Latest / Tech IPO Conversations with Fexingo: Public Software Companies and Capital Markets / Why Tech Companies Are Returning IPO Proceeds
Transcript
- Lucas: There is a quietly wild stat I came across this morning: eight percent of the companies that went public in 2025 have already announced share buybacks or special dividends within twelve months of listing. That is a record high. Luna: That does run counter to the usual narrative, where you IPO to raise capital for growth. Why would you turn around and hand it back? Lucas: Exactly. The canonical reason to go public is to fund expansion—hire engineers, build data centers, acquire competitors. But a growing subset of tech companies is signaling something different: 'We don't have a better use for this cash than to buy our own stock.' Luna: That feels like either extreme confidence or a tacit admission that growth opportunities are limited. Which one is it? Lucas: I think it depends on the company. Let me give you a concrete example. There is a data-analytics firm that went public last September. IPO price was $30, popped to $70 in the first week. Within six months, they announced a $500 million buyback. That move effectively returned all the primary capital they raised. Luna: So if the stock was $70 and they bought back shares, they were saying their own equity was the best investment they could make. Lucas: Right. And if you look at the current market, it's not hard to see why a founder might think that. Palantir, for example, is trading at $136 today—up more than 100 percent this year. ARKK is up nearly five percent in the last week alone. Strong momentum can make buybacks look very attractive. Luna: But there is a flip side. If you are a growth-stage investor who bought into the IPO narrative of expansion, seeing capital returned might feel like a betrayal. You invested for growth, not for a treasury operation. Lucas: That's where the tension lives. The old rule was: a public company returns capital to shareholders only when it's mature, with predictable cash flows and limited reinvestment opportunities. Think Coca-Cola or Procter & Gamble. But we are seeing young, high-growth tech firms doing it within their first year of being public. Luna: If today was actually useful to you, the way these stay ad-free is listener support. You can find us at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It helps keep the show independent. Lucas: And we appreciate that more than I can say. Okay, back to the buyback trend. One argument is that companies with high insider ownership are more likely to do this. Founders who still hold a large stake see the stock as undervalued relative to future earnings. Luna: But is the stock actually undervalued? Or are they just protecting their own dilution? Lucas: Could be both. Look at Shopify. They went public years ago, but they have been aggressive with buybacks. Today Shopify is at $104.90, up about four percent over the past week. Their CFO has said publicly that they view buybacks as a tax-efficient way to return capital. But they are also investing heavily in fulfillment and AI. Luna: So a hybrid model: keep investing but also buy back shares. That seems more responsible than the all-or-nothing approach. Lucas: Exactly. The companies I'm most skeptical of are the ones that raise a huge IPO, pop, and then announce a buyback with no strategic context. It suggests they didn't actually need the capital they raised. And that raises questions about the IPO itself—was it just an exit for early investors? Luna: That gets to the heart of the IPO process. If the company doesn't need the money, why subject yourself to the scrutiny of public markets? There are direct listings, SPACs, all sorts of alternatives now. Lucas: Right. And some market observers argue that these buybacks are a way for management to signal confidence without having to give earnings guidance. It's a concrete action, not just words. But it can backfire if the stock declines anyway. Luna: Have we seen any notable failures? A company that did a big buyback and then the stock cratered? Lucas: A few. There was a cloud security firm that IPO'd in 2024, bought back $200 million worth of shares at an average price of $45. The stock is now around $28. They essentially destroyed capital. But that's the risk—you can be wrong about your own valuation. Luna: So what should an investor look for? How do you tell the difference between confident capital allocation and hubris? Lucas: I would look at free cash flow. If a company is generating strong cash flow from operations, a buyback is more justified. If they are burning cash and borrowing to buy back stock, that's a red flag. Also look at insider selling. If founders are selling shares into the buyback, that's a bad sign. Luna: That makes sense. Let's zoom out: what does this trend say about the IPO market overall in May 2026? Lucas: I think it says that the market is maturing. Investors are demanding real profitability or a clear path to it. Companies that IPO without a compelling use of capital are being punished. The ones that do buybacks are effectively saying, 'We are disciplined stewards of your capital.' Whether that's true, we'll see. Luna: And for founders listening who are thinking about going public: what's the lesson? Lucas: Have a plan for the capital beyond just 'growth.' Be ready to explain to investors why you need it. If you can't, maybe a direct listing or a smaller raise is better. And if you do a buyback, make sure it's tied to a real conviction in your stock's value, not just optics. Luna: I think that's a fair place to leave it. Next time we'll look at how secondary markets are changing the lockup dynamics for early investors. Lucas: Looking forward to it. For now, thanks for listening.