Latest / The Checkout Point / Week 44 - Holiday Spending Forecasts: Adobe's $275.1B Number, Deloitte's Second Opinion, Prime Big Deal Days Results, and Shopify's Canvas Tool
Transcript
- 0:05[Max] Welcome to the Checkout Point, your quick dive into this week's eCommerce
- 0:08[Max] buzz with me, Alex, powered by Blicket.
- 0:12[Max] These 20 minutes pack the latest trends, news, and insights.
- 0:15[Max] Let's navigate the digital marketplace together.
- 0:18[Max] Ready?
- 0:19[Max] Let's go.
- 0:27[Rachel] Okay, quick poll.
- 0:29[Rachel] How many tabs do you have open with some holiday forecast in
- 0:31[Rachel] it?
- 0:32[Speaker 3] Max, it's four.
- 0:33[Speaker 3] Four tabs, and they do not agree with each other.
- 0:36[Rachel] Of course they don't.
- 0:37[Speaker 3] Which is my whole problem.
- 0:38[Speaker 3] Everybody wants to tell me how big the season is gonna be.
- 0:41[Rachel] Right?
- 0:42[Rachel] Big, bigger, biggest.
- 0:44[Speaker 3] But what's the actual number, and does anyone else land in the
- 0:47[Speaker 3] same place?
- 0:48[Rachel] Wait, that's the whole episode, isn't it?
- 0:50[Speaker 3] Pretty much.
- 0:51[Speaker 3] Oh, and before I forget, I'm Rachel.
- 0:53[Rachel] And I'm Max, and this is the Checkout Point week 44, where
- 0:56[Rachel] we read the forecast so you can skip the tab hoarding.
- 0:59[Speaker 3] Some of us can't quit.
- 1:00[Speaker 3] I'll be honest, I like a good spreadsheet.
- 1:03[Rachel] We know.
- 1:04[Rachel] We've all seen your face at a pivot table.
- 1:06[Speaker 3] Hey, it's a happy face.
- 1:08[Rachel] Here's the plan for today.
- 1:09[Rachel] One big forecast, a second opinion, a look at a recent sale
- 1:12[Rachel] event, and then something practical for your store.
- 1:14[Speaker 3] And we'll tell you where we're guessing so you can decide how
- 1:17[Speaker 3] much to trust us.
- 1:18[Rachel] So anyway, let's start with the big headline number everyone is quoting.
- 1:27[Rachel] Okay, the number.
- 1:28[Rachel] Adobe says US online holiday spending hits $275.1 billion.
- 1:34[Speaker 3] Billion with a B.
- 1:36[Rachel] Billion with a B, and that's for November 1st through December 31st
- 1:39[Rachel] this year.
- 1:40[Speaker 3] Fine, but a big number alone means nothing to me.
- 1:43[Speaker 3] Compared to what?
- 1:44[Rachel] Up 6.7% year over year, so a record, yeah.
- 1:48[Speaker 3] 6.7.
- 1:49[Speaker 3] Okay, that's not nothing, but it's not a rocket either.
- 1:53[Rachel] Rachel, you could make a lottery win sound like a rounding error.
- 1:56[Speaker 3] I mean, I've signed off on budgets where 6% was the difference
- 1:59[Speaker 3] between a bonus and a hiring freeze, so I respect it.
- 2:03[Rachel] Fair.
- 2:03[Rachel] Now, here's the part I liked.
- 2:05[Rachel] Adobe's release says Cyber Monday is still the biggest single day.
- 2:09[Speaker 3] Of course it is.
- 2:10[Speaker 3] What's the number?
- 2:11[Rachel] More than $15 billion in one day.
- 2:14[Speaker 3] Wait, really?
- 2:15[Speaker 3] One Monday?
- 2:16[Rachel] One Monday.
- 2:17[Rachel] People are sitting at their desks pretending to work and buying towels.
- 2:21[Speaker 3] Guilty.
- 2:22[Speaker 3] But the twist is Black Friday.
- 2:24[Speaker 3] Adobe expects it to grow faster than Cyber Monday.
- 2:27[Rachel] Why?
- 2:28[Rachel] Cyber Monday has the whole brand built around it.
- 2:30[Rachel] Discounts start earlier, so the Friday crowd isn't waiting for the weekend
- 2:34[Rachel] to wrap up.
- 2:34[Rachel] The deals are already out there.
- 2:36[Speaker 3] Mm, so the early deals pull demand forward.
- 2:39[Rachel] And the discounts reach up to 30% off.
- 2:42[Speaker 3] Up to.
- 2:43[Speaker 3] Those two words do a lot of work.
- 2:45[Speaker 3] In my Walmart days, up to 30% meant one sad item in
- 2:49[Speaker 3] the back of the page.
- 2:51[Rachel] The one lonely blender.
- 2:53[Speaker 3] Exactly.
- 2:54[Speaker 3] The lonely blender carries the whole banner.
- 2:56[Speaker 3] So what's the actual margin hit on a deal like that?
- 2:59[Speaker 3] Because a record top line doesn't tell me if anyone made money.
- 3:03[Rachel] Totally fair, and the forecast doesn't answer that.
- 3:05[Rachel] It's about spending, not profit.
- 3:07[Speaker 3] Right, which is why I always read these as demand signals, not
- 3:10[Speaker 3] victory laps.
- 3:12[Rachel] So what does a merchant do with that?
- 3:14[Rachel] If Black Friday is the faster-growing day, the timing of your own
- 3:17[Rachel] deals starts to matter.
- 3:19[Speaker 3] It does.
- 3:20[Speaker 3] If competitors are discounting earlier, showing up on the Monday means you're
- 3:23[Speaker 3] arriving after the crowd already spent its attention.
- 3:26[Rachel] Picture a small shop that plans its big email for Cyber Monday
- 3:29[Rachel] because that's what the calendar always said.
- 3:31[Rachel] If demand is leaning towards the Friday, that email lands late.
- 3:35[Speaker 3] Careful, though.
- 3:36[Speaker 3] Monday is still the biggest day.
- 3:37[Speaker 3] The forecast says Friday grows faster, not that Monday shrinks.
- 3:41[Speaker 3] Different claim.
- 3:42[Rachel] Right.
- 3:43[Rachel] So it's not abandon Monday, it's don't treat the weekend as dead
- 3:46[Rachel] air.
- 3:47[Speaker 3] Exactly.
- 3:48[Speaker 3] Have an offer ready earlier and keep something fresh for Monday too.
- 3:51[Rachel] Wait, doesn't that cost more, two big pushes instead of one?
- 3:54[Speaker 3] It can.
- 3:56[Speaker 3] That's where I'd go through ad spend line by line and ask
- 3:59[Speaker 3] which push earns its keep.
- 4:01[Speaker 3] Don't split the budget down the middle because it feels fair.
- 4:03[Rachel] Is there a simpler version of that for a tiny store?
- 4:06[Speaker 3] Pick the few things you actually want to sell and decide your
- 4:09[Speaker 3] lowest acceptable price on each before the season starts.
- 4:13[Speaker 3] Then you're not making margin decisions at midnight.
- 4:15[Rachel] Midnight decisions are how I ended up with a drawer full of
- 4:18[Rachel] cables.
- 4:19[Rachel] Okay, that's a me problem.
- 4:21[Speaker 3] It's a lot of people's problem.
- 4:23[Speaker 3] And remember the window.
- 4:24[Speaker 3] November 1st through December 31st is two months, so stock has already
- 4:29[Speaker 3] to be on the shelf.
- 4:31[Rachel] Okay, but check this out.
- 4:32[Rachel] What are people actually buying?
- 4:34[Rachel] Because I expected TVs and gaming consoles.
- 4:37[Speaker 3] Same.
- 4:38[Speaker 3] Give me the shiny stuff.
- 4:39[Rachel] Nope.
- 4:40[Rachel] Shoppers are stocking up on essentials, personal hygiene products, clothing basics.
- 4:45[Speaker 3] No way.
- 4:46[Speaker 3] Socks and shampoo?
- 4:47[Rachel] Socks and shampoo.
- 4:49[Rachel] Record holiday season, and people are loading carts with deodorant.
- 4:54[Speaker 3] Very festive.
- 4:55[Speaker 3] Nothing says joy like a bulk pack of undershirts.
- 4:58[Rachel] I mean, come on, that's practical.
- 5:00[Rachel] If a discount is real, why not buy the stuff you were
- 5:03[Rachel] going to buy anyway?
- 5:04[Speaker 3] Sure, but that changes how I'd read the headline.
- 5:07[Speaker 3] Essentials are low glamour.
- 5:09[Speaker 3] They're steady.
- 5:10[Speaker 3] They also tend to be lower margin, so the record might feel
- 5:13[Speaker 3] less recordy on the profit line.
- 5:15[Rachel] Okay, that's a fair worry.
- 5:17[Rachel] Though I'd say it also means shoppers are being smart with deals.
- 5:20[Rachel] They're timing it.
- 5:21[Speaker 3] Timing it or just being cautious.
- 5:24[Speaker 3] Same cart, different mood.
- 5:26[Rachel] Ha, yeah.
- 5:26[Rachel] The forecast doesn't tell us which.
- 5:28[Speaker 3] And that's my issue.
- 5:30[Speaker 3] One company, one model, one story about what shoppers feel.
- 5:34[Rachel] Here's the thing.
- 5:35[Rachel] One forecast is just one opinion.
- 5:37[Rachel] Adobe's is a big one, sure.
- 5:38[Speaker 3] So who else weighed in?
- 5:40[Rachel] Someone did, and they framed it differently.
- 5:47[Rachel] Okay, second opinion.
- 5:49[Rachel] Deloitte weighed in, and Retail Dive reported on it.
- 5:52[Rachel] The headline, eCommerce growth of up to 8.4%.
- 5:57[Speaker 3] Up to.
- 5:58[Speaker 3] Sorry, I know, we've used that one up, but yes, up to.
- 6:02[Rachel] You're allowed one nod.
- 6:03[Rachel] Now, here's the comparison point.
- 6:05[Rachel] Retail Dive says Deloitte's overall holiday retail growing between four and four
- 6:09[Rachel] point eight percent.
- 6:11[Speaker 3] So online is roughly double the rate of everything else.
- 6:14[Rachel] At the top end, yeah.
- 6:16[Rachel] And that overall pile of retail is about one point seven trillion
- 6:21[Rachel] dollars.
- 6:22[Speaker 3] Trillion, with a T.
- 6:24[Rachel] Wait, did you just steal my bit?
- 6:26[Speaker 3] Uh, borrowed.
- 6:27[Speaker 3] I'll return it.
- 6:28[Rachel] Fine, but picture it.
- 6:30[Rachel] Most of that one point seven trillion is still people walking into
- 6:33[Rachel] stores, and online is the faster slice.
- 6:36[Speaker 3] Mm.
- 6:37[Speaker 3] And I wanna flag the dates because this is where people get
- 6:40[Speaker 3] sloppy.
- 6:41[Speaker 3] Deloitte's window runs November twenty twenty-six through January twenty twenty-seven.
- 6:46[Rachel] Three months, so it runs a month longer than the other forecast's
- 6:50[Rachel] window.
- 6:51[Speaker 3] Right.
- 6:51[Speaker 3] Different start, different finish, so you can't line up the two growth
- 6:55[Speaker 3] numbers and say one forecaster is more bullish.
- 6:58[Rachel] Oh, come on.
- 6:58[Rachel] Everybody's gonna do it anyway.
- 7:00[Rachel] Eight point four is bigger than the other one.
- 7:02[Rachel] Screenshot, tweet, done.
- 7:04[Speaker 3] And then someone builds a budget on it.
- 7:06[Speaker 3] I've watched that happen.
- 7:07[Speaker 3] A planning team grabs a number that measures a different window, and
- 7:10[Speaker 3] suddenly inventory is off.
- 7:13[Rachel] Like ordering pizza for twelve when the party's for eight.
- 7:16[Speaker 3] Worse.
- 7:16[Speaker 3] Pizza gets eaten.
- 7:17[Speaker 3] Unsold inventory sits there and charges you rent.
- 7:21[Rachel] Okay, that's fair.
- 7:22[Rachel] So what do we actually take from two forecasts that don't line
- 7:25[Rachel] up?
- 7:26[Speaker 3] The direction.
- 7:27[Speaker 3] Both of them say online grows faster than retail as a whole.
- 7:31[Speaker 3] Different windows, same shape.
- 7:33[Rachel] That's kinda wild, right?
- 7:35[Rachel] Two separate forecasters, two different calendars, and they land on the same
- 7:39[Rachel] story.
- 7:40[Speaker 3] Which makes me more comfortable than any single number would.
- 7:43[Speaker 3] Still, what's driving it?
- 7:45[Rachel] And this is the part I didn't expect.
- 7:47[Rachel] The Retail Dive report ties part of that online growth to shoppers
- 7:51[Rachel] using AI tools.
- 7:53[Speaker 3] Wait, really?
- 7:54[Speaker 3] Part of it?
- 7:55[Rachel] Part.
- 7:55[Rachel] That's all the report says to me, so I'm not gonna invent
- 7:57[Rachel] a percentage.
- 7:58[Speaker 3] Good, because I'd ask for the ROI on that immediately.
- 8:03[Rachel] Of course you would.
- 8:04[Speaker 3] I'm serious.
- 8:05[Speaker 3] If AI helps shoppers find things faster, does the cart get bigger,
- 8:09[Speaker 3] or does it just get decided sooner?
- 8:12[Speaker 3] Those are very different outcomes for margin.
- 8:15[Rachel] Huh.
- 8:15[Rachel] Faster decision might mean fewer impulse tabs, which is bad for those
- 8:19[Rachel] of us who love impulse buys.
- 8:21[Speaker 3] Or it means fewer abandoned carts.
- 8:23[Speaker 3] I don't know yet.
- 8:24[Speaker 3] The report doesn't settle it.
- 8:25[Rachel] Let me push on the window thing a bit because I think
- 8:27[Rachel] it's the most useful part for store owners.
- 8:30[Speaker 3] Go for it.
- 8:30[Rachel] If one window ends in December and the other runs into January,
- 8:34[Rachel] what's in that extra month?
- 8:36[Speaker 3] The report gives us the window, not the breakdown, so I can't
- 8:39[Speaker 3] tell you what's counted in it.
- 8:41[Speaker 3] I could guess about returns and gift cards, but that would be
- 8:44[Speaker 3] a guess.
- 8:45[Rachel] So a longer window might just be catching a different kind of
- 8:48[Rachel] shopping.
- 8:49[Speaker 3] Might.
- 8:50[Speaker 3] That's a reason to be careful, not a conclusion.
- 8:53[Speaker 3] I'd rather say we don't know than make something up.
- 8:55[Rachel] Fair.
- 8:56[Rachel] So what's the move for someone building a budget?
- 8:58[Speaker 3] Treat each number as a statement about its own window.
- 9:02[Speaker 3] Write the dates right next to the number in your planning doc.
- 9:05[Speaker 3] It sounds silly, but that's how you stop the wrong number from
- 9:08[Speaker 3] sneaking into a slide.
- 9:09[Rachel] Dates next to the number.
- 9:11[Rachel] Simple.
- 9:11[Rachel] I like it.
- 9:12[Speaker 3] Simple is underrated.
- 9:13[Speaker 3] Most of my worst planning mistakes were complicated.
- 9:16[Rachel] And on the growth side, eight point four is a ceiling, right?
- 9:20[Rachel] Up to.
- 9:21[Speaker 3] Right.
- 9:21[Speaker 3] I read it as the top of a range.
- 9:23[Speaker 3] If you plan like you'll hit the ceiling, you're betting the best
- 9:26[Speaker 3] case lands.
- 9:27[Rachel] So plan for the middle and stay ready for the top.
- 9:30[Speaker 3] That's the version I'd sign off on.
- 9:32[Rachel] And the lower retail number matters too, doesn't it?
- 9:35[Rachel] Four to four point eight is the baseline online is outrunning.
- 9:38[Speaker 3] It is.
- 9:39[Speaker 3] If your store only grows with the market, you're keeping pace, not
- 9:43[Speaker 3] winning.
- 9:44[Speaker 3] The gap is where the opportunity sits, assuming you can serve it.
- 9:48[Rachel] Serve it how?
- 9:49[Speaker 3] Fast pages, honest stock levels, clear delivery dates.
- 9:54[Speaker 3] Boring stuff.
- 9:55[Speaker 3] It's like a supply chain bottleneck, except the bottleneck is a confused
- 9:59[Speaker 3] customer.
- 10:00[Rachel] I love that.
- 10:00[Rachel] Confused customer, the new choke point.
- 10:03[Speaker 3] Mm-hmm.
- 10:04[Speaker 3] Though I'd hold that loosely.
- 10:06[Speaker 3] One report ties some growth to AI.
- 10:08[Speaker 3] That's a clue, not a verdict.
- 10:10[Rachel] Totally.
- 10:10[Rachel] So we've got a rosy forecast and a second one that agrees
- 10:14[Rachel] on direction.
- 10:15[Rachel] Nice, but forecasts are predictions.
- 10:17[Speaker 3] And predictions cost nothing.
- 10:19[Speaker 3] What did actual shoppers just do?
- 10:21[Rachel] Prime Big Deal Days just happened.
- 10:24[Rachel] That's our peek at real behavior.
- 10:26[Speaker 3] Fine.
- 10:26[Speaker 3] Let's see whether the shoppers read the forecasts.
- 10:34[Rachel] Okay, so Prime Big Deal Days, October sixth and seventh, two days.
- 10:38[Rachel] Retail Dive citing Adobe data says US online shoppers spent nine point
- 10:42[Rachel] eight six billion dollars in that window.
- 10:45[Speaker 3] Wait, nearly ten billion in two days?
- 10:48[Rachel] Nearly ten billion, two days, one sale event, and Amazon didn't even
- 10:52[Rachel] need a holiday to do it.
- 10:53[Speaker 3] Which is convenient since the holiday is the thing we're trying to
- 10:56[Speaker 3] forecast.
- 10:57[Rachel] Huh, right.
- 10:58[Speaker 3] But I wanna know what that number actually tells us.
- 11:01[Speaker 3] Ten billion is a headline.
- 11:03[Speaker 3] What's inside it?
- 11:04[Rachel] Okay, so this is the part I liked.
- 11:06[Rachel] Mobile sales grew twelve point eight percent, up to five point one
- 11:10[Rachel] billion dollars.
- 11:11[Speaker 3] Mm.
- 11:12[Rachel] That's fifty-two percent of the total.
- 11:13[Rachel] More than half of the spending happened on a phone.
- 11:16[Speaker 3] Hmm.
- 11:16[Speaker 3] So the checkout flow on a small screen is not a side
- 11:20[Speaker 3] project anymore.
- 11:20[Speaker 3] It's the main store.
- 11:22[Rachel] Totally.
- 11:23[Rachel] I mean, come on, how many of us bought something from the
- 11:25[Rachel] couch with one thumb?
- 11:27[Speaker 3] I plead the fifth.
- 11:28[Rachel] Noted.
- 11:29[Speaker 3] But here's my ROI brain at work.
- 11:32[Speaker 3] When I ran promotions at a big retailer, mobile traffic looked amazing
- 11:35[Speaker 3] in the dashboard, and then the conversion rate on phones lagged desktop.
- 11:40[Speaker 3] So I'd wanna know whether your phone checkout can actually catch that
- 11:43[Speaker 3] traffic.
- 11:44[Rachel] Fair.
- 11:45[Rachel] The source doesn't say anything about conversion, so I won't pretend it
- 11:48[Rachel] does.
- 11:48[Rachel] It only gives us that the share was fifty-two percent.
- 11:51[Speaker 3] Good.
- 11:52[Speaker 3] Stay in your lane.
- 11:53[Rachel] Always.
- 11:54[Speaker 3] Though I can still tell you what I'd check in my own
- 11:56[Speaker 3] store, not from the source, just as homework.
- 11:58[Rachel] Go ahead.
- 11:59[Speaker 3] Open your store on a phone, not a laptop pretending to be
- 12:02[Speaker 3] a phone, an actual phone.
- 12:04[Speaker 3] Try to buy something.
- 12:05[Speaker 3] Count the taps.
- 12:06[Rachel] And if you get annoyed, your customers got annoyed first.
- 12:10[Speaker 3] Usually sooner.
- 12:11[Speaker 3] Form fields, a payment step that makes you type a long card
- 12:14[Speaker 3] number, a button you have to hunt for.
- 12:16[Rachel] I'd add ask somebody who's never seen your store to do it
- 12:19[Rachel] while you watch.
- 12:20[Rachel] Their pauses tell you more than a dashboard.
- 12:23[Speaker 3] Fine.
- 12:23[Speaker 3] That's the one time I'll side with watching over metrics.
- 12:26[Speaker 3] Pair it with the numbers, though.
- 12:28[Rachel] Always pair them.
- 12:29[Rachel] Deal.
- 12:29[Speaker 3] What about the discounts?
- 12:30[Speaker 3] Because that's where margin goes to die.
- 12:33[Rachel] Markdowns peaked at around twenty percent.
- 12:35[Speaker 3] Twenty?
- 12:36[Speaker 3] That's it?
- 12:36[Rachel] Yeah, that's it.
- 12:37[Rachel] Peaked, so some stuff was shallower than that.
- 12:40[Speaker 3] Interesting, because a deal day with a twenty percent peak and nearly
- 12:43[Speaker 3] ten billion in sales says people didn't need fireworks.
- 12:47[Speaker 3] They needed a reason to click now.
- 12:49[Rachel] Right.
- 12:50[Rachel] And it gets better.
- 12:51[Rachel] Shoppers traded up.
- 12:52[Rachel] They went for higher ticket items.
- 12:54[Speaker 3] Wait, really?
- 12:55[Speaker 3] Traded up during a sale?
- 12:57[Rachel] That's what the report says: bigger items, not just the towel and
- 13:01[Rachel] toothpaste stuff.
- 13:02[Speaker 3] Okay, I like that because it complicates the whole stocking up on
- 13:06[Speaker 3] basics story.
- 13:07[Speaker 3] Some people used the sale to finally buy the big thing.
- 13:11[Rachel] The thing they've been eyeing for months.
- 13:13[Speaker 3] Exactly.
- 13:14[Speaker 3] A day day is permission.
- 13:16[Rachel] Permission slip for the credit card.
- 13:18[Speaker 3] There's one more piece.
- 13:20[Speaker 3] Amazon wasn't alone.
- 13:22[Speaker 3] Target and Walmart ran competing sales at the same time.
- 13:25[Rachel] Which makes the total even more interesting, right?
- 13:28[Rachel] Shoppers had plenty of other places to go, and Amazon's event still
- 13:32[Rachel] pulled in that much online spending.
- 13:34[Speaker 3] Careful.
- 13:35[Speaker 3] The number is what Adobe tracked across US online sales for the
- 13:39[Speaker 3] event.
- 13:39[Speaker 3] It doesn't tell us who took share from whom.
- 13:42[Rachel] Yeah.
- 13:43[Rachel] No, that's fair.
- 13:43[Rachel] I'm just saying the rivals showed up, and the shoppers still showed
- 13:46[Rachel] up too.
- 13:47[Speaker 3] That I'll give you.
- 13:48[Speaker 3] And for a store owner, that's the takeaway.
- 13:51[Speaker 3] Rivals will run their own sales, so you can't count on a
- 13:54[Speaker 3] quiet field.
- 13:55[Rachel] So what does trade-up mean for a small store practically?
- 13:59[Speaker 3] It means your higher priced items deserve some attention during a sale,
- 14:03[Speaker 3] not just the cheap add-ons.
- 14:05[Speaker 3] Good photos, clear details, a straight answer on shipping and returns.
- 14:10[Rachel] Because nobody's spending real money on something they can't picture.
- 14:13[Speaker 3] Right.
- 14:13[Speaker 3] And the source says nothing about margin on those items, so I'd
- 14:17[Speaker 3] check yours before you discount them.
- 14:20[Rachel] Meaning don't mark down your best seller just because the whole internet
- 14:23[Rachel] is marking things down.
- 14:24[Speaker 3] Mark it down on purpose with a number you chose, not in
- 14:28[Speaker 3] a panic.
- 14:29[Rachel] Which brings up the practical question.
- 14:31[Rachel] If phones are more than half the traffic and everyone's discounting at
- 14:34[Rachel] once, how do you get your store ready?
- 14:37[Rachel] Shopify just dropped a new tool for exactly that.
- 14:40[Speaker 3] Okay.
- 14:41[Speaker 3] Tell me it comes with a return on investment.
- 14:49[Rachel] Ha.
- 14:49[Rachel] Good question.
- 14:50[Rachel] Honestly, the answer is not yet proven, but here's the tool.
- 14:54[Rachel] It's called Canvas.
- 14:55[Rachel] Shopify rolled it out on October first, and it's a store design
- 14:58[Rachel] tool where you just talk to it.
- 15:01[Speaker 3] Talk to it how?
- 15:02[Rachel] Chat.
- 15:03[Rachel] MediaPost reports that merchants build and customize a storefront by chatting
- 15:07[Rachel] with Sidekick, Shopify's AI agent.
- 15:10[Rachel] You describe what you want, it builds.
- 15:12[Speaker 3] Hmm, so the page builder is now a conversation.
- 15:16[Rachel] Pretty much.
- 15:17[Rachel] And I love this because I have lost whole afternoons dragging a
- 15:21[Rachel] banner three pixels to the left.
- 15:23[Speaker 3] Three pixels.
- 15:24[Speaker 3] Very high stakes work.
- 15:26[Rachel] Hey, it matters to me.
- 15:28[Speaker 3] Okay, but you didn't really answer me.
- 15:30[Speaker 3] What's the actual ROI?
- 15:32[Speaker 3] A chat box that makes a pretty homepage is nice.
- 15:35[Speaker 3] Does it move revenue?
- 15:36[Rachel] Nothing in what we've got says that.
- 15:38[Rachel] No conversion numbers, no before and afters.
- 15:41[Rachel] It's a launch, not a case study.
- 15:43[Speaker 3] Right.
- 15:43[Speaker 3] So I'm treating it as a speed question.
- 15:46[Speaker 3] How fast can a small team change a storefront when the season
- 15:49[Speaker 3] is already running?
- 15:51[Rachel] Which in the middle of the holidays is the whole worry.
- 15:54[Rachel] You need a new landing page on Tuesday, not in three weeks.
- 15:57[Speaker 3] I've lived that.
- 15:58[Speaker 3] At a big retailer, a banner change meant a ticket, a queue,
- 16:02[Speaker 3] and somebody's calendar.
- 16:03[Speaker 3] Basically a supply chain bottleneck, except the product was a rectangle of
- 16:08[Speaker 3] text.
- 16:09[Rachel] A rectangle of text stuck in customs.
- 16:12[Speaker 3] Exactly.
- 16:13[Rachel] Now, here's a piece I didn't see coming.
- 16:15[Rachel] MediaPost ties Canvas to a September agreement with Meta.
- 16:19[Speaker 3] Wait, really?
- 16:20[Speaker 3] Meta?
- 16:21[Rachel] Yeah.
- 16:21[Rachel] The deal integrates Meta's Muse agent with Shop Pay.
- 16:25[Speaker 3] Huh.
- 16:25[Speaker 3] So the checkout piece is plugged into an AI agent from a
- 16:29[Speaker 3] completely different company?
- 16:30[Rachel] That's how MediaPost links the two, yes.
- 16:33[Rachel] I'd be careful, though.
- 16:34[Rachel] The article connects them.
- 16:35[Rachel] It doesn't say Canvas runs on Muse, and I won't pretend it
- 16:38[Rachel] does.
- 16:39[Speaker 3] Fair.
- 16:40[Speaker 3] Two announcements, one thread.
- 16:42[Speaker 3] Build the store with an agent, and an agent can also help
- 16:45[Speaker 3] someone pay in it.
- 16:46[Rachel] Which loops right back to the AI shopper thing from the Deloitte
- 16:49[Rachel] report.
- 16:50[Rachel] If shoppers are using AI tools, stores probably need to be easy
- 16:54[Rachel] for those tools to work with.
- 16:55[Speaker 3] Probably, though that's us reading between the lines, and the sources don't
- 16:59[Speaker 3] go there.
- 17:00[Rachel] Totally.
- 17:01[Rachel] Flagging it as our guess.
- 17:03[Speaker 3] Okay, what about Shopify itself?
- 17:05[Speaker 3] Is this a company that can afford to experiment?
- 17:08[Rachel] Shopify's own press page says Q2 results in August showed growth above
- 17:13[Rachel] thirty percent, and that was across GMV, revenue, gross profit, and free
- 17:18[Rachel] cash flow.
- 17:19[Speaker 3] All four?
- 17:20[Speaker 3] Not just the flattering one.
- 17:21[Rachel] All four, which is rare.
- 17:23[Rachel] Usually, somebody's free cash flow is limping behind.
- 17:26[Speaker 3] Usually, it's in the back of the group chat, not answering.
- 17:29[Rachel] Right.
- 17:30[Rachel] And that same press page says Q3 results are scheduled for November
- 17:34[Rachel] third.
- 17:35[Speaker 3] So that's the next real test.
- 17:37[Speaker 3] If holiday prep tools are working, you'd hope to see it somewhere
- 17:40[Speaker 3] in that story.
- 17:42[Rachel] You'd hope, though Q3 ends before the holiday rush, so I wouldn't
- 17:46[Rachel] expect Black Friday in there.
- 17:48[Speaker 3] Mm, that's a good catch.
- 17:49[Speaker 3] I'd say watch what they say about the quarter ahead.
- 17:52[Rachel] Yeah.
- 17:53[Rachel] And the press page also lists an October sixth post about the
- 17:57[Rachel] first holiday season of the agentic era.
- 17:59[Rachel] We only have the title, so I'm not gonna guess what's in
- 18:02[Rachel] it.
- 18:02[Speaker 3] Wise.
- 18:03[Speaker 3] Title alone, we can say the company is calling this a first.
- 18:07[Rachel] Which is a big claim to hang on a season.
- 18:10[Rachel] Very confident.
- 18:11[Speaker 3] Confident is cheap.
- 18:12[Speaker 3] Show me the lift.
- 18:14[Rachel] There she is.
- 18:15[Speaker 3] Somebody has to be.
- 18:16[Rachel] Okay, before we wrap, let me ask the practical one.
- 18:19[Rachel] Say you run a small store, maybe two people.
- 18:22[Rachel] How would you even try Canvas?
- 18:24[Speaker 3] Carefully.
- 18:25[Speaker 3] I'd start with something low risk, like a single landing page for
- 18:29[Speaker 3] a sale, not your whole homepage.
- 18:31[Rachel] Right.
- 18:31[Rachel] Build the thing you can afford to get wrong.
- 18:34[Speaker 3] And I'd decide in advance what success looks like.
- 18:37[Speaker 3] Compare that page to your normal one, same traffic source if you
- 18:40[Speaker 3] can.
- 18:41[Speaker 3] Otherwise, it's just vibes.
- 18:43[Rachel] I'd also keep a copy of what works now.
- 18:45[Rachel] If the chat builds something weird at the worst moment, you want
- 18:48[Rachel] a way back.
- 18:49[Speaker 3] That's the part nobody wants to hear.
- 18:51[Speaker 3] Speed is great until you're fast in the wrong direction.
- 18:55[Rachel] And on the meta side, I'd just keep an eye on the
- 18:57[Rachel] news.
- 18:58[Rachel] We don't know how those pieces fit together beyond what MediaPost connects.
- 19:02[Speaker 3] Agreed.
- 19:02[Speaker 3] Watch November third, read what Shopify says about its own numbers, and
- 19:06[Speaker 3] don't build a strategy on a launch announcement.
- 19:09[Rachel] All right, let's wrap this up.
- 19:10[Rachel] We've got forecasts, a deal day reality check, and a chat box
- 19:15[Rachel] that builds stores.
- 19:16[Speaker 3] Which is plenty for one week.
- 19:18[Speaker 3] Let's land it.
- 19:24[Speaker 3] Okay, so I'll give the takeaway because someone has to bring a
- 19:28[Speaker 3] spreadsheet to this party.
- 19:29[Rachel] Of course you will.
- 19:31[Speaker 3] Before you set a holiday budget, read more than one forecast.
- 19:35[Speaker 3] Two forecasters gave us two different framings, and they still pointed the
- 19:40[Speaker 3] same direction.
- 19:41[Rachel] Right.
- 19:42[Speaker 3] So use them as a range, not whichever number made the nicest
- 19:46[Speaker 3] headline.
- 19:47[Rachel] And if someone asks what that looks like in practice, because use
- 19:52[Rachel] a range sounds great on a podcast and gets vague on a
- 19:55[Rachel] Tuesday afternoon.
- 19:56[Speaker 3] Fair.
- 19:57[Speaker 3] Step one, write down the low case and the high case before
- 20:01[Speaker 3] you spend anything, not after.
- 20:04[Speaker 3] After, you'll just defend whatever you already bought.
- 20:07[Rachel] Huh, so the budget gets decided before the feelings do.
- 20:11[Speaker 3] Exactly.
- 20:13[Speaker 3] Step two, tie each big spending decision to a number you chose
- 20:17[Speaker 3] in advance.
- 20:18[Speaker 3] How much inventory, how much ad spend, how deep a discount.
- 20:22[Speaker 3] If you can't say why, it's a vibe, not a plan.
- 20:26[Rachel] I mean, come on.
- 20:26[Rachel] We've all bought a vibe before.
- 20:29[Speaker 3] I've approved a vibe or two.
- 20:32[Speaker 3] They don't show up well in a quarterly review.
- 20:35[Rachel] Noted for the record.
- 20:36[Speaker 3] Step three, decide what would make you change course.
- 20:40[Speaker 3] If sales run ahead of your middle case, what do you do?
- 20:43[Speaker 3] If they lag, what do you cut first?
- 20:46[Speaker 3] Settle that while you're calm.
- 20:48[Rachel] That one's smart because in the moment, everybody wants to either panic
- 20:52[Rachel] or celebrate.
- 20:53[Speaker 3] Right.
- 20:54[Speaker 3] A rule you wrote in October is worth more than a mood
- 20:57[Speaker 3] you have in December.
- 20:58[Rachel] Wait, so you're telling me the safest plan is to not fall
- 21:01[Rachel] in love with a number.
- 21:03[Speaker 3] I'm telling you the number doesn't love you back.
- 21:06[Speaker 3] It never once sent me a card.
- 21:09[Rachel] Ouch.
- 21:09[Rachel] Poor number.
- 21:11[Rachel] It was just trying its best.
- 21:12[Speaker 3] It was.
- 21:13[Speaker 3] But a forecast is a forecast.
- 21:16[Speaker 3] It's someone's best guess with good graphics.
- 21:19[Rachel] Which is a great way to put it.
- 21:20[Rachel] Good graphics, honest uncertainty.
- 21:23[Speaker 3] And honestly, that's what I'd like people to take from today, not
- 21:26[Speaker 3] any one figure.
- 21:28[Speaker 3] The habit of asking, "What window is this?
- 21:31[Speaker 3] Who made it?
- 21:31[Speaker 3] And what does it leave out?"
- 21:33[Rachel] That's three questions you can ask of basically any number someone shows
- 21:37[Rachel] you.
- 21:38[Speaker 3] Any number, including ours, by the way.
- 21:40[Speaker 3] We told you where we were guessing, and you should hold us
- 21:43[Speaker 3] to that.
- 21:44[Rachel] Hold us to it, yes.
- 21:45[Rachel] Send us a note if we got something wrong.
- 21:47[Rachel] We can take it.
- 21:48[Speaker 3] Mostly.
- 21:49[Speaker 3] Max cries a little.
- 21:50[Rachel] Quietly in the other room.
- 21:52[Speaker 3] Back to our opening question, how big is this season?
- 21:56[Speaker 3] Big, and online probably growing faster than the rest of retail.
- 22:00[Speaker 3] The honest answer is a range plus a plan.
- 22:03[Rachel] I'll take that over a single number any day.
- 22:05[Speaker 3] Better.
- 22:06[Rachel] And for the record, that's a nicer answer than the four tabs
- 22:09[Rachel] I started with.
- 22:10[Rachel] Four tabs, four opinions, zero sleep.
- 22:13[Speaker 3] Close a few of them.
- 22:14[Speaker 3] Keep the ones with dates on them.
- 22:16[Rachel] Wow, productivity advice from the tab police.
- 22:19[Speaker 3] Somebody has to enforce it.
- 22:21[Rachel] One more thing before we go, and I mean this.
- 22:23[Rachel] If you run a small store, this stuff can feel like a
- 22:26[Rachel] lot.
- 22:27[Rachel] Forecasts, sale events, new tools, everything changing at once.
- 22:32[Speaker 3] It does, and you don't have to act on all of it.
- 22:35[Speaker 3] Pick one thing from this episode.
- 22:37[Speaker 3] One.
- 22:37[Speaker 3] Do that this week.
- 22:39[Rachel] Maybe it's checking your store on an actual phone.
- 22:42[Rachel] Maybe it's writing the dates next to your numbers.
- 22:44[Rachel] Maybe it's just deciding your lowest price before the rush.
- 22:48[Speaker 3] Any of those beats doing nothing and hoping.
- 22:51[Speaker 3] That's my whole career in one sentence.
- 22:53[Rachel] That should be on a mug.
- 22:55[Rachel] Oh, wait.
- 22:55[Rachel] We retired the mug.
- 22:57[Speaker 3] We did.
- 22:57[Speaker 3] Moving on.
- 22:58[Rachel] So anyway, thank you.
- 23:00[Rachel] Seriously, thanks everybody for hanging out with us this week.
- 23:03[Rachel] Seriously, it means a lot.
- 23:04[Speaker 3] It does.
- 23:05[Speaker 3] You've got a lot of places to spend your time, and you
- 23:07[Speaker 3] picked a couple of people arguing about spreadsheets.
- 23:10[Speaker 3] We don't take that lightly.
- 23:12[Rachel] And if you've been with us a while, thank you for sticking
- 23:14[Rachel] around.
- 23:15[Rachel] If you're new, welcome.
- 23:16[Rachel] Pull up a chair.
- 23:17[Rachel] Bring your tabs.
- 23:18[Speaker 3] Maybe not all of them.
- 23:20[Rachel] Maybe not all of them.
- 23:22[Speaker 3] If you liked the show, follow it wherever you listen.
- 23:25[Speaker 3] It's the easiest way to catch the next one without remembering what
- 23:28[Speaker 3] day it is.
- 23:29[Rachel] And send it to the one friend who keeps asking if this
- 23:31[Rachel] year's gonna be big.
- 23:32[Speaker 3] Or the colleague who owns the budget.
- 23:34[Speaker 3] They'd probably thank you, eventually.
- 23:37[Rachel] Totally.
- 23:37[Rachel] They're texting you right now, I promise.
- 23:39[Speaker 3] Probably with a screenshot of one forecast.
- 23:42[Rachel] Ask them for a second one.
- 23:44[Rachel] This has been The Checkout Point.
- 23:46[Rachel] See you next week.