Latest / Chatter that Matters / Canada - Reclaim the Canadian Dream
Transcript
- 0:04Welcome to the special edition of Chatter That Matters. What I have in store for
- 0:08you are 3 of the smartest Canadians that I know, Arlene
- 0:11Dickinson, Jon Love, and Dany Asap. I had the
- 0:15honor to interview them in front of an audience at Excellence Canada's
- 0:1840th anniversary. And to kick off the morning, I
- 0:22delivered a short keynote. Paraphrase it, I talked about my
- 0:26pride being a Canadian. And then I took the audience back to
- 0:301967 when I was a young boy, and I got to
- 0:33celebrate Canada's 100th birthday. And what a year. He had
- 0:37a caravan, a centennial train, and, of course, Expo
- 0:4067 in my hometown of Montreal. What an engineering feat.
- 0:45Built 3 man made islands, tumbled into the Saint Lawrence to extend our subway
- 0:48or what we called the metro. We built a monorail. Every country
- 0:52put their best foot forward, but nothing compared to Canada and the
- 0:56provinces. We demonstrated. Canada stood for
- 1:00and why we matter. And I wondered if it was just my rose
- 1:03colored glasses, that moment in time, or did
- 1:07Canada really stand for something? Well, for 2 years, we've been flying this
- 1:11new flag called the Maplelet. Pearson was our prime minister.
- 1:14We also had one of the highest per capita incomes. We had a growing
- 1:18middle class. The Canadian dream was within arms reach of desire.
- 1:23Immigrants that would come to this country could do whatever they wanted to do because
- 1:26of circumstances existed. Infrastructure, we built a
- 1:30TransCanada highway in 12 years, the Saint Lawrence Seaway in 5 years,
- 1:34and our social conscious, we said to the world that are on
- 1:38watch. We could bring universal health care and the Canadian pension
- 1:41plan unemployment insurance to our people. We set
- 1:45up such conditions for success that we continue to roar as a
- 1:49country. Blackberry, Nortel, Couche Tard, Cirque du Soleil, and
- 1:53so many other major innovations in health care, sciences, and
- 1:56technology. We had some of the best universities in the world, and we
- 2:00were a country known as peacekeepers where tolerance
- 2:04was something the world admired and respected. But then I asked
- 2:08what happened. Food banks overrun, tents have become affordable housing,
- 2:11unemployment's on the rise, capital's fleeing the country, and
- 2:15so is our talent. We've buried future generations in so much
- 2:19debt. It's like they'll be waiting through cement their entire life.
- 2:23Well, I wanna change that. I want the Canada that has a
- 2:26prosperity agenda back. I want the country that was known as peacekeepers,
- 2:30as tolerant, as a place to be, as a place to invent, as a place
- 2:34to access your dreams. Do we have what it
- 2:38takes to reclaim the Canada we all want and deserve?
- 2:42Well, now I turn the spotlight on Arlene Dickinson, Jon Love,
- 2:45and Dania South to hear what they have to say about making
- 2:49Canada the true north strong and free.
- 2:55Hi. It's Tony Chapman. Thank you for listening to Chatter That Matters presented by
- 2:59RBC. If you can, please subscribe to the podcast. And
- 3:02ratings and reviews, well, they're always welcome and they're always appreciated.
- 3:08So Arlene, I brought you up first. I'll begin with you. Age 30,
- 3:114 kids, divorced, no education, no
- 3:15prospects. Take us back to what you did then and how the
- 3:18conditions in Canada allowed you to do what
- 3:22you needed to do. I was reminiscing, and I was singing
- 3:26Canada. Do you remember that? Yeah. When they used to talk about the
- 3:30train coming through, you remember that? I remember that. And I was thinking
- 3:34about how romantic it sounded and how great it sounded.
- 3:37And the challenge that we have sometimes is that it's easy to say we wanna
- 3:41go back to the way we were. Things were were good
- 3:45back then and when we rethink them. But there was also lots of challenges
- 3:48back then. 1988, the year that I got divorced. So
- 3:52I'm a newly divorced, mom of 4, without
- 3:56a high school with a high school education but no other education and no skills
- 4:00or training, trying to figure out how to make a living, in Alberta.
- 4:05A very oil and gas energy focused province where,
- 4:09there was a lot of male leaders but not a lot of female as in
- 4:13business. It was also 1988, interest rates were about
- 4:1610 3 quarters percent. So when we think about how bad they are
- 4:20now, they went from 1988 to about 10 3 quarters percent to
- 4:24about 13 and a half percent in the next couple of years. And our mortgage
- 4:28was up to 18%. You know, I was divorced and had no kind
- 4:31of prospects. There was the everyone was afraid that Russia was gonna
- 4:35start a war tomorrow and World War 3 was about to break out. There was
- 4:38a lot of fear in the country and a lot of worry. We were overtaxed
- 4:42and under populated. We introduced our very first climate,
- 4:46targets in 1988 as a country. There was a lot happening
- 4:50in that period of time that was worrisome and and troubling
- 4:53and couldn't be as an entrepreneur things to stop you from saying I don't wanna
- 4:57do this. But for me, because I wanted to build
- 5:01something and because I couldn't get a job anywhere And so I decided
- 5:04that I would, you know, start a communication company, which is not really something
- 5:08that the country needed more of, but I decided that there could be a different
- 5:11way to do it. And so it was troubling times in many respects and there's
- 5:15a lot of parallels to today. Inflation, you know, still worried about what's
- 5:19going on with world geopolitics, still worried about what's going on with our
- 5:22climate, still concerned about all those things. But
- 5:26I think what's the say from then and now is this hope
- 5:30that Tony talks about, this dream, this ambition to be a stronger
- 5:33nation, to be better together. And I held on to that. I held on to
- 5:36this idea that, you know, I could help create a better future for this
- 5:40country. As an immigrant, I was taught to be very
- 5:44grateful for being here in Canada. But here I was
- 5:48in a country that I could do anything I wanted to do whenever I wanted
- 5:51to do it, and all I had to do was work hard. And if I
- 5:53worked hard, I could get rewarded. You know, Arlene, you do I mean, you just
- 5:57did a great Venture Park, conference. I talked a couple of people who were there.
- 6:00They said it was amazing. A lot of young people. Do you think that they
- 6:03have that same mentality that says if I work
- 6:07hard, I'm guaranteed success? No. And I think the question is, Tony,
- 6:11is that is that because the world is is it because he it's
- 6:15so much worse now? Or is it because we there's no regulations on social
- 6:18media and there's nobody tempering and, calming the
- 6:22waters in terms of what people can say and do on social media? It is
- 6:26such a negative impact. I mean, who wants to read every single time you pick
- 6:29up a social media platform how bad things are and how
- 6:33horrible? It affects all of us as it affects our mental health. It makes us
- 6:36believe it to be true. And I think it's it's not to say that that's
- 6:39all it is, but I do think that's a big piece of why you're seeing
- 6:42kind of the malaise you're seeing. It was hard to own a house in 1988
- 6:46too. It was it was different. I mean, he's so achievable.
- 6:49I do think that we're victims of algorithms
- 6:53and dopamine that comes from looking at social media to
- 6:57try and get, a hit of what's happening in the world. And we don't
- 7:01have enough critical thinking. And your point about educating and making sure
- 7:05people are trained on not just electoral, challenges
- 7:08and what's going on in poll political scenes, but in general, I think is the
- 7:12biggest issue in our country. So, Jon, we talked about earlier, we're just talking
- 7:16about that it's very difficult for a politician to live in the middle
- 7:19anymore given that attentions are oxygen and attentions
- 7:23on social media. You know, to live in the middle, you can't garner
- 7:27the kind of support you need and you just garner garner attacks. So that's that's
- 7:30why we're seeing divisions on both sides of the border. And while we
- 7:34look to the US, the current US situation with some horror, you know, it's not
- 7:38a lot different here. The fact is that, you know, over
- 7:42the last 20 years, globalization and technology
- 7:45has created an enormous amount of wealth. It's just has not
- 7:49been distributed very equally. So when you read a
- 7:53headline, like over the last 10 years, our GDP per capita
- 7:57hat is stagnant. Well, that's on average.
- 8:01You know, many of us actually have done fine, which
- 8:04means many of others have done much more poorly. And it's those
- 8:08people that are increasingly unhappy because they've been left out of the
- 8:12grand bargain of globalization and technology.
- 8:16And Dany, I'll go I mean, I your book is just wonderful and I love
- 8:19the your personal stories including, you know, the the Muslim kid in Edmonton who wanna
- 8:23be a professional hockey player. Talk to me about the conditions
- 8:27as you as a kid, you came out of, Alberta and you become
- 8:31one of the definitive minds when it comes to how
- 8:34Canada needs to play chess on the global trade scene. I reflect, you
- 8:38know, a lot on my childhood in Alberta as I look across
- 8:42the country today, and, you know, it's characterized by a
- 8:46few core things. First, there was an intense sense of
- 8:50belonging, optimism, and I grew up
- 8:53knowing there would always be opportunity. It could be
- 8:57channeled into opportunity, into what Arlene was talking about, which really reflect
- 9:01in the Canadian promise. The
- 9:04promise that if you do these things, it's
- 9:08most probable that you will be successful and be able to live the
- 9:11Canadian dream. So today, when I hear the conversations,
- 9:15the core thing that's missing, the beginning of it is
- 9:19belief. Nothing starts without
- 9:22believing in something because it softens all
- 9:26of the edges because it's true. There's always been if you
- 9:30look at it across history, it's not unique. There are
- 9:34people who hate. There are people who are
- 9:37unproductive. What that cannot be there's no generation that's different.
- 9:41Arlene said back then, interest rates were there's always something.
- 9:45And why is it that we were able to overcome? Because we
- 9:49believed, and that creates the consensus. And that's the Alberta that
- 9:53I grew up in where my great grandfather came from Lebanon in
- 9:57the 19 thirties. He came in the thirties because his cousin and his
- 10:01family came from some small village. In the early
- 10:051900, they became furriers. They became farmers. They did
- 10:08what was available. And from that, they built the first
- 10:12mosque in Edmonton, Alberta, Canada in 1938,
- 10:16it was finished. The real first little mosque on the prairie,
- 10:20that's the embrace of Canada. And that's the promise that
- 10:23we have to reclaim. Once we reclaim that and we draw
- 10:27upon our history, we've done it before,
- 10:31then the best chapter is yet to be written about this country. Jon,
- 10:34I use this analogy of castles and drawbridges. And, you know, I
- 10:38look at the private sector often subsidies and consolidation
- 10:42and protecting what I have, my status quo, and don't blame
- 10:46unions. They've earned certain things to their members. They want more. Education wants to
- 10:50protect tenure. Everybody wants to protect what they have. How do we
- 10:53get people to come to the middle ground and say, we're gonna all get might
- 10:57have to give up something to create a growing pie
- 11:00versus all attacking the shrinking pie. Do we, as a collective,
- 11:04think that growing the pie is important? You know, that may
- 11:07sound obvious, but you don't find in
- 11:11contemporary politics much of a prosperity agenda.
- 11:16Instead, we continually get exposed to
- 11:19wedge issues, more regulation, more taxes, more, you know,
- 11:23whatever it is. We don't have a prosperity
- 11:27agenda. No one's talking about how are we gonna grow
- 11:30the economy? How are we gonna give more people more opportunity
- 11:34to create businesses, to create jobs, to create tax revenue, etcetera?
- 11:38Instead, all we talk of is how are we
- 11:41gonna regulate and add more regulations. And so that it
- 11:45discourages investment, it discourages entrepreneurship, and it
- 11:49makes everything more difficult. And as we look at whatever our challenges
- 11:53we have today, things like the housing crisis, which is, from my
- 11:56perspective, existential, it is a 100% the
- 12:00result of bad public policy.
- 12:04Good public policy can reverse that ish. But we need as a
- 12:07collective to start talking about to our politicians, to
- 12:11our constituents, to our neighbors, to our friends, to our community,
- 12:15where is the prosperity agenda? The energy
- 12:18industry in Canada is 20% of our entire our entire
- 12:22GDP. It's 15% of the jobs of our country, the energy
- 12:26industry. And there are governments who won't
- 12:29engage with the leaders of the energy industry, the largest
- 12:33industry in the country, which, you know, sort of tells
- 12:36you where we are as a country. Massive untapped
- 12:40opportunity.
- 12:47I can campaign on a set of promises,
- 12:51and then when I'm in office, I can do a material change,
- 12:56and there's no national referendum. It just simply becomes
- 12:59now that I have power, I can choose what I do. Do you think part
- 13:03of our issue is that we as voters are so
- 13:07tolerant for that? I believe that a promise made is a promise kept. Private
- 13:11sector works that way. Why shouldn't government work that way that says if this
- 13:14is our policy, whether it's deficit, immigration, health care,
- 13:18dental care, whatever we're invested in, prosperity, that if that's what I'm
- 13:22elected on, that's what I have to deliver on. And if not, I have to
- 13:25I have to seek the approval of voters. I'll give the Trudeau government credit.
- 13:29In 2015, they ran on marijuana and a deficit. They
- 13:32delivered both. In 2019, they ran on
- 13:36gender, indigenous, climate. You know, they've made
- 13:39progress on all those agendas. The narrow issue is what
- 13:43Canadians want is not on their agenda. Because Canadians
- 13:47are concerned with housing, cost of living, opportunity,
- 13:50taxes, roads, I mean, which is why in the polls, you know, they're
- 13:54in slight difficulty. I think I think too, anytime you have, an
- 13:58economy that's driven by public sector employment versus private sector
- 14:01employment, you are in a place where there isn't going to be good productivity for
- 14:05the nation or innovation happening in the nation. You start to see
- 14:09this imbalance in terms of who we're going to put in power and what they
- 14:12run on. They're, they're running on a short term tactical
- 14:16approach to getting votes as opposed to a long term strategy
- 14:19for how they're gonna build the country. And that takes courage
- 14:23to say, I'm gonna do these things when maybe your special interest groups don't like
- 14:27those things, or maybe the people that are speaking to you. And frankly, let's face
- 14:30it, I think one of the challenges in our governments over time has
- 14:34been that the people who have the leaders ears are the elite
- 14:38in the country. They do not represent the majority of the country.
- 14:42And so you have whispering in politicians' ears people who do
- 14:46not need the things that the average Canadian needs and are out of touch with
- 14:49that reality. There's a question I've asked. Are we gonna continue as voters to
- 14:53accept that you can run on any promise? And when
- 14:57you're in power, things that are materially different to your promise allowed to
- 15:00do it. So, Dany, first well, I think, you know, necessity is the mother
- 15:04of all invention. Maybe we have become complacent
- 15:08and it really didn't matter, so we had a wide tolerance for that.
- 15:12But now we're starting to feel like these are very serious times. You know,
- 15:16like you're on a plane, autopilot. It's great when
- 15:19there's no turbulence or anything like that. But when there are turbulent
- 15:23times, you want that person in that cockpit to know how to handle this plane.
- 15:27And maybe we are in those times and it matters, and the people are smart
- 15:31enough to know. So I think it's gonna come back. And I think I love
- 15:34Jon and Arlene, what they're talking about is this prosperity agenda
- 15:38and entrepreneurship. So it's easy. Every day, get
- 15:42up, take shots at things. Don't like, don't like, don't like, don't
- 15:46like. You know what's harder? Pick something that's positive,
- 15:50create a consensus around that. That's harder. And, you know,
- 15:54as a father and as a Canadian like all of you, then what's the next
- 15:57big thing that's gonna make my kids feel that optimism?
- 16:01And then it's gonna be reflected in opportunity. I wrote a book about it, and
- 16:05it was a simple idea. I talked about my great grandfather coming.
- 16:09It was the agricultural age. Let's just call it, it was the agricultural
- 16:13age. Big trend. What did they do? They went out to the
- 16:16west. They went out to farms. They got farm implements. They
- 16:20worked the land. They never imagined you're gonna build a metropolis like this?
- 16:24Who would have thought? Today, what is it? Big picture.
- 16:28Digital age, the digital farmland. What's happened?
- 16:32The tools of productivity have been democratized. They're all
- 16:36in our hands. Give the people the tools to
- 16:39work the digital farmland and you just never know what they're
- 16:43going to be able to build. And that where that's where that
- 16:47opportunity comes and where there's entrepreneurship and this
- 16:50prosperity agenda can maybe come together to create that wave
- 16:54where that next chapter can be So Arlene, I wanna go to you on that
- 16:57because you're so vested. You're a champion of
- 17:01small business. How do we create a prosperity agenda for
- 17:05entrepreneurs in Canada that says we're creating the circumstances to dream it
- 17:08and do it and not feel embarrassed by being becoming wealthy for it,
- 17:12not becoming embarrassed about being successful for it. I mean, it's exactly what Jon
- 17:16said. We need a strategy and we need a plan for entrepreneurship in this
- 17:19country. It has to be declared that Canada is supportive of entrepreneurs,
- 17:23and it has not been declared that way in any way. In fact, the capital
- 17:26gains tax that we just saw implemented says the exact opposite. In fact, it
- 17:30should be as simple as you can incorporate for free. If you invest in a
- 17:34first time entrepreneur, there's just some tax saving for that. The first
- 17:38dollars that you earn in as an entrepreneur should be, you know,
- 17:41taxed at a lower rate. There are some simple measures that
- 17:45Canada as a country could stand behind that say
- 17:49to the world, we are in support of entrepreneurship. Those
- 17:52things do not exist today. You know, the superclusters, 1,000,000,000
- 17:56of dollars put into superclusters, but no accountability to whether those
- 18:00superclusters have actually delivered any value in terms of long
- 18:03term entrepreneurial innovation. We are a country that grows
- 18:07our ingredients, we do not commercialize our ingredients. The
- 18:11last mile of commercialization is where the value is. We are a country
- 18:15that invests in r and d and in IP, and then sell our r and
- 18:18d and our IP to other nations who turn it into products and services
- 18:22that we then buy back. We are not creating a
- 18:26strategic framework that allows entrepreneurs to be successful. You
- 18:30raise a good point on the superclusters. The amount of money that our governments give
- 18:33to businesses drive increased. Mhmm. The province of Prince
- 18:37Edward Island actually gives more money to businesses
- 18:41than they collect in business tax revenue. If you're Prince Edward
- 18:45Island, why don't you say, we're not gonna give businesses any money and we're
- 18:48not gonna charge taxes. It could be a tax haven. Wouldn't that be a
- 18:52gig? I mean, you know, we've gotta get government out of picking winners
- 18:56and losers, regulations and all the I mean, the if we wanna unleash
- 19:00creativity and the entrepreneur, it's not about giving them incentives and
- 19:03everything else, just get out of the way. We have spent so much
- 19:07money working the government and so little working for taxpayers.
- 19:11So how do we change that? The Fraser Institute's just done a an
- 19:15interesting, paper on how to balance the budget. And
- 19:19how to balance the budget, is actually cutting personal taxes,
- 19:23cutting corporate taxes, and eliminating 49
- 19:26different programs, subsidies, loopholes, etcetera. In
- 19:30other words, simplifying the tax code actually creates enough money to balance the
- 19:34budget. The tax code never gets simplified. It only gets complicated.
- 19:37So I'm gonna play devil's advocate. You you come up with this agenda and
- 19:41everybody oh, yeah. You're gonna take care of the rich. They're gonna get not pay
- 19:44the taxes. How about me? I'm struggling. Like how do we change the
- 19:48narrative in this country so that everybody goes, to you it's common
- 19:51sense. We have the tall poppy syndrome in Canada. We we
- 19:55we have it in spades where if somebody does is successful we wanna,
- 19:59you know, chop them down so that they don't stand out in life. We need
- 20:02to do the exact opposite. So in order to change it, we need to elevate
- 20:06the successful one first just like excellence candidates doing. How do you elevate
- 20:10excellence? How do you how do you show it as a
- 20:14beacon as opposed to an tax opportunity?
- 20:18And the rhetoric that we're getting from government about excellence. We have
- 20:21to start celebrating success. Here's another issue.
- 20:26Jon brought it up, our natural resources. How important it is to our economy, but
- 20:30more importantly, maybe to the western democracies? I'd rather have a
- 20:33national North American energy strategy, and I'd rather
- 20:37have my allies know that it's not Putin that's got the hand of natural gas,
- 20:40but it's coming from Canada. How do we change this so the average voter
- 20:44says bullshit? This is part of our strategy going
- 20:47forward because the wealth that we create can set up future generations to
- 20:51success. I think there's another key concept that we need to keep in mind, which
- 20:55is trust. If you are in a team and you
- 20:58trust one another, you know that the whole is gonna be
- 21:02greater than the sum of the parts. So belief and trust,
- 21:06very basic building blocks. From there, it does play into national
- 21:10natural resources, which is this is a collective asset of our
- 21:14nation. This is what we've been blessed with this. How do
- 21:17we provide these things to a world
- 21:21that's demanding them and needs them in a way that's
- 21:24going to enrich us, education and health care and all
- 21:28the things that are hallmarks of our nation, and also do it in a way
- 21:31we're gonna be leaders in preserving the climate. These are the
- 21:35things we have a conversation where we create consensus.
- 21:39I'll do this, you do that, shared sacrifice
- 21:43shared sacrifice. If you feel what you're contributing is somehow gonna
- 21:46benefit you as well, then that creates again an opportunity
- 21:50for people to say things like Jon is describing. Do you
- 21:54know that if we just tax one another endlessly, we'll
- 21:57create less wealth? Here's how we make more money. By
- 22:01unleashing everybody, you're all gonna get an opportunity to make
- 22:05the most of the digital economy, to make the most of whether
- 22:09you work in resources. Your chance is gonna be dictated by you.
- 22:12And when you get that success, it's going to be something that's
- 22:16gonna be reflected in the success of everybody in our country.
- 22:21In a moment, more of my in-depth conversation with Arlene Dickinson, Jon
- 22:25Love, and Dany Assaf.
- 22:32Hi. It's Tony Chapman. Investing in Canada? Well, that matters
- 22:36to RBC. $500,000,000,000 in sustainable financing
- 22:40to combat climate change. 500,000,000 for future launch.
- 22:43A 10 year program to prepare youth for the jobs of tomorrow. Helping
- 22:47to discover the next generation of Olympians, artists monetizing their
- 22:51talents, women entrepreneurs pursuing their dreams, supporting mental
- 22:55health, and so much more. Investing in Canada, well, that
- 22:58matters to RBC.
- 23:05On this special edition of Chatter That Manors, we're talking all things
- 23:09Canada, past, present, and future, and joining me
- 23:12are 3 of Canada's leading thinkers, Arlene Dickinson,
- 23:16Jon Love, and Dany Assach.
- 23:21Everything you're talking about sounds wonderful. I'm getting so excited. We're gonna lift
- 23:25Canada, but, well, is that gonna get me elected in my riding? Is
- 23:28that interest groups, the lobbyists that are taking care of me? All
- 23:32these people whispering my ear. How do we get to the point, putting
- 23:36narrative out saying, it absolutely is about Canada and future
- 23:39Canadians prosperity. It's about personalizing, it's about your grandkids,
- 23:43it's about people that are coming into this country, their success, they're chasing the
- 23:46dream. So, it's worth going after it versus being torn
- 23:50apart by fringes of society. Do we dare to
- 23:54dream? If you look at some of the great speeches of
- 23:58history, Martin Luther's Dare to Dream, Churchill's War Speeches, and so
- 24:01on, They all have a common theme.
- 24:05Are we able to be something better than we are
- 24:09today? As Canadians, do we wanna
- 24:12take on a big challenge? I'll give you a big challenge. Over
- 24:16the next 30 years, India's growth of its
- 24:20coal fired generating capacity, generate electricity,
- 24:23will generate more emissions than Canada does as a country. Why
- 24:27don't we, as a country, disintermediate the burning
- 24:31of coal for energy globally? We've got all
- 24:35the resources. We have all the skills. We have finances.
- 24:39We are uniquely positioned to actually make a
- 24:43difference in climate change if we want, and it
- 24:46involves every province. Everybody's got a stake in this narrative. We
- 24:50couldn't dare dream that we, in fact, could make
- 24:54an impact. What we need is leadership. When I talk about tax cuts,
- 24:58I'm not talking about tax cuts for the rich. God knows I don't need a
- 25:01tax cut. We need to make sure we have get money in
- 25:04people's pockets. That's what they're interested in, their standard of living. And
- 25:08that's how I would I would do tax cuts. And if we, you know, if
- 25:12we wanted to go down and really think about deregulation,
- 25:17and how you know, what regulation's really not needed and what
- 25:20frustrates the growth of business and what drives capital
- 25:24and talent out of this country. Every time
- 25:28I see capital and talent lead the country,
- 25:32I see tax revenue also go with it. So I wanna build, and you
- 25:35said we just need leadership. You started with the word leadership. I
- 25:39would put up lawn signs for any one of you 3 if you ran for
- 25:42politics. None of you wanna run because of the sit the
- 25:46circumstances of our democracy right now. How do we
- 25:50change that so that people of your caliber that can communicate, that
- 25:53have a social conscience, that care about people, not just their own
- 25:57pocketbooks, absolutely step into the public arena and
- 26:01run? I think the political gain is
- 26:05requires a very different skillset, but I don't have the skills
- 26:09to be a politician. But why don't we look at a model where I think
- 26:12it uses business skills very thoughtfully? In the
- 26:16US, you elect a president who appoints a
- 26:20cabinet, and that cabinet all comes from
- 26:24anywhere he wants. It's not elected pea he or she
- 26:27has the ability to select, you know, some of the
- 26:30leading minds and and and and says to someone,
- 26:34you know, Dany, I want to give you a role and it's 2 years or
- 26:38it's 4 years. Here's the mandate. Here's the department. Go at
- 26:41it. If we had the ability to do that in Canada, you
- 26:45could attract lots of super high quality
- 26:48talent that would be happy to work for a dollar a year
- 26:52around a specific mission. Arlene? Yeah. I mean, when you think
- 26:56about, like, finance minister Bill Moreau, who came from the
- 27:00public private sector and had the mandate similar to what I think if
- 27:03you talk to him today, he would say it was incredibly difficult to turn the
- 27:07tide in terms of what his mandate was. And so, you know, what we're seeing
- 27:10play out in the US is exactly what you're talking about here, which is we've
- 27:14got one leader down there, who is
- 27:17talking about the way things were. Let's go back to how it was. It was
- 27:21better it it was better in the past. We wanna, you know, make America great
- 27:25again. It was all about what we said earlier, like, the past was was so
- 27:28beautiful. It wasn't. And then we've got another leader who talked about
- 27:32hope and dreams and a vision for the future. There's this challenging
- 27:36thing about communication, and and you know us better than anybody, Tony, to get your
- 27:39message out there as a politician is so incredibly difficult because
- 27:43things get crazily blown out of proportion. Why
- 27:47don't we run well? I'm like you. I don't think I have the skills to
- 27:50be a politician. I'm not very politically inclined. I'll say that I shouldn't
- 27:54say. How do we change the circumstances of government?
- 27:58I'm not anti democracy. I'm just saying everything else has changed. I don't your
- 28:01business has changed, I have to believe, over 50 years. Entrepreneurship has changed.
- 28:05Law's changed. Everything's changed. How do we change the conditions so
- 28:09that people with a heart ahead and a bias for action
- 28:12have an ability to influence how this country is run. We all have to think
- 28:16about this, how we're gonna participate in our democracy.
- 28:20My real job is I'm a competition lawyer, and I think of how do you
- 28:22change the dynamics of any market? Maybe it's
- 28:26ideas like we need a new party. You need
- 28:30competition. You've got these parties which have had great
- 28:33history. They've all done great things. It's not to disparage anybody.
- 28:37But when things get locked in, you need a new
- 28:41entrant. These folks have built businesses. They've seen the
- 28:44great success and God willing, they'll see more. And you talk
- 28:48about their strategy. And people will have memos, they'll
- 28:52have PowerPoints, they'll have all kinds of things. You know, the one
- 28:56thing that can put an immediate stop to all of that
- 29:00is they pick up a paper, they get a call from a customer saying their
- 29:03competitor did something unique. I'll tell you, that
- 29:07clears the decks. Let's talk about immigration.
- 29:11This country was built on immigrants. Some of my best podcasts, either
- 29:15refugees or immigrants, it is what's made this country magical.
- 29:19Now the narrative is so anti immigrant, and it's
- 29:23becoming a put political football. And these are human lies. These are people, many of
- 29:26them coming here and going, I've given up everything to come to Canada very
- 29:30often for their kids. I'm a doctor. I'll drive an Uber if my kid's gonna
- 29:33have a better life. What do we need to do as a country to
- 29:37reclaim the sense that immigration matters and the right
- 29:40immigration's gonna help lift us to where we need to go? Okay. So can you
- 29:44imagine sitting around the cabinet table and say, why don't we grow
- 29:47the population of Canada by 10% over, say,
- 29:513 or 4 years, which is what's hot? In this high growth environment,
- 29:55everything's stressed. Health care, social infrastructure, everything's
- 29:58stressed. We don't have enough houses, etcetera, etcetera. So, you know, the
- 30:02growth strategy I'm pro growth. The growth strategy wasn't a company
- 30:06accompanied by, what if you have growth? Like, it's amazing.
- 30:10So in the Q2 of this year, we welcomed
- 30:14250,000 new Canadians to Canada. And we
- 30:18built enough houses for a 150,000 of
- 30:21them. Now it doesn't take a brain surgeon to
- 30:25say where are the other 100000 people supposed to
- 30:29live. New Canadians have built enormous amount of wealth for all of
- 30:32us and our country. We want more of them, and we need
- 30:36a policy that is that is accompanied
- 30:40by how do we support these people. We are a a mosaic
- 30:44as a country. We are not a melting pot. We are comprised of many
- 30:47different types of, ethnicities and cultures,
- 30:51and that's what makes our country great. And when we bring in people who
- 30:55have, ideas that come from, you know, whether let's say somebody comes from
- 30:58Europe, where they're used to high density, small, you know, like we wanna
- 31:02build mansions. Well, no. Maybe we need to build smaller homes and maybe we need
- 31:05to we need to make them more affordable. And we need to figure out how
- 31:08to, you know, ensure that everybody has an opportunity at home
- 31:12ownership. If you're in BC, good luck. We know what the issues are.
- 31:16But to your point, Toni, how do we fix this? Okay. Can I can I
- 31:20give you just 2 sound bites on housing? Because I'm here. Yeah. You
- 31:24know, in Toronto, city of Toronto, if you build an apartment building,
- 31:28a third of the cost of the building Yeah. Are taxes. Sweet.
- 31:32Okay. So if you didn't have all those taxes, you
- 31:36could charge 2 thirds of the rent. And people like us would be super happy
- 31:39about that because you are more likely to fill up the building.
- 31:43Second thing is, to get a building built
- 31:47typically takes 5 years of negotiation
- 31:50with the city. We have an affordable housing project
- 31:54that's now under construction. 420 it's Valhalla Business Park.
- 31:58So 427 in Dundas. So this is affordable
- 32:01housing, geothermal, zero carbon. K?
- 32:05So you might think That would be attractive, but
- 32:09we end up in this exhaustive struggle.
- 32:17All 3 of my guests, Arlene Dickinson, Jon Love, and Dania Sapp, have
- 32:21joined me previously on Chatter That Matters. Today, we're focusing
- 32:24on what matters most to Canada.
- 32:30AI. Venton, really, in Canada. This is, I've
- 32:34been working in AI now for 4 months. It's either gonna be something that
- 32:38allows you to soar or it's gonna be the greatest sledgehammer that ever hit you.
- 32:41And there's nothing in the middle. What's your take on
- 32:45how AI can play a role, positive
- 32:48role in what we're talking about today in
- 32:52finding a way to be much more efficient and much more
- 32:56pragmatic in terms of how we shape policy and, introduce
- 33:00policy in this country. AI is part of this digital
- 33:04farmland, and we did invent it. So it's this is a
- 33:08fascinating new experiment in how we're gonna go from
- 33:11basically building the technology to how we commercialize it. So
- 33:15oil, I don't know how many eras of
- 33:19oil there was, booms, and we still didn't weren't able to refine it
- 33:22and make the more, value added products. Critical
- 33:26Minerals, we're gonna see. We're gonna take it out of the ground. Are we gonna
- 33:29build those batteries? We're trying. Okay? But AI, this is
- 33:32really our strength. We developed this technology. Are we
- 33:36gonna be able to commercialize it? And where's the promise? So
- 33:40I've seen statistics. They say that AI itself is gonna it's
- 33:437% to global GDP. That is several
- 33:477, 8, 9,000,000,000,000 dollars are gonna be added.
- 33:51Not only that, the wealth that's gonna create the opportunity who
- 33:55built Facebook? Who built Amazon? All these they were unfamiliar
- 33:59names. Who is going to be those next
- 34:02people who are gonna develop technology and AI that are gonna revolutionize our
- 34:06way of life? They could be Canadian. And then when we
- 34:10think of the potential of it and efficiency, another big thing to tie in,
- 34:13productivity. We have a productivity problem.
- 34:17AI is the solution to that. Just think of the things you'll be
- 34:21able to do more efficiently. We were talking about it earlier today. Things that
- 34:24used to take a year can take a day. Think about
- 34:28in pharma. There are all these papers written over decades
- 34:32about how this molecule interacts with that molecule, interact with that
- 34:35molecule. They go into a desk or into a file folder. Now AI
- 34:39can correlate decades of research to tell
- 34:43you, boom, that's the molecule that's gonna cure this disease.
- 34:47We have the people. We have the institutions. Our schools, what are our
- 34:50strengths? In addition to minerals, our education
- 34:54system, our universities, those are the gold
- 34:57mines of the future. All those kids coming out of those
- 35:01schools, those are where that best chapter is gonna be
- 35:05written. So this is our moment to seize it. It is now.
- 35:09Jon, I mean, if you were running on an election on
- 35:12one thing that matters most to Canada, one thing that we say we're
- 35:16all gonna get every voter to say, yes, that makes sense. What would it be?
- 35:20Prosperity. Do you think voters are capable of understanding
- 35:24prosperity? Because there's 2 things. You're gonna come in and talk about prosperity and I'm
- 35:28gonna offer you universal healthcare. Or I'm gonna offer you free dental
- 35:31care. Or I'm gonna offer you whatever free prize inside. What do we
- 35:35need to do as a nation to make sure voters are voting not just for
- 35:38today, but ultimately for what Canada can become? In
- 35:42communication, there's two styles. There's those that can simplify
- 35:46and that there's those that complicate. And, you know,
- 35:50great leadership can take the concept of prosperity
- 35:55and simplify that and make it personal to each of
- 35:58us. Because while it's interesting to hear about
- 36:02more social programs, how are they funded?
- 36:06It's prosperity. While it's great to listen to think about
- 36:10more education, more pick whatever you want, but it's all funded
- 36:14by the same thing, which is more prosperity.
- 36:18And prosperity doesn't happen in a vacuum.
- 36:22Government's role is to set the stage, set the rules of the
- 36:25game, and encourage prosperity. And
- 36:29that is what I think a compelling leader could
- 36:33galvanize the country. But it seems like such hard work when they're
- 36:37just offering me something for free because what I understand Hard work.
- 36:40No. But I'm just saying that as terms of reaching a voter, I'm talking
- 36:44about your personal prosperity. Yeah. I'm talking about your standard of
- 36:48living. I'm talking about, you know, if if we think there's a housing crisis because
- 36:52we measure it by, you know, how many people, you know, don't have a house
- 36:55or whatever, think about all the under housed. Those are people that
- 36:59are in a one bedroom apartment that would prefer to be in a 2, etcetera.
- 37:03Right? Because density in housing has
- 37:07increased because people don't have options. You know, we've got a large
- 37:10population that would run that would like to
- 37:14improve their standard of living. So
- 37:18that is prosperity, and I would make it personal to you
- 37:22and the country. How do you make the debt personal? So I realized that
- 37:25because I talked to a long lot of young people, they don't personalize the debt
- 37:29as theirs. They think deficit is very different. Debt is simple.
- 37:33I'm living on my grandchildren's bill because they
- 37:37have to pay it back. Dany, I'm gonna talk to you in terms of some
- 37:40major negotiations. Canada is a trading nation. We're an
- 37:43export nation. What do we need to do to ensure
- 37:47that our destiny is a matter of choice and not left to the chance or
- 37:50the whim of maybe a new leader in the United States or what's
- 37:54happening politically around the world? I think we need a clear eyed strategy
- 37:58of how we're gonna create prosperity. So the number one thing behind that
- 38:01is that your children are going to be better off than you.
- 38:06That is the fundamental promise. And then from there, how do you create wealth?
- 38:10You need people. They need to be educated and healthy,
- 38:14just normal stuff. They need tools, a
- 38:17hammer, a computer, whatever it is. They need infrastructure.
- 38:21They need broadband, highways, whatever to go there. And at the end of that line,
- 38:25whatever you do, you need 2 things to make those a reality.
- 38:29You need capital to bring your idea really to life and give it
- 38:33scale. That's the oxygen. And then finally, you need
- 38:37to be able to sell it to somebody. How do
- 38:4040,000,000 people create the kind of wealth and the standard of living we have
- 38:44in a world of 8,000,000,000? You need to leverage
- 38:48that. And that is through trade agreements. Look across the
- 38:51world. We have our dear friends and allies. They will always
- 38:55be our core partners. There's no doubt. Whether the president
- 38:58comes or goes, whoever it is, we gotta negotiate in our
- 39:02greatest self international interest to make sure that we get the best deal for
- 39:05Canadians. But at the same time, we need to take a little bit of a
- 39:09Swiss approach of a little bit of neutrality, look out to the
- 39:12world, and say, who are our next trading
- 39:16partners and make sure that we have strong connections built off of our
- 39:19diverse population. Again, another one of our assets. People
- 39:23here from all around the world who have connections there and to see that
- 39:27those relationships are just as valued as our traditional
- 39:31relationship. So, Dany, while we're at it, and it sounds wonderful, we probably have the
- 39:34worst inter provincial trade agreements. I mean, we we have
- 39:38more free better free trade with many countries around the world than we do inside
- 39:42our borders. And, jeez, the last thing I wanna do is is,
- 39:45impact somebody that might not get me elected. How do we change this country
- 39:49so that there's free trade with them? I think it's simple. Does any one province
- 39:52think you're gonna be wealthier alone than together? If you
- 39:56do, good luck. Take a look around the world. It's
- 40:00not so simple. We need to know we need to unify
- 40:04here first to become stronger outside.
- 40:08And that's the message we need to get, to with to across Canada,
- 40:12within Canadians to know that this world is there's a lot of disruption,
- 40:16there's a lot of transformation, there's a lot of risk. But, again, there's a lot
- 40:19of opportunity in that if we come together here so we can be
- 40:23stronger abroad. And Arlene, too
- 40:26many talented individuals, entrepreneurs are
- 40:30leaving this country. Too much capital is flowing away from this country.
- 40:34What do we need to do because this country is entrepreneurs?
- 40:38What do we need to do to, make it the
- 40:41lifeblood going forward that not only are they gonna stay here
- 40:45and build their businesses here, but the more Shopifys are gonna be here,
- 40:49but we're gonna attract some of the best talent around the world because this is
- 40:52the fertile ground to grow. We need to celebrate entrepreneurs. We
- 40:55need to invest in entrepreneurs, and we need to buy from entrepreneurs. And if we
- 40:59do those things, we will elevate entrepreneurs to a place
- 41:03where they can actually prosper. You know, I always end my
- 41:07chatter that matters podcast with my 3 takeaways. And,
- 41:10Jon, what I took away from you, the most important word is prosperity.
- 41:14Start selling a prosperity agenda. Let people know what it's like to have
- 41:18that as a North Star and what it means for me personally if we're all
- 41:21in it together. I think, Dany, your passion
- 41:25and just the simple word of belief, how important it is to
- 41:29believe in positivity and possibility, and
- 41:32and what it would mean to sort of lift, elevate us so that it
- 41:36switches on every day. And Arlene, interesting enough, that is
- 41:40this concept of tall poppy. And I think you're right. If Terry Fox was, an
- 41:44American, they would have torn down the Statue of Liberty and and built a Terry
- 41:47Fox statue. Canada has had so many extraordinary things.
- 41:51We don't make these people our heroes. We don't make them our crusaders. We don't
- 41:54talk about the the employment they created, the wealth they mattered, how they've
- 41:58culturally impacted this country. And I think we've gotta do a lot more of
- 42:01elevating the tall poppy versus trying to to cut it off at the stem.
- 42:05So, ladies and gentlemen, I think these 3 deserve an incredible round
- 42:09of applause.
- 42:16Once again, a special thanks to RBC for supporting Chata That Matters.
- 42:20It's Tony Chapman. Thanks for listening, and let's chat soon.