Latest / Politics with Paul / Can We Disincentivize Extreme Polarization w Nathan Smolensky | Politics with Paul #106
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the politics with Paul podcast, your home for nonpartisan discussion of
- 0:04political science and civics.
- 0:06I'm your host, Paul Raider.
- 0:08And it's not just another guest interview today.
- 0:10No.
- 0:11No.
- 0:11No.
- 0:11We have our first ever repeat guest on the show today.
- 0:15And now for new and returning listeners, always add a disclaimer that I do not take a stance
- 0:20for or against a guest's political views or groups they support.
- 0:24But as destructive as polarization and tribalism can be, division in politics
- 0:29continues to be pervasive and in some ways is getting even worse.
- 0:34And as much as the toxicity is decried, there are still plenty of incentives to keep it
- 0:39going.
- 0:39The two parties pull further away from each other, and even some of those that are not
- 0:44democrats or republican can feel the pull towards one side or the other.
- 0:48But what if we can remove those incentives to pull towards extremes?
- 0:53Well, that's what today's guest, Nathan Smolensky, is here to talk about.
- 0:56Nathan is the founder and chief strategist of Unifier, u n I f I r e, Consulting, a
- 1:04campaigning and consulting firm that primarily assists independents, but also Republicans and
- 1:08Democrats looking to build bridges.
- 1:10And he's also the author of common ground from the ground up, which we discussed in his first
- 1:15appearance back on this show in episode 61 and was previously the state director of the
- 1:22Florida Forward Party and a writer slash editor with Second Look News.
- 1:27So let's discuss how to disincentivize polarization and make bridge building more
- 1:32appealing and palatable.
- 1:34Welcome back to the show, Nathan.
- 1:36How are you?
- 1:37Doing great.
- 1:38How about yourself?
- 1:40I'm doing not too bad.
- 1:41Not too bad.
- 1:42So you you know how these interviews start off now, but as we always do for for interviews,
- 1:48like to get to the bottom of why my guests are in their current line of work or why they're
- 1:53involved with the topic at hand.
- 1:54So what makes you so interested in the incentives for toxicity and polarization in
- 1:59politics and for trying to fix that problem?
- 2:03So there's a few few kind of elements to it.
- 2:07First, I mean, it's a big problem.
- 2:10Just the sheer amount of division and propensity toward gridlock and partisanship and
- 2:18tribalism in our politics undermines any effort to get just about anything done of meaning.
- 2:24There is not really a functional problem solving discussion or discourse going on, and I
- 2:32would like to see that.
- 2:33I would like to be part of it.
- 2:34I have ideas on a whole bunch of issues.
- 2:36And as far as really getting to the root of the incentives, that's just how you solve problems.
- 2:41That's just how you have to go about it, in my view, because that's the root of it.
- 2:49And if you're not changing the incentives, it's always going to gravitate toward divisiveness
- 2:56and tribalism and polarization.
- 2:58And so I try to use everything at my disposal.
- 3:03I'm a problem solving guy.
- 3:05I try to be methodical.
- 3:06I try to understand what messaging requires to work, and I try to be as strategic as I can to
- 3:15shift the incentives of the system.
- 3:17So it's something I'm very passionate about.
- 3:20And you need to be, right?
- 3:22It sounds like it's calling human beings all selfish, but it it's it's really not
- 3:27necessarily.
- 3:28We are naturally geared towards needing incentives to do something.
- 3:33It's I feel like it's pretty rare for us to do something when there's not any sort of impetus
- 3:39for it.
- 3:39And then, again, does not necessarily mean that people are selfish.
- 3:42It just means that there's gotta there are a lot of times has to be something that makes us
- 3:48go towards something.
- 3:49Now a lot of times, it does turn out to be selfish incentives.
- 3:52And even if it's destroying political debates and and discourse and the ability to solve
- 3:59problems, of course, that's where it starts to get into that more selfish territory.
- 4:02But sometimes, you know, people just can't see passer incentives.
- 4:07Do you have something to add?
- 4:08Well, I actually pushed back a little on that so far as Okay.
- 4:16First of all, I mean, there's incentive.
- 4:18Everything is driven by some sort of impetus.
- 4:21If you're going against the grain for whatever reason, there is a reason that you are going
- 4:26against the grain.
- 4:27There is another incentive that is competing with it.
- 4:30And you're getting to the heart of, I think, why this can be so difficult.
- 4:35Because it is more than just the selfish There is grifting.
- 4:40There is simply profiting off the division intentionally.
- 4:43But, a lot of people see engaging in the most extreme ways, engaging in the most destructive
- 4:49ways, as simply justified for the what they see as the moral ends or the ultimate political
- 5:00ends of what they're trying to do.
- 5:02If people view their livelihood as under attack, if people view an active threat of
- 5:08fascism or totalitarianism or communism, something that is threatening their values and
- 5:14the things they hold dear and their ways of life, I I don't think it would be necessarily
- 5:20fair to describe that as a a selfish incentive to push back extremely against it, or to to
- 5:28justify certain unsavory means of pursuing it.
- 5:33My focus is a lot on trying to lessen that incentive by helping people realize that that
- 5:40kind of doesn't work.
- 5:43Engaging in that division doesn't resolve anything.
- 5:46And that, to me, is a more critical way of going about it than what I see as a lot of
- 5:54trying to say that one incentive or the incentive toward better behavior, however you
- 6:01want to frame that, should override everything else.
- 6:05Because at that point, you're dealing with competing incentives, and you're not always
- 6:08gonna win.
- 6:10Oh, no.
- 6:11I I don't disagree with that.
- 6:12It's I think it's it's easy for us to see things as, you know, this divisiveness as
- 6:18selfish.
- 6:19I don't I'm sure a lot of it is, but some people are ultimately doing it because they
- 6:24feel like they have to do it, not just because they want to be divisive, belligerent, but they
- 6:30do see it as a necessity.
- 6:32But let's actually go into that a little bit more.
- 6:34Why is it so tantalizing for people to be polarizing, and who can fall into this trap of
- 6:40fanning the flames of division in your eyes?
- 6:43We are all susceptible to it.
- 6:45I will include myself in that.
- 6:46There is issues.
- 6:48There is topics.
- 6:49There's ways of going about talking politics that kinda set me off.
- 6:55And, you know, one of my big themes, and I might I'm going to get a tiny bit ahead of
- 7:00myself for a moment, is that emotion holds us back.
- 7:05And this is why I've tried to reel it in, in places where it does come up for me, where that
- 7:12approach, it is just very natural.
- 7:15It goes back.
- 7:17And if you want to frame it this way, you think about this child, like they're not getting what
- 7:23they want, and so they scream.
- 7:24And if they aren't being heard, they'll scream louder, and they'll start kicking things, and
- 7:29they'll start punching things, and it's just, well, I have to try harder.
- 7:33I have to push harder.
- 7:34I have to be louder.
- 7:36And it is very, very natural to go about that, and it has to be learned that, I think more
- 7:46importantly than that is not something we want to do often is that it doesn't actually work in
- 7:52this context.
- 7:53And that, I think, is the most vital lesson.
- 7:58Definitely wholeheartedly agree with that.
- 8:01And that and that's something I try to talk about whenever I'm either writing on LinkedIn
- 8:05or I'm doing the podcast or I'm writing a book, the one that I'm in the midst of writing now
- 8:12about how to more effectively depolarize politics is this whole I think a lot of people,
- 8:19even bridge builders, can fall into the same trap of thinking that they are that their group
- 8:24is the one that's or that everybody else is being polarizing and that they they cannot fall
- 8:31into that trap of polarization.
- 8:32We've figured it out, but it's like, that's that's just that's not how it how it is.
- 8:36Any one of us, just like you said, can fall into this trap because we all have our own
- 8:42moral compass and set of values, and it's very easy to feel like they're under attack when
- 8:48somebody else is disagreeing with them vehemently or vehemently.
- 8:53So I that's something I definitely agree with, and I think more bridge builders need to
- 9:00recognize that problem.
- 9:01But I stopped myself during part of that answer because I wanted to ask this question because
- 9:07there does seem to be a lot of people that think divisiveness and tribalism are a one side
- 9:13only problem, that they won't recognize it amongst their party or their ideological or
- 9:17social group.
- 9:18It's always them.
- 9:18It's never us.
- 9:20Do you think that a lot of these people are just not self aware about that or that they do
- 9:25have some understanding, but they are just too concerned with winning political battles?
- 9:29What do you think is the reason for not recognizing their own divisiveness?
- 9:35So I think it's just a matter of how we see the justification, what we see as something we can
- 9:45sympathize with, something we can understand.
- 9:47When it's our side, again, it goes back to this idea of, hey, if you think the current
- 9:53administration is fascistic and totalitarian and, you know, threatening the lives of
- 9:58immigrants and minorities and all of this, then you're going to be sympathetic to people who
- 10:05take that further, who take that sentiment and, like, you're going to understand where they're
- 10:10coming from.
- 10:11And at the same time, someone who has a different worldview and views something else as
- 10:16a more fundamental existential threat, you're just not gonna be able to understand that at
- 10:22all.
- 10:23And you'll see that as, oh my god, that is way out of line, way disproportionate.
- 10:29That's insane.
- 10:30How can they possibly do that?
- 10:31How can they possibly think that?
- 10:33They must be brainwashed.
- 10:35They must be, you know, really just complete disregard for any kind of morality.
- 10:44Because we all have that morality, more or less.
- 10:47It's just we all have that point at which we, you know, feel justified in making an
- 10:54exception.
- 10:56And it's when we see us at that point where we are going to differ and are going to be hit by
- 11:03that effect of alienation and that effect of being so dissonant from the other side and the
- 11:09way the other side views the world that we just can't see why they would act or respond the way
- 11:15they would.
- 11:18Yeah.
- 11:19And sometimes it can be hard to really appreciate.
- 11:23When you are a less polarized person, it could be very hard to appreciate that even though we
- 11:31can still fall into the same kinds of traps.
- 11:33And, you know, it's what it's it's something that's very easy to point out, but it's
- 11:37obviously far, far more difficult to do something about these incentives because
- 11:41otherwise, we would have solved the problem already.
- 11:44But I I think part of it is also that there's a significant failure across the board regardless
- 11:50of whether you're of one party or the other or you're not of a party to properly appreciate
- 11:56the long term impacts of divisive political strategies because there's too much focus on
- 12:02the now.
- 12:02It's yeah.
- 12:03This this might be too toxic for for politics that that that our discourse is getting worse
- 12:09and worse, but we need to do this in order to win this election and to fix ever all all the
- 12:13problems and we usher in a new golden age.
- 12:17Even if you step outside of the context of toxicity and divisiveness, you see political
- 12:22debates are just rife with preoccupation about short term victories over long term
- 12:27sustainability.
- 12:29Do you agree with this sentiment?
- 12:31And if so, how do we start getting people to recognize that what might get you a win in the
- 12:38short term often ultimately has a deteriorating effect on political discourse and legislating
- 12:43in the long term and then further down the line, you know, it's gonna it's gonna make it
- 12:46more difficult for you to win.
- 12:50So Kind of a loaded question, I know.
- 12:53No.
- 12:54No.
- 12:54No.
- 12:54Because I I think there's a few critical points to touch on there.
- 12:59It is I think the main thing you touch on is this kind of fog of war.
- 13:04This entrenchment in the conflict that blinds us to the greater implications that I've been
- 13:09talking about.
- 13:10You know, we may feel justified.
- 13:12We may absolutely feel justified.
- 13:15That doesn't mean that what we're doing is ultimately solving the problem.
- 13:20And again, we kind of shorthand this idea of we're going to win.
- 13:25We're going to win this battle.
- 13:26We're going sometimes, what I like to do is kind of ask ask people and ask myself, what
- 13:32does winning in this kind of culture war, partisan conflict look like?
- 13:37And it's hard to play out.
- 13:40What is the other side just going to lay down and never win an election again, and accept
- 13:47that they were wrong the whole time, and they were on the wrong side of history, and they're
- 13:52whatever it may be, I don't see that happening.
- 13:56And the other thing that you can point out is yeah.
- 14:00To your point, there's sort of the long term deteriorating effects of this polarized style
- 14:08of politics, but also the vulnerability that comes with our division, our state of fracture,
- 14:17where that is so easily it makes us more manipulable.
- 14:22It makes us more targetable.
- 14:24It can be exploited by rabble rousers and demagogues who are seeking office.
- 14:29It can be exploited by media fear mongers and hate mongers and whatever fish mongers.
- 14:35And it can be exploited by foreign powers who just see that as a critical vulnerability, that
- 14:41we are falling apart and we can be at each other's throats if they just say the right
- 14:46words.
- 14:47And that itself, I think, is something people lose sight of.
- 14:51And again, they may even see that and say, well, I'm sorry, but this this is life or
- 14:57death.
- 14:57This is good versus evil right now, and I cannot step aside or back down just because it
- 15:05of these costs that we're paying.
- 15:07So you have to make the case that ultimately I like to talk about this as a finger trap.
- 15:15If you know those old toys, it's sort of you feel like you need to pull apart.
- 15:20You need to pull away.
- 15:21You need to pull as hard as you can, and that only traps you in it.
- 15:26It makes makes it harder.
- 15:28It makes the lock stronger.
- 15:30And that is something that you can articulate to people, and you can make the case to people.
- 15:35But I think one of the more critical things that we don't do enough of in the bridging and
- 15:39political invasion spaces is show that, hey, by coming together, following that analogy, that's
- 15:46the way out of this.
- 15:47And here's what that looks like.
- 15:51The the finger trap thing.
- 15:53I don't know if this is the one that you were referring to, but I remember, like, in grade
- 15:56school, they had the, hey.
- 15:57You want a piece of gum?
- 15:58And there'd be one that that looks like it was stuck out, but it was actually if you pull it,
- 16:02it shocks your your hand really hard.
- 16:04Just it's it's kinda like that, I guess.
- 16:07But the
- 16:08The Chinese finger trap, it's sort of you hold one with each finger and you kind of pull and
- 16:14yeah.
- 16:14I'm
- 16:14sure Okay.
- 16:15Yeah.
- 16:15Yeah.
- 16:15I know what you're talking about now.
- 16:17Yeah.
- 16:17But the the point you had about, you know, are you actually solving anything?
- 16:22And and I think that's that's one of the big things too is, you know, when I talk about when
- 16:27you're getting really mad at something, you see something that that angers you on social media,
- 16:32which we've all been there.
- 16:33I've seen plenty of things that get me riled up.
- 16:36Just try my best to not engage with it so it doesn't have as you know, try to limit its
- 16:41reach in whatever little way I can.
- 16:43But a lot of times, it is just about making ourselves feel better even if and and sometimes
- 16:50we really think we're solving something because we're doing our part.
- 16:54But a lot of times, it really isn't doing anything.
- 16:58But sometimes it's hard to separate the whether you're you think you're solving anything versus
- 17:04whether it's just to make yourself feel better and to, you know, grandstand.
- 17:09And sometimes I've thought about those kinds of things dichotomously where it's either one or
- 17:13the other, but really, it's it's it's not so simple to think like that.
- 17:16Sometimes you genuinely believe you're solving something or you're just doing your little
- 17:21parts to solving because, I mean, nobody you're never gonna make long standing reforms of any
- 17:27kind on your own.
- 17:28So sometimes you think it's, oh, if I just retweet something, that's that's doing my part.
- 17:33Or if I make an angry comment, that's doing my part.
- 17:36And, yes, in reality, it's not actually fixing anything.
- 17:40And it like you said, it's partly just trying to get people to realize that it's not actually
- 17:47solving anything.
- 17:48It's not getting any sort of long term solutions they're looking for.
- 17:52But incenses are not just about what wins you elections.
- 17:55A lot of the most polarized people have very moralized attitudes, and so they're motivated
- 17:59to keep what they view as a moral consistency or integrity, which often can lead to polarized
- 18:05rhetoric in action.
- 18:06You kind of touched on this already.
- 18:08But do you think that the moral incentives require a unique approach to breaking versus
- 18:14just the regular incentives for winning elections?
- 18:16Some people are just like, I'm just doing whatever can get me the most votes.
- 18:20Whereas some people, it's like, well, I have a moral imperative to do to obviously, they don't
- 18:26think they're being divisive, but they they do act divisively because they think it's a moral
- 18:32imperative to stand for what they believe in.
- 18:34So is there a unique approach to breaking the moral incentives versus the simple winning
- 18:38elections incentives?
- 18:40And in any case, how do we break those moral incentives in particular?
- 18:45So you don't necessarily break the moral incentive.
- 18:48We all have the moral impetus that sort of driving force within it.
- 18:54And what you really don't want to be doing is competing with the moral incentive, with the
- 18:58moral imperative.
- 18:59Driving trying to drive another moral imperative against the moral imperative.
- 19:03Because guess what?
- 19:04I've seen so many bridging organizations can fail to capture the audience they're capable of
- 19:10because they present this as, let's be civil.
- 19:13Let's emphasize the importance of getting along with one another, of listening to one another,
- 19:20of being patient.
- 19:21And let's honor that virtue.
- 19:24And, okay, people will see that as a virtue.
- 19:27Now, is that more valuable to you in your life than the plight of immigrants?
- 19:32Or the future of abortion rights?
- 19:36Or the economy, or the sanctity of our institutions, or whatever else it may be.
- 19:42You don't want to just place another moral imperative and see who wins.
- 19:47It is, again, saying, alright.
- 19:49We get that you want to do good.
- 19:52You want to do good as a communicator, as a relationship builder, and, you know, advocate
- 19:58to those who are willing to listen to you, who you have time to engage with.
- 20:03You want to do good as a participant in the democratic process, or whatever pathway is open
- 20:09to you to impact sort of policy outcomes.
- 20:14If you make the case that the best way to get at all of those things is through the means of
- 20:22bridging, is through the means of reaching out, engaging, listening, that is a completely
- 20:28different equation.
- 20:29That is saying, hey.
- 20:31This same moral impetus, this same imperative that you see no other recourse with or no other
- 20:41solution to seeking out other than, you know, just fight harder, fight harder, yell louder,
- 20:49this can actually be served through these means, then you're operating on a completely
- 20:55different level.
- 20:56And positioning these more positive behaviors as means to the same end, to making your voice
- 21:02heard, ultimately.
- 21:04That is how we kind of drive those, not again, not destroy the moral imperative, but drive it
- 21:11towards something more positive.
- 21:13Break might have been the not quite the right word.
- 21:17I wasn't I couldn't really think of the word I wanted to use, but that's just kind of what I
- 21:20went with.
- 21:21But I think that's a good point to make is it's it's kind of more about you're not even really
- 21:27I guess you're not even really changing the moral incentives per se.
- 21:31You're just trying to divert more of the focus to trying to think of how to how to put this,
- 21:36but you're kind of changing what moral incentives they're actually focusing on, I
- 21:41guess.
- 21:41The moral you know, when you say you you brought up with how bridge building groups, and
- 21:48I and I agree with this idea is that a lot of them focus too much on the well, if we just
- 21:54make the case for why it's better to empathize with people and to hear people out that
- 21:59eventually we're going to break through people.
- 22:01And it's just that's just I mean, it might work for some people, but it's not gonna make as
- 22:07much of a of of headway as we would like it to.
- 22:11You have to still contend with the fact that there's these moral incenses.
- 22:17People are very stuck in them, so it's it's you can't really completely change their moral
- 22:24views.
- 22:24Very, very rare that that kind of thing happens, but there is definitely a better way
- 22:30to shift their focus of, well, well, how about the moral imperative of working together and
- 22:36how it's actually makes your moral goals more achievable if you at least talk to people
- 22:44versus just try to railroad things in.
- 22:46Because like you said a question or two ago, you have the the pendulum, and I, you know, I I
- 22:53talk about this a lot today.
- 22:54The pendulum is inevitably gonna swing back and forth between each party.
- 22:58It's just how it works.
- 22:59For Republicans, they've right now, they they've gotten a little overconfident before.
- 23:06Democrats have gotten a little overconfident, and then eventually, the pendulum just keeps
- 23:11swinging back and forth.
- 23:12One one side gets a little too complacent and comfortable, and then all of a sudden, the
- 23:18other party comes back.
- 23:19And I think that just the overall focus on trying to be morally consistent is it's it's
- 23:26not winning you consistently.
- 23:29It's not leading to any sort of long term solutions because even if you do implement a,
- 23:33quote, unquote, justified policy, eventually, you're going to lose, and then the next group
- 23:39is going to change that policy, at least at the federal levels.
- 23:42A lot of states don't necessarily have that kind of swing, but it's also it's not just
- 23:47politicians and interest groups and some voters who are incentivized to be polarized.
- 23:52Social media and traditional media outlets also have incentive to pander to these politically
- 23:58siloed groups and generally propagate incendiary content.
- 24:03So what are some ways and this is obviously a very difficult thing to do, but what are some
- 24:10ways that we can turn the tide where these outlets become less incentivized to promote
- 24:15outrage content and clickbait?
- 24:19With that, I think you have to make a a more positive product, something that people will
- 24:27enjoy for other reasons than than just the truth or accuracy of it, which is there, which
- 24:36is a big part of the appeal.
- 24:37But if if you're just kind of policy wonking it up, you're going to have a limited audience.
- 24:43That is not something where you can entirely affect people's behavior there.
- 24:48And they're going to gravitate to what is appealing and what is enjoyable in and of
- 24:54itself.
- 24:55There are media that lend themselves a lot more to conversation and thoughtfulness and nuance.
- 25:02And I would throw podcasts as one of the best media for that.
- 25:09I would also say that in the same way that The Division builds on itself, once you start to
- 25:16deflate it, and once you start to spread this idea that, yeah, maybe we don't have to like,
- 25:23we're not actually getting anything by going at each other in this way.
- 25:27This is undermining us, and it under serves us, and it pulls us back as communicators and all
- 25:32of this to engage in politics this way and it's deeply unhealthy, then that sort of builds on
- 25:39itself as well.
- 25:40And so you need to get that initial momentum going.
- 25:42You need to really catalyze that and and push that forward.
- 25:49And eventually, you can see you can see a dramatic shift is my belief and my hope with
- 25:54it.
- 25:56Yeah.
- 25:56And I I think so much of it because these social media companies and traditional media
- 26:03outlets are or social media companies are not gonna change their algorithms and traditional
- 26:07media outlets because of how fractured the media space is.
- 26:11They're really not going to change their attitudes and their approaches until the
- 26:16consumer changes their approaches.
- 26:18But that's that's that's where the rub is.
- 26:21It's how do you get consumers to change their approach?
- 26:24And that's something I've I've wrestled with quite a bit myself trying to tell trying to get
- 26:29people to understand that we're going to have to change how we consume things if we want
- 26:35these companies to change.
- 26:36But that's a very easy thing to say.
- 26:37How do you get people to change their things?
- 26:39Because all of us are susceptible to doom scrolling.
- 26:42All of us are susceptible to we see something that is purposely meant to make us angry, and
- 26:47then we even if we don't comment and we don't share it, we still might spend another few
- 26:54seconds on that that that content, and then now the algorithm sees, oh, well, now they're
- 27:01spending more time watching these things, and then you just propagate that even more.
- 27:05So it's obviously much easier said than done.
- 27:08But I think a lot of it does have to start with the people first.
- 27:11And I'm very reluctant to say that, you know, the government has to do this, that, and the
- 27:14other because it's always easy to say that, but, you know, how exactly is the government
- 27:20going to implement those kinds of things?
- 27:22It's it's a very when you get into the details of how that would happen, that's when things
- 27:27start to get murky, and then now is the government taking too much initiative to say
- 27:33how these media companies should be giving giving content to people.
- 27:41But something I wanna get to because obviously, talked about at the top that you're a campaign
- 27:46consultant and strategist.
- 27:47You run Unifier Consulting.
- 27:49So I wanna get a little bit more into that because you've been heavily involved in the
- 27:53independent slash third party space in politics because of the work you do with Unifier
- 27:58Consulting.
- 27:59They also used to direct the Florida Forward Party.
- 28:02We were both Floridians.
- 28:03So your work with Unifier Consulting or, yeah, Unifier Consulting is primarily catered to
- 28:10independent and third party candidates, but you also say on your website that you are willing
- 28:15to work with republicans and democrats who basically aren't hardcore partisan and
- 28:19ideologues and those that are trying to build bridges.
- 28:23So I wanna focus a bit more on the in independence part, though, and you you talked
- 28:28some about some of it in our first conversation we had on here.
- 28:33Does disincentivizing polarization toxicity require more independence to be competitive and
- 28:41win elections in The US, or is that putting the cart before the horse, or is that really
- 28:46besides the point?
- 28:49I think it's putting the horse before the cart, and I think that these are deeply intertwined
- 28:56objectives because bringing the independence to the table the way that I like to think about
- 29:02it, the way that I like to talk about it is the conversation is not functional.
- 29:07The conversation is not working.
- 29:09And rather than tell those people who are having this conversation, and I'm talking about
- 29:15the discourse that is happening within the halls of power, to quiet down or get along with
- 29:20each other.
- 29:21One of the most natural solutions is bring new voices into the conversation, and that is the
- 29:26mediating force that is the independent movement.
- 29:30And the dynamics that that creates, the dynamics that it takes away are really
- 29:35profound.
- 29:36And one of the biggest things is if you can have enough independence, and this is what we
- 29:42talk about as the fulcrum strategy.
- 29:45And it's often thought of through this lens of, well, you get leverage if you have enough
- 29:51independence to deny either party a majority.
- 29:54But there is something else that it does, which is it kind of liberates the parties from the
- 30:00very worst incentives that they're prone to now, and that they're susceptible to now, which
- 30:06is this constant fear of the other side taking power.
- 30:11If you have this meeting in force and you say, look, the Republicans aren't going to take
- 30:16power.
- 30:16The Democrats aren't going to take power.
- 30:18No one is going to have unchecked absolute control.
- 30:21That's off the table.
- 30:22One, if you can establish that, then that cudgel of this fear of the other side, this
- 30:30sort of divisive politics that comes from this zero sum two player game that falls naturally
- 30:38from the incentives that are in place now, it falls apart as a strategy.
- 30:44It no longer works.
- 30:45And you can't tap into that, so you just have to find other ways to get elected, and other
- 30:50ways to compete.
- 30:51And suddenly, you're being held accountable, and you're facing real competition in places
- 30:55you haven't before.
- 30:57And that means you have to get real politics done.
- 31:01That means you have to get real problem solving done.
- 31:05And that is the fundamental incentive shift that you have through the presence of the
- 31:10independent movement.
- 31:12And ultimately, that is trying to drive toward it's not about the independents gaining power.
- 31:17It is about driving the whole thing to a conversation that is additive, that is
- 31:22constructive, and that is productive, and allows us to have responsive governance that
- 31:28authentically represents the people.
- 31:31I I would always vouch for more competition, whether it's you know, I'm I'm not I don't
- 31:37argue whether or not we should or shouldn't have more independence, but I think the options
- 31:42should be there.
- 31:43And I think the options within the parties need to be more generally speaking, more options is
- 31:48is better.
- 31:49Now, obviously, there can be such a thing as too many candidates, and some of them are just
- 31:54not serious candidates.
- 31:57But, obviously, that's that's partly in the eyes of the beholder too.
- 32:00But I I will say to play a little bit of devil's advocate, I think you do still also
- 32:05have to contend with the fact that and and a friend and colleague of mine actually, I've had
- 32:11him as a guest on this show a couple months back.
- 32:14But he he he talked about some research that that showed that even when you take moderates,
- 32:22the really hardcore partisans still see moderates as basically closeted outsiders.
- 32:27So, like, a republican will see independents primarily as, oh, well, they're just really
- 32:32democrats, and they're gonna help democrats.
- 32:34And democrats will see them as, well, they're just really Republicans, and they're just gonna
- 32:37help Republicans.
- 32:38And I think that's part of another it's it's one of those other fronts of how do you get
- 32:43people to, a, not not, you know, not treat moderates inherently with derisiveness.
- 32:50And and and to an extent, you do have to be careful not to treat extremists that way too
- 32:54because then they'll just become more extreme.
- 32:56But how do you get them to not just see moderates as just spoilers or, oh, well,
- 33:03they're just they're really actually helping the other side because they're not us.
- 33:07Because they're not far enough to us.
- 33:09They're way more liberal than we really think they are.
- 33:12They're way more conservative than they really think they are.
- 33:15So I I do think there is still some of that mindset that you have to get past too.
- 33:21But I guess we already touched on this question, but I'll I'll ask it more directly
- 33:26this time.
- 33:27Do you think some reformers who are working in the bridge building and depolarization space
- 33:31get too focused on the normative moral arguments for why we should depolarize without
- 33:36sufficiently addressing the incentives and the structural issues that make that polarization
- 33:42more enticing?
- 33:45Yes.
- 33:46I will also add one element to that, which is they talk about the way things should be quite
- 33:53a bit, and I understand that.
- 33:56I also think a lot about how things should be.
- 34:00But one of the biggest roadblocks, and you touched on it, you know, in assessing kind of
- 34:07what independence face or what different candidates face, is this notion of viability.
- 34:13Is this kind of notion of, like, okay.
- 34:18Good luck with that.
- 34:19Where people perceive you as a dreamer.
- 34:21People perceive you as being indulgent.
- 34:23If you were just thinking about, hey, it would be great if we could get along.
- 34:27It would be great if we had this kind of leadership that was responsive, or if we had 15
- 34:32parties and this and that.
- 34:34And it's like, I I don't have time for this.
- 34:37I need to focus on what is affecting life right now, on what is affecting my cost of living, on
- 34:44what is affecting these people that I care deeply about.
- 34:49And I get that.
- 34:51And I think you have to be strategic, you have to be practical, you have to lay out not why it
- 34:56should work in a perfect world, whatever your strategy is that you're putting forward, but
- 35:03why it is a working strategy, why it's going to work.
- 35:06And without that, it's just going to fall on deaf ears and for very understandable reasons.
- 35:15And I think that goes back, and this is not just an independent thing.
- 35:18There's people who are not necessarily extreme in the parties, but are still pretty pretty
- 35:24staunch advocates for Republicans or Democrats where especially in campaigning where they just
- 35:30think, well, if we make the strongest argument, people are going to eventually see our point of
- 35:35view.
- 35:35Even in a district that is way lopsided against them, they think well, you they sometimes they
- 35:40think, you know what?
- 35:41It's it's because these other people just haven't made the right arguments.
- 35:44I'm going to make the right argument and get people to to understand.
- 35:49And, I mean, yes, every so often, you get a few people that are actually hearing you out, but
- 35:56the vast majority, it does not work like that where you just, oh, if you make the right
- 35:59argument, if you make the correct argument, people are gonna see your point of view.
- 36:03That's and for as easily malleable as we all can be, as the human mind can be, we also don't
- 36:10just turn on a whim like that just because you came up with a really good speech.
- 36:14And I bet I I agree with you that I do think and not not to rag on them, but I hope our
- 36:21fellow bridge builders do take that into account that it's just you know, there's only
- 36:26so much that these normative moral arguments can do to convince people.
- 36:31You have to show that it works, and you have to show that it does benefit these polarized
- 36:36voices.
- 36:37But speaking of which, more polarized voters have a lot more incentive to vote and
- 36:43participate in politics than those who are less polarized or even maybe not really polarized at
- 36:48all or barely to one way or the other.
- 36:52So we see this outsized influence from the more divided segments of the electorate because
- 36:56they're participating in a much higher rate.
- 36:58So how do we incentivize more of these nonpolarized voters who tend to not have strong
- 37:04attachments to parties, ideologies, issue stances.
- 37:07They may they may have just tuned out politics because they just they don't wanna deal with it
- 37:12because it's just too toxic, or maybe they just haven't cared enough about it or whatever the
- 37:17case may be.
- 37:17How do we convince more of these less polarized voters or non polarized voters to start
- 37:22participating in politics more often?
- 37:28I mean, you put better candidates out there.
- 37:32You put people that, you know, a, you're bringing what I like to call puppies to the
- 37:39table, which is messaging that is pertinent, unifying, positive, pragmatic, innovative,
- 37:45empowering, self aware.
- 37:46These are the ways that you kind of break from the mold of political convention and break from
- 37:52what I think a lot of people are tired of seeing.
- 37:55Those are the facets of how you want to stand out.
- 37:58At the same time as that, you want to really make this case a viability, and that is not
- 38:04something that an individual candidate is completely responsible for themselves.
- 38:09It's the movement and the successes that we find that can make people who've kind of given
- 38:14up on politics say, I can can actually make a difference here.
- 38:19My vote matters here.
- 38:20Oh, this is this could be something.
- 38:23And it's the impact messaging.
- 38:25It's understanding the implications of this and really sung people on.
- 38:29It's not just bluster.
- 38:31It's not just what you promised.
- 38:32It's you you are actually in a position to get stuff done.
- 38:36And at the end of the day, people have other things to do than vote.
- 38:41People have their lives to live.
- 38:42People have their jobs to do.
- 38:44And you need to have the mindset.
- 38:48And the other thing for independents, look, Republicans, they know that the Republican
- 38:56voters are on their team, more or less.
- 38:58They can break with it.
- 38:59They can they can lose that support.
- 39:02They can, you know, not get the turnout they want.
- 39:04All that, they're still on the same team.
- 39:07Independent voters and independent candidates, it's not that dynamic.
- 39:11You are not entitled to any of their vote by being an independent.
- 39:15You have to earn it.
- 39:16And it's that mindset, and that kind of ethos of really making people feel heard, letting
- 39:23them speak rather than speaking for them, that I think is it gets at the empowerment, which I
- 39:30think is one of the most powerful and most resonant and most needed elements of of
- 39:36political messaging to those who have tuned out for very understandable reasons from the
- 39:42political discourse.
- 39:44I like that puppies acronym.
- 39:46You should you should trademark them.
- 39:47Do do a specific article online, whether it's LinkedIn or Substack or whatever about that.
- 39:57I like that acronym.
- 39:58I think there's definitely something more.
- 40:00But yeah.
- 40:01And I think that's that last point you you just said about independence.
- 40:06It's it's something that I think and the book I wrote back in 2021 about independent candidates
- 40:12and why they struggle so much and how they could possibly become more competitive.
- 40:16I think there is and not just both within the independent sphere and from people who are not
- 40:22independents have this tendency to lump them in as a monolithic entity when not even the
- 40:30parties as even though they're becoming increasingly uniform where Republicans are
- 40:35thinking more and more alike, Democrats are thinking more and more alike, even they are not
- 40:39monoliths either.
- 40:40And independents most certainly are not either.
- 40:42And sometimes there's just this tendency to treat them all as, you know, the same entity
- 40:47when they're when people have a million different reasons for why they identify as
- 40:53independents.
- 40:55And I think that is very valuable advice to give people who do wanna run as independents is
- 41:00you you can't treat them the same way as Republicans would treat Republican voters and
- 41:04Democrats would treat Democratic voters.
- 41:06You have to really understand why they are an independent before you can really hone in on
- 41:13their vote.
- 41:15And so before we get to the final segment of this interview, any final thoughts you'd like
- 41:20to leave us with about disincentivizing polarization, excessive partisanship, toxicity,
- 41:26anything along those lines?
- 41:28I mean, the last thing is this is how I left off my book, which is addressing this question
- 41:36of should we be optimistic about things, about the way that it's going to go?
- 41:42And the last segment, the conclusion of my book, Common Ground from the Ground Up, which
- 41:47talks about how we kind of can rethink politics to to break from these destructive incentives.
- 41:56It ends with a case against optimism.
- 41:58And it ends with saying that the thinking that everything's going to be okay in the end,
- 42:05everything's going to be great, this is going to pass, takes away our agency.
- 42:11We can make a difference.
- 42:12We can make an impact.
- 42:13And you anyone listening to this who is just having conversations with a few friends and
- 42:19family around them, who has limited time to devote to this, you can make more of an impact
- 42:25than you realize by the way that you approach those conversations, by the things you say, by
- 42:30the words you pass along, by the recommendations that you give for people to buy
- 42:35common ground from the ground up on Amazon.
- 42:38Those things make a big difference.
- 42:41And little bit of a shameless plug at the end, but there's some shame there.
- 42:47So I'm happy with myself.
- 42:49No.
- 42:49That's alright.
- 42:50No.
- 42:50It didn't you don't need to have shame about it.
- 42:52I mean, I'm I'm gonna include that in the in the show notes.
- 42:55You had a an article called you have to burn the rope.
- 42:58You why don't you tell us about that a little bit?
- 43:01So that is really getting at my theory of change and getting at the unwinnability.
- 43:06A lot of the things we've touched on, which is the unwinnable nature of the partisan tug of
- 43:11war, and how we kind of end that game.
- 43:14We end that zero sum two player game by bringing the independents into the equation,
- 43:20And that's already happening in a lot of places.
- 43:22And that is where I think I base a lot of my work and why a lot of what I'm trying to do in
- 43:32coalescing, organizing, and furthering the independent movement, why that follows from
- 43:37just these fundamental concerns about where we're going and how we're getting there.
- 43:45Gotcha.
- 43:45Yeah.
- 43:45And I I will I will also link that in the show notes as well.
- 43:49I I remember what it was now.
- 43:51You you you said you argued against optimism, and I wouldn't say I would push back on that,
- 43:56but I I I do think you need some level of optimism.
- 43:59And that's and that's coming from somebody I I would not call myself an optimist.
- 44:04I'm actually more pessimistic a lot of times than I should be.
- 44:07But I was just thinking about how sometimes I do hear people say that because polarization is
- 44:14not new in this country.
- 44:16It's it's been around pretty much the entire time.
- 44:19It's just kinda had ebbs and flows.
- 44:21And so you do need to recognize that this isn't now how high it is is not exact is not exactly
- 44:28usual.
- 44:29I mean, the only comparable time arguably that you could talk about was when the civil war
- 44:35happened when we actually became two different countries.
- 44:38But I think it is an important point that you do bring up is that you really shouldn't don't
- 44:43just assume things will get better.
- 44:45If if you if too many people start assuming that, like you said, then people are are gonna
- 44:49lose their agency.
- 44:50They're not going to do anything about it.
- 44:52So you you should have optimism that you can make things better and that things will get
- 44:57better, but you can't just assume it's going to happen.
- 45:00So I wouldn't say I'm pushing back on what you said, but I I I would add that caveat.
- 45:06But that is going to do it for the main topic of this episode.
- 45:10So you this this part will be familiar to you, Nathan.
- 45:13But for those of you who are well, for you, if you're a new listener or you're a returning
- 45:18listener, every guest episode I have, I will end off with a random question of the day.
- 45:23It's meant to be just fun, nonpolitical, or if it is political, it's not it's it's not gonna
- 45:29be anything, like, super serious or anything like that.
- 45:31I don't remember what what our first question of the day with you was, but today's random
- 45:37question of the day for you, mister Smolensky, is is it pronounced coupon or coupon?
- 45:45For me, coupon is so much more fun to say.
- 45:47It's just it's almost you know, there is to segue into some of the destructive incentives
- 45:57that we have, just hearing that almost makes me want to say it more.
- 46:02Well, I changed your answer.
- 46:03Those are just based desires.
- 46:05That is Internet trolling in a nutshell, and it's this big red button that you can press.
- 46:10And, I mean, I I like to speak with flavor.
- 46:14I don't want to go so far as to fake accents, but I've noticed myself sometimes if I'm doing
- 46:21a speech or if I'm with people, I'll get a little more of a draw going.
- 46:27Yeah.
- 46:27And it's just it's fun to accentuate.
- 46:29It's fun to sort of you know, this gets into a great kind of broader discussion about
- 46:37language, which is, you know, is there a right or wrong way to say it?
- 46:41And there was this movement for a long time within the English language in particular to
- 46:46view this kind of Midwestern style of speaking English as the most neutral American English.
- 46:53And for me, there's just there's so much joy in especially as you learn the language more and
- 47:00just salt and pepper it with, you know, weird expressions or offbeat pronunciations or just a
- 47:08little spice.
- 47:09And so, yeah, coupon.
- 47:11Coupon it is.
- 47:12You know, I didn't I didn't I didn't expect some so much of a philosophical bent to this
- 47:16question, but I well, there you go.
- 47:19I I I look.
- 47:20Listen.
- 47:20I am not against adding a little flash and pizzazz to two words, but, like, come on, man.
- 47:26There's an o before the u.
- 47:27That that just that does does not feel right.
- 47:30It's a it's a coupon.
- 47:31You know?
- 47:32And I actually had this question already planned when I was preparing to have you on.
- 47:37But just a few hours before recording, I just I I went to my therapist, and then she they
- 47:44actually that she said coupon.
- 47:46And, obviously, I didn't say anything, but in my head, I was like, this is the this is the
- 47:50random question I'm gonna ask on how somehow this this has somehow popped up in my
- 47:55appointment here.
- 47:56Well, I'm I'm I'm not gonna pretend there's necessarily a rhyme or reason to whether when I
- 48:01think a word should have a specific pronunciation or not, but but yeah.
- 48:05Yeah.
- 48:05There's you gotta get there.
- 48:07You got a little bit of a philosophy lesson in in linguistics there.
- 48:10So you're getting everything in this podcast episode.
- 48:13But that will wrap things up here for today's episode.
- 48:17Oh, actually, quick.
- 48:19Besides the the besides your book and besides your new article on Substack, and then I'll
- 48:26I'll obviously put a link to Unifier Consulting.
- 48:28Is there any other are there any other links you wanna share?
- 48:33Just follow my work.
- 48:34I show up time to time.
- 48:37I've got a few articles coming out on the fulcrum, so just watch out for those in the
- 48:42coming coming weeks.
- 48:43And I also publish on Independent Voter News.
- 48:48That's IVN.
- 48:49And, yeah, keep following the independent movement and get in touch with me.
- 48:53Get in touch with your local candidate, and let's build something special together.
- 49:01Alrighty then.
- 49:01Well, if if I if you if you give any any of those to me before I post this episode, I'll
- 49:07also put them in the show notes so you you you all will be able to look at them there.
- 49:12For my notes, my other works, like my my writings on medium.com, my my own book about
- 49:19independence, why they rarely win elections, and how they become more competitive is on
- 49:23Amazon and several other book retailers, but the the Amazon links will be will be there.
- 49:30And my five day educational email course that talks a lot about what we just talked about
- 49:35today, the five of the biggest mistakes we make when it comes to trying to depolarize politics
- 49:41and how we can fix those mistakes.
- 49:43And my links, my LinkedIn profile, my Facebook page, my website, Paul Raider dot org, and my
- 49:51email, PaulRaiderwrites@Gmail.com.
- 49:53And that's where we're going to end things.
- 49:55So once again, thank you so much for all of you for listening and watching, and we'll see you
- 50:01next time.