work within a, a massive touch on it before
- 28:17working within a an existing ecosystem which can be quite
- 28:21complicated to navigate and figure out who you know, who,
- 28:25who provides what support. So we spent quite a lot of time
- 28:29our eyes not connecting with it. So we're working with all the
- 28:32key providers of of, of expertise and knowledge and
- 28:37support and off offshore wind innovation.
- 28:40So in the first instance, we discovered that actually there's
- 28:44quite a lot of information on the innovation challenges
- 28:47already exists, certainly at an industry level and and
- 28:51innovation Rd. maps. But you've really got to you've
- 28:54really got to work to find it. Ryan's one of the first things
- 28:57that we discovered at that and shared industry challenge level
- 29:00was just really squirreling away finding all these innovation Rd.
- 29:05maps and being able to sometimes package it in a, in a language
- 29:08that that maybe is more, you know, easier to communicate the
- 29:12challenges to your, your supply chain.
- 29:14Sometimes it can be quite technical.
- 29:15So at that first level, we mined existing innovation Rd. maps and
- 29:22challenge industry challenge information.
- 29:24We've also then built on that and drilling into a bit more
- 29:29detail. You mentioned floating, we're
- 29:31discussing floating earlier on. So we're involved in a an
- 29:34industry group. So there's a joint industry
- 29:36project where we're working with Cronus Day or a car.
- 29:40But NZTC, which I mentioned previously up in the Northeast
- 29:44to really get under the skinning and engage with industry about
- 29:46where are the key strategic challenges within floating
- 29:50offshore wind. And that is in were able to
- 29:54extract the value from that to to feed into a supply chain work
- 30:01and then down a level in terms of individual organisations.
- 30:04That's what I think it starts to get really interested.
- 30:07That's where you start to get into that, that first customer
- 30:09and their specific challenges. So I suppose just hard work and
- 30:13contacts to find the find the folks who are willing to share
- 30:16that level of detail and then actually translating and being
- 30:21able to capture a detailed innovation challenge, a
- 30:25functional specification sounds dead easier, but there's
- 30:28actually quite a bit of work and skill involved in that.
- 30:31And we've been able to and fortunate enough to, you know,
- 30:35have have folks internally who can do that to to do a degree.
- 30:38But there's also again, back to that existing innovation assets.
- 30:43There's other colleagues and pro shout out to one of our key
- 30:47partners in, in all this Innovate UK have got what they
- 30:50call it an innovation exchange, IX exchange programme, which has
- 30:54got resources associated with it and, and expertise to, to work
- 30:59with companies to, to really define their specific
- 31:02challenges. So that's different levels.
- 31:03And then in terms of how we communicate it will, we've got
- 31:07fantastic routes into to the supply chain through our own
- 31:12advisory network, but also are links into regional networks
- 31:16such as business gateway such as specific innovation partners
- 31:21mentioned ETZ. They've been fantastic for the
- 31:23Northeast in terms of getting out in their cluster.
- 31:25So really about really pushing it out through the networks and
- 31:29and being really, yeah, really quite relentless in terms of
- 31:33that marketing and communications and drum beat
- 31:36that, that right. Look, these are innovation
- 31:38challenges. These are opportunities for you
- 31:41and working very much in partnership with that that
- 31:44ecosystem that I described here. And you know, think and now that
- 31:47we've we've explained exactly what the program is, how it
- 31:51works, how it engages with the supply chain, how how Nasima's
- 31:56collaborating with that. I want to ask you Nasima, now
- 32:00forget Terry's here. I'm going to ask you about
- 32:02benefits or if there are any. Can you tell me is how is your
- 32:06company, if it has benefited from collaborating with Scottish
- 32:11Enterprise on this project? And I'm going to throw in a
- 32:14cheeky second question. How do you think participating
- 32:18in this programme is going to benefit your business in the
- 32:21long run? Right.
- 32:22I think Terry has really hasn't blown the trumpet quite right on
- 32:26Scottish Enterprise. I'm going to do that on his
- 32:27behalf. So Scottish Enterprise has been
- 32:32always behind the scenes and he he's talking about a significant
- 32:36amount of work out there. Most of it really goes and seen,
- 32:42you know, be in the glue to do what Terry has described to
- 32:47connect the dots and really bring the clarity between the
- 32:51ecosystem, the innovators and the industry.
- 32:55The industry itself is quite of an art.
- 33:01A lot of work that Scottish Enterprise perhaps is known for
- 33:06maybe by majority of companies out there is grant funding which
- 33:10is brilliant. You know having access to grants
- 33:13like you described in the in the innovation program that we're
- 33:16talking about today for the offshore wind is critical.
- 33:19You know, a lot of companies like ourselves benefit
- 33:23significantly from grant funding to de risk and take on project
- 33:29that otherwise we either can't do it ourselves or maybe it
- 33:33would be delayed for various reasons.
- 33:37Size of the company, you know, the way the cash flow and the
- 33:39way we manage our business. So that exactly the grant
- 33:43funding is always helpful and it's part of it.
- 33:46But that's just the tip of the iceberg.
- 33:48And I always describe when I talk about support and the value
- 33:53that we get from Scottish Enterprise Innovation team is
- 33:57taking grant funding is easy, burning through the cash is much
- 34:00easier. The grant funding helps
- 34:05companies to go and translate projects and innovative ideas
- 34:10into products to go and you know, and solve like we said,
- 34:14the problems. But the biggest challenge it
- 34:17comes after that it really is connecting with the industry,
- 34:22understanding the market, validating the gaps and the
- 34:27problems that we are trying to solve and not just at one touch
- 34:31point, at several touch points. You know, innovation is
- 34:40innovation is very, is very isolating.
- 34:44Actually it's quite, you know you do when you are innovating
- 34:47and you are taking risk to go and, and and spend investments
- 34:54and bandwidth and focus it quite terrifying for a lot of
- 34:58companies because if it doesn't work, you know, the losses are
- 35:03significant. Being able to go and validate
- 35:08and touch point and really understand if we what we are
- 35:11innovating is addressing a real problem, a real demand are the
- 35:17is, is the gap or the challenge that we're addressing is
- 35:22scalable. What, where are, where is the
- 35:26market? Where are the players?
- 35:27Who are they? How do they look like?
- 35:31What are what is their supply chain mechanism are what are
- 35:35their buying units? Are these are all practical.
- 35:39Sometimes, you know, boring points, part of what we do in
- 35:43the business, but it really are critical points to define
- 35:47whether you're successful or not when you are innovating and
- 35:51bringing something new into the market.
- 35:53So Terry has described the, the connectivity with the, with the,
- 36:00with the ecosystem. It's critical, but for us, I
- 36:05think it is connecting with the industry players.
- 36:10Having access to the industry players is always key and our
- 36:16success and I don't I don't want to go and pretend that it's you
- 36:20know, we are still coming into the market bringing innovative
- 36:24solutions that are actually we we do have customer.
- 36:28We have secured first commercial deployment for Windsafe in Scott
- 36:33Wind project here talking to and presenting our innovation to
- 36:41other industry players who are operating around the globe.
- 36:47Have we been successful to have access to the decision makers?
- 36:51How did we go about to present and bring ourselves into the
- 36:56same room and present our work, present the value proposition
- 37:02and the potential value that we can Enlock for these projects
- 37:07has been through networking and attending events that that are
- 37:15choreographed and organized in quite meticulously.
- 37:18Bringing the right people, the decision makers in the room to
- 37:24really hear and listen and you know, and meet the innovators
- 37:32face to face is priceless. That is really goes beyond any
- 37:37grant funding that any company can, you know, can, can put
- 37:41value on. So the tip of the iceberg is the
- 37:44grant funding. The biggest value is what comes
- 37:48underneath. And these are not one, not 2,
- 37:54but what Terry has described, relentless checkpoints to be
- 38:01present, to connect with the industry, to have access to
- 38:05decision makers and really have that, you know, continuous
- 38:12dialogue and conversation to make sure that the innovation is
- 38:18addressing a real demand. The innovation is addressing a
- 38:22real challenge. And the route to market is clear
- 38:27and accelerating our ability to commercialize our innovative
- 38:33technology becomes a reality. So that is, I think what you
- 38:40know what is hidden beneath the value of programs like that.
- 38:46So Terry, we've talked about the offering of the Scottish
- 38:50renewables and NASA has just been singing your praises.
- 38:53I think most notably for me was the, the, the, the investment,
- 38:57the, the cash is just the tip of the iceberg.
- 38:59I'm sure that's music to the accountant series, but I'd be
- 39:04interesting, interested to hear about.
- 39:07I think we've spoken about them under different names, different
- 39:10guises, if you will. And that's the feasibility calls
- 39:14that Scottish Enterprise hosts now.
- 39:18Can you tell me a little bit about, you know, what supports
- 39:21available for companies through these calls?
- 39:24And they'll they'll be supply guys in the supply chain right
- 39:28now listening to this going, I want AI, want a piece of what
- 39:32NASA was talking about. How do they get involved in this
- 39:36feasibility call that's happening later this year?
- 39:38Yep. So, yeah, not NASA might
- 39:41describe it really well there actually.
- 39:42So we just to kind of just say summarize some of the key
- 39:46elements. Yeah, the, the, you know, the
- 39:47cash is the tip of the iceberg, but there is cash there and
- 39:51we've designed the, the feasibility calls to be
- 39:54competitive and attractive in terms of the, the, the grant
- 39:58funding rate, the small scale, you know, the maximum 50,000
- 40:03three month projects. So they're short and sharp.
- 40:06But what it does is it is it allows us to, I suppose, dangle
- 40:10a lot of carrot, you know, who's out there who's out there, and
- 40:15also flush out organizations and companies and projects that,
- 40:19that that. Are best suited that are the
- 40:21best solutions potential solutions to those innovation
- 40:24challenges and often that can be enough to can you unlock and
- 40:28that and that's open for small companies and large companies
- 40:31and we took a bit of an internal discussion on that is that right
- 40:35and proper? Oh yes, it is because a lot of
- 40:36time large companies are battling for internal resources
- 40:40as well. And this is about providing
- 40:42companies with a bit of breathing space to to to
- 40:47validate whether that be a technical or commercial
- 40:49feasibility to prove to themselves and their
- 40:52organizations and their board. This has got legs.
- 40:55This is what taken to the next phase.
- 40:57So that's what the the feasibility calls are are are
- 41:00set up to do and we've been really blown away with the the
- 41:03interest and then they've been so successful in terms of
- 41:06generating interest. We could have funded a lot more.
- 41:09NASA mentioned it was, you know, 22 companies funded through the
- 41:13the 1st the first call, which was fantastic.
- 41:17And we've got a bunch of companies that didn't quite meet
- 41:20that cut off rate for just with limited funding that we had that
- 41:23we're working with as well. So we've built a, a really nice
- 41:26pipeline. We've got another 20 odds just
- 41:29coincidentally just about to, to sign off on on, on the next
- 41:35bunch. But what we're also doing so in
- 41:37addition to that is we are working with them and that
- 41:40someone mentioned a a recent and really, really valuable event
- 41:46showcase the event where we brought the 22 innovators
- 41:49together with key international players, developers and tier
- 41:53ones and tier twos as NASMA suggested.
- 41:55That was fantastic. And that was that was part of
- 41:58our efforts to support those companies with that that market
- 42:02engagement. And really, and some some folks
- 42:05already had it, you know, if their own steam and some folks,
- 42:09you know, including asthma got introduced to more an additional
- 42:12partners as well and looking to then build that interest into
- 42:16what's next. How well, how do we support you
- 42:19to go from where you are just now to that validation with that
- 42:23that first customer and that commercialization and what
- 42:27additional support can we leave it in?
- 42:30And that's funding, yes, and working with other partners, but
- 42:34advisory support as well. And all of this, Ryan, is about
- 42:38building a pipeline of companies that we can support through our
- 42:43our scaling innovation mission. So it's about who are the
- 42:46companies who've got international outlook,
- 42:48international ambitions, who have got potential to scale and
- 42:53create a disproportional impact on the Scottish, Scottish
- 42:58economy. We've got a significant number
- 43:00of them in the Northeast and that's worth highlighting as
- 43:02well. Disproportionate.
- 43:04And that's a validation of that offshore engineering expertise.
- 43:09That's really, you know, that's really been validated through
- 43:13this and was super pleased about because a lot of folks are
- 43:15talking about it, but we can see it.
- 43:17We're working with it, which is fantastic.
- 43:18And hopefully we can use the, the experience of, of, of of oil
- 43:23and gas and look at, you know, developing those innovations.
- 43:27But it's back to that international exporting, you
- 43:29know, high value products, high value services, but you know,
- 43:32really it's about the, the feasibility is a, a little car,
- 43:36a building, a pipeline to bring that wider, wider programme
- 43:40support into it. And in terms of how folks can
- 43:43find out more, the usual method, you can go on our, our website,
- 43:47scottish-enterprise.com. You could Google Scottish
- 43:51Enterprise and also offshore wind and there's a significant
- 43:55amount of information there about the opportunity.
- 43:57And you can sign up to our, our newsletter by taking Innovation
- 44:01Offshore Wind and be kept up to date, including the, the fees,
- 44:05the next feasibility call. But I should say that's just the
- 44:08front end. And we've got a regular drum
- 44:10beat, but we are really keen to engage with folks who may be
- 44:14interested. So if you're a, a developer or
- 44:16an OEM or a tier one out there that's looking for, for
- 44:19solutions, please reach out, get in touch.
- 44:22If you're an innovator that's got something new, think you've
- 44:25got something new, please get in touch.
- 44:27And again on the website and there's a contact form there
- 44:30that will get through to us and the team.
- 44:33Well, as a proud Aberdonian, I'm always happy to hear about, you
- 44:36know, no matter where you go in the world, if there's oil and
- 44:38gas, you hear a Doric accent. I'm hoping Scottish Enterprise
- 44:42can deliver that in offshore wind as well.
- 44:45Thank you very much for joining me, Terry and Nassima, and thank
- 44:49you very much for listening if you'd like to find out more.
- 44:52Well, as Terry said, Scottish Enterprise's website is always
- 44:55there. And if you'd like to stay up to
- 44:57date with all things offshore wind related, well, Energy Voice
- 45:00is a good place to be and I hope to see you all again very soon.