Latest / North Shore Nine: A Pittsburgh Pirates Podcast
Cutch Claps Back — Should Pirates Fans Be Worried?
Tonight on NS9LIVE, we’re joined by Pirates beat writer Alex Stumpf to unpack the sudden wave of controversy surrounding Andrew McCutchen’s future in Pittsburgh. Stumpf recently shared on Reddit that frustrations on both sides could make a 2026 reunion unlikely — only for Cutch himself to jump in on X and reply, “wow that’s news to me.”
We’ll break down what this all means, whether fans should actually be worried, and how the Pirates might navigate this crossroads with a franchise icon.
Plus, we’re diving into the trade machine: ESPN’s proposed Mitch Keller–for–Bryce Eldridge deal. Is it…
The skinny
The skinny isn't ready yet — notes appear once the transcript is processed.