Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The Last Trade E055: Financial Infrastructure for the Digital Age with Shalin Madan
Transcript
- 0:00What you're telling me is that music is about to stop and we're
- 0:04going to be left holding the biggest bag of odorous excrement
- 0:08ever assembled in the history of darkness. 1974198792972000 and
- 0:18whatever we want to call this, it's all just the same thing
- 0:20over and over. We can't help ourselves.
- 0:23I say when we sell. Hey, OK, so I'm behind.
- 0:28I say when we sell. Thank you for joining us for
- 0:33this week's episode of The Last Trade, a podcast from on Ramp
- 0:36Media. On today's show, we're joined by
- 0:38Shaolin Maidan, Chairman of the Hedge Fund Association and Co
- 0:41founder of Formidium, a multi asset class fund administrator
- 0:45and the global leader in back office services for digital
- 0:48assets. Shaolin shares his journey from
- 0:50hedge fund manager to fund administrator in the digital
- 0:52asset space. He articulates the importance of
- 0:55being involved in businesses you invest in, in the value of
- 0:58having professional experience in building new infrastructure.
- 1:01Sean also highlights the role of AI in improving fund
- 1:04administration services and the potential impact of artificial
- 1:07general intelligence on the economy and job market.
- 1:11We also touch on the impacts of inflation and how Bitcoin
- 1:13provides a solution for those who are falling behind.
- 1:16We explore the increasing scarcity of Bitcoin and how it
- 1:19sets it apart from gold as a store of value, as well as the
- 1:22growing adoption of Bitcoin by mainstream politicians and the
- 1:25need for leaders who understand the technology.
- 1:28And now, time for the show. Gentlemen, back for another
- 1:31week. It's beautiful here in South
- 1:34Jersey. The sunsets here, you forget how
- 1:36good the sunsets are until you get back.
- 1:40I've seen a couple of those posts the the I think two nights
- 1:43in a row is that is that you outside having a nice glass of
- 1:45rose and just watching the sunset?
- 1:49We don't get those in Texas. Not at, not at least in central
- 1:51TX. Marty, are you a Rose guy?
- 1:54I'll drink some rose every once in a while.
- 1:56I want to call myself a rose guy but.
- 1:58So not rose all day, rose once in a while.
- 2:01Yeah, every once in a while. So you can ease into the, you
- 2:04ease in with the Rose with Marty, and then you can go to
- 2:07the harder stuff later as a as a sunset.
- 2:10It depends what the wife opens up.
- 2:11That's what I'm excited for. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 2:17So we're joined by Chalamaydon from Permidium doing fun admin
- 2:22for a bunch of the funds in the Bitcoin and broader digital
- 2:27asset space. Full suite operation.
- 2:31Welcome to the show Shell. It's great to have you.
- 2:34Thank you for having me guys. So before we jump into the
- 2:40particulars of what you guys are doing it for Medium, why don't
- 2:44we learn a little bit about you, your background, what I
- 2:47understand you're former hedge fund manager run family office,
- 2:52you're chairman of the hedge fund Association.
- 2:56What was your career like before from For Midium and why did you
- 3:00decide to step into the fund admin space for all these
- 3:04digital asset funds? Yeah.
- 3:08So I started in the financial services business, in the
- 3:13alternative business. That is about three years after
- 3:17I started in financial services. So this will mark the 24th year
- 3:23in alternative investments. I started in hedge fund
- 3:26consultancy in 2000. In the year 2000 in New York, I
- 3:34kind of spent a few years doing that. 2004 I entered the fund of
- 3:40funds, hedge fund of funds world.
- 3:42Back then it was still a bit of an emerging world.
- 3:45People didn't really understand, you know, what hedge funds were,
- 3:47let alone funded funds. So funded funds were pretty
- 3:50necessary part of the ecosystem. I was promoted pretty quickly to
- 3:55portfolio manager right before the financial crisis, precisely
- 3:59May 2007, and had the pleasure of managing multi strategy hedge
- 4:05fund portfolios throughout the financial crisis.
- 4:09Unfortunately, the firm that I was with had some other issues
- 4:13and we were basically shuttered by the parent company and I had
- 4:20to go look for a job and that was round about 2010.
- 4:23As you can imagine, the environment wasn't very
- 4:26pleasurable back then. I had a young family, quite
- 4:29stressful, but interestingly enough, I had this notion and
- 4:35this belief that I should be in the family office world.
- 4:38I felt that I'd be well placed there.
- 4:40I also wanted to expand my horizons outside of hedge funds
- 4:43and understand, you know, things like real estate investing,
- 4:46private equity, venture capital structure credit a little bit
- 4:48more. And so I got into a family
- 4:51office job, which was I think pretty, pretty forward back then
- 4:552010, not a lot of family offices were hiring pretty, you
- 5:00know, sought after Subs or position, I think.
- 5:02And I helped build this family office that had a pile of cash
- 5:06after the financial crisis because they had sold their
- 5:08company right before steel prices had collapsed and they
- 5:15held it in cash. And it was actually quite
- 5:17informative to my investment strategy as well, just learning
- 5:20about their story. But I had the opportunity to do
- 5:23that for about 7 years, built out of portfolio across asset
- 5:27classes, both direct and through funds.
- 5:32Amazing experience. But around 2017, I don't know, I
- 5:39call me somewhat paranoid, I guess, but I felt like I wasn't
- 5:42adding value. And as an intellectualist, I
- 5:45feel like in order for you to compensate me, I have to add
- 5:48value. Now, our returns were good.
- 5:50We had double the AUM, but I felt that I could do more.
- 5:54And I was also a little concerned.
- 5:57Not concerned, but looking forward into the future and
- 5:59wondering if things like artificial intelligence could
- 6:02effectively replace allocation probably way ahead of that
- 6:07curve, but nonetheless felt that I had to take, you know, my
- 6:10personal destiny into my own hands.
- 6:13And like a lot of people do when they get that feeling, I became
- 6:17an entrepreneur. Mind you, at that point I was 42
- 6:20years old, so probably a little bit older than the average
- 6:24startup entrepreneur, startup fund manager, but nonetheless,
- 6:27you know, felt this was my my time to do it, my time and my
- 6:30life. So I started Bodhi Tree asset
- 6:33management. It was a quantitative macro
- 6:36firm. My background is macro.
- 6:38It's a passion of mine, still is, although much harder to
- 6:41understand the macro these days than back then.
- 6:44And I ran a quantitative strategy.
- 6:47I had some family office backers.
- 6:50I built out a number of algorithms across asset classes,
- 6:53and those algorithms were really meant to be a precursor to an
- 6:57eventual move to using artificial intelligence.
- 7:01I did that for 5 1/2 years. But along the way, only about a
- 7:05year after I started the fund, I needed a service provider, I
- 7:08needed a fund administrator. I needed a whole bunch of
- 7:12things. You know, you don't necessarily
- 7:13need a fund administrator or pardon me, an auditor at the get
- 7:18go, but you might need a fund administrator.
- 7:19You might need some past results fixed up for performance fees,
- 7:23just simple accounting, things like that.
- 7:25And I ran into the founder for Medium thought with it what they
- 7:30were doing. It was very interesting.
- 7:31By the way, it was not called for a medium at the time.
- 7:33It was called Sudrania Fund Services inexpensive, you know,
- 7:39efficient, great service or so why don't, why don't, why don't
- 7:42I try this out? Lo and behold, it turns out that
- 7:45I was one of the first clients of the firm.
- 7:50So it's kind of been an interesting journey because I've
- 7:52seen the firm from the beginning and the, really the, the, the
- 7:58point of the firm was and what was articulated to me was, you
- 8:01know, we have a vision to use technology.
- 8:04I got really interested and began chatting with the founder
- 8:09probably once a week, twice a week, really just giving my
- 8:12input based on this experience that I had already had.
- 8:15And about a year later decided, you know what, this hedge fund
- 8:20thing is kind of difficult. Maybe I should hedge my bets
- 8:24like a hedge fund manager right? And I invested in Sodrani.
- 8:27I ceded the firm with 0 revenues or or near 0 and began to advise
- 8:35the firm. Came on as an advisor and
- 8:38continue to advise the firm and saw the firm growing.
- 8:41While my hedge fund was was difficult to say the least in
- 8:44terms of growing, it was not trading crypto, probably should
- 8:48have been. And I ended up at the end of
- 8:532019, right before COVID writing probably the largest, one of the
- 8:58largest checks to date that the firm has received on my behalf.
- 9:03And, and, and, and those of my my syndicate to further invest
- 9:08in the firm and took on a effectively what was a Co
- 9:11founder role. And then I really began to
- 9:14advise the firm. And the first thing I did was
- 9:15move into crypto and digital assets, which which we can speak
- 9:19about. And yeah, the story of Sudrania
- 9:23and then for Medium is pretty well known, I think for those in
- 9:27this space, rapid, rapid growth. We did an acquisition in the
- 9:31meantime of a firm called Triple Leo, which was a pioneer in
- 9:36crypto fund admin, took over the clients.
- 9:39That was very difficult to do it in a pandemic do it in when
- 9:42you're experiencing hyper growth.
- 9:45But between the years of 2020 and mid 2022, we effectively saw
- 9:512000% growth in the business partially under my stewardship
- 9:57and of course under the stewardship of our of our
- 9:59fearless founder. So that's, that's my story. 2022
- 10:06going through that bear market, I kind of said, you know, I
- 10:09can't do both. It's very difficult.
- 10:11I was doing both, by the way. It's hard enough to be a hedge
- 10:14fund manager. It's hard enough to run a fund
- 10:16admin. It's impossible to do both,
- 10:19especially if you want to grow both.
- 10:20I think that's the key to manage money.
- 10:22But to grow business is a completely different thing.
- 10:24And so I decided to let go of my hedge fund, my baby and focus on
- 10:30my my attention on for medium and as well as my personal
- 10:33investments. That's my story.
- 10:36At On Ramp, we believe that Bitcoin will be the most
- 10:39important asset to own in the 21st century.
- 10:41Our Multi Institution custody solution is the safest and most
- 10:44secure way to ensure that your Bitcoin remains in your and your
- 10:47family's possession for decades to come.
- 10:50Multi Institution custody maximizes security and minimizes
- 10:52counterparty risk, leveraging Bitcoin's native properties to
- 10:55eliminate single points of failure that have historically
- 10:58complicated Bitcoin ownership. On Ramp provides Peace of Mind
- 11:01for your Bitcoin journey. For more information, check us
- 11:04out at on rampbitcoin.com. Incredible, incredible journey
- 11:09to Formidium. That's funny.
- 11:10I used to actually work at a fund of funds in the alt space
- 11:13as well managed futures fund that index CTAS.
- 11:17That is a a fascinating industry and it was a it was a good
- 11:23experience for me young 2122 on the portfolio management team.
- 11:27I think the best part of the fund of fund just get to talk to
- 11:31all these managers with different strategies and get a a
- 11:34pretty wide perspective on on what's going on in the world.
- 11:38Yeah, I'm just gonna agree. So Shaolin, how did crypto come
- 11:43into what Formidium was doing was was that it sounds like it
- 11:46wasn't there from the very beginning and then like what was
- 11:50it that led you or your your Co founder to decide that that
- 11:56would be a big part of the strategy for Formidium?
- 12:01So I think it's safe to say that a lot of the vision of the firm
- 12:04is being directed by me, not a lot of the management, but
- 12:08definitely a lot of the vision. And that kind of, you know,
- 12:10stems of course from my background as an allocator,
- 12:13investor, being the office guy, former hedge fund manager.
- 12:19So I became interested in crypto and Bitcoin after the crash of
- 12:262000 17 the previous crash. So I began to invest in crypto
- 12:34on my own. I was investing in some of the
- 12:37well known protocols that we know today, like, you know,
- 12:39chain link Bitcoin theory of etcetera, and really getting my,
- 12:45my, my, my feet wet, if you will.
- 12:47And it came to, you know, I really surmise that as an
- 12:53entrepreneur, I think it's, it's good to be a, a good position to
- 12:57be in as a big fish in a small pond.
- 13:00And that is something that we could do in crypto.
- 13:03And we had all of five clients by the way, when I, you know,
- 13:07gave my, my further round of investment to Sudrania, but it
- 13:13became Co founder. But I, I, I had a vision and I
- 13:19was really also it was informed by my macro trading as well.
- 13:24If everyone will recall in 2019 and even 2018, we had trillions
- 13:31of dollars of negatively yielding debt.
- 13:34It almost seems like a forgotten memory at this point, but
- 13:39central banks had negative interest rates and long term
- 13:42bonds were trading at negative yields.
- 13:45It was a surreal environment, impossible to trade my strategy,
- 13:50which had a lot of fixed income. And it just led me to believe
- 13:55that, you know, if this is going to be the case, I need to find
- 13:58ways to hedge myself. And that's how I learned about
- 14:01Bitcoin and said, you know, well, if I'm investing in this,
- 14:04others will probably start following at some point.
- 14:06And fund administration is a nice fix and troubles business
- 14:09to be in. Why don't we do this?
- 14:11Secondarily, because the ethos of the firm was to fix the
- 14:15issues that we saw in traditional fund administration.
- 14:19A lot of that revolved around the technology and building our
- 14:23own technology systems. So it seemed very suited to
- 14:27build a new stack, if you will, around crypto and digital assets
- 14:32because we already had the capability to build technology
- 14:36solutions around accounting. So to me, it just made a lot of
- 14:38sense and we just went forward with it in the in 2020 including
- 14:43an acquisition of Triple EO. Yeah, I think the the visionary
- 14:48aspects really important because you were on a call once and you
- 14:53brought up the the notion of some of the stuff you're doing
- 14:55on the event side that we can talk about.
- 14:57And you referenced the investment in working with firms
- 15:00like On Ramp and others that you work with as a vision of like
- 15:03bridging into the future and how there's an old world that's kind
- 15:06of like moving away. And curious if you saw that at
- 15:10the time and that was part of it or that like was solidified
- 15:13further down after running for midium and seeing that like the
- 15:17old guard is just not going to catch up to this.
- 15:19Like how did that realization 'cause you said it once on a
- 15:21call and it always stuck with me of like you're while you while
- 15:25we're smaller, not just us, just any firm that's in the space.
- 15:28It's an investment in that we will be the leaders in the
- 15:31future because of where it's going.
- 15:33And I thought it was very astute.
- 15:34And I'm just curious if like that's how you looked at it from
- 15:36back in the day when you got involved or did that like thesis
- 15:39kind of did you grow into that thesis over time after seeing
- 15:42the market and also seeing, you know, everything in the
- 15:45financial plumbing and how it's just fundamentally broken and
- 15:47that they can't come back from it in the existing models?
- 15:51Yeah, I think that not only do I hold that notion, I've tripled
- 15:55down on it really. I think that there was a lot of
- 16:01good things that I learned being in the family office world,
- 16:05managing money for wealthy people, but it doesn't
- 16:09necessarily parlay to the individual person.
- 16:12So when you're when you have billions of dollars, OK, your
- 16:17main concern is capital preservation.
- 16:20And you know, if you can compound that money a couple of
- 16:23bits above, you know, a 6040 portfolio, you're golden.
- 16:27You're doing great, right? And so when I structured my
- 16:31hedge fund, I was really trying to meet objectives around that
- 16:34like, hey, look, you know, I can get you two or three points of
- 16:36alpha, I guess the 6040 portfolio.
- 16:39Look how great I am. The truth of the matter is that
- 16:44in order to differentiate yourself as a start up and be
- 16:48outstanding, you really have to have something that's different
- 16:52and it's solving a a true problem.
- 16:56I thought I was solving the problem.
- 16:59Certainly the results of endowments and and other multi
- 17:03asset class investors, I've proven that my thesis was
- 17:06correct that the model was broken.
- 17:09The endowment model is what we called it, but it wasn't good
- 17:13enough to run a fund. And so, so, yeah, I mean, the,
- 17:19the sort of returns that were being generated in amongst
- 17:21crypto managers, the sort of opportunities, the new
- 17:25technologies, I I realized that I kind of need to kind of, you
- 17:32know, pump up the paper, throw it out and start all over.
- 17:36And I have to have a younger mindset.
- 17:39And I think that is actually something that all hedge fund
- 17:41investors know. A little rule of thumb with
- 17:46investing in hedge funds is you kind of want to invest with
- 17:50young and hungry guys. That's, that's, that's always
- 17:52been a thing. And I always viewed myself as
- 17:55young and hungry. And I am hungry and I'm young at
- 17:59heart. I had to relearn a few things.
- 18:01And, you know, to answer your point, it's exactly right.
- 18:03Like I'd rather be in the frontier and cutting edge of, of
- 18:07opportunities rather than trying to compete in, you know, very
- 18:11crowded and competitive spaces where, I don't know, there's
- 18:15really very difficult to have an edge unless you're say, Citadel
- 18:18or, or Millennium. It always has.
- 18:23To be evolving and coming back to the fun at the fund admin
- 18:27side of things and. Trying.
- 18:30To upgrade the the services the the incumbent fund admin
- 18:36landscape via forbidium. What are some of the top of mind
- 18:42problems that exist with typical fund administrators that you
- 18:46guys are looking to to upgrade and and improve on F Forbidium?
- 18:54I think it's really a question of, I think owning your own
- 18:56software and being able to do the accounting internally is, is
- 19:00incredibly important because off the shelf systems don't give you
- 19:04the sort of flexibility you need to handle emergent and exciting
- 19:08asset classes. And that's where I want to be.
- 19:10I want to be the leader in everything that's new and cool
- 19:13is what I say. And you have to have your own
- 19:15tech in order to do that because it's not worthwhile for an off
- 19:18the shelf system to handle, you know, XYZ, you know #454 rank
- 19:24protocol, on point market cap, if you know what I mean.
- 19:26So I think that that is important.
- 19:29I think that we are dedicated to building out our own technology
- 19:33across the board, which is, I call it an end to end system,
- 19:37which is connected as opposed to having competing systems attempt
- 19:40to communicate with each other. And that allows a much more
- 19:43seamless experience. Also the name of our accounting
- 19:45system, but it, it, it, it gives, you know, clients that
- 19:49ability to, to have comfort that, you know, the work can be
- 19:53done. So one of the things that is
- 19:55notable, notable about for medium is that we rarely, if
- 19:59ever say no to any sort of work. We want to get our hands on it.
- 20:04It's going to be a little messy in the beginning, especially if
- 20:06even the manager barely understands the asset class.
- 20:09It's hard for us to understand it too.
- 20:11But one thing that we do dedicate ourselves to is
- 20:13learning. About things and then once we've
- 20:17learned about them, we, we, we automate it and that's a big
- 20:21part of what what our what our, our mantra is automation
- 20:24automation automation reduce the number of mistakes, increase the
- 20:27efficiency, increase the delivery times and make the
- 20:32client experience overall easier.
- 20:35So I think that is the difference between for medium
- 20:37and others. I think the work, the staff that
- 20:40we have, the dedicated workforce, the the desire to
- 20:44make our clients happy, that's something that is lacking.
- 20:48And we were just speaking about that before the call started.
- 20:50But that's something that I think is lacking that that we
- 20:53and only a few others have. And it's going to be important
- 20:56because technology will make a lot of different asset classes
- 21:01very easy to do. So how do you differentiate
- 21:03yourself as a business? I think you differentiate
- 21:05yourself by improving the the the trajectory and the potential
- 21:12for success of the businesses that we serve.
- 21:15I think that is a lot of people can do accounting, albeit few
- 21:20can do crypto accounting. Even fewer could do D5 instead
- 21:23of the more complex parts that we specialize in.
- 21:26But the service I think is paramount.
- 21:31Yeah, it it strikes me as like you're a great microcosm of
- 21:38infrastructure being built in, in this nascent landscape of
- 21:44crypto. You know, we're focused on
- 21:47Bitcoin, there is a broader crypto ecosystem and everybody
- 21:52needs picks and shovel businesses and there's massive
- 21:55entrepreneurial opportunity to do to create a service that is
- 22:00needed and helps people who are, you know, themselves stepping
- 22:05into this landscape and need various services need need to
- 22:09buy picks and shovels and. You know.
- 22:14We, I, I think we, we spend a lot of time in Bitcoin and in
- 22:18crypto in general, thinking about like, when will the rest
- 22:20of the world figure out that this is the future and, and
- 22:22just, you know, start showing up.
- 22:25And to me, it, you know, it takes time because the
- 22:31infrastructure, like your business needs to be there in
- 22:34order for people to do business, you know, to arrive in, in the
- 22:39new frontier and have what they need in order to stay.
- 22:45And so, you know, it just strikes me as like this is how
- 22:48this process plays out. This is how an industry grows
- 22:50from a frontier into into, you know, a challenger to the
- 22:55establishment or mainstream, you know, tradify way of doing
- 22:58things. And and that just takes time and
- 23:01and entrepreneurial endeavor to prove out that there's a better
- 23:04way to do things. And we've already built it.
- 23:07And it, you know, just, you know, just show up and start
- 23:10using this new service or this new asset class because it's,
- 23:17it's been, it's been proven out, it's been de risked and
- 23:23everything you need to succeed is, now has been built by the
- 23:26entrepreneurs who came before you.
- 23:28So, you know, I, I, it's, it's exciting because to me, this is
- 23:32how, you know, for medium and, and businesses like it is, is
- 23:36how is what's necessary for crypto, Bitcoin in particular,
- 23:42to become the, the juggernaut that we believe it can from its,
- 23:47you know, its inherent properties, but it, it has to
- 23:51serve the needs of people. And the way that has to happen
- 23:56is through businesses like yours serving those needs.
- 24:01Yeah, I mean, or go ahead Shaolin, because I want to add
- 24:05you, but I want to hear your response first.
- 24:07I I know look I agree. I will say that having Trapfi
- 24:12routes helps because it creates a pathway to transition from a
- 24:18traditional to a digital world. You know, we're speaking with
- 24:21regulators all the time. You know, as mentioned, I'm the
- 24:23chairman of the Digital Assets committee for the Hedge Fund
- 24:25Association. The Hedge Fund Association is
- 24:28the longest standing trade group on behalf of the hedge fund
- 24:33industry was pivotal in terms of some of the negotiations around
- 24:39Dodd Frank in 2009 and 10. So yeah, of course we're members
- 24:44of other groups as well. So I think, you know, having
- 24:49tradified roots, but also being very open minded to what the
- 24:53future is going to look like and not attempting to thwart it like
- 24:56I think some others in the unnamed banks are trying to do
- 25:00or at least gobble it up for themselves.
- 25:02I think that's that's that's key, Yeah, I think.
- 25:08Part of what Jesse alluded to and what was exciting about your
- 25:11story and, and really fascinating is how many
- 25:14businesses and things have been impacted by individuals
- 25:16scratching their itch, either starting the business or as you
- 25:19found like imagine for Medium, if you hadn't been involved in
- 25:22what it would look like. And I go back to the story.
- 25:26It's kind of a little weird now, but Chris Sacca, who was an
- 25:29early, early like tech guy, he was at Google.
- 25:33He was one of the first checks into Twitter and ultimately
- 25:37wrote a check. And then when someone does when
- 25:40like you referenced right to check into a firm and you excuse
- 25:44me and you naturally need to de risk it, you start to provide
- 25:47value, you start to show up. And in his story, he would show
- 25:49up to Twitter and he was just like, look, this is the feedback
- 25:52and there's the stories of you like people are trying to figure
- 25:54out how you're going to monetize it.
- 25:56And he would just start, it would take him a year or two
- 25:58trying to explain the value of Twitter.
- 26:00And then eventually he just started buying their shares and
- 26:02end up owning at least at 1%, like one point, maybe 10% of the
- 26:05business. And that story rings true to
- 26:09similar to what you were describing of you were in the
- 26:12hedge fund space, you needed a better product, you started
- 26:14using it. And then you're like, well,
- 26:16maybe I can write a check because this makes sense for an
- 26:17investment opportunity. And then naturally wanted to get
- 26:21your hands dirty and improve it. You started to de risk it to the
- 26:23point you invested. It's even, it reminds me of
- 26:27similarly, like I was an early Unchained client when they moved
- 26:31from the, the, the loan product to the vault.
- 26:35And this is pre like caravan from the wall at config.
- 26:37And it was like tinkering with it and it was like ledgers and,
- 26:40and the USB sticks and the website and just like naturally
- 26:45trying to like you just like scratching an itch of like, I
- 26:48need a product to solve for custody.
- 26:50And then you start providing feedback and you know, I went
- 26:52and worked there for a few years and it's just this natural thing
- 26:55to Jesse's point of like, you got to like be in the weeds
- 26:57using it, needing the product and you naturally start to like
- 27:00just give back, whether it's via economic or personal gain.
- 27:04And then it ultimately like starts to build this ground up
- 27:06infrastructure that's going to be ultimately needed to build
- 27:09where we want to go. And like all of those learnings,
- 27:11at least on our side, like kind of transition along with Jesse's
- 27:15into like what we're doing here at On Ramp.
- 27:17So that the story that you shared just really resonates
- 27:19because it was like starts very small, but then it naturally can
- 27:23grow into something very big. And for anybody listening, this
- 27:25is like a great, you know, great time to like, if you're thinking
- 27:29about OPS or you're thinking about ways to leverage your
- 27:31professional experience into building, it's the perfect time.
- 27:35And I think that's the key is professional experience.
- 27:37Cause historically in Bitcoin or crypto, it's a lot of people
- 27:40that are generally tinkerers and they didn't really come from
- 27:43having already like an ingrained sense of professional like
- 27:47background to infuse in the Bitcoin ecosystem.
- 27:49And I think that's where the magic happens when somebody has
- 27:52their existing knowledge and market experience and expertise
- 27:56and then they map that to this new system.
- 27:59I think that's when I've seen historically the real like
- 28:02foundational stuff be built versus somebody that's like
- 28:05naturally just like tinkering and doesn't really have the
- 28:06frame of reference of how the existing world has worked and
- 28:09where it can be grafted on, if that makes sense.
- 28:12No, it makes total sense. And I can tell you as I learned
- 28:15this from my own investment experience as well.
- 28:17And it's funny, you mentioned guys like Chris Sacca, they were
- 28:19very informative in kind of my strategy as well, which
- 28:23continues to be my strategy today, which is that I generally
- 28:27only tend to invest in companies that I'm involved with because I
- 28:32know that I can have meaningful impact in improving those
- 28:35companies. I like to say if even if you
- 28:38look at my LinkedIn profile, it says taking companies from zero
- 28:40to one in the fraction of the time, if you just avoid the
- 28:43really dumb mistakes of which I have made every single one, you
- 28:47will have a successful business. And it's kind of funny when I
- 28:49evaluate and look at businesses, I can tell within a few minutes
- 28:52just by speaking to the founders what's wrong and what's right.
- 28:55I keep my mouth shut. But if they want my solicit to
- 28:59solicit my advice, I'll, I'll tell them.
- 29:00And I'm very frank and direct about it because I don't think
- 29:03there's any other way You, you can be no here and there.
- 29:07Of course I'll invest in the hot deals in Silicon Valley if I can
- 29:11get my hands on them. But by and large, if I'm going
- 29:14to write a check to an early stage company, I need to be
- 29:19involved and you know, it's probably going to be in
- 29:23financial services. I have been involved with the
- 29:25jewelry company. It's complete zero.
- 29:28You know, I, I wasn't involved actually I invested passively.
- 29:31So a lot of my passive investments when I wasn't
- 29:34involved, a lot of them didn't really amount to much.
- 29:38But when I'm involved, I've noticed that particularly with
- 29:40young entrepreneurs, I can be tremendously helpful.
- 29:44And I think that's, that that's a natural transition.
- 29:47I think for those of us who have had a little bit of success in
- 29:49our lives and, you know, have earned some money and, and still
- 29:52want to be involved, but know that, you know, we have to hand
- 29:56it over to perhaps a younger generation that has some very
- 30:00good vision. But crossing your TS and dotting
- 30:02your IS is absolutely important in running a business.
- 30:04And that's where where guys like me can come in.
- 30:09No, that's awesome. Makes a lot of sense.
- 30:10It doesn't get talked about enough.
- 30:12But to really allocate capital well specifically in venture
- 30:15like you kind of have to have built things before because how
- 30:17are you supposed to discern if somebody's stories is true or
- 30:19not 100. Percent. 100 percent No.
- 30:24I. Mean especially in a space like
- 30:27Bitcoin specifically, I know at 10:31 we're very involved with a
- 30:33lot of the portfolio companies and from the allocator side,
- 30:37like if you can actually add value, it is scarce in the
- 30:42Bitcoin space. It's a nation and nobody and
- 30:44we're still figuring out how to build things and it is cool
- 30:50being on the cutting edge. And now you see the emergence of
- 30:52AI, which is a topic I'd like to talk about with you Shaylin,
- 30:57incorporating it into for medium.
- 30:59And I know you mentioned you built your your quantitative
- 31:03algo with the idea that it eventually turned into AI.
- 31:06So being earlier to the trend back in 2017 and seeing where it
- 31:12is now, has it progressed more than you thought it would?
- 31:15Is AI on a trajectory that that you assumed that you assumed it
- 31:22would at this point? And how disruptive do you think
- 31:25it can be to the industry that we're in that's fund management
- 31:29or creating Bitcoin financial services?
- 31:35I'm going to give a standard off the shelf response on this, but
- 31:38it is absolutely outstripped what I thought it could be.
- 31:42I can tell you that the first day that chat to BT3 came out, I
- 31:46signed up and I push it on the entire team and it really became
- 31:52very influential in terms of helping me continuing to to
- 31:56evolve my view as to what I thought, you know, the future of
- 32:00our business could look like. So as an example, and I'm being
- 32:03very honest with you, so our offshore center, our Center for
- 32:07accounting and all things operations is located offshore.
- 32:12We have client service reps in North America, but the hardcore
- 32:18skills that are required to do what's needed in this, in this
- 32:21job are located primarily in India.
- 32:24But with that, at least in the past could come some
- 32:27limitations. Perhaps an e-mail comes in and
- 32:29it's funnily worded right, You have communication issues.
- 32:34Well, the interesting thing is though, is that when, for
- 32:37instance, I have my team now run all of their correspondences
- 32:41through chat to BT, making sure that there's no spelling
- 32:43mistakes. I think these things really
- 32:45matter in a business, right? They create the value where I,
- 32:50I, I really truly believe that, you know, in the near future,
- 32:53the not too distant future, you're not really going to care
- 32:56where the work is done anymore. You're going to care that it's
- 33:00done right. You're going to care that the
- 33:02communication is nice and efficient.
- 33:03You're going to care about those sorts of things.
- 33:05And AI helps tremendously in doing that.
- 33:09I mean, you can barely know English and run an e-mail or
- 33:12thought through AI and send something out and, and you know,
- 33:17as long as you know how to, I mean, you don't need to
- 33:19understand English to do accounting, right?
- 33:21So, and, and, and again, you know, India is an example of a
- 33:26bilingual country. English is the, is the, is the
- 33:28national language. Actually, I don't think a lot of
- 33:30people actually know that it's one of the, one of the national
- 33:32languages. But the point being that now you
- 33:36really can't tell. And it's to me as an investor,
- 33:39as an entrepreneur, it's such a major arbitrage that anybody who
- 33:43hasn't done it or hasn't set up shop, I don't know how you can
- 33:46run a business where you have a shortage of workers in the
- 33:49Western world, if that's that's known shortage of graduates.
- 33:53So even if you could find one or two or three good guys, it's
- 33:56hard to build a team, it's hard to build the necessary
- 33:59redundancies. If that guy leaves, we're done.
- 34:03You can't run a business like that.
- 34:04You can't have that sort of key man risk.
- 34:06And so I think a lot of people don't understand some of the
- 34:10limitations that are happening on the entrepreneur side, where
- 34:14in an ideal world, if there was a, a good supply of Labor and
- 34:21the sort of things that are needed and consistency of that
- 34:23labor in order to do the work for you, the clients, you would
- 34:28have your operation set up in a certain way.
- 34:30And if you could do it cost effectively, that's key.
- 34:33How do you how do you, how do you administer a, say, a $10
- 34:39million venture fund or a crypto fund that wants 24/7 service in
- 34:46the United States? It was doing D5 with multiple
- 34:49wallets. The accounting costs alone would
- 34:53eat up a good proportion of the return of that fund, right?
- 34:57So how do we do this in a way where we can still create
- 35:01businesses in the United States where entrepreneurs can still
- 35:04have a chance to compete against the, you know, the big
- 35:07monopolies, if you will, and do it cost effectively?
- 35:13And that's what AI is allowing us to do.
- 35:16It's something that I saw a few years ago in the Sudrania model,
- 35:19which was appealing to me, but it's even more appealing now
- 35:23with AI. Have you made the leap yet?
- 35:27Is being an interesting one to talk to.
- 35:29You made the leap that like AI is kind of in my mind synonymous
- 35:33with deflationary tools like software, right?
- 35:35Like you just need SAS software if you're going to run a
- 35:37business similar AI. It's it allows you to do more
- 35:39with less. Have you made the leap on
- 35:41bitcoins? Very similar in that sense.
- 35:43Like you referenced, if somebody gets leverages the tools, then
- 35:47they're going to be successful. If they don't leverage the
- 35:49tools. It's pretty straightforward.
- 35:51But this notion that if a company in a future state does
- 35:54not have some form of treasury in sweeping of cash flows into
- 35:59BTC, they're kind of working backwards because of just how
- 36:02bad. I think pre 2020, this could
- 36:04probably be more debated or not true, but given what we know
- 36:08about the amount of M2 money supply and everything that's
- 36:11happening with inflation, it's probably closer to 15 to 20%
- 36:13year over year. And that it's almost like
- 36:17upgrading in the same way. Forget about like, you know, the
- 36:19idea of money and the ideology and all the things that people
- 36:22in Bitcoin talk about just this idea of like upgrading from an
- 36:25analog dollar to a digital form that preserves or increases.
- 36:29Have you, have you thought about that at all?
- 36:33I have and I don't. I think my answer is as good as
- 36:37the next person with all caveats.
- 36:40I viewed Bitcoin as disruption. I was, I, I've been a precious
- 36:46metals guy since the year 2001 when the the 1st or I guess the
- 36:51technology.com crash occurred because I began to get very
- 36:54interested in Austrian economics.
- 36:56As I mentioned, I'm a macro guy and I saw, I've been, I've been
- 36:59an Austrian economist. If you want.
- 37:00I also graduated from Berkeley with a degree in economics and I
- 37:04also have an economic history background from NYU at my
- 37:08master's. So I'm I'm an economics guy and
- 37:10a history guy too. And I was very enamored with
- 37:13Austrian economics and Sal money.
- 37:16And so the natural thing to do was to become an expert in gold.
- 37:21And I traded gold quite successfully in the global
- 37:24market of 2000 and 2:00-ish to 2008 and 2011 up to 2011.
- 37:32So I wish I had learned about Bitcoin earlier.
- 37:38I wish I had been smart enough. And I had mentioned that I was
- 37:40in a bit of an old school, old world mentality in a capital
- 37:44preservation mode, managing a family office, which I think
- 37:47that if you really want to make 100X sort of returns, it's
- 37:51probably a mindset you have to get out of.
- 37:53And that's something that I have to deprogram, deprogram myself
- 37:57on. But ultimately, here's my
- 38:02argument on Bitcoin. Its performance in the long
- 38:06term, once it's fully adopted, should be no better or worse
- 38:09than gold because it's effectively, in my opinion, the
- 38:12same thing, right? Gold already serves the purpose
- 38:17of what Bitcoin does. So there must be some other
- 38:20attraction to Bitcoin which we of course know about.
- 38:22It's digital transfer, blockchain, all the various
- 38:26things that you can ascribe to why Bitcoin is a superior,
- 38:29superior form of capital or money preservation from, you
- 38:33know, central banking, you know, profligacy.
- 38:36I think I view Bitcoin as a, as a disruption story as far as
- 38:43what inflation is. I think that inflation it really
- 38:46depends on like if food and energy are going up, if you have
- 38:49a billion dollars, you don't give a shit, right?
- 38:52It's not a big part of your, your expenditure.
- 38:54I think inflation is a real personal issue for people,
- 38:56right? It really depends on where you
- 38:58are and this economic, you know, totem pole, you know, and a lot
- 39:02of people are unfortunately in the United States and globally
- 39:06falling behind whereby inflation as we understand it, the price
- 39:12of gas, the price of food, the price of, you know, everyday
- 39:15items, hospital care, things like that is hurting people.
- 39:19It's absolutely hurting people. It doesn't hurt somebody who's
- 39:22wealthy, but it hurts. It hurts the poor.
- 39:24And I think that's where Bitcoin with an ability to access it
- 39:29cheaply, with an ability to access it in a fractionalized,
- 39:33you know, amount ability to own something with everything else
- 39:37that you want to own, be it real estate or, or, or or assets on
- 39:42the and in the stock market even are so expensive, I can think of
- 39:45very few disruptive asset classes.
- 39:48So that's how I look at it in this current current moment.
- 39:56I manage my own portfolio. I personally think interest
- 40:00rates are in a real state, meaning that they're above 0,
- 40:03right? It's just a nominal rate in
- 40:05dollars, nominal rate minus inflation.
- 40:08It's no surprise to me that's why the dollar is rallying
- 40:12against other Fiat trash. But and that's that's also why
- 40:17Bitcoin has been somewhat contained, right?
- 40:21We have the adoption of the ETF. But again, from a macro
- 40:25standpoint, the real drivers for Bitcoin like the kind that we
- 40:29saw during COVID where it was complete insanity from a fiscal
- 40:32and monetary perspective, in my personal opinion, are not
- 40:35necessarily there. Now let's go into the future a
- 40:38little bit. Given the economic situation of
- 40:42the United States and the world and the average person, I have
- 40:46no doubt that at some point the central bank and the fiscal
- 40:52authorities will, and the fiscal authorities have already done
- 40:55this, will basically give up and they're going to go, you know,
- 41:00full Zimbabwe if you, you know, And I think that's where Bitcoin
- 41:05really will shine. I think gold will do well as
- 41:09well. But because Bitcoin has the
- 41:12added factor of adoption, it's going to give you a
- 41:17exponentially better return than gold, whether you've been.
- 41:21Buying Bitcoin for years or just getting started on your journey?
- 41:24Our Multi Institution Custody solution is the safest and
- 41:27easiest way to custody your Bitcoin.
- 41:29With On Ramp and our partners at Bitco and Coincover, you can
- 41:32sleep soundly at night knowing that your Bitcoin is safe from
- 41:34exchange failures, the loss of seed phrases and broken hardware
- 41:37devices. On Ramp's Multi Institution
- 41:40Custody Solution eliminates any single point of failure,
- 41:43distributes counterparty risk and minimizes required trust,
- 41:46all while providing greater assurances that a client's
- 41:49Bitcoin is secure and auditable on chain.
- 41:52As a client of On Ramp, your assets live in a multi sig vault
- 41:55controlled by three distinct entities, none of which have
- 41:57unilateral control. On Ramp provides products and
- 42:00services that honor our clients ownership and control of the
- 42:03underlying asset. To learn more about Multi
- 42:05Institution Custody, check us out at on rampbitcoin.com.
- 42:09Yeah. I agree with that, that the
- 42:11early stage adoption is, is I think key for you know, looking
- 42:15forward. Why?
- 42:17Bitcoin. Stands to outperform gold, but
- 42:20then the the magic sauce for me the thing that I've just, you
- 42:23know, I get zealous about so sorry I'm going to get on my
- 42:25soapbox, but is the increasing scarcity function of of Bitcoin
- 42:30is, is what sets it apart truly from, from gold because gold is
- 42:35is what 1 1/2 to 2% supply growth every year from gold
- 42:39mining and it's a 12 to $16 trillion asset right now So
- 42:45that's boy that's $320 billion every year of new supply that
- 42:54has to be absorbed by net inflowing demand.
- 42:56And you know so that's three billion wow 30 billion a month
- 43:02of of, of new supply creation that has to be absorbed by the
- 43:08market. And that's, I feel like that
- 43:09sets the price, that sets the ceiling for what gold can be in,
- 43:13in the global asset landscape is like, you know, how large of an
- 43:16asset class can gold be? Well, it has to, the market has
- 43:19to absorb so much demand every supply every, every month on, on
- 43:25on average. And then Bitcoin has this, you
- 43:27know, every four years, the, the amount gets cut in half such
- 43:31that, you know, 100 years from now, it'll be a zero creation.
- 43:37And that means that that ceiling of what it can possibly be just
- 43:40keeps ratcheting up because the amount of supply creation every
- 43:47month, every year ratchets down and then that the market has to
- 43:51absorb less. So if those, if those statements
- 43:55are true, then Bitcoin, the ceiling of what it can be keeps
- 43:59increasing. And then the IT serves as a
- 44:04savings vehicle that allows people to buy now and hold for
- 44:08more than four years to see their purchasing power
- 44:10appreciate over time versus gold, which serves as a store of
- 44:14value without promising anything about, you know, growth.
- 44:17Really, Bitcoin doesn't make any promises either, But that's the
- 44:21math, I think. And, and so, you know, that's I
- 44:24think in, in addition to early stage adoption, I think the
- 44:28increasing scarcity side of, of Bitcoin makes it something that
- 44:33is a better treasury asset to bring it back to what we were
- 44:36originally talking about there of, you know, if you hold this
- 44:40thing for over time and yeah, it'll be volatile along the way,
- 44:44but on net, because of the increasing scarcity and the
- 44:47early stage adoption, it will grow in purchasing power.
- 44:50And therefore, if you're if you're an individual or a
- 44:53business, you're well served to have it on your balance sheet.
- 44:58It certainly can't hurt and especially in a negative real,
- 45:02real interest rate environment, which, you know, it seems like
- 45:07based on the trajectory of central banks, based on what
- 45:11I've been reading, we're creeping towards that again,
- 45:15looks like it it's they're trying to hold the line.
- 45:17They're trying to hold the line. And that's what's keeping, I
- 45:19think, an all out, you know, feast in crypto assets and
- 45:25commodities at Bay. But you know, the, the the
- 45:30numbers just don't look good in my opinion.
- 45:32And I think that, you know, we saw Powell even admit that
- 45:36yesterday that the things like the job numbers, for instance,
- 45:39are not as rosy as the statistics might might be
- 45:44displaying. So, you know, well, did every
- 45:48did every we know the hit. Sorry, I was like didn't.
- 45:52They come out yesterday if we go there because we've been saying
- 45:54this for over a year. It's like, didn't they come out
- 45:56that they are cooking the books with the numbers like we've
- 45:58always known like these numbers on the employee and they're all
- 46:01just like, you know, kind of like smoothed over.
- 46:04But I think somebody from a very senior position came out and and
- 46:07described it well. It was.
- 46:09Pal calling them out right they they can never explicitly admit
- 46:12that they've been cooking the books on the job numbers I.
- 46:16I've got a, I've got a part time job, Uber Eats.
- 46:20I, I work, you know, part time at the gym and, you know, you
- 46:27know, at night I sell my clothes on Poshmark.
- 46:29I've got three jobs. Three jobs, yeah.
- 46:33Yeah, that sounds sustainable and healthy for an economy.
- 46:36Well, I. Mean, I mean, Powell's comments
- 46:38yesterday and the combination of that and the letter that
- 46:41Elizabeth Warren and one other senator sent earlier this week,
- 46:46that is a scary predicament that we find ourselves in because
- 46:50historically you've always had this separation between the
- 46:54federal government and the Fed. The Fed's supposed to be
- 46:56operating independently, it seems like, and this has been
- 47:00going on for over a year now between Janet Yellen and Jerome
- 47:02Powell to a certain extent, maybe over a year.
- 47:06But it seems like that independent nature of the Fed,
- 47:09the federal government is trying to erode that, to force interest
- 47:13rates lower, to improve, quote, UN quote, improve the economy
- 47:18during an election year. I think that if we if we want to
- 47:24just take it back to AI and this is kind of the I'm not the most
- 47:31popular guy at the cocktail parties nor.
- 47:34Are we? Look, I've been around the
- 47:40block, OK? My dad was in the automotive
- 47:44industry in the in, in the in the late 80s, early 90s.
- 47:48His business was obliterated during that recession.
- 47:53And I remember distinctly you'd read the New York Times.
- 47:57I was really into always a kind of, yeah, like young guys are
- 48:00like, interesting in the news, interested in the world.
- 48:03And I'd read about how it was unusual how long it was taking
- 48:09for people to kind of get jobs. That was something that hadn't
- 48:14really been seen. Usually you'd have a recession
- 48:16and you just snap right back and people start working.
- 48:18It's part of the business cycle, right?
- 48:20Same thing happened after.com bust, right?
- 48:24Each and every cycle that I can remember, starting with the
- 48:271990s, early 90s recession has been followed by an increasingly
- 48:32tougher market for job seekers to find jobs.
- 48:36And usually what ends up happening, depending on your
- 48:39age, of course, But if when you once you get to my about my age,
- 48:43which, you know, I'm going to be 50 soon, it's, it's, it's
- 48:49harder. It's harder.
- 48:50And, and you know, we know, I think retrospectively, when we
- 48:55kind of philosophize and look at the past, we know that
- 48:57technology efficiencies offshore and all the list of things that
- 49:02have, you know, affected and hurt workers in the Western
- 49:06world and globally too, by the way, I mean, there are people
- 49:09getting jobs offshore, but there's a lot of people who
- 49:10don't have jobs too. Just to be clear, I feel like
- 49:16this could be the last cycle. I think we're that close with
- 49:19AIII. I, I, I fail to understand how
- 49:24you get a recovery as we've understood it in the traditional
- 49:28sense. Once you hit AGI, artificial
- 49:31general intelligence and by, by a lot of respects, you know,
- 49:35that's, that's, that's in 2027. It doesn't mean you don't need
- 49:39people then. Just want to be very clear about
- 49:40that, but it just means the number of people.
- 49:43You might never need more people.
- 49:48I think you're, you're right. Something that nobody talks
- 49:50about is like when you understand, you know, individual
- 49:53looks at Bitcoin and efficient use of capital, how much fat
- 49:57exists at like we know the zombie companies that exist that
- 50:00are publicly traded. And you think about all of that
- 50:03coupled with private companies. And if inflation increases and
- 50:06your margins decrease and all the things we know with
- 50:09business, you naturally have to fall into leveraging
- 50:11deflationary tools like AI. It's like how many things just
- 50:14kind of just move out and you can just build efficient
- 50:17businesses. And if those companies probably
- 50:18don't do it because it's already entrenched in their model, as
- 50:20you know, it's hard to kind of back out of a big business and,
- 50:23and switch the operating model. So, but somebody will leave that
- 50:27company and go start a better firm for 110th of the cost and
- 50:31110th of in 110th of the time, 110th of the cost.
- 50:35And then they'll be able to undercut any of the cost from
- 50:37the legacy business because they can just do it more efficiently.
- 50:42I, I, I agree, and I think that a lot of people are looking at
- 50:45this negatively too, when they don't necessarily have to be.
- 50:48What does technology allow? I think technology gives us
- 50:51transparency, and I think transparency equals freedom,
- 50:55right? The more you can gatekeep the
- 50:58tools for becoming successful, the fewer people who can become
- 51:02successful. Now you can just go on YouTube
- 51:04and learn about whatever crypto you want.
- 51:06You can learn about how to date women and this everything's on
- 51:09YouTube, right? Travel.
- 51:09I'm traveling to, as we mentioned, I'm traveling to
- 51:12Europe and I can take a, you know, a bunch of videos and
- 51:14create my itinerary and just run it through chat with BT Amazing.
- 51:18So you are creating more sovereignty, I think for the
- 51:24worker where people can become entrepreneurs much easier,
- 51:30right? They can start servicing
- 51:32business, They can use AI to help businesses as perhaps 1099
- 51:36or contract workers rather than, you know, being beholden to the
- 51:42man, if you will. Yeah, I I agree.
- 51:49I agree. When you went to the political
- 51:51stuff, Marty, I was just thinking about Trump making
- 51:53Bitcoin great again in America. What?
- 51:55What was the quote that came out yesterday that all the bitcoins
- 51:57come into America? All the bits going to be made
- 51:59the. Rest of the Bitcoin.
- 52:01Will be mined in America. Which is.
- 52:03It's great to see, honestly, somebody cheerleading for
- 52:07Bitcoin. I think it's a smart move on his
- 52:10front. And there was another headline
- 52:11today too, that due to the energy infrastructure build out
- 52:16that's required for all this Bitcoin mining and the increased
- 52:21demand coming from AI, like there's a strong argument to be
- 52:24made that Bitcoin being this pioneer species for low cost
- 52:28energy can can help AI proliferate.
- 52:31Sort of goes in first, builds out the infrastructure, gets the
- 52:34power deals and then as hash rate goes up, you know, it
- 52:38becomes uneconomical and you just replace it with with AI
- 52:40data centers or a mixture of the two.
- 52:45On the on the Trump statement, it it is good that mainstream
- 52:50politicians are now viewing Bitcoin as a way to win votes.
- 52:53I sure hope that the Democrats respond at some point soon by
- 53:00trying to copy this move, because that would be, that
- 53:05would be the way that we avoid this becoming a partisan issue.
- 53:09And that could just, you know, that could be painful and, and
- 53:14hamstring adoption because, you know, if, if Bitcoin adoption is
- 53:17a is a political statement, then, you know, companies and
- 53:23individuals would be more reticent to to adopt it when,
- 53:28you know, objectively it has properties that anybody should
- 53:31want to adopt. So here's hoping that that we
- 53:34avoid the partisan, partisan nature of Bitcoin becoming
- 53:38partisan by, you know, the White House realizing that they can't
- 53:44afford to alienate the crypto voters and and trying to win
- 53:50them back when Trump has made this move already.
- 53:53Well, you'll, you'll be happy to learn, Jesse, that the Biden
- 53:55administration announced that they're currently figuring out a
- 53:59way to accept Bitcoin and crypto donations for for this election.
- 54:02See that's. Great, that's the game theory in
- 54:04action right there, right? Like they didn't give a shit
- 54:06about about crypto until Trump realized that, hey, this is an
- 54:12untapped opportunity that I'm going to take advantage of.
- 54:15So good. Yeah, And even as mining
- 54:19commented, people, some people in the Bitcoin space, like we
- 54:22don't want all the hash right here.
- 54:23It's like, no, obviously not. But if Trump signals, hey, we're
- 54:28going to put a concerted effort here in the US to allow the
- 54:31Bitcoin mining industry to flourish and to grow.
- 54:35And you just put it out there, we're going to mine all the
- 54:37Bitcoin. You start this this game
- 54:39theoretical battle where you have countries in the least,
- 54:42like, no, we're going to buy all the Bitcoin.
- 54:44And so they just start spinning it up mining infrastructure and
- 54:46actually leads to a further decentralization of hash rate
- 54:50geographically and. And for that matter, I think we
- 54:54should probably give some credit to RFK Junior for making a
- 54:58splash with Bitcoin a year ago. And then, you know, somehow that
- 55:01made it through the the Trump Organization to to say like, oh,
- 55:07you know, this one really well for him and and Vivek too.
- 55:11I was going. To say I would, I would give
- 55:13some credit to Vivek Ramaswamy because I think I mean, my
- 55:17personal opinion, you know, I am a fan of all the, the candidates
- 55:21that have that have run. I mean, he's absolutely one of
- 55:24the smartest people I've ever witnessed speak frankly.
- 55:28He is just so knowledgeable about, you know, almost every
- 55:33single subject in a multi faceted way.
- 55:36And he certainly has the ear of a lot of young conservatives,
- 55:42along with the Trump administration, who's trying to
- 55:44woo them. Yeah, he's watching it.
- 55:48Happen he's extremely. Impressive.
- 55:50I had him on TFTC in 2022. Sorry if you can hear my son
- 55:55screaming down there and let's go there.
- 55:56But that was when he was he was still full on its drive and at
- 56:02the time I couldn't. Imagine he'd be.
- 56:05Running for president but looking back in retrospectus, I
- 56:07completely agree. He's extremely well spoken,
- 56:10knows how to and the other thing too, you know, I'd like reach
- 56:13out and actually engage people in conversation, even if they
- 56:16have differing views, which I really was impressed by when
- 56:20during his campaign, when he was running the Republic.
- 56:23That's. Incredible.
- 56:24I didn't know he was on TFTC. You got to go find.
- 56:26We were at the conference last year that we put on and, and I
- 56:29didn't get to hear his speech. But to your point, Shaolin, he
- 56:34everybody says that like he can just he just like or like he'll
- 56:36just go for, you know, 20-30 minutes, not even like at least
- 56:40it doesn't look like it's, you know, pre, pre rehearsed.
- 56:44He's just like talking. He's just like that.
- 56:46He just knows multi multidisciplinary, multifaceted.
- 56:48He can just touch on a lot of topics and really well
- 56:51articulate them well. Would it be nice to have leaders
- 56:56who actually know subjects rather than deciding all day
- 57:00long? Or an AD it'd.
- 57:02Also, be nice to have leaders under the age of 75 too.
- 57:05You know, maybe that would be fun.
- 57:08Yep. Yep.
- 57:10I mean with all go ahead, OK. You got it?
- 57:14No. I was just going to say I one
- 57:16thing conscious of his time, but Sean, you, you guys are doing a
- 57:19lot for medium on the side of, you know, the focus.
- 57:23We've talked about events previously privately.
- 57:27Would love for you to be able to share any of the stuff you're
- 57:28working on that you want to get out.
- 57:30I know there's an event happening in New York because I
- 57:32think there's, there's you're trying to be forward thinking
- 57:35and, and you can call out the conference if you want.
- 57:37I don't want to name the name. But again, going back to that
- 57:40point of like recognizing the old way of doing things is kind
- 57:43of done. This notion of like everybody's
- 57:44going to a big conference. It's like so much noise, all the
- 57:47things associated. And I thought that was an
- 57:49interesting dynamic of like how you're just thinking about other
- 57:52ancillary services and and products and businesses outside
- 57:56of for midium or tied to it, but not directly if you wanted to
- 58:00talk about. So I think that everybody who is
- 58:05watching this has to understand that when we at Firmidium are
- 58:11taking on untested clients, untested strategies, we're
- 58:15taking a risk too, right? We have to do tech build outs.
- 58:19We have to deal with perhaps certain individuals who don't
- 58:23have as much experience. You got to look at it from the
- 58:25service provider side as well. That being said, having been an
- 58:29emerging manager, albeit a little bit older when I did it,
- 58:31more experienced, I can empathize with the the hardships
- 58:38of being an entrepreneur at all levels.
- 58:40By the way, you know, I've got children and I, I understand how
- 58:43it is. So really when I really began to
- 58:48meditate over it, I just felt like, how can you be?
- 58:54I don't think just being a service provider is enough.
- 58:56We have to become partners in business, OK?
- 59:00And that means that not only am I providing you with good
- 59:02service, I'm helping you grow your business.
- 59:05And if I can help you grow your business, OK, that's going to
- 59:10benefit me, right? You're going to obviously, you
- 59:13know, the fees that we can, that we can charge obviously go up,
- 59:16but you're going to tell people about us.
- 59:18I mean, it's such a, a wonderful virtuous circle when I can help
- 59:23our clients grow their businesses that, that I don't
- 59:28know why more people don't do it.
- 59:30Now there are some nuances around that.
- 59:33I cannot favor a client, right? We're the accountant.
- 59:36We have to be unbiased. That is, you know, we are old
- 59:38school in that sense. So, So what?
- 59:41So then I really got to think about how can I create perhaps
- 59:44platforms that can help our clients and even be available to
- 59:49people who funds who are not our clients.
- 59:51You know, there might be different service levels and,
- 59:54and, and whatnot, but but nonetheless, how can I create a
- 59:57platform that can be available to the entire community?
- 1:00:00And so that was the genesis of our alts marketplace, Alts
- 1:00:04marketplace.com. And what it is, is the listing
- 1:00:08service where fund managers of all stripes, long short equity,
- 1:00:12it could be crypto mining, it could be global macro credit.
- 1:00:17Multi billion dollars, $15 million under manager.
- 1:00:19Everybody can list their fund, have a basic listing, make
- 1:00:23themselves visible to potential investors, have allowed those
- 1:00:30investors to kind of do some pre due diligence.
- 1:00:33So when they're coming to the manager, they can be pre
- 1:00:35qualified. And we're now complementing that
- 1:00:40with other aspects. For instance, if you have
- 1:00:42events, you can list them on our marketplace.
- 1:00:44If you have insights, you can post them on our marketplace,
- 1:00:47we'll distribute them. The reason we want to distribute
- 1:00:50your insights is because I think those insights are very valuable
- 1:00:53because so many people in this world do not understand what we
- 1:00:56do. We want to educate the end
- 1:00:59investor. And so I just see it as a win
- 1:01:02win. It helps me grow my marketplace.
- 1:01:04It helps you grow your business. I was telegrammed yesterday by
- 1:01:09someone who said, you know, I heard that you're looking to
- 1:01:12invest in a few interesting funds.
- 1:01:16We're actually on your alts marketplace.
- 1:01:18So what did I do? I looked it up and I have a call
- 1:01:20with them tomorrow. So this actually works.
- 1:01:23I'm using it. I think that other serious
- 1:01:27allocators really need to be using it.
- 1:01:30I will expressed a little bit of disappointment just to be honest
- 1:01:34with you with some of the allocators in not even wanting
- 1:01:37to look at digital assets. I feel that that is a breach of
- 1:01:41fiduciary duty based on all the conversations we've had on
- 1:01:45Bitcoin as an example. But nonetheless, I digress.
- 1:01:48I think that for people who want to be on the cutting edge, who
- 1:01:52are serious investors also marketplace as a fantastic duel.
- 1:01:55And the the last way I think that I can compliment that is
- 1:01:59again, I want to grow my community.
- 1:02:01I want to grow my community as service providers.
- 1:02:03I want to grow my community as fund managers and investors,
- 1:02:06high net worth investors and credit investors.
- 1:02:08So to that end, we are hosting dinners on behalf of Alts
- 1:02:13Marketplace members in various cities like Miami and New York
- 1:02:18and Los Angeles, where you know, I'll be in attendance as well,
- 1:02:22where you can pitch your strategies.
- 1:02:24And the beauty of this is because we're the accountant, we
- 1:02:27don't take any money for it. We don't take any money for any
- 1:02:29money raised. That is, we take money for
- 1:02:31costs. Of course, dinners are
- 1:02:33expensive, but we don't take any money for any money raised.
- 1:02:36If you raised $100 million on Alts Marketplace, I congratulate
- 1:02:40you. Please be my, please be one of
- 1:02:43our clients. It's very.
- 1:02:46Cool. I appreciate you bringing up the
- 1:02:48fiduciary stuff because we've been talking increasingly more
- 1:02:51with pensions and this notion we've thought about this, right?
- 1:02:54It's like, well, I don't have a strategy.
- 1:02:55It's like maybe that's a problem.
- 1:02:57You know, they're, they would bring up initially, maybe we get
- 1:02:59sued like they bring up, well, maybe we get sued.
- 1:03:00It's like, well, maybe you get sued for adopting or like
- 1:03:03thinking about Bitcoin. So maybe you get sued.
- 1:03:04If you haven't, you don't have a good response on why you don't.
- 1:03:07And I think the Wisconsin thing was a big deal because now
- 1:03:12everybody knows they're just dipping their toe.
- 1:03:13Nobody starts with 1.1% and something until like and so you
- 1:03:17don't hear it a lot. And I feel bad in saying it
- 1:03:19because it's obviously talking our book.
- 1:03:20We believe they need Bitcoin, but to hear it on the other
- 1:03:23side, it's like at a certain point it's going to be a breach
- 1:03:25and, and some people may get sued because they're like, why
- 1:03:27don't a it's going to be less about, I think why didn't you
- 1:03:31allocate it to me more of like, what is your version or what's
- 1:03:34your thesis on why you didn't allocate?
- 1:03:35And most people are not going to have a good answer or response.
- 1:03:38The answer that I typically get is I don't understand it and
- 1:03:42that the the answer that I respond is, isn't that your job?
- 1:03:48Yes, I mean we're. We're quickly reaching the
- 1:03:53point, if not already surpassed the point where I don't
- 1:03:56understand it is not going to cut it.
- 1:03:57To your point, Michael, I think investors who are putting their
- 1:04:02capital with people that are supposed to be fiduciaries,
- 1:04:05they're going to say you are not a good fiduciary of my money if
- 1:04:07you missed out on the the best performing asset of all time.
- 1:04:13And before we wrap up here, I know we have 10 minutes, but one
- 1:04:16question I'm generally curious to hear your response to
- 1:04:22Shaolin, is like what when it comes to managing fund admin for
- 1:04:29Bitcoin or digital asset focus funds, Like what are the biggest
- 1:04:32difference with these funds compared to traditional alt
- 1:04:35funds? I imagine due to the 24/7, 365
- 1:04:39nature of the markets that a lot of these funds trade in and the
- 1:04:44nature of the assets that they're trading adds a bit of a
- 1:04:47wrinkle to fund admin, yeah. Yeah, I mean, there's that,
- 1:04:51there's the 24/7 365, there's the fact that there are certain
- 1:04:56rules are not necessarily established.
- 1:04:58So we've had to make up the rules and standardize those as
- 1:05:02time has gone on. You know, we are, we speak to
- 1:05:04regulators as well and we explain to them how we're doing
- 1:05:07things and they're generally pretty cool with it.
- 1:05:09You know, Cayman's been a great friend of for Medium, as an
- 1:05:11example, the Cayman, the Cayman regulators, SEMA.
- 1:05:14So, so I think that is a challenge.
- 1:05:18I think that definitely the challenges are less going
- 1:05:23forward than and fewer going forward than they were in the
- 1:05:26previous cycle. The previous cycle was a bit of
- 1:05:28a mess. Unadulterated speculation, of
- 1:05:32course, that's great. You know, we like, we like that,
- 1:05:34but the lack of understanding on all sides of the requirements to
- 1:05:43properly run businesses, administer asset classes, I mean
- 1:05:48the whole, the whole 9 yards. A lot of the, the, the fund
- 1:05:52managers in digital assets are younger.
- 1:05:56They don't necessarily have Tradfi experiences.
- 1:05:59They don't understand concepts like best practices.
- 1:06:03I think that when you are attempting to go 100 miles an
- 1:06:06hour and achieve some a goal very quickly, things like best
- 1:06:14practices can seem like a hindrance.
- 1:06:17And what I always like to say is that it's better to go 60 miles
- 1:06:22an hour in the right direction than 100 miles an hour in the
- 1:06:24wrong direction. And I think that now that we
- 1:06:28have, you know, funds that are now being spun out, for example,
- 1:06:33from say larger, more established entities, you have a
- 1:06:38new generation of portfolio managers who understand these
- 1:06:41concepts more. People are a little bit older
- 1:06:44now. People have a little, maybe some
- 1:06:46people have a little bit of Gray hair Now.
- 1:06:48I do think there these things help and there is a sweet spot
- 1:06:52in terms of experience and type of experience that one can have,
- 1:06:57you know, to be a successful fund manager.
- 1:07:00I don't think that we were in that sweet spot in the previous
- 1:07:03cycle and we've seen a lot of fun shutter as a result, but I
- 1:07:07do think that we're in that sweet spot now.
- 1:07:13Yeah, the the days of giving your money to a crypto fund
- 1:07:18manager who has his Ledger under his bed, managing all your money
- 1:07:22or problem hopefully behind us, who knows there's probably still
- 1:07:25some out there doing it. Yeah.
- 1:07:30What do we think happens throughout the rest of this
- 1:07:34year? We've got the election, ETFs are
- 1:07:36picking up steam. We just had the having in April.
- 1:07:41What are our predictions tend the year?
- 1:07:48I, you know, it was kind of funny.
- 1:07:52I've kind of given up on understanding this environment
- 1:07:55now and I've kind of made the recent decision to just allocate
- 1:07:58my money out. So I have almost like the little
- 1:08:02internal fund of funds now. Maybe that's just what happens.
- 1:08:06I, I, I don't understand valuations to say in the S&P
- 1:08:11500I. I, I think NVIDIA and, and you
- 1:08:13know, these companies are great, great, great companies, but at
- 1:08:163540 times revenues, I, I don't understand.
- 1:08:20So the way my mind works is let me find an NVIDIA competitor.
- 1:08:23Maybe it's even in the private market.
- 1:08:25So let me fund that. It's actually something I'm
- 1:08:27doing. Can't mention the name, but, but
- 1:08:30you know, I, I, my personal mantra now is that I'm always
- 1:08:35looking for disruption and cutting edge investments.
- 1:08:38I'll even give you an example. I've been investing earlier this
- 1:08:44year in the Bitcoin D5 BRC 20 ecosystem.
- 1:08:49So I think, you know, if, if, if, if you, if you like Bitcoin
- 1:08:54then and, and we all do, why not try to find what else we could
- 1:08:58potentially do with Bitcoin? So, so that, that's how I'm
- 1:09:00looking at my personal investments now is things that
- 1:09:03are different, either, you know, disruptive, cutting edge, or
- 1:09:07have some sort of barrier to entry as far as markets go.
- 1:09:11Yeah, I, I, I'm, I'm a little bearish.
- 1:09:14I'm a little bearish. Not necessarily on crypto.
- 1:09:17I think crypto is going to have to take a breather and it has
- 1:09:20been taking a breather since April.
- 1:09:21I think that could probably last all summer long.
- 1:09:24But until we get a very definitive aggressive rate
- 1:09:30cutting cycle that takes the yield curve out of inversion
- 1:09:33into kind of a steepening mode, I am hesitant to take on too
- 1:09:38much risk personally. That's, that's kind of my
- 1:09:41personal view. That's old man's, you know, you
- 1:09:45know, Catholic preservation view, but that that's how I see
- 1:09:47it. Yeah, I think it's a complete
- 1:09:53crapshoot what's going to happen.
- 1:09:54Everybody's trying to surmise what your own pal's going to do.
- 1:09:59Notice I didn't. Answer the election question on
- 1:10:00purpose. Definitely dodged that one.
- 1:10:07I think it's safe to say it'll be chaotic and highly
- 1:10:10controversial. I think that's yeah, that's the
- 1:10:14I've got I've. Got a I've got a a ticket out of
- 1:10:18the country round about call that.
- 1:10:23Call that an option, huh? It's tough.
- 1:10:26Because you, you know you have to, you can't put your head in
- 1:10:29the sand. You have to be aware, but then
- 1:10:30you also have to have the same. It's like using both sides of
- 1:10:33the brain that you know you can impact, it can and you can't let
- 1:10:35it influence almost anything you do in a day-to-day running a
- 1:10:38business. And so it's just like these two
- 1:10:41parts that are like hard to hold to.
- 1:10:45I think where you're explaining, Sean, it's like it's like
- 1:10:48there's a, it's all out of our control.
- 1:10:51And even if we have an understanding of where we think
- 1:10:54it goes, it's still out of our control.
- 1:10:56But you got to pay attention at least enough to, to have to get
- 1:10:59on that flight if you need to. And then it can't really impact
- 1:11:02your business because that's how you a negative outcomes goes.
- 1:11:05You just have to build and work. You know, with the only thing I
- 1:11:10would say, yeah, 100 percent, 100%, you know, crypt crypto
- 1:11:13effectively will say it started when would you say guys, 2910,
- 1:11:18right? And even then it was being
- 1:11:19adopted as Bitcoin very, very early.
- 1:11:21So you know, we don't have a cycle, a a down cycle of
- 1:11:28understand, a macro down cycle of understanding for crypto.
- 1:11:32We almost had it. We kind of had it during COVID
- 1:11:38and then the monetary and fiscal authorities threw so much money.
- 1:11:44I was shocked. I mean, I was utterly stunned
- 1:11:47that you could have negative interest rates and throw that
- 1:11:49much. I didn't think that these things
- 1:11:50were even possible. As an Austrian, you like, you
- 1:11:53tend to be a rational sound thinker about money.
- 1:11:56You're just kind of like what the what are you doing?
- 1:12:00And so, you know, now we have an inverted yield curve.
- 1:12:04Now we have fiscal spending which is albeit high, not
- 1:12:08necessarily additive plus anymore unless they just run
- 1:12:11bigger deficits, which of course is possible running 1520%
- 1:12:14deficits, I guess that's possible.
- 1:12:16I'm not counting anything out at this point.
- 1:12:19But we haven't yet seen that, right.
- 1:12:21And so it feels, and we haven't had job like real sustained job
- 1:12:27losses during the crypto cycle that began in the early, you
- 1:12:34know, early 2000 tens, we'll call it.
- 1:12:37So the answer is we don't know, you know, we really don't know.
- 1:12:41And I, I, I don't know either. All I know is that as somebody
- 1:12:45who does have a little bit of capital, I can make 6% fairly
- 1:12:49safe, 10 percent, 12% if I take some of the liquidity risk,
- 1:12:53that's not too bad. I have my crypto, I have my
- 1:12:56speculative long term kind of investments around alts,
- 1:12:59Bitcoin, BTCL, twos, you know, things like that.
- 1:13:07But I think that there is going to be an opportunity where those
- 1:13:12of us who understand this asset class and who have dry powder
- 1:13:17can have tremendous opportunity. I am begging and waiting for
- 1:13:21some managers to be down 30 and 40% because I will be the guy
- 1:13:25standing there to write you a check.
- 1:13:27That's all I'm going to say. We you should just you know what
- 1:13:32you should do is when Bitcoin goes 3040%, you should just you
- 1:13:35can buy into the fun spot Bitcoin.
- 1:13:38That's what I'm actually have to plan on doing that guys.
- 1:13:41So I'm just waiting. I love it this has been.
- 1:13:46This has been awesome. Really appreciate your time on
- 1:13:49this Thursday afternoon here on the East Coast.
- 1:13:52Michael, Jesse, anything you guys want to end up with?
- 1:13:57No. Thanks for joining us all and
- 1:13:58look forward to finally meeting in person whether it's in Miami
- 1:14:00or or down in Southern Florida or New York or the next kind of
- 1:14:05event you guys are hosting. So appreciate you jumping on
- 1:14:08yeah if. I could just mention, you know,
- 1:14:10we're on Twitter, follow us at for Medium, we're on LinkedIn.
- 1:14:14Again, you can just look up for Medium and you can look up Alts
- 1:14:16Marketplace. We had mentioned a conference in
- 1:14:18New York that's going to be on September 12th.
- 1:14:21It's navigating the crypto frontier.
- 1:14:23It's going to be at Station 3, which is the largest Co working
- 1:14:27facility for blockchain AI in New York City in lower
- 1:14:29Manhattan. So you know, anybody who wants
- 1:14:32to reach out to me is welcome to reach out via LinkedIn or you
- 1:14:36can just hit me up at my e-mail. It's first name, last name at
- 1:14:39formidium.com, firstname.lastnameishouldsay@formidium.com.
- 1:14:44Yeah. It's worth, it's worth pointing
- 1:14:46out Shalin's super responsive has been insanely helpful since
- 1:14:48we started working with Formedia, made introductions, we
- 1:14:51have a came in fun coming live that mirrors our onshore trust,
- 1:14:55introductions to legal teams, the whole 9 yards.
- 1:14:57So I couldn't recommend Formedia more from all across the board.
- 1:15:00So it's worth reaching out. Appreciate it, gentlemen.
- 1:15:04Yeah. Shalin, thank you so much.
- 1:15:06This is awesome conversation to hear your whole whole journey
- 1:15:09and perspective on on markets and crypto and AI too.
- 1:15:14Yeah, thanks for having me. And yeah, the, the, the future's
- 1:15:18bright, everyone. I think that focus, being a
- 1:15:23sound mind, being a little bit stoic about things, I think
- 1:15:27these are the things that will help us all get through it.
- 1:15:30Yeah, there's light at the. End of the tunnel It's it's
- 1:15:33glowing I. Always believe that, yeah.
- 1:15:37All right. We'll see everybody next week.
- 1:15:39Thank you for joining us. Thanks, guys.
- 1:15:40Thank. You.
- 1:15:43Thanks for listening. To this week's episode of the
- 1:15:45show, if you found the information valuable, please
- 1:15:47share the episode with a friend or leave a rating on your
- 1:15:49favorite podcast app. All the links we discussed in
- 1:15:52today's show will be in the show notes inside your podcast app.
- 1:15:55Before we finish, a quick reminder that on Ramp Media is
- 1:15:57for informational and entertainment purposes only, and
- 1:16:00nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 1:16:03Regardless of where you are on your Bitcoin journey, we'd love
- 1:16:06to hear from you. Visit on
- 1:16:07rampbitcoin.com/contact. Schedule a consultation with one
- 1:16:11of our private client advisors.