Latest / This is VANCOLOUR / #234 - Stu McNish / Bridgitte Anderson
Transcript
- 0:02Check podcasts. Hey folks, my name is Mohameir and this is Van Color,
- 0:19British Columbia's bona fide culture and politics TV talk show Tonight. Are we
- 0:24as good as we think we are? Is Canada broken? Is Vancouver truly
- 0:29a world class city? Is British Columbia a good place to do business?
- 0:34To answer that last question, our first guest is the founder and general manager
- 0:38of this studio space, Oh Boy Productions, so I have to be nice
- 0:42to him otherwise he'll lock me out next week. He is an award winning
- 0:45broadcaster and a successful entrepreneur. You may recognize him as the host of Conversations
- 0:51That Matter, a long form interview program that you can find on YouTube and
- 0:55right here on Check Saturdays at four thirty pm, where he talks to businessleaders
- 1:00and other community and political leaders. He is my friend Stu McNish. Stu,
- 1:06thanks for making the long trip from just from the other side of that
- 1:08door door. I appreciate it. So let's just get to business here.
- 1:12Is it really tough to be an entrepreneur or to do business here in British
- 1:17Columbia? Yes, it is. Now let's recognize it. It's tough to
- 1:23be an entrepreneur anyway. Sure, it takes a tremendous amount of gumption and
- 1:29gall to believe that you can go out and make something happen. Like,
- 1:33who do you think you are? I mean right away, Like it's so
- 1:36complicated. You take on a lot of risk, a lot of risky,
- 1:40but it gets complicated in a jurisdiction like this, and in the sense that
- 1:46there are so many rules and regulations that work against getting a small business going.
- 1:52So I'll tell you going back to when I first started, I got
- 1:57a call from the tax department one day saying you need to pay us like
- 2:02now, tomorrow, next week, and the week after because you're in arrears.
- 2:08I go, well, I'm waiting for money to be paid to me
- 2:10by my clients. I don't have it in the bank, right, too
- 2:14bad, Yeah, pay it now, like whether you got paid or not
- 2:17the moment you invoice. And it's a small business. You go, well,
- 2:22how am I supposed to be able to pay that bill right now?
- 2:23When I don't even have the money myself. That doesn't matter, And they
- 2:27go, well, you signed up for this. You must have known what
- 2:29you're getting into. No, I had no idea, and that would just
- 2:31be one thing, and then you start to layer in so many other things
- 2:35that are designed to protect everybody but the business owner and get politicians, banks,
- 2:43unions, all sorts of organizations run around saying oh, yeah, small
- 2:46business is the backbone of our economy and we're there for them, except for
- 2:51the fact that they're not right now, that doesn't seem particularly unique to British
- 2:55Columbia. So when we think of the BC context, how he's or tough
- 3:00is it to do business here? Well, well, there's a couple of
- 3:04different elements to that. One would be the rules and regulation side of it,
- 3:07and then there's others just the who are you going to have as your
- 3:12clients now? So depending on what kind of business that you're in, and
- 3:16if you're on the retail side, for instance, you've got every single rule
- 3:21and regulation there is that it's all designed to protect employees and they should be,
- 3:25but none of those safeguards are in place to protect the employer, the
- 3:30person who's taking the risk. So a politician will come along and I found
- 3:35it very interesting. Paul, there's a fellow Paul Dragon, who has a
- 3:38reckless writer, great guy. When we were doing an event with Premier eb
- 3:44recently, I had him ask a question on camera and he goes, you
- 3:46know, mister Premier, like the government comes along and suddenly adds another stat
- 3:53holiday. So now I have two stat holidays in October, one weekend after
- 3:58the other. But nobody says to me, and here's how you're going to
- 4:03pay for that stat holiday? He said, where does it come out of?
- 4:05It comes out of the bottom line of the business, right, And
- 4:09these businesses are running thin all the time anyways, But the politicians or the
- 4:14policy makers don't think that, Okay, we're going to create this policy and
- 4:19it'll all be fine. The problem is it's not all fine. And now
- 4:23take a look at the number of restaurants, for instance, that are closing
- 4:26that have been business for more than a decade or two. And the structure
- 4:31of city taxes, the changes in tax rates both provincially and now federally,
- 4:41and the cost of land and the cost of land all add up and make
- 4:45it almost impossible to make a profit. And if you're not staying ahead of
- 4:50the bills. And it's not that a lot of people go into business going
- 4:54I'm going to be rich. It's like, no, this is what I
- 4:57have a passion for I see an opportunity in market and I want to make
- 5:00it work. But it only works, especially over time, if there's money
- 5:04that's going into the bank account that can create a cash reserve and allows the
- 5:09business to keep growing. But the average person doesn't think about what's that cycle
- 5:15of money, where do you get it from, How quickly does it come
- 5:17in, how fast does it have to go out? What percentage to this
- 5:20government, that government, this agency work safe and on and on and on
- 5:25and it all starts to pile out. Right, But British LAMBIA has created
- 5:29some big companies, right. You can think of Lululemon on the retail side.
- 5:32You can think of innovative tech companies like Sanctuary AI or stem Cells Technology.
- 5:36So clearly it's not that bad or it's not uniquely bad here in BC.
- 5:42Right, Well, you're talking about the remarkable spirit of extraordinary entrepreneurs.
- 5:47Jimmy Patterson would be another one. Joe Siegel like, look at what he
- 5:51did now over time, And yes, what Vancouver is really good at is
- 5:59incubating ideas. There are so many other companies that probably could have been another
- 6:03stem Cell or Lulu Lemon. We've got a Ritzi as well. We've got
- 6:08the Mark Anthony group, but a lot of those like So if we take
- 6:11a look at Mark Anthony, Lulu Lemon or Ritzy and whatnot, they're here.
- 6:15And I think they're here because there's an emotional attachment to Vancouver. You
- 6:18asked Jimmy Patterson, white steam Vancouver because I love Vancouver. Is it the
- 6:23best business decision? No? But these are companies that did grow through passion
- 6:30and you know, investment from outsiders and whatnot who all believe in this concept.
- 6:34But what did they do? They grew, they started here, but
- 6:38their real growth is elsewhere. So stem Cell Technologies, I mean, there's
- 6:44a remarkable story of a company in the biotech sector that's buying American biotech companies
- 6:50and making them Canadian Whereas the trend here is that there could be a hundred
- 6:56different biotechs that can grow to some sort of significant size, but they never
- 7:00really get beyond that incubating stage before they're brought up by Americans or other interests
- 7:05who then take them away. Oh so we're basically losing a lot of we
- 7:10lose a lot. There's a brain drain, talent drain, innovation drain that
- 7:15comes the leaves BC, because once you reach a certain threshold, British Columbia
- 7:19is no longer a great place to be as a small business. If you
- 7:26make less than six hundred thousand dollars net, yeah, you really do have
- 7:30a good tax rate a provincial tax right two percent, But the moment you
- 7:34go to six hundred thousand and five bucks, it jumps to twelve percent.
- 7:39So you got to see a huge increase in your net profit before you realize
- 7:45a benefit because you now have this heavier tax burden. Then add on top
- 7:49of that, you go, Okay, now I need to start to attract
- 7:51a world class talent. Well, I want to bring those people in,
- 7:55but they're going to cost me two hundred thousand dollars let's say a year,
- 7:59and the tax rate here is above the fifty percent threshold. Well, that
- 8:05person may be able to say, well, I like the Pacific Northwest,
- 8:09but if I take my job in Bellingham or more importantly Seattle, I'm going
- 8:13to keep an awful lot more of that money, right, and I might
- 8:16be able to afford a house and have a little yard, and go on
- 8:20vacation and have a second car or whatever else it is, And so talent
- 8:26also makes the decision about, well, don't really want to be there when
- 8:30I can be one hundred and fifty kilometers away and keep a significant portion of
- 8:35my money in my pocket rather than in the hands of government. Fascinating.
- 8:39We have about thirty seconds left, so really quickly. If someone comes to
- 8:43you and says, hey, I want to be an entrepreneur, I as
- 8:46I have a business idea. Should I start a business here in British Columbia?
- 8:48What do you tell them? Think long and hard about it, because
- 8:52it will be one of the most thrilling but definitely one of the most difficult
- 8:58adventures of your life, and difficult INBC. I'm more so than anywhere else
- 9:03that I know of. Interesting. Stu A pleasure. I'm so glad we
- 9:05were able to do this. Thanks so much for your time tonight, ND
- 9:07pleasure folks. The man behind Conversations that matter and this very studio space,
- 9:13Oh Boy Productions, he is Stu McNish. Now up next, is Vancouver
- 9:18a world class city? What does that even mean? Let's talk about it.
- 9:22Up next, Welcome back to this as Van color. Is Vancouver a
- 9:31world class city? The recent and inaugural benchmarking Greater Vancouver report provided some great
- 9:39insights into how the Greater Vancouver region measures up to leading international peer cities based
- 9:45on things like economic performance, infrastructure, sustainability, and liveability. Here to
- 9:50dissect our world classness is the President and CEO of the Greater Vancouver Board of
- 9:56Trade who commissioned that report. She is Bridget And and this conversation is brought
- 10:01to you by Pacific Sands Beach Resort inta fino laid back luxury as beachfront as
- 10:07it gets. So Bridget, first things first, what does a world class
- 10:16city even mean? Is there a criteria? There is criteria, and so
- 10:20what's things like? Is there a highly urbanized development within the city, Is
- 10:26there a big financial sector? Do we have world class transportation and post secondary
- 10:31institutions? And so when you think about world class I think probably London,
- 10:37New York, Paris, Tokyo come to mind, and they fall into the
- 10:41world class city definition. If you will Vancouver, well, it seems like
- 10:46a stretch goal for us to be in that tier of cities. Right,
- 10:50stretch goal is funny you mentioned that because when Ken Sin became mayor, that
- 10:54was exactly what he said. And so in the way that we looked at
- 10:58evaluating how Greater Vancouver is performing comparative to its other peers globally, and we
- 11:03chose nineteen other comparative cities or regions. Vancouver does really well in some areas,
- 11:09but it's lagging another. So, like Swagger, we do really well
- 11:13thanks to Ken sim Right. We have got a really strong brand, which
- 11:16is great, you know, because you need a strong brand out there,
- 11:20and so globally a lot of attention on us, but when you kind of
- 11:22peel back some of the layers the performance, it's not so great. Okay,
- 11:26where are we lagging, I guess compared to those other world class cities.
- 11:31Well, maybe first the good news because one of the things that I
- 11:33think this region has done really really well is on sustainability and resilience, and
- 11:37we ranked third among our peers, which is amazing. And when you're talking
- 11:41about clean energy, decarbonization and green space per person, we did extremely well.
- 11:46We have done really well on the bounce back for transit ridership, strongest
- 11:52in North America, awesome, great news. And we have world class institutions
- 11:56and we've got this amazing pool of talent. Amazing Okay, So however,
- 12:03you know, we have fewer high and paying jobs, we have fewer high
- 12:07performing companies. We don't have a lot of multinationals here, we don't have
- 12:11a lot of headquarters. And some of this has been known for a long
- 12:13time, but that is really where we get this mixed picture of where we've
- 12:18got, whether we are a world class city, and the things that we
- 12:20can do a lot better. I mean, there's a whole bunch of economic
- 12:24performance indicators that we need to improve. But when you're talking about like the
- 12:28experience of being in Vancouver, it was really interesting because it said, like
- 12:33visitors, they love vang Coure course, I got so many tourists, especially
- 12:37in the summer, but all year round. Really well, the mountains,
- 12:39the ocean, like we've got it all, like it's really beautiful. But
- 12:43then for the people who are living here, whether there's residents, business people,
- 12:46are students or who is coming here and staying here, they're actually finding
- 12:52some of the few things that are lagging that really make it feel world class.
- 12:56And some of that, of course comes as no surprise around housing affordability,
- 13:00yeah, and otherfordability challenges, but other things like our culture is lagging
- 13:03a little bit too. Oh, interesting and what what senses are culture lagging
- 13:07well? And I mean, we have so many great restaurants, I know,
- 13:09so we've like definitely like we're foodies, we do really well there.
- 13:13But when we think about the kind of the night culture, it doesn't really
- 13:18stack up as well as some other places. And I say this with a
- 13:20caveat though, because you know, and I will give kudos here, it
- 13:24was the Tourism minister who called it the calendar of awesomeness. And so we
- 13:28keep talking about all of these events that are happening, whether it's you know,
- 13:31Great Cup in the Fall and Victus Games, FIFA, Taylor Swift,
- 13:35Juno's and all of that is happening, and it's in the calendar now.
- 13:39So when we go back and measure this in a year or two from now,
- 13:43I think we'll see some improvements. We've got the p Andy Amphitheater being
- 13:46built. You know, We've got a lot of things happening. But because
- 13:50this is measuring you know, the last several years, I think that people
- 13:54would say, like, our night scene wasn't really great. Our arts and
- 13:58culture, you know, is not forming as well as some peers. Interesting
- 14:01now is this does this fall on the municipality like the City of Vancouver,
- 14:05or is it a provincial issue, or is it even a federal issue.
- 14:09You know, I would say a little bit of all three, because what
- 14:13we looked at was we could write, let's do that. Yeah, maybe
- 14:16like we figures out one another all of it. No, but we're talking
- 14:18about the region overall. So there is some municipal responsibility around the City of
- 14:24Vancouver, but this looked at the whole region. So how is the whole
- 14:28region coming together or not, because it's not really and giving that really great
- 14:33experience. And so liveability is an issue for sure, like when people settle
- 14:37here and they're like, oh, I thought it was maybe a little stronger
- 14:41and over here, or this isn't quite the way I expected it to be,
- 14:46and so you know, we really have to take that to heart and
- 14:48think, well, what are those things that we can do to make it
- 14:50really welcoming and to make sure that people want to stay here, because we
- 14:54know, I just saw it this week. We know that according to the
- 14:58latest study, we've got a third of people thinking they're going to leave our
- 15:01province for a lot of really important reasons that we need to take to heart.
- 15:05Whether it's affordability, or it's the experience of living here in this region,
- 15:09and that disproportionately affects millennials who are kind of in the prime of their
- 15:13life. They're starting families, they're you know, peaking in their career or
- 15:16at least getting to that point. Right. Yeah, one of the most
- 15:18interesting things I thought that I saw in this report around housing affordability. We
- 15:22all know that home ownership in Vancouver is a bit of a pipe dream for
- 15:26a lot of people. But we looked in this report at rent so people
- 15:30who are renters and rents have accelerated faster here than almost anywhere else. And
- 15:35we spend more on our income as renters than almost anywhere else. Wow.
- 15:41Now, and those are young people. When we think of the world class
- 15:43cities that you that you pointed out, I mean, aren't they all kind
- 15:48of unaffordable? Like is that does that come with the territory of being there?
- 15:52And again I'm not saying we're New York or Tokyo or any place like
- 15:54that, but isn't that part of it? That is fair comment that you
- 15:58know, whether we're talking about New York or London or talking about Paris,
- 16:02those are cities that are more expensive to live in, and so I think
- 16:06Vancouver has. That has happened to Vancouver in part because we are such a
- 16:10destination of choice, so there's always going to be that element. And housing,
- 16:15i think though, is one thing that we are standing out in not
- 16:18a good way among our peers. And rent, the cost of rent and
- 16:22how much people are spending for rent is also I think something that is not
- 16:26doesn't make us stand out in a good light. But the other piece about
- 16:30the talent pool. A lot of really great talent here, really great talent,
- 16:34but they're not earning as much as they would earn in another other jurisdiction.
- 16:40So you've got this affordability problem, and then you've got people who are
- 16:45not earning enough, and then they We've got housing that is out of reach
- 16:48for a lot of people too, whether it's rent or ownership. So it's
- 16:52a really big problem. Is that why every time these surveys come out about
- 16:56the most livable cities and we see Vancouver somewhere in the top three, people
- 17:00who live here have a collective grown and go, well, that's not exactly
- 17:03true. Yeah, you know, because it is very livable. You know,
- 17:07people here we'd all say, like, it's a great experience that you
- 17:11can get outdoors, and we've got really great you know, we've got good
- 17:15health where you've got a stable banking system. Canada is a great country in
- 17:18that way. But you start to kind of dig away a little bit and
- 17:19you're like, oh, well, actually, you know, it's very expensive
- 17:22to live here, and I think for people to get ahead in their careers,
- 17:26it's difficult because we have. While we have a very strong small and
- 17:30medium network of enterprises, you know, those larger companies, they often they
- 17:36can't scale here. They have to go and grow their companies elsewhere, and
- 17:40so that they take their talent with them. Our talents start to look else
- 17:42elsewhere right really quickly, because we're almost wrapped up here. Is Toronto a
- 17:47world class city? I mean, they do have our national Financial District right
- 17:52you know there. I'm sure that Toronto would say it is a world class
- 17:55city, and I you know, it was one of the cities that we
- 17:57looked at comparatively to event to the region of Greater Vancouver, and in many
- 18:03ways it is suffering from some of the same challenges we are. When we're
- 18:07talking about housing affordability and also they've got some issues around productivity and prosperity that
- 18:11we do too, and so we outshine in some areas and they outshine in
- 18:15some areas. Fair enough, Bridget, thank you so much for your time
- 18:18tonight. The This was a pleasure. Thank you, folks. That was
- 18:21Bridget Anderson, the president and the CEO of the Greater Vancouver Board of Trade.
- 18:26Thank you so much to Pacific Sands Beach resorted to FINO for supporting local
- 18:32but world class conversations. Now stick around because after some business, Is Canada
- 18:37broken? I don't think so, but let's find out together. Welcome back
- 18:48to this as Van color. Canada is broken seems to be the rallying cry
- 18:52for disaffected Canadians from coast to coast. But is it true. I don't
- 18:56think so, but let's go through it together and let's let's take a moment
- 19:08back. In March, seventy percent of respondents in a Leege survey agreed with
- 19:14the statement it feels like everything is broken in this country right now, this
- 19:18country being Canada and those respondents being Canadians. And okay, we have our
- 19:23issues, like how just in the last two years, our real GDP per
- 19:27capita has declined to twenty fourteen levels, meaning your standard of living hasn't changed
- 19:33in the last ten years and most likely is worse because the gap between rich
- 19:37and poor has widened. But we have healthcare, although fewer Canadians have access
- 19:44to primary care family doctors, probably because we have fewer people training as family
- 19:48doctors, which, in addition to how our country spends less on hospital services
- 19:53than most other OECD nations, explains hospital wait times and overcrowding, since a
- 19:59lack of primary care increases the need for more expensive acute care and actually overburdens
- 20:04the whole system, since many healthcare needs could be treated more cost effectively if
- 20:10they were caught earlier by a family doctor. But our shelter and food costs
- 20:15forty percent more than three years ago, which is good news if you're a
- 20:21real estate investor or I guess a grocery chain tycoon. Okay, Well,
- 20:26at least we declared the toxic drug supply crisis and climate crisis as emergencies,
- 20:30although we seem to claw back or cancel out the little incremental progress we make
- 20:34to address those emergencies. But we have robust democratic institutions where our representatives may
- 20:41be committing treason. Thankfully, we have alternatives we can vote for who will
- 20:47common the sense and fix the things. Although when they verb the nouns,
- 20:52they never explain how they will reduce the cost of land, how's the homeless
- 20:56that's on the rise, to break up the price gouging monopolies, treat the
- 21:00emergencies like emergencies, or increase healthcare capacity. Yeah, I'm not going to
- 21:06go full on Principal Skinner meme on you here. Canada does feel like it's
- 21:11broken and until we stop relying on solutions from landlords, simps, for corporate
- 21:15oligopolies and apparently traders, it's gonna feel broken for a while. And on
- 21:30that dire note, that's our show. Thank you so much for watching,
- 21:33and thank you to Stu mcniche of Conversations that Matter and Bridget Anderson of the
- 21:37Greater Vancouver Board of Trade for their time tonight. As always, shoot me
- 21:42an email with your thoughts mo at This is vancolor dot com. Also please
- 21:47follow me on x or TikTok at van Color BC Premier David Ebe will be
- 21:52here in studio next week. I promise you will not want to miss it.
- 21:56But for Now this is Van color, and I'm moamir telling you that
- 22:00in a province where you can be anything, be colorful. Peace,