Latest / Eyes Wide Open with Nick Thompson / EYES ON: MAFS Scandal EXPOSED, Dr. Isabelle Morley weighs in on the psychological fall out of the MAFS allegations
Transcript
- 0:00Hello, everyone, and welcome to Eyes Wide Open.
- 0:02I am Nick Thompson.
- 0:03I hope you are all enjoying a nice Memorial Day weekend.
- 0:06If you're listening for the first time, this is our weekly roundup show where I share the stories you should have eyes on that I cover daily over on my YouTube.
- 0:15YouTube channel.
- 0:16Check it out if you want more content like this or the video version of the podcast.
- 0:21This week has been all about the Married at First Sight scandal in the UK that broke.
- 0:25The first segment covers the breaking story about the scandal that includes three sexual assault allegations from the wives of the show and what led to Channel 4 pulling every episode of Married at First Sight down from their streaming service.
- 0:41In the follow-up, I speak with psychologist Dr. Isabel Morley.
- 0:45to gain her expert perspective on what psychological methods are used in these shows to manipulate victims and the impact
- 0:51of these allegations on the mental health of those involved.
- 0:54Let's get to it.
- 0:55Are you going through life blind?
- 0:57This is Eyes Wide Open with Nick Thompson.
- 1:00On this podcast, we share knowledge and stories that build human connection while elevating stigmatized societal issues such as mental health, holistic wellness, culture, free speech, and more, all to ensure we show up in the world with our eyes wide open.
- 1:17The hit show Married at First Sight in the UK was completely wiped from the internet, with Channel 4 abruptly pulling every single episode from streaming services.
- 1:26This isn't a routine content rotation.
- 1:29The show was forced off the air after a harrowing investigation exposed multiple allegations of Grape and Essay on the set.
- 1:37While executives are hiding behind their...
- 1:39gold standard safety protocols, the London Metropolitan Police have officially stepped in, triggering a massive industry panic that is now heading for all of reality TV.
- 1:49Let's get eyes on it.
- 1:50Once again, the human cost of reality TV entertainment is evident.
- 1:54For those of you that don't know, I'm Nick Thompson.
- 1:56I was a main cast member on Love is Blind Season 2.
- 1:59After my experience in reality TV, I co-founded the UCAN Foundation to fight against exploitation, provide mental health services and legal support to cast members because there are practically no regulations in the industry, and it leads to things like this happening.
- 2:13Now, this has been all over the internet, BBC.
- 2:16This is CNN World.
- 2:17Two married-at-first-sight UK wives claim they were graped by on-screen husbands.
- 2:23This was published on May 19th by Christian Edwards.
- 2:26Two women have alleged they were graped during the filming of Married at First Sight UK, according to a BBC investigation that prompted Channel 4, a British broadcaster, to remove all previous seasons of the reality TV show while it reviews the allegations.
- 2:40The show, known as MAPS, bills itself as a bold social experiment in which single people marry strangers who they meet for the first time on their wedding day, although the marriage is not legally binding.
- 2:52The couples, while being filmed almost daily, then go on a honeymoon, move in together, and navigate their relationship.
- 3:00Now, this is the same format for many shows.
- 3:03You put couples or multiple people in manufactured environments.
- 3:08In many cases, you force them to stay together.
- 3:11You force them to live together in houses or in hotels without really any protection or options under the assumption that...
- 3:19everybody's safe.
- 3:20And if you want to leave for any reason, you get that contract waived in front of you with threats of being sued, fined, poorly edited, whatever they need to do to keep you there to finish filming their reality TV series and finishing those manufactured narratives.
- 3:35I have experienced this myself.
- 3:37We've seen it in MAPS Australia.
- 3:39I've covered it on this show.
- 3:41We've seen it in Love Island.
- 3:43We've seen it here in the States.
- 3:45Love is Blind.
- 3:45We have two lawsuits.
- 3:48ongoing right now, Renee Poche, Tran Dang, their stories you can find if you want to hear them, they're not mine to tell.
- 3:55But these stories and these lawsuits are just an ongoing thing where people are not safe or people are being hurt or people are being essayed or worse.
- 4:04A third woman has alleged she was subjected to a non-consensual sex act during the filming of the show.
- 4:10The three former participants told BBC Panorama, which broadcast an investigation into the allegations on Monday, that the show did not do enough to protect them.
- 4:19The BBC claimed Channel 4 was aware of some of the allegations before the MAP series in question were broadcast and that the episodes featuring the women had been available on a streaming service until recently.
- 4:32So they knew.
- 4:32It's gross.
- 4:33They knew.
- 4:34The very least there was a where something wasn't right, but they were going to make that money.
- 4:38They were going to get that bag because it isn't until public pressure gets so hot that they actually do something.
- 4:44And we just experienced the same thing here with the Taylor Frankie Paul Bachelorette season.
- 4:48What happened?
- 4:49Public pressure got so heavy on them that they stopped the new season from airing just days before it was supposed to premiere.
- 4:55Let's get through this story because I've got lots of thoughts on this.
- 4:58One participant who the BBC did not name said her onscreen husband graped her.
- 5:03and threatened her with an acid attack.
- 5:06She claimed that she noticed red flags about her partner on her show almost immediately and that their sex soon turned violent.
- 5:13He would bruise her during sex, she said, even though she kept saying stop.
- 5:18We were in our apartment on the sofa and he tried to have sex with me.
- 5:22I kept saying no and I didn't want to do it, she said.
- 5:25But he kept saying, you can't say no.
- 5:27You're my wife.
- 5:28And he just did it anyway.
- 5:30Having gone through this environment and the experience of this show, even though
- 5:35different show, different experience.
- 5:37It gets very blurry when you're filming, when you're talking about filming, when you're talking with the producers, when you're being filmed and you don't know it, when you're not being filmed, but you're expected to stay in a certain enclosed area, like a hotel room or an apartment with your partner.
- 5:54Like this scenario all checks out to me and it's really scary and scary.
- 5:59Proves to me that there's something that needs to be done about the way these shows are filmed because they do not have safety protocols in place that are working.
- 6:08A second woman said she began having consensual sex with her onscreen husband, but that he had had sex with her after she told him no on one occasion.
- 6:18She told the BBC that she informed both Channel 4 and CPL about the alleged grape, but that her episodes were aired anyway.
- 6:25Lawyers for the onscreen husband said he challenges the details of her account, said they began having sex consensually, and that she had then communicated through her body language that she was no longer consenting and that he stopped immediately at that point.
- 6:38A third woman, Hannah Maderson, who appeared on camera in the BBC Panorama program, alleged that their onscreen husband, Bradley Skelly,
- 6:46had subjected her to non-consensual sex act by ejaculating inside her without permission when they previously agreed to withdrawal as a method of contraception.
- 6:56She told BBC she later became pregnant and had an abortion.
- 7:00Pedersen said that she does not know if the pregnancy resulted from the alleged incident.
- 7:06This is disgusting and devastating.
- 7:09And I just want to say that my heart goes out to all of these women.
- 7:12And I am so sorry that you went through this all because you decided that you were going to participate in a reality TV show.
- 7:19You do not and did not deserve this.
- 7:22And of course, the men deny the claims, the production, the channel.
- 7:26They all denied knowing it.
- 7:28I think we all can make our own assumptions there.
- 7:31We are watching human beings get traumatized, manipulated, physically, or assaulted, all under the guise of unscripted entertainment.
- 7:46These shows like Married at First Sight, Love is Blind, The Bachelor Series, and others isolate people and then keep them in a total pressure cooker environment.
- 7:58Critics of the industry, even therapists, former cast members like myself and many others, were all calling these shows an accident that's already happened or something.
- 8:08Or an accident that's waiting to happen because it aggressively pushes strangers to become deeply intimate with each other, filming them in isolated honeymoons and scenes where they're sharing beds and sharing experiences and sharing small spaces.
- 8:23And we've seen this before.
- 8:25We've seen all sorts of abuse on screen, let alone off screen.
- 8:30Network executives and production companies are continually moving the goalposts.
- 8:36Some industry and commentators are even saying that the UK show shifted the format and the approach to their show to make it more like the Australian format because it's highly toxic and they're able to better deliberately engineer these high tension products.
- 8:50group dinners, intense conflicts with couples.
- 8:53And they all do it because they know that the extreme drama drives streaming numbers and therefore bigger profits.
- 9:01And this has become the escalation path, just like you see in the news, just like you see in the scripted shows and movies.
- 9:07There's an escalation path where you have to heighten the drama to keep people entertained, to keep people from becoming bored and to keep people entertained.
- 9:13and to numb them over time to what they're seeing.
- 9:16You really become desensitized to the things that you're seeing, and you get wrapped up in the narrative, and then all of a sudden you find yourself emotionally invested in what you believe is real people in a real scenario, but is actually forming sort of a parasocial relationship with these people and these stories that are being presented to you as real but are heavily manufactured and even more heavily edited.
- 9:41Regardless of the reality show, this is the case.
- 9:44Whether it's Love is Blind, it's Mavs, every single season is an escalation on the last.
- 9:49The people, the characters they play, the storylines they're involved in, they're all escalating every single season.
- 9:56The characters are getting crazier.
- 9:57The storylines are getting more ridiculous.
- 9:59And they're all still being presented as this is really what's happening.
- 10:03It's all created to increase the drama, heighten the stakes, and sacrifice human beings for your entertainment.
- 10:10And the UK has some of the strictest media regulatory oversight and labor conversations in entertainment globally.
- 10:18And we've actually had Tim Wilson from The Circle in the UK on this show before interviewing about his experience.
- 10:24And I'm going to have Professor Tim back here hopefully very soon to talk about this and get us a better understanding of what's the UK reality TV market look like right now.
- 10:34But these conversations, yet even in the UK, where they have sort of the gold standard of entertainment.
- 10:44ethics will say these atrocities are still happening and victims' pleas are looking like they're basically ignored while their episodes were edited and aired anyway.
- 10:56Production companies consistently hide behind a defense that their welfare protocols are industry-leading or the gold standard.
- 11:02And if your gold standard results in multiple allegations of grape, violent threats of acid attacks, psychological terror...
- 11:12casting people in The Bachelorette who have clear mental health challenges and have a domestic abuse with a child in the courts, your standard is broken or your standard is absolutely trash.
- 11:28The problem is not just a UK problem, an Australia problem, or a US problem.
- 11:32It's an unscripted television program, reality TV problem.
- 11:37The lack of standardized, legally binding duty of care frameworks means that these productions worldwide operate like it's the wild, wild west, where participants have zero autonomy, zero actual protections once they participate.
- 11:54Once they start participating in the reality TV show experience.
- 12:00In the U.S., we're literally in the middle of the Taylor-Frankie-Paul Bachelorette scandal where a video was leaked to TMZ showing the domestic violent incident involving her, her partner, and the child.
- 12:12All of which was already documented in the police reports.
- 12:15all of which was already played out on the secret lives of Mormon wives.
- 12:19And they did it anyway.
- 12:22They cast her as the Bachelorette.
- 12:24They recorded the entire season.
- 12:26They were set to launch the premiere episode.
- 12:30And this video came out.
- 12:31And it wasn't until public pressure got too hot for them to handle that they actually pulled the show from airing.
- 12:38But they knew all of this and they were going to air it anyway until that video leaked.
- 12:43And now there's report that it's actually still going to air this summer.
- 12:46What are we doing to people?
- 12:48I know everyone who participates in reality TV makes that decision themselves.
- 12:52I get that.
- 12:53But there is a duty of care, regardless of who it is, regardless of what their motives are, to not traumatize human beings and put them in harm's way to make a fucking reality TV show.
- 13:04And we need accountability.
- 13:06This is directed at you, American Psychological Association, the APA, and the American Counseling Association, the ACA.
- 13:13We need accountability to end the weaponization of psychology and mental health for entertainment purposes.
- 13:21Counselors and psychologists hired by production, whether that be to be an on-screen character or work behind the scenes, must be bound to the absolute medical standard of do no harm.
- 13:33Right now, the industry often weaponizes psychological profiles and mental health challenges to find participants' deepest traumas.
- 13:42They use the data that they gather in background checks, interviews to intentionally craft devastating narratives, trigger emotional breakdowns, and manipulate people on camera to tell a story and get the scenes that they want.
- 13:59This is a violation of medical and mental health ethics.
- 14:03I am calling on the APA and the ACA to step up immediately.
- 14:07You're...
- 14:08you must issue strict, detailed, and unyielding ethical guidelines specifically for the mental health professionals working within reality TV production.
- 14:17And they should be advocating for mental health support before, during, and after reality TV participation.
- 14:24And that should be independent of production.
- 14:27And it just so happens that the UCAN Foundation has hundreds of therapists in our network that would be willing to step up ethically to fill this gap and fill it fast.
- 14:35We need true background checks that are not for narrative mining and storytelling purposes for producers, but are actually to assess a person's ability to participate without doing harm in a reality TV show.
- 14:51We have standard casting background checks here in the U.S.
- 14:54I'm not sure what the standards are in the U.K., but these are frequently and most commonly used to determine what's good TV and to unearth leverage rather than protect a participant and their ability to participate in a show or not.
- 15:07We need transparent, independent criminal and behavioral background checks that are designed to filter out predators, abusers, and dangerous individuals so that we can ensure the physical safety of everyone on set.
- 15:20Our mission at the UCAN Foundation is to fight for these exact labor rights and mental health protections because what happened with MAPS UK is the ultimate warning sign.
- 15:29If the United States, the UK and all these countries don't regulate the reality TV industry with strict, formalized ethical standards and independent oversight right now, it's only going to be a matter of time before another catastrophic failure of care of this scale or worse happens again.
- 15:49As I always say on this topic, we have a decision to make as a civilized people.
- 15:53And I want to ask you, are you willing to sacrifice human beings' safety for your entertainment?
- 16:00Sound off in the comments.
- 16:01Take care of yourself.
- 16:02We'll see you next time.
- 16:03Hello everyone, welcome friend of the show, Dr. Isabel Morley.
- 16:06Dr. Isabel is a clinical psychologist, best-selling author of the book, They're Not Gaslighting You, and co-founder of the UCAN Foundation.
- 16:14And we have her on here today to discuss some of the psychological challenges that we see based on the chaos that erupted.
- 16:21with the Married at First Sight or MAPS in the UK where three women have alleged to be SA'd, assaulted by their onscreen husband.
- 16:33So that story I covered in a video the other day, you can find that right here.
- 16:40Isabel, thanks for joining today.
- 16:41How are you?
- 16:42I'm okay.
- 16:43I'm okay, Nick.
- 16:44I mean, this is, I think, just the problem that we've seen across all of these shows.
- 16:48And every time allegations crop up and a new problem arises, I think it's just upsetting to us every single time because nothing is being done about this industry.
- 16:57Yeah.
- 16:58Yeah.
- 16:58I actually did an interview with NBC right before we came on here and, you know, asked me what I thought about this.
- 17:05And I'm,
- 17:06I'm like, well, I'm not surprised anymore.
- 17:09I'm disgusted.
- 17:10And my heart goes out to the women who were put in this situation that they didn't ask for any of this to happen to them and the trauma that they have to live with now.
- 17:18But it's kind of like another day, another dollar.
- 17:20You know, it's it's bound to keep happening until there's real change that is done to protect human beings and not exploit them for our entertainment.
- 17:30And there's something about reality TV where people just don't have that much sympathy.
- 17:34There's a sense of like, you know what you were getting into, you put yourself in that position.
- 17:38Even though we've moved away from that narrative as a society of like, well, what were you wearing kind of mentality.
- 17:45But for reality TV, it seems to still be this like little protected space where we blame the victim for putting themselves in a position to be victimized, whether that's like through labor law violations or through violence.
- 17:57unsafe situations with a partner they're placed with.
- 17:59I just don't really understand that.
- 18:02I think it comes down to the thing we've talked about all along is there's no rules or regulations.
- 18:07There's no labor regulations because they list people as contractors, especially in this country.
- 18:11And then from a ethical standpoint, like psychologists and mental health professionals can work on the front end as a character.
- 18:18They can work on the back end and some sort of, you know, mental health services support.
- 18:23And whether that's to the cast member or the producers, you know, that's a black box at this point.
- 18:28You look around and it is the same type of issues where people are being put in unsafe situations, whether physically, whether mentally.
- 18:37And that's all to build out a narrative that they can show on TV.
- 18:41And what bothers me the most about this, and we just saw this with The Bachelorette with Taylor Frankie Paul season, right?
- 18:46There were court papers.
- 18:48There was a whole lawsuit.
- 18:50Everything was known.
- 18:51Yeah.
- 18:52It played out on the secret lives of Mormon wives in a season.
- 18:56And then they cast her in the Bachelorette role, knowing all of that.
- 19:02But it wasn't until the video came out and everybody got very upset, and rightfully so,
- 19:09that that child was in harm's way, especially in that domestic dispute.
- 19:15Then they pulled it.
- 19:17And now there's reports that it's going to come out this summer anyway, which I predicted in the video I did on this show.
- 19:23And so you look at it here, it's similar.
- 19:26Like the station, Channel 4, knew about the allegations.
- 19:30They aired the episodes in the show anyway.
- 19:33And until the police got involved...
- 19:36They did nothing.
- 19:38And now they've pulled all the seasons off of the streaming service.
- 19:41But it wasn't until the police got it wasn't until the seat got too hot to keep sitting on that they took action.
- 19:47Yeah.
- 19:48And that's the part that bothers me because they know.
- 19:52They do.
- 19:52They know.
- 19:53Yeah, they know.
- 19:55They're engineering these dangerous situations because it makes for good drama and makes for good TV.
- 20:01You know, like they know that they are putting people in risky situations or they're choosing people who are going to potentially be unsafe because that's going to create like really exciting stories that people will care a lot about.
- 20:13And they only act, you're right, when there is public backlash that they're doing this and then
- 20:22and nothing changes long term.
- 20:24Nothing changes.
- 20:25Well, I think that's a good segue to the first question I wanted to ask you because Channel 4, who is the service that distributes the show Married at First Sight in the UK, they and their producers defend the safety measures, saying they have the gold standard in care for reality cast members.
- 20:47Yet when we look at the allegations of grape and wine,
- 20:51threats of violence, like acid attacks, and all of the deep trauma that comes from being essayed in this environment, from like a psychological perspective, how can a gold standard, which by the way, the UK is considered in reality TV, as we know, the best, the best that there is, and this still happens.
- 21:10So if this is the gold standard, and it's failing so catastrophically to protect people.
- 21:17How is that possible?
- 21:19Like from your perspective, how can we say this is the gold standard and then this happens to three women on Married at First Sight?
- 21:28I mean, clearly the gold standard is not good enough, right?
- 21:31Like we used to say the gold standard of safety conditions and warehouses was okay until everybody kept getting injured.
- 21:37And then they had to change the standards for care, right?
- 21:40Like maybe it was the gold standard back in the day and it made sense, but we live in a new world where whatever they are doing is clearly insufficient.
- 21:48And so I think sort of
- 21:49Going back to like, well, this is what we agreed was the right way to treat people, even though nobody is being cared for in the way they need to be is such a cop out.
- 21:56Right.
- 21:57Like raise your standard.
- 21:58Well, and even now I'm blanking on her name, but the person who commented on it from Channel 4, it was just such a cop out.
- 22:05And we've seen this with with Kinetic, right?
- 22:08Like, how is it that they can do a PR stunt that?
- 22:12And the public just accepts it at this point.
- 22:15Like you see it over and over again.
- 22:16It's like abuse.
- 22:17It's like, I'm sorry, honey, I won't hit you again.
- 22:20And then what happens a week later?
- 22:22Like, have we not grown to learn that they're going to keep saying what they can say to get out of the trouble in the moment?
- 22:28And then it's kicking the can down the road on the problem itself.
- 22:31And I think this is something that you can, and I know you and I care a lot about, which is let's stop focusing in too tightly on the specific people and allegations and what they did or didn't do and look at the context they were put in, right?
- 22:44Like the organization that allowed it to happen, that selected them, that didn't intervene when they should have, that has restrictive rules when you're filming all of this stuff that makes it possible for people to.
- 22:56to act in this way.
- 22:58Right.
- 22:58Like, and I think they're really good at redirecting of like, this was a bad person.
- 23:02You know, like, I can't believe this contestant did this thing.
- 23:05But actually, when you look at the big picture, it's the system that's allowing all of it.
- 23:10Well, it's the same, that's the same playbook that's used like with police violence.
- 23:15Oh, it's a bad apple.
- 23:16And then what I think is especially difficult in this situation is they actually have
- 23:21the character they created on the show to point to and blame, whether that's accurate or not, doesn't really matter.
- 23:27They can point to that person and say, well, bad behavior, they're messy or whatever that is.
- 23:33And it gives them another out because it's playing out on,
- 23:36But you know what also blows my mind is, I mean, they have tape of so much, right?
- 23:42I mean, they have evidence.
- 23:43They don't have to release because this is not happening in court, right?
- 23:47They have evidence that could probably prove what everybody is saying.
- 23:51And they are so selective in how they edit and what they show people and when.
- 23:54It just feels like this whole thing is rigged from the start, which we know that it is.
- 23:59And at the end of the day, yes, they'll pull seasons for a little while.
- 24:02They'll do an investigation.
- 24:04It will turn out in their favor.
- 24:05We'll all be surprised by that.
- 24:07And then, you know, in six months, in eight months, something new will come out, whether it's MAPS or another show, it's going to happen again.
- 24:14Yeah.
- 24:15And I think that's what's so unfortunate.
- 24:17One thing you touched on MAPS and, you know, UK, but there's several shows that isolate strangers aggressively and pressures them into these sort of quick, immediate, you know,
- 24:27deep relationships or intimacy things that are all, as you said, like under surveillance, they're filming everything.
- 24:33What happens to a person's psychological boundaries or psychological state and their ability to like actually give consent when they're trapped in this manufactured or engineered environment?
- 24:45It's never good to be pressured into a decision, especially one as important as a relationship.
- 24:50The timelines for these relationships is absolutely insane.
- 24:54Humans do not get to know each other in a deep enough way within the context of a couple of weeks or even months.
- 25:00So because they put you together so fast and there's always this degree of commitment, whether it's that you're engaged or you're actually married, that's going to make you feel like, OK, I'm in this.
- 25:09I have to make this work.
- 25:10If I don't make it work now, it's a failure versus we're dating.
- 25:14We're going to see which way it goes.
- 25:15And if we don't end up together, that would be a success in another way.
- 25:18These shows really want a successful outcome, which is a long-term relationship.
- 25:23And humans are, especially with authority figures, compliant.
- 25:26We want to make them happy.
- 25:27We want to do a good job.
- 25:28We want to...
- 25:29make our relationships work.
- 25:31Nobody wants a failed relationship.
- 25:32So it makes you really stuck in this specific mindset that will make you agree to things and do things that you probably shouldn't do.
- 25:40And you maybe wouldn't do if you weren't in a manufactured environment.
- 25:44And that's the thing, with the producers is there's a power dynamic that slowly gets established there.
- 25:50They're the ones that take you where you need to go, tell you what you need to talk about,
- 25:56give you your breaks, take you to the bathroom.
- 25:58Like these are the things that have power and control over you very slowly and you don't even realize it.
- 26:05And I think that's a, you know, it all kind of contributes to this.
- 26:09And how badly can it mess someone up too when, you know, so before I ask that, let me say this.
- 26:17In this case, in this story with math,
- 26:21All three of them have reported that they reported incidents or red flags, discomfort, all of those things.
- 26:27So how does it impact someone when production completely ignores their cries for help, for lack of a better word, and broadcasts it to the world anyway?
- 26:40It honestly, it's unconscionable to me that they could be hearing people's legitimate concerns for their safety in a situation and do nothing about it.
- 26:49It makes people think, oh, you're overreacting.
- 26:51What you're saying is not true or it's not as big a deal as you actually think it is.
- 26:54Right.
- 26:54Like it's very minimizing.
- 26:56It's keeping people stuck in a bad situation.
- 26:59And we know with a lot of these shows, they actually won't let you leave.
- 27:02So you are actually contractually stuck.
- 27:05Right.
- 27:06with whatever situation you're in until they decide that they're done with you for the show.
- 27:10And it just feels like, once again, it's just so rigged.
- 27:13The idea that people could be doing the right things and reporting things that the gold standard isn't catching this and helping them goes to show this is not working.
- 27:22Yeah.
- 27:23And then you've got the whole element of
- 27:27the mental health aspects of being in this pressure cooker type of environment that you're not allowed to leave to where you've got someone that's kind of controlling you.
- 27:34And so then when those people who are in control ignore your cries for help, ignore what you're reporting, it can completely make you feel so little like you really don't have any say or autonomy in these cases with your own body.
- 27:49Yeah.
- 27:50And then with MAPS, I mean, and you know, this is one of my biggest concerns, then they have therapists on the show giving counseling and advice and trying to help you figure yourself out and make it work.
- 28:01These therapists don't know these people.
- 28:02None of this feels ethical to me.
- 28:04And they can even convince you, right?
- 28:06Like it's easy for abusers to make the victim seem like the problem.
- 28:10They can participate and like, yes, you're overreacting.
- 28:13Maybe this is the work you have to do, right?
- 28:15For your relationship.
- 28:17when in actuality that is causing more damage and abuse.
- 28:20Yeah, it's almost as if you're getting gaslit.
- 28:23Can you imagine?
- 28:25Yeah.
- 28:26Yes, I can.
- 28:27It's been there.
- 28:28I do want to shift because I want to get your take on this.
- 28:30You just touched on it.
- 28:31There's to me, there's two elements that I would love to hear your thoughts on.
- 28:35One is their psychological evaluations that are used in varying ways before the show.
- 28:40I had mine under the guise of this being whether or not I was mentally fit to participate in the show.
- 28:47Since then, I don't believe those are the cases.
- 28:49I believe that they are being used to profile people.
- 28:52Um,
- 28:53When it comes to that, part one, are these shows using psychological tests from the casting process to figure out how to control and mentally break people for the narrative of the show?
- 29:07I can only guess because, as you know, no one who conducts these evaluations will speak with me.
- 29:12They will not disclose what evaluations they are using.
- 29:15And all that we know is that contestants sign away the rights to even see the results.
- 29:19They have no idea what they say, but that production can access them.
- 29:22and see what's going on.
- 29:24So they're given this treasure trove of clinical information about you and all of your greatest vulnerabilities and fears and mental health issues.
- 29:30And we've heard from people that they were specifically used, like information from that was used during confessionals, right?
- 29:37They're pulling on threads of, I know this trauma happened to you or I know you have this issue.
- 29:42So it does feel like that that information is being specifically used to get reactions and to make drama, which makes me call into question the psychologists who are conducting these evaluations, because we are supposed to do no harm.
- 29:56And if you know that the work you're doing is being used to exploit and manipulate people, you should not be doing that.
- 30:02Yeah, I completely agree with you.
- 30:04I think there's real ethical concerns that I know I have.
- 30:07And I think that psychologists and therapists across the world should be sort of looking themselves in the mirror.
- 30:13And if these therapists are being hired to participate before, during or after the show, how are they, where should their priorities be?
- 30:22Because this is where I think it gets a little muddy in the waters.
- 30:25Because if you're a therapist, you're a therapist.
- 30:27as a therapist, you're supposed to do no harm, right?
- 30:30But if you're getting paid by production to be a character on the show, as you said, to participate, to get these psychological exams, to provide therapy services at any point in the life cycle of being a reality TV show, to me, it blurs the water about who you're supposed to do no harm to because you're technically being paid by production, right?
- 30:52How can therapists that are hired for these shows actually protect the cast?
- 30:58Or are they just going to keep protecting the network because that's who they're getting paid for?
- 31:03Or what should that look like maybe is a better way to put it?
- 31:06I think until, as we've discussed, until the APA and the ACA finally shows up with some strict guidelines for what that looks like, that I don't think therapists can participate in these shows in a way that makes ethical sense.
- 31:19Even if they're doing their best to protect cast members, to provide support and care, right?
- 31:25It can still be abused.
- 31:27It can still be manipulated.
- 31:28It can still be misconstrued.
- 31:29At the end of the day, they are being paid by production by these companies.
- 31:33So it does feel like there's really no ethical way to practice when they are there to make entertainment.
- 31:39They are not actually there to provide mental health counseling, no matter what they're saying.
- 31:44I think that's important for people to let sink in.
- 31:48They're not there to actually provide mental health counseling.
- 31:51They're providing a service, but that is not mental health counseling.
- 31:55No.
- 31:55And even if they think it is, and even if they try for it to be because of the context they're working in, it just can't be.
- 32:03You know what would be interesting?
- 32:04I just thought of this.
- 32:05I wonder what the contracts look like for the on-screen therapists.
- 32:10Dying to know.
- 32:11We have got to figure that out.
- 32:13There's got to be someone out there that would share that with us redacted.
- 32:16I wonder if there's a way to access that because I am so curious if they, how they even structure it.
- 32:25I know if you're practicing under your license or not, technically all sorts of things.
- 32:30Are you a performer?
- 32:31I mean, there's, Hmm.
- 32:33Are you acting?
- 32:34Can you not be an actor or an actress when you're a counselor?
- 32:37Of course you can.
- 32:39Like where that's so, you know, and I think it bleeds into like social media content.
- 32:45Like,
- 32:47Where's the line there?
- 32:48Like, just because you're a therapist, you can't be a content creator.
- 32:51You can't be an actor or actress.
- 32:53Yeah.
- 32:54But it's blurry.
- 32:56I mean, the strong recommendation is that you don't do that.
- 32:59If you are practicing under your license and presenting mental health information, that like there should be a clear line that you are a professional and you are accurate and you are not doing harm and you are following all the ethical guidelines, even in other contexts, right?
- 33:11Mandated reporters are mandated reporters all the time, not just at work, all the time.
- 33:15So it's the same kind of concept of like, this is the standard that you are now holding yourself to and you should be.
- 33:21But what I find crazy is that therapists are proud of their involvement, right?
- 33:25Especially the onscreen ones.
- 33:27Promote it.
- 33:27It's like a huge part of their business.
- 33:29And the APA has basically one article about therapist involvement in reality TV.
- 33:35It's profiling somebody who is...
- 33:37a person who does evaluations for these shows.
- 33:40And it's basically promoting it saying, therapists should do this more.
- 33:43What a great new avenue for us to pursue.
- 33:46That's it.
- 33:46That is so scary to me.
- 33:49That's, it's a grim way to look at it, especially when they are in a care business, the business of providing care to people.
- 33:58You can't, that's the thing is like, you can't, it can be done ethically.
- 34:02Like I'm not saying therapists shouldn't participate in reality TV.
- 34:05I'm not saying therapists shouldn't participate in content creation of any kind.
- 34:09Do whatever you want.
- 34:11But at the same time, like you, your thing as a counselor, I know is to advocate for your client.
- 34:17Yeah.
- 34:17Do no harm.
- 34:19Yeah.
- 34:19And so I could imagine being on a show once and thinking that you're going to provide great therapy to a couple or a great evaluation.
- 34:28But once you see the consequence, once you see the impact it has on those people, I think you can't ethically justify doing it a second time.
- 34:37But I think it's like, I agree with you.
- 34:39I also think the way these shows, it's a slow burn to indoctrinate you into the system.
- 34:45And at some point you don't even realize what you're doing anymore.
- 34:51That's my experience.
- 34:52That's the experience of so many people that I've talked to.
- 34:54And I can imagine it being the same.
- 34:57for therapists, right?
- 34:58And then you also look at the therapeutic relationship that you build in real life with your therapist or your couples counselor, whatever that is, like that becomes the real determinant measure from my understanding of whether therapy is successful.
- 35:12It's that relationship.
- 35:13And so when you're that psychologist doing that mental health evaluation and then an interview, which was my experience, I did the evaluation, I did about an hour long interview.
- 35:21And then you don't have to see or talk to me again.
- 35:23There's no relationship there.
- 35:25Or if I'm only interacting with you on camera.
- 35:29Not otherwise.
- 35:30There's no real relationship there.
- 35:32No.
- 35:32Again, it's performative at that point.
- 35:34Yeah.
- 35:35Right.
- 35:35It's not therapy.
- 35:36And maybe they're not contractually listed as therapists, but they're selling it as therapy, which is bad for viewers, too.
- 35:43That's not a good perspective on what therapy can and should look like.
- 35:48And you're right.
- 35:48And instead of people who maybe are therapy curious or could benefit from seeing the benefits of therapy, they're seeing this toxic rendition of it for entertainment.
- 36:00Yeah.
- 36:00And it's like...
- 36:02And it has long lasting impacts.
- 36:04Like I've talked to somebody at MAPS UK who like did not know himself afterwards of like, they told me with certainty that I am this and I have never thought that before.
- 36:14And they fully convinced me and it messes with you and your identity and your mental health.
- 36:19Like we have to take this so much more seriously than we do.
- 36:23That's the one thing that Christine, what is her line?
- 36:27The one that did that research report for Rutgers.
- 36:31Christine, I'm blanking on her last name.
- 36:33Christine, I'll put the research down in the show notes.
- 36:35But one of her big findings was that there's a very confusing, like awareness of identity coming out of it.
- 36:42Because when you're and I experienced this a little bit, too.
- 36:45I've shared this before.
- 36:46It's like people would tell me stay in your lane, reality star, when I would talk about anything that wasn't reality TV.
- 36:52Stay in your lane, reality star.
- 36:53You know, it's not my lane.
- 36:55Reality TV.
- 36:56That's not my lane.
- 36:58So there and now when you've got the Internet and people are, you know, snap away and you're building these weird paranormal relationships, there is an expectation of you behaving a certain way for your audience that you gain from the show who likes you or dislikes you from the character they saw you portrayed as.
- 37:17And even in a best case scenario, which I would say I got to, you know, my portrayal was probably the most people could ask for.
- 37:25And even that, like there was no nuance.
- 37:27There was not a lot of understanding of what Nick is like outside of this relationship that was brewing.
- 37:33And so there's a pressure that then becomes if I want to make money or God forbid something bad happens and you lose your job or your business, which happens to a lot of people too, you've got to become that character.
- 37:44And that can be a total confusing, conflicting thing every single day that you deal with with how you show up in your regular life, how you show up on social media and God forbid you do another show.
- 37:54Yeah.
- 37:54Yeah.
- 37:55It does sort of lock you into this persona that you have to be because now your livelihood depends on it.
- 37:59Now people not hating on the internet depends on it.
- 38:03Like it locks you into being someone that you probably weren't to begin with.
- 38:09So I got one more question I want to ask you.
- 38:12You and I have been fighting for massive change through the UCAN Foundation for a while now.
- 38:17And if you had two things specifically that you would say should be non-negotiable ethical guidelines for the APA and the ACA to mandate for mental health professionals working in the reality TV industry, what would those be?
- 38:31They have to have decision-making power.
- 38:33They have to be able to say, this person needs to be let to leave the show.
- 38:38This person needs a break today.
- 38:39Do not press on this issue with this person.
- 38:42They cannot handle it.
- 38:43They have to be able to have decision-making power with production and filming.
- 38:47Otherwise, they're just there to look good and make the show feel good about themselves.
- 38:53That would be number one, I think.
- 38:55That's a good second one.
- 38:56I don't know.
- 38:57A lot of it's about the show doing things to do more than the therapist.
- 39:00Yeah.
- 39:01I think that's access to their testing results.
- 39:04I think it should be, I mean, honestly, I think that if we're doing evaluations for these shows, people should be able to access their results.
- 39:11It is about them.
- 39:12They have a right to see it and that there should be incredibly strict access on the production side and or no access.
- 39:19But just a therapist saying, yes, they're mentally fit or no, I think they're not ready.
- 39:24Like it should be, there should be a harder boundary.
- 39:27Yeah.
- 39:28Very decision of yes or no.
- 39:30Yeah.
- 39:34Yeah.
- 39:34I mean, and I think that's a good one too.
- 39:36I think having that is a, is a very good one.
- 39:38Full transparency on the psychological exams is a good one.
- 39:42You know, I actually, I think I've shared this with you before, but I've shared it.
- 39:45Like I had the psych, I had the psychologist that did my psych eval have a conversation with my therapist.
- 39:52because I wanted, yeah, I wanted to get her take on it after working with me for several years and getting me, you know, teaching me some things to get me through some of the hardest points in my life.
- 40:01Little did we know those were yet to come, but...
- 40:06But, you know, I think like that there should be some sort of comprehensive, transparent thing.
- 40:12And then if there is something and you've said this before, which just because someone struggles with their mental health doesn't mean they shouldn't be able to be on reality TV.
- 40:20But how do we protect that person?
- 40:21We walk around the whole world trying to make safe spaces for people that they feel comfortable in.
- 40:26Why is reality TV get excused from that?
- 40:28It shouldn't be.
- 40:29So let's be transparent about it and let's take care of people and be comprehensive about it.
- 40:35So I love those.
- 40:36Those are two really, really good suggestions.
- 40:38And I know we're going to keep working to try and get these things implemented.
- 40:42I'm sure NBC is going to make those changes right away.
- 40:45They just didn't think of it.
- 40:46But now that they've heard it, they're going to do it.
- 40:48Now they get it.
- 40:49Now they get it.
- 40:51Well, I want to I want to thank you for hopping on and deep diving into this with me.
- 40:55I think that I appreciate the work you do.
- 40:57I think that what happened here is atrocious and it's just another reminder that these things need to change.
- 41:04Thank you for that.
- 41:05Tell people how they can find you for more content about this.
- 41:08I think you're done with the fish content, but that was fun for a little while too.
- 41:12But where can people find you on social media and online?
- 41:15On Instagram, DrIsabelMorley, or my website, DrIsabelMorley.com, or on Psychology Today, where I write about a lot of different things, but some of it touching on reality TV ethical concerns.
- 41:27Some great, great commentary and discussion being had there.
- 41:30So thank you again so much.
- 41:31It's great to see you again.
- 41:40Thank you for joining us on this week's episode of Eyes Wide Open.
- 41:43If you enjoy the show, the best way to support us is by sharing or dropping a review.
- 41:47For more information and content, check out engagewithnick.com or find me on Instagram at nthompson513.
- 41:55Don't go through life blind.
- 41:57Do the work so you can show up in the world with your eyes wide open.