Latest / Inside Automotive with Jim Fitzpatrick, powered by CBT News / Stop Chasing Transformations And Start Realigning Your Business
Transcript
- 0:14Jim Fitzpatrick: Hey everyone, Jim Fitzpatrick.
- 0:15Jim Fitzpatrick: Thanks so much for joining us this morning.
- 0:17Jim Fitzpatrick: Instead of grand transformations within your organization, Geoff Tuff and Steven Goldbach say that effective leaders focus on small, deliberate adjustments to keep their organizations aligned.
- 0:29Jim Fitzpatrick: Today we are exploring the idea from their new book, Hone: How Purposeful Leaders Defy Drift.
- 0:36Jim Fitzpatrick: And you're probably going to want to make notes on this one because this is going to be a really good show.
- 0:41Jim Fitzpatrick: So, Steven and Geoff, thank you so much for joining me on the show today.
- 0:45Geoff Tuff: Thanks for having us.
- 0:47Jim Fitzpatrick: So, Jeff, let me start with you.
- 0:48Jim Fitzpatrick: Can you explain what honing looks like?
- 0:53Geoff Tuff: Well, so Steve and I originally got the inspiration for the name of the book, the notion of the book we've carried in our head for some time now.
- 1:02Geoff Tuff: As many of your listeners and viewers may know, this is not our first book.
- 1:06Geoff Tuff: We've been doing this for a little while, and this felt like an appropriate end to a trilogy that we've been writing.
- 1:12Geoff Tuff: So the ideas behind Hone have been kind of bubbling around in our head since our first as since our last book came out about three and a half or so years ago.
- 1:19Geoff Tuff: And the whole idea that we wanted to bring to our readers with this one was that instead of waiting to make big transformational moves that often fail or costly, um, sometimes actually cost people their jobs and what have you, it's better to just stay on top of the date details day in, day out.
- 1:38Geoff Tuff: And I'm sure we'll talk in a lot more detail about what that looks like.
- 1:41Geoff Tuff: But the real inspiration actually came from a conversation that Steve had with uh a chef friend of his.
- 1:47Geoff Tuff: And um Steve talked to her.
- 1:50Geoff Tuff: She was preparing to cook a meal, and Steve saw her sharpening the knife.
- 1:54Geoff Tuff: And Steve said to Flannery, who actually is one of the uh people with the we profile in the book, you know, Flannery, do you really need to sharpen the knife after before every single time you cook?
- 2:03Geoff Tuff: And Flannery said, No, no, no, Steve, you got it wrong.
- 2:05Geoff Tuff: I'm not sharpening the knife, I'm honing the knife.
- 2:08Geoff Tuff: Okay, and there is a critical difference because when you sharpen a knife, what you're actually doing technically is destroying the blade.
- 2:15Geoff Tuff: You're taking steel off the blade to create a new sharp edge.
- 2:19Geoff Tuff: Whereas with honing, what you're doing is you're leaving the steel intact, you're leaving it in there, but what you're doing is just realigning, I think what she called them is all the snaggly-toothed bits of the of the knife that have gotten um kind of snaggled by over but by using it.
- 2:34Geoff Tuff: And so the idea that that occurred to Steve and me at that point is this is a great metaphor for business.
- 2:39Geoff Tuff: We want to try to avoid doing uh unnecessary and sometimes unintentional harm to a business by going too hard at sharpening it or transforming it and instead hone the business day in, day out, and we think that will lead to better outcomes.
- 2:54Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah, there's it makes sense, right?
- 2:56Jim Fitzpatrick: Steve, why do you think that uh so many organizations have become addicted to big transformations?
- 3:04Steve Goldbach: I mean, let's start with the fact that it sounds sexy, right?
- 3:07Steve Goldbach: It sounds like this—
- 3:08Geoff Tuff: To some people, Steve.
- 3:10Geoff Tuff: Maybe not actually to everyone, but yeah—
- 3:13Steve Goldbach: This is this is something that we want to do.
- 3:15Steve Goldbach: This is and it's kind of de rigueur.
- 3:18Steve Goldbach: Like it's like the the this is what leaders do.
- 3:20Steve Goldbach: They transform a business, they give grand edicts, um, and they tell people to go and change.
- 3:26Steve Goldbach: And um it's to some extent become the definition of of leadership, but really it's also become necessary because of the inattention to the small details of the day that lead up to big change.
- 3:40Steve Goldbach: So I think part of the reason why businesses have become addicted to transformation is because they're not honing day in, day out.
- 3:47Steve Goldbach: Geoff and I aren't uh anti-transformation.
- 3:50Steve Goldbach: We think that in certain situations it's actually quite necessary.
- 3:54Steve Goldbach: We just don't want transformation to have to be brought, you know, done to ourselves because of lack of attention to the details of how do we improve daily.
- 4:04Steve Goldbach: We think that there is a place for it when it's necessary and when disruptive technologies happen fast or when competitors make move.
- 4:12Steve Goldbach: But we'd rather transformation be necessary because of external events rather than because of letting the organization drift um away from its elemental purpose.
- 4:24Jim Fitzpatrick: It it seems to me, too, that uh you you you see these transformations in businesses, often in companies, when there's new leadership that's installed and they want to roll their shirt sleeves up and maybe even put their own brand, so to speak, on the leadership or the management or the company itself by saying, Okay, we're going to, we're going to have this big transformation.
- 4:44Jim Fitzpatrick: Is it is it some is it maybe even part ego of that of that leader to do that?
- 4:51Geoff Tuff: It it it it could be ego, and and um you know, for for me for some reason the the the word ego sounds like it's actually got a negative edge to it.
- 5:00Geoff Tuff: We all have ego, we all like to see ourselves in the picture of doing something, but it it is understandable that someone comes into a situation where let's take a just a uh um fictional company where past senior executives have come in, they've offered a bold vision, and the orthodoxy around the company is that's what leaders do.
- 5:18Geoff Tuff: They offer a bold vision and then they expect everyone else to go and execute on that vision.
- 5:22Geoff Tuff: It's not surprising, therefore, that when a new executive comes in, they'll have a slightly different bold vision and go in a slightly different direction, expect everyone to execute.
- 5:31Geoff Tuff: So, what Steve and I are arguing actually is that that's that orthodoxy needs to be challenged.
- 5:35Geoff Tuff: It needs to be blown up.
- 5:36Geoff Tuff: That's that's a job for a CEO and companies is to provide the bold vision, but we actually think it's much more important for them to be the ones who are hands-on day in, day out, adjusting the management systems to keep the company on track.
- 5:49Geoff Tuff: I mean, you just imagine, uh and we can talk a little bit more about this if you're interested, but uh the whole notion of drift actually comes from um the metaphor of being on the water and trying to stay on track.
- 5:59Geoff Tuff: And you imagine a company that's trying to stay on track, and one executive says that's the bold direction, the next one goes and says that's the bold direction.
- 6:06Geoff Tuff: You can see how that could get very confusing and discombobulating for anyone at the company.
- 6:11Geoff Tuff: And so ultimately um we would prefer it if the orthodoxy of companies is that the most senior person in the organization, whether she's the CEO or the CEO equivalent, um doesn't come in necessarily with the ego and the big pronouncements, but instead they see their job like their um predecessors as getting into the details and keeping the ship on track day in, day out.
- 6:37Geoff Tuff: And we think ultimately that is going to lead to better outcomes.
- 6:39Jim Fitzpatrick: Uh Geoff, the uh the the CEO is described as the chief system designer.
- 6:44Jim Fitzpatrick: Talk to us about that.
- 6:46Geoff Tuff: Well, so I'd I'd happily talk about chief system designer, but I have to ask my friend Steve to talk about management systems to begin with, because I I will tell you the guy's a little bit obsessed with management systems, and he can probably explain to you.
- 6:57Geoff Tuff: All right, you're you're on the side.
- 6:58Geoff Tuff: Set the what those up, uh what those are.
- 7:01Geoff Tuff: We can all talk about the Yeah.
- 7:03Steve Goldbach: So so so, in order to understand the chief system designer concept, the idea is really uh that what the subatomic particle that matters most in business is human behavior.
- 7:17Steve Goldbach: And if you want to drive any type of change, whether it's transformational or honing, the unit of analysis has to be the management system.
- 7:26Steve Goldbach: Lots of leaders like to talk about culture and so-called culture eat strategy for breakfast, but culture doesn't happen, you know, culture doesn't culture change doesn't happen by putting more posters up on the wall or leaders making grand speeches.
- 7:41Steve Goldbach: Sure.
- 7:41Steve Goldbach: Culture change happens because you change what good looks like at the organization.
- 7:47Steve Goldbach: And management systems are to some extent the definition of success.
- 7:51Steve Goldbach: It's things like your performance evaluation.
- 7:54Steve Goldbach: You've probably had an end-of-year discussion with whoever supervises you that says, Did I do my job well?
- 8:01Steve Goldbach: And if you're like literally almost everybody that we know, everybody wants to do their job well.
- 8:06Steve Goldbach: No one wants to be useless.
- 8:09Steve Goldbach: And management systems define what good looks like.
- 8:12Steve Goldbach: They say these are the things that you need to do and this is the kind of bonus that you might get if you do them well.
- 8:19Steve Goldbach: They offer also say these are the the decisions that you can make, and these are the the decisions that we you need to talk to your boss you know about making.
- 8:28Steve Goldbach: And so all of those things collectively governor, you know, govern the behavior that goes on in an organization.
- 8:35Steve Goldbach: Now, if you want to change the behavior that you're doing, you need to therefore change the management systems.
- 8:43Steve Goldbach: And the the challenge is that in transformation, you need to change a lot of them at once.
- 8:49Steve Goldbach: And so therefore, we say that the CEO needs to be the chief system designer because nobody else in the organization has the purview of designing the machine to get the outcomes that you want.
- 9:00Steve Goldbach: And to get the outcomes that you want, it's the collective behavior of the organization.
- 9:04Steve Goldbach: Yep.
- 9:05Steve Goldbach: Yep.
- 9:06Geoff Tuff: And I will and I will say it's not an easy move to make.
- 9:08Geoff Tuff: I mean, and and so the the way I I try to simplify this for myself is a management system is anything that will impact the behavior of someone within the organization.
- 9:17Geoff Tuff: They can be used to impact the behavior of others as well.
- 9:20Geoff Tuff: And so, as Steve gave some examples, it's things like performance reviews um uh systems, it's how budgets are allocated, it's the questions that the executive asks, the executives ask in the hallway or in meetings or what have you.
- 9:33Geoff Tuff: There's there's dozens and dozens of them that show up in any sort of meeting.
- 9:37Geoff Tuff: But just imagine if the mindset of a CEO is not just that they need to set the vision, but that they need to pay attention to those things that will drive the behavior of the people they're working with day in, day out.
- 9:49Geoff Tuff: That's a very different mindset than than we tend to see it at the top of most organizations.
- 9:54Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah, for sure.
- 9:54Jim Fitzpatrick: And does that doesn't that in and of itself though require more time and attention that the CEO uh of that company needs to allocate rather than just Yes.
- 10:06Jim Fitzpatrick: Yes, it does.
- 10:07Jim Fitzpatrick: It does.
- 10:07Steve Goldbach: It it yes, it does.
- 10:09Jim Fitzpatrick: But as you know, so many CEOs are they they they drop the bomb and then they're on to the next project.
- 10:14Jim Fitzpatrick: And they're like, okay, you guys work this out, and uh, I don't really have time to stick around to help you hone.
- 10:21Steve Goldbach: That's the problem.
- 10:21Steve Goldbach: That's the problem.
- 10:22Steve Goldbach: They they they they the the that sort of management technique, which we highlight in the book, that running from problem to problem doesn't allow for a sufficient understanding of how things are happening on the ground.
- 10:39Steve Goldbach: Like if you say, I want like Geoff and I worked with a um uh a leader once who was trying to drive uh you know commercial innovation, uh, you know, and what that means is innovation without touching the product.
- 10:54Steve Goldbach: But in every meeting that we were in with this leader, you know, they would fawn over the the product innovation.
- 11:03Steve Goldbach: And we took them aside and said, look, if you keep doing this, you're delivering the message that this is really important.
- 11:10Steve Goldbach: So you have to change your own behavior, you have to make sure that you're uh creating this because that was some a behavior that they wanted to change.
- 11:17Steve Goldbach: Um they it's not that they have to get into all the nitty-gritty details, but they have to see the system as a whole and and they they they have to know enough about the details to see not just you know make change happen, but how the all the different management systems are working together to collectively create that behavior because only the CEO has that purview.
- 11:39Steve Goldbach: So yes, it's it's it's important and it does require some attention to detail that comes from other parts of their job.
- 11:45Geoff Tuff: Well, and that that was a critical thing that you said at the end there, Steve, because I don't I would not want it to be taken that we're advocating that CEOs just need to work harder.
- 11:52Geoff Tuff: We think we're we're simply saying, and I I think we're as aware of anyone that CEOs probably have the most demanding calendars of anyone out there.
- 11:59Geoff Tuff: We're just saying work differently.
- 12:01Geoff Tuff: And so Steve characterized it at the beginning of his last answer as running from issue to issue.
- 12:05Geoff Tuff: And I'll go back to my, you know, the the shift turning back and forth.
- 12:09Geoff Tuff: If the shift didn't turn back and forth so often, there wouldn't be so much running around from issue to issue.
- 12:13Geoff Tuff: It actually would free up time to be able to focus on the details and understanding the influence systems through the organization to impact the behaviors that they're looking for.
- 12:22Jim Fitzpatrick: Sure, sure.
- 12:23Jim Fitzpatrick: I I'm the kind of CEO that that runs from from project to project like that.
- 12:28Jim Fitzpatrick: So I'm definitely going to be reading this book right after right after this interview because I need it.
- 12:32Jim Fitzpatrick: And uh I'm but I also the other question that I have is am I um undermining the efforts of our middle managers in the companies that that say, well, wait a minute, Jim's hanging on this too long, and and we'll we'll take care of this.
- 12:47Jim Fitzpatrick: Go on and and put out either the next fire or come up with the next great idea.
- 12:53Geoff Tuff: I would argue actually, I would actually um argue it could be a more um engaging and more motivating way to work with middle management.
- 13:02Geoff Tuff: So imagine if you're closer to the details of that, you as Jim as CEO are closer to the details of their job day in, day out, and you ask them questions, what are the what are the behaviors you're trying to drive?
- 13:12Geoff Tuff: Who is it that you see that's exhibiting those behaviors well?
- 13:15Geoff Tuff: What do you define as success?
- 13:17Geoff Tuff: And the CEO then doesn't have to directly intervene and actually push the button to change the budgeting process, for example, him him or herself, but he does get he or uh she can give the latitude for others in the system to make those changes because they're so engaged with the middle management.
- 13:35Geoff Tuff: So again, I go back to it just being a different way of working rather than a you know something that completely circumvents certain parts of the organization.
- 13:45Jim Fitzpatrick: Sure, sure.
- 13:45Jim Fitzpatrick: Um, and this is a perfect segue to what we were just talking about, but how does honing impact company culture over time?
- 13:53Steve Goldbach: Well, company culture is the sum of all the behaviors that exist in the organization.
- 13:58Steve Goldbach: So as you're as you're honing, you are consistently evolving your culture.
- 14:04Steve Goldbach: So if you're if you're changing your management systems, if you're changing what good looks like in an organization, then your culture is consistently evolving along with the objectives uh of the organization that you're trying to achieve.
- 14:19Steve Goldbach: It's not like you're it's not that your culture is is static.
- 14:23Steve Goldbach: Lots of people like to describe culture as we're an innovative culture or we're a traditional culture or this kind of culture, but really it's just about what you're behaving like.
- 14:33Steve Goldbach: And so therefore, whatever you're doing to change your management systems will bring your culture along.
- 14:40Steve Goldbach: And we just the reason why we're so uh insistent upon that that's the CEO's job is to design that set of that's that set of management systems is because that's their biggest that's their biggest lever of change.
- 14:54Steve Goldbach: That's the thing that they can um that change the most.
- 14:57Steve Goldbach: So that's the the job that they that they would say that they need to do is set organizational culture.
- 15:02Jim Fitzpatrick: For yeah, for sure.
- 15:03Jim Fitzpatrick: Um Geoff, if you had to pick one thing that you want the the reader to leave with after reading reading the book, what what would it be?
- 15:13Geoff Tuff: Um the most powerful opportunity for any or any executive um to stay on track and to exert change is understanding behaviors that matter.
- 15:22Geoff Tuff: And this is a thread that is run through all the books that Steve and I have written over time.
- 15:26Geoff Tuff: Things don't change unless people somewhere change their behavior.
- 15:31Geoff Tuff: And so having a real uh really keen understanding as to what behaviors matter the most and how you can drive um change in those behaviors is uh the not so secret trick to winning in business.
- 15:42Jim Fitzpatrick: Right, right.
- 15:42Jim Fitzpatrick: And Steve, do you want to add to that?
- 15:45Steve Goldbach: Um the the thing I would say is that it's just we often hold our businesses to this very different standard than we do human beings.
- 15:54Steve Goldbach: We were just using the metaphor of how many people try to go to the gym really regularly every January after they make their New Year's resolution, and then they're gone from the gym by February.
- 16:07Steve Goldbach: And that that to me is the same as transformation.
- 16:10Steve Goldbach: And the other thing that happens, you know, if you work out too much when you haven't been doing it, is you get yourself injured.
- 16:17Steve Goldbach: And and the we just think that there there are better techniques that we know of, and we would like to see those applied in the world of business.
- 16:25Jim Fitzpatrick: Yep, for sure.
- 16:26Jim Fitzpatrick: Geoff Tuff, globally recognized thought leader, speaker, writer, and best-selling author, and Steven Goldbach, who is a strategist and executive advisor, best-selling author as well.
- 16:35Jim Fitzpatrick: I know this thing's gonna fly off the shelves, it's coming out soon.
- 16:38Jim Fitzpatrick: I have an advanced copy, so you can't have mine.
- 16:41Jim Fitzpatrick: We're gonna make a link right below the uh video that you're currently watching to get your copy, which I highly recommend if you lead people, you're running a business, large or small, great, phenomenal book for you to get your hands on.
- 16:53Jim Fitzpatrick: So, gentlemen, thank you so much for joining us on the show.
- 16:55Jim Fitzpatrick: Very much appreciate it.
- 16:56Jim Fitzpatrick: Love to do a follow up because I got about 12 more questions here that time does not permit me to ask.
- 17:01Jim Fitzpatrick: So, thank you so much for joining us.
- 17:02Jim Fitzpatrick: Really appreciate it.
- 17:04Steve Goldbach: Thanks for having us.
- 17:04Steve Goldbach: Thanks for having us.
- 17:07Jim Fitzpatrick: Thanks for watching Inside Automotive with Jim Fitzpatrick.