Latest / AV SuperFriends / AV SuperFriends: Off the Rails Episode 137 - Markdown APIs
Transcript
- 0:05In case you missed the last episode of
- 0:07Off the Rails,
- 0:08the gang took a perfectly reasonable NAB
- 0:10recap and turned it into a wandering group
- 0:13therapy session for AV people who have
- 0:15strong opinions about Black Magic,
- 0:17Bird Dog, NDI, Dante AVH, RØDE,
- 0:21Sony camera metadata,
- 0:22and a terrifying mobile studio cart that
- 0:24looks like Johnny Five got into corporate
- 0:26video production.
- 0:28There was also a bi-amp fiftieth
- 0:29anniversary recap,
- 0:31an electric hummer side quest,
- 0:33anechoic chamber weirdness,
- 0:34clear one boxes being reborn with new
- 0:37stickers,
- 0:37and enough production AV convergence talk
- 0:40to make your campus network team start
- 0:42updating their resumes.
- 0:43While you were off pretending to be
- 0:45productive,
- 0:46we were over here decoding NAB
- 0:47announcements,
- 0:48mocking twenty-three thousand dollar robot
- 0:50things,
- 0:51and asking the hard questions like,
- 0:53does it drive itself?
- 0:55And,
- 0:55is there a tiny engineer living inside it?
- 0:58If you didn't listen,
- 0:59you are now technically behind on AV, AI,
- 1:03NDI, Dante, and wheeled studio furniture.
- 1:06Shameful.
- 1:07Embarrassing.
- 1:08Professionally reckless.
- 1:10Go listen to what you missed at
- 1:11avsuperfriends.com before the robots find
- 1:14out you're unprepared.
- 1:21This is AV Superfriends Off the Rails,
- 1:23an almost regularly scheduled open
- 1:25discussion on audio and video in higher
- 1:28education.
- 1:29We'll sound off about our most brilliant
- 1:30ideas, our dumbest mistakes,
- 1:32and everything in between.
- 1:33And because this conversation will almost
- 1:35certainly go off the rails at some point,
- 1:37we'll end up covering just about
- 1:38everything else.
- 1:39And now, the AV Superfriends.
- 1:45For May eight, twenty twenty six,
- 1:46it's the best sounding and the fourth most
- 1:49paid advertisements masquerading as
- 1:51content laden podcasts in higher ed.
- 1:53This is the super friends off the rails.
- 1:55Episode number one hundred and thirty
- 1:56seven.
- 1:57That's a lot of them broadcasting live
- 1:59from an undisclosed equipment closet where
- 2:01the cable management is theoretical.
- 2:03The firmware updates are pending and the
- 2:04only thing louder than the cooling fans is
- 2:06the collective sigh of every technician
- 2:08ever asked.
- 2:09Can't you just make that work real quick?
- 2:11From the land of blinking lights,
- 2:12mystery adapters, abandoned documentation,
- 2:13and that one touch panel that absolutely
- 2:15knows what it did.
- 2:17We're pushing signal through the noise,
- 2:18one questionable workaround at the time.
- 2:20I'm Chris Decker,
- 2:21and you're tuned in for another Friday
- 2:22afternoon podcast adventure with the AV
- 2:24Super Friends.
- 2:25And let's say hello to that panel.
- 2:28I moved all my buttons around with this
- 2:29one.
- 2:31Let me queue up the rest of these,
- 2:32too.
- 2:33These are all different.
- 2:33Just getting ready.
- 2:34Come on.
- 2:35Well, I shoved that cold open up front,
- 2:36and everything else moved over.
- 2:37So, yeah.
- 2:38All right.
- 2:39Gain the price.
- 2:40That's what happens.
- 2:41Our first panelist leads emergency
- 2:43reassurance efforts while quietly asking
- 2:45three different teams if we use that
- 2:48online vendor.
- 2:49He's a coordinator of cloud vendor
- 2:50management from Kansas City.
- 2:52Say hello to Mr. Jamie Reinhart.
- 2:54I just move the clouds around and around,
- 2:56and every now and then, tornadoes.
- 3:00CloudStorm.
- 3:03Our next panelist celebrates every major
- 3:05software-as-a-service outage by walking
- 3:07past the on-prem rack and whispering,
- 3:09you beautiful disaster.
- 3:11He's a director of Cloud Breach
- 3:12Schadenfreude from Corvallis, Oregon.
- 3:14Say hello to Mr. Mark Kolowczynski.
- 3:17One day,
- 3:18the old iron shall rise from the ashes.
- 3:21That day is today.
- 3:23Or yesterday.
- 3:24Yeah, or yesterday.
- 3:26Earlier this week.
- 3:26Our next panelist digs through
- 3:27six-year-old procurement forms to find the
- 3:31one checkbox where the vendor promised
- 3:35this exact thing could never happen.
- 3:37He's an assistant dean of vendor security
- 3:39questionnaire archaeology from Greensboro,
- 3:40North Carolina.
- 3:41Say hello to Mr. Larry Darling.
- 3:43Yep,
- 3:43and I asked it in a Teams channel,
- 3:45and I've had Copilot looking for it for
- 3:47the past week.
- 3:48Where is it?
- 3:48It's right there.
- 3:49Don't trust Copilot.
- 3:54And our final panelist spends his days
- 3:56planning a clean,
- 3:57orderly move to a completely different
- 3:59platform that will definitely never,
- 4:01ever have problems of its own.
- 4:03He's our executive vice president for
- 4:04emergency service migration from Bowling
- 4:06Green, Kentucky.
- 4:07Say hello to Mr. Justin Rexing.
- 4:09So if my plan is to just move
- 4:11it to the cloud,
- 4:12do I just call Jamie?
- 4:14Yeah.
- 4:16He leads the emergency reassurance
- 4:18efforts,
- 4:19so he can just reassure me that shit's
- 4:20being handled.
- 4:21Don't worry.
- 4:22I'll go from one cloud to the other.
- 4:24We're good.
- 4:25That's an easy job.
- 4:26I'll take that.
- 4:27put it in the cloud which one yes
- 4:29one of them all of it the dark
- 4:32one the deep dark cloud the dark cloud
- 4:37on today's show we're going to discuss
- 4:38media production studios and a listener
- 4:41email about microphones and lecterns but
- 4:43first
- 4:44a little bit of housekeeping.
- 4:45So if you're listening,
- 4:45this is recorded MP three.
- 4:46Congratulations.
- 4:47This file exists locally,
- 4:49which already makes it more reliable than
- 4:51whatever enterprise cloud platform your
- 4:52campus is currently wishing wasn't mission
- 4:54critical.
- 4:56We stream live on Fridays at about three,
- 4:57fifteen Eastern, twelve, fifteen Pacific,
- 4:58or whenever Mark successfully
- 4:59authenticates through six browser
- 5:01redirects and in a terms of service
- 5:03update.
- 5:04You can join us for that live on
- 5:05Twitter, LinkedIn and YouTube.
- 5:07If you can't join us live,
- 5:08you can follow AVSuperFriends on the
- 5:09socials, Twitter, LinkedIn, YouTube,
- 5:11and Blue Sky.
- 5:12That way,
- 5:12when the next global outage turns your
- 5:14carefully designed workflow into a
- 5:15spinning icon and a later followed apology
- 5:18banner,
- 5:19you can at least have something to read
- 5:20while your help desk explains that no,
- 5:22rebooting the room PC will not fix the
- 5:24data centers scattered all over Northern
- 5:26Virginia.
- 5:28Please share this show with your friends,
- 5:29colleagues, vendors, enemies,
- 5:30cloud architects, status page enthusiasts,
- 5:32and anyone who's ever said it's hosted so
- 5:34we don't have to worry about it anymore,
- 5:37which is everybody.
- 5:39If you'd like to support the show,
- 5:40hit the donation link in the show notes
- 5:41or at the top of the website there.
- 5:43Your contributions help to keep us
- 5:45bringing you the honest higher ed AV
- 5:46content without requiring a monthly seat
- 5:48license, compliant review,
- 5:49or a forty eight hour incident postmortem
- 5:51written exclusively in passive voice.
- 5:54In Markdown.
- 5:57No.
- 5:57And thanks for your support.
- 5:58We couldn't do this without you.
- 6:00Every time Mark says Markdown,
- 6:01it's just text.
- 6:02I was about to say.
- 6:04It's just text.
- 6:06I was about to say.
- 6:08Every show, he says Markdown now.
- 6:09It's all it is now.
- 6:10I'm just surrounded by Markdown.
- 6:12I don't even know where it's at anymore.
- 6:15everything's one reference markdown file
- 6:17just a text file yes with no formatting
- 6:20all right and now make sure we're correct
- 6:25in our run of show here yep you've
- 6:26waited for it all week it's time for
- 6:28the news which is a big deal this
- 6:30week yeah
- 6:36we've got two news stories we had a
- 6:38separate news story planned until
- 6:40yesterday then the news broke so then the
- 6:41news broke yeah so did everything else
- 6:44ruined all of it so unlike every other
- 6:47show podcast whatever who's going to cover
- 6:49this in like two weeks we're covering it
- 6:50today while it's happening deal with it um
- 6:54is it still happening no it's not now
- 7:00It was done a few days ago.
- 7:01We'll come back to that comment.
- 7:03What is it?
- 7:04What the hell happened?
- 7:04So the link we're using,
- 7:06because Jamie literally made these people
- 7:09leave the building they were in,
- 7:11comes from KCUR,
- 7:13comes from NPR in Kansas City there,
- 7:15who used to be on the Kansas City
- 7:17campus for UMKC.
- 7:19In fact,
- 7:20their name is based on the old name
- 7:22of the university.
- 7:23A little bit of trivia there.
- 7:25The headline is,
- 7:26hackers hit the University of Missouri
- 7:28system.
- 7:29comma, and nine thousand other schools.
- 7:33All of them.
- 7:35High school, everything.
- 7:36I got a thousand emails yesterday.
- 7:38We're fine.
- 7:39This is affecting.
- 7:40We're good.
- 7:40So it's in structure.
- 7:41Canvas was hacked or penetrated or
- 7:45whatever by somebody somewhere somehow.
- 7:48potentially as long as two years ago,
- 7:50depending on what you're getting at here.
- 7:52Short version is they took down,
- 7:54as I understand it,
- 7:54you guys can correct me because this is
- 7:56changing as we go,
- 7:58they took down the authentication
- 8:00capability and login capability so no one
- 8:03could get into any of their Canvas course
- 8:05shells.
- 8:06Is that fair?
- 8:07Are we at all accurate on that?
- 8:09I think at the baseline,
- 8:10it would say at least that happened.
- 8:12Yes.
- 8:12The immediate impact was that, correct?
- 8:16but it's not clear,
- 8:17did they exfiltrate any actual course data
- 8:19and would that be of any value?
- 8:21You know, it's hard to say.
- 8:22They got a lot of... Well, maybe,
- 8:25is it?
- 8:25I don't know.
- 8:27They got a lot of usernames, passwords,
- 8:29authentication information like that,
- 8:30but...
- 8:31not real like actual information there are
- 8:34concerns someone mentioned I didn't see
- 8:35who was yelling at the time there are
- 8:37concerns that if these were um uh school
- 8:40districts then these are people under who
- 8:43you now have email addresses and username
- 8:45and passwords and that's a whole different
- 8:46ball of wax so yeah I mean for
- 8:49anybody who's like dealt with integrations
- 8:52and the like into these platforms
- 8:56wow i mean i don't even do that
- 8:57but like like the apis and stuff and
- 9:00like how that i can't yeah lti which
- 9:03is a fancy word for the different apis
- 9:05the or mark down apis but how these
- 9:10these companies have operated and if raul
- 9:12was here he would just be screaming at
- 9:14us right now that some of these privileges
- 9:16that happen like it's just like god just
- 9:17go ahead and give us everything we'll just
- 9:19take all of it just give it we
- 9:20can just get in there do whatever we
- 9:21want to do and it's like wait what
- 9:23And so I'm not going to be surprised
- 9:25to find out that it wasn't necessarily
- 9:27infiltrated as much as it just was let
- 9:30in and they just had their way.
- 9:32The default password was admin.
- 9:33Yeah, it was just something stupid.
- 9:36A simple exploit that was just sitting
- 9:38there.
- 9:39So it's...
- 9:41I would bet,
- 9:42and I'll put my money on it,
- 9:43this is not the first or the last
- 9:45that we're going to see of these types
- 9:46of fun types of...
- 9:47This isn't the first or the last that's
- 9:49happened to Instructure.
- 9:50Yeah, that's what I'm saying.
- 9:52We're going to see rapid fire.
- 9:54Well, it's just a couple weeks.
- 9:55Well, as far back,
- 9:57I was talking to our CISO yesterday about
- 9:58this.
- 9:59He said,
- 10:00if I'm remembering correctly what he was
- 10:01talking about...
- 10:04There are these stories going back
- 10:05specifically with Instructure to twenty
- 10:07twenty four.
- 10:08And every time it happened to be like,
- 10:09no, no, no, it was minor.
- 10:10We got it.
- 10:10We got it cleaned up and got a
- 10:11fix.
- 10:11And then it happened again in twenty
- 10:12twenty five.
- 10:13Then it happened a few weeks ago.
- 10:14So it's like I suspect this same group
- 10:16and other groups, like you said,
- 10:17they've they found some sort of exploit,
- 10:19usually through some sort of poorly
- 10:21documented API from another cloud
- 10:24platform.
- 10:26And they've been in there gathering
- 10:27information for years.
- 10:28We let them in.
- 10:31I read.
- 10:31They just basically leveraged this
- 10:33authentication attack this week because
- 10:35they knew it was finals week,
- 10:36and that's funny.
- 10:37I read somewhere,
- 10:39I forgot what article I was reading,
- 10:40but there's tons of them out there that
- 10:41they went through one of their free
- 10:43platforms to get to everything else.
- 10:46Oh, geez.
- 10:47That's how I read that.
- 10:50I mean, let's be honest.
- 10:52Anybody who has like a max plan right
- 10:54now and can like open a terminal on
- 10:56the side of a browser can all of
- 10:58a sudden start to get this code fairly
- 11:00readily.
- 11:01Yeah, I've got half of it.
- 11:02I mean,
- 11:02if you're in your browser right now and
- 11:03you're watching this in YouTube,
- 11:04you're
- 11:05on your computer,
- 11:06just press F-twelve and open up that
- 11:08console on on the right hand side.
- 11:10That's only for developers.
- 11:12Yeah, come on, man.
- 11:15Copy and paste that into your IDE slash
- 11:19vibe coding thing of choice and and have
- 11:21fun.
- 11:21I mean,
- 11:21spend the weekend just really finding out
- 11:23what's under the hood here.
- 11:24I mean, that's all it takes.
- 11:26I mean,
- 11:26that's really what we're looking for.
- 11:27Find me every vulnerability.
- 11:30Go.
- 11:33Right.
- 11:33So that's where we are.
- 11:34Right.
- 11:36so everybody has this this newfound
- 11:39superpower of let me just hack into this
- 11:41thing and then but claude helped me break
- 11:44through the back i think you're talking
- 11:45about something that we're going to see a
- 11:47little bit more often coming up is you
- 11:50know this was an organized group and what
- 11:53mark's saying is this could be happening
- 11:55on accident just by people being curious i
- 11:59i believe that
- 12:01the traditional posture of a lot of
- 12:02security offices,
- 12:04pick your organization type, whatever,
- 12:06are overly concerned about looking at
- 12:08who's coming in, who's trying to get in.
- 12:10It's like they're already in.
- 12:13The calls are coming from inside the
- 12:14house.
- 12:15And so by way of all the integrations
- 12:17and everything like that that's happened
- 12:18because of the lack of clear governance
- 12:20around how APIs are structured and when it
- 12:22happens and it just goes out,
- 12:23you get the full keys to the kingdom.
- 12:25Or the documented APIs.
- 12:26Yeah,
- 12:27then that company is now beholden to
- 12:29whatever the security context of the other
- 12:31company that's now tied in through API.
- 12:34And it becomes this domino effect.
- 12:36And you can't keep track of every single
- 12:37one of these integrated vendors by way of
- 12:40LTI and API integration.
- 12:41So it's going to happen.
- 12:42It's going to continue to spread.
- 12:45Everything local.
- 12:47Correct, Justin.
- 12:48The challenge of a lot of this stuff
- 12:50is in years past and for years continuing
- 12:53because...
- 12:54People aren't going to migrate away from
- 12:57Canvas because of this.
- 12:58Now,
- 12:58if someone happens to be preparing an RFP
- 13:00for next week, it might change their mind.
- 13:02If your contract is about to end,
- 13:04you might renegotiate said contract and
- 13:06ask for a discount because, hey, thanks.
- 13:09But schools who are not on Canvas,
- 13:12and it's something like two-thirds,
- 13:14forty percent, something like that,
- 13:15there's some large number.
- 13:16including justin including justin but if
- 13:19you're on moodle if you're on blackboard
- 13:20if you're in other ones you're probably
- 13:21like breathing a sigh of relief but this
- 13:23could happen to you just as easily
- 13:24blackboard i mean anybody's gonna happen
- 13:28to anybody right well blackboard could
- 13:30happen yeah so i mean like we're on
- 13:31black i mean you said blackboard i mean
- 13:33this can happen to anybody it's just yeah
- 13:35canvas is probably the most used or the
- 13:36most targeted right i mean that's kind of
- 13:38how that works
- 13:39Well, Canvas is the biggest one right now.
- 13:42Yeah.
- 13:42So they're the highest target.
- 13:43They have the most data until yesterday.
- 13:46At the end of the day,
- 13:48all the cyber insurance companies are
- 13:49like, yes,
- 13:50we're just going to jack up these rates
- 13:53on everybody now and see such a risk.
- 13:55So, you know,
- 13:56that two hundred fifty thousand dollar
- 13:57policy you have,
- 13:57let's just make that a cool million and
- 14:00we'll see how this goes.
- 14:00I think in our particular vertical,
- 14:06this is really interesting in the fact
- 14:07that
- 14:10This is going to kick off more serious
- 14:12discussions to what you were just saying,
- 14:13Mark,
- 14:14is that sometimes these are coming from
- 14:16within the house.
- 14:18And I think for us in particular,
- 14:20because not all of us have to deal
- 14:21with canvas or any of that,
- 14:24it would be really interesting on how this
- 14:26starts to waterfall into our parts.
- 14:30And maybe we need to have the...
- 14:32Cloud controls the future.
- 14:34Oh, wait.
- 14:34Maybe we need to have our buddy Colin
- 14:37come back on and talk to us about
- 14:39it, right?
- 14:39Because our show a couple of...
- 14:40What was it?
- 14:41A couple months ago?
- 14:41We were going to do that anyway.
- 14:43We talked about security.
- 14:43We're going to follow up with AV Trust
- 14:45at Infocom.
- 14:46And now we have a reason.
- 14:48Something to talk about.
- 14:49Yeah, we didn't before.
- 14:50Because we are proponents of network-based
- 14:54stuff.
- 14:54We are proponents of cloud.
- 14:55We are proponents.
- 14:56We are proponents.
- 14:57We are proponents.
- 14:58But now...
- 14:59we all knew that this was a potential
- 15:02vulnerability.
- 15:03And it's like, well, maybe,
- 15:04and now it's like, oh Jesus,
- 15:05it is real.
- 15:06Like this can really happen.
- 15:08Never been a cloud hack before.
- 15:09Well,
- 15:09and I've been pushing that the next step
- 15:13in learning technology is true integration
- 15:16with the LMS.
- 15:18Like when the instructor can pull up the
- 15:21LMS on the display itself and just go
- 15:25from there and not have that compute in
- 15:27the middle,
- 15:28like that was going what yeah when what
- 15:34i know what's spaceship fever dream are
- 15:35you living here i have seen different
- 15:38software manufacturers that are building
- 15:40lmss with displays in the classrooms you
- 15:42said it's a really cool concept this is
- 15:45the kind of shit that i would have
- 15:46said a year ago yeah exactly but like
- 15:48this is this at least gives me
- 15:51falls that if the AV technology isn't
- 15:54mature enough to handle the security on
- 15:57that side,
- 15:57like how much access to data do we
- 16:00want to get?
- 16:00The concept would be fine until the only
- 16:02security apparatus that's existing on that
- 16:03display is some shitty Android thing
- 16:06that's sitting there.
- 16:06It hasn't been updated in fifteen years.
- 16:08And the default password you can't change.
- 16:10I don't think this is going to slow
- 16:11down some migrations to the cloud and
- 16:14things,
- 16:14but I do think it does bring to
- 16:15the forefront that there are some serious
- 16:17things that we need to discuss and
- 16:20you know, how do we go about it?
- 16:23Because this will trickle down.
- 16:25This is not going to stay at the
- 16:26cloud-based LMS system.
- 16:28It's going to go across in our world.
- 16:30We already see some of these protections
- 16:32in the corporate world and everything
- 16:34else.
- 16:34Mark,
- 16:34you mentioned this with some of these
- 16:36cloud monitoring platforms have literally
- 16:38told, and big vendors,
- 16:41big vendors have said straight up,
- 16:43just give me your default admin password
- 16:46for all your stuff.
- 16:47And we'll deal with the API in the
- 16:49back end.
- 16:50Yeah,
- 16:50and then it looks like they have it.
- 16:51Okay, Chuck.
- 16:52What?
- 16:52Here you go.
- 16:54Can you just use your login everywhere?
- 16:56That's what happens.
- 16:58But that's how they're structured.
- 16:58It just shows you they're a little over
- 17:01their skis on a lot of these things.
- 17:03And I'm not saying that's what happens in
- 17:04structure,
- 17:04but I think we're seeing such a push
- 17:07with cloud and AI and all this stuff.
- 17:09And Joe, you're absolutely right.
- 17:11There was breaches well before cloud was
- 17:12there.
- 17:13No, only yesterday.
- 17:14Right?
- 17:14And so that it's...
- 17:18Sometimes we have to just take a pause
- 17:21and reassess where we are and what's going
- 17:22on.
- 17:23I think that's kind of moving to where
- 17:24we are right now.
- 17:25We had that question, is it back up?
- 17:26It's not right.
- 17:27I think it's up,
- 17:27but I think there's a lot of organizations
- 17:29right now that are reassessing their
- 17:31posture towards this platform now and say,
- 17:33okay, this is a huge FERPA thing,
- 17:35so we have to be lockstep how we're
- 17:38going to move through this because there's
- 17:39so much
- 17:41leakage that can happen that we have to
- 17:42be brutally honest how we're gonna do this
- 17:44and so i think there wasn't this reaction
- 17:46just flip switch turn it back on and
- 17:47go everybody's like well
- 17:49let's take a good hard look around this.
- 17:51Let's understand what the governance looks
- 17:53like.
- 17:54How are we doing these integrations?
- 17:55And what are we,
- 17:56how are we gating this?
- 17:58However, for a lot of us,
- 17:59it's finals week.
- 18:00And so like the email that went out
- 18:01to my campus was,
- 18:03you can log in right now, go in,
- 18:05export your grade book stuff right now,
- 18:07do it right now.
- 18:08So you have your grades and then get
- 18:09the hell out of there.
- 18:10Because we don't know what it's going to
- 18:11be in an hour, in a day,
- 18:13in a week.
- 18:13We don't know.
- 18:14Username and passwords.
- 18:15I mean, that's really,
- 18:18since they're all linked,
- 18:19through the Azure services or whatnot,
- 18:22it's all linked.
- 18:23So once it only takes one or two
- 18:25per campus to really cause different
- 18:29havoc,
- 18:29because now everybody can get in or,
- 18:32you know,
- 18:32it's the one instructor that's on,
- 18:35you know, sabbatical.
- 18:36And so their username and password has
- 18:38been used.
- 18:40but they didn't come back and change them.
- 18:41I mean, if we're all instructed,
- 18:43do we have to change our passwords?
- 18:44Yeah.
- 18:45But I mean, we were,
- 18:47are you guys multi-factoring everybody
- 18:49who's doesn't have a campus IP or if
- 18:50they're on wifi or any of that stuff?
- 18:51I mean, it's, it's,
- 18:54it's borderline ridiculous for us.
- 18:55I know why it happens.
- 18:58They get that SSO access.
- 18:59They have a username and password as it
- 19:01stood at that point,
- 19:02or it's probably hashed and salted.
- 19:03It's hard to say.
- 19:04Could they get into financial systems and
- 19:06things?
- 19:06They'll certainly try,
- 19:07but I don't think they'll get very far.
- 19:09Did anyone else start their summer
- 19:11installs today?
- 19:13Because today was like our first day of...
- 19:16I did when the cloud was offline.
- 19:18No,
- 19:18this was our first day of classroom
- 19:20refreshes.
- 19:21And I had two rooms...
- 19:22You're like already in summer mode right
- 19:23now?
- 19:24Or we were supposed to be.
- 19:26The problem was our last day of finals
- 19:29was yesterday, which couldn't happen.
- 19:33And so I had a couple of rooms...
- 19:36that are being used for summer one
- 19:37session.
- 19:37And I had three days to get those
- 19:39completely refreshed and installed.
- 19:42So we went ahead and pulled them out
- 19:44first thing in the morning because Canvas
- 19:45was back up.
- 19:45We're like, OK, we're going to do this.
- 19:48Yeah.
- 19:48Now they're taking finals in there on
- 19:50Monday.
- 19:50Oh, wow.
- 19:50Like, thank God we knew it early.
- 19:54So Larry,
- 19:54if your finals were supposed to end
- 19:55yesterday,
- 19:56but they couldn't because of this.
- 19:57They're now being taken on Monday and I
- 19:59was able to like put them in other
- 20:00places.
- 20:01Yeah.
- 20:03That's weird.
- 20:04That's a weird finals week,
- 20:08sort of a week,
- 20:09your week start on Tuesdays.
- 20:10When's commencement?
- 20:11Is that tomorrow?
- 20:12Commencement was today.
- 20:14Those people graduated without the finals.
- 20:17What is happening in North Carolina?
- 20:19You guys even doing anything legal in
- 20:20education over there?
- 20:22Okay, Western Kentucky.
- 20:26We have a finals week,
- 20:27and then we graduate after finals.
- 20:29We do, too.
- 20:29It just happens to be on a Friday.
- 20:32Then you take finals after graduation.
- 20:34We weren't supposed to until Canvas
- 20:36decided not to work.
- 20:38Ruined the whole summer.
- 20:39It was going to work perfectly fine until
- 20:43then.
- 20:43They're saying there's larger
- 20:44ramifications with this because people are
- 20:46canceling flights,
- 20:46and all my flights are booked on Spirit,
- 20:48so...
- 20:50yeah that's not gonna go okay all right
- 20:52so um we had a second uh it's
- 20:54the waffle house of the sky uh i
- 20:55did mention we had a second news story
- 20:57because we had a first news story this
- 20:59became the news story so i do still
- 21:00want to bring up the other news story
- 21:01because it's about us talking about
- 21:04ourselves um
- 21:06So just as a bit of a preview
- 21:08here,
- 21:09so we are presenting at two conferences
- 21:11coming up here in a few weeks.
- 21:12We're presenting at the NWMET,
- 21:15the Northwest Met Conference in Salt Lake
- 21:18City, Utah in a week and a half,
- 21:21something like that.
- 21:21It's not next week, but the week after.
- 21:22It's like days away.
- 21:24It's literally days because my phone tells
- 21:26me how long until my flight and it's
- 21:28less than that.
- 21:28You're in the countdown.
- 21:29You're doing pre-boarding right now?
- 21:31Yeah,
- 21:32let me just check in right now on
- 21:34my phone and see what it says here.
- 21:36It says that flight's in nine days.
- 21:38Yeah, it says Spirit shut down,
- 21:42so good luck.
- 21:43Anyway,
- 21:44and then we're presenting a few weeks
- 21:45later at Infocomm.
- 21:46Basically,
- 21:47so if you're at either one of those
- 21:48or both, please join us.
- 21:50It's the same session at both,
- 21:51but we're going to leverage the slightly
- 21:53different environment at Northwest Met to
- 21:55kind of fine-tune
- 21:57um mark and justin you guys want to
- 21:58give them like what's what's the the the
- 22:01elevator pitch of what we're doing here
- 22:02because it's ai because everything's ai
- 22:03these days but but we kind of like
- 22:06with this instructor thing we're going
- 22:08local we're going to walk you through how
- 22:11to build and deploy a local agent that
- 22:14can help you do av design and math
- 22:17and then give you
- 22:19the ability to recreate that so you can
- 22:21control your own data and its responses.
- 22:23So you can run this thing wherever you
- 22:24want.
- 22:25So we're going to give you the skills
- 22:27to build your own agents and understand
- 22:29what it means.
- 22:29And we're not talking about just build an
- 22:31agent and chat GBT anything.
- 22:32You're going to run that model on your
- 22:33own iron and understand what that means.
- 22:36Token free.
- 22:38have your own power to do the magic
- 22:40on your own machines,
- 22:41build out your own workflows,
- 22:42and we'll give you the kind of the
- 22:44pillars of success to prop that up.
- 22:46And then we're going to have some large
- 22:47scale discussions around agentic workflows
- 22:49and what disruption that brings.
- 22:51And maybe, just maybe,
- 22:54Justin will share you some of the madness
- 22:57that he's got going on with his
- 22:58orchestration system.
- 23:00It's a lot.
- 23:01But what are we going to share with
- 23:03them, Mark?
- 23:05We're going to give away what?
- 23:08The recipe.
- 23:10Say it.
- 23:11Say the words.
- 23:12You say it.
- 23:13Markdown.
- 23:13I don't have to say it.
- 23:15It's right there.
- 23:16We're going to give away our markdown
- 23:18files.
- 23:19Yes,
- 23:19we will give you the entire step-by-step
- 23:21playbook.
- 23:22You will have it all.
- 23:22It's six thousand lines long.
- 23:25I don't know how many characters.
- 23:26Sixty-five.
- 23:27Well, yeah,
- 23:27the main one was sixty-five hundred lines
- 23:29of text.
- 23:29And then we chunked it down.
- 23:31Six thousand lines long.
- 23:32It cost me around...
- 23:34I don't have any tokens,
- 23:35but it's like forty,
- 23:35fifty bucks and we're going to give it
- 23:37away for free.
- 23:37So we're going to be talking about
- 23:39gateways.
- 23:39We're going to be talking about harnesses.
- 23:41We're going to talk about models.
- 23:42We're going to talk about knowledge base
- 23:43and rag,
- 23:43all the fun stuff that is in AI.
- 23:45So you can build your own stuff and
- 23:46be self-sufficient and not be holding to
- 23:48the cloud.
- 23:50And we'll also talk about the advantages
- 23:54and disadvantages of each because Mark is
- 23:57doing the local stuff.
- 23:58I've got some local stuff going on, but
- 24:00For what I want to use,
- 24:02this is derived from Pocket Justin,
- 24:04if you've been following this story.
- 24:06The way I have to use Pocket Justin
- 24:08is I've got to keep it on the
- 24:10cloud.
- 24:11And we're going to go through why.
- 24:12And then we're going to show you why
- 24:13you don't need to if you just want
- 24:17to keep it local and not spend a
- 24:18lot of money.
- 24:19Larry and I cannot wait to get our
- 24:21hands on Pocket Justin.
- 24:24Grab Pocket Justin with both hands.
- 24:25You don't know what's in there until you
- 24:27know what's in there.
- 24:28I technically can wait.
- 24:31Well,
- 24:31you're going to have to because you've got
- 24:32days until you can get your access to
- 24:34that.
- 24:34So, yeah, it should be a fun session.
- 24:35It's going to be hands-on.
- 24:36Bring some computing devices with you and
- 24:38bring some questions if you have
- 24:39curiosities around all these things.
- 24:41It is a hands-on.
- 24:42Let's build it.
- 24:43We're going to go through.
- 24:44We're going to give you copy and paste
- 24:45things.
- 24:45If you are attending,
- 24:46there are some prerequisites.
- 24:47Go download your packages in advance so
- 24:49that you can come prepared and not be…
- 24:50Yeah,
- 24:50we'll get some emails out both through… If
- 24:52you're at Northwest Met, through them.
- 24:54And if you're at Infocom, through Avixa,
- 24:56we'll get some emails out to you on
- 24:57some, like, prereq stuff.
- 24:58And I know not everyone's going to do
- 24:59it.
- 24:59And there's someone who will show up with
- 25:00the world's oldest laptop and stuff.
- 25:01Well, yeah,
- 25:01don't bring your Windows three dot one and
- 25:04expect us to be able to handhold you
- 25:05through this.
- 25:07I'm going to make the recommendation that
- 25:08we're going to flatten that out and run
- 25:09Linux on that first thing.
- 25:11And I will come with that and we
- 25:13will just fix that problem for you right
- 25:15there.
- 25:16Uh, so again, if you're,
- 25:16if you're attending the, uh,
- 25:18the NWMAT conference, um, if you're not,
- 25:20please sign up.
- 25:20There's still spots available and we'd
- 25:22love to have you there.
- 25:23Uh, in Salt Lake, uh, week after next,
- 25:25uh,
- 25:25we are presenting on whatever the date is
- 25:27on that Wednesday,
- 25:28the twentieth at one PM.
- 25:31So I believe that's the first day of
- 25:32that conference.
- 25:32There's workshops and things prior.
- 25:33It goes all week,
- 25:34but our session goes all week.
- 25:36It's three days.
- 25:37The first session, the first week,
- 25:38first day of the conference conference is
- 25:39on Wednesday.
- 25:40We're presenting right after lunch,
- 25:42so bring your sleepy time,
- 25:43nap time plans for that.
- 25:46And then at Infocomm,
- 25:47we're presenting Thursday at ten o'clock
- 25:51at Infocomm.
- 25:53Again, hands on,
- 25:53bring your laptop and we'll load up stuff
- 25:56for you and you can kind of walk
- 25:57through this process and see what's
- 25:59how to build your own local,
- 26:01basically automated tool set you can take
- 26:03with you to job sites or do whatever.
- 26:04And then Justin's going to talk about how
- 26:06you can then,
- 26:07if you want to build that out in
- 26:08the cloud,
- 26:10there's advantage in that because you're
- 26:11using somebody else's hardware,
- 26:12which is way more powerful than your
- 26:14laptop.
- 26:15But there's also other things it can do,
- 26:16and it's much more reasoning power and all
- 26:17that fun stuff.
- 26:18And so we'll show a lot of that
- 26:19stuff.
- 26:19And like Justin and Mark were arguing
- 26:21about there,
- 26:22we are going to give you the files
- 26:23you can take home to do this and
- 26:26build this out as a useful utility for
- 26:28yourself.
- 26:28Save you a lot of tokens.
- 26:30No recipe.
- 26:31It's pronounced receipt.
- 26:33That's right.
- 26:34It's going to be fun.
- 26:37That's our double news story.
- 26:38You got two news stories this week.
- 26:40No extra charge.
- 26:41Except people had to pay twice.
- 26:43There's more tokens involved.
- 26:45Okay.
- 26:46All right.
- 26:46We're going to take a quick break.
- 26:47We're going to come back and we're going
- 26:48to talk about, what are we talking about?
- 26:50Oh,
- 26:50we're talking about production media
- 26:53studio project weird things.
- 26:55Your standard one-offs.
- 26:56Yeah.
- 26:57These things,
- 26:57every five years you have to do one
- 26:58of these somewhere and the challenges that
- 27:01come with it and what's twenty twenty six
- 27:04look like.
- 27:04All right.
- 27:08The AV Superfriends are sponsored by
- 27:10Computer Comforts,
- 27:11and they've got a brand new product
- 27:13hitting the lineup.
- 27:14And this one exists because not every
- 27:16classroom needs a full server rack hiding
- 27:17inside a lectern.
- 27:19Shocking, I know.
- 27:20Last year,
- 27:21CCI's Evolve lectern was a big hit.
- 27:24A push-button power table combined with a
- 27:26super flexible AV cabinet.
- 27:27But let's be honest,
- 27:28not every room needs twenty-four units of
- 27:30rack space.
- 27:31That's where the new AV Hub comes in.
- 27:33It's a lighter,
- 27:34more space efficient solution for
- 27:35classrooms that still need real AV
- 27:37infrastructure.
- 27:39That's right.
- 27:39You get eight units of rack space and
- 27:41the whole thing sits only about ten inches
- 27:43off the wall.
- 27:44Which makes it a great fit when you're
- 27:45pairing it with a sit-stand power table
- 27:47instead of building a massive lectern
- 27:48footprint into the room.
- 27:50And this wasn't designed in isolation.
- 27:52The AV Hub was developed in collaboration
- 27:54with Texas State University.
- 27:55So it's very much built around real higher
- 27:57ed classrooms and real deployment needs.
- 28:00Meaning fewer compromises,
- 28:01cleaner installs, and way less,
- 28:03why is this furniture the size of a
- 28:04refrigerator?
- 28:05If you want to see photos, specs,
- 28:07and all the details,
- 28:08head over to Computer Comfort's website
- 28:09and check out the AV Hub.
- 28:11You can find that at ComputerComforts.com.
- 28:13It's a smart,
- 28:14compact approach to classroom AV furniture
- 28:16from a company that's been doing higher ed
- 28:17for decades.
- 28:19That's the new AV Hub from Computer
- 28:20Comforts.
- 28:21Purpose-built, space-efficient,
- 28:23and designed for how classrooms actually
- 28:25work.
- 28:25And thanks again to Computer Comforts for
- 28:27sponsoring the AV Superfriends.
- 28:33I've got to order one of those.
- 28:35The AV Hub.
- 28:37Yeah, actually.
- 28:38I have a really good.
- 28:39I have a great place for one.
- 28:41And I forgot.
- 28:42We're on a wall.
- 28:45Shocker.
- 28:46Wow.
- 28:48One on every wall.
- 28:50um they will have one of those at
- 28:51uh i believe at northwest and at infocomm
- 28:54so you can get hands-on with that um
- 28:55also there are some new uh let's say
- 28:58installation friendly modifications coming
- 29:01to uh some of their electrons so some
- 29:03cool stuff
- 29:05all right um so this topic we do
- 29:08have a uh it started with a news
- 29:09story i think we were going to cover
- 29:10this as news but it's it's really too
- 29:12broad it's not about specific project it's
- 29:14just kind of a broad discussion of the
- 29:16of the um the category uh so it
- 29:19and i'll link in the show notes uh
- 29:20edtech magazine university media centers
- 29:22bring creative technology to the community
- 29:25And it's talking about how a lot of
- 29:27schools,
- 29:28and everyone does this periodically,
- 29:29you build some sort of interactive media
- 29:33lab,
- 29:33some sort of media production studio
- 29:36space.
- 29:38Sometimes it's tied to an art program or
- 29:41a technology program at the school.
- 29:43Sometimes it's tied to journalism,
- 29:44sometimes the film school.
- 29:47We've all built these.
- 29:48We will all build them every couple of
- 29:50years.
- 29:51It seems to go around and around and
- 29:53around.
- 29:53And I think where this came from is
- 29:55several of us are doing this with LED
- 29:59virtual production studios at this point.
- 30:01That was the request.
- 30:02Well,
- 30:03until we found out that they had three
- 30:04thousand dollars.
- 30:08But you can't do it for three thousand
- 30:09dollars.
- 30:09Are you kidding me?
- 30:10I can.
- 30:11I think I'll pick it up at Best
- 30:12Buy for that.
- 30:14I got a quote on this LED wall.
- 30:15It's it's it is twenty foot by sixteen
- 30:18foot and it's like a three millimeter
- 30:20pixel pitch.
- 30:21It'll work, right?
- 30:22Sure.
- 30:23White shots only.
- 30:25There's three thousand dollars in that
- 30:27quote.
- 30:28Many three thousand dollars.
- 30:30So I think there's.
- 30:33a few variants of this strain that goes
- 30:35around that I think Jamie,
- 30:37what you were approached with and maybe
- 30:39the one that I built up a few
- 30:40years ago, there's that like production.
- 30:42We want a small studio and it's going
- 30:45to be like the super one button that
- 30:47people are going to walk in and they're
- 30:48going to push the thing and they're going
- 30:49to be media literate.
- 30:51Okay.
- 30:53And then there's kind of the new wave
- 30:54of this where it's like,
- 30:55we want to have this immersive experience
- 30:58where I can go be put in the
- 30:59middle of the data storm and have
- 31:01everything around me interactive and all
- 31:03that.
- 31:04And they're blurring.
- 31:05But I still want to do that production
- 31:06stuff too in here.
- 31:08And...
- 31:10How do we get like a couple of
- 31:11gram, like Chris said, what can we do?
- 31:13And I want to do zoom.
- 31:14Well, of course I can do it.
- 31:15Cause we can't have all the researchers
- 31:17there at the same time.
- 31:18It's got cameras.
- 31:20Yeah.
- 31:20Like obviously.
- 31:22But this is going to be a showcase
- 31:23piece.
- 31:24And we're going to have a couple of
- 31:25deans here when we open this thing up.
- 31:27And so it's going to be a big
- 31:29deal.
- 31:29You have a donor mark.
- 31:30Yeah.
- 31:31Well, I mean, it's a blood donor.
- 31:33There's no money, but like, yeah.
- 31:36I find that it is the different levels
- 31:39of this,
- 31:40and sometimes the ask isn't all that bad.
- 31:44In my case,
- 31:45they wanted to do broadcast journalism,
- 31:51and they didn't really have a studio
- 31:53space, a real one.
- 31:56And so they wanted to build their own
- 31:57little simplified studio space.
- 31:59And they had a budget.
- 32:00They wanted a wall,
- 32:01but then they realized that that's a level
- 32:02of complexity that they weren't quite
- 32:04ready for.
- 32:05So kind of got rid of the virtual
- 32:06production side.
- 32:06Well, there's that staffing question, too,
- 32:08beyond technology.
- 32:08Yeah, there's staffing questions.
- 32:10Because why am I building the whole thing
- 32:12from scratch?
- 32:12It's because some of these departments
- 32:15don't have an engineer.
- 32:17Maybe they're being led by more talent,
- 32:21more artistic-minded folks,
- 32:23and maybe not an engineer.
- 32:26But we're putting this thing together,
- 32:29and sometimes the thought process,
- 32:31in my case,
- 32:32and I'm going to throw it to Mark
- 32:34and Mick, because I think his is similar,
- 32:36is that there's this idea, well,
- 32:37it's going to be used for Broadcast
- 32:40Studio.
- 32:41We're going to record our shows in here.
- 32:43We're going to do this thing.
- 32:46And then you look at what this article
- 32:48is.
- 32:49And you start asking, well,
- 32:50could it be more?
- 32:52Could it also be rented?
- 32:54Can you help this be self-sustaining?
- 32:56It's a value play.
- 32:57Can you take, like in my case,
- 33:00I started asking,
- 33:00can we take more technically minded of
- 33:03your students who don't care about being
- 33:05the famous, the pretty face or the voice?
- 33:11They want to be the engineer.
- 33:13Can we take them and build it?
- 33:14Can we make this...
- 33:16bigger than just,
- 33:18we want to make TV shows.
- 33:20And it's not that the, now look,
- 33:22my peers,
- 33:23it's not that they overlooked these
- 33:25things.
- 33:25It just wasn't on the top of their
- 33:26mind.
- 33:26Their mind was,
- 33:27we have a hole in our program.
- 33:29We got to fill this specific hole in
- 33:31our program.
- 33:32And then you start asking, well,
- 33:33can you do more?
- 33:35Which is weird that we want to ask
- 33:36that.
- 33:36Can you do more?
- 33:37Because we don't want to give anybody
- 33:39more.
- 33:39That's just insanely complicated.
- 33:42But Mark,
- 33:42yours was kind of the other way.
- 33:44Yeah, it's different.
- 33:44I think the model you're kind of
- 33:46describing being the educational venture
- 33:48will never sustain itself.
- 33:50No, not by itself.
- 33:51It will cost more to build that stuff
- 33:53than you will have students that are
- 33:55paying tuition to use it.
- 33:56Correct.
- 33:56And that is the impossible piece you have
- 33:59to understand.
- 33:59And so that if that is the case,
- 34:02how do you subsidize this to make it
- 34:04so that you can get the value out
- 34:05of it?
- 34:06And the secret word, and pay attention,
- 34:08turn up your car stereo.
- 34:09Bicycle.
- 34:10Oh.
- 34:10public private partnerships that's not a
- 34:13word that's three words this is where
- 34:15everybody goes it just means how do we
- 34:18bring in outside dollars to use this space
- 34:21and that and that's leasing these things
- 34:22so we can kind of use them and
- 34:23i think that becomes we bolt that onto
- 34:26research and we say oh it's going to
- 34:27be transformative and voila we're bringing
- 34:30in other businesses to come in and start
- 34:31to use this thing so we can get
- 34:32some return and some revenue
- 34:34Where these things start to fail is you
- 34:37don't have buy-in,
- 34:38which coincides with having an accountable
- 34:41person responsible for that thing every
- 34:44day, whether that's one person or a team.
- 34:47If you build something that you're
- 34:50expecting faculty and students to fix and
- 34:52operate and run at the highest capable
- 34:55level,
- 34:56efficiency that that thing can run,
- 34:58it's not going to happen.
- 34:59It's going to fail.
- 34:59And then everybody's like,
- 35:00why is this so difficult to run?
- 35:02Why is this breaking?
- 35:05Go ahead, Larry.
- 35:06Yeah,
- 35:07I think what everybody has kind of danced
- 35:10around is the staffing issue.
- 35:11And Chris called it out earlier.
- 35:14We have one that we're in the process
- 35:16of building right now and finding the
- 35:20person who has the technical chops to own
- 35:23it
- 35:25I mean,
- 35:26and to care and feed it is the
- 35:28issue at this point.
- 35:29Just think about this.
- 35:30What, ten years ago, fifteen years ago,
- 35:33maybe even less,
- 35:34we had people in classes that were
- 35:37technicians running, you know,
- 35:39codecs and cameras and all that crap.
- 35:42That's just a classroom.
- 35:44But I think...
- 35:47a lot of this conversation and you're
- 35:49hearing it right now there's a lot of
- 35:51bias in this just because of the the
- 35:53way that it postures and i don't i'm
- 35:55gonna take the other side of this
- 35:56perspective as weird as it is because this
- 35:58has been the challenge in building up the
- 36:00space that i'm building that was the exact
- 36:03thing we did software we flew down to
- 36:04arizona state we looked at the mix center
- 36:06we went to all these different places that
- 36:07had these immersive spaces that were going
- 36:09to their decision theater yeah we did
- 36:11these things and that would you decide
- 36:13At the takeaway,
- 36:14the leadership said two things.
- 36:16One,
- 36:17do not seek a finished solution because
- 36:20you're going to want to change it
- 36:20immediately.
- 36:21So think of it more as a black
- 36:23box that's flexible and you're going to be
- 36:24able to change these things later on.
- 36:26And then the other thing we noticed
- 36:27looking around,
- 36:27it's like there is like teams of people.
- 36:30Who's going to change things later on,
- 36:32Mark?
- 36:32Who is that?
- 36:33Well, let me get to it.
- 36:34So I've taken that as like,
- 36:36okay, how do I take that challenge?
- 36:39So what do we need to do?
- 36:40And I do believe to deliver these in
- 36:42the next generation,
- 36:44you cannot look at it of how would
- 36:46we have done this yesterday?
- 36:48And how do I build on a traditional
- 36:49studio,
- 36:50you have to think automation first,
- 36:53what does it need to do successfully,
- 36:55at percent of the time,
- 36:55and how do you automate those things.
- 36:57And so they can deliver that without
- 37:00needing a whole production team and a
- 37:02television crew requires people
- 37:06It still does to build it and maintain
- 37:07those things,
- 37:08but resist building it in a way that
- 37:10you're inserting that human to need to be
- 37:13there for those simple functions.
- 37:15Yeah, we can build anything.
- 37:16We're all capable of this.
- 37:19Where it falls apart is the buy-in from
- 37:21the top and the bottom.
- 37:23Usually what I see is the top people
- 37:26like, let's do this idea.
- 37:28And the bottom people get it shoved in
- 37:30their face and they're like,
- 37:31I don't even know how to use this
- 37:32shit.
- 37:33Like, why do I,
- 37:34there's no buy-in that's consistent from
- 37:36the bottom up, top down.
- 37:38So you don't have a person accountable to
- 37:40run that and be the expert.
- 37:42So our charge was zero to success in
- 37:44sixty seconds.
- 37:46That's it.
- 37:47That's the challenge.
- 37:49So how does somebody come in the room?
- 37:50That sounds cool.
- 37:51What the hell is that?
- 37:51Within sixty seconds,
- 37:52have that room do something.
- 37:54Now,
- 37:54I'm not reproducing the Mandalorian in
- 37:57this for the average person who's coming
- 37:59in here.
- 37:59But if I walk in the room and
- 38:00I just want to do a visualization,
- 38:01I have my data, get up.
- 38:02It should not include me logging in and
- 38:05going through all these things and hooping
- 38:06through.
- 38:06Where's all my stuff?
- 38:07Well,
- 38:07now we're talking about five different
- 38:09things, though.
- 38:10But like the simple things to get that
- 38:13true...
- 38:14used so that can be used in and
- 38:16out.
- 38:16So and I think the big over the
- 38:18top production thing is actually less of
- 38:21the use case, as weird as it is,
- 38:24simple things more easily.
- 38:26I agree.
- 38:26I had I had a few years ago,
- 38:29I may or may not have been,
- 38:31you know, rage interviewing for new jobs.
- 38:33And I went into a place that did
- 38:34integrations and a lot of house of
- 38:35worships.
- 38:36And I asked a lot of these questions.
- 38:38because they specialized in these big,
- 38:40complicated, production-based,
- 38:42you've got to have seven people to run
- 38:44a TV studio thing.
- 38:45And I said, well,
- 38:47do you have an easy button so that
- 38:49the kindergarten class can have the little
- 38:52bitty Christmas program?
- 38:55Well, no, we bring in everybody.
- 38:57Why?
- 38:58Why can't you have?
- 38:59Because to Mark's point, like,
- 39:02sixty percent of your things
- 39:04Don't require twelve people.
- 39:05They require.
- 39:06Well, that's what I was about to say.
- 39:08What's your expectation of that content
- 39:09when you're done?
- 39:10That's yeah,
- 39:11it's just that's the other side of that
- 39:13thing.
- 39:13Usually you need those seven people based
- 39:15upon the expectations of that event.
- 39:18But to your point earlier about we used
- 39:20to have for video conference classes,
- 39:22we used to have a cruise of people
- 39:25and now they log into Zoom and hit
- 39:26go.
- 39:27What's good enough?
- 39:28What's the expectation?
- 39:29And that's what's good enough.
- 39:30That's what I'm saying.
- 39:31Good enough is good enough.
- 39:33But we're not building these spaces for
- 39:34good enough.
- 39:35Exactly.
- 39:37No, but we are.
- 39:39But we are.
- 39:40This broadcast studio that I'm making,
- 39:42it cannot reach...
- 39:44The level that is needed for most giant
- 39:48production companies, right?
- 39:48Does your administration know that,
- 39:50and they understand that,
- 39:51and they're bought into good enough?
- 39:52The people involved do know that,
- 39:54and it's a student production.
- 39:55They're going to do their thing, right?
- 39:58They're not getting Lucasfilm's sound
- 40:02stages here.
- 40:03It's a thirty-by-thirty room,
- 40:04for God's sake.
- 40:05So you can only do so much,
- 40:07and they have...
- 40:08realistic expectations but can they make a
- 40:11a one desk news program yes could you
- 40:15make a small um
- 40:20podcast station, right?
- 40:22Where you put it on a sofa and
- 40:23there's some chairs and you light it
- 40:24correctly and they can make small
- 40:26productions that look better than what
- 40:29they had yesterday.
- 40:30And now the question is,
- 40:33can you fulfill it?
- 40:36So we had to step into that.
- 40:37Like virtual studio is the next stage.
- 40:39That's tomorrow.
- 40:40That's later.
- 40:41But some of the big questions here were,
- 40:44Can you fill this?
- 40:45Like,
- 40:45are you going to utilize this space
- 40:47seventy, eighty percent of the time?
- 40:48Like, well, probably not with programming,
- 40:50probably not with academic programming.
- 40:53All right.
- 40:53So what if you open this up and
- 40:55you said, OK, well,
- 40:56how about other sources?
- 40:58Now your students have practicums.
- 41:01Have these things.
- 41:03And they're going to break stuff.
- 41:05And it's going to be just good enough.
- 41:07And these are the clients that won't hire
- 41:09a real production company or a real studio
- 41:11space because it's insanely expensive.
- 41:15It's insanely expensive.
- 41:17So it's good enough.
- 41:19So this is a broadcast studio that's,
- 41:20quote, good enough to put on a show,
- 41:24to put on a reel,
- 41:25to put on a resume.
- 41:27And we can move forward and they'll get
- 41:29their real world training some other day.
- 41:31And like Mark's big visualization space,
- 41:35it's different.
- 41:36Totally different.
- 41:36There's lots of,
- 41:38but you have that from the other side,
- 41:39you have donors throwing money at this and
- 41:41that's different.
- 41:42But even like the studio today versus the
- 41:44studio we went to school in and how
- 41:47you're using those things,
- 41:49it's different now, right?
- 41:50It's one thing to go and learn how
- 41:52to operate a camera and be hands-on.
- 41:55that's a different part of the curriculum
- 41:56that doesn't necessarily have to be this
- 41:58space right is that you can have cameras
- 42:01and you can do television camera but go
- 42:03look at modern television studios today
- 42:05remote cameras things are are being driven
- 42:07to be like so it's not about like
- 42:09there's motion yeah exactly so you it's
- 42:11not that old world philosophical approach
- 42:14you have more automation you have more
- 42:16remote connections and so
- 42:20you know,
- 42:20understand that it can be done more cost
- 42:23effectively,
- 42:23but you do need to understand what what
- 42:24is that success criteria, right?
- 42:26Is that is it make sure that the
- 42:28class can come in here and operate all
- 42:31those things and be hands on with all
- 42:32this stuff?
- 42:32It's like, well, no,
- 42:34maybe that's not what this venue is for.
- 42:35If you if you need that,
- 42:36go do that in the lab.
- 42:38This is where we're actually doing these
- 42:39shows.
- 42:39And we're using this automated equipment,
- 42:40we're going to do that.
- 42:41And this is about that product, right?
- 42:42And so it's not about necessarily building
- 42:44it and breaking it down and doing all
- 42:45this other stuff.
- 42:46That's a different piece of your
- 42:47curriculum.
- 42:48So it's the right tool for the right
- 42:51job, Justin.
- 42:51You say it all the time in that.
- 42:54are we doing the right thing in these
- 42:56spaces?
- 42:56We shouldn't be trying to do everything
- 42:58under the sun and do the things that
- 42:59they can do successfully most often.
- 43:01I mean, I don't disagree with that.
- 43:02And I think that's the key is that
- 43:03setting expectations with your clients who
- 43:05usually come up with these ideas are
- 43:07perhaps your bosses or your boss's boss.
- 43:10And you have to set like, no,
- 43:11we can't make this magic with a Pac-Man
- 43:14button in thirty seconds.
- 43:15That's not going to happen.
- 43:16But we can do this in thirty seconds
- 43:20to sixty seconds.
- 43:21Is that good enough?
- 43:22And they say, no,
- 43:23you go down that decision tree and just
- 43:25make it happen.
- 43:26And I'm starting to have a lot more
- 43:27conversations with these folks that are
- 43:30doing these kinds of things,
- 43:30even AR VR labs, even the gaming spaces,
- 43:34right?
- 43:35Like how can you make this a revenue
- 43:37generation?
- 43:37Because it was cool yesterday,
- 43:40but you have to keep that stuff up.
- 43:42Like you have to have upkeep,
- 43:44you have to have maintenance and you only
- 43:45got one time funding.
- 43:47So on the gaming stations, right?
- 43:50Can you have little high school
- 43:53tournaments there?
- 43:54Can you rent it out to the local
- 43:56public leagues?
- 43:57Can you do these things where now you're
- 44:00turning revenue with some of this,
- 44:04the ARVR?
- 44:05We have these whole studios set up that's
- 44:07only used like twenty percent of the time.
- 44:09Well,
- 44:09there's all kinds of businesses out there.
- 44:12Can they come in and start using these
- 44:13for a fee?
- 44:15Like I'm starting out more of these
- 44:16conversations that I've never had before.
- 44:18Right.
- 44:19Yeah.
- 44:19I mean, we're doing the same thing.
- 44:21Going to e-sports arena route.
- 44:22Like ours is the headquarters for the NC
- 44:27e-sports academic league.
- 44:29And so it's,
- 44:31It's a four-year-old system now that needs
- 44:33to be updated.
- 44:35But like you were saying,
- 44:37there is revenue there.
- 44:38There's also the pipeline for students.
- 44:40And so there are other avenues for these
- 44:43type of spaces outside of just...
- 44:47the academic side and the revenue
- 44:49generation side like if it is a pipeline
- 44:51to the community into the general
- 44:53population now that there are less
- 44:55students being produced those type of
- 44:58things matter i think the athletics model
- 45:00the athletics model is starting to bleed
- 45:03into the academics world right it is like
- 45:07how are you getting the interest in these
- 45:09things you know you got to
- 45:11build these things on the edge to what
- 45:13is your differentiator?
- 45:15What are you doing that's different at
- 45:17your university that I can't go get from
- 45:19XYZ down the road?
- 45:20And why should I come here?
- 45:22And so I do want to chime in
- 45:24on one thing you said that VR thing
- 45:26in this grand journey that I'm embarking
- 45:28on in this facility that I'm building.
- 45:31VR was one of those pieces that we
- 45:33always held in there as this use case.
- 45:35And it was probably the one that we
- 45:36had the least amount of confidence in.
- 45:38And we're like,
- 45:39we just don't have any champions that are
- 45:41going to come in here and have content
- 45:43for this.
- 45:44And so I had a placeholder for it.
- 45:45It's in the design, it's there.
- 45:47And then they're actually starting to hire
- 45:50the directors within the facilities.
- 45:53And
- 45:55last week I meet with him in the
- 45:57very first thing he said, he's like,
- 45:58I want,
- 45:58I need to know more about what we're
- 45:59doing for the VR pipeline.
- 46:01Cause I have,
- 46:01I'm not gonna name the company,
- 46:03but I have direct ties to this medical
- 46:05research fund and they're extremely
- 46:07interested in our VR capability.
- 46:09And they,
- 46:10it's part of their six billion dollar
- 46:13bringing a drug to market.
- 46:15And they're very,
- 46:15very interested in motion capture in the
- 46:17VR aspect of this research of what it
- 46:20is that their drugs are doing for these
- 46:21different, these kinesthetic outcomes.
- 46:23And I was like, shh,
- 46:26That was the piece I was least prepared
- 46:28to actually get into, and here we are.
- 46:30It is the number one revenue thing,
- 46:31and it's going to part the sea.
- 46:34When you start talking in terms of
- 46:36billions...
- 46:38It changes the whole dynamic.
- 46:40And into that research endeavor and these
- 46:42public-private partnerships,
- 46:43like I mentioned,
- 46:44it's a whole different game.
- 46:45So I was,
- 46:46just as everybody on this call,
- 46:48the most skeptical of the VR piece.
- 46:49And then lo and behold,
- 46:50it's the very first use case for this
- 46:52facility that we're building.
- 46:53It measured in billions.
- 46:55You can find IAM for billions.
- 46:56It's wild.
- 46:56It's all based on meta.
- 47:01No, it's not.
- 47:03But I mean,
- 47:03there are use cases in that in the
- 47:05pure research domain.
- 47:06It's different when you get into,
- 47:07you know,
- 47:09class needing to go hang out in Spain
- 47:11together versus, you know, I have,
- 47:12I'm gonna look at these molecules and
- 47:14understand how,
- 47:15when we give these to people,
- 47:16what happens in their, their motion.
- 47:18So it's just,
- 47:18it's a different game altogether.
- 47:22Chris, tell us about goggles.
- 47:24Yes.
- 47:26Wave of the future here.
- 47:28Question for y'all on those of you who
- 47:30have built these spaces or are going
- 47:31through this process and ones where they
- 47:34have local stat or whatever it is.
- 47:36Usually these take longer than a typical
- 47:38project, than a typical classroom,
- 47:40conference room, whatever.
- 47:41These are dedicated spaces are
- 47:43specialized.
- 47:43This is a year, two,
- 47:45three year long project sort of thing.
- 47:47Oftentimes you find by the time you get
- 47:49done and you're at day zero, day one,
- 47:51ready to launch these things,
- 47:53the use case has either changed or the
- 47:57the project champion is no longer there.
- 47:59The the stakeholders are now different and
- 48:02you you find a dramatically different use
- 48:05case that had never been conceived of.
- 48:08And this both this frustration on
- 48:11Well, no,
- 48:11it wasn't ever designed to do that.
- 48:13That's not how we built that,
- 48:14not how we conceived it,
- 48:15not how we kind of constructed this whole
- 48:18thing to do what was described here in
- 48:20the scope of work.
- 48:22And also this professional challenge of I
- 48:24could probably sort of make that happen or
- 48:26whatever.
- 48:26So I'm curious,
- 48:27have you run into that scenario?
- 48:28Because that was my experience a few years
- 48:30ago,
- 48:30and it was incredibly frustrating to see.
- 48:33After building this incredibly complex and
- 48:36very capable space,
- 48:38it wasn't being used to its fruition.
- 48:42They were using it to that ten percent
- 48:43level, and they were happy with that.
- 48:44I'm like, well,
- 48:45then all you needed was just a green
- 48:47painted wall.
- 48:48Why did we waste that money?
- 48:50So, I mean, for us,
- 48:51this endeavor was completely different.
- 48:53Now,
- 48:53it's part of a new building altogether.
- 48:55It did not exist previously.
- 48:57Which is even worse because now it's tied
- 48:58to capital construction.
- 48:59Well, that's the point I want to make.
- 49:01We actually pulled it out of the
- 49:02construction project.
- 49:03It was a separate project that it was
- 49:05going to be owner furnished,
- 49:06owner installed,
- 49:07and the construction project was
- 49:08completely not related to the space.
- 49:12They were delivering a box.
- 49:14Yeah.
- 49:14And we had a whole separate project
- 49:17because what we learned from this building
- 49:18we're in right now,
- 49:19when you're trying to do an innovative
- 49:21space,
- 49:21it's very hard to project what innovation
- 49:23looks like two years in advance.
- 49:24Yes.
- 49:26Three, four, five years.
- 49:27That's what I'm saying.
- 49:28These projects are on boats from overseas
- 49:31two years ago, right?
- 49:31And they're on their way here.
- 49:32They're just getting bolted together.
- 49:33So...
- 49:34from learning how this that affected us in
- 49:36other projects we said we're not gonna do
- 49:38that again this is too important that we
- 49:40we know up until the eleventh hour which
- 49:42is gonna go against every single project
- 49:45management best practice known we're gonna
- 49:47change this thing we're gonna change this
- 49:49up until the day we do grand opening
- 49:51it's gonna change and tinker because
- 49:53that's what everybody told us who had
- 49:55these spaces that you're going to
- 49:56continuously change them so don't seek
- 49:59them as finished spaces
- 50:02and that's that's good feedback good
- 50:03planning because it's leaving that
- 50:04flexibility there and even the space i'm
- 50:06talking about that i built several years
- 50:08ago yeah you could change what it would
- 50:10it's at the end of the day it
- 50:11was several rectangular rooms that were
- 50:13all interconnected with a control room
- 50:15between all the rest so you could do
- 50:16all sorts of things in there
- 50:18But what was delivered on day one was
- 50:20not what they tried to use on day
- 50:22two sort of thing.
- 50:23And it was incredibly frustrating.
- 50:24Yeah, I think to echo Mark's comment,
- 50:27like I'm in the middle of one of
- 50:29these right now.
- 50:29And every time I have a conversation with
- 50:33the client, the room changes a little bit.
- 50:36And so even though the building is in
- 50:37the construction phase, like...
- 50:39the deliverable for this space in
- 50:42particular the rest of the building it's
- 50:43going to be built and finished and this
- 50:46part is continually changing yeah like
- 50:49that's it's actually in a lot of ways
- 50:52refreshing to have a project that way
- 50:53that's not this the same old okay here
- 50:55we go or and go through it it's
- 50:58the challenge is fun
- 50:59in that iterative process that is
- 51:01different than the normal construction
- 51:02process.
- 51:03But it is nerve-wracking trying to do
- 51:06something that's yet to be invented.
- 51:08Yeah, the one I'm talking about here,
- 51:09it was a blast for a year and
- 51:10a half.
- 51:10This was my life.
- 51:12It consumed every aspect of everything I
- 51:13was doing, forty hours a week.
- 51:15And it was great, but...
- 51:17You're like, here you go.
- 51:17It's exactly what we talked about.
- 51:19All the renders, all the layouts,
- 51:20everything was, here you go, done, boom.
- 51:22That's not what you wanted at all.
- 51:23We're not doing that.
- 51:24What are we talking about?
- 51:24We just want to show this PowerPoint.
- 51:26By the way, Mark,
- 51:28I would suggest you guys,
- 51:29when you open your brand new visualization
- 51:31space,
- 51:31the day one test for three PowerPoints.
- 51:34Well, it's agentically driven, sir.
- 51:36So whatever that bot is going to deliver
- 51:38for us when we walk in and talk
- 51:40to it is what we're going to have.
- 51:40Can you put that guardrail in the comment?
- 51:42I can't remember what that's called,
- 51:43but the comments on every prompt it tells
- 51:45generator four three.
- 51:46Your first line of your personality is
- 51:50everything you do
- 51:52is four three aspect ratio yes that's it
- 51:54it's in there skill four three regardless
- 51:56of what content is generated squash it or
- 51:59stretch it to fit a four three aspect
- 52:01ratio those that are coming in i will
- 52:04walk you through what we're doing you'll
- 52:05get you'll see some behind the scenes on
- 52:07this and some of our presentation we're
- 52:08going to give to the agents i'll show
- 52:09you some under the hood of what we're
- 52:10doing for this specific space for the
- 52:12agent tech workflows so oh and by the
- 52:14way you only have one ear yes it's
- 52:17fine everything's mono the world is mono
- 52:20man
- 52:22So they're not the easiest to build.
- 52:25They may not be the easiest to maintain.
- 52:27They're not cheap.
- 52:29They're not cheap.
- 52:30They're certainly not fast,
- 52:33but they can lead to revenue.
- 52:36Like as Joe said,
- 52:37is it the opportunity for us to think
- 52:40more business-like around the things we're
- 52:41doing?
- 52:42And it can be a challenge because we
- 52:43may not be configured that way as an
- 52:45organization.
- 52:45That's been a lot of our conversation.
- 52:47How do we make services around this?
- 52:49This is just such a murky area.
- 52:52Welcome those new challenges because I
- 52:54think it is a brave new world that
- 52:56I think because of the pressures we're
- 52:58going to be seeing,
- 52:59we're going to be asked to do more
- 53:01of this type of work.
- 53:02All you need is just a credit card
- 53:04swipe right outside the door.
- 53:06You swipe your card to get in.
- 53:09And a spring card so that when the
- 53:10time runs out, broader turns on.
- 53:13And connect for a PayPal.
- 53:15I want to add the one thing to
- 53:17that is that use these as an opportunity
- 53:19to build those relationships with some of
- 53:21these places.
- 53:22Because sometimes we're just seen as a
- 53:23service provider, a gadget provider,
- 53:26and not as a solutions.
- 53:29And we have good ideas.
- 53:30We have bring in extra things.
- 53:31We have let's spin up particular parts of
- 53:35your curriculum that might help.
- 53:37Maybe we can help with that.
- 53:38And...
- 53:40Also,
- 53:40those students that are in those programs
- 53:43make really good student workers.
- 53:46So if you have that partnership,
- 53:48it's a great way to get some free
- 53:49labor.
- 53:50I just find sometimes it breaks down that
- 53:54idea.
- 53:54I don't pay my students.
- 53:55I don't know about you.
- 53:56I don't pay them enough, Doug.
- 53:58Experiential employment opportunities.
- 54:00I find it breaks down those barriers.
- 54:03You're not just a provider of things.
- 54:04You're actually a partner in their
- 54:06success.
- 54:06And Jim,
- 54:07that's a good point because in order to
- 54:09deliver a specialized space,
- 54:11especially a project like this
- 54:12successfully,
- 54:12it is a long-term partnership.
- 54:14with the stakeholders,
- 54:15with the project champion to build that
- 54:17relationship and to deliver what is needed
- 54:19at the end.
- 54:19And sometimes they're going to come to you
- 54:21as a resource.
- 54:22They kind of have a vague notion or
- 54:23they've seen other things at other schools
- 54:24or other institutions.
- 54:25And they're like, I kind of want this,
- 54:27but a little different.
- 54:28And we're going to do this.
- 54:29And it's up to you to put all
- 54:30those pieces together and figure it out
- 54:31and fill in the blanks.
- 54:32And yet sometimes that champion uses that
- 54:35project to get another job somewhere else.
- 54:36Yes, they do.
- 54:37Immediately.
- 54:38Within the first week.
- 54:39Yeah.
- 54:40And then we're stuck here now.
- 54:43They don't take us with them.
- 54:44You're stuck with the puppy and they moved
- 54:46on.
- 54:46They say, we've got six billion dollars,
- 54:48but I'm stuck here.
- 54:50Hmm.
- 54:51All right,
- 54:52any other last thoughts on specialized
- 54:55virtualization production sort of spaces?
- 54:57And no,
- 54:58we beat this one on the ground.
- 54:59All right, we're gonna take a quick break,
- 55:00we're gonna come back.
- 55:01We got a listener email, listener,
- 55:03a letter from a listener wants to know
- 55:05why the heck are we talking about the
- 55:06things we're talking about?
- 55:07How many F-bombs can we get?
- 55:10Well, he wants some sage advice.
- 55:12So let's see what we can come up
- 55:13with.
- 55:13But first,
- 55:15let's relax for twenty four seconds.
- 55:20And now,
- 55:21Quiet Contemplations by Miles Dante.
- 55:24Maybe instead of labeling cables,
- 55:27we should label people.
- 55:28Like, this person will unplug the camera,
- 55:32or this person believes Bluetooth is
- 55:34infrastructure.
- 55:36Then when something breaks,
- 55:37troubleshooting would be a lot faster,
- 55:40and probably more legally complicated.
- 55:46All right,
- 55:46so we got a letter a couple of
- 55:47weeks ago, or it was last week.
- 55:49It comes from a friend of the show,
- 55:51and I'll just say from Sam.
- 55:52I did not ask if we're okay to
- 55:55name and shame him on the air here.
- 55:56But Sam asks, hey,
- 55:57we've been adding some HyFlex classrooms
- 56:00to our inventory,
- 56:01and so far we've standardized on dual
- 56:03Sennheiser Team Connect ceiling mics.
- 56:05We just got a demo pack of the
- 56:07catch box systems with DSP.
- 56:08Our initial testing of the catch box
- 56:10system,
- 56:10whether used as a regular handheld or a
- 56:12lav in the box, has been very positive.
- 56:15I have found that the Team Connect does
- 56:17fine when one person is talking,
- 56:20but things get pretty choppy when you have
- 56:21more than one voice at a time,
- 56:23which can happen during discussion type
- 56:25activities.
- 56:26We have a small maximum of thirty six
- 56:28seats class sizes and mostly use Teams for
- 56:30video conferencing,
- 56:31although still a bit of Zoom.
- 56:32What's your experience with this type of
- 56:34application?
- 56:35Obviously, from a cost perspective,
- 56:36there's a lot of appeal to a catch
- 56:37box.
- 56:40So that's question one.
- 56:41He had two other questions here.
- 56:42But question one is,
- 56:43do we like ceiling mics for our HyFlex
- 56:47hybrid spaces?
- 56:48Do we like dedicated mics,
- 56:50like say a catch box,
- 56:50they may hand it around to students?
- 56:52And by catch box, he's talking about the,
- 56:54I can't remember the name of it now.
- 56:55The plus catch box or the plus.
- 56:57The plus is the hub,
- 56:59but it's the clip-on lav and the handheld
- 57:02adapter kit for it.
- 57:03Yeah.
- 57:04Not the traditional catch box,
- 57:06which also works very well,
- 57:07but they have a new line out there.
- 57:10So what do you guys think about that?
- 57:11Do we like mics that can be worn
- 57:12and handed around, mics on the ceilings?
- 57:14I'm doing that exact same thing right now.
- 57:17I wondered if, like,
- 57:19did he overcomplicate?
- 57:21Or she,
- 57:21I don't know who this person is,
- 57:22but is it overcomplicated?
- 57:24The things that stood out was like,
- 57:26we have a couple of Team Connect ceiling
- 57:28mics.
- 57:28How big is your room?
- 57:29In a thirty-five seat room.
- 57:31I think the maximum of thirty six seats
- 57:33to me,
- 57:33that does seem like do you need that
- 57:35many?
- 57:35I will also say at the outset and
- 57:36I've confirmed this with engineers at
- 57:38Sennheiser in particular,
- 57:39I don't know much.
- 57:39I can't speak to the sure ones.
- 57:41I can't speak to Yamaha.
- 57:42I can't speak to, you know,
- 57:45the the clear ones.
- 57:48Uh, Sennheiser under measures, they, they,
- 57:51they, they,
- 57:52they're very conservative on their
- 57:53estimates.
- 57:54So they'll say, you know,
- 57:55generally it's what they,
- 57:55I think they say,
- 57:56ten meter kind of diameter.
- 57:58It'll do way more than that.
- 58:00I will also say,
- 58:01and if you haven't looked at this, yes,
- 58:02and yet,
- 58:02and this is also something acknowledged by
- 58:04Sennheiser in particular,
- 58:05they make kind of the baby brother,
- 58:06the TCC medium.
- 58:09dramatically outperforms its big brother
- 58:12and has a far bigger pickup range.
- 58:15So if you haven't looked at that,
- 58:16you're getting way over,
- 58:17you're closer to like forty feet on these
- 58:19things, like twelve, thirteen meters.
- 58:21That said,
- 58:22two of those in a space that size,
- 58:24you could be dealing with a lot of
- 58:25internal fear.
- 58:26It's rare I use two ceiling mics.
- 58:27Yeah.
- 58:27Well,
- 58:28they would be fighting each other and
- 58:30maybe that's part of his problem some of
- 58:32the the the nodes set up is gets
- 58:34a little messy overlap over a complicated
- 58:37or is it and in that case when
- 58:38you're just using the one you can do
- 58:40the old trick of just use the auto
- 58:42the pre-auto mixed one you don't need to
- 58:44auto mix the auto mix you got to
- 58:47pay attention to more details there
- 58:49Yeah,
- 58:49when I when I first started using the
- 58:52beam tracking mics,
- 58:54like that was the first thing I ran
- 58:55into is I used the specifications for the
- 58:58sizes that they said.
- 59:00And just like he was saying,
- 59:02it got choppy audio all the time.
- 59:04I ended up like unbooking half of them
- 59:06and things cleared up.
- 59:07Especially if they're in the middle.
- 59:09Yeah.
- 59:10So now they're bouncing between the two
- 59:13lobes of the two different microphones.
- 59:15I ran into the same issue when I
- 59:17would put, well,
- 59:18I've got rooms with a dozen of the
- 59:21parlay mics from Biamp.
- 59:23At the very first,
- 59:24I ran into those issues all the time.
- 59:25It took me a long time to kind
- 59:27of get them dialed in,
- 59:28and every now and then,
- 59:29I still get it weird.
- 59:30Yeah.
- 59:31I also wonder if when they put the
- 59:33catch box system in with it.
- 59:35I think it's an either or.
- 59:37And if it's either or, that's great.
- 59:38But once you start adding that second
- 59:40thing in, and again,
- 59:41we get into the dynamics of what is
- 59:47being canceled out.
- 59:48In those rooms, you can reference that.
- 59:52and have those things dialed in.
- 59:53So it sounds amazing right there,
- 59:57like at your reference point.
- 59:58And then he, he threw those,
- 59:59those magic words,
- 1:00:00teams and zoom on top of this.
- 1:00:02Right.
- 1:00:03And historically they do not like chitter
- 1:00:08chatter, multi-conversation,
- 1:00:10any of that stuff.
- 1:00:11They, they just don't do well with it.
- 1:00:14And again,
- 1:00:15Like I said,
- 1:00:15I could listen to it as a reference
- 1:00:16and it's fine,
- 1:00:17but that at the encoding level and what
- 1:00:18that is doing through that application,
- 1:00:21it's always different.
- 1:00:22And that's a good point, Mark,
- 1:00:24something that I did to do some
- 1:00:27troubleshooting on one of those
- 1:00:28situations.
- 1:00:28Get a headphone amp that's Dante enabled.
- 1:00:31Listen to the mic directly.
- 1:00:32See where the problem is actually coming
- 1:00:34from.
- 1:00:34Because it could be a Zoom or Teams
- 1:00:36problem.
- 1:00:37Justin,
- 1:00:37I've done similar things where I'm not
- 1:00:39using Zoom or Teams,
- 1:00:40but just using something basic like
- 1:00:41Audacity and doing the same sort of
- 1:00:43recordings throughout the space.
- 1:00:45So you're getting,
- 1:00:46it sounds very different.
- 1:00:47It's unprocessed.
- 1:00:49There's no compression going on.
- 1:00:50It's just, it's much different,
- 1:00:51but you're getting like that raw audio off
- 1:00:53of it.
- 1:00:54I did also point out in an email
- 1:00:55back to him on this that I said,
- 1:00:56well, keep in mind,
- 1:00:57both Zoom and Teams do their own software
- 1:01:00processing.
- 1:01:01And if you don't have a dedicated DSP
- 1:01:04in the room,
- 1:01:04which I believe he does not,
- 1:01:06then the the microphone itself does some
- 1:01:08processing but you could potentially have
- 1:01:10those conflicting each other so you can go
- 1:01:13in now zoom to be fair gives you
- 1:01:15a lot of granular audio options teams
- 1:01:18basically just says like what's it says
- 1:01:20like uh noise reduction or something
- 1:01:22there's like one button on or off
- 1:01:23basically yeah it's basically sock or more
- 1:01:26sock yeah it's not great
- 1:01:28so you can turn that off and try
- 1:01:29the exact same test with multiple people
- 1:01:31talking to see if you're getting that that
- 1:01:32cut out because it's probably a
- 1:01:33combination of multiple microphones and
- 1:01:35multiple lobes trying to determine who am
- 1:01:37i going to be listening to and you're
- 1:01:38going to get a bit of drop every
- 1:01:39time it switches don't take headphone amp
- 1:01:41and that's a great way to listen to
- 1:01:42it so have someone else there checking
- 1:01:44that playing the far side or something
- 1:01:46Oh,
- 1:01:47you could do it by yourself with a
- 1:01:48Dante.
- 1:01:50That's the reason why I did it.
- 1:01:51But the software can also conflict with
- 1:01:53that,
- 1:01:53so it may work in one piece of
- 1:01:54software and not another,
- 1:01:55which means it's not your hardware.
- 1:01:57So it's going to require a little bit
- 1:01:58of troubleshooting.
- 1:01:59But I like, Jamie, you said it best,
- 1:02:01start removing stuff from the room first
- 1:02:04and dramatically simplify or set up a test
- 1:02:07space or something that's roughly the same
- 1:02:09size.
- 1:02:09I think individually, each thing,
- 1:02:11like in this particular case,
- 1:02:13thirty-six seats,
- 1:02:15I think a single microphone,
- 1:02:17you're probably going to be fine.
- 1:02:18I also really like that catch box plus
- 1:02:20system with its own clip in the stick.
- 1:02:24I couldn't remember.
- 1:02:24Yeah.
- 1:02:25Clip in the stick.
- 1:02:26I like that system and I like it
- 1:02:27that it comes.
- 1:02:28You can also get the throw around box
- 1:02:30that goes with it.
- 1:02:31It brings a different feel.
- 1:02:33Some instructors hate that.
- 1:02:34Some like it.
- 1:02:35I like both of them individually.
- 1:02:36When you start trying to cram them
- 1:02:37together, it gets a little,
- 1:02:39it's actually not that bad when you pair
- 1:02:41a ceiling mic with a hub because then
- 1:02:47you can manage it all in this i'm
- 1:02:48just saying that there's that extra step
- 1:02:50of things you got to think about yeah
- 1:02:52the ducking and yeah be careful if you're
- 1:02:54doing any speech lift in there though
- 1:02:56because that that throws the whole thing
- 1:02:58off speech lift from the cans yes
- 1:03:03All right.
- 1:03:04One more thing on that before we move
- 1:03:05on.
- 1:03:06So, Justin,
- 1:03:07because you mentioned it a hundred times,
- 1:03:09which of the Dante headphone amps are you
- 1:03:11using?
- 1:03:11Just name drop it right now.
- 1:03:12It was the RDO one.
- 1:03:14Okay, thanks.
- 1:03:14It works well.
- 1:03:16Because everybody out there is going to be
- 1:03:17like, what's he talking about?
- 1:03:18Let's find out which one is it.
- 1:03:19I use it as my tool.
- 1:03:21I've got it back there on my shelf.
- 1:03:22I just have to leave.
- 1:03:23well use the internet in front of you
- 1:03:25sir dude oh if you're buying it get
- 1:03:28the one with the uh dual ports on
- 1:03:31the front not the one with this why
- 1:03:32don't you go find a part number would
- 1:03:34go a long way here in this conversation
- 1:03:36sir that means i got a google god
- 1:03:38bless give me something don't you have you
- 1:03:40have a boss
- 1:03:43I'm doing a show.
- 1:03:45Reach in your pocket and ask Pocket
- 1:03:47Justin.
- 1:03:48Stroke the magic lamp and see what comes
- 1:03:50out.
- 1:03:51All right.
- 1:03:51Yeah.
- 1:03:51All right.
- 1:03:52Hold on.
- 1:03:52Give me a minute.
- 1:03:55Two other comments here while Justin looks
- 1:03:56up that part number.
- 1:03:57He said, by the way,
- 1:03:58the discussion with the cybersecurity
- 1:03:59nonprofit guys was really excellent.
- 1:04:01We agree.
- 1:04:02We got a lot of good feedback on
- 1:04:03that one.
- 1:04:03AV Trust got a lot of good feedback
- 1:04:05from their appearance here.
- 1:04:07So we're going to follow up with them
- 1:04:08at Infocom and probably do another
- 1:04:11specifically AV kind of
- 1:04:13cybersecurity-related show later in the
- 1:04:15year with some further updates.
- 1:04:17All right, Justin,
- 1:04:17what do you got for us?
- 1:04:18All right, you ready?
- 1:04:19Yes.
- 1:04:20R-D-L space A-V as in audio-video dash
- 1:04:28N-H-one.
- 1:04:31Very dramatic.
- 1:04:32But you said it had two ports.
- 1:04:34Is there an N-H-two?
- 1:04:35The two port.
- 1:04:38It says...
- 1:04:40That was really supposed to be a simple
- 1:04:42question.
- 1:04:43Moving on.
- 1:04:44One last comment in our voluminous email
- 1:04:50here, our listener email.
- 1:04:53Oops, I scrolled right past it.
- 1:04:54He said,
- 1:04:56And this is especially pressing given
- 1:04:58today's conversation.
- 1:04:59I know some of you love this whole
- 1:05:00push to the cloud and single pane of
- 1:05:02glass thing, but man,
- 1:05:03that feels like a house of cards with
- 1:05:06a lot of potential vulnerability.
- 1:05:07Sometimes I wonder,
- 1:05:09people have been learning pretty darn
- 1:05:10successfully for thousands of years before
- 1:05:12we outsource our brains to technology.
- 1:05:14So you're not wrong.
- 1:05:16And a lot of these big,
- 1:05:18and I mean big cloud monitoring services
- 1:05:21just say,
- 1:05:22give us your admin passwords to all your
- 1:05:24stuff.
- 1:05:25So first of all,
- 1:05:25expose all your stuff to the outer
- 1:05:27internet and then give us your passwords.
- 1:05:28I'm on the other side of this whole
- 1:05:30thing because I just built it myself and
- 1:05:32it runs out.
- 1:05:32That's right.
- 1:05:32That's the only way to do it.
- 1:05:34Build it yourself and leave it local.
- 1:05:35I think that's going to be the solution
- 1:05:37is using AI and vibe coding to build
- 1:05:40your own customized middleware for all of
- 1:05:42your stuff.
- 1:05:43Takes a weekend.
- 1:05:44Mark, your technology schizophrenia,
- 1:05:46we can't keep up.
- 1:05:47I know, I'm sorry.
- 1:05:48Seriously.
- 1:05:48I'm just trying to be honest.
- 1:05:50Bounce back and forth.
- 1:05:51Yes, I mean, I try to have one.
- 1:05:52Team Zoom.
- 1:05:54One of you others need to go cloud
- 1:05:55now.
- 1:05:55I'm coming back over.
- 1:05:56Team Zoom, NFTs, AI, don't AI, cloud,
- 1:06:00on-prem, tokens.
- 1:06:01Google Meet.
- 1:06:03I've never been that crazy.
- 1:06:05That headphone amp you mentioned has one
- 1:06:07port, so what's the two port?
- 1:06:08No, it's the two port.
- 1:06:09It's the damn two port option.
- 1:06:11It's right there.
- 1:06:11No, you gave us the one port.
- 1:06:13That's why I was questioning it.
- 1:06:15photos wrong then what's the audio you're
- 1:06:18not just at the H one we got
- 1:06:21there in H two good sure okay I'll
- 1:06:25put it in the show notes getting a
- 1:06:28dedicated headphone amplifier you can use
- 1:06:31basically as a dedicated monitor for audio
- 1:06:34you said it'd be very useful no the
- 1:06:37two the two is something different
- 1:06:41That's an in and an out.
- 1:06:42Hit the button, Chris.
- 1:06:44You want a headphone?
- 1:06:46Get a headphone amp that's Dante Peewee.
- 1:06:48Don't matter the manufacturer, they work.
- 1:06:50Set up your computer.
- 1:06:52Does a Dante sound good?
- 1:06:53Yeah, exactly.
- 1:06:54Many options, but do some monitoring.
- 1:06:56All right.
- 1:06:57Back next week with more of this type
- 1:06:59of nonsense.
- 1:07:00See ya.
- 1:07:07Well,
- 1:07:08we've managed to ruin yet another episode
- 1:07:10of AV Super Friends Off the Rails.
- 1:07:12You can contact us with questions,
- 1:07:13topic ideas,
- 1:07:14or general complaints at mailbag at
- 1:07:16avsuperfriends.com.
- 1:07:18If you complain loud enough,
- 1:07:19we might just invite you on the show.
- 1:07:24Nice work, everyone.
- 1:07:26Sharp broadcast.
- 1:07:26Really good.
- 1:07:27Everyone on the floor as well.
- 1:07:29Really a lot of hustle.
- 1:07:30I liked it.
- 1:07:31The opinions expressed by the AV
- 1:07:33Superfriends are solely those of the
- 1:07:34individuals and do not represent their
- 1:07:36respective institutions, organizations,
- 1:07:38companies, or clients.