Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The Scarcity Paradigm: Wealth Preservation in an Era of Debasement
Transcript
- 0:00Let's be clear, Bitcoin is an international asset.
- 0:04We are spending like drunken sailors.
- 0:08Bitcoin is the only economic entity where the supply is
- 0:12unaffected by the demand. If you want to preserve.
- 0:16Your wealth. You have to convert that
- 0:18currency into an asset that's scarce.
- 0:21Desirable, portable. Durable.
- 0:24And. Maintainable.
- 0:31All right, welcome back to Scarce Assets.
- 0:35We are kicking off a new format for the show.
- 0:38So we're really excited to use this first episode as a
- 0:42framework to give you the audience a better understanding
- 0:46of how we're thinking about Scarce Assets, which is part of
- 0:50the On Ramp Media umbrella, how we'll think about this podcast
- 0:54and the value that we'll bring to you going forward.
- 0:58You see here if you're following on the screen today that we have
- 1:02a a new lineup of hosts. We have myself, Jackson
- 1:06Michaelic and I'm joined by my Co host Glenn Cameron and Tim
- 1:10Kotzman. We're going to get into some
- 1:12introductions here shortly, but just to tee things off because
- 1:17we will be taking a new strategy with the show scarce assets.
- 1:21What we'll be doing here is a bi weekly podcast.
- 1:24And So what this podcast will be dedicated to is exploring the
- 1:28investment landscape shaped by the paradigm of scarcity as the
- 1:32ultimate driver of value. So there's certainly a
- 1:35recognition in the investment community and capital allocation
- 1:39world that traditional investments are struggling to
- 1:42provide real returns and Fiat currencies are losing their
- 1:47appeal and have been losing their appeal due to debasement.
- 1:51And so our show provides a forward-looking lens on how
- 1:55investors can preserve and grow their wealth in the 21st
- 1:57century. So the podcast will feature
- 2:01insights from industry leaders in traditional finance and
- 2:03alternative investments, really with the goal of providing
- 2:08practical strategies for building future proof
- 2:11portfolios. So that gives you a high level
- 2:15overview. Really what we want to dive into
- 2:18one of these eternal questions and themes for the show will be
- 2:21understanding why scarcity drives value.
- 2:24So this is really more important than ever because we have
- 2:26reached a tipping point in the debt based monetary system or
- 2:31debt levels really all across the world for sovereign nations
- 2:35and corporations for that matter.
- 2:36And the cost of servicing that debt have really reached
- 2:39unsustainable levels. And so at the sovereign level,
- 2:43what we've been living through is really the only feasible path
- 2:45at this point, which is the debasement of the money.
- 2:48And so that really undermines the traditional unit of account,
- 2:51which is the money itself. And so that money, whether it's
- 2:55dollars or pounds or EUR or yen, historically those have provided
- 3:00individuals with the ability to store as a store hold of value
- 3:04over time. But what we've seen over the
- 3:06past several years and certainly over the decades too, but it's
- 3:09accelerated now, is that this debasement due to the structural
- 3:12issues of debt is causing these currencies to lose purchasing
- 3:17power at a more rapid rate. So naturally investors are
- 3:19looking for scarce assets to preserve and grow their wealth
- 3:24over time. So that's what we'll be bringing
- 3:27to the table. You may have noticed I, I didn't
- 3:29mention the word Bitcoin once in that overview and that was
- 3:32intentional because we will be talking about Bitcoin as part of
- 3:36the show, but it won't be the show's focus.
- 3:38This will be a show that's focused on the overarching
- 3:43investable landscape. And so we'll be covering
- 3:45traditional assets and alternative investments.
- 3:48And so for those that don't sit in the finance world, typically
- 3:52the way you can think about this is in traditional finance,
- 3:56traditional investments are typically public equities and
- 4:00private fixed or public fixed income.
- 4:02And then kind of cash equivalents and then alternative
- 4:06investments has been a umbrella term to categorize everything
- 4:10that's not that. So at this point, it's become,
- 4:12it's become a, a wide range, it's a large bucket of
- 4:16investable opportunities, but includes real assets, digital
- 4:20assets, commodities, private assets as well.
- 4:25So there's a lot that we'll be diving into in the show.
- 4:27So hopefully that'll give you a better sense of the theme and
- 4:31the strategy for scarce assets. And with that, I would like to
- 4:35introduce my Co hosts, Glenn and Tim.
- 4:38Glenn, maybe we could start with you if you just want to give a
- 4:40quick overview into your background and ultimately why
- 4:44you're excited about this show. Maybe if there's an anecdote you
- 4:46could share about kind of how you think about scarcity or one
- 4:49that clicked for you as part of your personal investment thesis.
- 4:53Yeah, sure. So I've worked in various parts
- 4:59of the institutional investment management world for about 28
- 5:04years now. I'm a chartered financial
- 5:06analyst, I've worked as a portfolio manager and an
- 5:10institutional investment consultant.
- 5:12I've worked with most types of institutions in various
- 5:17capacities. And I think the first time that
- 5:24I started to think about scarcity or it was more for me,
- 5:30it was about like what is going on with the money was in the
- 5:36GFC. It kind of felt like, you know,
- 5:41investing for me, the fascination, the intellectual
- 5:46simulation of it is kind of figuring it all out.
- 5:51Like what is the relationship between things?
- 5:53What's undervalued, what's overvalued?
- 5:56How do you control risk, all of this kind of thing.
- 6:00But in the GFC, it sort of felt like all of a sudden the rules
- 6:07of the game were just being broken.
- 6:09It would be sort of like, you know, the simple analogy that
- 6:13I've often said is it's like playing Monopoly, right?
- 6:18The, the thing that makes the game, the board game interesting
- 6:21is that their rules and you have to follow the rules and you have
- 6:24to try and beat the other players by following those
- 6:28rules. But what I felt like in the GFC
- 6:31was that what was happening is with some players had a few
- 6:35other boards, you know, stashed away with their money in it and
- 6:41they were just stealing the the money out of the other boards
- 6:45and kind of flooding our game with all of that money.
- 6:52And so just sort of took a lot of the interest and passion in
- 6:59the game of investing and money management.
- 7:04It started to make me question a lot of things.
- 7:06I mean, up until late 2008, I'd never heard the term quantities
- 7:12of easing, although it had been done in Japan before.
- 7:17But it just wasn't kind of on my radar throughout my education
- 7:21and my early career. You know, I didn't realize that
- 7:25we were kind of playing a manipulated game.
- 7:29And I think where scarcity really became, you know, the
- 7:38idea of scarcity being a key driver value came onto my radar
- 7:43was when I discovered Bitcoin, right?
- 7:48But like you said, you know, the plenty of places where scarcity
- 7:52drives value, you know, the, you know, Ferrari GT250 sold for £42
- 7:58million at Sotheby's in 2023, right?
- 8:04And that's because there are only a handful of them.
- 8:08You know, you see it with vintage wine, obviously gold,
- 8:13etcetera. And in a world where, you know,
- 8:18money is kind of the money supply of almost every country
- 8:23in the world is being inflated, The, the, the one thing that is
- 8:28not scarce is the unit of account, right?
- 8:33So you're trying to get out of the money into some kind of
- 8:37asset to kind of protect yourself.
- 8:39And so, yeah, it's taken me a while to figure out that you're
- 8:43not just trying to create more dollars or bonds.
- 8:46You got to do that at a rate that kind of beats the rate of,
- 8:50you know, which the the supply of those things is being
- 8:53increased. Yeah.
- 8:56And that could be a challenging game because unless you're
- 8:59paying attention to this as core focus of your day-to-day, you
- 9:04may not actually understand just the insidious nature of this,
- 9:08right? Because if you're a everyday
- 9:12person, even a lot of individuals within Wall Street,
- 9:14they don't fundamentally think through these from a first
- 9:17principles basis, right? And so I remember the past
- 9:21couple of years living through COVID and, and the fiscal and
- 9:26monetary stimulation that we saw.
- 9:29And the result of that was higher prices.
- 9:31But if you went to Wall Street Journal or the Times or New York
- 9:35Post, you had all sorts of conflating and conflicting
- 9:39opinions about what was causing the higher prices.
- 9:42So it does become, and you see this too in, in the professional
- 9:45investment community, if you, there's almost like a disconnect
- 9:50between the unit of account increasing and the price of
- 9:55things going up, where there's all this like noise in the
- 9:57middle where people try to pinpoint different reasons as to
- 10:00why the prices are going up. And they may play a part, You
- 10:03know, maybe corporations are increasing their prices, but is
- 10:06corporate price gouging the reason why prices are going up?
- 10:09No, it's, it's not right. And is that the reason why
- 10:11equity valuations are increasing?
- 10:13No, it's not. And so I think that's a really
- 10:16astute observation. And Tim want to hand it over to
- 10:19you as well, just to share more about your background and you
- 10:22know, why you're excited about this show.
- 10:24And then I'll I'll be happy to do the same before moving,
- 10:27moving on here. Yeah.
- 10:32So my background is in the land side of oil and gas for the past
- 10:3815 or so years. And I don't think I really was
- 10:46clued into shrink flation until 2020 and 2021 when there was a
- 10:56lot of conversation around a pack of Oreos being like,
- 11:03there's just less cookies in the jar, so to speak.
- 11:08Prior to that, I was just kind of running as hard as I could,
- 11:12trying to work hard and work smart and put together either,
- 11:19you know, consulting deals or small businesses.
- 11:22And when I was introduced to Bitcoin in the beginning of
- 11:252021, it seemed pretty clear to me from the beginning that the
- 11:3421 million hard cap of Bitcoin was a scarce asset as opposed to
- 11:42what I kind of term is like perceived scarcity.
- 11:46If someone's just marketing that there's only one hotel room left
- 11:49tonight, but you're like, I don't know, Travelocity, if
- 11:53you're telling me the truth or not, Maybe it's just marketing.
- 11:57So yeah, it's just definitely been a journey.
- 12:05Yeah. No, I was on a similar timeline
- 12:07as both of you, it sounds like because for me it was in 2020
- 12:13and I was working in New York, Tim, I was in this a similar
- 12:18office to where you're sitting today, right across from Bryant
- 12:21Park. And my background was in
- 12:24alternative investments and at that time I was doing fund
- 12:27manager research and so our desk covered private markets, which
- 12:33would be private equity, credit, real estate venture and then
- 12:38covered public markets as well, but on the alternative side.
- 12:41So that would be hedge funds and long only limited partnerships.
- 12:45And it became apparent to me in the spring of 2020 with the
- 12:51coordination of fiscal and monitor monetary authorities
- 12:56with trillions of new dollars and trillions of liquidity
- 13:00across the board and all sorts of currencies entering the
- 13:02market and robust measures taken by central banks to ease
- 13:07liquidity and financial conditions by lowering interest
- 13:11rates to 0 and in some cases negative interest rates, which
- 13:15was tough to wrap my mind around at the time.
- 13:19And so I was speaking with fund managers and in my role, I was
- 13:22doing initial investment due diligence.
- 13:24So we would vet hedge fund managers and private assets.
- 13:28We would vet their strategies to see if we would want to have
- 13:31them on our platform for our ultra high net worth and high
- 13:35net worth accredited clients to allocate to if they so choose.
- 13:39It was part of if that was a match with their, you know,
- 13:42personal investment strategy, philosophy, financial planning,
- 13:45etcetera. And so we would vet these
- 13:48managers and then if they were on the platform, we would have
- 13:50quarterly calls with them to review their performance and
- 13:53their attribution against the benchmarks.
- 13:54And so it's kind of business as usual until you get to the
- 13:59spring of 2020 and you have this surge of liquidity that starts
- 14:04to distort markets in all sorts of ways.
- 14:07And what I came to realize at that point was because of this
- 14:13unit of account, Glenn, that you mentioned, because the unit of
- 14:16account was growing so dramatically and so rapidly, the
- 14:20prices of all other asset classes for the most part
- 14:24besides bonds were, were increasing in tremendous amount
- 14:29of value or at least that was the perception, right.
- 14:31But then you recognize that a lot of this is being driven by
- 14:34the growth in the money supply. And so a lot of managers did
- 14:38really well in 2020 and 2021 because there was so much money
- 14:42sloshing around and that was creating more or higher
- 14:47valuations and more stretched valuations.
- 14:50But at the end of the day, what I noticed was for me, Bitcoin
- 14:54caught my attention because it was really the fastest horse in
- 14:57the race at the time because it was the most scarce asset in the
- 15:01context of abundant liquidity and abundant Fiat currencies.
- 15:05But that could also be applied to investors that were
- 15:09allocating capital to high quality equity companies too.
- 15:14There's, there's, we were talking about this last week a
- 15:16little bit where there's still scarcity in equities.
- 15:19Maybe not so much in the sense that a company can issue more
- 15:23equity, but their scarcity may be the fact that they have,
- 15:27they're the only company in the world that does what they do
- 15:30right? Or they have some sort of
- 15:31competitive advantage or Moat that makes them scarce as an
- 15:35investable opportunity. So I went down that path and,
- 15:38and things started to make a lot more sense when you think about
- 15:42the abundance of money that exists today.
- 15:44And all investors are in the same position now where they
- 15:47need to figure out how to allocate capital to scarce
- 15:50assets to preserve and grow that wealth, because now the money
- 15:55that in theory should help them to just save over the long term
- 15:59doesn't serve that purpose anymore.
- 16:01Yeah, Yeah. I mean, I think it's fascinating
- 16:06to think about the fact that so the modern dollar, you know, as
- 16:10we think of it today, kind of was created in 1913.
- 16:15And between 1913 and 2020, you know, a certain amount of
- 16:20dollars were created. And then since 2020, that total
- 16:25supply of dollars has increased by more than 40%, right?
- 16:29So 40% of all of the dollars in existence were created in the
- 16:33last five years, right? That you know that that's got to
- 16:41make people sit up and think, hang on a second, you know what?
- 16:48Why is it that 40% of all the dollars that were created over
- 16:54111 years were created in the last five times?
- 17:01And you know, I think there's a reason why there's certain
- 17:08things that have gone up in value a lot over the last five
- 17:13years. And those are, if you think
- 17:15about it, they're the most kind of the things that people
- 17:21prioritize most. So you know, if you look here in
- 17:26in London, a sort of a paint toss apartment in Chelsea or
- 17:32Mayfair, the kind of two most desirable kind of areas in the
- 17:38City of London to live in with a very wealthy owned property.
- 17:43Or you think of Manhattan or you you think of various places in
- 17:48the US particularly kind of sea front property or whatever.
- 17:53You've seen the price of those kinds of assets go up, you know,
- 17:58kind of add rates reflecting that increase in the money
- 18:02supply. You also see it like with the
- 18:04Ivy League kind of university tuition fees.
- 18:10You see it in kind of high end healthcare, all of these kinds
- 18:15of things where it's like people have taken all of that excess
- 18:21money supply and they've tried to apply it or invest it in
- 18:26places where they've where they kind of know there is inherent
- 18:34scarcity and value, right? It's either in the form of I'm
- 18:38going to get a big payback, it's good, I'm going to get a very
- 18:41good return on investment, yeah, or I'm going to plow it into
- 18:46something that I know is always going to be valuable and scarce,
- 18:50right? And that's why when investors
- 18:54measure their the real return they're getting on investments
- 18:59against CPI, which is measuring the price increase of, you know,
- 19:05I don't know, toilet paper or, you know, all of these kind of
- 19:13consumer products, right? It's like, well, is that really
- 19:18a measure of the real return you're making on your wealth?
- 19:23You know, do you store your wealth in those type of consumer
- 19:26products? No, you don't.
- 19:28So if you've gotten a 12 or 13% return on average over the last
- 19:34four years, have you actually increased your wealth?
- 19:37No, not really. Because if you sell those assets
- 19:41and you want to buy other assets that where people store their
- 19:46wealth, those things have also gone up by 12 or 13%, right?
- 19:52So all of that money supply has created asset price inflation,
- 19:58right? So you, so you, you all you've
- 20:02really done in monetary terms is protect your wealth, but you
- 20:06haven't really grown your wealth.
- 20:08You haven't become any wealthier.
- 20:11Yeah. And one of the really
- 20:13challenging parts of this is that most people's earnings
- 20:19don't grow with the rate of the money supply, right?
- 20:22So Glenn, to your point, if the money supply, I forget the exact
- 20:29numbers, but if it's compounded at a certain rate over the past
- 20:31couple of years, most people aren't growing their wages that
- 20:35fast as well. People who work in white collar
- 20:39businesses, unless they get a promotion that year, they
- 20:42typically see some sort of increase in their wage kind of
- 20:46commensurate with what inflation has been historically.
- 20:49So maybe a 2 or 3% bump. And then when you get promoted
- 20:53to the next level, you get some sort of increase in your salary,
- 20:55whether it's 10% or 15 or 20%. But that doesn't happen every
- 21:00year. So the issue then is you have
- 21:02this increase in the money supply, which by the way, it
- 21:06does have been flow, right? And so in 2020 and 2021, Glenn,
- 21:10you highlighted how enormous that increase was.
- 21:14But then we did see a contraction of liquidity and
- 21:17money supply, I believe in 2022. So it's not a straight line, but
- 21:21over time, what happens is up and to the right that money
- 21:24supply, money supply grows. And so the really insidious
- 21:28thing at play here is that most individuals are not able to
- 21:32actually grow their wealth at a rate faster than that because
- 21:36they usually rely on some somewhere, some sort of income.
- 21:39They're working at an employer. And so that's a big disconnect,
- 21:42right? Because if you're everything
- 21:43that you desire in life, whether you want to purchase a home or
- 21:46you want to take your family on a vacation or you just want to
- 21:50be able to afford quality groceries at the store, things
- 21:54have increased probably 4050 sixty percent, depending on what
- 21:57that is in the past five years, Most people are sitting on maybe
- 22:01a 510 or 15% increase in their salary.
- 22:05So it's becoming harder now to the treadmill.
- 22:08You're running faster against it, right?
- 22:09And it's becoming harder and harder to grow that wealth.
- 22:12And that's one dynamic at play. Yeah.
- 22:16And I mean, that's affecting not only individuals, it's also
- 22:19affecting businesses, you know, you know, I've, I've, you know,
- 22:29working with pension schemes and stuff like that.
- 22:32Pension schemes are usually attached, well, they either
- 22:36attached to one company or several companies.
- 22:40And so you end up working both with the pension trustees, but
- 22:43also the board of directors of the companies to a certain
- 22:48extent as well because they're kind of supporting those pension
- 22:51schemes. And so you come to understand a
- 22:56lot of different businesses and what you find out is that
- 22:59they're finding the same thing, particularly those who work in
- 23:02competitive industry. So this goes to your point
- 23:05about, you know, scarcity and equities, meaning companies that
- 23:10have something that makes them unique, some kind of, you know,
- 23:16economic modes or competitive advantage that gives them sort
- 23:20of almost monopolistic kind of power.
- 23:24Those kinds of companies have pricing power.
- 23:28So as the price of things, you know, as the money supply gets
- 23:32inflated, they can raise their prices kind of at a rate that's
- 23:36quite similar to that rate and increase in money supply.
- 23:40But if you're AI don't know a manufacturer of some kind of
- 23:46good and you're the parts that you're creating are kind of
- 23:52generic, right? And that you've got 30
- 23:56competitors, right? You can't just raise your prices
- 24:01because there's very big competitive pressures, but you
- 24:07do tend to see at least over the short term, all your inputs kind
- 24:12of go up at that, you know, fast clip of 10 or 15% if you're
- 24:16using steel or copper or commodities.
- 24:21I mean, if you go and look at commodity prices and see what
- 24:27happened over that period where they were just kind of creating
- 24:30trillions of dollars, right? I mean the price of natural.
- 24:35Gas, kind of. You know, it was blamed on
- 24:39supply chain bottlenecks and whatever, right?
- 24:44But the reality is, OK, that's a reality.
- 24:47There can be supply chain issues, right, because of wars
- 24:51or pandemics or stuff like that. But then you would expect that
- 24:58after those issues kind of go away, the prices should come all
- 25:03the way back down to where they were, right?
- 25:06But what you find out is that isn't the case, right?
- 25:11You know, natural gas prices, for example, are 6070% higher
- 25:17now than they were in 2020, right?
- 25:22Copper prices are about 5060% higher than when they were then,
- 25:28right? So, you know, if you're a
- 25:31business and you using these things as inputs to, you know,
- 25:35generate their lease electricity that you're buying or as raw
- 25:39materials that go into your manufacturing process or
- 25:42whatever, and you can't pass those goods on because of
- 25:48competitive pressures, well then you make far less profit and
- 25:53you've got far less free cash flow.
- 25:55So when you value that business, it's not as valuable anymore,
- 26:00right? And it's not going to keep up
- 26:02with the pace of monetary debasement.
- 26:08So and and that goes to that whole thing.
- 26:11It's kind of a cliche by now. But you know, if you look at the
- 26:15S and B500 and you look at it with the Magnificent 7, which
- 26:19are all these kind of monopolistic ballistic type
- 26:23companies, right, you've gotten a 12 or 15% return per year over
- 26:30the last five years. But if you strip those out, you
- 26:34basically even in nominal terms, it's been pretty flat, right?
- 26:38And then when you take into account inflation as measured by
- 26:42CPI, or more realistically, the increase in the money supply,
- 26:47you've gotten a lot poorer. Yeah.
- 26:51And so how does this tie in then to the changing landscape for
- 26:57capital allocation? Because when I think about this,
- 27:01I take a very macro view to capital allocation in terms of
- 27:08demographics and generations. And things change over time,
- 27:13right? There's not necessarily a
- 27:15standard way to allocate capital over the course of a decade or
- 27:19let alone 20 years a generation, etcetera.
- 27:22I always anchor back to the way my own family has done this.
- 27:29And I grew up in like a upper middle class family in the
- 27:34Northeast part of the United States.
- 27:37Didn't have a ton of money but was fortunate to be comfortable.
- 27:42My dad was very savvy with how he managed his finances.
- 27:45And so he always taught me from a young age things that I should
- 27:49be paying attention to. And then over time I've learned
- 27:52that things change, right. So when my dad has told me, he
- 27:55used to speak to my grandfather years ago about things are
- 27:59changing, You might want to invest a portion of the little
- 28:02retirement money you have into equities.
- 28:05But my grandfather lived through the Great Depression and wanted
- 28:09nothing to do with equities, right?
- 28:10Because he anchored back to this period in time where he was, he
- 28:14lived through people losing effectively all of their money,
- 28:17right? And So what he anchored to as an
- 28:20investor of very modest means was as my grandfather, he would
- 28:27have a little bit of precious metals, not a significant amount
- 28:31by any means. He would have some certificate
- 28:33of deposits, you know, government bonds.
- 28:36And these were effectively ways that he wanted to preserve the
- 28:40wealth that he had over time. And then my father, he's on the
- 28:46younger side of the baby boomers.
- 28:48And so he grew up in a time in the United States at least where
- 28:53equities became the de facto savings technology, right?
- 28:57People indexing became popular or first service mutual funds.
- 29:02And then indexing became popular, I think in the late 90s
- 29:05or so, early 2000s. And it's only grown.
- 29:07And now passive investing is really the way that everyone
- 29:10does it. And so you've gone from where
- 29:13fixed income, the rate of the basement wasn't as significant
- 29:17as it was today back then. So you could actually hold fixed
- 29:19income and some precious metals and likely be OK over a long
- 29:23enough time scale. And then naturally as that rate
- 29:26increases, you have 1971 the the breaking of the dollar to the
- 29:32gold peg. And so that was a crisis in and
- 29:35of itself. And then equities became a more
- 29:37crucial role for growing people's wealth over time, but
- 29:40they still had that component of fixed income.
- 29:43And so now what I I think is worth discussing is we've been
- 29:46in a environment now for a couple years for that portion of
- 29:51the portfolio, the fixed income, which was a crucial part of
- 29:55people's portfolios 50 years ago.
- 29:57And, and even more recently it's been touted as four.
- 30:01It should be 40% of someone's portfolio and then give or take
- 30:03depending on their age and risk tolerance.
- 30:06But now that's a portion of the portfolio that doesn't really
- 30:08generate any real returns. It loses money over time.
- 30:12It may play a role, particularly for older people to have current
- 30:18income, right, to generate some income for potential obligations
- 30:22they have in a given year, but it's not actually helping them
- 30:27to secure their retirement or work toward their long term
- 30:30goals. So I think that's the crucial
- 30:33thing that really will be diving into a lot on the show is like,
- 30:37how do investors take the framework that used to work and
- 30:40tailor it to a framework that's going to work for the next 5
- 30:45years, the rest of this decade and beyond, right?
- 30:47So what are your thoughts on that Tim or or Glenn, how do you
- 30:51guys think about portfolio construction at a personal level
- 30:55or how are your thoughts changed on this topic over time do?
- 31:02You want to go ahead, Tim or? Yeah.
- 31:05I mean, being exposed to alternative assets through the
- 31:12work in the minerals, you know, natural gas and oil, minerals
- 31:16and royalty space, and then being introduced to digital
- 31:23assets has really, you know, had had me thinking a little bit
- 31:29differently, along with some of the guys that I talked to on a
- 31:34regular basis that really, unless it's a top performing
- 31:41equity. To your point from earlier,
- 31:44Jackson, right, a few decades ago, it was kind of the
- 31:50transition from all bonds to a little bit of exposure to
- 31:54equities. And I feel like now it's you're
- 31:58seeing it again, but from equities to hopefully the top
- 32:03performing equities and then also to digital assets like
- 32:08Bitcoin. So I'm, I'm really intrigued and
- 32:14excited to hear from the guests that we bring on.
- 32:20Like what are their actual allocations to the extent that
- 32:25they can share and, and why it's, you know, one thing to say
- 32:29what your allocation is, but but what's their position and, and
- 32:35what is it about their background and what has
- 32:38influenced them that's really gotten them to that conclusion
- 32:41and, and what would change their mind?
- 32:45You know, hopefully we're all on a journey and learning.
- 32:48So yeah, I think that'll be really telling and and yeah,
- 32:53should make for a great discovery and and a great
- 32:56conversation. Yeah, I'll, I'll add this.
- 33:00So I mean it's, you know, so you can have a really great company
- 33:07that's, you know, got a great business.
- 33:10It's got a huge competitive advantage.
- 33:14It's got a big sort of Moat around its business model and
- 33:19everything. And that'd be a really bad
- 33:23investment, right? And why is that?
- 33:26It's simply because the price that you have to pay to have a
- 33:33share in the ownership of that business is too high, regardless
- 33:37of how good the business is. And if you kind of generalize
- 33:41that right now, equities have only been more expensive.
- 33:46I'm talking about US equities, which are kind of 60% of global
- 33:50equities. Yeah.
- 33:54So that chart there shows the what's known as the cyclically
- 33:58adjusted price to earnings ratio, right in the blue line.
- 34:02The red line is long term interest rates.
- 34:05So the way to think about this is so you got your normal PE
- 34:11ratios right, but they're very noisy because like for example,
- 34:18earnings only come out once every 12 months, right for each
- 34:22company and prices are changing day-to-day.
- 34:26So like for example in if you were using normal PE ratios,
- 34:35backward looking PE ratios during 2020 when equities fell
- 34:40by 40%, right, PE ratios went up by 40% because the price is the
- 34:46numerator in the PE ratio. And that's nonsense because you
- 34:52know, equities were actually a lot cheaper after falling 40%.
- 34:56So what this matrix does is it takes earnings over the last 10
- 35:01years, right? But it adjusts each earnings by
- 35:05inflation, right, and then averages the earnings over the
- 35:09last 10 years and uses that as the denominator and then
- 35:13measures that against price. So it's a far more accurate and
- 35:17less noisy way of measuring equity valuations over time.
- 35:21And you can see there that the Cape ratio cyclically adjusted
- 35:24to price to earnings ratio currently is about 37, right?
- 35:29And it's only been higher than that two times in history.
- 35:34And that was during the craziness in 2022 when, you
- 35:42know, specs and GameStop and all of that were going through the
- 35:48roof and there was a lot of insanity, right?
- 35:52And the other time was at the height of the.com bubble, right?
- 35:56So that gives you some sort of context for how expensive
- 35:59equities are at the moment. I mean, much higher than they
- 36:03were that at the sort of in the 1929 kind of stock market bubble
- 36:10that made your grandfather afraid of the equity markets,
- 36:14right. But then, and that's because
- 36:20everybody knows you don't want to be in fixed income
- 36:23instruments because you look at where date levels are.
- 36:27I'm talking about government debt levels.
- 36:29And I'm not just talking about the kind of explicit data.
- 36:33I'm also talking about the unfunded liabilities.
- 36:35So like Medicare, Medicaid, Social Security, on this side of
- 36:41the pond, they call it state pension and public health costs,
- 36:47as well as the explicit date, right?
- 36:50In the US, if you measure date like that, the date to GDP ratio
- 36:54is not 115, it's 950%, right? Here in the UK, it's like 550%,
- 37:04right? And it's way, way higher than
- 37:07it's ever been. And we know from history what
- 37:11happens next, right? Because it's not politically
- 37:15feasible to kind of, you know, say to people, you're not going
- 37:19to get Social Security or Medicare or Medicare, They're
- 37:22not going to take those things away, right?
- 37:24And yes, there's things like doge and stuff like that.
- 37:28And of course you want to make, you want to stop waste and you
- 37:31want to make, but that's kind of at the margins, right?
- 37:34The big picture is unchangeable here is the only way you get out
- 37:39of the situation is by debasing the money, right?
- 37:43And so then you look at what your options are.
- 37:47Well, you definitely don't want to be in fixed income because
- 37:50that's where the debasement is going to occur.
- 37:52The bondholders are going to be the bag holders, right?
- 37:57But and then you look at equities and you're like, well,
- 38:01what's the earnings yield? So the earnings yield is the
- 38:04reciprocal of the PE ratio. So the long term average of that
- 38:08Cape ratio is 16, right? So the earnings yield, the
- 38:12reciprocal of that is 1 / 16, it's about 6.8% earnings yield.
- 38:18But when it's 1 / 37, right, you're getting earnings yield of
- 38:23less than 2%, right, on equities.
- 38:28So you're like, well, equities are a good place when there's
- 38:32going to be monetary debasement, but it's all about the price,
- 38:36right? And that's price is too high.
- 38:38So I've got to find other places to put the money right.
- 38:41And that's where alternative assets come in because bonds
- 38:44aren't going to work, equities aren't going to work.
- 38:47So where are the places where I can store value, right or grow
- 38:52value in real, real terms? And it's not in public listed
- 38:58equities or public fixed income markets.
- 39:02And so the idea behind this show is to talk to experts in all of
- 39:07these areas of alternative investments and get them to make
- 39:11the case to us why their area of speciality is the place where
- 39:17people should be allocating to. Hey, Glenn, Speaking of places
- 39:23to put capital and the name of the show being scarce assets, a
- 39:29few minutes ago it was announced that President Trump signed an
- 39:32executive order to create a sovereign wealth fund.
- 39:36With your institutional background, like how do you
- 39:39interpret that or any color? Because it's easy to kind of
- 39:43jump to a conclusion depending on, you know, what your, you
- 39:49know, current holdings are, how you view the world, but from
- 39:52like an institutional lens. What does that say to you And
- 39:55and how could that kind of play out?
- 39:58So, I mean, so I've worked with a couple of sovereign wealth
- 40:01funds in my career as the investment consultant.
- 40:07You know, it's kind of funny, even in with pension schemes or
- 40:11sovereign wealth funds or whatever, people, I think kind
- 40:14of make the assumption that the people that are on the board,
- 40:18the investment teams or the OR the boards of trustees of these
- 40:22organizations must be investment experts.
- 40:26But you. You often find out, no, that
- 40:29they're not investment professionals at all.
- 40:31So that's why they hire investment consultants to kind
- 40:35of help them think through these things.
- 40:37And you get different types of sovereign wealth funds.
- 40:40You get what are called stabilization funds, which are
- 40:45like in countries where, you know, like there's some
- 40:49countries where like, you know, 70% of their GDP comes from, you
- 40:55know, the mining of one commodity or oil or something
- 40:59like that, right? And can cause distortions in the
- 41:02race of the economy. So a lot of them Raven you from
- 41:07the production of that stuff goes into the sovereign wealth
- 41:10fund, right? So that it kind of doesn't
- 41:12assault the race of the economy and it's kind of used for the
- 41:15common good of all of the citizens of that country over
- 41:18time. So a good example of that is
- 41:20Norway, right? The Norwegian sovereign wealth
- 41:25fund basically takes in the large majority of the money from
- 41:28the oil that Norway's got off its coast, oil and natural gas.
- 41:35But then you also have these ones called savings funds.
- 41:39And so the stabilizations funds tend to invest in like fixed
- 41:44income assets. They, they want everything to be
- 41:48kind of very stable and liquid all of the time, the savings
- 41:54type of sovereign wealth and they tend to actually try and
- 41:56grow the wealth, right? So it's kind of one time
- 41:59windfalls and they want to use it as kind of intergenerational
- 42:04equity over time, right? So they'll tend to be kind of
- 42:08more in the equity kind of bucket, kind of mixed with some
- 42:14fixed income for the shorter duration type of spending that
- 42:18they're planning to do. I don't know.
- 42:25So I guess if I had to, you know, just hazard a guess of
- 42:29what the Trump administration are trying to do.
- 42:33Well, first of all, there's droll, baby droll, right?
- 42:37So, you know, potentially they're thinking, OK, you know,
- 42:42let's, you know, really plow into the energy kind of
- 42:48resources we have. They've also spoken about, I
- 42:51mean, if you think about all these tariffs and stuff like
- 42:54that, I've heard President Trump talking about, you know, the
- 42:59lumber that's available in the US and, you know, wanting to
- 43:04kind of make better use of the assets that United States has.
- 43:10And so if you're going to do that and you're going to be
- 43:14generating a lot of revenue and potentially from tariffs as
- 43:18well, you're going to want to you, you don't want to just be
- 43:23kind of wasting that money. So you, you'd want to be kind of
- 43:27putting it into something. And yeah, it'll be interesting
- 43:34to see because obviously there's been conversations about a
- 43:38strategic Bitcoin reserve or strategic digital assets
- 43:42reserve. So, I mean, I can only hazard a
- 43:48gay said worker. The other thing that I've, I
- 43:53think's going on with the US is with the US as the global
- 44:00reserve currency, there's Triffin's dilemma applies,
- 44:06right? So you've got kind of like the
- 44:09way to think about this, you can forget about that terminology is
- 44:13that because there's global demand for a reserve currency,
- 44:18the reserve currency tends to be overvalued, right?
- 44:21And what that means is for manufacturers or service
- 44:26providers in the country that has the global reserve currency,
- 44:31when they try to export their goods or services, they are
- 44:36expensive from the perspective of importers in other countries
- 44:40because they're having to pay for things in the dollar, right?
- 44:45And the dollars kind of, you know, overvalued, right?
- 44:50And So what you kind of need to do is and, and that's led to the
- 44:56deindustrialization that is well acknowledged in the US, right?
- 45:01And it's also kind of where a lot of Trump's political support
- 45:05comes from, you know, those areas of the United States, the
- 45:09Midwest and stuff like that, you have kind of been hollowed out.
- 45:14The automotive industry, all of this kind of thing has, you
- 45:19know, essentially it's because the reason why American cars
- 45:23don't sell well around the world, any other reasons aside,
- 45:28is because they're very expensive, right, compared to
- 45:32other cars. And part of that is to do with
- 45:35this currency issue. And So what you want to do and,
- 45:39and the reason why there's so much demand for dollars is
- 45:43because global trade is conducted in dollars.
- 45:47And because of that, people want to store the reserves in
- 45:52dollars. So they buy U.S.
- 45:54Treasuries and everything and they don't ever kind of move out
- 45:59of the dollar. So what you need to do is you
- 46:02need to create some kind of way for people to store their
- 46:07reserves in something else. So the obvious example there is
- 46:10gold. And we've seen over the last
- 46:13sort of three or four years historic levels of gold
- 46:16accumulation by central banks around the world.
- 46:20But I think that, you know, you need kind of a a 21st century
- 46:27version of that. And so the two versions are the
- 46:32Treasury bonds and Treasury bulls.
- 46:35But then obviously you're going to run into that debasement kind
- 46:38of issue if you're going to if that's where you're going to
- 46:41keep your reserve assets. So you're left with gold, which
- 46:44is you found really operationalized because you
- 46:47can't kind of send, you know, you can send dollars to another
- 46:52part of the world. It'll take you a couple of days,
- 46:54but you can get it there. But if you need to send 100 tons
- 46:57of gold to somewhere else, you know, as final settlement of a
- 47:01date, it's going to take a couple of months and it's going
- 47:04to cost an absolute fortune. So you kind of you need an
- 47:09asset. So I think maybe there's an
- 47:11element of that in the sovereign wealth fund is trying to like
- 47:15funnel capital into something else besides the dollar so that
- 47:20you can kind of bring down some of that overvaluation of the
- 47:25dollar to allow the country to reindustrialize.
- 47:31Yeah, very well said. I'm curious to see what happens
- 47:34because I do remember before Trump won in November, there
- 47:39were discussions, particularly with Howard Lutnick, who's the
- 47:44secretary of commerce, who was talking about some
- 47:48unconventional ways to use the resources and assets that the
- 47:52United States has to strengthen the position of the country.
- 47:57So, Tim, good call out there. I didn't see the news break, so
- 48:00appreciate you bringing that up. Be curious to see or see what
- 48:03other guests in the future have to say as this develops.
- 48:08Well, I think this is probably a nice place to wrap for the first
- 48:11episode to conclude. Just for the listener's sake,
- 48:17certainly encourage you to follow along with us.
- 48:20We'll be releasing the show every two weeks and if you want
- 48:24to subscribe to on Ramp Media on your YouTube account or on your
- 48:28podcast player, that'll be the best way to stay up to date.
- 48:32Our aim is to bring perspectives that are fresh and unique, so
- 48:35you'll be hearing from people you likely haven't been, you
- 48:38have not heard from before. And for those people you have
- 48:41heard from before, we'll be sure to ask them engaging questions
- 48:45that are also actionable for you as well.
- 48:47As Tim mentioned earlier in the show, we want this to be a way
- 48:50that you can leverage the collective expertise and
- 48:54knowledge of the guests that come on to future proof your
- 48:57portfolio. And so it'll be quite
- 48:59interesting as we have these discussions to talk about how
- 49:03investors are navigating this practically, how are they
- 49:06implementing changes into their portfolio.
- 49:08And we're certainly in uncharted waters as it relates to just
- 49:11where nations are with their sovereign debt levels, the
- 49:16challenges that exist in traditional assets and this kind
- 49:19of fraying of the unipolar world.
- 49:21So certainly more to come. Excited to be navigating the
- 49:26ship here with you, Tim and Glenn.
- 49:28It should be a good a good show. Great resource for folks that
- 49:33will be excited to follow along going forward.
- 49:37Yeah, awesome. Thank you, guys.
- 49:39Yeah. Thank you, looking forward to
- 49:41it. Thanks for listening to this
- 49:44week's episode of the show. If you found the information
- 49:46valuable, please share the episode with a friend or leave a
- 49:49rating on your favorite podcast app.
- 49:51All the links we discussed in today's show will be in the show
- 49:53notes inside your podcast app. Before we finish, a quick
- 49:56reminder that on Ramp Media is for informational and
- 49:58entertainment purposes only, and nothing should be construed as
- 50:01investment or legal advice. Regardless of where you are on
- 50:04your Bitcoin journey, we'd love to hear from you.
- 50:07Visit on rampbitcoin.com/contact to schedule a consultation with
- 50:11one of our private Client advisors.