Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / Credit Union Vs Banks: What You Need to Know About the Insurance Funds
Transcript
- 0:00Treichel: Hey everyone.
- 0:00This is Mark with a special archive episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:05I hope you enjoy.
- 0:07I'm here today with Steve Farrar, formerly of NCUA and currently of my
- 0:11team at Credit Union Exam Solutions.
- 0:13Steve, how are you doing today?
- 0:15Steve Farrar: I'm doing all right.
- 0:16Treichel: So Steve, today we're going to talk about the National Credit
- 0:19Union Share Insurance Fund versus the Deposit Insurance Fund one of which is
- 0:24for NCUA and the other is for banks.
- 0:28And but before we jump into that, why don't you give a little bit of
- 0:31your background as it relates to this topic and or just what you did at N.
- 0:36C.
- 0:36U.
- 0:36A.
- 0:36in general.
- 0:38Steve Farrar: Yeah, I decided that to delve into this topic, it has to
- 0:42do with my back 30 plus years at N.
- 0:45C.
- 0:45U.
- 0:45A.
- 0:46and dealing with as a problem case officer dealing with the assistance that
- 0:50was offered and available through the N.
- 0:54C.
- 0:54U.
- 0:55S.
- 0:55I.
- 0:55F.
- 0:56And then as my career went on in the central office, I started dealing with
- 1:01helping to manage the equity ratio of the fund and I found myself and a lot of
- 1:08times doing comparisons to the deposit insurance fund to, to make sure that
- 1:14I wasn't missing something that they were seeing coming along in the future.
- 1:18Those duties that I had, it made me always interested in contrasting, comparing the
- 1:23two funds and thought maybe I'll share some of that information on this podcast.
- 1:28Treichel: Yeah, that sounds good.
- 1:29I'm looking forward to this.
- 1:31This is right in your wheelhouse from all that knowledge that not a lot of
- 1:34people have about one, one or the other, but because of your role at NCUA you
- 1:39know a little bit about both of them.
- 1:41So why don't we, why don't we jump jump in and talk about what the purpose
- 1:45of these funds are, which I think a lot of listeners will know, but it's
- 1:48a good way to maybe start it off.
- 1:51Steve Farrar: Yeah, as it goes back early, they're both set up to
- 1:54maintain public confidence in the U.
- 1:56S.
- 1:56financial system and resolve failed banks and credit unions.
- 2:01And so that if you look back prior to deposit insurance, the banking
- 2:07and losses, or it was like, operating in the wild West, either had a good
- 2:12institution that did fine, or you were in 1 that involve a lot of fraud
- 2:16and you ended up losing your deposit.
- 2:18They wanted to have stabilize our deposit system and that's
- 2:21the the use of deposit insurance.
- 2:26Treichel: Very good.
- 2:26Yeah, I was watching a documentary Wyatt on Netflix.
- 2:31It's a 4 part documentary about the wild West and it was about Wells Fargo.
- 2:36And shipping gold from, excuse me, shipping silver from Arizona and the, the
- 2:42stagecoach is coming to the East coast and how that played a role in the U.
- 2:45S.
- 2:46financial system in the economy being built.
- 2:49And of course, back in the wild West there was no deposit insurance.
- 2:52And like you said, if you picked a good bank that stayed alive you were lucky.
- 2:56And if you had one that failed, you could lose your life savings.
- 2:58So it's a great a great system that we have here in the United States,
- 3:03but let's so let's talk about the National Credit Union Share Insurance
- 3:07Funds and the principles of it, when it was started, how all that works.
- 3:11Steve Farrar: Yeah, it's that one was back when the Federal Credit
- 3:14Union Act came into place with, what, 1934 or something like that.
- 3:18You might know the exact date.
- 3:19I didn't write that down.
- 3:20It was established and it is managed, the fund is managed by the NCUA board.
- 3:26And like we say, the purpose to ensure deposits of all federally insured credit
- 3:31unions and the thing about it is that the fund is backed by the full faith and
- 3:36credit of the United States government, which is a real important item to have
- 3:41specifically included in the in the act.
- 3:45And then, as of I did all the numbers as of the end of 2023 for comparison
- 3:51sake, because I could work off of audited financial statements, the
- 3:55insured shares at that time were 1.
- 3:597 trillion in the credit union system.
- 4:02So if I go and compare that to the deposit insurance fund their thing is insures.
- 4:08Deposits have insured depository institution and resolve failures upon
- 4:11appointment as receiver in a manner that will result in the least possible
- 4:16cost to the deposit insurance fund.
- 4:17That's their.
- 4:18Directive and at the same on 12 31 23, they had a 10.
- 4:236 trillion in their insured deposit.
- 4:27So it's like 617.
- 4:30Percent of the insured deposit of the we'll contrast and compare them
- 4:33a lot based on kind of those, how much bigger the deposit insurance
- 4:38fund is and and so I say, yeah.
- 4:42Treichel: That's interesting.
- 4:43And by the way, I don't know the exact date of when that was signed, but
- 4:46I do know fun fact that the picture I use on LinkedIn with me standing
- 4:52in front of a flag, and I also use it as advertising for this podcast.
- 4:56That picture was taken at NCUA's celebration of the
- 5:00signing of the Act in 2019.
- 5:03However many years that would be, it was some ought five without doing the math,
- 5:08but but anyway yeah, that's it's been in place a long time it it ensures a lot of
- 5:13deposits as the deposit base keeps growing and that's a good, it's good you've got
- 5:17that data there so we can walk through it As we walk through different things here.
- 5:20So you mentioned that you, you got involved because of your
- 5:25understanding of working with troubled credit unions and providing
- 5:28insurance and assistance from the N.
- 5:30C.
- 5:30U.
- 5:30S.
- 5:30I.
- 5:30F.
- 5:31Could you touch base on that?
- 5:32What that actually means to the for the listeners?
- 5:35Steve Farrar: Yeah, it is one of those evolving things and a lot of the
- 5:40work I did as a problem case officer in resolving troubled institution
- 5:44was pre prompt corrective action.
- 5:46So some of the items that we did then are less likely to occur now because of
- 5:52Of the change in capital requirements but then so he still has the ability to
- 5:57do the items that were included there.
- 5:59So items that included assistance would be waiver of statutory reserve
- 6:04requirements liquidity assistance in the form of a guaranteed line of credit.
- 6:10And that would be as a very last resort that the insurance fund
- 6:14would guarantee to land credit.
- 6:16It would just be for a severe troubled institution, liquidity
- 6:20problem cash assistance in the form of a subordinated note.
- 6:24And, that would be that, basically, and so investing in the institution
- 6:29for a, limited period of time.
- 6:331, that doesn't occur much and it's always a problem thing there.
- 6:36And that if the government is supporting an institution, that's
- 6:40competing against other institutions that don't have government support.
- 6:43So that's why that 1 is less used at this point in time.
- 6:48And a big 1 that you see a lot is merger assistance in the form of cast assistance.
- 6:53Purchase of certain assets by the N.
- 6:56C.
- 6:56S.
- 6:56F.
- 6:56out of a troubled credit union.
- 6:59And our guarantees of the values of certain assets, primarily loans, but
- 7:04that is the assistance that's available.
- 7:08Got it
- 7:10Treichel: And loan guarantees that's something that did I think quite
- 7:14a bit before you and I started, but then it what it happened.
- 7:18As I recall, is they stopped wanting to do loan guarantees because it became
- 7:23complicated for the audits that NCUA would have done, but the cash assistance.
- 7:28So those would be examples where Credit Union A is in danger of closing, has
- 7:34poor net worth, and NCUA is actually involved in shopping that institution.
- 7:39And someone comes in and prices the assets.
- 7:42That would be an example of the merger assistance.
- 7:45On the liquidity assistance, You mentioned that's not used that frequently.
- 7:50It used to be used more.
- 7:52I remember, back in our problem case officer and director of special
- 7:55actions days, you'd get, we'd get phone calls from the corporate saying, Hey,
- 7:59this credit union here were worried about their financial statements
- 8:02because to get the loans, they would provide their financial statements.
- 8:06And then, they would call we would work with the central office and
- 8:10then a guarantee would be put in place where the insurance fund
- 8:13agreed to guarantee any loss there.
- 8:16At the end of your career, was it working different?
- 8:18It was less frequent, but were the mechanics generally the same?
- 8:23The
- 8:23Steve Farrar: mechanics would have been the same.
- 8:25It's just that fewer institutions would get into that position anymore because.
- 8:31We, the corrective action starts so much sooner, right?
- 8:35And once capital gets below 6, the.
- 8:39Everybody's Interest gets elevated and those problems
- 8:42tend to get resolved quicker.
- 8:44Treichel: Sure.
- 8:45Sure.
- 8:45That goes to prompt correction action, prompt corrective action, which
- 8:48requires them to have the capital.
- 8:49So situations get to a brought to a head quicker.
- 8:53Steve Farrar: I was going to buy 1 of these is like, when we do that, do the.
- 8:57Merger assistance and then we sometimes will put them out for
- 9:00basically competitive bidding.
- 9:02And anyway, we'd like to do the deals where you give us the deal as to how much,
- 9:06what is the assistance that you need and do the 1 time kind of deal on that because
- 9:12of the incentive is so great for the.
- 9:15continuing institution to maximize the value of that.
- 9:19And I'll contrast that I'll talk quick about what the FDIC really
- 9:23doesn't do assistance because those are pro for profit institutions.
- 9:26So they don't tend to want to prop up for profit institutions versus
- 9:30ours being non profit, but their institutions are placed into receivership.
- 9:36They're currently managing 74.
- 9:39Active receiver shifts, but they their resolution and using purchase and
- 9:42assumption transactions with shared loss agreements is what they use predominantly.
- 9:48There's a difference in how liquidations and resolutions can take place.
- 9:54Treichel: Got it.
- 9:55Got it.
- 9:55NCOA cashes out and FDIC does loss sharing.
- 10:00Got it.
- 10:01Got it.
- 10:02As far as liquidations and resolutions of institutions that kind of goes into that.
- 10:06Is there anything else relative to that you want to touch on?
- 10:09Steve Farrar: Yeah, for liquidations on the NCSAF side they establish
- 10:15an asset management estate, and those are generally run by our AMAC.
- 10:22Down in Texas there.
- 10:23So it says that unless especially guaranteed by the NCAA and backed by
- 10:27the full faith and credit United States, the AME's unsecured creditors, including
- 10:31the NCAA could only expect to be paid if recoveries from the asset management
- 10:36estate are efficient to be distributed to unsecured creditors in order of priority,
- 10:41which is included in the regulations.
- 10:44In, if not a straight liquidation and total payout, most.
- 10:49Liquidations are completed using a purchase and assumption agreement.
- 10:53So that there's just a nice kind of clean break for the continuing institution.
- 10:58That's only absorbing those assets and liabilities that
- 11:02they specifically purchased.
- 11:05Protects them
- 11:06Treichel: got it.
- 11:07Got it.
- 11:07Yeah.
- 11:07And if they don't purchase it, exactly as identified it in the documents.
- 11:12It falls upon the insurance fund, which is a smart way to acquire
- 11:15something if there are unknowns.
- 11:20So Of course the, you mentioned the dollars that are in each insurance
- 11:25fund and they're funded differently.
- 11:28Credit unions fund the insur, the N-C-U-S-I Diff, N-C-U-S-I-F
- 11:33different than how the DIF is funded.
- 11:35Can you talk through that?
- 11:38Steve Farrar: Yeah.
- 11:38This is probably like the single most different item in between the
- 11:42two funds is how they're funded.
- 11:44You're probably aware that, 1% of insured shares are required to
- 11:48be deposited into the N-C-S-I-F.
- 11:50So that is a the lion's share of the money in the insurance fund.
- 11:57The NCSF can assess premiums to all credit unions as provided in the
- 12:01act, and we'd rarely ever do that.
- 12:05Investment income is a big source of funding.
- 12:08There, when we had guarantee fees that were, Active in the corporate resolution
- 12:15that we're providing income to the fund.
- 12:18And then, of course, as we get recoveries from the asset management
- 12:21estates those can can contribute to provided everybody else has been
- 12:26been paid according to the priority.
- 12:29The other source of funding is the authority to borrow from the treasury and
- 12:33from the NCOA central liquidity facility.
- 12:35The NCOA SIF can borrow up to 6 billion from treasury, but in times
- 12:41of extreme duress, that can be raised, but that, becomes very difficult
- 12:48and quite political, at that point.
- 12:51Treichel: Yeah that's that's an understatement.
- 12:52It does become political back in the great recession.
- 12:55N.
- 12:55C.
- 12:55U.
- 12:56A.
- 12:56was using every trick in the book to try and provide liquidity to the to
- 13:00credit unions and then also got some relief through an acts of Congress
- 13:04that have since sunset, as I recall.
- 13:07Steve Farrar: Yeah, and the difference being there that the
- 13:08deposit insurance fund is primary source of funding is assessments.
- 13:13On the insured depository institutions, and then they're, they have their
- 13:17interest earned on their investments and they too can borrow from treasury
- 13:22and they're borrowing authority is 100 billion from treasury.
- 13:27Very much where, they do have significant more exposure in terms of that too big
- 13:32to fail type problem that they deal with.
- 13:35That raises the specter of needs of extreme amounts of liquidity.
- 13:42Treichel: Sure.
- 13:43That, no, that.
- 13:44That makes good sense.
- 13:45N.
- 13:45C.
- 13:45U.
- 13:45A.
- 13:46last recently did their budget briefing and there's a slide
- 13:50in their budget briefing where they compare the costs of N.
- 13:54C.
- 13:54U.
- 13:54A.
- 13:54's exams and the assessments of F.
- 13:58D.
- 13:58I.
- 13:58C.
- 13:59and O.
- 13:59C.
- 13:59et cetera for operation.
- 14:01And every year when you, when they show it, it shows that the cost of being a
- 14:05credit union is less than the Of being a bank yeah which is used to calm the nerves
- 14:12of the trade groups who say NCOA's budget is too high, which they say every year but
- 14:16then that data shows some context, there's peer groups for credit unions, the FDIC
- 14:21is essentially the only peer group for NCOA, but that's another Another rabbit
- 14:26hole that that I thought I'd touch on.
- 14:29There are, certain statutory ratios which are required, like the equity
- 14:34ratio, you mentioned the normal operating ratio and that you've been
- 14:38involved in that, that in the past.
- 14:41And there's something called the available asset ratio,
- 14:44which which I'm showing my age.
- 14:47I'm getting I'm not remembering that one so much.
- 14:50So anyway, let's talk through these statutory ratios a little bit.
- 14:54Steve Farrar: So each of the fund does have some statutory ratios that
- 14:58they have to deal with for the NCSF.
- 15:01The main one is, it's the equity ratio.
- 15:03It's the amount of the funds capitalization, including the
- 15:071% capitalization, deposit, and retained earnings of the fund.
- 15:10And it says net of direct liabilities and contingent liabilities for
- 15:14which no provision has been made.
- 15:16Now that sounds pretty simple, but there's been a few times like during 2008 2009,
- 15:22we're had to deal with what exactly was the mean net of direct liabilities
- 15:27and contingent liabilities for which no provision has been made because we could,
- 15:32there was some significant exposures out there that was hard to determine if
- 15:35they would fall under that or not, but those were resolved to and this is that's
- 15:40taken to the aggregate amount of insured shares and all insured institutions.
- 15:44Thanks.
- 15:45Now, if NCOA projects that the equity ratio will fall below 1.
- 15:492 percent within 6 months, the board must establish and implement a
- 15:53restoration plan within 90 days that will return the equity ratio to over 1.
- 15:592 percent before the end of an 8 year period, beginning with
- 16:02the implementation of the fund.
- 16:05So we did have to do one of those that back in 2008 or so and I was Worked
- 16:13closely with some of our other people and putting that together It what nco is in
- 16:19pretty good shape on that and you know through The natural adjustment of the one
- 16:24percent and improved earnings there wasn't a lot of additional assessments that had
- 16:28to be made to get back to that point so Now the equity ratio is the measurement,
- 16:37and then NCOA sets the normal operating ratio using the equity ratio as that
- 16:42measurement, and the normal operating ratio means the equity ratio specifies by
- 16:47the board, which shall not be less than 1.
- 16:502 percent and not more than 1.
- 16:525%.
- 16:53The normal operating is NCOA board's target level for the fund, and the board
- 16:59has set the normal operating level at 1.
- 17:0233%.
- 17:02for your attention.
- 17:04And at the end of 2023, it was 1.
- 17:0730 and the board may declare a distribution for the year end equity
- 17:13ratio exceeds the normal operating and the available asset ratio exceeds 1%.
- 17:19So I might as well explain the available asset ratio, which is
- 17:22a lesser known and rarely comes into play, but it's statutory.
- 17:27Is the amount determined by subtracting 1, direct liabilities for which no provision
- 17:31has been made from the sum of cash and market value of unencumbered investments
- 17:37to the aggregate amount of insured shares, and that must remain above 1%.
- 17:41And that ratio was 1.
- 17:4222 percent at December of 2023.
- 17:46That's the statutory requirements for the.
- 17:49And so I say F and there are similar ones for the deposit insurance fund.
- 17:54They have their equity ratio is called the designated reserve ratio, and it's
- 18:00the total of the insurance fund divided by the total, and they use the term estimated
- 18:05insured deposits for the industry.
- 18:08The Act, their act requires the FDIC board to set a target for the DRR annually.
- 18:16The FDIC has broad discretion in managing the deposit insurance fund,
- 18:22including the level at which the DRR designated reserve ratio is set.
- 18:26The required minimum ratio is 1.
- 18:3035%.
- 18:30There is no upper limit on the reserve ratio and thus no statutory
- 18:34limit on the size of their fund.
- 18:35The FDIC Act provides for dividends from the fund when the reserve ratio exceeds 1.
- 18:425 percent, but grants the board sole discretion in determining whether
- 18:47to suspend or limit the reserve ratio or payment of dividends.
- 18:51Under the long range PRI plan, the FDIC set the DRR at 2% since 2010.
- 18:59Their analysis using historical fund and simulated income data from 1950
- 19:04to 2010 showed that the DRR would have to exceed, would have had to exceed 2%
- 19:11before the onset of the two crisis that occurred during the past 30 years and
- 19:16have maintain and would have maintained a positive fund balance and stable
- 19:20assessment rates throughout the crisis.
- 19:23Their DR as of 12 31 23 was 1.
- 19:2715%, so that sounds a little scary at the end of last year,
- 19:30but it already increased to 1.
- 19:322 percent by 6 by June of 2024.
- 19:37They have another ratio to I think a real blaster ratio that
- 19:40limits the amount of obligations.
- 19:42The deposit inference fund can incur to the sum of cash, 90 percent of the fair
- 19:48value of other assets and the amount authorized to be borrowed from treasury.
- 19:53Their minimum obligation limitation was 210 billion as of.
- 20:001231 to 23, so that's the statutory requirements that kind of drive some
- 20:08of the decision making that goes on behind the management of the 2 funds.
- 20:12Treichel: Got it and I'm going to paraphrase some things.
- 20:14You tell me if I got this, right?
- 20:15So the FDIC has broader authority to raise.
- 20:18There's higher.
- 20:20The F and as of right now.
- 20:24Or the data that you have the nearest data that you have the.
- 20:29Looked at in a vacuum, the NCUSIF appears stronger just by the math, not looking
- 20:36at risks and what could impact it, but the NCUA's reserve is higher than
- 20:41what you just said the FDIC's is at 1.
- 20:442.
- 20:45Steve Farrar: Yeah, and we'll go into that.
- 20:46We're going to discuss the balance sheet of the 2 funds and I'll explain that
- 20:51a little bit further as it's related to recent events more than anything.
- 20:56Treichel: Got it.
- 20:57Got it.
- 20:57And I know you're going to talk about NCUA assessments.
- 21:00And I know there's some calculations.
- 21:03NCUA can only do assessments at certain times.
- 21:06And there's certain times that the only way that the fund can go up is through
- 21:11earnings off of the fund and operating, operating at a surplus as opposed to
- 21:16doing An assessment, whereas the FDIC, it sounds have such broad discretion while
- 21:23they might not want to do it politically.
- 21:25They have more authority in that area.
- 21:27But when you're walking through these other topics, if you wanted
- 21:29to speak to those, feel free to.
- 21:32Steve Farrar: And to differentiate the 2 things that you have the N.
- 21:35C.
- 21:35U.
- 21:35A.
- 21:36assessments.
- 21:37Which is really the operating fee so that that, that is, the annual amount that,
- 21:44that federal credit unions end up paying.
- 21:46It's on a sliding scale based on asset size.
- 21:49And, of course, if you're an operating credit union, you also
- 21:52would be paying your, in your estate charter, you're paying an assessment
- 21:56to that state regulator also.
- 21:59Then there's also.
- 22:01And so as I have premiums, which are different than assessments,
- 22:04and those would be specifically issued to increase the equity.
- 22:08Level of the fund, and then that 1, what is unique on that is.
- 22:14The has to charge all credit unions.
- 22:17The same rate On a premium and versus banks can do a risk based pricing
- 22:24on their premiums or assessments.
- 22:28So right there, because everybody gets charged the same.
- 22:30If the fund gets into trouble and they have to issue premiums, that is
- 22:34what kind of is a good thing in our industry that it encourages everybody
- 22:40to look at your fellow credit unions.
- 22:42Somebody is taking huge amounts of risk.
- 22:46And they're large enough to affect that equity ratio of the funds
- 22:49should they fail senior best interest to speak to them about that.
- 22:54Start with speaking to them and maybe speaking to the
- 22:57regular that you have concerns.
- 22:59I think that's a nice safety check that's built into the fund.
- 23:03Treichel: And so Steve, on the risk based premium, so if a credit
- 23:07union, excuse me, if a bank.
- 23:09Does commercial loans and for some reason they want to.
- 23:13Provide a different premium for those credit unions that are doing
- 23:16commercial loans versus not Fdic has that ability but ensu aid does not
- 23:21Steve Farrar: right.
- 23:22Yep.
- 23:23They do have a different basis for how What the assessment rate or
- 23:28a premium rate is set for them?
- 23:31Treichel: Got it
- 23:32Steve Farrar: Yeah,
- 23:33Treichel: so on occasion ensu is able to pay dividends on the fund.
- 23:37Can you walk through how that might work?
- 23:40Steve Farrar: Really, they could only do it if the normal operating
- 23:44level is is above the equity races above the normal operating level.
- 23:49And choices we say shall issue a pro rata.
- 23:54Equity distribution from the insurance fund to eligible insurance funds
- 23:58after each calendar year as of the end of that calendar year, when
- 24:03the equity ratio exceeds the normal operating level and the insurance
- 24:06fund available asset ratio exceeds 1%.
- 24:09It says per the Federal Credit Union Act, the NCOA shall distribute the maximum
- 24:13possible amount that does not reduce the share insurance fund equity ratio below
- 24:18the normal operating ratio and does not reduce the available asset ratio below 1%.
- 24:26As the fund does very good, and, share, insured shares aren't
- 24:31growing at astronomical levels, and it's not having to do.
- 24:35Provision expenses there's always the possibility of insuance dividends.
- 24:40Treichel: Great point.
- 24:41And, under the during, since the pandemic.
- 24:44Share growth and deposit growth has been controlled, which does have
- 24:47a, which a controlled denominator makes the insurance fund stronger.
- 24:53Again, all other things being equal, but that kind of is a good spot
- 24:57to pivot into the balance sheet and what was on the balance sheet
- 25:00of the fund at the end of 2023.
- 25:03Yeah.
- 25:04Steve Farrar: Okay.
- 25:04Before we do that, a little bit about the coming of the differences for the
- 25:08deposit insurance funds assessment.
- 25:10Yep.
- 25:10They have a statement here that their risk based assessment system allowing
- 25:14moderate steady assessment rates throughout the economic cycles is
- 25:18designed to reduce pro sycticality.
- 25:21They're there to maintain a positive fund balance during banking crisis
- 25:26is due to the 2023 failures.
- 25:29The FDIC imposed a special assessment to recover the losses to the insurance fund
- 25:34arising from the protection of uninsured depositors, which they did in the case
- 25:40of, let me make sure you get the names of that Silicon Valley bank and the
- 25:45signature bank issues they dealt with.
- 25:47Yes.
- 25:48And this is the special assessment rates would be collected
- 25:50at an annual rate of 13.
- 25:524 basis points over 8 quarterly assessments since it started this year.
- 25:58Treichel: Okay.
- 25:59Very good.
- 25:59Yeah, I know.
- 26:01Steve Farrar: Now, they're paying for those losses that were from
- 26:042013 their assessment revenue in 2023, when they had to do some
- 26:09special assessments was 41Billion.
- 26:11Compared to kind of 2022, which was a normal assessment
- 26:15schedule, which was only 88.
- 26:173 billion.
- 26:18So it shows, they're paying a lot for, what happened with
- 26:22those 2 significant failures.
- 26:24And then for them paying dividend, the law does allow FDIC to issue dividends if
- 26:29the designated reserve ratio exceeds 1.
- 26:315%.
- 26:33It says the board does not intend to issue dividends, but
- 26:36lower assessments in the future.
- 26:38If that would happen now, they are currently operating under a restoration
- 26:43plan that they had to put together.
- 26:45And do the extra ordinary growth and insured shares during 2020 cause
- 26:51their designated reserve ratio to decline below the statutory minimum 1.
- 26:5635%.
- 26:56As of June of 2020.
- 26:58In September, the board adopted a restoration plan to
- 27:02restore the reserve ratio to 1.
- 27:0435 percent within eight years.
- 27:08In 2020, the board approved amended restoration plan proposed to increase
- 27:12an initial deposit insurance assessment rate uniformly at two, two basis points.
- 27:18So that's how they did it by increasing their Assessment
- 27:22rates, and they they do anticipate reaching the statutory minimum 1.
- 27:2835 percent by September 30th of 2028.
- 27:31Wow, it is not fun to be operating under, it's not fun for a bank to be out or for
- 27:36a credit union to be operating under a.
- 27:39A net worth restoration plan.
- 27:42It's not fun for your regulator to be operating under a restoration plan.
- 27:47But what's good for the goose is good for the gander.
- 27:49I guess.
- 27:49Treichel: And I, I'm going to try and not get up on my soapbox about the
- 27:52failure of those institutions and.
- 27:54And how they.
- 27:55Janet Yellen and came out and said, it's not a bailout.
- 27:58It was a bailout.
- 27:59They bailed out the uninsured depositors of fintech companies, and it wasn't very
- 28:03many companies on the West Coast, but they used an exception that they have to do
- 28:08it because they didn't want to have the contagion spread to other institutions.
- 28:14And 1 of the big credit union different differentiators other than the insurance
- 28:18fund is that credit unions don't have a lot of uninsured deposits compared
- 28:23to these big banks in some instances.
- 28:25And that's where these uninsured deposits.
- 28:27At the banks became so large that they had to put a plan together that spread
- 28:33the cost of it over four years, which should keep the cost of being a credit
- 28:37union well below the cost of being a bank.
- 28:40So there is that positive for credit unions.
- 28:43So what else, Steve what do you want to talk about next as it relates to this?
- 28:45Let's go
- 28:46Steve Farrar: over their their balance sheets.
- 28:48Okay.
- 28:49It's interesting that they are different.
- 28:50We've about some of these issues before.
- 28:53For the N2SIF, It holds 21.
- 28:573 billion in intergovernmental governmental assets.
- 29:00That's the investment treasury investments.
- 29:02It has and keep in mind that the lion's share of the balance sheet
- 29:07assets of the N2SAF is the 1 percent capitalization deposit, and that is 17.
- 29:142 billion.
- 29:15That 1231 23.
- 29:18And of course, that does, get adjusted as each year goes along, and it helps
- 29:24maintain the equity ratio of the fund.
- 29:26But keep in mind, because that 1 percent also resides on federally
- 29:31insured credit unions, balance sheet is an asset that created an issue,
- 29:37and that is why the minimum net worth ratio to be well capitalized
- 29:42is 7 percent for credit unions.
- 29:44And 6 percent for banks.
- 29:45It's just strictly because of that 1 percent capitalization deposit, because
- 29:50if the fund became insolvent and credit unions would have to write off the
- 29:531 percent capitalization posit, then they would have to, they'd have to
- 29:58expense that 1 percent and then they'd have to put a, the 1 percent back
- 30:02in there again certainly items that.
- 30:05In the time frame of, 2008 and nine, it was like, wow, we can't let that happen.
- 30:11Treichel: The cascading effect.
- 30:13Yes.
- 30:13Steve Farrar: Yeah.
- 30:14Yeah.
- 30:14And so the, and so that holds the balance of 21.
- 30:184 billion in total assets.
- 30:20And very little in liabilities for basically a net position of 21.
- 30:252 billion.
- 30:27Now it's interesting when you start looking at the deposit insurance
- 30:30funds balance sheet as of 1231 23.
- 30:34And it's nice to be able to explain some of these things that happen.
- 30:38It, they only held 24 billion in inter government assets at
- 30:43the time, treasurer investments.
- 30:44It's about the same as NCOA.
- 30:47And then they had 23 billion in an assessment receivable that they were
- 30:52able to record as an asset because they knew the timing and certainty of the
- 30:56amount of those assessments coming in.
- 30:59Then they had 98 billion in receivables from resolutions.
- 31:04And that is from the 23, 20, 23 failure of three blanks with over 100 billion
- 31:11in assets triggered the bailouts.
- 31:13FTC used emergency authority to guarantee the uninsured deposits of
- 31:16Silicon Valley Bank and Signature Bank.
- 31:19As this illustrates, some creditors, uninsured depositors,
- 31:22may receive bailouts.
- 31:24But others bond holders of the banks, which were liquidated did not.
- 31:29So that changed their balance sheet dramatically, at least for a certain
- 31:34measurement period, because they became receivables from resolutions.
- 31:40Yeah,
- 31:41Treichel: their audit must be a lot more complicated today than it was before that.
- 31:44And a lot more complicated than NC ways is right now as well.
- 31:48Yeah.
- 31:50Steve Farrar: Yeah.
- 31:51Yeah.
- 31:51Yeah.
- 31:52Yeah.
- 31:53Everything when everything's running pretty good.
- 31:56Everything looks really good.
- 31:57But boy, when we have these, big items that cause a bit of chaos,
- 32:02the accounting becomes really difficult because I know establishing
- 32:06the accounting for the corporate resolution fund that was extremely
- 32:10difficult and required us to, use.
- 32:14Extremely smart people from outside the agency to assist with that number
- 32:18because it just it was very complicated.
- 32:21Treichel: Yeah, I think they're those extremely smart
- 32:23people when they were at N.
- 32:24C.
- 32:25U.
- 32:25A.
- 32:25There was you could see a path on the carpet at N.
- 32:27C.
- 32:27U.
- 32:27A.
- 32:28from your office to where they were.
- 32:30To where the chief financial officer, Marianne Woodson was
- 32:33because those were some hectic times.
- 32:35Steve Farrar: Yeah, I remember telling Marianne, you're going to have a tolerance
- 32:38for ambiguity for a little while.
- 32:41It goes shortly after she took the job, when all that happened.
- 32:46She was great.
- 32:47Treichel: Yeah, she was.
- 32:48That sounds like a good band name, or at least an album.
- 32:51Tolerance of Ambiguity.
- 32:53Steve Farrar: Yeah, I'm gonna
- 32:53Treichel: Google that when we're when we get off.
- 32:56Steve Farrar: I think I stole that probably from Greenspan or somebody
- 32:58like that But their fund had a hundred and twenty two billion fund balance And
- 33:05the thing is you go fast forward by the middle of 2024, they were back up to
- 33:1170Billion in intergovernment assets.
- 33:14And all of that position was starting to normalize.
- 33:18But their fund balance is a 574 percent of the net position of the, so it's,
- 33:24there's a similarity between the size difference and insured deposits
- 33:28and the size of the fund balances.
- 33:31Treichel: Makes sense.
- 33:32Makes sense.
- 33:33So there, there's the operating expenses.
- 33:36There's the provision for loan loss.
- 33:37There's other topics along these lines.
- 33:40What would you like to highlight relative to the costs and the
- 33:46operating expenses and the provisions?
- 33:50Steve Farrar: We're going to just run through basically the
- 33:53income statements a way of each of these items, because, everything
- 33:58that doesn't go or increase the.
- 34:02Earnings kind of those funds is money out of the system, the big topic always
- 34:08there is, the NCOA and so I said, operating expenses, because every dollar,
- 34:12it has to the system has to put in the.
- 34:14So that is a dollar that's not available to cover insurance losses.
- 34:18So it's a big deal.
- 34:20So the total budget for expenses and the NCF operating fund were 360
- 34:25million for 2023 with 1, 214 positions.
- 34:30The actual total expenses for 2023 were 377 million.
- 34:35The thing is they have, NCWA has that combination of the
- 34:40operating fund, which takes care of federally insured credit unions.
- 34:45And then they have the overhead transfer rate that And to us is
- 34:49charged by the operating fund for the services based on an actual allocation
- 34:54factor drive for masculine usage for insurance related activities.
- 34:59So that money was a 62.
- 35:014 percent and going through the overhead transfer rate is like
- 35:06a whole discussion upon itself.
- 35:08Treichel: It is.
- 35:08Oh, that's a yeah, that's a that's about a 3 hour podcast.
- 35:12Steve Farrar: Yeah.
- 35:13So I just tried to just keep it as here's this kind of total expenses that.
- 35:16Yeah, they didn't system that don't go towards insurance.
- 35:19And it's that basically 370 million a year.
- 35:24Joe
- 35:26Treichel: Rogan can do a three hour podcast.
- 35:28Steve, you and I probably should keep it to keep it short.
- 35:32Steve Farrar: The total expenses for the deposit insurance fund
- 35:35operating expenses in 2023 were 2.
- 35:388 billion.
- 35:41And that their staffing level was That's 6, 817 or we get back to
- 35:46the same percentage as you see all the time, 561 percent of NCOA stat.
- 35:51So you'll see that, follow along with almost all these measurements and that
- 35:55The doesn't appear really out of step and they're in agreement with each other
- 36:01as level staffing and some of these other measures that that we look at.
- 36:07Treichel: Got it.
- 36:07Got it.
- 36:08Steve Farrar: The other item that of course, comes into play is, each
- 36:10of these funds has exposure to loss.
- 36:13And they both estimate losses determined on a funds reserve methodology.
- 36:18And I was highly involved in, Moving into a pre CECIL as to how we would do it and
- 36:24the, losses given default and all those, the calculations that came into play.
- 36:28And I remember we were, we're working in a room with a lot of people working
- 36:32on on that analysis and complication.
- 36:35And we worked together and we'd ran some simulation and we found that changing
- 36:40some element had changed a factor out in a way out in a further decimal place.
- 36:46And they're all really happy about it.
- 36:48Oh, look at this improvement that we made.
- 36:49And I was like, yeah, and if I jump, I'm closer to the sun,
- 36:55it was like, I think we're there.
- 36:57I think we have a really good system if we are happy about something
- 37:01changing a way out denominator.
- 37:03But those are, that is a process that both of them do.
- 37:07It's similar to what credit unions do for their provision for losses.
- 37:12And so they only had 3 failures in 2023.
- 37:166 in 2022 the cost of 1.
- 37:194 million is all in 2023 and 9.
- 37:218 million in 2022 at the end of 2023, 1 credit unit was in conservatorship the
- 37:27provision expense in 2023 was negative.
- 37:3012 million and it was a negative 39 million 2022, meaning that the losses
- 37:36are less than what the analysis was per was projecting and the institutions
- 37:42that generally were improving.
- 37:44So
- 37:45Treichel: were you what back in the corporate crisis and the, the, you had
- 37:48the audits that that you were involved in.
- 37:52I remember from afar not from far, but from afar that there was discussions
- 37:58about should NCUA have to consolidate their financial statement, the
- 38:03conserved credit union's financial statements into the insurance fund.
- 38:06And it was concluded, it was a scary time.
- 38:09Because if that was the conclusion, it was going to impact the numbers
- 38:12negatively, but they landed on the fact that they didn't have to do that.
- 38:16Do you recall any specifics tied to that?
- 38:20Steve Farrar: I do remember that discussion and because there
- 38:24was a chance that would create.
- 38:27Such gyrations in both, both the, our, because if we'd have to do it,
- 38:32it'd be, we would tend to follow that FDIC was doing something similar.
- 38:37And you can see the gyration they had.
- 38:39Just with what they did in 2023, if you add that, you'd be like, these
- 38:44funds would be jumping all over up and down all the time, and it probably
- 38:49would go against that very 1st thing.
- 38:51That we're supposed to maintain public confidence in the U.
- 38:55S.
- 38:56financial system.
- 38:57And these wide gyrations just aren't consistent with that.
- 39:00Treichel: No, I like that.
- 39:01I like that.
- 39:02As far as investments that they can make, we've talked about the
- 39:06costs and the losses and everything.
- 39:07Any thoughts on the invest, so the asset side and what
- 39:11the insurance fund invests in?
- 39:13Steve Farrar: It is, there is, there's some similarity in, in, that we can
- 39:17all only invest in basically treasury instruments and generally the treasurer
- 39:23doesn't want the, these type of, our type of institutions doing trading of the
- 39:28government securities or, operating on, on selling and and then rebuying them.
- 39:34They don't they didn't care for that.
- 39:36When it's interesting that the investment income for the insurance fund was 432
- 39:42million in 2023 and 287 million in 2022 as rates went up it fund earned a lot more.
- 39:50The, it's interesting that the weighted average investment maturity for the
- 39:56fund in 2023 was 33 years, but you compare it to what FDIC because of
- 40:02what they were dealing with at the end of 23, they were down to 0.
- 40:0621 years.
- 40:07Now the, it's, it is interesting also because of what they held.
- 40:11They only were, seemed to be holding some really high yielding stuff.
- 40:15Their rated average yield was 4.
- 40:1766 at the end of 2023 on a much smaller denominator than they normally had.
- 40:22And the weighted average yield for the NCSF was 2.
- 40:2633%.
- 40:26Treichel: That's because of the ladder that NCOA had the, I don't know.
- 40:29Yeah, NCOA does have
- 40:31Steve Farrar: the investment strategy that's put together.
- 40:33It generally had been a laddering when I was involved in it.
- 40:37I think they've done some adjustments to that, but I haven't kept up
- 40:40exactly what the sure nuances of the investment strategy are.
- 40:46Very good.
- 40:47It comes down to, so who's better?
- 40:49They're both very healthy and both able to react with the situations that they have.
- 40:53So they're really hard to compare in terms of who's better.
- 40:56They're similar, but different.
- 40:59And we thought that might be useful information for this podcast.
- 41:03Treichel: Very good.
- 41:04You reminded me of a, of an Alan Parsons songs that I won't bore people with, but
- 41:08then the same with no, I guess I will bore him same with no similarity is the
- 41:13line of the song I'm thinking about, but
- 41:15Steve Farrar: yeah,
- 41:17Treichel: very good.
- 41:17Steve, that was there was a lot of chock full information there that that.
- 41:22that basically points out, like you said at the end, you wrapped it up very well.
- 41:26There are two very good funds that serve this country well, serve the
- 41:30economic engine of the country.
- 41:32Served us well when we were at N.
- 41:33C.
- 41:33U.
- 41:33A.
- 41:34And we'll be robust into the future, hopefully.
- 41:39Want to thank you as always for your thoughtful analysis of this.
- 41:43And listeners, I want to thank you for listening as always.
- 41:46This is Mark Treichel signing off with Flying Colors.