Latest / The Office Politics Podcast with Fexingo: Workplace Dynamics, Influence, and Getting Things Done / Use the Decoy Effect to Win Office Decisions
Transcript
- Lucas: So we've talked about anchoring, scarcity, the contrast principle — but there's one cognitive bias that's especially sneaky because it doesn't feel like a trick. It just feels like... good judgment. Luna: Which one? Lucas: The decoy effect. Also called the asymmetric dominance effect. And the classic example — the one every MBA student learns — comes from The Economist back in 2009. Luna: Oh I remember this. They ran a pricing experiment. Lucas: Exactly. Here were the options. Option A: web-only subscription for 59 dollars. Option B: print-only subscription for 125 dollars. Option C: print plus web subscription for 125 dollars. Luna: And that print-only option — the 125 dollar one — is the decoy. Lucas: Right. Because nobody in their right mind would buy a print-only subscription for the same price as print plus web. But its presence makes the combo deal look dramatically better. When the print-only decoy was removed, most people chose the cheap web-only option. With the decoy, 84 percent chose the combo. Luna: That's a massive swing. So how do we use this at work without feeling icky? Lucas: That's the whole episode right there. Because the decoy effect isn't about lying — it's about framing. You're not hiding information. You're just making sure the choice you actually want is the one that looks like the obvious rational pick. Luna: Give me a concrete office scenario. Something I can use tomorrow. Lucas: Let's say you're a marketing manager and you need approval for a seventy-five-thousand-dollar CRM platform. Your boss is budget-averse. If you just ask for that one option, it's a yes or no vote — and 'no' is easy. Luna: So you need options. Lucas: Exactly. You present three. Option one: a basic CRM that does the bare minimum — twenty-five thousand dollars, but it won't integrate with your email platform and reporting is manual. Option two: the CRM you actually want — seventy-five thousand, full integration, automation, dashboards. Option three: a premium enterprise version for one hundred fifty thousand dollars that includes features your team of twelve doesn't need. Luna: And option three is the decoy. It makes option two look like the smart middle ground. Lucas: Exactly. Option one is too limited. Option three is overkill. Option two is just right. Your boss feels like they made a thoughtful choice, and you get the tool you needed. Luna: But what if your boss is sharp and calls you out on the decoy? Lucas: That's a fair risk. The decoy only works if it's a genuine alternative — not something obviously ridiculous. So the enterprise option has to be a real product that a different team might actually buy. If it's clearly a fake, you lose credibility. Luna: So do real research. Don't just make up a pricing tier. Lucas: Exactly. And the decoy doesn't have to be more expensive. It can be less capable. Remember the principle: the decoy is dominated by the target option on one key dimension — usually price or features — so the target looks superior by comparison. Luna: I've seen this work in reverse, too. At my old company, a product manager wanted to kill a feature. So she proposed three options: keep the feature as-is, remove it entirely, or replace it with a stripped-down version that would create more work for everyone. The stripped-down version was the decoy — it made 'remove entirely' look like the obvious win. Lucas: That's a great move. The decoy doesn't have to be a price anchor — it can be a time anchor, a resource anchor, a hassle anchor. You're shaping the decision landscape. Luna: Let's talk about the ethics for a second. When does this cross the line into manipulation? Lucas: I'd say two red lines. One: if the decoy is a phantom option — something you know won't be available. That's dishonest. Two: if you're using it to push a decision that genuinely harms someone else's interests. But if you genuinely believe option two is the best outcome for the team and the company, giving people a helpful comparison isn't manipulation — it's good decision architecture. Luna: Yeah, I think context matters. If you're a salesperson trying to upsell a customer into something they don't need, that's bad. If you're a project lead trying to steer a committee toward the most efficient solution, you're doing your job. Lucas: Right. And the research backs this up. In a 2018 study from the Journal of Marketing, researchers found that when decoys are used transparently — meaning people can see all three options and compare them — customers actually reported higher satisfaction with their choice. They felt more confident. Luna: Because they had a frame of reference. They could see what they were avoiding. Lucas: Exactly. So the decoy doesn't just steer choice — it reinforces that the right choice was made. That's powerful when you're trying to build consensus. Luna: Let's zoom out. How often do people actually use this in real office politics? I feel like most people just present one option and fight for it. Lucas: Most people do. And that's exactly why the decoy effect gives you an edge. When everyone else is making binary pitches — 'approve my budget, yes or no' — you're the one who walks in with three options and a clear recommendation. You look prepared, thoughtful, and collaborative. You're not demanding anything. You're inviting a decision. Luna: You look like a leader, not a beggar. Lucas: That's the frame. And it works in all kinds of meetings — budget reviews, project scoping, resource allocation, even hiring decisions. Luna: Hiring? Give me an example. Lucas: Say you're on a hiring panel and you really want Candidate A — mid-level, strong culture fit, reasonable salary. But the committee is split. Some want Candidate B — junior, cheaper, less experienced. So you add Candidate C — a senior expert who's overqualified, expensive, and might leave in a year. Candidate C is the decoy. Now Candidate A looks like the Goldilocks pick: not too junior, not too risky. Luna: But again, Candidate C has to be a real candidate. You can't invent someone. Lucas: Of course. But in most hiring processes, you do have a third candidate who applied. You're just putting them in the comparison set intentionally. Luna: That's smart. So the key takeaway is: never go into a decision with just two options. Always craft a third that makes your preferred choice look like the obvious winner. Lucas: That's the core tactic. But there's a nuance: you have to know what dimension your audience cares about most. For a budget-conscious boss, the decoy should make your option look like the best value. For a risk-averse boss, the decoy should make your option look like the safest bet. Luna: So you tailor the decoy to the decision-maker's priorities. Lucas: Exactly. You're not pushing a single button — you're designing the choice set so the path of least resistance leads where you want it to go. Luna: I think that's a really practical framework. And it's not about being sneaky. It's about being strategic. Lucas: Speaking of being strategic — you know, we've been doing this podcast for over a hundred episodes now, and it stays free because of listener support. If you've ever used one of these tactics to get a proposal approved or land a project you wanted, and you want to help keep the show ad-free, you can support us at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. No pressure at all, just if the show's added value to your career. Luna: Yeah, and that support genuinely lets us keep digging into these specific, actionable angles. Every coffee helps. Lucas: Alright, so let's wrap with one more application. The decoy effect also works in reverse — when you're the one being pitched to. Luna: How so? Lucas: If someone presents you with three options, pause and ask yourself: is one of these a decoy? Am I being nudged toward Option B? If you can spot the decoy, you can reframe the decision on your own terms. Luna: So it's a defensive tool too. Lucas: Exactly. The best negotiators know both sides of the table. So next time you're in a meeting and someone walks in with three neatly stacked options, don't just pick the middle one. Ask: what would I choose if the third option didn't exist? That's your real preference. Luna: Love that. So the decoy effect is about being intentional with options — both as the presenter and as the decision-maker. Lucas: That's the whole play. Thanks for listening, and we'll be back with another tactic next time.