Latest / Five Games for Doomsday / 5G4D News-The Fire and Swords Episode
Transcript
- 0:07From the kitchen of the cabin. It's the Five Games for Doomsday News with
- 0:11Ben and Steve. So here we are. Is this exciting? The Five
- 0:19g for D News show Transcontinental Stephen, I'm vibing, Ben, I'm vibing
- 0:26you know what. I'm back in New York City. I feel like whenever
- 0:29I come home to the place of my birth, something happens to me,
- 0:32like I'm transformed into like the person who I really am. When I'm in
- 0:36Vierlin, I'm someone else entirely. I'm like some weird globe tritting eurofile.
- 0:40But back in back in America, back in New York City, I'm the
- 0:43real Steve, the real deal. How many times have you been on a
- 0:46jet skate since you've been back. I'm on a jetsky right now. Ben,
- 0:49Can you hear the noise in the background. That's the surf, That's
- 0:52incredible. I'm always in New York cr Thankfully, that's what we are.
- 0:56Thankfully the city. It's a city known for water sports. You ride right
- 1:00on jet skis. So I've got a question for you, Steve. You
- 1:03went to America because you're a huge nerd. How was the eclipse? The
- 1:11eclipse a little bit of a disappointment. Then, I gotta tell you the
- 1:14eclipse was on Monday, right, Sunday, beautiful sunny blue skies. Yesterday,
- 1:19beautiful sunny blue skies. Tuesday, Monday, fucking shit, fucking shit,
- 1:25clouds, fucking bullshit. I didn't see ship second time in a row,
- 1:30fucking solar eclipse. You didn't see the eclipse, Well, I'm dropping
- 1:36out of There were lots of pictures on the Internet of people who saw the
- 1:40eclipse, so you missed out. Well, the eclipse the path of totality
- 1:46ben extended from Mazatlan, Mexico, all the way to somewhere in Canada,
- 1:53Northeast Canada, and I was in an area that happened to have heavy cloud
- 1:59cover. I knew it was a possibility. It happened to me last time
- 2:01I went to see a fucking eclipse. I went to China to see an
- 2:04eclipse, same same thing two years from So, actually, in twenty twenty
- 2:09six and twenty twenty seven, there's gonna be a solar eclipse in Spain in
- 2:15August, and there are no clouds in Spain and August, and I'm already
- 2:19talking to Big kaas we're gonna do a fucking eclipse can in twenty twenty six
- 2:23in Spain. Oh exciting, and we're gonna play eclipse eclipse, Well,
- 2:30I mean you have to, Yeah, I want. I once took a
- 2:32two hour plane ride and then an eighteen hour train ride to see the northern
- 2:38lights in the very north tip of Sweden. Have a guest, Steve,
- 2:44how many Northern lights I saw on that trip? Somewhere between zero and fuck
- 2:50off? It was northern fuck all. And not only that, on the
- 2:53way back, the person I was with in the sleeper vomited in their in
- 3:00their sleeper and I just think their pukel night. It was amazing. What
- 3:04a trip. And you know, you know what the people told me after,
- 3:07we were all collectively disappointed and not seeing the eclipse. And and maybe
- 3:12you have a similar situation with your northern lights. Well you know, at
- 3:15least we're together, at least you have a memory. Yes, blah blah
- 3:19blah. Yeah, fuck it. No, I'm disappointed. And you know
- 3:22what, it's okay to be disappointed. Disappointment is a legitimate human emotion.
- 3:24I'll get over it. But I am disappointed. Well, since the americanization
- 3:30of our culture, you're not allowed to voice disappointment anymore because your country is
- 3:36terminally optimistic. Yeah, I traveled, you know, several thousand kilometers or
- 3:44miles as we say, here to see a fucking you know, rare astronomical
- 3:49event. I didn't see it, And people are like, are you disappointed?
- 3:53Like, yes, I'm disappointed, but interestingly, Ben, you might
- 3:58you might, you might like the sound of this. Twenty twenty six in
- 4:00Spain, the path of totality passes over Burgo, Spain, or there most
- 4:05of them. And yeah, I know, because it passes over most of
- 4:09the path of the Camino de Santiago. Oh im a reprise, A reprise
- 4:15of the Camino during a total solar eclipse. I mean that would be good.
- 4:18I mean, I doubt I'm going to do it. I don't have
- 4:20money, but it would be great anyway, Steve. So we're moving on.
- 4:23This is the news. Ask me some questions, Steve. I want
- 4:28you to turn interviewer. Ask me some questions about the current state of five
- 4:32games for Doomsday and what's happening in that. I have a question prepared.
- 4:36Oh, good question. My question. Why do you always wait until one
- 4:41hour before we record to ask people on the discord to give us questions for
- 4:45the AMA. Well, I don't always do it, but this time I
- 4:48had to because of your globe trotting escapades. I didn't know when we were
- 4:56recording, and you rather that you were free cord. You knew we would
- 5:00record eventually, That's that's true. So so what you're doing is you're pulling
- 5:08back the curtain to reveal my ineptitude is that it? Yes? Are you?
- 5:14Are you lashing at you didn't get to see the eclipse? Is that
- 5:16what it is out? It's a very thin curtain. It's like it's like
- 5:25it's like, is there even a curtain here? So transparent? All right,
- 5:30ask me another question about what's happening with five G for D and that
- 5:35Okay, you put me on the spot. So uh, let's let's let's
- 5:40let me ask you a question about the the RPG. So what do we
- 5:43have to look forward to with the forthcoming Temple of Elemental Evil RPG series?
- 5:50So fascinating. So we had the final prelude episode on Monday with your Good
- 5:57Lady Wife. Have you listened to it yet? Yes? Yeah, I
- 6:00thought it was rather good. And so when you get back from your trip,
- 6:06then we'll sit down and have everybody at the table, We'll record it
- 6:11live, I'll edit it, and so I'm hoping beginning of May will be
- 6:15when the first real episode with everyone sat around the table, the first actual
- 6:20play episode comes up. And I'm very excited about it. It's gonna be
- 6:24cool, I think, Yeah, I'm very excited about this too. And
- 6:27there are a number of reasons. First of all, you're the best DM
- 6:31I've ever had, and that's like not at of course, although very little
- 6:36competition, you've done and you did the entirety of the Curse of Strawd for
- 6:42myself and my coworkers as like a team building activity. I think, did
- 6:46it take us one year or two years to finish the whole thing? I
- 6:48don't even know, like eighteen months something like that. Yeah, it was,
- 6:51it was. It was great. I loved it. I've been wanting
- 6:55to play Temple of Elemental Evil since I was a teenager, and I knew
- 7:00about it as a campaign, but it's such a large, hairy campaign and
- 7:04it's like a first edition module. It just happens to uh yeah, yeah
- 7:12exactly, and it's like perfect opportunity. And you've been doing these solo RPGs
- 7:17over the last few years. We haven't had one recently, but I think
- 7:20that they're very popular. The listeners really like them, and it's just like
- 7:25all of this has been preparation for this event, this major RPG podcast contribution.
- 7:31So I think it's going to be good. I'm really I'm really into
- 7:33it. Yeah. I want to get some art done of the characters if
- 7:36I can as well. So if you're a budding artist out there, I
- 7:40want to do some arts of characters. Get in touch with me. I
- 7:43can pay, not a lot, but I can pay anyway. Also,
- 7:46use you could just use AI. Then I'm not doing it. I'm not
- 7:49doing it, Steve, I mean I use AI. Well, I don't
- 7:53use AI. My my thumbnail producer, I think uses AI for my thumbnails
- 7:58on YouTube. But so on the subject of YouTube, last week I did
- 8:05five games for nihilists. Who was talking about YouTube? You well, I
- 8:09was talking about YouTube. Oh you did a segue. I see, Yeah,
- 8:13it's called a fucking seamless segue that you just pointed out. Stop pulling
- 8:18back the curtain. I'm not wearing any pants fucking invisible curtains. So then
- 8:24Thursday, so that's tomorrow from when we were recording, I'm bringing out my
- 8:28second video in my philosophy series, five Games for Hedonists. And do you
- 8:37know what my I didn't realize you were doing a philosophy series. Yeah,
- 8:41so I've done nihilism, I'm doing hedonism and you know what I'm gonna do
- 8:45the week after I'm really looking forward to it. Is Hedenism a philosophy?
- 8:50Yeah, it's a kind of philosophy, isn't it. I don't know,
- 8:54maybe like Epicureanism is a philosophy. Yeah, I was thinking about Epicureanism,
- 8:58but it's a little too specific for me. I went for hedonism. I
- 9:01think it's like, I mean, I don't know, a little bit too
- 9:03to out there intellectual to say like five games for Epicureans. I mean,
- 9:09this is true, this is true. The listeners can't hear it I'm wearing
- 9:11I'm wearing my intellectual glasses now, but do you know what I'm doing next
- 9:16week? They can hear it in the elevated chamber of your intellectual I'm worrying
- 9:20it'll take away my comedic superpower, Steve wearing glasses, and I'll become more
- 9:26serious in that. So do you know what I'm doing next week. I'm
- 9:30really excited about it. Next week, five games for uh Bellndez, five
- 9:39games Steve, four Objectivists. That's going to be my video next week.
- 9:46I mean that would be like basically any economic Euros that's easy. I'm just
- 9:50going to do five economic Euros. It's going to be brilliant. But I
- 9:56get to make loads of jokes about Annie Rando, so it's going to be
- 10:00anyway. Yeah, and like Ruthless, Pitiless Capitalist Apples exactly all eurogames.
- 10:07So also, we had Joel Topping on the show, who's not only a
- 10:11game designer but also a priest, so that was interesting to talk about that.
- 10:15Next week we have the co designer of Undaunted and many other games,
- 10:20Trevor Benjamin is coming up on Monday. So it's going to be exciting.
- 10:26And that's what we've got for five g fo D. But Steve, Now,
- 10:30I came to a conclusion, a rather painful conclusion. I must confess.
- 10:37Is this going out on the fore you by the way, Yeah,
- 10:39this is going out the main for you. Yeah, okay, just check
- 10:41in because you came to a conclusion. Yeah, So I came to tell
- 10:46me about the conclusion to which you so abruptly came. The painful conclusion is
- 10:50that the new Patreon backers don't want me to give them a nickname. I
- 10:56think it's true, to be honest, so I have to go that you
- 11:01have to be the official five GVD nickname giver, because we put it out.
- 11:05We put it. From now on, it's just you officially. It's
- 11:07been stamped because I we asked a listener a new patron backer which they wanted
- 11:13to go with, and they came on the discourse and they said they wanted
- 11:16to go with your bloody, stupid populist Nigel Farage, Boris Johnson, Donald
- 11:20Trump, bullshit of a nickname, not my super intellectual Susan Sontag, the
- 11:26esculus of a nickname. You know what I mean? The glasses are really
- 11:31working. That was Did you know this? When I leapt for intellectual people,
- 11:39I went Susan Sontag Andculus. It's not bad, it's not bad,
- 11:43and it's not bad. All right, person one person rejected you, and
- 11:50yeah, that's it. You're out. You're at it, comte your responsibility,
- 11:58all right. So but we don't do nicknames in this episode, do
- 12:01we? Yeah, this is the new show we do. Okay, we
- 12:07do nicknames in the news show, we don't do it in the hashtag channel
- 12:09show. How many? How many nicknames do I have to come up with?
- 12:13Two? Okay, I think you can manage that. All right.
- 12:18So the first one, Steve is someone we both know. Wait, we're
- 12:22doing it now, we're doing it now. You're such a bloody you're such
- 12:26a nickname master. So we're gonna do it now, all right. Okay,
- 12:33So the first person, Steve is someone we both know personally, and
- 12:37that's Ave. No ben Acham, Oh, no way, no way,
- 12:41this is this is too much pressure. Better good knowing ben Achham. Yeah,
- 12:50what am I gonna have? They know him? Because I have to
- 12:52actually, like, I have to face him in person exactly. He's a
- 12:58he's a he's a friend of mine. You want me to get to see?
- 13:00Now you've got the responsibility. You don't want it, do you.
- 13:03Now you've got the responsibility. You're feeling oh ooh ooh my nickname ability,
- 13:07And now now you're crumbling under the pressure. Hang on a second, Hang
- 13:13on a second. I've got an idea. I go to google something.
- 13:16Though googling I don't usually get to google things when we do these things,
- 13:24these uh, these episodes. Right, Yeah, you don't usually have your
- 13:26computer in front of you, which is a good thing. Yeah, we
- 13:28should. We should do this from now on. I like it. Hang
- 13:33on, hang on, hang on. I'm using a ten year old computer
- 13:37and everything is falling apart. Oh, I've got it. I've got it
- 13:41all right. So ab they know him the Krav Magician. There not okay,
- 13:48I mean I'm not in love with it, but I'm sure he'll love
- 13:50it, the Krav Magician. I'm looking for names of Krav Magot techniques and
- 13:54I can't find any. So, I mean they're all in English. It's
- 13:58not as much fun, but you know, I get it. I get
- 14:03it. I just don't love it, that's all. But I'm not.
- 14:07I mean, you're the official one, now, whatever you say goes.
- 14:09And the second one, Steve, he's not. He's not in the discord
- 14:11anyway. The second one is Telo Marnig Steve what manig monig Kelo lime pie
- 14:26manig no Telo with a T not okay, not Kelo Tilo. But that
- 14:31ruins my whole key. Hey, hey, you just you wanted the responsibility
- 14:37you have it, Telo Marnig Steve Key lime Pi. So there he goes
- 14:46telo Key lime Pie Marnig excellent. So, uh, to wrap up this
- 14:50section, Steve, you love Lord of the Rings. That's right, because
- 14:54you're a bloody huge nerd, don't you. Oh God, love is not
- 14:56the word for it. What do you think of a hard game implementation of
- 15:01the War of the Ring game board game, the one you and I played?
- 15:07Yeah? Good? Yeah? Why why do you act? Cars?
- 15:11Coming up, we've got an interview about the new War of the Ring the
- 15:15card game expansion with designer of the game, Ian Brody. Nice. So,
- 15:20is this is this an expansion that we can actually play or is this
- 15:24like the there's some like co op expansion that you mentioned. Yeah, no,
- 15:26no, it's it's the new one. That's Uh, it's the new
- 15:30one that we can actually play. Are we going to play it? I've
- 15:33alled, I've pre ordered it, so when it comes yes, all right,
- 15:37let's play it. During the interview. I don't have it. You're
- 15:39in America. Let's go to Ian new So I am delighted on the news
- 15:48show to have with me Ian Brody, designer of Quartermaster General and one of
- 15:54my favorite games of twenty twenty two War of the Ring the card game,
- 15:58and that's what we he has to talk aback. So, so, first
- 16:02of all, I know Quartermaster General because it's for a while was incredibly popular
- 16:08in my game group. People were playing it every week. But how did
- 16:11you get the gig to design the War of the Ring card game? Well,
- 16:17it's actually came out of Quartermaster General that once I had decided to become
- 16:23a game designer. My wife and I mostly play the games I'm working on,
- 16:27and we like the game, you know, five nights a week type
- 16:30of thing. So we were playing War of the Ring the board game,
- 16:34which is one of my favorite games ever, and I said, you know,
- 16:38it'd be really fun to make something like Quartermaster General cards for this game,
- 16:45to make it a real multiplayer and you know, just because it'd be
- 16:49fun to work on that. But I realized that they're like approaching intellectual property,
- 16:56like the Lord of the Rings. You just don't I wouldn't even bother
- 17:00starting It's you know, it's one thing to do something as labor of love,
- 17:03but once you decide you're going to do this for a living, you
- 17:06have to focus on realizable projects. So I contacted aries, and I said,
- 17:11you know, I'd love to make a set of cards that people could
- 17:14buy that they could use with your game, you know, the board and
- 17:17the pieces. And they actually knew the game and this was all the way
- 17:22back in twenty late twenty fifteen, and said, well, we like the
- 17:26game, but we thought about it, and we thought decided that we have
- 17:29too many spaces on our board for your game, and so you just have
- 17:33to have a lot of extra cards for a killing time basically, and that
- 17:40you should make the board be exactly what it was. They also told me
- 17:42that they found that when they made and this was I think Fantasy Flight,
- 17:51but when they designed the the the Word the Ring expansion that had Ministeris and
- 17:59Helms deep that basically and they include an expansion for War the Ring. And
- 18:03what they realized is a lot of people were mad because they were buying an
- 18:06expensive game to get a little expansion. So what they said is that let's
- 18:11not if people just like your Quartermaster General having them have to have an expensive
- 18:18War of the Ring just to play your expansion of your imagining. You know,
- 18:22say, you know, five decks of cards type of thing. That's
- 18:26a big extra expense. So they said, why don't you come up with
- 18:30your own board and let's take a look. So we did, and we
- 18:34submitted it to the licenseor who said, well, there's a board, it's
- 18:40got the pieces and it's got cards. So how is this different than War
- 18:44the Ring? And you don't tell them, you know, they don't play
- 18:47the games. They're looking at product lines. So they said, what we
- 18:51really would be interested in is they were very happy that it was something for
- 18:55base for teams, but they said they were really interested in a card only
- 18:59format. Now I don't know if I it is my belief and founded on
- 19:04nothing, but I read this on other people saying it online, so it
- 19:07must be true. Whether were before the two licensers of Middle Earth were uh
- 19:15were merged, which is like a year or two ago. That basically they
- 19:19just were competing against each other. So if one had a card game,
- 19:22the other had if the so if the movie license had a card game,
- 19:26the literary license wanted a card game. So anyhow, that's sort of how
- 19:29we went. So I said, okay, we can. I can make
- 19:32it to a card a game, and it basically is a card game,
- 19:34but with the board as an interface. So I made a version that I
- 19:41spent a year, not just continuously because other stuff was happening, making a
- 19:45version that I wasn't super happy with, and I presented it to aries,
- 19:49and about three weeks after I played it with ROBERTA. Dimiglio, who was
- 19:56the sort of lead game you know, uh, head of the game production
- 20:00and also one of the designers of Wore the Ring. I was play testing
- 20:04with someone who said, you know, this is just like the one that
- 20:07you made with the pieces, but with all this fun sucked out of it.
- 20:12So I immediately told him that I wanted to withdraw that submission because I
- 20:18knew I would only get one shot and if it wasn't a good game,
- 20:22that was it. Like I might as well just not be a game designer.
- 20:26I love The Lord of the Rings. I've read it aloud three times.
- 20:30I hope to do it one more time if I ever have grandchildren.
- 20:32Who knows, But like I love Lord of the Rings that I'd want to
- 20:36do at justice, and I knew I hadn't come up with a great game,
- 20:40so I kind of went back to the beginning of just basically looking at
- 20:45card names, looking at interactions, and also thinking a lot about what does
- 20:51a card game, what's it supposed to do? What's it supposed to be?
- 20:56Like? Going around the table people playing a card you know, taking
- 21:00tricks, you know, holding a card in their hand for that perfect moment
- 21:04where they get to throw it down and say aha, that type of thing.
- 21:08And was I getting all of that? And also a card game is
- 21:14it's going to be a little bit more random. People expect to shuffle the
- 21:18cards and go through them the way they go. So so we basically ended
- 21:25up with something that a second go about that I did really like. I
- 21:30submitted it, they really liked it, and we went from there. So
- 21:38I will tell you this is that. So it originally started as a team
- 21:42game. I like team games. I am not socially competent, so in
- 21:51a multiplayer game, I don't know who to make is my enemy, and
- 21:55then I end up not wanting to attack anybody. So like you can probably
- 22:00just pick on me if we're playing a game, you know, like a
- 22:03multiplayer free for all. Although sometimes by just keeping your head down you in
- 22:07anyhow, like I won a game of Eclipse recently by not fighting anyone the
- 22:15uh and so, and team games give me that experience of having a group,
- 22:21a big group of people together at the table, or a group of
- 22:23people together at the table, So it's social. I know who the enemies
- 22:29are, but I also get to cooperate with teammates, and there's no like
- 22:33bad feeling. When you know who your enemy is. You're supposed to do
- 22:36everything as possible, mean or you know what to the best of your ability.
- 22:41Whereas the multiplayers there's more of a dynamic that way. So and I
- 22:48think, uh, in terms of I'm just for the viewing audience, I
- 22:55have a little bit of a prompt of what we're going to be talking about.
- 22:57I don't have these things written now anyhow, but the sort of next
- 23:02question I like it prompt in a way is like talking about the theme.
- 23:07And I'm really into theme. So I look at game design sort of more
- 23:12like a seventies war gamer. And so when you think about that, they
- 23:19when I think of what was going on, say in the SPI offices or
- 23:23Avalon Hill offices in nineteen seventy five, they weren't necessarily thinking of a system
- 23:30dynamic that and searching for a theme. They were picking a theme and then
- 23:37trying to figure out which systems dynamics would best abstract the theme so when so
- 23:44it's very different than a lot of modern euro games because I didn't because I
- 23:51start with the theme, the names of the cards came before the card text.
- 23:55Something's changed, you know. Sometimes you're like, I really need a
- 23:57card that does this, so let's find that. But that's like three quarters
- 24:03into the design where you're trying to, you know, figure out what's wrong,
- 24:07and the game is basically going right. So we could do a whole
- 24:15long hour on theme. I'm not going to, but let's just say that
- 24:19it's one of the most interesting aspects of game design to me. And so
- 24:26let's talk about the first expansion then, And I'm gonna I'm gonna be honest
- 24:27with you that I was a little bit because I loved the game, I
- 24:33loved ordering the card game, and I was a little bit disappointed with the
- 24:36first expansion because the last thing I wanted was to turn into a co op
- 24:40because I'm just not a fan of co ops. Essentially, why why did
- 24:44you decide to go for a co op for that first expansion? Okay,
- 24:47so there was it was pretty unbeknownst to me. It was pretty clear that,
- 24:55especially during the pandemic, co op and solo gaming had taken off.
- 25:02Like I said, I'm blessed to have a wife who likes gaming a lot,
- 25:06so that doesn't come up for me that often. I mean, we
- 25:08could play sometimes we play co ops, but anyhow, what was obvious was
- 25:15that people wanted a co op mode, and so I sort of worked on
- 25:21one and it ended up I just thought about it a lot. I made
- 25:26about six pages of notes and a rough outline of what I was going to
- 25:33what became the co op version, and I sent it over to aries and
- 25:37I said, well, this is it. It's it's there's eight pages of
- 25:41rules. Six of the pages are card notes. I don't think it's playable.
- 25:47I don't think it's fun to have to pick up the card and look
- 25:51at this, like multiple pages to figure out what your card does. Now,
- 25:56so I was like, I'm not going to public post this on BGG
- 25:59or line. This is not I'm not proud, like I'm not comfortable with
- 26:03this. This is not a game. This is just sort of an idea,
- 26:07so I said. I also said that you know, there are a
- 26:12lot of games, especially now that are not super competitive, not super that
- 26:18there's low player interaction. We're making it into a solo game is immediately obvious,
- 26:25like you know where where all you're doing is say drafting you know,
- 26:30uh, an item from a common pool, and then everybody works on their
- 26:33own tableau. Then it's super simple just to say, okay, there's you
- 26:38know, you just have fewer choices in what you're drafting, or you make
- 26:41a or you only have one rule to change. But in this, in
- 26:45my games, your play affects the other person's play every time, and it
- 26:52should and I want it to be like more like a chess game that like
- 26:56you you can't play against, you can yet play if there's no opponents,
- 27:02so that it's not a So it was a real major overhaul. Like so
- 27:08I said, you know, if I were going to make a co op
- 27:11or solo game, my model would be the Victory Games Sniper. It was
- 27:18called from like the mid eighties where it was purpose built solo. It wasn't
- 27:22trying to be a mode, it was just this is just for a person.
- 27:27And so I said, if I do that and I write wipe out
- 27:30all the shadow cards, we can do it. And they said, well,
- 27:33let's see. So they did a little bit of asking around the partners
- 27:37and everybody said, yeah, sure, if you want to replace the components,
- 27:42we can sell it. So we basically decided it would be so I
- 27:47looked at it kind of as a different game design because it does use a
- 27:49lot of the same components, but it's it feels different when you're playing it,
- 27:56and it is. And so what I'm gonna say is that it's something
- 28:03that is really a different game, set in the same universe and in a
- 28:07very very specific sort of way, so almost like a story set in Gotham
- 28:14in the Batman universe and not like playing the Batman game. I don't know
- 28:19if that makes any sense, but I really felt like this is in order
- 28:22for me to make a good solo co op, I really just have to
- 28:26write a different game, and that's what it is. So I don't know
- 28:30if that's satisfying. I'm hoping I'm not unselling any copies. However, if
- 28:36you do like the theme, and you like Lord of the Rings, and
- 28:38you like something that's to say, a big challenging solo game, this is
- 28:45going to be it. I think some people have complained that it is a
- 28:48little too challenging. I didn't consider the balance to be that important in a
- 28:52solo game, like, do you expect to win half the time? I
- 28:56mean I was winning. I win more than much more than half the time.
- 28:59Again, but I'm the designer, But isn't there a space for mastery?
- 29:03Shouldn't you lose most of the time when you first started, and then
- 29:07win most of the time after you've done it twenty times and then put it
- 29:11on the shelf, you know what I mean, like because it becomes a
- 29:14puzzle. It's not a true it's not an interactive game, so there's no
- 29:18human that you know, to surprise you anyhow. So that was so the
- 29:23expansion really came out out of basically players really want It was sort of this
- 29:30crazy process of players asking for a solo mode, me deciding that it couldn't
- 29:34be done without new components, and then just deciding let's just go for it
- 29:41because you know, it uses the same artwork and things, so as a
- 29:45as a product, it was an easy game to get onto the market quickly.
- 29:51So it's so it's going on to your to the second expansion. The
- 29:55immed about it, I don't want to talk about a lot more. Yes,
- 30:00it's fire and swords, so can you give us then an overview of
- 30:04what this expansion is and what it does and how it changes up the base
- 30:08game. Well, okay, so the first thing is that I want to
- 30:15say is that this was written at the scene. Most of these cards were
- 30:18written at the very same time as the original game, because the very first
- 30:22design was based on the sort of first quartermaster general of three against three.
- 30:27What we decided early, very very early. What I decided was that six
- 30:34players was hard to get to the table, and I wanted to make a
- 30:38really brilliant, I mean, hopefully, I don't know it's an okay,
- 30:41brilliant four person game were something that would make people like really get them into
- 30:48it. And also I felt that the six player version spent a lot of
- 30:52time in places in Middle Earth that the movies didn't touch, and I wanted
- 30:57the four player game to be satisfying to movie only. You know, Lord
- 31:03of the Rings fans, you can only spend so much time hanging out with
- 31:07Tom Bombadeo, right right. Well, and it's also if you never saw
- 31:11read the books, you're then gonna feel like, who is this guy?
- 31:14I'm not getting Like there's no sort of validation against the theme. And so
- 31:19so the first thing is that the new expansion allows you to get to six
- 31:26players around the table and fills out the world of Middle Earth to where the
- 31:32War of the Ring the board game, so all the way. You know
- 31:34the Siege of Arabor, which is not covered in the main narrative, but
- 31:38it's in the appendix appendices of The Return of the King, I'm and you
- 31:45know the Scouring of the Shire, which which I'm which I'm super excited about
- 31:51because I'm it's my one disappointment with the move is that that isn't in them,
- 31:55because I love that section of the book. Yeah, well it's you
- 31:57know, I do too, and it's and the Scouring of the Shire was
- 32:00actually more like he puts what Peter Jackson has them like six endings to that
- 32:07move to the series, but he couldn't add a seventh one where the Hobbits
- 32:10become full like the whole coming of age story. I'm sorry, We're just
- 32:15gonna skip the last one where we're able to handle things on our own without
- 32:20the help of the big people. You know, it's just sort of like
- 32:22never mind, you see what I'm saying, Like there's like there is a
- 32:25story arc that we're just gonna like cut off at the very end anyhow.
- 32:31But in general I thought the movies were great, but you know, and
- 32:36I loved them. But I've got a bunch of notes for Peter Jackson.
- 32:44So so I think one of the things about so I want to say about
- 32:49the expansion, it's not only for five or six players, though that there
- 32:54are. I decided that the way to make the game more playable, like
- 33:00and more have more variety, was create scenarios. And so that basically is
- 33:07going to be to pick and choose amongst the cards for something that plays with
- 33:13say fewer players, or in a shorter amount of time, or focused on
- 33:16one sort of section of the conflict. So there's a scenario for four players
- 33:24which is more in the North, which essentially is focuses on that area of
- 33:31the board, but is still the full nine paths journey the and and there's
- 33:40a two person epic scenario where each path is split into two is it's split
- 33:49into two and you actually go eighteen paths, and it takes a long time
- 33:52to play, but is super duper satisfying. It's a sort of game you
- 33:57leave set up and come back to. It takes that much, but we
- 34:00just had a great time with that I didn't think we would, but you
- 34:04know, getting making it, you know, having to move the fellowship seventeen
- 34:07times, but we really had a great time when we got to see all
- 34:13of Middle Earth, you know out at some point the So that's going to
- 34:16be in there. The addition of new cards will allow me to also write
- 34:22more scenarios, which I'm hoping that say at gen Con that we have some
- 34:28interesting tournaments that by you know, essentially coming up with a somewhat smaller deck
- 34:35by picking out the cards and having a I don't want this to become sort
- 34:37of a CCG or LCG, but I like the part of it is because
- 34:43I don't want to have a situation where people have a free for all pool
- 34:46of cards to pick from, because some like it's not how I it's not
- 34:52how I envision the game. I feel like that, of course you're going
- 34:55to pick gand off. It's not like you know what I mean to me,
- 35:00it's a little bit like, I mean, a lot of games would
- 35:02have sort of a point system, like okay, Gandalf is worth fifty points,
- 35:06and you know Fatty Bulgers were two points. No, it's just one.
- 35:09I don't have that in here. Because it was never considered as something
- 35:14that would be like constructed like that. And I really hate the idea that
- 35:20like Pippen, who probably weighs about Somebody pointed out online saying like, oh,
- 35:24I wish Pippen could pick up Gimli's axes, like the Acts probably weighs
- 35:29more than Pippen. Okay, you know, it's like, remember, people
- 35:32grow in all three directions, So if Hobbits are half the height of humans,
- 35:37that means they're in eighth of the weight. So it's like, you
- 35:42know, no, that wouldn't happen. He wouldn't be able to do anything
- 35:45with the Acts, And so I'm really so that's where it kind of goes
- 35:49into that whole you know, dedication to theme. And I'm not gonna go
- 35:53trashing anybody else's game, but just to say that there are games where things
- 36:00like that happen and I don't like to play them. I can't get past
- 36:06that. And so, you know, I'm a fan of this game,
- 36:08and I'm I'm a fan of this game, but not generally a fan of
- 36:14expansions. Why should I pick up this expansion? What is it? What
- 36:21is it going to give me that's new to sync my teeth into With regards
- 36:24to the card game, well, the the first thing is is that it's
- 36:30going to play up to six people, so that if you all of a
- 36:34sudden end up with more than four people who want to play, you can
- 36:37do that, and that it really completes the whole aspect of parts of Middle
- 36:46Earth, as I discussed, fills it out. The the new mechanics are
- 36:53very light. So one of the things that I find about I'm mostly with
- 37:00you on expansions. I used to be one of those people I got to
- 37:04get every expansion, and I realized that there was I had no game that
- 37:08essentially every game ended up with one too many expansions because the last expansion would
- 37:15always sort of not be very good, and then the publishers would say that's
- 37:19enough. Like American TV, the last season's always bad because they don't cancel
- 37:24a show because the because the writers get sick of it. They cancel it
- 37:28because the audience stops watching. So the so I'm I'm highly dubious. It's
- 37:36also one of the things about it is that fans may know that like this,
- 37:43we don't have plans for like you know, every every three months,
- 37:49another pack of cards like this is again, this is no LCG just because
- 37:53it was considered and developed as a standalone and it was considered a developed the
- 38:00expansion in mind. So again, the expansion was being written at the same
- 38:05time, back in twenty sixteen and through and so that I don't well,
- 38:10I don't say that you only purchased two thirds of a game the first time
- 38:15I will be because again I wanted to be a four person experience, and
- 38:19the expansion was originally native six player. But I also understood that decision that
- 38:24scenarios was how I wanted to support the game meant that the expansion actually gave
- 38:30me a lot more than the ability to go to six because with a greater
- 38:34card pool, I made it so that I could create many more scenarios for
- 38:39four players by mixing up what cards were in which decks, if that makes
- 38:45sense. So I think that what I'm trying to say is that you're not
- 38:47going to get only a bigger game, You're also going to get a bunch
- 38:52of similar sized games that have a slightly different dynamic. Let's get to the
- 39:00vital statistics then, So how much is it going to cost, when is
- 39:04it going to come out? And Why should anyone listening to this who hasn't
- 39:08tried watering the card game yet and they don't trust me enough to go on
- 39:13my recommendation, why should they try it? Okay, well, I wish
- 39:17I could be more specific about the cost, but I think it is going
- 39:23to be maybe thirty nine dollars or thirty five dollars something like that in the
- 39:30US dollars, and then and in Europe with the VAT. I'm not quite
- 39:34sure what it means in Euros, but it is maybe it'll be a little
- 39:40less. I'm not one hundred percent sure, so that's very unhelpful of me,
- 39:46and especially since I knew you were going to ask that ahead of time
- 39:50and and I ended up not. I don't know. Sometimes I feel funny
- 39:55about asking people things like that. My publisher that because you know, they
- 40:00are not one hundred percent sure right now. Shipping is such a Shipping costs
- 40:07are highly are fluctuating a lot right now, and that you know, for
- 40:12the gamers, they have to understand that that's like, could be five dollars
- 40:16on you know, the shipping itself to get it to your door is for
- 40:21a game, you know, a full sized box that's like ten dollars out
- 40:24of the game. So the release date I do know, which is June.
- 40:30So I'm hoping that they'll have probably something like an air freight palette at
- 40:37UK Games Expo or Origins, and I'm definitely not promising that again with the
- 40:43shipping, it could be that's what ends up at gen Con, but basically
- 40:46the summer. Now, why should we not? Why should you try War
- 40:51the Ring the card game if you haven't yet and you shockingly and not quite
- 41:00conceivably don't trust Ben that I mean, I mean, I'm I'm as confused
- 41:06at the existence of that possibility as you, but yes, exactly. Well,
- 41:13the first thing I'll say is that if if you like War the Ring
- 41:19the board game, but you want something that is an epic Lord of the
- 41:23Rings game that takes a little bit less time to play and is and as
- 41:28of a native team mode, this is going to help you with that.
- 41:32If you like Lord of the Rings and you just like the artwork, just
- 41:38get it for that. There's lots of people who like get like to get
- 41:43cards just for the artwork, and I still get a royalty even if you
- 41:46don't play the game. So please, if you like the artwork, go
- 41:51for it. And by the way, computer artwork just not going to be
- 41:53as fun the But all in all seriousness, I think that if you seriously,
- 42:07if you like games with theme, or if you like team and you
- 42:09like team games and like somewhat heavier ones, I'd say go for it.
- 42:16There's people who I would say, I don't think every game is for every
- 42:20person. My wife had a game store for seven years and the first six
- 42:24months was a big learning experience for us that everybody likes different games and that's
- 42:30okay, and it's a big broad hobby and people have very who have very
- 42:37little to do with each other and their oft time go to the same place
- 42:40to buy their you know, their buy their hobby supplies. So you know,
- 42:45if you are really not interested in The Lord of the Rings at all,
- 42:51it's not an abstract where you can say, well that doesn't matter,
- 42:53I get it and I like to play it. This isn't this isn't going
- 42:58to satisfy somebody who is sort of a system's dynamicszuro gamer. If you don't
- 43:04like direct competition in games, like if you like things where sort of everybody
- 43:09has their own kind of solitaire, but you're together drinking and making jokes,
- 43:14but nobody feels sort of weird about winning or whatever. You know, this
- 43:19is not the game. But if you like, you know, holding a
- 43:22card in your hand and then throwing it down right at the right moment and
- 43:25feeling very clever about that, then yes, this is that sort of game.
- 43:29So it's got that kind of card game feel to it. So so
- 43:36really, in a nutshell, if you like a deeper, thinkier card game
- 43:43and or like the Lord of the Rings theme, this is for you.
- 43:50In terms of the expansion, to me, it's kind of a must buy
- 43:54in this case, I am. I will not deny that I am working
- 44:00on another expansion that one might not be a must buy, because that one
- 44:06is more along the lines of some ideas that I never wrapped into this game,
- 44:13that doodling around with and trying to figure out if it would be fun.
- 44:16And I don't know if it will be, but we're like probably a
- 44:20couple of years out from like that, seeing that if it does turn out
- 44:23to be fun. But this is really like basically you know, getting the
- 44:31you know, finishing all of Middle Earth, looking at the map of Middle
- 44:36Earth and being able to pull out all the cards and locations saying they're all
- 44:39here. I want to talk a little bit if I can, about just
- 44:45a couple of new mechanics I said there weren't many. The main new mechanic
- 44:52is that there's a new type of battleground called a skirmish and the war of
- 44:55the Ring game. If you like the word of the Ring game, you'll
- 45:00notice there's a lot of the same concepts reflected at a very high level.
- 45:05So all of the different locations in the lower of the Rings game that are
- 45:10marked, like the fortresses and citadels, also have battlegrounds. Once you get
- 45:16the expansion, you'll see them all there. Some of the smaller ones are
- 45:21called skirmishes, and they can resolve in the middle of a round. And
- 45:25I think that the expansion will make the game a little bit even thinkier because
- 45:30there's far more likelihood that the skirmishes will you know, you'll have more to
- 45:37do, more choices like where where can I play a card on this battleground
- 45:42or on the skirmish, And the skirmishes will also permit a lot of things
- 45:46to happen that normally don't happen. So, for example, if care Andrus,
- 45:53which is an island which actually isn't in the word of the Ring board
- 45:58game, but was an important location in the books that is sort of off
- 46:04screen. It's an island in the middle of the undoing that was overrun or
- 46:12was defended, but essentially there was a battle there and if it had been
- 46:16fully overrun, then the Easterlings would be able to cross the river and take
- 46:22on Roehan from the other side. So if that comes out, there's a
- 46:25possibility of you know, basically adding Easterling swords to a Rowhan fight. And
- 46:35so I think that a lot of people are going to be satisfied that the
- 46:37cards can be used in a lot more situations, and that the number of
- 46:43battlegrounds and my number of things that are happening at once just you know,
- 46:46went up again. And so I would also say this about the expansion is
- 46:52that it's not like one of these things where you'll forget to do things.
- 46:57Which is my biggest problem with expansions is that sometimes the rules get too complicated
- 47:00and you start forgetting the rules. That it's more about a little bit more
- 47:07ap which is someplayer analysis paralysis, which for a lot of my games is
- 47:15probably spent probably the longest amount of time you spend in any one of my
- 47:20games is on thinking about the move. They're very I try to make games
- 47:28there that that's that are super thinky and not a lot of stuff to do
- 47:35with your fingers, say per se if that makes sense. Although the scoring
- 47:39in the original Quartermaster General I don't deny as a hassle, totally separate topic.
- 47:46That's just try to get people who are listening who never heard of Quartermaster
- 47:51General to try it. Excellent. Well, Ian Brody, thank you very
- 47:57much for your time. Thank you so much for your viewing me. I'm
- 48:00sorry I went up for so long. Not at all new. All right,
- 48:07Steve, it's your favorite part of the new show. It's the Q
- 48:10and A. And I've been desperately asking the discord is the new show?
- 48:15I forgot I stop paying attention during the break. Great interview, by the
- 48:19way, thanks, I really I really liked the bit where they explained about
- 48:24the game. Yeah, it was good. Yeah, I chose you listen
- 48:29to the interview. Give us another detail about the interview, Stave. So,
- 48:32I think it's exciting that there are new cards, and with the new
- 48:36cards come additional like aspects of the gameplay like like powers and some storyline that
- 48:42we didn't have in the original. And when you mix the cards into the
- 48:45base game, it changes the possibilities for play. And that's what I think
- 48:49is most exciting about this expansion. And I was really chuffed to learn about
- 48:53it. Shuffed. That's a word you use, right, yeah, chuffed?
- 49:00Yeah, I mean it's very interesting. Okay, So, Steve,
- 49:07we got one question from Richard Nrkele and it's a rather confusing question because he
- 49:12thinks I've helped to develop a game I didn't develop. And we've got another
- 49:15question afterwards. We got another question afterwards. Someone just someone just dropped in
- 49:20with a question. It's fine. So he says, Lacerda's inventions is delivering
- 49:25to backers at the moment, and he then he goes on to say,
- 49:30what does it mean to see a game like that arriving personally knowing and having
- 49:35been involved in some of the history of its developments at Laria Coon, et
- 49:37cetera. I think he thinks I had a development I didn't. But so
- 49:43I guess my question to you is how significant And this is about Lacerda,
- 49:51but it's also about other games. How significant do you think crowdfunding has been
- 49:59to the wh hoby since you reacquainted yourself with it about five years ago.
- 50:04How significant do you think crowdfunding has been and to what degree has it affected
- 50:08your appreciation of the loudiological arts, Steve Well, I actually have a way
- 50:15of answering the question as it was posed, so I can answer that one,
- 50:20and I can answer your question, and I have a question of my
- 50:22own if I may so. First of all, answer Norkle's question. We
- 50:29have nothing to do with inventions or any asserta game. But I have had
- 50:36the opportunity to play test a few games in the past, and one instance
- 50:39in particular remains with me as a memory because it was with Elizabeth Hargraves during
- 50:45the pandemic. I played Wingspan Doug over Zoom with Elizabeth and my wife Samantha,
- 50:52because we'd met Elizabeth at the previous Berlin Bretch bil Khan and we became
- 50:58friends and put a few games with her at the beginning of the pandemic online,
- 51:01and when we played Wingspan, she wanted to try out some additional bonus
- 51:07tiles that she was thinking about including in the next expansion. I don't remember
- 51:09which expansion, and I don't know if she included them, but we played
- 51:15the game with these bonus tiles, and she ate like sincerely asked for feedback
- 51:20at the end, and I had feedback and I gave it to her.
- 51:22And I have no idea what happened after that. I never followed up on
- 51:23it, but I'm not going to lie to you. I mean, it
- 51:27is like, you know, the smallest of visceral thrills, to be involved
- 51:32at that level of something that you care about so deeply. I mean,
- 51:35Elizabeth Hargrave is like a big name in our hobby and it's not like Wingspan,
- 51:38that's my favorite game, but you know, I got to contribute,
- 51:42like I thaw an idea that may have had some influence on what she decided
- 51:45to do, and like that's really cool. I mean, honestly, it
- 51:47is like there are very few pastimes that you can have in this world in
- 51:52which you where you have that kind of access or could possibly have that kind
- 51:54of access to, like, you know, the makers at the heart of
- 51:59the hobby. I mean, we're a little bit privileged in that regard.
- 52:01But you're not giving really bad You're not giving editing tips to Denny velnerve on
- 52:07June two. You you know what I mean? For yeah, yeah,
- 52:08For example, for example, like no chance I'm going to be involved in
- 52:14film or you know, recorded music or any anything like that, board games
- 52:17that can happen, and I think it it's attainable for anybody. So that's
- 52:22very cool. Now, to answer your question, there was no crowdfunding when
- 52:27I was playing board games in the nineties and during the period when I like
- 52:31just barely managed to maintain my involvement in the hobby in the two thousands.
- 52:37I was aware of Kickstarter, of course, I mean we did. I
- 52:42did a Kickstarter in twenty fourteen. Actually I don't. I wasn't really paying
- 52:46attention to like board game and Kickstarter though, So I have no idea when
- 52:50board games first started appearing on Kickstarter, do you twenty eleven twenty twelve was
- 52:57where it really first kicked off. Alien Frontiers was the first big campaign,
- 53:02I think can It raised about sixty thousand dollars, which at the time was
- 53:07hugely significant. I think yeah. I mean, I don't want to overstate
- 53:10the case. I think that it's arguable that that Kickstarter and crowdfunding in general
- 53:16has transformed the hobby. I mean, for better or worse. We've talked
- 53:20about before, but it's obviously had a massive influence. I mean, is
- 53:24it driving the hobby? I mean that would be interesting question. Is crowdfunding
- 53:29now like actually like defining the hobby or at least like the cutting edge of
- 53:34the hobby. I think there's still like a massive part of board gaming that
- 53:37is determined by traditional publishers who are publishing family games and kids games, and
- 53:44it's really just a certain subset of hardcore hobbyist gamers that are that are on
- 53:49Kickstarter and care about it. But I mean, I really don't know.
- 53:52It's clearly like when you go to Essen, you see Kickstarter everywhere and crowdfunding
- 54:00everywhere. Everyone's got a game that's either about to be on Kickstarter or was
- 54:04on Kickstarter. People go there and you now like you treat Kickstarter like a
- 54:07shop and you just pick up the game that you crowdfunded, So it doesn't
- 54:10feel like you're supporting an artist who's like struggling to bring something into existence.
- 54:16It's just basically a pre order service that has impacted I think the size of
- 54:22games, the scope, the components, probably the aesthetics, the art,
- 54:27because these are the things that make you want to buy something, and you
- 54:30get to like immerse yourself in the Kickstarter campaign only on that superficial basis.
- 54:34I mean, you can watch the little rules explanation, but that doesn't give
- 54:37you, like really that much of a feel for what the game is like
- 54:40to play. So I think it's probably like the components and the minis and
- 54:45the art. I mean, it's great that that stuff is improved, by
- 54:46the way, it's not all terrible, But along with that, I think
- 54:51some of the magic has been taken away, some of the like you don't
- 54:52go to Esten anymore with like anticipation of what's going to come out, because
- 54:57you already know, in fact, a lot of that stuff has already even
- 55:00been delivered. So the you know, some of the anticipation or the expectation
- 55:06has been like drained from the hobby again, for better or worse, I
- 55:08don't know. Now my question to you on the subject, can I answer
- 55:13that question first? You want to answer the question that you asked me,
- 55:17Yeah, or you would like to so that you and I can have a
- 55:22kind of concrete exactly. So mind you use that word. I use that
- 55:29word because you're wearing those glasses and Therefore I know that you know what it
- 55:31means. Now I look like an existentialist philosopher. Now this is true,
- 55:35So the point is right, I think to hear me talk about it a
- 55:39lot, I think people might think I have a very negative view of crowdfunding,
- 55:44but I don't think that's necessarily true. And I don't have a big
- 55:47issue with companies like Queen Games or whatever going on Kickstarter, because fundamentally Queen
- 55:53Games is about is two people essentially, right, Board game companies are very
- 55:59small, and having that capital upfront for a very small company is very useful.
- 56:02So I don't really have an ideological problem with it. And what it
- 56:07has done is improved components, no end. I think that has transmitted itself
- 56:13into straight to retail games as well. I think that's a really good thing
- 56:15by and large, and it has enabled some of my favorite designers to become
- 56:22designers to have a viable life in this industry, which is a great thing.
- 56:25I'm sponsored. I do a sponsored podcast with ULI once a month,
- 56:30and it's transformed the way spiel works works to its benefit, I think,
- 56:34and that's great. My issue. Your podcast has transformed the way spiel Yeah,
- 56:40yeah, yeah, exactly. My fundamental issue on the negative side of
- 56:45crowdfunding though, is that it has changed game design, and I don't think
- 56:50in a positive manner. So what it is is, rather than having a
- 56:53game that is a beautifully designed, self can coined, rigorous piece of art,
- 57:02what you have is often situations that games are designed with twenty expansions in
- 57:07mind to begin with. And not only is that the problem of making production
- 57:12an absolute nightmare, it also lessens the quality of the game. The great
- 57:15example I use is Evil High Priest, which was fine, which wasn't a
- 57:20bad game, but everyone told me, oh, you need the expansions to
- 57:23make the game good. Had it not have been for Kickstarter, that would
- 57:28have been a game that would have had those expansions baked in. It felt
- 57:30like half a game. Also, you know, when you have a game
- 57:36that comes out with twenty expansions on release, something has got to give,
- 57:43something has got to give in the design. And also it encourages a kind
- 57:46of unhealthy consumption because you're never going to play those expansions. Most people aren't
- 57:51going to play the game enough to be able to do that. And then
- 57:54also I think it's that negative purchase thing that I don't like that you get
- 58:01excited about a game when you buy it, and by the time it arise,
- 58:06you no longer think about it anymore, and you're no longer excited by
- 58:08it. That's a negative thing of crowdfunding. So I think it's a thing
- 58:12of both sides. Anyway, what was the question you wanted to ask,
- 58:14mat, I'm just on that. I'm really glad to see that there's been
- 58:17kind of like a reaction to the the like stretch goal bloat, if I
- 58:24can call it that, where you know, we're gonna keep adding shit to
- 58:28the game, expansions whatever, and a lot of kickstarters now they have you
- 58:32know what, one price for the game. They don't have the game and
- 58:37the deluxe game and the expansion and the second expansion and the solo version and
- 58:42the fucking you know lube. I want to so ali Kat Games is a
- 58:46publisher I think is doing it right. I think Restoration Games are doing it
- 58:51right. Twenty fifth Century Games are doing it right. I'm gonna show you
- 58:53something then. I've been waiting for the time of this for a long time.
- 58:58Now I know that this is not your Faceavorite Games. I'm showing he's
- 59:02holding up a copy of Raw for the listeners. Yeah, Ryan er Kannisi
- 59:07is raw. But what I think is special about this game is that this
- 59:09is a classic game that's been reprinted with with new art and new components.
- 59:15It wasn't expensive. And another ali Alikat games I mentioned, by the way,
- 59:21because they're doing Kali Mala kind of the same thing. And this I
- 59:24think is to the good, like classic games being brought back and being given
- 59:29new life in new containers for a new generation of gamers. I think that's
- 59:34great. That probably is made possible by crowdfunding, and it's unlikely to have
- 59:38happened otherwise just through traditionally traditional publishing. So I think that's that's one good
- 59:43thing, if I can say. So, So, what was this question
- 59:46you wanted to ask me? Then? So Noracle wanted to know what it's
- 59:52like to be involved in I think maybe Loserto is just an example, but
- 59:55it's a good example because we do see him every Laria. Now my question
- 1:00:00is this, so vital Aserta is definitely like a titan of a board game
- 1:00:06publishing, right, and every single year he's at Lria Khn, We're at
- 1:00:09Lria Khan. He's demoing one or two or maybe sometimes even three of his
- 1:00:14games. We never play them. We never demo his games, we never
- 1:00:19play test them, we never participate in that. I think it's an interesting
- 1:00:22question why not, because usually we've planned out what games we're playing. Secondly,
- 1:00:30usually Vitals games are always booked out the minute he puts them up.
- 1:00:36They're put up on the on the COLN website. They booked out, And
- 1:00:40frankly, I don't really want to. I guess the thing is it's something
- 1:00:46we don't even we don't even make the effort, right, No, I
- 1:00:52I am not really a fan of that level of complexity in games, though
- 1:01:00though I have often said I think this Boa is great, I think the
- 1:01:02Galerist is great. I'm not generally a fan of that level of complexity of
- 1:01:08games. And when I'm at a convention, I play my heavy game in
- 1:01:14the morning and I don't have the headspace to do the rest of the day.
- 1:01:19I can't play a game that heavy, and so generally I don't.
- 1:01:22I don't. I don't feel the exactly exactly you use, you lose your
- 1:01:27stamina. So that's that's the reason, basically, And it's nothing against Vitalisota's
- 1:01:32games. They don't sit in my ideal wheelhouse, though, I must confess.
- 1:01:38Okay, so is there some way in which you can answer the question
- 1:01:42the way I did? So you've actually contributed content to games, You've done
- 1:01:45voiceovers, there are games which feature like, uh, depictions of you and
- 1:01:49so forth. So I mentioned this thing with Elizabeth Hargrave. I mean,
- 1:01:52this is like me barely, you know, grazing against that level of like
- 1:01:59game designer, the hobby you're You're much closer to these things. Is it
- 1:02:01some kind of like a thrill for you? Or I mean, like,
- 1:02:04what does it mean for you if we subtract, like you tell assert from
- 1:02:07the question, like what feeling does it give for you to to be able
- 1:02:10to contribute to the design process in any way? I don't contribute to the
- 1:02:15design process in any way. I consider my role within the industry apart from
- 1:02:17the game I'm designing. And I had a very very productive discussion with my
- 1:02:22co design partner yesterday actually, and but I but I consider I consider my
- 1:02:30role to be more investigating what the game is after it's been published, essentially,
- 1:02:37So I don't contribute to the design process. You've given feedback on prototypes
- 1:02:44right, Sure, I have, but I don't consider it very useful feedback
- 1:02:47most of the time. And I tend not to play prototypes for that reason
- 1:02:52because I don't because I find when I'm doing the after game discussion that I
- 1:02:57sounded it stupid. So, so you know that your your design partner in
- 1:03:01your game is not a fan of Yin or Knisio. That blows my bloody
- 1:03:07mind, and I'm not designing the game them anymore. So let's move on
- 1:03:09to the next question. Let's move on to the next question. So are
- 1:03:15you familiar with the with the famous conundrum shag Mary throw off a cliff?
- 1:03:24We we we call it Mary fuck kill America. Yeah, in America we
- 1:03:29call it, well, I call it shag Mary throw off a cliff.
- 1:03:31Are you familiar with this concept? You're trying to be clever? Right,
- 1:03:37No? Interesting? Fuck Mary kill? Like, why do you see?
- 1:03:45Because you know? So who Farga has asked Stephen who fos asked Uli?
- 1:03:54Famed board game designer Isaac shalev ced Hunter jag Mary throw a cliff? Oh
- 1:04:02okay, this is this is a good one. So, uh my choice
- 1:04:10is so CD Hunter, Sam's board game designer Isaac Shulev and mm hmmm mmmm,
- 1:04:18are you going to answer yourself or do I? Yeah, yeah,
- 1:04:23okay, so let him and Mary obviously, And I mean, I'm gonna
- 1:04:28come to mind in a minute. But C D. Hunter. I think
- 1:04:35CD Hunter. C D Hunter sucked because I assume he's really good at it.
- 1:04:42He's probably like he's like read a lot of manuals and he knows exactly
- 1:04:45how to do it, and he'll explain to me how to do it,
- 1:04:47and it will be like the most sort of like pedantic sexual encounter of my
- 1:04:51life. But then I will be lett. I will come to understand how
- 1:04:55it's also the best and why any other could not possibly be as good as
- 1:04:59that. And Isaac Shalev, I mean, right off the fucking cliff,
- 1:05:01come on. So so I am marrying faintball game designer Isaac Shalev because you
- 1:05:11know, I like to be corrected. It's a kink I'm shagging. Might
- 1:05:19be it might be, it might be against his faith. I don't think
- 1:05:21that Jewish people are allowed to marry bellens anyway. And I'm shagging Uli because
- 1:05:29after a couple of pints, I think he's wild, and unfortunately I'm throwing
- 1:05:33CD Hunter off the cliff and hopefully he won't sue me afterwards using his loyally
- 1:05:43powers of pedantry. So we didn't match in any category, did we?
- 1:05:49No? No, I'm just the original baby, all right, Steve.
- 1:05:54Anyway, very satisfying answer to that question for the listeners. Indeed, So
- 1:06:00here we are, Steve. It's the end of the news show. I'd
- 1:06:03just like to thank you for giving over some of your holiday time to record
- 1:06:06this. And yeah, it only remains, It only remains for me to
- 1:06:12say say goodbye, Steve. Goodbye, Steve, thank you for listening to
- 1:06:19the Five Games for Doomsday News. To listen to past episodes, you can
- 1:06:24go to five Games Fordoomsday dot com. Or to back the show, you
- 1:06:28can go to Patreon dot com, forward slash five g fo D So join
- 1:06:32us again next month for some hot and spicy Five Games for Doomsday New