Latest / Pedagogically Speaking / 10 Teaching Lessons We Learned Watching the World Cup
Transcript
- Ilana: Every four years, millions of people become football or soccer experts. We started watching for the goals, but before long we realized we were seeing incredible examples of learning, teamwork, leadership, assessment, feedback, and classroom culture. Today I want to share the things that every teacher can learn from the World Cup. Some people think number five is controversial, but it's 100% true. Welcome back to Pedagogically Speaking. My name is Lana Huffer. I've been a teacher for 16 years and I'm currently an inclusive education teacher. And this is a space where I hope that we can learn from each other Let's get into it. The first lesson is that nobody learns without making mistakes. Even on the world stage, with the best male soccer players in the world this year, mistakes are made. Players are missing penalties, they miss passes, and they're missing their chances. And Yes, we can absolutely see the frustration of those missed opportunities play out in different ways on the soccer field, just like in the classroom, but no player ever wants to get subbed off when they're frustrated. You know, they don't say they don't want to do it anymore, they can't do it anymore. They keep taking those chances, they keep trying, they stay in the game. And that is a really valuable lesson for students. Think about it. A game is all about trying to figure out how to win, how to accomplish a goal. the strategies change with each team you play. So you have 90 minutes to try different strategies. Adjust the adjust the strategies you use to keep trying. To get a goal. Well, a lot of that time, just like in The World Cup final match. Let's try that again. Well, a lot of the time, just like in the Men's World Cup final match, it's spent figuring those things out and not necessarily getting what you want out of it, which is a goal. At school, students often think that a mistake means failure. Students have this belief. That they should just learn something immediately and be able to move on. And you know, that looks like when you're teaching sentence structure or paragraph structure and students getting frustrated because they just wanna be done and get it over with, and you're giving them things that they need to revise or showing them what they've missed. or you know, it's in math class when students need to understand the strategy. To be able to apply it correctly in order to get an answer. You know, and that does take a lot of time. And even after they start understanding it, it takes a lot of review and repetition, right? And I think this Men's World Cup was really good for identifying that. You know, even though you might not get that goal, you are absolutely learning. You're learning what's working and what doesn't work. You're learning more things about the players that you're playing against. And yeah, okay, sometimes it can feel when a goal isn't scored that you know the team isn't doing well on the outside, right? Like people watching the game. But a lot of the success in ho in soccer does happen before the goal is even scored. And I find often that students, they don't realize when they go from not knowing or not understanding like a concept or something that they're learning to mastering it. unless it's pointed out to them by like a peer or or you or they see it in a quiz, right? And so I think that's just that's a really important parallel. Lesson two, I think kind of piggybacks on that where you know the most important learning is is often invisible. You know one thing that struck me when I was watching the World Cup was how much of the game really is invisible. Yeah, we celebrate the goal scorer. We know who made the assist. Their names are on the sheets. They're the ones that people remember, but goals don't just happen. They start with the defender making like an amazing interception, a midfielder finding the space, someone making a run that pulls two of the defenders away, even though, you know, they'll never gonna touch the ball. Ten, fifteen, sometimes twenty passes before the ball ends up at the back of the net. The goal is the visible moment. But the real work happened long before that. And you know, learning works the same way. Students often think they've got it the moment they like earn a good mark on a quiz or a test or a project, but that's not when the learning happened. Learning's happening when they're wrestling with like a difficult idea, when you know they're revising their thinking after they've realized that they've made a mistake. You know, when they can explain their reasoning to a classmate, you know, when they finally see the pattern that had been hiding from them all along. you know, those moments rarely get celebrated because yeah, they're invisible and students often don't realize that it's happening until like weeks later when they're solving a new problem and like they suddenly think, Wait, I know how to do this you know? And y mastery it doesn't come Usually with like trumpets and fanfare, but that would be nice. You know, instead, mastery really does sneak up on students, on on all of us. And as teachers, I think part of your job is helping students recognize those invisible victories. You know, to pause and say, Do you remember when this felt impossible? Do you remember when this was hard for you? You know, look what you can do now. Because Confidence isn't built by the final score. It's built by recognizing all the progress that happened before anyone was even keeping score. And so this brings me to lesson three, which is feedback only works when it's immediate. And I think so one of the biggest differences between a World Cup match and a classroom is like the speed of feedback, right? Soccer players they do not have to wait until after the game to find out how they're doing because every few seconds they're getting new information telling them how it's going. you know. They're getting the coach is calling instructions from the sidelines, teammates are pointing, people are encouraging, asking them to move into a space, the crowd is singing or booing all kinds of things. And you know, they're they're aware they're constantly checking, constantly checking. and the opposition is also giving, you know, you feedback just by how they're defending and And they can also clock like how they're doing in the game, right? Like, did that sprint make me feel exhausted? Did that pass connect? Did my decision to do this create an opportunity? You know, and that feedback loop is constant and it's immediate, and players can just adjust everything immediately. But if we really compare that to school, you know, a student might write a final assignment on the Monday, you take it home market, and you're handing it back on the Friday. And kind of by that time the learning really has passed. And your feedback is absolutely, you know, thoughtful and excellent, but it can be a bit late. And the purpose of the feedback isn't to explain what happened, it's really just to just improve what happens next. And I think that's why some of the most like powerful feedback in your classroom, it's not when it's like written in the margins of an assignment. It's that quick question, you know, during independent work. It's the one-on-one check-ins, the conferences beside a student's desk, you know, thumbs up. I love those like self-check-ins, you know, like little writing something down. maybe you've got like student success criteria that the students can like check it on, or an exit slip. Everyone loves an exit slip, you know, and then you can see if you need to reteach something tomorrow. And like if I'm being honest personally, sometimes it's those blank stares after a lesson that you worked so hard on and that you realize looking at the student spaces that you are going to have to try to rework that so that they have more of an understanding of what the lesson was about. So you know, I think the shorter the feedback loop, the greater the opportunity for learning. And so like my wonder is, you know, where in your classroom could you shorten the feedback loop? Maybe because like the goal isn't that it's more feedback, it's just giving it sooner. Okay, so my like number four lesson that I've taken from the men's world cup this year is that everyone has a role. If you watch the highlights of a World Cup match, you will see the goals or attempts on goals. You'll see the player who s like when they score, they're celebrated. Sometimes a full minute, minute and a half of like a highlight reel, which is like ten minutes or less usually, is like the celebration of the goal. headlines and like, you know, the player of the match, right? But if you watch the whole game, you do kind of realize that something important, which is the goal scorer rarely gets there alone, right? Someone won the ball back, someone made a tackle, someone spotted the opening, someone made a decoy run, maybe that pulled the defender out of position, someone delivered the perfect pass. And you know, sometimes the most important player in a sequence never even touches the ball. But it's that their movement like created a space. And the scoreboard gives credit to usually just the goal scorer. We do always kind of understand if there's an assist or not. But the full game really tells a completely different story. And classrooms are very similar. You know, we celebrate the student has the right answer, earns the highest mark, gives the most polished presentation. But learning communities are built on more than that, right? Every classroom has students whose strengths look different. Some students are incredibly organized. they can keep a group on track, make sure everyone knows the plan, get the communication out there. Some students are encouragers. They notice when a classmate is struggling, and they quietly help them keep going, right? Some students notice details that others miss. Some are natural problem solvers who can untangle a challenge, you know, when the group gets stuck, some are artists, they can They can really see things in a different way and be able to communicate in a in a vibrant way that catches people's attention. you know, others ask those like questions that everyone's thinking, but they're not afraid to ask them, right? you know, they don't have the answer, but they know what needs to be asked. And those contributions matter just as much as the student who presents the final product, right? That's one of the reasons group projects, you know, when they're designed really thoughtfully, they're so valuable. They give students the opportunity to contribute in a way that is meaningful to them And they can experience something that's true, which is you know, success depends on people bringing different strengths to a shared goal. You know, of course, you know, group work isn't automatically effective. We've seen projects where one student does all the work while everyone else watches, and yeah, that isn't teamwork. But like the real collaboration that happens, you know, when students understand that every member has something like valuable to contribute. And then the task also allows for the different students to contribute in their own way. I think also we can look at this as teachers where, you know, one of your jobs is to know your students well enough to recognize your strength their strengths. You know, which student keeps calm under pressure, who notices when someone's been left out, who's asking those thoughtful questions, who sees the connections that the others don't, right? Who can explain an idea in a way that their classmates actually understand. Right? Like those are strengths that are absolutely worth naming. And it's equally important that students learn to recognize those strengths in themselves and in one another. You know, when students are able to appreciate what each person can bring to a team, you know, something really does shift. And the questions stop being like, well, who's the smartest? And instead it's more along the lines of like, who can help us with this part? You know, who's really artistic? Who do we need for this? Or, you know, who's able to ask those questions so we can figure out, you know, what more to research kind of a thing? And that is a really different classroom culture because in the end, just like in soccer, success isn't about one superstar. It's about building a team where everyone knows they have a role. Everyone understands why their role matters and everyone has the opportunity to help the whole team succeed. Okay, so lesson five, you know, I do think it's controversial. should classrooms be quiet? So I do find that this is very much like your one or the other. For some teachers, a quiet classroom is a sign that students are focused, they are respectful, they are learning, they're sitting at their desks. Heads down, doing what they're supposed to be doing. Concentrating, reading, writing, thinking independently. And I've seen teachers do this from you know, grade one upwards. Other teachers would argue that some of the deepest learning is anything but quiet. Their classrooms are filled with discussion, debate, students explaining their thinking, challenging ideas, questioning. Building off of one another's learning or experiences and learning from each other. So which is it? Well, when I watched the World Cup, one thing became impossible to ignore, and that is that great teams communicate constantly. Great teams communicate constantly. Players are talking all game long, pointing, calling for the ball. Warning teammates about pressure, celebrating great plays, pointing to where they're going to run so that you can kick the ball to where they're going to be, picking each other up for mistakes. And during a soccer match, communication, it's not a distraction from the game. It is the game. It is the learning. it's how players are able to learn, adapt, and succeed together. And I think, okay, so what happens in your classroom? Have you ever said, okay everyone, quiet? And yeah, there's absolutely times when that's exactly what's needed. students need opportunities to think independently, read deeply, and reflect. But I also wonder, sometimes, if there's an unintentional confusion where quiet equals learning. Because some of the richest learning experiences happen when students are thinking out loud, when they're questioning one another, explaining reasoning, testing ideas, respectfully disagreeing, and That is anything but quiet. You know, I'm not saying the goal is a noisy classroom, but I do think the goal is a classroom where students know when to think quietly and when to think together. and this purposeful conversation means room gets a little louder, you know, maybe that's not something to eliminate. Maybe it's something to design for. You know, what would happen if collaboration in your classroom sounded more like a World Cup match? Where could you create opportunities for students to coach one another or encourage one another and think together instead of always trying to think alone? And I'd love to hear your perspective in the comments. Do you think a quiet classroom is a sign of learning or do you think learning is meant to be noisy? Let me know. Okay. So lesson six. When you watch the World Cup match, you are seeing 90 minutes of exceptional soccer, incredible skill, teamwork, and decision making. You don't see the thousands of hours that made those 90 minutes possible. Okay? Performance is the visible tip of preparation, but preparation is invisible. You don't see the early morning training sessions, the fitness work, the tactical meetings, the film study. Coaches analyzing opponents or the individual players practicing the same movement over and over again until it becomes automatic. Like with the multiplication chart. So when the whistle blows and the game starts, the prep is invisible and all that gets noticed is the performance. And let's face facts, teaching is a lot like that. Teaching is full of invisible labor, right? We've talked about how teaching is the job where you do your job before you get to the job to do your job and then when the job is over you do your job to do your job tomorrow, right? Admin parents, students, they see you walk into the classroom and you teach a brilliant lesson and they don't see all the things that happened before the bell rang. All of your lesson planning, bring to the photo photocopier For it to work, searching for resources, thinking which questions might spark discussion, the assessment from yesterday that changed today's lesson, the adjustment you make because half the class understood yesterday's concept while the other half didn't, and they definitely do not see the reflection that you do every day after school. Those moments when you ask yourself, did that work? Why didn't that activity land the way I had expected? What should I change for tomorrow? You know, like athletes, our best work happens when no one's watching. And I think, you know, this is a really important conversation because So much of What students believe is that success just happens. You know, they don't understand or they forget that everything takes time. Learning takes time and preparation. Work takes time and preparation. You know, and doing the same thing over and over again until you get it. It's just like, you know, when they have to review math work, students see the polished presentation, but they don't see the drafts. They see the classmate that aces the test, but they don't see the hours of studying. You know, they see the final product without really appreciating or understanding the process to get there. And so, you know, when we make like to go one step further, I think, from the World Cup, when we make the invisible work visible, we really do help students and everyone around us understand that some understand that success is not about talent. You know, it's about preparation. It's those small decisions that you make every day that no one is applauding you for, you know? So I think one of the questions I'm certainly grappling with is like, is there a way to make that invisible hard work that is linked to performance visible? Like Is there a way to make sure that students understand that learning isn't something you're born with? It's something you build. So, yeah, that's definitely what I'm like grappling with. The coach doesn't play the game. it's my favorite analogy. The coach cannot score. The coach cannot pass. They cannot really make the decisions. They can certainly yell things from the sidelines, but it's up to the players if they're going to do that or if if they can even hear them, right? That is it. So like those are the extent of what the coach can do during the game. And the players run the game, make the calls, apply their learning, use the strategies to ultimately win or try to win the game. And you know, I love it because, like, as teachers, like as a teacher, you are coaching your students. You're asking questions, you're inspiring your students and guiding them and making them see the world in relation to themselves, right? In order to build empathy and create connections, you are encouraging and You adjust your teaching and your lessons to suit the needs of your students. And as much as you might want to, you can never just take over a student's learning. You give them the best. And you see where that takes them and you see the decisions that they make. And I just I just love that. I think it's it's so wonderful and powerful. And I think it's definitely one of my favorite lessons from the World Cup. And it does kind of blend a little bit into like Lesson eight, which is psychological safety matters. You know, one of the best things that I saw during the Men's World Cup this year didn't really have to do when a goal was scored, but it's really what I saw when a mistake was made. And like, okay, there were plenty of mistakes, right? There was a lot of bad passes, missed shots, defensive errors, keepers misstretching across. But I will say I have loved the keepers at this World Cup, like Vizinho and Corti. Courtois and there's just been so many amazing keepers. but yeah, there's been a lot of mistakes, and mistakes. I mean, one, it's just a beautiful lesson. Mistakes happen at any level, right? Like everyone's making mistakes, even on the world's biggest stage. but make what makes the most impact isn't the actual mistake, it's how the players are responding to those mistakes, right? And on great teams, you see players immediately encouraging one another, quit clap. you know, a hand on the back, thumbs up, someone saying, Shake it off, there's gonna be another one, don't worry about it, right? It's that understanding that we don't really have time to stay stuck. Right? We have to keep moving, we have to keep trying. and you know, those are the successful teams, you know, maybe less successful teams, they respond differently to that. They'll, you know, point fingers for their hands in the air, argue with their teammates. And You know, when that happens, you can watch confidence disappear in real time and then see the next few mistakes that get made. You know, the mistakes become bigger than the moment itself. And as soon as that happens, players are taking risks and playing cautiously. Players stop taking risks, they play cautiously, they hesitate, they're more worried about making another mistake than about being part of the next great play. And if that sounds similar, probably because it's happening in classrooms. All over, you know, the classrooms work in the exact same way. Students make mistakes every single day, and that's not the problem. You know that mistakes are part of learning. The question is like what happens next? You know, when a student gives a wrong answer, do they feel embarrassed or encouraged to keep thinking, to keep trying? psychological safety, it's not about lowering the expectations. It's about creating an environment where students know they can take intellectual risks without losing their dignity. You know, and that's because like learning really is it's vulnerable and learning requires vulnerability. Every time a student raises their hand, shares an idea, asks a question, or tries something new, they are taking a risk. And if that risk is met with ridicule or blame or embarrassment, they're gonna stop taking it. You know, that's a strong lesson that they've learned there, like, I this makes me feel bad. I don't wanna do this anymore, right? And so the best classrooms, like the best teams, expect mistakes. They know they're gonna happen. And the most important part is that they've already decided how they'll respond when those mistakes happen. So here's like here's a question to reflect on. When mistakes happen in your classroom, what do students learn about making mistakes? You know, because they're not just learning in the classroom, they're not just learning about reading or math. They're learning about whether your classroom is a place where it's safe to learn. So speaking of vulnerability, let's get into lesson nine that I learned from the World Cup, which is learning is emotional. So emotional. Pressure affects performance. And you know, in the World Cup, we see that with set plays, crowds, expectations. You know, if you look at like what it means to take a penalty kick, you know, there are athletes who have done all that invisible work, they've taken thousands of shots in practice, they know exactly what to do. The skill isn't what the the problem or the challenge is. S the challenge is that there's eighty thousand people watching, millions more watching, you know, on the television, and the weight of your entire country and their expectations is on your shoulders. And that pressure changes everything. It really is a I think a quite a powerful reminder that performance isn't about ability, it's also about emotion. You know, our students do experience that every day. You know, think about the student who understands the math, you know, during practice and and working, but they freeze on the test. You know, my daughter's teacher in grade three would tell me all the time that, well, she can do the math, but as soon as there's a quiz, she she can't answer the questions. You know, and that peacher teacher put more of an emphasis on the quiz, then you know, the learning, and you know, would take marks away. So you have the student who can explain an idea perfectly, but who struggles during an oral presentation. You have a confident reader who suddenly stumbles when they're asked to read aloud in the classroom. You know, it's not that that learning disappeared. It the pressure got louder for that student. And Yeah, you can't remove every stressful moment from school. Assessments, presentations, and challenges are all part of learning. However, you do have that ability to think carefully about the conditions that you create. And I guess, you know, asking yourself, do the students have the opportunities to practice before they're evaluated? Do they receive feedback, you know, before they are assessed or given a mark? Can they build confidence in lower stakes situations before facing higher stakes ones? And I really do think just like Teachers are meant to remove barriers to learning. If you can also reduce unnecessary pressure, it's not that you're lowering those expectations. You're actually just creating the conditions for students to show you what they know. And that is more powerful data to actually be able to show what the students know instead of what the students are able to deliver in a high pressure situation. Right. So I think the world the lesson from the World Cup is simple. Like even world class performers are affected by pressure. So maybe instead of thinking like, well, can they do it, the better question is what conditions will help them to show what they can do? What would help them show their learning? Okay, so thanks for sticking with me this long. We're at lesson ten. During the World Cup, teams celebrate every little win. They celebrate when a defensive play worked, when a tackle went well, every time they took the ball off the opposition, every shot on goal. Even when it d didn't go in. Every corner kick, every time the keeper saved the ball, right? Great teams understand that success is built from the small moments, not just one spectacular finish. And mm yeah, they understand that it you need all those small wins to get to the big one. And your classroom should be the same. If the only thing that's celebrated is that perfect test score, polished presentation, you know, students start believing that only perfection deserves recognition. I'm sure you've had that when you've praised a student and they're like, Well, that's not perfect. I didn't do that great. That person did better than me, right? And then that's kind of a cue of like, we need to like work on this culture in the classroom, right? Because we know that learning doesn't happen in one big moment. It happens when the student tries a strategy they've been avoiding, right? When they ask a very thoughtful question or they revise their work instead of giving up, right? Shutting down. When they take the risks they're not completely sure about, you know, when your students persist through something that felt impossible a month ago, those are the moments that deserve the celebrating because you can absolutely celebrate growth. And that way your students can learn to value their own learning. And in the long run, that really is what we want students to carry with them, right? Like it's not the memory of getting everything right. But the confidence that they really can keep getting better. So that is the end. I do have a bonus lesson that I learned because as I was going through this, I thought, you know what else? You know what all of this is really like the beginning of the path? It's the beginning of the path to lifelong learning. The bonus lesson is that the best players never stop learning. You know, and that is it's like whatever. My absolute favorite lesson is. From watching elite players is understanding that the best in the world are still learning. You know, the players that we admire the most Marta, Millie Bright, Samker, Messi, Bellingham, Mbappe, they have incredible skill, experience, and success. And they don't reach a point where they say, I've made it. I don't need to improve anymore. The best players in the world are still learners. And we should expect the same from our teachers. Teaching, as you know, is a profession where there's always more to discover. There's always new strategies to try, new perspectives to consider, new research that's come out, and new ways where we can understand our students. Ask yourself, what fundamentals are you still practicing? Is it, you know, you're practicing asking better questions, creating stronger relationships? Are you practicing deepening meaningful learning experiences, give more effective feedback, having more hands-on activities for learning. You know, the goal is never to become a perfect teacher, just like the goal is never to create a perfect student. And just like, you know, the goal isn't for a soccer player to never make a mistake. The goal is to stay curious, keep learning, continue continuously improve yourself because The very best teachers, just like the very best athletes, never stop being students themselves. So, you know, the World Cup, it's not really about soccer, I don't think, not at its core. It's about people learning to perform together under pressure. It's about trust, communication, resilience, feedback, preparation, and the belief that. Every person has something valuable to contribute, and that each contribution is worth celebrating. Every day your students step onto the field, and yes, they aren't competing for a trophy, but they are facing challenges, making mistakes, taking risks, learning from others, and discovering what they're capable of. Your job isn't to create perfect students. It's to create environments where every student has the support, confidence, and opportunity to grow because the greatest victories in the classroom aren't always the ones that show up on your assessment data. It can be the quiet moments. A student who finally understands, a student who finds their voice. Or a student who realizes that they can do something they once thought was impossible. I think the greatest lesson you can take from the World Cup is that learning is a team sport. We all have a role, we all have room to grow, and the best outcomes happen when we help each other get there. Thanks for listening. I'll catch you next time.