Latest / Politics with Paul / Politics with Paul Podcast #10 - The Durability of American Political Parties
Transcript
- 0:00Alrighty.
- 0:01Welcome back to the politics with Paul podcast with your host, Paul Reeder.
- 0:06Today, we're gonna talk about the durability of the American political parties, specifically
- 0:12the Democratic and Republican party, although with a little bit of history even before how we
- 0:17know them today.
- 0:18So the Democratic and Republican parties have been around for a very long time.
- 0:24The Democratic Party's existence can be traced back to at least the ratification of the US
- 0:29constitution when it was known as the Democratic Republican Party.
- 0:34And the Republican Party today has only been around since the 18 fifties, and it filled the
- 0:39vacuum left by the Whig Party, which filled the vacuum left by the Federalist Party.
- 0:46But even though it seems like more and more people these days are dissatisfied with the
- 0:51Democratic and Republican parties, including some of their own members, parties are still
- 0:56just as robust as ever, and people gravitate toward 1 or the other even when they describe
- 1:03themselves as independent, not everybody, but a lot of people do.
- 1:06So why is that?
- 1:08Why are these parties such mainstays of the American political system?
- 1:14Well, let's dive in.
- 1:15So at first, it makes sense to dive into why parties even exist in the first place.
- 1:20And this book right here, why parties, it's it's it's a dark cover, so it might be hard for
- 1:27you to see.
- 1:28But it's, why parties by John Aldrich, which is a great in-depth look at the reasons parties
- 1:35not only exist in American politics, but why they are as strong as they are.
- 1:40So first, we need to understand what exactly is a political party.
- 1:45And that might sound like a very obvious question, but one way to define it is that it's
- 1:51a group of people with similar views and preferences that band together to achieve
- 1:56specific goals.
- 1:58And the reason we need to know that is because there's plenty of incentives for people to form
- 2:02these parties.
- 2:03It's generally much harder to achieve your policy goals if you don't have a coalition,
- 2:08especially with what you call pork barrel legislation, which is legislation that refers
- 2:12to projects that only benefit a specific district or several districts.
- 2:17If you don't have a party, there's a lack of organization, and there's too many competing
- 2:22interests without a party.
- 2:24And, also, the majority party can usually pass whatever bill they want as long as there's not
- 2:29a significant amount of infighting.
- 2:31So there's a lot of reasons why you would want to get into a party.
- 2:37Also, you form parties because it's much easier to mobilize voters that way.
- 2:41Voters identifying with either the Democratic or the Republican party often turn out at much
- 2:48higher rates than independence do, and party and identification gives voters a clue as to
- 2:55what your policy stances are.
- 2:57Now, obviously, not every democrat is the same and not every republican is the same.
- 3:01There's variations to how much they support their party's typical platform, but those
- 3:08democratic and republican labels give you at least a heuristic to give you a general sense
- 3:13of what they think about things like abortion, guns, those sorts of things.
- 3:19And, also, lots of politicians are ambitious.
- 3:22And if you're ambitious, you're trying to climb the ladder, you're not gonna be able to do that
- 3:27without a party.
- 3:28You wanna become speaker of the house or majority leader or a a whip in in the case of
- 3:35if you're the minority party, if you wanna become the minority party leader.
- 3:38Obviously, you're hoping to be a majority party leader eventually.
- 3:42But any of those kinds of things that you're you're trying to get to become top or near the
- 3:47top, you're gonna need a party to do that.
- 3:50Independence do not get up there.
- 3:53So even if we were all to agree that party suck and they must be thrown out with the trash,
- 3:59it's not happening.
- 4:00There's too many incentives for people to join up with the party, and the affiliation with the
- 4:06party is ingrained in a lot of people, whether because it's how their parents work.
- 4:10My dad was a my mom and dad were democrats.
- 4:13My mom and dad were republicans.
- 4:16Or because of the friends they affiliate with, may maybe they they get to college, and their
- 4:20college friends really influence their views a lot.
- 4:23Whatever the case may be, those views are ingrained in them.
- 4:26And not to say that they can't possibly change those views over time, but the affiliation with
- 4:31party is very hard to break.
- 4:33So if you wanna get rid of parties, well, that's don't count on it, basically.
- 4:39So now onto the origins of parties, parties are nowhere to be found in the US constitution, and
- 4:45founding fathers did not envision political parties.
- 4:49But they quickly gravitated to them under the US constitution.
- 4:53A lot of people talk about how founding fathers would have never wanted political parties and
- 4:59technically true, but they were also instrumental in their formation.
- 5:05Even George Washington who famously spoke out against political parties was unofficially, he
- 5:11was a federalist.
- 5:12He often sided with Alexander Hamilton.
- 5:14Yes.
- 5:15That Alexander Hamilton, as opposed to Thomas Jefferson on a lot of policy matters.
- 5:20Not always, but on a lot of policy matters.
- 5:22So he is sometimes considered a federalist even if he never actually declared himself as one.
- 5:30And speaking of which, those original two parties were the Federalist Party and the
- 5:35Democratic Republican Party.
- 5:36Federalist Party being born out of those strong supporters of the US constitution, replacing
- 5:41the articles of the Confederation, which is which was the original governing document of
- 5:47the American government.
- 5:49Well, the big reason why they what chose to have a new US constitution replace the articles
- 5:57of articles of confederation is because of the need for a strong central government, whereas
- 6:03the Democratic Republicans were born out of those anti federalists who were highly
- 6:08skeptical of the US constitution and strongly supported the articles of confederation because
- 6:12they were very wary of a strong central government.
- 6:17They wanted the states to retain most of those powers.
- 6:20And now, obviously, under the US constitution, states do still have a lot of those powers, but
- 6:25not nearly as much as they did under the articles of confederation.
- 6:28And when you break down the philosophies of the original parties, you have Federal's party.
- 6:33Their strength was in the northeast amongst the mercantile classes, strong centralized
- 6:38government, including support for a national bank.
- 6:41They were also pro British in their economic ties, which, you know, looking back way after
- 6:47the fact, that might sound crazy.
- 6:49You just shed yourselves of the British and became a free country away from Britain, why
- 6:56would you wanna tie yourselves at the hip, so to speak?
- 6:59Some somebody might see it that way.
- 7:02But they're talking strictly economics.
- 7:04They saw Britain as the more reliable economic partner versus, say, a France.
- 7:10And for them, there is a lot of support for implied powers of the US constitution.
- 7:15Those powers that weren't necessarily in the US constitution, but at least were, at least
- 7:21according to them, inferred by the constitution to be a power of the federal government.
- 7:27Whereas the Democratic Republican Party, they were strong in the south amongst the agrarian
- 7:33classes.
- 7:34They were skeptical of strong centralized government and wanted more power for the state
- 7:38governments.
- 7:39They were also pro France as opposed to bro pro Britain.
- 7:44And for them, they eventually became supporters of the US constitution, but they were very much
- 7:51explicit powers of the US constitution only.
- 7:53They saw implied powers as giving too much power and influence to that centralized federal
- 8:00government.
- 8:01So that was the beginning of the history of the party system, and US political history is often
- 8:07broken up into multiple party systems.
- 8:09And most of these are democrat versus republican.
- 8:13There's actually several democratic versus republican systems that are considered to be in
- 8:18existence at one time or another.
- 8:21There's not necessarily full agreements as to when exactly these eras begin and end, but
- 8:27there's general estimations.
- 8:28So this first party system was the federalist versus the democratic republicans.
- 8:33Democratic Republicans come to eventually support the US constitution.
- 8:38Federalists start experiencing a lot of major struggles, controversies, scandals, including
- 8:44the Alien and Sedition Acts under John Adams, the 2nd president of the United States, which
- 8:49targeted those with democratic republican views, especially those with pro France
- 8:54sentiments.
- 8:55Jefferson and the democratic republicans defeated the federalist in 1800, and there was
- 9:00a landslide reelection in 1804, and that really helped to tank barrelist power along with the
- 9:09federalist opposition to the Louisiana Purchase and the war of 1812, war of 1812 being with
- 9:15Britain who federalists supported having more economic ties with, and there was a lot of
- 9:22federalists in fighting, which included the death of Alexander Hamilton at the hands of
- 9:27Aaron Burr in a duel.
- 9:29Hamilton hated Burr so much even though they were both federalists that he'd rather help his
- 9:35political arch nemesis, Thomas Jefferson, win an election as opposed to Aaron Burr.
- 9:41So that led to a lot of enmity, although that wasn't the only reason, there was enmity
- 9:46between those two men.
- 9:48And controversy over the Hartford Convention of 18/14, federalists saw a crisis for their
- 9:54party.
- 9:56And, eventually, a moderate federalist won out over the more militant federalist, including
- 10:04Aaron Burr, trying to get several New England states to secede and form their own nation.
- 10:10And, again, even though more federal more moderate federalists won out with their
- 10:14proposals, the secrecy and potential of secession from the convention led to further
- 10:21decrease in federal support, and they would cease to exist sometime in the 18 twenties.
- 10:27And so for a while, there was only, a one party system in America, the Democratic Republican
- 10:33Party, but that leads to the second party system where the Democratic Republican Party is
- 10:39then reshaped by Andrew Jackson when he becomes president, and the Whig party soon forms in
- 10:46retaliation against them.
- 10:47Whig party was an amalgamation of wildly different policy interests, but the thing that
- 10:55really united them was their hatred of Jacksonian democratic philosophy.
- 10:59Democratic Republican party becomes the democratic party.
- 11:04And, although the wigs would win a couple presidential elections, but the winning
- 11:09candidates died shortly into their terms.
- 11:11I guess, sort of a foreshadowing of the short lived existence of the Whigs.
- 11:17William Henry Harrison, famously only 1 month into his presidency, dies.
- 11:24Vice president John Tyler takes over, finishes that term.
- 11:27Later on, Zachary Taylor wins a presidential election, dies something like 9 months into his
- 11:35tenure, and then is replaced by Millard Fillmore.
- 11:38The thing that would really break the wigs apart was the slavery issue, which had only
- 11:44become more and more intense in term the debate over slavery had become more and more intense,
- 11:52more and more toxic.
- 11:54Anti slavery remnants from the Whigs and the Democrats would go on to form the Republican
- 11:59Party in the 18 fifties.
- 12:01And the Whigs still were technically in existence when the Republicans started forming,
- 12:06but they would eventually completely cease to exist in the 18 fifties.
- 12:10So third party system is when the Republican Party is born in 1854 out of a meeting in a
- 12:17little schoolhouse in Ripon, Wisconsin.
- 12:20And the 2 parties would obviously, it's not the only thing, but they would primarily butt heads
- 12:25over the slavery issue.
- 12:27Their first Republican presidential candidate, John c Fremont, lost in 1856, and the Whigs
- 12:33still, competed in that election, but they weren't really even close to winning.
- 12:39But in 18 60, Abraham Lincoln would win.
- 12:43Civil war happens in 1861 to 1865 for various reasons, but slavery being one of the biggest
- 12:50reasons contrary to what a lot of people wanna say.
- 12:53It wasn't just slavery, and it also wasn't about states' rights either.
- 12:59There was a it was a lot more complicated than that, but slavery was a big component of why
- 13:04the civil war happened.
- 13:06And this period from the civil war and especially in the in the immediate post war
- 13:11years in the era known as reconstruction, the federal government in federal government
- 13:16elections, Republicans mostly came out on top, although less so towards the end, they won 7 of
- 13:2210 presidential elections.
- 13:25US senate control for the vast majority of the time was also Republican, and US house control
- 13:29initially belonged to Republicans for a lot of the time, but Democrats started to take more of
- 13:35those US house elections or control in those US house elections from the mid 18 seventies to
- 13:41about the mid 18 nineties.
- 13:43And that's when we get to the 4th party system where the republican party comes to claim a
- 13:49very tight grip on federal government power.
- 13:53A lot of the success in federal politics in 1894, they gained a 130 seats in the US house,
- 14:00give or take a few.
- 14:03William McKinley wins the presidency in 18 96 and then is reelected in 1900, although he's
- 14:08assassinated shortly into his second term.
- 14:11And they also gained 9 seats in the US senate in 18/98 to hold 53 of what was then 90 total
- 14:19seats because it wasn't 50 states then.
- 14:21We still have a few states that were territories at the time.
- 14:24The only time of democrat control in this era that's generally considered a 4th party system,
- 14:31so roughly 1894, 18 96 to 19 32.
- 14:35Democrat Woodrow Wilson became president from 19 13 to 1921.
- 14:40US house control was, under democrats from 1911 to 1919, and then US senate control from 1913
- 14:47to 1919.
- 14:48But other than that, republicans dominated federal politics at the time, and this era was
- 14:53also marked by the progressive era of widespread social and political activism and
- 14:59reforms.
- 14:59And perhaps most notably from those reforms was the 16th amendment, which instituted income
- 15:06tax, and the 17th amendment, which instituted the direct election of US senators.
- 15:11At the time, state legislatures chose US senators.
- 15:15But then you get into 1932, which is the 5th party system, or some might say the 9th the 19
- 15:2230 election was kind of a precursor to that.
- 15:25Franklin Roosevelt and the Democratic party sweep into power, in the wake of the great
- 15:30depression.
- 15:31FDR wins 4 presidential elections, and that's prior to the limit from the 22nd amendment on
- 15:37presidential tenures, ushers in the new deal.
- 15:40The coalition is named after that.
- 15:43Democrats thoroughly dominate the federal government from 1932 through the 19 seventies.
- 15:48They win 7 of 11 presidential elections, win or maintain control of US house and US senate in
- 15:55every election except for the 1946 and 1952 election.
- 16:00You also see the civil rights era and the Vietnam War and the subsequent protest of that
- 16:07conflict.
- 16:08But at the time, what may which may seem crazy to think about today, but at the time, there
- 16:13wasn't a lot of ideological distinction between the parties.
- 16:17There were a lot of conservative democrats.
- 16:19There were a lot of liberal republicans.
- 16:21And this actually led the American Political Science Association in the 19 fifties to
- 16:27publish a report that lamented the lack of what they would consider a meaningful difference
- 16:32between the two parties.
- 16:35Be interesting to see to know what the people of the American Political Science Association
- 16:40then would have thought about the ideological distinction between the parties today, but the
- 16:46end of the 5th party system is probably the most debated of the party system eras.
- 16:52There's lots of debate about when exactly the 6th party system began.
- 16:57Some scholars would place it in the late 19 seventies or even 1980 when Republican Ronald
- 17:02Reagan won his first term as president.
- 17:07But in any case, the seeds for it began back in the late 19 sixties when the party started
- 17:12becoming more ideologically distinct, more of what you see today.
- 17:17Particularly with republican Barry Goldwater's 1964 presidential bid against Linden Lyndon b
- 17:23Johnson.
- 17:25Unsuccessful, but he really hammered home his conservative philosophy, influenced
- 17:30conservatives for generations to come.
- 17:33There was a realignment of southern Democrats that started to begin where they started
- 17:36shifting into the Republican Party, and coalition started to take their time to really
- 17:44sort out into their parties that you see today.
- 17:49Whereas in previous elections, you saw these coalitions form a lot more quickly.
- 17:55This one was much slower, and you also saw the religious right become a political force,
- 18:02especially in the 19 eighties.
- 18:04And one of the things that really distinguishes the 6th party system from the several previous
- 18:11ones was the fact that control between the Democratic or Republican parties was barely
- 18:17even.
- 18:18You know, there's democrats had their fairs their fair share of success.
- 18:24Republicans had their fair share of success.
- 18:26So now that leads into some debate about whether we're now in a 7th party system.
- 18:31Did the election of Donald Trump in 2016 assure in a new party system with a more durable
- 18:38change in the coalitions of the 2 main parties?
- 18:42Probably not gonna know until later on down the road.
- 18:44It's hard to know when an era is fundamentally changing for an extended period when you're in
- 18:49the middle of it.
- 18:51But if Trump loses in 2024 and his general philosophy starts to lose favor across the
- 18:56Republican Party in the in the years to come, it might be hard to argue that we're in a 7th
- 19:02party system.
- 19:03But, again, it's gonna take a little while before we can really say for certain.
- 19:07Yeah.
- 19:08I have a bit of a hindsight as 2020 kind of mindset there.
- 19:12So we might be in the 7th party system now, might not be, depends on who you ask.
- 19:16So we talked about how the federalist party ceased to exist, then the wigs fill that
- 19:21vacuum.
- 19:22They would cease to exist, And then the Republican party came into existence, and
- 19:28they've stuck around, and the Democratic party has been around this whole time.
- 19:32So why have the Democratic and Republican parties in particular been so durable besides
- 19:37the aforementioned incentives to forming them?
- 19:41Well, one of the reasons is that they become increasingly effective at building up party
- 19:45operations.
- 19:45The democrats and republicans have state and county affiliations in every state and county
- 19:51or county equivalent in the United States, and they have very sophisticated infrastructures
- 19:56for reaching out to and mobilizing these voters.
- 20:01Back in the very early days, didn't exactly have that kind of thing.
- 20:05Didn't have these well oiled machines of mailing out to voters or TV advertisements,
- 20:14those sorts of things.
- 20:15You didn't really have that in the very early days of the US and even in the early days of
- 20:22the conflicts between the Democratic and Republican parties.
- 20:24But over time, those kinds of operations built up, and now you see what they are today, and
- 20:31they're very well oiled machines.
- 20:34But you also have what's known as Duverger's law.
- 20:37It's not an actual law.
- 20:38It's more of an axiom, I guess.
- 20:41But, basically, political systems with single member districts, plurality voting system tend
- 20:46to favor 2 parties.
- 20:48Or in more layman's terms, if it's just one person who gets the most votes wins, it's
- 20:54typically gonna be 2 parties that duke it out for that seat the vast majority of the time.
- 20:59You contrast that with places like a lot of European countries that have proportional
- 21:05representation systems that use multi member districts.
- 21:08Multiple plea multiple people can win a seat in a district based on how much of the vote that
- 21:14party wins instead of being a winner take all scenario where it's just the one person that
- 21:19wins and everybody else gets nothing.
- 21:22Whether that's the better way to do things or not, that's that's up to you to decide.
- 21:26We're not trying to get into the debate about that.
- 21:30But Duverger's law basically says, in the case of a system like American politics, typically,
- 21:38it's gonna be 2 parties duking out.
- 21:40Not not that other parties can't contend for a few seats here or there.
- 21:45They're not gonna be a potent political force, at least not for a for an extended period of
- 21:50time.
- 21:51And then also you've just got basic voter psychology.
- 21:55Typically, especially those in group, out group dynamics.
- 21:58My group is great.
- 22:00Your group sucks.
- 22:01Or even they might think their group sucks, but they don't say that out loud to other people.
- 22:05They're too busy being antagonistic to other groups.
- 22:09And we and there there it's ingrained in all of us.
- 22:12There's there's a desire to wanna be part of a group.
- 22:16So it it happens to all of us.
- 22:18But even amongst democrats and republicans, many of them vote against the other party
- 22:24instead of for their own.
- 22:27And so you we we all have a little bit of that in group out group dynamic.
- 22:32It's it's about whether we actually recognize that and try to correct that a bit.
- 22:37But you see that a lot in politics and for in the case of Democrats and Republicans, you see
- 22:43a lot of that in group, out group dynamic, and it helps to have really kept the conflicts
- 22:50between those two going.
- 22:52But another thing to consider when we're talking about durability of the parties is we
- 22:57have several context that we consider, and political scientists typically think about it
- 23:03as party and electorate versus government versus organization.
- 23:08Party and electorate, party in government, and party in organization.
- 23:13Now it's typically democrats versus republicans and all those context.
- 23:16But when we say party in electorate, we're talking about the voters.
- 23:20Party in government is elected officials, and party in organization is talking about those
- 23:26party entities at the federal state and local levels that work to get their voters to turn
- 23:31out and get their candidates elected.
- 23:33So XR County Republicans, Orange County Democrats, Texas, and New York respectively in
- 23:41those cases.
- 23:43Those kinds of entities that don't aren't actually elected officials, and they're not
- 23:50just regular voters.
- 23:52The ones who are actually on the ground trying to get their candidates elected, that's party
- 23:56in organization.
- 23:58Now, again, it's typically democrat versus republicans in both of those or in all of those
- 24:03context, but party might be weak in one context, but strong in another.
- 24:11And by that, we just mean weak as in the ties to parties might not be as strong in comparison
- 24:19to another context.
- 24:20So for example, we see more and more independence, self identified independence in
- 24:27the voting population.
- 24:28So we can argue that the party in the electorate is weaker, but we see very few
- 24:36independence in elected office.
- 24:38So we see a lot of strength in party and government.
- 24:41And, also, the strength and durability of these parties can and often does differ in the
- 24:48context of federal versus state level politics.
- 24:50So democrats are quite strong in Maryland, but they're pretty weak in Wyoming.
- 24:57Republicans are quite strong in Florida, but they're pretty weak in Hawaii.
- 25:03They just all have their own different strongholds and then how strong the parties are
- 25:08in the electorate versus organization versus government and still differ for each of those
- 25:13states.
- 25:14Or even, you know, getting it into the weeds a little bit further, They strengthen durability
- 25:20of the parties can differ based on localities, cities, counties.
- 25:24So a lot of this has focused on the democrat versus republican conflicts.
- 25:30But what about independence and third parties?
- 25:32How have they factored into the system?
- 25:34So I am going to shamelessly plug my own book.
- 25:37This is actually an old cover.
- 25:38The cover is different now.
- 25:40But why independents rarely win elections and how they could become more competitive?
- 25:45It talks about a lot of those ways that independents and third parties factor into the
- 25:50system.
- 25:51And by end up in this in this context, independence being those who don't have a
- 25:54party.
- 25:55So people who don't have a party and third parties, how are they factored into it?
- 26:00So some tidbits from the book is that third party elected officials used to be much more
- 26:06common in the US.
- 26:07They're a lot less common post World War 2, but some state governments still have a surprising
- 26:12number of independence and third party elected officials.
- 26:17Vermont has the Vermont progressive party, which would otherwise probably be democrats,
- 26:24but they are still their own party.
- 26:27Maine's also got a lot of well, not a lot, but they have a fair number of independent or third
- 26:34party elected officials much more than you would see in most other states.
- 26:42But independence and third parties have been increasingly hampered by election laws over
- 26:46time, which has strengthened the Democratic and Republican parties.
- 26:51One way that independents and third parties have been hampered is that independent
- 26:55candidates often have much tougher ballot access hurdles to make themselves to even make
- 27:01themselves an official candidate.
- 27:02And when we talk about ballot access, we're talking about the laws that govern how a
- 27:06candidate even gets on the ballot in the first place to have their name actually printed on
- 27:12the ballot.
- 27:13So there's 2 ways 2 basic ways that candidates get on the ballot.
- 27:16They either have to get a certain number of petition signatures from potential voters,
- 27:22people who can actually vote on that on that race, or there's a fee that you pay that's
- 27:30however much money depending on what the office is.
- 27:33So an independent candidate often needs far more petition signatures than a democrat or
- 27:40republican does.
- 27:41Sometimes 7, 8, 9 times as many signatures.
- 27:46And in the case of money, oftentimes that that fee is not even available, or if it is, it
- 27:53might cost more than it would for a democrat or republican.
- 27:57And then in the case of 3rd parties, they need a certain amount of support in petition
- 28:02signatures to become a ballot qualified party.
- 28:05Ballot qualified mean candidates on the ballot can actually run under that label.
- 28:09So if a libertarian party in a state is ballot qualified, that means people can actually run
- 28:16under that libertarian party label.
- 28:18But that that's not all that's not always the case.
- 28:21Not every state has a libertarian party as a ballet qualified party.
- 28:28But that's the most new that's the most common third party, and then you also see a little
- 28:33less common, but the green and constitution parties would be the next most common third
- 28:38parties, and they face similar hurdles as well.
- 28:42But independence aren't always middle of the road.
- 28:46And by independence, in this case, I'm talking about people who don't identify with the party.
- 28:51Examples being US senators Bernie Sanders of Vermont and Angus King of Maine, both caucusing
- 28:56with Democrats, oftentimes voting on Democratic lines.
- 29:02And in many cases, independence and third parties are simply seen as spoilers, quote,
- 29:07unquote, who siphon votes off from either the Democrat or the Republican candidate or both.
- 29:13And a lot of that is because of Duverger's law.
- 29:16And then even when independence, when non party or or third party candidates have made some
- 29:23noise, they tend to fizzle out pretty quickly.
- 29:26Ross Perot in 1992 made a very strong push, didn't win any electoral votes, which is what
- 29:32you really need, but he did win, I wanna say, 20,000,000 popular votes.
- 29:37Ran again in 1996, didn't have nearly as good of a showing.
- 29:413rd parties over the course of American history have sometimes made fairly strong pushes for
- 29:49the presidency, but in the next presidential election, they're either completely gone,
- 29:54nowhere to be found, or they've have a paltry level of support compared to what they had had
- 30:00previously.
- 30:02Probably the most successful third party candidate was when Theodore Roosevelt ran back
- 30:09in 1912 because he was dissatisfied with his former protege William Taft, didn't feel that
- 30:16he was progressive enough.
- 30:17So after Theodore Roosevelt left office in 19 09, he comes back to try to take down William
- 30:26Taft, and the amount of support that he siphoned off from Taft is the biggest reason
- 30:32why Woodrow Wilson, a democrat, became president and was also a progressive himself.
- 30:39So but other than that, hit Theodore Roosevelt's Teddy Roosevelt's whole Moose
- 30:45Party, They were strong in 1912.
- 30:49I don't know if they even competed in 1916.
- 30:52I have to I don't remember.
- 30:54I'd have to check that again.
- 30:55But even in those kinds of cases, third parties and nonparty candidates, their ability to
- 31:02meaningfully contest an election is often short lived.
- 31:06So that leads us to the future of American political parties.
- 31:12Again, you're never going to get rid of the political parties even if that was if we all
- 31:17even if we all agreed that that was for the best or if we could say objectively, parties
- 31:23need to go.
- 31:24It's not going to happen, especially the Democratic or Republican parties.
- 31:27There might be some there will be third parties that come and go, but there's too many
- 31:32incentives to for people to form parties.
- 31:34There's too many incentives to join the Democrat or the Republican party.
- 31:38They're too ingrained in the political culture at this point.
- 31:41And even if you attempted to get rid of them, there's first amendment concerns.
- 31:45It's a matter of respeech, of petition, of assembly.
- 31:50Those 5 well, not so much the religion part, but freedom of press, religion petition
- 31:58assembly speech in the first amendment.
- 32:02Those would all be a concern if you were to actually try to get rid of the parties.
- 32:06If there was a meaningful or not a meaningful, but there if there was an actual strong push to
- 32:12get rid of the parties, you run into all those issues.
- 32:15And one might say, well, look at how many people have a negative opinion of those
- 32:20parties, even people within those parties.
- 32:23Surely, they're going to break at some point, but they haven't yet.
- 32:27And they still often get a lot of support from people who have the mindset of the, quote,
- 32:32unquote, lesser of 2 evils.
- 32:34And some of these people are are democrats or republicans, but they just don't wanna admit
- 32:39it.
- 32:40So parties are gonna be around for a long time.
- 32:42Now maybe they'll become weaker, and that's not to say that independents and third parties
- 32:48can't win elections.
- 32:50They do.
- 32:51That's why my book is why independents rarely win elections, but there's a lot of things that
- 32:58need to change for them to be more consistently competitive.
- 33:02So for the foreseeable future, it's the democrats or republicans that are going to keep
- 33:06duking it out for the vast majority of elections.
- 33:10So they are twice durable regardless of any regardless of how negative how negatively
- 33:19people view them.
- 33:21So But in any case, that's it for today's episode.
- 33:26Thank you so much for listening.
- 33:28As always, gonna end you off on a random question of the day.
- 33:32And that random question is, are pop tarts good?
- 33:37Now I'm under the impression that I have an unpopular opinion about this because anytime I
- 33:42hear about them, people talk about how great pop tarts are.
- 33:45But I'm just gonna say it.
- 33:46I'll talk to suck.
- 33:47Now to be fair, I haven't had a pop tart in a while, but I found them incredibly bland and
- 33:54dry regardless of how they're made.
- 33:57I really do not get what the big deal about pop tarts are.
- 34:02Now if this this debate might not mean anything unless you're a a younger person.
- 34:08One of them, some tarts have been around for quite a while, so it probably doesn't really
- 34:12matter that much about what your age is.
- 34:13But I think that they're grossly overrated and that they're gross.
- 34:18But, you know, it's at the end of the day, obviously, it's it's about your tastes and
- 34:26tastes are subjective.
- 34:27Unless they're my taste, which are obviously objective and completely correct.
- 34:32And if you don't share them, you're wrong.
- 34:34Of course, I don't.
- 34:36I don't actually mean that.
- 34:37Or do I?
- 34:38Anyways, that's enough for today's episode.
- 34:41Once again, thank you so much for listening.
- 34:43You can find me on Facebook, Paul Raider, comma, author and speaker, LinkedIn, medium.
- 34:50If you wanna book me on your own podcast, I have a profile on matchmakerfm.
- 34:55And my website, paulrader.org.
- 34:58And I have more information about those about that media and the actual links in the
- 35:03description in the episode.
- 35:05Please like, comment, subscribe, and share these episodes with people you know, and I
- 35:11think that's it.
- 35:11So once again, thank you so much.
- 35:14And until next time, take care.