Latest / Science Behind the Glass: illuminating the human side / Hidden voices: How language impacts science with Valeria Ramirez
Transcript
- 0:01Who are the characters behind science? This is
- 0:04Science Behind the Glass, Illuminating the Human
- 0:06Side. In this podcast, we unveil the human side
- 0:11of laboratories and science. Scientists share
- 0:14personal experiences and we discuss their meanings
- 0:16from different perspectives and fields of research.
- 0:22Disclaimer, this is a translated version using
- 0:25AI voice for the guest. Welcome to Science Behind
- 0:30the Glass, Illuminating the Human Side. the podcast
- 0:33where we break down the barriers between language
- 0:35and science to make it accessible to everyone.
- 0:38Today, we have the honor of welcoming Valeria
- 0:41Castaneda, a Colombian researcher with an impressive
- 0:44background in evolutionary biology and scientific
- 0:47communication. Valeria is a PhD candidate in
- 0:51integrative biology at the University of California,
- 0:55Berkeley. She previously studied at the National
- 0:57University of Colombia. and holds a master's
- 1:00degree in biological sciences from the University
- 1:03of Los Andes. She also earned a master's in scientific
- 1:07communication from the University of Barcelona,
- 1:09which has allowed her to promote science as an
- 1:12inclusive tool, free from language barriers.
- 1:15In today's episode, we will focus on how the
- 1:18dominance of English in science can create exclusions
- 1:21and barriers, and what we can do to build a more
- 1:24inclusive and diverse scientific landscape. Valeria,
- 1:28thank you very much for accepting this invitation
- 1:30and for being here with us. Hi, lovely to be
- 1:34here. Thank you so much for the invitation. What
- 1:37an honor. To start off, tell us what inspired
- 1:40you to pursue evolutionary biology. And what
- 1:44exactly is evolutionary biology and herpetology?
- 1:48Also, what was there a key moment in your life
- 1:51that led you down in this path? How do you end
- 1:54up connecting these with science communication?
- 1:57Wow, that's a whole lifetime story. Let's start
- 2:00with what is evolutionary biology? Basically,
- 2:04evolutionary biology is about understanding the
- 2:07history of organisms, why they are the way they
- 2:09are, where they live, why they behave and interact
- 2:12the way they do. It's about understanding why
- 2:14we see them the way we do. So it's kind of like
- 2:17studying history, but of creatures that aren't
- 2:20human. I got into evolutionary biology because
- 2:23I really enjoyed the university class on the
- 2:25subject and I was also deeply interested in the
- 2:28philosophy of science. The development of evolutionary
- 2:30biology is very tied to the history of science,
- 2:34especially in Europe, and it sort of arose as
- 2:37a rebellious response to creationist worldviews.
- 2:39So, it started developing ideas about how organisms
- 2:43are historical entities, that they have a past,
- 2:46and that they are related to each other. I was
- 2:48really drawn to that theory. I loved understanding
- 2:51how theory and biology are deeply connected to
- 2:55philosophy. That fascinated me. Herpetology came
- 2:59later. The word herpeto actually comes from a
- 3:02root meaning monster, and herpetology is the
- 3:05study of what were once thought of as monsters,
- 3:07what we now know as reptiles and amphibians.
- 3:11I got into it because of a university class where
- 3:14I was randomly assigned to be the person in my
- 3:16group responsible for frogs. That meant I had
- 3:19to go out and collect and search for frogs. This
- 3:22happened during a field trip to the Colombian
- 3:24Pacific, in Nambi, Norino. And, it was incredible.
- 3:28Being around frogs, being able to touch them
- 3:31and see them through a new lens, it was magical.
- 3:34I found them beautiful. So, I thought, I want
- 3:38to study the evolutionary biology of frogs. But
- 3:41for one reason or another, I ended up studying
- 3:44the evolutionary biology of the creatures that
- 3:46eat frog snakes. So now I love snakes. I really
- 3:50like snakes. They inspire beautiful feelings
- 3:53in me, especially in terms of empathy because
- 3:55there's so much fear, even hatred, around snakes.
- 3:59That's why I also really like to name them, to
- 4:02talk about them as beautiful beings who deserve
- 4:04to live in this world. So yes, snakes are very
- 4:08dear to me. I love them. And the last question
- 4:11was, how does this relate to English and science?
- 4:14It connects because I was doing my master's in
- 4:17Columbia on snakes that eat frogs. And at the
- 4:21end of the program, as is usual, I had to submit
- 4:24my thesis. Everyone, my classmates and also the
- 4:27professors, kept insisting, write the thesis
- 4:30in English, it's better that way, you'll be able
- 4:32to publish faster, and so on. And I really did
- 4:35try, like, with all my strength, to write the
- 4:38thesis in English. But at that time, it was absolutely
- 4:41impossible for me. I couldn't even get past a
- 4:44single sentence in English. So I said, well,
- 4:48I still have to graduate, so I'm going to write
- 4:51it in Spanish. And I did. But during that internal
- 4:55struggle, like, why do I have to write it in
- 4:57English if it frustrates me so much if it's not
- 5:00my language? That's when I started developing
- 5:02thoughts about how unfair it felt for me to be
- 5:05expected to write in English. And it also made
- 5:08me realize how much easier it must be for native
- 5:10English speakers to write and succeed as scientists.
- 5:14From there on, I started noticing more and more
- 5:17of these inequalities throughout my academic
- 5:19path. At the public university where I studied
- 5:22in Colombia, we were often assigned readings
- 5:24in English. And I saw so many people, including
- 5:27myself, struggling not to understand the science
- 5:30but to understand the English. That's a huge
- 5:33additional barrier we face when learning science
- 5:35in Colombia. That's when I started forming these
- 5:38ideas, and later I pursued a master's in science
- 5:41communication, which helped me develop them in
- 5:43a more formal way. Yes, what you are saying is
- 5:46incredibly important because I'm sure your experience
- 5:49resonates with so many people from non -English
- 5:53-speaking countries. And in my own personal case,
- 5:56like you mentioned, I really struggle. Through
- 5:59my undergrad and postgraduate studies, all the
- 6:02literature, all the theory on evolution. All
- 6:05the scientific articles were in English. And
- 6:10for me, at that time, it was my partner who helped
- 6:13me, almost like teaching a small child. He would
- 6:17sit down with me and read scientific articles
- 6:22or papers in English so patiently. But I know
- 6:25so many people don't have that kind of support.
- 6:28Reading an entire article or paper in a foreign
- 6:32language is like doing the triple work. And translating
- 6:36it is even worse. It's not just putting it in
- 6:40Google Translate. It has to make sense. It has
- 6:43to mean something. There is also a matter of
- 6:46lost opportunities on a professional level. For
- 6:49example, I didn't want to go to an English -speaking
- 6:51country. I wanted to stay in my comfort zone.
- 6:54But then I started stepping outside of it and
- 6:58thinking, well, I really have to write this thesis
- 7:00in English. It was a huge challenge for me and
- 7:04it's still... And it still is for many people.
- 7:07And that's one of the biggest barriers imposing
- 7:09developing countries. Students want to apply
- 7:11for scholarships abroad, sometimes not even in
- 7:15English -speaking countries. But they are still
- 7:18required to have English proficiency because
- 7:21English is a dominant language, especially in
- 7:23science. And those language exams, they're absolutely
- 7:27expensive and ridiculous. And they end up taking
- 7:31away opportunities from students. So now that
- 7:34you have shared with us some of these personal
- 7:37barriers, we know you have faced many challenges
- 7:40in communicating your research in another language,
- 7:43specifically in English. Yet, despite all that,
- 7:47you decided to pursue your PhD in the United
- 7:50States. What made you choose the U .S.? And what
- 7:56are the emotional challenges you face in your
- 7:59work, especially as a Latin American woman? Well...
- 8:03I don't think I chose the country in the sense
- 8:05of I want to live in the United States. It was
- 8:08more like, here I have a work opportunity that
- 8:11allows me to work with Colombian species. Because
- 8:14something I've always tried to do and still strive
- 8:16for is this, research in Colombia is difficult,
- 8:19but I want to research Colombia. I don't know
- 8:22how else to say it, but I hope that makes sense.
- 8:24Even though I'm not there. But thanks to funding,
- 8:28you have the opportunity to continue researching
- 8:30in Colombia. even if the funds came from abroad.
- 8:34Exactly. So I said, wherever they'll accept me
- 8:38with a project on Colombian species, even if
- 8:41it's in the US or Europe, I'll go. And that's
- 8:44how it happened. I've continued working during
- 8:47my PhD on the same snakes I studied in my master's.
- 8:51What happened was that my thesis advisor here
- 8:53in the US said, yes, come with that project and
- 8:56develop it here. And I said, Yes, I want to,
- 9:00because truly, I wanted to do science that helps
- 9:03me understand the creatures from that territory.
- 9:05And also to stay connected with that space, because
- 9:08I think I remain deeply connected to the place
- 9:11where I was born. So that's why I decided to
- 9:13come to the United States. It gave me that opportunity,
- 9:16and I kind of just went for it when it came along.
- 9:19What has it meant to be a Colombian woman, etc.?
- 9:22Many things. Many tough lessons, but also a lot
- 9:25of love and support from the Latino community.
- 9:28which I deeply value and who have carried me
- 9:31through really difficult times. Many of us here
- 9:33left our homes, so we end up building new families.
- 9:36I have a new family here. The hard part is that
- 9:39our new families also graduate from their PhDs,
- 9:43and then they leave. So it's also a temporary
- 9:46space. It feels like this ongoing wave of migration,
- 9:49people arriving and leaving, arriving and leaving.
- 9:53So there's this fluidity in our families. But
- 9:56building that family far from home has been something
- 9:59beautiful and really important for me. Still,
- 10:02American universities and honestly the whole
- 10:04US context have a long way to go in terms of
- 10:07accepting and understanding that this is already
- 10:09a Latin space. The US is already a Latin country.
- 10:13In California, for example, around 40 % of the
- 10:16population is Latino or the children of Latino
- 10:19immigrants. And they bring cultures and values
- 10:22that come from what we call Latin America. Yet
- 10:25despite that, universities don't even have their
- 10:28official websites translated into Spanish, which,
- 10:31to me, is absurd. They don't really offer support
- 10:35for Latino students. For example, I came here
- 10:38as a migrant, there are many ways to migrate,
- 10:40and I came as a PhD student with a visa. But
- 10:43many of the students here are children of first
- 10:46-generation migrants, many of whom are farm workers.
- 10:49And in those families, there's no reference point
- 10:52for anything academic. So when they enter university
- 10:56and see it full of white, privileged kids whose
- 10:59parents are often professors at the University
- 11:01of California, it's jarring. And because it's
- 11:04the U .S., there's this strong culture of comparison
- 11:07and individualism. So these students constantly
- 11:10feel like they're being compared. They feel literally
- 11:13like they're stupid. And they've told me this
- 11:16because I talk a lot with them and try to collaborate
- 11:18with them. They've told me directly, I feel inferior.
- 11:23I feel dumb. This happens a lot here, not only
- 11:26with undergrads but also at the PhD level. I
- 11:30personally went through a deep depression in
- 11:32my third year. I had to come to terms with the
- 11:34fact that I didn't feel welcome. That was just
- 11:37the environment here. And even if I tried to
- 11:40feel more at ease to belong, I felt like in order
- 11:43to be accepted, I would have to change. I'd have
- 11:45to be white. I'd have to be American. And I wasn't
- 11:49willing to make those changes. I can't, I literally
- 11:52can't look any different. Coming to terms with
- 11:55that was also a lesson. Science itself carries
- 11:58these values. And that was hard for me to realize,
- 12:01that even biology, which I love so much and has
- 12:04meant so much to me, carries within it values
- 12:07I no longer appreciate. Values of exclusion.
- 12:11Values that I hope will change someday, but they're
- 12:13still there. That led me to keep thinking about
- 12:15English and science, and about what it really
- 12:18means to do fieldwork. What is fieldwork? And
- 12:21to top it all off, and I really want to name
- 12:23this here because I think it's important to honor
- 12:25him, a colleague of ours, Gabriel Trujillo, was
- 12:28murdered while doing fieldwork. And the way the
- 12:31department responded, I don't think it was adequate
- 12:34considering the impact that event had on all
- 12:36of us. Gabriel was indigenous. He was racialized.
- 12:40And for us, as Latinos in the department, it
- 12:43was incredibly painful to witness how the situation
- 12:46was handled. It's been really hard. I do hope
- 12:49the universities will take stronger action, but
- 12:52it's also been exhausting to keep pushing against
- 12:54the current. There's always this balancing act.
- 12:57What can I do? What can I take on emotionally?
- 13:00How much can I endure without responding? So
- 13:04yeah, it's been a heavy process. Absolutely.
- 13:07Especially the things you have already lead.
- 13:10But for someone to be murdered and for that event
- 13:14not to receive the attention or importance it
- 13:16deserves, that kind of neglect makes the discrimination
- 13:20feel even heavier. What you mentioned is so important
- 13:24because, yes, unfortunately, science has perpetuated
- 13:27this discrimination. That's one of the reasons
- 13:30we do this podcast bilingually, so we can create
- 13:33channels of communications that remind us we
- 13:36don't live on a different planet. We live on
- 13:39the same planet. But as humans, we have built
- 13:42these barriers, not only linguistic, but also
- 13:45geographic. Our idea is to bring people closer,
- 13:48to help everyone to see that we actually have
- 13:50more similarities than differences. We are more
- 13:53alike than we realize. We share a lot in common
- 13:57with people from different places, like Australia
- 14:00or the United States. A nationality is just a
- 14:03label. At the end of the day, we are all human.
- 14:07We are all the same species. Of course, we also
- 14:09have differences, and that's beautiful. But sadly,
- 14:12science has built walls, and that's why we want
- 14:15to expand this conversation, to help people realize
- 14:18that scientists are not from another world. They
- 14:20are people, too. They go through challenges,
- 14:23different ones than people in other professions,
- 14:26but it's just as real. As human beings, we live
- 14:30through hard things like the ones you have experienced,
- 14:33for example. The absence of equality and inclusion.
- 14:37I was lucky. But for example, when I spent five
- 14:41months in Finland, I started to feel depressed.
- 14:43I didn't feel comfortable where I was. I didn't
- 14:46feel included. I felt what I was doing was more
- 14:49like a manual labor than real research. Thankfully,
- 14:53I had a family in Colombia. My mom even told
- 14:56me, come back. But then there is a social pressure.
- 14:59You will be a failure if you quit. You will fail
- 15:02if you say no. And then someone who always has
- 15:06been very important to me, my undergraduate supervisor,
- 15:09asked me, what are you doing over there? Come
- 15:12back. Who is going to live that experience? You
- 15:15are. No one else is going to live that for you.
- 15:18Later, I came to Australia and I always say this.
- 15:22I will repeat it again and again. I believe that
- 15:2690%, even 99 % of the success of the PhD comes
- 15:30down. to your supervisors because they become
- 15:33your family. I was very lucky with my supervisors.
- 15:37But it's not easy. You are in a place completely
- 15:40different from your own. You build new families,
- 15:44like you said, but these families also live.
- 15:46So I think it's important to share with our audience
- 15:49that the people working in science, those working
- 15:52for biodiversity and knowledge, and also go through
- 15:56these challenges, especially not just in terms
- 15:59of language. Now that you mention it, let's move
- 16:01on to the topic of scientific publishing standards
- 16:04and science communication, which most of the
- 16:07time is in English. How do you think this affects
- 16:09the ability of scientists from non -English speaking
- 16:13countries to share their knowledge? What kinds
- 16:15of barriers does it create? Well, to answer your
- 16:19question, I usually talk about four main ways
- 16:21that English impacts science. The first, as you
- 16:24mentioned before, is the disadvantage non -native
- 16:27English speakers face. when participating in
- 16:30science. A good example is my own experience,
- 16:33the difficulty I had writing in English. The
- 16:36second is the breakdown of communication between
- 16:39science and the 95 % of the world that doesn't
- 16:42speak English. That's a huge gap. And what you're
- 16:46doing with this podcast, making it bilingual,
- 16:48is exactly the kind of thing we need. At least
- 16:51that way, science can reach new spaces and audiences.
- 16:55But the truth is… 95 % of people can't read science
- 16:59in their own language. So, what happens when
- 17:02science isn't published in English? It doesn't
- 17:04reach the mainstream. Or worse, it's undervalued.
- 17:08Third, when we're learning science, we're also
- 17:10learning English at the same time. And learning
- 17:13both is not the same as learning just one. It
- 17:16requires a completely different set of skills,
- 17:18and of course, that creates new and different
- 17:21barriers. And finally, There's a lack of understanding
- 17:25that language is deeply tied to knowledge itself.
- 17:28Language is a cultural process that allows us
- 17:31to observe the world. It shapes how we perceive
- 17:34things. So, someone who speaks a different language
- 17:37than you doesn't just say things differently.
- 17:39They see and understand the world differently.
- 17:42And that's a beautiful thing. It shouldn't be
- 17:45a problem. It should be something we embrace.
- 17:47That's why it's so important to protect languages.
- 17:51That's why revitalizing endangered languages
- 17:53matters, because they hold knowledge that's been
- 17:56built over thousands of years. They tell us about
- 17:59the creatures in a territory, about concepts
- 18:01of time, about space. That absolutely affects
- 18:05science. If we do all science in English, we
- 18:08create what some call monolingual epistemologies.
- 18:11What that means is that all knowledge is shaped
- 18:14by a single language. And when that happens,
- 18:17there are things we can no longer name in the
- 18:19same way. we can't observe them the same way.
- 18:22We can't feel them the same way. We lose pieces
- 18:26of the world, pieces of its observation. To me,
- 18:30that's one of the biggest problems with English
- 18:32as the hegemonic language of science. And going
- 18:35back to your question, why is it so important
- 18:38to publish in other languages? Or what happens
- 18:41when we're forced to publish only in English?
- 18:43Well, for one, we disconnect from society. But
- 18:47more importantly, we create very real disadvantages.
- 18:51For example, we recently released a preprint
- 18:54with an Australian researcher, Tatsuya Amano.
- 18:57One of our findings was that non -native English
- 19:00speakers publish fewer papers in English, but
- 19:02often more overall. That is, they publish a lot
- 19:05of science in their own language, and sometimes
- 19:08more than native English speakers. They're producing
- 19:11a lot of knowledge, but it's not being valued
- 19:13because it's not in English. And that also means
- 19:16regional knowledge isn't being valued. So, who
- 19:20matters? Who is science for? It ends up undermining
- 19:24the importance of the contextual, the regional,
- 19:26and the local. Of research that looks at the
- 19:29small stuff which actually isn't small at all.
- 19:31What we call global is often just the US and
- 19:35Europe. But that's not truly global. That's just
- 19:38another region of the world. If you publish a
- 19:41paper about a neighborhood in California in English,
- 19:44It's considered important. But if you write about
- 19:47a neighborhood in Bogota and publish it in Spanish,
- 19:50it won't be seen the same way. But that neighborhood
- 19:53matters just as much. So the language we publish
- 19:56carries political weight. It tells us which worlds
- 19:59are worth researching and which aren't. It tells
- 20:02us who science is meant to reach and who it's
- 20:05not. To me, all of this is political. It speaks
- 20:09to inequality. Colonial inequality. Global inequality.
- 20:14And in a place like Colombia, it's also a social
- 20:17inequality. Because the people who can afford
- 20:19to learn English are the ones who went to bilingual
- 20:21schools, who had the money to pay for English
- 20:23courses. So ultimately, it's also a class issue.
- 20:27A social issue in countries where English isn't
- 20:31the first language. And those inequalities? They
- 20:34just keep piling up one on top of the other.
- 20:36There's something you said that's really important
- 20:38about the need to preserve languages. And actually,
- 20:41Dr. Ana Maria Cheto, whom I mentioned to you
- 20:45earlier, also talk about this. She explained
- 20:48how science started, how scientific publications
- 20:51were originally written in the author's native
- 20:54language, whether it was German, French, or English.
- 20:58And something else she mentioned was that when
- 21:01the model shifts with industrialization during
- 21:04the Industrial Revolution, science itself also
- 21:07becomes industrialized. Scientific communication
- 21:10through journal articles began to serve the purpose
- 21:14of updating others on the current state of science.
- 21:17But eventually, that shift too. Knowledge became
- 21:20a kind of currency, traded for prestige for impact
- 21:24factor. And like you said, when something is
- 21:27published in a native language, it doesn't have
- 21:30a high impact factor, a number, then it's considered
- 21:34worthless. So the value of knowledge gets lost
- 21:37in the process. And that makes us, as scientists,
- 21:41question, are we still sharing knowledge or are
- 21:45we just producing articles to maintain this economy
- 21:48of prestige? Your work advocates for science
- 21:51to be more accessible and equitable. You have
- 21:54already mentioned many things, but what changes
- 21:58would you like to see in the current model? And
- 22:00what motivates you to keep fighting for inclusion
- 22:03and diversity in science, technology, engineering,
- 22:06and mathematics? Well, I'd like to see a lot
- 22:09of changes. But maybe I'll start by saying why
- 22:13I keep doing this work. First, I don't think
- 22:15I have much of a choice. I'm a scientist and
- 22:18I also experience these inequalities. So as a
- 22:22scientist who lives these inequalities just by
- 22:24doing science, through my presence, through my
- 22:27opinions, I'm already exercising a different
- 22:29way of seeing the world. But also, I genuinely
- 22:32believe that the values that currently guide
- 22:34science, values rooted in colonialism, patriarchy,
- 22:38and capitalism won't allow humanity to survive
- 22:41in the long term. Right now, science is very
- 22:44aligned with sectors I find troubling, like the
- 22:46military, for instance. Or here in the US, science
- 22:50is deeply tied to the pharmaceutical industry.
- 22:53And while I'm not saying that medical development
- 22:55isn't important, here it's largely about capital
- 22:58accumulation. There's no real public healthcare
- 23:01system, for example. So the alignment of science
- 23:04with those kinds of power structures? I think
- 23:07they ultimately won't help us move towards a
- 23:09future where everyone, as you said, can enjoy
- 23:12their own bodies, enjoy their territories, and
- 23:15imagine a future they belong to. And that's the
- 23:18direction I want to go in, a place where a different
- 23:21future is possible. From my position as a scientist,
- 23:25that means I have to help change science. I have
- 23:28to. It has to become something else. It needs
- 23:31to think differently. It needs to align with
- 23:34different communities. It needs to imagine new
- 23:37futures for different people. Some scientists,
- 23:40for instance, have goals like deeply understanding
- 23:42a specific species, say a certain snake. And
- 23:46I think that's beautiful. But my personal goal
- 23:48goes beyond that. Even though I love snakes,
- 23:51what drives me most is imagining a more diverse
- 23:54science, doing science with others. That's where
- 23:57I'll keep putting my energy. As for more concrete
- 24:00changes, especially about English and science,
- 24:03there are simple things that scientific journals
- 24:05still aren't doing. For example, journals could
- 24:08allow or encourage the use of AI tools to translate
- 24:11papers more quickly. Many people are already
- 24:13doing this. I translate all my articles into
- 24:16Spanish myself. But those translations end up
- 24:19buried in the supplementary material. No one
- 24:22knows they exist. The journals don't even include
- 24:25a note saying, this article is also available
- 24:28in Spanish. That's the bare minimum, in my opinion.
- 24:32Reviewers could also require that if a study
- 24:34was conducted in a place like Colombia, at the
- 24:37very least it should be translated into the local
- 24:39language. That seems like a basic standard. Of
- 24:43course, there are challenges. I work in the Amazon
- 24:46now, and there are many indigenous languages
- 24:48spoken there. I haven't yet been able to translate
- 24:51all my papers into every Amazonian language.
- 24:54That's still a massive task. But even if we can't
- 24:58do all of them, we can do some. That's already
- 25:01something. And what you're doing, bilingual podcasts,
- 25:04bilingual or trilingual conferences and seminars,
- 25:07that's the kind of initiative we need more of.
- 25:09We need to expand the accepted languages of science.
- 25:13And we need to recognize what scientific education
- 25:16looks like in other languages. We need to make
- 25:19sure students are really understanding the material,
- 25:21not just memorizing foreign terms. We need to
- 25:24create opportunities for researchers to be valued,
- 25:27even if they publish in their native language.
- 25:30or in multiple languages. All of this can be
- 25:33done without a complete revolution. These are
- 25:36small shifts. We already have the tools. We just
- 25:40need the will. And many people are trying. But
- 25:43what's missing is a broader willingness from
- 25:45those in power. Because what we realize as we
- 25:48advance in science is that, yes, there is such
- 25:51a thing as scientific power. And the people in
- 25:54those positions of power, they're usually native
- 25:57English speakers. So it doesn't even occur to
- 26:00them that this might be an issue. So we need
- 26:03to create more decision -making spaces for other
- 26:05people. We need to value different ways of doing
- 26:08science, of doing academia. For example, in this
- 26:11paper I'll send you, we found that compared to
- 26:14a native English -speaking cisgender man, women
- 26:17publish less. Non -native English -speaking women
- 26:20publish even less. And women from countries with
- 26:23lower socioeconomic indices publish even less
- 26:26than that. That's what we call intersectionality,
- 26:29how different forms of inequality compound depending
- 26:32on your background. And that shows up directly
- 26:35in scientific production. So we need to open
- 26:37up alternative ways of valuing science. Because
- 26:40women, for example, are the ones doing most of
- 26:43the service work in universities. They carry
- 26:46the emotional and caretaking labor. They're also
- 26:49the ones publishing in non -English languages.
- 26:51They're doing a lot of science communication.
- 26:54And none of that gets valued as science. But
- 26:57it is science. Because science should communicate.
- 27:00It should flow back and forth with society. And
- 27:04it should also care for the people who do science.
- 27:06So we need to start rethinking how we value scientists.
- 27:10That's something we could start doing right now.
- 27:12And yet we haven't. One concrete thing? Translate
- 27:16our scientific papers into the languages spoken
- 27:18where the research was done. We already have
- 27:21tools. AI now translates things much faster than
- 27:24before. So it's possible. Could you share an
- 27:28anecdote that really marked you? And I know you
- 27:30must have many from your journey as a scientist.
- 27:33Something that inspired you to keep going despite
- 27:36the obstacles. Let's see. I'll start with something
- 27:39that's been very important for me. Understanding
- 27:42that our families are extended. That your friends
- 27:44are also your family. And among my friends, many
- 27:48of whom are scientists too, they support me,
- 27:50they give me arguments, they help me out. Like,
- 27:53if I couldn't figure out how to run our code,
- 27:55someone would be like, Come on, I'll help you.
- 27:58So that chosen family becomes a source of support.
- 28:01We walk together. It's like that phrase, make
- 28:04comrades, not competitors. For me, it's about
- 28:08making friends along the way and looking out
- 28:10for each other. That's been so important. Also,
- 28:14more and more, I've been drawn towards an interdisciplinary
- 28:16path, blending biology with the social sciences
- 28:19and rethinking academic work in more integrative
- 28:22ways. And in that process, my friends from other
- 28:25disciplines have been fundamental. Sometimes
- 28:28I feel a bit like an outsider in biology, like
- 28:31I'm too interested in things that my peers don't
- 28:33focus on. But my friends in other fields remind
- 28:36me of the value of what I do. They cheer me on,
- 28:39they tell me, this is important work. So even
- 28:43if I sometimes feel like the black sheep of biology,
- 28:46my friends are there, encouraging me. Especially
- 28:49my fellow biologists from the global south, like
- 28:52my Colombian friends. They really value this
- 28:54work. They support me. Including you, thank you.
- 28:58That's part of why I'm here today. They recognize
- 29:00that I'm talking about problems that resonate
- 29:02deeply with many of us, that affect us all. When
- 29:06I started speaking publicly about English and
- 29:08science, so many people reached out, not just
- 29:11with solidarity, but also with pain. They'd say
- 29:14things like, this happened to me too. I left
- 29:17science because of the language barrier. I've
- 29:20also had awful experiences. Or, thank you for
- 29:24saying it, I didn't know how to name it, and
- 29:26I needed to hear it out loud. That's been so
- 29:28moving. One beautiful outcome is that I've started
- 29:32getting more and more interested in linguistics.
- 29:34It shares a lot of similarities with evolutionary
- 29:37biology, which I think is super cool. Through
- 29:40that, I discovered some incredible thinkers.
- 29:43One I want to recommend is Yasnaya Aguilar, a
- 29:46brilliant linguist and thinker. She's my And
- 29:50she lives in the territory we now call Mexico.
- 29:53She's extraordinary. Please read her blog. She
- 29:57doesn't write heavy academic articles. She writes
- 30:00for everyone. She writes beautifully. She publishes
- 30:04in newspapers, she has books, and she even has
- 30:06a podcast. Excellent. And to wrap up, what advice
- 30:11would you give to scientists, especially those
- 30:13facing cultural and linguistic barriers in their
- 30:15careers? I'd say two things. First, Never feel
- 30:20bad for using the tools that are out there. Use
- 30:22chat GPT. Use every translation tool available.
- 30:26For example, I used to struggle so much with
- 30:29writing emails in English. I didn't know the
- 30:32cultural norms. In Colombian Spanish, we're very
- 30:35formal. It's all cordially. Through this communication,
- 30:38I inform you. But in English? I had no clue.
- 30:42Since chat GPT came along, I've been like, chat
- 30:45GPT, write me an email like this. Here's what
- 30:49I need to say. Help. And I know some people approach
- 30:52tools like that with guilt. But no, get over
- 30:55the guilt. This is the only way we can level
- 30:58the playing field in a very unfair game. So use
- 31:01them. They're your tools. Second, understand
- 31:05that what you're going through is the result
- 31:07of structural injustice, not your personal failing.
- 31:10I did interviews with students at universities
- 31:13in Colombia and one thing that kept coming up
- 31:15And that really hurt was hearing them call themselves
- 31:18stupid. They'd say things like, I can't do it.
- 31:21I'm dumb. I'm too slow. And it was heartbreaking.
- 31:26These are students who've gone through so much,
- 31:29who've survived so much. They're brave, smart,
- 31:33and valuable like anyone else in the world. And
- 31:36all of that pain came from not being able to
- 31:38understand English. They'd say, I can't read.
- 31:42Or, I'm dumb because I take too long. And I just
- 31:45wanted to scream, please don't talk to yourselves
- 31:48that way. Treat yourselves with kindness. We
- 31:52need to understand that these are structural
- 31:53inequalities that affect all of us, not a reflection
- 31:57of our worth. These are violent systems of power.
- 32:00So my message is, never again call yourself slow
- 32:03or stupid. Many of us have been there too. We're
- 32:06walking this path with you. And we're here, together,
- 32:10to support each other as we navigate this life.
- 32:14Yes, you're right. You're not alone. There are
- 32:16many of us who have walked this path before and
- 32:19we are still walking it. And for a lot of people,
- 32:23it is not easy. It is not easy to leave home,
- 32:25to go to a place where your family isn't, where
- 32:28your language isn't spoken. Sometimes you just
- 32:30want to talk to a friend, not in English, but
- 32:32in your language. That's why it is so important
- 32:35to have a community, to seek out connection,
- 32:38to never ever be ashamed of where you come from.
- 32:42On the contrary, you should feel privileged.
- 32:45I said that with all my heart. Be proud of where
- 32:48you come from. Be proud of your experiences.
- 32:51And never compare yourself. That's so important.
- 32:53Never compare. Valeria, thank you so much for
- 32:58sharing all these amazing stories with us. Your
- 33:00insights, your personal experiences, your knowledge.
- 33:03This episode was inspired by the courage to question
- 33:06the status quo and to open new paths towards
- 33:09a science that is more inclusive, diverse, and
- 33:12human. Valeria's journey reminds us that science
- 33:15is not only about generating knowledge. It is
- 33:18about recognizing the voices, languages, and
- 33:21realities that have historically been excluded.
- 33:24She invites us to imagine and build a future
- 33:26where doing science doesn't depend on the language
- 33:28you speak or the place you come from, but on
- 33:31your passion for understanding and caring for
- 33:34the world we inhabit. This episode is dedicated
- 33:36to Gabriel Trujillo. And to all scientists who
- 33:39have lost their lives doing science, we want
- 33:42our audience to remember that not all scientists
- 33:45work in laboratories. Many venture in the field,
- 33:48crossing jungles, climbing mountains, or exploring
- 33:51remote ecosystems, sometimes risking their lives
- 33:54to collect data, protect a species, or simply
- 33:57to better understand our environment, our world.
- 33:59Being a scientist goes far behind the stereotype.
- 34:03And here we honor that deep admiration and respect.
- 34:06We hope this conversation has led you with a
- 34:08new perspective. I encourage you to keep asking
- 34:12questions, building community, and defending
- 34:14equity in every corner of knowledge. Because
- 34:17change begins with those who dare to ask, what
- 34:20if science could be different? Science Behind
- 34:23the Glass, La Ciencia Detrás del Cristal, is
- 34:26an independent produced and edited podcast hosted
- 34:28by Linda Hernandez and Danides Guerra. With the
- 34:32invaluable support of our technical director,
- 34:35Rafael Giordano, and original music by our colleague
- 34:38and friend, Bernardo Aguirre. Follow us on Instagram,
- 34:41X, Facebook, TikTok, and LinkedIn. And visit
- 34:44our website for more studies, resources, and
- 34:46updates. Don't forget to subscribe and share
- 34:49this podcast with your friends, colleagues, and
- 34:51community to amplify these essential conversations.
- 34:54If you enjoyed this episode, we invite you to
- 34:56support us with a contribution via PayPal. Just
- 34:59click the support us button and our website.
- 35:02Your support is vital for this project to keep
- 35:05growing. Thank you for listening. Keep questioning,
- 35:08sharing, and celebrating science made from every
- 35:10corner of the world. Until next time.