Latest / DIVEBOMB Formula One Podcast / Episode 33 - Spygate & Crashgate (Rewind Episode)
Transcript
- 0:00Hello and welcome to another episode of the Dive Bomb F1
- 0:02podcast. I'm Maham and I'm joined by my
- 0:04wonderful Co host Marie and Rohan.
- 0:07Now, we love to talk about so many different things on this
- 0:09podcast, with some of our favourites being our issues with
- 0:11the timing tower on broadcast, some of the less thought out
- 0:14decisions made by the stewards, and our passing judgments on
- 0:17some of the more experimental strategy choices made by teams
- 0:20that I won't name, but I'm sure that you can guess anyway.
- 0:23However, I think there's nothing that the three of us enjoy more
- 0:26than discussing the history of this wonderful sport, which
- 0:29includes some colorful episodes and instances.
- 0:31The exact thing that we're going to be focusing on today for
- 0:34another rewind episode. We're going to be discussing
- 0:37Spygate and Crash Gate. Without giving any spoilers to
- 0:40any new F1 fans who might be listening, or old F1 fans who
- 0:43have only ever heard about these events in passing, I would
- 0:47suggest that you get comfortable because this is certainly going
- 0:49to be entertaining. Let the three of us set the
- 0:52scene for you before we actually get into discussing anything too
- 0:55technical, and start with the absolute basics.
- 0:58What actually were Spygate and what actually was Crash Gate?
- 1:02I'm happy to take the reins on Crash Gate.
- 1:04I was definitely, I was really familiarized myself with it.
- 1:06But to anyone who was not aware, this was essentially when it was
- 1:10suspected initially, then found out that Renault basically team
- 1:14principal at the time and then Gavier, Briatore and the
- 1:18technical director, I don't remember his exact title, Pat
- 1:20Simmons basically instructed Nelson Piquet junior to crash at
- 1:25intentionally at Turn 17 in the 2008 Singapore Grand Prix.
- 1:30So it would benefit Fernando Alonso strategy and they ended
- 1:34up winning the race because of it.
- 1:35Although I do want to know at the time, the actual controversy
- 1:39didn't end up like cropping up until about a year later, a
- 1:42couple months later and nobody thought much about the time.
- 1:45But that is the basic outline of what happened.
- 1:47That was very concise. I'm just going to add and say
- 1:52Pat Simmons official title at the time was he was the
- 1:55Executive Director of engineering at RENA.
- 1:58OK, right. And then Spygate.
- 2:00Spygate was in 2007 and then essentially your main people are
- 2:04McLaren and Ferrari. So McLaren at that point were
- 2:07really looking for a win. They had Fernando Alonso and
- 2:10Lewis Hamilton going into the season 2 very, very good drivers
- 2:14and they were very excited about this season.
- 2:16In the background you have Nigel Stephanie which who was the
- 2:19chief mechanic at Ferrari in the peak Schumacher days, so like
- 2:23early 2000s when they were winning all their championships.
- 2:25He was part of the what was known as the Dream team.
- 2:28Basically Schumacher retires and Stephanie is not happy about how
- 2:31the team is being run and how the team is going forward with
- 2:34different things. He asks for a promotion and gets
- 2:37one, but not quite the 1 he wants.
- 2:39And so basically in retaliation, he takes 780 pages of
- 2:43confidential documents from the Ferrari factory, including stuff
- 2:46about technical info, finances and the hands it over to
- 2:50McLaren's lead designer at the time, Mike Cooglin.
- 2:53And basically he's handing them the entire Ferrari car.
- 2:56Since McLaren and Ferrari were huge rivals at this point,
- 3:00that's what makes this such a big deal anyways, Coogland's
- 3:03wife. This is so 2000s to me.
- 3:05This is really funny. Goes to the local photocopier to
- 3:09go photocopy all these documents on two different CDs and then
- 3:12they're going to burn the original documents, which they
- 3:14do do but the clerk at the store notices the prancing horse on
- 3:19each page of the documents and he's like wait a second, this
- 3:22isn't right. And he basically gets a hold of
- 3:25Ferrari to tell them that, hey, these random people.
- 3:29Well, he actually found out that this woman was affiliated to
- 3:31McLaren because her husband worked there.
- 3:33But he was like, these McLaren people are photocopying all
- 3:36these Ferrari documents. So Ferrari finds out and it's
- 3:39this whole big thing. And essentially they get caught.
- 3:42And it goes kind of more down the road than that, but we'll
- 3:46discuss that. Yeah, so those are two of
- 3:49probably in the 21st century, 2 of the biggest events to happen
- 3:53in Formula One. There are undoubtedly more and
- 3:56we'll get on to that a little bit later on in the episode, but
- 3:58that's effectively it. And it's still amusing to me
- 4:00even now. And I was smiling as Marie was
- 4:02giving her explanation of Spygate.
- 4:04That these two Motorsports giants, as obviously all three
- 4:08of us have come to understand and appreciate McLaren and
- 4:10Ferrari to be, were brought down by the fact that a senior member
- 4:14of the McLaren design team did not own a printer or a
- 4:18photocopier in his own home. Which is why they had to go
- 4:20outside. Which is a comment I'm not the
- 4:21first person to make, and I will certainly not be the last person
- 4:24to make either when it comes to discussing Spygate.
- 4:28Crash Gate as well is an incredibly interesting event and
- 4:32Will we'll get on to who was actually involved in this next
- 4:34because some of the names are quite familiar.
- 4:38And then people that we still discuss even now today on the
- 4:41current grid. And like I said, we'll get on to
- 4:42that in a little bit. But these were definitely the
- 4:45reason that we have focused on these two events for today's
- 4:48episode is because they are undoubtedly, like I said, two of
- 4:52the biggest events to happen in F1 in the 21st century.
- 4:54And obviously the fact that they happen one after the other.
- 4:57And it's a saga that starts in 2007 with Spygate, goes on into
- 5:012008 with Crash Gate and continues into 2009 when
- 5:04Crashgate actually comes to light, when Nelson PK Junior,
- 5:08who is the driver who was told to crash in Singapore in 2008,
- 5:11is dropped due to quote UN quote, performance related
- 5:14issues. And that's when he decides that
- 5:16he's going to go to the media and discuss everything that
- 5:18happened in 2008, which is where we get the story that obviously
- 5:22we're discussing today. So we we've explained what the
- 5:24events actually were and we've alluded to some of the main
- 5:27characters and we've given their job titles and everything.
- 5:29But as I've said before on a couple of occasions in the
- 5:32podcast, the Paddock is an exceptionally small place.
- 5:35So who was everyone actually involved in these respective
- 5:38controversies? Let's go in chronological order
- 5:41and start with Spygate, which obviously, as we've already
- 5:43said, took place in 2007. Right.
- 5:46Well, with Spygate, obviously we've mentioned it, but Nigel
- 5:49Stephanie, who was the chief mechanic at Ferrari for a time
- 5:52before he essentially retired. And then Mike Cooglin, who is
- 5:55McLaren's lead designer. And then kind of by proxy, you
- 5:59have Ron Dennis, who was the team principal at McLaren at the
- 6:02time. And then of course, Fernando
- 6:03Alonso and Lewis Hamilton, who were the drivers for McLaren at
- 6:06the time. I want to focus on Ron Dennis
- 6:08just really quickly, because if there's anyone who knows
- 6:11anything about McLaren during this era and his own former
- 6:15drivers will say this as well. Ron Dennis probably ran one of
- 6:18the tied to ships in like F1 history to the point where his
- 6:22office was expected to be a certain way.
- 6:25But not only his own office at McLaren HQ, Every other person's
- 6:29office had to be a specific way as well.
- 6:31To the extent that when Adrian Newey joined the team very
- 6:34briefly and they did work together, Ron Dennis would not
- 6:36go into Adrian Newey's office because he didn't like the way
- 6:38it was set up. The McLaren garage at F
- 6:42Circuits, when they would obviously travel around to go
- 6:44racing, also had to be set up a very specific way.
- 6:47There were very specific colours that were allowed within the
- 6:49garage. So the fact that obviously this
- 6:51all takes place while Ron Dennis is in charge is yet another one
- 6:55of the fantastical elements of everything that happens during
- 6:59Spygate. And for Crashgate, the people
- 7:02involved were Fernando Alonso, who was a driving for the
- 7:06Renault F1 team at the time, Nelson Piquet.
- 7:08June works in the same. We already mentioned was
- 7:12basically the team principal, he's in charge of the team, Pat
- 7:15Simmons. We've already mentioned by
- 7:18extension Felipe Massa, because he was one of the people
- 7:21involved in raising it the next year because it essentially how
- 7:25it affected him was it was one of the events that led to him
- 7:28losing the championship. It's sort of in the modern fans
- 7:31context, it's like Max Verstappen trying to appeal what
- 7:34happened in Barcelona 2025, if it makes any kind of sense,
- 7:37because it's basically the crucial event that costume would
- 7:40have more costume the championship and those are the
- 7:44main, main people involved. I'm.
- 7:46Also going to say that I would include Max Mosley in that list
- 7:51of people as well, because if there's anyone ever had anything
- 7:54to say about Crash Gate obviously as it later came to be
- 7:58known as, it would be Max Mosley 100%.
- 8:01So controversies in F1 are not something that can be kept
- 8:04hidden, and in fact there's almost this unspoken agreement
- 8:06in F1, at least from the last few years if we can take them as
- 8:09an example, that there has to be 1 sensational headline per
- 8:12season, even if it's not a controversy in the traditional
- 8:15sense. Spygate and Crash Gate are no
- 8:17exceptions to this rule, so how did the truth behind these
- 8:20events eventually come to light? Well, I think we've we've
- 8:23already mentioned it as nothing really happened to do with
- 8:26Crossgate at the time already. Really.
- 8:29I mean, the podium was Fernando Alonso, who won one of runner's
- 8:32first race in quite a long time and his first win in about a
- 8:35year. And at the time runner when were
- 8:38about basically a midfield team. They weren't doing great, but
- 8:41they weren't who they were two years ago.
- 8:43The podium and shown would it be Fernando Alonso first, Nico
- 8:46Rosberg second, Lewis Hampton 3rd.
- 8:47And nobody really thought much about it until the year after
- 8:50when Nelson Pinko junior got fired and he raised the
- 8:54allegations that he he was instructed by senior members at
- 8:58the team to crash turn 17 for the Singapore area.
- 9:02Even at the time it was a very hard place to to to to get a car
- 9:08back that that crashed into the barrier.
- 9:10So he was essentially he rose up to the FY and said they did it
- 9:14on purpose to do this because they were running quite
- 9:16aggressive strategy on Fernando Alonso's car.
- 9:19And obviously we mentioned fully paid Massa had a role in this
- 9:23because he argued is essentially one of the reasons he lost the
- 9:26championship that season by one point.
- 9:28And and it kept developing onto there.
- 9:30And it basically ended with part Simmons not avoiding the
- 9:36indefinite ban from Formula One due to his cooperation with the
- 9:39investigation by the FIA and Flavio Briatore.
- 9:43Oh I actually actually thought got a permanent ban, but I
- 9:46checked the fine print and it technically wasn't permanent.
- 9:48And in the end the FYA ruled and the world multiple council
- 9:52meeting a couple months later in 2009, around one year after the
- 9:57incident happened. And that's that was essentially
- 9:59it. I'd just like to say we've
- 10:00mentioned the FYA on quite a number of occasions and I name
- 10:03dropped Max Mosley. The reason I name dropped Max
- 10:05Mosley is because he was the. FYA placement at the time.
- 10:09Seeing all of this happening and if you know anything about Max
- 10:12Mosley and obviously any of the other management about F1 during
- 10:16this period, then you know that it was very much handling glove
- 10:19between Bernie Eccleston and Max Mosley, which is a much wider
- 10:23web. And we'll come on to obviously
- 10:25Felipe Massa's involvement, all of this and the legacies of
- 10:27these controversies a little bit later on as well because it's
- 10:30something that still continues today, which makes this all the
- 10:33more exciting to discuss. Right.
- 10:34And then Bernie Eccleston, for anybody who doesn't know, was
- 10:37the CEO of Formula One for a very, very long time and quite a
- 10:40controversial character in Formula One just based on how he
- 10:43wanted to run things. But to explain a little bit more
- 10:47kind of the Nelson Piquet piece and why Felipe Massa was so mad
- 10:51about it and kind of the aggressive strategy that Renault
- 10:54was running, Fernando Alonso, I believe, qualified P6P15 in
- 11:00Singapore in two. Thousand.
- 11:01Yeah. With a where crash Gate was and
- 11:03then his team mate Nelson Piquet junior qualified one place below
- 11:07him. And so basically since Renault
- 11:09we're looking to win the race. Of course, they this was in the
- 11:12days where you could still refuel during a pit stop.
- 11:15And so they fueled Fernando Alonzo's car quite low so that
- 11:20he could kind of make gains in the early laps and have a
- 11:24lighter car. And so he pits super early
- 11:26essentially. And so he pits, he goes
- 11:29whatever, and then a few laps later, his teammate crashes.
- 11:32So nobody thinks anything of it, especially because it's at
- 11:35Singapore. Such a difficult track.
- 11:36But of course, we later learned that it was intentional because
- 11:39then the safety car comes out and every single person in the
- 11:43field pits. And the important thing, well,
- 11:45the important thing to note here is during this time, you
- 11:49actually couldn't go into the pit lane while the safety car
- 11:52was out. So the entire field bunched up
- 11:54because of the safety car. And then everybody else pitted,
- 11:57meaning Fernando Alonso went to the front and Felipe Massa, who
- 12:01was leading the race I believe, or at least in the front pack,
- 12:04dropped down massively and basically his championship was
- 12:07ruined from there. And of course for Lewis Hamilton
- 12:10went on to win the 2008 championship for Spygate.
- 12:14As we talked about the clerk, this is so funny because we mean
- 12:18you're the lead designer at McLaren and you don't you
- 12:20couldn't photocopy this either at the McLaren factory or at
- 12:23your home. But essentially they got caught
- 12:25because the clerk at the store saw the Ferrari logo.
- 12:30Didn't want McLaren to have an advantage over Ferrari cuz he
- 12:32was a Ferrari fan basically. But McLaren then gets cleared in
- 12:36court because they were kind of unaware of everything that was
- 12:39going on. Mike Cooglin and Stephanie gets
- 12:42sent to prison for a year and eight months and he's
- 12:44essentially blacklisted from being hired from any teams in
- 12:47Formula One. He later gets hired in other
- 12:49forms of motorsport, but this kind of goes all under the rug
- 12:53and except for McLaren are disqualified from the
- 12:57constructors championships because of the advantages they
- 13:00have their car and but the drivers are able to keep
- 13:03competing for the drivers championship because they were
- 13:06basically unaware of all the things that were happening.
- 13:08And McLaren were cleared in court and then Fernando Alonso
- 13:12got mad. So I think this is something
- 13:14that's also kind of adds another layer to the story.
- 13:17Essentially, when Fernando Alonso went to McLaren, he was
- 13:20promised the number one driver's seat.
- 13:22Of course, Lewis Hamilton comes in to McLaren and he doesn't
- 13:25really agree with this and his performances even as a rookie
- 13:29show that he shouldn't be the number 2 driver indefinitely.
- 13:32He won his, for one example. He won his first race 6 races in
- 13:37to his rookie season, which remains I think the best result
- 13:40of any driver in terms of like how soon they got their race
- 13:44win. But essentially Fernando Alonso
- 13:46is very mad at McLaren and he's mad at Ron Dennis especially who
- 13:51is the team principal as we've mentioned.
- 13:53So after the Hungary GP, which he gets a five place grid
- 13:57penalty because in qualifying he held up Lewis Hamilton who was
- 14:01behind him in the pits so that he couldn't go on another lap
- 14:05and basically out qualify Fernando Lonzo.
- 14:07So after this happens and the FIA gives him a five place grid
- 14:10penalty, he's mad and goes to Ron Dennis threatening to go to
- 14:14the FIA with I believe hundreds of emails from the inner
- 14:18workings of McLaren basically detailing more things about
- 14:22Spygate that hadn't come out. Dennis thinks that he's joking,
- 14:26he's like, OK, yeah, sure you're going to do that.
- 14:28So he essentially ignores him and then Fernando Alonso goes
- 14:31and releases them to the FIA. And then from there, McLaren are
- 14:35given a £100 million fine and disqualified from.
- 14:42And I'd also just like to add that that fine remains, and I
- 14:45did double check this just to make sure.
- 14:47It remains the biggest sporting fine that has ever been given to
- 14:51a team in not just Motorsports history, in sporting history.
- 14:55They didn't actually end up paying all of the 100.
- 14:58I think it was $100 million, but I could be wrong about that, I
- 15:00think. Yeah, I think they have paid the
- 15:03equivalent of 31 million, which is still a really big number.
- 15:08I mean, I just want to say just because it wasn't the 400
- 15:10million doesn't mean that it was any less substantial of a fine
- 15:14to pay. But it reminds me, obviously, we
- 15:16talk about these incidents and we talk about these teams and we
- 15:19talk about these names. It's the sheer fact that for
- 15:21some reason, at the heart of it all, you always have Ferrari,
- 15:26McLaren, Alpine or Ren. Obviously Alpine is what they're
- 15:29known as now, but Renault and somehow Fernando featuring in
- 15:33both of these incidents because while I was running through,
- 15:36obviously these are like I said at the beginning of the episode,
- 15:39these are events that everyone's heard of.
- 15:42Even if you don't know them in depth, everyone's heard of them.
- 15:45And yet somehow not only is Fernando Alonso in the middle of
- 15:48all of this, somehow he's one of the only people to get off Scott
- 15:52free in both instances. They kind of plead innocence for
- 15:57him in both occasions. Obviously the spy it won less
- 16:01so, but he's he pleads innocence to say, well, I didn't really
- 16:03have anything to do with it, which is why he's still able to
- 16:06fight for the drivers championship title in 2007 and
- 16:082008. He's completely written off a
- 16:10crash gate. How this ends up happening and
- 16:13the fact that he's still on the grid today as well.
- 16:15He returned then to Renault, obviously once they had
- 16:17rebranded as Alpine. But obviously we'll get on.
- 16:20Like I said, we'll get onto the legacies of these events a
- 16:22little bit later on. It's just the, it's the sheer
- 16:24fact for me that when you discuss these events, it's
- 16:27always these three big names. And obviously they're
- 16:29Motorsports giants. We've established this, we
- 16:32established this like 30 episodes ago when we started
- 16:34working together, the three of us.
- 16:35But it's always, always McLaren, Ferrari and Renault at the
- 16:40middle, in the middle of all of this.
- 16:42It reminds you that Professor Mcgonagall from Harry Foster is
- 16:44like whenever anything bad happens, why is it always you 3?
- 16:48It genuinely is. And what really entertains me is
- 16:51obviously we think about things that have happened like from the
- 16:552000 and 10s onwards in terms of like controversies or incidents
- 16:59where we've been like, oh, we're going to be talking about this
- 17:01for generations. And obviously I can think of a
- 17:03couple of examples off the top of my head, but I don't know
- 17:07whether anything really matches up to because I think there's no
- 17:10way of actually explaining or replicating.
- 17:12And I wasn't even watching F1 at the time, so I can't even fully
- 17:15appreciate this myself, but just the sheer intensity of the
- 17:18situation at the time. Obviously, these are the names
- 17:21that are battling each other, four titles.
- 17:24So it's not a case of like these are back market teams where all
- 17:27of this is happening and it almost feels like children are
- 17:29squabbling on the playground. This is genuine.
- 17:32And these are like the top dogs of Motorsports at the time.
- 17:35And this is what they're doing. They're being caught by the fact
- 17:38that they don't have home photocopiers and home printers.
- 17:41They're being caught by the fact that they've they're sending
- 17:43coded messages to each other on the radio or they're discussing
- 17:47these things like behind the scenes before they even get out
- 17:50on track. What?
- 17:51Absolutely gets me about the about crash gate in specific is
- 17:55if you watch the warm up laps for the 2008 Singapore Grand
- 17:59Prix, Nelson PK Junior practices his crash in the exact same spot
- 18:05where he ends up crashing during the race.
- 18:07And somehow it still takes a year to put together that maybe,
- 18:13just maybe, there was something worth investigating in this
- 18:16situation. And I'm not even kidding.
- 18:18I've rewatched this footage because obviously it's freely
- 18:21available online because there is something to investigate.
- 18:24It is the exact same. It's the exact same way.
- 18:27Like it's carbon copy pasted how he does it in the warm up lab
- 18:32and then when he actually goes off then as well.
- 18:34I suppose the another interesting part to me linking
- 18:36to the president is all these people borrowing people like
- 18:39Nigel, Stephanie, Ron Dennis, who aren't really uninvolved
- 18:43with their phone or anything more hold so quite prominent
- 18:45roles. I mean, Fernando Alonso, Lewis
- 18:48Hamilton is still Formula One drivers, Fabio Bria, Tories a
- 18:52successfully unsuccessful running NRP in Formula One team
- 18:55depending on who you ask. Pat Simmons is an executive
- 18:59engineering consultant for Cadillac.
- 19:01You know they're also very prominent people in Formula One
- 19:04all these years later. Promote from the restaurant.
- 19:08This was why it was so controversial for Flavio to come
- 19:11back to Formula One, and I believed her.
- 19:15It was kind of like a hostile takeover.
- 19:18It was well. What's to be kind about it
- 19:20getting? We're getting off track at the
- 19:22moment, hoping for those who don't know in that, I don't
- 19:26know, I would say like 23 to 24 after once Flavio kind of
- 19:32assumed the team principal role. In effect, they were going like
- 19:37through team principles, like there was no tomorrow.
- 19:39They had Omar, they had Omar for a few years and then he was
- 19:43doing bad. And they were like, no, we don't
- 19:44like you anymore. And then they had some other guy
- 19:47and then they had another guy and then he left and then it was
- 19:51all going on. It was quite, but This is why
- 19:54everybody was so shocked. If you didn't know, people were
- 19:57very shocked. And when Flavio came back to
- 19:59Formula One, because, as Rohan mentioned, it was assumed that
- 20:03he had a lifelong ban because of course.
- 20:06After crash gate, Flavio and I believe and the chief engineer
- 20:10were banned from all FIA events, not just Formula One.
- 20:13Every FIA event. So essentially every single
- 20:15motorsport event that you can think of, they were banned from
- 20:18for their involvement in the scandal essentially.
- 20:21And so when he comes back, people look what is he doing
- 20:24here? And I think it's still hotly
- 20:25contested if he should be in Formula One or not because of, I
- 20:31mean just his management style in general, but because of his
- 20:36involvement in this and kind of other just controversial
- 20:40behaviour. And I would just like to say
- 20:42that if there was ever a person within the world of Formula One
- 20:45who could probably write the authoritative text on what it
- 20:49means to exploit loopholes, I would say that would be Flavio
- 20:52Brutori. Because when obviously he, I'm
- 20:55going to use the word return in quotation marks because it does
- 20:59feel like to a certain extent he never actually left given how
- 21:02intertwined he was in the world of F1, even obviously after
- 21:05Crash Gate. But when he returned to Alpine
- 21:08and it was initially stated from APR perspective, obviously that
- 21:12he's only here as like an executive advisor.
- 21:14He doesn't actually have an official role within the team.
- 21:17So it's OK. He's just kind of here to give
- 21:20everyone Pats on the back and maybe give a couple of
- 21:22suggestions here or there, so on so forth.
- 21:24Even now, I don't actually think he's ever been given the
- 21:28official title of team principle.
- 21:29I think it's de facto team principle or interim team
- 21:33principle that he's referred to. But then again, that's again,
- 21:36just an exploitation of a loophole.
- 21:39I do believe that his lifetime ban, Mike Rohan said, is not
- 21:42actually a lifetime, lifetime ban.
- 21:44I think there are ways that he's gone about it to avoid
- 21:48obviously, like crossing any red tape or anything, which is why,
- 21:51obviously he shows up on our screens every weekend that F1 is
- 21:55obviously on. But yeah, if there was ever a
- 21:58person who could write the authoritative text on what it
- 22:01means to exploit exploit loopholes in the world of
- 22:04Formula One, it would be Flavio. But obviously he would only be
- 22:06able to write that book once he stops micromanaging any of the
- 22:10drivers that he manages. And I think Jack Doohan and
- 22:12obviously Franco Kolapinto could would have a word or two to say
- 22:16about that. I wouldn't ever say when I was
- 22:18researching into Crash Gates specifically, it was ever really
- 22:21a ban. It was more like an exile.
- 22:23He was really just exiled on F1. It's it's kind of very long.
- 22:27I mean, yeah, it didn't last very long.
- 22:28It's like, I think that's all it was in exile, but he's back to
- 22:31controlling people every millimeter now.
- 22:34A quote from How to Survive for those for those who didn't
- 22:37watch. One that we absolutely love to
- 22:39reference on here, but that's just because, and that just goes
- 22:41to show how much we talk about LP that that comes up so much.
- 22:44I mean it clearly, it's clearly working.
- 22:47It also reminds. Me, I'm not joking.
- 22:49Off track, but I don't care because this is really funny.
- 22:51It also reminds me of the thing that Will Joseph Lindo, Norris's
- 22:55race engineer, said to him. I don't remember what race, but
- 22:58I was. I believe it was in 2024 when he
- 23:00was fighting for the championship but he was
- 23:03struggling or something. And then Will Joseph goes to
- 23:06Lando Norris. Just imagine, step Andrea on on
- 23:10your shoulder. No wheel spin.
- 23:12What? But I remember this radio
- 23:14message and I'm trying to think of what race it's come from
- 23:16because I distinctly remember this.
- 23:18Hold on. But but OK, Andreas Stella, team
- 23:21principal at McLaren. Imagine.
- 23:23For now, can. You just imagine like a little
- 23:25Andre Stella Orlando's shoulder, no wheel spin, no wheel spin.
- 23:29Because I believe it was at a start.
- 23:30I don't know. Or maybe it was, I don't even
- 23:32know. But it's really funny.
- 23:34And that's what that quote also reminds me of.
- 23:36I think it was in Baku that. Sounds right.
- 23:39I think it was in Baku and I believe it was on a restart
- 23:43which is why it was because the exact radio message is is magic
- 23:47Andrea on your shoulder saying no wheel spin at every corner
- 23:51exit. Did they once developed
- 23:54themselves out of that one? They certainly did.
- 23:56And you know what, I would like to think that it was Minnie
- 23:58Andrea sitting on Lando Norris's shoulder saying no wheel spin,
- 24:02which meant that they were able to develop themselves out of
- 24:04that one. But it just goes to show like
- 24:07it's McLaren is a team that can go from, I would say pretty
- 24:12unsuccessfully trying to conduct corporate espionage to
- 24:16apparently becoming, I don't know how.
- 24:18What would you say about McLaren in 2024 and 2025?
- 24:21The most family friendly team on the grid.
- 24:25It's like a, it's like a for a reality show.
- 24:27It's a Formula One team like. Oh no, I would have to give
- 24:30that. So much drama a. 100% I would
- 24:32have to give that to. Missing.
- 24:33No, I'll get that honestly. Red Bull or Ferrari Red I.
- 24:36Think every team would be a reality TV?
- 24:39Show Red Bull or Ferrari for me. What reality TV show is every
- 24:42Formula One team? Because I think Formula One is
- 24:45all a big reality TV show, essentially.
- 24:48There is a reality TV show Formula One.
- 24:50Exactly, evidenced by the fact that there is literally reality
- 24:54team about Formula One. But I think every team would be
- 24:57a little bit different, you know what I mean?
- 24:59I don't feel like Mercedes would be a good reality TV show.
- 25:02The only ever drama is who they're gonna like, who they're
- 25:04gonna replace the driver with or something, or who's gonna when
- 25:08the driver's gonna get 1 + 1 contract or something.
- 25:10Have you ever seen George Russell in any situation ever?
- 25:13He's the biggest diva we've ever seen.
- 25:16He's Barcelona 2025 are. You kidding?
- 25:18Radio message in question is when he's discussing with his
- 25:22Marcus Dudley, his race engineer, about a McLaren being
- 25:25in a uncomfortable position for him about whether he should just
- 25:28let the McLaren pass. I don't remember that happening.
- 25:32You don't remember that incident happening?
- 25:34Me and Marie talked about this radio message as it happened.
- 25:38Wait, what? What incident?
- 25:40We'll have to discuss this. And I think we're getting a bit
- 25:43off track, pun intended. Slightly, but we will have to
- 25:46enlighten you about the radio message off air because
- 25:48unfortunately it's not the most family friendly thing so we
- 25:50can't include it in the recording.
- 25:52Yeah. I have been insistent up until
- 25:55this point that we give as minimal spoilers as possible
- 25:58because obviously for events like this, you want to make sure
- 26:00you're learning them as they unfolded at the time as well.
- 26:03But obviously it goes without saying that these events didn't
- 26:06happen in isolation and that meant that they had an impact on
- 26:08the respective championships for that season.
- 26:10So, Marie and Rohan, please enlighten us and tell us what
- 26:14happened in the standings in the immediate aftermath of these
- 26:16incidents and what had ended up happening at the end of the
- 26:19season when the titles were given.
- 26:21So for crash gate Fernando Alonso to won the race and won
- 26:24Renault's first race in a year or two, I believe, and won his
- 26:28race in a year since he was at McLaren due to what happened to
- 26:31Felipe Massa in the pit lane when they were trying to refuel
- 26:33his car at Ferrari. They left the like the end of
- 26:36the hose, like I don't want to what it's called specific, the
- 26:38fuel hose. And that essentially ended his
- 26:40race. And it was a big reason as to
- 26:43that and Brazil as to why he lost the championship that
- 26:45season. And the effects of that for him
- 26:48are still being felt today. For Renault, it made a
- 26:50difference. But as I was saying, they were
- 26:52around 4th, 5th in the constructor standings at the
- 26:55time. So they were doing well, but it
- 26:56didn't end up making that much of a difference.
- 26:58They finished in a respectable condition.
- 27:00Nelson Piquet Junior stayed on that season but was dropped to
- 27:03midway through the next season. But and he hadn't been performed
- 27:06very well anyways, 2009 specifically scored no points
- 27:09and that was what happened to him.
- 27:10Fernando Lance obviously won the race and it boosted him the
- 27:13driver's standings, but it was basically his only standout
- 27:17result from that season and he was kept on for 2009.
- 27:20As I was saying, Flavio Briatore and Pat Simmons were both banned
- 27:25from FIA sanctioned events with a varying amount of time,
- 27:28although as we've said earlier, both returned.
- 27:31As I basically mentioned, McLaren were disqualified from
- 27:34the constructors championship due to their actions in Spygate
- 27:38and then Fernando Alonzo and Lewis Hamilton were essentially
- 27:41marked not guilty. Like they didn't had nothing to
- 27:43do with it essentially. So they were allowed to compete
- 27:45in the championship. However, they still lost to can
- 27:50you reckon in by one point in the final race in Brazil in
- 27:522007. I would just like to say between
- 27:55Lewis Hamilton and Fernando continued to dwindle, though it
- 27:59was never really that's wrong to begin with.
- 28:01Yeah, I can hardly imagine that they were linking arms and
- 28:03skipping behind the McLaren centre at any race.
- 28:06Second Oscar. For sure.
- 28:08No, they certainly weren't, and I can't imagine that Ron Dennis
- 28:10was obviously very happy about that situation either.
- 28:13But that's a story for another time.
- 28:16I would also just like to say, and I can imagine that any
- 28:18Ferrari fans who are listening will not be happy at the fact
- 28:20that I'm pointing this out. McLaren having corporate
- 28:22espionage and involving Renault at the same time in the same
- 28:26year that Ferrari ended up winning the up until today, the
- 28:29final World Drivers Championship title is probably not the best
- 28:33look, but I believe that there in 2007 obviously with Kimi
- 28:36Raikkonen is what I'm referring to.
- 28:38Now both of these events happened almost 2 decades ago
- 28:41and despite the distance between them actually taking place and
- 28:43now we're still sat here talking about them today on this podcast
- 28:46episode, we've had headlines and stories that have persisted
- 28:49across the expanse of time. But what is it about these two
- 28:52events that mean that we're still talking about them all
- 28:54these years later? We'd say for Crashgate, it's the
- 28:57fact that the A-Team intentionally cheated to gain an
- 29:02advantage, which we've rarely ever seen in Formula One.
- 29:05I think this, if ever really, I mean this, it was very, it was
- 29:09very uncommon type of thing to happen and it was the nature of
- 29:12what happened that I think makes it so memorable to this day.
- 29:15Yeah, I would say it's quite something of a spike.
- 29:17It just like the shock value of what actually happened that
- 29:21essentially some man's ego got hurt and then he, yeah, decided
- 29:25to commit corporate espionage and was caught by the clerk at
- 29:30the photocopy store because of the prancing.
- 29:32Horse. That's the best thing.
- 29:33That's the best part is that the guy was like a Ferrari fan and a
- 29:37learner Ferrari. He was like, wait, what do you
- 29:39mean Mclarens getting advantage? I'm not gonna let that happen.
- 29:42Yeah, it's hilarious and I think it's also.
- 29:45We kind of touched on this, but the thousands of it all like now
- 29:48you would take your phone and put like if you didn't have a
- 29:51photocopier, you would just scan every document with your phone
- 29:54and make a document out of it. Or you would buy you would
- 29:57Amazon a photocopier to your like.
- 30:00It would be very quite simple. There are solutions to this
- 30:02problem. Exactly.
- 30:04And not get caught. So yeah, I think just the like
- 30:08fact that all of this happened and like so obviously as well is
- 30:13quite hilarious. I'm just thinking about it now,
- 30:15like it wouldn't have taken much effort to have just taken the
- 30:18papers but cut off the Prancing Horse logos.
- 30:22Like surely they're not plastered everywhere?
- 30:24Yeah, but what? The clerk would have just found
- 30:26that really suspicious that the bottom right corner is just
- 30:29suspicious of the cut out on every single page.
- 30:33Literally every single page. Am I less suspicious than to be
- 30:36pointing them in the first place?
- 30:38I. Don't know something guys.
- 30:39Literally all you need is a dream and some tip X.
- 30:43That's it and that's all you need.
- 30:44And all of a sudden one of these two major controversies of the
- 30:48early to mid 2000s and F1 just doesn't exist then.
- 30:51But I could be wrong about this. I'm so sure that the
- 30:54photocopying place was either close to McLaren HQ or it was so
- 30:59close to their home where everyone in their near vicinity
- 31:02he knew exactly where he worked. Which is also why the dots
- 31:06started to connect as well and people were like hold on, you
- 31:08don't work for this team. I could be wrong, but I'm so
- 31:12sure it's one or the other. Which is obviously again what
- 31:15adds to the early thousands sitcom drama of it all.
- 31:18I don't think that anyone can deny the importance of these two
- 31:20events in F1. And of course the fact, like I
- 31:22said, that we're still talking about them now no matter what
- 31:24the reason just goes to prove that.
- 31:25But would you say that we can still see the legacies of these
- 31:29controversies in F1 today? Absolutely.
- 31:31I mean, as we've mentioned the a lot of the P people involved in
- 31:34those events are still in F1 today and Flavio's management
- 31:38store, for example. I don't it has not aged a single
- 31:40bit. He still manages like he did
- 31:42back in the day. I mean, it's somehow working
- 31:45right now, but I don't know how much longer obviously.
- 31:48Sorry, I'm just fulfilling A sponsorship obligation, so
- 31:53that's not on. Yeah, it's the he's Flavio's
- 31:57hundred star hasn't changed Crashgate.
- 31:58So that he could pay Rohan today.
- 32:02It all moves in a circle. I've been paid with blood, yeah.
- 32:07I mean, I was the one of the key impacts obviously the the lot
- 32:10the people, key people involved in Crashgate are still in F1 to
- 32:14varying capacities. So I think that's that's how I
- 32:17see it mainly. Yeah.
- 32:18I mean same with Spygate, I would say.
- 32:20With Crashgate, you also see like Felipe Massa still
- 32:24challenges the 2008 championship.
- 32:26It's like it's getting a little sad.
- 32:28I hate to say it, but like the basically his argument is that
- 32:332008 Singapore Grand Prix should be null and void from the 2008
- 32:37championship because the results were essentially fabricated
- 32:41because of the crash. What that negates is that that
- 32:44also negates everybody else's work in that race to get where
- 32:47they got essentially. So yes, it was unfair.
- 32:51Yes, it was staged, yes, they shouldn't have done it.
- 32:53No, you can't just kind of like get rid of that race because the
- 32:57result you wanted didn't happen and then you didn't win your
- 33:00little championship. Sorry.
- 33:02But yeah, he will. Still.
- 33:03He still continuingly challenges the 2008 Formula One Drivers
- 33:07Championship in court and has repeatedly gotten basically
- 33:12denied. Yeah, they basically just told
- 33:13him to get lost. Did I do want to mention because
- 33:16because they found Fernando Alonso not guilty.
- 33:20But even though he technically could have been in some very
- 33:23capacity, because of the suspicion of like the structure,
- 33:25he was allowed to keep his winning points.
- 33:27I can't remember how the old point system went beyond third,
- 33:31but he was allowed to keep the points he got for winning, which
- 33:33in itself was very controversial at the time.
- 33:37As a self-proclaimed expert in the Filippo Massa case, because
- 33:41I was just following it because it was interesting, it's do you
- 33:44feel for him? Because obviously the manner in
- 33:46which he also lost that championship in 2008, I can
- 33:49imagine is another thing that's spurring him on.
- 33:51Obviously to have been a world champion for all of 30 seconds
- 33:54until Lewis Hamilton overtook Timo Glock and ended up getting
- 33:58the points he needed to be able to secure his first world
- 34:00champion championship in Brazil of all places.
- 34:03Felipe Massa, for anyone who doesn't know, is a Brazilian, is
- 34:06a Brazilian citizen and he represented Brazil while he was
- 34:09racing in Formula One. I can imagine that that's not
- 34:12easy. Obviously if you look at any of
- 34:14the old clips of Massa celebrating, he, I believe he
- 34:17won in Brazil in 2008, but he ended up losing the
- 34:20championship. If you see him celebrating on
- 34:22the podium is obviously quite an emotional thing because he was
- 34:25world champion for all of 30 seconds until Lewis Hamilton
- 34:28obviously crossed cross the finish line.
- 34:30It's been acknowledged that Benny Eccleston and Max Mosley
- 34:34were at fault for not investigating the incident
- 34:37properly. But yes, Felipe Massa has
- 34:39effectively been taught, has been told by courts within the
- 34:43UK obviously where he's fighting this case and continues to even
- 34:46now, that unfortunately the actual championship itself can't
- 34:49be reversed. The race can't be stricken from
- 34:51the record either. The only thing that they can do
- 34:54is award him compensation financially for all that he
- 34:57would have lost because if he had been champion, he would have
- 35:00obviously had extra sponsorships which would have generated more
- 35:04income. So that is something that he's
- 35:05liable for and courts have agreed that that is something
- 35:08that can be taken in front of a judge and obviously with his
- 35:11team and then with the team of Bernie Eccleston and Co.
- 35:14But unfortunately that championship is not going
- 35:16anywhere anytime soon. I remember reading a really odd
- 35:19headline in the aftermath of 20, 21 that said that Lewis Hamilton
- 35:23hasn't become an 8 time world champion and all of a sudden
- 35:27could be demoted to a six time world champion because Felipe
- 35:30Massa could be awarded the 2008 title in retrospect, which was
- 35:34very confusing. And that's kind of where my
- 35:36fascination with the legal case started.
- 35:38So this has been a very long standing thing for me, hence the
- 35:42extreme amount of detail. But yeah, basically he'll be
- 35:44given money if he ends up winning, but there's no
- 35:47guarantee that he will. Which is the what?
- 35:49The judge who did the initial inquest into the hearing said, I
- 35:53believe it was a couple of months ago, back in 2025.
- 35:56Now, I said in the introduction to this episode that there's
- 36:00certain things that the three of us absolutely love to talk
- 36:02about. And if our discussion in this
- 36:03episode has shown anything, then it's that controversies are most
- 36:07definitely on that list. Although this episode on Spygate
- 36:09and Crash Gate might have felt like a long time coming
- 36:11considering how many rewind episodes we've already done.
- 36:15Are there any other controversies that you think
- 36:17could rival these two in terms of magnitude or championship
- 36:21implication? Gentlemen, short view back to
- 36:24the first. It's rewind to December 2021 and
- 36:28the Abu Dhabi GP, which probably is the most controversial race
- 36:32of all time. I mean, obviously we know it was
- 36:35rigged because the FIA president and that race director, Michael
- 36:39Massey basically rigged it No, I'm joking.
- 36:42I'm a Lewis Hamilton fan. He.
- 36:43Basically did he was like, OK, this needs to be more exciting
- 36:46than it is. I'm gonna ship Lewis's
- 36:48championship. Because so to explain it at the
- 36:51time, it was the end of the Abu Dhabi Grand Prix.
- 36:54Lewis Hamilton and Max Verstappen have been fighting
- 36:57the entire season for the 2021 drivers title, and Nicholas
- 37:03Latifi crashed towards the end of the race in the hotel section
- 37:08in the third sector of the Abu Dhabi GP track.
- 37:11Mohan might have been able to see it given she was there.
- 37:13Maybe, but this caused a safety car.
- 37:17Lewis Hamilton did not box for new tyres under this safety
- 37:21CarMax Verstappen did. Which essentially meant that Max
- 37:24Verstappen got fresh softs for the last couple laps of the race
- 37:27and Lewis Hamilton was on like dying cards and I'm pretty sure
- 37:30they'd already passed their expiry date.
- 37:32And he lost the He lost his eighth title because of a rigged
- 37:36safety car. And after this essentially.
- 37:39What happened was that this has never happened in Formula One
- 37:42because when you're in a safety car, people don't unlap
- 37:45themselves. Normally this just.
- 37:47I was about to and sorry get to that.
- 37:49Well, and then, but Michael Massey says, OK, all the
- 37:53unlapped cars unlap yourselves, which means Max, what's
- 37:56happened, who is at the back of the pack because he pitted is
- 37:59right behind those Hamilton and of course very close to him
- 38:02because there's a safety car and then he overtakes it and wins
- 38:05the championship. I was just about to mention that
- 38:08actually, I was just saying Michael Massey and then but
- 38:11essentially that happened and Max was often won the race and
- 38:15cost Lewis is 8th title and I I for Eddie Lewis Hamilton found
- 38:21it's probably the sore subject and I myself.
- 38:23I've never watched the race since Yeah, since 2021 when it
- 38:27was live. I've never watched it since.
- 38:28I've sworn to myself, I'm never watching you ever again.
- 38:31Yeah, I'll be done with 2021 first and I'll scroll away as
- 38:34quickly as possible. It's like it's a very it's not
- 38:36even a sore subject. It's just it's like a post PTSD
- 38:39or something. It's.
- 38:40The wound that will never heal for you, that that.
- 38:43That's the impression that I'm getting from both.
- 38:44Of you if I I mean, there was a lot of controversy around a lot
- 38:49of controversy around Michael Massey and I don't.
- 38:55And he did get fired after the race, indeed.
- 38:59Thank God. And I hope he's never allowed
- 39:01near an FYA sanctioned event ever again.
- 39:03But we've seen how those kind of rules have been circumnavigated
- 39:07in recent years, so you just never know really.
- 39:09Yeah, it's I've never watched the race since I never will.
- 39:13And honestly, I don't think I've I can never live with the fact
- 39:16that Lewis lost his eighth title to a rigged safety car.
- 39:19Sometimes I think it was like an inside job that that Nicholas
- 39:23let's TV crash. OK well cuz crash game 2.0.
- 39:26This was my thought while I was searching both of these events
- 39:30is we mentioned the way these happened are very like it's like
- 39:35they got they didn't get away with it essentially because they
- 39:38didn't ever printer. Oh, they didn't get away with it
- 39:40essentially because they didn't cover their tracks enough.
- 39:43And like because like literally you were practicing your crash
- 39:47on the warm up lap. Like they were just dumb about
- 39:49it. So my thought is what if all of
- 39:52these things are keep happening in Formula One, but people are
- 39:55smarter now and we have better technology now, you know what I
- 39:59mean? So that was my thought as well,
- 40:00is that means we don't have other scandals like this because
- 40:04people gotten. People aren't as dumb and people
- 40:06have realized oh I can Amazon a printer to my house so I'm going
- 40:10to do that instead of getting caught and fined £1,000,000.
- 40:14I love how in the space of a single podcast episode, we've
- 40:17gone from comparing F1 to a reality TV show to all of a
- 40:20sudden it's now the plot of the next Ocean's movie.
- 40:24I absolutely love that and I think if that.
- 40:26Doesn't. I'm telling you, Abu Dhabi 2021
- 40:28was an inside job. I'm convinced.
- 40:32Please don't, because the next F1 movie is going to have that
- 40:35exact plot you had. I mean the F1, the only thing
- 40:38they didn't do in the F1 movie was Ferway.
- 40:40They actually did do that. They basically did every illegal
- 40:43thing in the book. I would.
- 40:44Love to know when I watched the F1 movie, and I know we said
- 40:47this when we did our review episode all those weeks ago, I
- 40:52would love to know what Fernando Alonso's reaction was at the
- 40:55premiere when he watched Crash Gate effectively happen right in
- 40:59front of him on the screen. And it was one thing in and
- 41:02obviously in 2007 when when 2000 when Crash Gate actually
- 41:08happened because it happened once, given the nature of Nelson
- 41:11PK Junior's crash in the F1 movie.
- 41:14It happens, I believe on three separate occasions.
- 41:17Now let's put everything else aside.
- 41:19We're currently operating an F1 in a cost cap era.
- 41:23I would love to know how Apex GP justified all of those costs
- 41:27because I think if James Valves had anything to say about it, if
- 41:30he had been in charge of Apex GP, that conversation would not
- 41:33be a fun one. Probably overweight.
- 41:37OK guys, one problem at a time if you're Williams, one problem
- 41:40at a time. But yeah, I'd we just don't have
- 41:43controversies to the same extent anymore.
- 41:46And I honestly think obviously Abu Dhabi 2021 was now five
- 41:50years ago and we're, the fact that we're still talking about
- 41:53it again, I can't imagine what it would have been like if
- 41:56you're McLaren or if you're Renault or if you're Ferrari to
- 41:59have just basically finished reeling from Spygate and all of
- 42:04a sudden bam, crash gate. Just I honestly, I don't know
- 42:07how you would do it. But that's the crazy thing is
- 42:09they happen within two years of each other like.
- 42:12Maybe that was planned as well. Things we'll never.
- 42:15Maybe we'll never know. This is somehow gone from a
- 42:17rewind episode that. Again, and we will know.
- 42:20I would love for that. I would love for his, like,
- 42:22parting gift to F1 when he decides that he's going to
- 42:25retire to be a mass e-mail filled with everything he's ever
- 42:29been Privy to across all his teams, all his years of racing
- 42:33to everyone. And then that's it.
- 42:35We just never hear from Fernando Alonso again, but I do.
- 42:38Have an. Ibook.
- 42:39Or better yet, like a podcast episode.
- 42:42We should invite him. When he does decide to retire,
- 42:45we should ask him to come and speak to us here.
- 42:48I would probably have to caveat that and say that he can't
- 42:51listen to anything we've ever done before, but I do think that
- 42:54it would be probably one of the most interesting episodes we'd
- 42:57ever have. I mean, as a producer of the
- 42:59show, I'm sure I can work on that.
- 43:02I mean, he's probably just watching the F1 movie thinking
- 43:04I've played these games before. And I did them better.
- 43:07I would not. There is not a doubt in my mind
- 43:10that he watched Crash Gate happen on the screen and be
- 43:12like, yeah, the real thing was so much better than this.
- 43:15But I do also just have to say again, we went from comparing F1
- 43:19to a reality TV show to an oceans, the plot of an oceans
- 43:22movie. And now somehow we've gone from
- 43:24a rewind episode to a conspiracy theory episode.
- 43:26So again, just goes to show F1 is a sport of many layers.
- 43:31And if there's anyone who ever doubted that it could be
- 43:34interesting and that it is more than just men driving around in
- 43:37circles in very fast cars, this episode is the one to listen to,
- 43:40to change your mind. Moving back towards F1 in the
- 43:43current day, last week's headlines were dominated by
- 43:45rumors and now confirmed news that GP would be leaving Red
- 43:49Bull to join McLaren, as so many of his former Red Bull
- 43:51colleagues have done, including but not limited to Rob Marshall
- 43:55and Will Courtney. However, another move also took
- 43:58place and that was Dan Milner leaving Mercedes to join his
- 44:01former Mercedes colleague James Vowels over at Williams.
- 44:05Milner, who was the chief engineer for research and
- 44:07development at the Silver Arrows, joins Williams with a
- 44:09key focus on development, something they could desperately
- 44:12use right now given where they are in the Constructors
- 44:15Championship. Where does this what does this
- 44:17new signing indicate about Williams view of the future and
- 44:20what they need to do when it comes to getting to where they
- 44:23want to be? I think it signals that Williams
- 44:26are doubling down on the problems they're facing so far
- 44:28this year and the fact that even though they're in quite a bad
- 44:31situation, as it's done, they're trying to pull a McLaren and
- 44:34develop their way out of it and work their way through what
- 44:37they're having to face at the minute.
- 44:39That's what that's my initial thoughts on this.
- 44:41And also I think it just shows how they value kind of people
- 44:45have come from really high up teams or teams who have been
- 44:48very, very. The best team, Obviously the
- 44:50best team. Right.
- 44:51I think that was the main thing with Carlos Sainz's move is like
- 44:54they want James Wallace essentially was like we want a
- 44:57driver who knows the inner workings of a top, top team
- 45:01well. The best team?
- 45:02Maybe not the strategy, but, you know, other things to basically
- 45:06make Williams function as a top, top team and therefore hopefully
- 45:10be a top, top team. And so I think that's kind of
- 45:13the same thing here with bringing in someone from
- 45:15Mercedes. I mean, I'm sure it's someone
- 45:17that James Wells knows quite well given his time at Mercedes,
- 45:20and someone who will of course have good insight into what it
- 45:25takes to get to the top. I think the really interesting
- 45:27thing about obviously the Milner signing is the fact that, yes,
- 45:30he's coming from a position where his focus literally was on
- 45:32recession development, but also at the same time, he's overseen
- 45:36Mercedes across multiple different teams as well.
- 45:39Was there, I believe it was 13 years, which means that
- 45:42obviously he was there when they were born in their one
- 45:45championship winning season. And then prior to that then as
- 45:47well, which means that it when it comes to overseeing
- 45:51development on like a rapid major scale, that's something
- 45:54that he is able to do. And obviously 13 years means
- 45:57that he was there for every single one of Mercedes's 8
- 46:00record-breaking constructors championship wins.
- 46:02What I do want to follow that up with though obviously because
- 46:05Marie, you said that he is an indication that they want the
- 46:08right people from and the right teams in the right places.
- 46:11What would you say then separates the same choice that
- 46:16Aston Martin have made from what Williams are doing?
- 46:19Because effectively it's the same thing, isn't it?
- 46:20You get the right people in the right places and hope that it
- 46:23works, but it's obviously yielding to not significantly
- 46:27different, but different enough results at the moment.
- 46:30I mean trash gate. Goats.
- 46:32Ghosts of the past haunting Fernando Alonso.
- 46:36That might be it. The spy gate.
- 46:37Ghosts of. The difference between the
- 46:39Williams and Aston Martin is Williams have a plan.
- 46:43Aston Martin and just I don't even know what they're doing at
- 46:46this point. They're kind of just like the
- 46:47Aston Martin because. They don't even and have a team
- 46:49principal from what I can understand, which I think
- 46:52something that we've praised Williams for the last few months
- 46:55or however long we've been doing this podcast is how kind of, I
- 46:59want to say distinguished he is as a leader in the team.
- 47:02Like he's very poised. He's very has a plan.
- 47:06He's always speaks to the team in a very like for not like
- 47:10formal, but friendly. I want to say like kind of way
- 47:13like he has a very clear plan. He tells everybody that plan, He
- 47:17attempts to execute said plan. And it seems, I think this is
- 47:21what Rohan was getting at. So add to my point if you have
- 47:24anything to say but or anything to add, but is that it seems
- 47:27that Aston Martin are kind of floundering and that they're
- 47:29like, oh, we'll get Adrian Newey and then we'll be good.
- 47:31It wasn't. These are the steps we need to
- 47:34take to get to this certain point.
- 47:35And then we can move on from this certain point by doing this
- 47:37like it was. Yeah.
- 47:40Essentially, it feels like Williams would like if they're
- 47:43playing F1 manager, except they've got all the settings
- 47:46turned on to low and they're doing a rebuild, but Aston
- 47:48Martin are doing playing F1 manager, but they've got all
- 47:52this like maximum money, all the best drivers, the best staff and
- 47:55stuff, and then you're already at the top, you're still
- 47:57failing. That's the only analogy I could
- 47:59think of. What an analogy though.
- 48:01Like you've rendered both of us speechless because that is
- 48:03basically effectively what they're doing as the Martin have
- 48:06a blank checkbook and a dream. A dream that I don't foresee
- 48:09being realized anytime soon. It's a pipe dream.
- 48:12Yeah, Given their current trajectory, this is not
- 48:14something that's going to be happening anytime soon,
- 48:16Williams. Everyone was so hopeful and
- 48:19obviously we've been talking about this for so, so long.
- 48:21Everyone really thought that this was it, 2026 was going to
- 48:25be the year and we're going to see, especially because they
- 48:27left off in 2025 in such a positive way and in such a good
- 48:31place as well in terms of the constructors championship
- 48:33standings and then they've taken in this massive step backwards.
- 48:37It's good that obviously they know what it is that they need
- 48:39to change. My concern I suppose is the fact
- 48:43that obviously once they get that car underweight, do they
- 48:46already have an idea about what other potential problems could
- 48:49be in either the chassis or their management of the power
- 48:52unit that could be hindering that performance?
- 48:55Because it's no good if all of a sudden you get the car within
- 48:58the weight conditions and yet you're still not fast.
- 49:01That that's my main concern as it currently stands.
- 49:03But obviously again, the signing, the focus on research
- 49:06and development, I think it's a good indication, but I also
- 49:09think it's an indication that nothing is going to be
- 49:12drastically changing in terms of where they are and how quick
- 49:14they are anytime soon. When you bring someone in for
- 49:18research and development, that's a long term thing.
- 49:20And considering they're already in the first stage of a long
- 49:23term project, I'm not even cautious to be optimistic about
- 49:26the rest of this season. And I think that's a shame
- 49:28because you can't make a really big statement and say 2425,
- 49:32break it, I don't care because 26 is the focus and then start
- 49:3626 like this. I'm sure that almost everyone is
- 49:38tired of hearing about the GP news by this point, given how
- 49:41much three of us spoke about obviously in last week's
- 49:43episode. But I'm going to reference it
- 49:45one more time and then I promise I'm done.
- 49:47The departure of GP from Red Bull brings to an end one of the
- 49:50greatest driver engineer partnerships on the current grid
- 49:53and perhaps in F1 history. Between obviously the two GP and
- 49:57Max Verstappen, who've been together since Verstappen's
- 49:59promotion to the senior team all the way back when in 2016.
- 50:03Given how long the pair have worked together and how this is
- 50:06truly the end of an era, it got me thinking about something and
- 50:09I thought I'd put the question to you both.
- 50:11What are some of the other best driver engineer pairings in F1
- 50:15history? Lewis and Bonnet Jinx.
- 50:18That's right. Lewis and Bonner, Max and GP
- 50:22Lando and Will Joseph. I would say he's going to become
- 50:25iconic. I don't feel like it is at the
- 50:27minute because I would say that's one to look out for.
- 50:31I think across history my knowledge is not as strong as
- 50:34that, but I would say there's so many.
- 50:36I also have to say Sebastian Vettel and his race engineer,
- 50:39whose name I'm completely blanking on right now, but
- 50:42obviously. Good job, Good job.
- 50:44Delivered one of the most incredible radio messages in F1
- 50:47history. You just wait, sunshine, when
- 50:49Sebastian Vettel crossed the line and Abu Dhabi to win the
- 50:52first of four consecutive World Championship titles. 2 It's a
- 50:57great. He's the head of the Red Bull
- 50:59Junior Academy now. Actually last time I chat I
- 51:02can't remember his name. I would also add to the list
- 51:05Brian and in this. Kind.
- 51:08Of vain as Sebastian Vettel and his race engineer, Brian and
- 51:13Charles Leclerc because you listen to any of their radio
- 51:16messages. Must be the water.
- 51:18Must be the add that to the words of wisdom.
- 51:20Some of the greatest radio messages in modern Formula One.
- 51:25But I want to Ricardo, Ricardo Adami and then Ricardo Adami and
- 51:30Carlos Sainz and Lewis Hamilton because the amount of times you
- 51:32just trolled them in every race is very funny.
- 51:35Maybe for the opposite reasons of the other ones we're getting.
- 51:38We're getting too many here, but I would also say Marcus Dudley
- 51:41and George Russell because like, their radio messages are also
- 51:47iconic. Absolutely, 100%.
- 51:49Yeah, yeah, Mexico, 2020 people. Go look it up.
- 51:54I would also say, Oh my gosh, tell me I'm doing good.
- 51:57Tell me I'm doing good. For a Singapore do that 2025 was
- 52:01quite funny. I don't.
- 52:02It's just the positive motivation that he needs.
- 52:05That's all it is. I would just like to add in
- 52:07here, it is Sebastian Vettel. And please forgive my
- 52:10pronunciation of this. I'm not even going to try with
- 52:12his first name, but it's Rocklin.
- 52:14And the reason I remember it's Rocklin is because his nickname
- 52:16was Rocky. That that's why.
- 52:18That's what sticks in my head. But that was obviously
- 52:20Sebastian. Vettel.
- 52:21Amazing. Amazing.
- 52:22That's what that was. Sebastian Vettel's race engineer
- 52:25at Red Bull. And the final one that I'm going
- 52:27to add to this list is Jensen Button and Andrew Chauvelin.
- 52:30Andrew Chauvelin, who obviously still remains at Mercedes even
- 52:32now, That was his race engineer during his during the season.
- 52:37I'm just going to confirm this to make sure.
- 52:39Yes, during the season when Jensen Button won his one and
- 52:43only world championship title, but he's just great.
- 52:47He speaks to Sky on occasion when Sky is given access to
- 52:50Mercedes's pit wall across an F1 weekend and I I think he's just
- 52:54great. So I think that's another great
- 52:56partnership and obviously to step into that role, knowing
- 52:58bronze tumultuous history as they were obviously moving from
- 53:02being a Honda team into being Brown and then Brown into
- 53:04Mercedes and sticking at the team and obviously rising
- 53:07through the ranks as well. I think it's just a phenomenal
- 53:09job. It's a testament to obviously
- 53:10what both of them achieved together.
- 53:12That's all for our rewind episode discussing 2 of the
- 53:14biggest sporting controversies in Motorsports, Spygate and
- 53:17Crash Gate. On behalf of myself and my
- 53:19wonderful Co host, thank you so much for listening and we hope
- 53:22that you enjoyed the episode. If you enjoyed the episode and
- 53:24would like to listen to more Dive Bomb podcasts, then please
- 53:27do check out the Formula E, IndyCar, NASCAR, and Endurance
- 53:30Racing podcasts. Thank you.