Latest / My Playful Wife — A Tender Literary Love Story / My Playful Wife — Season 1, Episode 71: Tara

Transcript

My Playful Wife — Season 1, Episode 71: Tara · My Playful Wife — A Tender Literary Love Story

0:00
My playful wife. You're pleased, I said to her
0:05
that night. I'm more than pleased, she said.
0:08
Do you understand what we watched today? Tara
0:11
reached him. Tara came to the flat on a Sunday,
0:17
a few weeks after the good day, and I was more
0:20
nervous about it than I let on, because it was
0:22
the first time the two halves of what Saloni
0:25
has made were going to be in the same room. Tara
0:27
is Saloni's apprentice. the young woman she has
0:30
been teaching for years, the one she reached
0:33
the way she reaches everyone, by handing her
0:36
a craft instead of a kindness, and Kabir is the
0:40
boy she is reaching now. They were both, in their
0:43
different ways, Saloni's makings, the products
0:46
of the same patient looking applied across a
0:48
decade, and I did not know what would happen
0:51
when they met. Whether Kabir would close up against
0:54
a stranger the way he closes against most new
0:57
people, whether the careful equilibrium of the
0:59
flat would hold against the introduction of a
1:02
fourth body into it. It is a real thing, the
1:05
fragility of a system you have spent months stabilizing,
1:08
and the reluctance to disturb it. We had achieved,
1:12
in the flat, A kind of working equilibrium, a
1:15
set of routines and understandings that helped
1:17
Kabir study, and every introduction of a new
1:21
variable felt like a risk to it. A stone dropped
1:24
into a pond we had only just got to stop rippling.
1:27
I knew this was, in part, its own small trap,
1:30
the overprotectiveness that can calcify into
1:33
a cage, the very thing the school had warned
1:36
me against. A child cannot be kept safe by keeping
1:40
his world tiny. He has to be allowed new people,
1:43
new variables, the ordinary widening risks of
1:46
an ordinary life. But knowing that and feeling
1:49
calm about it are different things, and I was
1:52
not calm watching Tara come up the stairs. I
1:56
need not have worried, though not for any of
1:59
the reasons I had imagined. It went well, but
2:02
it went well sideways, in a way I had not predicted
2:05
and would not have known how to engineer. The
2:11
first thing Tara did, which alarmed me, was to
2:14
be completely uncareful with him. I had developed,
2:19
over the months, and so had Saloni, an entire
2:22
choreography of carefulness around Kabir. The
2:26
watching for triggers, the gentle voice, the
2:28
managed transitions, the constant low -level
2:31
vigilance of adults handling a child they know
2:34
to be breakable. It is necessary, that carefulness,
2:38
and I do not regret it. But Tara did not have
2:41
it and did not adopt it, and within about four
2:44
minutes of arriving she had looked at Kabir,
2:47
who was doing his usual guarded appraisal of
2:49
the new person, and said, flatly, Why are you
2:53
staring at me like that? You look like a little
2:56
owl. Stop it. It's weird. And I froze, certain
3:01
this was a disaster, certain the bluntness would
3:04
wound him. would trigger him, would undo months
3:08
of careful work in a sentence. And Kabir, who
3:12
flinches from warmth and stone walls every adult
3:15
who comes at him gently, looked at this young
3:18
woman who had just called him a weird little
3:20
owl, and something in his face did a thing I
3:23
had not seen it do with a stranger before. It
3:26
loosened. He almost very nearly smiled. I had
3:30
been trying, for months, with every tool of the
3:34
careful, attentive, hard -won wisdom in my six
3:38
notebooks to coax exactly that loosening out
3:41
of his face and had earned it only in rare hard
3:44
-won flashes. Tara got it in four minutes by
3:48
insulting him. I sat there with something between
3:51
outrage and laughter rising in me, the particular
3:55
humbling of watching someone achieve effortlessly,
3:58
by being the right person, what you have been
4:00
straining at by being skillful. There are doors
4:03
a key cannot open that swing wide for the right
4:06
hand simply laid flat against them. I had been
4:10
picking the lock of that child for months, with
4:13
enormous care. Tara had been shaped, by her own
4:17
history, into the one shape the lock was already
4:20
cut for, and the door fell open at her touch.
4:26
It took me the rest of the afternoon to understand
4:28
what had happened, and when I understood it,
4:31
it rearranged something in how I think about
4:33
all of it. Tara had given him the one thing all
4:37
our careful love could not. She had treated him
4:41
as normal. Every adult in his life, however kind,
4:45
handled him as a special case, a damaged thing,
4:48
a child to be managed delicately, and that carefulness,
4:53
necessary as it is. carries a hidden message
4:56
that a sharp child reads instantly, which is,
4:59
you are not like other children. You are fragile.
5:03
You are a problem to be handled. Tara sent the
5:06
opposite message, the one he was starving for,
5:09
by being blunt with him, by teasing him, by calling
5:13
him a weird little owl and meaning nothing by
5:16
it. She told him something no amount of gentleness
5:19
could. You are just a kid. An ordinary, annoying
5:22
kid, and I am going to treat you exactly like
5:25
one, because I do not see a tragedy when I look
5:28
at you. I see a slightly odd seven -year -old,
5:31
and that is all you are to me. To a child exhausted
5:34
by being a special case, by being everyone's
5:38
careful project, that ordinariness was not an
5:41
insult. It was the deepest possible relief. She
5:45
was not handling him. She was just talking to
5:48
him. And he had not known, until she did it,
5:52
how badly he had needed someone to. I have thought
5:55
since about how much damage is done, with the
5:58
best intentions, by the very carefulness that
6:01
is meant to heal, and how little we acknowledge
6:04
it. We are so afraid of hurting the wounded that
6:07
we wrap them in a delicacy that itself becomes
6:10
a kind of wound, a daily message that they are
6:13
too broken to be spoken to normally. The grieving
6:16
know this. The ill know it. Anyone who has ever
6:20
been the object of everyone's careful concern
6:22
knows the peculiar loneliness of it. The way
6:26
the very gentleness sets you apart, marks you,
6:29
confirms that you are not one of the ordinary
6:32
people who get argued with and teased and treated
6:35
as merely, blessably normal. Sometimes the kindest
6:39
thing is to stop being so careful. Sometimes
6:42
a wound heals fastest in the hands of the one
6:46
who forgets it is there. And there was something
6:51
underneath it, too, that I could see and Kabir
6:54
could probably sense, which is that Tara was
6:56
not careful with him because she did not, in
6:59
some deep way, think of him as foreign. She had
7:03
been, herself, a young person nobody quite chose,
7:07
reached late and by luck, an outsider who had
7:11
wandered into Celonies looking and been made
7:13
into something. She knew, from the inside, the
7:17
exact territory Kabir occupies, and so she did
7:21
not approach him as a fortunate person approaches
7:23
an unfortunate one, with the careful pity that
7:27
wounds. She approached him as one of his own
7:29
kind, sideways, as a slightly older version of
7:33
the same animal. She did not say any of this.
7:37
She would never say any of this. It is not how
7:40
the recognition works. But it was there in the
7:43
ease of her. In the way she did not lower her
7:46
voice or soften her edges or perform tenderness,
7:49
because she was not visiting a damaged child
7:52
from a safe distance, she was greeting a younger
7:55
member of her own tribe, the tribe of the not
7:58
chosen. And Kabir, who can smell carefulness
8:02
at fifty paces and recoils from it, could smell
8:06
its absence in her, and relaxed into it like
8:08
a boy stepping out of a tight collar. There is
8:11
a recognition between the wounded that the unwounded
8:14
can neither fake nor fully see, a frequency they
8:18
broadcast on that only their own kind receive.
8:21
I have it, faintly, with Kabir myself. It is
8:25
why I could reach him at the first meeting when
8:27
Saloni's warmth could not, because I too was
8:31
an unwatched child, and he could sense it. But
8:35
Tara's version was purer than mine, because she
8:38
was closer to him in age and in freshness, her
8:41
own not chosen years barely behind her, the membrane
8:44
between her and his condition far thinner than
8:47
the decades thick one between his and mine. She
8:51
did not have to remember being unchosen. She
8:54
practically still was. And so the signal passed
8:58
between them clean and strong. The wordless I
9:01
am one of you that no adult, however empathetic,
9:05
can quite transmit across the gulf of a safe
9:08
and finished life. By the end of the afternoon,
9:14
they had found their thing, and it was not the
9:17
gentle bonding I might have scripted. It was
9:20
the metro, and it was an argument. Because Tara,
9:25
it turned out, also knows the Metro, having grown
9:28
up riding it, and instead of doing what we all
9:31
do, which is to admire Kabir's expertise with
9:34
careful encouraging noises, she challenged it.
9:37
She told him he was wrong about something. A
9:41
route, a timing, with the flat confidence of
9:44
an older kid who is not going to defer to a little
9:46
one just because he is fragile, and Kabir, who's
9:49
been handled so gently for so long, lit up like
9:53
a switch had been thrown, because here at last
9:56
was someone treating his obsession not as a poignant
9:58
symptom to be indulged, but as a real subject
10:01
to be argued about on the merits as equals. They
10:05
argued about the Metro for 40 minutes. It was,
10:08
I am fairly sure, the happiest 40 minutes of
10:11
his time with us so far, and it was made entirely
10:14
of contradiction, of a young woman refusing to
10:17
let a damaged child win an argument just because
10:20
he was damaged, which is its own profound form
10:23
of respect, the respect of being argued with
10:26
rather than humored. Nobody humors an equal,
10:29
and to be humored is to be told, gently, that
10:33
you do not count enough to be contradicted. We
10:36
had all been humoring Kabir, in our care, agreeing
10:40
with him too readily, praising his metro knowledge
10:44
with the slightly false enthusiasm adults produce
10:47
for children, and he had felt the falseness in
10:50
it, because children always do. Tara's flat contradiction
10:54
was the opposite of humoring. It said, Your ideas
10:59
are real enough to be wrong. Your expertise is
11:02
real enough to be challenged. You are a real
11:05
enough person to argue with. There is no respect
11:08
deeper than that. The respect of being taken
11:11
seriously enough to be told you are mistaken.
11:13
And Kabir, who had been handled and praised and
11:17
managed but rarely simply argued with, drank
11:20
it like water. I asked Tara about it later. when
11:26
Kabir had gone to do something else and what
11:28
she said gave me her side of it, and it was not
11:31
what I expected. He's easy, she said, with a
11:36
shrug, and then, seeing my face, explained. I
11:40
mean, he's not easy, obviously, I can see he's
11:43
a lot. But he's easy for me, because I know exactly
11:48
what he is. I was him. Not the same story, but
11:52
the same thing. The waiting to be sent back.
11:55
The not trusting it. I spent years being the
11:58
project everybody was so careful about, and the
12:02
best thing anyone ever did for me was treat me
12:04
like I wasn't one. She looked at where Kabir
12:08
had gone. Everyone's so gentle with him. He's
12:12
drowning in gentle. What he needs is someone
12:15
to call him a weird little owl and argue with
12:18
him about the blue line and let him be normal
12:21
for five minutes. She paused, and something passed
12:25
over her face, younger and rarer than her usual
12:29
composure. Also, I don't know. It's nice. To
12:34
be the one who gets it for once, instead of the
12:37
one who needs getting. I spent a long time being
12:41
the kid who needed reaching. It's, I don't have
12:44
a word for what it is, to be on the other side
12:47
of that now. To be the one reaching down. And
12:53
there it was, the thing the whole afternoon had
12:56
been quietly showing me, the thing I went and
12:59
wrote down that night because it was too large
13:01
to lose. Saloni's looking had not stopped with
13:06
Saloni. It had gone into Tara, years ago, the
13:10
patient attention that made a wandering, unchosen
13:13
girl into a person who knew her own worth. And
13:16
now that same looking, having matured in Terra,
13:20
was flowing back out of her and into Kabir, sideways.
13:23
From one of the not chosen to another, reaching
13:26
a child Celonie herself could not have reached
13:29
the same way. Because Celonie is an adult and
13:32
a parent, and Terra is something Kabir needed
13:35
that we could not be, a slightly older version
13:38
of himself who got out. The lineage was not a
13:42
line. It was a network, a thing that branches.
13:45
that loops, that flows in directions its source
13:48
could not predict. Celonie had lit Terra, years
13:52
ago, candle to candle, the way her mother lit
13:56
her, and now Terra, lit, was lighting Kabir,
14:00
and the light Celonie had given was reaching,
14:03
through a hand that was not hers, a corner of
14:06
a child's darkness that her own hand could not
14:09
have touched. She had made two people, and now
14:13
her two makings were making each other, and the
14:15
thing she had started was traveling outward along
14:18
paths she would never have to walk herself. This
14:21
is the thing about real influence that the people
14:24
obsessed with their own legacy never understand,
14:27
that it does not look like a monument with your
14:29
name on it, but like a stranger being kind to
14:32
another stranger three links down a chain you
14:34
started and cannot see the end of. Saloni will
14:38
never get credit for what Tara gives Kabir. Kabir
14:41
will never know that the ease Tara brings him
14:44
was lit, years ago, in a workshop by a woman
14:47
taking pains over a different lost young person.
14:50
The light arrives anonymous, its origin lost
14:54
in the passing on. And that anonymity is not
14:57
a flaw in the system. It is the proof that the
15:00
light is real, because a light given in order
15:03
to be credited is not quite a gift, and the truest
15:06
looking is the kind that goes on working long
15:08
after anyone remembers who first switched it
15:10
on. Saloni watched all of it from the side, all
15:17
afternoon. Mostly silent, with an expression
15:20
I have learned to recognize as her deepest happiness,
15:23
the quiet one she wears when something she has
15:27
made turns out to be alive enough to make things
15:29
of its own. You're pleased, I said to her that
15:33
night. I'm more than pleased, she said. Do you
15:38
understand what we watched today? Tara reached
15:41
him. The girl I taught reached the boy I'm teaching,
15:44
and she did it better than I can in a way I never
15:47
could because she's got something I haven't got,
15:49
which is that she was where he is. I gave her
15:53
that, not the being unchosen. Life gave her that,
15:56
but the coming through it, the learning to look.
15:59
And she just handed it on to him. That's it.
16:03
That's the whole thing. That's what I'm for.
16:07
She was quiet a moment. You write about lineage
16:10
in those notebooks. The Diaz, the candle to candle.
16:14
Today you got to watch it actually happen outside
16:18
of you between two children who aren't even mine
16:21
by blood. The light I lit is lighting other lights
16:25
now, without me. There's no better thing than
16:28
that. There isn't anything better than that.
16:34
I wrote the working line late, the flat quiet,
16:39
Two of Celonie's makings asleep and at home in
16:42
the world she had made for them. The looking
16:45
you give a person does not stop with that person.
16:48
It travels. Attend to someone truly, and you
16:52
do not merely change them. You make a thing that
16:55
can, in its turn, attend to others, often reaching
17:00
corners of the world you never could have reached
17:02
yourself. Lineage is not a line but a network.
17:07
The light you light goes on to light lights you
17:09
will never see, by hands that are not yours,
17:12
in directions you could not have predicted. So,
17:15
do not measure the worth of your looking only
17:17
by what it does to the one you look at. Measure
17:20
it if you can bear the largeness of it, by everyone
17:23
they will go on to look at because you looked
17:25
at them first. You are not lighting one candle.
17:29
You are lighting a candle that lights candles.
17:32
The dark is very large, and you will not live
17:35
to see most of the lights your light will start.
17:38
Light it anyway. That is how the dark actually
17:41
loses. I capped the pen and looked down the hall
17:46
toward the room where Kabir slept, a boy who
17:49
had spent the afternoon being argued with about
17:51
the blue line by a young woman who had once been
17:53
as unchosen as he was and who had reached him,
17:57
sideways, with the exact light my wife had handed
18:00
her years before. Saloni had been right. There
18:04
was nothing better than that. I had spent six
18:07
notebooks learning to see one woman, and she
18:10
had spent a lifetime learning to see everyone,
18:13
and the difference between us was written plainly
18:16
in the afternoon I had just watched. My looking
18:19
made a marriage, hers made a world, a widening
18:22
one, a network of lit and lighting people that
18:26
was even now reaching, through Tara's blunt kindness.
18:30
a corner of a child I could not reach myself.
18:33
That was the day I stopped thinking of what we
18:36
had done as taking in a child and started thinking
18:39
of it as joining a current. We had imagined,
18:42
in the empty room, a closed transaction, two
18:46
people, one child, a defined and manageable addition.
18:51
But there is no such thing as a defined addition
18:54
to a human life. Every person you let in is a
18:57
door to all their people, and all of theirs the
19:00
whole live branching web of human connection.
19:03
And in taking Kabir, we had not added one node
19:06
to our lives, but plugged ourselves into a network
19:08
without edges. A thing that would go on rerouting
19:12
our love into corners we would never map. I had
19:15
thought we were widening a marriage. We were,
19:18
it turned out. joining the great circuit of the
19:21
lit and the lighting, which has no boundary anyone
19:24
has ever found. We had set out, in an empty room,
19:29
to widen a marriage by one. We had not understood,
19:33
then, that you cannot let one new person into
19:36
a life like ours without letting in everyone
19:38
they are connected to, and everyone those people
19:40
will go on to touch, the whole branching human
19:43
network of it, lighting and lighting and lighting,
19:46
out past anything the two of us would ever live
19:49
to see. To be continued in Episode 72, The Review.
20:06
of My Playful Wife. If this story is staying
20:09
with you, the next episode is already waiting.
20:13
Subscribe so you don't miss it. The complete
20:16
book is on Amazon, and early episodes plus bonus
20:19
chapters are on my Patreon. Links are in the
20:23
description. Thank you for listening.