Latest / Humanise The Numbers - for ambitious accountants in practice / Stuart Clark, Managing Director at Russell + Russell
Transcript
- 0:05Paul Shrimpling: Welcome to the Humanize the Numbers podcast series Leaders, managers and owners of ambitious accounting firms sharing insights, successes and issues that will challenge you and connect you and your firm to the ways and means of transforming your firm's results.
- 0:22Stuart Clark: You know, I think we've got a really great team.
- 0:23Stuart Clark: I think the culture is really good.
- 0:26Stuart Clark: I think the purpose and the values and stuff that we've built tie into all that.
- 0:31Stuart Clark: Attracting the right talent and retaining the right talent, um, I'm sure you know, on any given day there's people got issues and stuff that we do the kind of weekly one-to-ones, and there's always, you know, something that's not quite right but gives us an opportunity to try and correct things and make things better for for going forward.
- 0:51Stuart Clark: Um, so, yeah, I think the team, uh, is probably the number one thing.
- 0:57Douglas Aitken: How do you articulate how your firm is different from others In a sea of sameness?
- 1:04Douglas Aitken: Stuart Clarke of Russell, Russell Business Advisors has found a way to articulate the difference of how he operates in Glasgow in his firm.
- 1:14Douglas Aitken: Listen on to find out.
- 1:16Stuart Clark: Hi, my name is Stuart Clarke.
- 1:17Stuart Clark: I'm the Managing Director of Russell Russell Business Advisors.
- 1:21Stuart Clark: We're a firm of accountants and business advisors in Glasgow, a team of 20 of us.
- 1:27Stuart Clark: We've been going for almost 50 years.
- 1:30Stuart Clark: Actually, next year will be our 50th anniversary, but I've only been with the firm since 2012 and completed a management buyout in November 2022.
- 1:40Stuart Clark: So it's been a couple of years since we've been taking over the ownership of the firm ourselves.
- 1:45Douglas Aitken: Fabulous Welcome to the podcast, stuart.
- 1:47Douglas Aitken: Great to have you on and thanks for that introduction.
- 1:50Douglas Aitken: As you probably know from previous podcasts, we always ask our guests the same question at the start, so our purpose is to humanise the numbers.
- 2:00Douglas Aitken: What pictures does that set in your mind, stuart?
- 2:06Douglas Aitken: What kind of meaning do you get from that?
- 2:08Stuart Clark: I think for me, when we're speaking to our clients, it's, you know, the numbers tell a story of the business, but the business also runs on people and processes.
- 2:17Stuart Clark: So it's how do we marry the two together and how do we make them understandable?
- 2:21Stuart Clark: You know, I think numbers quite a lot of business owners maybe get into the business because they're good at what they do, but they're not necessarily, you know, good at the accounting side of things or don't understand the numbers behind it.
- 2:32Stuart Clark: So it's trying to give them the context and understanding and break down the barriers.
- 2:37Stuart Clark: You know, I think again don't want to be demeaning to the accounting industry, but in the past it's maybe been oh, we want to be the smartest in the room and we use lots of jargon and you know, if a client's not confused by the end of the session, we've not done our job right and shown how intelligent we are and how impressive we are.
- 2:53Stuart Clark: But for us it's trying to break down those barriers and make the numbers understandable and, yeah, make them relatable to the business owners yeah, brilliant, brilliant.
- 3:02Douglas Aitken: I noticed in your introduction you led with russell and russell business advisors yes, as opposed to accountants, and that's.
- 3:11Douglas Aitken: That seemed a very deliberate choice of phraseology.
- 3:14Douglas Aitken: What's behind that chip?
- 3:17Stuart Clark: um, I think it's because we're trying to put ourselves, yeah, as a sort of advisor, trusted advisor, to the clients we work with.
- 3:24Stuart Clark: We're not, I think people say, accountant.
- 3:27Stuart Clark: Obviously some people just switch off automatically.
- 3:29Stuart Clark: Do you know?
- 3:29Stuart Clark: There's that stereotypical accountant that's a sort of from the 1950s and people just not interested in that.
- 3:36Stuart Clark: So I think it's part of part of the reasons that.
- 3:39Stuart Clark: I think the other thing is we don't want to be just churning out year-end accounts, one after the other sausage factory, we want to work closely with our clients and give that kind of advisory aspect.
- 3:50Stuart Clark: So part of that, of what I should have led with this, of course, is making lives better.
- 3:54Stuart Clark: Our purpose, I realized I focused on as soon as I said it and as soon as you went, I was like, oh no, I've said, said how long have you been in business?
- 4:01Stuart Clark: Said all the stuff that's not actually relevant.
- 4:03Stuart Clark: But yeah, I think making lives better is actually, you know, is the purpose of what we do, and again, it's trying to stand out from the crowd in this sea of sameness.
- 4:11Stuart Clark: I think a lot of accountants, we go on their websites and we compare ourselves to competitors.
- 4:16Stuart Clark: Our old website used to look very similar to theirs and we felt like we were internally different but weren't really expressing that outwardly.
- 4:26Stuart Clark: I think we've definitely changed that now.
- 4:27Stuart Clark: I think it's still room for improvement, but we are trying to lead with that, making lives better, and we're trying to make it a part of every meeting that we hold and make it part of the day-to-day within the team as well.
- 4:35Douglas Aitken: Brilliant.
- 4:36Douglas Aitken: I love that.
- 4:36Douglas Aitken: Making lives better.
- 4:37Douglas Aitken: How did you arrive at that?
- 4:42Douglas Aitken: In the end, we look at the functionality of what accountants do, of course, and the products that they provide but how did you arrive at making lives better in the end?
- 4:58Stuart Clark: I think partly it was from discussions with yourself which we were trying to get clarity.
- 5:00Stuart Clark: You were pushing us on getting clarity on our purpose and we kind of had some things written down but they weren't really nailed and we find it hard to articulate to the team and and so it's trying to distill it into that kind of sentence and we kind of went through what we do so it's like okay, well, you know, we provide them less stress, more time, more money, all these kind of different things that we do.
- 5:25Stuart Clark: It's like okay, and what?
- 5:26Stuart Clark: What is that doing?
- 5:27Stuart Clark: It's like, oh, we're, I guess, at the heart of what we did as well and I think it's something I've always had is, you know, what's the client's goal?
- 5:34Stuart Clark: What are they trying to achieve?
- 5:37Stuart Clark: I think I quite often use the example no one sets out to turn over 1.233 million and 33 pounds.
- 5:44Stuart Clark: It's.
- 5:45Stuart Clark: You know, that's the break-even point if they go.
- 5:47Stuart Clark: I want to go on holiday once a year and I've got a margin of this, and I want to put money aside for my kids to go to university.
- 5:54Stuart Clark: I want to put money into a flat, I want to take them to Disneyland for a trip of a lifetime.
- 5:57Stuart Clark: You know, working out what their personal goals are is allows us to then help understand what the company goals are, and normally small business owners those things are intertwined.
- 6:09Stuart Clark: Um, so it then became like that personal aspect.
- 6:14Stuart Clark: It's like, okay, we might be helping the company achieve this, but it's really the individual and it's their lives that we're impacting and trying to make better yeah, fabulous, and I guess it's a case of trying to capture these landmark stories, isn't it that illustrate that purpose coming to life?
- 6:31Douglas Aitken: How have the team adapted to that purpose and to what extent have they feel attached to it, can you tell?
- 6:40Stuart Clark: Yeah, I think we have quarterly Making Lives Better days, so we do things out with the business as well, so going and volunteering, helping local communities and local charities, um, and I think it's you know, because we're able to articulate it a bit better you know, we've got that kind of flag point or that master like right, making life better.
- 7:03Stuart Clark: What we're trying to do.
- 7:03Stuart Clark: So for me it's making life better for the people in our team.
- 7:06Stuart Clark: How do we make improved processes?
- 7:08Stuart Clark: How can we make sure that their lives are better, that they enjoy working at Russell Russell?
- 7:13Stuart Clark: If I look after them, they'll look after the team their clients, sorry or look after their own team, who then look after their clients as well and make life better.
- 7:21Stuart Clark: And if we make lives better for those clients, help grow their businesses, that's going to have a knock-off impact on the local community and things like that as well.
- 7:29Stuart Clark: So I think we had that kind of central point okay, making lives better.
- 7:35Stuart Clark: We then also again did some work with yourself as to okay, how does that feed into?
- 7:39Stuart Clark: What does that, that mean?
- 7:40Stuart Clark: And we came up with the kind of the values and the behaviors that that and again, getting clarity over those just makes it a lot easier to have those conversations with the team if maybe someone isn't living up to the values or isn't doing stuff.
- 7:53Stuart Clark: But again, every decision we make, if someone makes not necessarily the wrong decision, but a slightly different version of the decision that I might have made if they've done it with making life better at the core and I was trying to make life better and I was trying to be my best self and challenge the client and I was trying to do all these things you can't really be upset with them.
- 8:13Stuart Clark: They've stuck true to what we've set out to do.
- 8:17Douglas Aitken: Yeah, that's a great point, isn't it?
- 8:19Douglas Aitken: It becomes a disagreement about tactics, but not about strategy.
- 8:25Douglas Aitken: So, and we can live with tactical disagreements, can't we?
- 8:29Stuart Clark: yeah, and I think we've all bought into that.
- 8:31Stuart Clark: Once we kind of got that legalized better, we've all bought into it and we're like, okay, this is what we're we're trying to achieve.
- 8:37Stuart Clark: So we're all in the same boat and I said someone might have a slightly different way of getting there, the end result, but we're all aiming for the same thing and we're, all you know, pushing towards it together, so that that helps as well yeah, brilliant, excellent.
- 8:50Douglas Aitken: So just to bring another human angle to um, to what we're talking about today what, what's your own background?
- 8:58Douglas Aitken: And, uh, do you have family?
- 9:00Douglas Aitken: You know, tell us a bit about yourself yeah.
- 9:02Stuart Clark: So I am a qualified physiotherapist who was absolutely terrible at physiotherapy, and so I decided to retrain.
- 9:11Stuart Clark: I actually went for three job interviews.
- 9:12Stuart Clark: I studied in glasgow and went for three job interviews.
- 9:17Stuart Clark: Every time I got the phone call for feedback or for they let me know.
- 9:22Stuart Clark: I was like all that was going through my head was just please, don't tell me I've got this job.
- 9:25Stuart Clark: Please don't tell me I've got this job.
- 9:27Stuart Clark: And I, after the third interview, I thought actually something's got to change here, because I'm going to land one of these, whether I want to or not.
- 9:33Stuart Clark: Someone's going to give me a job just because there's something there, rather than I'm actually good at it.
- 9:38Stuart Clark: And so I thought I need to change and so went to a graduate fair at the SECC in Glasgow and spoke to ICAS.
- 9:48Stuart Clark: They said if you've got a two, one or above, you don't have to go back to university.
- 9:53Stuart Clark: You can actually retrain with a firm and go through your exams.
- 9:56Stuart Clark: And I think I think it's still the same, but it was if you'd qualified, you'd done four years at university as accountant.
- 10:02Stuart Clark: You had two lots of exams, but you still need to get your three years practical experience.
- 10:06Paul Shrimpling: I was non-relevant.
- 10:07Stuart Clark: I had one extra set of exams but still needed three years.
- 10:10Stuart Clark: It was the same length of time and I was earning rather than getting myself into more debt.
- 10:14Stuart Clark: So I moved to Johnson Carmichael in Edinburgh, worked there for about seven or eight years, had a wee brief kind of I'm not sure what you're trying to do.
- 10:29Stuart Clark: It went off for a bit because I entered a thing called sporting giants.
- 10:32Stuart Clark: All right, was the 2012 olympics.
- 10:36Stuart Clark: Steve redgrave had, um, they were looking for tall people, tall, lanky people.
- 10:41Stuart Clark: I was a bit lankier then I'm putting a bit of beef now but and they were looking for people because london was hosting the olympics, the uk got entry into every single event, whereas in the past you have to be, you know, at a certain level.
- 10:55Stuart Clark: So there were certain events that we've never qualified for, but we did qualify for this.
- 10:59Stuart Clark: So they were trying to get tall people to come in and test out for these sports.
- 11:03Stuart Clark: So I put an application in.
- 11:07Stuart Clark: I used to play rugby at age group level for Scotland and things like that.
- 11:10Stuart Clark: So I think because of that I got managed to get through the first set of process.
- 11:15Stuart Clark: I think 15,000 applications got invited down to Sheffield.
- 11:19Stuart Clark: They measured my wingspan and my hands and all this kind of stuff and said, right, okay, there's volleyball, rowing and handball I think were the three sports and I got put into the handball selection, got through to the next set of that, which was going down again for a weekend at the Institute of Sport playing with the current British team and kind of having a trial.
- 11:43Stuart Clark: Got through that weekend, went to live in Denmark for a week, got through that, then moved down to Sheffield for two months, three months between Denmark and Sheffield, and it was down to about the final 20 at that point out of 15,000 and then unfortunately got.
- 11:59Stuart Clark: I didn't get cut at that point but I didn't get to move to Denmark at that point.
- 12:04Stuart Clark: I was moved to Denmark, go back to Sheffield and live in Sheffield or uh, cut completely and I got the Sheffield option.
- 12:12Stuart Clark: But at that point I was kind of I'd already put my exams and studies on hold for a couple of uh months, was taking unpaid leave from work and things like this and I thought actually, if I'm not in Denmark playing four or five hours a day, if it's just me and a couple of guys in Sheffield going to the gym and playing the odd game, I'm not going to get any better, so I took the decision just to leave and then went back and finished my accountancy exams.
- 12:39Douglas Aitken: Wow, that was a sliding doors moment, wasn't it?
- 12:42Stuart Clark: Yeah, but it's great fun a sliding doors moment, wasn't it?
- 12:50Stuart Clark: Yeah, but it's great fun, it's.
- 12:51Stuart Clark: It's a.
- 12:51Stuart Clark: Like handball is a.
- 12:51Stuart Clark: I really enjoy it as a sport.
- 12:52Stuart Clark: It's very physical, it's very fast paced, lots of goals, but for some and it's just throwing and catching.
- 12:54Stuart Clark: So everyone can play it.
- 12:55Stuart Clark: But um, yeah, I don't know why it's never taken off in scotland, do you think?
- 12:59Stuart Clark: With our weather it'd be perfect, an indoor sport you can play all year round.
- 13:02Stuart Clark: But yeah, and you had no previous experience of it before you went to the trial no, no, wow, never played it and you get this like glue that you put in your hands to make the ball stickier and obviously never, ever done it before.
- 13:14Stuart Clark: You just put your hand in and just slap on.
- 13:16Stuart Clark: It was like and I put so much on, just like the ball was stuck honestly couldn't bounce the ball.
- 13:21Stuart Clark: And then one guy when we were in Denmark because he put on every time, it was brutal and it's just, your hands are sticky all day long.
- 13:29Stuart Clark: It was horrible, but they, uh, his finger tips came off, like because he put too much glue on, so it pulled the fingertip off.
- 13:36Stuart Clark: So he then had to start like putting, uh, plasters on.
- 13:39Stuart Clark: But occasionally you get the ball and it's about the plaster off.
- 13:41Stuart Clark: You get this bloody plaster spinning across the ball coming towards you.
- 13:45Stuart Clark: So that's my main memory of handball.
- 13:47Stuart Clark: Um, but at that point it was because they were trying to do that.
- 13:52Stuart Clark: There's that they had that 10 000 hours idea in their head.
- 13:56Stuart Clark: It was like you need to get 10 000 hours before 2012.
- 13:58Stuart Clark: So we're training.
- 14:01Stuart Clark: We did two sessions a day, morning and afternoon, two-hour sessions each and a gym session on top of that, and I think I found an old diary which kind of had what I ate for the day and it was like 7,000, 8,000 calories or something like that, and I was still losing weight.
- 14:18Stuart Clark: So it was fairly intense.
- 14:22Stuart Clark: I don't think I could have kept up for much longer.
- 14:24Stuart Clark: To be honest, I was probably right.
- 14:26Stuart Clark: I got cut to the level I was.
- 14:28Douglas Aitken: That's almost some story.
- 14:30Douglas Aitken: Well, it is some story anyway to get down to the last 20 from that, but almost an Olympic athlete.
- 14:38Stuart Clark: Yeah, well, from the 20, I think about 14 of them got into the squad, or quite a few of them did, and actually one of the guys, Bobby, that had never played before he captained the GB team and stuff like that.
- 14:51Stuart Clark: So there was guys I played with that made it all the way through to that four or five years later.
- 14:57Stuart Clark: So, yeah, it was a great experience.
- 15:01Stuart Clark: And yeah, being an Olympian was something that I was always like, oh, I'd love to do that, but I'm not fast enough, I'm not strong enough and you know rugby wasn't part of it and things like that at that point.
- 15:09Stuart Clark: So, uh, it was to get the opportunity was unbelievable.
- 15:14Stuart Clark: But and yeah, it's a good story still got my wee british olympic passport that I had, that got me into places and things like that.
- 15:21Stuart Clark: But yeah, kids don't believe it's me because I've got hair and I'm a bit thinner, so uh, superb.
- 15:29Douglas Aitken: Yeah, well, handballs loss was accountancy's gain.
- 15:32Douglas Aitken: Yeah, um, so you said you.
- 15:35Douglas Aitken: Uh, what made the major move from johnson kermichael to russell and russell?
- 15:40Douglas Aitken: How did that come about?
- 15:42Stuart Clark: again.
- 15:42Stuart Clark: It was just it's actually my wife.
- 15:44Stuart Clark: I met my wife um, who is a physio and I was actually at university with.
- 15:49Stuart Clark: But we had the separate, different partners at that point and kind of were friendly.
- 15:53Stuart Clark: But uh, one of our mutual friends had a fundraising, kayleigh um and so I came through to that to Glasgow, met her.
- 16:04Stuart Clark: Then we started seeing each other, was commuting back and forward between Edinburgh and Glasgow and after a couple years you're kind of like, right, one of us needs to make the move.
- 16:12Stuart Clark: I was happy in Edinburgh, she was happy in Glasgow.
- 16:14Stuart Clark: But we thought, right, well, we both liked each other's cities as well.
- 16:19Stuart Clark: So we thought, well, let's just see who gets the job first and we'll.
- 16:21Stuart Clark: Whichever one gets one, we'll move.
- 16:23Stuart Clark: So she was looking for jobs in Embra, I was looking for jobs in Glasgow neither of us were taking that seriously, probably in hindsight.
- 16:29Stuart Clark: And then she got an opportunity for a job in Glasgow in cardiac rehab, which was where she'd always wanted to work and she really loved it and the job had only come out.
- 16:39Stuart Clark: I think it was the first time a job had come up in the eight years in the NHS for that role.
- 16:44Stuart Clark: So she thought I'm going to apply for this and just see what happens.
- 16:47Stuart Clark: And so she got that.
- 16:48Stuart Clark: So then it was okay, right, decisions made, I'm moving to Glasgow and so I just started speaking to recruitment agents and stuff like that and got put in front of a couple of places.
- 17:00Stuart Clark: But Russell and Russell was the one that kind of just stood apart with what they were trying to do the fact that it was proactive.
- 17:08Stuart Clark: You know, at that point we had a rule that we only took a client on if we met them four times a year.
- 17:13Stuart Clark: We kind of have that still to a certain degree, because with all the stuff we do, we probably are, have got more touch points, but we don't have it in quite as a hard line in the sand, because some clients find it difficult going from you know they've only seen their account once a year.
- 17:31Stuart Clark: If you say you got to meet them four times a year, they're like, oh, hold on a minute, I don't even like going to see my accountant.
- 17:36Stuart Clark: Why do I want to put myself through that pain four times a year?
- 17:38Stuart Clark: So but hopefully once they come on board and get working with us they kind of see the value and they start to see us more.
- 17:44Stuart Clark: But yeah, I just really like the different.
- 17:46Stuart Clark: They had unlimited telephone calls, they had all sorts of different things, which again really enjoyed my time at John Schumacher.
- 17:54Stuart Clark: But I remember one client coming in one day and we had a year-end accounts meeting and we're talking about they bought, put a company car, a really expensive diesel Land Rover or Porsche or something through the business, and I was sitting down with him and explaining he had an unforeseen 10 grand tax bill because of this benefit in kind charge and I was like why didn't you give us a call?
- 18:15Stuart Clark: We could have told you how to structure this most efficiently.
- 18:17Stuart Clark: And he was like, oh, but I knew as soon as I picked up the phone you'd bill me a couple hundred quid for a phone call, and I guess it was.
- 18:26Stuart Clark: It was like russell, russell had that fixed price element and it was like, okay, we want you to get the phone.
- 18:33Stuart Clark: We don't want these uh like stopwatch in the background to put you off picking up the phone does.
- 18:36Stuart Clark: And so I really like that approach and so joined in 2012.
- 18:43Douglas Aitken: And how did you find the change in approach to clients once you were actually in Russell Russell?
- 18:51Douglas Aitken: What was the main difference, do you think?
- 18:54Stuart Clark: I think you know it was a real focus on proactivity.
- 19:00Stuart Clark: I think John Scarmichael said I don't want to sound like a bad man I really enjoyed my time there and it was very collaborative with clients as well, but it wasn't maybe as structured.
- 19:11Stuart Clark: It was waiting for a client to phone you and then come to them with some advice and that, although maybe proactive advice, it still felt quite reactive to me that we were waiting for the client, whereas you know, at Russell Russell it was like, okay, we're going to contact you before your company year end, we're going to contact you before your personal tax year end.
- 19:29Stuart Clark: We're going to try and do a bit more of that advisory stuff.
- 19:33Stuart Clark: So it's not just here's your accounts, your margins down, looks like you had a shit year.
- 19:37Stuart Clark: It's okay.
- 19:38Stuart Clark: Why is your margin down?
- 19:40Stuart Clark: Is your pricing right, what?
- 19:41Stuart Clark: How are the ways we can improve this and things like that.
- 19:44Douglas Aitken: And so that, yeah, just felt was a bit more structured proactivity, if that that makes sense yeah, definitely, and it was two brothers that um ran the firm, hence russell, and russell, ken and alistair.
- 19:55Douglas Aitken: Um, yeah, what was it that drove them?
- 19:58Douglas Aitken: Do you think to have have that approach, because it was quite different from others?
- 20:04Stuart Clark: Yeah, so they'd been on the accountants bootcamp with Paul Dunn in 2000, I think, and said yeah, said they kind of felt like they'd been brainwashed by the end when they came out like I've seen, the light came to the office, we've got all these ideas and the team's going hold on a minute, like it was so radically different then in 2000.
- 20:25Stuart Clark: Um, but yeah, they started to make those changes.
- 20:30Stuart Clark: I think at that point as well, ken had actually started to firm with his father, and it was his father, bert was, and Ken with the original Russell, russell and then Alistair joined after Burt passed away.
- 20:41Stuart Clark: Ken and Alistair there was 15 years age difference between them and so they weren't quite, you know, polar opposites with regards to what their goals were, but they were in slightly different life stages and up until 2000, I don't think they'd actually sat down and said what are we trying to achieve?
- 20:59Stuart Clark: And so it gave them quite a lot of clarity, even from themselves, to go right, what's the end goal for this business, what are we trying to do?
- 21:05Stuart Clark: And and that's when they kind of said we want to be one office based in Glasgow, grow to about 15 people, and that was it and it also, I think helped them focus, go right.
- 21:16Stuart Clark: Actually, what do we want to do the?
- 21:20Stuart Clark: What do we want the business to be once we leave?
- 21:22Stuart Clark: Is it going to die with us or are we going to actually put a proper succession plan in place?
- 21:27Stuart Clark: And so when I came in 2012, they were quite clear in that as well that they wanted myself and Roslyn to be part of the, the succession plan and it.
- 21:37Stuart Clark: As we kind of grew in numbers and you know, people's roles changed and and ian were part of that as well.
- 21:43Stuart Clark: Ian was always part of it, but yeah, um, he was already a director at that stage when I joined, so but they very much.
- 21:49Stuart Clark: They wanted rosalind and myself to to come in and be part of that succession plan, so they'd already started thinking about that, whereas you know, a lot of other sort of firms our size with sort principles of their age, maybe hadn't considered that or just kind of run it until the day they die.
- 22:07Douglas Aitken: Yeah, I was going to say so.
- 22:08Douglas Aitken: You knew from an early stage that you had a real future there, provided it met what you wanted.
- 22:15Douglas Aitken: But you were really clear on what the pathway looked like for you.
- 22:20Stuart Clark: Yeah, well, but you were really clear on what the pathway looked like for you.
- 22:24Stuart Clark: Yeah, well, it was, it wasn't.
- 22:26Stuart Clark: It wasn't.
- 22:26Stuart Clark: I think there was elements like we knew what we wanted to get to.
- 22:29Stuart Clark: How we got there wasn't maybe laid out step by step, but I think that's because, yeah, obviously when you come in, it's like we've got the opportunity of becoming a director and becoming an owner.
- 22:40Stuart Clark: How we're going to get there is it's not necessarily laid out in stone, but, um, there's certainly the option and the opportunity to to get that if that's what I wanted.
- 22:50Stuart Clark: So, yeah, it was.
- 22:52Stuart Clark: It was great to get that.
- 22:53Stuart Clark: It was something that, bizarrely enough, I kind of thought when I first started I was like, well, I'm quite happy just being an accountant.
- 23:00Stuart Clark: I'm not, it's not necessarily something that I'm.
- 23:03Stuart Clark: Possibly it might be nice, but it's not necessarily.
- 23:07Stuart Clark: It wasn't something I considered necessarily at Johnson Michael, my goal was never to become one of the partners there.
- 23:11Stuart Clark: I was just like that sounds like too much stress and too much hassle.
- 23:20Stuart Clark: But I think because we were working closely with businesses and you're doing some of that business strategic advice and stuff like this, and you're like, oh, what if we did that in our business or what we did this, you kind of started to get that ownership, and so maybe it's because it's a smaller team, that kind of opportunity seemed more exciting, whereas I think at Johnson and Michael they're so huge I just thought, well, if I become a partner there, am I actually going to have anything to do with driving the business forward or coming up with ideas, or will they get implemented?
- 23:45Stuart Clark: Whereas it felt like you know, rosalind and Ian, we've got a real stake in the business.
- 23:51Stuart Clark: Even before we were directors, we were helping to drive the business forward.
- 23:57Douglas Aitken: So how did you adapt to the type of work that you were doing?
- 24:00Douglas Aitken: Because, if I heard you right, you were saying earlier that there was very much a focus on proactivity and advisory type work.
- 24:10Douglas Aitken: So how did you adapt to that from your time at Johnston and Michael?
- 24:14Stuart Clark: I think I had a really good training and core set of skills, really good training and like core set of skills.
- 24:24Stuart Clark: Um.
- 24:24Stuart Clark: So you know, from that point of view, I'd been done my icas.
- 24:25Stuart Clark: I'd then started my tax exams as well, so I had those kind of core components there.
- 24:30Stuart Clark: It was, just as I said, that made more structured stuff.
- 24:34Stuart Clark: But some of the business advisory stuff, you know, was kind of new to me.
- 24:38Stuart Clark: You can, obviously, you learn how to do your profit and loss and stuff that, but you're not necessarily using the things to how to drive the business forward.
- 24:45Stuart Clark: And so I think I remember Alistair when I first came in.
- 24:49Stuart Clark: There's things that they were doing within the business, like the four ways to grow the business.
- 24:54Stuart Clark: They had that model there, but it was very manual and it was kind of like right, can we do this and stuff this?
- 25:01Stuart Clark: And so because I was coming in then I didn't have a client list and because they had capacity, they were like, right, we want you just to build an excel model that does the four ways to grow a business and stuff like this.
- 25:14Stuart Clark: So I started building in macros and you press the button that ultimately has one percent to everything and all you'd see a graph which showed you the profit improvement potential and all this kind of stuff.
- 25:24Stuart Clark: So because I was given getting these tasks and I was building models for the first few months I was in, I think it kind of helped me to go right, okay, this is what they're trying to do.
- 25:35Stuart Clark: And then I'd go out to meetings with Alistair or with Ken and they'd go through it and we'd have those discussions and I think that's.
- 25:44Stuart Clark: You know, you can read all the books and stuff like that, but it's actually speaking to business owners and seeing Ken and Alistair have those discussions really helped.
- 25:52Stuart Clark: It was the same.
- 25:54Stuart Clark: You know, I had an element of it with Andrew Shepard when I was at John Scarmichael, when I'd gone into meetings with him.
- 26:02Stuart Clark: It wasn't about the counts, it was about like here's your counts, let's sign them off, but actually what's your future plans, what are you trying to achieve, and things like that.
- 26:10Stuart Clark: But he was just.
- 26:11Stuart Clark: You know, him and Alistair were both quite naturally gifted at that.
- 26:14Stuart Clark: I'm trying to bring a bit more structure to it and also trying to.
- 26:18Stuart Clark: You know, I only learn by being in meetings with them.
- 26:20Stuart Clark: So we're trying to make sure we're taking people into meetings with us so they can learn, because, yeah, the only way you learn is by doing, and it's not always easiest to get access and get the opportunity to learn those skills for yourself.
- 26:34Douglas Aitken: Yeah, definitely, fab.
- 26:36Douglas Aitken: And was there a point where the penny dropped?
- 26:40Douglas Aitken: Or were there particular uh clients that you met and you came away with thinking, oh yeah, this, this is great.
- 26:47Douglas Aitken: This is definitely what I want to do more of, I think you know you're stretching my memory now because it's 12 years ago, but there yeah, there will be.
- 26:57Stuart Clark: I mean, I certainly remember being in some things.
- 26:59Stuart Clark: I remember one client in particular where Alistair, kind of the first year's new client, took on board, did the business advisory, and he said, right, you're gonna just run the next session, I'm not going to be there.
- 27:14Stuart Clark: And I was like, oh god, right, what do I do?
- 27:18Stuart Clark: But, um, it was fine and I think it was like he obviously recognized that I was a couple years into that stage.
- 27:27Stuart Clark: I've been in a number of meetings.
- 27:28Stuart Clark: Uh, I just needed that push to go and, you know, sink or swim, and I was like, right, you just need to.
- 27:34Stuart Clark: Obviously probably prepared more for that meeting than any other meeting in my life, because I wanted to make sure I had everything covered and I had an agenda down to every single minute of what was going to be covered.
- 27:44Stuart Clark: But yeah, things like that.
- 27:47Stuart Clark: We had Paul Dunn over for an event, a couple of events actually, and that was great.
- 27:54Stuart Clark: Some of the stuff that he was talking about and then you're able to go and speak to clients about it.
- 27:58Stuart Clark: The clients get.
- 27:59Stuart Clark: Everyone came at that event buzzing and people were talking to us and stuff like that.
- 28:03Stuart Clark: And then on the back of that we started running the wally events.
- 28:06Stuart Clark: So the wally interview that used to be part of ran one or raz one, and back in the day as well, and it will also list a video.
- 28:13Stuart Clark: We had it on video.
- 28:15Stuart Clark: We have to lug a video recorder about.
- 28:17Stuart Clark: We've now got it on online but a digital version.
- 28:21Stuart Clark: But running those events, and again I actually ran I think Alistair was running it and then I can't remember if he was ill or something happened, but I ended up.
- 28:31Stuart Clark: I sat in quite a few and I ended up running with them and then, yeah, that kind of was like, okay, I can do this, I can, can get, can get it, but again, just try to get more systemized.
- 28:42Stuart Clark: I was trying to put notes in place.
- 28:44Stuart Clark: So again, the first time I ran it I must have known I was gonna run.
- 28:47Stuart Clark: Actually, because I ran, yeah, I wrote all these notes out of things I want to make sure we covered off.
- 28:51Stuart Clark: But now we've got a kind of template and a more kind of, uh, detailed notes, so that again, hopefully other people in the office could run it if they, if they needed to, because there's discussion points and things to make sure we covered before and it was quite a a basic handbook that we had as part of it yeah.
- 29:08Douglas Aitken: So, um, when you, when it came to buying out the, the previous owners of the firm, tell us about that process.
- 29:16Douglas Aitken: How did it, how did that come about and what kind of timescale did it follow, and what were the highs and lows of that?
- 29:27Stuart Clark: I suppose there's different timescales.
- 29:28Stuart Clark: I think pre-COVID, so August 2019, we were in talks about what Ken and Alistair were wanting to do and they asked me if I wanted to be the managing director, and so it was kind of agreed, from that point on, that would be the the case.
- 29:49Stuart Clark: I don't think we formally announced it until february 2020, which is obviously perfect timing, just in time for covid, um, and so it kind of got put in the back burner at that point, because covid hit and just totally changed and it was like, right, we just need to survive, just to get through yeah, get through it.
- 30:08Stuart Clark: Um, I think it's all.
- 30:09Stuart Clark: It changed for them a bit, because they were suddenly at home all day and going what would I do if I'm not working?
- 30:16Stuart Clark: yeah, do you know what does my day look like?
- 30:19Stuart Clark: I've spent 40 years in the business.
- 30:21Stuart Clark: Um, do I really want to to leave?
- 30:24Stuart Clark: So, yeah, when we came out of Covid, we were quite keen to push on.
- 30:31Stuart Clark: It didn't always I don't know if they were I said, said, having not second thoughts, but just kind of like, actually, when do I want to retire?
- 30:42Stuart Clark: Um, and then we had a lot of back and forth um throughout.
- 30:50Stuart Clark: I think the start of 2022.
- 30:53Stuart Clark: I think I kind of internally put a deadline on myself, saying if this isn't wrapped up by our year ends january, uh, this isn't wrapped up by january 23, then I might just have to cut my losses and try something different or set up on itself or do do something else.
- 31:12Stuart Clark: Um, and it kind of got somewhere and installed and, yeah, just couldn't quite get across.
- 31:20Stuart Clark: I think it's partly because the day job just took priority and we're just firefighting with client stuff and sometimes, um, partly because I think, as I said, they weren't entirely sure what they they wanted to do.
- 31:34Stuart Clark: But I think there was a budget announced in for November 22 and they they thought there might be there's a risk that capital gains might go up.
- 31:45Stuart Clark: So it basically got done in a week and that from that point.
- 31:51Stuart Clark: So it kind of dragged and dragged and dragged and then it was basically it was a day of just signing everything off and going through everything and agreeing what the figures were and what we did, and we just spent a day locked up in a room, the six of us, hammering out everything that we'd been kind of trying to push through for the previous 12, 24 months, 36 months maybe, but we got there in the end.
- 32:17Douglas Aitken: There's nothing like a deadline to focus.
- 32:19Douglas Aitken: The mind isn't there.
- 32:20Douglas Aitken: And how did that feel for you and the other people involved Roslyn and Ian Maybe not so much Ian, and he'll forgive me for saying this, he's slightly older as well but for you, three as younger people suddenly assuming all that responsibility, and it was sudden.
- 32:41Douglas Aitken: Over the space of a week, the deal was done.
- 32:44Douglas Aitken: How did that all feel?
- 32:46Stuart Clark: I think it was.
- 32:47Stuart Clark: Yeah, it was a mix of emotions.
- 32:50Stuart Clark: It's something that we've been talking about for so long.
- 32:53Stuart Clark: It was kind of like relief that we'd finally got across the line and you're like, and you're kind of excited to get going.
- 33:01Stuart Clark: But then there probably is a bit of nervousness as well once you kind of start to get things.
- 33:06Stuart Clark: Because although we were directors and shareholders, it very much still was Ken and Alistair dealt with the majority of things on a day-to-day basis, or certainly from the kind of ownership point of view and stuff like that.
- 33:19Stuart Clark: So, um, like I don't think I had access to the bank until the day we bought it, so like we couldn't go in and make bank payments.
- 33:28Stuart Clark: So it was like suddenly even things like that like okay, bank lines is an absolute, horrific bit of software or interface, so like how do we make payments to the, the team to pay the wages this month and stuff this, all these kind of things that we uh shouldn't have been big deal.
- 33:45Stuart Clark: But suddenly, yeah, it was just a bit more testing and trying than we thought we'd be.
- 33:49Stuart Clark: We've all been in the business.
- 33:50Stuart Clark: I was the most.
- 33:52Stuart Clark: I mean, I've been in the business for 10 years and I was the person that served the least time out of the four of us directors.
- 34:00Stuart Clark: Everyone else had been in longer than me.
- 34:01Stuart Clark: Um, so you should go right.
- 34:03Stuart Clark: We should know the business inside and out, but there's still things that came out that would work from from that.
- 34:07Stuart Clark: So I think I'd also.
- 34:11Stuart Clark: I think I bought the business on the Friday and started a house extension on the Monday, which was not maybe the best.
- 34:21Stuart Clark: It was actually similar.
- 34:22Stuart Clark: When I became a director, I think, my daughter was born.
- 34:27Stuart Clark: I then got made director.
- 34:28Stuart Clark: I then bought a new house and then my wife and I got married, which is probably completely the wrong order.
- 34:33Stuart Clark: I'm sure my parents would say it was the wrong order, but we were happy with it.
- 34:38Stuart Clark: But that was quite a stressful year and then, I think, when we bought it, I was like, well, this is similar, and you had Covid in the middle of that as well, just to add to things.
- 34:48Stuart Clark: So it was quite a all in all.
- 34:51Stuart Clark: I think going back it was quite a stressful period.
- 34:53Stuart Clark: But yeah, I think going back it's quite a stressful period, but yeah, I think we got to where we wanted to get to in the end good, good, and so you're now owner of the business alongside the others.
- 35:10Douglas Aitken: Tell me about those first few months, because, although you knew it was coming to an extent, you were still thrown in at the deep end.
- 35:18Douglas Aitken: So tell me about these first few months, how?
- 35:20Stuart Clark: were they scary?
- 35:31Stuart Clark: I think a bit of everything.
- 35:33Stuart Clark: I it almost seems so long ago like, yeah, it feels like a distant memory, but I think you know we were champing a bit to get get going and to start to put things in place.
- 35:46Stuart Clark: So we started like we did a website rebrand we changed the name.
- 35:51Stuart Clark: We not changed the name.
- 35:53Stuart Clark: We kept Russell Russell because we wanted to keep that.
- 35:55Stuart Clark: None of us were bothered about having our names on the door and Russell Russell was something that we do have a good reputation in Glasgow and people have heard of us.
- 36:04Stuart Clark: So we didn't want to lose that and we didn't want to alienate potential clients as well, because some of them had long standing relationships with Ken and Alistair.
- 36:14Stuart Clark: And so you've got that handover period.
- 36:16Stuart Clark: You know you don't want to pay X amount on the pound for something and then to leave the door the next day because they think everything's going to change.
- 36:25Stuart Clark: So some of it was just, you know, we wanted to put these changes in but we didn't want to rock the boat too much as well and sort of.
- 36:32Stuart Clark: But I think the things we had put in place and you'll start with yourself feeling things like making life better and a purpose in place.
- 36:40Stuart Clark: You know, I think that could have been the existing clients can be like, oh, hold on a minute, that's not what I signed up for.
- 36:47Stuart Clark: But I think because we were meeting with clients regularly, we were doing all these things, it just was getting kind of.
- 36:53Stuart Clark: It wasn't actually a huge change, yeah, in direction.
- 36:57Stuart Clark: It was just crystallizing what we're already doing and trying to explain to clients what it was, and so I think overall client feedback's been been pretty good.
- 37:06Stuart Clark: I don't think anyone's kind of said oh, don't agree with that, because, yeah, again, it's quite a positive message.
- 37:12Stuart Clark: If you don't agree with making lives better, I know what is happening there.
- 37:18Stuart Clark: So, yeah, it's the first couple of years we had a couple of things.
- 37:26Stuart Clark: We had a telephone contract that we put in place during Covid that just was not fit for purpose and had to try and extract ourselves from that and they tried to take us to court and sue us and charge us all these fees that we didn't think were appropriate.
- 37:45Stuart Clark: And so there were, you know, we went back to them with a proposal and they said, no, we went to the lawyers back and forth and a lot of stress with that and then eventually the lawyer said oh, you know why about this proposal, and they agreed it, and it was the same thing that I put forward six, eight months earlier, but without incurring all the legal fees on both sides.
- 38:03Stuart Clark: So there was that.
- 38:05Stuart Clark: There was a another bit of software that again, we put a new fyn this last year it'll be a year ago fyi in place, and so it meant that the former mail management system, email management system that we had in place, wasn't needed.
- 38:19Stuart Clark: So we gave them notice and they came back and said, oh, you've got this 89 days notice.
- 38:24Stuart Clark: It's actually 90 days notice you need to give us.
- 38:26Stuart Clark: It's a two-year contract, otherwise so you owe us 10 grand.
- 38:30Stuart Clark: And then we went back, said I don't think that is the case, and then never heard back from them.
- 38:31Stuart Clark: And then till we got a lawyer's letter saying no, you owe us 10 grand.
- 38:33Stuart Clark: And then we went back and said I don't think that is the case, and then never heard back from them.
- 38:35Stuart Clark: And then we got a lawyer's letter saying no, you owe us 10 grand.
- 38:37Stuart Clark: Then I went back actually went back onto the Wayback Machine, which is like an internet archive, and found the terms and conditions that were on their website from the day that we signed the document, I was like no, you can clearly see here, it's 30 days notice and it's only a year at worst case.
- 38:53Stuart Clark: And they came back and said, oh yeah, sorry, you're right, you are right, we didn't check it, we just thought it was the new terms, but we never issued to them.
- 39:01Stuart Clark: You signed up to those ones.
- 39:02Stuart Clark: So yeah, there isn't anything here.
- 39:03Stuart Clark: So I've got good reading terms and conditions over the last couple of years.
- 39:10Stuart Clark: So, yeah, there's just a couple of things like that where it just needed to be ironed out, there's issues that need to be resolved, but it takes you away from the day-to-day and takes you away from the things that you're wanting to do to grow the business.
- 39:21Stuart Clark: So I think, because we're doing things like that, we probably like the sales and marketing side of things we slowed down on when we bought the business.
- 39:31Stuart Clark: Obviously we didn't have the cash to pay Ken and Alistair upfront, so we're paying them out of the profits that we make going forward.
- 39:39Stuart Clark: But since then, corporation tax has gone from 19% up to 25% from when we signed the deal.
- 39:45Stuart Clark: You've got employers NI's just gone up, minimum wage has gone up, all these extra costs.
- 39:51Stuart Clark: So all these things kind of, yeah, just cause a bit more stress, a bit more tension, which kind of can sometimes pull you away from looking after the team and making life better for them or pull you away from the client work and stuff that.
- 40:04Stuart Clark: So it's been a bit of a juggling act the last couple years but I feel like we're kind of, yeah, getting getting getting through the choppy waters as we're and not it's gonna be plain sailing, but ipy waters as we're in Not that it's going to be plain sailing, but I think we're getting there and we've put a real focus on new sales and marketing and bringing clients in.
- 40:22Stuart Clark: This year that's starting to pay off, got lots of good leads and lots of clients of the type we want Good and the client base itself.
- 40:32Stuart Clark: We've got a lot of good clients as well.
- 40:34Stuart Clark: We kind of go through ranking the clients and being sure that the type of clients that are aligned with our values and they value our services, things like that.
- 40:44Stuart Clark: And yeah, there's not any clients that we're kind of like, oh the phone, every time the phone rings, your heart drops.
- 40:51Stuart Clark: There's none of them on our client books which historically, especially especially during COVID, there was maybe some clients that you called that maybe weren't the right fit for us.
- 40:59Stuart Clark: Just because you weren't sure, maybe you didn't do the gate of acceptance, which may be a little bit easier to get through because you're just like, right, we'll see.
- 41:10Stuart Clark: We don't know what's going to happen, but yeah, I think it's got its challenges.
- 41:18Stuart Clark: But we've got a good team behind us as well, which is obviously freeing us up as well.
- 41:22Stuart Clark: It's kind of touching it.
- 41:24Stuart Clark: Before, like before covid, there was 13 of us, which included the four of us and two at ken and alistair, so it's only really 17 members.
- 41:32Stuart Clark: We're now at 20 team members and only four directors.
- 41:35Stuart Clark: So even just that shift and you've got two people leaving that are quite senior, trying to replace that and build the team back up and build a bit of resilience in there.
- 41:43Stuart Clark: It's been a longer process than we probably anticipated.
- 41:47Stuart Clark: We've had quite a few trainees come in that maybe weren't quite the right fit and stuff like that, but got a really good core team now and, yeah, feel like we're ready for the next step.
- 41:58Douglas Aitken: Great.
- 41:58Douglas Aitken: And what are you most proud of today, stuart, you were thrust into it and you've had to find your feet as a management team and whatnot.
- 42:07Douglas Aitken: So what are you most proud of?
- 42:10Stuart Clark: I think the team that we've built, you know, I think we've got a really great team.
- 42:13Stuart Clark: I think the culture's really good.
- 42:16Stuart Clark: I think the purpose and we've built you know, I think we've got a really great team.
- 42:19Stuart Clark: I think the culture is really good.
- 42:20Stuart Clark: I think the purpose and the values and stuff that we've built tie into all that attracting the right talent and retaining the right talent, that we do the kind of weekly one-to-ones and there's always, you know, something that's not quite right, but it gives us an opportunity to try and correct things and make things better for for going forward.
- 42:41Stuart Clark: Um, so yeah, I think the team, uh, is probably the the number one thing and it's not underpinned by the getting those values and and the rebrand as well and getting the purpose and everything up on the website.
- 42:54Stuart Clark: So it's really identifiable that we do stand for something different and we're not just a I said a sausage piece that churns out year-end accounts.
- 43:03Douglas Aitken: Yeah, yeah.
- 43:04Douglas Aitken: And what does the future hold?
- 43:06Douglas Aitken: What's the vision over the next few years?
- 43:09Douglas Aitken: Yeah, so.
- 43:12Stuart Clark: I'd like to get to about 30 people.
- 43:14Stuart Clark: I don't really well, again, these things always change.
- 43:18Stuart Clark: We suit the clients and they hit one goal and then there's another goal after it.
- 43:21Stuart Clark: But I think 30 feels like it's manageable, that I'd still know everyone's name, still be in first term basis with everyone and, you know, be able to go into the room and have a chat with them and not, uh, yeah, it wouldn't be too, too unwieldy.
- 43:37Stuart Clark: Uh, we'd also be able to sort of stay in this premises that we've got and you know, manage it from there.
- 43:42Stuart Clark: Um, and it just feels like a kind of nice manageable number but also could be a really great business and, uh, provide really exciting opportunities for the team, good clients to work with and can add lots of value.
- 43:57Stuart Clark: But yeah, I think it's something we're constantly reviewing and revisiting.
- 44:03Stuart Clark: I'm sure we've touched on it in the past, like AI and all the things like that, like what's that going to do to industry?
- 44:10Stuart Clark: So it's always something you're kind of thinking about.
- 44:12Stuart Clark: But yeah, I think a team of 30 probably still one office in Glasgow, would be where I want to be and kind of get, so that I'm taking myself away from the kind of day-to-day stuff and I'm doing maybe more kind of strategic advisory stuff with businesses and stuff like that and, yeah, letting the team run the business and do the that kind of stuff yeah, fab, excellent.
- 44:41Douglas Aitken: Okay, that's great.
- 44:44Douglas Aitken: Stuart, thank you so much for your time today.
- 44:47Douglas Aitken: It's been a joy talking to you and getting a feel for the journey that you've been on, and it's been a heck of a journey.
- 44:54Douglas Aitken: I think, what stuck with me a lot was that, the kind of resetting after Covid of Ken and Alistair, and that was completely explainable.
- 45:03Douglas Aitken: I think a lot of us went through that reset yeah rethinking a number of things at that point, but I hadn't quite appreciated.
- 45:11Douglas Aitken: The deal was done in a week and in fact in a day of signing, so a heck of a change quickly for you.
- 45:21Douglas Aitken: But, yeah, a brilliant story and I'm sure it'll inspire loads of others as well.
- 45:26Douglas Aitken: So really appreciate the time.
- 45:27Douglas Aitken: Again, stuart, thanks for joining us.
- 45:29Douglas Aitken: Thank you.
- 45:30Douglas Aitken: You've just heard Stuart Clarke talking about the importance of purpose, values and vision and how you articulate your firm differently in a sea of sameness.
- 45:43Douglas Aitken: These are the sort of things that we tackle at the Accountants Growth Academy, which you can find more about on remarkablepracticecom.
- 45:54Paul Shrimpling: You'll find more valuable discussions with the leaders of ambitious accounting firms at humanizethenumbersonline.
- 46:01Paul Shrimpling: You can also sign up to be notified each time a new podcast is made available.
- 46:06Paul Shrimpling: You're about to hear a short excerpt from a podcast discussion with stefan meyer, author of the employee advantage.
- 46:19Paul Shrimpling: If you like what you're hearing and you want more, please go to humanize the numbersonline or go to your favorite podcast platform you know the small teams is a good start, but you actually the culture needs to change as well.
- 46:32Speaker 4: how you know how those innovation and how you create those psychological safety that people are actually willing to to express voices, and obviously they need to empower.
- 46:45Speaker 4: You know, if you have no power and there is nothing you can, I mean why would you express anything or put in effort in doing so?
- 46:52Speaker 4: And and ING is a really good example I mean they also got hit by competition, you know, by more nimble, for technological reasons somehow as well, and I could imagine that might happen in the accounting industry as well.
- 47:06Speaker 4: You know, like suddenly smaller firms with technology together might suddenly be a competition that were not before and now you have to.
- 47:20Speaker 4: Ing had to change because they were now competing against those fintech firms who are organized very differently, much smaller, much nimbler, and they needed to completely change their operational model smaller teams, flatter hierarchies and then on top of it, kind of the culture shift, empowering the employees, creating those psychological safety environment to actually get those innovation going.