Latest / Mythmakers / Rock Music in Gerwig's Narnia and Other Film News
Transcript
- 0:05Hello and welcome to Mythmakers.
- 0:07Mythmakers is the podcast for fantasy fans and fantasy creatives brought to you by the Oxford Centre for Fantasy.
- 0:15My name is Julia Golding and I'm joined by my podcast partner, Jacob Renecker, who is sitting over the other side of the...
- 0:24The Atlantic from me.
- 0:26And we are today going to be discussing like a roundup of the latest film and TV news in the world of fantasy, but majoring mostly on the Narnia, the magician's nephew, Greta Gerwig.
- 0:43So Jacob, welcome.
- 0:45Thanks.
- 0:46Good to be here, Julia.
- 0:47So we have both run out and got ourselves a copy of the Empire magazine article with Greta Gerwig and from the set.
- 0:58And we both have just been discussing how we couldn't find a physical copy.
- 1:02Shows you how much the sort of magazine world has changed since...
- 1:08I suppose last time I bought copies for the Lord of the Rings and the Hobbit films.
- 1:14But we both have managed to secure digital copies.
- 1:18And it really was a very interesting from the set explanation of what's going on.
- 1:27So, Jacob, why don't you tell us a little bit about what you gleaned?
- 1:31Yeah, there was a lot.
- 1:33It was really the first sentence of it is Gerwig asking, you know, where are the vibes?
- 1:41So in terms of vibes or ambiance, theming, there's a lot in the article about
- 1:50the feeling that she's going for with this particular film.
- 1:54And I think, and it's, so like the headliner is kind of rock opera vibes or something that's like, so, and by that, I think she means by the pictures and the way that they're describing it, what we've seen is, you know, bright, bright colors, something that is, I think, I don't want to say like,
- 2:14upbeat, up-tempo, something that has a lot of energy to it, kind of maybe unbridled energy and enthusiasm to it.
- 2:25So, yes, there was a lot of mention of rock music, music.
- 2:34in there, but it's also, which it looks like will be woven in there, but also it's more of kind of like the essence of this, this coming out of, and she's setting it kind of contextually, with World War II, the people that, like David Bowie, who are growing up to become these kind of iconic pop music authors, they're growing up in World War II, the rubble of World War II, is how they describe it in the articles.
- 3:01So what she's doing, and this is where the director's author, she is rewriting a take on The Magician's Nephew.
- 3:12She's decided to set it in 1955, which is the year it was published, not the year it is set.
- 3:19And she is coming at it with the idea that for her as an individual,
- 3:25Her windows of perception, her doorway into imagination was through rock musicians, the Paul McCartneys, the David Bowies and Robert Plants, that kind of thing.
- 3:39But she then thought about their childhoods.
- 3:42These were children who were either born just after or some during, but a lot just after the Second World War in a bombed out landscape.
- 3:53And their escape from that was through the rock music coming in initially from the States mainly.
- 4:01And then they sort of had this explosion of creativity, which was the swinging sixties and the
- 4:08Dazzling 70s.
- 4:09I'm not sure what we call that.
- 4:12And so she thought, right, this is the journey.
- 4:14So we've got purposely make our world bleak and bombed out.
- 4:20And they've had to rebuild the sets because it's not like that anymore.
- 4:23Yeah.
- 4:23You know, so they've gone for that.
- 4:29And then the world of Narnia and Chan, because we mustn't forget Chan, is the contrast, the place you escape to.
- 4:37uh so one of my favorite bits in the article is she refers to the wood between the world as being based on the london underground map it's an iconic design feature which anybody from the uk and possibly a lot of people globally knows the idea that you can pop up in regent's park or you can pop up in
- 5:01Victoria, just by going, connecting.
- 5:05So I love that idea.
- 5:06That's a really, I thought, oh yeah, that's really fun.
- 5:09So she's not saying...
- 5:13She's admitting to this or enjoying the idea of this lair, which will annoy like crazy the ones who want – because we've never seen a magician's nephew, so we've not seen the late Victorian period from the book with Queen Jadis riding a chariot like some kind of Babylonian queen, which is what Lewis had in mind.
- 5:39She's moving it to this context.
- 5:42And just to bring into the design idea, Chan is like a Barbarella 60s...
- 5:52It's like a broken pinball machine.
- 5:54Yeah.
- 5:54So it's like flashing lights and really kind of garish colors.
- 5:59Pulp fiction.
- 5:59It's that stuff.
- 6:00So...
- 6:04So it feels like one of those films made from the era, the kind of Flash Gordon type special effects.
- 6:11So that's what was outlaid in, well, both in the sort of rumours coming in advance, but also very clearly in this article, which I thought was well worth a read out there if you want to sort of dig into the details.
- 6:25So thinking of all of that, yeah.
- 6:29What is your response, Jacob, to this?
- 6:31Does this work?
- 6:33Do you think it's going to work?
- 6:35Yeah.
- 6:36So...
- 6:38I think so.
- 6:39What impressed me was Greta finding emotional touch points for her own life and kind of like translating those, finding points of resonance.
- 6:49Like, okay, what was, for me, what opened up my imagination and made life seem like wildly full of possibilities for her?
- 6:58Like you mentioned, it was this rock music.
- 7:00And she said, it saved my life, whatever that means.
- 7:04So it was very important to her.
- 7:05It's a bit hyperbolic, I think.
- 7:06But, you know.
- 7:07Right.
- 7:08Right.
- 7:09So she's finding that point of resonance and then finding something in the story of Magician's Nephew, and she's finding a way to marry those two.
- 7:17So I think anything that's written out of a place of emotional truth for the author is going to come across as being more resonant for the audience.
- 7:27Because if you don't care about the material and you're just kind of doing a paint-by-numbers technique,
- 7:31strict adaptation if you don't have a personal investment in it then i think it's easier to see those stories films shows when people don't really care as much um she even mentioned with what something was funny with the the charn her design there she said it was um in the article inspired by a childhood trip to las vegas which is bright and shiny you know on the on the outside so she got lost and ended up in like the back alleyway beyond the the strip which is like the
- 8:00curated, dazzling lights, clean, everything is meant to grab your attention.
- 8:05And then she ended up going behind the buildings accidentally and seeing this like broken down things.
- 8:11And so seeing on the other side of this like glittering, glamorous world, there was something that showed it's like emptiness inside.
- 8:19And that for her wasn't like an emotional experience as a child that she's bringing to her.
- 8:24how she's dealing with charn itself.
- 8:26So the points of emotional resonance, like that's really inspiring to me for how the story can turn out and unfold.
- 8:32She clearly has a unified vision for what this world is and finding points of personal connection emotionally.
- 8:40I think that's very promising for me.
- 8:43Yeah, so the slightly odd thing, I'm just thinking about it.
- 8:46I mean, I've had fun thinking about what 70s rock songs would I use as my soundtrack.
- 8:52She's presumably going to cherry pick her way through these.
- 8:55So obviously, is this a real thing?
- 8:57Is this just fantasy?
- 8:58You know, the Bohemian Rhapsody.
- 9:02It's going to be in there, surely.
- 9:03Things like that.
- 9:04So I can have fun like she has making my playlist.
- 9:09The odd thing about it for me is, well, there's quite a few odd things about it.
- 9:13I'm excited by the vision.
- 9:16And if someone's going to do this, let's jump straight in and see if it stands.
- 9:21You know, if it works as a film, it works.
- 9:24She doesn't have to apologize.
- 9:25Right.
- 9:26But it's not her generation's experience.
- 9:31It's actually the experience of my parents' generation.
- 9:34So the Paul McCartneys of this world are actually in their 80s.
- 9:38And she's also not British.
- 9:40So she's leaning into something which is very specific
- 9:44to a sort of British memory of the time, the Festival of Britain, and all sorts of other points of reference, which I guess she's probably clever enough to know about and informed herself about.
- 9:57But it'd be interesting to see...
- 10:00how this works because her saying, oh, Paul McCartney, David Bowie saved my life, that stuff seems, she's a bit young.
- 10:10So she must have come across these people later in her own, you know, how old is she?
- 10:19She's not my age, she's younger than me.
- 10:21I think she's in her 40s, yeah, must be like early 40s.
- 10:24She was that kid in school who was listening to stuff from almost
- 10:30So that's really odd.
- 10:33But fine, because the other thing to remember, she is going to carry, if she's going to carry on doing Narnia film, she needs somewhere to go.
- 10:41So she can't, she has to set it far enough back so that the Professor Diggory grows up and becomes, you know, the Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe, if she does that, is contemporary, which would be fun to see what she does, because if you do the math, it works out.
- 10:55Yeah.
- 10:57Yeah, interesting.
- 10:59I think one of the things, so obviously looking at the book, so she has mentioned in that article that the whole spread of the series is from creation to the end of the world.
- 11:14So she's aware of the arc.
- 11:16There was no mention of the sort of spiritual message there.
- 11:20Right.
- 11:21So that's, yeah, which is interesting.
- 11:23And I think this, so this is interesting.
- 11:24So she said, yeah, when she's describing her vision for the series, she's describing it to Netflix, the head of film at Netflix at the time that she was talking with it.
- 11:34It's about the creation and destruction of an entire universe.
- 11:38And so seeing it set in the rubble of World War II, its creation is...
- 11:43in the like seedbed of destruction, right?
- 11:46So it's cyclical.
- 11:47So there's hope.
- 11:48So she's talking about this like locating hope, which I think is interesting.
- 11:53But yeah, regarding this, like the spiritual lack of like spiritual core, what I was thinking, I was actually thinking about,
- 12:00C.S.
- 12:00Lewis, his essay, Sometimes Ferry Stories May Say Best What's to Be Said.
- 12:05And I think here's a quote that I think is worth reading in full.
- 12:09So this is Lewis talking about his some of what he's doing in writing, reimagining
- 12:16ideas that are rooted in his religious worldview in fantasy or the fairytale kind of mode of communication.
- 12:26So he says, I thought I saw how stories of this kind could steal past a certain inhibition which had paralyzed much of my own religion in childhood.
- 12:36Why did one find it so hard to feel as one was told one ought to feel about God or the sufferings of Christ?
- 12:42I thought the chief reason was that one was told one ought to.
- 12:46Kids never want to do what they're told to, right?
- 12:48An obligation to feel can freeze feelings, and reverence itself did harm.
- 12:51The whole subject was associated with lowered voices, almost as if it were something medical.
- 12:56But supposing that by casting all these things into an imaginary world,
- 13:00stripping them of their stained glass and Sunday school associations.
- 13:03One could make them for the first time appear in their real potency.
- 13:07Could one thus not the steel past those watchful dragons?
- 13:11I thought one could.
- 13:13So what I see, so interestingly, I think that she's, what she can do here is take Narnia out of a, you know, maybe primarily through,
- 13:25a particular religious lens or spiritual lens.
- 13:28And in a landscape where, especially like Lewis was deeply Christian, where in an age where Christianity has become so politicized on both ends of the spectrum and polarized, that this is perhaps a way to kind of steal past
- 13:43our own kind of modern watchful dragons for the ideas or knee-jerk reactions we have to ideas of spirituality, which like, again, like, so like the world as a whole, and people are on different sides of the fence on different issues.
- 13:55And the people who are even like people who are religious versus non-religious, this, this perhaps is a way to kind of like cut through and say is here's, here's this story.
- 14:05And maybe this is giving people a chance to experience the core
- 14:14their kind of like natural defenses against a story like this.
- 14:17So in some ways that actually seemed kind of Lewisian in its approach to, which is kind of ironic, right?
- 14:24Like what C.S.
- 14:24Lewis was trying to do with kind of his Christian story or story of morality and ethics was,
- 14:30she almost seems to be doing something similar with his story, which has achieved a sense of reverence and on.
- 14:37Perhaps people are looking at it too rigidly in some ways or feel like they know exactly how it is and become solidified.
- 14:43And so C.S.
- 14:43Lewis is an author.
- 14:44I feel like he was a very generous reader, not just as an author, but as a reader.
- 14:50So in the notes that he's writing and books, he wants to take the book as it was written, try to understand it, give it the benefit of the doubt.
- 14:56And so I feel like Lewis would probably be...
- 14:59Pickled by, whereas I think Tolkien would have, I feel they would have very different reactions to interpretations of their work.
- 15:06I feel like Lewis might... Just on the point of how to treat Lewis's...
- 15:14book, I think one of Tolkien's problems was there was too much more obvious messaging in it because his own policy was to strip away, strip out the obvious religious messaging in order to have Christianity, in his case, more present.
- 15:31And I'm actually quite relieved that she's not actually talking about the sort of spiritual messaging of it for similar reasons to you in that you can't
- 15:44So either you offend a lot of sort of, you know, Sunday school teacher type people.
- 15:49Right.
- 15:51Or you put off a global audience who don't want to go and see a Christian film.
- 15:57So just don't talk about it.
- 15:59Let the material be the story and just get on with it.
- 16:03So I think that's.
- 16:05That's a wise choice.
- 16:07Yeah.
- 16:08Because, you know, it's not a plot spoiler now, is it?
- 16:12But it reruns the Garden of Eden, a version of the Garden of Eden.
- 16:18So it's there and it's about resisting temptation.
- 16:22And because Lewis had a sort of preoccupation with can you avoid a fall?
- 16:28And in the way the fall happens in Narnia, but it's by accident.
- 16:33It's bringing Jadis into Narnia by mistake.
- 16:39So that's what produces evil there in a way.
- 16:46It's not so much the Apple moment, though, of course, that's running a Garden of Eden parallel very clearly.
- 16:53So, no, I'm interested.
- 16:54I think it would be fun to see.
- 16:57And it leaves space, just to sort of put it, you know, the book remains.
- 17:03The book has a Victorian atmosphere and feel.
- 17:07It leaves space for that to still exist in its own world, leaves space for other people to tackle it again in the future.
- 17:17might be quite a shot of energy.
- 17:21Yeah, exactly.
- 17:23Which is what I think is interesting and I think could help.
- 17:26Again, people usually are familiar with Magicians and the Narnia books because their parents read it to them.
- 17:34They have these experiences or they've even seen the films.
- 17:36The films are...
- 17:37how many, 20 plus years old at this point.
- 17:40And so they might've seen those films and they have a very particular feeling.
- 17:42And those feelings, so the original, or not the original, because there were other adaptations of Narnia before that, but the most recently Disney, Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe, that one was produced after the success of the beginning of the Lord of the Rings film.
- 18:00So it very much has that same kind of like subdued, kind of high fantasy, medieval,
- 18:06uh, tone and then filmed with like a sort of like medieval reverence.
- 18:11Right.
- 18:12Um, in, in a sense.
- 18:13And so it's very similar there.
- 18:15And so seeing, and, and they're, they're different, like Lewis, not that Tolkien didn't have joy in his work.
- 18:21He clearly has fun with the songs and moments, but there is like, uh,
- 18:26Tolkien, in his mind, the long defeat is something that's always kind of like looming in the background.
- 18:31And so like, these are moments of brightness, but this inevitable kind of decline is coming and what people can do in the light of that.
- 18:39And Lewis, to me, and reading the story is like, it seems more joyful in many ways.
- 18:47I don't know if that's the audience that he's particularly writing for there.
- 18:51And so the sense like the way that you could have trying to adapt to
- 18:55magician's nephew as if it were Lord of the Rings, I think that's a mistake because they're in different tones.
- 19:01So we have these conversations about Lewis's world building, if you can call it that.
- 19:07He's kind of piecemeal, kind of bringing things together.
- 19:11Some might say that that's sloppy world building.
- 19:13Lewis, I think, was doing it joyfully in terms of bringing everything and inviting all of these different sources together and having fun with them, whereas Tolkien is more fastidious in making sure everything.
- 19:23Everything is connected just so, and every tree has a history and who planted it and when.
- 19:29So there are different approaches to world building.
- 19:32And I think Lewis's is more open, is more kind of like flexible in many ways.
- 19:39And so I think that this type of approach lends itself well.
- 19:42Like you tried to do this to Lord of the Rings, I think is a mistake.
- 19:46I don't think you could do it as well.
- 19:47I would actually love to see that, to see what generates from that.
- 19:51But I think given Lewis's kind of playfulness and his ability to, again, play with ideas and put them into conversation with each other, that he does so well in so many different settings, in a fantasy, in a sci-fi setting, I think, yeah, I'm excited to see...
- 20:09how the whole thing shapes out here.
- 20:11I think it is a positive way, a completely legitimate way to approach the source material, and I'm excited to see how it actually turns out.
- 20:23Yeah, I think there's a couple of, sort of looking at the cast, within this rock opera world, it's going to be quite tricky for David McKenna, who's playing Diggory, and Beatrice Campbell, who's playing Polly Plummer,
- 20:40Be cool in that world.
- 20:42You know, because they're young and they look like 1950s kids.
- 20:49They're very sweet looking.
- 20:52And one of the things about the Narnia stories is the children do become the heroes, right?
- 20:59So it does be interesting to see how they balance out this We Are All Rock Gods type feel with Emma Mackey as the White Witch and Meryl Streep as Aslan.
- 21:10Interesting to see how they come through that to be, you know, if it should be their film.
- 21:17It should be their film, not the adults.
- 21:21Daniel Craig as Wicked Uncle Andrew, I think, is going to be a great film.
- 21:29she's very cleverly picked the one person still riding a horse-drawn vehicle in the 1950s.
- 21:37Well, maybe there were some...
- 21:40beer deliveries.
- 21:42The breweries use horses for longer.
- 21:46But Cobb and Holbrook Smith is playing, I think, Albert.
- 21:49Is that the name of the character?
- 21:50The cabbie.
- 21:51Anyway, the cabbie from the story also gives a sort of bit of diversity as well, which is great to see that happening, which would have been harder to have put in, I suppose, in an early Victorian...
- 22:04a late Victorian piece because this is after the Windrush generation.
- 22:08So it all fits.
- 22:10Windrush, for American listeners, is the name for the larger amounts of immigration for work from the Caribbean coming into Britain.
- 22:23It was called the Windrush after the boat that brought lots of people across.
- 22:28So I think that all sounds good.
- 22:30And I'm actually having...
- 22:32read the explanation in the Empire magazine, thank you, Empire, I actually feel, oh, okay.
- 22:41Maybe we're not heading for a complete car smash of a film and maybe this will work.
- 22:47I just think it's going to be holding such an explosive idea with these two little kids is going to be interesting.
- 22:56Can I ask you what you think of the lion in the room?
- 23:01Oh, Meryl.
- 23:02Well, in the article...
- 23:02Yes, what are your thoughts there on the explanation?
- 23:04In the article, it says she chose a voice because she wanted room for other voices.
- 23:11So I wonder if she does more films, if she actually recasts Aslan, doesn't have the same voice.
- 23:19A bit like Doctor Who regenerating.
- 23:22Yeah, right, right.
- 23:24I have no idea.
- 23:26I would have to see the visual of Aslan with the voice coming out of it.
- 23:30The voice, yeah.
- 23:31Because who knows what they're going to do digitally to the voice.
- 23:34Yeah.
- 23:34Yeah.
- 23:35And so, again, when she says she wanted the tone or, again, to draw on her words at the beginning of the article, the vibe of Aslan that she was looking for, she said she wanted someone who was profound but not pretentious, who had gravitas but not morose self-seriousness, someone who could communicate depth and pathos as well as joy and delight.
- 23:56And so that language was very...
- 23:58G.K. Chesterton, in my mind, right?
- 24:01This kind of like these paradoxes holding this like grandness, but also this like childlike, you know, like omniscience, but as well as this like childlike joy and exuberance that you want like both of those in as an and typical like so with Liam Neeson, great quality of voice.
- 24:16He's a very, you know, like subdued, sometimes angry, but they're
- 24:21there isn't like a sense of like sparkling joy, like lying underneath the surface.
- 24:24So that erupts occasionally, but you do see when Aslan in mind, which word are, when he's like,
- 24:31playing around with the girls.
- 24:33And so I think, so that to me was interesting.
- 24:36I kind of find a voice that wasn't just that you would think of a James Earl Jones, kind of a severe voice of your character who's kind of representing God.
- 24:46But this is somebody who's like, has wonder, who has like, yes, gravitas, but also like joy and delight.
- 24:54And then, so that's really interesting to find again, like short circuiting, kind of stealing past our watchful dragons of what we think,
- 25:00a voice of, you know, cosmic significance could be.
- 25:04Is it a serious, is it a Sunday school, like you were saying, like type of voice, does it need to do that?
- 25:09Or is there room for different types of voices to express that idea of what kind of lies at the core?
- 25:17So that was interesting to me, again, like you were saying, like from the way Gret is describing it in the article.
- 25:22Because Aslan comes in quite late in the story, and he comes in singing.
- 25:29But his singing is magical singing because it's creating a world.
- 25:34So it's realizing something which works on the page, actually having to make decisions how you realize that.
- 25:42on the screen is what she gets the big bucks for, I suppose.
- 25:46And when you think about Benedict Cumberbatch being a dragon, what they do is they put his voice through a lot of layers of sort of, I don't know, whatever their magic jiggery-pokery is going on in the background.
- 26:00Yeah.
- 26:00But it's still his performance with all this other element added in.
- 26:04I don't know what a lion sounds like.
- 26:08I guess for me –
- 26:10If I can hear Meryl Streep too much, it will be distracting.
- 26:13Yeah.
- 26:14Because I'll be thinking that's Meryl not... And also it's just a gender thing as well.
- 26:19You know, it should have been a lioness kind of thing.
- 26:23But if they are good at it and if the performance is good, they're going to sell it.
- 26:27And also I think it's probably deliberate because in terms of...
- 26:32getting the outrage going online is part of the marketing.
- 26:35Yes, yeah, people are talking about it.
- 26:38And I refuse to be outraged.
- 26:40Right, yeah, and somebody made a really good point that I heard talking about this was that in the movie The Exorcist, right, the movie about demonic possession, the voice of the demon devil was actually voiced by a woman.
- 26:57You couldn't tell it.
- 26:58It was like, it seemed...
- 27:00very sinister.
- 27:03It didn't seem, you know, like female coded necessarily, but it did.
- 27:07So equal opportunity.
- 27:09Women can be just as scary as men.
- 27:12It's terrifying.
- 27:13And vice versa.
- 27:14It's probably more an issue if you can...
- 27:17if you're picturing Meryl Streep, so that's what I mean.
- 27:21It's the, when your brain is sort of firing into Mamma Mia mode and the screen is Aslan.
- 27:29But I know that they will have...
- 27:32They would have considered all of that.
- 27:33It would be up to the sound team to make sure it's processed in such a way that we don't get any of that.
- 27:39Well, and part of what I'm interested in seeing is how the reaction, how the actors were able to react against it.
- 27:46Because Meryl Streep was there sometimes on set reading lines.
- 27:51And so they were actually reacting to it.
- 27:52They said they had like a puppet, you know, a large Aslan head that they were...
- 27:57that they were looking at.
- 27:58But Meryl Streep said that at one point she was up on a ladder reading with her script, reading to them.
- 28:04So they're actually interacting with the voice itself, whereas I know with the original Mind the Witch and the Wardrobes, Liam Neeson's voice was brought in in post-production afterwards.
- 28:13They would have had somebody else there delivering the lines, but having the person whose voice is that they're actually responding to there and interacting with the actors, I think that can...
- 28:26that I think creates an environment for a better response from the actors, allows you to actually enter into that imaginative world more easily.
- 28:35So yeah, I'm hopeful.
- 28:38Yeah, and going forward, if she does more Narnia films, it'd be, and if this sort of,
- 28:43glam rock era, 60s rock as well, works, then you could imagine that each of the Narnia films could have a different sort of musical genre.
- 28:56You know, the line of witch and the wardrobe can be, I don't know.
- 28:59whoever moves her in prints or somebody, some kind of 90s type stuff going on or whatever, you could imagine that she can pick different eras to give each film a sort of different flavor and leaving this sort of the previous generation's rock music for this first one.
- 29:18So it's quite clever, I think.
- 29:20Okay, so we are both refusing to clutch our pearls and be upset about it.
- 29:25Right.
- 29:26We are both thinking, oh, that sounds interesting.
- 29:28Yeah.
- 29:29Good luck.
- 29:31Yeah.
- 29:31I think there are some ways it could fail, and my biggest worry is about how the children match up because the children look like more regular casting, how they match up to sort of more sort of, you know,
- 29:52huge sort of orchestral, loud rock music world.
- 29:58But we'll see.
- 29:58We'll see.
- 30:00Okay, so just sort of briefly touching on some other news.
- 30:04There are some stills from the Hobbiton set that was published by Warner Brothers.
- 30:10I don't know if you've seen those, but this is for filming for the Andy Serkis, The Hunt for Gollum.
- 30:20Did you notice those at all?
- 30:22Yes, yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 30:23I saw the one, the official one, and then another one of, I can't remember if it was a director of photography or something.
- 30:29There's a whole spread of them.
- 30:31There's one which looks like Frodo, an older Frodo going into Bag End.
- 30:38That's one that I saw, yeah.
- 30:39There's one that could be Rosie and Sam or a couple who looks like Rosie and Sam.
- 30:44There's some with pumpkins and children.
- 30:48And there's one of Andy Serkis standing outside Bagshot Row with a long camera in front of him.
- 30:54He's obviously filming some kind of wide shot.
- 30:57The point of these, I think, for what it's worth, is that they are picking autumn as the tone for this opening.
- 31:09It looks wet.
- 31:10It's not the happy summer of the previous Hobbitons.
- 31:15They presumably filmed it in the New Zealand autumn slash winter.
- 31:21So I think it's saying something.
- 31:24My suspicion is it's...
- 31:27That could be the venue for the retrospective.
- 31:31You know, we survived and now looking back, this is what happened at the moment just before Frodo departs.
- 31:40But it also could be when they set out because they set out on the 22nd of November.
- 31:48September in the autumn so it's also useful for filming from that point of view so that's what I gleaned from that and of course we all know what Hobbiton looks like I did check in have a look at Hobbiton as a result and they've added since I went there you can now do a wild walk and meet some stone trolls
- 32:11Oh, wow.
- 32:12Those prop stone trolls or a version of them have been put.
- 32:14So there's an extra thing to go and see.
- 32:16I don't think I'll be flying back to New Zealand just to see those, but it looked very fun.
- 32:22Yeah.
- 32:23So that was the news there.
- 32:24Oh, and the other sort of tiny little fragments was that Jamie Dornan, who is playing Aragorn, is getting on well, according to Andy Serkis, because it will be his film, as is the one hunting.
- 32:43And then, of course, you've got the...
- 32:47there's a sort of glimpse of Gandalf having, you know, Ian McKellen in his Gandalf makeup.
- 32:54So he's obviously gone back to reprise.
- 32:56What do you think they're doing with the autumn setting?
- 33:00Yeah, I think that's interesting tonally, right?
- 33:03So this film, I think, isn't going to be, I think, if you had thought that it was going to be set in the Shire, and it would be like an optimistic film.
- 33:13But I don't know if that's setting the tone for the rest of this.
- 33:17This is kind of like a fall.
- 33:18This is like going into the winter that will shortly happen.
- 33:23fall over all of middle earth with Sauron and the ring, um, to, to kind of set.
- 33:29Yeah.
- 33:29So either there's a part perhaps tonally, but then also to set it apart from the films themselves.
- 33:34Right.
- 33:34To, to show like, Hey, this is Hobbiton in a slightly different light.
- 33:39And so perhaps that is a way to kind of prepare people, uh, for the difference that this is a slightly different film.
- 33:47It's set in the same universe, but it's not, uh, same timeline technically.
- 33:50Right.
- 33:51Uh, uh,
- 33:53cinematic universe, cinematic adaptation of Lord of the Rings, Peter Jackson's vision, but slightly different.
- 34:00So we're turning it at a different time.
- 34:01So, yeah, I'm interested.
- 34:06I'll go watch it.
- 34:08Yeah, I suppose I'm just trying to work out where the Hobbiton
- 34:12sits.
- 34:13It's easier to see how it sits for the Stephen Colbert film, which is the Hobbit story.
- 34:21I'm guessing here it could be about the fact that the Rangers are looking after the Shire.
- 34:28So it could be almost like seeing their interaction with the Shire and how they're sort of standing on the outside of the Shire keeping bad guys away.
- 34:37Or it could be what I was suggesting if these are the older characters looking back, it could be the idea of Lord of the Rings is it's written with the reports, with the contribution of friends.
- 34:51telling them what happened.
- 34:52So it could be whilst Frodo is writing it down.
- 34:55So, you know, you start with a book and, you know, Gandalf taught me that, you know.
- 35:01So that's the sort of connecting tissue there.
- 35:03I don't know.
- 35:05But I think the autumn is really important for the Hobbits.
- 35:10It's the birthdays.
- 35:13It's when people set out on adventures and when they return.
- 35:18Yeah.
- 35:19So it has that feel.
- 35:22Anyway, we'll see.
- 35:23I think the release date for that is sometime at the end of next year, isn't it?
- 35:29Yeah, and it also just happens to match the release window, the season around which the movie would probably be released as well.
- 35:41Yes, okay.
- 35:42Yes, that's right, because quite often it's really weird if, say, you're watching a film and the timeline has slid and you're suddenly finding yourself in Christmas because they've decided to put it out in, you know, May.
- 35:56They did that with the Sherlock retellings where clearly, clearly it'd been time to be released at what we have over here is like a fireworks night, bonfire night.
- 36:06It was a big...
- 36:07But of course, it ended up in New Year or something.
- 36:09You're thinking, why are they talking about Bonfire Night?
- 36:12It was, yeah, so that does happen when things shift.
- 36:15Okay, so that's the news so far on Lord of the Rings, extra films.
- 36:22Stephen Colbert said when he came over to get his, what did he win, an Emmy or something, that he's working full time on it.
- 36:31So he seems to be enjoying himself writing the film after this.
- 36:37I wonder how much the fortune of that film is tied to the success of The Hunt for Gollum.
- 36:44Anyway, we'll see.
- 36:47We'll see.
- 36:48I just wanted to also mention, because we've not ever talked about it, another big sort of UK fantasy franchise that's sort of coming along, which I don't know that much about, though I do know the author.
- 37:03That's Catherine Rundle's Impossible Creatures.
- 37:07which has been bought by Disney for, I think, a multi-movie deal.
- 37:12They've really thrown lots of money at it.
- 37:15And she's writing it with her partner, who's also representing her.
- 37:20So there's a sort of a team where they've managed to sort of get some power for themselves in what is quite hard to do against these sort of film studios.
- 37:34The reason I'm mentioning her is because she's another Oxford author.
- 37:37And as the Oxford Central Fantasy, we should mention her existence.
- 37:41She is also an academic and wrote a very respected biography of the poet John Donne, which is very good.
- 37:53She's an unusual...
- 37:57Her backstory is full of all sorts of unusual things.
- 38:02And she is based in one of the most bizarre colleges in Oxford.
- 38:05So she basically lives in a fantasy world.
- 38:09And she described her politics as being closer to Philip Pullman than J.K. Rowling.
- 38:15Anyway, that's what's happening there.
- 38:17Have you come across her writing at all?
- 38:19She made it all in the States.
- 38:21Yes, yes.
- 38:22I think she got the Barnes & Noble Book of the Year for children over here.
- 38:29And yeah, so I've read Impossible Creatures, and it is good.
- 38:32It is mythologically rich.
- 38:34You can tell that she knows and is honoring and appreciates classical mythology.
- 38:40And so that's something that I appreciated.
- 38:44It does...
- 38:46It is tonally closer to his dark materials than it is to Harry Potter, to the Wizarding World.
- 38:56But I think, but it's still, but it isn't quite as...
- 39:01I don't want to say cynical sometimes.
- 39:06I think it comes across in Pullman's writing for children.
- 39:11I think that it is more...
- 39:14There is the ending of the book.
- 39:17And so there's a mixture of comedy and tragedy.
- 39:21And even in the midst of tragedy, there is hope.
- 39:24Yeah.
- 39:26and explicitly.
- 39:28And so I think, yeah, I enjoyed it.
- 39:30I picked it up actually after.
- 39:32I hadn't had a chance, right?
- 39:33It had been on my list.
- 39:34And then when I learned about Disney, picking up the rights for it, I said, I need to look at this now.
- 39:40And apparently, and looking into it, so she, it was initially...
- 39:43planned as a trilogy of books.
- 39:49But after some of these developments and talks about kind of fleshing things out, it's now become a five book planned series.
- 39:57The third book just came out, I believe, or is either coming out or just came out, the third book.
- 40:02So of a planned five.
- 40:04And after...
- 40:06talking about with Disney about really they want to kind of develop this into an IP in itself.
- 40:11And so she's slated to write the first two scripts with her creative partner.
- 40:17And she also has plans beyond those five books now that she kind of has plotted out or planned.
- 40:23She wants to write some like prequels, spinoff stories to kind of further enrich the world, similar to what has been done with the Wizarding World.
- 40:30This is fascinating because we saw what happened to Fantastic Beasts.
- 40:34Do you think it has the charm and the humor and the sort of child-centered adventure to carry it?
- 40:43Or does it have the Philip Pullman problem, which is it's not that charming?
- 40:48For children, yeah.
- 40:48It isn't as...
- 40:50Yeah, it didn't have the same sense of whimsy and wonder.
- 40:57In the story, there's two children as the main characters, one is a native to this magical world that exists kind of.
- 41:08not a lot like not inside or within ours, like the wizarding world with Harry Potter, but this is like a separate realm where there's entrance into a different world.
- 41:17And so there's the boy from our world who comes in here.
- 41:21So you do get the sense of wonder through his, through his perspective.
- 41:26But it isn't,
- 41:27it isn't as whimsical and fantastic as the early Harry Potter books and even the later Harry Potter books where you still have that kind of like edge of whimsy.
- 41:34And so, yeah.
- 41:35So the, and then the issue, I think when, when, uh, the golden compass came out, when it was adapted into a film starring Daniel Craig, ironically or unironically, wicked uncle, wicked father, right.
- 41:46Wicked father instead of wicked uncle.
- 41:48Yeah.
- 41:48So typecast for sure.
- 41:50But he, so that film, I know that like, you know, this is coming out around, it came out after Narnia, I believe, right?
- 41:58The Golden Compass film adaptation.
- 42:01So again, so there's different, I think that one appealed.
- 42:06more to adults or there were more adults I know who wanted their children that they were like, they're excited.
- 42:12This was there for some people, right?
- 42:15His dark materials is like the anti-Narnia for them.
- 42:17So they're like a reaction to it.
- 42:19They see it as like a personal identity, a statement as like Narnia is, this is how I feel about Narnia.
- 42:25Narnia is presenting this world and
- 42:27which is tied to religion.
- 42:30And his dark materials is clearly kind of like anti-establishment, anti-institutional religion.
- 42:36And so they'll identify with that one.
- 42:38And so it appealed more, I think, to adults philosophically than it did to the children.
- 42:44I had actually just...
- 42:45And anecdotally, the person lived in an apartment or a room in somebody else's house.
- 42:51He had two young children, elementary school-aged children.
- 42:55And he was very excited for the film to come out because he liked the book.
- 43:01And I think it's somebody who identified himself.
- 43:03as kind of like anti-Narnian in his worldview and wanted his children to be exposed to that and was really wanting them to, you know, become like awakened, alivened by that view.
- 43:15And they went and saw it.
- 43:17But the children, like it just didn't seem like it connected in the same way to them, the children, from their perspective, as it did to him as an adult.
- 43:27So yeah.
- 43:28It could be something similar.
- 43:31I do think it isn't as, like I said, it isn't as, if you're putting his dark materials on one end of the hole and like Narnia, those sentiments there, I would see Wizarding World Harry Potter kind of being in the middle, but as in the earlier books, leaning more towards the Narnia sense of like wonder magic, whimsy, and then later as the protagonists grow older
- 43:56leaning maybe a little bit more into like the reality, like maybe more like political realities, kind of edging more towards Pullman.
- 44:03But of course, I think Impossible Creatures, at least the first book, I haven't read the other ones yet, but Impossible Creatures, I think, is sitting kind of right there in the middle to begin with, whereas the early Harry Potter books, I think, are leaning more towards the whimsy and wonder side.
- 44:17So I think, and the characters aren't children.
- 44:21They're really like characters,
- 44:24three teens, almost teens.
- 44:28And so I think it's not going to be like children, like a Harry Potter movie.
- 44:32could appeal to some elementary school age children at that world.
- 44:36I think this is probably going to be one they'll want to because Disney will want to try to, I think, push it for a younger audience.
- 44:44I think it's slated to be PG.
- 44:46So there are those in the film adaptation could perhaps do something different because it is being produced and promoted by Disney that Disney could have some
- 44:55notes like Want It to air on the side of the wonder.
- 45:00And Wimstein emphasized that in the film adaptation.
- 45:02That's my guess.
- 45:03It's kind of what will happen.
- 45:04But it's definitely needy enough to attract an adult audience in terms of mythology and...
- 45:13And even like ecology, right?
- 45:14So it's dealing with fantastical creatures and their world is kind of like slowly dying.
- 45:19The magic is being kind of drained from their world.
- 45:22So they're kind of facing a magical slash ecological threat.
- 45:28to their world and this boy is coming over and trying to find out what the source of that is and and return it so there's definitely like modern like relevant themes for the world that we live in today but I think yeah so so I think you're right that the trick is with some of these books and it can be difficult with adults writing for children that
- 45:54Very often, it's the concerns of adults as adults that can make their way into children's literature.
- 46:00But for those special, blessed authors who are able to either remember what it was like when they were a child or have close relationships with children today and understand what they're concerned about, what they're afraid of.
- 46:16What do they love?
- 46:17What enlivens them right now as a child?
- 46:20But those are the authors that seem to be able to capture the vibrancy of youth.
- 46:25And I think that's what C.S.
- 46:26Lewis did with Narnia really well.
- 46:31Well, that means I have to go away and educate myself.
- 46:33I have read other books, but not this series.
- 46:35So, yeah, I will go and do that before the films come out.
- 46:40She's a very fine writer.
- 46:41I'm just intrigued because this secret sauce of what it is that makes something a good IP, I sometimes fear that...
- 46:49studios think they've got it and actually they're missing something and I don't and we'll see if this this is the thing it would be fascinating to see and of course they might do what they did with Cressida Cowell is you take an idea and the films are completely different from the books.
- 47:08Great.
- 47:09Yeah, well, the fact that the author is writing it, is writing the screenplay, to me, it says it'll probably queue closer to the book itself.
- 47:19So, yeah, I don't know.
- 47:21Interesting.
- 47:22Yeah, it is interesting.
- 47:23And I think just really quickly on this, so I know some of our chats we haven't seen.
- 47:28given recommendations on things lately, but there was a book that I just read that is directly relevant to this about writing for children.
- 47:35Mac Barnett is an award-winning children's author, and he had a book that came out this past year called Make Believe,
- 47:46the subtitle on writing for children.
- 47:49Um, and it's, it's, it's phenomenal.
- 47:51And I think it's good for like storytelling in general, but especially for people who want to write to a younger audience.
- 47:57Um, he, and I didn't know this about him.
- 47:59I, I was exposed to him, um, reading his children's books to my picture books to my child and was just delighted.
- 48:06He writes a
- 48:16And just some like, just like delightful books, but also are like offbeat.
- 48:20They're not saccharine.
- 48:21They're just like completely original and captivate children and myself.
- 48:27And he wrote this book.
- 48:28He was chosen as kind of the children's literature laureate for the United States for I think last year or whatever.
- 48:35And so he, this is what he did during his kind of
- 48:39year of being the laureate was writing this book for adults about writing for children.
- 48:45It's very engaging.
- 48:46So it's a children's author.
- 48:47I found out that he, I think I need to find out this, but it sounds like he went to grad school for Norwegian medieval Scandinavian court poetry.
- 48:59So I can deep like...
- 49:00academic background, but who's writing these like, silly, wonderful stories for children that are just delightful.
- 49:07And so his, his way of talking about storytelling, and engaging with your audience and understanding an audience, especially for children, I think is well, well worth anyone reading.
- 49:18It's just Yeah, it's and it's a short, it's a very short read.
- 49:21If you're like, he does the audio book, and it's like,
- 49:25two and a half hours long.
- 49:26Okay, so that's special.
- 49:28Yeah.
- 49:28It's very short, and it has a printed book with some nice little whimsical illustrations in it, but it's for adults written well, and his theory, he does the greatest...
- 49:38like a literary analysis of Margaret Weiss Brown's Good Night Moon, American classic book, this like phenomenal literary analysis of it.
- 49:48That's worth the price of admission just for this children's book.
- 49:52Like how he's seeing like philosophically what's happening there.
- 49:54Anyway, that's my recommendation.
- 49:56So that was Make Believe by?
- 49:58Make Believe by Mac Barnett, B-A-R-N-E-T-T, I believe.
- 50:04Okay.
- 50:04Okay.
- 50:05So just on book news, I was very excited that I received the proof copies for my children's book, which is coming out on the 31st of December in the UK, called The Mystery of Treason Castle.
- 50:18Children's Castle.
- 50:19Treason Castle.
- 50:20And what's really fun about the proof copies here, which are very nicely produced, thank you, Usborne, is that there's two versions.
- 50:29And they're sending them out.
- 50:30One of them, it says on the front, you are on Team Innocent.
- 50:35And the other one says you are on Team Murderer, which, of course, is the thing of the game.
- 50:41And it's got some of the interior artwork in place.
- 50:48But I've just received today...
- 50:51The PDF of the final artwork in the interior, which is always really exciting to see.
- 50:58And so we're cooking up, taking these round to – because proof copies go to sort of bookshops and, you know, people who have influence in the industry.
- 51:10They're going to be doing some proof drops but in costume.
- 51:13Oh, fun.
- 51:14This is when being an author becomes –
- 51:17gets out of your imaginary world in your study and you have to go in the real world and make a complete idiot of yourself.
- 51:23But that's part of the job.
- 51:26That's exciting.
- 51:27So I have questions for you about that.
- 51:29So for those proof copies, are those going to be the final copies?
- 51:33They'll have two different A and B covers there or is that just kind of promotional for the advanced reading copies?
- 51:39That is the promotional copy.
- 51:43The final cover is on the back.
- 51:48Oh, okay.
- 51:49Which is a sort of dynamic castle.
- 51:50I think it would be just the one cover.
- 51:53But I haven't quite, we can probably lean into it.
- 51:59There is going to be another one.
- 52:00I'm writing the follow-up at the moment.
- 52:03So I don't know.
- 52:04We'll see how it goes.
- 52:05But it would be quite fun to have something in the interior that is a kind of URL.
- 52:10We can probably do some point-of-sale material.
- 52:14That's great.
- 52:15Yeah, yeah.
- 52:16I was going to say, yeah, some bookmarks, some other.
- 52:19Yeah.
- 52:20So when's the shelf date for that one will be available?
- 52:23It's a January book, which means it comes out on the 31st of December.
- 52:27Yeah.
- 52:27So the idea here is that you don't want to put something out in the Christmas market because it gets cluttered by either really big sellers or, you know, sticker books with nativity scenes or Father Christmas.
- 52:42So we have a sort of slot in the earlier part of the year, which is in the run up to World Book Day in end of Feb, beginning of March.
- 52:50So that's a good slot to be in.
- 52:57doing it then maybe doing a little tour of schools and that kind of thing and that's fantastic or being on the who knows i might be on the the summer festival circuit as well we'll have to see it all depends how well it sells and that's yeah i don't know so buy coffee folks
- 53:16Yes, everyone by a copy.
- 53:18Free order now, yes.
- 53:20And it's, of course, going to Frankfurt, which is happening very soon.
- 53:24Oh, yeah, yeah, that's happening.
- 53:25Yeah, that's happening in October.
- 53:26Yeah, that's the first, second week of October.
- 53:29Yeah.
- 53:29So what happens behind the scenes, if you're interested, is so my agent is representing this book.
- 53:34She is representing the foreign rights.
- 53:35So her team who do the foreign rights will take it there.
- 53:38Mm-hmm.
- 53:40And so we'll try and get it into as many territories as possible.
- 53:45And I've sort of said, go to the territories where they've got, because it's sort of inspired by the traitors TV program.
- 53:52That's the same kind of game is happening in the book to what that is, except as a layer of a real murder that happens within that context.
- 54:01And so it's already a sort of known idea because of the TV program in many, many territories.
- 54:10And then there was also the audio rights were separate this time.
- 54:15So it's just been sold for the audio rights.
- 54:17So that's nice.
- 54:19Excellent.
- 54:19And so it's great for...
- 54:20Sort of begins to build.
- 54:21Begins to build.
- 54:22Yeah, yeah.
- 54:23And so when it's at, say it's at the Frankfurt Book Festival, is that where your agents and publishers will be like hoping to get to sell rights for international for different translations of the book?
- 54:38Yeah.
- 54:38So what happens at Frankfurt is publishers will go with like, or agents in my case, will go with sort of books they're promoting online.
- 54:48And it's a series of meetings that you don't normally hear until sometime afterwards.
- 54:53Because what happens is people take their books back to their, you know, home and say, oh, this sounds like a book that would fit on our list.
- 55:01Right.
- 55:02Sometimes you do sell there and then.
- 55:03It just varies.
- 55:05Yeah.
- 55:06And sometimes if you're, say, like a, you know, a big seller like Richard Osman is, there'll be people competing for the rights.
- 55:13That's unlikely to be my case.
- 55:15Right.
- 55:15Right.
- 55:16So it just depends what the buzz is around a title.
- 55:19But it's still done by lots.
- 55:24I've been to Frankfurt once back in the 2010s with a German publisher.
- 55:33And it's still done in this sort of way of you all go to this massive conference center and,
- 55:41it's it's crazy it is a overwhelming world it's definitely not somewhere to go as an author unless you're invited by a publisher because you're such a small small little minnow in a massive massive right massive pool yeah i was very close very close to going to frankfurt book festival um this year so the book my book quest of wonders that just came out is in uh the they'll be featuring their robinsberger press the one that published it they'll
- 56:08It is in German.
- 56:09So people who are actually German can get a copy of it already translated for them.
- 56:14So they're doing some things there.
- 56:16And it sounded like very interesting place.
- 56:17Like I felt like I would want to like go and wander.
- 56:19If you've got something like that, where you've got a book that's actually that that's fine to go because you've got someone you can go up to up, you know, you've got a home base.
- 56:30But just wandering up because you want to talk to publishers or whatever as an author, it's really difficult.
- 56:35People do that at the London Book Fair.
- 56:38I know they do that.
- 56:39Okay, okay.
- 56:39The London Book Fair.
- 56:40When is London Book Fair?
- 56:42That's in usually April time.
- 56:45April.
- 56:46And that usually has a program for…
- 56:49writers and authors like separate seminar type thing so there's a reason for going but i'm just sort of saying if you're out there thinking oh i'll go there and pitch my book it's not a very good place to pitch because it's professionals pitching to other professionals unless it's organized there's a sort of
- 57:09we're open to see you kind of thing.
- 57:12Otherwise, you just feel very depressed, I think, even by the time you got back because you'll be thinking, wow, there's a lot of books in the world.
- 57:21So I went because I was on a shortlist for a prize, so that was fine.
- 57:26You know, there was like a presentation and a dinner and all that kind of thing.
- 57:31But I did come away thinking, gosh, that was an interesting experience.
- 57:35I met Sarah J. Mars on that visit, so that was fun.
- 57:38Oh, thanks.
- 57:39He was coming up as the new, young, fresh-faced, rising author.
- 57:44So that was, you know, you do meet people.
- 57:46But, yeah, so that's the wonderful world of these huge book fairs.
- 57:56Right, Jacob, we should probably end it there.
- 57:59Thank you so much for talking through this wide range of news of me.
- 58:04It's been great fun.
- 58:06And, yeah, fingers crossed that Greta Gerwig gets her vision actually really works because I've got high hopes now.
- 58:16Yeah, yeah.
- 58:17So we'll find out February 12th in cinemas and then on Netflix in April, I believe, is when you can view it from the comfort of your own couch.
- 58:26Yeah, Netflix Films, I suppose, is going to come out.
- 58:29I will definitely try and see it in a cinema, though, I think.
- 58:31Yeah.
- 58:31Particularly with all that rock music going on.
- 58:34Right.
- 58:35Okay, thank you very much for joining us.
- 58:42Thanks for listening to Myth Makers Podcast.
- 58:46Brought to you by the Oxford Centre for Fantasy.
- 58:49Visit OxfordCentreForFantasy.org to join in the fun.
- 58:54Find out about our online courses, In Person Stays in Oxford, plus visit our shop for great gifts.
- 59:01Tell a friend and subscribe wherever you find your favourite podcasts worldwide.