Latest / Eyes Wide Open with Nick Thompson / What a FIASCO! The Bachelorette is Canceled, & Taylor Frankie Paul is NOT at Fault w/ Nick Thompson
Transcript
- 0:00Soft, cushy, plush, cozy.
- 0:04Soft, smooth, buttery, marshmallowy, warm.
- 0:09Soft.
- 0:10Socks, underwear, tees, and more.
- 0:13Bombas.
- 0:14Everyday comfort worth obsessing over.
- 0:17Visit bombas.com slash audio and use code audio for 20% off your first purchase.
- 0:22That's B-O-M-B-A-S dot com slash audio.
- 0:26One purchase equals one donated.
- 0:27Always.
- 0:28Always.
- 0:33We have to talk about the Taylor, Frankie, Paul, Bachelorette fiasco.
- 0:37And yeah, I'm calling it a fiasco because that is exactly what it is.
- 0:40On March 19th, ABC and Disney decided that they were going to do something they've never done before.
- 0:45They canceled the Bachelorette just a few days before it was supposed to air.
- 0:49But I want to move past the headlines for a second and reiterate that I am a mental health advocate.
- 0:55If you've listened to this show, if you follow me, you know that I have co-founded the UCAN foundation and I've spent years now fighting for the ethical treatment of people.
- 1:02that are on these reality TV shows.
- 1:04So when I look at this, I don't just see messy, dramatic reality TV.
- 1:08I'm seeing very calculated business model that I've been talking about and exploring that thrives on exploiting people when they're at their lowest points, all for entertainment.
- 1:20Now, if we take a look at how this started back several years ago,
- 1:24To understand how we got to this point, you have to understand how it started.
- 1:28And it wasn't just an overnight explosion or a downward spiral, similar to what we've experienced in the past.
- 1:34It started back in 2020 when Taylor started MomTalk on TikTok, in which she did a little bit of Internet fame there for kind of being this perfect mom and Mormon mom in Utah, doing dances and lifestyle content with her husband, Tate Paul, and their two kids.
- 1:55sort of shattered.
- 1:56And then Taylor revealed on TikTok that she and Tate were divorcing due to some soft swinging scandal within their friend group.
- 2:03And it wasn't really just drama at that point.
- 2:06It was more of the beginning of sort of a very public display of unraveling and some, what I would argue, mental health challenges that have been escalating in this relationship and from this relationship failing.
- 2:23And
- 2:24In summer 2022, she started a relationship that was pretty volatile from the beginning with Dakota Mortensen.
- 2:32And it's been on again, off again, Secret Lives of Momen Wives, very loud on social media, the on again, off again nature of it.
- 2:40And in February of 2023, that was kind of where the breaking point happened and Taylor was
- 2:47was arrested for aggravated assault at her home.
- 2:50And now we have a leaked video that shows her throwing metal chairs and one of them even hit her little daughter.
- 2:58And I'm not gonna show the video here.
- 3:00If you wanna see the video, you can go check it out on pretty much anywhere reporting this on social media.
- 3:05The video has gone crazy.
- 3:07While I understand that, I think that that's something that people should choose to see.
- 3:12I don't know that showing someone clearly unraveling and having a mental health crisis of whatever is going on there in that relationship isn't really something that needs to be out there on the internet.
- 3:23If you think about what happens in this video and the fact that it's on the internet now forever, that these children and their family members are going to have to deal with this.
- 3:32with this for the rest of their life.
- 3:33They're gonna have to see their mother in this crisis.
- 3:36They're gonna have to see their parents in this physical altercation.
- 3:39This is the kind of stuff that causes generational trauma.
- 3:41This is the kind of stuff that normalizes abusive relationships and bad behaviors in a relationship.
- 3:46And I don't think that that's something that should be out there the way that it is, but we live in the world of social media and I,
- 3:53feel for these children, especially who are going to have all of their friends for all of their lives, being able to watch this and comment on, and hopefully they're going to be able to get some support through all of this as well.
- 4:03But she pleaded guilty to this later that year, abrogated assault and started a probation period for three years.
- 4:11She and Dakota had a child, but like the toxicity and the on again, off again, just continues.
- 4:18body cam footage from the secret lives of Mormon wives.
- 4:22We hear some of the police calls, despite all of this, all of the chaos, all of the crisis, it's all public.
- 4:31It's all documented.
- 4:33This is when the ABC, the,
- 4:39Disney announced her to be, despite all of this on the record, this is when, despite all of this, the record, the probation, documented violence, ABC decides in October of last year, 2025, to announce her as the next bachelorette.
- 4:56What?
- 4:57This is what I've been talking about.
- 4:58You see TMZ leaked this video from 2023 assault that's all documented and in police reports and, and.
- 5:07Settled in court, they show this unedited video and ABC finally decides to pull the plug.
- 5:16This isn't a hidden past that was a secret relationship that was toxic or a secret relationship.
- 5:25that she kept away mental health issues or illnesses or challenges or whatever abuse, however you want to frame it.
- 5:32There is public documentation, legal documentation, in addition to what you can follow and see on social media and in these shows.
- 5:41And so TMZ leaks the video, ABC finally decides, okay, it's time to pull the plug.
- 5:46This calculated choice by ABC, they didn't just find out.
- 5:49On these reality shows, you go through extensive background checks.
- 5:52So they had to have known she was on probation.
- 5:55You go through psychological evaluations.
- 5:57So they had to know some of the things that were going on with her.
- 6:01Okay.
- 6:01They didn't cast her.
- 6:04in spite of the mess that she was or the messiness that she has or the mental health challenges that she had or the relationship stuff.
- 6:13They did it because of it.
- 6:15Because when someone that's this messy, they look at that as someone who is not a human being anymore.
- 6:22They saw a woman who was clearly having a public mental health challenges and a toxic relationship for years.
- 6:28And they, instead of supporting it or honestly just leaving her alone, they put her in a high stress, high stakes pressure cooker, as I like to call it, environment.
- 6:38knowing exactly what her history was, seeing it play out on other shows, seeing it play out on social media and seeing it playing out in the court room.
- 6:47They didn't miss these red flags.
- 6:49They knew they were a marketing plan.
- 6:52They knew they were messy and they knew that it would make great TV.
- 6:57And I'm using air quotes for those of you who are just listening.
- 7:00There's a human cost to this.
- 7:02Here's the part that should really make us all sick.
- 7:05And I, in my heart, as I said, it goes out to the children.
- 7:08They are innocent in all of this, but they're in the crossfire.
- 7:12And now because a production company wanted a viral lead for their bachelorette franchise, that trauma and that video and all eyes are going to be on this for a long time.
- 7:24It's going to be online forever.
- 7:26So think about that.
- 7:27These kids are going to live with this for the rest of their lives.
- 7:30Their best friends, their teachers, their friends.
- 7:32their future partners, everyone's going to have access to one of the worst, most violent moments they've probably experienced in their child.
- 7:40On top of that, the family as a whole is now traumatized by this.
- 7:46I can't even imagine, except I can't imagine because I lived through it, but that family's pain, Taylor's suffering, Dakota's suffering,
- 7:54Doesn't matter who's right and wrong.
- 7:56I'm sure they're both wrong in a lot of ways, but take away that.
- 7:59Imagine your darkest moment where you were behaving at your worst, saying things at your worst, physically violent.
- 8:07If that's some of you out there to have that moment play out on reality TV, social media and be out there forever.
- 8:15That is traumatizing, not just to the people in the video or the people directly tied to the people in the video.
- 8:20Yeah.
- 8:21That cascades out to an entire family, an entire friend group.
- 8:25Their family's pain and struggles is now a digital history book, digital archive that they'll never be able to get away from and they'll have to answer to for the rest of their life.
- 8:36Now, I know that there's a responsibility of people to take their own, make their own decisions on why they do show or why they live a public life.
- 8:44But everybody, in my view, also has a responsibility and a right to have a private life.
- 8:50And when personal videos and personal private accounts or text messages are shared publicly, that's not fair.
- 8:57Think about some of the worst things that you've been through.
- 9:00What if someone was videoing that and shared it out to the internet?
- 9:03And now you're not just dealing with,
- 9:05incident itself and the ramifications from it but you're dealing with the public's opinion on it all as well so video you want to watch it do at your own risk but we're talking about like a mother who was in no condition to be in the position of dating 30 men on one of the biggest reality shows in history the network decided her stability was worth far less than a sunday night time slot they put her and those children
- 9:31in danger and for what?
- 9:33So we could have something to talk about at the water cooler the next day.
- 9:37So we could have something to go gossip about on social media.
- 9:40I just think there is a big responsibility that we need to have as viewers because this is terrible.
- 9:47And I'm not excusing.
- 9:49Anything, sure.
- 9:50Maybe Taylor did it for the clout.
- 9:52Maybe all of the drama is something that she feeds on.
- 9:56The toxic relationship is obviously something she's comfortable in.
- 9:59I'm not excusing any of that.
- 10:01But I want to be clear about something.
- 10:02People are responsible for their own decisions.
- 10:04They're also responsible for their own behavior.
- 10:07And I'm not defending her actions, her clout chasing, or the abuse of either side of the relationship, as I said.
- 10:11But the bottom line is recognizing that someone is responsible for their own action doesn't mean that it's okay to exploit them for purposes of entertainment.
- 10:21ABC saw someone whose mental health and drama was public.
- 10:26They saw probably someone who would be on fire and good TV, good for ratings, good for advertising.
- 10:37They threw gasoline on that fire and invited all of us to come watch it burn.
- 10:41This is a escalation up to a whole new level, in my view, to the point where ABC's had to cancel the Bachelorette show for this season.
- 10:52Now think about what that means.
- 10:55My understanding is it costs about a million dollars an episode.
- 10:58So you're looking at about a 10, I don't, I don't know how many episodes, 10, 12.
- 11:01So you're looking at, let's say 12 to $15 million in production gone.
- 11:07Veritizing revenue, probably my estimation, 90, a hundred million dollars gone.
- 11:13And I heard they are putting American idol reruns in the time slot.
- 11:17That's not going to generate the same kind of.
- 11:19Rating, same kind of ad revenue.
- 11:20But there is a big financial implication to all of this.
- 11:26And the public backlash, which took the video release, not the fact that everybody knew what happened.
- 11:32And it's all public record.
- 11:33We've all watched it for years.
- 11:35They realized that they had to pull the plug on this show for this season to avoid problems.
- 11:42pushback so bad.
- 11:43And you know, when they did their cost benefit analysis, that if they didn't see this costing them more than what it would be to pull it, that shows power.
- 11:55That shows the power of all of us.
- 11:58That when we say no, even in reality TV, no matter which side you're on, and I don't think you should be on a side.
- 12:05I think this is a people using our power and what we spend our time consuming and entertaining ourselves with.
- 12:11We have power.
- 12:13This entire thing was an escalation of an already bad situation that was intentionally to manufacture drama with a character that they decided should be the lead of a season of The Bachelorette, where she's going to go on and date 30 men with the history we've seen and the police reports that we know are public.
- 12:34At the end of the day, this is the business model.
- 12:37And this was a business model that they actively implied to exploit people in an inauthentic way to leverage them for TV.
- 12:46And our power, after we saw that video, even though everything we knew, our power was to get them to pull it.
- 12:52Now.
- 12:53The Bachelorette and ABC, Disney, when they decided they would do this and this was going to be their model until that video showed up and there was backlash that forced their hand.
- 13:02Keep in mind all of the stuff that had to go leading into that moment.
- 13:06I think it's time for us to be asking ourselves as a society with atrocities going around the world.
- 13:12Is this who we want to be as a society where we watch the deconstruction of a human being and relationships for our entertainment?
- 13:23ABC knew, Disney knew, the production crew knew, everybody knew.
- 13:28This is awful.
- 13:29This is on the network and the production company who made the decision that this was the route they were going to take.
- 13:37And this was manufactured for your entertainment.
- 13:41Let that sink in for a second.
- 13:43Last thing I want to say, as this escalates even more on social media, in communities, on podcasts that are just going to be...
- 13:51gossiping about this and exploring it and not addressing these issues that I'm bringing up here whatsoever.
- 13:56I guarantee you that if this shifts and public sentiment shifts in favor of Taylor, I guarantee you mark my words, I'm saying it now, you can quote me later, they will release this season.
- 14:11They will air this if they have the opportunity, public sentiment changes, production new, ABC new.
- 14:20We've got to ask ourselves, is this who we want to be?
- 14:22I wish everyone well.
- 14:23In this scenario, I know it's not easy to have your life play out on TV this way.
- 14:28I am proud of everyone standing up for what's right.
- 14:30Stay above the drama and recognize that this was a calculated decision by a production company and a TV network to go down this path until it was absolutely undeniably going to cost them more to run this show than to cancel it.
- 14:47Based on information they knew before they even cast the lead.
- 14:51Nick Thompson, keep your eyes wide open.
- 14:53Thank you for listening to this clip from the full episode of Eyes Wide Open.
- 14:57Please like and subscribe for daily clips and new episodes that drop every Tuesday.
- 15:01I appreciate you.
- 15:06500 orders a month was manageable.
- 15:085,000 is madness.
- 15:11Embrace intelligent order fulfillment with ShipStation, the only platform combining order management, warehouse workflows, inventory, returns, and analytics in one place.
- 15:21What used to take five separate tools, ShipStation does in one.
- 15:25Automate fulfillment and rate shopping to ship up to 15 times more with up to 90% savings.
- 15:30Go to ShipStation.com and use code AUDIO to try ShipStation free for 60 days.