Latest / Inside Commerce: Ecommerce Strategy, CX and Technology Podcast / EP162: Commercetools Chief Strategy Officer Kelly Goetsch on Product Strategy, Mid-Market & B2B
Transcript
- 0:02Thanks for tuning into the re-platform podcast sponsored by
- 0:04attraction. Hypersonics, you're listening to
- 0:06the ungodly voice of me. James GERD and the silky patwari
- 0:10of my co-host. Paul Rodgers, how are you mate?
- 0:13Yeah, good thanks. How are you doing?
- 0:14Yeah, I'll know I'm interested in this because both you and our
- 0:18wonderful guest today, a mildly broken off the back of NRF in
- 0:22the US. Whereas I feel positively
- 0:24radiant in comparison for the world.
- 0:26Yeah, yeah, we'll see how I got on my got back in.
- 0:30Four hours ago from the u.s. except hopefully I'll survive.
- 0:33Yes, good. So dear listeners.
- 0:35We are going to break pool today and thanks for tuning back in.
- 0:38And if this is the first time on the podcast, thank you to give
- 0:41us a chance. We hope you enjoyed the content.
- 0:43Do subscribe to get new alerts. We drop them every week and we
- 0:46love a like on YouTube Spotify. Apple Amazon Etc, makes us feel
- 0:50better about our insecure and Tiny lives.
- 0:53So let's let's introduce the topic.
- 0:55And then I'll hand over to our guest.
- 0:56So interesting, one, continuing our theme of really getting
- 0:59deep. Plugs into some of the leading
- 1:01e-commerce vendors and Technologies out in the
- 1:03platform. We're catching up with, with
- 1:05Commerce tools to Commerce tools are really interesting story of
- 1:08the past. Four years been pushing very
- 1:10heavily in the Enterprise space and really big brands.
- 1:13Have been adopting it. Yeah, it's part of the
- 1:18composable side of the Commerce platforms.
- 1:21API driven package business capabilities.
- 1:26A lot of flexibility suton suit in different organizations.
- 1:29Who would Go down the route of like a prepackaged sash
- 1:32solution. For example, so we're speaking
- 1:34today with Commerce tools is Chief strategy officer about
- 1:38their go-to-market strategy views on the, mid-market,
- 1:42including shopify's. Recent announcement in that
- 1:44space core product focus and key capabilities like B2B and
- 1:47pricing and roadmap. So warm, welcome to cadie gay.
- 1:51She's Chief strategy officer, hi Kelly.
- 1:53Hey thanks for having me really, really looking forward to seeing
- 1:57it. Enjoying your start, the air
- 1:59updates on LinkedIn. As well.
- 2:01And I know that. So you got interesting
- 2:03background, your co-founder of the Mac Alliance, you're also a
- 2:06fellow podcaster, you're on your own Commerce tomorrow podcast.
- 2:08So, before we start grilling you, with questions of compost,
- 2:11or do you want to give people a flavor who you are?
- 2:13And I like, how do you position comments tools when people ask
- 2:16for the his sure actually started my career back with atg
- 2:22in the early 2000s, which for those who aren't aware was the
- 2:25leading Commerce platform and it was very much called a platform
- 2:28back then. And I was the Professional
- 2:31Services, Architects are launched a lot of the big 8, EG
- 2:34customers in a production at that time doing a lot of
- 2:36architecture deployment work. I did a lot of Maximum
- 2:41availability architecture. So active active, deployments,
- 2:45really love the technology side of this business and then my
- 2:48wife and I had our first child and I couldn't be traveling
- 2:51every single week, although actually ironically travel
- 2:54probably more now than I ever did.
- 2:56But that, that irony aside I thought I would get a job with
- 3:01Oracle as a product manager and travel a lot less.
- 3:06So I spent five years at Oracle, I led some of the earlier Cloud
- 3:10products there and mount last year there.
- 3:12I really, I really took ownership of microservices loves
- 3:17to beginners, should have their thoroughly enjoyed,
- 3:19microservices intellectually and I thought there's somebody out
- 3:24there who's got to be doing Commerce, cloud in micro
- 3:25services. And by that point, I had written
- 3:27e-commerce in the cloud for a Riley.
- 3:30And it was just a very natural fit for me to find someone who
- 3:34is really innovating. And I found this small German
- 3:36company which at the time had 75 employees, you know, very
- 3:42heavily weighted towards Professional Services but they
- 3:44had at the time fantastic products.
- 3:47And it's obviously only gotten better since then, I joined as a
- 3:51chief product officer. So I was the still live in the
- 3:56US but I was the third us employee.
- 4:00And at a global role still do. But anyway, I was part of a team
- 4:06that really took Commerce tools on the Enterprise.
- 4:09So I led product management built product management.
- 4:13Let it let design Ops development for a little while,
- 4:19product marketing. Did a lot of everything, you
- 4:21know, in a company that size that's kind of what you do you
- 4:25pitch in and, you know, the lot of responsibility and I very
- 4:28much enjoyed it. I was in that role for six years
- 4:33and then this past summer, we forked my role.
- 4:36So we have Mike Sharpe now as our Scipio, great guy really
- 4:41really experienced. And I'm doing more of the
- 4:44external side of Commerce tools. So a lot of corporate
- 4:48development type work, Acquisitions working with our
- 4:52investors, working with analysts are going to trade shows
- 4:58speaking. I do it.
- 4:59Little bit of everything, it feels like.
- 5:01But you know, when you're a 700 plus person company, I guess you
- 5:05can specialize a little bit more which is, which has been fun.
- 5:10Right. Okay.
- 5:11Well, I'll ask question. And one thing that you did, say
- 5:14that about both make DJ. I do find it crazy.
- 5:18How many of the kind of veterans and he comes face of come out of
- 5:21that company? Yeah, I know a few people that
- 5:24are in the early Commerce days and yeah, it just feels like so
- 5:28many different people than came from a TJ and so on to tell
- 5:33their tracks Talent, really, you know, you end up with these,
- 5:36these these Talent hubs and it just The more smart people, you
- 5:41bring together and attracts more smart people, and they do good
- 5:43things and then you need more of those smart people.
- 5:46So yes, atg was very much a hub and and RF.
- 5:51There's an 80, g meet up, that's done every year.
- 5:54That's always fun and you get together with old atg alums.
- 5:57And in a lot of really strong sea level execs cross the
- 6:01industry. You know, people have really
- 6:03gone out and done things from that, and I think it was kind of
- 6:05the right time to be in the space because it was so early in
- 6:08the Enterprise Commerce space. So if you were, you know,
- 6:12relatively senior at atg you could then write your own ticket
- 6:15and do something really interesting as Cloud then became
- 6:18a thing. Yeah.
- 6:20Absolutely. So your answer the first
- 6:23question, so for that for our listeners that I guess a new to
- 6:26Commerce tool, don't know much around kind of the proposition
- 6:30and go-to-market strategy. How does the current Commerce
- 6:33tools? Go to market strategy look, is
- 6:36it that you kind of only integrate by RSI partners?
- 6:40And how does this look or how will this change going forward
- 6:43and in 22? So we only Implement through, as
- 6:48our partners, or the customers, do it themselves.
- 6:51So, of all of our 700, something employees, we have, we have
- 6:56three and Professional Services. If that says something and
- 7:00that's their just provide, high-level architecture,
- 7:03guidance. You know, few pointers in the
- 7:05right direction. So we're will support our
- 7:08customers but not really do like Hands-On work.
- 7:11That's not our business model. Our business model is very much
- 7:13to enable our customers. Emerson and enable our partners
- 7:16to deliver and going back kind of the founding story of
- 7:20Commerce tools because I do think it's relevant.
- 7:23Commerce tools is actually started as the world's first
- 7:27hybrid systems integrator. So for those are not in the
- 7:32space hybrids was bought by sap. It was kind of the dominant
- 7:35platform next to 80 g there for a while.
- 7:38And the First Commerce to his office is Rex Lee in the hybris
- 7:42office. So sublet and there's a lot of
- 7:45History between the two companies and that was a great
- 7:48business that was successful business from 2006 onwards.
- 7:53And when Dirk started doing that, and team started doing
- 7:56that 2006, the world's changed really, really quickly in those
- 8:00subsequent years. So, we had the launch of the
- 8:03iPhone in 2007, real public cloud in 2008, the public Cloud
- 8:08gave rise to things like microservices, gave rise to
- 8:12Eventing. Nosql databases, you know, all
- 8:14these things that we know, See as modern and default for
- 8:17Building Products, we also saw the rise of rest apis in a rest
- 8:22apis were first invented in 2000, but never really took off
- 8:25until the App Store. And when iOS really started to
- 8:30take off, we also saw the rise of social media, you know, For
- 8:34Better or Worse, depending on how you look at it, but social
- 8:37media really became a thing in those couple of years and it
- 8:41just generally the world changed a lot.
- 8:43You know, that was those were very five, very Pivotal years
- 8:46there between 2006 and 2011 in 2011, Dirk decided to sell off
- 8:53the Consulting side of the business, which he did and
- 8:57completely changed to products. So, from 2011 to 13 built.
- 9:02What we now know as Commerce tools and took that to Market
- 9:05and really did a hard pivot to Enterprise in 2016 and we're
- 9:10very different from our competitors and a couple key
- 9:14respects first We have a relatively narrow surface area
- 9:18and we go very, very deep on that functionality.
- 9:22So a lot of our competitors out there.
- 9:23Are they offer Commerce? Yes.
- 9:26But they also offer a CMS. They offer search and
- 9:30Merchandising they offer a CD P. They offer Marketplace that have
- 9:35an integration platform as a service.
- 9:37They have you know you name it. They have everything in the box
- 9:41and I think that's fine if you're selling to a smaller
- 9:44business, you know, maybe Somebody, he's doing less than
- 9:4625 million in and, and gmv a year.
- 9:49I think that approach works just fine, but a lot of them are
- 9:52trying to sell that to Enterprise and I'm a big
- 9:54believer that now, in the Enterprise space mock is really
- 9:58a thing, which stands for micro Services, apis cloud, and help
- 10:02us. And there are all these great
- 10:04new vendors out there that do one thing.
- 10:06And one thing really, really well, you know, so Commerce
- 10:09tools on the Commerce side, you know, we have so many great
- 10:12Partners on the search side, you know, ungoliant.
- 10:15Instructor, you know, Clay, vu's popular as well.
- 10:19We have on the content side, you know, content, stock contentful,
- 10:25and plans ego. But, I mean, you know, even on
- 10:28the pen side, you know, bluestones doing really well.
- 10:30These days, there are so many good vendors out there that are
- 10:34really specialized in other two, three, four, five hundred people
- 10:38and they just do one thing really, really well.
- 10:40So it's really easy to mix and match and our philosophy at
- 10:43Commerce tools is we do the Core Commerce pieces.
- 10:47So product catalog, anything related to customers pricing
- 10:49promotion, check out. We do that.
- 10:52Corbett really well, go really deep on it and then we have
- 10:56best-of-breed Partners in our ecosystem who are able to offer
- 11:01a complete solution to our customers.
- 11:03So that's one difference is just focus.
- 11:05You know, we're not trying to do everything, we're very much
- 11:07trying to do one thing really, really well.
- 11:11Another thing is, I like to say we're commoditized, And I think
- 11:16a lot of people have an allergic reaction to the word commodity,
- 11:19but I think it really makes sense.
- 11:21In this case, where we are that vendor at scale offering
- 11:25Commerce apis as a service and historically, Commerce platforms
- 11:30were not Commodities, right? They did a lot of battles over
- 11:33features and functions in rfp's, you know, they all had their own
- 11:37slight differentiation but but the major players on the market,
- 11:41you know. So us Salesforce, you know, all
- 11:44those major Vendors. We've all been on the market.
- 11:47Now, for North to 10 years, we all have roughly the same
- 11:49Benchmark of features and I would very much argue that
- 11:51Commerce is a commodity. We're also very on opinionated,
- 11:56and that separates us quite a bit.
- 11:58So, our general philosophy is, we've got some really cool apis,
- 12:03but we don't really care what you do with them.
- 12:04And the same way that will either, doesn't really care what
- 12:07you do with their apis. You know, they're not telling
- 12:10you what to build their, how to build it, and it's the same
- 12:12thing for us, we offer a great Set of developer tooling we have
- 12:18graphql support sdks, we have open documentation, open trials.
- 12:24And our philosophy is kind of like we have a box of Commerce
- 12:27tools. Go have fun with them.
- 12:28Do with them as you please. We're not going to tell you what
- 12:31had to put on. We're not going to tell you
- 12:33where you can call them from, you know, you kind of mix and
- 12:36match. So we're pretty different from
- 12:39our competitors and some of those really key aspects there,
- 12:43attract, you'll Complete product Discovery growth engine, create
- 12:48relevant shopping experiences that convert into sales and grow
- 12:51online Revenue with personalized, search
- 12:53merchandising, and recommendation Solutions powered
- 12:56by a I find out more at a tract.com Makes sense.
- 13:03And so the next question, I guess a lot of people would
- 13:06consider and as you say, you know, you've kind of focused
- 13:09last kind of five or six years on the Enterprise Market, I
- 13:11think a lot of people would see you as an Enterprise vendor
- 13:15competing against the likes of adobe and Salesforce and you
- 13:17know, some of the maybe more Legacy ones you mentioned
- 13:20earlier, the question here. So I've definitely seen cuts of
- 13:24up. I think James and I both do a
- 13:26lot in the mid Market space. I think we've both seen Commerce
- 13:29tools come up a lot more over the last couple.
- 13:31Of years in that space. Is that kind of, I guess a big
- 13:36Focus for you. Yeah and kind of like what's
- 13:40your view on? Kind of how you can sit in the
- 13:41middle? Well yes.
- 13:44So in a word yes, we're very much focusing on that market.
- 13:51Our ideal customer profile though is somebody who's not
- 13:55looking for a website in a box. You know, if we find ourselves
- 13:59competing head-to-head with say Shopify in a dido, then one of
- 14:03us is probably in the wrong room because we are such
- 14:06fundamentally different products going after different markets,
- 14:10different value props, different everything, So what we're
- 14:14finding and we've had a lot of success in the space is there
- 14:18are mid-market organizations which we Define as let's call
- 14:21it. 25 million in gmv all the way up through a billion and
- 14:25gmv. You know, that's what we
- 14:27Commerce tools would call mid-market.
- 14:29Where they say look, you know, we're outgrowing, Shopify,
- 14:31Aurora, growing Magento. We want something that we can
- 14:35grow into not grow out of And they might have a little bit
- 14:39more sophistication, you know. Maybe they already have an
- 14:42existing Pim and searched and they just want to slot Us in for
- 14:46Commerce. Maybe they're having a really
- 14:49good partner for example, you know that they can partner with
- 14:53that, would be helpful. So there are quite a few good
- 14:57partners out there that you know, that compliment Us in that
- 15:02mid market and the barrier to adoption here is actually pretty
- 15:06low, right? Because we're very standards
- 15:09rest-based apis. Easy to consume you know, for a
- 15:14lot of reasons it's it's a very enticing market for us and we've
- 15:18made some pretty substantial investments in it.
- 15:24Something there's definitely been interested in.
- 15:27Start the areas and I know that you've noticed as a common,
- 15:31today's shopify's attempt to move into that Enterprise space
- 15:34around the component based approach or more composed from
- 15:37base to Commerce and they, they've announced Shopify
- 15:39components. I'd love to know where your,
- 15:42where you'll see that the moment like our is Commerce tools
- 15:45seeing Shopify, as a potential direct competitor.
- 15:49If it involves that approach, are you seeing this as something
- 15:52different. It's just just Trying to to
- 15:54appeal to a different type of audience.
- 15:57What is this components think? I've never heard of it before.
- 16:02Yeah, sorry it was a joke, guys. Apparently, it's a future of
- 16:06Commerce base design. It will never catch on.
- 16:12So look Shopify, does a really good job but the low end of the
- 16:16market, you know, folks wanting a website in a box, you know, I
- 16:20have a niece and she's going to start a little jewelry business.
- 16:23I told her go to shopping if I you're not gonna find anything
- 16:26better, it's great for that segment of the market, they do
- 16:30have some customers in the plus section, right?
- 16:33So you go from Shopify to Shopify plus and you get a
- 16:37little bit more support. And I think for some of the
- 16:40especially digitally native vertical Brands, I think it's
- 16:43just fine. Right?
- 16:44It works. They have this new offering
- 16:47called components which as far as we can tell is largely
- 16:51marketing, but it's very similar to what we're doing.
- 16:53Doing. All right?
- 16:54I've called Our Stars are functionality, componentized for
- 16:58years. And the concept.
- 17:00There is sell individual pieces. And the reason that folks leave
- 17:06Shopify plus is because with Shopify plus, it's a very
- 17:10all-in-one platform both technically and commercially,
- 17:14right? So you can't just use them for
- 17:16checkout, only or for PIM only or whatever those pieces are
- 17:20right. And by at least from a marketing
- 17:23standpoint, it's the same product but at least from a
- 17:25marketing standpoint offering pieces helps prolong the
- 17:30lifespan of a Shopify Plus customer so I get why they're
- 17:33doing it. It makes perfect.
- 17:35Sentence, its great validation for us at Commerce tools because
- 17:39we really have a good product on the market and when it comes
- 17:41head-to-head, if it ever does maybe even won't, I'm not sure.
- 17:46I think we'll do really well there, but I think they need to
- 17:51fundamentally rewrite their platform.
- 17:53And I do call it a platform because it is a platform, they
- 17:56need to fundamentally rewrite that because it's still very
- 18:00monolithic behind the scenes for a marketing standpoint, it's
- 18:03great. I think they'll see Some value
- 18:05from it but I'm not concerned. I think it's good.
- 18:08Validation and good marketing. Good free marketing for us.
- 18:12Okay, I'm excited. And so, the next question, one
- 18:17that I wanted to get in, so I guess I've had quite a lot of
- 18:19feedback on Connors tools from different people.
- 18:21I know in the industry that are either working for brand.
- 18:24So integrating Commerce, tools or less.
- 18:26I don't think Alex. And I think like you say as like
- 18:30a fundamental difference between a Commerce tools, kind of
- 18:34platform versus some of the monolithic platforms.
- 18:38And I guess one thing that always comes up is kind of
- 18:40what's actually Within the admin, how you can compare
- 18:45Commerce tools to some of these monolithic platforms or even
- 18:48some of the other kind of Morehead look focused Solutions.
- 18:53Can you just talk us through? Kind of what I guess you would
- 18:56see as being core functionality within shop by around some of
- 18:59the kind of core functions. Within e-commerce.
- 19:02They like promotions catalog management, order management
- 19:05that kind of stuff. And how you see that differing
- 19:08from the rest? So we do basically product
- 19:14catalog. So that's anything you need for
- 19:16a product detail page, a category listing page.
- 19:22We do anything related to prices, inventory promotions,
- 19:27customer, login, account management, you know, you want
- 19:31to update your address, you want to update your preferred
- 19:33shipping method and then shopping cart anything there.
- 19:38And again, all these are standalone Moments.
- 19:41And then finally, check out. So we differentiate by again
- 19:45going really, really deep on those core bits of functionality
- 19:48and also offering them all a card because nobody has the risk
- 19:53appetite or budget or timeline to do a big bang replacement of
- 19:57whatever Legacy they have instead.
- 19:59They're incrementally adopting us piece by piece over time.
- 20:04That makes sense. And I guess just on some of
- 20:07those areas I would you would you say that your average
- 20:11customer would typically use a pimp.
- 20:13For example I like a promotions engine and is it a case of I
- 20:17guess having some of that base functionality some of which can
- 20:20be extended by you know kind of bespoke development work and
- 20:25then you have your kind of networkers best-in-class
- 20:28Partners and yeah, how does that look for the average comments
- 20:31towards implementation? We have a pretty big tent, so we
- 20:36have our own promotion and even for example, but we regularly
- 20:40partner with Talon 1, when ours doesn't meet the customer needs,
- 20:44you know, we see the same thing with Pim, you know, Bluestone
- 20:48for example, we have a very, very large income and customer
- 20:51and they said, you know what, the Commerce tools Pim is fine.
- 20:54But we need something a little bit more, and we're happy to
- 20:56partner with our best to breed vendors in this space.
- 21:00You know, we have searched about half of Customers you said it's
- 21:04great for specific use cases. It's not for others, and I think
- 21:07there's this in the market. There's this there's this
- 21:12Antiquated view of like, you know, everybody has to get every
- 21:16dollar of every deal, right? Where you have to just over
- 21:21sell, whatever it is that you have and our view at Commerce
- 21:24tools is different where we are very, very close with our is V
- 21:28Partners who are completing our Solutions.
- 21:32And that's I think The key is, you know, we're connected with
- 21:37the CMS is of the world, a searches of the world, whatever
- 21:39it is and we'll go in together to solve real customer needs and
- 21:43I think that's the key differentiator, for us is, we're
- 21:45very friendly. We've got a very big tents.
- 21:47You know, we bought front tastic year and a half ago for our
- 21:51front end as a service. But we partner very, very
- 21:54closely with you storefront because for whatever reason
- 21:57people, you know, some people aren't able to use front tastic
- 22:00which is now known as Commerce tools front end.
- 22:02And that's fine, right? Not not every product is for
- 22:05every company and when that is the case, with very good friends
- 22:09and partners over at View and we'll bring them in.
- 22:12So we really want to solve customer problems.
- 22:14Thurmont, that's what we do. A question that has come up from
- 22:19a few economists. Things I've worked with when
- 22:21they've been trying to understand how I come on stools.
- 22:24Compared to a big commercial Shopify, where their app stores
- 22:27is, you know, you have an Integrations Marketplace and
- 22:30there seems to be a lot of activity, building that out
- 22:32powder, the connectors where, if somebody is using commas tools,
- 22:35and then you've got an integration in your Marketplace
- 22:38for a p.m., does that mean? It's, it's pre-integrated and
- 22:42those API connections already established and they just need
- 22:44to turn on that connection. On or is there also additional
- 22:48like development work, customization with the people
- 22:50need to factor in when they're turning on these connectors?
- 22:57So it's a different orientation in Commerce tools world than
- 23:01historically. So if you look at the Adobe
- 23:04world, for example, or hybris world, Those platforms and I
- 23:09call them platforms, were the center of the universe and to
- 23:13get from the front end, to say your pimp, you had to go through
- 23:19the platform and the platform then had a very, very tight
- 23:23Integrations back to the him, or back to the search, or whatever.
- 23:27That thing I happened to be in the back end.
- 23:30So, as a result, you have these these very tightly coupled
- 23:35Solutions, but the platform is mediating the connections.
- 23:38The back, the third party product, and commerce, tools
- 23:42world. We are instead building a
- 23:44catalog of apis and some of those apis come from us, some of
- 23:48them come from third parties. Some of them are customers build
- 23:52themselves or through an SSI. But basically, they're building
- 23:55and buying their, their way to a catalog of apis.
- 24:00And in that model were exchanging data with our
- 24:04partners, primarily through events, So we and other mock
- 24:08vendors instead of us calling search, for example, to update
- 24:12it with a new product. We will throw that as an event
- 24:16to the queue of the customers Choice.
- 24:17Whether it's Google, pubsub could be SNS, sqs.
- 24:21It could be event Bridge, whatever, right?
- 24:25We'll throw the event there and then the search product that
- 24:27they choose subscribes to the event from there.
- 24:31So instead of us meeting the connection, instead we're
- 24:34throwing data to a common event Bridge.
- 24:38My boss and then the relevant systems are pulling the data off
- 24:42of that. So that's how you integrate with
- 24:44order Management systems. For example, we capture the
- 24:46order will throw it to the queue and then the OMS and any other
- 24:51system that needs order data is subscribing to it.
- 24:54And when you have a subscription based system like that, it's a
- 24:57much less brittle approach because now instead of you know,
- 25:01us being the center and if something happens the whole
- 25:05thing breaks now we're publishing.
- 25:08Once, and then you can set a very complex workflows using the
- 25:11cloud of your choice and some much more resilient event based
- 25:14architecture. But to directly answer your
- 25:21question, we actually do have Integrations with all of our
- 25:23major partners for sure, and that's a largely event-based,
- 25:27but it's some direct point-to-point.
- 25:29I mean there, again, we're very much an ecosystem play.
- 25:33We're not just a, you know, we're not everything in a box.
- 25:36So we have to have these. And we do a very good job with
- 25:38them. Abandoned ice.
- 25:40It's a to say what you'll find in terms of Trend in technology
- 25:44because I just face it, they become a multi universes, huge
- 25:48thousands of different you referenced earlier.
- 25:50How many different platforms Technologies are out there from
- 25:54your Marketplace in the projects you work at what are the most
- 25:57popular, like, third-party tools that people are plugging in and
- 26:00using alongside Commerce tools to deliver their Enterprise
- 26:03e-commerce Vision. You able to like share some of
- 26:06the most, the most commonly used ones whether that's ER These
- 26:10pins like specific names or just the categories.
- 26:14Yeah, Baines arsenate pick out a couple of categories and some of
- 26:16the most popular chosen vendors and then that space would be
- 26:19very interested to know what's what's been used?
- 26:22The most in your ecosystem. So, people are buying some
- 26:27combination of Commerce, search and content.
- 26:33Usually, they'll start with Commerce and then bring in
- 26:35Search and then content on occasion, we see at the
- 26:38opposite, You know, they'll start with content and work
- 26:41their way backwards, but typically those three are
- 26:43purchased within a 12 month time, period and implemented
- 26:47pretty successively. And they're typically buying all
- 26:52of these in alignment, right? So, it's rare to see, like, an
- 26:58old-school, CMS upfront, but then have us in the back end,
- 27:02right? Instead, people are buying, you
- 27:04know, us and mock based search and mock base CMS.
- 27:09Us in terms of Partners. Again this is hard because we
- 27:13have really good partners across our entire ecosystem, and
- 27:17anytime I name specific Partners, I get angry emails.
- 27:21Probably rightfully angry emails from people, but on the content
- 27:27side, we see a lot of content stack content, full, and plants
- 27:34bloom Rich. We see a lot of A lot of Legacy
- 27:38Adobe experience manager, surprisingly.
- 27:42We see a high graph, a little bit, but that's kind of the cool
- 27:47thing in the spaces. You know, anybody can go out
- 27:50there and start a CMS these days because Cloud enables that on
- 27:54the search side, we see Constructor.
- 27:57I'll go Leah. A little bit of room range there
- 28:00as well. And attract we see, who else do
- 28:05we see a little bit of lucid works?
- 28:08It's a pretty long tail there, in the search side again.
- 28:12You know, the barrier to entry is relatively low on the pimp
- 28:18side. We see blue stone a kidney.
- 28:22Oh, you know, those are popular the earpiece side.
- 28:28We do have a modern ear p in our mock Alliance and I should
- 28:34remember their name. But you know, folks typically
- 28:37aren't buying Commerce and Erp together, you know, instead
- 28:41they're One, or the other, I can't find the name.
- 28:48You having worked on two projects where people were
- 28:50putting in Erp and e-commerce new systems at the same time.
- 28:53Like I strongly advise people to not do, it's probably good idea.
- 28:59We also have on occasion people go, third party for promotions,
- 29:05usually it's Talon one, sometimes voucher if I.
- 29:08But Talon one has a pretty strong Monopoly right now in the
- 29:11cuit. Yeah, those are the major
- 29:16buckets at this point. We also see some other
- 29:18categories that we have dams that people buy a lot of people,
- 29:22get the amply and stem as well. What else?
- 29:29Apollo for all the graphql? Tooling is super popular.
- 29:32See a lot of that. Now if I you know for for up
- 29:35front front, end type of work. We see a lot of that with Fi out
- 29:38there for cell as well again, it's hard because we have so
- 29:43many good partners and I don't want to and a missing out on
- 29:48naming somebody specifically. But we're a big tent.
- 29:51Let's put it that way. and so, the next question, I think in
- 29:56the market and I don't know if you agree with this but I would
- 29:59say there's like there's a bit of a preconception that if
- 30:02you're looking at you know doing a composable project with the
- 30:06likes of Commerce tools and you know, other kind of Mac
- 30:09orientated Solutions, you need a CT 0 or you know at the very
- 30:14least very senior kind of engineering head and potentially
- 30:17than a team of Engineers regardless of whether you have
- 30:21an asylum Alongside that kind of In-House capability.
- 30:25What's your view on this? I would agree with that.
- 30:30I think you need somebody, you know, could be an architect, it
- 30:33could be a CTO, a CD Ocio. Somebody who has an
- 30:38understanding of what fits where somebody who has the rough
- 30:42outlines of, you know what Mark is and how it works.
- 30:45I think there needs to be some technical competency the barrier
- 30:49to adopting. This is most lower it when we
- 30:52really started seeing some Market Traction in 2017, 2018,
- 30:57you know, at that point. You did have to be more
- 31:00technical, right? Like it was a reasonably
- 31:03technical product at that point, but now with the proliferation
- 31:06of apis and mock based Technologies random people like
- 31:12I shouldn't say random but like normal business users people,
- 31:15you know who make decisions, you know, cfo's they understand what
- 31:19apis are they get this, you know, in my first couple of
- 31:22years at Commerce tools I'd hear from prospects of ours and
- 31:26they'd say you know, why does it have to be cloud-based?
- 31:29Right. We don't want multi-tenant SAS.
- 31:31We want to have this in our four walls in our own data center.
- 31:34I'm haven't heard that in years now, right?
- 31:37They would say, why isn't your products Complete?
- 31:40Because it doesn't have a no muss and it doesn't have a CMS.
- 31:43And I would, I would very politely, say well you're kind
- 31:46of missing the point, right? This is all we do.
- 31:49It's like asking twilio why they're incomplete for not
- 31:51offering a graphql library, right?
- 31:55It's different philosophy. So the market has moved Pretty
- 32:00quickly in our Direction which is great to see.
- 32:03And as a result, the barrier to adoption is lower.
- 32:06I do think you need someone who can at least put the pieces
- 32:09together or you need a good partner who can put the pieces
- 32:13together, but I don't think, you know, you're if you're just
- 32:17wanting a website and a box, we are not that we are really a
- 32:21solution for innovators, somebody needs to be slightly
- 32:24technical to understand what goes where and how it all fits
- 32:27together, that makes sense, and that is my view as well as if
- 32:30someone's like a tenant or technology vision.
- 32:33Essentially or yeah, it kind of makes sense.
- 32:38So, coming back to the product, how big a focus B2B for Commerce
- 32:43Tools in 2023 and has that changed over the last few years.
- 32:48We've historically sold a lot of B2B out there, which is, which
- 32:52is good, it's a healthy market for us, we've really Double Down
- 32:55from a product standpoint, and we're really there feature
- 32:58compatibility wise with the major herb, top 2 or type 3 B2B
- 33:03platforms on the market. So, now we are very confident
- 33:08and in winning these and we're starting to see some really big
- 33:10deals come our way in the B2B space.
- 33:12Although again, we sold lots of B2B to building plus dollar gmv
- 33:16customers for years now. But it is a big area.
- 33:20You'll see a lot more marketing thought leadership from us on
- 33:23this. And if you just look at the
- 33:25total addressable Market, B2B is way bigger than B to C is and
- 33:29we've already really dominated the b2c space and B2B is
- 33:35different but it's not that different if that makes sense,
- 33:38right? It's a market.
- 33:39That is something that we can really come in and clean up.
- 33:44Because we already have the product for it.
- 33:45And now with these additional features, we're even More easily
- 33:49able to compete. Makes sense and just just kind
- 33:55of expanded on that little bit. Would you be able to just talk
- 33:58us through kind of what your native bee to be offering?
- 34:01Looks like and kind of maybe how this side is kind of built into
- 34:05the apis. I'm sure that's kind of pretty
- 34:07standard for you guys and then also how you handle things like
- 34:11quoting or cpq or like multi-tiered account, all of the
- 34:14standard kind of B2B stuff. Yeah, we're a bit different from
- 34:19our competitors. In the we have a catalog of Epi,
- 34:22there's a single catalog and you can use it in a beauty as C or B
- 34:25to be flavor you pick. And a lot of our customers are
- 34:30b2c with a flavor of B2B or their B2B.
- 34:34But act like be to see, you know, there isn't this.
- 34:38This hard split in the market and a lot of our competitors
- 34:41have two separate products in their portfolio.
- 34:45And I think that's hard because Again, it's not a very firm your
- 34:50B to C or B to B. It's usually a, some flavor of
- 34:53those things. So again, we've long supported,
- 34:58you know, all of the standard features.
- 35:01We now have some pretty Advanced features around workflows, for
- 35:03example, around, you know, supplier specific pricing
- 35:08inventory promotions, being able to much more easily scope those
- 35:12objects to a given buyer. So we support that really well.
- 35:17You know, quoting is something we've supported for a long time
- 35:20but maybe even better. Now we've added some beauty to
- 35:23be specific discount. Approaches, what else have we
- 35:27done? Honestly, a lot of it is just
- 35:31how we talk, right? We've talked B to C, only as
- 35:34Commerce tools to our own detriment.
- 35:37And we've had to be to be organizations, come to us and
- 35:39say, hey, we see you basically support everything we need.
- 35:43Can we use you for B2B? And now we can confidently, say
- 35:47yes. And that we've closed this
- 35:48feature gaps. We do not do cpq.
- 35:52We have some great Partners there.
- 35:55Like a logic. I 0 is 1, for example, that we
- 35:57work with pretty closely their mock Taste.
- 36:01But that's cpq is a great example of where, if you've got
- 36:05a five or ten person team working for a Converse vendor,
- 36:08they're never going to be able to have a cpq that matches a
- 36:11standalone vendor. That has 250 people who only do
- 36:14cpq all day. I guess the question that links
- 36:20into this quite noisy because we've talked about lots of
- 36:23different capabilities. Functionalities.
- 36:25You know what's in the 10? You talked about in terms of
- 36:28like product catalog of the core Commerce, extending out to be to
- 36:32be Tau because you work differently to like a standard
- 36:36license Pace saspa. How does pricing work?
- 36:38Because this always comes up in every conversation.
- 36:41I have already any new prospective client about the
- 36:43types of platform that soon. The first thing, the finance
- 36:45pestilence know is, but what am I paying for?
- 36:48How do I pay for a, how does it change?
- 36:50So how how do you, how does the pricing work on a?
- 36:53I know you've got lots of different projects sizes, is it
- 36:58license base. Could you give you share a bit
- 37:00of modification people sir. It's a function of two things.
- 37:05So the first is the number of orders that you place per year
- 37:11and then average order value. So, if you're selling new cars
- 37:15for you know, seventy thousand dollars a year.
- 37:19Right. The price per order is going to
- 37:21be higher than if you're selling donuts for 50 cents a piece,
- 37:25right? So there's that scale and then
- 37:28there's the number of orders that you're placing per year.
- 37:30And again, if your B2B manufacturer and you're selling,
- 37:34you know, giant piece of farm equipment and you're selling one
- 37:37of those per day, you're going to have relatively few orders
- 37:42compared to. If you're, you know, a much
- 37:44larger Mass Merchant retailer, for example, so it's a function
- 37:47of those two things and We do that because we don't want gmv
- 37:51based pricing. And I think it's a little
- 37:54amateurish, to be honest with you, and our customers don't
- 37:56want gmv pricing, you know, they very clearly said that they
- 37:59don't like that model. And then what we also didn't
- 38:05want to do was a strict API, call based model, because when
- 38:08you only do it based on API calls, it's hard to wait the
- 38:12value of different apis, you know, if you're just retrieving
- 38:15a product from the cash, that's very different from From placing
- 38:19a very large order API call right there different and what
- 38:24we didn't want was for folks to have to think that they need to
- 38:29architect their platform to minimize API calls.
- 38:32We don't want them doing unnatural things to avoid API
- 38:35calls So we have it set up as a function of the number of orders
- 38:40and average order value. And that's proven to be quite a
- 38:42fair approach for both sides, and it captures, the value that
- 38:46we offer. We're quite reasonably priced.
- 38:50Usually, our customers are paying a third roughly of what
- 38:53they would be paying their legacy vendor and just
- 38:55maintenance cost. And yeah, it's proven to work
- 38:59really well. Oh, thanks.
- 39:02And I'm and if anybody wants to reach out, and if they want to,
- 39:07like, challenge you on anything or probe deeper or talk about a,
- 39:12an issue to see whether or how commas tools could help solve
- 39:15it, how do they reach out? You can return on LinkedIn.
- 39:21That's where I hang out on occasion.
- 39:23I've been known to be Twitter, I'm on, but I used in spurts.
- 39:29I've such a love-hate relationship with it, but I
- 39:34think a lot more people have it ever since the Glorious musk
- 39:37took over as well. But if I think it's become more,
- 39:40my it is you know LinkedIn. I find people actually have real
- 39:45discussions. Yeah.
- 39:46And because It is tied to your real name.
- 39:49I think people are more having good faith arguments and they're
- 39:53polite. And what I find on Twitter is
- 39:56that there are people who just take shots at you behind
- 40:00Anonymous accounts and they're performing for Their audience as
- 40:05opposed to really trying to learn.
- 40:07So it's hard to have substance of discussions on LinkedIn or on
- 40:09Twitter because of the format. LinkedIn is better.
- 40:12It's tied to their professional accounts, people generally try
- 40:16not to look too stupid. You know, people will engage in
- 40:19good faith arguments and I find it's better.
- 40:23But yeah, I've look, I have a lot of good good discussions
- 40:26with folks that I love for people to follow and follow
- 40:29Commerce fools follow myself and engage with us.
- 40:34You know we were very much, a developer first company we like
- 40:39talking with folks out there, we do a lot of public thought.
- 40:42Leadership, you know, things like this podcasts, which thanks
- 40:44again for the invite. You know, we do all of that.
- 40:47And are very responsive as a company.
- 40:49You know, we're not a big Global Behemoth, where, you know,
- 40:53everything has to be run by our PR department in anytime
- 40:57somebody comments on LinkedIn. Well, not yet, at least.
- 41:00There we go. It's open season for sending
- 41:03challenging questions to Kelly online said, appreciate Kelly,
- 41:07really. Appreciate you taking the time
- 41:09and thanks to everyone as always for list and we hope you've
- 41:12enjoyed it too. If you've got any follow-up
- 41:14questions, feel free to reach out to Kelly on myself and Paul
- 41:17on, Tin keep your eyes open for the next episode.
- 41:19We drop every Tuesday. I do, subscribe if you haven't
- 41:22already. And please don't forget to give
- 41:24us a rate on Apple Spotify or YouTube, a and wherever you're
- 41:27listening. Thanks very much and take care
- 41:29of everybody. Thanks for having me, clicker,
- 41:39more information on this topic, head over to re-platform dot.
- 41:42F m, for our audio podcasts to discuss a project or if you like
- 41:46to chat about any of the topics covered in this episode in more
- 41:48detail. Please reach out to myself,
- 41:50James guard and my co-host Paul Rodgers via LinkedIn and
- 41:52Twitter. Thanks again for listening and
- 41:54keep your ears peeled for the next episode.