Latest / Politics with Paul / Politics with Paul Podcast #9 - Interview with Seth David Radwell
Transcript
- 0:00Alright.
- 0:01Folks, welcome back to the Politics with Paul podcast with your host, Paul Rader.
- 0:05Today is a very special day in this podcast's history because it is the first episode of the
- 0:11podcast where we have a guest, and that guest is Seth David Radwell.
- 0:16Now Mr.
- 0:16Radwell here originally made his name as a business executive, including working as the
- 0:21president, excuse me, of Scholastic, the digital arm of a global children's publishing
- 0:26and education company, and as president of Bookspan Bertelsmann.
- 0:30But more relevantly for today, he is the author of the book titled American Schism: How the Two
- 0:35Enlightenments Hold the Secrets to Healing Our Nation, and he tours as a speaker on the book's
- 0:41content.
- 0:42And that very book is right here.
- 0:45We're gonna be talking about that book, his work as a speaker, and issues of political
- 0:50polarization and toxicity in today's political culture and climate for America.
- 0:56And as you all know, I try to keep things as impartial as possible, so I'm not here to say I
- 1:01do or do not agree with any particular point Seth here makes.
- 1:04But, nonetheless, it's an interesting perspective that I think people should hear,
- 1:08and you should check out the book which you can buy on Amazon.
- 1:11So without further ado, please welcome to the show Mr.
- 1:15Seth David Radwell.
- 1:16Seth, how are you doing today?
- 1:17Anything else you wanna add to that
- 1:19Well, thank you so much, Paul.
- 1:20It's a pleasure to be here with you, and thanks for that nice introduction.
- 1:26No.
- 1:26I appreciate you coming here.
- 1:28So it only makes sense to start off with this question.
- 1:31Why was it so important for you to write this book while it's not like you had no experience
- 1:36with politics previously?
- 1:37You have a master's degree in public policy from Harvard.
- 1:40You come primarily from the business executive world.
- 1:43So why switch gears and write this book?
- 1:46It's a great question.
- 1:47I mean, my motivation, I think, started to develop during, around 2015, 16, 17.
- 1:54During that time, I watched as increasingly the political environment, kind of the dialogue, if
- 2:02you will, collapsed in the US, I think.
- 2:05And more and more, it seemed like that acrimony and rancor were crowding out reason in the
- 2:11public discourse.
- 2:13So that was annoying me as someone who's very sensitive and has followed the public sector my
- 2:20whole career, even though I have been in business, as you mentioned.
- 2:23But I think, Paul, what pushed me over the edge to do something about and write this book was
- 2:30that I had watched over the last couple of years as my peers, fellow CEOs in business,
- 2:38were increasingly putting their heads in the sand and afraid to engage, for fear of touching
- 2:44the third rail or bringing on the wrath of some group.
- 2:47And I thought if the public discourse is not working and if private sector leaders won't
- 2:52engage, how can we expect to bestow a democratic republic to our kids, the next
- 2:59generation?
- 3:00And that's what got me starting to do some research.
- 3:03I didn't know originally it was gonna lead to a book, but I did research all through 2018 and
- 3:09ultimately left my private sector career to work on the research and writing of this book,
- 3:15American Schism.
- 3:17Yeah.
- 3:17No.
- 3:17I there's a lot of people with you there, and, you know, it's an interesting balance you have
- 3:24to strike with how do you not come into conflict with people, but also at the same
- 3:30time, can't, you know, there are things we have to talk about.
- 3:33That is most certainly true.
- 3:35So now, obviously, it's not like I want you to give away this whole book, but just give, like,
- 3:42a brief synopsis of a couple of the main points, maybe, like, a minute or so of the main
- 3:47point you wanna drive home with this book.
- 3:50Sure.
- 3:51Well, the first thing I would say is that if we really want to understand why we're so divided
- 3:57today, why America is so polarized, we need to look at our history.
- 4:02And that's precisely what the book does.
- 4:04It traces our divisions back to the founding.
- 4:07And the main thesis is that what we see today is derivative of an original schism, an
- 4:13original split that happened during our founding between two groups of our founders.
- 4:19And understanding that original schism as well as how it's evolved over our history is key if
- 4:26we want to heal where we are today, bring divisions together.
- 4:29And so that's important.
- 4:31I can sometimes I say history can act as a salve for our wounds, but we have to be willing
- 4:36to apply it.
- 4:37And too often today, we don't.
- 4:40That's the first point.
- 4:41The second point I would say is that the way we're currently dealing with public sector
- 4:46problems is no longer productive.
- 4:49It's counterproductive, and we have to fundamentally change how we interact with each
- 4:54other as citizens and how we develop solutions in the problem-solving space.
- 5:01And the current mindset, as opposed to looking at it that way, is as if we're rooting for a
- 5:08sports team in an arena.
- 5:09That's how we're treating our fellow citizens, cheering for the in-group and, and blasting the
- 5:16out-group and demonizing them.
- 5:18That's no way that we're gonna solve our problems.
- 5:21And when this has happened over our history, as the book shows, we've at times, we've been able
- 5:27to move forward using a couple of what I call a secret sauce, a couple of key ingredients.
- 5:32And the book goes into what those key elements of the secret sauce are that I think we need to
- 5:37deploy today.
- 5:39So that's kind of a summary in shorthand, and we'll get into it in more detail of what
- 5:44"American Schism" is all about.
- 5:45It did win the International Book Award last year, and it's been quite well received by the
- 5:50public, both praised professionally by the reviews as well as by consumers, readers who've
- 5:57read the book.
- 5:59Yeah.
- 5:59No.
- 5:59Absolutely.
- 6:00And the in-group, out-group thing, I mean, that's a big point of my own about, you know,
- 6:06the things I do.
- 6:07It's just this whole everything that everybody in the in-group does in my in-group is perfect,
- 6:13or we you know?
- 6:15Or if we do something that we normally think is wrong, it's actually good that we did it
- 6:18because of whatever mental gymnastics that we use to justify the in-group, and then
- 6:23everything the out-group does is just everything they do is wrong.
- 6:27And if there is something that's good that they do, it's the exception to the rule, basically.
- 6:33So now to dive in a little bit more into the points you talked about with the Enlightenment,
- 6:41I thought it was a pretty unique approach to the issue of polarization in this country where
- 6:45you talk about these two enlightenments.
- 6:48You talk about a moderate Enlightenment and a radical Enlightenment and then a
- 6:51counter-Enlightenment as well and how they have led to these polarization issues today.
- 6:55So when you talk about philosophers of that era, like John Locke or Jean-Jacques Rousseau
- 7:00or Montesquieu and their ideas are brought up, it's in relation to how they influence the
- 7:04founding fathers' views on how to formulate a government, which you do talk about.
- 7:07But what led you to talk about or think about taking the two enlightenments and expanding
- 7:12this concept to say, for all the positive impacts that they've had on American political
- 7:16thought, it has also sparked divisions at multiple critical junctures in American
- 7:21history, including today.
- 7:23Well, it's a great question because, first of all, it it's important to recognize for your
- 7:28listeners that, you know, the whole premise of the modern society, what we now think of as the
- 7:34as a modern society, really came out of the enlightenment's construct of the social
- 7:40contract.
- 7:41That was the the element that was during enlightenment was very vast in terms of what it
- 7:45covered, the 18th century and and and the end of 16th century and the 8th and 17th cent I'm
- 7:51sorry.
- 7:51The end of 17th century and 18th century.
- 7:55But the political, framework paradigm, if you will, was this idea of why do we form a
- 8:02society?
- 8:03What what what is a social contract?
- 8:04What is it made up of?
- 8:06What rights does the state have to protect, and what rights do we need to give up to the state
- 8:11in order to live in a civilized society?
- 8:15And so the philosophers you mentioned, along with even going back to Hobbes, these are all
- 8:20important philosophers that affected very much our founders.
- 8:24I mean, of course, our founders were also well-versed in the classical philosophers in
- 8:29ancient Greek democracy, for example, and the Roman Senate and how that operated.
- 8:35But the key point here is that the Enlightenment actually had a vast disagreement
- 8:42about what the appropriate social contract needed to look like for a republic.
- 8:48And here's where this original American schism, this is where it started because you had one
- 8:55group of our founders, people like Alexander Hamilton and John Adams.
- 9:00And they were influenced very much by Montesquieu and the whole balance of powers,
- 9:05but they were as much influenced by the British model.
- 9:08And the British constitutional model at that point was to create a structure to control the
- 9:16monarch so the monarch couldn't abuse powers.
- 9:19And the way that the British did that was what was called at the time an aristocratic
- 9:25republic, meaning aristocrats, well-educated people, like John Adams of his day.
- 9:32They would govern on behalf of the people to control the monarch and make sure that the
- 9:38monarch wasn't infringing upon the rights of citizens.
- 9:41So in the aristocratic republic, it was the responsibility of the best and brightest to
- 9:46govern on behalf of the people and finally achieve what Rousseau would call the common
- 9:52good.
- 9:54Now the other school of our founders, namely Thomas Jefferson, Benjamin Franklin, and even
- 10:00Thomas Paine, they were more influenced by the French Enlightenment and, specifically, what I
- 10:06call in the book the Radical Enlightenment.
- 10:08People like Denis Diderot and Condorcet and Holbach.
- 10:12And what their difference was that they thought the only sustainable form of social contract
- 10:21had to be a representative democracy where citizens choose representatives to advocate on
- 10:29their behalf.
- 10:30Now the other school did not like democracy.
- 10:33They were afraid of democracy because they thought democracy meant mob rule.
- 10:37They were very concerned about it.
- 10:39Whereas this more radical group, Jefferson, and we became the Democratic-Republicans in our
- 10:47early history versus the Federalists, which was Hamilton's party.
- 10:50The Democratic-Republicans really believed in a decentralized government and a representative
- 10:56democracy where people, citizens, were electing representatives to govern on their behalf.
- 11:02So that key difference was very profound in the early history of the country.
- 11:08And just to give your listeners, like, a fast forward, as I mentioned before, that split is
- 11:15important to understand.
- 11:16That split is, in my view, the tension we see today, for example, between the elite
- 11:23establishment and the people, the popular vote, or let's say people who are not in the
- 11:30establishment, who've been so attracted, for example, to what Trump has been able to offer
- 11:36them because they feel the establishment has left them behind.
- 11:39So those same tensions appear today, but it's important to understand their original history.
- 11:49Yeah.
- 11:49No.
- 11:50That's a very interesting way to look at things, especially when, you know, when you
- 11:55study history, you think about how Federalists and Democratic-Republicans had all these
- 12:01differences on, first of all, about the Constitution, Democratic-Republicans being born
- 12:06out of the Anti-Federalists who were very much against the Constitution and wanted to stick
- 12:10with the Articles of Confederation, Thomas Jefferson and others like him being very
- 12:16supportive of the French Revolution, whereas Alexander Hamilton and Federalists were not so
- 12:20much, and they actually advocated for still being, for lack of a better term, tied at the
- 12:25hip economically to Britain.
- 12:28It's just a really interesting way to, you know, view it from that lens of moderate and
- 12:33radical Enlightenment and really just helps to reinforce why exactly each side thought the way
- 12:40they did.
- 12:41So just a fascinating way to look at it in that context.
- 12:48So as always, for my works, because you actually mentioned him, I do not make personal
- 12:53opinions.
- 12:54I've just for anybody listening, obviously, I do not make my personal opinions about
- 12:59particular political figures or groups, no, but I must repeat that disclaimer because I have to
- 13:03ask you, Seth, about one man and one group that you specifically name in the book and just a
- 13:09moment ago as emblematic of the schism, and that's Donald Trump and the Republican Party.
- 13:15So for some people that read this book, they will think and have thought that it was
- 13:19appropriate for you to highlight them and criticize them as being highly polarizing and
- 13:23divisive.
- 13:24But other people will read this book or have read this book and say that it was divisive of
- 13:28you to shine such a light on them and possibly even hypocritical since you lament the
- 13:34polarization in this country but single out one side.
- 13:37And that's not to say that there aren't other opinions that you're highlighting, but what do
- 13:40you think about those two types of responses?
- 13:43And just what do you think of those two responses?
- 13:47Well, first of all, I, I, I, you know, to me, I think what the book does is talks about many
- 13:53political actors over the course of our history.
- 13:55In fact, the section you're talking about in the third part of the book, some of the book
- 13:59traces these different individual sections of our history.
- 14:03And the last part is Obama and Trump, which talks about both.
- 14:06Now what I think I show in the book is that look.
- 14:10I mean and certainly, I've written a lot about this since then is the divisiveness and the
- 14:15polarization that we see today.
- 14:18Trump, by no means, created it.
- 14:20I mean, it had been building, I think, and this is where Trump was right.
- 14:24It had been building for decades because so much of the establishment was no longer
- 14:30understanding the needs of Americans across the country.
- 14:33In fact, that's really what started the wave of polarization.
- 14:38What Trump knew how to do was how to use it, how to leverage it to basically garner
- 14:44political support.
- 14:45And, you know, I think in that way, he was he's very much a political genius.
- 14:51The issues that he's raising on behalf of Americans are very real.
- 14:55So I don't buy into the fact that, you know, I think it's hypocritical to talk about both on
- 15:01the left and the right.
- 15:02Well, I mean, in fact, I talk about how both the extreme left and extreme right are both to
- 15:07me not helping the conversation.
- 15:08They're counterproductive because in my eyes, both the extremes on both sides end up crowding
- 15:16out logic and rational problem-solving that the frustrated majority people in the center,
- 15:22center-left, center-right, are looking for.
- 15:25In fact, they become the loudest voices in the room, and and that is, unfortunate and
- 15:31counterproductive.
- 15:32So I I would say that I'm, you know, I'm willing to be critical of both the extremes on
- 15:38the left and the right.
- 15:39And for different reasons, I think they they have they have I mean, on the left, I think
- 15:43there's this, sanctimonious need to cancel and and, you know, to to be to anyone who's not
- 15:51woke is all of a sudden canceled, and there's a desire to throw out the institutions because,
- 15:58many on the extreme left believe we haven't made progress at all on advancing society,
- 16:03which I think is not at all true.
- 16:05And on the extreme right, there's a willingness to to not look at truth, to not look at facts
- 16:09and history, and to be in denial about about, you know, what are basically empirical issues.
- 16:15So I think both sides, both the extreme sides have their have their net need criticism.
- 16:21But the fundamental purpose of the analytics of the book is to say that while we've always been
- 16:29divided in our history, many times in our history, we've usually had a more constructive
- 16:34way of dealing with it than we seem to have now.
- 16:37And I think it's gotten worse and worse over the past decade.
- 16:41You know what's interesting, you know, talking about that is there was a point back in and
- 16:47like you said, the divisiveness isn't anything new.
- 16:51But an interesting point is back in the 1950s, how the American Political Science Association
- 16:58basically came out with a report that lamented the fact that these that the two parties at the
- 17:04time didn't have much difference between them at all.
- 17:08There was a lot of conservatives and liberals in the Democratic Party and conservatives and
- 17:12liberals in the Republican Party.
- 17:14And now fast forward 60, 70 years later, it's now, you know, on the on the opposite end.
- 17:20Now speaking of the center, center left, center right, center center, do you think that they
- 17:26necessarily look at the issues we're facing today in terms of not necessarily that they're
- 17:34thinking, I'm a radical Enlightenment thinker or a moderate Enlightenment thinker, but do
- 17:37they have similar thought processes to what you would consider these Enlightenment thinkers
- 17:44having, or is it something completely different from from that kind of perspective?
- 17:51I think the closest thing that resembles today's political dialogue is a
- 17:56counter-Enlightenment.
- 17:57I don't think we're using Enlightenment, empiricism or data and observation, rational
- 18:05problem solving to look at our problems.
- 18:07I think what's happened is elected officials for too long now have realized that the best
- 18:13way to mobilize voters is to push buttons, is to trigger them, get them angry or and this is
- 18:19on both sides.
- 18:20It you know, it's to get them angry or fearful, and that is what motivates voters to go to the
- 18:25polls.
- 18:26But, you know, rational arguments are not great motivators for campaigns.
- 18:32The problem with that is that almost any issue that we face—let's take some of the most
- 18:37difficult ones, immigration.
- 18:39You know, both sides of the immigration debate are completely not reasonable.
- 18:45We can't open borders.
- 18:46We need some system to have secure borders and manage immigration.
- 18:51And on the other hand, we can't have no immigration.
- 18:54We need certain skills in the country, and we have an asylum process.
- 18:57So the truth is, you know, we've had four bipartisan immigration bills that have come up
- 19:04to Congress in the last 15 years, and none of them have passed.
- 19:07So as if any of those bills had passed, we would have had already secure borders.
- 19:13We would not have the conflict and the crisis that we've been in.
- 19:18So my point is that the real solutions to these problems require things that have become a
- 19:25dirty word, like compromise.
- 19:27You know, we got to the Constitution in the first place because we were willing to
- 19:32compromise between what were the northern and the southern states.
- 19:36And some would say we shouldn't have compromised on slavery.
- 19:39But had we not compromised, we wouldn't have had a country.
- 19:43So, again, you know, most of the problems that we face today require a compromised solution.
- 19:51And today, unfortunately, the loudest voices are unwilling to do that.
- 19:58But you know what?
- 19:59Paul, my research for the book shows that 70% of Americans, 70% are in what I call the
- 20:06frustrated majority.
- 20:07Meaning, that they feel like they're in the minority, by the way, because the extremes on
- 20:11both sides are the loudest.
- 20:13But in fact, that 70% believe we have more in common than not, and we have to find a more
- 20:20productive way to solve our problems.
- 20:22So the book American Schism is speaking to that frustrated majority.
- 20:27And my argument to those Americans, both in the private sector and young people, is to take
- 20:34back the gavel.
- 20:36Let's not let the lunatics on the extremes who are trying to run the asylum.
- 20:41Let's not let them have their way because we need rational problem solving, a centered
- 20:48approach to things like climate change, to immigration, to violence, to epidemics, all
- 20:57these problems that we face.
- 21:01You know, it's interesting, you know, that you bring those points.
- 21:04So it kind of makes me think of all those clickbait YouTube videos and all where, you
- 21:10know, they have to have all these capital letters.
- 21:13So and so was owned by so and so and just all this nonsense.
- 21:17I'm like, no.
- 21:18You just agree with their points, so it just kind of made me think of that.
- 21:22But on your point about compromise, what was really an intriguing finding was that
- 21:30Georgetown University just—I think it was just earlier this year, maybe it was last year—but
- 21:34they just had a poll that came out.
- 21:36And amongst their findings was people talking about the house, civility, and respect.
- 21:46A huge majority of the respondents said that those things were needed, but a really
- 21:50interesting and at least seemingly paradoxical perspective for people is that a lot of them
- 21:57believe in the need for compromise, but they believe that their side has compromised enough,
- 22:02and it's the other side that hasn't compromised.
- 22:06What do you think about that kind of finding, that kind of thought process, and how exactly
- 22:13do you think we fix that disparity, I guess, whether through the context of the American
- 22:24schism or just in general?
- 22:26How do you think we approach that issue?
- 22:30Well, there's an interrelated problem here that's causing that.
- 22:36So we talked about how elected officials are too easily using emotional buttons to stimulate
- 22:46voters to vote and getting a rise out of their anger or fear.
- 22:50Well, it turns out the media is doing that as well because the entire media, as you
- 22:55mentioned, your YouTube, the media model today is based on clickbait or eyeballs.
- 23:01So invariably, sensationalism and provoking anger or fear, those are the stories that do
- 23:07the best financially for the media owners.
- 23:10So the channel owners.
- 23:11So we have both the elected officials on one hand and the media landscape on another, both
- 23:17driving towards sensationalism in terms of their pursuits.
- 23:22And that's really where the incentive system is misaligned today.
- 23:26It's not appropriately aligned.
- 23:28Now, what I would say to your question about how to get a more civilized dialogue going is
- 23:38both sides have to recognize that what we're involved in right now is completely
- 23:43counterproductive, and we're not gonna solve problems by screaming at each other.
- 23:47So, you know, it takes getting into a room, let's say, being in person with people to
- 23:54really understand where they're coming from.
- 23:56So, in the mindset side, what I say in the book, by the way, is there are two types of
- 24:01changes we have to drive towards.
- 24:04One side is all these systematic changes because the system we have today is providing
- 24:13bad incentives.
- 24:14And there are structural things that we could change to make that better, and I'll come back
- 24:19and give some examples.
- 24:20But on the other side, besides the structural change, there's a mindset change too.
- 24:25And it's about learning how to listen to each other, taking a step back and understanding
- 24:30where people are coming from, what I call deep listening.
- 24:33It's about making sure the data matter and not everyone having their own facts, their own
- 24:42alternative facts, if you will.
- 24:44It's about understanding why compromise is the way we've been successful in the past and how
- 24:49can we use it again today.
- 24:52So those are some of the mindset changes.
- 24:54And I think directly to your point, the way we get through some of the polarization mindset is
- 25:01by adapting these mindset changes that I talked about.
- 25:04And I'm very much involved with both in the private sector and with colleges, with students
- 25:10talking about how to think about these different things.
- 25:14Yeah.
- 25:15The introspection part is a big thing for me, and it's something I've, you know, I obviously
- 25:20can always get better at it.
- 25:23But, you know, just the whole introspection aspect of how we approach things.
- 25:26I'm actually working on an educational email course.
- 25:33They basically talk about how we unintentionally inflame polarization, and one
- 25:37of those things is about, you know, we don't really actually examine ourselves and how we
- 25:43approach the topic even if we ultimately want to heal the polarization or to mitigate the
- 25:49polarization and heal the political divide.
- 25:50There are some ways that we approach it that actually kind of make it worse.
- 25:56So just I appreciate you bringing that up in the in-group, out-group perspective, especially
- 26:02because with the in-group, a lot of that is a lack of self-awareness, a lack of
- 26:06introspection.
- 26:07It's everything the in-group does is great.
- 26:10Everything the out-group does is wrong.
- 26:13Now you touched a little bit about it about some of the structural and other changes that
- 26:17you were talking about for how to heal the American schism.
- 26:22So to go on to that a little bit is what are some of these prescriptions you have for
- 26:31healing the political divide in America?
- 26:33How do we get at the core of dissension and polarization and toxicity and get people to
- 26:39fully realize these are the things that we need to do.
- 26:42Well, so the structural problems are many and when I go into the book in the third part of
- 26:49the book in detail on these prescriptions but let me just say, you know, many of these
- 26:55structural changes don't require any kind of constitutional amendment or yeah.
- 27:00Some do, but, like, for I'll give an example.
- 27:05By the way, your listeners probably know this.
- 27:07Most of the way elections work is decided by the individual states.
- 27:10There's nothing in the Constitution that specifies exactly the mechanics of elections.
- 27:15So one great example of a change that I recommend is opening up primaries.
- 27:20By having closed primaries in many states, it creates a very bad incentive.
- 27:26Here's why.
- 27:27First of all, independents, which is a third of the electorate in many states, can't vote in
- 27:31the primaries.
- 27:32So let's use an example.
- 27:35If I'm a congresswoman from Kentucky's 8th, which is a red district—by the way, I think
- 27:41your listeners know this, but 85 percent of districts have been gerrymandered.
- 27:46So they're safe.
- 27:48That's another change we have to make, by the way.
- 27:50I'll come back to it.
- 27:51So they're safe red or blue.
- 27:53Now, if I'm in a safe red district and I'm a congresswoman of, let's say, Kentucky's 8th who
- 28:02is willing in my turn to compromise with someone from the other side of the aisle and
- 28:08solve a problem, when it comes to the primary, which is where it matters, I'm gonna be
- 28:14primaried on the right because the folks who vote in the primary—for the Republicans, it's
- 28:20the base of hardcore Republicans.
- 28:23And for the Democrats, it's the base of the hardcore Democrats.
- 28:26That's why we have congresspeople like, you know, Marjorie Taylor Greene on one hand and
- 28:32Elizabeth Warren and AOC on the other.
- 28:34Now, if there are open primaries, then independents could vote in the primary.
- 28:40And so it might not just be the party loyalists who show up in the primary.
- 28:47So that's one example of it.
- 28:48You know, nothing in the Constitution says how we should run primaries or how we draw
- 28:55districts.
- 28:56I mentioned before the gerrymandering.
- 28:58In fact, one of the prescriptions that I advocate for and spend time on is getting the
- 29:03individual states and the legislatures locally to appoint bipartisan commissions to redistrict
- 29:10in a nonpartisan way.
- 29:11I think it's really important.
- 29:14If you look at a nonpartisan organization like RepresentUs, they say that in the last cycle,
- 29:20around 8% of the electorate was responsible for 85% of the House seats.
- 29:26Think about that.
- 29:278%.
- 29:28Because the combination of gerrymandered districts where only the primary matters and
- 29:35then the people the actual people who show up for the primaries, very small sliver of the
- 29:40voters.
- 29:41So as a consequence, a very small electorate is driving the bus here, and that's what I mean by
- 29:47the frustrated majority, you know, needing to take back the gavel.
- 29:51So nonpartisan redistricting, open primaries.
- 29:55I believe in ranked choice voting.
- 29:57I think it's a way of voting which forces candidates to appeal to a broader base than
- 30:05just their partisan base.
- 30:08Because in ranked choice voting, you have to be people's number two choice as well if there are
- 30:14five candidates.
- 30:15You can't only appeal to your base.
- 30:17It also is a better incentive system with ranked choice voting than with the current
- 30:23voting we have now.
- 30:24All three or four of these changes are state by state, first of all, is where they happen.
- 30:31They're fine.
- 30:33They're not going against anything that's in the Constitution.
- 30:37These are decisions that the states have implemented mostly because of the legislatures
- 30:43trying to keep control.
- 30:45It's about legislators locally in the state houses and the state senates wanting to pick
- 30:51their voters as opposed to the voters picking them.
- 30:55So this is an incentive problem that's structural.
- 30:58And I'm sorry for going on so long, but I wanted to give you listeners some examples of
- 31:02these.
- 31:04No.
- 31:04No.
- 31:04No.
- 31:05No.
- 31:05I mean, answer it as much as you need to.
- 31:09Now, obviously, I won't, like I said, I don't want to agree or disagree with any particular
- 31:14prescriptions, but the whole aspect of political competitiveness or lack thereof is, I
- 31:21wholeheartedly agree, is a very serious problem in this country, and it needs to be addressed
- 31:27when you have all these districts that are just a foregone conclusion, not necessarily the
- 31:31specific candidate, but which party is going to win it.
- 31:34It's just not good for anybody.
- 31:38It's supposed to be competitive.
- 31:39I mean, the idea of competitive politics is that by getting in this circle of ideas, a
- 31:46broad base of ideas to conflict and argue it out, that's what democracy is supposed to do.
- 31:52So if the districts are all safe, then there's not a good exchange of ideas and a good
- 31:57injection of innovative concepts in the problem-solving mode.
- 32:01And that's why in many ways, gerrymandering is so damaging, and both parties do it.
- 32:09Both parties are guilty of this.
- 32:13No.
- 32:13Absolutely.
- 32:16It's just a and it's the whole gerrymandering, the ways for catching it have gotten better,
- 32:22but the ways of trying to make gerrymander or how people try to gerrymander is also getting
- 32:27better.
- 32:28So it's just, you know, kind of all this whole big back and forth between who can gerrymander
- 32:36successfully and who can't, I guess.
- 32:38Now I do know you have to sorry.
- 32:41I do know you have to get going in a little bit, so I do want to end off with the last few
- 32:47questions I have.
- 32:48So what do you think the next big dividing issue that, what do you think the next dividing
- 32:53issue will be that is emblematic of your conception of the American schism, or is it
- 32:57even going to be a single issue in your opinion?
- 33:00Well, the most critical, issue is the lack of faith, the breakdown in trust in our
- 33:07institutions.
- 33:08I mean, already and and this is you know, you you asked me before about, my perspective on
- 33:16both the extreme sides.
- 33:17Are they equally kind of disruptive?
- 33:20Here's where I think, you know, the the the the the there's been folks on the right that have
- 33:24intentionally been election what we call election deniers.
- 33:27This is very problematic because if we don't have a peaceful transfer of power in this
- 33:32country, that's this that's the landmark of what makes a democracy work.
- 33:37And if we lose faith in our elections, which all the data show that there's not been
- 33:44systemic fraud in our elections, they're reliably safe, and they've been proven so.
- 33:50So here's where, you know, truth matters.
- 33:53And what I would say is that what I'm most concerned about in terms of issues is this
- 33:58erosion of faith in our institutions.
- 34:01Because if our institutions no longer have the trust of the American people, our democracy as
- 34:07we know it is over.
- 34:09It's really the beginning of the end.
- 34:11And so I'm hopeful that we can restore trust in our institutions because despite all of our
- 34:19problems, Paul, you know, we still are the best example of self-governance in the history of
- 34:25the planet even with all of our problems.
- 34:28No society has pulled off what we've done.
- 34:32And, you know, for those on the left who are willing to criticize America, you know, go try
- 34:38living somewhere else and see what it's like.
- 34:41And for those on the right who don't want to give credit or faith in our institutions, I
- 34:48think you're also doing a tremendous disservice.
- 34:50So that's to me, the trust in our institutions is the most important issue.
- 34:56Now I just wanted to make one other point.
- 34:57You know, I spoke about three structural changes that don't require constitutional or
- 35:03federal action.
- 35:04There are two structural changes I think we need that do require federal action.
- 35:11One of them is campaign finance reform.
- 35:13I think since Citizens United, we've allowed the level of what I'll call bribery in our
- 35:19system, special interests to, you know, give enough support to really be the ones that end
- 35:26up writing the laws.
- 35:27Their lobbyists are the ones that write the laws that those industries take advantage of.
- 35:32That's corrupt.
- 35:34So we need campaign finance reform.
- 35:36And in the book, I talk about it.
- 35:37I won't go into it now.
- 35:39That probably does require a constitutional amendment, and I support a group called
- 35:43American Promise, which is a nonpartisan group that's trying to pass a two-sentence amendment
- 35:50to the Constitution that would make sure that all money in campaigns is disclosed properly.
- 35:58I'll leave it at that.
- 36:02Yeah.
- 36:02No.
- 36:02Absolutely.
- 36:03It is definitely a, shall we say, controversial ruling in that Citizens United case, and I've
- 36:11been writing a little bit, not specifically about that, but it was a little bit of a part
- 36:17of that educational email, of course, I was talking about and a couple of other things I've
- 36:22been writing lately.
- 36:23So and it but, yeah, it's I think everybody can agree that campaign finance is broken.
- 36:30Now how to actually address it?
- 36:32Obviously, there could be a debate there, but it's definitely something that needs fixing to
- 36:38some extent.
- 36:39And now, I mean, we could go on about this all day, but I don't want to hold you up.
- 36:43So just to end on a couple of questions, one on a bit of a lighter note, and then, obviously,
- 36:49I'll give you a chance to plug any media that you want to plug.
- 36:53But as always for the podcast, I conclude with a random question, and it doesn't necessarily
- 36:58have anything to do with politics.
- 36:59A lot of times, it doesn't, and there's not necessarily a right answer.
- 37:03So for you, Seth, my question is this.
- 37:06Who is one person, doesn't have to be the person, but who is one person dead or alive
- 37:11that you would want to have an in-depth conversation with?
- 37:14And again, it doesn't have to be the person at the absolute top.
- 37:16Just one person.
- 37:18Well, I'll give you two answers.
- 37:19So, alive, I would say it's someone like Adam Kinzinger.
- 37:27I think he's a Republican congressperson, but he's not been part of the Trump camp.
- 37:32He's conservative, but I think he's someone who is and I've spoken to him briefly.
- 37:38I would love to do some more.
- 37:40I think he's someone who really puts country first, which is what we need more of in our
- 37:46leaders.
- 37:47A dead person, I would say I mean, the obvious ones would be Abraham Lincoln or Martin Luther
- 37:53King.
- 37:53They're great leaders.
- 37:55I would probably pick someone like, who I'd love to just have a conversation with Winston
- 38:00Churchill because in terms of courageousness in the public space, I think he was one of the
- 38:07most emblematic heroes of the 20th century.
- 38:10And so, you know, if you ask me of a dead person, you know, someone like him or maybe
- 38:15even FDR, Franklin Roosevelt, those are people I would love to have a conversation with.
- 38:23I mean, can't really argue with any of those.
- 38:27Obviously, major historical figures for me are a big thing, but I'm gonna give you the might
- 38:33be actually the top of the list.
- 38:34And now I'm sure you know who this is, but for those listening who don't know, I'm gonna pick
- 38:40Rod Serling.
- 38:41Now if you don't know who he is, he was the creator of the original Twilight Zone back in
- 38:47the sixties and was the head writer there.
- 38:50And if you hear him in interviews and just the stuff that he wrote, it's just an incredibly
- 38:56prescient, well ahead of his time guy who just had an uncanny ability to look into the nature
- 39:05of humanity and look at our flaws and really articulate them in a manner that nobody else
- 39:14really can.
- 39:14And it's a shame that he passed as young as he did back in, I believe, the seventies.
- 39:19So Rod Serling is going to be my answer.
- 39:24But now to end things off, once again, thank you so much, Seth, for being on this show.
- 39:30Anything else you wanna plug, including your book?
- 39:32Sure.
- 39:33Well, American Schism, I think, would I would love your listeners to take a look at it.
- 39:37I think if you like history, you wanna understand better the root of our divisions
- 39:41today.
- 39:42I think it's a great read, and I love hearing from readers.
- 39:45So, please take a look at the book.
- 39:47It's available in Kindle audio and hardcover at Amazon.com, American Schism.
- 39:53And I would also say that I do write regularly on these issues, and I love to hear from
- 39:58readers.
- 39:58So my website, SethDavidRadwell.com, is something that you can sign up for my
- 40:03newsletter, which is free, and I'd love to keep the dialogue going.
- 40:08Thank you, Paul, for the work that you do in this important space.
- 40:12Hey, absolutely.
- 40:13And once again, thank you for coming on, Seth.
- 40:16So once again, that book is American Schism: How the Two Enlightenments Hold the Secret to
- 40:22Healing Our Nation.
- 40:24Get it on Amazon in ebook and paperback format.
- 40:27Once again, thank you to Seth for coming on to the show as the first ever guest on this
- 40:31podcast, and thank you to those who tuned in to view and/or listen to this interview.
- 40:35And until next time, take care.