Latest / Politics with Paul / How We All Can Reevaluate and Refine Our Political Beliefs w/ Lisa Ekman | Politics with Paul #62
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Politics with Paul podcast, your home for nonpartisan discussion of
- 0:05politics and civics.
- 0:06I am your host, Paul Raider.
- 0:08It's another guest episode today.
- 0:10And for guest episodes, I always give the disclaimer that I do not take a stance for or
- 0:15against a guest's political views or groups they support.
- 0:18But regardless of political views, there is immense value in reevaluating what you believe.
- 0:25None of us have all the answers, and none of us are infallible.
- 0:28Nevertheless, it can be very difficult to be introspective regardless of whether you are
- 0:33politically left, right, or middle.
- 0:35It's a skill that takes time to develop.
- 0:37So how can we effectively reexamine not only what we believe, but why we believe those
- 0:43things?
- 0:44Here to talk about that is my guest today, Lisa Eckman.
- 0:48Lisa is a farmer, but she used to work as a democratic lobbyist and advocate for twenty
- 0:53years, particularly in disability advocacy.
- 0:56That work included for two democratic US senators, democratic appointees at federal
- 1:01agencies, government contractors, and nonprofits.
- 1:04But disenchantment led her away from that and to write a book titled deprogramming democrats
- 1:10and uneducating the elites.
- 1:11Now before you positively or negatively react to all that you just heard, she does have
- 1:17takeaways that left, right, and middle can use for themselves.
- 1:21And I've had liberals, conservatives, and moderates on this show, and I try to let them
- 1:26voice their beliefs while also keeping things level.
- 1:29As always, I encourage you to hear the guests out first and then come to a conclusion.
- 1:33Speaking of which, let's have this discussion about how we all can improve in reexamining our
- 1:39views.
- 1:39Please welcome in Lisa Eckman.
- 1:41Lisa, thank for you coming on today.
- 1:42How are you?
- 1:43I'm doing I'm great, Paul.
- 1:45Thank you so much for having me.
- 1:47It's a pleasure to come in and talk about my experience and how it might help others in
- 1:54improving their critical thinking, examining assumptions they make they don't even know what
- 1:58they do, and improving the political discourse in this country.
- 2:03So thank you so much.
- 2:05Sure.
- 2:05And thank you for coming on.
- 2:06It's always good to have a guest come on.
- 2:08So like I said, while I do wanna keep most of the discussion from leaning too far toward any
- 2:13particular side or the other, I think it makes sense to use some of your story as an example
- 2:19of what you'll be talking about today.
- 2:20So how would you describe your political upbringing?
- 2:24I was raised by very liberal liberal parents.
- 2:28You know, I often describe them as hippies who didn't do drugs.
- 2:32They, you know, would have been really they were very pleased with Jimmy Carter as
- 2:38president, very unpleased with Ronald Reagan.
- 2:40That gives you kind of a sense of where they were coming from.
- 2:44At the same time, you know, and I think this may have been true a lot for Democrats, JFK era
- 2:51Democrats, they were very patriotic, loved their country, loved the constitution, and they
- 2:58raised me to believe in freedom, liberty, our constitution, the amendments to it, and
- 3:06treating everyone equally.
- 3:11They believed in patriotism, they believed in hard work, and they believed in accountability,
- 3:16both at the individual and the governmental level.
- 3:19And so, they raised me to be really what I would call a First Amendment absolutist,
- 3:27meaning that, you know, sometimes the hardest part about the First Amendment is accepting
- 3:33speech you don't agree with, and even speech that may be factually incorrect.
- 3:40But what they instilled in me was the idea that my right to speak freely is only as secure as
- 3:47everybody else's, even if I, you know, abhor what they have to say or vehemently disagree
- 3:52with them.
- 3:54You don't want to give anybody else, especially in the government, the ability to decide who
- 4:01gets to speak and who doesn't.
- 4:03I use this as an example to kind of show how they taught me this, and that was that the
- 4:11ACLU, an organization that I I used to be a member of and really supported, defended the
- 4:18right of the Nazis to march in the 1970s in Skokie, Illinois which is a subgroup Chicago.
- 4:24I grew up in the Chicago area and have a lot of, you know, Jewish residents there in Skokie.
- 4:31And I just couldn't believe it.
- 4:32Why was the ACLU defending them?
- 4:34And my parents used that as an example to teach freedom of speech, you know, obviously, Nippor,
- 4:40Nazi ideology.
- 4:43But if they don't get to speak in March and exercise their First Amendment rights and
- 4:48someone gets to decide that, then you might not.
- 4:52So, I think that gives you kind of a good idea of where my parents were coming from.
- 4:59I always voted Democratic throughout.
- 5:06Once I got the right to vote, I volunteered for Democratic campaigns.
- 5:12I came to believe, and I think a lot of people on the left did, I I think if you think back to
- 5:18the '60s, there was a great deal of anti government sentiment among the left, especially
- 5:24around the Vietnam War and those kinds of things.
- 5:27You saw a lot of protests and don't trust the man and those kinds of things.
- 5:31Think slowly over time, the left came to really believe much more in government and a much
- 5:38bigger government role in our daily lives.
- 5:42I advocated for improving government programs, creating new government programs, always with
- 5:50the goal of improving the lives of individual citizens, and as you mentioned, often people
- 5:58with disabilities.
- 6:00Does that kind of get a good background of where I came from that you were looking for?
- 6:05Yeah.
- 6:06I I I think the the whole point about the freedom of speech is obviously a a great point
- 6:11to make because there are so many think I there's a lot of people across the political
- 6:17spectrum that really don't support the freedom of speech as much as they should.
- 6:23And it's not just about in regards to the government, but also in regards to we need to
- 6:30make sure we promote it in our daily lives too, not having these echo chambers, for example.
- 6:35And I I don't wanna jump too far ahead, but it does sound like for a lot of people or, you
- 6:42know, you talk about the the phenomenon of the great sorting out from since the sixties where
- 6:48more and more liberals drifted towards the Democratic Party and away from the Republican
- 6:54Party and more conservatives drifting away from the Democratic party towards the Republican
- 6:58party.
- 6:58Sounds like there may be a little bit of of that going on, but actually, let's let's go
- 7:03ahead to that whole change of belief.
- 7:05So what exactly was the catalyst for you in challenging your beliefs and writing this book?
- 7:11Was it several different things, a gradual transformation, and how exactly did your
- 7:15beliefs change?
- 7:17I the first thing I think, I think think there are three things I want to point out here.
- 7:23I think over the time I've been in DC, you know, I moved to DC when I finished my master's
- 7:29degree in social work.
- 7:30I was nominated for a program that was designed to pull people with graduate level education
- 7:38into federal service, and I moved to DC to do that work.
- 7:43It was the very tail end of the Clinton administration in 1999, and I went directly to
- 7:48work at an agency, the Social Security Administration, working on disability
- 7:53employment policy directly for Clinton and Clinton in that agency.
- 7:57And, you know, I think I arrived in DC, way I would describe it is, eyed and bushy tailed and
- 8:04believing that I could really make a difference to really change our programs to really help
- 8:12support people and create better opportunities and more independence for people with
- 8:16disabilities.
- 8:19Think over the first five years maybe I was there, I really saw that that was still the
- 8:25case.
- 8:27Think during my time, I think maybe right around the election of President Obama for his
- 8:37first term, I saw that kind of change and we started to see, I think everyone who watches
- 8:42politics could attest to this, gridlock happening in DC in a way that it never had
- 8:49before.
- 8:51We started to see things like, you know, we have our current government shutdown where we
- 8:56couldn't even agree enough to keep the government open.
- 9:01And I saw sort of the shift away from what I would call good faith conversations about
- 9:06trying to come up with compromise solutions.
- 9:10You know, the thing about compromises is that nobody ever gets everything they want and
- 9:15everybody walks away a little bit unhappy, but you come up with something that both sides
- 9:20think is better than what we had before.
- 9:24You started to see less and less of those kind of good faith conversations.
- 9:28You started to see more and more sort of attacks on people based on their beliefs, as
- 9:35opposed to good faith policy discussions.
- 9:38And so I was starting to see less opportunity for our government to positively influence
- 9:46people's lives.
- 9:47And I think that started to kind of make me think about, well, what is my philosophy about
- 9:53government and how does it fit in this new environment?
- 9:57And are we really helping people through that?
- 10:00The second part of that I wanted to kind of talk about a little bit is a story about my
- 10:07parents' health because I've had a huge impact on the way I've looked at our federal agencies
- 10:13and those agencies that are designed to or tasked with keeping us healthy, protecting us,
- 10:21you know, in terms of pharmaceutical drugs and all of the standards and everything else.
- 10:26So, I lost both of my parents in relatively short order.
- 10:32My dad passed in 2014 and my mom passed in 2016.
- 10:37And I'm going talk a little bit about her story because that is the part that's really relevant
- 10:42to your question.
- 10:45My mom, while she was taking care of my dad, who had a back issue, had surgery, all these
- 10:51complications, became functionally quadriplegic, and needed a wheelchair, needed
- 10:57help with everything, she developed a very aggressive cancer that was not diagnosed until
- 11:05stage four.
- 11:06She already had multiple sclerosis, so she was already dealing with a lot of issues.
- 11:11And, you know, she got the, you you have a very short time to live speech, should get your
- 11:18affairs in order.
- 11:19And so, knowing what I did for a living, knowing my research skills, I was a competitive
- 11:25debater in high school and college, so she said, Lisa, I want to live.
- 11:29So please look and tell me, is there anything I can do that will improve my outcome?
- 11:36And so the first thing I told her to do was to not do any research herself because all it
- 11:40would do was make her depressed and make her sad and make her think she couldn't get better,
- 11:45and believe it or not, that has a huge impact on your outcomes.
- 11:48If you've heard of the placebo effect, it's real, and so is the opposite of it, which there
- 11:55is research on about.
- 11:56So I did some research and I found a couple of books that I found to be very persuasive, very
- 12:01well researched, lots of data and evidence using studies, and one was called Feeding
- 12:06Cancer with Nutrition and the other was called Anticancer and Your Way of Life.
- 12:11Both of them heavily focused on how what you put into your body affects your health.
- 12:17The ability to really, through nutrition and detoxification, change the outcomes.
- 12:24Had story after story, anecdotal of course, but backed by data and evidence of people with
- 12:32diagnoses like my mom becoming cancer free.
- 12:36And so we worked to get my mom completely changed her diet, every product she put in her
- 12:42body, on her body, cleaned her home with.
- 12:45We worked, the anti cancer way of life also really looks at how does stress, how does your
- 12:52psychological state and how you deal with that affect your chances to heal.
- 12:57So we also did things like help her work to decrease her stress reactions, to manage stress
- 13:04in a better way.
- 13:05We did guided meditation, focused breathing, all sorts of things.
- 13:10So my mom, know, full on went into this.
- 13:13She also had conventional treatment and so she had surgery and then she started around with
- 13:20chemo, which was six chemo treatments.
- 13:23Halfway through, they did a bunch of tests and my mom tested no evidence of cancer after the
- 13:29third chemo treatment.
- 13:33Her doctor and her nurse practitioner that she saw were astounded, called it a miracle,
- 13:38couldn't believe it, never seen it before.
- 13:41You know, and she finished that round of chemo and she was completely cancer free for two
- 13:45years.
- 13:47Yeah, I mean, amazing, right?
- 13:50So here I have learned all these things about what is good for your health, how you can
- 13:56affect, you know, change when you get the worst news ever.
- 14:01You can have a change on that that is really completely independent of our Western medical
- 14:07system.
- 14:09It's using a lot of things that you would get from, you know, Eastern medicine, Chinese
- 14:15medicine, and those kinds of things.
- 14:17Because she did a lot of supplementation in those too, and it was really about giving your
- 14:21body the nutrition it needs and getting rid of all the toxins that it's constantly exposed to.
- 14:27So After two years, they did a scan and found a small group and they got her back down to
- 14:37chemo.
- 14:38That first round of chemo caused kidney failure and she died.
- 14:43And so, you know, this really started me to ask a lot of questions about what are our health
- 14:50agencies actually doing and where are they getting their funding?
- 14:55Where are all these studies coming from?
- 14:57Because I just read these books, right?
- 14:59And if you look into our treatment of cancer, it really hasn't changed that much over fifty
- 15:08years.
- 15:09We're continuing to give people chemo, do surgery, give chemo and maybe radiation, and
- 15:15the outcomes for it are really not very good.
- 15:17What is, in my head, what is the FDA doing?
- 15:22Who's funding the FDA?
- 15:23Where is their funding actually coming from?
- 15:26Who's running the FDA?
- 15:28Who's making these decisions?
- 15:30And so, losing my parents like that was the hardest thing I had ever gone through up to
- 15:36that point.
- 15:37And it started to raise a lot of questions for me like, are we actually doing?
- 15:42Are we actually helping people?
- 15:45Or are we just advancing the interests of industry because they have a lot of money in
- 15:52power?
- 15:52So those things started to kind of circle around in my head, but I went back to DC, went
- 15:59back to work, working with those very agencies that I was beginning to question.
- 16:04And so I kind of had to put that into the back recesses of my mind so that I could continue to
- 16:09do my job in good faith and continue to have that kind of trusting relationship with the
- 16:16agencies that I've already had.
- 16:19Now jump forward to COVID.
- 16:22Really, I think if you talk to a lot of people who maybe have changed their opinions about
- 16:29politics over the last five or six years.
- 16:33COVID and the response to it had a lot to do with that.
- 16:36And that was very true in my case.
- 16:39So the government response to COVID, first of all, a lot of the things they were recommending
- 16:46just didn't sit right based on all that research and all the knowledge I gained that I
- 16:52was just talking to you about for my mom's help.
- 16:57So I'll tell, this is I think the easiest example to give for people to understand.
- 17:02If you recall at the very beginning, they were saying, Don't leave your house, you can't go
- 17:06outside.
- 17:07Even if you have a backyard, you're not even supposed to go out in the backyard.
- 17:12Well, one of the best things you can do for your immune system and your health is to get
- 17:18natural sunlight because that's how your body creates natural vitamin D, which is essential
- 17:23for all of the things that keep us healthy and also actually all of the different chemicals
- 17:30our body secretes that keep us happy.
- 17:33So the worst thing you can do, and you're also, you you get to breathe fresh air, get lots of
- 17:39oxygen, and oxygen rich environments are really hard for most diseases, especially cancer, but
- 17:47also every other disease to grow in.
- 17:49So stay in your house, you can't get fresh air, you can't get sun.
- 17:54I had to say, Why are they giving us these recommendations?
- 17:59It brought back all of these ideas that I had started to question when helping my mom deal
- 18:07with her cancer.
- 18:08So there was that aspect of it, then there was the six foot social distancing, and because I'm
- 18:14a researcher and that was sort of my background, I looked for the data to support it
- 18:19and couldn't find it.
- 18:20So it became really I think he was Well, I think in 2023 or 2024, Anthony Fauci was
- 18:33testifying before Congress and he said, Yeah, there wasn't really any science.
- 18:36It just kind of appeared, I don't know where it came from.
- 18:39But it was those kind of things that just kind of made me say, Well, our government is
- 18:46completely obliterating our rights without even having these conversations and without
- 18:53necessarily having the data and evidence to support it.
- 18:57And then what I started to see happening was overt censorship of people who ask questions or
- 19:06question what the government was saying.
- 19:09And that really raised alarm bells for me about the First Amendment.
- 19:17As a lawyer, I have also a law degree, as well as a social work degree.
- 19:22As a lawyer, it's very clear to me that there is no public health exception to our
- 19:27Constitution.
- 19:28In fact, there are no exceptions to the government abridging our freedom of speech.
- 19:35And it is was terrifying to me to hear my government use the word disinformation and then
- 19:45misinformation and then malinformation.
- 19:49And then realize that the party I had supported my whole life.
- 19:57That I dedicated my life to was the one using those words.
- 20:02And I might have agreed with what they were saying sometimes about it and sometimes not,
- 20:07but again, as we talked about at the beginning, my answer to the first question, once you've
- 20:14cede the power to the government to tell you what's true, you never get that right.
- 20:19And so I think that is really what started me questioning, so whose interest is the
- 20:27government really protecting, and are these agencies really doing what I would call
- 20:36positive things for?
- 20:39Well, while I can't put forth my particular opinion just because I try to keep my personal
- 20:44opinion out as much as possible, I think it is a good point to bring up that there isn't no
- 20:51such thing as being above questioning.
- 20:54There you do have to keep even if you agree with something, you do have to at least pose
- 21:00some questions about why do we believe this thing or why exactly do we not let any sort of
- 21:07other information come up and who's saying what and any and everything like that.
- 21:12So I think that is a good point to bring up.
- 21:15Now, of course, you can also go the exact opposite direction.
- 21:18Some people can be disingenuous in their questioning, but, you know, you gotta find find
- 21:24that right balance.
- 21:25There is still a reason to find or to question the things that that you hear.
- 21:32So that that is that I think that is a good point and one that if if people take particular
- 21:37context out, I think most people can agree on that point.
- 21:41So let me just make sure that I hear it straight from you.
- 21:47I don't wanna make assumptions based on what you've said.
- 21:50Obviously, it's difficult for any of us to challenge our assumptions and beliefs because
- 21:55those are our assumptions and beliefs.
- 21:57We're all human beings, so it can be difficult to be introspective.
- 22:00But did you find it particularly challenging to challenge your assumptions and beliefs, and do
- 22:06you still find it hard to do so?
- 22:10I it was very, very challenging.
- 22:15And I, you know, I think it was even, to be honest, harder than losing both my parents that
- 22:21I just talked about.
- 22:22I think it's the hardest thing I've ever had to do.
- 22:26You know, I spent my life being validated for my beliefs.
- 22:33Spent, you know, I think what happens with a lot of people these days, I know it used to
- 22:39happen as much, but people's entire identity gets wrapped up in their politics, who they
- 22:45are, and it becomes sort of a moral badge to people on both sides, you know, maybe not in
- 22:51the middle as much, but left, right, doesn't matter.
- 22:53It becomes sort of a badge and all your friends believe the same way that you do.
- 23:00And you know, in my case in particular, I didn't just have that identity in my personal
- 23:06life, that was also my career, and the way that I had decided I wanted to leave an impact on
- 23:13the world.
- 23:15Beyond that, I was an expert in my field.
- 23:20Worked on all sorts of things, healthcare, employment, civil rights for people with
- 23:28disabilities, but I mostly focus on the Social Security Disability Insurance programs.
- 23:35And so, it was sort of a I was one of the top experts on the left in that subject matter.
- 23:44So I didn't just go telling my friends about what I thought, I told the whole country about
- 23:50what I thought about these things.
- 23:53And I was challenging everything I had ever thought to be true and real.
- 23:59And so it was really, really hard and I think, you know, I don't want to skip ahead into other
- 24:08questions, but I think one of the things is that you know, when you do make big changes
- 24:15like I did, and you challenge the assumptions that you have, you often end up losing those
- 24:21friends.
- 24:21And I think we see, and having strained relationships with your family.
- 24:27I don't think it should be that way, but it just really is.
- 24:30Things right now are so polarized in our country.
- 24:34And, you know, you see people cutting family members off completely because of who they
- 24:41supported in the election.
- 24:42And so, yeah, it was really hard and I lost a lot of my friends and there are family members
- 24:54that I, you know, don't have the relationship that I used to because of it.
- 25:00And that is really hard.
- 25:03And I also think the other thing that happens when you make as big a change as I did, Paul,
- 25:09is that you question your own sanity too, you know, because when you had such strong beliefs
- 25:15like I did, challenging basic assumptions, you know, it can cause you to say, Now, have I just
- 25:27lost it?
- 25:28Have I just lost my mind?
- 25:30Do I no longer have a grip on what's real?
- 25:36So, yeah, hardest thing I've ever done.
- 25:39It was I had to sort of recreate myself because I changed how I believed at such a basic level.
- 25:50And, there was a lot of depression.
- 25:52I will be honest, you know, that happened.
- 25:56In addition to kind of not really understanding where I was sitting, you know.
- 26:04Like, I say, I was not your average just I go vote and I have these feelings over someone
- 26:10whose entire life was centered around those particular beliefs and assumptions.
- 26:16And so it took a lot of work to actually get to the point where I am now, get to the point
- 26:24where I wrote the book, and get to the point where I'm able to have these conversations that
- 26:29I think are so very important, because we, you know, I think there's more about us that unites
- 26:37us if we stop making assumptions, stop judging based on labels, and start actually listening
- 26:44to each other respectfully.
- 26:48Listening to each other and getting back to a point where we can agree to disagree without it
- 26:57causing us to make moral judgments about the person.
- 27:03You you spoke to one of my big pet peeves about politics as they there's a very self
- 27:11congratulatory nature of, hey, you think the way I do.
- 27:14You're so good.
- 27:15You're so smart.
- 27:16And, you know, getting the pat on the back that, you know, you're so intellectual and
- 27:21you've you've got everything figured out.
- 27:23That's something that I very strongly oppose and has driven me crazy now.
- 27:28I mean, I'm not gonna say that I've been immune to that or that I haven't done that for people
- 27:33that thought similar to me because I have done that before.
- 27:36So I have to make sure I'm self aware, and I acknowledge that too.
- 27:39But there is just that whole that not just a group thing, but just to, like, tell people how
- 27:47great they are because they think the same way.
- 27:49I think, obviously, I strongly believe that we all need to be be able to be heard and and not
- 27:54be denigrated.
- 27:55But at the same time, I am not about pandering to people, and I I think that's a serious issue
- 28:01that we have.
- 28:02But and and you also mentioned how, you know, this had been your life, and you're I think,
- 28:09you know, when you talk about polarized people, they the more polarized people tend to be ones
- 28:14who are so ingrained in this stuff, whether they work in politics or at least they're
- 28:19strongly activists.
- 28:20They're not just people who just vote.
- 28:21So it it can be even more difficult for them to change their minds just like you were talking
- 28:25about.
- 28:26So I I think there's a lot of people that share your sentiments, not just as Democrats or
- 28:31former Democrats, but Republicans and former Republicans too.
- 28:35So let's take this not just for you, but apply to other people now.
- 28:41So what do you think are two or three, let's say, of the biggest reasons people find it
- 28:48difficult to reexamine their beliefs?
- 28:51Not even just changing them, just reexamining and realizing, okay, maybe I don't have
- 28:56everything figured out.
- 29:01Well, I think the first thing that I'd point to is just sort of people's the identities and
- 29:08self worth being tied up in those beliefs.
- 29:11And I think that you're right, it does turn to be the people who are more maybe on the fringes
- 29:18of each party or side.
- 29:23But I also think that technology and specifically social media has increased the
- 29:32level of political awareness and attention that people have from the past.
- 29:39It's almost impossible if you go online to escape all of this anymore, and people spend
- 29:46way more time looking at a screen than they actually do, sadly, I will say, interacting
- 29:55with people in real life now.
- 29:57And so with that, I think everybody's identity and self worth gets tied up in it more now than
- 30:04it used to.
- 30:06So I think that that's one reason why it is so hard, you know, for them to evaluate or even to
- 30:15like question those assumptions underneath.
- 30:21I think the second thing is, and I actually will have like four reasons here, but the
- 30:26second thing is that many of these assumptions or basic beliefs are really not conscious ones,
- 30:33people.
- 30:34They're things that maybe were instilled in them by their parents and it subconsciously
- 30:40undergirds the thinking that they have, but it isn't like they're consciously thinking some of
- 30:47these goals.
- 30:49I think often when we're making judgments about things, they are taking into account many
- 30:57things that are not at the conscious level that we have accumulated over our lifetime.
- 31:05I think the third thing is something I mentioned about myself, but it's the fear of
- 31:12alienation from your friends and family, of thinking different than the people that are in
- 31:17your life.
- 31:18And again, I have a love hate relationship with technology, and I think we'll talk about that
- 31:24more a little bit later too, and that is that now if you had a disagreement about politics
- 31:33with your friend back in the nineties, you know, you might like joke about it and then get
- 31:37a beer and, you know, it's in the past.
- 31:40If you have a disagreement online with politics now, you may get doxxed, you may get canceled,
- 31:47may get fired, you may get de platformed, you may, you know, have your life completely
- 31:53destroyed, simply because you may have said something that someone took offense to.
- 32:01And I think that that makes it dangerous in a way that it never was before, to even like
- 32:08question some of the beliefs that you have, at least to question them out loud.
- 32:18And then the final thing I think is that, you know, there's groupthink and then there's also
- 32:24confirmation bias that happens.
- 32:27So, you know, you might start to question something, but then you're gonna turn to all
- 32:31your trusted news sources and your social media bubble, and they're all gonna tell you, nah,
- 32:36you're right.
- 32:37You're totally right.
- 32:38Oh, yeah.
- 32:39We all think that way.
- 32:41And, you know, that sort of feeds back into fear of alienation from friends and family.
- 32:47So that's sort of a self fulfilling circle of when you start questioning it, you're like, Oh
- 32:53my God, what are my friends gonna think of this?
- 32:56And then you go and look at what all of the new sources you trust say, and they're gonna
- 33:02confirm what you thought.
- 33:05So then you're right back where you were.
- 33:08And I think that also gets to that it's hard when you're just sitting there thinking about,
- 33:14well, maybe I should take a look at my own beliefs of seeing the upside in that.
- 33:19What is the good that's going to come out of that?
- 33:24There's an awful lot of chance for disruption and sadness and all of those things.
- 33:29A lot of times it's just easier and more comforting to continue to believe the way that
- 33:36you've already been.
- 33:38So those were the reasons that I really thought of why it's so hard.
- 33:42I think technology in this instance makes it exponentially worth it.
- 33:53Yeah.
- 33:53I think all of those are are really good points.
- 33:55I think about the the self worth.
- 33:57It it just made me think of governor Spencer Cox of Utah and then Michelle Lujan Grisham of
- 34:02New Mexico.
- 34:03They had some sort of summit that they were a part of.
- 34:06Might have been National Governors Association, but they talked about, to paraphrase, one of
- 34:10the big things was when you talked about your politics, how when you when people now, they
- 34:20lead off almost with the politics.
- 34:22Or it's like, if you take the list of things that make up who you are and your identity, it
- 34:26used to be maybe 10 to 15 on the list.
- 34:29Now it's one or two.
- 34:32And that is something that is very concerning to me.
- 34:36Now, of course, for a lot of people, it's expected that it's gonna be a huge part of who
- 34:42you are, and that's not necessarily too much of a problem where, like, yeah, as it's important
- 34:47to you.
- 34:48But, obviously, some people just it just it is the thing that drives them and just the fact
- 34:55that somebody could think something different is completely anathema.
- 34:58So definitely can that part in particular speaks to me.
- 35:04But, of course, all of those are good points, and anybody of any political persuasion can
- 35:10relate to that.
- 35:11So you are a lobbyist.
- 35:14So let's just spend just a little bit of time on that specifically, because there are a lot
- 35:19of assumptions about what lobbying is that I think a lot of people, yeah, get a little bit
- 35:27wrong.
- 35:28And, I mean, sometimes I I I have my own misconceptions about it because I I was never a
- 35:33lobbyist.
- 35:33I have some understanding of how it works, but I never actually worked at it a whole lot
- 35:38myself.
- 35:39So one or two of the biggest misconceptions that people have about lobbying and how it
- 35:45works?
- 35:46What was the reality that you experienced?
- 35:49So I think, you know, it's a little and when I was thinking about this question, it's a little
- 35:56hard to answer.
- 35:57I don't know what people actually think about lobbying, and I'm not sure they think that much
- 36:03about it, to be honest.
- 36:04You know, I think they know that there are lobbyists.
- 36:09I'm not sure they understand the extent to which money plays a part in this, so I think
- 36:16that may be one of the misconceptions.
- 36:19I can start by saying that in 2024, dollars 4,500,000,000.0 was spent on lobbying members
- 36:30of Congress.
- 36:33So based on your reaction, I think that would be a misconception that people have.
- 36:38The actual scope of that is incredible.
- 36:43Okay.
- 36:43And that is separate from last year, the $20,000,000,000 spent on the election.
- 36:50Okay.
- 36:51And I think that the misconception might be that your vote matters as much as the dollars
- 36:59of lobbyists do.
- 37:01And I think it's sad for me to say that.
- 37:04I think that is also part of what happened during the time when I was doing this work, and
- 37:10part of the reason why those conversations that I said that we used to have, or I thought we
- 37:15could have good faith disagreements, seemed to disappear.
- 37:21That was also because, in part, the Supreme Court decision in Citizens United, opened up
- 37:30our elections to tons of dark money.
- 37:34And so, you know, I think that the other thing that I think may be helpful for people to
- 37:44understand that they may have a misconception about is, especially for House members, they're
- 37:54really required to raise a lot of money for the party, for political action committees, and for
- 38:03their own reelection campaign.
- 38:06And so at the end of my career, I administered a small political action for an organization
- 38:15that I worked for.
- 38:17And when I say small, we generally raised a couple $100,000 a year for an election.
- 38:27That may not seem small to a lot of the people listening to this, but that just gives you an
- 38:33idea of the scope of what lobbying is.
- 38:37So as a lobbyist, I might take $1,000 and go have lunch with a particular member of Congress
- 38:46that they can use for their election campaign.
- 38:50Following the rules, there's no quid pro quo.
- 38:54That doesn't mean they're gonna pass the legislation I want or include the provision I
- 38:59want in a bill, but what it does do is give me access to the legislator that I might otherwise
- 39:06not have if I didn't have one.
- 39:08And the impact of that, and I will just tell you, relate the story.
- 39:16So a lot of times after an election, if someone has won, they'll have sort of a thank you.
- 39:22And by the way, this is completely nonpartisan.
- 39:25This is both sides.
- 39:26This is everybody in Washington.
- 39:28So I don't wanna give the impression that it was only Democrats or only Republicans.
- 39:33It was everybody.
- 39:34They will actually throw a little thank you party, a breakfast or a reception for those
- 39:41lobbyists who helped fund their campaign.
- 39:45Say thank you, and now here I am and you helped me get here, and so thank you so much.
- 39:51And then their door is pretty much going to always be open to you in a way that it isn't
- 39:57for someone who didn't give that money.
- 40:01And again, that doesn't mean that they're doing anything illegal.
- 40:06It doesn't mean that that lobbyist is automatically gonna get what they want, but it
- 40:11does change the relationship with that legislator to that lobbyist in a way that the
- 40:16average voter doesn't have.
- 40:20And, you know, I went to one of these thank you breakfasts for a brand new member of Congress.
- 40:25It was her third day in the house.
- 40:28And someone asked a question like, what's your least favorite part so far of being a member of
- 40:34Congress?
- 40:35And she looked around and she was a little bit sheepish to say this, but she said, call time.
- 40:42What is call time?
- 40:43Well, that's when her fundraiser hands her a list of people she needs to call to ask for
- 40:48money.
- 40:49This was for the third day in congress.
- 40:53So, the amount of money, that $20,000,000,000 I was talking about, and the impact that it has
- 40:59on our legislators to be responsive to us as voters and to be held accountable to us as
- 41:07voters.
- 41:07And again, this applies left, right, middle, I think would be very shocking to a lot of people
- 41:17who are not familiar with the process.
- 41:19You can react to that, but I think that is really what I would want to get across.
- 41:26I think as an average voter, most people probably feel that Congress isn't representing
- 41:31us the same way they did when we were back twenty years ago, maybe thirty years ago.
- 41:38I think they would be right, and a lot of that has to do with the tremendous growth in
- 41:45lobbying expenditures.
- 41:47So that's where I'll leave that.
- 41:53I think it's interesting that your initial response was you weren't sure what
- 41:59misconceptions people had.
- 42:01Hey, I guess another assumption of mine to challenge was I thought you would be like, oh,
- 42:06well, I have plenty of misconceptions, but you you weren't quite sure where other people were
- 42:11coming from.
- 42:11So that was just kind of an interesting response.
- 42:14I I think I'll I think some of the misconception lies in what you were talking
- 42:18about, like, a, that people people don't realize that a lot of this is this amount of
- 42:27time that they have to spend fundraising, the these government officials, these elected
- 42:33officials.
- 42:34It's not necessarily because they want you and they want to be bought by people, but, like,
- 42:38it's almost like a requirement for their job.
- 42:41So even if they don't really wanna spend the time, and I've I've heard from other people who
- 42:46have been involved in lobbying or even other people who've been in office that a lot of them
- 42:50really hate that part of the job.
- 42:51They do not enjoy that whole, like, having the the glad hand basically or at least spend as
- 42:58much time as they do because it takes time from doing other things that they are trying to do,
- 43:04whether they're, you know, in Capitol Hill or in the state legislature for the right reasons.
- 43:10And I think another thing is whole like you mentioned before about how when a lobbyist has
- 43:17dinner with a with a politician, for example, it's not necessarily, oh, because they're doing
- 43:23that, that politician is gonna do something for them.
- 43:25It's it's there is that level of access, but some people don't realize that's like, if you
- 43:30painted lobbyists as you call an advocate, tends to have a lot more of a positive
- 43:36connotation amongst people where they say, oh, they're advocating for something.
- 43:40I like to advocate for things, but then you call them a lobbyist, then all of a sudden
- 43:43they're opinion tanks.
- 43:44Now, obviously, there are a lot of nefarious lobbyists, and there is a lot of underhanded
- 43:50things that go on, but I think some people think that basically everything they do is bad.
- 43:54And I've every once in a while, I hear people say, well, we need to get rid of lobbyists.
- 43:58And it's like, well, you you think you want that.
- 44:00You don't want that.
- 44:01And there's a lot of things that need to be reformed, but actually getting rid of lobbyists
- 44:05completely is not going to quite have the the positive impact you think it will, at least
- 44:13from my understanding.
- 44:15But so shifting gears from the lobbying aspect and now more just for the general overall view
- 44:24about reexamining our beliefs.
- 44:26So on one hand, I think echo chambers and groupthink are arguably they're more prevalent
- 44:32than ever.
- 44:33They're a lot more in your face, but we also have more easy access to info than we used to.
- 44:38So since you've been involved in politics for a long time, do you think it's easier for people
- 44:44to question their beliefs now than they did in the past, and why or why not?
- 44:52I think it's probably harder.
- 44:56In part, first home reasons that we've already talked about.
- 44:59I can only speak really from the left perspective, so I don't intend for listeners to
- 45:09think that I don't think this happens on the right or that it isn't also true.
- 45:14I can only speak though from the perspective that I had.
- 45:21You're not encouraged, I think, as a member of the left, especially as sort of you get into
- 45:30the more progressive, sort of farther left, to actually listen to people who think
- 45:36differently.
- 45:37It's not an encouraged thing.
- 45:40And there is definitely very strong groupthink going on.
- 45:46And if someone isn't educated, you are basically empowered to completely ignore that,
- 45:58because only educated credentialed experts are entitled to have an opinion that anyone should
- 46:05listen to.
- 46:07And it may be the very same on the right.
- 46:09Like I said, I can't speak to that because that's not a community I've never really been a
- 46:15part of.
- 46:15I consider myself pretty independent these days, and I'm not sure I will ever label myself
- 46:23as part of a political party again.
- 46:27But on the left, that sort of limits how you might challenge your own ideas if you've
- 46:34already automatically said someone who thinks differently is probably not an expert and you
- 46:39shouldn't listen to them.
- 46:41I also think that while you have at your fingertips the ability to access so much
- 46:50information, most people, again, if they participate in social media, are going to have
- 46:58a social media bubble that is people who think exactly.
- 47:02It takes more work to sort of go out of your way to hear what people who don't agree with
- 47:12you think.
- 47:14It's very easy to get that sort confirmation bias that I was talking it's about before, or
- 47:22simply only trusting certain news sources that may tend to favor the political side that you
- 47:36identify.
- 47:38So while on the one hand it could be so much easier, if people took advantage of the
- 47:48unprecedented access to information that we have.
- 47:52But I don't think that in reality it plays out that way for most people.
- 48:00And I also think that the search algorithms on certain platforms and the algorithms on social
- 48:11media also impact your ability to access information in a way that may also
- 48:19I think another problem that doesn't necessarily really get lampshaded is, I mean,
- 48:27yes, the whole, even though we have this information at our fingertips, people aren't
- 48:31necessarily equipped to research that information.
- 48:35But another side effect of all this increasing research that we have on psychology, for
- 48:42example, is yes, it it helps us to really better address how to talk to people, but I
- 48:48think also a lot of nefarious actors have been able to exploit that information too and more
- 48:56effectively box people into echo chambers and groupthink like social media companies, for
- 49:03example, with their algorithms, how they've engineered it to really just keep people in a
- 49:08never ending cycle of anger and just sticking with their echo chambers.
- 49:13And I I think that's I I I don't know what the solution is to keep people from exploiting
- 49:19that.
- 49:19I don't know if you necessarily can, but beyond just trying to help equip people better to try
- 49:25to withstand that kind of onslaught for lack of a better term.
- 49:29I think I'd be inclined to agree that it's probably more difficult now even though, you
- 49:34know, way probably should be easier than ever because of all the information that you have.
- 49:39But, you know, it's one thing to have that information be readily available.
- 49:44It's another to teach people to how to find that information.
- 49:47And then it's another thing to get them to want to find that information kinda like what we're
- 49:51talking about at the beginning with, you know, how do you what prevents people from wanting to
- 49:57reexamine their beliefs?
- 49:58And, obviously, we'll get a little bit more into into that in these next few questions.
- 50:03So even though your book is more directly critical of of Democrats or at least
- 50:08progressives, I wanna make sure to highlight takeaways that anyone watching this episode can
- 50:13use, and you've already made that point too.
- 50:16So what are one or two general views or attitudes, not even necessarily specific views,
- 50:22but just general attitudes for each of the groups, the left, the right, and the middle,
- 50:28that you would encourage each group to challenge?
- 50:33So I'm gonna have them for the left and the right, and then sort of adapt those a little
- 50:38bit for the middle.
- 50:39I think people in the middle usually tend to read one direction or the other, you know, they
- 50:46have a little bit.
- 50:47I'll start with the left.
- 50:50And the first thing that I would suggest that they think about and challenge is that experts
- 50:59are always right.
- 51:02I think there is the default opinion that if someone has gone to school and gotten
- 51:08credentialed, they're not going to be wrong and they're not going to give you wrong
- 51:13information.
- 51:14I think that isn't the way science is supposed to work, right?
- 51:21I mean, the scientific method is all about challenging someone once they know the answer.
- 51:26That's the basis of it.
- 51:28I think with that, we can identify, and I won't go into specifics, but if we wanted to have a
- 51:36whole hour conversation, Paul, about the times the experts were wrong, I could give them to
- 51:41you.
- 51:41But I think on the left, there is this automatic assumption that if an expert said it,
- 51:47you can't question It's almost a religious belief in experts, okay?
- 51:54The second thing that I would say is people on the left should question or should challenge
- 52:00themselves to really ask themselves, is government always the right answer?
- 52:05More government, especially at the federal level.
- 52:09The farther away from the actual voter you get, the harder it is, can be, to hold those elected
- 52:20individuals accountable as a voter.
- 52:24So, when we think about, you know, on the left, expanding programs, more federal expansion and
- 52:33those kind of things, challenge yourself.
- 52:36Is government always the answer?
- 52:40I think lastly, I would say for people on the left, I've heard this a lot and I still do,
- 52:47sort of the idea that everyone on the right is uneducated and therefore should not be misled.
- 52:54And that just really isn't true.
- 52:59In my experience, especially since I've sort of become an independent and listen to a lot of
- 53:05people, there are a lot of educated people who call themselves conservatives, libertarians,
- 53:12those kind of things.
- 53:17Along with that, challenging the assumption that if you don't have a formal education
- 53:23beyond, say, twelfth grade, that somehow that means you aren't intelligent.
- 53:29Somehow that means that you can't make rational decisions themselves.
- 53:36So that would be what I would say to people on the left.
- 53:40Now the people on the right, they're very similar, I'll be honest, but sort of inverse
- 53:45almost.
- 53:47I would say you hear a lot of things of people on the right calling people on the left
- 53:54student, you know, and so it's sort of the inverse of that last one, but, you know, I
- 53:59don't wanna use terminology.
- 54:02I don't like calling people names.
- 54:04There are many names that people on the right might call someone who is on the left that
- 54:10would imply that if you are a liberal, you must be dumb.
- 54:15And so I would challenge them to know, challenge that assumption.
- 54:21Think about what could it be, what could be some of the reasons besides them not being
- 54:27intelligent that they might have this difference.
- 54:32I would challenge them to challenge the assumption that government programs are
- 54:39network.
- 54:40There's sort of this assumption that we I'm not saying everyone on the right is a libertarian
- 54:46and doesn't want any government, but in general, it's sort of the assumption no
- 54:51government program is good or worthwhile.
- 54:53And I think there's a lot more nuance than that.
- 54:56I do think that it makes sense for us to ask questions.
- 55:00Know, if we've had this program for fifty years, are we getting good outcomes?
- 55:04Is it actually helping people?
- 55:06Are we getting a good return on our investment in this program?
- 55:11Those are different questions than to just start from the assumption of, Hey, government's
- 55:15already We should never have government programs.
- 55:19And so, it's sort of like I said, they're kind of the opposites, but I think that those are
- 55:24things that are at the base of a lot of what the disagreements are between the people with
- 55:32different political views, and those would be the ones that I would start with.
- 55:37And I think the other thing is that, as we've talked about, it's gotten so polarized that
- 55:45there's sort of this assumption that people on the other side are, they're not moral because
- 55:55of the beliefs that they hold.
- 55:57And I think I would challenge everybody to start thinking about the fact that policy
- 56:07disagreements, two people could have the same goal, you know, let's improve the economic
- 56:17situation for children when they become adults.
- 56:20And very different ways of thinking about how you achieve that without making a moral
- 56:27judgment about the fact that this person wants the government and this person doesn't, to help
- 56:35make that help help achieve that outcome.
- 56:39So I guess basically that one kinda comes down to stop assuming people differently than you
- 56:45are bad, you know, and just like try to come at any question you're having with an open mind as
- 56:55opposed to prejudging someone based on a label that you've given them often, and they might
- 57:04not even give that to themselves, like you've given them and then assuming that what you
- 57:10think goes along with that label is at the base of that person's reasoning, rationale, or moral
- 57:18goodness in this situation.
- 57:21So that would be what I would say.
- 57:22And for the middle, obviously, it applies to everybody.
- 57:25Those kind of apply to everybody.
- 57:27And I think, you know, since I have sort of changed how I believe, I've seen these kind of
- 57:33assumptions coming from every aspect, no matter where people find themselves sort of left,
- 57:40right, and go in between.
- 57:43And so I think if we could just start with challenging some of these assumptions, and
- 57:49especially about the moral goodness of the people who were having a disagreement, we could
- 57:54have a lot better discussions and maybe get back to a point where we can talk about
- 58:00compromise, actually help people and actually move us towards what some of our shared goals
- 58:08might be, even if we disagree.
- 58:15Yeah.
- 58:15And it's hard to get that everybody everybody out of that mindset of, well, I've morally, I
- 58:21am superior.
- 58:22I've talked about it in a couple previous episodes of the the whole moralized attitudes
- 58:28where people, they feel like they would be doing their moral code and themselves a
- 58:34disservice if they didn't fight tooth and nail for that supposed morally superior set of
- 58:41beliefs.
- 58:42And so it's not even about winning or it's not you know, even if they were the the idea of,
- 58:49like, giving up on any of that that that's supposedly what compromises that that that
- 58:57they're being that they would be immoral if they did that.
- 58:59And, yeah, it's that's definitely one of the things to really break people out of.
- 59:04And it's it's okay to believe that something is morally superior, but to assume that somebody
- 59:10does not have morals because they don't think the same way is not really a moral way to think
- 59:15yourself to really impose on people.
- 59:17If you really think if it's really that important to you that to push those morals,
- 59:24then I think making trying to force people into a box, you're not trying to bring people quote
- 59:30unquote into the light.
- 59:31So you're still really just doing your set of moral beliefs to the service in my opinion.
- 59:37There are so many assumptions that everybody across the political spectrum really needs to
- 59:43not even necessarily change, but at least re examine and be willing to re examine.
- 59:48And that kind of goes into this next question.
- 59:51So critical thinking is unfortunately not taught well in school, and that has carried on
- 59:56into adulthood as well, and we don't really teach it well for adults either.
- 1:00:00And that's regardless of level of intelligence or interest.
- 1:00:03Smart people can also be not not always think critically all the time.
- 1:00:11So what are two or three whether they're from the book that you from the book specifically or
- 1:00:16from just your general observations.
- 1:00:18What are two or three critical thinking tips you have that anybody can use?
- 1:00:26Sure.
- 1:00:26And I do talk about these in the book, but I think it is about having a free mind and
- 1:00:34thinking critically about any issue that comes in front of you.
- 1:00:39The first thing I would say is don't accept anything at face value.
- 1:00:44Question.
- 1:00:46One thing that's happened that happens in our education system, in our employment, in
- 1:00:53corporations, is that questioning the people in charge is not encouraged.
- 1:00:59It is actually very discouraged.
- 1:01:01So, when you're in school, you can ask questions to better understand the subject
- 1:01:07matter.
- 1:01:07But if you start questioning your teacher and saying teacher's wrong, you're not gonna get
- 1:01:14rewarded for that kind of thing.
- 1:01:16There's all sorts of ways you might get punished, actually.
- 1:01:22And the same thing at your job.
- 1:01:25A lot of times, you know, you're a troublemaker or you're trying to upset the apple cart as
- 1:01:31opposed to, I'm trying to understand why we're actually doing what we're doing.
- 1:01:35So you don't have to do it publicly, but when something gets thrown at you and it's a new
- 1:01:41idea, or even just when you're trying to digest the news of BA, does it make sense?
- 1:01:49Is what they're saying makes sense?
- 1:01:51Does this line up with what I know to be true about this topic?
- 1:01:57Why would they be saying it?
- 1:01:59Is there a reason that they have that they might wanna put this forward that may not
- 1:02:03actually be true?
- 1:02:05So that would be really the first.
- 1:02:08And the corollary to that in politics especially, but I think in general as well, is
- 1:02:17that I would encourage people to follow the money.
- 1:02:22And what that means is when you are asked to believe something, ask yourself who paid for
- 1:02:28this?
- 1:02:30For example, back when I was a kid, pharmaceutical companies could not advertise on
- 1:02:36TV.
- 1:02:37And now if you turn on mainstream news, almost every ad is a pharmaceutical.
- 1:02:44So ask yourself, do you think that the mainstream media who depends almost entirely on
- 1:02:49pharmaceutical advertising for their income is reporting fairly on pharmaceuticals.
- 1:02:57Now, that doesn't mean they aren't, but what it means is that you should be asking yourself
- 1:03:02that question and you should be asking yourself, well, where did the money come from?
- 1:03:06Who benefits from it?
- 1:03:08And then where does it go?
- 1:03:09So when you start tracing the money, then you can kind of think critically about, well, maybe
- 1:03:16they're saying that because if they don't say that they'll lose money, or maybe they're
- 1:03:20saying that because they were paid to say that.
- 1:03:23And you know, it doesn't automatically mean that something is wrong because somebody paid
- 1:03:32for it.
- 1:03:33But it makes sense to understand the money trail in order to understand is being is what
- 1:03:40I'm being told accurate and true?
- 1:03:44Or is there some slant to it because of who paid for it, or they're making money for it
- 1:03:52from it, or where the money is going after.
- 1:03:56So that would be the second one.
- 1:03:58And then the final one, and we've sort of already alluded to this, but I would say, look
- 1:04:06for and listen to people that you disagree with with an open mind.
- 1:04:13So get yourself out of your echo chamber.
- 1:04:17You know, any idea that's true and right stands up to scrutiny.
- 1:04:22And this is the whole thing about censorship to me too.
- 1:04:25If you have the facts and you have the data and you have the evidence to support your position,
- 1:04:30you should welcome debate.
- 1:04:32You should welcome questioning, you should welcome challenges to your ideas.
- 1:04:38And so get out of your echo chamber, even if it's someone that your friends might make fun
- 1:04:43of you for listening to, listen to them.
- 1:04:46And then you can say, you know, I've listened to this person and here's why I disagree and
- 1:04:51here's why they're wrong.
- 1:04:53I think what you will find when you do that is you will start thinking about things in a
- 1:04:59different way, and it may help you challenge some of the assumptions that we've been taught.
- 1:05:04Now, that doesn't mean this person's gonna be right, and it doesn't mean that you're wrong.
- 1:05:09What it means is that you are examining the ideas and the assumptions you hold and the
- 1:05:16assumptions that you make in order to hold those ideas.
- 1:05:20It will make you infinitely better, infinitely better at defending your own position.
- 1:05:27If you understand what someone who disagrees with you thinks, why they think it, and then
- 1:05:34you can then respond to that.
- 1:05:37And sometimes it might cause you to change your mind or something and there's something wrong
- 1:05:43with that.
- 1:05:44I think it's really, really hard to admit you're wrong about something, it really is.
- 1:05:55The opening line to my prologue on my book is admitting you're wrong is never easy, admitting
- 1:06:01you're wrong about everything is next to impossible.
- 1:06:03But when, to me, that is the sign of a truly free mind and someone who also has freed
- 1:06:13themselves from needing to conform and fit in and being afraid of what people think of you
- 1:06:24because of your beliefs.
- 1:06:26So, you know, you may never, you may do all the things I just said and may not change one idea
- 1:06:32or one assumption that you have, but then you can at least say to yourself, you know what, I
- 1:06:38know that idea I have is right because I looked at the other side.
- 1:06:42I examined the evidence that the person who is supposed to be the smartest on the other side
- 1:06:50about this, And it didn't persuade me and it made me aware of the assumptions that I was
- 1:06:55making.
- 1:06:55When I went and looked, assumptions are right.
- 1:06:59Or you may come away from it and say, You know what?
- 1:07:01I was wrong about this.
- 1:07:03And to me, the person who can admit they're wrong is the person who's growing, who's
- 1:07:08learning, and who really has, you know, not that I really does have more of a ground to
- 1:07:15stand on because they aren't just, you know, they are attempting to make the best decision
- 1:07:22that they can based on all the available evidence and not just that which confirms.
- 1:07:32Yeah.
- 1:07:33And admitting you're wrong is is definitely difficult.
- 1:07:35Fortunately, I've never been wrong about anything.
- 1:07:37No.
- 1:07:37I'm kidding.
- 1:07:38But I the the the point about the following the money, I I I think a good way to also put that
- 1:07:45as the the who, what, where, when, why, and how.
- 1:07:48Who is saying what this information, what is the information, where did you see the
- 1:07:54information, when did you get the information, was it nearer an election time, for example?
- 1:07:58Why would they tell you that, and how do they tell you that?
- 1:08:00I think those are good ways to also put forth what you were just talking about with the
- 1:08:06following the money.
- 1:08:07So now, obviously, it's it can still be difficult for people to bring themselves to to
- 1:08:13use those tips, but they are still things that people can do.
- 1:08:17So more specifically about your book, what are one to two misconceptions of your book?
- 1:08:25Whether you've actually heard them or you wanna preempt potential misconceptions that you want
- 1:08:30to clear up?
- 1:08:33So I think one of them I kind of already mentioned.
- 1:08:36I'm not a Republican, and I think if you saw the title, you'd think that person's probably a
- 1:08:44Republican.
- 1:08:44Well, I'm not.
- 1:08:47Believe that Or someone might believe, I think the Republican Party is better than the
- 1:08:53Democratic Party.
- 1:08:54Republicans are better than Democrats.
- 1:08:55I don't.
- 1:08:57I actually believe that the parties themselves are way too powerful, and that is something
- 1:09:05that, yeah, I don't have an easy answer for it because I don't want to see us become like a
- 1:09:12lot of European countries where you have 23 parties and there's a majority government, I
- 1:09:19don't know that that's any better.
- 1:09:21But part of when we were talking about lobbying, what happens is that you really do
- 1:09:27have to toe the party line because the party's gonna give you a lot of money, right?
- 1:09:31They're gonna help you with your reelection.
- 1:09:33We also get to determine what committee you sit on, and whether you ever move up and become a
- 1:09:37chairman or a ranking member or all of those.
- 1:09:40So I think that our system has, and some of the founding fathers really warned against are
- 1:09:49these becoming powerful.
- 1:09:50It's one of the things that could really corrupt our republic.
- 1:09:54And I think, unfortunately, it kind of has.
- 1:09:57And so, think that's a misconception people could have reading the title.
- 1:10:07Oh, this is just another conservative Republican who thinks Democrats are bad.
- 1:10:12I don't.
- 1:10:13And I specifically think that what we really face is a challenge of a system in which the
- 1:10:21parties have become too powerful, and what we have is an establishment that has all this
- 1:10:28power and that fights really, really hard.
- 1:10:3295% of incumbents get reelected, 95%.
- 1:10:37Yet the approval of Congress is in, I think, the low teens now or something like that.
- 1:10:44So people seem to have this idea that Congress is terrible, but I'm gonna reelect my person.
- 1:10:51And a lot of that has to do with the money that is funneled into these election campaigns by
- 1:10:56their parties.
- 1:10:58And so, I think also that, again, I couldn't write a deprogramming everybody politically
- 1:11:10because I only came from one side.
- 1:11:13And I think that there are people that are just as programmed on the right as there are on the
- 1:11:18left.
- 1:11:18It may be different, but I think, again, that what we all need to focus on is how we're the
- 1:11:26same and how we can reclaim our power as we are given it in the constitution, as we, the
- 1:11:34people, go away from the establishment.
- 1:11:38In part, that starts from having respectful conversations like we're having today, and
- 1:11:46doing some of the things that we were talking about in terms of changing our assumptions
- 1:11:50about people we disagree with, and critically thinking about all of our beliefs all the time.
- 1:12:01The more you can re examine them, the better.
- 1:12:03And again, if you have looked at the other side's arguments, quote unquote, other side,
- 1:12:11and all their data and evidence and come away thinking that you're still right, then I think
- 1:12:18you've done a good service in critical thinking for yourself, then you'll be able to be more
- 1:12:24persuasive to people in order for us to all come to better agreements.
- 1:12:29So I think that, again, the misconception would be that I'm attacking Democrats and I'm a
- 1:12:37Republican and that's just all.
- 1:12:45Yeah.
- 1:12:45I was I suspected that was gonna be at least a misconception that you brought, but obviously,
- 1:12:50I didn't wanna make that assumption this whole thing is about not making assumptions or at
- 1:12:54least challenging your assumptions.
- 1:12:56So I wanted to make sure that that was made clear because I I like you said, the book title
- 1:13:02can make it sound like to somebody like, oh, yeah.
- 1:13:04Well, okay.
- 1:13:05They're just they just went to the other side kind of thing.
- 1:13:08So so thank you for clarifying that.
- 1:13:12So we are running a little low on time, but we're pretty much at the end of this.
- 1:13:16Before we get to the final question, the the fun question, any final thoughts you want to
- 1:13:21share about your book or critical thinking or reexamining your personal beliefs?
- 1:13:27I think, you know, I would say my book would be a good place to start in reexamining your
- 1:13:35beliefs regardless of which side of aisle or in the middle that you think about yourself.
- 1:13:42Someone said to me as I was examining my own beliefs, I have a website.
- 1:13:49You can send me an email through it.
- 1:13:51If you buy the book and you read it and you think I'm completely wrong, tell me, tell me
- 1:13:56why, completely wrong.
- 1:13:57Show me the evidence and data that says I'm wrong.
- 1:14:01Now I am open to conversations with anyone, And I promise with any conversation that I'm gonna
- 1:14:09be respectful about our disagreements.
- 1:14:12And I will come armed with data and evidence to the conversation.
- 1:14:18I think every conversation that I have makes me a little bit better in my critical thinking and
- 1:14:24my ability espouse my position.
- 1:14:27My book is available on Amazon, Barnes and Noble, and I do have a website that is
- 1:14:33deprogrammingdemocrats.com.
- 1:14:36And through that website, anyone can get in touch with me.
- 1:14:39And, you know, I'm I I believe that we're at a critical juncture where our country has to do
- 1:14:51some healing.
- 1:14:53A house divided cannot stand, at least not in the long run.
- 1:14:58And as we become more tribal and less civil and start viewing each other less and less as
- 1:15:09fellow humans with which we share a lot of innate characteristics and things in common, it
- 1:15:19makes me really worried for the future of our republic.
- 1:15:21So I think we, you know, that's part of why I wrote the book.
- 1:15:27That's part of why I'm on this podcast with you talking about this, because I think we have to
- 1:15:33reclaim the ability to have these civil conversations, view each other as human beings
- 1:15:42who wanna do the right thing that we just don't agree with about everything.
- 1:15:48And so that is really why.
- 1:15:58Yeah.
- 1:15:58The and and definitely agree with this being a critical critical juncture now.
- 1:16:04I obviously try not to fearmonger.
- 1:16:06Obviously, you don't wanna do that, but it is a very concerning time we do live in, and it it
- 1:16:12it is something that we do need to fix and fix soon, or this is going to get even worse.
- 1:16:18And at at some point, our republic cannot stand just just like you said.
- 1:16:24So really appreciate you making that last point.
- 1:16:29So let's now shift a little bit though from the the more apprehensive doom and gloom for lack
- 1:16:36of a better term, and let's go to a little bit more of a fun question.
- 1:16:40So for those of you who are new to the podcast, I like to end guest interviews with a random
- 1:16:46question of the day.
- 1:16:46It's a fun, nonpolitical question that tries to make things more well rounded, get a different
- 1:16:52side of the guests for that episode.
- 1:16:57And so for you, Lisa, today's random question of the day is, if you had the power to
- 1:17:05unilaterally enact one or two policies, which are fairly noncontroversial and not politically
- 1:17:11charged, they're relatively trivial, so they're not really that important in the grand scheme
- 1:17:15of things.
- 1:17:16What would they be and why?
- 1:17:18And if you want a couple of ideas, I have already got a couple that are locked and
- 1:17:21loaded.
- 1:17:25Not political and fun.
- 1:17:29So I would love to see and I don't, you know, some people might see this as political because
- 1:17:43it would be government telling you you're supposed to do something.
- 1:17:46So I just phrase it that way.
- 1:17:49But a mandatory thirty minutes of disconnection time when you get off your devices and you go
- 1:17:59outside and you see the sun and you touch the earth and you reconnect to nature.
- 1:18:08Think, and again, like I said, some people would say, Oh, you can't mandate that.
- 1:18:14But I do think our society and our mental health would be much better if people got off
- 1:18:20their machines sometimes and stepped outside.
- 1:18:25Looks like Lisa dropped out.
- 1:18:26So, well, hopefully, she'll be able to to come back on.
- 1:18:30But for me, my answer is so I would make it so that you get heavy fines for not parking
- 1:18:41between lines when you don't need multiple spaces.
- 1:18:44So you're going to a parking lot and people just decide to not park in between lines like
- 1:18:52they're supposed to, and they're and they are completely inconsiderate of other people and
- 1:18:57putting chewed gum anywhere that is not a trash can.
- 1:19:01And I'll I use those two specifically because back in grad school when I parked one day to go
- 1:19:08to some sort of function for our our the political science department at the University
- 1:19:13of Florida, Parking there sucks.
- 1:19:16Parking also in my other alma mater, University of South Florida, also sucks.
- 1:19:20I suspect that parking at universities is just awful in general, but there was somebody who
- 1:19:30did a poor job parking, and I could barely get out of my car, and I was getting a little
- 1:19:35annoyed.
- 1:19:35And I I verbally said, really?
- 1:19:38Really?
- 1:19:39He clearly didn't like that because when I came back to the car and I tried to open the door,
- 1:19:45that same person put chewed gum on the inside of the handle.
- 1:19:48Even though they did a horrible job parking, that is totally their fault.
- 1:19:51They decided to do that, and they were already gone, the coward.
- 1:19:57He was definitely somebody that got me a little bit salty, and I was none too pleased with
- 1:20:06that.
- 1:20:06But, yeah, heavy fines for both of those things.
- 1:20:09And then people just spinning their gum out on the sidewalk in general.
- 1:20:11Like, what is wrong with you?
- 1:20:14You know, this is supposed to be a proper society, but whatever.
- 1:20:18That's dead.
- 1:20:18Those are those are a couple of things that that drive me crazy.
- 1:20:22So those were the those would be the the things I would unilaterally enact.
- 1:20:26Not not to obviously, actually politically charged.
- 1:20:29I wouldn't really do that.
- 1:20:30You obviously couldn't actually enact those policies anyways on your own, but it's more to
- 1:20:34be sort of a fun exercise.
- 1:20:36But unfortunately, since Lisa drops out, won't be able to ask her or I'll ask her afterwards
- 1:20:43what other links she wants to share, and I'll put those in the show notes.
- 1:20:47But really wanna thank Lisa for her time being on here, and that's gonna wrap things up today
- 1:20:52for us on today's episode of the politics with Paul podcast.
- 1:20:56So please check out my show notes and her show notes, my show notes, my Facebook, Paul Raider
- 1:21:03author and speaker, my LinkedIn, my medium.com profile, my website paulrader dot org, my email
- 1:21:08paulraderwrites, as in writinggmail dot com, and my five day educational email course about
- 1:21:16how we can more effectively depolarize American politics.
- 1:21:21So that is going to end it for today's episode.
- 1:21:24So as always, thank you so much for listening.
- 1:21:26And until next time, take care.